After My Son-in-Law PUNCHED Me, I Made Him REGRET Going After My Three Million — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00My son-in-law hit me hard enough to put
- 0:02me on the floor of my own daughter's
- 0:05front hall. And
- 0:07the first thing I thought, lying there
- 0:09with blood in my mouth, was that I had
- 0:11left my good reading glasses on the
- 0:13kitchen counter.
- 0:15That's the kind of thing your mind does.
- 0:17It grabs something small so it doesn't
- 0:19have to hold the big thing.
- 0:21The big thing was this.
- 0:23My daughter, Erin, stood over me,
- 0:26grabbed a fistful of my gray hair and
- 0:28hauled me across the tile and out the
- 0:30front door.
- 0:32She screamed that I had ruined
- 0:33everything and that $3 million wasn't
- 0:36worth losing her family over.
- 0:38She dropped me on the front walk like a
- 0:40bag of trash. It was a Saturday
- 0:42afternoon in Dayton, Ohio, and half the
- 0:45cul-de-sac was out mowing lawns.
- 0:47I sat there bleeding while the whole
- 0:49street watched.
- 0:51What none of them knew, what Erin and
- 0:53Brett certainly didn't know, was that I
- 0:56had walked into that house expecting
- 0:58something like this.
- 1:00Within the hour, their lives would start
- 1:02coming apart in front of those same
- 1:04neighbors.
- 1:05I'm Joyce Wagner.
- 1:07I'm 68 years old, a retired school
- 1:09secretary and a widow.
- 1:11Let me tell you how I ended up on that
- 1:13sidewalk because it didn't start with a
- 1:15fist. It started with a casserole.
- 1:18I'd love to know where you are.
- 1:21Tell me your city in the comments before
- 1:22we go on.
- 1:24My husband, Dale, died in March of the
- 1:26year before.
- 1:2843 years of marriage, and then one
- 1:30Tuesday he sat down in his recliner with
- 1:32the crossword and didn't get up.
- 1:35Dale had built a small commercial
- 1:37roofing company from nothing. Two years
- 1:39before he passed, he sold it to Clark
- 1:41Engineering for a good deal more than
- 1:43either of us ever expected.
- 1:46We were not flashy people. We drove a
- 1:4810-year-old Buick, but after the taxes
- 1:50and the paperwork were done, there was a
- 1:52little over $3 million sitting in
- 1:55accounts in my name, and I had no idea
- 1:58what to do with it
- 2:00keep it safe.
- 2:01Aaron was my only child. She'd married
- 2:04Brett Cunningham 11 years earlier. He
- 2:06was tall and polished with a salesman's
- 2:08handshake, and he sold commercial real
- 2:10estate, or said he did.
- 2:13They had two kids, Scarlett, who was
- 2:15nine, and Jackson,
- 2:17six. I loved those children more than I
- 2:19can put into words. They were the reason
- 2:21I said yes when Aaron called in October
- 2:24and said, Mom, you shouldn't be alone in
- 2:27that empty house. Come stay with us for
- 2:29a while, just through the winter.
- 2:32I'd had a hard fall in September, a slip
- 2:35on wet leaves that bruised my hip. Aaron
- 2:37drove over that evening with a chicken
- 2:39casserole in her arms and tears in her
- 2:41eyes. Nothing broken, but it scared me,
- 2:45and it scared her. That was the doorway
- 2:47they used. I'll give them credit for
- 2:49that. It was a good one.
- 2:52I sold nothing and gave up nothing.
- 2:55I kept my house in Kettering with the
- 2:56mail forwarded and the heat turned down
- 2:58to 55.
- 3:00I told myself I was visiting. Looking
- 3:02back, that decision probably saved me.
- 3:05The first few weeks were lovely, and
- 3:07I'll say that plainly plainly because
- 3:09people think these stories begin with a
- 3:11monster at the door. They don't.
- 3:14Aaron made pot roast on Sundays.
- 3:17Scarlett taught me a card game I never
- 3:19did understand. Jackson fell asleep
- 3:21against my arm during movie nights.
- 3:24Brett carried my suitcase up the stairs
- 3:26and said, Joyce, this is your home, too.
- 3:29He said it warmly, and he said it often.
- 3:32I've learned since that when a man says
- 3:34something that warmly that often, he's
- 3:36rehearsing.
- 3:38The first crack was small.
- 3:40One evening, Brett mentioned over dinner
- 3:42that he'd found a once-in-a-lifetime
- 3:44deal, a chain of boutique fitness
- 3:47studios looking for one anchor investor.
- 3:50He said it lightly, cutting his steak,
- 3:52and I said it sounded interesting and
- 3:54changed the subject to Scarlett's
- 3:56spelling test. Aaron looked at her
- 3:58plate.
- 3:59I noticed that. I filed it away.
- 4:0230 years of running the front office at
- 4:04Roosevelt Elementary taught me to notice
- 4:07the child who stops talking when the
- 4:08principal walks in.
- 4:10After that, the topic came up the way
- 4:12water finds a crack in a foundation.
- 4:15Aaron asked if I'd thought about my
- 4:17estate. What would happen to the money
- 4:19if I got sick?
- 4:21Brett offered to help me look at my
- 4:22accounts just to organize them.
- 4:25Then he suggested a joint account for
- 4:27emergencies. Then a power of attorney
- 4:30because Joyce, if you fall again and
- 4:32can't speak for yourself, who's going to
- 4:34handle things?
- 4:36Every suggestion came wrapped in worry
- 4:38for me. Everyone ended at the same place
- 4:41which was my signature.
- 4:43I said, I'll think about it so many
- 4:45times that the phrase wore smooth.
- 4:48Then one afternoon I came home from the
- 4:51pharmacy and found the door to the
- 4:53little office off the dining room
- 4:54standing open. My purse had been on the
- 4:57hall chair. It was sitting on the seat
- 4:59of the chair now, zipped, but I never
- 5:02zip it. I carry my checkbook in the side
- 5:05pocket and the side pocket was turned
- 5:07the wrong way. Brett was in the kitchen
- 5:09whistling.
- 5:10I walked past him, set the purse on the
- 5:13counter and said,
- 5:14Anything interesting today?
- 5:16Just work, Joyce, he said. Just work.
- 5:19That night I lay in the lilac guest room
- 5:22Aaron had so lovingly decorated and
- 5:24listened to the house settle. I thought
- 5:26about Dale. He used to say, Joyce, trust
- 5:29people, but keep copies. It was his joke
- 5:32about contracts. I thought about it
- 5:35differently that night.
- 5:36The next morning I called my attorney, a
- 5:38woman named Susan Phillips.
- 5:41She'd handled Dale's estate and had a
- 5:43way of speaking that made you feel like
- 5:45you were being briefed rather than
- 5:47comforted.
- 5:48I told her what was happening. She was
- 5:50quiet for a moment and then said, Joyce,
- 5:53I want you to hear this clearly. Nothing
- 5:55you've described is illegal yet,
- 5:58but everything you've described is how
- 6:00it begins. Do you want to be prepared?
- 6:03I said yes.
- 6:05Susan walked me through it over the next
- 6:07two weeks, mostly by phone from the
- 6:09parking lot of the grocery store,
- 6:12where I'd sit in my Buick with the
- 6:13engine off. First, she moved the bulk of
- 6:16the money into an irrevocable trust with
- 6:18a corporate trustee, a bank in Columbus
- 6:21that wouldn't release a dime without my
- 6:23voice, my face, and a callback to a
- 6:25number only Susan and I knew. Nobody
- 6:28could sign anything on my behalf, not
- 6:31Aaron, not Brett, not a judge on a bad
- 6:33day. Second, she had me change every
- 6:36password and every security question,
- 6:38and she had me stop using my own mailing
- 6:40address for statements. Third, and this
- 6:43was the one I resisted, she said, Joyce,
- 6:46you need to document everything, dates,
- 6:49times, what was said.
- 6:51I bought a spiral notebook with a
- 6:52cartoon cat on it from the dollar store
- 6:55so that it would look like something a
- 6:57grandmother scribbles recipes in.
- 7:00I wrote down every conversation.
- 7:03I wrote down the day Brett asked me for
- 7:05my social security number to double
- 7:07check a form. I wrote down the day Aaron
- 7:09cried and said, Mom, we're drowning, and
- 7:12I held her and she let me, and I hated
- 7:15how much part of me wanted to just fix
- 7:17it. I wrote down the day I found a
- 7:19printed power of attorney in the printer
- 7:21tray with my name typed in and the
- 7:23signature line blank, and the day I took
- 7:26a photo of it with my phone and slid it
- 7:28back exactly as I'd found it.
- 7:31And here is something I did that I'm
- 7:33still proud of. I told Aaron the truth
- 7:35about the trust in my own time and my
- 7:38own way.
- 7:39I sat her down at the kitchen table in
- 7:41January and said, Honey, I've put the
- 7:43money somewhere safe so that nobody can
- 7:46ever pressure me about it, not you, not
- 7:48anybody. I want you and the children
- 7:50taken care of, and there are provisions
- 7:53for that, but I won't be signing
- 7:55anything for anyone.
- 7:57She looked at me for a long time. Her
- 7:59eyes were wet. She said, Okay, Mom, and
- 8:02I believed her. God help me. I believed
- 8:05my daughter for about four days
- 8:07because here's what I hadn't factored
- 8:09in.
- 8:10When I told Erin the money was locked
- 8:12away, she didn't hear that I was
- 8:14protected. She heard that her husband's
- 8:16plan had failed, and she went and told
- 8:18him.
- 8:19I know that now. I know exactly what
- 8:21passed between them because three months
- 8:24later, their text messages and bank
- 8:26records would be laid out for me line by
- 8:29line, and I'd have to read about my own
- 8:31child's panic in a legal exhibit.
- 8:35February turned strange. Brett stopped
- 8:37smiling at me. He stopped carrying my
- 8:39suitcase, my coffee, anything. Erin
- 8:43started leaving rooms when I entered
- 8:44them. Scarlett came to me one night in
- 8:47her pajamas and whispered, Grandma,
- 8:49Daddy says you're being selfish. I held
- 8:52her face in my hands and told her that
- 8:53grown-ups sometimes say things when
- 8:56they're worried about money and that
- 8:58none of it was her job to carry.
- 9:00She nodded like she understood. She was
- 9:03nine. She understood far too much.
- 9:06Then came the Thursday I think of as the
- 9:09real beginning of the end.
- 9:11I came home from my Bible study group
- 9:13and found my bedroom door open. The
- 9:15drawers were pulled.
- 9:17My jewelry box, which held nothing but
- 9:19Dale's mother's cameo and some costume
- 9:21pearls, lay upside down on the bed. The
- 9:24closet had been gone through, my winter
- 9:27coats shoved aside, my suitcase
- 9:29unzipped.
- 9:30Someone had been looking for papers.
- 9:33I didn't scream. I went and sat down on
- 9:35the edge of the bed, and I took out my
- 9:37phone, and I photographed every inch of
- 9:40that room. Then I called Susan.
- 9:43She said,
- 9:44Joyce, I want you out of that house
- 9:45tonight.
- 9:46I said, no.
- 9:48I know how that sounds.
- 9:50People in the comments of videos like
- 9:52this one always say the same thing. She
- 9:54should have left the first week.
- 9:56And they're not wrong, not entirely.
- 9:59But here's what I told Susan, and I'll
- 10:01tell you.
- 10:02If I walked out that night, I'd have a
- 10:04bad feeling and a notebook. Brett would
- 10:07tell every story he wanted.
- 10:09He'd say the confused old woman wandered
- 10:11off. He'd say she was paranoid. He had
- 10:15already started laying that groundwork.
- 10:17I'd heard him say to a neighbor,
- 10:19Joyce has been a little forgetful
- 10:21lately. I'd heard it from the kitchen.
- 10:23What I wanted was proof that couldn't be
- 10:26argued with, proof of what these people
- 10:28would do when they believed nobody was
- 10:31watching.
- 10:32Susan didn't like it. She made me
- 10:34promise a list of things. I'd keep my
- 10:37phone charged and the location on. I'd
- 10:39sleep with my door locked and a chair
- 10:41under the knob. I'd leave the burner
- 10:43phone she'd bought me on the shelf of my
- 10:45closet inside a sock because if Brett
- 10:48was tracking my phone, there was no need
- 10:51to hand him my calls. I'd check in with
- 10:54her every night at 9:00 using the burner
- 10:57while keeping up my usual evening calls
- 10:59to my sister on my cell so that the
- 11:01pattern looked ordinary.
- 11:03And I'd tell one neighbor.
- 11:05I picked Russell Burns who lived next
- 11:08door, retired Air Force 71, a man who
- 11:12kept his lawn like a golf course and his
- 11:14opinions to himself. I knocked on his
- 11:16door one morning when Brett's SUV was
- 11:18gone.
- 11:19I told Russell only this much. I said, I
- 11:22may need you to watch for something and
- 11:24if you hear shouting, I'd like you to
- 11:26call 911 and not wait to be sure.
- 11:30He looked at me for a good 3 seconds.
- 11:32Then he said, Ma'am, I've got a doorbell
- 11:35camera that faces your side of the
- 11:36street and a very loud voice. Say no
- 11:39more.
- 11:40I think about Russell nearly every day.
- 11:43The weeks ground on into April and the
- 11:46weather warmed. Brett changed tactics.
- 11:49He got sweet again. He brought home
- 11:51flowers for me, tulips, my favorite,
- 11:54which he'd never known before and had
- 11:56obviously gotten from Erin. He sat at
- 11:58the edge of my bed one night and said in
- 12:00a soft voice, Joyce, I think I've been a
- 12:03jerk. I want to fix it. Can we start
- 12:05over?
- 12:06I said, I'd like that.
- 12:08He said, Then let's get the money
- 12:10working for the kids, a small piece,
- 12:13just 400,000 for the studios, 12% return
- 12:17guaranteed in writing. I'll sign
- 12:20whatever you want.
- 12:21I said I'd talk to my lawyer.
- 12:24His face did something then. It didn't
- 12:26change much. It just went flat the way a
- 12:29pond does when the wind stops.
- 12:31And I understood that I'd just seen the
- 12:33real Brett, the one underneath, for
- 12:35about 1 second.
- 12:37The following Saturday was the day
- 12:40Susan had called the night before with
- 12:42news. The bank in Columbus had flagged
- 12:45two attempts to get information on my
- 12:47accounts, both from a phone number
- 12:48registered to Brett's business. Someone
- 12:51had called Brett pretending to be me.
- 12:53The voice, the bank said, was a man's
- 12:56voice badly disguised. Susan was going
- 12:59to file a formal complaint on Monday.
- 13:02She wanted me out of the house that very
- 13:04night.
- 13:05I said all right, one more night.
- 13:08I'm not sure why I said it.
- 13:10Maybe it was the grandchildren.
- 13:12Maybe I wanted one more normal Saturday
- 13:14morning,
- 13:15or maybe some stubborn part of me wanted
- 13:17to see what he'd do.
- 13:19Saturday morning, I packed a small bag
- 13:22and put it in the trunk of my Buick,
- 13:24which was parked on the street so I
- 13:25wouldn't have to ask anyone to move a
- 13:27car.
- 13:28Then I went back in to say goodbye to
- 13:30the kids who were going to a birthday
- 13:32party with a friend's mother. When the
- 13:34doorbell rang and the car pulled away
- 13:36with Scarlett and Jackson waving from
- 13:39the back window,
- 13:41the house went quiet in a way I felt in
- 13:43my teeth.
- 13:44Aaron was in the kitchen. Brett came in
- 13:46from the garage.
- 13:48Joyce, he said, sit down. Sit We need to
- 13:50have a conversation, and I'm done being
- 13:53polite about it.
- 13:54I said I'd rather stand.
- 13:56He put a folder on the table.
- 13:59Inside were papers he'd obviously
- 14:00prepared for weeks, a power of attorney,
- 14:03a transfer authorization, a letter on
- 14:06letterhead I didn't recognize.
- 14:08All of them had my name typed in. All of
- 14:11them were waiting for a signature.
- 14:13He said
- 14:14you're going to sign these today.
- 14:16I said, no.
- 14:18You think you're so smart, he said,
- 14:21hiding money, locking us out.
- 14:23Do you know what this is doing to your
- 14:25daughter?
- 14:26She's falling apart.
- 14:27We've got a mortgage payment we can't
- 14:29make and a business that's a month from
- 14:31collapse and you're sitting on $3
- 14:33million like a dragon.
- 14:35It's obscene.
- 14:37Brett, I said, you forged Aaron's name
- 14:40on a second loan application for this
- 14:42house.
- 14:43I know.
- 14:44I saw the notice on your desk the day I
- 14:46found the power of attorney.
- 14:48Aaron turned white. She said, Brett,
- 14:50shut up, Aaron, he said, not even
- 14:53looking at her.
- 14:54I'd like to tell you my heart stayed
- 14:56steady.
- 14:57It didn't.
- 14:58It was pounding so hard I thought they
- 15:00could hear it.
- 15:01But I had a little white button recorder
- 15:03clipped inside my cardigan that Susan's
- 15:05investigator had given me and I thought,
- 15:08keep him talking. Just keep him talking.
- 15:12I said, this isn't about the children,
- 15:14is it?
- 15:15He slammed his hand on the table. The
- 15:17salt shaker jumped. He said, sign it.
- 15:20Sign it right now, Joyce, or I swear to
- 15:22God.
- 15:23Swear to God what? I said.
- 15:25And that's when he came around the
- 15:27table.
- 15:28I backed into the hall by then toward
- 15:30the front door. He caught my arm hard. I
- 15:33said, let go of me. He said, you stupid
- 15:36old woman, you've ruined us. I said,
- 15:39Aaron, call someone.
- 15:40Aaron stood in the kitchen doorway with
- 15:42her hands over her mouth.
- 15:44Then Brett hit me.
- 15:46It wasn't a slap.
- 15:48It was a closed fist right across my
- 15:50cheek and eye. The world flashed white
- 15:52and I went down on the tile, my shoulder
- 15:54hitting the baseboard, my cardigan
- 15:56riding up.
- 15:58I tasted blood. I heard Aaron shriek my
- 16:00name and for one wild second I thought,
- 16:03thank God she's going to help me.
- 16:05She grabbed my hair.
- 16:07I want you to hear that sentence slowly
- 16:10because I have had to.
- 16:12She grabbed my hair and pulled and my
- 16:14scalp felt like it was tearing from my
- 16:16skull and yanked me toward the door
- 16:19screaming.
- 16:20Why couldn't you just sign it? Why do
- 16:22you always have to make everything so
- 16:24hard? Brett was behind her, breathing
- 16:26hard, saying, get her out, get her out
- 16:29of here.
- 16:30She hauled me through the front door,
- 16:32over the threshold, onto the porch step
- 16:35and down the walk. She let go and I
- 16:37landed on my hands and knees.
- 16:39Erin stood over me with her chest
- 16:41heaving and tears all over her face.
- 16:44She said, loud enough for the street to
- 16:46hear,
- 16:47it's $3 million, mom.
- 16:49$3 million, and you'd rather watch us
- 16:51lose everything.
- 16:53I looked up.
- 16:55Over her shoulder I saw Russell Burns
- 16:57standing on his lawn in his work gloves,
- 16:59with his phone already pressed to his
- 17:01ear.
- 17:02Across the street, Mrs. Tanner had
- 17:04stopped her hedge trimmer.
- 17:06A young father on the corner had his
- 17:08hand over his little boy's eyes, and I
- 17:10saw the small black dome of Russell's
- 17:12doorbell camera over his front door, its
- 17:15blue light steady.
- 17:17Brett came out onto the porch. He saw
- 17:19the audience. He saw Russell. For the
- 17:22first time that afternoon, I watched him
- 17:24realize that there are things you can't
- 17:26undo.
- 17:28Go inside, he said to Erin, suddenly low
- 17:30and tight. Go inside, now.
- 17:33She didn't move.
- 17:34She looked at the neighbors. She looked
- 17:36at me, at the blood dripping off my chin
- 17:39onto the concrete.
- 17:41Something went across her face that I'll
- 17:43remember until I die.
- 17:45Something that might have been horror
- 17:46and might have been waking up.
- 17:49But it was too late for waking up.
- 17:51I stayed on the curb.
- 17:53I didn't say a word.
- 17:54I held my sleeve to my mouth and counted
- 17:56the seconds, and at 4 minutes and 10 I
- 17:59heard the first siren.
- 18:01One of the officers who came was a woman
- 18:03named Officer Delgado,
- 18:05with a steady voice and a notebook that
- 18:07never trembled.
- 18:09She knelt in front of me and said,
- 18:11ma'am,
- 18:12I'm going to ask you some questions and
- 18:14I want you to take your time. I told her
- 18:16my name, my age, and that the man on the
- 18:19porch had punched me, and the woman
- 18:20beside him had dragged me out by my
- 18:22hair.
- 18:23I held out my cardigan and showed her
- 18:25the little recorder and said, it's all
- 18:27on here, and Russell's camera has it
- 18:30from the street, and I have a lawyer.
- 18:33Her name is Susan Phillips. She's
- 18:35expecting my call.
- 18:37Officer Delgado looked at me for a long
- 18:39moment. Then she said quietly, Mrs.
- 18:42Wagner, you did everything right.
- 18:44I almost cried then.
- 18:46It was the first kind sentence anyone
- 18:48had said to me in months.
- 18:50They took pictures of my face. They took
- 18:53Russell's statement and Mrs. Tanner's
- 18:56and the young father's.
- 18:58Russell handed over the footage from his
- 18:59doorbell camera with the calm of a man
- 19:02delivering a casserole. It showed
- 19:04everything from the moment my body hit
- 19:06the walk.
- 19:07It showed Aaron's face. It showed Brett
- 19:09on the porch watching a woman bleed.
- 19:13Meanwhile, Susan arrived in her gray
- 19:15Volvo, still in her gardening clothes,
- 19:18and it was she who told me what had been
- 19:20happening behind the scenes for weeks.
- 19:23That week, the bank had passed what
- 19:25they'd found to the Montgomery County
- 19:26prosecutor.
- 19:28The investigator had pulled records on
- 19:30Brett's company, and it turned out my
- 19:32son-in-law had a history I'd never been
- 19:34told.
- 19:35Two earlier business partners, a widow
- 19:37in Springboro, a complaint that had been
- 19:40dropped when she ran out of money to
- 19:42fight him.
- 19:43I was not the first person he'd worked
- 19:45this on. I was just the first person
- 19:48whose lawyer had told her to write
- 19:50everything down.
- 19:51The police arrested Brett on the front
- 19:53porch in front of the same neighbors who
- 19:56had watched his fist land.
- 19:58He didn't resist. He didn't say much of
- 20:00anything. He just kept looking at his
- 20:02own front door as though it might open
- 20:05and make this go away.
- 20:07Officer Delgado read him his rights
- 20:09while Mrs. Tanner stood at the end of
- 20:11her driveway with her arms folded. That
- 20:14part, I admit, I watched. I wanted to.
- 20:17Aaron, they questioned inside for almost
- 20:20an hour.
- 20:21When she came out and officer walked
- 20:23beside her, and she wasn't in handcuffs
- 20:25yet, but she wasn't free either.
- 20:27She stopped at the curb where I was
- 20:29sitting with a paramedic holding an ice
- 20:31pack to my eye.
- 20:33Her mouth opened.
- 20:35I don't know what she meant to say. I
- 20:37looked at my daughter and said the only
- 20:38true thing I had left.
- 20:41I said, I'm not going to scream at you,
- 20:43Aaron. I'm going to let the record
- 20:45speak.
- 20:46She started to cry. Officer Delgado
- 20:49touched her elbow and led her to the
- 20:50car.
- 20:52That was the Saturday.
- 20:53I told you everything fell apart within
- 20:55the hour, and it did.
- 20:57But the courtroom came later, in the
- 20:59fall, and I want you to see it the way I
- 21:02did.
- 21:03The Montgomery County Courthouse smelled
- 21:05of floor wax and old coffee. I wore my
- 21:08navy suit, the one I'd worn to Dale's
- 21:10funeral, and I sat in the front row with
- 21:13Susan on one side and Russell Burns on
- 21:16the other in a sport coat that looked
- 21:18like it had been pressed with a ruler.
- 21:20Behind us in the gallery sat a woman
- 21:23with white hair and a cane, Paula, the
- 21:25retired nurse from Springboro. She had
- 21:28driven up alone.
- 21:30Brett came in wearing county orange. He
- 21:32had lost weight.
- 21:34The salesman's polish was gone, and what
- 21:37was left looked like a man who had read
- 21:39the footage and understood it. He had
- 21:41pleaded the week before because his own
- 21:44attorney had shown him Russell's video
- 21:46and told him what a jury would see.
- 21:49The judge asked if the victim wished to
- 21:50speak. My knees didn't want to hold me,
- 21:53but I stood. I said, Your Honor, I
- 21:56opened my home, my family, and my trust
- 21:59to this man. He called me a stupid old
- 22:01woman, and then he hit me, and my own
- 22:03daughter dragged me out in front of the
- 22:05whole street. I'm not here for revenge.
- 22:08I'm here so that the next widow he sits
- 22:10down with doesn't have to learn what I
- 22:12learned.
- 22:13Then the judge asked Brett if he had
- 22:15anything to say.
- 22:17He stood.
- 22:18He looked at me for the first time since
- 22:20that porch. He said, Joyce, I never
- 22:23meant for it to go that far. I was under
- 22:25pressure.
- 22:26I thought if you would just sign, we
- 22:28could all fix it.
- 22:30I said, you thought I would sign because
- 22:32you hit me?
- 22:33He opened his mouth and nothing came
- 22:35out.
- 22:36The judge, a gray-haired woman with half
- 22:38moon glasses, said, Mr. Cunningham, I
- 22:41have the recording. I have the video.
- 22:44I have the bank's records, and I have
- 22:46Miss Paula's affidavit from six years
- 22:48ago.
- 22:49I don't think pressure is the word.
- 22:51She sentenced him to seven years in
- 22:53state prison and ordered full
- 22:55restitution to me for my medical bills,
- 22:57my legal fees, and the cost of the
- 22:59investigation.
- 23:01She ordered his real estate license
- 23:03revoked.
- 23:04The bank had already taken the house.
- 23:07Brett swayed a little. His attorney put
- 23:09a hand on his elbow. As the deputies led
- 23:12him out, Paula leaned over the rail, and
- 23:14in a clear, steady voice she said,
- 23:17six years I waited for somebody to
- 23:19believe me. He didn't look at her
- 23:21either.
- 23:22Aaron's hearing came in the same
- 23:23building two weeks later. She stood in a
- 23:25gray cardigan with her hands clasped in
- 23:28front of her, and she did not look for
- 23:30me, though I was there. She had pleaded
- 23:32to misdemeanor assault. The judge gave
- 23:35her 18 months of probation, mandatory
- 23:37counseling, and 150 hours of community
- 23:40service, and a no contact order that
- 23:43would stand until the court said
- 23:45otherwise.
- 23:47The judge told her, Miss Cunningham, you
- 23:49put your hands on your own mother.
- 23:51Whatever Mr. Cunningham did, that part
- 23:54was yours.
- 23:55Aaron said, yes, your honor. I know it
- 23:57was.
- 23:58In the hallway afterward, the deputy let
- 24:00her stop three feet from me. Her voice
- 24:03was barely there. She said, mom, I'm so
- 24:06sorry. I said, I heard you. And I walked
- 24:09past her to the elevator because I was
- 24:11not ready to hear more, and because the
- 24:13order said I couldn't.
- 24:15The children went to stay with my sister
- 24:17Gloria in Cincinnati for five months,
- 24:20and that was the part that nearly broke
- 24:22me.
- 24:23Scarlett wrote me letters on lined
- 24:25paper. Dear grandma, I hope your face
- 24:27doesn't hurt anymore.
- 24:29I drew you a bird.
- 24:31I didn't speak to Aaron for nearly 11
- 24:33months. I wanted her to hurt the way I'd
- 24:36hurt, and I'm not ashamed of that. A
- 24:38parent is allowed to be angry. A parent
- 24:41is allowed to be done.
- 24:43After the no contact order expired, what
- 24:45changed things was a letter.
- 24:48Aaron wrote 60 pages in her careful
- 24:50handwriting, and she did not make a
- 24:52single excuse.
- 24:54She wrote that she had known, deep down,
- 24:56what Brett was and had chosen the
- 24:58version of him that kept her
- 25:00comfortable. She wrote that she kept
- 25:02seeing my blood on the concrete. At the
- 25:04end, she wrote,
- 25:06I don't expect you to forgive me. I only
- 25:08want you to know I know what I did.
- 25:11I read it twice and put it in the drawer
- 25:13where I keep Dale's old watch. I didn't
- 25:15answer for three more months. When I
- 25:17did, I wrote one line. You may write to
- 25:20me once a month. Nothing more for now.
- 25:23It's been nearly two years, she writes.
- 25:26She's working at a dental office and
- 25:28living in a rented duplex with the
- 25:30children, and she's paid back the court
- 25:33costs herself. I have not given her a
- 25:35dime of the trust, and I won't until I'm
- 25:37sure the person receiving it is the
- 25:39daughter I raised and not the one who
- 25:42stood in that hallway.
- 25:44But Scarlett and Jackson come to my
- 25:46house every other Sunday, and I make pot
- 25:48roast, and we play that card game. I
- 25:51still don't understand.
- 25:53I moved back to my little house in
- 25:54Kettering with a new lock on the door.
- 25:57Russell still calls me ma'am. His camera
- 25:59is still up. Mrs. Tanners brings me
- 26:02tomatoes in August.
- 26:04I volunteer now two mornings a week at a
- 26:06legal aid clinic that helps older adults
- 26:09understand what they're signing. I teach
- 26:11one small class called Keep Copies.
- 26:14The first slide is a picture of a
- 26:16cartoon cat notebook. People laugh at
- 26:19that. Then I tell them what's in the
- 26:20notebook, and they stop laughing and
- 26:23start writing things down.
- 26:25If you take one thing from my story,
- 26:28take this. Love is not a reason to hand
- 26:31someone the key to everything you've
- 26:33built. You can love your children and
- 26:35still say no. And if something feels
- 26:38wrong in a house that's supposed to be
- 26:39your family's, don't wait for the first
- 26:42punch to prove it. Write it down. Tell a
- 26:45neighbor, call a lawyer, keep your
- 26:47copies.
- 26:48I never planned to be a woman who sat on
- 26:50a curb bleeding in front of her
- 26:52neighbors, but I'm proud of the woman
- 26:55who got up off it.
- 26:57Sometimes the hardest boundaries to set
- 26:59are with family members who claim they
- 27:02only want to protect us.
- 27:04Have you ever had someone close use
- 27:06worry to control your life?
- 27:08And how did you finally draw the line?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of After My Son-in-Law PUNCHED Me, I Made Him REGRET Going After My Three Million by Emily's Family Stories, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,752 words across 748 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.