Ai đã cứu Phú Quốc khỏi một cuộc chiến tranh lãnh thổ lần thứ hai? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:10That morning, the small fish market on Tho Chu Island was open as usual. The
- 0:15offshore fishing boats had returned from the night before. Turtles were being weighed and sold to traders
- 0:20from Ha Tien. And no one on this southwesternmost island of the country knew that
- 0:25in just a few weeks they would be almost completely wiped off this land.
- 0:30Not just a few individuals, but almost the entire population of an island would disappear
- 0:36without a trace. Just 10 days after the gunfire across Vietnam
- 0:41had finally ceased, another war had begun on the very island that
- 0:45this series has been following since its first broadcast. Hello everyone
- 0:49. Welcome to [music] the Asia Chronicle program. Today we
- 0:53will explore one of the
- 0:57most painful and least told [music] chapters in the relationship between Vietnam and Cambodia. The period from the massacre
- 1:01on Tho Chu Islands in 1975 to the historic maritime agreement signed
- 1:07in 1982 is a painful chapter in the history of two
- 1:12neighboring nations. This is recounted not to rekindle hatred, but to ensure that
- 1:16those who perished are not forgotten, and to understand why a wound,
- 1:19seemingly legally closed, still smolders in memory today. In
- 1:24previous broadcasts, we explored the journey of Mac Cuu's pioneering work in
- 1:30Ha Tien under the patronage of the Khmer court, followed by Vietnam's submission to the Nguyen Lords, establishing
- 1:35Vietnamese sovereignty over Phu Quoc long before the French arrived.
- 1:39We also read a letter that seemed to be evidence of Khmer sovereignty but
- 1:44turned out to be evidence of a loss of control. We explored the Br line
- 1:49in 1939, a deliberately ambiguous administrative line drawn
- 1:55by the French colonial government, and in the most recent broadcast... We witnessed
- 2:00a great paradox when the very symbol of Khmer nationalism was
- 2:05the one who proactively abandoned its demands for Celiba in exchange for border security. But
- 2:10Sihanouk was not the last voice of Khmer nationalism. Just
- 2:14a few years after he left, another regime came to power. A regime that would reclaim
- 2:19not only the land but a much larger territory, and would reclaim it with blood.
- 2:24In April 1975, the two old regimes in Indochina almost collapsed
- 2:30simultaneously. On April 17, the Khmer Rouge entered the border. Thirteen days later, on
- 2:37April 30, Saigon fell. An unprecedented power vacuum appeared
- 2:41across Indochina, and that vacuum became the condition for
- 2:46what was to come.
- 2:50[music] Just days after the fall of Saigon,
- 2:55the Khmer Rouge launched their first attack. Most Western sources
- 3:00record the raid on Phu Quoc Island as taking place in early May,
- 3:04while some domestic documents cite May 3rd. Regardless of the exact date,
- 3:08the result is the same. The Vietnamese armed forces on the ground quickly
- 3:13repelled the landing and held the island. But just a week later, on May 10th, the Khmer
- 3:19Rouge returned with a different target: the Tho Chu Archipelago, located nearly 200
- 3:25km from Rach Gia. By this time, the old regime's navy had retreated, and the Vietnamese revolutionary forces
- 3:30had not yet arrived to take over. Taking advantage of this gap, the Khmer Rouge landed
- 3:36without firing a single shot, but they did not attack immediately. Initially, the Khmer
- 3:41Rouge soldiers, wearing scarves and carrying A-Co rifles, claimed to be subordinates of the liberation army, saying
- 3:48they had come to defend the island in case the American imperialists returned. They promised to organize
- 3:53collective work and distribute rice to each household to gain trust. The people of Tho Chu originally lived
- 3:58by building fishing nets, catching seafood, and raising sea turtles. There was no reason to doubt
- 4:03those who spoke the same local dialect and wore military-like uniforms.
- 4:07Their true nature only revealed itself when the Khmer Rouge began forcing the entire island population into
- 4:12hard labor, digging hundreds of meters of trenches along the coast. And when the trenches
- 4:17were completed on the night of the 23rd, they turned their backs on the people, pointing their guns directly at them. The entire
- 4:23island population was herded onto the beach, where two 100-ton fishing boats that
- 4:29the Khmer Rouge had just seized in the Gulf of Thailand were waiting. A
- 4:33noteworthy detail recorded is that the people's reaction was not entirely submissive
- 4:37. One witness recounted that a woman among them stood up and protested
- 4:41right on the beach, saying they would rather die than be taken to
- 4:45Cambodia, in an attempt to appease the panicked crowd. The Khmer Rouge commander was forced to
- 4:50lie, saying that the people were like parents, that they would never be killed, and that they would only be taken across the border.
- 4:56Cambodia took refuge. Among the hundreds of people herded onto the ship that night, one family was
- 5:01fortunate enough to survive. According to accounts given to the press, a man
- 5:05named Nguyen Van Si, along with his wife and three young children, asked to tow their small boat
- 5:11behind the large ship for convenience in their business. A Vietnamese
- 5:15boat captain, forced to steer by the Khmer Rouge, secretly advised them to remain silent and
- 5:20prepare engine oil. At dawn on May 24th, in the pitch-black ocean,
- 5:26a loud snapping sound broke the tow rope, and the large Khmer Rouge ship
- 5:31sped away into the darkness without a trace. Mr. Si's family immediately started the engine
- 5:35and headed straight for Hon Mau. They escaped. They were among the very few who returned
- 5:41from that fateful journey, while more than 500 others were on the two large ships.
- 5:46For many years afterward, no one knew what had happened to them. This figure of
- 5:51over 500 didn't come from a simple count of bodies. It came from comparing
- 5:56the island's population records before that fateful night with the number of people who disappeared
- 6:01over the years that followed. This information gap initially led some
- 6:05to doubt the true scale of what had happened. But later, two independent sources
- 6:10matched: demographic records from Vietnam and sworn testimony
- 6:16from those who had been on the other side at an international tribunal established
- 6:20years earlier to try the Khmer Rouge for their crimes. When the victim records and
- 6:25the perpetrators' testimony point to the same number, that figure is no longer an estimate
- 6:29. At this point, we must pause the story of the people of Tho
- 6:34Chu. Because at the same time, not far away, another event is unfolding. An
- 6:39event that will take the world's attention. [Music]
- 6:48[Music]
- 6:53On May 12, just two [music] days after seizing the island, the Khmer
- 6:58Rouge navy seized the American cargo ship Mayages as it passed through waters near
- 7:04Pulowai Island. U.S. President Gerald Ford called this an act of piracy and ordered
- 7:09an immediate military response. On May 15, the U.S. Air Force bombed the island, and Marines
- 7:14landed on the dry island to rescue the crew. The fighting,
- 7:19along with a helicopter crash during the operation's preparation, resulted in a total of
- 7:2441 American servicemen killed, although ironically, 39 sailors they were trying to rescue
- 7:30had been released by the Khmer Rouge onto another fishing vessel. Before that, let's consider
- 7:36a coincidence that history rarely arranges so neatly. In the same
- 7:42week of May, the same aggressor force, the 164th Division of the
- 7:49Khmer Rouge navy, and the same isolated island on one side of the island. Forty-one American servicemen
- 7:56fell in a hostage rescue operation. Their names are solemnly
- 7:59inscribed on the Washington Monument. Their deaths were studied in
- 8:04military academies for half a century. On the other side, more than 500 Vietnamese civilians
- 8:10were rounded up and taken to that very island, silently buried beneath the sand, and for decades,
- 8:15not a single word of their story appeared in the world press. The same perpetrator, the same
- 8:20piece of land—one side: the lives of a superpower thrown against granite, the other
- 8:26: the lives of small fishermen sinking into the stillness of
- 8:31the ocean. So what determines whether one death is remembered by the world, while
- 8:35another is forgotten? The answer probably doesn't lie in the degree of pain
- 8:40, but in who is watching and whose interests they are pursuing. For America, in the midst of
- 8:46a peaceful war, the capture of an American ship was a matter of superpower prestige
- 8:52just days after its defeat in Vietnam. For a country like Vietnam, having just
- 8:56emerged from 30 years of war and grappling with millions of reconstruction issues
- 9:00, news from a remote island could hardly compete for attention. And there's
- 9:05another, more delicate reason: research notes that at the time,
- 9:10Hanoi also didn't want to publicize the incident, hoping to maintain an image of
- 9:16solidarity with neighboring socialist countries and resolve the matter peacefully
- 9:21through internal diplomatic channels. But the bigger question remains: Why would
- 9:26a regime that had only been in power for less than a month rush to attack
- 9:30both countries simultaneously? Was this not an accident or a misunderstanding
- 9:34at the border? According to researchers like Ben Kirnen,
- 9:39author of the famous work on the Paul Pot regime, the attacks on Phu Quoc and
- 9:43Tho Chu stemmed from an ideological obsession within the Communist Party leadership.
- 9:47Cambodian territory. During that period, they harbored the ambition to reclaim the land they called
- 9:53Cambodia Crom, which is the Mekong Delta today, while also fearing
- 9:59that Vietnam was trying to swallow Cambodia. The records of the International Tribunal for
- 10:04Khmer Rouge crimes later showed that the decision to attack the islands in the Gulf
- 10:08of Thailand was not a spontaneous act by local commanders but stemmed from
- 10:13central directives. In previous broadcasts, we encountered the
- 10:17Brevia Line, a line drawn by the French Governor-General Jeels Bravia in 1939
- 10:24, who clearly stated in a letter that it was only for administrative division, while
- 10:29sovereignty was entirely reserved. It is noteworthy that the Cambodians themselves
- 10:33understood this, especially Sarinchak, the border researcher who
- 10:38served at Shop, whom we mentioned in the previous broadcast. In his book published
- 10:42in 1966, he frankly admitted that the Brevia Letter
- 10:48did not resolve the issue of sovereignty over the islands. Yet, less than 10 years later, the regime
- 10:53that Sarck would later serve was ready to wage war to turn that very line
- 10:58into an unnegotiable maritime border. At a
- 11:021976 Fnompeng negotiations, when the Vietnamese side proposed applying the
- 11:08median line principle according to international law, the Khmer Rouge accused
- 11:13Vietnam of expansionist ambitions and suspended negotiations indefinitely. This is one
- 11:18of the most silent tragedies of this period. Part of the blood was shed not
- 11:23because of a real dispute, but because of a misinterpretation that even the best scholars
- 11:28of the side proposing the argument had rejected beforehand. Ironically, Sarck himself
- 11:32later became the foreign minister of the Khmer Rouge regime, serving
- 11:37the very argument that his own research had refuted.
- 11:41Where would a war based on such a misinterpretation lead?
- 11:46[Music]
- 11:49In response, in early June 1975, [music] the Vietnamese army launched an attack
- 11:55on Pulowai Island, a Cambodian-controlled island, to eliminate
- 12:00the Khmer Rouge's attack base. But just two months later, in May,
- 12:05Vietnam voluntarily withdrew its troops and returned the island to Cambodia as a
- 12:10diplomatic gesture of goodwill. This is a detail that is rarely mentioned. But importantly,
- 12:15from the very beginning, Vietnam's response was not to occupy the island permanently, but
- 12:20to deter and then withdraw in goodwill. Unfortunately, this did not prevent the escalation.
- 12:27For the next three years, the Khmer Rouge continuously shelled and infiltrated deep into the territory of
- 12:31South Vietnam. The climax was a massacre of civilians in An Giang in
- 12:36April 1978, claiming the lives of over 3,000 people.
- 12:41A story we will dedicate to another broadcast to justify
- 12:45our actions in the face of increasing international pressure. In September of that year, the
- 12:50Khmer Rouge's Ministry of Foreign Affairs published a document called the Black Book, accusing
- 12:55Vietnam of being the aggressor and plotting to annex Cambodia into an
- 12:59Indochinese federation. This was clear evidence of the escalating
- 13:03propaganda war, which ran parallel to the war on the ground. Finally
- 13:07, on December 25, 1978, the Vietnamese army, along with Cambodian revolutionary forces,
- 13:14launched a large-scale counter-offensive. On May 7, 1979,
- 13:22the Khmer Rouge genocidal regime collapsed, forcing it
- 13:27to retreat into guerrilla operations on the Thai border. The People's Republic
- 13:31of Cambodia was established, and it was in the early days of 1979, when forces
- 13:38advanced onto Co Tang Island, where the Tho Chu people had been taken nearly four
- 13:43years earlier, that the question that had been hanging over the program finally received an answer. The
- 13:47remnants of a forced labor camp and mass graves were discovered
- 13:51among hundreds of people; history only managed to preserve a few names, one of
- 13:57which was found in the pocket of a mother's shirt. When her remains were found
- 14:03on Co Tang Island, a personal identification card bearing the name Nguyen Thi Tu, 29 years old, residing in
- 14:10Tho Chu, issued by the former Saigon government on May 20, 1968—
- 14:17seven years before that government ceased to exist—was discovered. A personal document
- 14:21from a fallen regime became the only relic proving the existence
- 14:25of a Vietnamese woman buried on a foreign island. There were no maps
- 14:30, no directions, no agreements to explain her whereabouts.
- 14:35We know who she is, only from that card. And sometimes, to understand the true cost of
- 14:41a territorial dispute, we don't need to look at a map, just at
- 14:45a name. Four years later, the people of Tho Chu were herded onto ships. The
- 14:50war waged by the extremist doctrine of territorial restoration ended with the
- 14:54complete collapse of the very regime that pursued it. A new, quieter, and
- 14:59far less dramatic school was about to begin.
- 15:03[music] On May 7, 1982
- 15:09, in Ho Chi Minh City, two foreign ministers signed a document
- 15:13called the Agreement on Historical Waters. On the Vietnamese side was Nguyen Co
- 15:18Thach, on the Cambodian side was a young diplomat named Hunen. The
- 15:24agreement resolved two issues simultaneously in two different ways concerning the
- 15:28islands. Both sides agreed to use the Breví line, which we have mentioned, as the
- 15:32demarcation line. Any island north of this line belonged to Cambodia, and any island south
- 15:37belonged to Vietnam. This definitively resolves the sovereignty issues of Phu Quoc and Tho
- 15:42Chu. [music] However, regarding the waters, that is, the sea surface and continental shelf, the agreement
- 15:47does not immediately demarcate but combines the entire sea area between the coast of Kien Giang, Phu
- 15:52Quoc, and Tho Chu of Vietnam and the coast of Campus and Pulowai Island of Cambodia into
- 15:58a common historical water area, applying the internal waters regime, meaning that both countries jointly
- 16:03patrol and control, and fishermen from both sides continue to fish according to their customs.
- 16:08The exploitation of seabed resources requires the consent of both sides. The
- 16:13formal demarcation of the maritime border is left open for another negotiation. At
- 16:17an appropriate time in the future, if the two governments are placed side by side, there is
- 16:22a rule that researcher Ramses Amer, an expert on
- 16:26border conflict management in Vietnam at Sala University, has pointed out: the regime that demanded the
- 16:31most territory and demanded it through absolute violence was the Khmer Rouge. Two years later,
- 16:37their state was erased from the regional political map. The succeeding administration chose the
- 16:41opposite path, setting aside the most difficult disputes, only addressing the solvable ones
- 16:46, and signing an agreement. According to Amar's analysis, this was not a
- 16:51weak concession but a model of conflict management, freezing unresolved issues
- 16:56to defuse them immediately. The document, born from that choice
- 17:01, remains in effect today, more than 40 years later. Amar also notes that this was
- 17:07the first maritime delimitation agreement that Vietnam ever signed, a model that Vietnam later applied
- 17:12when cooperating with Malaysia in joint exploitation in 1992
- 17:18and negotiating maritime delimitation with Thailand in 1997.
- 17:23Another perspective from maritime law expert Nguyen Hong Thao suggests that
- 17:28establishing historical waters is consistent with international legal practice, which has
- 17:33exceptions for cases with special historical titles. However,
- 17:36not everyone agrees. In a subsequent study on maritime boundaries
- 17:41, the U.S. State Department declared that it did not recognize
- 17:45this historical territorial claim, arguing that for a maritime area to be considered historically legitimate
- 17:50, the coastal state must demonstrate a continuous, long-term, and publicly acknowledged
- 17:54exercise of sovereignty over the area, and that this exercise must be
- 18:00tacitly accepted by the international community. History here seems to be whispering that
- 18:05the more absolute the claim, the more likely it is to self-destruct. But even the wisest agreement is
- 18:11only as strong as its signature. And this is the weakness that the 1982 document
- 18:19could never overcome. It was signed by the government of the People's Republic of Cambodia,
- 18:24a government that emerged when Vietnamese troops were still present in
- 18:28Cambodia just weeks before the agreement was signed. A coalition government
- 18:33in exile had been formed, bringing together Shihan's royalist faction, Sonan's republican faction
- 18:38, and remnants of the Khmer Rouge regime. For those in this alliance, the
- 18:43Vietnamese military presence was sufficient to declare all treaties signed with the People's Republic of
- 18:48Cambodia, including the historic waters agreement, invalid, signed under pressure. Conversely
- 18:54, researchers like Sudomet point out that many years after becoming
- 18:59a fully sovereign government, internationally recognized, and
- 19:03without Vietnamese troops on its territory, the Phnom Penh government, then
- 19:08led by Hungen, voluntarily reaffirmed the validity of the
- 19:121980s border treaties through a supplementary agreement signed in 2005.
- 19:19So, is the 1982 agreement valid? Asia Chronicle will not
- 19:25arbitrate that question. That is a matter for international law and for the two
- 19:30nations themselves. What the program wants you to take away is a different realization. There are
- 19:35wounds that a legal document can heal, and there are wounds that
- 19:40cannot. To this day, the official maritime border between the two countries in the
- 19:44historical waters has not yet been drawn. Negotiations at the appropriate time
- 19:49mentioned in the Agreement, more than 40 years later, are still ongoing.
- 19:54[Music]
- 19:58On the night of May 23, 1975, in the same sea, two destinies diverged
- 20:04because of a single rope. One family was
- 20:09saved by the broken rope, returned, continued to live, had children and grandchildren, and had normal mornings
- 20:14like the morning we begin today's program. There's another 209-year-old woman
- 20:18left with only an identity card, found years later on an island
- 20:23far from her homeland. An agreement can freeze a disputed body of water
- 20:28, but no document can freeze a name, no
- 20:32border can define a 29-year-old, and nothing can compensate for an
- 20:37identity card lying untouched in a mother's pocket for years under the sand
- 20:42of a foreign island. Perhaps the real question isn't where the border
- 20:47lies on the map, but when will this historical pain truly
- 20:53dissolve into the ocean? See you again in the
- 20:57next broadcast of Asia Chronicle. [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Ai đã cứu Phú Quốc khỏi một cuộc chiến tranh lãnh thổ lần thứ hai? by Á Lục Ký, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,187 words across 250 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.