A Dangerous Decaf Video: Health and Brew Science — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00what's up everyone Lance Hedrick here in
- 0:02today's video we are talking about
- 0:04decaffeinated coffee now this is a long
- 0:06time coming I've been wanting to talk
- 0:08about decaf and especially how you can
- 0:10Brew it how you can optimize your
- 0:11Brewing at home and considering I've
- 0:13been drinking a lot more decaf lately
- 0:15some really Banger decafs figured it was
- 0:17time to do that also recently my friend
- 0:20James Hoffman posted a video I'll link
- 0:22right there on decaf and he's about to
- 0:24start a decaf project where he's going
- 0:26to different facilities different plants
- 0:28in order to look at different decaf
- 0:30processes so I figured now is a good
- 0:32time to kind of follow up on his video
- 0:34do my own video do kind of my angle on
- 0:36what I like to talk about the way I like
- 0:38to talk about things and we're going to
- 0:39do a little Deep dive onto the science
- 0:41of it the health of it and how to brew
- 0:43it near the end now what really kind of
- 0:45started my desire the dopamine hit for
- 0:48me to do this video was not just the
- 0:50amount of request to show how to brew it
- 0:52but was the fact that California
- 0:54recently has been attempting to ban the
- 0:56use of dimethyl chloride in decaf coffee
- 1:02what are the implications for me so
- 1:04let's first go back and kind of
- 1:06understand how decaf started in the
- 1:07early 1900s around 1903 1904 a German
- 1:11man discovered how to make decaf by
- 1:13taking acids and bases and using those
- 1:15to steam green coffee and then in order
- 1:17to leech out the caffeine he used
- 1:20Benzene brilliant idea something we
- 1:23definitely want in our bodies in those
- 1:24doses well because they figured out that
- 1:26wasn't very healthy for you they then
- 1:29decided a few years later in like the
- 1:301920s or so to instead of benzene use of
- 1:35course chloroform yeah the stuff that
- 1:37you can knock people out with they use
- 1:39that and instead of knocking people out
- 1:41they knocked out the caffeine all good
- 1:43to go right no so then they went to tr
- 1:46chloroethylene wrongo and then in the
- 1:49mid 20th century we kind of stumbled
- 1:51upon dimethyl chloride now this is
- 1:54available in massive quantities cuz the
- 1:55demand is high it's used in a lot of
- 1:57different Industries so it's cheap it's
- 1:59effective it's easy and it sucks out
- 2:00that caffeine without any issue and
- 2:03we've been using that since the 50s
- 2:04essentially in most coffees that has
- 2:06been the of majority of the world's
- 2:09decaf since about the ' 50s you take
- 2:11green coffee you steam it you toss in
- 2:14some of that dimethyl chloride and bada
- 2:16bing bada boom you get that caffeine out
- 2:18repeat as necessary get as much as you
- 2:19want out really and you got some decaf
- 2:21all right you got that caffeine
- 2:23extracted you're good to
- 2:25go until California decided to invoke
- 2:29propos position 65 which does rightly
- 2:31show that diyl chloride is a dangerous
- 2:34thing to have ingested in massive
- 2:37quantities to help you understand this
- 2:38the amount of that chemical that is
- 2:40allowed in coffees and roasted coffees
- 2:43per the FDA is 10 parts per million so
- 2:45what that means essentially is a coffee
- 2:47roaster and 1 kilogram of coffee is
- 2:49allowed to have 10 mg of this substance
- 2:53and the EPA says that a person a normal
- 2:55human being can take up to 6 milligram
- 2:58per kilogram they weigh per day
- 3:00so you are way in the clear if you're
- 3:02anywhere near that FDA standard which of
- 3:04course are they really enforcing this
- 3:06with all the specialty Roasters etc etc
- 3:08but I digress even still you can have an
- 3:12pretty absurd amount of decaf day that
- 3:14was created with dimethyl chloride and
- 3:16be absolutely fine according to the the
- 3:19health experts in the US now I can't
- 3:21speak for the rest of the world as far
- 3:23as the the the limits on it but in
- 3:25general gcaf has Next To None in it it's
- 3:28not really going to do anything to to
- 3:29you well of course if California ends up
- 3:32Banning the use of it and coffee then
- 3:34you can have violations as early as 2027
- 3:36if you go against that ban which will
- 3:38make prices of decaf Skyrocket in
- 3:39California making it inaccessible to a
- 3:41lot of people who may need it now we
- 3:43know that there's a ton of health
- 3:44benefits to coffee so a lot of people
- 3:46should be able to have access to it it
- 3:48has a really high level of antioxidants
- 3:50chlorogenic acids and what's interesting
- 3:52is in the past few years there's been a
- 3:54lot of effort in the scholarship world
- 3:56to kind of see what the relationship is
- 3:58between coffee and health benefits some
- 4:01of the things that you've probably seen
- 4:02online or read in some news articles or
- 4:04read in some research papers is the fact
- 4:06that coffee can actually help with
- 4:08Parkinson's with cancer with liver
- 4:10disease and with Diabetes Type 2 malius
- 4:13but it also has the capability of
- 4:15fighting off some viruses there was one
- 4:17interesting paper that was looking at
- 4:18the chlorogenic acid levels in coffee
- 4:21and seeing its neurom minase inhibitory
- 4:23activity and how it can combat some of
- 4:25these viruses so there's a plethora of
- 4:28health reasons why you should take take
- 4:29your coffee just like you take a
- 4:31supplement or a multivitamin now talking
- 4:33about those chlorogenic acids one more
- 4:35time before moving on it's interesting
- 4:37because I have found in all the research
- 4:39papers I read over these past few weeks
- 4:41up above a dozen there was no real
- 4:43consensus on if there was more
- 4:44chlorogenic acid in decaffeinated coffee
- 4:47or in regular coffee there have been
- 4:49some people say there's more chlorogenic
- 4:51acid in the decaf which means that
- 4:52there's arguably more antioxidants and
- 4:54more benefits to that and some who say
- 4:56it's more regular I will say the
- 4:58majority of the papers I read say it's
- 5:00more so in regular but I think it does
- 5:03boil down to what process you're using
- 5:05and how dark you're roasting it those
- 5:06have direct correlations with those
- 5:09levels inside the coffee itself now
- 5:11chlorogenic acid is a very interesting
- 5:13thing because the presence of it can
- 5:16relate to the bitterness of the coffee
- 5:18more chlorogenic acids means more
- 5:21lactones produced during the roasting
- 5:22which lactones are bitter chlorogenic
- 5:25acids themselves are not bitter but they
- 5:26do produce the lactones which
- 5:28chlorogenic acid lactones are better so
- 5:30it is interesting to look at chlorogenic
- 5:33acid in their levels but like I said
- 5:35making a decisive decision on whether or
- 5:37not there's more in decaf or regular
- 5:39whether it's green or roasted is
- 5:41difficult people are definitely split
- 5:42across the board because there are lots
- 5:44of different measurements and I've seen
- 5:46some say it's 10% Less in decaf I've
- 5:48seen some people say it's 10% more in
- 5:50decaf who's right I don't really know
- 5:53who really cares let's just move on but
- 5:55of course with all those good things
- 5:57come the bad which is the caffeine and
- 5:59caffeine can cause insomnia it can cause
- 6:00an irritated stomach it can elevate your
- 6:02respiratory rate and your heart rate and
- 6:04a lot of people have low sensitivities
- 6:05to those that need decaffeinated coffee
- 6:08if they're going to get those benefits
- 6:10which they should be able to and if this
- 6:12goes to pass in California it's going to
- 6:15become a lot more inaccessible for a lot
- 6:16more people now speaking of that
- 6:18insomnia it's something I've talked
- 6:19about having and a lot of people are
- 6:20like well it's cu the caffeine you drink
- 6:22well that may be the case but because
- 6:24I'm not going to stop drinking coffee
- 6:25anytime soon I decided to look into
- 6:27other areas where I could benefit my own
- 6:29health and that's where it comes to the
- 6:31sponsor of today's video which is train
- 6:35well hey well here's the fun fact about
- 6:38me I actually used to work out quite a
- 6:40bit take a little ganner at that beauty
- 6:42right there when I was in my Super
- 6:43Saiyan era well it's been a while since
- 6:45I've actually worked out and I figured
- 6:47I'm not sleeping very well having some
- 6:49issues so let's get back on the pony
- 6:51well I've done that with train well
- 6:52through trawell you get partnered up
- 6:54with a personal trainer one-on-one and
- 6:56through the app you can connect with
- 6:58them chat with them and guess what it's
- 7:00fantastic I've been having an incredible
- 7:02time over these past 6 weeks getting
- 7:03back into
- 7:06shape obviously there are loads of
- 7:08benefits to working out not only can you
- 7:11protect yourself from against injury but
- 7:12you can also improve your mental and
- 7:13physical wellness and how are things
- 7:15going so far going well with this train
- 7:18wall app I've been able to have constant
- 7:19contact with my trainer and he makes all
- 7:21these workout plans for me easy peasy
- 7:23lemon squeezy I don't have to think
- 7:25about it I just get on the app click go
- 7:27and I start working out everything's out
- 7:29right right there for me thank you Rod
- 7:31this has been an absolute Game Changer
- 7:32in my everyday life not having to stress
- 7:35having someone do the planning for me
- 7:36and just getting to get in get the work
- 7:38done and continue living my life on an
- 7:40elevated plane now since working out my
- 7:42Sleep Quality has increased dramatically
- 7:44I went from the beginning about 3 to 4
- 7:46hours a night to getting almost s every
- 7:48single night with a high quality of
- 7:50sleep that's pretty
- 7:52great if you want to try doing something
- 7:55like this for 14 days for free your own
- 7:57trainer check out the link down below
- 7:59where at says go. TRW well.net ledric
- 8:03maybe you'll start doing things like
- 8:06[Music]
- 8:08this so thank you trawell for sponsoring
- 8:11this video and getting me back in
- 8:15shape so what are these different
- 8:17processes we have swiss water which is
- 8:19literally taking green coffee soaking it
- 8:21in water until the thing all the goods
- 8:23extract out and then they put that
- 8:25extracted through a carbon filter which
- 8:27takes away the caffeine and they kind of
- 8:29keep reusing that water over and over in
- 8:31order to decaffeinate the coffees this
- 8:33is probably the most sustainable way of
- 8:35doing decaffeination but it's not cheap
- 8:38in order to get that coffee done that
- 8:40way it's got to be shipped to the
- 8:41specific plants in order to do it and
- 8:43it's not the cheapest way so when you
- 8:45buy a Swiss water coffee they tend to be
- 8:47a bit more expensive though the quality
- 8:48is quite nice in fact personally I
- 8:51really really really enjoy Swiss water
- 8:53decaf African coffees some of the best
- 8:56decafs I've ever had have been Swiss
- 8:57water processed Ethiopia coffee
- 9:00absolutely chef's kiss now when you look
- 9:02at ethylacetate and other solvent-based
- 9:04decaffeination processes like dimethyl
- 9:06chloride what they're doing is they're
- 9:08kind of steaming the coffee and then
- 9:09they're hitting it with whatever solvent
- 9:11they're using in order to extract out
- 9:13the caffeine with ethylacetate it's
- 9:15obviously using eth acetate now the way
- 9:18that they get it a lot of times you'll
- 9:19hear kind of the term sugar cane
- 9:21processing that's because a very common
- 9:23way of getting ethylacetate is by
- 9:25fermenting sugar cane when they ferment
- 9:27the sugar cane you get out ethanol and
- 9:30another byproduct is acetic acid put
- 9:32those together ethylacetate and then
- 9:34they're able to suck out that caffeine
- 9:36using that so you have a similar thing
- 9:38going on they put it in the water they
- 9:39steam it they pull it out kind of like
- 9:41they did with Benzene but not with acids
- 9:42and bases they use water and ethyl
- 9:44acetate so a lot of people say it's the
- 9:45natural process because it all is all
- 9:47kind of natural but they definitely use
- 9:49chemicals in it technically so it does
- 9:52have a chemical aspect to it that being
- 9:54said it's absolutely delicious no issue
- 9:57at all healthwise cuz even at the of it
- 9:59they steam it again it's so far away
- 10:01from being at any threshold for it to
- 10:03even have a speck of issue when it comes
- 10:05to health that literally there's there's
- 10:08even as little issue as dimethyl
- 10:10chloride could potentially be this is
- 10:11like a 100 times even safer you also
- 10:14have the super critical CO2 which is
- 10:16doing a similar thing but they're using
- 10:18CO2 which is in like a gaseous and
- 10:20liquid form in order to take out that
- 10:21caffeine and good to go it makes the
- 10:24coffee actually quite dark all these
- 10:25processes make the green beans quite
- 10:27dark they look pretty brown when you're
- 10:29done but the CO2 process even more so
- 10:32makes coffee look very Brown and then of
- 10:34course we have the triglyceride process
- 10:36which is one that was very unfamiliar to
- 10:38me before I did this research this one
- 10:40literally is taking coffee oils as
- 10:42opposed to these other solvents in order
- 10:43to leech out the caffeine all very
- 10:45interesting and all very scientifically
- 10:47driven but what tastes the best honestly
- 10:50in my experience I have found that my
- 10:52the ones I have enjoyed the most tend to
- 10:54have been Swiss water and ethyl acetate
- 10:57when it comes to Central American
- 10:58coffees I found ethylacetate to be just
- 11:00absolutely Stellar some of my favorite
- 11:02coffees have been Columbia coffees that
- 11:04have used the sugar can process whereas
- 11:06like I said with African coffees Swiss
- 11:08water has been absolutely spot-on for me
- 11:10and so overall those are the ones I've
- 11:12gravitated towards I can't say I've ever
- 11:14had triglyceride and I've only had a
- 11:16couple of the CO2 super critical CO2 and
- 11:18then as far as dimethyl chloride they
- 11:20tend to have all just been just just not
- 11:22good they they're honestly they're not
- 11:25really used in the specialty coffee
- 11:26world people are usually using these
- 11:28more alternative processes that are a
- 11:30bit more sustainable a bit a bit better
- 11:31to get because making dimethyl chloride
- 11:33is not necessarily the greatest thing in
- 11:35the world especially when you have
- 11:36Alternatives like sugar cane process or
- 11:39especially Swiss water which is the most
- 11:43sustainable now let's move into
- 11:46pragmatics how you should Brew decaf at
- 11:48home this stuff that might kill you um
- 11:51no it won't there have been loads of
- 11:52issues I've noticed on Reddit on home
- 11:54Barista at coffee shops talking with
- 11:57other professionals everywhere you have
- 11:59the these issues with decaffeinated
- 12:00coffee you see people freaking out cuz
- 12:02they can't dial in their espresso they
- 12:04can't go fine enough it it runs too
- 12:05quickly but on the opposite side you
- 12:07have people doing pour overs and they
- 12:08say it clogs really easily the beds are
- 12:11super muddy so what's going on well
- 12:13obviously there are massive structural
- 12:14changes going on in any of these
- 12:16decaffeinated processes some more than
- 12:18others of course but chemically the
- 12:20structure is absolutely changing which
- 12:23is going to affect the grinding Dynamics
- 12:25as well as the Brewing Dynamics that's
- 12:27an incontrovertible fact dur during the
- 12:29decaffeination process regardless of the
- 12:31process you use there are soluble
- 12:33compounds that are being pulled out
- 12:35which will affect the flavor but also
- 12:37that structure as well as other things
- 12:38that are happening inside of the beam
- 12:40itself now I want to point out a very
- 12:42interesting post made by Dr Mark alarie
- 12:46now he actually decided I want to I want
- 12:48to see objectively what's going on of
- 12:50course he didn't have a big enough
- 12:51sample size of different coffees for it
- 12:53to be kind of the final say but I think
- 12:56it's very interesting his results so
- 12:58first of all what he took was a
- 12:59Colombian coffee that was a mix of
- 13:01Castillo and Cur and he had the same lot
- 13:04decaffeinated and washed with this he
- 13:06did five different roasts of each he was
- 13:09looking at the behavior with roasting
- 13:11and the behavior with grinding now my
- 13:13long-standing hypothesis on grinding eaf
- 13:15coffee is that it produces more fines
- 13:17due to a more brittle structure and that
- 13:18therefore it causes a lot of that
- 13:19stalling a lot of that clogging Etc
- 13:21what's interesting is he found that
- 13:24across all five samples of the decafs
- 13:26and the regulars that there was a 4%
- 13:29increase in the share of fines for
- 13:31decaffeinated coffees as well as a lower
- 13:33median particle average across set bur
- 13:37apertures now I'll have this link below
- 13:39so you can check out the data but what
- 13:40that means is he took an ek43 at
- 13:43settings 2 4 and 6 he ground coffee at
- 13:45decaf and the regular through each of
- 13:48those settings and he used a particle
- 13:50size analyzer that was a laser not an
- 13:52Imaging unit Imaging units historically
- 13:54are not good at that seeing things below
- 13:5630 microns as well as a laser which is
- 13:59fantastic at it so he used a laser in
- 14:02order to check out those teeny tiny
- 14:04little bitty baby particles and there
- 14:06seemed to be a 4% increase as well as a
- 14:08decrease in the actual median Peak so
- 14:10what's really interesting here is not
- 14:12only do you have a higher fraction of
- 14:13finds but you have a lower medium Peak
- 14:16particle this is interesting I saw one
- 14:18specific post that were saying they
- 14:20typically grind on their Niche zero at
- 14:2218 for typical coffees when they switch
- 14:24to decaf from the same rooster they have
- 14:26to go to 14 so if they went at 18 we
- 14:29would expect it to have a smaller medium
- 14:31Peak particle already and we would
- 14:34expect more fines already yet he's still
- 14:37has to go a lot finer which means that
- 14:39decaf coffees need to be ground
- 14:41substantially finer not just with a peak
- 14:43particle but also with the the share of
- 14:46fines in order for it to run in a
- 14:49typical time what it makes me think is
- 14:52that because those grounds are obviously
- 14:54not causing back pressure well enough on
- 14:56their own is that there must be a
- 14:58massive decrease in the prevalence of
- 15:00CO2 and decaf coffee now of course you
- 15:03can have freshly roasted coffee and
- 15:04it'll have more CO2 than as it ages but
- 15:07it seems that decaf coffee ages
- 15:09incredibly incredibly quickly he looks
- 15:12at the macro porous structure of the
- 15:14green samples of decaf and of regular
- 15:16and it seems that macro porously they
- 15:18look about the same but it doesn't take
- 15:20into account the micro or even the
- 15:22nanoporous structure of these beans and
- 15:24on top of that it doesn't show what it
- 15:26looks like post roasting talking with Dr
- 15:28smirk he was saying that it defin it
- 15:31seems that the pores would open up as
- 15:33it's roasted so a roasted decaf Bean
- 15:35perhaps is losing CO2 at a much faster
- 15:38rate than the counterpart regular in
- 15:41addition to this what's interesting is
- 15:42in in a paper by Dr SM as well as Andre
- 15:45Airman when they were looking at
- 15:46different capsules from different
- 15:48manufacturers they found that across the
- 15:50board decaf coffees were Ground much
- 15:52more coarsely and that's because if they
- 15:54grounded the same median particle Peak
- 15:56as they did with regular the capsule
- 15:59would stall so we have all this
- 16:01conflicting information when you grind
- 16:03it it actually goes it shifts finer so
- 16:06at the same set aperture you have finer
- 16:08grounds and more fines which in your
- 16:10mind would give you more resistance but
- 16:13when we're pulling espresso we have to
- 16:15go even finer than the same as the
- 16:17regular we have to go way finer that's
- 16:19really weird but then in pods they
- 16:21realized that it clogs whenever you go
- 16:23too fine or if you match regular so they
- 16:26go coarser hm what's going on
- 16:29I'll be honest with you I don't really
- 16:30know I have hypothesis I have
- 16:32speculations but in the end it's
- 16:34anecdotal and it's based strictly off of
- 16:36what I think is happening and so I'm
- 16:37going to I'm going to offer that but of
- 16:39course this is just based off of
- 16:40experience as well as what kind of seems
- 16:43like the right thing what I have noticed
- 16:45as I said earlier is in pour-overs you
- 16:47tend to have clogging and a lot of
- 16:48people have noticed this I'm not alone
- 16:50in this when you do too many pores with
- 16:51decaf or if you agitate it too much if
- 16:53you stir it or whatever it clogs and it
- 16:55clogs hard if you sometimes if I'll do
- 16:59one extra pour boom it's stalled and I
- 17:00just have to take off and waste the last
- 17:02bit of the coffee inside the dripper but
- 17:04with espresso it'll fly out in like 15
- 17:07seconds sometimes at the same bur
- 17:09aperture as a similar coffee it it just
- 17:11flies but if you notice if you ever pull
- 17:14decaf and you let it run for 40 or 50
- 17:16seconds just let water keep going
- 17:17through you'll see that flow restricts
- 17:19more and more and more and more and I'm
- 17:21imagining that's because the fines clog
- 17:23more and more it seems that there isn't
- 17:25enough back pressure inside of that to
- 17:27go against that 9 bar extraction and so
- 17:30it goes through really quickly and you
- 17:31have to compensate by going incredibly
- 17:33powdery in order to hit it some of you
- 17:36may not be able to go fine enough to hit
- 17:37typical parameters with the decaf you
- 17:39use so I'm thinking that perhaps there's
- 17:42just lower CO2 content if you're if
- 17:45you're using a weak or more off roast
- 17:47decaf coffee it also deases really
- 17:49quickly which takes away that back back
- 17:51pressure which gives you less resistance
- 17:53which is going to lessen the pressure
- 17:54and make the flow rate a lot higher
- 17:55through it but there are a lot of findes
- 17:57in there and the more quickly they can
- 17:58migrate through like in a pod which is
- 18:00not packed very intensely not like a
- 18:02tamped puck and so the fines can
- 18:04immediately clog that the orifice that's
- 18:06leading out because it's not a full
- 18:08basket like an espresso so I'm thinking
- 18:10that what's happening is you have a lot
- 18:11of findes migration like you do in the
- 18:13POR overs which causes clogged filters I
- 18:16think that's what's going on when we're
- 18:17looking at the effects across these
- 18:19different Brewing
- 18:21apparati maybe a bit confusing but
- 18:23hopefully this is going to kind of help
- 18:24you when you're approaching these things
- 18:26so what I recommend when you're actually
- 18:28brewing your coffee when you're Brewing
- 18:29decaf coffee is to first off I've
- 18:32noticed always lower temperature rain
- 18:34Supreme even on the lightest decaf you
- 18:36find I never go above 90° C I'm staying
- 18:39quite low on the temperature now yes
- 18:41more chlorogenic acids will come out
- 18:43with the higher temperature water and
- 18:44the longer contact time but like I said
- 18:47I mean if you're drinking solely for
- 18:49chlorogenic acids okay whatever go with
- 18:51boiling water and steam the M Mish out
- 18:53of it but if you're going for Taste
- 18:56lower temperature is going to do a lot
- 18:57better and it's my thinking that because
- 18:59we have already taken out a lot of the
- 19:01soluble compounds during the
- 19:02decaffeination process there's just not
- 19:04that much to give if you push the
- 19:06extraction too hard you're going to get
- 19:07a lot more uh of the bitter side of the
- 19:10equation probably a lot more stringency
- 19:11and things like that and in this picture
- 19:14here what you're going to see is this is
- 19:15the same coffee roasted at the same
- 19:17temperature at the same Inlet Air at the
- 19:19same time look how much more dark that
- 19:21decaf looks I mean that's that's a lot
- 19:24darker granted the color variation is
- 19:26much tighter than it is with the lighter
- 19:28roasted coffee but even still look how
- 19:30much darker that is it caramelizes a lot
- 19:32more quickly it's a lot darker in color
- 19:33it's going to have a lot more bitterness
- 19:35that will be imbued because of that so
- 19:37this is what's happening with these
- 19:38decaf coffees they're going to have that
- 19:40inherent bitterness due to how they're
- 19:42being roasted which is a necessity you
- 19:44have to roast a little differently and
- 19:45again that's in some of the things I'll
- 19:47link below if you want to read more into
- 19:49it but I recommend doing a lower
- 19:51temperature in addition I like doing
- 19:53lower ratios and this again goes to the
- 19:55fact that there's a lot less goodies to
- 19:57extract now let's say we have 20 G of a
- 20:00regular coffee that has 20 G worth of
- 20:02incredible goodies in it well decaf it
- 20:04takes away a lot of that 20 G goodies so
- 20:08with decaf in 20 gram we probably have
- 20:1075% of the goodies so we increase the
- 20:12dose in order to match the amount of
- 20:14goodies we get in that 20 gram of course
- 20:16it's not going to be the same like I
- 20:18said chemical structures solubles gone a
- 20:20lot of the Aromas precursors for Aromas
- 20:22are gone so you're not you just can't
- 20:24have the same potential into caffeinated
- 20:26coffee versus the caffeinated
- 20:27counterpart but increasing the dose will
- 20:30help as well another big thing I
- 20:33recommend is smaller doses I know that
- 20:36sounds contradictory but what I mean is
- 20:39doing smaller recipes so instead of
- 20:41doing 20 gram to 320 gram and say I need
- 20:44more coffee make it a 25 gr dose to 320
- 20:47gam instead of doing that start at like
- 20:5010 to 160 which is the same ratio but up
- 20:54dosing like 12 to 160 or 14 to 160 and
- 20:57the reason I say this is the deeper that
- 20:59bed is the more coffee that's in that
- 21:02the more fines potential there is when
- 21:04you look at the filter the difference
- 21:05from here to here is not much as far as
- 21:07the exiting so it's going to clog a lot
- 21:09more easily the more coffee you put in
- 21:11there and you want to have a seamless
- 21:13draw down the longer contact time the
- 21:15more bitter and drying the coffee will
- 21:17inevitably get so I like to use a little
- 21:19bit smaller doses maybe 12 14 G maybe 15
- 21:22G and a V60 I never really go over that
- 21:25though and if you're experiencing
- 21:26difficulties Brewing big batches of
- 21:28decaf that's probably why it doesn't
- 21:30want to drain through and it's going to
- 21:31be stalling out and it's just not going
- 21:33to have a good time another thing that I
- 21:35recommend is grinding just a little bit
- 21:36more coarsely and again that's because
- 21:38of the potential findes increase so we
- 21:41want to be careful with how we're
- 21:42Brewing it we don't want to go way too
- 21:44coarse and have a lot of Boulders and a
- 21:45lot of fines and have this weird multi-
- 21:47extraction thing that doesn't taste very
- 21:49good but we want to grind maybe a little
- 21:51bit coarser than you would with regular
- 21:53coffee and then the last thing I would
- 21:55say is fewer pores SL less agitation
- 21:58maybe even try a single poure I'm not a
- 22:00big fan of those but honestly with decaf
- 22:02it's just a different Beast you may not
- 22:04need to De gas it nearly as much the
- 22:06water should be able to access the beans
- 22:07a lot more quickly because there's a lot
- 22:09less CO2 the comparatively and my again
- 22:14that's anecdotal it's based off of
- 22:16experience and looking at it the bloom
- 22:17is a lot less when you're Brewing
- 22:18espresso there a lot less Crema a lot
- 22:20less back pressure etc etc but because
- 22:22of that maybe just do a single pore or
- 22:23do two pores and don't really swirl
- 22:26don't do much crazy stuff maybe you can
- 22:28do a spin in order to allow the slurry
- 22:30to spin as it goes down to force fines
- 22:32into the upper parts of the filter but
- 22:34other than that I wouldn't do too much
- 22:37aggressive agitation but all these
- 22:39things kind of combined are really going
- 22:40to help you with your filter coffee as
- 22:42regards espresso this is going to be
- 22:44really difficult cuz you need to
- 22:45completely reframe espresso in your mind
- 22:47you are not going to get tasty shots
- 22:50chasing traditional recipes this is the
- 22:52same thing if you were to switch from
- 22:54araba to Robusta or something along
- 22:56those lines you need to approach d
- 22:58differently decaffeinated coffee will
- 23:00not extract the same way as caffeinated
- 23:03so why would you treat it the same way
- 23:04in chasing the same ratio and the same
- 23:06time I would highly recommend doing
- 23:08shorter shots and when I mean shorter I
- 23:10mean a smaller ratio and faster times
- 23:13they're going to be a lot tastier you're
- 23:15not going to get the body but really the
- 23:17only way to get a heavy body decaf shot
- 23:19is if you're drinking super dark roast
- 23:21that's really fresh or really just any
- 23:23really fresh decaf which leads me to my
- 23:26final bit of advice when you find a you
- 23:28like buy it as fresh off roast as
- 23:31possible and freeze it almost
- 23:33immediately and then grind off Frozen
- 23:36this is going to help you enjoy your
- 23:38decaf a lot longer decaf ages so quickly
- 23:41and you'll begin to get that kind of
- 23:42meaty taste on the palette really
- 23:45quickly after even with the lightest of
- 23:47decaf roasts within 2 weeks you have
- 23:49meat you don't want that meaty flavor I
- 23:51don't know what the meaty flavor is it's
- 23:53really Grosso and you don't want it
- 23:54maybe single dose them into like
- 23:55airtight containers or you know V seal
- 23:58them or something but do something to
- 24:00get them in the freezer immediately in
- 24:02your freezing when time and then just
- 24:03use it as you're going on and that's
- 24:05going to give you the best experience
- 24:06with decaf you can
- 24:10have if you want more pointed recipes on
- 24:13decaf I would recommend usually a 1 to
- 24:1615 ratio I would recommend usually a
- 24:19below 90° C if you're on the really
- 24:21light end of the spectrum with roast
- 24:23then maybe you're around 89 888 if
- 24:25you're a darker roast lover and there
- 24:27it's a darker decaf Maybe around 82 83
- 24:2984 and focus on that 1 to 15 ratio focus
- 24:32on getting a quicker draw down and don't
- 24:35focus on agitation don't focus on those
- 24:37things get a little coarser grounds
- 24:38don't go crazy though but get a little
- 24:40coarser than you would for your typical
- 24:42pourover that you like at home for
- 24:43espresso again for more specific pointed
- 24:46recipes for lighter coffees do maybe a 1
- 24:48to2 ratio and go shoot for like that 18
- 24:51to 20 second time if you're doing a
- 24:53darker roasted coffee if you can lower
- 24:55the temperature do that but also shoot
- 24:57for something like a one to one or a 1
- 24:59to one and a half and you will find a
- 25:01lot more pleasant experiences in your
- 25:04Chase for a tasty decaf shot and again
- 25:07don't be bound by time 15 seconds may be
- 25:09delicious you may just be losing out on
- 25:11some of that texture so I guess for the
- 25:13people who enjoy darker coffees you have
- 25:14to ask yourself do you want texture or
- 25:16do you want taste if you want texture
- 25:18needs to be right off roast and you need
- 25:20to get that 1 to one and a half in like
- 25:2125 seconds that's great just may not
- 25:23taste nearly as good as if you were to
- 25:25let it go through a little bit faster
- 25:27but anyway anyway I think that hits all
- 25:29that I wanted to hit today on decaf I
- 25:32hope it was a nice overview and maybe a
- 25:33little refresher of some of the things
- 25:34that you may have already known maybe
- 25:36you learn some new things again like I
- 25:37always do with videos like this I'll put
- 25:39a lot of the research papers that I used
- 25:41in constructing this video down below as
- 25:43well as some helpful links now if you
- 25:45enjoy the content if you enjoy the
- 25:46amount of effort I put into these videos
- 25:48if you enjoy this video please hit the
- 25:49like hit the Subscribe turn on the
- 25:51notifications all that good stuff check
- 25:53out my patreon down below my second
- 25:55YouTube all that stuff regardless I
- 25:57really appreciate you staying with me
- 25:58this whole time thanks for watching the
- 26:00video and I hope that you bre something
- 26:02tasty today cheers
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of A Dangerous Decaf Video: Health and Brew Science by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,455 words across 754 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.