A Top Mathematician's 9 Lessons for Anyone Who Feels Behind | Ken Ono, Axiom Math — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hi, my name's Ken Ono.
- 0:01I'm a mathematician.
- 0:02I work at Axiom Math and the University of Virginia.
- 0:06But in my life, I was not a good student in college.
- 0:10In fifth grade, we had a, a math contest, and I got third.
- 0:14Now, third is pretty good out of the fifth grade,
- 0:17but my father was a famous mathematician.
- 0:19They came to the competition,
- 0:21and son of famous mathematician
- 0:22gets third in Hampton Elementary School.
- 0:25I thought for 50 years of my life that I w- had utterly failed.
- 0:31But the reason I bring this up is that when my dad
- 0:34passed away in January, we were cleaning up his belongings,
- 0:39and of all the things that he could have kept,
- 0:41and it was just in a closet now,
- 0:43was that plaque from my fifth grade contest.
- 0:48And I, I thought, "Wow."
- 0:50I had misinterpreted that event my whole life.
- 0:56It actually meant something to him to keep a plaque
- 0:58where I didn't win, but I got third place.
- 1:01What he saw, I'm sure, was that I wanted to do well.
- 1:05We live at a time where the world places so much emphasis
- 1:10on benchmarks, how these AI firms and the state-of-the-art
- 1:15large language models are competing for these crazy scores.
- 1:18There's a lot of anxiety over benchmarks.
- 1:21But when it comes to assessing intelligence, do we honestly
- 1:24believe that someone who gets a higher IQ score is somehow smarter?
- 1:29No, of course not.
- 1:30It should put people at ease, right?
- 1:32If you have to live up to the standards set by someone else,
- 1:36then you're not living for yourself.
- 1:38You're not giving yourself credit.
- 1:40I consider that toxic because you know what the brutal truth is?
- 1:44The brutal truth is if you're not LeBron
- 1:47James or Rafael Nadal or a Nobel Prize-winning scientist,
- 1:53the reality is you will always be able to find someone
- 1:56that looks better, achieves something that you cannot do,
- 2:00and you're not then giving yourself
- 2:01permission to live the life that was meant for you.
- 2:04It's important to give yourself permission to live your life.
- 2:23Almost exactly one year ago,
- 2:26I was part of a group of mathematicians hired by a company called
- 2:31Epoch AI to write very difficult math problems that would serve
- 2:36as a benchmark for state-of-the-art large language models.
- 2:40And I thought it would be easy money.
- 2:43We were paid.
- 2:44But last year, I found it
- 2:47very difficult to write some of these problems.
- 2:50Strictly speaking, the models would make mistakes,
- 2:52but when you studied the reasoning traces,
- 2:55it was frightening how far these large language models have come.
- 2:59So I think the right way to describe it is, well,
- 3:01is an identity crisis.
- 3:03Maybe it was something like being the sharecropper,
- 3:06the farmer in the late 19th century who comes face to face
- 3:11with the first combustion engine tractor, recognizing that, well,
- 3:16maybe there's no future for my work as a sharecropper.
- 3:19What to do next?
- 3:20What's next for a mathematician?
- 3:22It was pretty devastating, honestly,
- 3:25seeing these models solve problems that were on my research program.
- 3:31Well, came to realize that technology
- 3:34has helped mankind over and over again.
- 3:37There was the invention of the wheel,
- 3:40and later there was the invention of the engine,
- 3:42and then calculators and computers,
- 3:44and somehow we adapted.
- 3:48What's surprising about this
- 3:49particular moment is that many of the techno-
- 3:52technological advances were about lightening physical work.
- 3:56An elevator meant that you didn't have to climb all these stairs.
- 3:59Tractors can do a lot of work that humans shouldn't do.
- 4:02The difference now is the work is mental.
- 4:05That is the stuff of identities.
- 4:08And where are we now?
- 4:09We are now at a point where
- 4:10many of those skills can be done automatically,
- 4:13and AI companies are talking about what's called self-play.
- 4:18They want their AI systems to play with themselves.
- 4:21And so where does that leave us?
- 4:24Well, mathematics, it's, it is devastating.
- 4:26It would be dishonest to say that a student who's graduating
- 4:30from college now with a bachelor's degree in mathematics
- 4:33or who is in graduate school now isn't deeply worried about
- 4:37all the years of effort they put into learning a trade,
- 4:40learning a body of knowledge that now anybody
- 4:43who can type if they have access to a large language model.
- 4:47So there's no dancing around that fact.
- 4:50This is very disruptive.
- 4:51When I was a graduate student and a young assistant professor,
- 4:56I would have said that I was most proud of my works that depended
- 5:02on the accumulation of knowledge involving years of effort.
- 5:06I could solve this paper
- 5:08because a few years ago I learned this technique,
- 5:09and last year I learned this technique, and here we are.
- 5:13I've, I've written this paper.
- 5:15My view has changed on that, and I
- 5:19hope that the viewers here think about this.
- 5:23There's actually something quite hollow about how I viewed
- 5:27myself as a mathematician that I only recognized recently.
- 5:31If my success as a mathematician relied only on my ability to learn
- 5:36techniques that somehow could be put together to prove a theorem,
- 5:41well, then maybe that was actually automatable,
- 5:44and maybe I mistook all of that hard
- 5:47effort for something maybe it wasn't, right?
- 5:51As hard as it was to master bodies of work,
- 5:55many papers, graduate texts, maybe at the end of the day
- 5:59there is some truth to that being an automated process.
- 6:03Now, make no mistake, that's not what
- 6:05we do for a living in mathematics and in most fields.
- 6:09In my work now, and this is how I think about what
- 6:12we do with AI at Axiom, is supported in a number of ways.
- 6:16The, the cop-out would be to say,
- 6:18"Can I ask an interesting question that I want an answer to?"
- 6:21But make no mistake, that's not what research is.
- 6:24Research begins with a question
- 6:25that you're probably not able to answer.
- 6:27You try to answer, and by failing,
- 6:30you learn a little bit more about that conjecture,
- 6:32and the work that you do sheds light on a path that might reveal
- 6:36a long list of questions that you one by one try to attack,
- 6:40and eventually you might prove a theorem.
- 6:42And if you prove that theorem, you backtrack and say, "Maybe
- 6:45I could have proven this previous question I couldn't answer."
- 6:49Right?
- 6:49This is how you learn.
- 6:50It's, it's really the proverbial two steps forward, one back.
- 6:54And when you recognize that research is not ask a question,
- 6:57you get an answer, you realize that the AI tools are lowering
- 7:02the burden for your ability to actually perform discovery.
- 7:06When you were doing all of these homework problems,
- 7:08when I was doing homework problems as a college student,
- 7:10as a graduate student, I was learning techniques,
- 7:13but was I really discovering?
- 7:15No.
- 7:16What I was doing, though, was important.
- 7:17I was learning how mathematics fits together to help
- 7:20me become a mathematician who can ask these questions
- 7:24and participate in the discovery.
- 7:26So that process, I think, is, is changing.
- 7:30For students and faculty who want to stick to the traditional ways,
- 7:35well, the reality is in some areas of mathematics,
- 7:39they will be left behind.
- 7:41We have computers that can compute 20 million
- 7:44cases overnight while you're sleeping, and you ...
- 7:47And it might take you years to do those 20 million cases,
- 7:49and you have to decide,
- 7:51would you like to have that power at your disposal,
- 7:54freeing you up to participate in the process of discovery?
- 7:57And that's what we have to value.
- 7:59So that's what I think science is going to become.
- 8:03So let me give a concrete example.
- 8:05Typical person that drove a car today doesn't have the foggiest
- 8:09idea of chemical reactions and engineering advances that had to come
- 8:14to fruition before they could actually get in the car and drive.
- 8:17The automobile is an incredible invention,
- 8:20and it requires mastering chemical processes
- 8:23and engineering challenges.
- 8:24All of that is, is available to us now for free.
- 8:28But maybe when Henry Ford made his first car,
- 8:30he had to solve all of it.
- 8:32How do I make the wheel?
- 8:33What do I make tires out of?
- 8:34Today, maybe you only need to know how to pump gas.
- 8:38Now, is that bad?
- 8:40No, because think about all the things that mankind can do now
- 8:44because they can travel great distances very quickly,
- 8:46what that opens us up to.
- 8:48And I think that's going to be our future.
- 8:53Is that rosy now?
- 8:54No.
- 8:54This year's horrible.
- 8:56If you ask me, I w- I would rather wake up and have it be 2017.
- 9:00Given that that is our future, I think we should do our very best
- 9:04to encourage people of all professions, teachers, parents,
- 9:09young students, to do their best to be prepared to be flexible,
- 9:13to seek out those opportunities as they pop up.
- 9:15But I don't think the loss
- 9:17of, of jobs is anywhere near as significant,
- 9:22and I hope that remains to be true.
- 9:25But this is really the time to think very carefully about education,
- 9:29thinking about opportunities,
- 9:31and being very human.
- 9:41So what makes a good question?
- 9:42There's several things I want to say.
- 9:45The first thing as a, as a teacher,
- 9:48my immediate response is there's no such thing as a bad question.
- 9:51Of course, that's not quite true.
- 9:53If you genuinely want to know the answer to a question,
- 9:58then that's a great question.
- 10:00You should never, ever doubt your interest in a subject.
- 10:04Okay, but I don't think that's necessarily
- 10:05what you're asking, right?
- 10:07I could ask, what is the meaning of life?
- 10:08That's a great question on the one hand,
- 10:11but on the other, it's kind of an impossible question.
- 10:15Another question is, like, I wonder what I have to do to be rich.
- 10:17I want to be rich.
- 10:18How do I do it?
- 10:19Well, that is a question, but is it a great question?
- 10:22No, I think it's a flawed question in many ways.
- 10:24First of all, the question is, well, how do I achieve that?
- 10:27So you need to break that down so that a question
- 10:30becomes maybe a plan, something that's actionable.
- 10:34But it's also somewhat hollow.
- 10:35So questions that don't speak to your humanity somehow,
- 10:39whether it's why do you want to be rich
- 10:42or what are you gonna do to make the world a better place,
- 10:44makes that line of reasoning richer.
- 10:48Now, as a scientist, you might be facing an open
- 10:51problem that you're interest in, in your field cares.
- 10:56Maybe people outside your field might not care so much.
- 10:59If I told you about the questions I think about on a daily basis,
- 11:02I'd be very surprised that you would care at all.
- 11:05But, you know, I wouldn't take that personally.
- 11:07I would start by saying, "Here's a math problem that I deeply
- 11:09care about," and I would expect that you would respect that.
- 11:13If you're in a situation where you have to think about whether
- 11:16the question you're asking has value, I think you should pause
- 11:20and think about who you're asking the question for.
- 11:22If you're not asking a question for yourself, well,
- 11:25my question to you would be, well, then who are you living for?
- 11:28Are you living the life meant for you, or are you living
- 11:30a life that you think someone should be meant for you?
- 11:33And then my question for you would be, why?
- 11:45I'm not honestly comfortable talking about superintelligence
- 11:48because it puts me at unease.
- 11:50Something that is super, it means that it's better than others.
- 11:55And I think what we're really talking about here is a future,
- 11:59and a present, honestly,
- 12:01where AI is a co-pilot,
- 12:04gives us tools that we cohabitate with at our service.
- 12:08So to say that a computer could be superintelligent
- 12:13is a bizarre thought to me because I would never
- 12:16call my automobile super fast compared to people, right?
- 12:20Obviously, it's super fast compared to people.
- 12:22I would, I would have never even thought about it for a moment.
- 12:25Reducing the load and physical work is super
- 12:28The only reason we're really worried about superintelligence
- 12:31is that so much of our identity is based on thinking skills.
- 12:36Many of the exams I took in college that I crammed
- 12:38for, did my best to get a good grade in, only to recognize
- 12:43that I'd forgotten the facts maybe by the middle of summer,
- 12:46yeah, I did learn something from that, the process.
- 12:49But is what I learned the information that I'd forgotten?
- 12:53No.
- 12:54So let's not talk about what is superintelligence
- 12:57because I don't know what intelligence is.
- 12:59But I do know quite well when I see achievement.
- 13:04We live at a time
- 13:06where the world places so much emphasis on benchmarks.
- 13:11In sports, I get it.
- 13:13Runner A runs faster than runner B, they're a better runner.
- 13:15Okay, that's academic.
- 13:17But when it comes to assessing intelligence, do we honestly
- 13:20believe that someone who gets a higher IQ score is somehow smarter?
- 13:24Do you actually believe a school
- 13:26that might be ranked fifth in the college rankings is really
- 13:29better than a school that's ranked seventh, only to turn
- 13:31around the next year to see that the rankings have changed?
- 13:34And now you think about how these AI firms and the state-of-the-art
- 13:39large language models are competing for these crazy scores,
- 13:42and we're all caught up in that.
- 13:44Is any of that intelligence?
- 13:47No, of course not.
- 13:48But if somebody writes a poem that just knocks you off your feet,
- 13:52if someone solves a math theorem, even if it's with the help of AI,
- 13:56that represents knowledge mankind had never seen before,
- 14:00that is intelligence.
- 14:02Is that superintelligence?
- 14:04Absolutely.
- 14:10The easiest way to make a mistake in the era of AI is to confuse
- 14:17what people are saying when they're talking about AI.
- 14:20It's important to first understand
- 14:21that AI comes in many different forms.
- 14:23The forms of AI that most
- 14:25people encounter these days would be the ChatGPT.
- 14:29But make no mistake, that's only one form of AI.
- 14:32AI's ability to use machine learning techniques to conduct
- 14:36a superhuman search that no person would ever want to do, right?
- 14:40This is how John Jumper and Demis Hassabis won
- 14:43the Nobel Prize in chemistry for solving protein folding.
- 14:47It's just smarter and it, and it is accelerated.
- 14:49And the third part of AI is, is where I think there is so much hope.
- 14:52The third part of AI is called formalization,
- 14:55and the idea in formalization is to take human natural language,
- 15:00transform it into computer code,
- 15:03which is an enhanced or at least
- 15:05an exact interpretation of the human language,
- 15:09and then have AI study this code and look for vulnerabilities.
- 15:13It's called verifiable computer code.
- 15:16We live at a time now
- 15:18where an enormous proportion of the computer code that's written
- 15:22and deployed in the world is not the stuff of human programmers.
- 15:26It's called vibe coding.
- 15:28But make no mistake, that code is not perfect.
- 15:30And so the space that we're in now in terms
- 15:33of formalization is to cut back on those inefficiencies.
- 15:36And when we start teaching mathematics or computer science
- 15:40or any field that has been formalized, we've come to learn
- 15:43that our original framing of these subjects was somehow incomplete.
- 15:47So I'll give you an example.
- 15:49Our company is partnering with Scott Commoners.
- 15:52He's a very distinguished economist at Harvard,
- 15:54a mathematical economist.
- 15:56And in our work, we are formalizing,
- 15:58as I described for you before, mathematical theories in economics.
- 16:03And we've discovered that some of the foundational
- 16:06theorems in the subject weren't really
- 16:09accurately portrayed or implemented or applied.
- 16:13Let me give you an example.
- 16:142026 is the 50th anniversary of a very famous
- 16:17theorem by the Nobel laureate Robert Aumann,
- 16:20and one of his most famous theorems is the theorem that's
- 16:23called We Agree to Disagree, or Can We Agree to Disagree?,
- 16:29where the phenomenon is if you have different parties observing
- 16:33and making decisions or indicating their preference,
- 16:38preferences based on the same common prior knowledge,
- 16:41is it possible for these parties to disagree?
- 16:45And this is the stuff of modern vernacular.
- 16:47You might get in an argument with a friend.
- 16:49You listen to each other, and you
- 16:50understand each other's perspective,
- 16:52and the end is quite satisfying to say,
- 16:53"Well, I guess we're just gonna have to agree to disagree."
- 16:57Aumann's theorem doesn't allow for that.
- 16:59It can't be that you can agree to disagree.
- 17:02What really happens is you
- 17:03can actually end up understanding each other's perspectives,
- 17:06and that's a very big theorem.
- 17:08However, there are subtleties.
- 17:09There are hypotheses.
- 17:10What does it mean to say you have the same priors?
- 17:14And that's where the formalization came in, and it's
- 17:17become kind of a, a viral moment in mathematical economics.
- 17:21Many economists from around the world are joining our effort,
- 17:25recognizing that for the sake of getting economics right,
- 17:29it should be formalized.
- 17:30And this is happening across fields.
- 17:32We are even working with computer scientists,
- 17:35rethinking and formalizing machine learning,
- 17:37which underlies all of AI to begin with, and so this is our future.
- 17:41So I said, "What are the opportunities for AI?"
- 17:44Maybe we're worried about the loss of work,
- 17:46but there are new opportunities.
- 17:48One is, how do we use AI to best guardrail the other forms of AI?
- 17:55Cybersecurity will need legions of computer scientists.
- 17:59Also ethicists, make no mistake,
- 18:01and lawyers who have to rethink or imagine this new world, right?
- 18:06There are gonna be legal issues that come up.
- 18:09And certainly for the AI experts
- 18:11who are into and devoted to formalization,
- 18:15that group will be setting up the guardrails that will keep us safe.
- 18:19A large language model is something like the most
- 18:22incredible librarian, a librarian who's read everything.
- 18:25But that doesn't mean you want your librarian
- 18:26to be your neurosurgeon.
- 18:28In very high-stakes situations, you need taste.
- 18:31You need human judgment.
- 18:33And of course, on top of that, you need someone with the emotional
- 18:36intelligence to understand how decisions impact people.
- 18:41Well, all of those things can be part of formalization,
- 18:44and I think that's an opportunity.
- 18:46And whether you want to help robotic surgeons be accurate or whether
- 18:53you're worried about securing the internet or financial networks,
- 18:56any system that can be rewritten or is somehow controlled
- 19:01by a mathematical language after translation should be formalized.
- 19:07So yeah, I think that's a very big future.
- 19:10And for students entering college and graduate school,
- 19:14if you want to be a mathematician, start formalizing.
- 19:17You may still prove unsolved conjectures along the way,
- 19:21but make no mistake, this is 2026, 2027 I
- 19:25don't believe now is the race for more compute.
- 19:29It really should be the race for more truth,
- 19:31and I think that, and I hope I'm right,
- 19:33will be by means of formalization.
- 19:41When a scientist says that a fact is formally verified,
- 19:45this statement is true, end of story.
- 19:47If there is a mistake, it's
- 19:48because you didn't frame the problem correctly.
- 19:52That's not judgment.
- 19:53That's a yes/no binary question.
- 19:55Judgment is how do people,
- 19:58when given this information, choose to act?
- 20:02We have autonomous drones
- 20:05flying all over the world doing all sorts of things,
- 20:07whether it's keeping track of traffic in Los Angeles or Seoul,
- 20:12or whether it's looking for dangerous people in fields of battle.
- 20:17All of those situations require judgment.
- 20:20In some of those low-stakes situations, well, yeah,
- 20:23maybe the drone that's measuring air quality above Los Angeles,
- 20:28maybe the human judgment there isn't so important.
- 20:31But if we're talking about whether or not to target a city,
- 20:34how do you know that a building that you're targeting actually
- 20:38has a dangerous person in it versus being a school or a hospital?
- 20:43And I don't actually think it's very difficult to distinguish
- 20:46situations that really are so high stakes that most rational
- 20:50people would not be comfortable with letting an AI decide.
- 20:54I think in most cases that we care about the most
- 20:57that are high stakes when you want a person involved.
- 21:00Maybe it's not that easy.
- 21:01We have rideshare services
- 21:04that are driverless, but people like them.
- 21:06These opinions and these viewpoints can change over time,
- 21:09but apart from those strange situations,
- 21:12I think it's very clear when you want a human in the room.
- 21:24We live at a time where the world makes judgments,
- 21:29snap decisions, snap evaluations on very little data.
- 21:34It's crazy.
- 21:35You apply for a job.
- 21:37You're probably gonna submit your cover letter and your CV or resume
- 21:42to an automated system that has an algorithm that has a bunch
- 21:45of check boxes that you have to predict so that you know
- 21:48that you're not sieved out in the first round for no good reason.
- 21:52None of us should be happy with that.
- 21:54Everywhere you look,
- 21:56we have adopted a system where we are replaced by numbers.
- 22:02We are replaced by what an algorithm seeks.
- 22:04And this is coming from someone who works in AI.
- 22:07How can any of us be happy with that?
- 22:09My children, they're 27 and 30.
- 22:11They're beyond the most critical
- 22:13phases of getting their career started, but they knew.
- 22:16And I'll be lying to you if I didn't say
- 22:18when they were applying to colleges,
- 22:20as a university professor myself, I knew a university college
- 22:24admissions committee is going to be looking for these 10 things.
- 22:27Make sure you check those boxes,
- 22:29but then still be absolutely
- 22:31genuine about what you're passionate about.
- 22:33Yeah, I would be lying if I didn't say we didn't do that.
- 22:36But let's pause and think about what all of that means
- 22:39because if we buy into that 100%, then you're
- 22:45forgetting that the quality of someone's character matters.
- 22:49You're forgetting that the quality of human judgment
- 22:52and achievement matters.
- 22:53You're saying that what matters is can you check every box
- 22:57and imagine what those boxes are.
- 22:59And I'm sorry, if you want to find the cure for cancer,
- 23:01it's not going to be a bunch of check boxes.
- 23:03If it was, we would have already found the cure for cancer.
- 23:06So the question then becomes if we live in a society and a community
- 23:11where we are so rigid because the computer age allows us to...
- 23:15When I was starting out, you would look for a job,
- 23:18you might actually go to a company and drop off your CV
- 23:21and resume and shake the hand of a business owner
- 23:23and try to make that human contact.
- 23:25Who does that now?
- 23:26You probably upload your, your resume and cover letter to a website,
- 23:31and you might even apply to, like, 500 jobs.
- 23:33I mean, what, what's human in any of that?
- 23:35My dream for the future has many pieces to it.
- 23:38One, what I would give to fight against that so that we
- 23:42could start a movement where we could slow down and really
- 23:45evaluate people for who they are, where they've come from, what
- 23:49their personal experiences are, the quality of their character,
- 23:53and how they interact with others.
- 23:54That would be awesome.
- 23:56Now, how have I been lucky enough
- 23:59to identify some of my best students, the ones that maybe
- 24:02other schools wouldn't have never taken a chance on?
- 24:05They were the outliers.
- 24:06I had a graduate student.
- 24:08His name was Robert Schneider.
- 24:09He was actually, and still is, a famous independent rock artist.
- 24:13He was the producer for a band called Neutral Milk Hotel
- 24:17and lead singer for a band called Apples in Stereo,
- 24:20and he had the most fascinating story.
- 24:23He loved equipment.
- 24:25He loved to perform with these old microphones,
- 24:28solid-state old microphones and speakers when they went on tour.
- 24:33But because they were old, they were constantly breaking,
- 24:37and they needed to be repaired,
- 24:39and it became so expensive repairing them that he
- 24:42decided that he was going to start learning electronics.
- 24:44So he bought a book.
- 24:46And the first formula he saw in this book was Ohm's Law.
- 24:50And he said to me the first time I met him,
- 24:53and it was the craziest thing.
- 24:55He had decided to go back to school.
- 24:58He was a college dropout.
- 24:59He stopped touring.
- 25:00He went to college, got his math degree,
- 25:03and found his way into my office,
- 25:05and it begins with what I just described to you.
- 25:08And when he said, "When I saw Ohm's Law,
- 25:10it made me stop and think about what is it that I am producing
- 25:15when I'm writing and singing music?
- 25:18Electrical circuits populate my brain.
- 25:20That's the creative part.
- 25:22I somehow write down the music on paper,
- 25:24and then I perform it on my guitar
- 25:25to be picked up by the microphone to go back into my brain,
- 25:29and all of this was modulated by an equation called Ohm's Law,
- 25:32and I wanted to figure out how does the biology work?
- 25:35How does that equation work?
- 25:37How does the world work?"
- 25:38Three hours later, I said,
- 25:40"You know, you have to be my student because you made me
- 25:43rethink everything I thought about mathematical equations,
- 25:47thinking that I knew how you could find inspiration in math."
- 25:52I never thought I would have found that story.
- 25:54So from Robert to some, some of the other students that I
- 25:58could tell you about, I'm proud of all of my students.
- 26:00I've had 35 PhD students, but if,
- 26:03if we were to go through them one by one, I could tell you a story.
- 26:07His is just particularly colorful.
- 26:09And what I like about the process is when they finish their graduate
- 26:13degrees or when they finish their undergraduate thesis,
- 26:16there's a huge moment, undeniable.
- 26:20You know it when it happens.
- 26:21And this is particular for graduate students.
- 26:23When you can look at the student and say, "You know,
- 26:26you're like a professor now," and they look back at you,
- 26:30and they know exactly what you mean,
- 26:32and it's not because they check some box,
- 26:35they fulfilled their thesis.
- 26:37That has somehow become irrelevant.
- 26:38It's the other part.
- 26:40So to answer your question, how do I recognize that?
- 26:42It circles back to what I was saying earlier.
- 26:45We have no shortage of students who mistakenly think,
- 26:50and it's not their fault, who mistakenly think that the path
- 26:53to success is you go to the right schools, you get the right grades,
- 26:57you'll fi- you know, you get the right degree,
- 26:59and all good things will happen to you.
- 27:01That's a mindless way of going about one's life.
- 27:07It's not actually giving yourself
- 27:08permission to live the life that was meant for you.
- 27:11It's just saying I'm following
- 27:13a recipe that we think will be very successful,
- 27:15and the odds of success are very high.
- 27:17That's on us.
- 27:19That's on the universities.
- 27:20That's on us, the parents.
- 27:21That's because we have decided that there
- 27:25are benchmarks that will evaluate whether you're successful.
- 27:28Go to the number five school instead of the number 10.
- 27:31Get the best test scores.
- 27:32Do all of that.
- 27:33We haven't given enough credit where credit should be due,
- 27:38and we place so much emphasis
- 27:39on all of this other stuff that we're now paying for it,
- 27:43and we have to fix that right away.
- 27:44I don't know if this is controversial, but I think that's all true.
- 27:53I know what you're talking about.
- 27:55I work at an AI company,
- 27:56and for the last year, I work with AI models.
- 28:00I study them.
- 28:01My wife will say, "Ken,
- 28:03you must have a relationship with these models."
- 28:05And I don't think she is wrong.
- 28:07It's sometimes quite satisfying
- 28:10when the models start thinking like you do because they learn.
- 28:14But I also believe that if it's not cared for and those in charge
- 28:18aren't mindful of its use, it could be a train wreck.
- 28:21Do you want to take a trip with your AI?
- 28:23"Hey, ChatGPT, here we are.
- 28:26I'm in Rome.
- 28:27What kind of wine would you like with dinner?"
- 28:29Now, that's not living.
- 28:31I was in the taxi cab from Incheon
- 28:33Airport to the, my hotel in Gangnam yesterday,
- 28:36and the traffic was horrible.
- 28:38Monday, 4:00, you can sit for 10 minutes at a, at a block.
- 28:42So I did a little experiment.
- 28:43I started counting the people
- 28:44walk by with their phones in their hands like this,
- 28:48and it was something like 70% of the folks here in Gangnam
- 28:52walking on the street, probably going home from work,
- 28:54were looking at their phones like this.
- 28:56That's messed up.
- 28:57Think about all the opportunities that you are missing
- 29:01because you think your world evolves from that little screen.
- 29:04You might be missing the opportunity to make a new best friend.
- 29:09If you find yourself engaging
- 29:12with a chatbot as if it was really a person, stop.
- 29:17Put it down.
- 29:17Go for a long walk.
- 29:19Put yourself in a position
- 29:20where you see something beautiful or provocative.
- 29:24Do something that reminds you that the world
- 29:27before AI has a much longer history than the world with AI.
- 29:40As a 58-year-old mathematician,
- 29:42I want to see some questions answered in my lifetime.
- 29:46We're already beginning to see that happen.
- 29:49There are famous examples.
- 29:51OpenAI a few weeks ago announced a proof
- 29:54of a theorem called the Erdos unit distance conjecture,
- 29:58which is a problem that I thought
- 29:59was never gonna be solved in my lifetime.
- 30:02And post hoc, meaning when you go back
- 30:03and look at how this was achieved,
- 30:05the truth is it was achieved by a little bit of human collaboration,
- 30:08the mathematicians at OpenAI with their system.
- 30:11But I don't think it could have been solved
- 30:14by people alone unless you had a remarkable collection
- 30:19of experts from different fields who somehow came together.
- 30:23I don't think this would have been the stuff of one person.
- 30:26And that, I think, represents some of the strength
- 30:28and possibility in AI where think about all the things
- 30:34in science that you would like to have solved,
- 30:37and maybe the accumulated wisdom of mankind can solve it.
- 30:40But when would you ever be in a position
- 30:42to put the right people together in a room to discuss it?
- 30:45So what AI offers in promise is the access
- 30:48to the accumulation of human knowledge tirelessly,
- 30:52and it lowers the bar for solving these problems.
- 30:55Is it the case that some of the ideas
- 30:58and solutions are beyond what humans have ever come up with?
- 31:02And this is probably the most provocative point.
- 31:05There are many who will argue that, yeah,
- 31:08AI is gonna come up with ideas,
- 31:10genuinely new ideas that people have never thought of before.
- 31:14I don't know that I believe that.
- 31:16I do believe that AI computer systems can compute
- 31:20more than people have ever done before, can find patterns
- 31:24in different areas of science that humans are unable to do,
- 31:28but the ideas are somehow already there.
- 31:30Do people come up with new ideas?
- 31:33All the time.
- 31:34The artwork that you find in Picasso,
- 31:36good luck finding evidence of that before Picasso.
- 31:39Do I think AI has that ability to come up with those new ideas?
- 31:44I don't know.
- 31:46Do I hope it does?
- 31:47God, I hope never.
- 31:55What worries me about what you just said is this
- 32:00need to compare your personal situation now with others.
- 32:06That sounds horrible.
- 32:07If you have to live up to the standards set by someone else,
- 32:11then you're not living for yourself.
- 32:13You're not giving yourself credit.
- 32:15Whatever pressures someone may feel that inspires them to constantly
- 32:21be comparing themselves to others, I consider that toxic,
- 32:25because you know what the brutal truth is?
- 32:28The brutal truth is if you're
- 32:30not LeBron James or a Nobel Prize-winning scientist,
- 32:34the reality is you will always be able to find someone
- 32:38that looks better, achieves something that you cannot do,
- 32:41and you're not then giving yourself
- 32:42permission to live the life that was meant for you.
- 32:46In my life, I was not a good student in college.
- 32:48In fifth grade, we had a, a math contest, and I got third.
- 32:53Now, third is pretty good out of a fifth grade,
- 32:55but you probably would have thought,
- 32:57"Ken Ono is a famous mathematician.
- 32:59He probably won easily."
- 33:00No, I got third.
- 33:01In fact, when I was in fifth grade and I got third,
- 33:05I thought I let my parents down.
- 33:07My father was a famous mathematician.
- 33:08They came to the competition,
- 33:10and son of famous mathematician
- 33:12gets third in Hampton Elementary School.
- 33:14And this is one of those defining moments.
- 33:16On the drive home, it was just silence.
- 33:20Mom didn't talk about it.
- 33:21My dad didn't talk about it.
- 33:24I thought for 50 years of my life that I w- had utterly failed.
- 33:30Now, it's not true that this experience weighed on me so much that I
- 33:35thought about it for, for decades and decades and dec- decades.
- 33:39But it was instances like that where, like you,
- 33:42I was worried about how I would stack up with others.
- 33:45But the reason I bring this up is that when my dad
- 33:48passed away in January, we were cleaning up his belongings.
- 33:52There was very little left
- 33:53because they'd already downsized to a very small apartment
- 33:57in Florida where my parents w- we had just moved them.
- 34:01And of all the things that he could have kept,
- 34:04and it was just in a closet now,
- 34:06was that plaque from my fifth grade contest.
- 34:10And I, I thought, "Wow."
- 34:12I had misinterpreted that event my whole life.
- 34:18It actually meant something to him to keep a plaque
- 34:20where I didn't win but I got third place.
- 34:23And although he had passed away and I could never ask him about it,
- 34:26it's obvious he saw something else.
- 34:28What he saw, I'm sure, was that I wanted to do well.
- 34:32So I hope that's a lesson for anyone who thinks this way,
- 34:35because I thought that way.
- 34:37And if you put yourself in a position
- 34:40where you're always comparing with others,
- 34:43you might not actually be right,
- 34:45and you might actually be completely wrong.
- 34:48So you have to give your s- self
- 34:49permission to the life that was meant for you.
- 34:53And this might be morbid, but one day you will be on your deathbed.
- 34:57You may only have a few days left,
- 34:59and someone might ask you some questions.
- 35:02"What are your five deepest regrets?"
- 35:04And p- this comes up all the time.
- 35:05I'm not making this up.
- 35:06People, certainly when you get to my age,
- 35:08you start being around these kinds of conversations.
- 35:12And I think the number one regret is, "I wish
- 35:15I had the chance to live the life that was meant for me.
- 35:18I wish I was able to keep
- 35:21in close contact with the friends that I lost touch with."
- 35:25So try to imagine what those four or five wishes are.
- 35:30And at your age, do your very best
- 35:32to recognize that you don't want those to be your regrets.
- 35:36You need some inspiration often.
- 35:39You need a creative idea often.
- 35:41And so encouraging students,
- 35:44encouraging all people to wonder about the world that they
- 35:47live in is, one, giving permission to think that way.
- 35:51And wouldn't the world be a much
- 35:52better place if everyone thought about what their talents
- 35:55are, gave themselves permission to be creative?
- 35:59Wouldn't the world look a lot more interesting instead of, "Yeah,
- 36:03I'm supposed to do this," or, "I'm
- 36:05supposed to do that, so I, I do it"?
- 36:08So I hope that is food for thought.
- 36:10I think I've said several times today that it's
- 36:12important to give yourself permission to live your life.
- 36:16Now, that doesn't mean ignore
- 36:18all the signals of what might help you be successful.
- 36:22That's not wh- we don't wanna be ignorant.
- 36:24But giving yourself permission
- 36:25to lead the life that was meant for yourself
- 36:28also is giving yourself permission to find your passion.
- 36:31And that passion might be something that isn't popular.
- 36:34But if you find it, you can draw strength from it.
- 36:38I'm a Japanese kid that grew up in a very white suburb of Baltimore,
- 36:42Maryland, at a time when it wasn't good to be Japanese.
- 36:46I wore glasses.
- 36:47I was Mr.
- 36:48Four Eyes.
- 36:49But that gave me strength.
- 36:50As difficult as that was, being
- 36:52one of the only Oriental kids in an all-white school,
- 36:54being different, I ultimately drew strength from that.
- 36:58Wasn't easy, and it probably took 10 years to overcome that.
- 37:02But whatever demons AI or culture or family and friends impose,
- 37:08they don't all have to be there.
- 37:10And quite frankly, the moral of this conversation is there's
- 37:13very little you can do about the world th- th- that's around you.
- 37:16So how can you choose a life that's meant for you, be flexible,
- 37:20and embrace and chase opportunities
- 37:23that were, that seem to be destined for you?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of A Top Mathematician's 9 Lessons for Anyone Who Feels Behind | Ken Ono, Axiom Math by EO, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,195 words across 741 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.