America's most courageous insider, Dr. Jeffrey Wigand — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:06hello one and all thank you very much
- 0:08for joining me for my podcast the Ingle
- 0:11angle I am Fort Worth Star Telegram
- 0:13columnist Matt Engel my guest for this
- 0:16episode is someone who quite
- 0:18accidentally kicked my career down paths
- 0:21away from Sports
- 0:23and for that I am eternally grateful
- 0:26I met him back in 2000 or 2001 and at
- 0:31the time I was a beat writer covering
- 0:33the Texas Rangers
- 0:36now at the time I had a lot of other
- 0:37interests away from Sports something
- 0:40that this podcast has given me the
- 0:42opportunity to further explore
- 0:44the same certainly can be said of my
- 0:46employer the Fort Worth Star Telegram
- 0:48which has been so kind over the years to
- 0:50allow me the opportunity for the chance
- 0:53to report opine and pursue other topics
- 0:57ranging from movies culture books travel
- 1:01pop culture politics news
- 1:05and in this case newsmakers
- 1:08I do often remind myself how fortunate I
- 1:11have been to cover subjects that are
- 1:13further afield from Sports even though I
- 1:15still love sports
- 1:17now this began for me back in 1999 after
- 1:20I had seen the movie The Insider
- 1:23uh in the movie theater
- 1:25I remember when back when people did
- 1:26that
- 1:27the movie stars Russell Crowe Al Pacino
- 1:30Christopher Plummer and as directed by
- 1:33Michael Mann I'm a big Michael Mann fan
- 1:35Michael Mann also co-wrote The Insider
- 1:38Michael Mann is best known as the man
- 1:41who created the hit TV series Miami Vice
- 1:43directed popular movies such as heat
- 1:47thief and The Last of the Mohicans among
- 1:49other titles
- 1:51the movie the inside was actually based
- 1:53on a Vanity Fair article about the story
- 1:56of former big tobacco scientist Dr
- 1:58Jeffrey weigand and specifically his
- 2:01ordeal with cbs's top-rated news show 60
- 2:04minutes and it struggles to air his
- 2:07interview
- 2:08it was an interview where he revealed
- 2:10that the tobacco companies manipulated
- 2:13its lethal product to be even more
- 2:16addictive you go public and 30 million
- 2:18people hear what you gotta say nothing I
- 2:21mean nothing will ever be the same again
- 2:25now the work we did here is confidential
- 2:27not for public scrutiny any more than
- 2:29our one's Family Matters
- 2:34we're very serious about protecting our
- 2:36interests
- 2:41he's got something to say he wants to
- 2:43say it I want it on 60 Minutes
- 2:46for the audience it's just voyeurism
- 2:47something to do on a Sunday night and
- 2:49maybe it won't change a thing and people
- 2:50like myself and my family I left hung
- 2:52out to dry used up alone
- 2:55what does this guy have to say a little
- 2:58bit paranoid to him that threatens these
- 3:01people but it isn't cigarettes are bad
- 3:02for you who is this
- 3:07they have no right to hide behind a
- 3:09corporate agreement he could talk we can
- 3:11air it the worst kind of an organized
- 3:13smear campaign against a whistleblower
- 3:16shoplifting failing to pay child support
- 3:18they can paint everything with that
- 3:20brush what are you going to do now you
- 3:22know finesse me lawyer me some more try
- 3:26Mr Wallace
- 3:27cleared this segment I was told don't
- 3:30talk mind my own business we could be a
- 3:32grave risk we're doing this with or
- 3:34without you LOL are you a businessman or
- 3:37are you a newsman
- 3:40he's only the key witness in the biggest
- 3:42Public Health reform issue in U.S
- 3:45history
- 3:47does he go on television and tell the
- 3:49truth yes yes is it newsworthy yes are
- 3:53we gonna air it of course not why
- 3:56because he's not telling the truth no
- 3:58because he is telling the truth and the
- 4:00more truth he tells the worse it gets
- 4:03it you manipulated me into this I fought
- 4:06for you and I still fight the American
- 4:09public needs to know
- 4:11Jeffrey and you wish you wouldn't come
- 4:13forward Dr wagon's deposition will be
- 4:16part of this record you wish you hadn't
- 4:18blown the whistle do I think it's worth
- 4:20it I told the truth it's valid and true
- 4:22and true people that's not the point
- 4:24whether you tell the truth or not
- 4:33why Dan's interview and subsequent Court
- 4:36testimony ultimately led to the nation's
- 4:38four largest tobacco companies agreeing
- 4:41to the largest civil litigation
- 4:42settlement in the history of the United
- 4:44United States which in 1998 totaled
- 4:48about
- 4:49250 billion dollars
- 4:52that agreement also included dramatic
- 4:54reform throughout the tobacco industry
- 4:57Dr weigen went on to become one of the
- 4:59world's foremost experts on the dangers
- 5:01of tobacco and he used his expertise and
- 5:05fame to serve as an educator for people
- 5:07all over the world he's also one of the
- 5:11foremost experts in the dangerous art of
- 5:13whistleblowing
- 5:14I originally met him more than 20 years
- 5:16ago that interview took me about six
- 5:19months to set up I kept peppering him
- 5:21with emails and he finally agreed to do
- 5:23it so I drove out to what was then a
- 5:25very little place called Frisco Texas to
- 5:27meet him in the lobby of a Holiday Inn
- 5:29or upon greeting him he said you've got
- 5:32to try
- 5:34they're chocolate chip cookies
- 5:36he was right they were really good so he
- 5:39got into my red Pontiac Grand Am I drove
- 5:42him to a Starbucks he had some tea I had
- 5:44some fruit for a drink and I got to talk
- 5:47to Dr Jeffrey wagan for about an hour
- 5:49maybe a little bit more
- 5:51uh it was a great interview then and
- 5:53it's a great pleasure to introduce
- 5:55Dr Jeffrey wygan
- 5:58very
- 6:01unexpected victory in the Netherlands
- 6:04what was it
- 6:06well
- 6:08nine years ago
- 6:11I was in the Netherlands and working
- 6:13with their
- 6:15tobacco control group folks
- 6:17and people at the
- 6:19the hospitals and started a program for
- 6:22kids
- 6:23and one of the things they were trying
- 6:24to look at is they revised
- 6:27testing for filtered cigarettes
- 6:31and they were looking at any litigative
- 6:35issues and so I demonstrated for them
- 6:37the
- 6:39Block versus unblock
- 6:43FTC testing
- 6:45so when you block the filter ventilation
- 6:48holes you deliver up to four times the
- 6:51amount of
- 6:52tar car carbon monoxide nitrous oxide
- 6:55which is pretty pretty important in
- 6:57Europe because there's a label on a
- 6:59product that says this is what you're
- 7:01getting so people who are a little
- 7:03helpful conscious go and look at the
- 7:06numbers rather than quit and look for
- 7:08the lowest tar nicotine
- 7:11and so we unveiled it and I showed them
- 7:14the
- 7:17semi-invisible unless you're looking for
- 7:19laser perforations around the
- 7:21circumference of the filter
- 7:24and it started litigation against the
- 7:26tobacco industry the deceptive practices
- 7:30and it just came down from the Supreme
- 7:31Court of the Netherlands that they had
- 7:34to revise the test method and remove all
- 7:37the product that's on the shelves
- 7:39a replacement product that's been
- 7:41measured appropriately which then of
- 7:44course involves a separate part of the
- 7:45government which is dim and IVM which is
- 7:49basically their
- 7:51slash CCC slash
- 7:54FDA
- 7:56and they have not been using the the
- 7:58Block versus unblocked like Canada's
- 8:01been using since I've been there for
- 8:03almost 15 years now and Massachusetts
- 8:06been doing it versus Block versus
- 8:09unblocked
- 8:10uh educate me real quick what you're
- 8:13describing sounds
- 8:16vaguely similar to what was going on in
- 8:19the 90s when you blew the whistle on
- 8:23Brian Williamson are these are there
- 8:25similarities are there parallels are
- 8:27these different types of
- 8:30um product manipulations with a
- 8:32cigarette David there I have it on that
- 8:34case since 1996 and not have been able
- 8:37to get to any traction in this country
- 8:39which is somewhere backward in terms of
- 8:42this regulation tobacco products they
- 8:45haven't they can't be a package labeling
- 8:48as well the rest of the world has that
- 8:51uh they don't require labeling
- 8:54on a package they refuse the band
- 8:58menthol
- 9:00which allows the industry to Target
- 9:01African-Americans
- 9:04yeah mental
- 9:06menthol cigarettes cause a very
- 9:09different effect on the smoke in terms
- 9:11of anesthetizing the respiratory tract
- 9:15so I can help inhale more and deeper
- 9:18wow so that's a slide so
- 9:22they have to now develop a new testing
- 9:25amount of methodology in
- 9:28Europe or particularly the Netherlands
- 9:31to accommodate the open and closed
- 9:34filters so they can put a
- 9:40accurate assessment numbers on the
- 9:44package I don't know if you've ever
- 9:45traveled to Europe pick up a pack of
- 9:48cigarettes with a big white label on his
- 9:49side
- 9:51not Todd nicotine and carbon monoxide
- 9:55so that just came through which was on
- 10:01tomorrow writing a paper about it
- 10:04so even though you're celebrating your
- 10:0680th birthday uh you're not slowing down
- 10:10in what I think can kind of be called
- 10:13the third Act of your of your long
- 10:16career it seems to me
- 10:18pardon it's the first acting that's
- 10:22great well I mean
- 10:23your your trajectory changed quite a bit
- 10:2625 years ago did it not
- 10:29in 1994 94. okay yeah more than that wow
- 10:33gosh I can't believe it's been that long
- 10:35um so I wanna I do want to backtrack
- 10:38because I want to go back to that point
- 10:40in your life
- 10:42because you're known as a whistleblower
- 10:45and maybe
- 10:46you might
- 10:48be the most significant whistleblower in
- 10:51the history of the United States at
- 10:52least you're in that in that Echelon yes
- 10:54I am
- 10:55if someone was contemplating doing that
- 10:58on a government agency on an employer
- 11:01taking the risks that you would take
- 11:03that you took uh
- 11:06what would you tell them in terms of how
- 11:09to do it and maybe to avoid some of the
- 11:12unknowingly maybe maybe mistakes that
- 11:15you made in that process
- 11:17well
- 11:21I talked to potential
- 11:23persons unconscious truth tell us every
- 11:25day
- 11:27calling me for advice what to do
- 11:29and I don't have any really good
- 11:31succinct advice
- 11:33other than what do you believe what do
- 11:36you know what is substantiated with
- 11:38documents
- 11:42um
- 11:44and that will go a long way second is
- 11:46you need to go
- 11:47some
- 11:49specific connections with the media
- 11:53it's about the media much of what I did
- 11:56would never be ever become
- 11:58popular 60 Minutes The Wall Street
- 12:01Journal the New York Times LA Times
- 12:03Washington Post
- 12:06okay you need to understand that this is
- 12:09not a a cheap process
- 12:12that you're going to need specific legal
- 12:15help and anything you're going to get a
- 12:19pro bono
- 12:20or you're going to get it
- 12:22through the through paying for
- 12:26and it's not cheap I didn't pay for any
- 12:28of my litigation
- 12:32it was pro bono for me from people from
- 12:34South Carolina Mississippi Florida New
- 12:38York Indiana
- 12:42the attorney generals
- 12:45so you know when you when you and I
- 12:48spoke back in 2001 I vividly recall you
- 12:52telling me I think you said it to me
- 12:54twice that you regained your moral
- 12:56compass yes that stuck with me
- 13:00um
- 13:01was that a prior was that was that a
- 13:03priority for you when you started this
- 13:05doctor that that you felt like you had
- 13:08compromised it in the name of
- 13:10oh I don't know a job or just making a
- 13:13lot of money
- 13:15but money was never an issue to me in my
- 13:18career I mean I always make good money
- 13:22whatever company I made with and I was I
- 13:25always made a significant increase in
- 13:27management responsibility as I moved
- 13:29from company to company
- 13:31the hook that got me involved with
- 13:35the tobacco industry was
- 13:39how could I use my scientific
- 13:42tell us my medical knowledge to make a
- 13:45safer cigarette
- 13:47and so that
- 13:50coupled with a substantial pay hike
- 13:54health care benefits to my family as you
- 13:57know I may have told you I have one
- 13:58daughter that lives in Texas yeah that
- 14:01is significant medical issue and
- 14:04and at the same time we would get to
- 14:07move closer to family
- 14:09in Kentucky
- 14:11so when I did the calculus of all of
- 14:13this
- 14:15I said I I'll do it
- 14:18so I signed on in 1989
- 14:22in December and then it was go and as I
- 14:27continued
- 14:28at the level of responsibility I had as
- 14:30a vice president
- 14:32I got to see things that were in
- 14:34different silos that never integrated
- 14:38and so
- 14:40the industry that I work for
- 14:42particularly but the industry as a whole
- 14:46to deliberately and consciously
- 14:48lied about what their product does and
- 14:51what are the
- 14:53changing the packaging with with Salem
- 14:55cigarettes or coolest thing right to to
- 14:59put them in the
- 15:02category of the way an African-American
- 15:08Smoked Cigarettes
- 15:10to turn the pack upside down they peel
- 15:12around and they tap it down so it's
- 15:14hanging out
- 15:16is the business into the cigarette
- 15:21and that was deliberately launched in
- 15:24Philadelphia
- 15:26and the record particularly to the
- 15:28African-American minorities
- 15:32menthol cigarettes
- 15:34do you still see uh because I remember
- 15:37when we spoke
- 15:39you spoke specifically about the tobacco
- 15:42industry and how it targeted young girls
- 15:45yes it basically as as an appetite
- 15:48suppressant which obviously it had
- 15:50worked successfully it successfully a
- 15:53hard word to use but it had worked for
- 15:56Generations decades what I don't see
- 16:00people smoke very much anymore doctor so
- 16:03what methods of I'm Dallas Fort Worth
- 16:05because I remember when I was there I
- 16:07worked with the mayor
- 16:09of Dallas
- 16:11he was in supporting of smoke-free
- 16:13environments
- 16:16but the company still exist so what
- 16:18methods of marketing are they using now
- 16:20to attract customers
- 16:23I need the same vaping vaping yeah okay
- 16:27how do I deliver nicotine
- 16:30and a large bowl of nicotine
- 16:33um
- 16:34they have not
- 16:37substantively changed
- 16:41okay there are some changes around the
- 16:44fringes of the issue
- 16:47but they continue to work they continue
- 16:49to supply and nicotine they now have a
- 16:51Next Generation product for vaping
- 16:56okay which by the way is epidemic in
- 16:59Middle Schools
- 17:00in Middle Schools middle schools I
- 17:03didn't know that
- 17:04yeah
- 17:05middle schools is a fate
- 17:08and I've read stories about of how a
- 17:11vape cartridge can can blow up but as a
- 17:14vape experience
- 17:16the same as a cigarette
- 17:18it has a resistance to draw
- 17:21okay it delivers a bolus of nicotine
- 17:23depending on what you get anywhere
- 17:25between zip
- 17:26zero to fifty
- 17:29milligrams of nicotine
- 17:31so you can get a whole pack of
- 17:33cigarettes and one dose of you wanted a
- 17:36pack of cigarettes and a dose yeah a
- 17:38pack of cigarettes average cigarettes
- 17:40say Marlboro light but the light is not
- 17:43used anymore
- 17:44well Marlboro blue
- 17:4720 cigarettes in there delivers
- 17:49approximately 22 milligrams of nicotine
- 17:54uh so what you're describing to me is a
- 17:57vape even though it's friendly inside a
- 18:01restaurant or a bar so to speak
- 18:03is it okay so I just don't see it very
- 18:07much I know people are doing it I don't
- 18:08see it very much but what you're
- 18:10describing is that something that's far
- 18:12more potentially dangerous to a person's
- 18:14health
- 18:15than the cigarette
- 18:18it's children
- 18:20yeah that's awful
- 18:22fifth grade
- 18:24fifth grade yeah for the fifth grade up
- 18:27so when you and I spoke
- 18:29a camp for the kids
- 18:33that's so bad you know in some ways it
- 18:37looks to me like America
- 18:39is made tremendous strides tremendous
- 18:43strides when it comes to
- 18:45um
- 18:47tobacco use because I just don't see it
- 18:49as much just because we don't see it as
- 18:52much are we fooling ourselves about that
- 18:54it's a certain degree I mean you have to
- 18:57know that the Target or the market of
- 18:59the industry is children
- 19:027 to 12.
- 19:037 to 12.
- 19:06if you hook them early
- 19:08you have them for life
- 19:11yeah okay yeah I know and you know you
- 19:15they they're particular targeting of
- 19:18African-American Hispanic communities
- 19:20continue talking to girls women
- 19:23and of course those that are
- 19:27that just do it out of spite people who
- 19:30start now go pick up a pack of Lucky
- 19:32Strike
- 19:34I saw it there it's like it might blows
- 19:37your head off
- 19:39you know you mentioned the Netherlands
- 19:42and I know for a long time you thought
- 19:45and I'm paraphrasing what you said
- 19:47Europe was kind of a lost cause but the
- 19:51last time uh I was there it seemed to me
- 19:54that's been a number of years ago I was
- 19:56there but it seemed to me I saw fewer
- 19:58smokers there than I'd ever seen before
- 20:00yeah have have they made in as Western
- 20:03Europe Germany France Italy I just I
- 20:05didn't see it as much is have they
- 20:07reduced have they reduced it have they
- 20:10done that a worldwide tobacco companies
- 20:12Philip Morris Ronald Williamson or bat
- 20:15Industries continue doing what they're
- 20:18doing
- 20:22the lawsuits ended here in this country
- 20:25they were also exported overseas yeah
- 20:30and the awareness of what was going on
- 20:32through publications of their effort in
- 20:35a Wall Street Journal
- 20:37in the New York Times about how a
- 20:40cigarette was designed to addict and
- 20:43ultimately killed you
- 20:45that knowledge had never been out
- 20:47ever
- 20:48until 1994-95
- 20:53and so that knowledge filtered its way
- 20:56to Europe okay generally there's a lag
- 21:00time in Europe between the United States
- 21:02and what goes on in Europe about
- 21:04anywhere between three to five years
- 21:06years
- 21:08wow okay and you can go to Asia and
- 21:12particularly Japan the the
- 21:16shift who goes on here happens also five
- 21:19to ten years
- 21:22okay
- 21:24and I would say in Japan you have a
- 21:27unique
- 21:28Market segment is that nobody really
- 21:30starts really spoken in the late 1819.
- 21:33they're not getting the key
- 21:36but they have they have actively
- 21:38promoted charcoal filters removal all
- 21:41the poisons
- 21:43they have yeah
- 21:45do you remember tarrington
- 21:47Yeah by name block
- 21:51they had a club activated carbon fiber
- 21:55aspect of the filter
- 21:57which is supposed to capture and reduce
- 21:59aldehydes does it work
- 22:02yeah somewhat but not doesn't remove all
- 22:05of it
- 22:06the filter is only put on in the after
- 22:08the 19th well the 1950s built on his
- 22:12board up because when you spoke with
- 22:14cigarette without a filter you get a lot
- 22:16of little pieces of tobacco in your
- 22:18mouth right and some people saw the
- 22:21filter it was you think of something
- 22:23that says it's filtered what's the
- 22:26matter
- 22:28what comes to mind a filter yeah uh I
- 22:32think of something like
- 22:34um
- 22:34like a coffee filter
- 22:37yeah I think of something where it's
- 22:39it's basically blocking other items from
- 22:41coming through right
- 22:43yeah but a filtered
- 22:46in the late 50s and 60s and 70s did
- 22:50virtually nothing
- 22:52so it was a filter and a protector and
- 22:55name only and that but that's the
- 22:57imagery people got yeah
- 23:0050s you know the whole studies of
- 23:03window doll Etc about the link between
- 23:06smoking and lung cancer people got all
- 23:08rattled up
- 23:10what did you think about uh America's
- 23:14changing attitude towards the
- 23:16legalization of marijuana
- 23:18I have a real problem with it you do
- 23:21yeah I do why
- 23:24well first of all you're legalizing for
- 23:26profit
- 23:27an experimental product that's never
- 23:29been tested
- 23:31tell me where you've done a clinical
- 23:34trial
- 23:35tell me where you have done the
- 23:37statistical studies
- 23:40that allow you to say it's safe to use
- 23:44it's not marijuana has drastic effect on
- 23:47the brain tissue particularly of young
- 23:49people
- 23:51it doesn't say take pain away
- 23:55oh you don't think it's as a pain
- 23:56reliever no prove it to me
- 24:00um show me the data that's the gold
- 24:02standard of testing of a product
- 24:05well how do you necessarily prove and I
- 24:08need you to educate me on this when you
- 24:10say prove it to me that this isn't uh
- 24:13effective against pain relief
- 24:15isn't it isn't pain relief wouldn't that
- 24:18be sort of subjective it's the person
- 24:19who says yeah I I feel better now or I
- 24:22don't feel like there are ways of
- 24:24measuring it
- 24:26because I'm I'm I don't know what to
- 24:28think about it I I I think it was a cash
- 24:31grab by States for sure exactly and then
- 24:35companies that wanted to just make an
- 24:36ungodly amount of money are we what what
- 24:39would you guess yeah obviously it's not
- 24:41legalized everywhere doctor but if you
- 24:43had to guess
- 24:44not yet not yet no but it's coming it's
- 24:47it's like gambling it's kind of all
- 24:49these things are coming
- 24:51no what would you guess we're going to
- 24:54see the consequences of this
- 24:56legalization will look like in 15 years
- 24:59yeah I was going to say 10.
- 25:0215 to 20 years I think you'll see you
- 25:05can smoke a marijuana joint are you
- 25:07getting the same combustion product as
- 25:09you get with a cigarette
- 25:12that's what we're going to see yeah
- 25:15will it be the health care Fiasco that
- 25:19cigarettes proved to be and ultimately
- 25:21why that case was successful your case I
- 25:24think so
- 25:26when you've done that study who has done
- 25:29the work that just allowed people to run
- 25:32with nons unsubstantiated
- 25:36claims
- 25:38I mean I I well
- 25:41who would do the study some prominence
- 25:45yeah University
- 25:47the company is marketing a product an
- 25:50enormous profit
- 25:52why would they do this study
- 25:54I mean why would the company like what's
- 25:57the financial incentive for the company
- 26:00well your advertising product is safe
- 26:03you're advertising a product delivers
- 26:05you know
- 26:07THC that has no effect on you you could
- 26:11say you know
- 26:15risk and the only way you're going to
- 26:17convince me that it's useful
- 26:20is providing me the data that allows you
- 26:22to
- 26:23substantiate the claims that you've been
- 26:25made
- 26:27have you gotten in this debate with
- 26:29somebody who sits there and tries to oh
- 26:32yeah other side of the fence on you like
- 26:34what's what's their counter argument to
- 26:36your position
- 26:37you know Sanjay Gupta sure yeah I got
- 26:41the debate with him at the University of
- 26:43Buffalo medical school when I was
- 26:45getting
- 26:45a postgraduate award
- 26:47and his position was what
- 26:49he was very prone
- 26:52THC
- 26:54cannabis
- 26:56what does he think what did you think of
- 26:58his argument
- 27:00quite frankly I know you taping this I
- 27:01think it's [ __ ] it's okay
- 27:05it was [ __ ]
- 27:07we didn't have any data to support it he
- 27:11had one anecdotal data that started out
- 27:13of that lets thousands and thousands of
- 27:15people use it
- 27:17think about it
- 27:19no I I the one thing I don't I will
- 27:22never trust ever and I know you don't
- 27:26I'm not going to trust the company that
- 27:29has a financial stake in that product
- 27:31whatever it is
- 27:33Coca-Cola name it I'm not going to trust
- 27:37their study I'm not going to trust the
- 27:40oil company that just had an oil spill
- 27:43in the middle of wherever and if they
- 27:45hire a couple of uh ivy league you know
- 27:48environmental professors to sit there
- 27:50and say oh gee whiz we think in 30 years
- 27:52this is actually this spill is actually
- 27:54going to be good for the environment I
- 27:56want to see their bank account and I
- 27:57want to see the six figure check that
- 27:59they got from that oil company well the
- 28:01tobacco industry has many canceled
- 28:03checks from a prominent
- 28:06pathologist at Yale at Harvard I'm sure
- 28:10they was they paid them big bucks even
- 28:13it ever heard the name Gio Bata gory
- 28:16that one I'm not familiar with but Corey
- 28:19was a Nida employee who said that the
- 28:23best way
- 28:25to make cigarettes safer is to take out
- 28:28some of the hazards
- 28:30take out some of the additives that make
- 28:33it easy to become addicted it's
- 28:34substantially
- 28:38that's great so you know when when
- 28:41you're talking about now
- 28:43sounds to me like where we were America
- 28:46was with
- 28:49um cigarettes back in the 40s you know
- 28:51my dad's my dad's 90. he's from New York
- 28:54like yourself and he's from 90 and my
- 28:55mom my mom was a total was a was
- 28:58addicted to cigarettes for decades and I
- 29:00would hear stories from them both about
- 29:02how for a long time cigarettes were sold
- 29:05and marketed as very safe and very
- 29:08healthy
- 29:10White
- 29:12yeah so say doctors advertising the
- 29:16white coat right there
- 29:19so it took decades for America or the
- 29:23consumer to wake up and say well wait a
- 29:25minute maybe this isn't such a good idea
- 29:27a week going down the same in your
- 29:30prediction are we going down that same
- 29:32path with I think there are many
- 29:33similarities back many savannahs uh when
- 29:37you look at is so when it comes to
- 29:40cigarettes because I read this story
- 29:41about southeast Asia are cigarettes now
- 29:44mostly
- 29:46a third world and lower socioeconomic
- 29:49product
- 29:50that is correct
- 29:52hey it's easy to BS somebody's
- 29:55uneducated right okay it's easy to go
- 29:57and sell something that addicts people
- 29:59they have to come back for it
- 30:02uh when you look at what you did in the
- 30:0690s to that industry
- 30:09I think the prediction was Doctor was
- 30:12going to be an atomic bomb and Philip
- 30:14Morris and Reynolds and all these
- 30:16companies were just gonna not not go
- 30:18away but really really dramatically go
- 30:21through a major restructuring and
- 30:23downsizing and loss in profit did that
- 30:26happen
- 30:27some of it did but you have to realize
- 30:30that
- 30:31365 billion dollars to be paid over 25
- 30:35years by tobacco industry
- 30:38was supposed to be shared with the
- 30:39states 20 of that money to go into
- 30:43prevention
- 30:45treatment
- 30:47does not happen I could imagine how you
- 30:50can name the states on one hand that
- 30:53actually use the money
- 30:55or health cause related issues and like
- 30:59Kansas you're
- 31:01okay like that yeah it's my alma mater
- 31:04I know so I'm gonna tell you I was
- 31:06talking about Kansas
- 31:08took the money
- 31:10billions and what did they use it for
- 31:12roads
- 31:14roads Bridges libraries libraries okay
- 31:19so they built they bought some books
- 31:21that's good that's good and it wasn't so
- 31:24the 20 that is supposed to work how
- 31:26about Mississippi putting 20 in how
- 31:29about Florida
- 31:30what did Mississippi do it because they
- 31:32were Ground Zero for that for that case
- 31:35like what did they do with it take 20 to
- 31:38their money
- 31:393.8 billion dollars I believe
- 31:43and they took 20 of that they hired a
- 31:45nurse and they put education programs in
- 31:48Middle School
- 31:50would you say that was money well spent
- 31:52I think some of it's well spent I think
- 31:55it's good
- 31:56I mean
- 31:57I mean I I've been doing this now for 25
- 32:00odd years and the most effective part is
- 32:03going into a middle school
- 32:05of teaching the kids about it
- 32:07do they listen to you
- 32:09it's a middle school kid you never know
- 32:14oh you got this movie guy coming in and
- 32:16so but you can actually take them
- 32:18through you know quote and I tell them I
- 32:21showed the quote actually on the
- 32:22industry guy you know smoke this [ __ ]
- 32:24reserved from dumb the black the
- 32:26ignorant and the boy
- 32:28wow that's a the statement made by
- 32:33RJR marketing exactly
- 32:37you've never heard
- 32:39that statement was made you brought that
- 32:42for a second there I didn't I didn't no
- 32:44I know you didn't say it that was the
- 32:45executive of RJ Reynolds tobacco
- 32:49that is now married to bat Industries
- 32:52the parent company of brown Williamson
- 32:55so they they're continuing to do
- 32:58Club out okay
- 33:01they have maintained and Protected Their
- 33:03swap it my prices
- 33:06by price increases yeah yeah the whole
- 33:09cost of Philip Mars
- 33:12well the course of of the noise the
- 33:16settlement to them
- 33:18was gained back immediately by a 25
- 33:21increase
- 33:22on cigarettes
- 33:25so net net what do they what do they pay
- 33:28what did they pay I just covered their
- 33:30losses they were okay yep
- 33:33okay so you're 80 years old
- 33:36um what do you want to see in the next
- 33:3810 years in terms of anti-tobacco
- 33:42uh I don't I guess legislation or just
- 33:46societal attitudes I feel very
- 33:48frustrated in my own country do you yeah
- 33:51go look at Canada
- 33:54as you know I work for the minister of
- 33:56health of Canada I set up the whole
- 33:58program with tobacco and denormalization
- 34:00in Canada
- 34:03tobacco denormalization
- 34:05take take tobacco out of us normally
- 34:08accepted environments
- 34:10no smoking a restaurant cognitive
- 34:12awareness of what it does to you and the
- 34:15people around you
- 34:16who are the additives there for
- 34:19so Canada has gone from roughly 20
- 34:22smoking for almost nine percent wow
- 34:27so they put that program in place
- 34:30yeah lots of hey
- 34:33child children smoke-free environments
- 34:37okay
- 34:38when did you when did you put that
- 34:39program in place doctor
- 34:41wait yeah what year
- 34:4895 96 I
- 34:50so in about a 25 year about 25 years
- 34:53they've seen an 11 consumption
- 34:57it takes dedicated people money
- 35:01and elected officials to do the right
- 35:04thing
- 35:06I can't can you see that happening here
- 35:08that that means that you've got the fire
- 35:11bit of this and it started the whole
- 35:13thing
- 35:14started here and not in New York City
- 35:17New York state or Chicago it happened in
- 35:21Jackson Mississippi
- 35:25what do they think
- 35:29a lot of negative things civil war
- 35:33flagrant racism poverty uh bureaucracy
- 35:37that props up the city I mean name it
- 35:40none of it's I mean not not much of it's
- 35:42good bad water I mean on and on I so um
- 35:47you know when you look back on it now at
- 35:50tremendous cost to your personal life
- 35:53given the way the industry has shifted
- 35:55and morphed to cover its losses
- 35:59are you glad you did it
- 36:01hell yeah great I thank God you said
- 36:03that I was going to be scared you were
- 36:05going to say no it wasn't worth it I
- 36:07have New Zealand will Outlaw our tobacco
- 36:10products in this country in 2025.
- 36:13wow
- 36:15yeah I work with a New Zealand
- 36:17Parliament particularly but the native
- 36:20that was called the Mori they grow it
- 36:24they can use it
- 36:25thank you
- 36:27they can't buy a pack of cigarettes and
- 36:29that makes even more fun because New
- 36:32Zealand bat industry was building a new
- 36:34plan
- 36:35I'm sorry
- 36:37I think all that concrete and steel and
- 36:40shove it
- 36:42[Music]
- 36:44from
- 36:46tobacco Executives anymore do you ever
- 36:48get an email
- 36:50or in court
- 36:52but do you ever get threatened anymore
- 36:56doesn't scare me anymore I mean
- 37:00I I get Frets threats right uh
- 37:04electronic threats like I get physical
- 37:08threats
- 37:09uh I have had damage to my personal
- 37:12property by home
- 37:14it's always related to my testify and
- 37:18what's called the
- 37:20the penalty stage of litigation which
- 37:23looks at what kind of egregious conduct
- 37:26did you use for what happened that's
- 37:28mostly against the lawyers
- 37:32and they're not happy with me because
- 37:33that you get you can get damages per
- 37:37hundred thousand which would get
- 37:41the greatest Behavior
- 37:43or
- 37:45hundreds of thousand I know that's a
- 37:47significant amount of money yeah uh when
- 37:51you and I spoke a long time ago I still
- 37:53remember so much that interview just
- 37:55without even rereading it you told me
- 37:59back then when you were going through
- 38:01all that what really scared you was the
- 38:04prospect of going to jail which they had
- 38:07threatened you potentially with
- 38:09of all the times you have been
- 38:11threatened of all the things that you
- 38:12went through does that experience of
- 38:14being threatened to go to jail does that
- 38:16remain the thing that still scared you
- 38:18the most throughout after all these
- 38:19years
- 38:20well how about having two armed ex
- 38:23Secret Service
- 38:26Guardians
- 38:28who protected me daily
- 38:30opened my mail
- 38:32okay
- 38:34and then because I was scared of they
- 38:37started my car in the morning they
- 38:39followed me into school
- 38:41but the most
- 38:45scariest part was finding a bullet my
- 38:48mailbox address to my daughters
- 38:50they that was addressed to your daughter
- 38:52yeah
- 38:54I never knew that I thought the bullet
- 38:57was just in your mailbox I never knew
- 38:58that was addressed to your daughters God
- 39:00I can't imagine what you went through
- 39:02then in an envelope with a letter and a
- 39:05350
- 39:06a large epistle now Israeli cartridge
- 39:12primes and ready to go
- 39:15and that's good I carried a gun after
- 39:18that
- 39:19did you really
- 39:22uh I know you have children I remember
- 39:26you telling me when the movie premiere
- 39:27you took them to the movie and it gave
- 39:30them a better sense of what it was that
- 39:32you went through even if the movie
- 39:34wasn't maybe you know completely true
- 39:36but it was close enough that they got
- 39:38the point it was a thank you drama yeah
- 39:40well and yeah it was terrific it was a
- 39:41great movie since that time did you ever
- 39:44when as they got older did you ever sit
- 39:46down with them did they ever ask you or
- 39:48you could explain them why you did what
- 39:51you did and and what happened because
- 39:53they were young they were pretty young
- 39:54at the time and they were like
- 39:57five and seven
- 39:59I didn't have any idea I had no idea why
- 40:03you talked to him about it since then
- 40:05they've been with me in a number of
- 40:06events which I basically told the story
- 40:10and they got it I I don't
- 40:13you know the divorce was that pretty
- 40:16I remember you told me that yeah and my
- 40:19ex
- 40:21what do I call her I'm gonna be polite
- 40:24but she lives in Texas
- 40:27in Plano coming back I remember that
- 40:29yeah okay I don't know you know Jones
- 40:33Day a little firm uh-huh okay she worked
- 40:37with them
- 40:39accepted funding
- 40:40to stop the movie from being released
- 40:43because she felt that she was
- 40:46unreasonably characterized as
- 40:50a good a gold digger
- 40:54really I did not think the movie
- 40:56characterized her as that at all it
- 40:58characterized her as a someone who was
- 41:00angry at her husband for going through
- 41:02all that stuff as opposed to just taking
- 41:04the money and living in Louisville in a
- 41:06nice house
- 41:07yeah
- 41:09one nice house to another nice house
- 41:11uh so all right what do you we've got
- 41:15time for one or probably one more
- 41:16question doctor how much time do you
- 41:18have about three more minutes about
- 41:21about three more minutes no this has
- 41:22been great uh you're always wildly
- 41:24entertaining so for the uh for the
- 41:26person out there let's let's think about
- 41:28attacking a parent attacking someone
- 41:30we're addressing a parent a parent has a
- 41:33child who they know now is experimenting
- 41:36in marijuana use or vaping or cigarettes
- 41:40how should the parent talk to the child
- 41:43to dissuade them from using it hopefully
- 41:46a parent that's going to provide the
- 41:47advice that a child has doesn't use the
- 41:50stuff okay
- 41:52second is
- 41:54become knowledgeable
- 41:57there are many houses out there that
- 41:59that you can learn about by
- 42:02learning from it
- 42:03teaching okay there is there is a whole
- 42:06process of creating knowledge in
- 42:09children in the third grade I do it I
- 42:12know it
- 42:13I watched them with their input
- 42:15afterwards and if I tested their
- 42:18questions
- 42:19okay
- 42:20um and what they've absorbed
- 42:22showing that secondhand smoke is not
- 42:25nothing taken in a smoke chamber I have
- 42:28a smoking Sally
- 42:30um
- 42:31device we should smoke a cigarette
- 42:33Inside by popping it and watch the
- 42:35windows of the glass of the poly Pro uh
- 42:38probably polycarbonate
- 42:40[Music]
- 42:41build up and then I go in and wipe it
- 42:45then they get to see that what's on the
- 42:48walls in terms of having the same thing
- 42:50in a smoke-free environment is things
- 42:53that you'll breathe
- 42:56and we know that there's an equivalency
- 42:59between active and passive smoking
- 43:03you do die for Passive smoke you do die
- 43:06from passive smoking that means you're
- 43:09breathing somebody else's secret when
- 43:11you choose not to breathe or swallow
- 43:14do you remember the days when we used to
- 43:17have smoking sections in airplanes yeah
- 43:19it was crazy yeah it's the same as an
- 43:21opening pool
- 43:24uh I really want to thank you for your
- 43:26time today and and all the time that
- 43:28I've bugged you in the past you remain
- 43:30absolutely my favorite interview and
- 43:32I've I've been fortunate to interview
- 43:33some really interesting people in my
- 43:35life I there's no one more interesting
- 43:37uh or courageous than I've ever
- 43:39interviewed than you and I wish you the
- 43:41very best of continued good health and
- 43:43continued success in your fight and what
- 43:46is a worthy endeavor
- 43:48I think so it's like going
- 43:51fantastic take care of yourself doctor
- 43:53I'll be in touch have a happy holiday
- 43:55have a safe holiday news
- 43:58I will thanks doctor take care
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of America's most courageous insider, Dr. Jeffrey Wigand by Engel Angle, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,084 words across 1,032 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.