A NEW Trace! The FULL MH370 Story, so Far.. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:04[Music]
- 0:35how can a boing trip 7 one of the
- 0:38biggest and most modern aircraft in the
- 0:40world just vanished without the
- 0:44trace it
- 0:49can't everything lost leaves a
- 0:56trace at a Malaysia Airlines flight with
- 0:59200 39 people on board Mage 370 flight
- 1:03370 flight image
- 1:06370 there are mysteries in the world and
- 1:09then there is the story of
- 1:11MH370 this is a story so full of
- 1:14questions and theories that it's almost
- 1:16impossible to tell it without resorting
- 1:18to Pure speculation this is the reason I
- 1:21have refrained from covering it up until
- 1:23now but since at the time of this
- 1:25video's release it's gone 10 years since
- 1:28239 people disappeared Without a Trace I
- 1:32decided to make an exception this story
- 1:35is created with one goal and one goal
- 1:37only and that is to persuade the
- 1:39authorities to restart the search for
- 1:41the missing boying Triple 7 and with
- 1:44that hopefully also provide some closure
- 1:46to the families some of which I've been
- 1:48in contact with before making this video
- 1:51I will today share with you new
- 1:52potential evidence based Parton a
- 1:54technology that has been enhanced and
- 1:56refined over the last few years to the
- 1:58point where it now possibly can provide
- 2:00new Clues to where this aircraft finally
- 2:03ended
- 2:04up this is the story of Malaysian
- 2:06Airlines flight 370 as far as we know
- 2:21it on the 7th of March 2014 a crew from
- 2:25Malaysian Airlines checked in for a
- 2:26night Duty which was to take them from
- 2:28qual lumur International airport in
- 2:30Malaysia up to Beijing International in
- 2:33China except for the late start time it
- 2:36was supposed to be a quite nice Duty
- 2:38with a calculated flight time of only 5
- 2:40hours and 34 minutes meaning that they
- 2:42would eventually be finished in Beijing
- 2:44around midm morning the following day
- 2:46the captain of the flight arrived first
- 2:48and signed in at the Malaysian Airlines
- 2:50crew room at local time
- 2:522250 he was Then followed by his
- 2:54colleague the first officer around 25
- 2:56minutes
- 2:57later this was planned as a training
- 3:00flight for the first officer since he
- 3:02was completing a transition type course
- 3:04over from the Airbus A330 to the boing
- 3:06trip 7 which they would be flying on
- 3:08this flight the training had gone really
- 3:11well up until this point and if
- 3:13everything went fine on this flight he
- 3:15would be recommended for final line
- 3:17check by the captain for the following
- 3:19Duty having said that this was the first
- 3:22time that these two pilots were planned
- 3:23to fly together which might explain why
- 3:25the captain had turned up a little bit
- 3:27earlier you see it's pretty Comm for us
- 3:30instructors to do so if we need to
- 3:32review someone's training file for
- 3:33example before the flight to check out
- 3:35if there's any areas that might require
- 3:37special attention in any case once the
- 3:40first officer had also signed in the two
- 3:42pilots proceeded by going through the
- 3:44pre-flight briefing which from what they
- 3:46could see looked pretty straightforward
- 3:48the weather in kumur was generally nice
- 3:51and dominated by a subtropical high
- 3:53pressure center over Thailand and the
- 3:55weather at their destination Beijing
- 3:57also looked quite good from what they
- 3:59could see
- 4:00the only potential issue was that about
- 4:022/3 down the route they would be passing
- 4:04through a pretty strong jet stream with
- 4:06high winds which could cause a bit of
- 4:08turbulence but apart from that it was
- 4:10looking pretty
- 4:11straightforward with that in mind and no
- 4:14Nots affecting the flight either the
- 4:16pilots then turned their attention to
- 4:17the flight plan there were two
- 4:20alternates listed for Bing and taking
- 4:22into consideration both of these the
- 4:24pilots decided on a final fuel of
- 4:2649,100 kilos which was in line with the
- 4:29expect expected amount for this flight
- 4:31neither substantially more nor less than
- 4:33required this fuel would give the
- 4:35aircraft an approximate endurance of 7
- 4:37hours and 31 minutes around 2 hours
- 4:40longer than the anticipated flight time
- 4:42and that will of course become very
- 4:44important in the
- 4:46story so who were the pilots that were
- 4:49going to be in charge of this flight
- 4:51then well the captain was a 53y old with
- 4:53a 33-year great track record in Malaysia
- 4:56Airlines he was married with three
- 4:58children and on his spare time he was
- 5:00involved in the local opposition party
- 5:02helped deliver groceries to elderly and
- 5:05Tinker with some home electronics he had
- 5:08also started a YouTube channel which by
- 5:10the way is still there where he showed
- 5:12how to mend certain home appliances and
- 5:14also crucially where he showed off his
- 5:16home simulator which he had built to be
- 5:18able to practice his trade at home this
- 5:21simulator would later be investigated
- 5:23thoroughly it had been erased weeks
- 5:25before the flight but the investigator
- 5:27still found some manually entered
- 5:28waypoints of interest in a backup memory
- 5:31but without it proving to be anything
- 5:34conclusive in any case the captain had
- 5:36stable finances no known illnesses and
- 5:39was regarded as a solid reliable member
- 5:41of his community in terms of his
- 5:44Aviation career it had started when he
- 5:45was accepted into a sponsored program
- 5:47for Malaysian Airlines already back in
- 5:501981 he completed his licenses and then
- 5:53started flying for them back in
- 5:551983 he then worked his way up the ranks
- 5:58starting on the f27 and then the
- 6:0173700 Airbus a300 and finally he got his
- 6:04first command on the 50 This Was
- 6:07Then followed by command on the 737 400
- 6:10and the Airbus A330 until actually on my
- 6:12birthday the 22nd of September 1998 he
- 6:16received his command on the Boeing trip
- 6:177 which he then continued to operate
- 6:19until the day of this
- 6:21flight his good track record and
- 6:23seniority eventually gave him the
- 6:25opportunity to also become a typ rating
- 6:27instructor as well as an examiner on
- 6:29this typ Ty and it was in this capacity
- 6:31that he was going to operate Malaysian
- 6:33Airlines flight 370 on this evening he
- 6:36had a total experience of just over
- 6:3918,400 hourss and
- 6:418,659 of those had been flown on the
- 6:43boing Triple 7 the first officer was 27
- 6:46years old and single he had also been
- 6:49accepted into the airline as a Cadet
- 6:51pilot started in 2008 and he'd been
- 6:53flying initially on the boing
- 6:5577400 he had then changed over to the
- 6:58Airbus A330 Fleet 2012 and then onto the
- 7:01boing trip 7 in November 2013 just a few
- 7:04months before this flight and this was
- 7:07obviously why he was still in training
- 7:09he had a total experience of just over
- 7:112,800 hours and very little only 39
- 7:14hours on the type there is not much more
- 7:17mentioned about the first officer in the
- 7:18final report except that he was known as
- 7:20a nice person with stable economy and no
- 7:23recent major changes in his life now
- 7:26given the vast difference in experience
- 7:28seniority and the fact that this was a
- 7:30training flight it can be easily assumed
- 7:32that the power gradient in the cockpit
- 7:34would have been quite steep but nothing
- 7:37indicated any personal issues between
- 7:39these two colleagues both of them had
- 7:41also received more than the required
- 7:43rest before the flight and their
- 7:45licenses and Medicals were all up to
- 7:48date when the pilots had completed their
- 7:50pre-flight preparation and training
- 7:52briefing they walked over to their 10
- 7:54cabin crew members that they were
- 7:55scheduled to operate together with this
- 7:57was a vastly experienced crew with a
- 8:00most Junior attendant having flown for
- 8:0213 years and the most senior over 35
- 8:05years so the briefing would have been
- 8:07pretty quick and efficient after they
- 8:09were finished they all walked together
- 8:11out to the aircraft that was being
- 8:13prepared for them by the ground crew
- 8:15outside it was a majestic Boeing 7200 ER
- 8:20equipped with two Rolls-Royce Trent 892
- 8:23Bravo turbofan engines and it was in
- 8:26perfect working condition according to
- 8:27the tech log the only point of Interest
- 8:30was that the flight crew oxygen cylinder
- 8:31had been topped up just prior to the
- 8:33flight but this was a routine
- 8:35maintenance thing now there are numerous
- 8:37systems aboard this aircraft that will
- 8:39become important for this story and in
- 8:41order to explain it I will have to
- 8:42become quite technical in some places
- 8:45but also that's kind of what we do here
- 8:47on the
- 8:47channel anyway the two pilots had
- 8:50decided that the first officer was going
- 8:52to be Pilot Flying for this flight
- 8:53meaning that he immediately started
- 8:55completing the pre-flight preparation as
- 8:56soon as he arrived to the cockpit this
- 8:59included inputting flight information
- 9:02like the flight number and the airline
- 9:03info into the FMC CDU which he did at
- 9:06time 2356 and 8 seconds now you might
- 9:10wonder how we can know that so exactly
- 9:13and this has to do with a system that
- 9:14will play an incredibly important role
- 9:16here the aircraft Communications
- 9:19addressing and Reporting System more
- 9:21commonly referred to as acars this is a
- 9:24digital data link system which connects
- 9:26data providers on the ground directly to
- 9:28the aircraft via either VHF or satellite
- 9:31Communications it enables people on the
- 9:33ground to send things like updated
- 9:35weather flight plans and even make calls
- 9:37or send messages directly to the
- 9:39aircraft when it's airborne and the part
- 9:41of this system which is going to be most
- 9:43important here is the satellite
- 9:44Communications or satcom system the ACR
- 9:48system booted up and established a link
- 9:50through the satcom at time 2354 and
- 9:52about 1 minute and 20 seconds later it
- 9:54captured the first office's inputs as I
- 9:57just mentioned before this showed that
- 9:59the system worked fine in the beginning
- 10:01of this flight and it's worth noting
- 10:03here that the system uses two different
- 10:05satellite antennas depending on if the
- 10:07aircraft's navigation system is working
- 10:09or not remember that anyway as the first
- 10:13officer was working away in the cockpit
- 10:15he soon received an acar message
- 10:16containing something known as a no talk
- 10:19frequent viewers of this channel will
- 10:21know that this stands for notification
- 10:23to Captain and is normally sent out if
- 10:26the aircraft would be carrying dangerous
- 10:27goods in this case there were actually
- 10:30no dangerous goods on board just some
- 10:32special load being loaded consisting of
- 10:34several tons of mango which apparently
- 10:37had a tendency to leak juice and water
- 10:40and therefore had to be checked closely
- 10:42the Noto message confirmed that the
- 10:44cargo had been checked and that it
- 10:45wasn't leaking but what it didn't say
- 10:48was that there was also nearly 2 and a
- 10:50half tons of lithium ion batteries
- 10:52loaded on board but these batteries were
- 10:54individually packaged and stored in such
- 10:56a way that they were not considered
- 10:58dangerous goods and they have therefore
- 11:00been ruled out as a possible cause for
- 11:02what's about to happen eventually the
- 11:04captain returned from his walk around
- 11:06and together with his colleague they
- 11:07completed the rest of the pre-light
- 11:09preparations and briefings and at time
- 11:112325 the first officer called up quala
- 11:14lumur delivery to request their
- 11:15departure
- 11:16clearance delivery
- 11:20[Music]
- 11:2137 the delivery controller told them
- 11:23that they were clear to follow the pus
- 11:25one alpha departure from Runway 32 right
- 11:28and initially climbed to 6,000 ft with
- 11:30transponder the code
- 11:3421577 to Beijing departure 6000 ft s
- 11:3957 this was read back by the first
- 11:41officer and less than 2 minutes later
- 11:43Malaysia 370 also requested push and
- 11:46start which was almost immediately
- 11:58approved
- 12:11P after the push back the aircraft
- 12:13received its taxi clearance and then
- 12:15started taxiing out to watch Runway 32
- 12:17right through the dark Malaysian night
- 12:19and for anyone watching the aircraft
- 12:21everything looked completely normal but
- 12:24this was going to be the last time
- 12:26anyone saw this aircraft with their own
- 12:28eyes so what about the passengers then
- 12:31well there were 227 passengers on board
- 12:34coming from 14 different nations 153
- 12:38were from China making those the largest
- 12:40group followed by 50 from Malaysia and
- 12:42seven from
- 12:43Indonesia two of those passengers were
- 12:45later found to have been flying on
- 12:47Stolen passports and they were
- 12:49identified as Iranians who were most
- 12:51likely looking for Refugee status and
- 12:53were not considered a threat none of the
- 12:56other passengers raised any type of
- 12:58Suspicion and this means that in total
- 13:00there were 239 passengers and crew on
- 13:03board when the giant Bo 7 lined up on
- 13:05Runway 32 Right and started spooling up
- 13:08its
- 13:09engin and I'll tell you all about what
- 13:11happened next right after this talking
- 13:13about leaving traces did you know that
- 13:15there's a whole industry out there known
- 13:17as data brokers who live off selling
- 13:19your digital traces off to the highest
- 13:21bidder what they do is they Snoop up
- 13:23things like your address book contact
- 13:25details financial data and even family
- 13:27information and then sell it on to
- 13:29scammers financial institutions and even
- 13:31spam Mills now this is totally legal
- 13:35unless you tell each and every one of
- 13:37them to stop and that's where today's
- 13:39sponsor incog comes in incog basically
- 13:42works as a guardian of your digital
- 13:44footprint and they will work diligently
- 13:46to contact all of those companies for
- 13:48you and then scrub your name off their
- 13:50lists they will then make sure that you
- 13:52don't reappear for as long as you stay
- 13:54with them constantly scanning to make
- 13:55sure that your name doesn't appear with
- 13:57any new company when I signed up I was
- 14:00amazed when I looked at my dashboard and
- 14:02could see just how widespread my data
- 14:05was and it didn't take long after I
- 14:07signed up for the amount of spam and
- 14:09irritating Robo calls to start
- 14:11decreasing so if you are ready to start
- 14:13taking control of your online presence
- 14:15then consider giving incog a try and if
- 14:18you use this link here below which is
- 14:19incog docomo with the Code Pilot you
- 14:23will get an exclusive 60% discount off
- 14:25the annual plan thank you incog now
- 14:27let's continue at 40 minutes and 37
- 14:30seconds past midnight on the 8th of
- 14:32march quala Tower cleared Malaysian
- 14:34Airlines flight 370 for
- 14:37takeoff
- 14:383 take
- 14:45off the first officer was at the
- 14:47controls at this point and had therefore
- 14:49handed over the radio to the captain and
- 14:50after the engines were stabilized he
- 14:52pushed the toga buttons and the aircraft
- 14:54started accelerating down the runway at
- 14:5642 minutes past midnight the SAT system
- 14:59recorded that the aircraft was airborne
- 15:01and did then continued to transmit the
- 15:03aircraft's identification codes together
- 15:05with all of the other normal data and
- 15:07this just showed that everything was
- 15:09completely normal at that
- 15:11stage the procedures in qual lumur was
- 15:14for the pilots to automatically switch
- 15:15over to the departure frequency after
- 15:17takeoff so that's exactly what the
- 15:19captain now also did once he called up
- 15:22and identified himself the departure
- 15:23controller told them to cancel the
- 15:25standard instrument departure and
- 15:27instead proceed direct toward Waypoint
- 15:29called igari and continue to climb to
- 15:31flight level 180 it's pretty common that
- 15:34controllers give clearances like this
- 15:36especially at night when there's
- 15:38typically less traffic and therefore
- 15:40easier to give these kind of directs the
- 15:43captain just read back the clearance and
- 15:45then selected igari as the active
- 15:47Waypoint in the FMC the first officer
- 15:49would have then verified it told him to
- 15:51execute a routing and then selected
- 15:53flight level 180 in the mode control
- 15:55panel for the captain to verify just
- 15:57like they would have done thousand of
- 15:59times before at this stage of the flight
- 16:02everything was still completely normal
- 16:04and when you listen to the ATC tapes The
- 16:06Voice level of the captain is completely
- 16:08relaxed and routine the aircraft
- 16:11continued its climb towards igari and
- 16:13they were eventually changed over to the
- 16:14next frequency lper radar on 132 decimal
- 16:186 this was going to be the controller
- 16:20looking after them until they reached
- 16:21thei and the FI boundary towards
- 16:24Vietnam
- 16:2670ct 13269
- 16:33the captain read backed his Handover
- 16:35more or less exactly as he should by
- 16:36confirming the new frequency and giving
- 16:38his call sign again sounding completely
- 16:41normal when he called up the new area
- 16:43controller he was told that they could
- 16:45continue their climb to flight level 250
- 16:47which he also read back and only 3
- 16:49minutes later they received further
- 16:51clearance to climb to their requested
- 16:53Cruise level flight level
- 16:56350 as flight 370 progressed up towards
- 16:59the Northeast they were still fully
- 17:01visible on radar for all involved ATC
- 17:04units and here it's probably a good time
- 17:06to start explaining a bit about Radars
- 17:08in general there are two different types
- 17:11of radar to keep in mind for this
- 17:12episode primary radar which is also
- 17:15referred to as raw radar and secondary
- 17:18radar under normal circumstances
- 17:20commercial air traffic always uses both
- 17:22of them but the secondary radar is what
- 17:24gives the majority of the information it
- 17:27is dependent on a small radio
- 17:29transmitter known as a transponder on
- 17:31board the aircraft and this transponder
- 17:33will be identified by a four-letter
- 17:35numerical code with numbers from 0 to 7
- 17:39remember that was the code that the
- 17:40first officer received earlier as part
- 17:42of the departure clearance now there are
- 17:44two transponders on board the aircraft
- 17:46and the active one will when it's
- 17:47activated by the pilots send their
- 17:49traffic control loads of information
- 17:51like position altitude speed and even
- 17:53mCP Selections in some cases the
- 17:56transponders also communicates with
- 17:58other traffic and therefore enables
- 17:59tcast maneuvering and it's these
- 18:01transponders that makes apps like Flight
- 18:03Radar 24 work since anyone can pick up
- 18:06the adsb signals that they
- 18:09transmit but the key thing to remember
- 18:11here is that the transponders are on
- 18:13board the aircraft and without them
- 18:15functioning secondary radar will not
- 18:17work and neither will those websites or
- 18:21tcas and this brings us to the primary
- 18:23radar which is an invention that has
- 18:25been with us for a very long time by now
- 18:29in this Essence it works on a simple
- 18:31idea of sending out a radio pulse and
- 18:33then measuring any waves that might hit
- 18:35a Target and then bounce back to the
- 18:37receiver the direction those returning
- 18:40waves are done coming from will give a
- 18:42bearing towards the target obviously
- 18:44this technology has become much more
- 18:46refined since it was first invented
- 18:48making it much more complex but you get
- 18:50the general idea this type of radar can
- 18:54be used to see things that are not
- 18:56transmitting any information voluntarily
- 18:58and it's therefore often used by the
- 19:00military but given the nature of
- 19:02shortwave radio signals this type of
- 19:04radar has a quite limited range and
- 19:06cannot accurately track altitude and
- 19:08speed very well something that will
- 19:10become important
- 19:12soon at 1 minute and 14 seconds past 1
- 19:16in the morning the captain of Malaysian
- 19:18flights 370 called up the lumper area
- 19:20controller to advise him that they were
- 19:22now level at flight level
- 19:25350 370 M over 3
- 19:29Malaysian
- 19:31370 this was acknowledged by the
- 19:33controller but this was not a necessary
- 19:35call to make by the captain it was more
- 19:38of a courtesy thing but you could still
- 19:40hear from the sound of his voice that he
- 19:42was relaxed when he made this call from
- 19:44the way that his intonation kind of
- 19:46dropped towards the
- 19:48[Applause]
- 19:51end and is from here on that I have a
- 19:54feeling that we can see the first
- 19:56indication of something being slightly
- 19:57out of order
- 19:59now I want to make it absolutely clear
- 20:01that nothing in the final report has
- 20:02highlighted that whatever happened
- 20:04started as early as here but I
- 20:06personally reacted to something that was
- 20:08just briefly mentioned in the report you
- 20:11see about 7 minutes after the captain
- 20:13called in that they were level that
- 20:15flight of 350 he called up again and
- 20:18reported the very same
- 20:22thing7 maining level 3 in the report
- 20:25this was highlighted as anomalous but
- 20:28the expert didn't think that it was
- 20:29worth paying any attention to but I
- 20:32disagree you see we Pilots tend to make
- 20:35these extra calls for two different
- 20:38reasons the first is that we have just
- 20:40simply forgotten about it and therefore
- 20:42call again just to be on the safe side
- 20:44but like I said earlier this was not a
- 20:46mandatory call to make the other reason
- 20:49we do it is because we've been away from
- 20:51the frequency for a while maybe because
- 20:53we have been fiddling with the radios or
- 20:55turned down the volume or something else
- 20:57and we just want to make sure sure that
- 20:59ATC hasn't tried to call us while we
- 21:01were gone you see if we make that call
- 21:04again and ATC just responds Roger or
- 21:07something similar well then we know that
- 21:08they haven't been trying to call us
- 21:10because if they would have they would
- 21:12now repeat any other messages that they
- 21:14had previously tried to send so with
- 21:17that in mind there were s minutes
- 21:19between the first call and the second
- 21:21call which means that something might
- 21:23have happened to take the captain away
- 21:25from the radio between those calls
- 21:29the other thing that I reacted to was
- 21:31the tone of voice of the captain when he
- 21:33made that second
- 21:36call Main level
- 21:393 again the experts in the report said
- 21:42that they couldn't detect any stress in
- 21:44the voice from the recordings but what I
- 21:46hearing is a clear difference in Pitch
- 21:48between the first and the second call in
- 21:51the first the captain sounds relaxed
- 21:54with a clear dropping intonation towards
- 21:56the end and in the second he just sounds
- 21:59busy like he's working on something at
- 22:01the same time that he's making that
- 22:04[Applause]
- 22:09call Main
- 22:11L this the sound of workload is
- 22:14something that I often hear in the
- 22:16simulator as well as when I'm doing
- 22:18training in the aircraft and that's why
- 22:20I reacted to it when I heard it anyway
- 22:23as expected the controller just
- 22:25responded with Malayan 370
- 22:30now this doesn't have to mean anything
- 22:32and I don't want to speculate any
- 22:34further on this detail but I thought it
- 22:36was worth to highlight given what's soon
- 22:38about to
- 22:40happen so the aircraft continued its
- 22:42cleared track up toward igari and within
- 22:44minutes of that last call from the
- 22:46captain the acart sent out its last
- 22:49complete routine message via satcom down
- 22:51to the ground station after this there
- 22:54would be a complete silence from the
- 22:56aircraft satcom for almost 1 hour hour
- 22:58and 17 minutes this detail is super
- 23:02important because it tells us a lot
- 23:04about what likely happened in the
- 23:05cockpit but I'll get back to that soon
- 23:08at time 0119 and 24 seconds the lper
- 23:12area controller instructed Malaysian
- 23:14Airlines FL 370 to contact hoimin
- 23:16control on frequency 120 decimal 9 malan
- 23:20370 contact hoimin to0 de 9 this
- 23:24happened about 1 minute before the
- 23:26aircraft flew past thear so they were
- 23:28still technically in Malaysian airspace
- 23:30but would soon pass into
- 23:32Vietnam and this is where the very last
- 23:35radio transmission occurred from flight
- 23:37370 with the captain simply
- 23:40[Music]
- 23:46answering now for some people that might
- 23:49have sounded like an omnus farewell but
- 23:51what I heard was once again someone who
- 23:53was busy so busy in fact that he didn't
- 23:56complete the read back correctly like I
- 23:58mentioned before all frequencies we are
- 24:00given must always be read back to avoid
- 24:03mistakes but that was not done in this
- 24:05call in any case now things started
- 24:08happening very quickly 5 seconds after
- 24:12the aircraft flew past the gari the mode
- 24:14s functionality of the transponder that
- 24:16was the part that gives that extra
- 24:18information was suddenly switched off
- 24:21now the only way to switch off only that
- 24:23is to turn the transponder knob in the
- 24:25cockpit from t r to the altit ude off
- 24:29position a technical malfunction would
- 24:32have removed all signals completely and
- 24:34immediately but in this case it took
- 24:36another 37 seconds for the secondary
- 24:38radar return to completely disappear and
- 24:40as it did the aircraft abruptly stopped
- 24:43following the planned
- 24:44route we know this because the primary
- 24:47radar recorded the turn and what it
- 24:49registered was that after the initial
- 24:51right turn towards a point called bod
- 24:54the aircraft now started a sharp almost
- 24:56180° left turn
- 24:59instead now boing tried to replicate
- 25:02this turn in the simulator but weren't
- 25:04able to match up the turn and the
- 25:06timings perfectly the only simulation
- 25:08that got close included a manually flown
- 25:11turn meaning that the autopilot must
- 25:13have been
- 25:14disconnected and why is that you might
- 25:16ask well the outter pilet will only
- 25:18allow certain Bank angles and this turn
- 25:21was so tight that a much steeper Bank
- 25:24must have been used at least partially
- 25:25throughout the turn in order to
- 25:27accomplish it the only reasonable
- 25:29conclusion that can been drawn from this
- 25:31is that someone had now started
- 25:33interfering with the flight's trajectory
- 25:34on purpose the timing and position of
- 25:37where all of this took place also looks
- 25:39far from random igar was the point just
- 25:42before the F boundary between Malaysia
- 25:45and Vietnam which meant that the
- 25:46controller from a new country would now
- 25:48be taking over the responsibility for
- 25:50the flight the Malaysian controller
- 25:52which forly still had the responsibility
- 25:54had handed the aircraft over and
- 25:56therefore probably didn't monitor it too
- 25:58close closely and the new hushi Min
- 26:01controller would likely wait until the
- 26:02aircraft called him up before starting
- 26:04to pay much attention to it which is
- 26:06also exactly what now
- 26:08happened given this it was the perfect
- 26:11place to initiate this maneuver if the
- 26:14intention was to try to avoid detection
- 26:17and now you might ask why disengage the
- 26:18autopilot why not just complete the
- 26:21turn well just to the north of igari
- 26:24Thailand has something known as an air
- 26:26defense identification Zone which on a
- 26:29high Lev chart shows up as two dotted
- 26:32parallel purple lines as the name
- 26:35suggests the Thai military would be
- 26:37monitoring any traffic entering into
- 26:39that zone and follow it up unless it was
- 26:41properly identified had a working
- 26:43transponder and followed a filed Flight
- 26:46Plan by carefully avoiding that zone
- 26:48whoever was now in control would also
- 26:50avoid any direct scrutiny from the Thai
- 26:52military and given the direction the
- 26:54aircraft was now turning it's likely
- 26:56that anyone looking at the primary radar
- 26:58would assume that the aircraft was just
- 27:00diverting still under Malaysian control
- 27:03this turn would also position the
- 27:05aircraft between that Thai ADI said and
- 27:08Airway Mike 765 which would avoid any
- 27:11opposite
- 27:13traffic this shows us that whoever was
- 27:16now in control was likely very well
- 27:18versed with the airspace structure over
- 27:20this particular area and that this was
- 27:22likely very carefully planned
- 27:25out after the U-turn was finished the
- 27:27air continued in a semi straight line
- 27:30down towards the southwest and a VR
- 27:32Beacon known as Victor Papa Gulf near
- 27:35panang in Malaya the track showed small
- 27:38deviations consistent with an aircraft
- 27:40being flown manually and not on
- 27:42autopilot now since these radar echos
- 27:45were only captured on RAR radar it was
- 27:47impossible to get any reliable speed or
- 27:49altitude data from them it is possible
- 27:52that the aircraft descended slightly
- 27:54during this segment maybe to gain a
- 27:56higher true air speed that it was
- 27:58overflying Malaysia this theory was
- 28:01further corroborated by the fact that a
- 28:03celom mobile Mast on the island of
- 28:05panang briefly detected a mobile phone
- 28:08signal which was later confirmed to have
- 28:10come from the first office's phone those
- 28:12type of signals generally have a very
- 28:15limited vertical range maximum around
- 28:1730,000 ft and often much lower than that
- 28:20but given that atmospheric conditions
- 28:22have huge impact on the Range it's very
- 28:25hard to speculate here but since turning
- 28:28off the mobile phone is a checklist item
- 28:30in most Airlines this could indicate
- 28:33that the first officer was trying to
- 28:34communicate here but no call signals
- 28:37ever came through and the signal was
- 28:39only detected for a very short while but
- 28:43what is really intriguing during this
- 28:45segment of the flight is another system
- 28:47that we have already talked about a
- 28:48little bit which is the satcom system
- 28:51you see the satcom sends out regular
- 28:54interrogations every hour if no other
- 28:56information is being transmitted
- 28:59and when the groundbased station tried
- 29:01to Uplink an acar message at time 3
- 29:03minutes past 2 in the morning it didn't
- 29:05receive any acknowledgement back from
- 29:07the aircraft satcom so what does that
- 29:11mean then well if the acar system was
- 29:14just switched off or failed the link
- 29:17would still take place it would just
- 29:19communicate the fact that acars wasn't
- 29:21working and if the system was manually
- 29:23logged off from the cockpit this would
- 29:26also be shown in that log and because
- 29:28none of that happened the most likely
- 29:30reason for this satcom loss was a power
- 29:33failure to the system
- 29:35itself now this system can be powered
- 29:38from several different electrical buses
- 29:40and from most of the aircraft redundant
- 29:42power sources so this fact has led some
- 29:45incredibly experienced boing trip 7
- 29:47Pilots whose excellent work I will be
- 29:49linking to in the description by the way
- 29:51to believe that whoever was in charge of
- 29:54the aircraft after that initial turn
- 29:56must have manually turned off all of
- 29:58those
- 29:59sources this can be done by deselecting
- 30:02both the primary and backup generators
- 30:04from their buses using the buttons on
- 30:06the overhead panel after that the
- 30:09aircraft would react by trying to outo
- 30:11start the Apu in order to replace those
- 30:13systems so the person in charge would
- 30:15then have to put the Apu switch to on
- 30:17and then back off again to stop that
- 30:19outter start from happening if that
- 30:21would happen that would then trigger the
- 30:23ram air turbine the rat to be activated
- 30:26either manually or automatically and it
- 30:28would start to provide electrical power
- 30:29for the most critical systems like
- 30:31primary flight displays navigation
- 30:33displays and navigation equipment but
- 30:36not the
- 30:37autopilot hydraulic movement of the
- 30:39flight controls would not be a problem
- 30:41since both engines were still working
- 30:43and providing hydraulic so maneuvering
- 30:45the aircraft manually would still work
- 30:46perfectly fine now of course removing
- 30:49the primary power sources in this way
- 30:52would cause everything else except
- 30:53emergency lighting to go black in the
- 30:55aircraft and it's likely that this would
- 30:57make make things very difficult for both
- 30:59the crew and the passengers in the back
- 31:02and while we're on the subject of the
- 31:04passengers and crew I want to point out
- 31:06here that we really have no idea about
- 31:08what actually happened to them some
- 31:11theories have suggested that whoever was
- 31:13in charge might have depressurized the
- 31:16cabin in order to get everyone into
- 31:17their seats and keep them under control
- 31:20this is possible to do by just opening
- 31:22the outflow vals manually was still
- 31:24keeping the air conditioning running the
- 31:26fact that the air conditioning was kept
- 31:28running would provide Heating and make
- 31:30it bearable in the cockpit as it
- 31:32otherwise would become freezing cold
- 31:34almost immediately the passenger oxygen
- 31:36masks would then drop in the back but
- 31:38the oxygen generators in the trip 7
- 31:40would only last for about 22 minutes or
- 31:42so but the oxygen cylinder which is
- 31:45providing the cockpit crew with oxygen
- 31:47would last a full 27 hours in case
- 31:50there's only one person using it and it
- 31:52had like I mentioned before been topped
- 31:54up just that very
- 31:56morning this means that if the cabin was
- 31:59kept unpressurized without descending
- 32:01the passengers would become completely
- 32:03incapacitated once the oxygen generator
- 32:05stopped working but whoever was still in
- 32:09the cockpit would be able to just
- 32:11continue to operate just fine the time
- 32:13of useful Consciousness at 35,000 ft is
- 32:16about 1 minute extending to a few
- 32:18minutes at 30,000 ft and anyone
- 32:21subjected to those altitudes without
- 32:23supplemental oxygen would after that not
- 32:25be able to take any rational decisions
- 32:27and soon become
- 32:29unconscious after that if no oxygen
- 32:32would be provided it would take another
- 32:3320 minutes or so until death would
- 32:39occur but like I said before we don't
- 32:41know for a fact what happened and we
- 32:43won't know more until the aircraft is
- 32:45found which is why it is so important
- 32:48that we continue the
- 32:50search now flying an aircraft at these
- 32:53altitudes manually whilst possibly
- 32:55wearing an oxygen mask and with only rud
- 32:57mentary navigation available would be
- 33:00quite tiring and that's likely why the
- 33:02radar images were showing this small
- 33:05heading variations anyway at this stage
- 33:08the aircraft continued to be tracked by
- 33:10both civilian and Military Roar radar as
- 33:13it continued its way around the south of
- 33:15panang where it started turning right
- 33:17through the malaka straight there were
- 33:19temporary lapses in the radar coverage
- 33:22but all in all it painted a fairly clear
- 33:24picture of an aircraft flying in a
- 33:26controlled way and not in any way
- 33:29random so why wasn't the aircraft
- 33:33intercepted or tracked more closely then
- 33:36well this was due to a combination of
- 33:39factors and misunderstandings between
- 33:41different Air Traffic Control units and
- 33:42the operations controllers in Malaysia
- 33:44Airlines
- 33:45Headquarters when the aircraft first
- 33:48disappeared from radar it took around 20
- 33:50minutes before the hosi Min controller
- 33:52called up the Malaysian controller to
- 33:54ask about where the aircraft actually
- 33:57was
- 33:58now this was significantly longer than
- 34:00the standard 5 minutes it should take
- 34:02before Aquarius sent but like I
- 34:04mentioned before this happened at an
- 34:06intersection between two different
- 34:07countries in the middle of the night so
- 34:10it's likely that the controllers were
- 34:12just dealing with other traffic and
- 34:14didn't monitor their strips too closely
- 34:17when the Malaysian controller who was
- 34:18still technically responsible for the
- 34:20flight was made aware of the missing
- 34:22aircraft he eventually contacted
- 34:24Malaysian Airlines who confirmed that
- 34:26they could see the aircraft flying up
- 34:28through
- 34:29Cambodia this meant that the air traffic
- 34:31controllers now started contacting their
- 34:33colleagues along the route that the
- 34:34aircraft was thought to be flying to see
- 34:37if they could get into contact with them
- 34:39and this in turn meant that none of them
- 34:41saw the lonely faint radar Echo that was
- 34:44traveling Southwest instead it was later
- 34:47found out that the Malaysian Airlines
- 34:49tracking software was basing the
- 34:51position of the aircraft on predictions
- 34:53when it didn't receive any real data and
- 34:56that's what had caused that initial
- 34:58confusion now the military did see the
- 35:01aircraft turning left after agari but
- 35:03since it wasn't violating any new
- 35:05airspace they assumed it was just a
- 35:07normal air turn back and didn't raise
- 35:09any further alarms or send anyone up to
- 35:12intercept it was only later with the
- 35:15help of radar playbacks that the picture
- 35:17of MH 370's true path became clearer
- 35:21after the aircraft had turned right up
- 35:23towards the Northwest it looked like it
- 35:25was heading towards a waypoint called
- 35:27vamp
- 35:28the satcom system still had not logged
- 35:30on at this stage so we can assume that
- 35:31the aircraft was still flying in a power
- 35:33degraded State possibly only with the
- 35:35ramare turbine as a power source but
- 35:37even if that was the case navigation
- 35:39would still not be a problem the Victor
- 35:42Papa go VR was still well within range
- 35:45meaning that the aircraft could use raw
- 35:47data navigation to find vampy and the
- 35:49Waypoint could also be displayed on the
- 35:51aircraft navigation display so whoever
- 35:53was flying could just point the nose
- 35:55towards it vampy was soon paused and the
- 35:58now more and more faint radar Echo
- 36:01continued flying up in the general
- 36:02direction of Airway November 571 towards
- 36:05another Waypoint called mear and it's
- 36:08soon after the aircraft passed slightly
- 36:10to the south of that waypoint at time
- 36:120222 and 12 seconds that all
- 36:15conventional radar traces from this
- 36:16flight completely
- 36:23disappeared now there is a real
- 36:25possibility that there were military
- 36:27radar picking up signals from this
- 36:28aircraft for longer than this but given
- 36:31the sensitivity around showing military
- 36:33capability or positions of mobile Radars
- 36:36we haven't seen any such information
- 36:38come forward so this means that from
- 36:40this point onwards we're now going into
- 36:43the unknown and with that comes
- 36:45speculation or hypothesis which you all
- 36:47know I try to avoid on this channel so
- 36:50let's Instead try to stay with what we
- 36:52do
- 36:54know in order to further track this
- 36:56aircraft the inves ators scientific
- 36:58community and several commercial
- 37:00companies had to start using any data
- 37:02they had received in completely new ways
- 37:05and a great example of this is the
- 37:07inmarsat data inmarsat is as the name
- 37:10suggests a company providing Satellite
- 37:12Communication services and it was
- 37:14through their satellites that the satcom
- 37:16system for the aircraft acar was
- 37:18operating the signals these satellites
- 37:21were sending were never designed to
- 37:22track aircrafts but since there were
- 37:25signals exchanged with MH370 those
- 37:28signals could be reverse Engineers to
- 37:30provide a crude singular position
- 37:32indicator every time that they appeared
- 37:35the way this was done was basically by
- 37:37mimicking certain parts of the GPS
- 37:40system you see each GPS satellite is
- 37:43basically an extremely accurate timing
- 37:45device and when a device on earth like
- 37:47your phone or in this case a boying
- 37:49Triple 7 connects to one of them the GPS
- 37:52satellite transmits a quick signal which
- 37:54basically says this is where I am and
- 37:56this is the time right now that signal
- 37:59then travels at the speed of light which
- 38:01still takes a certain amount of time to
- 38:03arrive to your device that time is
- 38:06measured to determine how far away you
- 38:08are from that GPS satellite and with the
- 38:11satellite's position and your distance
- 38:12from it we can determine that you are
- 38:14somewhere along the radius of a circle
- 38:18then obviously your device will connect
- 38:20to multiple satellites which each one of
- 38:22them drawing its own Circle and where
- 38:24all of these circles meet well that's
- 38:26where you are so in the case of the
- 38:28inmarsat data this same technique could
- 38:30basically also be used each time the
- 38:32aircraft connected to the satellite
- 38:34using the satcom system the time its
- 38:36system took to respond to the satellite
- 38:38signals was recorded the same happened
- 38:41at regular intervals when the satellite
- 38:43checked that the plane was still
- 38:45connected and each of these connections
- 38:48seven of them in total are the famous
- 38:50handshakes that were reported about
- 38:52basically everywhere every one of those
- 38:54handshakes could then be used to place
- 38:56the missing aircraft somewhere along a
- 38:58circle at a specific point of time and
- 39:00that process of defining a circle or Arc
- 39:03is called burst timing offset or BTO but
- 39:07this was not the only information that
- 39:09the inmar set signals could provide
- 39:11analysts could also pick up another
- 39:13value in the signal something known as
- 39:14burst frequency offset or
- 39:17bfo bfo gave information that could help
- 39:20the investigators determine how the
- 39:22aircraft was moving in relation to the
- 39:24satellite as its name suggested involved
- 39:28studying the actual frequencies of the
- 39:29signal that the satellite received and
- 39:31then how they differed from the expected
- 39:34frequencies think of this like the way
- 39:36an ambulance siren seems to change its
- 39:39tone as it drives towards and then past
- 39:41you when it's coming towards you the
- 39:43sound waves are denser making for a
- 39:45higher frequency and after it goes past
- 39:47you the sound wav moves further apart
- 39:50giving the tone a lower frequency this
- 39:53is called the Doppler effect or the
- 39:55Doppler shift and primary radars
- 39:57actually also use this in the same way
- 39:59to determine for example the speed of an
- 40:01aircraft now I am of course
- 40:03oversimplifying these Concepts a bit
- 40:04here but in the case of MH370 since
- 40:07these signals between the aircraft and
- 40:09the satellite traveled mostly vertically
- 40:11the birth frequency offset or bfo was
- 40:14instead used to help investigators
- 40:16determine whether the aircraft was
- 40:17climbing or
- 40:19descending now those of you who have
- 40:21been paying attention will have noticed
- 40:23that I have said that the satcom system
- 40:25was not working so how could the inm
- 40:28maret analyst get any of these
- 40:30handshakes well here is where we get to
- 40:33a really interesting development that
- 40:35happened at time 0225 and 27 seconds
- 40:39then all of a sudden the previously
- 40:41nonresponsive satcom system of MH370
- 40:43suddenly came back to life and proceeded
- 40:45to start sending a log on request to the
- 40:49satellite this would later be referred
- 40:52to as the first handshake this happened
- 40:55almost exactly 1 hour after the aircraft
- 40:57had completed its turn after Rari and
- 41:00the interesting bit is that the burst
- 41:02frequency offset value in this first
- 41:04handshake was deemed unreliable due to a
- 41:06quite large frequency error and what's
- 41:11making that so interesting then well it
- 41:13turns out that the quch crystals used in
- 41:16the satcom radio transmitters needed to
- 41:18be kept at a constant temperature to
- 41:20avoid big frequency
- 41:22oscillations this was achieved with the
- 41:24help of something known as an oven
- 41:26controlled Crystal oscillator which was
- 41:28basically a temperature controller and
- 41:31it needed time to warm up after a
- 41:33lengthy power Interruption so it is
- 41:35likely that it hadn't reached the
- 41:38correct temperature at this point when
- 41:40the first log on message was sent hence
- 41:42the bfo frequency error and this is how
- 41:46we know that the aircraft was likely
- 41:48powered down up until just prior to this
- 41:50point science is truly amazing now this
- 41:55first handshake also lacked a valid
- 41:57flight and Company ID which the aircraft
- 42:00previously had transmitted
- 42:02correctly we cannot know this for sure
- 42:05but if the aircraft power had been
- 42:07manually restored at this point well
- 42:10then the person in command would likely
- 42:12also know that the satcom system would
- 42:14soon boot up and start sending out data
- 42:17so in order to stay hidden he would have
- 42:19had to manually go into the
- 42:21multifunctional display and disable all
- 42:24Communications through the
- 42:25communications manager page before the
- 42:28satellite communication unit the sdu
- 42:30became fully
- 42:31operational if this was done this way
- 42:34this would also erase the flight and
- 42:36Company info which is exactly what the
- 42:38data also
- 42:39showed so you can see even though no
- 42:42data was actually sent out with a lot of
- 42:45Ingenuity the signals themselves can
- 42:47actually tell us a lot about what was
- 42:48likely going on we also know for example
- 42:52that the navigation system was working
- 42:54because of which antenna the setcom
- 42:56system was using when it started
- 42:57transmitting like I said
- 43:00amazing so using the inmarsat data we
- 43:03know for sure that the aircraft
- 43:04continued to fly long enough to allow a
- 43:07total of seven handshakes where the
- 43:09first and the last were log on requests
- 43:11sent by the aircraft itself like I
- 43:14explained before these log on requests
- 43:16were most probably caused by power
- 43:17interruptions where the last one was
- 43:19likely caused by the fuel station of one
- 43:22or possibly both engines after the
- 43:23aircraft had flown for around 7 hours
- 43:25and 35 minutes
- 43:28that last handshake came at time 0819
- 43:31Malaysian time which corresponds quite
- 43:32well with the endurance of the aircraft
- 43:34based on the recorded fuel now these
- 43:37handshakes occurred roughly every hour
- 43:39since the system was sent to send out a
- 43:41ping every hour unless other satcom
- 43:43activities were initiated two of the
- 43:45handshakes were caused by groundbased
- 43:48satellite calls from the Malaysian
- 43:49Airlines operations center who reached
- 43:51the cockpit but was left unanswered even
- 43:54so they reset the hour timing of the
- 43:58other handshakes and that's the reason
- 43:59why all of these seven handshakes were
- 44:01not happening on the same hourly
- 44:04intervals but of course we now have a
- 44:08huge
- 44:10problem since the inmar data was all
- 44:13coming from one satellite the arcs
- 44:15created by these seven handshakes
- 44:17created multiple possible routes that
- 44:19the aircraft might have flown and
- 44:21therefore an enormous potential search
- 44:23area several hugely accomplished pilots
- 44:26and inves have come up with very
- 44:28plausible scenarios on how the aircraft
- 44:30must have been flown after that last
- 44:32radar position to both align with all of
- 44:35those seven handshakes and avoid
- 44:38detection almost everyone agrees that
- 44:40the most likely route includes a turn
- 44:42from the previously northwesterly Co
- 44:44around the area of a waypoint called
- 44:46neam onto a more southwesterly
- 44:49course this would bring it down past the
- 44:51northern tip of Indonesia close to band
- 44:54AE and sometime after that it might
- 44:57might have chosen a suddenly course
- 44:58straight down into the southern Indian
- 45:00Ocean now I will link to some incredible
- 45:04investigative work made by Captain
- 45:05Patrick blle and John Luke marand in the
- 45:08description of this video which lays out
- 45:10a very plausible final route but what I
- 45:14really want to do now is to also look at
- 45:16the possibility that there actually
- 45:18might be more physical evidence of where
- 45:20this aircraft finally ended up all of
- 45:23the evidence that I've presented to you
- 45:25so far points to a deliberate action
- 45:27from someone on board with expert
- 45:29knowledge of the aircraft its systems
- 45:31and the airspace it was flying through
- 45:34but a question that has been nagging me
- 45:36is that would someone who has obviously
- 45:39planned this so thoroughly to avoid
- 45:41detection bring the aircraft out to this
- 45:44point and then just turn the aircraft
- 45:46South and wait several hours until it
- 45:47ran out of
- 45:49fuel it it feels a bit unlikely given
- 45:52how active this person was during those
- 45:54initial parts of the maneuver and I
- 45:57wouldn't be surprised if he continued to
- 45:59be as active until the very end but
- 46:01again this will be hard to prove without
- 46:03further physical
- 46:05evidence and it now looks like we might
- 46:08possibly have just
- 46:12that you see back in 2008 an American
- 46:15astrophysicist by the name of Joseph
- 46:17huton Taylor Jr started working on
- 46:20something called the weak signal
- 46:21propagation reporter protocol or whisper
- 46:24for short he had previously received
- 46:26Nobel Prize in physics back in 1993 for
- 46:29his work on pulsars but he was also a
- 46:32keen amateur radio
- 46:34Enthusiast whisper is a protocol for low
- 46:37power radio Transmissions that explores
- 46:39how low medium and high frequency
- 46:41Transmissions propagate over large
- 46:43distances and Taylor designed computer
- 46:45software that was used to analyze these
- 46:47signals when these signals move over
- 46:50large distances they sometimes scatter
- 46:52when they hit obstacles in their path
- 46:54and this causes tiny anomalies in the
- 46:57signal strength this was interesting for
- 47:00radio amateurs because they could
- 47:01sometimes use those obstacles to improve
- 47:03overall reception and crucially one
- 47:06feature in the whisper protocol is that
- 47:08the reception from thousands of these
- 47:10signals have been uploaded into a shared
- 47:13database and stored all the way back to
- 47:162008 now I want to be absolutely clear
- 47:19here and say that Taylor himself never
- 47:21designed whisper to be used for the
- 47:23tracking of aircraft neither did he
- 47:25actually think that it was possible but
- 47:28back in 2021 an avionic system engineer
- 47:30called Richard Godfrey started exploring
- 47:32the possibility of using the whisper
- 47:34data base together with algorithms to
- 47:36look for anomalies in several different
- 47:39simultaneous Transmissions as a kind of
- 47:41poor man's primary
- 47:43radar theoretically if you know the
- 47:46exact location of the transmitter and
- 47:47the receiver together with the time of
- 47:49day and about a million other factors
- 47:52there might be a possibility to use tiny
- 47:54concurring anomalies in several of these
- 47:56signal signals to track something like
- 47:59an aircraft and the really cool thing is
- 48:01that this technology samples thousands
- 48:03of signals every two minutes which could
- 48:06potentially give us much more
- 48:08information than we previously had
- 48:11Godfrey understood this and from 2021
- 48:13until today he and his colleagues Dr
- 48:15hannes quet and Professor Simon maskell
- 48:18have been trying to analyze this data
- 48:20base to try and find traces of MH370 and
- 48:24in a report released on the 31st of
- 48:27August 2023 they claim that they have
- 48:29actually done just that again this video
- 48:33is not about whether this technology
- 48:35actually can be used this way or not but
- 48:37what I find fascinating here is that
- 48:39it's based on verifiable stored data so
- 48:42just like with DNA that couldn't be used
- 48:45much during the early years but has
- 48:47since been refined to incredible
- 48:49accuracy maybe there actually is
- 48:51something hidden inside of these
- 48:54signals this team's Trace data have
- 48:57actually already improved significantly
- 48:59from their first results as their
- 49:01algorithms have been evolving and this
- 49:04latest report tells a quite fascinating
- 49:06story initially the whisper data
- 49:09coincided nicely with the existing radar
- 49:11information up until just prior to vampy
- 49:14where it indicated that the aircraft
- 49:16made a turn to a more Westerly heading
- 49:19it then paralleled the assumed track on
- 49:21a slightly more suddenly course than
- 49:23indicated by the RAR radar and this
- 49:25could be because of the inherent in
- 49:27preciseness of the technology or the
- 49:29same from the radar which at that point
- 49:31was at the very limit of its effective
- 49:33range in any case the whisper track
- 49:36continued up towards the Northwest where
- 49:38it intercepted exactly the arc from the
- 49:40first inmarsat handshake at time 0228
- 49:42and 15 seconds the data then indicates
- 49:45that the aircraft continued up towards a
- 49:47point known as sanb after which it made
- 49:49a left turn towards uram all very close
- 49:52to what the other experts predicted that
- 49:54the aircraft must have done to continue
- 49:55avoiding military Radars and additional
- 49:57scrutiny by ATC now I won't go into all
- 50:02of the details of the route that the
- 50:03whisper data indicated but I want to
- 50:05highlight a few important things this
- 50:08data pointed to a track that wasn't
- 50:10completely straight down into the
- 50:12southern Indian Ocean instead it showed
- 50:14a series of turns Each of which was
- 50:17pointing towards an existing Waypoint
- 50:19but not ever on the same Airway this
- 50:22corresponds nicely with an aircraft that
- 50:24was still being piloted but in planned
- 50:27way to avoid interfering with existing
- 50:29Airways where a potential traffic
- 50:31conflict could arise remember it would
- 50:33not be seen on tcast nor could whoever
- 50:36was flying it see other traffic if the
- 50:39intention was to not be detected this
- 50:42type of behavior would make perfect
- 50:43sense since its ultimate destination
- 50:45would be very hard to predict in case it
- 50:47was partially being
- 50:49monitored The Whisper data also
- 50:51suggested that the aircraft slowed down
- 50:54slightly during two different intervals
- 50:56of its Jagged flight down towards the
- 50:58South which could possibly mean step
- 51:00climbs but the thing that really stood
- 51:02out to me was the fact that the whisper
- 51:04data corresponded almost perfectly with
- 51:06all of the seven inm Marat handshake
- 51:08arcs which is data that no one is really
- 51:12disputing towards the end of the flight
- 51:14The Whisper position also indicated
- 51:16something very
- 51:17strange because it looked like the
- 51:19aircraft started flying in a figure
- 51:21eight pattern in between the sixth and
- 51:24the seventh handshake which would have
- 51:25been when the aircraft was predicted to
- 51:27be running out of fuel the aircraft
- 51:29wouldn't do that by itself because the
- 51:31Ruder compensating system in the Boeing
- 51:337 is designed to compensate for the
- 51:35asymmetric trust after an engine failure
- 51:37so if this pattern was actually flown it
- 51:40must have been a deliberate act by
- 51:42whoever was in controls now it is very
- 51:45hard to speculate on why someone would
- 51:47do something like that but at this time
- 51:50it would have been daylight in that area
- 51:51and the weather was clear so it is
- 51:53possible that this was done to look out
- 51:55for ships in the area nearby as a
- 51:58reassurance that the aircraft's final
- 52:00resting place would not be seen the bfo
- 52:04from the inmas data indicated that the
- 52:05aircraft could have been in a very steep
- 52:07descend during the last log on handshake
- 52:09as high as 14,500 ft per minute but that
- 52:13doesn't necessarily mean that it just
- 52:15Dove straight into the sea instead again
- 52:17according to the excellent report of
- 52:19Captain Bley and januk Mand there is a
- 52:22possibility that the right engine flamed
- 52:24out due to fuel starvation and that this
- 52:26led the person in charge to start the
- 52:28Apu and open the Crossfield valve to
- 52:31maximize the use of the remaining fuel
- 52:34the Apu standpipe sits a little bit
- 52:36lower in the tank than the engines does
- 52:39so that gives it a little bit more
- 52:40access to all available Fuel and the
- 52:43person in command could then have
- 52:44manually shut down the remaining engine
- 52:46to maximize the Apu use which would have
- 52:49given access to all flight controls and
- 52:51systems for as long as possible and also
- 52:54enable the flaps to be extended which
- 52:56would wouldn't be possible without
- 52:58either one engine or the Apu running
- 53:01when the last inmat log on was completed
- 53:03it lacked information from for example
- 53:05the inflight entertainment system which
- 53:07is logical if the aircraft was being
- 53:08powered by only the Apu since systems
- 53:11like the if would then have been shed to
- 53:14prioritize more important
- 53:16systems according to Captain bl's
- 53:18calculations the aircraft could have
- 53:20ended up either very close to the
- 53:22seventh Arc if it was in a rapid dive or
- 53:25as far as 60 7even nautical miles
- 53:27further south if the aircraft was flown
- 53:29to maximize its Glide and touch down
- 53:32with flaps 30 selected the whisper data
- 53:34showed a possible last position at time
- 53:360819 and 37 seconds and after that there
- 53:39were no more correlated anomalies found
- 53:42we do know that the aircraft crashed in
- 53:44the ocean in or near the already
- 53:46searched area because both internal and
- 53:48external parts of the aircraft have been
- 53:50found the confirmed piece of debris
- 53:53comes from a flapper on from the right
- 53:55hand Wing as well as multiple other
- 53:57components which are almost certainly
- 53:59coming from
- 54:00MH370 all of those pieces have been
- 54:02washed up along the coastlines of
- 54:04Eastern Africa and islands around by
- 54:06currents that can be tracked back to
- 54:08this general area and given that some of
- 54:11the debris found comes from inside of
- 54:13the aircraft it is likely that it broke
- 54:16up upon
- 54:18impact this horrific story have already
- 54:21led to improvements in tracking
- 54:23commercial aircraft over oceans longer
- 54:25life for emergency located transmitters
- 54:28and better ATC procedures for tracking
- 54:30aircraft but we can't lay this to rest
- 54:33before the wreckage is actually found
- 54:36again this is why I created this video
- 54:39linked below here in the description are
- 54:41two different theories outlining two new
- 54:44search areas outside of those already
- 54:47searched in the biggest search effort in
- 54:49aviation history one of those theories
- 54:51are based on the skill and knowledge of
- 54:53two veteran Tri 7 captains and the other
- 54:55on a L contested new application of
- 54:58existing Radio Data but data that has
- 55:01been recently proven to work following
- 55:03flights in other
- 55:08areas I am not here to judge what is
- 55:11right or wrong the only thing that I
- 55:12want to achieve is to get the search
- 55:14going again for the sake of the families
- 55:17left behind so here are two relatively
- 55:20small new areas to search please get the
- 55:23boats out there and let's get to the
- 55:25bottom of of this literally
- 55:40[Music]
- 55:49[Music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of A NEW Trace! The FULL MH370 Story, so Far.. by Mentour Pilot, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,212 words across 1,420 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.