YouTube2Text

ABUS 4013 Employment Law — Transcript

by OES Team · 9,067 words · 1,511 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01good morning welcome to the employment
  2. 0:03law video for abus4013
  3. 0:08today we have a guest with us named
  4. 0:10holly robbins
  5. 0:12and holly is an employment lawyer in
  6. 0:14minneapolis
  7. 0:15she works with the firm of littler
  8. 0:17mendelssohn
  9. 0:18which is a firm that specializes in
  10. 0:20employment and labor law
  11. 0:22and they have offices across the u.s and
  12. 0:24overseas as well so
  13. 0:26thank you holly for joining us this
  14. 0:28morning thank you for having me
  15. 0:30um
  16. 0:31so we have a top 10 list of tips for
  17. 0:34managers from an employment lawyer that
  18. 0:36we've put together
  19. 0:38and so we're going to structure our
  20. 0:39conversation to get today with following
  21. 0:41that that list so holly yes number 10.
  22. 0:45all right make sure your employees are
  23. 0:48classified and paid properly what's that
  24. 0:50about so what that means is that
  25. 0:52employees are either classified as
  26. 0:54exempt employees or non-exempt employees
  27. 0:57and
  28. 0:58employees who are non-exempt have to be
  29. 1:00paid overtime they have to keep track of
  30. 1:03their hours it's important to get that
  31. 1:05right because right now this is a very
  32. 1:08hot topic with plaintiff's lawyers to
  33. 1:10look for companies that are not doing
  34. 1:13this properly and to try to structure
  35. 1:15class actions where the plaintiff's
  36. 1:17lawyer can then
  37. 1:19find a bunch of people who all have been
  38. 1:21paid improperly and try to get the money
  39. 1:24back and that attorney would get
  40. 1:26attorneys fees if they win as well so
  41. 1:28there's an incentive there for the
  42. 1:29plaintiff's lawyer to try to find these
  43. 1:32these classes of people
  44. 1:34now there are also sometimes issues with
  45. 1:37independent contractors that feed into
  46. 1:39this area
  47. 1:41independent contractors
  48. 1:43that has a very specific meaning and
  49. 1:45often you may have someone who wants to
  50. 1:48to fashion themselves as an independent
  51. 1:50contractor and that may be beneficial
  52. 1:54to the company as well
  53. 1:56but if they're not really an independent
  54. 1:59contractor if they're really doing
  55. 2:00something that an employee would be
  56. 2:02doing and they're directed the same way
  57. 2:04that an employee is directed then both
  58. 2:07for tax purposes
  59. 2:09and for wage and hour purposes they
  60. 2:12really should be classified as an
  61. 2:14employee and again you see these class
  62. 2:16actions popping up that address these
  63. 2:19wage and hour issues with independent
  64. 2:22contractors
  65. 2:23okay so when um these lawsuits crop up
  66. 2:26yeah they're saying the plaintiffs are
  67. 2:28saying that they should have been
  68. 2:30classified as an employee that's
  69. 2:32exempt
  70. 2:34non-exempt usually and should have been
  71. 2:36paid over time right so it's the
  72. 2:38overtime that they're looking to get
  73. 2:40it's the overtime they're looking to get
  74. 2:42yes and it would be back pay for
  75. 2:43whatever period that the employee was
  76. 2:46not treated as a non-exempt correct it
  77. 2:49could be and so when i think of a
  78. 2:51non-exempt employee i'm usually thinking
  79. 2:53of someone who's a manager is that
  80. 2:56an exempt employee is someone who's in a
  81. 2:58manager so someone who's salaried right
  82. 3:00and sometimes people want to think of
  83. 3:03themselves as salaried and they get even
  84. 3:05insulted if you say okay we're going to
  85. 3:07change you from an exempt salaried
  86. 3:09employee to a non-exempt employee but
  87. 3:12for the employee there really is an
  88. 3:14advantage in that they're going to get
  89. 3:16paid over time right so there's been
  90. 3:18some cases about that in the news
  91. 3:20recently with managers at a large
  92. 3:22retailer company there there have been
  93. 3:25there have been a number of cases
  94. 3:27involving large retailers
  95. 3:29restaurants construction companies it's
  96. 3:31really running the gamut of of companies
  97. 3:35i mean sometimes even a smaller company
  98. 3:37now they might not have a class action
  99. 3:39but maybe they have someone that they're
  100. 3:42they're calling a salaried employee who
  101. 3:44is um someone that they think of as
  102. 3:47their executive secretary
  103. 3:49but
  104. 3:50if that person really is doing mostly
  105. 3:52traditional secretarial work they should
  106. 3:55be classified as non-exempt and they
  107. 3:57should get overtime okay so are those
  108. 3:59what are the main factors to decide
  109. 4:02whether someone is should be classified
  110. 4:04non-exempt versus exam it really depends
  111. 4:06upon the type of position okay but a lot
  112. 4:09of times it depends on kind of the level
  113. 4:11of work that they're doing so how
  114. 4:14sophisticated and complicated and how
  115. 4:16much control that they have over what
  116. 4:19they're doing in their job
  117. 4:21with independent contractors there are
  118. 4:23also issues of if somebody is only
  119. 4:26working for one company is prohibited
  120. 4:29from working from another company by
  121. 4:31contract that person probably isn't
  122. 4:33going to be classified as an independent
  123. 4:35contractor and if they're directed very
  124. 4:40precisely in their work by the company
  125. 4:43for whom they're working then they
  126. 4:45probably aren't an independent
  127. 4:46contractor they're really a traditional
  128. 4:49employee you should be taking out the
  129. 4:51taxes and paying them overtime if
  130. 4:54they're
  131. 4:54if they're working more than 40 hours a
  132. 4:57week
  133. 4:58all right number nine
  134. 5:00uh disability and leave laws are often
  135. 5:02complicated and unintuitive yes
  136. 5:05so there are a number of
  137. 5:08laws that protect people who have
  138. 5:10disabilities and also that protect
  139. 5:12people who need to take a leave because
  140. 5:15for example they're having surgery or
  141. 5:17they're having a baby or they had a baby
  142. 5:20and so with respect to those disability
  143. 5:23and leave laws they
  144. 5:25they interconnect first of all sometimes
  145. 5:28for a disability
  146. 5:29you need to take a leave right um and
  147. 5:33the other thing that can be very
  148. 5:34complicated with leave laws is that
  149. 5:37intermittent leave is something that is
  150. 5:40provided
  151. 5:41by the federal statutes
  152. 5:44that govern disability leave it's called
  153. 5:46the americans with disabilities act and
  154. 5:48that allows someone to take time off
  155. 5:51intermittently so they might be able to
  156. 5:53take off
  157. 5:54two hours a day every
  158. 5:56week
  159. 5:58because they need to because their
  160. 6:00doctor says that they can't work the
  161. 6:03full day or they might need to take off
  162. 6:05one day a week to go get a treatment uh
  163. 6:08to go get a therapy or something like
  164. 6:11that um or they may just need to take
  165. 6:14leave off
  166. 6:15intermittently without any kind of
  167. 6:17notice because they get migraines and
  168. 6:19when they get migraines they're unable
  169. 6:21to work and that's just an example of
  170. 6:24the kind of
  171. 6:26condition that can be protected
  172. 6:29by the family and medical leave act
  173. 6:31which is a federal statute by the
  174. 6:33americans with disabilities act another
  175. 6:35federal statute and also by the
  176. 6:37minnesota statutes the minnesota human
  177. 6:39rights act so even if a company isn't
  178. 6:42big enough to be covered by the family
  179. 6:44medical leave act which has
  180. 6:47certain requirements of more than 50
  181. 6:49employees working within certain areas
  182. 6:51they may be covered by minnesota
  183. 6:53statutes and in minnesota there's a
  184. 6:56statute that
  185. 6:57the law is actually changing on august
  186. 6:591st and there is a greater opportunity
  187. 7:03for leave for people who are looking for
  188. 7:05parenting leave so people who have just
  189. 7:08had babies men and women covers both
  190. 7:11and or women who have conditions that
  191. 7:13are related to pregnancy so they may
  192. 7:16need to leave before
  193. 7:18um before they have the baby or after
  194. 7:21they have a baby because of
  195. 7:23a pregnancy related condition
  196. 7:25um
  197. 7:26the intermittent leave i think is
  198. 7:28something that's particularly
  199. 7:29complicated
  200. 7:31and often seems like maybe someone is
  201. 7:34cheating the system a little bit
  202. 7:36because
  203. 7:38it comes up sporadically it's
  204. 7:40unpredictable but people do have
  205. 7:43conditions
  206. 7:44that may cause them to need to miss work
  207. 7:47periodically because of that condition
  208. 7:49and frankly they may not be safe to work
  209. 7:52when they're um having when they're
  210. 7:54having a migraine or having an episode
  211. 7:57um it often comes up with mental health
  212. 7:59issues as well which are protected under
  213. 8:02the americans with disabilities act the
  214. 8:04minnesota human rights act and the
  215. 8:06family and medical leave act
  216. 8:08so it does sound really complicated what
  217. 8:10do you advise people to do if they are
  218. 8:13if they don't have someone who's an
  219. 8:15expert on this in their company what
  220. 8:16would be a good thing to do first of all
  221. 8:18you want to have a policy get your
  222. 8:20policy in shape um there are
  223. 8:24there are examples of policies online
  224. 8:26you can work with an attorney to to
  225. 8:28create a policy um human resources
  226. 8:30professionals are often very um
  227. 8:32knowledgeable about about these policies
  228. 8:35as well so have a policy um and then
  229. 8:38follow your policy but when you get
  230. 8:40those complicated questions it is
  231. 8:43something that you probably want to
  232. 8:44consult with an attorney about okay
  233. 8:47and is it better to do that some of them
  234. 8:49are straightforward i will say there are
  235. 8:51very some very straightforward issues
  236. 8:53yeah um but certainly you know if
  237. 8:55it's better to to start when you realize
  238. 8:58this is too complicated and i can't i
  239. 9:01can't quite figure it out um or you know
  240. 9:04if somebody is coming to you and saying
  241. 9:06i need to take time off i'm going to
  242. 9:07have a baby
  243. 9:09it's a pretty it's pretty cut and dried
  244. 9:11okay there's paperwork that needs to be
  245. 9:13done you get that paperwork filled out
  246. 9:16the paperwork is mandated by federal law
  247. 9:19so you can find that again it's online
  248. 9:23okay department of labor issues certain
  249. 9:26examples of that paperwork
  250. 9:28and then um the person gets under the
  251. 9:31family and medical leave act 12 weeks of
  252. 9:33leave one thing to consider however is
  253. 9:36say someone has taken 12 weeks of leave
  254. 9:39off because they have cancer and at the
  255. 9:42end of 12 weeks they're not quite ready
  256. 9:44to come back to work
  257. 9:46but they will be ready to come back to
  258. 9:48work at some point even though the
  259. 9:50family and medical leave act doesn't
  260. 9:52necessarily cover them for any more time
  261. 9:55the americans just with disabilities act
  262. 9:57may and leave is what's called an
  263. 10:00accommodation a reasonable accommodation
  264. 10:03or maybe a reasonable accommodation
  265. 10:06under the americans with disabilities
  266. 10:08act so under that act you have to
  267. 10:10consider whether
  268. 10:12that person needs additional time as a
  269. 10:15reasonable accommodation so it's it's i
  270. 10:19say it can be cut and dried but it can
  271. 10:21also not be
  272. 10:22okay so if you have questions like that
  273. 10:25it's worth the call to an attorney that
  274. 10:28has the expertise it is because when
  275. 10:31when companies get it wrong
  276. 10:33they can be held liable for it
  277. 10:36they can get a charge or a lawsuit for
  278. 10:38under the disabilities act or under the
  279. 10:41family and medical leave act and that's
  280. 10:43something you're better off making sure
  281. 10:46you do things right so that you can
  282. 10:48avoid that
  283. 10:49okay so we talked a little bit about
  284. 10:51policies in the last issue now so our
  285. 10:54number eight uh top tip is know your
  286. 10:56policies yes so first of all
  287. 11:00have policies
  288. 11:02and
  289. 11:03this doesn't mean you have to have a
  290. 11:04policy on every little thing but there
  291. 11:06are certain things that is really
  292. 11:08important to have a policy on
  293. 11:10leave is one of those things right um
  294. 11:12because that's that's part of at least
  295. 11:15if you're again if the company is large
  296. 11:17enough to be covered by the family and
  297. 11:18medical leave act it's a requirement you
  298. 11:21really need to have that policy another
  299. 11:23thing that it's really important to have
  300. 11:25a policy on is an anti-harassment policy
  301. 11:29so that's something that says that
  302. 11:31the that the employees of the company
  303. 11:33must not harass
  304. 11:35other employees
  305. 11:37and managers must not harass employees
  306. 11:41on the basis of any protected status so
  307. 11:44protected status there are a number of
  308. 11:46different ones it can be race sex
  309. 11:49disability age
  310. 11:53marital status in minnesota sexual
  311. 11:55orientation in minnesota those are
  312. 11:57aren't federal but they are in minnesota
  313. 11:59covered uh religion creed national
  314. 12:02origin and i'm sure i'm missing some
  315. 12:05sorry
  316. 12:06that there are a number of protected
  317. 12:07statuses and all of those people are
  318. 12:09protected from being harassed
  319. 12:12and
  320. 12:13the way that the the law works is that
  321. 12:15having that policy and following the
  322. 12:18policy is part of a defense that a
  323. 12:20company would have
  324. 12:22if for example someone complained and
  325. 12:25said i feel like i've been harassed by
  326. 12:27my manager having the policy that says
  327. 12:31this is the person to whom you should
  328. 12:32complain if you have a problem and when
  329. 12:35we get a complaint we will um we will
  330. 12:39investigate that complaint and we will
  331. 12:41take prompt and effective remedial
  332. 12:43action and so
  333. 12:45if the company has that
  334. 12:47in effect
  335. 12:48then they may have a defense if the
  336. 12:51employee fails to follow the policy
  337. 12:54however if the
  338. 12:55the
  339. 12:56company doesn't have the policy they
  340. 12:59they lose that defense so it's important
  341. 13:01to have that in effect it's also
  342. 13:03important just so that if there's a
  343. 13:06problem the company knows about the
  344. 13:07problem and the employees know what am i
  345. 13:11supposed to do if i have this problem
  346. 13:13how do i remedy it and they're not just
  347. 13:16saying okay i think i'll remedy it by
  348. 13:18going and talking to all of my
  349. 13:19co-workers about it that's my my remedy
  350. 13:22no there's a specific way go to the hr
  351. 13:25person that's typically the person that
  352. 13:27in the policy we would say
  353. 13:29go to the hr person if you don't have
  354. 13:32uh an hr function then it may just be go
  355. 13:35to your manager
  356. 13:36and if the manager is not the right
  357. 13:38person go to the person above the
  358. 13:40manager ultimately you can always go to
  359. 13:42the president of the company if you need
  360. 13:44to do that so having that policy in
  361. 13:47effect is important and managers should
  362. 13:50be familiar with those policies how does
  363. 13:52training for employees work into that
  364. 13:54yeah and the training is an important
  365. 13:56part there as well because if the
  366. 13:58employees the employees really have to
  367. 14:01know about the policies as well in order
  368. 14:03to be able to follow them so certainly
  369. 14:05we recommend having training on things
  370. 14:08like the the um
  371. 14:11the
  372. 14:12anti-harassment policy uh with the
  373. 14:14family and medical leave act there are
  374. 14:16certain posters that are supposed to be
  375. 14:18posted in workplaces um as i think there
  376. 14:21are with the discrimination laws as well
  377. 14:23but the fmla
  378. 14:25things like that or that's the family
  379. 14:27and medical leave act right that should
  380. 14:29be posted so that employees are familiar
  381. 14:32with um the family and medical leave act
  382. 14:34and there is actually a federal posting
  383. 14:36that's supposed to be up and again you
  384. 14:38can find it online
  385. 14:40um so do clients ever worry like
  386. 14:43companies call you up and say if i train
  387. 14:44my employees aren't they gonna sit down
  388. 14:46and think of all these claims that they
  389. 14:48can bring i mean what do you say to that
  390. 14:50yeah it is something that i have heard
  391. 14:52employers say well we've decided we're
  392. 14:54not going to have any policies because
  393. 14:56then no one can complain and no one will
  394. 14:58know and
  395. 15:00having policies just creates problems
  396. 15:03i just really disagree with that because
  397. 15:06again if you don't have the policies it
  398. 15:08doesn't mean that the problem doesn't
  399. 15:10exist the problem may still exist but
  400. 15:13it's just festering there and eventually
  401. 15:15it comes out in a piece of litigation
  402. 15:18which is going to be costly and
  403. 15:20time-consuming and distracting and you
  404. 15:23don't have your defenses in place either
  405. 15:26um there are you know
  406. 15:28certain things that are mandated by
  407. 15:30federal law the federal law doesn't say
  408. 15:32you have to have a policy but it does
  409. 15:34say if you don't have one there's no
  410. 15:36there's no you don't have a defense to
  411. 15:38the harassment cases a big part of the
  412. 15:42anti-discrimination laws it ends up
  413. 15:45being about fairness and the people
  414. 15:48who are similarly situated they're doing
  415. 15:50the same jobs
  416. 15:52are going to be treated the same way in
  417. 15:55the same types of situations so if you
  418. 15:58have one employee and they want to take
  419. 16:02a leave and you say okay yeah you can
  420. 16:04take 12 weeks of leave and then we'll
  421. 16:06give you a couple more weeks after that
  422. 16:08and and um and that's fine
  423. 16:11we'll we'll do that for you and then you
  424. 16:13have somebody else who comes along the
  425. 16:15next week and says i think i'm also
  426. 16:16going to need 14 weeks instead of 12
  427. 16:19weeks and you say no we we're not going
  428. 16:21to do that for you then the question is
  429. 16:24why
  430. 16:25and is it because one employee is
  431. 16:27younger and the other's older or one
  432. 16:29employee is black and the other is white
  433. 16:33so you need
  434. 16:34so the policies are helpful to have to
  435. 16:37help
  436. 16:38managers manage similarly in similar
  437. 16:42situations part of our focus in this
  438. 16:44course is risk management yeah and i
  439. 16:47think what you're saying about having
  440. 16:48the right policies in place is part of
  441. 16:51an overall sort of risk management
  442. 16:52strategy for
  443. 16:54uh you know limiting potential liability
  444. 16:57but also just making sure that we're
  445. 16:58doing things the right way definitely
  446. 17:00treating people and you know a big part
  447. 17:02of risk management is having these
  448. 17:05complaint mechanisms so that when an
  449. 17:08employee has concern
  450. 17:10that concern can be brought to the right
  451. 17:12person and that person can manage that
  452. 17:15complaint can
  453. 17:17do an investigation if that's necessary
  454. 17:20or figure out who should do the
  455. 17:21investigation
  456. 17:23and can
  457. 17:24take care to make sure that the
  458. 17:26situation is properly handled that if
  459. 17:29there's a problem there are prompt and
  460. 17:31appropriate remedial measures now that
  461. 17:34doesn't mean
  462. 17:35employee complains
  463. 17:38and then
  464. 17:39the
  465. 17:40hr person to whom the employee complains
  466. 17:43has to fire the person that they
  467. 17:45complained about no
  468. 17:47the discipline would be appropriate to
  469. 17:49the particular situation and situations
  470. 17:52have to be
  471. 17:53handled on a case-by-case basis but as i
  472. 17:56said keeping in mind that similarly
  473. 17:58situated people should be treated in a
  474. 18:00similar way
  475. 18:02great we're going to switch gears a
  476. 18:03little bit now our number seven tip is
  477. 18:05sometimes ignorance is bliss but privacy
  478. 18:09is important
  479. 18:10yes and this is it's kind of funny
  480. 18:12because it seems like the flip of some
  481. 18:14of the other things that i'll i'll be
  482. 18:15saying today but there are certain
  483. 18:17things
  484. 18:18that managers should not be talking to
  485. 18:20their employees about and that includes
  486. 18:22an interview situation so for example
  487. 18:25you don't want to be asking in
  488. 18:27interviews
  489. 18:28about somebody whether they're married
  490. 18:30do you have kids things like that those
  491. 18:33are things that can be a tip off to
  492. 18:35agencies like the eeoc or the department
  493. 18:38of human rights
  494. 18:39that the company is looking for
  495. 18:41information that tells about someone's
  496. 18:43marital status if they have kids they
  497. 18:45may think oh well that company is going
  498. 18:47to want to discriminate against uh
  499. 18:49someone who has children because they're
  500. 18:52going to think oh they have to go home
  501. 18:54or asking about you know are you are you
  502. 18:57pregnant or do you have any plans to get
  503. 18:59pregnant just an absolute no-no in terms
  504. 19:02of asking interview questions
  505. 19:04um so those are the types of things to
  506. 19:06stay away from in interviews and you
  507. 19:09know i recognize that the workplaces are
  508. 19:11places where
  509. 19:13people know each other well and you're
  510. 19:15going to learn those things about your
  511. 19:16employees and that's okay but it is
  512. 19:18something that employ that managers
  513. 19:20should be very
  514. 19:22conscious
  515. 19:23about not prying into if an employee is
  516. 19:27um closed-mouthed about their health
  517. 19:30their family etc and managers should
  518. 19:33really stay away from those topics their
  519. 19:35religion is another one you know all
  520. 19:38things to to be a little sensitive to
  521. 19:40between managers and
  522. 19:43the employees that they manage what
  523. 19:45about age is that something age yep age
  524. 19:48is another one of those things that you
  525. 19:49want to be a little careful about asking
  526. 19:51we shouldn't be asking about age in an
  527. 19:53interview
  528. 19:54and be careful about talking about
  529. 19:56people's age people can be
  530. 19:59very sensitive about that and you know
  531. 20:02even the sort of
  532. 20:04joking around about hail man or
  533. 20:07you know your birthday or what have you
  534. 20:09those things can be very sensitive with
  535. 20:12people and it's funny how they come up
  536. 20:14later if you know you're joking around
  537. 20:17about something about someone's age and
  538. 20:20that person ends up being
  539. 20:22let go for some reason
  540. 20:24and they file a disability suit all of a
  541. 20:26sudden you're going to see that time
  542. 20:27when you called someone old man in a
  543. 20:30complaint
  544. 20:31in a lawsuit and that's very
  545. 20:34disconcerting and something that you
  546. 20:36know you can you can avoid by just not
  547. 20:39doing that in the workplace the other
  548. 20:41privacy issue that i want to talk about
  549. 20:43is privacy and health issues um the less
  550. 20:47managers know about this sort of thing
  551. 20:50really the better if you have an hr
  552. 20:52function
  553. 20:54things like leave should be handled
  554. 20:56through that hr function
  555. 20:58and now if a manager
  556. 21:00is told by an employee hey i need to
  557. 21:03take a leave the manager should
  558. 21:05immediately
  559. 21:07take that information to human resources
  560. 21:09and have human resources deal with it
  561. 21:12now if you don't have that kind of hr
  562. 21:14function the manager will have to deal
  563. 21:16with that but if you do
  564. 21:17it's good to really keep that
  565. 21:19information separate similarly even
  566. 21:21having your personnel file don't mix up
  567. 21:24the health information in the personnel
  568. 21:26file keep that information separate if
  569. 21:29you for example have um
  570. 21:32leave issues or
  571. 21:34companies like construction companies
  572. 21:36there may be you may
  573. 21:38have physicals of employees there may be
  574. 21:41health and information that's related to
  575. 21:43making sure the person can do the job in
  576. 21:45the first place
  577. 21:46um and you know can lift certain amounts
  578. 21:50and is is um able to
  579. 21:53do the essential functions of the job in
  580. 21:56the first place that information again
  581. 21:58should be kept separate and should be
  582. 22:00handled by human resources folks as
  583. 22:02opposed to the manager if the manager
  584. 22:05doesn't know that someone for example
  585. 22:07has a disability that manager can't
  586. 22:10discriminate against that person because
  587. 22:11they have a disability
  588. 22:13and you know even if that you know the
  589. 22:15manager would never do that anyway
  590. 22:18that does create a very simple defense
  591. 22:21in a disability case to say
  592. 22:24i never knew that that person had that
  593. 22:26condition so i couldn't possibly have
  594. 22:28discriminated against them i did not
  595. 22:30make the decision to demote fire not
  596. 22:34promote etc that person because of a
  597. 22:38disability that i didn't know about so
  598. 22:40there can be situations where it's
  599. 22:41better not to know about someone's
  600. 22:44condition
  601. 22:45health condition because it protects you
  602. 22:47from a charge that you
  603. 22:49treated them differently
  604. 22:51because of their disability correct so
  605. 22:53for that to be effective the health
  606. 22:55information has really got to be kept in
  607. 22:57a locked drawer like somewhere really
  608. 22:59well separated it should be kept
  609. 23:01separate also because it is you know
  610. 23:03private information
  611. 23:05and
  612. 23:06shouldn't be shouldn't be accessed by
  613. 23:08other employees who have no need to know
  614. 23:11about it shouldn't be accessed by
  615. 23:14people from outside the company
  616. 23:16certainly who have no need to know about
  617. 23:17it health information is is private and
  618. 23:21should be kept separate now managers
  619. 23:23will have to know sometimes about
  620. 23:25conditions because they need to work
  621. 23:28with human resources and the employee in
  622. 23:30order to come up with say an
  623. 23:32accommodation right so um
  624. 23:35under the americans with disabilities
  625. 23:37act and the minnesota human rights act
  626. 23:40it's necessary to provide a reasonable
  627. 23:42accommodation
  628. 23:44that will allow a person with a
  629. 23:46disability to do the essential functions
  630. 23:48of their job so if an employee can do
  631. 23:52the essential functions of their job
  632. 23:54with a reasonable accommodation
  633. 23:56then the company should be making that
  634. 23:58accommodation and there's always a
  635. 24:01question of what's reasonable what
  636. 24:04accommodations will allow the person to
  637. 24:07do the job
  638. 24:08what are the essential functions of a
  639. 24:10particular job um but you know those are
  640. 24:13things that employers
  641. 24:15the managers and the human resources
  642. 24:18person and the individual and the
  643. 24:20individual's doctor all have a part in
  644. 24:22defining what that is okay
  645. 24:25uh let's move on to number six beware
  646. 24:28social media yes so social media is
  647. 24:31obviously something that's interesting
  648. 24:33to
  649. 24:34people generally and it contains so much
  650. 24:38personal information
  651. 24:40and it contains so many messages that
  652. 24:43people
  653. 24:44put out
  654. 24:45into the
  655. 24:47universe
  656. 24:48when they're mad or
  657. 24:50when they're happy
  658. 24:52or when they're thinking about quitting
  659. 24:54their job or when they hate their
  660. 24:56supervisor or
  661. 24:58when they um are have have been having a
  662. 25:02bad day
  663. 25:03and um they people are are not always
  664. 25:06i'm sure we all know people are not
  665. 25:08always very good about um keeping their
  666. 25:11their feelings silent and can sometimes
  667. 25:14put things that are kind of ill-advised
  668. 25:16on the internet on facebook or snapchat
  669. 25:18or whatever it is that that people are
  670. 25:20doing
  671. 25:22and so
  672. 25:23employers have
  673. 25:25an interest sometimes and saying well
  674. 25:27i'm looking at hiring this person
  675. 25:30maybe i should look at their facebook
  676. 25:31page if it's not private or you know
  677. 25:34this employee seems to be i'm i don't
  678. 25:37think i think that they're cheating on
  679. 25:39fmla i don't think they're really sick i
  680. 25:42think they're um
  681. 25:44i think they're just pretending to be
  682. 25:46and so i'm just gonna check out their
  683. 25:47facebook
  684. 25:49um another thing that happens sometimes
  685. 25:50is you'll get an employee who brings
  686. 25:52something in you know i'm friends with
  687. 25:55bob on facebook
  688. 25:57and i just saw that he's
  689. 25:59put up this rant about his supervisor
  690. 26:02and how the supervisor is being unfair
  691. 26:05and treating employees badly and
  692. 26:07harassing people and i don't think that
  693. 26:09he should have put that up there so i'm
  694. 26:11going to give it to you mr supervisor
  695. 26:13and
  696. 26:14i think you should just know this now mr
  697. 26:17supervisor gets that information and bob
  698. 26:20has been ranting about him on facebook
  699. 26:23and mr supervisor's first instinct is
  700. 26:27i'm gonna fire bob
  701. 26:29but
  702. 26:30the
  703. 26:31actions that people take on facebook the
  704. 26:33things they say on facebook can be
  705. 26:36what's called protected concerted
  706. 26:38activity
  707. 26:39which um the
  708. 26:40the national labor relations board says
  709. 26:44well if that's
  710. 26:45if what bob is saying on facebook is
  711. 26:48something about the fairness at work
  712. 26:50that may apply to more than more than
  713. 26:53just bob and they're acting as you know
  714. 26:56they're they're reaching out to a group
  715. 26:58of people that could be protected
  716. 27:01so
  717. 27:02really it's not always in the employer's
  718. 27:05interest or best interest to go looking
  719. 27:07on facebook for things as i said often
  720. 27:10what happens is somebody else brings it
  721. 27:12in and makes the employer see it and
  722. 27:14it's really hard to not think about the
  723. 27:17fact that bob has been
  724. 27:19um talking about you on facebook but it
  725. 27:22is something that supervisors need to be
  726. 27:23able to sort of separate themselves from
  727. 27:26interesting this employee is you know is
  728. 27:28ranting on me about me on facebook but
  729. 27:31what he's saying
  730. 27:32is
  731. 27:33something
  732. 27:34about fairness and about treating people
  733. 27:37generally badly now it doesn't mean that
  734. 27:40bob can say on facebook i want to kill
  735. 27:42my supervisor and that is protected
  736. 27:45activity but you got to be really
  737. 27:47careful when you're looking at what
  738. 27:50people are saying on social media
  739. 27:52as to whether that is
  740. 27:55something you can actually act on
  741. 27:58similarly when employees employers are
  742. 28:00hiring if they're looking on social
  743. 28:03media to find out information about
  744. 28:05people it may again tell them things
  745. 28:08that they don't want to know it might
  746. 28:09say something about the person's
  747. 28:10religion or their national origin that
  748. 28:13the employer didn't know before and you
  749. 28:16don't want your employment decisions to
  750. 28:18be
  751. 28:19be tainted by those issues so
  752. 28:22probably best to stick with the
  753. 28:24information
  754. 28:25that the employer knows or at least be
  755. 28:28very conscious that if you are going out
  756. 28:30to look at what's on
  757. 28:32social media
  758. 28:34that
  759. 28:35if if you find out information that is
  760. 28:38about protected status
  761. 28:40that you don't take that into
  762. 28:42consideration okay and you know i
  763. 28:44shouldn't i don't want to say you should
  764. 28:46never look on social media i mean there
  765. 28:48are some things that are about someone's
  766. 28:50professional background you know
  767. 28:52linkedin seems pretty you know that's
  768. 28:54that's supposed to be about someone's
  769. 28:56professional background and if someone
  770. 28:58someone's resume on linkedin doesn't
  771. 29:00match up with their resume that they
  772. 29:02gave you it might actually raise some
  773. 29:05good questions i mean kind of common
  774. 29:06sense is don't put stuff on facebook
  775. 29:08that you wouldn't want it is potential
  776. 29:10employer employees both for the employee
  777. 29:13and for the employer because if you
  778. 29:14think about
  779. 29:15if you as a manager are putting
  780. 29:17information up there um
  781. 29:20then
  782. 29:21your employees might be seeing it
  783. 29:23and
  784. 29:24that can have an effect on how they see
  785. 29:26you depending upon
  786. 29:27what the picture is or what the message
  787. 29:30is so um you know it it may also be
  788. 29:35not the best idea for managers to friend
  789. 29:38their
  790. 29:40their employees and to
  791. 29:42be in more social networks as opposed to
  792. 29:46professional networks with their
  793. 29:48employees great
  794. 29:50all right um let's see number five
  795. 29:53listen to employee complaints yeah and
  796. 29:56this is a little bit something that
  797. 29:57we've kind of talked about up until now
  798. 29:59as well
  799. 30:00that um when employees
  800. 30:03make complaints supervisors have an
  801. 30:06obligation to act if they're making
  802. 30:09complaints about protected issues
  803. 30:11if someone comes to a supervisor and
  804. 30:13says i feel like i'm being harassed by
  805. 30:16this other supervisor or by this
  806. 30:18employee
  807. 30:19then that's something that you want to
  808. 30:21really listen to but it doesn't just
  809. 30:23have to be the word harassed it could be
  810. 30:26i'm really uncomfortable this person
  811. 30:28makes me really uncomfortable
  812. 30:31and that shouldn't be something that you
  813. 30:33go oh uncomfortable okay she didn't say
  814. 30:36harassed she said uncomfortable so
  815. 30:38well i'm sorry about that
  816. 30:40you know maybe you should just stay away
  817. 30:42from him and then leave it at that
  818. 30:44no that's something you want to get into
  819. 30:46a little bit more now the supervisor
  820. 30:49again if you have an hr function this is
  821. 30:51something that supervisors probably
  822. 30:53should go to hr with and let them take
  823. 30:56the appropriate action again they're the
  824. 30:58ones who
  825. 30:59kind of own those policies
  826. 31:01and can work with them and we'll know
  827. 31:04how they've been
  828. 31:05um addressed in similar
  829. 31:07circumstances so again people can have
  830. 31:10that that fairness but supervisors
  831. 31:12really need to listen to what um what
  832. 31:15they're hearing even when they're things
  833. 31:16that sound like little gripes
  834. 31:19if those little gripes are actually
  835. 31:22gripes where the person's saying well i
  836. 31:24think this is illegal well there's a
  837. 31:26minnesota whistleblower act the
  838. 31:28minnesota whistleblower act protects um
  839. 31:33people for who have made complaints of
  840. 31:35illegal conduct
  841. 31:37and
  842. 31:38so even if the person is wrong
  843. 31:41and nobody committed that illegal
  844. 31:44conduct they have a reasonable belief
  845. 31:46that that someone did
  846. 31:49that could be a protected activity
  847. 31:52now you want to look into it you want to
  848. 31:54treat it okay treat it properly and
  849. 31:56seriously and not retaliate against that
  850. 32:01person for having made that complaint
  851. 32:04now here again is sometimes the
  852. 32:06employers um
  853. 32:08say well you know it's better just to
  854. 32:11ignore it because
  855. 32:12then you know i if i didn't know about
  856. 32:14if i don't
  857. 32:15pry into the situation then i could say
  858. 32:18well i didn't really know but
  859. 32:20you again there don't have to be magic
  860. 32:22words it doesn't have to be the word i
  861. 32:24think this is illegal i think this is
  862. 32:26sexual harassment i feel like i'm being
  863. 32:29discriminated against um the
  864. 32:32if the the words are more as i said i
  865. 32:35feel uncomfortable or this person is
  866. 32:38really bothering me or i saw this
  867. 32:41inappropriate um
  868. 32:43you know i saw
  869. 32:44naked pictures on the on the screen of
  870. 32:47one of my co-workers
  871. 32:49that should be enough for you to say
  872. 32:50okay i'm gonna let's
  873. 32:52tell me about that and let's do
  874. 32:53something about it now
  875. 32:55a corollary to this is sometimes you
  876. 32:57will get
  877. 32:58these kinds of complaints from employees
  878. 33:01who will say
  879. 33:03this is confidential i just want to tell
  880. 33:06you i don't want to do anything about it
  881. 33:08but if you're getting that as a
  882. 33:10supervisor and this can be hard because
  883. 33:13sometimes your employees you feel like
  884. 33:14they're your friends and they won't
  885. 33:15trust you but if you're hearing about
  886. 33:18sexual harassment or
  887. 33:21illegal conduct or something like that
  888. 33:23from your or disability discrimination
  889. 33:26from an employee you really have an
  890. 33:29obligation to
  891. 33:32look into that further to take it to hr
  892. 33:35to make sure that it gets addressed even
  893. 33:37if that employee is saying
  894. 33:38i don't want to do anything about it
  895. 33:40because
  896. 33:42that puts the company by them coming to
  897. 33:44you as a supervisor it puts the company
  898. 33:47on notice and it creates the potential
  899. 33:49for liability
  900. 33:51so if someone does come to you and say
  901. 33:53i want to share this but it's
  902. 33:54confidential yeah should you right away
  903. 33:56say
  904. 33:58i want to hear what's bothering you and
  905. 34:00i may have to
  906. 34:01take action on that before they spill or
  907. 34:04is that a bad thing to say no i don't
  908. 34:06think that that's a bad thing to say i
  909. 34:07think you want to be honest with
  910. 34:10employees about how things are going to
  911. 34:12work right out to the extent that you
  912. 34:14can and we'll talk about this a little
  913. 34:15bit
  914. 34:16um later about the sort of honesty is
  915. 34:19the best policy but um
  916. 34:22if an employee is coming to you and says
  917. 34:24i want this to be confidential and
  918. 34:26better to say look you know
  919. 34:28why don't you tell me what it is
  920. 34:30i can't say that it's going to be
  921. 34:32confidential depending on what you're
  922. 34:34telling me but we what the the point is
  923. 34:36that we want to get it figured out we
  924. 34:38want to we want to address the issue
  925. 34:41yeah i mean just like if an employee
  926. 34:43came to you and said i want to tell you
  927. 34:45something confidential and then they
  928. 34:46told you that they did something illegal
  929. 34:49you shouldn't be keeping that to
  930. 34:50yourself either right um you you want to
  931. 34:55as a supervisor you have that
  932. 34:57responsibility to your company and to
  933. 34:59yourself frankly that you need to take
  934. 35:03action on any complaint you get
  935. 35:06um you know i i often see cases where an
  936. 35:10employee says well
  937. 35:12i
  938. 35:13i complained of something and i'm i was
  939. 35:16harassed i complained about it nobody
  940. 35:17did anything about it and then i talked
  941. 35:19to the company and they said well no
  942. 35:21that person never complained about
  943. 35:22anything we never got any complaint we
  944. 35:24don't know anything about any complaint
  945. 35:26and
  946. 35:27as it turns out when we get down to the
  947. 35:30supervisor level and talk to the
  948. 35:31supervisor they say well yeah i mean she
  949. 35:34said this but i didn't you know she
  950. 35:36didn't say anything about harassment and
  951. 35:39she you know didn't use that word and so
  952. 35:42and she said it was okay and she said
  953. 35:44she didn't want to do anything about it
  954. 35:45and therefore i didn't
  955. 35:48and then there's a problem
  956. 35:50again this is a place where having
  957. 35:52policies can help because then you can
  958. 35:54say look she didn't follow that policy
  959. 35:57but it's still
  960. 35:58it creates a
  961. 36:00a problem situation if the supervisor
  962. 36:02really did know something and they
  963. 36:04didn't do anything about it now you
  964. 36:06mentioned uh whistleblowers and
  965. 36:07retaliation yeah so that retaliating
  966. 36:10could be anything like even demoting the
  967. 36:13person or taking them off a certain
  968. 36:15project they could or moving even moving
  969. 36:17them within the company doesn't just
  970. 36:19mean they're getting fired right it
  971. 36:21could be any kind of change in their
  972. 36:23situation it could be an ad an adverse
  973. 36:25action or even just a sort of a negative
  974. 36:29in their workplace a standard under the
  975. 36:31minnesota whistleblower act has actually
  976. 36:33and that that's a law that has changed
  977. 36:36recently as well and has made it
  978. 36:39easier for employees to make claims
  979. 36:42of whistleblowing and
  980. 36:45so even very kind of slight changes in
  981. 36:49someone's
  982. 36:51work that are
  983. 36:53that the employee finds to be negative
  984. 36:55can be maybe considered to be
  985. 36:58enough to support a retaliation claim so
  986. 37:00the way that works is a person has made
  987. 37:03a complaint
  988. 37:05of
  989. 37:06what they perceive to be some illegal
  990. 37:08conduct uh the employer then
  991. 37:12three weeks later
  992. 37:14starts to
  993. 37:16have them work nights instead of days
  994. 37:18the employee may say well you you put me
  995. 37:21on nights which i don't want to work
  996. 37:22nights
  997. 37:23and that's a you know days to nights can
  998. 37:26be a big deal because i made that
  999. 37:28complaint and that action is a protected
  1000. 37:31action
  1001. 37:32so
  1002. 37:33and i mean this is a this is a tough
  1003. 37:35area the the whistleblower stuff because
  1004. 37:38you know you may get that employee there
  1005. 37:40are there are those employees out there
  1006. 37:42who are serial complainers they can
  1007. 37:45always find something to complain about
  1008. 37:47and at a certain point it's sort of you
  1009. 37:50know
  1010. 37:51they create morale issues they waste
  1011. 37:53time they do this they do that and i
  1012. 37:55don't want them here anymore
  1013. 37:57but you have to go back and look is this
  1014. 37:59really connected back to them making
  1015. 38:01protect
  1016. 38:03making protected complaints and engaging
  1017. 38:05in protected conduct and you have to
  1018. 38:08disentangle that protected conduct from
  1019. 38:11is there a real reason beyond that
  1020. 38:14conduct that we want to take a
  1021. 38:16particular action toward this employee
  1022. 38:19got it
  1023. 38:20number four if you know of a problem act
  1024. 38:22on it
  1025. 38:23yes so this is kind of talked a little
  1026. 38:25bit about it already so
  1027. 38:27listen to hear whether they're
  1028. 38:30whether they're employee complaints and
  1029. 38:33if you know about it do something about
  1030. 38:35it again that the cone of silence
  1031. 38:38doesn't really work for super
  1032. 38:39supervisors great yeah
  1033. 38:42and
  1034. 38:43moving on number three
  1035. 38:45you i guess that means individual
  1036. 38:47supervisor you can be personally liable
  1037. 38:50that is true there are um areas in which
  1038. 38:53individual supervisors can be personally
  1039. 38:55liable so
  1040. 38:57not only do you have the interest of
  1041. 38:58your company to think about but
  1042. 39:00supervisors also have their own
  1043. 39:01self-interest to think about a little
  1044. 39:03bit
  1045. 39:05managerial employees are often brought
  1046. 39:07in as individual defendants in lawsuits
  1047. 39:11where there may be a claim against the
  1048. 39:13employer and against the supervisor
  1049. 39:16saying
  1050. 39:17this um this supervisor for example
  1051. 39:20committed a tort like intentional
  1052. 39:22infliction of emotional distress
  1053. 39:24the supervisor was um so
  1054. 39:28you know made my life so miserable
  1055. 39:30basically you know harassed me and
  1056. 39:33um
  1057. 39:34took all kinds of actions against me and
  1058. 39:36made my life miserable and
  1059. 39:38um caused me to suffer from stomach
  1060. 39:42pains and what have you and i'm i'm
  1061. 39:45going to bring them in individually now
  1062. 39:48oftentimes that's something that is the
  1063. 39:51the company would would defend the
  1064. 39:53employee and the and the company but
  1065. 39:56if the if the employee has been not
  1066. 39:58acting in the employee's best interest
  1067. 40:00the supervisor has been acting against
  1068. 40:03the company's best interest
  1069. 40:06they're creating a a real problem for
  1070. 40:08themselves and really you don't want to
  1071. 40:11have your name in a lawsuit anyway so
  1072. 40:13pushing that to kind of the ultimate
  1073. 40:15extreme like if you if you were sued
  1074. 40:17individually as well as your employer
  1075. 40:19and the employer decided you were kind
  1076. 40:22of on your own here yeah um
  1077. 40:26are you gonna have to pay that your
  1078. 40:28attorney out of your own pocket usually
  1079. 40:30yeah yeah yeah there's um the way that
  1080. 40:33that a lot of employment laws work
  1081. 40:36um the
  1082. 40:38discrimination laws and the
  1083. 40:40the wage and hour laws and many other uh
  1084. 40:43many other statutory laws is that if the
  1085. 40:46employee wins the employee gets
  1086. 40:49attorney's fees if the employer wins or
  1087. 40:52the supervisor wins
  1088. 40:53the employer and supervisor still have
  1089. 40:56to pay their own attorney so there's a
  1090. 40:58fee shifting but only in one direction
  1091. 41:01only in the direction of the employee
  1092. 41:04so
  1093. 41:04the company is going to be paying their
  1094. 41:06own attorney's fees and if there's an
  1095. 41:08individual
  1096. 41:09defendant uh a manager that person is
  1097. 41:12going to be paying or their or their
  1098. 41:14company is going to be paying for their
  1099. 41:16attorney's fees as well right right
  1100. 41:19our number two top tip we're getting
  1101. 41:21close to the top so these are the big
  1102. 41:22ones number two document document
  1103. 41:25document yes
  1104. 41:26um this is another one where i sometimes
  1105. 41:28have employers tell me
  1106. 41:30well we don't want to put this in
  1107. 41:31writing because we don't want to create
  1108. 41:33a paper trail about it
  1109. 41:35but
  1110. 41:36typically if you're doing the right
  1111. 41:39thing you want your paper trail
  1112. 41:41another thing that i see sometimes is
  1113. 41:44there's no paper trail and all of a
  1114. 41:46sudden the person say
  1115. 41:49makes a protected complaint and then all
  1116. 41:52of a sudden everything is documented
  1117. 41:54thereafter well that looks kind of
  1118. 41:57suspicious when you
  1119. 41:58when the when the whistleblower ends up
  1120. 42:01filing a lawsuit that yeah as soon as i
  1121. 42:03made that complaint
  1122. 42:05they started scrutinizing me they were
  1123. 42:08documenting everything i did they were
  1124. 42:10looking for excuses to fire me
  1125. 42:12so and if you have zero documentation
  1126. 42:15and then tons of documentation
  1127. 42:18well
  1128. 42:19that's kind of how it looks yeah so be
  1129. 42:22consistent i really recommend that
  1130. 42:24employers do employee evaluations on at
  1131. 42:27least an annual basis and do them again
  1132. 42:30consistently do them for if you're gonna
  1133. 42:32do them for one person do them for
  1134. 42:34everyone
  1135. 42:36and um and really do them
  1136. 42:39and resist the temptation for things
  1137. 42:42like great inflation and be honest on
  1138. 42:44these things because they are your
  1139. 42:46documentation that's where you're going
  1140. 42:48to say
  1141. 42:49when you're at the point of
  1142. 42:52say terminating an employee's employment
  1143. 42:55look we've been telling you this for the
  1144. 42:56last two years it's in your review it's
  1145. 42:59in your other review or it's you know
  1146. 43:01it's in your review for the last two
  1147. 43:02years it's also we gave you a verbal
  1148. 43:05warning we gave you a written warning
  1149. 43:07now we're giving you we gave you a
  1150. 43:09suspension and now we're firing you this
  1151. 43:12is not a surprise
  1152. 43:13a lot of times i think this wards off
  1153. 43:16litigation altogether because if an
  1154. 43:19employee
  1155. 43:20knew this
  1156. 43:22they're less likely to go to an attorney
  1157. 43:24and say
  1158. 43:25i think that this was totally unfair the
  1159. 43:27attorney may also be less likely to take
  1160. 43:30it if take the case if they see okay
  1161. 43:33yeah there's two years worth of
  1162. 43:34documentation that's backing this up
  1163. 43:37so having that documentation is
  1164. 43:40important
  1165. 43:41um and doing it
  1166. 43:44you know it doesn't all have to be long
  1167. 43:46and involved but it you know it's
  1168. 43:48important to have that now
  1169. 43:50a little flip side you know document
  1170. 43:52document document be careful of email
  1171. 43:55because email um
  1172. 43:57can be discovered in litigation and so
  1173. 44:00when you're ranting and raving about
  1174. 44:02your employee on email to someone else
  1175. 44:05that email that you may have sent to the
  1176. 44:06heat of the moment may come up and be
  1177. 44:09you know an exhibit that gets blown up
  1178. 44:11on a big screen in a piece of litigation
  1179. 44:13and that's something that you really
  1180. 44:16don't want so document and be
  1181. 44:19conscious
  1182. 44:20of what you are putting into any
  1183. 44:23documentation that you write to from or
  1184. 44:25about your employees so that would
  1185. 44:27include email
  1186. 44:29texts texts could be voicemails
  1187. 44:32transcripts anything right yes
  1188. 44:35once it's created it's kind of out there
  1189. 44:37it's out there and all that is going to
  1190. 44:39be fair game in a lawsuit yep yep yeah
  1191. 44:43so i mean sometimes you do hear this
  1192. 44:46sort of well we don't want to put
  1193. 44:47anything in writing because we're afraid
  1194. 44:48of how it's going to show up well
  1195. 44:51do just do it well yeah right do you
  1196. 44:54know when you put things in writing put
  1197. 44:56them put in writing the things that are
  1198. 44:59truthful and accurate and that you can
  1199. 45:01back up and it also makes you think
  1200. 45:04about things you know as you're putting
  1201. 45:06something down okay i'm gonna i'm going
  1202. 45:08to discipline this person and as you're
  1203. 45:10thinking about what you would put in the
  1204. 45:12discipline it helps you to
  1205. 45:16consider you know what are the real
  1206. 45:18reasons that you want to discipline the
  1207. 45:19person and to make sure that you have
  1208. 45:22the backup information the specifics
  1209. 45:25so
  1210. 45:26we we really recommend doing good
  1211. 45:28documentation
  1212. 45:30i don't recommend overload documentation
  1213. 45:32or sort of micromanagement documentation
  1214. 45:35you don't need to write down everything
  1215. 45:37an employee does but doing things in
  1216. 45:39sort of a regular sequence having
  1217. 45:41reviews
  1218. 45:44if someone is for example
  1219. 45:47having poor performance and you put them
  1220. 45:49on what's called a performance
  1221. 45:51improvement plan so something that's
  1222. 45:53supposed to help them to get to a point
  1223. 45:55where they can improve their performance
  1224. 45:58then you want to perhaps document that
  1225. 46:01yes i met with this employee every two
  1226. 46:03weeks to try to help them to meet their
  1227. 46:06performance improvement plan so again
  1228. 46:08that's a place where you would have some
  1229. 46:10documentation
  1230. 46:12so having the documentation is really
  1231. 46:14valuable if there is litigation now
  1232. 46:17that's not to say that if there isn't
  1233. 46:20documentation there's no defense
  1234. 46:22but
  1235. 46:23having the document is really worth
  1236. 46:26five people going up on the stand and
  1237. 46:28saying yes it's really true
  1238. 46:30people seem to tend to believe what they
  1239. 46:33can see on paper what's put on paper as
  1240. 46:36in comparison to just what somebody says
  1241. 46:39um
  1242. 46:40doesn't that doesn't necessarily make
  1243. 46:42sense and it doesn't really make it any
  1244. 46:44more or less true
  1245. 46:46but having the documentation can really
  1246. 46:48be
  1247. 46:50very helpful
  1248. 46:52our number one top 10 tip for managers
  1249. 46:55is honesty is the best policy it is and
  1250. 46:59it sounds sort of silly but i'm going to
  1251. 47:01give you a little scenario here
  1252. 47:03um you have an employee um
  1253. 47:06mary mary's been working for you for 30
  1254. 47:10years and she kind of morphed into the
  1255. 47:13human resources person
  1256. 47:15as the company grew
  1257. 47:17but you've grown from a company of four
  1258. 47:20people to a company of 200 people
  1259. 47:23all of your payroll issues are more
  1260. 47:25complicated your hr issues are more
  1261. 47:27complicated now and mary really isn't
  1262. 47:30able to do the job anymore um and the
  1263. 47:33job that although she started out just
  1264. 47:36being an administrative assistant
  1265. 47:38her most recent title is director of
  1266. 47:40human resources
  1267. 47:42and she really doesn't have any
  1268. 47:44background in human resources but she's
  1269. 47:47grown into that role
  1270. 47:51just grown into it to a certain degree
  1271. 47:53and she's but she really isn't able to
  1272. 47:55handle what the company does now
  1273. 47:58so
  1274. 47:59you need to get in a person a more
  1275. 48:01professional human resources person who
  1276. 48:04has more background in it and a better
  1277. 48:07understanding and can handle your more
  1278. 48:09complicated business
  1279. 48:11well
  1280. 48:12so
  1281. 48:13obviously you don't want to say
  1282. 48:14to mary mary your performance isn't very
  1283. 48:17good and you don't know how to do this
  1284. 48:18job and
  1285. 48:20so we're going to let you go
  1286. 48:22what you want to say is
  1287. 48:24mary
  1288. 48:25we're going we're just going to
  1289. 48:27eliminate this position we're not going
  1290. 48:29to we're not going to have this position
  1291. 48:30anymore we're going to let her go
  1292. 48:33don't do it that's a as much as you
  1293. 48:35would want to save mary's feelings and
  1294. 48:38not let her feel like
  1295. 48:40um she's a failure or you feel like well
  1296. 48:43she's such a she's such a nice person
  1297. 48:45we've known her forever she's really you
  1298. 48:48know she's she's like part of the family
  1299. 48:51but we just can't have her doing this
  1300. 48:53job anymore and we really don't have
  1301. 48:54another job for her to do so but we want
  1302. 48:57to save her feelings
  1303. 48:59but what happens is mary loyal employee
  1304. 49:03that she is
  1305. 49:04um
  1306. 49:06gets told we're eliminating the position
  1307. 49:08she's a little puzzled she says okay
  1308. 49:10and she goes off and she finds another
  1309. 49:13job as an administrative assistant
  1310. 49:15someplace doing something else and then
  1311. 49:18she sees that you hired someone 20 years
  1312. 49:20younger than she is
  1313. 49:23and call are calling them the manager of
  1314. 49:25human resources
  1315. 49:27and she says well wait a minute you
  1316. 49:29didn't fire me because you you just
  1317. 49:32wanted to get this younger person in
  1318. 49:33there and you wanted um and i'm gonna
  1319. 49:36sue you for age discrimination and first
  1320. 49:38of all you're shocked that mary would
  1321. 49:40ever do this because you've known her
  1322. 49:42for so long and she was so loyal but
  1323. 49:44i'll tell you it happens
  1324. 49:46and
  1325. 49:48second you say okay well but we fired
  1326. 49:50her because she couldn't do this job her
  1327. 49:53performance wasn't wasn't good enough
  1328. 49:55and she doesn't have the background for
  1329. 49:58it and we have a great reason
  1330. 50:00but what you've told her is we're
  1331. 50:01eliminating the position
  1332. 50:03and in an age discrimination lawsuit and
  1333. 50:06a sex discrimination disability
  1334. 50:08discrimination or any uh of these other
  1335. 50:11types of discrimination lawsuits one of
  1336. 50:13the defenses that you would have
  1337. 50:15is
  1338. 50:16that you let someone go for a legitimate
  1339. 50:19discriminate or non-discriminatory
  1340. 50:20reason
  1341. 50:21and you have that
  1342. 50:23but mary can then come back and say
  1343. 50:26that's pretext that's not the real
  1344. 50:29reason you fired me and you know what's
  1345. 50:31evidence of pretext what's evidence of
  1346. 50:33predex is that you told me a totally
  1347. 50:35different reason for firing me you told
  1348. 50:37me that my job was eliminated you didn't
  1349. 50:40tell me that my job was
  1350. 50:43that i was let go because i wasn't
  1351. 50:45qualified for the job anymore and so all
  1352. 50:48of a sudden you go from having a really
  1353. 50:51good reason
  1354. 50:52for replacing her
  1355. 50:54to
  1356. 50:55having
  1357. 50:56no reason at all and having and not
  1358. 50:59having that particular defense and
  1359. 51:01having a reason that looks like and
  1360. 51:03yeah having a reason that looks like you
  1361. 51:05were lying
  1362. 51:06and
  1363. 51:07that that creates a problem for you in
  1364. 51:10in a litigation setting
  1365. 51:12um i mean the honesty is the best policy
  1366. 51:14works in a lot of other ways in the
  1367. 51:16employment employment situation as well
  1368. 51:19um as i mentioned before when you're
  1369. 51:22documenting resist the urge to great
  1370. 51:24inflation because again you may have
  1371. 51:27someone and they're tripping along and
  1372. 51:30you know yeah they probably they're
  1373. 51:32probably
  1374. 51:33not even satisfactory but you know if
  1375. 51:36you say not satisfactory that really
  1376. 51:38makes people upset so satisfactory but
  1377. 51:41everybody knows that satisfactory really
  1378. 51:42means not satisfactory so i'm going to
  1379. 51:45give this person an uh
  1380. 51:48an
  1381. 51:49ex
  1382. 51:50you know excellent on their review or
  1383. 51:52very good or whatever the next one up is
  1384. 51:55you know everyone knows that a three is
  1385. 51:57just barely getting by so i'm gonna give
  1386. 52:00them a four even though they really
  1387. 52:01should be a two well again when you get
  1388. 52:03to the point of saying
  1389. 52:05you you don't get this promotion because
  1390. 52:08your performance really isn't that good
  1391. 52:10and they say but my employment is my
  1392. 52:13my um
  1393. 52:14my performance is very good you've you
  1394. 52:17said it here it is on on the
  1395. 52:18documentation
  1396. 52:20um and that's which is why sometimes
  1397. 52:22people say i don't want to document at
  1398. 52:24all because i'm going to get caught by
  1399. 52:27my documentation but if you're going to
  1400. 52:28document do it honestly and
  1401. 52:32then that creates um i mean first of all
  1402. 52:35it should be helping you to help your
  1403. 52:37employees
  1404. 52:39become better and understand how they
  1405. 52:41can do better in their jobs
  1406. 52:44but also
  1407. 52:46there's no shock factor when suddenly
  1408. 52:48someone gets fired or demoted or not
  1409. 52:50promoted and they can't use your your
  1410. 52:54own words against you to say i i'm an
  1411. 52:57excellent employee you said so in my
  1412. 52:59review and you say well but that was
  1413. 53:01just great inflation well that doesn't
  1414. 53:03work very well um even though you know
  1415. 53:06you think everybody knows it happens it
  1416. 53:08doesn't work very well with the employee
  1417. 53:10who thinks
  1418. 53:11she really is excellent because you said
  1419. 53:13it right
  1420. 53:14but i like the focus that you also
  1421. 53:16brought on
  1422. 53:17honest communication does give the
  1423. 53:19employee what they need to possibly
  1424. 53:21improve their performance if they can
  1425. 53:23yes if you never say to someone this is
  1426. 53:25a problem right you're not giving them
  1427. 53:27the information they need to
  1428. 53:29try to work on a certain area yeah and i
  1429. 53:32think sometimes employers forget that
  1430. 53:35um
  1431. 53:36you know what they put into employees to
  1432. 53:39get them to
  1433. 53:40a certain place that rather than
  1434. 53:43firing someone you want to think about
  1435. 53:46well how do i make this person a better
  1436. 53:49employee because you as an employer put
  1437. 53:52a lot into
  1438. 53:53hiring the hiring process bringing
  1439. 53:56someone on
  1440. 53:57training them getting them up to speed
  1441. 53:59on your systems on your programs on how
  1442. 54:02your workplace works integrating them
  1443. 54:04into your workforce
  1444. 54:06and all of that has cost to the employer
  1445. 54:10and so really you are often better off
  1446. 54:13trying to
  1447. 54:15train and and improve an employee's
  1448. 54:19performance than
  1449. 54:21scrapping that employee and starting
  1450. 54:23over again where you're going to have to
  1451. 54:24start with those costs again and you
  1452. 54:26have an unknown you know someone who you
  1453. 54:28don't know if they're going to you may
  1454. 54:30be right in the same position in a year
  1455. 54:32with that employee as with the last one
  1456. 54:35so you know think about your you know
  1457. 54:37employees are are valuable to companies
  1458. 54:40and providing them the the information
  1459. 54:43and knowledge they need in order to be
  1460. 54:45the best that they can for your company
  1461. 54:48is helpful it's great advice
  1462. 54:52well um we got to the end of our top ten
  1463. 54:55i would just want to ask you holly um
  1464. 54:58you know bringing back to our focus on
  1465. 54:59risk management yeah if
  1466. 55:02you know i know sometimes you hear from
  1467. 55:03clients when something bad
  1468. 55:05has already happened or is about to
  1469. 55:07happen
  1470. 55:08is it worth if you're unsure about
  1471. 55:10whether it's a good time to pick up the
  1472. 55:12phone to talk to your attorney is it is
  1473. 55:14it
  1474. 55:15do you wish people will call you sooner
  1475. 55:17rather than later do you feel like
  1476. 55:19people wait too long absolutely i mean
  1477. 55:21most um most litigation
  1478. 55:24results from something that
  1479. 55:26could have been avoided
  1480. 55:28um and that doesn't mean that the
  1481. 55:30employee wouldn't have been fired ever
  1482. 55:32it just means that
  1483. 55:34they if
  1484. 55:36the process was
  1485. 55:39taken sometimes it's the process needed
  1486. 55:40to be taken more slowly there needed to
  1487. 55:42be a little more patience sometimes the
  1488. 55:44documentation needed to be better
  1489. 55:47sometimes the communications needed to
  1490. 55:49be done in a different way
  1491. 55:51but oftentimes if you get the advice on
  1492. 55:53the front end you can avoid a much
  1493. 55:55bigger cost on the back end and
  1494. 55:57litigation isn't something that just has
  1495. 55:59a cost in attorney's fees it also has a
  1496. 56:03cost in
  1497. 56:05employee time
  1498. 56:06in the attention that it takes for
  1499. 56:08management sometimes it has a cost in
  1500. 56:12publicity
  1501. 56:13so there are lots of other slightly less
  1502. 56:16tangible costs
  1503. 56:18that are
  1504. 56:20added to
  1505. 56:21just the the expense of litigation which
  1506. 56:25really is quite significant
  1507. 56:27right
  1508. 56:29well thanks holly i really appreciate
  1509. 56:30the time you taken to come in and share
  1510. 56:32your wisdom with us yeah thank you it
  1511. 56:34was fun to talk about thanks very much

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of ABUS 4013 Employment Law by OES Team, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,067 words across 1,511 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.