Amelia Dyer: The Woman Who Only Killed New Borns (Female Murder Documentary) | Absolute Crime — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00you going to mug me I I going to mug you
- 0:02is that gorgeous or what e and I believe
- 0:05I can run a de American download V
- 0:10[Applause]
- 0:12now welcome to the Dark World of the
- 0:15lady killers
- 0:17[Music]
- 0:21[Applause]
- 0:23[Music]
- 0:24[Applause]
- 0:26[Music]
- 0:45why do people
- 0:47kill if there's one thing I've learned
- 0:49in my time as a crime writer it's that
- 0:51there are a million and one motives for
- 0:53murder but in the case of a serial
- 0:56killer what could be the motive for not
- 0:58one but a lifetime time of
- 1:01murders
- 1:02power
- 1:04corruption
- 1:05blackmail or maybe the most common one
- 1:08of all
- 1:10money or more precisely
- 1:15greed this is Amelia D perhaps Britain's
- 1:19most prolific serial killer a woman who
- 1:21is notorious for many years but whose
- 1:23name is barely known
- 1:25today she was no all painting but there
- 1:28are many more reasons why would be hard
- 1:30to paint a pretty picture of The Life
- 1:32and Times of Amelia Dy Amelia Dy killed
- 1:35for money nothing KN in that even in
- 1:38Victorian England but what is
- 1:40astonishing about Amelia is that all of
- 1:42her victims were
- 1:44newborns Amelia D delivered fostered and
- 1:47adopted illegitimate babies for
- 1:51money if you gave her 5s and the baby
- 1:56she would take the baby and either have
- 1:58it adopted
- 2:00or raise it
- 2:02herself but of course what she really
- 2:04did was kill it and take the
- 2:115B Amelia D was a murderer and she knew
- 2:15what she was doing this was a calculated
- 2:17career plan that she'd embarked on and
- 2:19sustained over 30 years come what
- 2:23may she say she felt peaceful after she
- 2:26put the baby's body in the river she
- 2:28used to look at them and dve some kind
- 2:30of pleasure and some kind of perverted
- 2:32maternal perspective on these babies who
- 2:34she just killed you know as as they're
- 2:36lying there she gets some kind of
- 2:39glue using many aliases and addresses
- 2:42Amelia D evaded detection for decades
- 2:45despite complaints of police in the
- 2:46pursuit of young mothers desperate to
- 2:48know the fate of their babies she
- 2:51disposed of a lot of them straight away
- 2:53by throwing them in in rivers but we
- 2:56also believe that she kept hold of the
- 2:58parcels for a while while until the
- 3:00body's decomposed so that there would be
- 3:02no chance of the babies being traced
- 3:04back to
- 3:06her the letters that survived tell of an
- 3:09articulate persuasive and plausible
- 3:11woman rather than a Savage butcher who
- 3:13killed and killed again for a period of
- 3:1530 years she wrote These adverts that
- 3:18would were very cleverly crafted saying
- 3:20that the child would be looked after and
- 3:22they'd been wanting a child for a long
- 3:24time and it would be loved it would be a
- 3:26caring home all these things were
- 3:28hitting exactly the right buttons for a
- 3:30young mom who you know was giving a
- 3:32child
- 3:35up in 1896 Amilia D's career caught up
- 3:39with her the body of a baby that she had
- 3:41adopted and murdered was found in a
- 3:43package dumped in the river and was
- 3:44traced back to her
- 3:46address at the time of her arrest Amelia
- 3:49D was 56 a stocky middle-aged woman with
- 3:52gray and brown hair the ordinariness of
- 3:54the picture betraying an evil
- 3:57within cold heart
- 4:02unfearing those kids meant nothing to
- 4:04her it was just a means of getting
- 4:10money upon her arrest it emerged that
- 4:13she' narly escaped discovery on several
- 4:15occasions even preferring to be
- 4:17committed as insane rather than face up
- 4:19to her
- 4:21crimes I don't think ailia D was insane
- 4:25I think she was a very bad person
- 4:30who
- 4:31deliberately committed murder for
- 4:35profit I am fascinated by milia dial not
- 4:38just because of the Savage nature of her
- 4:40crimes and the innocence of the victims
- 4:43but also because of the sheer
- 4:45volume this was a 30-year career um and
- 4:49at her worst we know that there were six
- 4:51babies a day various other points six
- 4:53babies a week even if this was one
- 4:55infant death a month over 30 years
- 4:57looking at 400
- 5:01but who was Amelia
- 5:03Dyer and what made her kill this
- 5:05shocking number of children over such a
- 5:07long period of time and how could such
- 5:10horrific crimes be so very easily
- 5:16forgotten as a crime author I'm
- 5:19intrigued by what circumstances and
- 5:21forces combine to create crimes and
- 5:24criminals and nowhere is this more
- 5:26gripping than in the story of the 19th
- 5:28century baby killer Amelia
- 5:31D Amelia D prematurely ended the lives
- 5:35of an estimated 400
- 5:37babies I'm interested to know what would
- 5:40prompt this woman to richly kill baby
- 5:42she was being paid to look
- 5:45after I want to find out all that I can
- 5:48about the real Amelia di but because she
- 5:51lived in Victorian times there are
- 5:53actually no living Witnesses and know
- 5:56people who are close to her so I'm going
- 5:58to start my search with all that's left
- 6:00of
- 6:05her this is temps Valley Police Museum
- 6:08and all the evidence relating to Amelia
- 6:10diary is kept here so I'm going to go
- 6:12through now and see what they've
- 6:20got Kim who was Amelia D um Mrs D was a
- 6:25lady who set up quite a lucrative
- 6:29business
- 6:30of fostering children that couldn't be
- 6:33looked after by the mother or father and
- 6:38she would adopt them for a fee for
- 6:40looking after the child which could be
- 6:43something like
- 6:4520340 I know you shouldn't sort of
- 6:48accuse people because of what they look
- 6:49like but she does look like quite a
- 6:51Stern person doesn't she I don't know if
- 6:54I'll be quite happy leaving any of my
- 6:55children with no
- 6:59[Music]
- 7:01Amelia D's lifetime was Victorian
- 7:03England a time of social extremes where
- 7:05person's life chances were randomly
- 7:07dictated by factors of class and wealth
- 7:10Dickens did a really good job of
- 7:12describing social conditions in the
- 7:151850s and 60s certainly there were a lot
- 7:19of poor people there were a lot of
- 7:22neglected and abandoned
- 7:24[Music]
- 7:26children Victoria in England has been
- 7:28recorded as a time when Family Values
- 7:30were a priority and it's a period that
- 7:33Margaret Thatcher revered and tried to
- 7:35revive in the 1980s but a close
- 7:37examination of the history of that
- 7:39period paints a very different
- 7:43picture there was no work there was no
- 7:46social services there was no
- 7:49welfare one in every 12 women was a
- 7:52prostitute a child being born under
- 7:55normal circumstances only had a 50%
- 7:58chance of reaching age of five so that's
- 8:01how bad it was dead infants or abandoned
- 8:05infants were as common place on the
- 8:07streets of British cities as roadkill
- 8:10today babies were found parcel up in
- 8:12Railway stations under Railway
- 8:17arches it was desperation by the vast
- 8:20majority of these ladies the whole
- 8:22illegitimacy thing was seen as hugely
- 8:25immoral even orphanages would only
- 8:28accept orphans from families where the
- 8:31parents were married and the father had
- 8:32died they wouldn't accept a child who
- 8:35was born out of wedlock by the mid 1800s
- 8:38Victorian society was facing widespread
- 8:41poverty and a rising illegitimacy
- 8:42epidemic and new laws were needed to
- 8:45address these problems in 1834 the
- 8:48British government passed the PO law
- 8:50Amendment act and this was one of those
- 8:52spectacular pieces of Victorian wisdom
- 8:55aimed at preventing premarital relations
- 8:58because what it did was to actually
- 8:59exacerbate an already existing problem
- 9:02because men could father illegitimate
- 9:05children and not be expected to pay for
- 9:08the consequences leaving women stranded
- 9:11completely abortion was not an option
- 9:15that most people considered so the
- 9:17simplest thing to do was hide have the
- 9:21baby and get rid of it pay somebody to
- 9:24take care of it or pay somebody to get
- 9:27rid of it
- 9:29designed to protect the sanctity of
- 9:31family life the illegitimacy laws would
- 9:33backfire and create new social problems
- 9:36the biggest one of these would turn out
- 9:38to be the baby
- 9:39Farmers so clim what was exactly baby
- 9:42farming baby farming was a business
- 9:47carried out throughout the
- 9:50country uh whereby if a mother was
- 9:54unable to look after their child there
- 9:57was an option of sending it to a baby
- 10:00farmer or or known as fostering uh on
- 10:03the understanding that they could go and
- 10:05visit the child whenever they wanted to
- 10:08farming out literally is where the
- 10:10expression comes from either on a weekly
- 10:12fee in which case they're referred to as
- 10:13nurse children or on a permanent basis
- 10:16for a oneoff sum they were actually
- 10:19providing a service legitimate ones they
- 10:22were what the Ware does today you would
- 10:25take a a child that was abandoned or was
- 10:28not wanted
- 10:29and then give them to a foster parent
- 10:32and that's what these people were doing
- 10:33for
- 10:35money established to assist with the
- 10:37adoption and fostering of children baby
- 10:39farming was a lucrative practice while
- 10:42many acted in good faith it was
- 10:43unregulated and unpoled and therefore
- 10:46open to
- 10:47exploitation had the bad ones like aad
- 10:51who started getting rid of the children
- 10:53they couldn't pass on to other foster
- 10:55parents you took the babies in you got
- 10:58quite a a reasonable feed
- 10:59and then you didn't do anything with
- 11:00them you let them die of starvation or
- 11:02or you hasten their
- 11:06end Amelia D would become the most
- 11:09notorious baby farmer of them all born
- 11:12in Bristol far from the poverty of a day
- 11:14nothing in her background would point to
- 11:16the path she would
- 11:18take for the time she had a pretty good
- 11:21start her father had a good trade and
- 11:23paid for her to go to a church run
- 11:26school um which at the time only a
- 11:28quarter of children her age actually got
- 11:31an education so she was privileged in
- 11:33that
- 11:38respect blessed with a comfortable
- 11:40childhood in the Bristol suburbs life
- 11:43would change dramatically for Amelia
- 11:45when her mother contracted typhus fever
- 11:47and suffered from violent hallucinations
- 11:50and delusions she witnessed her mother
- 11:52basically losing her mind and dying a
- 11:54slow horrific death and I guess being a
- 11:57a young girl she may have even been
- 11:59called called upon to you know nurse her
- 12:00mother slightly or at least wait upon
- 12:02her despite her young age at the time
- 12:05her mother's illness and death would be
- 12:06a defining influence on the rest of
- 12:08Amelia's life Amelia was later to claim
- 12:12that mother died as a result of of
- 12:14hereditary Insanity um and I think
- 12:17though this isn't true it's really easy
- 12:19to understand how she could have
- 12:21remembered it that way it would
- 12:23certainly have a massive impact on her
- 12:25and she may have learned a few little
- 12:27things about what kind of symptoms may
- 12:29be shown by someone who's losing their
- 12:34mind the enjoing memory of the severity
- 12:37of her mother's illness and the early
- 12:38demand to be a carer may have also
- 12:40influenced her choice to train as a
- 12:42nurse at the Bristol Royal infirmary
- 12:44Amelia turned to one of the most arduous
- 12:47professions she could have turned to
- 12:49nursing was just starting to change it
- 12:51was post Crimean War nursing was
- 12:53starting to have a much better profile
- 12:56um as a result of Florence Nightingale
- 12:59but it was still a thankless
- 13:04profession it wasn't such a caring
- 13:06profession as it is present day they
- 13:08train you psychologically to be a lot
- 13:10more robust around dealing with people
- 13:13so she became quite Hardy and
- 13:15emotionless from having been trained
- 13:18through the nursing
- 13:25regime in
- 13:271864 26-year-old Amelia fell pregnant
- 13:30with her first child women were not
- 13:32allowed to continue working once their
- 13:34pregnancies began to show so Amelia left
- 13:38nursing but it wouldn't be long before
- 13:40she discovered another way of putting
- 13:41her train into use when a young woman
- 13:43called Ellen Dayne came to border at her
- 13:46[Music]
- 13:48house Ellen Dayne was a
- 13:50midwife but she earned additional money
- 13:55taking in women who were illegitimate
- 13:57who wanted to keep their pregnancies
- 13:58quiet
- 14:00and she offered the additional service
- 14:02of then adopting The Unwanted offspring
- 14:05of these women she was a baby
- 14:10farmer Amelia could see it was a very
- 14:12easy way to make money although with
- 14:15risks involved obviously and you know
- 14:17milia did have training as a midwife as
- 14:19well through her nursing experience so
- 14:22it was certainly something that she knew
- 14:23she was capable of
- 14:25doing that was the beginning of a
- 14:29massive change in in the direction
- 14:30Amelia's life was to
- 14:33take the influence of Ellen D would take
- 14:36a few years to incubate but surface when
- 14:39Amelia's husband George Thomas died and
- 14:42she was faced with a hard realities of
- 14:44being a single mother in Victorian
- 14:46England aware of the rich pickings the
- 14:48trade could generate Amelia decided to
- 14:50open a baby Farm but first she made a
- 14:53chilling and telling decision
- 14:57[Music]
- 15:02it was a choice that she made she had
- 15:04options she could have kept her child
- 15:06she could have worked through but
- 15:08instead what she does is to farm her own
- 15:10child out and to opt for the easy money
- 15:14that she'd seen elen Dayne able to make
- 15:16mommy is everything going to be
- 15:19okay as Amelia chose to go into the baby
- 15:23farming business she was maybe you know
- 15:25traveling Around Here There and
- 15:26Everywhere adopting babies so it made
- 15:28sense for her daughter to be out of the
- 15:35wayed come
- 15:39[Music]
- 15:41on on any day in any newspaper Ed would
- 15:44run soliciting for the weekly monthly or
- 15:47even yearly care of infants all aimed at
- 15:49the mothers of illegitimate babies who
- 15:51wouldn't be able to work with the added
- 15:53liability of a child in
- 15:561846 Amelia's ad started to appear along
- 15:58alongside the rest she opened the doors
- 16:00as a as a House of confinement accepting
- 16:04women at the point where their pregnancy
- 16:05was no longer concealable um and seeing
- 16:08them right through to the delivery of
- 16:10the child and then just as DNE had done
- 16:12either saying goodbye to mother and
- 16:14child offering to keep the child on a
- 16:17weekly fee or a permanent adoption for a
- 16:20much more considerable
- 16:23[Music]
- 16:25fee by the mid 19th century the
- 16:28estimated to be almost 2,000 baby
- 16:31farmers in London alone such was the
- 16:33supply of illegitimate babies and many
- 16:36like Amelia recruited mothers through
- 16:38charming and persuasive
- 16:40correspondents this one
- 16:43here is an advert that she read in the
- 16:49local paper yeah whereby uh a lady is
- 16:53asking is anybody available to Foster
- 16:56her child and she wrote a letter to the
- 16:59lady saying that she was prepared to uh
- 17:03Foster this child well I do like the bit
- 17:06here where she said I do really want a
- 17:08nice baby I don't mind boy or girl I
- 17:10would love either and I don't mind a
- 17:13small sum to pay for it so she obviously
- 17:16must have had quite a nice way with her
- 17:17for these people to trust
- 17:19her Amelia was already aware of the fact
- 17:22that this was not going to be her
- 17:23helping children this was going to be a
- 17:25fairly cruel and anti-m mothering act uh
- 17:29that would be taken that would be
- 17:31actually carried out in order to gain
- 17:33all this
- 17:34money life in the baby Farms would have
- 17:36been Grim domestic dormet is housing ill
- 17:39and sickly babies showing the results of
- 17:41a Savage
- 17:42practice baby farmers use different
- 17:44methods that I know of some of which are
- 17:48less palatable than others quite often
- 17:52she would smother babies at Birth
- 17:54suffocating the baby at the moment it
- 17:56its head came out so that it um
- 17:59didn't turn blue because that was a sign
- 18:01that it had taken its first breath so it
- 18:03would look like a still birth so the
- 18:05death certificate would be all above
- 18:07board the one-off premiums were
- 18:10certainly not enough to sustain a
- 18:12child's life for long financially and
- 18:15the only way that it would be profitable
- 18:17for a baby farmer was to subject a child
- 18:20to persistent underfeeding that would at
- 18:24some point bring about the infant's
- 18:26death
- 18:28[Music]
- 18:29and of course a hungry child is a noisy
- 18:31child is a difficult child to raise um
- 18:34and what they referred to was something
- 18:35that was chillingly referred to
- 18:37colloquially as the quietness this was
- 18:39an over-the-counter anticolic cordial
- 18:42and it did contain liquid opium which
- 18:45was linum and in some cases
- 18:50Brandy people gave babies Lum who were
- 18:53supposed to be giving them food because
- 18:56it DED the I guess D the need or the
- 19:00awareness of the baby that it was hungry
- 19:03of course it didn't nourish the baby So
- 19:05eventually a baby that was given that
- 19:07and not given enough food would
- 19:14[Music]
- 19:21die Amelia you know would have been
- 19:24quite drawn to the idea of
- 19:26self-medicating if you like um possibly
- 19:29seeing it as a root you know to to ease
- 19:31the situation to make it even easier for
- 19:33her to put up with what she was
- 19:38doing she took it on a regular basis she
- 19:40took it you know almost daily so she was
- 19:42an addict so that would you know induce
- 19:45a form of um you know state from her
- 19:48mentally where she'd be detached from
- 19:50reality and I think that was part of her
- 19:52coping mechanism to detach from you know
- 19:54reality of what she was doing
- 19:58[Music]
- 20:03by the end of the
- 20:041860s the scale of the national
- 20:06infanticide epidemic had started to get
- 20:08noticed by Parliament and the pressure
- 20:10was on for Action the high-profile
- 20:13arrest of brickton baby farmer Margaret
- 20:16Waters in 1870 threatened Amelia's
- 20:19livelihood Margaret Waters had The
- 20:22Misfortune to be
- 20:24caught uh having killed somebody's baby
- 20:30who actually didn't want the baby
- 20:32killed Margaret Waters and her sister
- 20:35were investigated and it was found that
- 20:37four other babies had died of neglect in
- 20:40their care in a very short
- 20:43period what the marget waters case did
- 20:46was to confront British Society the
- 20:49ruling classes with the scale of the
- 20:51problem of infanti side and baby farming
- 20:54so that it could no longer be ignored it
- 20:56turned it into a scandal for the first
- 20:58time and somebody had to hang and guilty
- 21:01or not Margaret Waters had to
- 21:03hang during the course of the trial
- 21:06there was evidence brought forth that
- 21:07connected Amelia D to Margaret Walters
- 21:10Amelia had worked under the pseudonyms
- 21:12of Mrs Harding and Mrs Smith and both
- 21:15names were mentioned at the Old Bailey
- 21:16hearing and as a result in the Press
- 21:19aware that her brutal business could be
- 21:22exposed Amelia went into hiding she saw
- 21:25colleagues beginning to struggle Ellen
- 21:28danne
- 21:29had fled the country to the states
- 21:30pursued by the police Waters had hanged
- 21:34and so she gave up baby farming and
- 21:36moved into the anonymity of the Asylum
- 21:38as an
- 21:39[Music]
- 21:41attendant come on it's Time come on she
- 21:45was a very clever lady with the police
- 21:49getting close to her then she needed to
- 21:51lose herself and what what better place
- 21:54but to go to somewhere like that
- 22:00for a time it looked like Amelia was a
- 22:02reformed woman she married again to
- 22:04William Dy in 1872 and settled down into
- 22:07a standard Family
- 22:12Life their attempts to establish their
- 22:14self- sustaining life however were
- 22:16disastrous I've lost my job and when yet
- 22:19another business venture failed Amelia
- 22:21was once again back on the
- 22:25farm once he loses his job that's it she
- 22:27seems to go you know straight back into
- 22:29it big
- 22:31time it would be easy to argue that
- 22:33Amelia is the victim the hard times
- 22:36forer to ever Desperate Measures but it
- 22:39wouldn't explain why she would return as
- 22:40a more menacing murderer time and time
- 22:43[Music]
- 22:44again committed what many serial killers
- 22:48um do uh the mistake of accelerating and
- 22:52being over enthusiastic either for
- 22:54reasons that she was you know either
- 22:56enjoying the process or qu simply greed
- 22:59was driving her over the
- 23:01edge as the pressure was increased
- 23:03across the country for raising the
- 23:05standards and conditions of infant care
- 23:08Amelia's practices once again came under
- 23:10police scrutiny when four of her nurse
- 23:12children died within the space of two
- 23:14weeks suspicions were aroused and
- 23:17inquests were ordered into the
- 23:21death convinced that the full extent of
- 23:23her criminal career will be exposed in
- 23:25the cult Amelia D decided on a very
- 23:28different
- 23:30ending Amelia Dar took a massive Lord
- 23:34overdose she was found to have emptied
- 23:37two bottles of
- 23:39lham during the process and she was
- 23:41raging she was
- 23:44delusional and her favorite phrase at
- 23:47the time I took about the right amount
- 23:49I'm part doctor myself it was certainly
- 23:51a dose that was sufficient enough to
- 23:54have carried her off she very nearly
- 23:56died but the fact that she survived it
- 23:58at all is a very strong indication that
- 24:01she had a prior tolerance to the
- 24:03drug she certainly did genuinely tried
- 24:06to kill herself um because that it was
- 24:10you know it had all fallen down around
- 24:11her that was it she was you know she was
- 24:14caught two bottles of lorda would have
- 24:16killed most people but not Amelia D she
- 24:20had come close but her failed attempt to
- 24:22take her own life was to prove a costly
- 24:24mistake both for her own immediate
- 24:26future and the countless children
- 24:28children who would subsequently die by
- 24:30her
- 24:34hand Amilia Dy is one of the most
- 24:36prolific British serial killers D lived
- 24:39in the 19th century England and had a
- 24:41Savage and brutal career as a baby
- 24:43farmer taking advantage of the fact that
- 24:45illegitimate babies lives were all but
- 24:47worthless in Victorian
- 24:50Britain Amelia D fosted an adopted
- 24:52babies and then she killed them for
- 24:55profit the more children she murdered
- 24:57the more money she
- 24:59made in 1879 the police had a chance to
- 25:02nail her as a coldblooded murderer
- 25:04Amelia Dy had been arrested after four
- 25:07of her infants had died suspiciously
- 25:09within the space of two weeks the
- 25:12inquests are held both in the city and
- 25:14in sumerset and they're pretty certain
- 25:17that these babies have died as a direct
- 25:19result of neglect an opium overdose but
- 25:22they can't prove it and interestingly
- 25:25she gets off with a six-month sentence
- 25:28of with hard labor Amelia was charged
- 25:32under the infant Life protection act
- 25:34where the prosecution were required to
- 25:36prove that she was aware that the opiate
- 25:38she administered would cause death
- 25:40rather than a CIS sleep the difference
- 25:43between a murderer or carried away Cara
- 25:46she managed to side step The Gallows but
- 25:48without a sympathetic
- 25:51coroner she'd have been hanged in
- 25:571879 it's incredible really that she
- 25:59just got 6 months there was one example
- 26:02we read of a chap who got sentenced to
- 26:0412 months for stealing a piece of
- 26:08bacon in the long term it mostly would
- 26:11have served as a very hard lesson in
- 26:14forensic awareness that she wasn't going
- 26:16to get caught again and there was no way
- 26:19she was going to leave any evidence
- 26:20which had been the problem leading up to
- 26:23her
- 26:25capture at this point in her life Amelia
- 26:29is 46 if the calculation of her killing
- 26:31spr is correct her toll of murders would
- 26:34have reached
- 26:35100 I want to know how she was capable
- 26:38of abusing and then killing innocent
- 26:40babies dependent infants that look to
- 26:43her for life I also want to know why she
- 26:46repeatedly returned to Baby farming
- 26:48could it have been more than pure
- 26:51greed there was obviously more to it
- 26:54than just the money there was something
- 26:55else about her that was enabling her her
- 26:58to commit these horrific
- 27:01crimes could Amelia Dyer have been
- 27:03fueled and simultaneously numbed by the
- 27:06lordin them and alcohol cocktail she was
- 27:08administering certainly the drugs would
- 27:10have had an impact on her without a
- 27:12doubt on her mental state maybe induced
- 27:15you know this complete Detachment from
- 27:19reality a long-term Lord and habit will
- 27:23lead to periods of of depression they
- 27:25can lead to mood swings even when you're
- 27:27not Under the Influence I think it also
- 27:30exacerbates any underlying mental health
- 27:33issues if you accept you had the mental
- 27:35illness did it contribute to her
- 27:37criminal Behavior or could it be that
- 27:40they coexisted and I tend to think that
- 27:42her criminal Behavior which went on for
- 27:44such a long time and it it's done in
- 27:46such a calculated way uh wasn't related
- 27:48to her to her mental illness the actual
- 27:53killing of the child and watching the
- 27:55child peacefully to some degree die it
- 27:57paral
- 27:58perhaps seeing her mother U pass away
- 28:01where she felt an almost Godlike power
- 28:04over these children uh that she had
- 28:06decided we're going to go to their
- 28:10maker by 1884 pressure was mounting for
- 28:13the reform of the laws on infant care
- 28:15and baby farming was becoming a very
- 28:18Risky Business there was just a change
- 28:21in the public attitude and it was more
- 28:23risky because you were more likely to be
- 28:25reported if you were seen you know with
- 28:27a with with an obviously looking sickly
- 28:30or abused child she couldn't have all
- 28:33these neglected children lying around
- 28:36anymore she definitely changes her her
- 28:38modus operand at this point she
- 28:41doesn't use the slow neglect she's
- 28:44beginning to to murder these children by
- 28:48strangulation Amelia's murderous method
- 28:51had become ritual she had developed a
- 28:53precise practice that chillingly
- 28:55maximized the efficiency of her limited
- 28:57resources
- 28:59but that was as casual for her as it was
- 29:05routine she would go to the town where
- 29:07she was to collect the baby
- 29:10from get the
- 29:13money take the baby get
- 29:17home take out some
- 29:21tape tie the tape around the baby's
- 29:24neck and pull
- 29:27[Music]
- 29:29baby would stop
- 29:32breathing she would wrap the baby in a
- 29:35package of brown paper tie it up with
- 29:40string and drop it into the
- 29:43penss with a
- 29:46brick the idea of strangling and using
- 29:49the tape may seem almost symbolic or or
- 29:52bizarre to to to ourselves but in terms
- 29:55of criminal awareness she was aware of
- 29:57the the fact that if she' tried to
- 29:59suffocate a baby it's not always
- 30:01absolutely certain that the baby is dead
- 30:03and tape around the neck meant that
- 30:05child was never going to come round
- 30:06again the first however many times when
- 30:09it's a new thing it's probably you know
- 30:12a difficult process without a doubt but
- 30:14the more she does it the more
- 30:16desensitized she is to doing it and I
- 30:19think for her is all she kept in her
- 30:21mind was the end result which was
- 30:24getting the money and you know bringing
- 30:26the next baby in and the next baby in
- 30:29Amelia also made a routine of her
- 30:30Recruitment and responded daily to
- 30:32notices in the papers by now she was
- 30:34deliberately targeting children from
- 30:36wealthy families where the financial
- 30:38return would be greater but climbing the
- 30:40social ladder as a baby farmer brought
- 30:42new risks Amelia was taking on the
- 30:45babies of educated people people who
- 30:47would not be so easy to Due pomis lead
- 30:51in 1890 young Governor discovered to her
- 30:53cost that Amelia D was not the good
- 30:55mother she promised or appeared to be
- 30:58this young woman would be the beginning
- 31:00of the undoing of Amelia
- 31:07D this was a young governor who had
- 31:11fallen in love with the young Master of
- 31:12the House that she worked in and and and
- 31:14had got
- 31:17pregnant she was left on her own and she
- 31:20responds to an advert gets in touch with
- 31:22Amelia D and moves in with
- 31:26her Amelia was eight able to gain the
- 31:29trust of this woman as with many others
- 31:31and um so much so that the governor was
- 31:34persuaded to leave her baby in the care
- 31:36of Amelia once once it was
- 31:41born a couple of months later the
- 31:43governor returned to pay the final
- 31:48payment Amelia arrives cradling a baby
- 31:51that the governor knows is not her own
- 31:53this is a two three-month old child and
- 31:55she knows this isn't her child
- 31:58Amelia tries to fobber off infants
- 32:00change a great deal in three months she
- 32:02tells her but the governor strips the
- 32:04baby's clothes looking for a birth milk
- 32:06on on her child's hip which of course
- 32:08isn't there coming back tomorrow and I
- 32:09want my
- 32:10[Music]
- 32:17baby but this was a tragedy that was far
- 32:19from over like many mothers before her
- 32:23the governor's repeatedly tried to
- 32:24reclaim her child from Amelia even
- 32:26bringing the police with her on several
- 32:29occasions well miss we have a problem
- 32:32this but each time Amelia made her
- 32:34familiar excuses no that's not my
- 32:36despite knowing that the baby in
- 32:37question had died a long time before and
- 32:40by her own hand situation SED see you
- 32:43next week she managed to put them off
- 32:45Time and Time Again by sending them on
- 32:47Wild Goose chases pretending the baby
- 32:49had been adopted by a couple that lived
- 32:50here a couple that lived there
- 32:52relocation relocation relocation just
- 32:55one of the ways Amelia D managed to
- 32:57evade the authority
- 32:58aided and abetted by an endless stream
- 33:00of alyses and a cruel ability to string
- 33:03innocent parents long
- 33:04indefinitely with the governor on a
- 33:06trail Amelia D is once again under a
- 33:09spotlight and Under
- 33:12Pressure she did feel hounded and hunted
- 33:15for a good many years whichever way she
- 33:17turned eventually there'd be a knock on
- 33:19the door with the governor and and a
- 33:20police officer and I'm sure that would
- 33:22have had an impact on her she would have
- 33:24felt that
- 33:25pressure the governor certainly raises
- 33:29the very real Prospect of of another
- 33:31prison sentence and that does seem to
- 33:33have a dramatic effect on Amelia's
- 33:35mental
- 33:35[Music]
- 33:39stability she suddenly has these period
- 33:42where she turns completely iral
- 33:44threatened suicide the doctor was called
- 33:46in and she flew at
- 33:49him she was hearing voices the birds are
- 33:52telling me to do it to do it um yes
- 33:55seemingly having a bit of an episode so
- 33:58much so that she was sent to an
- 34:02asylum but is she mental on metic
- 34:05Amelia's breakdown seemed to be time to
- 34:07coincide with a possible capture and
- 34:09also provided her of a convenient escape
- 34:12to get into a Victorian asum you needed
- 34:14a medical certificate and you needed the
- 34:16magistrate agree into it so you couldn't
- 34:17just walk in uh so I think at those
- 34:21stages uh she she was uh she was
- 34:26unwell her breakdowns were very
- 34:28shortlived even if she did kind of have
- 34:30a bit of an emotional collapse it was
- 34:32very very very short period of time and
- 34:33then she picked herself up and got it
- 34:36all back together again so I mean to me
- 34:38that would say that there isn't a mental
- 34:40illness
- 34:42there she should never fell apart while
- 34:44she was killing children she never fell
- 34:46apart while she was disposing of bodies
- 34:48um she only fell apart when it looked
- 34:51like there might be a confrontation with
- 34:53the
- 34:54law from the Asylum Amelia was
- 34:56eventually trans ferred back to the
- 34:58workhouse in 1895 but it's clear that
- 35:01even here she was plotting a comeback
- 35:03she befriends an old lady called Jane
- 35:05Smith who's widowed and she's resigned
- 35:08to spending her last days in the
- 35:10workhouse and Amelia seduces her really
- 35:12with stories of rescuing The Unwanted
- 35:14infants of single mothers and nursing
- 35:17them and it's a very very seductive
- 35:19image and Jane Smith buys into it
- 35:24wholesale Amelia's clever plot thickened
- 35:27she groomed Jane Smith to be the perfect
- 35:29front for her next assault on the young
- 35:31mothers of Britain Jane Smith was
- 35:33instructed to refer to Amelia as mother
- 35:36and in turn Amelia would call her Granny
- 35:38Smith the perfect family unit that any
- 35:41mother would feel comfortable
- 35:42surrendering their baby to Jane Smith
- 35:45didn't get the life she was promised at
- 35:46all she was treated as no more than a
- 35:48servant really um she was made to look
- 35:50after the children to clean the
- 35:55house Amelia seems to know now adopt
- 35:58infants with Fury so fast they're coming
- 36:01and going at such a speed that Jane
- 36:04Smith never gets a chance to learn their
- 36:06names she never knows from one minute to
- 36:08the next you know what child's in the
- 36:10house then it's taken out
- 36:13again eyewitnesses neighbor reports are
- 36:16saying that there's six infants a day
- 36:18coming to the house and that as many
- 36:20times as they're arriving they're seeing
- 36:22her leave the house with another
- 36:26baby Jane Smith has no idea where these
- 36:28infants are
- 36:29going she's beginning to feel very
- 36:32uneasy about the
- 36:37situation already suspicious about
- 36:40Amelia's actions and intentions the
- 36:42turning point for Granny Smith was just
- 36:44around the
- 36:46corner granny finds a shop in readin
- 36:50which had been turned into The National
- 36:52Society of prevention AC City children
- 36:54center and that's when she saw the
- 36:56photographs
- 36:59the children at being
- 37:01misused and that's when Mrs Bennett came
- 37:03out and asked her what was wrong help
- 37:05you how could you do this to these poor
- 37:08little children granny said I'm I'm a
- 37:10nurse to Amelia D and she takes these
- 37:13children in and before I can actually
- 37:16get attached with them they disappear
- 37:19the nspcc was 3 years old at this point
- 37:22and was Waging War on child CR in
- 37:24mistreatment the woman's husband was an
- 37:26nspcc officer called Charles Bennett but
- 37:29despite visiting Amelia dy's house his
- 37:32concern was confined to her unregistered
- 37:34status a lack of Records rather than the
- 37:37welfare of the baby's present he asked
- 37:39whether she had any license to do this
- 37:42she said she didn't and then he reported
- 37:44that to the police um he also reported
- 37:47to his headquarters and his headquarters
- 37:49said make a record of this and keep her
- 37:52under observation and that's what he did
- 38:00just a few weeks later it was Granny
- 38:02Smith who first noticed a terrible smell
- 38:04coming from one of the kitchen cupboards
- 38:06it seemed to be coming from a strangely
- 38:08wrapped parcel on the
- 38:14Shelf a lodger living in one of the
- 38:16downstairs rooms began to complain of
- 38:18the smell and so one morning um Amelia
- 38:22got up and characteristically early and
- 38:25cleaned the cupboard out scrubbed it and
- 38:28was seen to leave the house with a brown
- 38:30paper parcel under her arm saying that
- 38:33she was going to take some clothes to
- 38:34the porn
- 38:41shop there was a TS bargan he was on the
- 38:45river and he saw this package in the
- 38:50river he hooked it out and it's a brown
- 38:52paper
- 38:55parcel now inside that
- 38:58was a body of a baby with tape around
- 39:01the
- 39:01neck and then inside the package there
- 39:05was a name and
- 39:08address Amelia had been careless not
- 39:11only had the parcel fa to sink but one
- 39:13of her older dresses was still clearly
- 39:16visible written within the package but
- 39:19the capture of Amelia dial wouldn't be
- 39:21so cut and DED the name on the path was
- 39:23a Mrs Thomas and the police would have
- 39:26to be as clever as a criminal to bring
- 39:28Amelia Dyer to
- 39:29[Music]
- 39:32trial Amelia Dy is one of Britain's Most
- 39:34Fascinating and prolific serial killers
- 39:37in a career that lasted 30 years she
- 39:39killed into the hundreds and managed to
- 39:42escape detection several
- 39:44times but by 1890 she had started to
- 39:47make
- 39:51mistakes one of the babies that had been
- 39:54retrieved from the river had been WRA up
- 39:57in brown paper and it hadn't been in the
- 40:01river terribly long and when the police
- 40:04uh unraveled the paper and on some of
- 40:07the brown paper she had left a name and
- 40:10address uh of where she lived which was
- 40:13one of the ruses
- 40:15[Music]
- 40:16absolutely Mrs
- 40:18Thomas at Picket Road and Picket Road is
- 40:22where our ailia D was living under the
- 40:25name of Mrs Thomas
- 40:31from that moment on it was down to good
- 40:33old-fashioned police work to make the
- 40:35connection between the name and address
- 40:36on the parcel and Amelia
- 40:39di this is di can we have a word
- 40:42[Music]
- 40:45please Amelia tried to wriggle out of it
- 40:48tried to pretend she wasn't who she was
- 40:50that she operated by a different name um
- 40:52but the police had none of it what have
- 40:55we got here at that time it would only
- 40:57been very simple evidence they would
- 40:59have been looking purely for clothing
- 41:01and things which would link to the
- 41:03children which had been
- 41:05found they found a house bulging with
- 41:10evidence of the adoptions of babies
- 41:12reams of letters from mothers arranging
- 41:14adoptions cupboards full of clothes and
- 41:17a jar stuffed full of porn tickets where
- 41:20infant clothes had been
- 41:22porned we' have to invest them can you
- 41:26come with me please
- 41:35so here's Amelia's
- 41:37hair why would they have kept a locker
- 41:39hair all that time ago I mean what were
- 41:41the the state of the forensics in those
- 41:42days well I don't I have no idea really
- 41:45I've often pondered on this whether it
- 41:47was taken for forensic reasons for
- 41:50example if any of this hair could be
- 41:52matched to the hair uh on the uh
- 41:56clothing of the babies that have been
- 41:58retrieved from the river but I don't
- 42:00really feel that the advancement of
- 42:03looking at hair was the same as it is
- 42:06today it seemed a bit ghoulish somehow
- 42:08doesn't it having her
- 42:09here um so this is her child sheet and
- 42:12it says here she did feloniously
- 42:14willfully and with malice of forethought
- 42:16kill and murder a certain female infant
- 42:19Helena fry daughter of one Mary
- 42:22fry Amilia was taken to the reading
- 42:24police station where the first thing she
- 42:26did was to attempt suicide again this
- 42:29time by removing a bootlace and tying it
- 42:31round her neck with a knot under her
- 42:34right ear in the same way that she'
- 42:35strangled her
- 42:38infants the police dredged the river
- 42:40looking for more evidence and on the
- 42:4210th of April 1896 a carpet bag
- 42:45containing Doris Maron and Harry Simmons
- 42:48was discovered the carpet bag was a key
- 42:51piece of evidence Amelia had a nurse
- 42:53child an older boy um living in the
- 42:56house and he identified the carpet bag
- 42:58as his
- 43:00[Music]
- 43:03own over the course of the dragging
- 43:05operations upwards of 50 babies are
- 43:07pulled out of the temps between reading
- 43:10and London and Amelia says well you'll
- 43:12know All Mine by the tape around their
- 43:16necks with the news tightening around
- 43:19Amelia's neck her daughter and
- 43:20son-in-law were also arrested as
- 43:22accessories to murder Amelia was so
- 43:25distressed by this that she confessed
- 43:27and wrote a letter taking all
- 43:29responsibility for the crimes as God
- 43:32Almighty is my judge in heaven as on
- 43:34Earth neither my daughter Maryanne
- 43:37Palmer nor her husband Alfred Ernest
- 43:40Palmer I do most solemnly declare
- 43:42neither of them had anything at all to
- 43:45do with it they never knew I
- 43:47contemplated doing such a wicked
- 43:50thing she knew the chances of her living
- 43:54through uh a trial like this uh and
- 43:57coming out and being just given a
- 43:58sentence of prison or something would
- 44:00virtually nil um women of this statue
- 44:03were almost always
- 44:06hanged she decided a plea of insanity
- 44:09was going to be the only possible way
- 44:12that she was going to get off she
- 44:13claimed that there was Insanity in the
- 44:15family because of her mother mama mama
- 44:19to go for a plea of insanity what you're
- 44:22effectively trying to do is stop them
- 44:23executing you there's two questions that
- 44:25come out that did she know what she was
- 44:27doing yes she did did she know what she
- 44:29was doing was wrong simple question if a
- 44:32police officer was standing beside you
- 44:33would you have done it no you know it's
- 44:36wrong the jury said she's sane she's
- 44:41[Music]
- 44:43guilty on the 10th of June 1896 Amelia
- 44:47Dy was executed at Newgate wall like
- 44:50many of a victim she felt a noose around
- 44:52her neck and suddenly knew no
- 44:55more her death closed a case book on one
- 44:57of the most deadly serial killer cases
- 45:00in British
- 45:03history the idea that over time Amelia
- 45:06will have dispensed with you know
- 45:08possibly 500 children um is is quite
- 45:11remarkable because you know you would
- 45:13think that someone would get become
- 45:15jaded uh or at least would start to feel
- 45:17you know that some kind of pangs of
- 45:19conscience that you are cannot carry on
- 45:21slaughtering these
- 45:23babies she had a final interview and she
- 45:27described the murdering she described
- 45:29the voices that drove her to murder and
- 45:31she said I used to like to watch them
- 45:33with a tape around their neck this was a
- 45:36woman who grew to love what she did to
- 45:38these children she grew to like the act
- 45:42and standing back and watching the child
- 45:46die amila Dar is one of the most brutal
- 45:48and consistent serial killers we have
- 45:50come across in this series her crimes
- 45:53have to be seen in the context of the
- 45:54times in which she lived Victor England
- 45:57was a brutal and barbaric period where
- 45:59the life of a child and bastard children
- 46:01especially was
- 46:04worthless so when we remember the
- 46:06crimes even in history we should always
- 46:10remember the victims
- 46:14[Music]
- 46:38[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Amelia Dyer: The Woman Who Only Killed New Borns (Female Murder Documentary) | Absolute Crime by Absolute Crime, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,902 words across 1,066 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.