AI Can Copy Any App Now - Here's What People Will Still Pay For — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Everyone and their mom is talking about
- 0:02one GitHub repo right now. It's called
- 0:04REA, and that stands for reverse
- 0:06engineer anything. You point Claude at
- 0:09an app you don't have the code for, and
- 0:11Claude figures out how it works. Then,
- 0:14you can rebuild it from scratch for
- 0:17free. It has over 149,000 stars on
- 0:20GitHub, but here's the weird part. It's
- 0:236 months old, and for almost all of that
- 0:25time, nobody [music] cared. Last
- 0:27Wednesday, it had about 13,000 stars.
- 0:30Five days later, it had 149,000.
- 0:34It blew up the same week someone used
- 0:36Claude to build free copies of Photoshop
- 0:38and six other Adobe apps. So, people
- 0:41were already asking how far AI can go
- 0:44with copying apps. REA showed up with an
- 0:47answer. One post on X put it like this,
- 0:50"We spent years teaching AI to write
- 0:52software. Now, we're teaching it to take
- 0:54software apart." When I first saw it, I
- 0:56figured it was a hacker tool I'd never
- 0:58touch, but it actually answers a
- 1:00question I've been stuck on since my
- 1:02last video, which was about those Adobe
- 1:04copies. If anyone can copy an app, what
- 1:08are people going to pay for? So, here's
- 1:10a quick test you can run on your own
- 1:13product right now. Ask yourself one
- 1:15question about whatever you sell. If
- 1:18someone copied my product perfectly
- 1:20tomorrow, why would my customers stay?
- 1:23Whatever your answer is, that's your
- 1:25moat. A moat is just the thing that
- 1:27keeps competitors from copying you. And
- 1:29if you can't answer that question, you
- 1:31first need to give your customers a
- 1:33reason to stay. Maybe you answer their
- 1:35messages the same day. Maybe you already
- 1:37know their business inside [music] and
- 1:39out. Maybe they just like working with
- 1:41you. None of those have anything to do
- 1:43with your code. Get one of those first
- 1:46before you worry about anyone copying
- 1:48your app. [music] So, I'll show you what
- 1:50REA actually does, and who should and
- 1:53shouldn't touch it.
- 1:55Then, I'll give you the three things
- 1:56people will still pay for when anyone
- 1:58can copy anything. The third one is the
- 2:01one I'm betting my whole business on. If
- 2:03you like building cool things with
- 2:05Claude, I co-founded the Claude Code
- 2:07Club. That's where we build stuff like
- 2:09this together, and the link's in my
- 2:11description.
- 2:12Before any of that, you need to
- 2:13understand one thing. Every app on your
- 2:16computer is a sealed box. Photoshop,
- 2:19Notion, the game you played as a kid.
- 2:21You get the box, but you never get the
- 2:23code inside it. For a long time, opening
- 2:26that box took a specialist and a lot of
- 2:29patience. What the REA repo does is hand
- 2:32that sealed box to Claude, so Claude can
- 2:34open it up and see how the app [music]
- 2:36works. So, what is REA really? Well, REA
- 2:40is a free add-on for your AI agent. It
- 2:42works with Claude Code, Codex, Cursor,
- 2:44Gemini CLI, and a few others.
- 2:47>> [music]
- 2:47>> It plugs in through something called
- 2:48MCP, which is just a way to give Claude
- 2:51new tools. Installing it is easy. Just
- 2:54paste the GitHub link [music] into
- 2:56Claude Code and say, "Install this for
- 2:58me." Claude sets it up, and then you
- 3:00restart Claude Code. Pro tip, before you
- 3:02install it, paste the same link and ask
- 3:04Claude what this repo does and how you
- 3:06could use it.
- 3:08Now, Claude has a toolbox for looking
- 3:10inside apps. So, here's how it works
- 3:12under the hood.
- 3:14When a company ships an app, its code
- 3:15gets turned into machine code. That's
- 3:17the ones and zeros your computer runs,
- 3:19and a human can't read it. There are
- 3:21other programs that turn machine code
- 3:23back into something a human can read.
- 3:26The big ones are called Ghidra, Hopper,
- 3:27and IDA. Ghidra is free, and fun fact,
- 3:30the NSA built it. REA lets Claude drive
- 3:33those programs for you. Claude asks a
- 3:36question, REA digs into the app, and it
- 3:38shows you the exact spots in the app
- 3:40that prove its answer, so you know it
- 3:42isn't guessing. [music]
- 3:44It also tells you what it couldn't
- 3:45figure out. Think of it like a chef at a
- 3:47restaurant. Normal coding with Claude is
- 3:49cooking from a recipe card. You have the
- 3:51formula, so you can make it. REA is the
- 3:54chef who can figure out the entire
- 3:56recipe and every ingredient from a
- 3:58single bite. The example prompt in their
- 4:01own repo is simple. You type this into
- 4:03Claude. Understand how search works in
- 4:05the notes app, show me the evidence, and
- 4:07build a similar feature for my project.
- 4:10Swap notes for any app and swap search
- 4:12for any feature you like. The last part
- 4:15is the line that got everyone talking.
- 4:17Build a similar feature for my project.
- 4:20Another pro tip is give Claude
- 4:22screenshots of the feature you want or
- 4:24tell it to open the app and look for
- 4:26itself. The more Claude can see, the
- 4:28better it does. So, how far can it
- 4:30actually go? The use cases people have
- 4:32come up with are wild. So, what are
- 4:35people actually building with it? Well,
- 4:37here are three real examples. The first
- 4:38use case comes from a developer named
- 4:40Mukesh Murugan. He pointed REA at the
- 4:43color picker in PowerToys, which is
- 4:45Microsoft's free toolkit for Windows. He
- 4:47only gave Claude the finished app, not
- 4:50the code. But, Microsoft's code for that
- 4:52app is public, so he could check REA's
- 4:54answers against what Microsoft actually
- 4:56built. REA got eight out of nine
- 4:59findings fully right. Then, he used what
- 5:01it found to build his own color picker
- 5:03in under 750 lines of code. The second
- 5:06use case is a game called DX Ball. It's
- 5:08a brick breaker game from the 1990s. One
- 5:10developer even used REA to find the
- 5:13exact math the game uses to move the
- 5:15sound from your left speaker to your
- 5:17right as the ball moves. Then, they
- 5:20rebuilt that math from scratch. The
- 5:22rebuilt version matched the original
- 5:24game in all 3,205
- 5:26tests down to the exact byte. That's a
- 5:2930-year-old game rebuilt without ever
- 5:32seeing its code. And the third use case
- 5:34is the one that made me stop scrolling.
- 5:36Another developer pointed REA at a free
- 5:39trial of QuickBooks, the accounting app.
- 5:42Then, they built their own open-source
- 5:44accounting app with invoices, bank
- 5:46imports, and reports. Even they say REA
- 5:49didn't hand them the original code or a
- 5:51finished product in one step, and that
- 5:53it took real work. But, think about
- 5:55that. One person studied a paid app
- 5:58that's worth billions of dollars and
- 6:00built their own version of it. And it
- 6:02goes way past desktop apps. The repo
- 6:05lists websites, Android apps, the code
- 6:07inside devices, and even crash reports.
- 6:10Now, some people on XA say a lot of
- 6:12those stars are just hype, people
- 6:13clicking a star to save it for later,
- 6:15and that's fair. But, the downloads tell
- 6:17the same story. In September, the
- 6:19install package got downloaded about 100
- 6:22times a week. Last week, it got
- 6:24downloaded 128,470
- 6:27times. So, people aren't just starring
- 6:30it, they're actually installing it. But,
- 6:32just because you can point REA at any
- 6:34app doesn't mean you should. So, should
- 6:37you install it? I'll give you my honest
- 6:38take, and it might not be the one you
- 6:40expect. Think of REA like a locksmith
- 6:43set of picks. Owning one is legal, what
- 6:45you open with it is the part that
- 6:47[music] matters. The makers are really
- 6:49clear about this. REA is for security
- 6:51research, learning, making your own app
- 6:54work with other apps, saving old
- 6:55software, and checking software you own.
- 6:58Their own rules say they won't help you
- 7:00break copy protection, build game
- 7:01cheats, or copy someone else's paid
- 7:04software. So, that QuickBooks project
- 7:06sits right in the gray area. Studying
- 7:08how an app works is one thing, copying
- 7:10it is another, and trying to sell your
- 7:13own copy of someone else's product is a
- 7:15major red flag. And reverse engineering
- 7:18an app can break its license agreement
- 7:20depending on where you live and what you
- 7:22agree to. I'm not a lawyer, so if you're
- 7:24doing this for a business, ask one. So,
- 7:26who should use it? If you do security
- 7:28work, this was built for you. If your
- 7:30company still runs an old tool and
- 7:32nobody has the code anymore, this is
- 7:34huge for you. And if you want to
- 7:36understand how a feature works so you
- 7:38can build your own version, it's an
- 7:39amazing way to learn. So, who shouldn't
- 7:42use it? If you haven't shipped your
- 7:44first project with Claude yet, skip it
- 7:46for now. The deep stuff needs extra
- 7:48programs like Hopper or Ghidra, and it
- 7:50gets technical fast. I've never written
- 7:53a line of code by hand in my life. I
- 7:55build with Claude every single day, and
- 7:57I'm still not the main user for [music]
- 7:59this tool. So, for most of you, the tool
- 8:01itself isn't what matters. What it means
- 8:03for the apps you build is what matters.
- 8:05Because REA isn't the only repo like
- 8:08this. A couple days ago, I made a whole
- 8:10video about another one called Art
- 8:12Craft. And when you put Art Craft and
- 8:14REA together, it all comes down to one
- 8:16simple question. If anyone can copy
- 8:19anything, what are people actually going
- 8:21to pay for? To answer that, you need to
- 8:23see what Art Craft pulled off. An
- 8:25engineer named Brandon Thomas used
- 8:27Claude to build free, open-source copies
- 8:29of seven Adobe apps, including
- 8:31Photoshop, Premiere, and Lightroom. The
- 8:34Photoshop copy alone got over 24,000
- 8:36stars on GitHub in 8 days, [music] and
- 8:38his team never touched Adobe's code.
- 8:41They rebuilt every app from scratch
- 8:43using public documents and by studying
- 8:45how Adobe's apps look and behave. If you
- 8:47want the full breakdown of all seven
- 8:49apps, I'll link that video right here.
- 8:51So, put those two repos side by side.
- 8:53Art Craft never opened Adobe's sealed
- 8:55box. They rebuilt the apps from scratch
- 8:58from the outside. REA opens the box and
- 9:01looks inside all the way down to the
- 9:03machine code. So, now Claude can rebuild
- 9:06an app from the outside and look at one
- 9:08from the inside, so there's not much
- 9:09left of an app that stays hidden.
- 9:12Now, are the copies as good as the real
- 9:13thing? Not yet. Art Craft's own team
- 9:16says their Photoshop copy isn't ready
- 9:17for daily professional work, but the
- 9:19cost of copying an app just dropped like
- 9:21a rock, and it keeps dropping. So, back
- 9:24to that question. If anyone can copy
- 9:26anything, what are people going to pay
- 9:29for? And honestly, the answer was
- 9:31sitting in my own business the whole
- 9:32time. The Claude Code Club is $9 a month
- 9:35and has over 8,000 members, and there's
- 9:37a lot of content about code code on
- 9:39YouTube for free, but people pay anyway.
- 9:42[music] So, why? Because they like the
- 9:45way we teach, so they trust us. And free
- 9:48YouTube is a lot of noise. You watch 10
- 9:50different people and you still don't
- 9:51know what to do first. Inside the club,
- 9:54you get a clear structure and you know
- 9:55exactly what to focus on next. So, they
- 9:58believe the club gets them better
- 10:00results in less time and with less
- 10:02effort, and they feel more sure it'll
- 10:04actually work. So, the content was never
- 10:06the thing they were paying for. So, here
- 10:08are the three things they are paying for
- 10:11and the three things people will still
- 10:12pay for when anyone can copy anything.
- 10:16The first thing people will still pay
- 10:17for is the result. Picture two products
- 10:20built on the exact same [music] code.
- 10:22One is a $49 a month app that helps you
- 10:25write LinkedIn posts. The other is $500
- 10:28a month and it books sales calls for you
- 10:30from LinkedIn. The code underneath is
- 10:32the same, but one charges 10 times more.
- 10:35The first one sells a tool and anyone
- 10:37with code can copy a tool. The second
- 10:39one sells a result and a result needs
- 10:42someone who knows what works, keeps
- 10:44tuning it, and stands behind it. The
- 10:46closer you get to the money your
- 10:48customer actually wants, the harder you
- 10:50are to copy. Think about photos. Your
- 10:53phone made taking a photo free, but
- 10:55wedding photographers still charge
- 10:57thousands because couples pay for the
- 10:58day to be captured right by someone
- 11:00[music] they trust. And that word trust
- 11:03leads right into the second thing.
- 11:05The second thing people will still pay
- 11:07for is someone who answers when it
- 11:09breaks. Say you run a business doing $2
- 11:11million a year. Remember [music] that
- 11:13QuickBooks copy from earlier? You can
- 11:14run your books on a free accounting app
- 11:16that a stranger rebuilt from a trial, or
- 11:19you can pay for the real one with backup
- 11:21support and a phone number. Your numbers
- 11:23come out wrong the week your taxes are
- 11:25due, which one do you want? Free code is
- 11:28cheap until it breaks, then it's the
- 11:30most expensive thing you own. So, as
- 11:32apps get easier to copy, the person
- 11:34standing behind the app gets more
- 11:36valuable. That's the second thing. But,
- 11:38the third one matters more than both,
- 11:40and it's the one I'm betting my whole
- 11:42business on. The third thing people will
- 11:44still pay for is you and the people who
- 11:47already trust you. Picture what happens
- 11:49next. When anyone can build an app in a
- 11:51weekend, there won't be 10 apps for
- 11:53every problem. There will be 10,000.
- 11:56So, the hard part stops being building
- 11:57the thing. The hard part becomes getting
- 12:00anyone to care. The person who already
- 12:02has an audience, a community, or a list
- 12:04of customers who trust them wins that
- 12:06game. They can build something on Monday
- 12:08and have buyers by Friday. That's why I
- 12:11spend my time on YouTube and in the
- 12:12Cloud Code Club and almost no time
- 12:14worrying about someone copying my stuff.
- 12:17Someone could copy every lesson in the
- 12:18club tomorrow. They can't copy the 8,000
- 12:21people in the club who already know me.
- 12:23So, does all of this mean software is
- 12:25dead? No.
- 12:26>> [music]
- 12:26>> It means the part of an app's price that
- 12:28came from this was hard to build is
- 12:30going away. And the result, the support,
- 12:33the trust behind an app, and your
- 12:34ability to get traffic and win customers
- 12:37are all getting more valuable every
- 12:39month. So, here's the recap. REA lets
- 12:42Cloud look inside apps without having
- 12:44the code. Use it if you do security
- 12:46work, rescue old software, or want to
- 12:49learn how a feature works. Skip it if
- 12:51you're just getting [music] started. And
- 12:53when anyone can copy anything, people
- 12:54still pay for three things. They pay for
- 12:57the result, for someone who answers when
- 12:58it breaks, and [music] for the people
- 13:00who already trust you. So, here's your
- 13:02one thing for this week. Ask the
- 13:04question from the start of this video.
- 13:06If someone copied my product perfectly
- 13:08tomorrow, why would my customers stay?
- 13:11Write your answer down in one sentence.
- 13:13Then, check your product against the
- 13:15three things [music] people still pay
- 13:16for. First, can your customers point to
- 13:18a real result like more sales or hours
- 13:21saved every week? Second, if something
- 13:23breaks, do they know they can reach you
- 13:24and get it fixed? And third, do people
- 13:26already know and trust you, and do you
- 13:28have a way to get in front of new
- 13:30customers? [music]
- 13:31Every yes is part of your moat. Find the
- 13:34one that's a no, [music] and spend this
- 13:36week fixing it. And if you want to build
- 13:38things with Cloud that people will
- 13:40actually pay for, that's what the Cloud
- 13:42Code Club is for. It's a step-by-step
- 13:44path to master Cloud Code in 45 days,
- 13:46and it has lessons on turning what you
- 13:48build into something people pay for.
- 13:50It's $9 a month, and the link's in the
- 13:52description. Anyone can copy your app
- 13:54now, nobody can copy the people who
- 13:56trust you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of AI Can Copy Any App Now - Here's What People Will Still Pay For by Duncan Rogoff | Learn Claude Code, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,695 words across 383 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.