A Republic, Not A Democracy by Dan Smoot 1966 Apr 18 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00a constitutional republic not a
- 0:04democracy the ideal of a democracy is
- 0:07Universal equality the ideal of a
- 0:09constitutional republic is individual
- 0:11liberty a democracy always degenerates
- 0:14in the dictatorship which promises
- 0:16government guaranteed equality and
- 0:18security but it delivers nothing but
- 0:20poverty and serfdom for the people it
- 0:22robs and rules America was founded as a
- 0:25constitutional republic to safeguard the
- 0:28liberties of the people against the
- 0:29tyranny of democracy are a one-man
- 0:31dictatorship in this century great
- 0:34strides have been made toward the goal
- 0:36of subverting our republic into a
- 0:38democracy the form of tactic of the
- 0:40subversion subversion of language by
- 0:43calling America a democracy until people
- 0:45thoughtlessly accept and use the term
- 0:47the totalitarian have obscured the real
- 0:50meaning of our principles of government
- 0:52that is a summary of my report on a
- 0:55constitutional republic not a democracy
- 0:57the film report after a message from my
- 1:00sponsor
- 1:07a democracy is a political system in
- 1:10which the people periodically by
- 1:11majority vote at the polls select their
- 1:13rulers the rulers then have absolute
- 1:15power to make whatever laws they please
- 1:18by majority vote among themselves in a
- 1:20constitutional republic the people also
- 1:22by majority vote as opposed select
- 1:24rulers who make laws by majority vote
- 1:26among themselves but the rulers cannot
- 1:29make any laws they please because the
- 1:31Constitution's severely restricts their
- 1:32lawmaking power the ideal of a democracy
- 1:36is Universal equality the ideal of a
- 1:39constitutional republic is individual
- 1:41liberty in this century great strides
- 1:43have been made or the goal of subverting
- 1:46our republic and transforming it into a
- 1:47democracy the foremost tactic of the
- 1:50subvert or subversion of language by
- 1:53calling America a democracy until people
- 1:56thoughtlessly accept and use the term
- 1:59totalitarians
- 2:00have obscured the real meaning of
- 2:02American principles of government note
- 2:04the following passages from a recent
- 2:07article distributed by the New York
- 2:08Times News Service quote in the United
- 2:11States and in other leading democracies
- 2:13recent years have seen perceptible
- 2:16growth in executive authority as society
- 2:19becomes more equalitarian it tends
- 2:21increasingly to concentrate absolute
- 2:24power in the hands of one single man
- 2:26this is a voluntary surrender of a free
- 2:29people escaping from freedom to one
- 2:32autocratic master in quote and note the
- 2:35following from gunnar myrdal's an
- 2:37American dilemma quote in America
- 2:39Liberty often provided an opportunity
- 2:42for the stronger to rob the weaker
- 2:44against this the equalitarian ISM in the
- 2:47American creed has been persistently
- 2:50revolting and in the conflict between
- 2:52equality and liberty equality is slowly
- 2:56winning in America conservatism has to a
- 2:59great extent been perverted into a cult
- 3:02of the Constitution this is unfortunate
- 3:05since the Constitution is in many
- 3:06respects impractical and ill suited for
- 3:09modern conditions the worship of the
- 3:12Constitution is also a most flagrant
- 3:15violation of the American creed the
- 3:18Constitutional Convention was nearly
- 3:19a-plus
- 3:20against the common people end quote now
- 3:23goon are mere dolly Swedish socialism
- 3:26was hired by the Carnegie Corporation of
- 3:28New York in 1937 to direct a study of
- 3:30the Negro in the United States engaged
- 3:33the large staff some of them Communists
- 3:35and pro-communist an American dilemma
- 3:37resulted first copyrighted in the United
- 3:39States in 1944 in 1954 the Supreme Court
- 3:44handed down his school segregation
- 3:46decision which deliberately violated the
- 3:49Constitution reversed a previous Supreme
- 3:51Court decision and lit a fuse touching
- 3:54off explosive violence which has been
- 3:56shattering our society ever since the
- 3:59court cited an American dilemma as one
- 4:02of the modern authorities on which it
- 4:03relied in preference to the Constitution
- 4:06for justification of its decision an
- 4:09American dilemma written by Swedish
- 4:11socialists provided a basic rationale
- 4:14for the conversion of our Free Republic
- 4:16into an equalitarian democracy mere doll
- 4:20contains that the American Declaration
- 4:21of Independence 1776 proclaimed the
- 4:25ideal of an equalitarian democracy
- 4:27because it contains the phrase all men
- 4:29are created equal
- 4:3011 years later the Constitution created
- 4:33not a democracy founded on the idea of
- 4:35equality but a Republic founded on the
- 4:38ideal of Liberty this is by a mere doll
- 4:40says the Constitutional Convention was
- 4:42nearly a plot against the common people
- 4:45but he and those who parrot his ideas
- 4:48are either ignorant or dishonest the
- 4:50Constitution was ordained specifically
- 4:53to safeguard the principles of Liberty
- 4:55proclaimed by the Declaration of
- 4:57Independence the Declaration sprayed all
- 5:00men are created equal means that men are
- 5:03equal before the law and before the
- 5:06Creator regardless of their inequality
- 5:08in human society the Declaration says
- 5:11that men are endowed with unalienable
- 5:13rights and that the purpose of
- 5:15government is to secure these rights the
- 5:18unalienable rights of man enumerated in
- 5:20the Declaration of Independence do not
- 5:22include equality but they do include
- 5:24Liberty along with life and pursuit of
- 5:27happiness equality of all men in the
- 5:30eyes of God and before the law is a
- 5:32condition essential to freedom
- 5:34but no other kind of equality is
- 5:36possible government efforts to achieve
- 5:39material equality will produce crushing
- 5:42tyranny but will not make people equal
- 5:45the writers of the Constitution were
- 5:47anxious to safeguard Liberty against
- 5:50dictatorship monarchy they called it but
- 5:52their chief anxiety was to protect the
- 5:55country against democracy Edmund
- 5:57Randolph delegate to the Constitutional
- 5:59Convention from Virginia said the
- 6:01general object of the Convention was to
- 6:03provide a cure for the follies and fury
- 6:06of democracy Elbridge Gerry and Roger
- 6:09Sherman delegates from Massachusetts and
- 6:10Connecticut urged the Constitutional
- 6:13Convention to create a system to
- 6:14eliminate the evils that flow from the
- 6:16excess of democracy Alexander Hamilton
- 6:19delegate from New York said we are now
- 6:21farming a republican government real
- 6:23Liberty is not found in democracy we
- 6:25incline too much to democracy we shall
- 6:28soon shoot into a monarchy John Adams
- 6:31one of the Giants of the American
- 6:33Revolutionary period said democracy will
- 6:36end we all contend with all endeavor to
- 6:39pull down all and when by chance it
- 6:42happens to get the upper hand for a
- 6:44short time democracy will be revengeful
- 6:46bloody and cruel speaking of pure
- 6:50democracy in which the people by
- 6:52majority vote act as their own laws
- 6:54instead of electing representatives to
- 6:56make laws James Madison said such
- 7:00democracies have ever been incompatible
- 7:03with personal security of the rights of
- 7:05property a republic promises the cure
- 7:08for which we are seeking Madison known
- 7:11as the father of the Constitution knew
- 7:13and said that enlightened men will not
- 7:15always be at the helm of government to
- 7:17serve as proper guardians of the public
- 7:19weal he knew that unlimited political
- 7:22power cannot safely be entrusted to the
- 7:25nation's elected representatives to use
- 7:27as a majority of them see fit because he
- 7:29said a majority of a group of men is far
- 7:33more likely to be tyrannical than one
- 7:35man is in a democracy if a majority
- 7:39should develop hatred for all blue-eyed
- 7:42babies and order them eliminated the
- 7:44babies could be legally
- 7:46executed because whatever a majority
- 7:48wants at any given moment his supreme
- 7:51law of the land in a democracy how can
- 7:55liberty be safeguarded against the
- 7:56mindless soulless tyranny of majority
- 7:58rule when government is founded on the
- 8:01principle of majority rule
- 8:03Jefferson answered that one in questions
- 8:06of power let no more be heard of
- 8:08confidence in man but bind him down from
- 8:11mischief the chains of the Constitution
- 8:12in short America was founded not as a
- 8:16democracy but as a constitutional
- 8:18republic we pledge allegiance to the
- 8:21Republic for which our flag stands not
- 8:23to a democracy the Constitution requires
- 8:25a Republican form of government for all
- 8:27states but does not mention democracy
- 8:29and neither does the Declaration of
- 8:31Independence or the Bill of Rights the
- 8:32Constitution is a binding contract
- 8:35enumerated limited powers which the
- 8:38federal government can legally exercise
- 8:40prohibiting it from exercising any power
- 8:43not read it in the contract it denies
- 8:46federal officials the power to do
- 8:47whatever they claim to be necessary for
- 8:49the general welfare federal action not
- 8:52clearly authorized by the Constitution
- 8:54is illegal even if approved by an
- 8:57overwhelming majority of the people
- 8:59because all the elastic powers of
- 9:01government are left with the state's
- 9:04ultimate power to change the organic
- 9:06structure of government laws left with
- 9:08the people but the means of making
- 9:11changes amending the Constitution were
- 9:13carefully prescribed to militate against
- 9:15hasty unwise decisions by the people as
- 9:19Benjamin Franklin left the Statehouse in
- 9:21Philadelphia on the closing day of the
- 9:23Constitutional Convention a woman asking
- 9:26what kind of government the convention
- 9:28had given America and Franklin replied a
- 9:31republic if you can keep it very old and
- 9:35very wise Franklin saw through the mists
- 9:37of time to the day when Americans might
- 9:40trade their freedom in a constitutional
- 9:42republic for the promise of government
- 9:44guaranteed equality and security in a
- 9:46democracy and beyond that to the day
- 9:50when democracy in evitable degenerates
- 9:52in the dictatorship guaranteeing nothing
- 9:55but poverty and serfdom for the people
- 9:58that robs and
- 9:59the American constitutional system
- 10:02unique in history enabled Americans to
- 10:05develop a backward continent into the
- 10:08most magnificent nation at all time the
- 10:11system was designed to prevent both
- 10:12tyranny by government and reckless
- 10:15rebellion by the people we must restore
- 10:18it and keep it and what can you do
- 10:21toward that end your job you who care
- 10:25and understand is to help educate others
- 10:28I suggest that you might find a
- 10:30subscription to my report helpful the
- 10:32dance book report on which these
- 10:34broadcasts are based is set every week
- 10:37through the mails and will reach you
- 10:38long before the broadcast does it
- 10:40contains documentation in details I
- 10:42cannot put on the broadcast you can read
- 10:45it make up your own mind pass it on to
- 10:47others I think it may be an effective
- 10:49tool for you to use to help educate and
- 10:52activate others and only by this means
- 10:56can we restore our Republic
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of A Republic, Not A Democracy by Dan Smoot 1966 Apr 18 by Camp Constitution, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,646 words across 266 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.