Abonnement Tesla à 99€/mois : faut-il boycotter l'autopilot payant ? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Heads up, this video covers a sensitive
- 0:02topic, but I'm going to dare to address
- 0:04it. I'm going to ask the uncomfortable
- 0:05question. Shouldn't we show some
- 0:08minimum resistance to the new business
- 0:10model Tesla is putting in place with
- 0:12its € 99 per month subscription, on
- 0:13top of the premium connectivity
- 0:15subscription? I've been following the
- 0:18situation closely. Especially when we
- 0:20see what the competition plans to do in
- 0:21this regard, just to show we aren't
- 0:23ready to accept anything and everything
- 0:24. Because you'll see, it's not just
- 0:27this point that bothers me, or even
- 0:29worries me about what comes next. I ask
- 0:32this because I love my Tesla, but
- 0:33honestly, what I'm hearing lately about
- 0:35the brand's strategic choices is
- 0:36starting to irritate me a bit. Let me
- 0:39give you an example. Tesla might soon
- 0:41remove basic Autopilot from its used
- 0:43models, just as it intends to do with
- 0:45new models, by the way. It remains to
- 0:48be confirmed, but if it's true, we are
- 0:50going from used vehicles with enhanced
- 0:52Autopilot included to the removal of
- 0:54this enhanced version, which is already
- 0:56the case on that front. And tomorrow,
- 0:59nothing at all. Seriously, everything
- 1:01is being done to make owners pay for
- 1:03the bare minimum. And on the used
- 1:06market, when a new vehicle is resold
- 1:08and ownership changes, nothing stops
- 1:10Tesla from stripping all software
- 1:12options, because yes, apparently, basic
- 1:14Autopilot is now considered an option
- 1:16and not a standard feature. And that
- 1:19leaves the door open to any scenario.
- 1:22When supervised Full Self-Driving
- 1:24arrives in a country, Tesla repositions
- 1:26its standard offer and simply removes
- 1:28basic Autopilot without lowering the
- 1:30sale price. Up until now, before this
- 1:33subscription was introduced, when you
- 1:36bought a Tesla, you got a standard
- 1:37assistance system: lane keeping,
- 1:39adaptive cruise control, trajectory
- 1:41correction—a real sense of assisted
- 1:43driving for a modern vehicle. So
- 1:47basically, when this subscription
- 1:48becomes available here, it's a safe bet
- 1:50that basic Autopilot will be removed
- 1:51for those looking to buy a Tesla. There
- 1:54will only be cruise control left. Lane
- 1:56keeping will no longer be standard. And
- 1:58yes. Now, another point: I read all
- 2:01your comments on my previous video
- 2:03about the supervised Full Self-Driving
- 2:05subscription, and there is one
- 2:06observation that keeps coming up, which
- 2:08can be summed up in one sentence: "The
- 2:10price is too high for a promise that
- 2:12isn't fully aligned with reality."»
- 2:15And that is precisely why Tesla was
- 2:17forced to rename its autonomous driving
- 2:19with the adjective "supervised" to be
- 2:21more in line with reality. and not to
- 2:24mislead the consumer. And at the time I
- 2:27am filming this video, supervised
- 2:29autonomous driving is still not
- 2:30available in France. I advise you not
- 2:32to get this subscription now; you will
- 2:34be disappointed. We tested it with Anas
- 2:37in this video at the top right to show
- 2:39you what we actually have at the moment
- 2:41. Is it worth it for you, or is it
- 2:43better to wait for supervised automatic
- 2:45driving to take advantage of it?
- 2:47Well, I’m going to be totally honest.
- 2:49Uh, it’s really not worth it for now.
- 2:51We will also discuss the standard
- 2:53autopilot of the competition, since
- 2:55Tesla is going to remove it, and
- 2:56especially the future of Tesla vehicles
- 2:58. At the speed the company is
- 3:00transforming or adapting, by choice,
- 3:02will they still be selling them to us
- 3:04in less than 10 years? The question is
- 3:06very serious, and I will present you
- 3:08with arguments we can debate. And this
- 3:10video comes at a good time. I’d like
- 3:11to take a quick detour to address a
- 3:13comment that basically said this
- 3:15channel seemed pro-Tesla to them and
- 3:17that they were pleasantly surprised by
- 3:19my video, which was critical. So yes, I
- 3:21am a fan of these vehicles, otherwise
- 3:22you can imagine I wouldn't have bought
- 3:23one. However, "pro-Tesla" if it implies
- 3:26only saying good things and hiding the
- 3:29rest, no. I belong neither to an
- 3:31association nor to Tesla. I have always
- 3:33sought to maintain the freedom to say
- 3:35what I wanted. Hence the fact that I no
- 3:38longer associate with an accessory
- 3:40manufacturer who even pressured me to
- 3:41remove a video, because when a product
- 3:43isn't good, I either say it or I don't
- 3:45make the video. And in full
- 3:47transparency, I have already submitted
- 3:49video edits to Tesla. It is mainly
- 3:52because there are employees whose
- 3:53privacy must be respected, to ensure
- 3:55they were blurred or not filmed. And
- 3:57that, I think, in the context of
- 3:59certain shoots on their premises in
- 4:01particular, well, it is understandable.
- 4:03And a quick anecdote: about 2 years ago
- 4:05, I made a video about a tire defect
- 4:07and it earned me quite a bit of
- 4:08criticism. You can actually find the
- 4:11video on the channel; I didn't delete
- 4:13it, but I think some pro-Tesla fans
- 4:15didn't appreciate the approach.
- 4:17What’s more, the defect didn't come
- 4:18from Tesla but from Michelin. But
- 4:19anyway, there you go, I’m closing
- 4:21this parenthesis. So, the question
- 4:23today is simple for a Tesla owner, but
- 4:25it is important and can even be crucial
- 4:27. Should we boycott the supervised full
- 4:31self-driving subscription to pressure
- 4:33Tesla and get a price reduction or get
- 4:35a standard autopilot that matches the
- 4:37competition? And yes, I am very serious
- 4:41when I say that. So naturally, the
- 4:43question becomes disturbing. Isn't
- 4:45Tesla testing just how much customers
- 4:47are willing to pay? Because I think
- 4:49that's what it looks like. You take
- 4:50impressive tech, you market it as
- 4:52something revolutionary—and it does
- 4:54have a revolutionary aspect, let's not
- 4:56hide that—but you still put a premium
- 4:58subscription on it, except that the
- 5:00customers today aren't the same as five
- 5:02years ago. Today, they compare, they
- 5:04test, they see what the competition is
- 5:06doing, and above all, at what price.
- 5:08With paid supervised autonomous driving
- 5:10, the driver must remain constantly
- 5:12attentive, hands near the wheel, eyes
- 5:15on the road, and retains full
- 5:16responsibility in the event of an
- 5:18accident or traffic violation. That, we
- 5:21must not forget, right? The FSD seems
- 5:23very reliable, but if it makes a
- 5:25mistake, you are the one at fault. For
- 5:27law enforcement, there will be no room
- 5:28for discussion. So you won't be able to
- 5:30hide behind this technology or turn
- 5:32against Tesla in the event of an
- 5:34accident. So, I would say that,
- 5:36effectively, we are very far from
- 5:38complete autonomy, from self-driving.
- 5:40It is indeed supervised. And that is a
- 5:42key point because when we talk about a
- 5:44relatively high monthly subscription of
- 5:47€ 99, we naturally expect something
- 5:49truly differentiating for that price.
- 5:51Still in the comments of the previous
- 5:53video on the subject, many of you are
- 5:55saying exactly the same thing. Why pay
- 5:57so much for something that isn't truly
- 5:59autonomous? And honestly, I totally
- 6:02share that reaction because in the
- 6:05collective imagination, "full
- 6:07self-driving," even supervised, evokes
- 6:09a real revolution. Except that in
- 6:12practice, we remain in an advanced
- 6:13assistance system. And besides, in our
- 6:16Teslas, we don't have anywhere near the
- 6:18same computing power as in robotaxis,
- 6:20which are truly autonomous. So for us,
- 6:22advanced, yes, but assistance
- 6:24nonetheless. The second point that
- 6:26comes up a lot is the comparison with
- 6:28the competition. And that stings a
- 6:30little. Today, brands like BYD, Xpeng,
- 6:32or Renault offer extremely
- 6:34high-performing, standard-equipped
- 6:36driver-assistance systems. Certainly,
- 6:38Tesla once had an obvious technological
- 6:41lead. Today, that lead still exists in
- 6:43certain aspects, particularly vehicle
- 6:45efficiency, but it's no longer so
- 6:47overwhelming, and above all, the value
- 6:49for money is starting to become
- 6:50questionable. It's true that for now,
- 6:52Tesla benefits from subsidies, vehicle
- 6:54trade-in incentives, and government
- 6:56bonuses. But when a manufacturer offers
- 6:58a comparable system, sometimes even
- 7:00smoother in certain situations as
- 7:02standard—meaning without a
- 7:04subscription or at a lower price—well
- 7:06, the question naturally arises. And
- 7:08that’s where we get to the heart of
- 7:09the debate. Tesla is in the process of
- 7:11changing its strategy. We can see it
- 7:13very clearly. Instead of including its
- 7:15features, the brand is pushing toward a
- 7:17subscription model. It is stopping
- 7:19production of its high-end S and X
- 7:20models. It is focusing on autonomous
- 7:23taxis, working on vehicles for public
- 7:25transport, and on robots that will
- 7:27replace part of the company's staff,
- 7:29among other things. In short, Tesla is
- 7:32heading toward AI-managed autonomy with
- 7:34the sale of services. And at the speed
- 7:37things move, it is not impossible that
- 7:38in less than 10 years, Tesla will stop
- 7:40selling vehicles to individuals. It
- 7:43sounds crazy, but it is probably no
- 7:44longer their priority at all, in my
- 7:46opinion, and even less so since their
- 7:48closer alignment with SpaceX. Today, we
- 7:51already see the early signs of what is
- 7:52unfolding. You can pay a subscription,
- 7:55like Netflix or Spotify, to have an
- 7:57improved version linked to safety.
- 8:00Tesla even unexpectedly released
- 8:02stripped-down, cheaper Model 3 and Y
- 8:04versions. Obviously with the goal of
- 8:06selling even more of them. And if you
- 8:09think about it, it is clearly to hope
- 8:11for even more FSD service subscriptions
- 8:13while phasing out the luxury S and X
- 8:15models. And so, as I was saying, with
- 8:18all the trade-in discounts and
- 8:19government bonuses, Tesla crushes the
- 8:22competition on price. Delivery times
- 8:24are exploding. And without all these
- 8:26discounts, would their success be as
- 8:28strong against the competition? Well,
- 8:30that's not certain. So, what is Tesla's
- 8:32plan for tomorrow, concretely? Vehicle
- 8:35ownership fading away in favor of
- 8:37autonomous taxis, 100%AI-driven
- 8:39autonomous service that will dominate
- 8:41transport. And if we zoom out a bit,
- 8:44this is now to finance the mass
- 8:46creation of Optimus robots and to
- 8:48continue the race toward Mars. The
- 8:50Optimus robots are no joke. The S and X
- 8:53assembly lines are now dedicated to
- 8:55them, and that is absolutely not
- 8:56science fiction. I'm not making any of
- 8:58this up. It looks like it, but this is
- 9:00indeed the roadmap for everything
- 9:01revolving around Elon Musk's companies.
- 9:04So, is this subscription model being
- 9:06accepted by users? For now, the answer
- 9:08seems to be not really. And that is
- 9:11where some of you are proposing a
- 9:12rather radical idea: a boycott. Don't
- 9:15subscribe, refuse to pay, and wait for
- 9:17Tesla to adjust its prices or change
- 9:19its strategy. So, is this a good idea,
- 9:22and is it all actually viable? Let’s
- 9:24be very clear. In principle, it could
- 9:26work. Throughout history, many
- 9:28companies have adjusted their prices or
- 9:30offerings following poor adoption. So
- 9:32obviously, I think if Tesla sees that
- 9:34very few owners are subscribing, Elon
- 9:36Musk will not have met the promises
- 9:37made to his shareholders. There would
- 9:39then remain three options. The first is
- 9:41to lower the price. The second is to
- 9:44add more features, and the third is to
- 9:46include certain functions as standard.
- 9:48So yes, collectively users have power,
- 9:51but there is a big "but." A boycott
- 9:53only works if it is massive and
- 9:55coordinated. And here, we are talking
- 9:58about thousands or even millions of
- 9:59users on a global scale. Is that
- 10:01realistic? Honestly, I don't really
- 10:03believe so, because there will always
- 10:05be early adopters, enthusiasts, and
- 10:07curious people who want to test it.
- 10:09Myself included, for that matter; I’m
- 10:10not hiding it. And Tesla knows that
- 10:12very well. Second important point:
- 10:13Tesla is not a conventional company.
- 10:16They don't think only in the short term
- 10:17, as you may have understood from my
- 10:19previous comments. They are investing
- 10:22heavily in artificial intelligence,
- 10:23camera vision, and neural networks. And
- 10:27for them, this subscription is not just
- 10:29a source of revenue; it goes much
- 10:30further. And yes, thanks to all the
- 10:33cameras on a Tesla, it's also a way to
- 10:36collect data through us, improve the
- 10:38system, and finance future development
- 10:40that will eventually do without our
- 10:42contribution in terms of investment
- 10:44when we buy a vehicle or when we hit
- 10:46the road. So at this stage, even if
- 10:49adoption is average, it doesn’t mean
- 10:51they will immediately change their
- 10:53strategy. But be careful, that doesn't
- 10:55mean your opinion doesn't count—on
- 10:57the contrary—because I still think
- 10:59that today, what we see in the comments
- 11:01remains a strong signal. To summarize,
- 11:04users are saying, "We are ready to pay,
- 11:06but not at this price.""We want a real
- 11:08difference." And Tesla won't be able to
- 11:11ignore that forever, especially with
- 11:13the competition. Now, I'm going to give
- 11:15you my personal opinion, and I'll be
- 11:17completely transparent. Today on my
- 11:192026 Model Y, even without that
- 11:21subscription, I find the system
- 11:23impressive nonetheless. With everything
- 11:26it currently includes, it really is a
- 11:28great car. In some situations, I even
- 11:30find it stunning. But regarding the
- 11:33subscription price, even for supervised
- 11:35autonomous driving, I don't feel it's
- 11:37justified for daily use. Why? Well,
- 11:40precisely because I have to stay
- 11:42focused. I can't relax, I can't do
- 11:45anything else. We aren't at autonomous
- 11:48driving yet, and paying € 99 to still
- 11:50have to stay focused on the road, I
- 11:52struggle with that. You can't let your
- 11:55guard down. So in the end, the gain in
- 11:57comfort is real, certainly, but limited
- 12:00. And that is the key point. If Tesla
- 12:02offered true autonomy tomorrow where I
- 12:05could really delegate driving in
- 12:06certain situations, then the price
- 12:08would be much more accessible. Now yes,
- 12:11there is a barrier in terms of
- 12:13legislation. We already struggle to
- 12:15have supervised autonomous driving in
- 12:17France. But regardless, we are talking
- 12:19about the price here, and today we're
- 12:21between two worlds. So, should we
- 12:23boycott? I'd say we should be smart
- 12:25about it instead. Not necessarily a
- 12:27total boycott, but a clear signal.
- 12:29Don't subscribe on principle, maybe
- 12:31test it for a month, but don't stay
- 12:32subscribed if the value isn't there.
- 12:35Basically, vote with your wallet and,
- 12:37above all, keep talking about it.
- 12:39Because I think this kind of debate is
- 12:41essential. We shouldn't let this Tesla
- 12:44model shape the automotive industry of
- 12:46tomorrow where everyone follows this "
- 12:48subscription or nothing" business
- 12:50strategy. There is another possible
- 12:53scenario, and that one is interesting.
- 12:56If the competition keeps offering
- 12:58equivalent, or even better, systems as
- 13:00standard, Tesla will be forced to react
- 13:02. Not necessarily by choice, but by
- 13:05necessity. And that could drive prices
- 13:07down or completely change the business
- 13:09model. So in the end, we are at a
- 13:12turning point. Tesla is making a bet, a
- 13:14risky bet, but nothing ventured,
- 13:16nothing gained. That of heavily
- 13:18monetizing a technology that is still
- 13:20imperfect. Let's not be afraid to say
- 13:22it. And all this in a market where the
- 13:24competition is becoming more and more
- 13:25aggressive. And we as users, as owners,
- 13:29have a role to play. Not necessarily by
- 13:32boycotting en masse, but by demanding,
- 13:34by refusing to pay for something that
- 13:36doesn't meet our expectations and by
- 13:38making it known. We have the right to
- 13:40be critical and to expect a service
- 13:42that is aligned with the price being
- 13:44charged. Now, and this video is of
- 13:46course made for that, I really want to
- 13:48hear your opinion. Do you think that a
- 13:50boycott is the right solution? Do you
- 13:52intend to subscribe and keep this
- 13:54subscription for the long term? And if
- 13:56so, do you really find that it’s
- 13:58worth the price? Or on the contrary,
- 14:00are you going to test it and stop.
- 14:02Personally, I have never done it so far
- 14:04, but I plan to start testing other
- 14:06electric vehicles to see what is
- 14:08included as standard, to see if the
- 14:10grass is greener on that front. So,
- 14:12tell me everything in the comments, I
- 14:13read absolutely everything. And as
- 14:15usual, if you liked the video, you know
- 14:17the drill, subscribe, leave a like,
- 14:20give it a boost and we'll see you very
- 14:22soon for another video. That’s it for
- 14:24this video. Don't hesitate to subscribe
- 14:26to the channel and click on the bell to
- 14:28turn on notifications so you don't miss
- 14:30upcoming videos. You also have the
- 14:33option to visit the site
- 14:35testlastuceus.com which offers you
- 14:37promo codes for all accessory shops,
- 14:39great deals, sentry magnets, news and
- 14:41articles on many topics regarding Tesla
- 14:44and its ecosystem. Alright, see you
- 14:46later on Tes Lastuce.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Abonnement Tesla à 99€/mois : faut-il boycotter l'autopilot payant ? by Tesla Astuces, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,701 words across 423 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.