ADHD VS Autism in Gaming — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Now, if you're normal, you may not have
- 0:01realized this, but there's a war going
- 0:04on right under your nose since the dawn
- 0:07of, I don't know, 2002, around the time
- 0:09when the human body became 50% plastic.
- 0:12And every person could be categorized as
- 0:15one of two things, either autistic or
- 0:18ADHD. Now, I know some people don't
- 0:20believe ADHD exists or ADD or whatever,
- 0:23but even if you just consider it a
- 0:25personality trait, it does not change
- 0:27the fact that these two groups are
- 0:30diametrically opposed. They are
- 0:32naturalborn enemies. And unfortunately,
- 0:36for both parties, they tend to like the
- 0:38same things, just for different reasons.
- 0:41Any attempt to satisfy one party
- 0:44ultimately alienates the other. Now, so
- 0:46far I've basically presented this as if
- 0:48it's an even feud. Both sides hate each
- 0:51other equally. But really, it's the ADHD
- 0:54people who are hyper aware that it's
- 0:56autistic people ruining everything they
- 0:58like, while the Teismos are blissfully
- 1:01unaware that this dynamic even exists.
- 1:04Well, why, oh viewer, should you care?
- 1:06If you're on this channel to begin with,
- 1:08you're probably a part of one of those
- 1:09two groups. But ignoring that fact,
- 1:11every video game that's not Call of Duty
- 1:14or NBA 2K Madden 24 are forced to appeal
- 1:19to one of these two groups. And because
- 1:22neither group is as large as John
- 1:24Normal, it's usually both. So, if you
- 1:27ever wondered why game series you like
- 1:29keeps getting worse and yet people keep
- 1:32buying it and defending it, this might
- 1:34be why. The perfect example of this
- 1:37being Pokémon that no matter how bad the
- 1:39games get, it doesn't matter as long as
- 1:42it contains those central appeals to the
- 1:45ADHD and autism crowd. That's why the
- 1:48games have been getting worse for a
- 1:50decade. And only now with Pokemon
- 1:53Legends ZA have they finally gone too
- 1:56far. They've made the game unpalatable
- 1:59to the ADHD. And I say that as the king
- 2:02of the spazzes. I watch all my YouTube
- 2:04videos at two times speed while playing
- 2:07Runescape on one monitor while playing
- 2:09another video game on the other. And
- 2:11Pokémon Legends ZA is the first game I
- 2:14would consider unplayably bad. But if
- 2:17you paid any attention to the kind of
- 2:18people who defend that game, the autism
- 2:21people do not care. they still love it
- 2:24because as long as the game contains
- 2:27collecting colorful and easy to
- 2:29understand characters, brain deadad
- 2:32difficulty, and as much nostalgia as it
- 2:34can contain, they will always love it.
- 2:37So, before we get into what makes an
- 2:39autism game versus an ADHD game and why
- 2:42they tend to like the same things, make
- 2:44sure to like, comment, and subscribe
- 2:46because, you know, YouTube's not going
- 2:48to push this video. I just don't think
- 2:50you can say autism this many times.
- 2:52We'll start with the teas who are
- 2:54defined by a whole host of symptoms that
- 2:56I don't really care about. The only
- 2:58important things for this discussion is
- 3:00their inability to understand social
- 3:03cues, their tendency to get hyperfixated
- 3:06on something, sometimes permanently, as
- 3:09well as their general aversion to
- 3:11change. So, unsurprisingly, they like
- 3:13baby games or if you want to be nice
- 3:15about it, Nintendo stuff because they
- 3:17get obsessed as a child and that
- 3:19obsession never fades. While Sony and
- 3:22Microsoft seem to have a new mascot
- 3:24every generation, Nintendo has used the
- 3:27same characters since the NES, a lack of
- 3:30change that would bother some people is
- 3:33why Teismos like it in the first place.
- 3:35They also like depth in their games. If
- 3:38you're going to be obsessed about
- 3:40something, you have to have something to
- 3:42dig into. And the game doesn't even have
- 3:44to facilitate this depth. Despite being
- 3:46incredibly easy games, they tend to have
- 3:49complex movement that is never necessary
- 3:52for the main game, but that doesn't
- 3:54matter because they'll just turn into
- 3:55speed running or competitive multiplayer
- 3:58as an outlet for that obsession.
- 4:00Pokemon, extremely easy games, massive
- 4:03competitive scene. Smash Bros., a party
- 4:07game with a massive competitive scene.
- 4:09all of the 3D Mario's very easy games
- 4:12with complex movement you never really
- 4:14need to use, which is fine cuz they're
- 4:16also the biggest speedrun games. I
- 4:19shouldn't have to tell you that the
- 4:20people playing competitive Pokémon,
- 4:22Melee, speed running are all tease
- 4:25modes. Normal people get bored doing the
- 4:27same thing over and over again, but the
- 4:29tism yearns for it. I feel like I've
- 4:31already given enough examples of the
- 4:33kind of games Teismos like, but in
- 4:35general, it's stuff that minimizes
- 4:38change. If it's going to have a sequel,
- 4:40we're talking the Pokemon games where
- 4:42it's basically the same game every time.
- 4:43It should either have a lot of content
- 4:45to delve into or a lot of depth to
- 4:48obsess over. And if it's going to have a
- 4:50story, we're talking simple characters,
- 4:53simple emotions, or if not that,
- 4:55everything has to be highly exaggerated.
- 4:57No subtlety, none. All right. Now ADHD's
- 5:00turn. Due to the whole iPad Kid thing,
- 5:03this probably includes every zoomer in
- 5:06Gen Alpha on the planet. And if you've
- 5:07never heard the acronym, it is an
- 5:09attention deficit disorder, meaning low
- 5:12attention span. Throw a hyper in there
- 5:14and that's where you get the H. So
- 5:16that's just high energy. Given high
- 5:18energy and low attention span, what we
- 5:21look for in games is constant action,
- 5:24minimal interruption, and most
- 5:26importantly, consistent escalation. You
- 5:30would think at least, but it's really
- 5:31only part of the puzzle. The constant
- 5:33action and minimal interruption makes
- 5:35sense cuz that's how you lose attention.
- 5:38And then to keep that attention, the
- 5:39action has to be constantly escalating
- 5:42something new and interesting. But it's
- 5:44not the full story because ADHD people
- 5:47are also known for one other thing. What
- 5:50we do more consistently than anything
- 5:52else, and it's multitasking. We both
- 5:55love to do it and can't stop ourselves
- 5:57from doing it. If you've ever heard a
- 5:59Midwit talk about multitasking, they say
- 6:02you can't do it. You're actually
- 6:03switching between the two things really
- 6:06fast, which I have some crazy
- 6:07information for those people. Did you
- 6:09know you're not actually looking at
- 6:11anything moving on your screen right
- 6:13now? It's a bunch of pictures that are
- 6:15flashing really fast. Wa, dude. So, you
- 6:18would think a game with consistent low
- 6:21points of low attention would be
- 6:23horrible for ADHD people, but it's
- 6:26actually great because it's during those
- 6:28low attention points that we're able to
- 6:31switch task effectively. Multitasking.
- 6:34Old school Runescape should be the worst
- 6:37ADHD game ever. what I'm doing right
- 6:39now. I only click on the screen once
- 6:42every 30 seconds or so. If it was the
- 6:44only game I was playing, I would hate
- 6:46this. But I'm playing it on the side and
- 6:49it fills in the low points of the other
- 6:53tasks I'm doing. I'm actively playing
- 6:55this game while recording the audio
- 6:58right now. And I'll probably be playing
- 7:00while I edit the video, too. So, the
- 7:02type of games we like are extremely high
- 7:04attention or very low attention with no
- 7:07in between. They can have interruptions
- 7:10or low points, but those points must
- 7:12require no attention at all to allow for
- 7:15us to do something else at the same
- 7:17time. This is why I hate cutscenes. They
- 7:20break the flow, require no input from
- 7:23the player, and demand all of your
- 7:25attention. Then, we also need constant
- 7:28change or escalation. It's the only
- 7:31thing stopping us from just moving on to
- 7:33a different game is something new to
- 7:35peique our interest. This concept is
- 7:37kind of another core symptom or
- 7:39personality trait of ADHD is obsession
- 7:43with one thing for a short period of
- 7:45time. Games can take advantage of this
- 7:48by changing before that time ends. That
- 7:51way it feels more like a new obsession
- 7:53every time. Then the final pillar of
- 7:55ADHD game design is infinite options or
- 7:58as many options as you can have. If
- 8:00we're going to get distracted anyway,
- 8:03let that distraction be within the game.
- 8:05So big open worlds, a ton of skills, a
- 8:08ton of upgrades, tons of team building
- 8:11options, anything that distracts us
- 8:13without causing us to close the game.
- 8:16Let me give you two examples of peak
- 8:18ADHD gaming. One is live service
- 8:21multiplayer. Multiplayer games require
- 8:24all of your attention to win, assuming
- 8:26you're playing against people of the
- 8:27same skill level. You're always
- 8:29improving, giving infinite escalation,
- 8:32and the game is always updating, so
- 8:34there's always new stuff to learn or
- 8:36things to try out, keeping our very low
- 8:38attention. Then on the other end of the
- 8:40spectrum is baby game RPG. It's super
- 8:43easy, so we can give it half our
- 8:45attention, the other half being used
- 8:47watching a movie or YouTube. a basically
- 8:50infinite number of options for team
- 8:52building and dialogue that adapts to our
- 8:55attention span. If we're paying more
- 8:57attention, we read faster and progress
- 8:59faster. If we're paying less attention,
- 9:01then we just read slower. So that's ADHD
- 9:03and autistic. And everything would be
- 9:05fine if you just had ADHD games and
- 9:07those exist and autistic games and those
- 9:10also exist. But unfortunately, things
- 9:12aren't allowed to be made for a niche
- 9:14anymore. You have to shoot for a larger
- 9:16audience. Everything has to appeal to
- 9:19everyone and sometimes it succeeds, but
- 9:22at what cost? Well, let me tell you a
- 9:24little story. I've already explained how
- 9:26Runescape is kind of geek ADHD. It has
- 9:29different activities for different
- 9:31attention levels from a click every 30
- 9:33seconds to full attention to a click
- 9:35every 10 minutes, meaning you can fit it
- 9:38in with any task. But it's also a great
- 9:40autism game. It functions entirely on
- 9:42nostalgia. Despite getting updates all
- 9:45the time, the game has intentionally not
- 9:47evolved since 2007. Only now, after 18
- 9:51years, has the game finally gotten one
- 9:54new skill. And being a game that's been
- 9:56updated for that long, it has a ton of
- 9:59content to get obsessed with. Not to
- 10:01mention, I bet you there are people who
- 10:03have been obsessed with this game since
- 10:052007. The game also has goofy characters
- 10:08with a light-hearted story and a ton of
- 10:10hyperbole. Point is, great game for the
- 10:12teasmos too, which would be great if not
- 10:15for one thing. The one thing that has
- 10:18kept this game good and also creates so
- 10:20much conflict and that's that every
- 10:22update operates on a polling system. The
- 10:25developers suggest an update or change
- 10:28to the game and the players must vote on
- 10:31if they want it in the game or not. And
- 10:32if 70% of people don't agree, it doesn't
- 10:36make it into the game. While every game
- 10:37tries to appeal to its player base, this
- 10:40is the only one where the players have
- 10:42direct influence on every change. So, if
- 10:45something happens you don't like or
- 10:47something you wanted in didn't make it
- 10:49in, you have your fellow players to
- 10:51blame for it. Why do you think it took
- 10:5318 years for one new skill? It's cuz the
- 10:56teas can't handle change and they voted
- 10:58no every time. And once us ADHDs finally
- 11:02get our win, new stuff, the first thing
- 11:05the Teismos do is whine and cry about
- 11:08everything. They're complaining on day
- 11:11one that it's too hard to get to level
- 11:1399. If you don't know, that's the max
- 11:16level a skill can be in Runescape in
- 11:18something that usually takes hundreds of
- 11:20hours to reach. And they were
- 11:22complaining day one that it was too
- 11:25slow. To the ADHD, this doesn't even
- 11:27make any sense. The point is that it
- 11:29takes a really long time. Every skill is
- 11:32taking a really long time. That's the
- 11:33game. But the Teismo reached 99 on every
- 11:37other skill thousands of hours ago and
- 11:39have no recollection of what it was
- 11:41like. Their experience of the game has
- 11:43just been PvP for thousands of hours,
- 11:45which hasn't changed in a decade, or
- 11:48fighting the same boss, which takes full
- 11:51attention hundreds, if not thousands of
- 11:54times, something a normal person could
- 11:56only stand to do once or twice. Imagine
- 11:59fighting Millennia from Elden Ring
- 12:01thousands of times, except it takes
- 12:03twice as long, and you had to click
- 12:05rocks thousands of times just to get to
- 12:08that point. Does it sound absurd yet?
- 12:10Now imagine that guy trying to tell you
- 12:13what a good update looks like. So
- 12:15unsurprisingly when sailing, that's the
- 12:18new skill, came out and the teas started
- 12:21complaining, there was blowback. They
- 12:23were attacked and immediately they cry,
- 12:25"Oh, toxic positivity. No, we're just
- 12:28sick of you ruining the things we like."
- 12:30that when you complain that sailing
- 12:32feels useless because you have every
- 12:34teleport in the game, which takes
- 12:36hundreds of hours of grinding to get to,
- 12:39that maybe you don't represent everyone.
- 12:42And actually, I want you dead. How about
- 12:44we give another example? Pokémon. Ton of
- 12:46options, easy to multitask for, good
- 12:48ADHD game, extremely nostalgic, barely
- 12:51ever changes, colorful, simple
- 12:53characters. Japanese, very autistic.
- 12:56Well, if you looked at my comment
- 12:58section, autistic people don't seem to
- 13:00care how bad the games get. In fact, it
- 13:02seems like they don't care about quality
- 13:04at all. That has nothing to do with why
- 13:07they like a game. All that matters is
- 13:08that appeals to their specific tastes. I
- 13:11mean, they get to collect stuff. And you
- 13:13ever seen an autistic person's room? You
- 13:15know they love collecting stuff. And it
- 13:17doesn't matter how low quality it is. I,
- 13:19however, care a lot cuz things that are
- 13:21bad are boring and they lose my
- 13:23attention. But I try and say that and
- 13:25the tism freaks out cuz they're like,
- 13:26"What do you mean? How can you not like
- 13:28this game? It has the Pokemons in it."
- 13:30And if you want or need anything else,
- 13:32you're clearly asking for too much. Now,
- 13:35I've really only given examples of games
- 13:37being ruined for the ADHD, but it works
- 13:39the other way around sometimes. Not
- 13:41nearly as often cuz we have taste, but
- 13:43it does happen sometimes. Probably most
- 13:46commonly, it happens with multiplayer
- 13:48games. when they're in a good spot. The
- 13:50first people to demand a change are the
- 13:52ADHD. They can't handle a character
- 13:55being too good even for a week. Best
- 13:57example of this is also Pokémon. Pokemon
- 14:00Showdown is the competitive singles
- 14:02website where all bands or rule changes
- 14:05are determined by a council and
- 14:07community votes. While the autistic are
- 14:10generally happy and they want to explore
- 14:12the metag game, the ADHD are constantly
- 14:15complaining, constantly asking for
- 14:17changes. They want to ban vote every
- 14:20other day. God forbid you let the format
- 14:22develop or you just adapt in some sort
- 14:25of way. But although we claim it's about
- 14:27balance, really we just want something
- 14:29different cuz we're getting bored. So
- 14:31while an autistic person's having fun,
- 14:33we end up getting it changed before they
- 14:35even had the opportunity to explore
- 14:37their obsession. The difference is
- 14:39though, while the ADHD are perfectly
- 14:41aware that it's the Teismos ruining
- 14:43everything and we hate them for it,
- 14:45autistic people have no idea who's doing
- 14:47this to them and couldn't figure it out
- 14:49if they tried. You see, there's one big
- 14:51difference between these two groups I
- 14:53haven't mentioned yet, and it's pattern
- 14:55recognition. ADHD are hyper aware of
- 14:58patterns, probably to the point where
- 15:00they identify patterns that don't even
- 15:02exist. Now, I would argue that they all
- 15:03exist and that normies are just stupid,
- 15:05but that's why they call me a skitso.
- 15:07Autistic people, on the other hand,
- 15:08couldn't identify a pattern if it was a
- 15:11brick thrown at their head. They'd be
- 15:12like, "Huh, I wonder where that brick is
- 15:14going." This doesn't really affect the
- 15:15games at all, but it certainly makes the
- 15:18discourse infuriating. At no point does
- 15:20anyone question how we're somehow able
- 15:22to see the future, or maybe you really
- 15:25can tell if a game's going to be bad
- 15:27before it comes out. So, the animosity
- 15:30stems from us liking the same games for
- 15:33different reasons and each group
- 15:34actively trying to change those games to
- 15:37appeal more to them and less to the
- 15:39others. Any attempt at discourse is
- 15:42stifled by the fact that autistic people
- 15:44can't really communicate with anyone.
- 15:46But it's even worse for the ADHD who are
- 15:48obsessed with patterns. Not to mention,
- 15:50what makes the autistic like a game is
- 15:53extremely personal and based on
- 15:55basically nothing. So, there's nothing
- 15:57to discuss. I say the game would
- 15:59certainly be better for everyone if it
- 16:01didn't look terrible and had a dynamic
- 16:03environment. And you say, "Well, I
- 16:06played Pokemon since I was five and I've
- 16:08always liked it and that means it can
- 16:10never be bad. And if you insult Pokémon,
- 16:12that means you're insulting me and I
- 16:13hate you forever." And I can already
- 16:15hear people saying, "And not you, the
- 16:17viewer, cuz you're a real one. If you
- 16:18made it this far, why should I care? I'm
- 16:20totally not one of these two groups. I'm
- 16:22completely normal." Well, these are two
- 16:24quickly growing populations. Thanks to
- 16:27iPhone kids and social media, ADHD is
- 16:31going to be the dominant trait of
- 16:32humanity. Every new kid has it. Autism
- 16:35has also been shown to be growing for
- 16:37many reasons. Who knows? And no, it has
- 16:40nothing to do with us being better at
- 16:43diagnosing it. Cuz one, it wouldn't be
- 16:45growing at the same rate. It's not like
- 16:47we're suddenly learning so much about
- 16:49autism every year. And two, if that was
- 16:52really the case, low functioning autism
- 16:54would be growing much more slowly or not
- 16:57at all compared to high functioning
- 16:59autism. Cuz obviously it would be easier
- 17:02to diagnose low functioning compared to
- 17:04high. Both are growing rapidly. I love
- 17:07how if you bring up there are more
- 17:08autistic people now, that's the first
- 17:10thing anyone ever says is, "Oh, we're
- 17:12just better at diagnosing it." Even
- 17:14though if you think about it for even a
- 17:16second, it doesn't make any sense.
- 17:17Problem is, people don't think. They
- 17:19just say things to make themselves feel
- 17:21better. No, go ahead. You can take
- 17:22whatever you want while pregnant. The
- 17:24point is soon the entire human
- 17:26population will be a part of one of
- 17:27these two groups. And if we want our
- 17:29games to be good, you got to pick one.
- 17:31Now, ADHD is the obvious choice, not
- 17:34just because we're the ones with taste.
- 17:36People with autism don't care about
- 17:38quality at all. So, as long as they grow
- 17:40up with it, they'll still like it. So,
- 17:42who cares if they get what they want?
- 17:43But more importantly than that, what
- 17:45appeals to the ADHD is just good game
- 17:47design. Let me give you one more
- 17:49example. If you've ever played a
- 17:50multiplayer game, most of the fun comes
- 17:53from learning. It's from getting better
- 17:55at the game. It's an intrinsic reward.
- 17:58The problem is the better you are and
- 18:00the more you learn, the harder it is and
- 18:03the longer it takes to get better.
- 18:05Initially, all you have to do is play
- 18:07the game, which is fun. Then maybe you
- 18:09have to start practicing in a training
- 18:12room until finally you're spending
- 18:14nearly all of your time just training,
- 18:17not actually playing the game for barely
- 18:20noticeable improvements. But what if we
- 18:22could avoid all that? What if we made it
- 18:23so you learned at the same rate forever?
- 18:26Well, it's not that hard and games
- 18:28actually do it all of the time. Imagine
- 18:30you start a new game and you have to
- 18:32learn a character. You have to look up
- 18:34all their moves, when they're strong,
- 18:36when they're weak, or maybe a card game
- 18:38where you have to read all the cards,
- 18:39know what they do, how does this deck
- 18:42play, and every time you learn a card or
- 18:44a character, you are objectively a
- 18:46better player. It doesn't take very
- 18:48long. All you have to do is read, but
- 18:50you are now better than you were before
- 18:51and you feel good when the last time you
- 18:54fought them, you lost cuz you didn't
- 18:55know. And now you fight them again and
- 18:58you win thanks to your new knowledge. It
- 19:00feels extra good to improve in such an
- 19:02objective and obvious way. Well, the
- 19:05game releases a new character or
- 19:07releases new cards. You now get to have
- 19:10that exact same experience all over
- 19:12again. And it takes no longer to read
- 19:15your 1,01st
- 19:17card as it does to read your very first
- 19:19card. Now, the reality is it's not that
- 19:22you're literally improving at the same
- 19:24rate forever, and it's more so that as
- 19:26soon as they release a new character or
- 19:28card, you actually get worse and have to
- 19:30catch back up. But that's not what it
- 19:32feels like. This constant change and
- 19:35adaptation is exactly what ADHD people
- 19:38love because it's just good game design.
- 19:40And the teas hate it cuz they hate
- 19:42things that are good. Really, the whole
- 19:44point of this video is I was watching a
- 19:46guy play Smite. Really like that game.
- 19:48It gets updated every 2 weeks. And in
- 19:50his tism, he said, "Man, I can't wait
- 19:53for this game to stop updating. Anyone
- 19:55who wants this game to update all the
- 19:57time doesn't like the game. You should
- 19:58play a different game." MOAs usually
- 20:00have over aundred characters. The whole
- 20:02point is to learn a bunch of new stuff
- 20:04all of the time. But they can't help
- 20:06themselves. They love missing the point
- 20:07all in an attempt to ruin everything for
- 20:10everyone all the time. I do not like
- 20:12them. That's all I wanted to say with
- 20:13this video is that there needs to be
- 20:15more abbleism, not less. Bully. Bully
- 20:18them. I don't like them. Subscribe. This
- 20:20is probably going to be my worst
- 20:20performing video cuz I said autism 300
- 20:22times.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of ADHD VS Autism in Gaming by Lord Frogmire, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,701 words across 531 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.