African Americans Have NO CULTURE?! Franck Zanu Discusses This w/ Karen Hunter & Dr. Daniel Black — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00You you you say that.
- 0:01No, you say the word the
- 0:02African-American culture. What is it?
- 0:05Okay, fine.
- 0:06>> Like like hip hop, not hip hop. I mean,
- 0:09I don't want to
- 0:11Yes, I feel like
- 0:12>> You haven't thought about it. It's fine.
- 0:14Don't make things up. I'm not making it
- 0:16up. I feel like
- 0:17>> me. You feel.
- 0:19You should know. You were born and
- 0:21raised here. Bring it down, Smith. Um
- 0:23bring it down.
- 0:25Do you stand by that, Frank Zano?
- 0:28Yeah. We're ready.
- 0:30We're prepared. Do not give in to fear.
- 0:34We are fearless.
- 0:36This is not the time to be afraid. This
- 0:39is a time to stand up and fight back.
- 0:42And to resist any temptation for them to
- 0:44divide us.
- 0:46We're in this together. The rule OF LAW
- 0:48IS ON OUR SIDE. WE WILL NOT give in, not
- 0:52give up, WE WILL NOT CAPITULATE, WE WILL
- 0:54NOT BOW, WE WILL NOT BEND, WE WILL
- 0:58SURVIVE.
- 1:01BUT I brought you here because of a
- 1:02comment you made, and I'm I'm sure it
- 1:04was taken out of context. So, I want to
- 1:06give you an opportunity to talk about
- 1:08it, and I want to play a clip from that
- 1:11interview, that discussion you had. Play
- 1:13it, Smith.
- 1:14African-Americans in this country are
- 1:16the only groups they have no culture.
- 1:18It depend on who you meet, where you
- 1:20meet them.
- 1:21But currently, there's not an
- 1:22African-American culture? No.
- 1:25Yes, there is.
- 1:26>> What is it?
- 1:28Um
- 1:29>> Name two value systems in the
- 1:30African-American culture.
- 1:32Value systems?
- 1:33>> Name Yes.
- 1:34Name two taboos in the African-American
- 1:36cultural system.
- 1:38Name two traditions, by the way, in the
- 1:39African-American cultural system.
- 1:42There is no value
- 1:44for freedom if you don't understand what
- 1:46it is.
- 1:47The concept of free You have to have a
- 1:50foundation on which it would balance
- 1:52when you ask for it. Civil right, they
- 1:54give it to you. You have no culture.
- 1:57Nancy, you've been here, born here. Why
- 1:59would you be surprised if I say
- 2:01African-Americans don't have a culture?
- 2:03For twerking?
- 2:04So, anything
- 2:05>> We may but I feel like African-American
- 2:07culture has definitely You you you say
- 2:11that.
- 2:11No, you say the word the
- 2:13African-American culture. What is it?
- 2:16Okay, fine.
- 2:17>> Like like hip hop, not hip hop. I mean,
- 2:20I don't want to
- 2:21Yes, I feel like
- 2:23>> thought about it. It's fine. Don't make
- 2:24things up. I'm not making it up. I feel
- 2:27like
- 2:28>> me. You feel.
- 2:30You should know. You were born and
- 2:31raised here. Bring it down, Smith. Um
- 2:33bring it down.
- 2:35Do you stand by that, Frank Zano?
- 2:38Yeah.
- 2:40Okay. And you're talking to somebody
- 2:42who's not African-American and asking
- 2:43her questions.
- 2:45You have a problem with that? You don't
- 2:46think that that was a little So,
- 2:49that conversation
- 2:51was the Haitian conversation.
- 2:54So, it was
- 2:55>> said African-American. You brought You
- 2:57brought black people in. You You didn't
- 2:58say Haitians.
- 2:59No, I'm saying the conversation I had
- 3:01with Nancy
- 3:02was Haitians can fix Haiti. It was in
- 3:05that conversation that this came up, and
- 3:07it was
- 3:08a sound bite on Tik Tok. Now, when the I
- 3:11went to the W.E.B. Du Bois Center in
- 3:14Ghana,
- 3:15uh I was a young fellow when first we
- 3:18went, and there was a sign on the wall,
- 3:20big one. I don't know, maybe a poet who
- 3:22wrote it, maybe Langston Hughes or
- 3:24something. I forgot. But they had it on
- 3:26the wall, and it said,
- 3:28"The problem and the pain of slavery was
- 3:31not the work they make us do.
- 3:34It is the fact that it took away our
- 3:36language, our culture, our history, our
- 3:39traditions.
- 3:40And that leaves a man like a tree with
- 3:42no roots." And he hit me. I wrote it
- 3:45down in my notebook.
- 3:47Now, when you
- 3:48you listen to a lot of the writings
- 3:51about slavery, the first thing you hear,
- 3:54even in the United States, is about how
- 3:56our life, our culture, our language, and
- 3:59history was taken away from us.
- 4:02Mhm. That is very common. So, so what
- 4:06Okay. Okay.
- 4:10I met Alex Haley's I'm Hold on.
- 4:13You're from Benin.
- 4:15Yeah. You're not You're not there now,
- 4:16you're here. You're an American citizen.
- 4:18You came here, you left there
- 4:20to come here. Mhm.
- 4:24The Homie Kingdom We We love the Black
- 4:26Panther and all of this, and the the
- 4:28Dora Milaje based on the the Homie
- 4:30warriors, and Woman King, we love that.
- 4:33Um
- 4:35But the the Homie Kingdom
- 4:37one of the ways in which
- 4:40your
- 4:41origin your country of origin, Benin,
- 4:45conquered,
- 4:46they would sell their
- 4:48people into bondage to the Europeans
- 4:51into this transatlantic transatlantic
- 4:53slave trade when you lost. When you
- 4:56lost, you got sold. And
- 5:00every year every year, you got 333,000
- 5:03lb sterling
- 5:05for bodies for black bodies to be sold
- 5:07into the transatlantic slave trade,
- 5:09which would be worth about 16.7 million
- 5:11dollars annually every single year. It
- 5:14was Benin, known as the Slave Coast,
- 5:17because of the flourishing trade of
- 5:19human bodies. That was your protocol.
- 5:22That was the way in which you dominated.
- 5:25And it went on for more than a decade,
- 5:27in the 1780s to '90s. Benin sold more
- 5:29than 102,000 bodies into bondage.
- 5:34So, epigenetically, one could argue,
- 5:36Frank Zano, that
- 5:38part of your way of knowing is to sell
- 5:41out your people. One could argue that.
- 5:44Maybe that's in your epigenetics,
- 5:46because to me, to say something so
- 5:48boldly
- 5:49that black people have no culture
- 5:52with no references, and you're talking
- 5:53to somebody that's not black, you're
- 5:55talking to somebody who clearly wasn't
- 5:56educated enough, you're throwing
- 5:58questions at her, you know, give us two
- 6:00things, two two values.
- 6:03Well, I can give you 15. I'mma give you
- 6:05more, but family and integrity.
- 6:08And we don't really do well with
- 6:10sellouts. That's another black cultural
- 6:13value. But I was looking at that, and I
- 6:15was saying, "Wow." And And you stand by
- 6:17it. So, you still stand by black people
- 6:18have no culture? So, Benin didn't sell
- 6:22slaves.
- 6:23>> They sold I I did my research. I'm
- 6:25sorry. Maybe you don't know it, because
- 6:28it's clear to me that you don't know a
- 6:30lot of things. But you don't know it.
- 6:32>> Allow me to explain what I mean.
- 6:35Please. I really want to have a very
- 6:38respectful conversation.
- 6:40So, you said Benin sold. Benin did not
- 6:44sell slaves, because when slaves were
- 6:46bought from that region, there was no
- 6:48Benin. There was no country called
- 6:50Benin.
- 6:50>> Dahomey.
- 6:51No. No. Okay. Well, whoever This is the
- 6:54same landmass, correct? Same people? No,
- 6:58at all. They have nothing in common.
- 7:00Please, allow me.
- 7:02The place that became called Dahomey
- 7:08was at independence.
- 7:13The place you're calling Benin
- 7:15was not there. Dahomey was not there
- 7:18during slavery.
- 7:20What was there were tribes. Abomey, the
- 7:24women warriors you mentioned, they are
- 7:26not from Dahomey or from Benin. They are
- 7:29from only one tribe called the Abomey
- 7:31tribe.
- 7:35That region had about 52
- 7:38different distinct tribes.
- 7:42Only one of them
- 7:45captured slaves from either the Aja, the
- 7:49Yoruba, the Bariba, or the Nagongo areas
- 7:52and sold. They didn't sell their people.
- 7:56An example, if there is a war in, let's
- 7:59say, Asia or in Europe,
- 8:01Italians captured Portuguese or Spanish
- 8:04and English and sold them to the
- 8:06Chinese. They haven't sold their own
- 8:08people, even though they are Caucasians
- 8:10who live in the region. So, the slaves
- 8:13sold were only sold by Abomey tribe.
- 8:17>> Right. Right. Way before it became
- 8:20Dahomey as a republic that forced 52
- 8:24different tribes to come together by the
- 8:27French and call the place Dahomey. The
- 8:30people, the other 51 tribes that are now
- 8:34part of the country called Benin,
- 8:36including Abomey,
- 8:39they all, including my father's tribe,
- 8:41we hate the Abomeys, because we know
- 8:44they capture people and they sell them.
- 8:47So, that is a correction I want to make.
- 8:48So, saying Benin
- 8:49>> but you you're actually making my point
- 8:51that
- 8:53it is that notion that somehow you are
- 8:55not part of when we talk when I talk
- 8:57about black culture, it is the oneness.
- 8:59It is the understanding that we may be
- 9:01something torn and new, but we are in
- 9:03this thing together that God has got to
- 9:06begin with, that got you got to begin
- 9:08with. And for you to come here and and
- 9:10to make that somehow we don't have
- 9:12culture because of your lack of
- 9:13knowledge of what culture is.
- 9:15>> What I'm saying the science says buy
- 9:17slaves, the danger of buying slaves is
- 9:20you rob them of their culture. That is,
- 9:23of course, a fact you know. Okay. I'm
- 9:25going to bring in cuz I'm I'm very clear
- 9:27that I'm not a historian. So, I'm not
- 9:29going to speak on things I do not know.
- 9:32I'm going to invite everybody who is not
- 9:34a historian. If you read some things or
- 9:36you went down a YouTube rabbit hole, you
- 9:38are not an expert. You have not lived
- 9:40your life studying this. And I'm going
- 9:42to invite you to stop talking about
- 9:43things you don't know. But in the
- 9:45meantime, I'm going to also
- 9:46>> You haven't said something I don't know.
- 9:48That's the point. What is it I don't
- 9:50know? That black people don't have
- 9:52culture. You believe that black people
- 9:53don't have culture.
- 9:54>> you to explain to me if it
- 9:57if it if it protected you from your
- 9:59>> original habitat and they took
- 10:02everything away from you.
- 10:05What is wrong to say these people's
- 10:08culture have been taken away from them?
- 10:10Mhm.
- 10:11I don't understand.
- 10:12>> It's Okay, well I'm going to I'm going
- 10:14to actually bring somebody in who knows
- 10:17more about this than I do, who studies
- 10:19Africa, who studies black history, who
- 10:21teaches at Clark Atlanta. So we're going
- 10:23to bring in Dr. Daniel Black when we
- 10:24come back. Frank Zana was here. Um he's
- 10:28made a statement before the break uh
- 10:30and quoting W.E.B. Du Bois whose
- 10:34uh he has a whole center in Ghana in
- 10:36Accra. There was a quote there that you
- 10:38quoted and you went on a talk show or
- 10:41you were on your own show, you invited
- 10:43somebody on and you said black people
- 10:44have no culture. And I asked you, do you
- 10:46stand by that and you said yes because
- 10:48of that quote. So I thought it would be
- 10:50great to have somebody who actually
- 10:51teaches this
- 10:52to come on and inform all of us why that
- 10:56is
- 10:57I called I called I said you were wrong,
- 10:59but you know, this is your view and your
- 11:01view can't be wrong, but why it's
- 11:03uh
- 11:04not helpful. Let's say let's say it like
- 11:07that, it's not helpful. So let me
- 11:08welcome professor of Africana studies at
- 11:12Clark Atlanta in Atlanta
- 11:15author of many books, Dr. Daniel Black
- 11:17is here. Hi.
- 11:23Uh-oh, your your internet. Look at God.
- 11:26Go ahead. Wait a minute. Yeah, uh
- 11:27brother Frank, how are you up my
- 11:29brother? Doing very well, thank you.
- 11:31Good, very good. I first want to say
- 11:34that uh I am on here to um
- 11:37to enjoy a beautiful exchange. I'm I am
- 11:40not at all on here to um to attack or to
- 11:44or to um to in in any way uh incite
- 11:48rebellion, you know, um I I certainly
- 11:51believe in in communication as Karen
- 11:54does. I certainly believe in truth like
- 11:56all three of us do. And you know, we all
- 11:58believe in integrity. And I think that I
- 12:02think it could be helpful if I can just
- 12:03offer this possibility, right? I think
- 12:05what could really really really really
- 12:07help this dialogue is that there's a
- 12:09premise here that I think it's
- 12:11problematic, but I don't think it's
- 12:13yours, Mr. Frank. I think it's what
- 12:14people have taught in the world.
- 12:16And most of us have taken it because
- 12:18it's just what historians have said. And
- 12:21that premise is this.
- 12:23When Africans were enslaved in Africa
- 12:25and scattered around the world
- 12:28>> [clears throat]
- 12:28>> everything all their culture I I I think
- 12:30you were saying this a minute ago was
- 12:31stripped from them.
- 12:34That's the error.
- 12:36That's the error in this whole thing.
- 12:40Because
- 12:42a process cannot strip culture, the
- 12:45totality of culture from a people.
- 12:48Culture sometimes is in the artifacts of
- 12:51what people have, but culture is also in
- 12:53the flesh.
- 12:56Anywhere a person goes, their culture
- 12:58goes with them.
- 13:00Pieces of that culture in the dance, you
- 13:02know, it's in the body.
- 13:03In the language, we brought we brought
- 13:06African languages to America because we
- 13:09spoke African languages in Africa. We
- 13:11were certainly denied speaking those
- 13:13languages after while once we were
- 13:14enslaved, but the those languages and
- 13:16the influences of those languages are
- 13:19still in our black English tongues right
- 13:21now.
- 13:22Right? So the premise here is that
- 13:25African people who were enslaved and
- 13:27taken from Africa lost all of Africa in
- 13:30the process of being enslaved. That's
- 13:32the error.
- 13:35Right? Much of the culture came with us.
- 13:38Then through transmutation and synthesis
- 13:41we revised through some force and
- 13:43through some voluntary actions, we
- 13:46revised a lot of African culture in
- 13:49order that it could fit the context and
- 13:52the circumstances and the brutality
- 13:54under which we lived in this in this
- 13:57diasporic place, right?
- 13:59>> [snorts]
- 13:59>> Um called the Americas.
- 14:02So Africa there's much much much much
- 14:04much culture here that came along with
- 14:07us and there's much culture that we
- 14:09revised
- 14:10and gave birth to once we got here. For
- 14:13example
- 14:14you get jazz music in America, but jazz
- 14:17has its roots in Africa.
- 14:21But the jazz itself is absolutely an
- 14:24American continuum on the American
- 14:26continuum on the American aesthetic
- 14:28continuum in terms of culture. You get
- 14:30gospel music in America. You don't get
- 14:33gospel music in Africa. You get what you
- 14:35get now is Christian music in Africa
- 14:38that that white Christians have taken,
- 14:40but gospel music is a is is a cultural
- 14:44uh regenerative act that happened in the
- 14:46Americas that has certainly found its
- 14:48way back to Africa. Even traditions like
- 14:51jumping the broom when when we when we
- 14:53as enslaved people wanted to get
- 14:55married, we created that ritual here.
- 14:57African people created that ritual as a
- 14:59part of African culture as a means of
- 15:02creating a ritualized way whereby we
- 15:04could signify the validity of our own um
- 15:08of our our own marriages and
- 15:10relationships. But that is particularly
- 15:13an African-American cultural phenomenon,
- 15:16right? And so what I'm simply saying is
- 15:18is I understood the premise of what you
- 15:20were saying, Mr. Frank, right? What what
- 15:23most people misunderstand though is
- 15:25that we brought a culture with us and we
- 15:30modified and transmuted it once we
- 15:33arrived in this place called America.
- 15:37Thank you. What might you say to that,
- 15:40sir?
- 15:41I said thank you. Oh, I thought I didn't
- 15:43hear you. And and let me just say let me
- 15:45just clear this up cuz you know, if you
- 15:48you felt an ambush coming.
- 15:51I feel like if people have airwaves, we
- 15:54are in a space right now where there's
- 15:55so much division, particularly um
- 15:58there are these culture wars going on
- 16:00right now between blacks and Caribbeans
- 16:02and that's on purpose because divided
- 16:05divided we are conquered. That's how we
- 16:07got conquered. You just told us the
- 16:08story of the whole area known as what
- 16:11was first, you know, uh the French West
- 16:13Africa and it was divvied up, but all of
- 16:16Africa's been divvied up. And you said
- 16:18you hate these people cuz they sold
- 16:20these people, but they we're all one
- 16:21people. And if we don't understand that,
- 16:24we're going to be conquered again. And
- 16:25if people have microphones and they're
- 16:27constantly out here saying these things
- 16:29that animate a negative vibe about black
- 16:32people, it's
- 16:34it's no good and especially when it
- 16:36comes out of a black mouth. It it
- 16:38creates the division or it foments the
- 16:40division or it seasons the division that
- 16:43is already brewing for what purpose?
- 16:47So I'm just I I really just wanted to
- 16:49say like what's your purpose? When
- 16:51people hear things Mhm. you make
- 16:54individual conclusions
- 16:56as you you hear it.
- 16:58It may not be the Why would I come from
- 17:00Benin Republic
- 17:02and be saying things
- 17:05I was speaking not long ago in Boston
- 17:08and I said Benin has no culture.
- 17:14Now I don't understand what at all it's
- 17:18offensive when people but I was lucky
- 17:20that it was a monologue and it waited
- 17:22until a Q&A. So somebody asked me to
- 17:25explain.
- 17:26And I say you cannot raise your child as
- 17:29a Beninois.
- 17:30But you can raise your child as an Adja
- 17:33tribe a Bomba tribe
- 17:36a Wida tribe. But now they are calling
- 17:38us Benin. And if you take five Beninois
- 17:42people from Benin are called Beninois.
- 17:43If you take five, let me use Nigeria
- 17:45that is more popular. If you take five
- 17:48different Nigerians to France or any
- 17:50outside country and you ask them
- 17:54what do you speak in Nigeria?
- 17:56They will start looking at each other
- 17:58and say it depend on who you ask. Right.
- 18:00If you ask them, what is a Nigerian
- 18:02culture?
- 18:04They will say it depend on who you ask.
- 18:06If you ask them, what do you eat in
- 18:07Nigeria? They will say it depend on who
- 18:09you ask. If you ask a Nigerian, five
- 18:12different ones, Igbo, Yoruba, Bendel
- 18:14Calabar, Plateau, Sokoto
- 18:17what is the value systems of Nigerians?
- 18:19They will say it depend on who you ask.
- 18:22But if you ask these same five questions
- 18:24to a a Yoruba
- 18:26he will give you right answers.
- 18:30So it means
- 18:31when the countries were created
- 18:35the people who once had distinct culture
- 18:38with which they raised their children,
- 18:40traditions, norms and everything
- 18:42when they told them to become Nigeria or
- 18:44Benin or Ghana, they don't have anything
- 18:47at all in common. They are the tower of
- 18:50Babel.
- 18:52And I have to educate myself that we
- 18:55have a problem.
- 18:57When I call my nieces and cousins
- 18:59they cannot finish a sentence in my
- 19:01language completely without adding
- 19:04English or French. The French and
- 19:06English itself, they can't even speak it
- 19:08properly without us adding.
- 19:12That is a problem. Mhm. So you can see
- 19:15the problems we are suffering on the
- 19:17continent today
- 19:19it's all because in some cases like
- 19:21Kenya 42 different tribes that have
- 19:24nothing in common with each other
- 19:26are forced to believe that they have a
- 19:29country.
- 19:31So I did a test in in Kenya.
- 19:34Uh
- 19:36I I went to speak on the university
- 19:37campus. There were about 250 and I asked
- 19:40them, how many Kikuyus are in the room?
- 19:42And many students raised their hands.
- 19:43How many Luos? How many Maasai? How many
- 19:48Right. I did about seven of the 42
- 19:50tribes and they raised their hands and I
- 19:51paused for a second and I said, "How
- 19:53many Kenyans are in this room?" And the
- 19:55same hands went up again. And then
- 19:57everybody burst out laughing.
- 19:59So, I asked them, "When you wake up in
- 20:00the morning,
- 20:03are you a
- 20:04a Kenyan first or you are a Kikuyu
- 20:06first?"
- 20:08And that became a long conversation
- 20:10for them to understand why corruption,
- 20:13nepotism, tribalism, all these things
- 20:16have become and even killing each other
- 20:19in the same country thoughtlessly.
- 20:21Mhm. Mhm. Mhm. Mhm. So, what
- 20:24[clears throat] I mentioned here
- 20:26was because I was speaking here.
- 20:29Once upon a time, John Lennon sang a
- 20:31song and said, "Imagine if there is a
- 20:33world with no religion. There was no
- 20:34heaven. There was no earth. It would be
- 20:36a brotherhood of mankind living in
- 20:38love." Now, imagine a world without
- 20:40cultures,
- 20:41which gives birth to these world views
- 20:44and superiority and all that. It would
- 20:47be a brotherhood of mankind. Now,
- 20:50if somebody takes a soundbite from that
- 20:52long conversation, which was an hour,
- 20:54and you listen to it,
- 20:57then of course,
- 20:58as I read the comments and I have got
- 21:00many phone calls, many have said, "I
- 21:03think I know what you tried because I've
- 21:04been saying this, both Africans and
- 21:07African Americans.
- 21:08I do not believe at all that simply
- 21:11describing something because I have seen
- 21:14and I must say, if you take people from
- 21:17their original root." Now, whatever
- 21:19Everything Dr. you said,
- 21:22yes, it's true.
- 21:24People live thousands of years.
- 21:27Some of the things they do becomes
- 21:28almost like a DNA. Mhm.
- 21:31And I said to
- 21:33my friend in Bridgeport, who was a
- 21:35retired African American police officer,
- 21:37and I said, "I look at you." He said,
- 21:39"Take a look at me and tell me, where do
- 21:40you think I came from?" And I said, "You
- 21:42would fit easily as a Yoruba man." We
- 21:44were laughing. He said, "Look, I did my
- 21:46DNA." And actually pointed to those
- 21:47areas. And I said, "But
- 21:50he asked me, "Why is it that we can't
- 21:52get along?" And I said, "Let me explain
- 21:54something which is happening in my own
- 21:55country."
- 21:56I said, "Dwayne,
- 21:58the African Americans you see, the
- 22:00Jamaicans you see, the Asians you see,
- 22:03the reason they could not speak the
- 22:05language, continue to speak it, is
- 22:07because
- 22:09it was not one group tribe that was
- 22:12enslaved. If they did that, they would
- 22:14have continued speaking their language.
- 22:16Mhm. Take a little [clears throat] bit
- 22:17of this, this, this, this. When they
- 22:19arrive here, they could not because in
- 22:21Benin, when I travel 9 miles from my
- 22:24birthplace in my own country, I need an
- 22:27interpreter.
- 22:28Sure. Sure. Sure. Sure.
- 22:31>> African Americans or the Asians or the
- 22:32Jamaicans who arrived here, because they
- 22:34were just pockets of different tribes
- 22:36with different languages, they couldn't
- 22:38speak. So, in the case of Jamaica, they
- 22:40started using a little bit of their
- 22:42language they can remember, a little bit
- 22:43of French or English or Spanish, and
- 22:45then it become patois. Correct. The same
- 22:48became Creole. Correct. Remember, the
- 22:51Americo-Liberians, they took
- 22:54former slaves and sent them to Liberia.
- 22:57Right. They came back, they could not
- 22:58speak their languages. But, there were
- 22:59indigenous still in Liberia. So, they
- 23:02now have to force to speak with the
- 23:03indigenous. Finally, Liberia is one of
- 23:06the countries in Africa that has Creole,
- 23:09the only one, and Sierra Leone.
- 23:12So, very possibly, it seems to me, cuz
- 23:14what you're saying, I think it's right,
- 23:15Mr. Frank there, right? I think that's
- 23:17right. I I want to propose possibly, my
- 23:20elder, that perhaps the way
- 23:24you said it, or yes, it might have been
- 23:25taken um um um maybe I just out of the
- 23:28context, but also
- 23:30perhaps the way you said it, the notion
- 23:31that black people in America have no
- 23:33culture, I think that may not have been
- 23:35the way you wanted to say it. Maybe we
- 23:37might want to say that black people in
- 23:39America have a hybridized culture,
- 23:42right?
- 23:44Not that it's one culture from Africa
- 23:46that got transplanted here, and that one
- 23:48culture is clear. Cuz where you're right
- 23:50is we are the amalgamation of many
- 23:52different tr- uh um um cultural and
- 23:55tribal groups in Africa. That is
- 23:56absolutely true. Right? So, we
- 23:58definitely have cul- a cult- we
- 24:00definitely have culture here. But, what
- 24:02is true is it's not one example of one
- 24:05culture coming from Africa. So, there's
- 24:08not a cul- cultural continuity um that
- 24:10was unbroken. That is absolutely true.
- 24:13Yeah. Yeah. I cited in that
- 24:15conversation, I cited I said, "Haitians
- 24:18couldn't build." And I said, you you
- 24:20know, Africa stopped building.
- 24:23Why?
- 24:25When the Yoruba spoke only one language
- 24:27led by Oduduwa, which is their leader.
- 24:29When the Bomen people spoke only one
- 24:31language. When the Weda spoke one.
- 24:33Ashanti spoke only one language, one
- 24:35God, they were able to build that
- 24:38chieftaincy
- 24:40to a very powerful level.
- 24:41>> you don't you don't bring colonization
- 24:44and and what the Europeans have done and
- 24:47the Portuguese before them and the
- 24:49Spaniards have done in terms of
- 24:51stripping people of all of the things
- 24:52and forcing all of what you talked
- 24:55about, the one language and the one
- 24:58culture, Christmas and all of that. You
- 25:01you don't think that that's a source,
- 25:02you know, and you don't find it You
- 25:04don't think it was insulting?
- 25:06>> Absolutely.
- 25:06>> other videos, I explained that
- 25:09when people have a language, you see,
- 25:11all the G8 countries, one of the things
- 25:14that is common among them,
- 25:16one language,
- 25:18and they try hard Okay.
- 25:21>> to keep it that way.
- 25:22Um I said in my videos that
- 25:26tribes,
- 25:27I like the Ashanti, which is common, and
- 25:29you went to Ghana. These people were
- 25:31building quick and fast
- 25:34because they had only one language,
- 25:36which gave them one self-determination
- 25:38through their world vision or world
- 25:40view.
- 25:41When the languages were put together
- 25:43after the scramble, and it became Twi,
- 25:46Ga, Adangbe, Ewe, we couldn't speak to
- 25:48each other.
- 25:49That region ceased to build. And I used
- 25:52the Tower of Babel as an example. I
- 25:54said,
- 25:56"There is a time, this according to the
- 25:58story, people with one language were
- 26:00building a tower. For me, a vertical
- 26:02structure means development."
- 26:04And God changed the language, and they
- 26:07could not continue building. I said,
- 26:09>> But, the missing part here that I think,
- 26:11sir, and that is once all of these
- 26:14different Africans who are who are and
- 26:16it is right, are speaking different
- 26:17language, get on these slave ships, one
- 26:19of the magical things that happens is
- 26:21those Africans in the bellies of slave
- 26:23ships begin to to piece together their
- 26:26own communication systems. But, it's
- 26:29often as much through gestures as
- 26:31through words. So, that once the minute
- 26:33we get off those slave ships, we begin
- 26:35building a nation, and people now call
- 26:37that nation America. People now call
- 26:39that nation Haiti. People now call that
- 26:41nation uh
- 26:43uh Brazil. We begin to build And where
- 26:45you're right is because we we do create
- 26:48a system, but the language system is not
- 26:50only a language of words. It's also a
- 26:53language of gestures, right? And that
- 26:55allows us to create not only buildings,
- 26:57but also ideas, concepts, right? Uh a
- 27:01spiritual systems, etc., right? That
- 27:04allow us to to make lives and and allow
- 27:07us to make
- 27:08uh uh headway into um a cultural reality
- 27:10that has kept kept all of us alive. And
- 27:12one of the things I think that's
- 27:14important to say, we may not want to say
- 27:16that folks here didn't have a culture.
- 27:18What we might want to say is that that
- 27:20culture was hybridized. That culture
- 27:23>> Okay, y'all. I feel like we going
- 27:24around. Are you are you going to stand
- 27:26by this, Frank Zana? Um when you go out,
- 27:28you're going to when when the clip is
- 27:30played and a a person asks you, do you
- 27:32stand by that? Are you still standing by
- 27:35black people have no culture? I just
- 27:36want to Yes, I will explain
- 27:37>> All right.
- 27:38>> give the details after the
- 27:39>> can't then then there's there's no more
- 27:41no more to talk about.
- 27:43say we have no culture. Yeah. No, that's
- 27:45all right. Do you're not going to
- 27:46convince him. It's fine. He's going to
- 27:48stand by it. Thank you uh for coming in
- 27:50and answering our questions today. I
- 27:52appreciate you. Uh Zana project, Frank
- 27:55Zana,
- 27:56thank [applause] you.
- 27:57Thank you very much for having me. Okay.
- 28:00All right.
- 28:00>> Happy holidays to you all of you.
- 28:02Likewise.
- 28:03>> That's very African.
- 28:05Sorry. [laughter]
- 28:06Not at all. Oh my God. Okay. Goodbye,
- 28:09Frank. Bye.
- 28:11We're ready. We're prepared. Do not give
- 28:14in to fear.
- 28:16We are fearless.
- 28:18This is not the time to be afraid. This
- 28:21is the time to stand up and fight back.
- 28:24And to resist any temptation for them to
- 28:26divide us.
- 28:28We're in this together. The rule OF LAW
- 28:30IS ON OUR SIDE. WE WILL NOT GIVE IN, not
- 28:34give up, WE WILL NOT CAPITULATE, WE WILL
- 28:36NOT BOW, WE WILL NOT BEND. WE WILL
- 28:40SURVIVE.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of African Americans Have NO CULTURE?! Franck Zanu Discusses This w/ Karen Hunter & Dr. Daniel Black by The Karen Hunter Show, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,721 words across 765 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.