Alluvium Foundation nature repair market webinar session 1 24/4/24 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03good afternoon and welcome to session
- 0:05one of the nature repair Market
- 0:09webinar presented by the alium
- 0:11foundation my name is Ian Rutherford I'm
- 0:14the chair of the alium foundation which
- 0:16is a new not for-profit entity
- 0:19associated with the alivium group of
- 0:23companies i''d like to acknowledge the
- 0:25traditional owners of country throughout
- 0:28Australia and people are joining us
- 0:30today from all over
- 0:31Australia and we recognize the
- 0:33continuing connection of those
- 0:35traditional owners to land Waters and
- 0:37culture and pay our respect to their
- 0:40Elders past and
- 0:43present first some context for today's
- 0:46webinar we've all seen the explosion
- 0:50interest in water and carbon markets and
- 0:54how they're contributing to
- 0:56Environmental Protection and repair
- 1:00in 2022 the cop 15 Summit released a
- 1:05Kunming Montreal Global biodiversity
- 1:08framework which released a series of
- 1:10goals and targets and brought
- 1:13biodiversity really into the same
- 1:16framework as carbon in particular those
- 1:19goals included 30% of threatened and
- 1:22endangered species protected 30%
- 1:26of of dis degraded lands repair cared
- 1:31and $200 billion US a year invested in
- 1:35achieving those
- 1:37goals but it was recognized at that
- 1:39meeting that we can't rely on
- 1:40governments alone to achieve these goals
- 1:43we have to have private investment and
- 1:46that private investment has to be
- 1:48regulated by the market to some
- 1:52extent responding to that the
- 1:53Commonwealth released in 2022 a nature
- 1:57positive plan and part of that plan was
- 2:00a nature repair act released in 2023 to
- 2:03establish a biodiversity market for
- 2:06Australia and this is the
- 2:08first government sponsored biodiversity
- 2:10Market in the world so it's really
- 2:12important for everybody in Australia
- 2:14involved in the environment area and uh
- 2:18lots of interest in that enhance today's
- 2:21seminar there's a huge appetite from
- 2:23investors governments NOS Community
- 2:26groups in how markets can help to to
- 2:30achieve the ambitious goals that were
- 2:31set at cop
- 2:3315 so today in the first of our two
- 2:36seminars we have a focus on the nature
- 2:40repair
- 2:41legislation and the first speaker on a
- 2:44government perspective on that
- 2:45legislation is Tony mot from the commw
- 2:48Department the second is an
- 2:50international context for biodiversity
- 2:53investment with Laura Waterford from
- 2:55pollination and the third speaker today
- 2:58is Jillian button a lawyer with Alan
- 3:01linklaters who will give us a legal
- 3:03perspective on this complicated
- 3:06space the regulation of the legislation
- 3:09forth to the clean energy regulator and
- 3:12we're fortunate to have kyl binning
- 3:14talking about their
- 3:16perspective next Wednesday in the second
- 3:18of these webinars we'll have three
- 3:21speakers focusing on the challenges of
- 3:23nature repair markets in general so a
- 3:26bit broader and we're going to talk
- 3:27about risks opportunities and net out
- 3:29comes with Dr Megan Evans an ecological
- 3:32perspective with associate professor
- 3:35Patrick OK Conor and finally the
- 3:38challenges of biodiversity markets in
- 3:40general with Dr Neil
- 3:43Bon our first Speaker today is Tony mot
- 3:46from Department of climate change energy
- 3:48environment and water now unfort
- 3:51unfortunately the first two slides of
- 3:54Tony's talk weren't recorded so I'll
- 3:56just go over those before Tony starts
- 3:58speaking on the third
- 4:01slide these are the topics that Tony has
- 4:05covered today six topic why new
- 4:07environmental Market is part of the
- 4:08nature repair positive
- 4:11plan broadening interest from the
- 4:13business and corporate sectors overview
- 4:16of Market design for the new legislation
- 4:19what will people actually be investing
- 4:21in how the arrangements and the market
- 4:24will work and finally the indicative
- 4:26timing next steps and potential
- 4:28evolution of that
- 4:31market now Tony made the point that the
- 4:35legislation we're talking about is just
- 4:36one part of the nature positive plan
- 4:39released by The Commonwealth in December
- 4:422022 that plan sets out the government's
- 4:44commitments to better protect restore
- 4:46and manage our unique
- 4:48environment it notes that private sector
- 4:51investment can make a significant
- 4:53contribution to repairing and protecting
- 4:54our environment and that the legislation
- 4:58the nature repair Market legislation is
- 5:00only one part of that nature positive
- 5:02plan and that plan aims to deliver
- 5:05better Environmental Protection and laws
- 5:06that are nature positive to speed up
- 5:09decisions and make it easier for
- 5:10companies to do the right thing and
- 5:13finally to restore integrity and Trust
- 5:16the systems and environmental laws now
- 5:19over
- 5:23toony
- 5:26thir through three major um
- 5:29consultations exercises um in early
- 5:33sorry late 2022 we consulted on the
- 5:35underlying policy
- 5:36options um early
- 5:392023 U we consulted on an exposure draft
- 5:42of the legislation that was introduced
- 5:44to Parliament in March
- 5:4823
- 5:50and that legislation was um delegated to
- 5:55a senate committee pretty much
- 5:57automatically at that time so we went
- 6:00through um an inquiry from a senate
- 6:02committee for much of 2023 with the
- 6:06negotiations to finalized that the bill
- 6:09and um and Associated um amendments to
- 6:12the engga legislation they started um
- 6:16with a bit of enthusiasm in late
- 6:18November December with the result that
- 6:21the nature of pair bill was actually
- 6:23passed by parliament uh in early
- 6:26December um it received Royal asent on
- 6:28the 14th in came into effect on the 15th
- 6:30of December since then um we've been
- 6:33very busy building the elements of the
- 6:35market now um I need to be quite clear
- 6:38here the government is establishing the
- 6:40parameters for the market the government
- 6:42is not the market the market will be the
- 6:45sum of the interactions between buyers
- 6:46Sellers and intermediaries so under our
- 6:49current uh approach government is not a
- 6:52buyer in the market it's not a supplier
- 6:53in the market it's not a risk taker in
- 6:55the market it has set the parameters the
- 6:57legislation thank you legislation is
- 7:00obviously a very important element um
- 7:03the nature repair Act is sets the
- 7:05umbrella um parameters for uh the scheme
- 7:10um but it relies on a series of
- 7:12subordinate legislation which comes in
- 7:14to um fill in the Gap so to speak and we
- 7:16are working on that subordinate
- 7:18legislation right now so the slide at
- 7:20the top refers to the nature repair
- 7:23rules the biodiversity assessment
- 7:24instrument uh and some methodology
- 7:27determinations which are supporting
- 7:28legislation
- 7:30that underpin the act so we're working
- 7:31on those right now and I should have
- 7:33said earlier um there is because of
- 7:36probity reasons there may be some
- 7:38questions I'm unable to answer today
- 7:39because we're still working on policy
- 7:41we're still working through some
- 7:42procurement exercises and I know we've
- 7:44got procurement activity coming up so if
- 7:47some questions kind of strain into an
- 7:49area where it would be unfair or
- 7:51inappropriate for me to answer um I'll
- 7:53let you know but the legislation sets
- 7:56the parameters um but we have the advant
- 7:59AG of gaining in independent advice
- 8:02through two through two formal
- 8:04mechanisms one is an expert reference
- 8:07group on how to assess biodiversity
- 8:08changes in a variety of uh systems
- 8:12habitats
- 8:13ecosystems and then there is a statutory
- 8:15nature repair committee whose role is to
- 8:17advise the minister on uh some key
- 8:19recommendations before the minister
- 8:21makes some
- 8:23legislation as part of that exercise
- 8:26once a project is formed
- 8:30and an application submitted to the
- 8:32clean energy regulator and approved
- 8:35there is a register where Joe public can
- 8:38look up the nature of projects where
- 8:40they are what they're trying to achieve
- 8:41Who's involved those sorts of
- 8:44details a successful project that
- 8:46delivers a you know lasting sustainable
- 8:49resilient Improvement
- 8:51biodiversity is then entitled to apply
- 8:54to get a biodiversity certificate uh
- 8:57which is a notional thing it's not a
- 8:58certificate that you put on the wall of
- 9:00your office it's it's an electronic um
- 9:02record in
- 9:04a register that the C will maintain but
- 9:08it's tradable personal property separate
- 9:11from the underlying project area
- 9:13separate from the land tenure uh
- 9:17and ownership of that certificate alls
- 9:21the owner to make claims about the
- 9:23project so whether they have restored a
- 9:27sensitive area whether they've expanded
- 9:29it whether they've uh improved
- 9:31conditions to the extent that uh the
- 9:34area can recover so examples might be um
- 9:37dealing with invasive species removing
- 9:39those sorts of stresses from the system
- 9:41it might include tree plantings it might
- 9:43include a combination of those things
- 9:45I'll go into those a little bit later
- 9:47but in order to make sure the
- 9:49certificate has some Integrity it needs
- 9:51to be a high level of monitoring
- 9:52compliance did the project actually do
- 9:54what it set out to do so monitoring
- 9:57Appliance will focus on both activities
- 10:00did you put the fence in how many
- 10:02seedlings did you put in did you restore
- 10:04the title flows all those sorts of
- 10:06examples that's activity based reporting
- 10:08but there's also outcome based
- 10:11reporting as in to what extent has
- 10:13biodiversity improved is it
- 10:16statistically significant um can we rely
- 10:20on the claims being made by the
- 10:22project I'll go to the next slide thanks
- 10:25Ian
- 10:33so the hook if you like is that the
- 10:35certificate has value and it's the
- 10:39willingness of people to buy the
- 10:40certificate that provides the finance to
- 10:42run the projects so the question is so
- 10:45what will people be investing in what
- 10:47does the certificate
- 10:48represent well they are tradable
- 10:51personal property and they will have a
- 10:54value based on whatever the market
- 10:56ascribes to
- 10:57them and how the market approaches that
- 11:01question condra depends on their
- 11:02motivations and I've just listed a
- 11:04handful of motivations at the bottom of
- 11:05the page throughout our consultation
- 11:07there were those who are approaching
- 11:09this from a philanthropic point of view
- 11:11and this is the right thing to do um we
- 11:14want to restore culturally and
- 11:18environmentally sensitive areas pack
- 11:20protect endangered species but then
- 11:23there are a whole suet of others who are
- 11:25looking at this as a purely Financial
- 11:27investment uh and others
- 11:30who are thinking of it as potentially a
- 11:34marketing opportunity you know their
- 11:37organization may have large impacts on
- 11:39nature um or their supply chain does and
- 11:43they're looking to protect their social
- 11:45license perhaps even to attract a
- 11:47sustainability premium you know in terms
- 11:49of their company valuation whether
- 11:51that's a a public listed company or
- 11:52private there's a whole range of
- 11:54motivations that we've picked up through
- 11:57consultation and I think um how you
- 11:59approach the question of is this a good
- 12:01investment kind of depends on your
- 12:04motivation uh next slide
- 12:09than the market design is based on
- 12:12projects being run which deliver a
- 12:16sustainable and resilient biodiversity
- 12:18Improvement uh but those projects have
- 12:20to apply an improved method similar to
- 12:22um methods approved under the acq scheme
- 12:25you can't just do whatever you want you
- 12:27need to work within parameters so there
- 12:28will be a series of methods uh developed
- 12:32and approved by the minister that
- 12:34projects can
- 12:37apply those methods will be very
- 12:40specific to certain AK systems and we're
- 12:42working on those right at the moment so
- 12:45I'm limited to the what I can say about
- 12:47them but the scheme does allow for
- 12:50projects to
- 12:52run inter terrestrial ecosystems Inland
- 12:56Coastal and Marine water so we're going
- 12:57as broad as we can and when the market
- 13:01commences it's natural that it'll be
- 13:04interest in
- 13:06some methodologies more than others some
- 13:09areas more than others so whilst it's a
- 13:11national scheme um the take up might be
- 13:15a bit patchy around the country so to
- 13:17speak because uh the market may decide
- 13:20that they are more interested in certain
- 13:24areas High rain rainforest or rangelands
- 13:28or restoring areas that are badly
- 13:30degraded the market will decide which
- 13:31projects get
- 13:33up successful projects that are on the
- 13:36pathway to delivering the biodiversity
- 13:39outcomes or can demonstrate they already
- 13:40have will be entitled to a certificate
- 13:42so they would apply to a regulator with
- 13:44their argument and all of their
- 13:46monitoring and auditing reports and say
- 13:48we believe we have demonstrated we have
- 13:50to delivered a lasting benefit and if
- 13:52the regulator agrees that we issued a
- 13:56certificate okay next one Ian
- 14:01okay this is my my last slide and this
- 14:02is an indicative time frame so the
- 14:04nature repair Act was passed in mid
- 14:07December last year and the minister is
- 14:10on the record of saying in around 12
- 14:12months after the ACT is passed she would
- 14:14like the scheme to commence so I'm
- 14:17coordinating a branch within our
- 14:19department uh and working with the clean
- 14:22injury regulator on delivering all the
- 14:24bits and pieces that need to happen and
- 14:26for a complex project like this you can
- 14:27imagine that certain things need to
- 14:29start before others certain things need
- 14:30to finish before others and that's my
- 14:33day job um on that time frame I've
- 14:36indicated where April 24 is um along the
- 14:39time frame so we have just established
- 14:41the biodiversity expert reference group
- 14:43and we're working our way through
- 14:45establishing the nature repair committee
- 14:47so arguably we're about a third of the
- 14:49way there against the time frame that's
- 14:52a little bit misting because some tasks
- 14:53are obviously harder than others
- 14:57and a number of things we are doing
- 15:00quite Innovative have never been done at
- 15:02the scale we're talking about now so um
- 15:05just because the timeline to this we
- 15:06about a third of the way there it
- 15:08doesn't confirm that uh um the rest of
- 15:12it will be an easy run for us so um
- 15:15indicatively we're hoping to give the
- 15:18minister what she wants within 12 months
- 15:20of um the ACT being passed but there are
- 15:23still many hurdles to overcome before we
- 15:25get
- 15:27there I think I will stop there for now
- 15:31um the clean energy regulator is uh an
- 15:34implementation partner for us so they
- 15:35are a separate organization um there are
- 15:38seven work streams in the branch that I
- 15:40work in and we are viewing the clean
- 15:42energy regulator's contribution as
- 15:44another work stream so they're very much
- 15:45a delivery partner for us working
- 15:48closely with us handing glob in fact
- 15:49I've spoken more to the C staff this
- 15:51week than I have to my own staff so
- 15:53we're that closely embedded um as we
- 15:55should be given that the Clint je
- 15:58regulator role in supporting the market
- 15:59moving
- 16:01forward right I don't know how we're
- 16:03going for time in as whether there's
- 16:04room for questions now or whether we
- 16:06park them for later oh we've got time
- 16:09for questions
- 16:10Tony and um thank thanks very much for
- 16:12that here's the um the contact details
- 16:15for Tony to register your interest in
- 16:17this uh and to contact the nature repair
- 16:20Market team um so we we've got a lot of
- 16:23questions online Tony and I I'll just
- 16:24ask a couple of those the first one is
- 16:26will the slides be made available they
- 16:28they will will be made available to
- 16:30everybody um there a a a question um
- 16:35here from from Li Davis there is one
- 16:38certificate issued for the life of the
- 16:40project how will project proponents
- 16:42ensure they value the certificate
- 16:44appropriately to ensure it funds project
- 16:46activities monitoring and auditing for
- 16:48the life of the
- 16:49project also will the cost of the
- 16:51certificate be a barrier for smaller
- 16:53investors so so um Tony is there a cost
- 16:56to actually establishing the certificate
- 17:01uh a number of reports will be required
- 17:03of projects uh before they can apply for
- 17:05certificate uh there'll be some auditing
- 17:07required too and there's there will be a
- 17:10mix of monitoring activities required
- 17:12which will be part of the approval for
- 17:14the project provided by the C there'll
- 17:16also be a series of audit reports
- 17:19um the range of uh audit reports
- 17:22required we're still working our way
- 17:23through now but I guess we've worked on
- 17:25a rule of thumb that an an audit report
- 17:28which is did you do what you said you
- 17:29would do to the required
- 17:31standard um where working on a rule of
- 17:34thumb it might cost about $10,000 per a
- 17:37report to get that kind of conclusion
- 17:39now an order report is not the same as
- 17:40monitoring an audit is uh a
- 17:45Reconciliation of these were the
- 17:47approval conditions you were given have
- 17:48you followed the right process in order
- 17:50to get there they're not there to judge
- 17:52whether if the a th seedlings that you
- 17:55planted have all struck and um all
- 17:58survived that's a separate
- 18:00exercise yeah there were several
- 18:02questions on that about how we'll
- 18:05establish the um wether the
- 18:07market deliver what the certificates um
- 18:11uh say they will so we'll probably have
- 18:14to move on to uh to the next speaker
- 18:16Tony but thanks very much for that that
- 18:18fantastic overview I should um I'll just
- 18:20go to the next slide and mention that um
- 18:22Tony has a further eight additional
- 18:24slides which are packed with information
- 18:26as well uh and
- 18:30they'll be um be made available to um to
- 18:32everybody as well so um it's it's really
- 18:36great Tony that the department is
- 18:37providing this this information some of
- 18:39the questions that have been um posed
- 18:40will be really for Carl around uh regul
- 18:43regulatory arrangements for that our our
- 18:46second speaker uh today is Laura
- 18:48Waterford who'll talk about biodiversity
- 18:50credit markets thank you Laura thanks
- 18:53Ian and thank you Tony for the update as
- 18:55well on the government side of things
- 18:57it's really helpful to have that
- 18:58overview a launching pad for what I'm
- 19:00going to speak to which is really just
- 19:03to situate this conversation about the
- 19:05emerging nature repair Market or nature
- 19:07repair scheme in Australia in the sort
- 19:09of broader conversation around carbon
- 19:12markets firstly but then also the global
- 19:15developments around uh what I think most
- 19:18people are calling voluntary
- 19:20biodiversity credit markets but I might
- 19:22actually start there with a note on
- 19:23terminology um which is to say that
- 19:26terms like credits offset
- 19:29and um certificates are being used sort
- 19:32of somewhat interchangeably in this
- 19:34conversation around biodiversity markets
- 19:37at the moment and so to the extent that
- 19:40I'm going to focus on using the language
- 19:41biodiversity credits today aside from
- 19:43where I speak to the range of potential
- 19:45uses of biodiversity products on this
- 19:47slide I'm going to use that term to
- 19:49refer to voluntary products that are not
- 19:52intended to be used to support
- 19:54offsetting claims first of all and
- 19:56that's in line with the intended use of
- 19:57the nature repair certificates under the
- 19:59federal government scheme as well so
- 20:01putting aside the the offsetting
- 20:03conversation and I'm going to talk about
- 20:05biodiversity credits to mean usually a
- 20:08unitized approach but also I think it's
- 20:11fair to say that the voluntary
- 20:14certificates to be issued under the
- 20:15nature repair scheme that the federal
- 20:17government is proposing which are to be
- 20:18issued at the whole of project level fit
- 20:20broadly into this conversation around
- 20:22voluntary biodiversity credit markets
- 20:24and so scooping up all of the the
- 20:27potential products that fit into
- 20:28voluntary space when I'm stepping
- 20:30through some of the trends that we're
- 20:31seeing emerge I think first of all I
- 20:34just wanted to provide a little bit of
- 20:36context around how this emerging market
- 20:39for biodiversity fits against existing
- 20:41compliance biodiversity offset
- 20:44requirements that have existed for a
- 20:45long time in many jurisdictions
- 20:47including Australia and also how this
- 20:50conversation sits alongside the nature a
- 20:52Solutions carbon Market because I think
- 20:54they're both really important things
- 20:55that have an intersection here and where
- 20:57we can learn quite a bit from how those
- 20:59markets have been administered and
- 21:01participated in um by all stakeholders
- 21:03over the last few decades so I think the
- 21:06first thing to acknowledge is that for a
- 21:08long time we've had um carbon markets
- 21:10operating in Australia and all over the
- 21:12world where there has been a premium
- 21:13paid for nature-based Solutions carbon
- 21:15credits and in Australia that's AC use
- 21:18on the Assumption to some degree that
- 21:20those credit types are likely to have a
- 21:22biodiversity co- benefit whether that's
- 21:25measured or unmeasured um and for many
- 21:28years I think um that premium was
- 21:30payable on the assumption that those
- 21:31benefits likely existed but over the
- 21:33last few years there's been a bit of a
- 21:35trend towards buyers um seeking a bit
- 21:39more clarity and confidence around those
- 21:41biodiversity co- benefits and so pushing
- 21:43toward a measurement approach uh so that
- 21:46the primary product you're buying is
- 21:48certainly a carbon credit but with the
- 21:50Assurance of measured biodiversity
- 21:51outcomes alongside that to give
- 21:53confidence that that credit deserves the
- 21:56premium price that the market has been
- 21:57paying so that's been bubbling along um
- 22:00for many years as has the offset
- 22:04biodiversity Market in Australia which
- 22:06exists primarily um at the state level
- 22:09in a few different jurisdictions where
- 22:11there are actually biodiversity units
- 22:13already traded to support um the demand
- 22:17side meeting their compliance
- 22:19obligations where they've for example
- 22:21undertaken a project that requires land
- 22:23clearing and then under legislation they
- 22:25are required to offset that impact on
- 22:27biodiversity by purchasing a um
- 22:30specified number and type of
- 22:32credits what has happened in the last
- 22:35few years really since 20120 is a
- 22:37conversation about well isn't there a
- 22:39niche here for voluntary biodiversity
- 22:42products so where it's not necessarily
- 22:43tied to the negative impacts on
- 22:46biodiversity associated with a product a
- 22:48project sorry so won't be caught by
- 22:50compliance
- 22:51requirements and really where we can
- 22:53reward good biodiversity outcomes over
- 22:56and above wrapping that into what buyer
- 22:58might be willing to pay for carbon and
- 23:01there's a few reasons that that
- 23:03conversation has come about um from a
- 23:06regulatory perspective there is a a
- 23:08significant focus on biodiversity coming
- 23:11down the line um so much more of a focus
- 23:14on uh corporates and financial
- 23:16institutions reporting on their nature
- 23:19impacts at the highest level um and that
- 23:23generally increasing scrutiny on where
- 23:25and how uh their operations intersect
- 23:27with by diversity and nature in the
- 23:29broad in their direct operations and
- 23:31their supply chains so suddenly Nature's
- 23:33on the agenda in a way that um it wasn't
- 23:35previously and it's starting to kind of
- 23:37enter that conversation alongside
- 23:38climate at the board level and in
- 23:41addition to that I think the push
- 23:43towards starting to unitized
- 23:45biodiversity co- benefits has
- 23:46contributed as well or sorry the push
- 23:48towards trying to measure those
- 23:49biodiversity co- benefits has pushed the
- 23:52conversation even slightly further
- 23:53towards unitization and a formal
- 23:55separate way of recognizing those
- 23:58benefits as either a certificate or a
- 24:01credit
- 24:02um and the last piece of this puzzle I
- 24:05think is nature-based Solutions carbon
- 24:09projects obviously need to be carried
- 24:11out in ecosystems where there is a
- 24:12carbon uplift
- 24:14achievable and there are many ecosystems
- 24:16that we can have really good
- 24:18biodiversity outcomes for where that's
- 24:20just not possible so desert ecosystems
- 24:22or coral reefs for example and so
- 24:24there's actually a gap in the ability to
- 24:26pull in private sector Finance by carbon
- 24:28markets for those kinds of ecosystems at
- 24:32the moment and so this is a niche that
- 24:33voluntary biodiversity credits can also
- 24:35start to
- 24:36fill so sitting alongside nature-based
- 24:40Solutions carbon credits and
- 24:41biodiversity offsets we now have this
- 24:43conversation around biodiversity credits
- 24:45happening um and I sort of alluded to
- 24:48this at the start but to put a very fine
- 24:50point on it the predominant um
- 24:53discussion in the market around how
- 24:55voluntary biodiversity credits would be
- 24:57used that they will not be used to
- 24:59support offsetting claims and that is
- 25:02not set in stone and there's still a lot
- 25:04of debate uh and discussion happening
- 25:07around that and I don't say that that's
- 25:08where the market will be 10 years from
- 25:10now but there is a hesitancy in the
- 25:12voluntary space at the moment to say
- 25:15that voluntary products could be used to
- 25:16achieve offsetting because it's very
- 25:18challenging from a scientific
- 25:20perspective to really certify that
- 25:23scientific equivalence has been achieved
- 25:25um where you might have negative impact
- 25:28in one location and positive impacts in
- 25:30another and um biodiversity is a very
- 25:32difficult thing to measure those
- 25:34outcomes for so sticking with voluntary
- 25:37claims around contributing to positive
- 25:39outcomes and steering clear of offsets
- 25:41in that space the last thing I just
- 25:44wanted to touch on before I move on to
- 25:46some more of the stateof of the market
- 25:48content is um just the notion that you
- 25:51can actually
- 25:52stack carbon and biodiversity credits or
- 25:55combine them in different ways there are
- 25:57some examples of these things happening
- 25:59in the market or whether it's intended
- 26:00that it will be possible to do these
- 26:02things and I actually think the intent
- 26:04with the nature of pair certificates is
- 26:06that it will be possible to have those
- 26:09issued over the same land as land that
- 26:11is generating acuse so in that instance
- 26:14there'll be two separate products that
- 26:16have different claims attached to them
- 26:18in terms of the carbon and biodiversity
- 26:19outcomes and there are other schemes
- 26:21globally that are looking at the same
- 26:23thing um and there's also schemes in the
- 26:26past that have combined biodiversity
- 26:29credit issued in Australia with a carbon
- 26:31credit issued overseas they've been
- 26:33stapled together and then sold as a
- 26:35product that has both a carbon and
- 26:37biodiversity benefit but where those
- 26:39outcomes weren't achieved from the same
- 26:41project which is quite an interesting
- 26:42and Innovative model as well so there
- 26:44are lots of moving parts to what this
- 26:46Market will look like and how the
- 26:48voluntary biodiversity credit Market
- 26:50intersects with offsets and with the
- 26:53carbon space
- 26:55um but I think there's a a reason able
- 26:58degree of sophistication of
- 26:59understanding around these different um
- 27:02Dynamics playing out as well and in
- 27:03Fairly short order given this
- 27:04conversation around voluntary
- 27:06biodiversity credit markets really only
- 27:07commenced from
- 27:112020 I just wanted to spend a few
- 27:14minutes talking to this world map which
- 27:17probably by now needs updating again
- 27:20because what this map represents is the
- 27:22proliferation of voluntary biodiversity
- 27:25credit schemes that have cropped up all
- 27:27over the world in the last few years and
- 27:30each one of these bubbles is a scheme
- 27:33not a project so it is possible that
- 27:35these schemes have multiple pilot
- 27:37projects already going on in multiple
- 27:39locations and In geographies from which
- 27:41they haven't originated and in fact I
- 27:43know that that's true for several of
- 27:44them but I think it's important to
- 27:47understand how quickly this is evolving
- 27:50and also how complicated the Market's
- 27:51becoming from a global perspective
- 27:54because each one of these schemes has
- 27:55slightly different approaches to the
- 27:57measurement of biodiversity so what
- 27:59metrics they use and then also all the
- 28:02other features of a scheme that go to
- 28:04things like Integrity or
- 28:06unitization there are some broad tenants
- 28:09um across all of the schemes that are
- 28:11emerging that are similar and I'll get
- 28:13to that in a moment we um conducted a
- 28:16review of eight of the leading schemes
- 28:18where there was the most publicly
- 28:19available information for us to use for
- 28:21that purpose last year and there are
- 28:23some interesting findings that have come
- 28:24out of that but just before I move on to
- 28:27that from Geographic
- 28:29perspective just wanted to acknowledge
- 28:31that a lot of the Innovation um in this
- 28:34space is actually coming out of
- 28:35Australia I think we're well and truly
- 28:38on the radar in the global conversation
- 28:41not least because of the nature of
- 28:42repair scheme and the fact that our
- 28:43government has already passed that
- 28:45legislation we were the first government
- 28:47globally to do that I think New Zealand
- 28:50is the second most advanced government
- 28:53in terms of um being out for
- 28:54consultation on potentially designing a
- 28:56scheme but Australia's also got a couple
- 28:59of other voluntary schemes emerging so
- 29:02there's the nature plus scheme which
- 29:03seeks to issue um nature related
- 29:06voluntary units and also the wilderland
- 29:08scheme which has had a couple of
- 29:10transactions um that are well known in
- 29:12the market and I I think what's
- 29:15interesting is that even within
- 29:16Australia within those schemes if we
- 29:18think about the nature repair Market the
- 29:19nature plus scheme and the Woodland
- 29:21scheme each one of those voluntary
- 29:23products um takes quite a different
- 29:25approach to how they would unitize and
- 29:26represent the biodiversity outcomes so
- 29:28even within Australia we have a really
- 29:31interesting microcosm um to think about
- 29:33in terms of what products um are likely
- 29:36to to be best fit for what the the buyer
- 29:44needs um what I wanted to give a sense
- 29:47of because I think uh it's not
- 29:49necessarily intuitive to to know easily
- 29:53what constitutes a biodiversity credit
- 29:55um for some of the reasons that I've
- 29:57mentioned before for there are different
- 29:59uh options around how we think about
- 30:01what metrics are relevant for
- 30:02biodiversity different activity types
- 30:04that can either maintain or improve
- 30:05biodiversity values and different areas
- 30:08and time periods that you can think
- 30:09about in terms of what a credit might
- 30:12represent and so across the schemes that
- 30:14we looked at last year for that Global
- 30:16review we found that the the common
- 30:18components were um a clear articulation
- 30:21of what types of outcomes or activities
- 30:24the unit was seeking to achieve and then
- 30:26usually an approach to unitization that
- 30:28meant that um the credit represented for
- 30:30example one meter or a hect and then
- 30:33that the outcomes that were achieved
- 30:35over that area were achieved within a
- 30:37given period of time and so this model
- 30:40that I'm speaking about now
- 30:42contemplates multiple issuances over a
- 30:44project life so say every 5 years if
- 30:47that's when the change in ecological
- 30:48conditions likely to be
- 30:50detectable and that there would be
- 30:52multiple credits issued each of a the
- 30:55same area um so
- 30:58multiple credit credits for one hectare
- 31:01of a project that might be 40 hectares
- 31:04that is a bit different to the nature
- 31:05repair scheme that we've just heard
- 31:06about in the sense that that is a single
- 31:08certificate issued at a single point in
- 31:10time um and that I think goes to support
- 31:13the the sort of broader point which is
- 31:15there's so much diversity emerging in
- 31:16the market and we're not quite sure yet
- 31:19um exactly how buyers will want to
- 31:21participate or what features of a
- 31:23product will be most attractive to them
- 31:25but I think it's Food For Thought um um
- 31:28and kind of goes to the the point about
- 31:31um the complexity for buyers in knowing
- 31:34what to buy and how supporting a project
- 31:36like this will align with their own
- 31:38objectives whether that's targets that
- 31:40they've set or just a broader ambition
- 31:42to be able to articulate um ESG
- 31:44credentials to the market that they have
- 31:46confidence
- 31:48in the other really interesting thing to
- 31:51think about in terms of what is a
- 31:52biodiversity credit is what the metrics
- 31:56are that are being selected
- 31:58um to measure and therefore what Claims
- 32:01can be made about what has been measured
- 32:04so I I'm been referring broadly to this
- 32:07Market as a biodiversity Market um but
- 32:10biodiversity has a very broad definition
- 32:12and there's certainly not Universal
- 32:13agreement on what is important to
- 32:15measure within that context yet and so
- 32:17across the schemes that we have looked
- 32:19at they've taken probably three buckets
- 32:21of approaches to measurement some are
- 32:23focused on a whole of ecosystem
- 32:25perspective but um can refer to that as
- 32:28a basket of metrics approach where the
- 32:30standard specifies a range of metrics
- 32:32that need to be measured to get that ho
- 32:34of ecosystem perspective and then the
- 32:37project proponent chooses from those
- 32:38metrics which are most appropriate for
- 32:40the ecosystem type it's probably the
- 32:42most comprehensive approach that we've
- 32:44seen there's also an approach around um
- 32:48really focusing on specific habitat
- 32:50attributes for a given species so for
- 32:53example koala habitat so that might
- 32:56consist of looking at um vegetation
- 32:59condition and extent metrics but then
- 33:00overlaying on top of that the specific
- 33:02factors that are relevant for koala
- 33:04habitat um with or without measurement
- 33:07of the presence absence or abundance of
- 33:09the species itself and then the last
- 33:12category is just a focus on vegetation
- 33:15so really just thinking about condition
- 33:17and extent um as a proxy for the other
- 33:22biodiversity values that might exist
- 33:23within an ecosystem so if you look top
- 33:27to bottom on that table really what that
- 33:29um represents is varying cost in terms
- 33:32of measurement reporting and
- 33:34verification and varying degrees of
- 33:36confidence in terms of the outcomes that
- 33:38are delivered from a whole of ecosystem
- 33:40perspective and this is another one of
- 33:42those things where I've just say we
- 33:44don't know yet um what the demand side
- 33:46is most interested in or prepared to pay
- 33:48for are they going to be satisfied with
- 33:50vegetation condition and extent as a
- 33:51proxy for biodiversity outcomes are they
- 33:54really going to want to know how each
- 33:56part of an ecosystem is performed in and
- 33:59will that push us up into the ecosystem
- 34:01poll of um basket of metrics approach
- 34:04and will they be willing to pay for that
- 34:07um because MB is one of the significant
- 34:09considerations or the cost of MB is one
- 34:11of the significant considerations in
- 34:12terms of how credits will be priced in
- 34:14the Market at least for the first few
- 34:18years um just some higher order Trends
- 34:21kind of moving beyond what is a credit
- 34:22now and what are the considerations
- 34:23around how you would design a credit in
- 34:25that review that we have done of the
- 34:28eight schemes that were emerging there
- 34:29were a few really big trends and I think
- 34:31it's interesting to reflect on those um
- 34:34in the context of the nature repair
- 34:35scheme as well the first one was that
- 34:38most of the schemes that we looked at
- 34:39were really focused on terrestrial
- 34:41ecosystems um some of them had an
- 34:43ambition to be applicable to other
- 34:44ecosystem types but didn't actually have
- 34:47methodologies to support measurement for
- 34:49ecosystems that were freshwater or
- 34:51Marine for example um but it's really
- 34:54good to hear that the nature repair
- 34:55scheme has been set up to comprehend of
- 34:57those different ecosystem
- 34:59types uh second was uh a lot of the
- 35:03schemes had articulated an approach to
- 35:06engagement with indigenous peoples and
- 35:08local communities but there was a
- 35:11significant amount of Interest kind of
- 35:13in our conversations in the market about
- 35:14maybe elevating that conversation Beyond
- 35:16benefit sharing and free PR and informed
- 35:18consent into more of a position around
- 35:21pursuing ownership um for example or an
- 35:24equity position for IPs and LC's so elev
- 35:27away from um thinking of them as
- 35:29stakeholders more towards owners is a
- 35:31really big theme in this
- 35:34market also um quite Innovative
- 35:37approaches coming through to solve for
- 35:40the challenge of permanence or rather to
- 35:43do away with that Concept in the sense
- 35:45that in carbon markets and in the AI
- 35:48Market in Australia we've got crediting
- 35:50periods followed by a lengthy permanence
- 35:52period to try to ensure that we're able
- 35:53to preserve the benefits that a
- 35:55Project's achieved but during that
- 35:57permanence period um obviously there are
- 35:59no payments flowing to the land holder
- 36:01and it's kind of yet to be seen how that
- 36:03will come out in the wash um but what
- 36:07some of the schemes that we're seeing
- 36:08emerge in the voluntary biodiversity
- 36:09space are doing is actually allowing for
- 36:11indefinite crediting so um if you can uh
- 36:16line up a buyer who wants to purchase
- 36:18credits from your project in perpetuity
- 36:21which you know probably won't um be
- 36:24realistic on day one but or you can find
- 36:26multiple buyers I suppose over time that
- 36:28are interested in the product there's
- 36:30actually no end to the Project Life
- 36:31which means that there'll be continuous
- 36:33or there is at least the potential for a
- 36:36continuous Revenue stream to support the
- 36:38ongoing management of biodiversity which
- 36:41I think is a really important and
- 36:42interesting evolution in how we think
- 36:45about the permanence requirements as
- 36:47compared to carbon
- 36:48markets um the fourth is also kind of a
- 36:52a question of whether or not we follow
- 36:54the same trend for biodiversity markets
- 36:56as we had for carbon markets around
- 36:58additionality so it's been very hard
- 37:00historically for some um countries or
- 37:03types of land to participate in carbon
- 37:06markets so for example protected areas
- 37:08and countries with High um Forest cover
- 37:11and low rates of deforestation haven't
- 37:13met the historical additionality tests
- 37:15that have been in place in carbon
- 37:17markets I think that there is thinking
- 37:20that perhaps that approach is not as
- 37:22applicable in the in the context of
- 37:24biodiversity because we need to manage
- 37:26biodiversity as in people people need to
- 37:27be in Landscapes um ensuring that
- 37:30biodiversity values are maintained or
- 37:32they will go backwards and there
- 37:33actually really good data for that in
- 37:35the context of national parks where we
- 37:38know that often if they're not
- 37:39sufficiently funded biodiversity values
- 37:41are actually going backwards and so
- 37:43there is an argument from a fential
- 37:45additionality perspective to say that we
- 37:47should be able to think about a role for
- 37:49voluntary biodiversity um projects in
- 37:52even national parks if that additional
- 37:54Finance is going to mean that they were
- 37:56able to maintain or enhance biodiversity
- 37:58values that otherwise wouldn't be
- 38:00possible um and then the last couple are
- 38:03not really concerns for the nature
- 38:05repair scheme I think the nature repair
- 38:07scheme's been very clear about its
- 38:08intent around these two but some of the
- 38:10other emerging schemes that are not
- 38:11government
- 38:13L um they are at the moment in the
- 38:16position of being both standard and
- 38:19project developer which raises some
- 38:21questions around Integrity um and so I
- 38:24think in the next few years we'll see a
- 38:25lot of those um schemes that areg ing in
- 38:28currently in piloting phase move on to a
- 38:30position where actually stands
- 38:32administered by an independent body but
- 38:34the nature repair scheme's been
- 38:35obviously set up that way with
- 38:36government as administer so that's not a
- 38:38problem uh and then some more
- 38:41transparency as well I think from some
- 38:42of the schemes that we looked at that
- 38:44were not government L um around exactly
- 38:48what how they were going to track their
- 38:50projects for example um and what
- 38:52information would be made publicly
- 38:53available but again the nature repair
- 38:54schemes been very clear on that in terms
- 38:56of the registry and some of the other um
- 38:59functions that the C will perform so I
- 39:01don't think that's a concern with
- 39:02respect to the nature of P
- 39:05game so that's it for me in terms of the
- 39:09global Trends um but I don't know if we
- 39:13have time for a couple of questions no
- 39:15thank thank you we do we do have some
- 39:16questions in fact there's hundreds of
- 39:18questions online Laura and uh a lot of
- 39:20those questions relate to additionality
- 39:22that you were uh talking about for
- 39:24example um that the there's there's C
- 39:27benefits to carbon investment but
- 39:28there'll be co- benefits to certificates
- 39:31as well um how do you see that all um uh
- 39:35playing out
- 39:37yeah I'm not sure the co- benefits
- 39:40question relates specifically to the
- 39:42concept of diality but I I would
- 39:44acknowledge that definitely certificates
- 39:46will have co- benefits social co-
- 39:48benefits and First Nations co- benefits
- 39:50in many cases depending on the project
- 39:53design and I think that that capturing
- 39:56that value is going to be really
- 39:58important but we need to trade really
- 40:00carefully and be led by First Nations as
- 40:02to how they would like to articulate
- 40:04that think about it and um you know
- 40:07whether or not they want to capture that
- 40:09as economic value a lot of the work that
- 40:12we're doing is in that space thinking
- 40:14about how traditional owners can
- 40:15participate in in and help to shape
- 40:17these markets in a way that they feel is
- 40:20culturally appropriate and I don't think
- 40:22that we're going to have an answer to
- 40:24that um or a mainstream answer to that
- 40:27in in the very near future but I
- 40:29certainly agree it's something that um
- 40:31project proponents need to be really
- 40:32mindful of and and certainly probably
- 40:35move Beyond just engagement with
- 40:37traditional owners into bringing them
- 40:38into project design and asking the
- 40:41question genuinely about Equity
- 40:42ownership as I sort of flagged as a a
- 40:45macro Trend in the
- 40:47space you you mentioned at the beginning
- 40:49that there's a lot of different markets
- 40:51emerging different models emerging and
- 40:53and an interesting question is how
- 40:55they'll run in parallel and a question
- 40:56that PA Elton asked is about whether the
- 40:59Commonwealth itself could invest uh
- 41:02substantially in the
- 41:04certificates uh whether that that could
- 41:07emerge I think others on this call
- 41:10probably have views about this but I my
- 41:12understanding is that the common wealth
- 41:13has the power under the legislation to
- 41:16purchase the certificates if it were to
- 41:18so choose but that it hasn't actually
- 41:20signaled a policy position that would
- 41:22suggest that that's the intent in the
- 41:23short term at least
- 41:28good um thanks very much for that Laura
- 41:31we we'd better move on to our next
- 41:33speaker but but as I said there there
- 41:35are hundreds of questions online and
- 41:37it's they're really detailed and very
- 41:38interesting if if you want to have a
- 41:40look at those and we'll um work at
- 41:42getting answers to as many of those as
- 41:44we can um post seminar but now um
- 41:48Jullian we'll move to you thank you
- 41:51thanks Ian um well look I might just
- 41:54start by observing that the
- 41:57establishment of the nature repair
- 41:58Market is part of a broader Trend in
- 42:01Australia of setting up market-based
- 42:03schemes to help us achieve policy
- 42:05objectives so we've got the acq scheme
- 42:08set up to help us on our climate targets
- 42:11LGC trading to help us with our
- 42:13renewable energy goals and there are
- 42:16also moves a foot um to establish a
- 42:19guarantee of origin scheme for hydrogen
- 42:21and renewable energy and a vehicle
- 42:23emissions standard trading scheme um and
- 42:27you know from a corporate perspective
- 42:28which is often the perspective I look at
- 42:30these uh markets through um they're not
- 42:33the be all and end all of helping
- 42:35organizations navigate their way through
- 42:38to Net Zero or to contributing to Nature
- 42:41positivity but they Supply a really
- 42:45important tool to organizations with e
- 42:48ESG goals to Leverage The governance and
- 42:53integrity uh and oversight that is
- 42:56embedded in those schemes to then
- 42:58support their U Net Zero in nature
- 43:01positive objectives and the claims they
- 43:04they want to make publicly so in in that
- 43:06sense and as a broad overarching
- 43:09observation the establishment of this
- 43:11nature repair Market is a potentially a
- 43:13big step forward to supporting
- 43:16businesses to adopt nature positive
- 43:18strategies um and also you know a tool
- 43:22available to um have some comfort that
- 43:24there's robustness underpinning the
- 43:26project and and proper governance to
- 43:29oversee long-term management of land um
- 43:33so we are seeing interest from clients
- 43:35in this market and some of the questions
- 43:37that are coming up are how does this
- 43:39compare with the acq market how does
- 43:42this compare with biodiversity
- 43:43offsetting schemes um and you know where
- 43:46where can we play in this market and
- 43:48what are some of the legal issues that
- 43:50we might encounter so those are the
- 43:52topics I wanted to step through briefly
- 43:54and I I'll start by situating
- 43:57the market um within the context of um
- 44:01the acq market uh building on some
- 44:04similar comments that I think Laura made
- 44:07so there are some familiar elements to
- 44:10this scheme um the first and obvious one
- 44:13is that the nature repair act provides
- 44:15that projects can be registered if they
- 44:16are consistent with a government
- 44:18approved methodology so in the climate
- 44:21space the two the two classes of
- 44:23methodologies are avoidance
- 44:25methodologies and sration methodologies
- 44:28in the nature context there'll be
- 44:30enhancement methods and protection
- 44:34methods um both regimes um provide for
- 44:37the relinquishment of certificates if
- 44:39there's a reversal event or in the case
- 44:41of nature um repair a significant
- 44:44reversal event um something to observe
- 44:48perhaps in the nature space is that uh
- 44:50where as in you know in ACU land um if
- 44:54there is a uh a loss of carbon stores
- 44:57due to a fire um the extent of of
- 45:00relinquishment can be scaled to the loss
- 45:02of carbon stores whereas um in the
- 45:05biodiversity uh Market as there's only
- 45:08one certificate per project um
- 45:11relinquishment is very much an All or
- 45:12Nothing Affair which uh perhaps could
- 45:16make that as something that's regarded
- 45:18as a more significant risk than in the
- 45:20ACU space um the nature repair Market
- 45:24also borrows Concepts around
- 45:26additionality and permanence periods of
- 45:2825 and 100 years um I guess from a
- 45:31regulatory system design perspective
- 45:33it's smart to borrow uh Concepts that
- 45:36have been Road tested in the market and
- 45:39that we know work uh but the
- 45:42correlations between the two regimes
- 45:44will also potentially be helpful in
- 45:46terms of the uh stacking of projects
- 45:50that Laura mentioned before so the
- 45:52correlation of permanence periods for
- 45:54example may be facilitative of that that
- 45:57stacking um
- 45:59opportunity so turning to the
- 46:01differences um as I mentioned the
- 46:03biggest practical difference will uh be
- 46:06that the um the project under the nature
- 46:09repair scheme will create one large
- 46:12monolithic biodiversity certificate um
- 46:15which will be issued at a single point
- 46:17in time um and so those units aren't
- 46:21going to be highly commodified unitized
- 46:24and fungible um so and that's a big
- 46:28difference for from the acq market where
- 46:30of course um that projects can generate
- 46:33a stream of acus which are sort of
- 46:35Highly fungible units and where it's
- 46:37easy to obtain uh relatively easy to
- 46:41obtain good price Discovery um and so
- 46:45you know there may be some limits to the
- 46:46liquidity of the um the biodiversity
- 46:49certific certificate
- 46:52Market um so that challenge could also
- 46:55stimulate some creativity in how Market
- 46:59participants use these units so um I I
- 47:03observed that there is the ability to
- 47:05deposit a biodiversity certificate with
- 47:07the CER for safekeeping you don't
- 47:09relinquish ownership of it but you can
- 47:11post it with them for
- 47:12safekeeping um so you know one potential
- 47:15concept would be for a carbon aggregator
- 47:17to um Place their biodiversity
- 47:20certificate for their carbon project
- 47:22with the CER for safekeeping and then
- 47:26perhaps look at the opportunity to use
- 47:28that as a form of co- benefit
- 47:30certification rather than trading the
- 47:32unit itself um I think we'll also look
- 47:35to the banks and other clever um
- 47:38innovators in this space to see whether
- 47:40they look at opportunities to unitize or
- 47:43tokenize these units um through their
- 47:46own means if the given that the um
- 47:48government scheme it does itself doesn't
- 47:50allow allow for um further unitization
- 47:54within within a project
- 47:57um another absolutely key difference
- 47:59which we've touched on is that there
- 48:01isn't a mandatory market for
- 48:02biodiversity certificates um because the
- 48:06use of biodiversity certificates is is
- 48:08not um allowed for for offsetting um and
- 48:12that's a key contrast point with acus
- 48:14which can be relinquished for Safeguard
- 48:17mechanism compliance
- 48:19purposes um and as we've discussed there
- 48:22is the statutory architecture for the
- 48:24government to come in and become a major
- 48:28source of demand for biodiversity
- 48:31certificates but um again there's no
- 48:33policy on foot to do so and that's a big
- 48:36point of difference with the acq market
- 48:38where um many millions of dollars have
- 48:40been um funded into the market through
- 48:43uh the emissions reduction
- 48:47fund so another key comparison um is
- 48:51with the biodiversity offset markets
- 48:53which are already operating in in States
- 48:56um and as many of you will already know
- 49:00um when a project is carried out which
- 49:02has an impact on um ecological values um
- 49:07in many cases environmental offsets will
- 49:09be required uh potentially both under
- 49:12state law and under our national
- 49:14environmental law the epbc act and even
- 49:17when those offsets are required to
- 49:20comply with the epbc approval which is a
- 49:22federal approval we tend to turn to
- 49:25State biodiversity um offset markets to
- 49:28satisfy those
- 49:30requirements um so it's an interesting
- 49:33and maybe slightly um perverse results
- 49:37of prohibiting the use of uh nature
- 49:39repair Market um certificates um under
- 49:43the epbc act for offsetting that um it
- 49:47we will continue to use these
- 49:49state-based offset markets and these
- 49:50State based offset markets will continue
- 49:52to operate alongside our national um
- 49:57nature repair
- 49:59scheme so the coexistence of those
- 50:01markets will will be interesting um
- 50:04it'll be interesting to see um you know
- 50:06how much the nature repair Market uh
- 50:09Machinery so the methodologies for
- 50:11example borrow from what's already been
- 50:14learned from the offset um methodologies
- 50:17that are in place um so just to go into
- 50:21a bit more detail in Victoria in our
- 50:24offsetting Market there's generally a
- 50:26require for a 10year activity period um
- 50:29followed by the land needing to be
- 50:31protected in
- 50:33perpetuity um so permanence period in
- 50:37the nature repair Market isn't is
- 50:39certainly not in perpetuity there is a
- 50:41limit to it but if a company is
- 50:44undertaking a nature repair Market
- 50:46project and wants to make claims about
- 50:49um absolute permanence they might borrow
- 50:51a piece of our state offsetting uh
- 50:54architecture and place for example a
- 50:57conservation Covenant on the land so
- 50:59that they can make that green claim um
- 51:02that the land is protected in
- 51:05perpetuity um more differences in in the
- 51:08state schemes we have like for like
- 51:10requirements and in some cases proximity
- 51:12requirements between the offset and the
- 51:15project um so in nature repair there
- 51:20isn't this underlying like for like or
- 51:22proximity requirements but we may
- 51:24nevertheless see um High preferences
- 51:27emerging around um you know some sort of
- 51:31more appealing uh subject matters like
- 51:33the Great Barrier Reef protection or uh
- 51:36charismatic species like koalas or
- 51:38greater guide gliders um and in some
- 51:41cases we may see organizations having a
- 51:44preference for um biodiversity
- 51:46certificates that are generated on land
- 51:49that is proximate to where they're
- 51:51active even though that's not a strict
- 51:54requirement um before moving on to uh
- 51:58the next topic I think the other thing
- 52:00to observe is that there will likely be
- 52:03ongoing competition in terms of access
- 52:05to land with natural Capital potential
- 52:08between these two markets so a
- 52:11well-informed um landh holder May well
- 52:15already have been in touch with their
- 52:17local biodiversity offset broker uh and
- 52:20may have a good understanding of their
- 52:22opportunities in the you know
- 52:24pre-existing biodiversity offset markets
- 52:26and so it's um something to keep in mind
- 52:29for those moving into the nature repair
- 52:31Market that there could could well be
- 52:32this competition from these separate um
- 52:35offset
- 52:38markets so another question clients are
- 52:41asking themselves is where do we fit
- 52:43into the market
- 52:45ecosystem um and apart from sort of
- 52:47Furnishing the opportunity for a bit of
- 52:49a Cheesy pun in the heading there um I
- 52:52do think it's an important um thing for
- 52:55organizations to reflect on and in
- 52:58particular for potential of corporates
- 53:02looking to go into the market from an
- 53:03ESG
- 53:04perspective it is worth considering
- 53:07whether they have the um you know the
- 53:10the ability or the willingness to build
- 53:12up the capability and resources to
- 53:14become proponents of these projects or
- 53:18whether they can support these projects
- 53:20by supplying for example access to their
- 53:23land estate um supplying Capital um
- 53:27maybe even buying into a project
- 53:29proponent that's aggregating projects um
- 53:32across the country and perhaps even just
- 53:35making sure that they've got security of
- 53:37of offtake so um it doesn't necessarily
- 53:41it's not necessarily the case that if an
- 53:43organization wants to be a participant
- 53:45in the market that they need to rush
- 53:47straight into being a project proponent
- 53:50and in many cases organizations might
- 53:52consider an iterative approach where
- 53:54they um participate in in one of these
- 53:57uh ways before moving in the future into
- 54:00becoming a proponent
- 54:04themselves so the key legal
- 54:07considerations for Market
- 54:09participants um look I've mapped out
- 54:11here some of the key legal
- 54:14considerations um the cluster on the
- 54:16left are more of the governance uh type
- 54:19considerations and the cluster on the
- 54:21right are more sort of project level
- 54:24considerations um from head office
- 54:27perspective um you know or organizations
- 54:31are uh now increasingly looking at how
- 54:34their directors and officers are
- 54:35discharging their duties of care and
- 54:37diligence to uh manage and mitigate
- 54:40nature related risk so in moving into
- 54:43nature repair markets it it will be
- 54:46important to think about how these
- 54:48activities tie into and support the
- 54:50organization and its leaders management
- 54:53of uh those risks and opportunities
- 54:57um I can't emphasize enough the
- 54:59greenwashing uh Point um most
- 55:02greenwashing activity uh of late has
- 55:04focused on climate related um marketing
- 55:07materials and representations to
- 55:09shareholders and investors uh but
- 55:12shareholders are uh already and EOS are
- 55:15already F uh turning their focus to
- 55:18Nature related
- 55:19greenwashing um and Asic and AG Z I have
- 55:23no doubt will follow suit uh shortly so
- 55:25having check checks in place to ensure
- 55:28that representations or green claims
- 55:30that are made on the back of nature
- 55:32repair Market participation will be
- 55:34really
- 55:36important um I think the other one I've
- 55:39put there is is compliance pathway I
- 55:41came off the phone this morning with a
- 55:43um large organization that's putting
- 55:45together a compliance uh pathway for
- 55:47their participation in and origination
- 55:50of um carbon farming projects and that
- 55:54will look at all sorts of things from
- 55:56native title through to land use
- 55:59approvals um through to fraud risk risk
- 56:02management and and so on and that will
- 56:05enable Central risk management and
- 56:07compliance teams to take comfort that if
- 56:10it's rolled out with the project
- 56:12origination team and there's a checklist
- 56:14in place that um the company's overall
- 56:17compliance management uh situation will
- 56:20be will be appropriately managed I mean
- 56:23that type of pathway can be picked up
- 56:26applied in the nature repair market and
- 56:29from a governance perspective can help
- 56:30manage risks as um organizations move
- 56:33into nature repair
- 56:35space um turning more to the project
- 56:38side um obviously there'll be a need to
- 56:41give thought to how the deal will be
- 56:43structured and um you know who brings
- 56:46what uh resources and skills to the
- 56:48project how the activities are financed
- 56:51what time Horizons The participants will
- 56:53work together uh and so on um and as I
- 56:57mentioned before you know there's
- 56:59similar deal structures that are already
- 57:01happening in the carbon Market that we
- 57:02can be picking up and adjusting for
- 57:05nature
- 57:06repair um site due diligence will also
- 57:09be important and legal site due
- 57:12diligence might include looking at uh
- 57:14whether the project will impact Native
- 57:16title or cultural heritage and what
- 57:19approvals will be required from
- 57:20traditional
- 57:21owners um it will also be important to
- 57:24look at whether the land already has
- 57:26encumbrances like existing conservation
- 57:28covenants or biodiversity maintenance
- 57:31areas um or restrictive covenants
- 57:34easements leases to third parties that
- 57:36have an inconsistent use of land in mind
- 57:38and so on um and inquiries can be also
- 57:42made about um the the landholder
- 57:45themselves and what if they are to be a
- 57:47proponent whether they are a fit and
- 57:48proper
- 57:50person um so in some cases we and we
- 57:54have encountered this already um
- 57:56companies or proponents of
- 57:58infrastructure projects uh that already
- 58:00have mandatory offsetting requirements
- 58:02under their epbc approval or other
- 58:05approvals are interested in the
- 58:07opportunity in of um setting aside a
- 58:10larger piece of land than is required
- 58:12under their approval and then using that
- 58:14extra bit for the voluntary markets um
- 58:18and there's certainly nothing stopping
- 58:20that and in fact it could be quite a
- 58:22good outcome because it will reduce Edge
- 58:25effect potentially could create habitat
- 58:28corridors could sort of help support uh
- 58:31larger breeding uh colonies within a
- 58:34larger area um so there's potentially
- 58:37something to suggest itself there um
- 58:40although the challenge will be that
- 58:42because the nature ofair Market can't be
- 58:43used for offsetting um you could have
- 58:46one contiguous piece of land that's
- 58:48holistically managed but there's an
- 58:49invisible line during through the Middle
- 58:52with one side being managed under state
- 58:54offsetting laws and the other being
- 58:56managed under the nature repair uh
- 58:58market so a fair bit of sort of admin to
- 59:01take care of uh making sure those are
- 59:04integrated
- 59:05carefully um and the other piece to call
- 59:08out is of course putting in place
- 59:10measures um principally backed up by
- 59:13contract but also through technical
- 59:14means to manage key project risks and
- 59:18the obvious one is the risks around
- 59:20reversal events um but also things like
- 59:23the risk of land changing hands uh the
- 59:26risk of misleading information going to
- 59:28the clean energy regulator uh and so on
- 59:31so I I list those things not just aest
- 59:34that this is hard and difficult and
- 59:35impossible and in fact our experience in
- 59:38the biodiversity offset space and the
- 59:40carbon uh trading space is that these
- 59:42are very uh manageable and achievable uh
- 59:46things to do and it's just a matter of
- 59:48working through them as you go uh into
- 59:50the market so I'll stop
- 59:53there thanks very much Julian if you go
- 59:56to your next slide it's got your your
- 59:58contact details
- 1:00:00there and uh there there's a lot of Mark
- 1:00:03questions again the quite a few
- 1:00:04questions about permanence Jillian about
- 1:00:07um is there a time frame for for these
- 1:00:10certificates or are they in
- 1:00:12perpetuity that is a really interesting
- 1:00:14question so the certificates uh will
- 1:00:18continue to exist until the underlying
- 1:00:21project uh is completed so if it's a 25e
- 1:00:25project the certificate will um come to
- 1:00:27an end in 25 years uh and if it's a
- 1:00:30100-year project it will come to an end
- 1:00:32in 100 uh years um the other point to
- 1:00:36make is that if the underlying project
- 1:00:38is is deregistered my understanding is
- 1:00:40that the certificate is also uh
- 1:00:42deregistered so that sort of unbundling
- 1:00:46from the underlying land and the project
- 1:00:48isn't perhaps as complete as we see in
- 1:00:50the acute
- 1:00:52Market thanks there's also a series of
- 1:00:55questions there about about cost and
- 1:00:56complexity do you think that this will
- 1:00:58mean that really there are scale limits
- 1:01:01to the projects that can actually go
- 1:01:03ahead here because there's so much
- 1:01:04probity and Regulatory cost that it only
- 1:01:07works for very large project
- 1:01:10areas I think that it is an an
- 1:01:12interesting observation um you know the
- 1:01:15the flip side of all this fantastic
- 1:01:16governance and integrity is that the um
- 1:01:20the cost and complexity in getting a
- 1:01:22project up U may be higher than uh
- 1:01:26perhaps looking at a a less evolved
- 1:01:29scheme so um it's certainly something
- 1:01:32that we've seen uh where we've been
- 1:01:34approached by clients that simply just
- 1:01:36want to get on with a project they're
- 1:01:39getting for example pressure from head
- 1:01:41office abroad to get trees in the ground
- 1:01:43and do it quickly and we've sort of um
- 1:01:46you know it is a consideration that if
- 1:01:48there's a small scale Pro planting
- 1:01:50project that a an organization wants to
- 1:01:52carry out with the local CMA will it the
- 1:01:56right fit to look to have this
- 1:01:58registered under the um the scheme given
- 1:02:00all the the delay and cost that that
- 1:02:02might uh bring with it um there there
- 1:02:05may well be projects that of a smaller
- 1:02:08scale and where there's a sort of an
- 1:02:09impatience to get going um where it will
- 1:02:12be appropriate for organizations to to
- 1:02:15look at other
- 1:02:17options and a final one jul and this
- 1:02:20might be one for Laura as well when you
- 1:02:21look back on this scheme in 10 years
- 1:02:23time do you think that the the new
- 1:02:25certificate
- 1:02:26um process is a game
- 1:02:28changer amongst all the other investment
- 1:02:31opportunities that that you've talked
- 1:02:34about that is an interesting question I
- 1:02:38I do see it as a a g game changer
- 1:02:42there's the signaling to Australian
- 1:02:45business that this is a credible
- 1:02:48activity for them to participate in um
- 1:02:53there is the creation of a secure a unit
- 1:02:56that um isn't just sitting on an
- 1:02:58administrative registry it is sitting on
- 1:02:59a legislative registry and um it has the
- 1:03:03backing of you know the Constitution if
- 1:03:05if it's unjustly taken from you through
- 1:03:08legislative change then you're entitled
- 1:03:10to compensation I mean that's a that's a
- 1:03:12big thing to in in terms of gaining the
- 1:03:15confidence of in investors and um
- 1:03:17signaling that this is something that
- 1:03:19can be um invested in with some degree
- 1:03:22of of confidence um it's there's aspects
- 1:03:25of it that I think a little bit clunky
- 1:03:26and um you know over the course of 10
- 1:03:29years I don't think I'd be surprised if
- 1:03:31we saw the the architecture evolve
- 1:03:34somewhat to to make it more investable
- 1:03:37but um I I do see it as a step change in
- 1:03:39terms of how we look at nature markets
- 1:03:43Laura
- 1:03:44Laura I think we um probably would just
- 1:03:47have the same response almost I guess
- 1:03:49what I would say is that one thing
- 1:03:51investors love is regulatory certainty
- 1:03:53and so having government backed volun
- 1:03:56scheme is a step change for Australia
- 1:03:59it's also a step change globally as I
- 1:04:00said Australia is the first government
- 1:04:02to have come out and legislated for that
- 1:04:04um so I think it is a bit of a a
- 1:04:06trailblazing move the question will
- 1:04:10be as Jillian alluded to whether or not
- 1:04:12the the product uh architecture
- 1:04:14currently is going to support the demand
- 1:04:16side in in the way that kind of makes
- 1:04:19sense for them to be able to make claims
- 1:04:21about the products that are consistent
- 1:04:23with the types of reporting that they're
- 1:04:24going to need to be doing under the the
- 1:04:25tnfd and things like that there there's
- 1:04:28a little bit of um uncertainty about
- 1:04:30exactly how it will play out from the
- 1:04:31ban side but I think it is like a bold
- 1:04:35um move in terms of having a government
- 1:04:37back scheme that rightly be called a
- 1:04:39step
- 1:04:41change thanks very much and thanks
- 1:04:43Julian as well so Carl we'll move to you
- 1:04:45now uh from the view from the the
- 1:04:49regulator right thanks uh Ian um could I
- 1:04:52also just start by acknowledging country
- 1:04:54um here on N small country um uh at the
- 1:04:57turn of the Season always a beautiful
- 1:05:00time of year here in CRA and just
- 1:05:02acknowledge Elders past present and
- 1:05:04emerging and particularly just
- 1:05:06acknowledge um all the tus Strate
- 1:05:08Islander and Aboriginal people uh who
- 1:05:11have joined the call and just reflect
- 1:05:13you know how important this work is and
- 1:05:16how important uh we create Pathways for
- 1:05:19First Nations uh participation and
- 1:05:21acknowledge uh country and Heritage and
- 1:05:25um traditional ecological knowledge uh
- 1:05:28in everything that we
- 1:05:29do um also just wanted to say it's uh
- 1:05:32incredible to see 250 uh people on the
- 1:05:36call I scan through the list there are a
- 1:05:38couple of old friends for me uh but more
- 1:05:41excitingly there are uh so many uh new
- 1:05:44people and um if we just go to the next
- 1:05:47slide in um uh I just going to very
- 1:05:50briefly reflect on the role of the C uh
- 1:05:54in the market um
- 1:05:56and I'll try and do that fairly briefly
- 1:05:58um uh because uh Tony and others have
- 1:06:01sort of covered the ground and there's
- 1:06:04much more to discover than we know uh
- 1:06:07today um and so then I'll reflect a
- 1:06:09little bit on what I think some of the
- 1:06:12uh opportunities and challenges uh sort
- 1:06:15of moving uh forward are and um you know
- 1:06:20reflecting on uh I just think this is an
- 1:06:23incredible opportunity but is it's also
- 1:06:25another step on a a long journey and i'
- 1:06:28I'd like to call out and acknowledge
- 1:06:30sort of people whove been working in
- 1:06:32this space for you know uh decades in uh
- 1:06:35some cases some of whom are on the call
- 1:06:37today so just turning briefly uh to the
- 1:06:41next slide and the role of uh the
- 1:06:44regulator
- 1:06:46um uh our role is to administer uh the
- 1:06:50market and uh to do so in a way that has
- 1:06:54you know trans Arcy uh integrity and
- 1:06:58underpins uh the fact that products that
- 1:07:00are being produced are property um and
- 1:07:04can be traded and create a platform and
- 1:07:07register through which things can be
- 1:07:09traded so uh at the regulator we um uh
- 1:07:14look after a range of environmental
- 1:07:15markets as I'm sure people uh are aware
- 1:07:18so we look after the Safeguard mechanism
- 1:07:21we look after acus we look after the
- 1:07:23renewable energy Target we're doing the
- 1:07:25foundational work for uh guarantee of
- 1:07:29origin and um we will leverage all of
- 1:07:32that existing
- 1:07:33infrastructure um and so that allows us
- 1:07:36to register people register projects
- 1:07:39assess applications against a
- 1:07:41methodology as Tony has outlined issue
- 1:07:45certificates register those certificates
- 1:07:48um uh enable them to be traded um and
- 1:07:53allow information to flow about those
- 1:07:56projects and as I talk through some of
- 1:07:59the opportunities and challenges um I
- 1:08:01think we'll um shine a light on there's
- 1:08:05a lot in uh each of those uh
- 1:08:08functions um and for us there's also
- 1:08:12just a lot of foundational work that
- 1:08:13needs to be done uh to ensure that our
- 1:08:16it systems work that our it systems are
- 1:08:19secure that the registry is functional
- 1:08:22uh that the certificates can be lodged
- 1:08:23they can be held securely as a financial
- 1:08:26product etc etc and so um we're busy
- 1:08:30busy sort of building those uh
- 1:08:33foundations uh sort of currently if we
- 1:08:36move to the next
- 1:08:39slide um so I I just wanted to reflect a
- 1:08:43little bit um on the nature of the
- 1:08:46opportunity and maybe building on the
- 1:08:48earlier conversation um reflecting that
- 1:08:52I I do think this is uh potentially a a
- 1:08:55a game
- 1:08:56changer um uh I've sort of been
- 1:09:01reflecting a little bit as someone who
- 1:09:03sort of involved in writing about
- 1:09:05biodiversity conservation and private
- 1:09:07land stewardship uh right back in the
- 1:09:09early
- 1:09:101990s and um there's lots of things that
- 1:09:14we're building upon here so um one of
- 1:09:18the first things is to remember that we
- 1:09:20have um you know tens or hundreds of
- 1:09:22thousands of land stewards in Australia
- 1:09:24and they have
- 1:09:26existing Suite of responsibilities and a
- 1:09:29stewardship function as it stands today
- 1:09:33um back then in the 90s we we talked
- 1:09:35about the duty of care that a land owner
- 1:09:38has uh to be a responsible Steward of
- 1:09:41biodiversity then running alongside that
- 1:09:43you had um lots of people involved in
- 1:09:46private lands conservation be the
- 1:09:48covenanting organizations like trust for
- 1:09:50nature or bush Heritage fund Australian
- 1:09:53Wildlife Conservancy the Us's nature
- 1:09:56conservancy also came to Australia and
- 1:09:59then you had a whole Community movement
- 1:10:01Bush care land care a whole bunch of
- 1:10:03related activities um and in and amongst
- 1:10:07all that um you've had tens of thousands
- 1:10:10of land managers in one way or another
- 1:10:13involved in private lands uh
- 1:10:16stewardship and reflecting back on all
- 1:10:19that I think there's a dilemma um in
- 1:10:22that we need to create
- 1:10:26property we need to unitize we need to
- 1:10:29make it fungible and we need to ensure
- 1:10:31that it's seen and valued across society
- 1:10:34and through businesses hence the
- 1:10:37creation um of a more formalized market
- 1:10:39and certificates is a good idea um but
- 1:10:42it is hard and um sitting underneath
- 1:10:47that we need active
- 1:10:51Pro um or ProActive Management
- 1:10:56active stewards who are looking to
- 1:10:58improve biodiversity outcomes every day
- 1:11:02and I wanted to start just by reflecting
- 1:11:04that those two things aren't entirely um
- 1:11:08comfortable uh bed fellows uh so uh if
- 1:11:12you um ask someone who does something
- 1:11:15voluntarily and then you commoditize it
- 1:11:18you unleash a range of dynamics that can
- 1:11:20actually get uh quite difficult uh to
- 1:11:24manage
- 1:11:25um but nevertheless I think it's an
- 1:11:27absolutely necessary step because it
- 1:11:31gives the opportunity for biodiversity
- 1:11:33to be recognized and valued in the
- 1:11:37marketplace um and we can see that it's
- 1:11:39important as others have said because
- 1:11:42carbon markets are starting to
- 1:11:45discriminate uh so uh they're looking
- 1:11:48for nature-based Solutions they're
- 1:11:50looking for First Nations and Indigenous
- 1:11:52uh
- 1:11:53participation they're looking looking
- 1:11:55for mechanisms by which um other
- 1:11:58products including food supply chains
- 1:12:00can recognize other values uh that land
- 1:12:03managers uh deliver um and their
- 1:12:06delivery of ecosystem
- 1:12:08services and so ideally if we think
- 1:12:11about this from a land managers uh point
- 1:12:14of view they will have on a single set
- 1:12:17of land a set of accounts from which
- 1:12:20they can create a whole bunch of
- 1:12:21different rights whether it be
- 1:12:23biodiversity uh C Cal Heritage rights
- 1:12:27through First Nations
- 1:12:28participation uh sustainable and
- 1:12:31certified food products
- 1:12:34Etc um I think though the CH the
- 1:12:38opportunity in the next 10 to 15 years
- 1:12:41will be dominated by the presence of
- 1:12:44carbon as the big Financial driver uh in
- 1:12:47this
- 1:12:48Marketplace so as uh the world grapples
- 1:12:52with the climate Challenge and carbon
- 1:12:54increas ly is recognized and has a price
- 1:12:58and has uh markets to trade in people
- 1:13:01will start to look for multiple benefit
- 1:13:05and how we start and modify a market
- 1:13:10with that large driving force sitting in
- 1:13:15behind it I think is the one of the
- 1:13:17things that we need to uh discover over
- 1:13:20the next 10 years or so I'm really
- 1:13:23encouraged by the issue in of um
- 1:13:26biodiversity certificates I think it's a
- 1:13:29start uh but not an end point but that's
- 1:13:31often uh the way these things uh go um
- 1:13:36and so I sort of had the last doop point
- 1:13:38on this slide around uh from uh Little
- 1:13:41Things uh big things grow so I don't
- 1:13:45think uh the market um uh is anywhere
- 1:13:48near mature I don't think between Tony's
- 1:13:52team and my team that are working
- 1:13:54incredibly closely with one another I
- 1:13:56don't think we're going to be able to
- 1:13:57answer uh all the questions I don't
- 1:14:00think we're going to uh deliver you know
- 1:14:03a fully uh mature uh Marketplace uh on
- 1:14:07day one but what we are going to do uh
- 1:14:10is create the possibility uh that people
- 1:14:14who are sitting outside of natural areas
- 1:14:17can participate in the protection and
- 1:14:19management of those natural areas and be
- 1:14:22recognized uh for doing so and I think
- 1:14:25over time those participants as well as
- 1:14:28governments will then learn modify
- 1:14:31refine and further mature a Marketplace
- 1:14:34and I think uh that's the best way of
- 1:14:36thinking about uh this uh step of the
- 1:14:39journey let's go to the next
- 1:14:42slide um so the challenges um one of the
- 1:14:46big challenges is um we've um elected I
- 1:14:50think perhaps wisely um not to
- 1:14:53unitize um
- 1:14:55so there isn't a unit of biodiversity
- 1:14:58credit there is a biodiversity credit
- 1:15:00that is aligned to a
- 1:15:03certificate um so I'm trying to sort of
- 1:15:07communicate this and I think it already
- 1:15:08has been done so but are you are a van
- 1:15:11go person or a Fred Williams person or
- 1:15:15um Kanani heel I'm not quite sure who
- 1:15:17that is must be an emerging artist um
- 1:15:21each of the pictures has got their own
- 1:15:23Beauty um each of them has got a
- 1:15:26different
- 1:15:27origin and a different history a whole
- 1:15:31bunch of different attributes about it
- 1:15:33and are presumably worth uh different
- 1:15:36amounts uh of
- 1:15:38money um and sitting within that analog
- 1:15:42or that metaphor of of the paintings
- 1:15:44there are a whole number of questions
- 1:15:46how how do we
- 1:15:48register what the
- 1:15:51attributes um of a biodiversity
- 1:15:53certificate are
- 1:15:55um are those um attributes codified
- 1:16:00legislated verified with compliance
- 1:16:04monitored or are there other attributes
- 1:16:06of projects where a claim is essentially
- 1:16:09made by a project owner or a project
- 1:16:12proponent but they're subject to
- 1:16:15verification um of the purchaser in the
- 1:16:17same way that when you buy a car um you
- 1:16:21uh have to do your own verification
- 1:16:23around what you're uh buying
- 1:16:25and if we look at uh the bi if we look
- 1:16:28at the carbon market and how it's
- 1:16:30currently evolving we are starting to
- 1:16:33see some small differentials in the
- 1:16:36market around uh pricing for uh
- 1:16:39different types of Australian carbon
- 1:16:41credit units um so those that um have
- 1:16:45First Nations participation some of the
- 1:16:48Savannah projects up north for example
- 1:16:50attract a reasonable premium uh in the
- 1:16:53marketplace
- 1:16:54we also have uh project owners making a
- 1:16:58whole range of claims uh around um why
- 1:17:03their projects uh might be uh better or
- 1:17:07differentiated uh from others and then
- 1:17:10at the other end of the spectrum on uh
- 1:17:12the demand side we have purchasers who
- 1:17:15are vitally interested um in assuring
- 1:17:18themselves that the projects that they
- 1:17:19become involved with uh generate um
- 1:17:22Australian carbon credit units that they
- 1:17:24are incredibly comfortable with and
- 1:17:27proud to be associated with and on the
- 1:17:30other hand um there are organizations on
- 1:17:33the demand side uh who are simply uh
- 1:17:36seeking a unit of carbon um that is
- 1:17:39certified by government uh that can be
- 1:17:41utilized uh for compliance purposes and
- 1:17:45so there's a whole Myriad of issues
- 1:17:48embedded in that story of what is a
- 1:17:50certificate what are its attributes
- 1:17:53what's it worth
- 1:17:55how's it registered what information do
- 1:17:58we log around uh that and what are the
- 1:18:03things that we're verifying versus what
- 1:18:05are the things that a buyer and seller
- 1:18:08need to negotiate uh between
- 1:18:11themselves um another huge challenge is
- 1:18:14clearly verifying uh uh
- 1:18:17outcomes um I think the only observation
- 1:18:20I'd make today is that a regulator
- 1:18:22operating in isolation is going to have
- 1:18:25to have an extraordinarily large staff
- 1:18:28um uh or is going to have to rely on
- 1:18:31others in one way or another uh I think
- 1:18:34we need to take a pragmatic approach uh
- 1:18:38particularly uh in the early stages of
- 1:18:40the formation of the market and I think
- 1:18:43there is a huge untapped resource uh in
- 1:18:45our existing uh land holder networks and
- 1:18:48also a wide range of our community
- 1:18:51organizations and so um I think uh that
- 1:18:55will be uh quite interesting to see how
- 1:18:57that U Maps out uh the final uh second
- 1:19:02last sort of challenge that I wanted to
- 1:19:04highlight is um one of the most
- 1:19:08important things when you are beginning
- 1:19:10to form a market is we need people to
- 1:19:13participate uh and so I regularly uh put
- 1:19:16myself in the position of uh thinking
- 1:19:19through if I was a land manager how
- 1:19:21would I react uh to this uh do I need a
- 1:19:27professional uh broker uh to uh support
- 1:19:30me uh in developing biodiversity project
- 1:19:34or is it something that I could take on
- 1:19:37on my
- 1:19:38own um uh how does this
- 1:19:42integrate uh with um the verification
- 1:19:45I'm doing uh for the food and fiber
- 1:19:48products that I'm selling into the
- 1:19:51marketplace how does it relate to the
- 1:19:53carbon project that I just entered into
- 1:19:56can we align our Administration can we
- 1:19:59align our reporting uh can we align
- 1:20:03compliance and audit uh services so they
- 1:20:06uh operate uh
- 1:20:08seamlessly uh all of these things are
- 1:20:11sort of not uh significant uh
- 1:20:14insignificant um barriers so I think
- 1:20:18there are um many things we could think
- 1:20:21through and um seek to codify if we are
- 1:20:24and try and create if you like the
- 1:20:26perfect uh
- 1:20:28Marketplace um and uh at the other book
- 1:20:31end um there would be a strategy around
- 1:20:35uh I suppose letting a thousand flowers
- 1:20:37bloom I suppose based on uh sort of uh
- 1:20:41lived experience I would say um the
- 1:20:44answer obviously lies a little bit in
- 1:20:45the middle we need some clear guard
- 1:20:47rails so that people can be assured that
- 1:20:50when they participate um and when they
- 1:20:52purchase uh that they are
- 1:20:55buying a commodity if you like that has
- 1:20:58genuine value and on the other hand we
- 1:21:00need to uh resist making um uh the
- 1:21:05process so complex uh that it becomes uh
- 1:21:08impossible to
- 1:21:09participate um so I might sort of just
- 1:21:13finish the last stop point Sorry on um
- 1:21:16Market formation I think um uh imagining
- 1:21:21and envisaging what the trading
- 1:21:23platforms are and how we bring uh buyers
- 1:21:26and sellers uh together um what that
- 1:21:30Marketplace looks like uh and how it
- 1:21:33functions and uh supporting a variety of
- 1:21:36different ways in which uh people can
- 1:21:38trade and one of the things that we are
- 1:21:41currently doing with our Registries is
- 1:21:43seeking to modernize those Registries so
- 1:21:46that various trading platforms can put
- 1:21:49uh apis into the registry to enable uh
- 1:21:52you know very efficient Trading
- 1:21:54marketing and settlement of these things
- 1:21:57and uh whilst that's all uh fairly
- 1:22:00administrative uh stuff it's incredibly
- 1:22:02important in getting uh functioning uh
- 1:22:05liquid and deep markets over time so
- 1:22:08I'll finish there
- 1:22:10thanks thanks very much Carl we haven't
- 1:22:13got much time but there's
- 1:22:14a a bunch of questions that really
- 1:22:17relate to the point that you made about
- 1:22:19um really commodification that the the
- 1:22:21danger of of making everything TR
- 1:22:24transactional this um a question by Paul
- 1:22:27moxen for example arguing that this
- 1:22:30whole commodification is really the the
- 1:22:32um the opposite almost of an indigenous
- 1:22:34view of of value are we in the process
- 1:22:38of really um you know if you think about
- 1:22:42the whole land care movement and how
- 1:22:44that's
- 1:22:45transformed uh a lot of the landscape in
- 1:22:47a voluntary sense are we in danger of
- 1:22:50commodifying this so much that we'll
- 1:22:53sort of degrade a lot of the values that
- 1:22:55underpin a lot of the work we've seen
- 1:22:58over the last
- 1:23:00decades um
- 1:23:03well I don't think government and I I
- 1:23:06don't think uh corporate Australia are
- 1:23:08ever going to be able to afford um the
- 1:23:11full cost of biodiversity conservation
- 1:23:15and so um uh the engagement and
- 1:23:19encouragement of individual land owners
- 1:23:22uh to take uh self-direct action is
- 1:23:26going to remain incredibly important and
- 1:23:28there's a very long and proud history of
- 1:23:30of that in Australia as I talked about
- 1:23:32earlier and I think the interaction
- 1:23:35between that and a if you like a
- 1:23:38commoditized uh Market is one of the
- 1:23:41more difficult things uh to navigate and
- 1:23:44so you know in an Ideal World um we want
- 1:23:48those two markets to be highly
- 1:23:50complimentary uh to one another um and
- 1:23:54it probably also plays into this issue
- 1:23:56around uh additionality and that
- 1:23:59biodiversity has got that sort of unique
- 1:24:01attribute of requiring proactive and
- 1:24:03ongoing management and so um uh all I
- 1:24:08could really do is acknowledge that
- 1:24:10those tensions exist um and I would
- 1:24:14underscore I don't think that's a reason
- 1:24:16not to create a
- 1:24:17Marketplace because a Marketplace
- 1:24:20creates an opportunity for those who
- 1:24:22otherwise couldn't participate
- 1:24:25uh to participate and be recognized for
- 1:24:27their contribution so I think it's an
- 1:24:29incredibly part of the mix but I don't
- 1:24:32think it's the whole
- 1:24:34story we're gonna have to leave it there
- 1:24:36I'm afraid and uh I just like to um
- 1:24:39invite you to come to next week's
- 1:24:41seminars where we'll talk more about
- 1:24:42this whole uh the
- 1:24:45biodiversity and aspects of this of this
- 1:24:48issue I would just like to thank though
- 1:24:51our speakers today Tony Laura Julian and
- 1:24:53Carl for their generosity thanks
- 1:24:55everybody for coming along we'll um send
- 1:24:58this um video out to everybody along
- 1:25:02with as many uh answers to the uh 50 or
- 1:25:05so questions that we can U muster thanks
- 1:25:09again for coming along and have a great
- 1:25:11day thank
- 1:25:13you thanks Ian
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Alluvium Foundation nature repair market webinar session 1 24/4/24 by Alluvium Foundation, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,312 words across 2,052 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.