A 1971 Abductee Exposed What Aliens Harvest From Humans — It’s Far Worse Than We Were Told — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00In 1971, a 43-year-old grain farmer
- 0:03named Harold Wexler walked out of a
- 0:05field in rural Nebraska and told his
- 0:07wife he'd lost 4 hours.
- 0:10That's it.
- 0:11That's the whole story, or so it seemed.
- 0:15But Harold also came back changed,
- 0:17quieter, thinner,
- 0:19with marks on his forearms no doctor
- 0:21could explain, and a terror of sleeping
- 0:24that lasted until his death in 1994.
- 0:28He never sought fame. He never sold his
- 0:30story. He filed one report with one
- 0:32investigator and then went silent.
- 0:35That silence, I've come to believe, is
- 0:38exactly where the truth begins.
- 0:40I want to start with Harold Wexler, not
- 0:42because his case is the most dramatic.
- 0:44It isn't. But because it's the most
- 0:47ordinary. And ordinary cases in this
- 0:49field of research are the ones that tend
- 0:52to survive scrutiny.
- 0:54It was August 14th, 1971.
- 0:57Harold had been walking the eastern edge
- 0:59of his property near Colfax County,
- 1:02checking on drainage after a wet week.
- 1:05His wife, Dorothy, expected him back by
- 1:07noon.
- 1:08He returned at 4:17 in the afternoon. He
- 1:11had no explanation for the missing time.
- 1:14He wasn't drunk. He wasn't disoriented
- 1:16in the way you'd expect from a fall or a
- 1:18medical episode. He was calm. Eerily
- 1:22calm. Dorothy described it later as him
- 1:25looking like a man who had just been
- 1:26told something very important and was
- 1:29still deciding what to do with the
- 1:31information.
- 1:33Within 2 weeks, Harold began
- 1:34experiencing what his family physician,
- 1:37Dr. Raymond Kessler of Schuyler,
- 1:39Nebraska, called anomalous
- 1:41dermatological presentations.
- 1:44Three parallel marks on his left
- 1:46forearm, a circular depression, roughly
- 1:492 cm in diameter, on the inside of his
- 1:52right wrist.
- 1:55Kessler noted these in Harold's medical
- 1:57records, records which, I should
- 1:59mention, went missing from the Colfax
- 2:02County Rural Medical Archive sometime
- 2:05between 1989
- 2:07and 1991.
- 2:10The archive itself was reorganized
- 2:12during that period.
- 2:14The official explanation for the missing
- 2:16files, a water damage event in the
- 2:18basement storage facility,
- 2:20a single event,
- 2:22that managed to affect records from
- 2:24exactly three patients, all of whom had
- 2:26reported unusual experiences in the
- 2:29summer of 1971.
- 2:32That's where the official explanation
- 2:34starts to thin.
- 2:37Harold eventually agreed to speak with a
- 2:39researcher named Carol Ann Spach, a
- 2:41civilian investigator affiliated with
- 2:44the Midwest Phenomenological Research
- 2:46Group, a small, underfunded organization
- 2:49that operated out of Omaha from 1968 to
- 2:531983.
- 2:55Anspach recorded four sessions with
- 2:57Harold between November 1971 and March
- 3:011972.
- 3:03In those recordings, which I've spent
- 3:04considerable time reviewing, Harold
- 3:07doesn't talk about spaceships. He
- 3:09doesn't describe little gray men with
- 3:10oversized eyes, the way popular culture
- 3:13would later teach us to expect.
- 3:16He describes light, a specific kind of
- 3:18light, and he describes a process.
- 3:21"They were doing something to the inside
- 3:23of me," Harold says in the third
- 3:25session. "Not cutting, not like surgery,
- 3:29more like draining. Like they wanted
- 3:32something out of me, and they were being
- 3:34very careful not to spill it. Draining."
- 3:38That word has stayed with me.
- 3:40And it should stay with you, too,
- 3:42because as I went further into this, and
- 3:44I mean much further, further than I
- 3:46initially intended, that word begins
- 3:49appearing again, and again, and again.
- 3:51Across cases, across decades, across
- 3:55continents.
- 3:57Let me tell you about a woman named
- 3:59Ingrid Solberg, Oslo, Norway, February
- 4:031973.
- 4:05Ingrid was a 31-year-old school teacher
- 4:07who reported a missing time event during
- 4:09a late-night drive on route E18 between
- 4:13Drammen and Oslo.
- 4:15She described pulling over to inspect
- 4:17what she thought was a disabled vehicle
- 4:19on the road shoulder.
- 4:21The next thing she remembered was
- 4:22sitting in her car, engine running, 2
- 4:25hours and 40 minutes later, with no
- 4:28vehicle on the road and no other cars in
- 4:30sight.
- 4:32Ingrid's case was documented by
- 4:34Norwegian journalist and amateur
- 4:36investigator Torsten Blithe, who
- 4:39interviewed her extensively throughout
- 4:401973 and 1974.
- 4:44What Blithe recorded, and what was
- 4:46eventually translated into English
- 4:48through a 1979 monograph published by
- 4:51the European Anomalous Experience
- 4:52Society,
- 4:54was striking not for its drama, but for
- 4:56its specificity.
- 4:58Ingrid described, under a form of guided
- 5:00recall that Blithe facilitated,
- 5:03not hypnosis, I want to be clear about
- 5:05that, because the hypnosis question
- 5:07matters later,
- 5:08a sensation of what she called tumming,
- 5:11an emptying.
- 5:13She said the beings she encountered
- 5:15seemed primarily interested in something
- 5:17she produced,
- 5:19not blood, she was explicit about that,
- 5:21not tissue, something she described
- 5:24haltingly as closer to emotion,
- 5:27to feeling,
- 5:29but not in a metaphorical sense.
- 5:32She meant it literally.
- 5:34She believed they were collecting it.
- 5:37Now, at this point in my research, I
- 5:39filed this under suggestibility and
- 5:41cultural contamination.
- 5:43Two witnesses describing similar
- 5:45metaphors proves nothing.
- 5:47Metaphors are shared. Language is
- 5:50limited.
- 5:51People reach for the same words because
- 5:53the same words are available.
- 5:56But then, I found the Cali accounts.
- 5:59Between 1969 and 1977,
- 6:02a Colombian physician named Dr. Emilio
- 6:05Garza Mendez
- 6:07compiled what he privately called the
- 6:09Registro de Experiencias
- 6:11Anomalas.
- 6:13A registry of anomalous experiences
- 6:15drawn from patients and community
- 6:17members in and around the city of Cali.
- 6:21Garza Mendez was, by all accounts, a
- 6:23rational man.
- 6:25He was not a believer in the
- 6:26extraterrestrial hypothesis.
- 6:29He began his registry as a sociological
- 6:31exercise, attempting to document what he
- 6:34believed was a localized psychological
- 6:36phenomenon tied to social stress and
- 6:38political instability.
- 6:41He ended the registry in 1977,
- 6:44and he never published it.
- 6:46A copy of the registry, per carte, 214
- 6:49pages, handwritten bound, was discovered
- 6:52by a researcher named Felipe Oquendo in
- 6:552003, tucked inside a box of donated
- 6:58medical texts at the Universidad del
- 7:01Valle library.
- 7:03Oquendo shared portions of it with a
- 7:05small network of Latin American anomaly
- 7:07researchers,
- 7:08and eventually, a partial translation
- 7:11reached a researcher I was in contact
- 7:13with in 2019.
- 7:16What Garza Mendez found, across dozens
- 7:19of separate accounts gathered over
- 7:21nearly a decade from people who had no
- 7:23contact with each other, no access to
- 7:26American or European UFO literature,
- 7:29no television program seeding the
- 7:31narrative, was a pattern so consistent
- 7:34it eventually disturbed him enough to
- 7:35abandon the project entirely.
- 7:39He wrote in his final entry in November
- 7:411977.
- 7:43I cannot explain the uniformity.
- 7:46It is not possible that these people
- 7:48borrowing from one another.
- 7:50And yet they are all describing the same
- 7:52extraction.
- 7:54The same extraction.
- 7:56Garza Mendez's subjects described with
- 7:59varying levels of articulation a process
- 8:01by which something they identified as
- 8:03integral to their sense of self, not an
- 8:05organ, not blood, not any physical
- 8:07substance they could name
- 8:09was removed by beings who appeared
- 8:11either indifferent to or actively
- 8:13pleased by the process.
- 8:16Several subjects described the beings as
- 8:18purposeful
- 8:20efficient
- 8:21as if they had done this before
- 8:23many times before.
- 8:25And here's what I keep returning to.
- 8:28Garza Mendez was trying to debunk this.
- 8:30He wasn't collecting stories to confirm
- 8:32a theory.
- 8:33He was a skeptic gathering data that was
- 8:35supposed to evaporate under scrutiny.
- 8:38And instead it solidified.
- 8:41Once you see that tension the reluctant
- 8:43recorder, the inconvenient uniformity
- 8:47you can't look away from it.
- 8:49Carol Ann Spash finished her interviews
- 8:51with Harold Wexler in March 1972
- 8:55and spent the following 18 months
- 8:56cross-referencing what she documented
- 8:59against every accessible case file the
- 9:02Midwest Phenomenological Research Group
- 9:04had collected since 1968.
- 9:08In a 1974 internal memo, I've held a
- 9:11photocopy of this document obtained
- 9:14through a researcher who prefers not to
- 9:15be named, she wrote the following.
- 9:18The consistency of the extraction
- 9:20narrative is not explainable by cultural
- 9:22transmission in these cases.
- 9:25The subjects range from a Nebraska
- 9:26farmer to a Kansas City postal worker to
- 9:29a retired school teacher in Dubuque.
- 9:32None of them read UFO publications. None
- 9:34of them had access to the Hynek studies
- 9:36at this time.
- 9:38What they share is not a vocabulary
- 9:39borrowed from science fiction. What they
- 9:41share is a description of a procedure.
- 9:45A procedure, Anspach presented her
- 9:47findings at a closed-door research
- 9:49gathering in St. Louis
- 9:51in January 1975,
- 9:53attended by approximately 30 civilian
- 9:56researchers from across the Midwest.
- 9:58According to three people who were
- 10:00present and who spoke with me separately
- 10:03over the past 4 years, the response in
- 10:05the room was not dismissal.
- 10:07It was unease.
- 10:09Several attendees had documented similar
- 10:11patterns in their own case files and
- 10:13hadn't yet articulated what they were
- 10:15seeing.
- 10:17The Midwest Phenomenological Research
- 10:19Group dissolved in 1983.
- 10:22The official reason given at the time,
- 10:24funding exhaustion.
- 10:27But the group's founder, a retired
- 10:28engineer named Thomas Blow, gave a brief
- 10:31interview to a Kansas City alternative
- 10:33newspaper in 1985,
- 10:36in which he said, and I'm paraphrasing
- 10:38here, that the group had made
- 10:40discoveries they didn't know what to do
- 10:42with and that several members had been
- 10:43strongly encouraged by unnamed parties
- 10:46to discontinue their work.
- 10:49When pressed on who those parties were,
- 10:51Blow declined to specify.
- 10:54The interviewer noted that he seemed
- 10:56genuinely frightened.
- 10:58The newspaper in question, The Heartland
- 11:00Observer, ceased publication in 1986.
- 11:04Its archives were never digitized.
- 11:07The silence that surrounds this research
- 11:09is not passive.
- 11:10That's what I've come to understand.
- 11:12It's not simply that no one is paying
- 11:14attention.
- 11:15Something about this particular line of
- 11:17inquiry consistently disappears. Files,
- 11:19organizations, people.
- 11:22Not destroyed necessarily,
- 11:24just
- 11:25gone.
- 11:26Relocated into inaccessibility, which is
- 11:29almost worse. This is the part where I
- 11:31have to slow down because what I'm about
- 11:33to describe sounds on the surface like
- 11:36science fiction.
- 11:38And I want to be clear. I'm not
- 11:40endorsing a theory. I'm reporting what
- 11:42multiple independent sources across
- 11:44multiple decades and continents
- 11:47appear to be describing.
- 11:49The abduction literature, and I use that
- 11:52word with full awareness of its baggage,
- 11:54is dominated by accounts of physical
- 11:56examination.
- 11:58Needles, tissue samples, reproductive
- 12:01interference. This is what gets
- 12:03reported. This is what gets studied.
- 12:05This is what the popular imagination
- 12:07seized on after the Hill case in 1961
- 12:11and the subsequent wave of accounts in
- 12:13the 1970s.
- 12:15But there's a subset of accounts,
- 12:17quieter, less publicized, more
- 12:20internally consistent, that describe
- 12:22something different. Something that
- 12:24doesn't fit the biological sampling
- 12:26model.
- 12:27And it is this subset that Harold Wexler
- 12:30belongs to.
- 12:31In 2007, a retired professor of
- 12:33comparative psychology named Dr. Wen Lee
- 12:36Hua,
- 12:37formerly of Fudan University in
- 12:39Shanghai,
- 12:40self-published a monograph titled "A
- 12:42Recurring Phenomenology in Anomalous
- 12:45Contact Reports: A Cross-Cultural
- 12:47Survey".
- 12:48The monograph was 340 pages and sold
- 12:52fewer than 200 copies.
- 12:54I found it through a footnote in a
- 12:56researcher's bibliography, ordered a
- 12:58physical copy from a small press in Hong
- 13:00Kong, and read it over the course of a
- 13:03week that I can only describe as deeply
- 13:05uncomfortable.
- 13:07Lee Hua had spent 15 years collecting
- 13:10and categorizing anomalous contact
- 13:12accounts from Chinese, Japanese, Korean,
- 13:15Filipino, and Southeast Asian sources,
- 13:19most of which had never been translated
- 13:21into English, and therefore had never
- 13:23been cross-referenced against Western
- 13:25accounts.
- 13:26His conclusion, stated plainly in his
- 13:28introduction,
- 13:30the phenomenon being described in these
- 13:32accounts is not physical extraction of
- 13:34biological material.
- 13:36It is extraction of what the subjects
- 13:38consistently describe as their
- 13:40accumulated experience, their memory,
- 13:43their emotional history, their sense of
- 13:45having lived. Their sense of having
- 13:47lived, Lihua proposed, tentatively,
- 13:51carefully, with every appropriate
- 13:53academic hedge, that what the beings in
- 13:56these accounts appeared to be harvesting
- 13:57was not tissue or genetic material, but
- 14:00something closer to what we might call
- 14:03experiential data.
- 14:05The lived texture of a human
- 14:06consciousness.
- 14:08Fear, love, grief, joy, not as
- 14:11metaphors, but as resources.
- 14:14Is this possible?
- 14:16I'm not a scientist. I can't evaluate
- 14:18that claim on a physical basis,
- 14:22but I can tell you what the accounts
- 14:23say.
- 14:24And the accounts from Nebraska and Oslo
- 14:27and Cali and Shanghai and a dozen other
- 14:29places I've now documented
- 14:32say the same thing with variations so
- 14:34minor they read like dialect, not
- 14:36contradiction.
- 14:38Loftis County, Tennessee.
- 14:41October, 1974.
- 14:45A 28-year-old man named Gary Tullock was
- 14:47found by his brother-in-law in a field
- 14:49behind his property,
- 14:51unconscious and cold at approximately
- 14:545:00 in the morning.
- 14:57Tullock had been reported missing by his
- 14:59wife the previous evening.
- 15:01He was hospitalized at Ridgecrest
- 15:03Regional Medical Center and examined by
- 15:05a Dr. Patricia Norwood.
- 15:08Dr. Norwood's examination notes, filed
- 15:11with the hospital on October the 19th,
- 15:131974,
- 15:15described findings she characterized as
- 15:17biologically anomalous
- 15:19and without precedent in my clinical
- 15:21experience.
- 15:22Specifically, Tullock's cortisol levels
- 15:25were at the absolute floor of measurable
- 15:27range.
- 15:29His cerebrospinal fluid showed unusual
- 15:31protein markers that Norwood could not
- 15:33classify.
- 15:34And this is the detail that stops me
- 15:36every time I return to this case. His
- 15:39brain's limbic region, as assessed
- 15:41through the neurological examination
- 15:43tools available in 1974,
- 15:46showed what Norwood described in her
- 15:47notes as evidence of organized
- 15:50depletion.
- 15:51Organized depletion, not damage, not
- 15:54trauma, organization.
- 15:57As if whatever had happened had been
- 15:59conducted with intention and precision.
- 16:02Tullock recovered physically.
- 16:05He was discharged after 6 days,
- 16:07but his wife Louise told a local
- 16:09researcher named Margaret Holloway in
- 16:111978 that Gary was
- 16:14not the same man who went into that
- 16:16field.
- 16:17She said he lost access to memories he'd
- 16:19had before. Not all of them, not in the
- 16:22way you'd expect from brain injury, but
- 16:24specific ones.
- 16:26Emotional ones.
- 16:28She said it was as if certain files had
- 16:30been removed while leaving the cabinet
- 16:31intact.
- 16:33Dr. Norwood's examination notes were
- 16:35requested by Holloway in 1979
- 16:38under a Tennessee public records
- 16:40inquiry.
- 16:41The hospital informed her that the
- 16:43relevant records could not be located.
- 16:46An administrative assistant told
- 16:48Holloway informally that the records
- 16:50from that wing for that period had been
- 16:52transferred to an off-site storage
- 16:54facility in 1977.
- 16:57The storage facility, when Holloway
- 16:59contacted it, had no record of receiving
- 17:01them.
- 17:03This is the moment in my research where
- 17:05I stopped calling these disappearances
- 17:08coincidences because this pattern, the
- 17:10existence of documentation, the initial
- 17:13accessibility, the subsequent
- 17:15disappearance into administrative
- 17:17ambiguity repeats with a precision that
- 17:20starts to feel less like bureaucratic
- 17:23incompetence and more like a method. I
- 17:26want to introduce you to a few more
- 17:28people.
- 17:29Akosua Mensa, a 45-year-old market
- 17:32vendor from Kumasi, Ghana.
- 17:341976,
- 17:36missing time event during a walk between
- 17:38villages.
- 17:39Documented by a Ghanaian folklore
- 17:41researcher named Kwaku Asante
- 17:44who was conducting field work on
- 17:45traditional encounter stories and
- 17:47stumbled somewhat against his will into
- 17:50something contemporary.
- 17:53Mensa described the beings as taking the
- 17:55part of her that held her children's
- 17:57faces.
- 17:58Not memories in an abstract sense,
- 18:00specific emotional memories, the felt
- 18:03sense of them.
- 18:04Pavel Dmitriev, a 33-year-old Soviet
- 18:07railway engineer, Sverdlovsk, Russia,
- 18:101968.
- 18:13Dmitriev's account was documented
- 18:15internally by a Soviet research body
- 18:17whose name translates roughly to the
- 18:19Committee for Unexplained Atmospheric
- 18:21Phenomena.
- 18:23A body whose existence was denied until
- 18:25a tranche of documents appeared in a
- 18:271994 Moscow archive opening.
- 18:31Dmitriev described through his
- 18:33interpreter in a 1969 session a process
- 18:36of siphoning the years.
- 18:38He used that phrase three times.
- 18:41The Soviet researchers noted in their
- 18:43session transcript that Dmitriev
- 18:45appeared to have genuine difficulty
- 18:47accessing emotional memories prior to
- 18:49the event.
- 18:51Rosamond Chakravarty, a 52-year-old
- 18:53retired civil servant from Kolkata,
- 18:55India. 1981.
- 18:59Documented by the Calcutta Fortean
- 19:01Research Society, a small organization
- 19:04that operated from 1975 to 1990.
- 19:08Chakravarty described the beings as
- 19:10working carefully
- 19:12the way a jeweler works.
- 19:14She said they seem to be selecting,
- 19:17not taking everything, choosing a grain
- 19:19farmer from Nebraska,
- 19:21a school teacher from Oslo, a market
- 19:23vendor from Kumasi, a railway engineer
- 19:26from Sverdlovsk, a civil servant from
- 19:28Kolkata.
- 19:30They don't know each other. They have no
- 19:32common language. They have no common
- 19:33cultural framework for what they're
- 19:35describing.
- 19:36And yet, what they're describing is, in
- 19:38its essentials, the same event, not the
- 19:41same imagery,
- 19:42not the same peripheral details, the
- 19:44same event. That is the thing I cannot
- 19:46explain away.
- 19:48And the deeper I've gone into these
- 19:49accounts, the more I find I'm no longer
- 19:51trying to.
- 19:52There's a discipline within anomaly
- 19:54research. It's practiced by a very small
- 19:57number of people who have enough
- 19:58intellectual honesty to apply genuine
- 20:01rigor to genuinely strange data,
- 20:04called structural phenomenology of
- 20:05contact accounts.
- 20:07It asks not what the accounts claim, but
- 20:09how they are structured.
- 20:11What do witnesses emphasize? What do
- 20:13they omit? Where are the silences? And
- 20:16what shape do those silences take?
- 20:20A researcher named Dr. Silvia Ortega,
- 20:22who held a position at a private
- 20:24research institute in Barcelona until
- 20:27her retirement in 2012,
- 20:29spent 22 years applying this methodology
- 20:32to a database of 847 contact accounts
- 20:35from 31 countries.
- 20:38Her findings were never peer-reviewed.
- 20:40She submitted to three journals, was
- 20:42rejected each time on grounds she
- 20:44characterized as reflexive rather than
- 20:47substantive, and eventually published
- 20:50her analysis privately in 2009.
- 20:54Ortega identified what she called the
- 20:56involuntary tribute structure
- 20:58in 23% of the accounts in her database.
- 21:02Those being accounts where physical
- 21:04examination was secondary to or absent
- 21:07from the reported experience,
- 21:09replaced by what subjects described as
- 21:11extraction of non-physical content.
- 21:15What made Ortega's work significant and
- 21:17troubling
- 21:18was her observation about what subjects
- 21:20consistently failed to report afterward.
- 21:23Not what they said,
- 21:25what they couldn't say.
- 21:27In account after account, subjects in
- 21:29the involuntary tribute category showed
- 21:31a specific deficit in emotional
- 21:34recollection.
- 21:35They could recall the facts of their
- 21:37lives prior to the event, names, dates,
- 21:40places. The architecture of memory
- 21:42remained, but the feeling of those
- 21:44memories, what Ortega called the
- 21:46affective dimension,
- 21:48was diminished or absent. They knew they
- 21:51had loved people. They could not feel
- 21:53that they had.
- 21:54Ortega described this as the library
- 21:57with empty shelves.
- 21:59The structure is there. The books are
- 22:01gone.
- 22:02And here's what she noticed, the thing
- 22:04that made her pause in her own research,
- 22:06and apparently lose several months to
- 22:08what she described in a personal
- 22:09correspondence
- 22:11as a very dark period of thinking.
- 22:14The subjects didn't always know anything
- 22:16was missing.
- 22:18Some of them felt fine.
- 22:20Some of them felt lighter, even,
- 22:22relieved of something they couldn't
- 22:24name,
- 22:25which raises a question I find very
- 22:27difficult to sit with.
- 22:29If you remove something from someone in
- 22:31a way they didn't fully register, in a
- 22:33way that left their functional
- 22:34intelligence intact, in a way they might
- 22:37even misinterpret as feeling better,
- 22:40would that be the perfect harvest? I
- 22:42want to come back to Harold Wexler for a
- 22:44moment, because Harold was a farmer.
- 22:46And the word he used, draining,
- 22:50is a farmer's word.
- 22:52It's a word for a process,
- 22:54a managed repeatable process, something
- 22:57you do not once, but seasonally,
- 22:59something with a yield.
- 23:02I don't think it's accidental that the
- 23:03agricultural metaphor appears
- 23:06in various forms across the accounts
- 23:08I've reviewed.
- 23:10Ingrid Sollberg in Oslo said the beings
- 23:12moved the way you harvest, taking what
- 23:15is ripe and leaving the rest.
- 23:18Rosamond Chakravarthy in Kolkata
- 23:20compared them to collectors who have
- 23:22done this in many places before this
- 23:25place.
- 23:27Pavel Dmitriev in Sverdlovsk said they
- 23:29worked as if on a schedule.
- 23:31A schedule? Are these metaphors are
- 23:33frightened people reaching for the most
- 23:35familiar frameworks they have for
- 23:37organized extraction?
- 23:39Possibly. Probably even.
- 23:41I want to be fair to the alternative
- 23:43explanation, but I also want to ask what
- 23:45if the metaphors are accurate?
- 23:48What if what we are describing here is
- 23:49not abduction in the sense of study or
- 23:51experiment,
- 23:53but something closer to resource
- 23:54collection?
- 23:56What if human emotional experience,
- 23:59grief, longing, fear, love accumulated
- 24:02over a lifetime,
- 24:04constitutes something of value to an
- 24:05intelligence we don't understand in ways
- 24:08we can't currently measure?
- 24:11What does that make us? Not subjects,
- 24:13not curiosities, not objects of
- 24:16scientific interest to a more advanced
- 24:18civilization.
- 24:19Crops.
- 24:21I want to be transparent about
- 24:22something. The evidentiary record for
- 24:24everything I've described in this
- 24:26documentary is
- 24:27at best, partial.
- 24:30Documents are missing. Archives are
- 24:32incomplete. Key researchers died without
- 24:35transferring their work.
- 24:37Organizations dissolved under unclear
- 24:39circumstances. Medical records were
- 24:42transferred to facilities that have no
- 24:44record of receiving them. Is this
- 24:46consistent with large-scale deliberate
- 24:49suppression?
- 24:50It might be.
- 24:51Is it also consistent with the ordinary
- 24:53entropy of poorly funded civilian
- 24:55research into a stigmatized subject
- 24:59conducted over decades in an era before
- 25:01digital preservation.
- 25:04Absolutely.
- 25:05I don't know which explanation is
- 25:07correct. I'm not sure I can know.
- 25:10And I've learned to be suspicious of
- 25:11researchers in this field who are
- 25:13certain
- 25:14certain either that the evidence proves
- 25:17extraordinary claims
- 25:19or certain that the evidence proves
- 25:22nothing.
- 25:23Certainty in this territory feels like a
- 25:26failure of attention.
- 25:28What I can tell you is what's missing
- 25:31and what the shape of that absence looks
- 25:33like.
- 25:34In 1977, a researcher named Franklin
- 25:38Osei working in Accra, Ghana, claimed to
- 25:41have compiled a registry of West African
- 25:44contact accounts spanning nearly a
- 25:45decade
- 25:47with particular focus on accounts
- 25:48matching what I've been calling the
- 25:50extraction pattern.
- 25:53He announced this registry at a small
- 25:54conference in Lagos.
- 25:56He stated his intention to publish. The
- 25:59registry was never published.
- 26:01Osei died in 1979.
- 26:04His family has no knowledge of any
- 26:06research materials. The conference
- 26:08organizer, when tracked down by a
- 26:10researcher I know in 2015
- 26:13said he remembered Osei's presentation
- 26:15clearly and remembered being struck by
- 26:17it
- 26:18but had never been able to locate any
- 26:20follow-up material.
- 26:22In 1982, a Japanese researcher named
- 26:25Fumiko Tanabe at a private research
- 26:27center in Osaka reportedly completed a
- 26:30comparative study of Japanese contact
- 26:33accounts from the 1960s and 1970s
- 26:37cross-referenced against American and
- 26:39European cases.
- 26:41The study was circulated in draft form
- 26:43among a small group of researchers in
- 26:45Japan and is referenced by name in at
- 26:48least two letters I've seen from that
- 26:50period.
- 26:51The final study does not appear to
- 26:53exist.
- 26:55Tanabe's former colleagues at the
- 26:56research center, contacted by a Japanese
- 26:59journalist in 2008, stated that they had
- 27:02no knowledge of any such study.
- 27:05In 1988, Carol Ann Spash,
- 27:08the woman who first documented Harold
- 27:10Wexler, died of a cardiac event at the
- 27:13age of 61.
- 27:15She had, by several accounts, been
- 27:17working on a comprehensive manuscript
- 27:19that drew on her 20 years of research
- 27:22and cross-reference cases
- 27:24across multiple countries.
- 27:27The manuscript has never surfaced. Her
- 27:29home was cleared by a nephew who donated
- 27:31most of her papers to a local church
- 27:33charity sale.
- 27:35He doesn't know what happened to her
- 27:37research files specifically.
- 27:39He thought a neighbor had taken some
- 27:41boxes. The neighbor moved in 1991.
- 27:44Registry, study, manuscript, gone.
- 27:48Gone.
- 27:49Gone. Not destroyed. Not officially
- 27:52suppressed, just absent. Just occupying
- 27:56the space where evidence should be,
- 27:58leaving only the negative shape of
- 28:00itself, a shadow without a source.
- 28:04There are a small number of accounts
- 28:05I've encountered. I want to be honest
- 28:07that they're at the edge of what I can
- 28:09verify and at the edge of what I'm
- 28:11willing to present without significant
- 28:13qualification
- 28:15that suggest the extraction phenomenon
- 28:18may not be a one-time event per
- 28:20individual.
- 28:21Repeat experiences. Harold Wexler
- 28:24himself, in his final recorded session
- 28:26with Ann Spash in March 1972,
- 28:30said something that she noted in her
- 28:31summary as requiring further
- 28:34investigation,
- 28:35but that, as far as I can determine, was
- 28:37never followed up.
- 28:39He said,
- 28:40"I don't think this was the first time.
- 28:42I think I just don't remember the other
- 28:44times.
- 28:45I think I just don't remember the other
- 28:48times.
- 28:50Ingrid Solberg in a follow-up
- 28:52conversation with Torsten Blith in 1976,
- 28:56four years after her initial account,
- 28:58mentioned seemingly in passing
- 29:01that she had been experiencing a feeling
- 29:03she described as scheduled diminishment,
- 29:06that she felt at certain intervals she
- 29:08couldn't precisely define a lightening,
- 29:12a periodic sense of something being
- 29:14absent that had been present before.
- 29:17She asked Blith whether other people had
- 29:19described this.
- 29:21He didn't answer in the transcript. The
- 29:23transcription shows a gap of
- 29:24approximately 40 seconds before the
- 29:26conversation continues on a different
- 29:29subject.
- 29:31Why the gap? What was said in those 40
- 29:33seconds?
- 29:34Was the recorder paused deliberately?
- 29:37Was Blith composing himself?
- 29:40I've listened to a portion of that
- 29:42recording. The quality is poor, the tape
- 29:44degraded. I can't resolve the gap.
- 29:48But I can tell you that Blith, who was a
- 29:50methodical and prolific note taker,
- 29:52made no written observation about what
- 29:54Solberg had said.
- 29:57A man who documented everything, writing
- 29:59nothing
- 30:00about that particular moment.
- 30:03The silence from Torsten Blith is not
- 30:05explainable to me.
- 30:07And silences, I've learned in this
- 30:10research,
- 30:11are often where the most significant
- 30:13things are located.
- 30:15Let me step back from the individual
- 30:17cases and ask the larger question.
- 30:20If pace, and I want to keep this
- 30:22conditional, I want to resist the
- 30:24seduction of false certainty,
- 30:27if what these accounts are describing is
- 30:28real or even partially real, what are
- 30:31the implications?
- 30:33We are not dealing with a civilization
- 30:35that wants our resources in the
- 30:37conventional sense. They're not, as far
- 30:39as these accounts suggest, interested in
- 30:42our water or our metals or our genetic
- 30:45code in isolation.
- 30:47They appear, if we take these accounts
- 30:49seriously, even provisionally, to be
- 30:52interested in something that only living
- 30:54human beings generate and accumulate
- 30:56over time.
- 30:58Experiential data.
- 31:00Emotional history.
- 31:03The felt texture of a consciousness that
- 31:05has suffered and hoped and loved and
- 31:07lost.
- 31:08Something that perhaps cannot be
- 31:10manufactured. Something that perhaps can
- 31:12only be grown.
- 31:15This raises a question about time scale
- 31:17that I find genuinely vertiginous.
- 31:20How long has this been happening?
- 31:22Because if we're talking about a
- 31:23resource that requires human lifetimes
- 31:26to accumulate, decades of experience,
- 31:28layers of emotion, the depth that only
- 31:31time produces,
- 31:33and if the collection of this resource
- 31:35is organized and scheduled and ongoing,
- 31:38then we may not be talking about
- 31:39something that started in the 20th
- 31:42century. We may not be talking about
- 31:44something that started in recorded
- 31:45history.
- 31:47What if we have been, in some sense,
- 31:49managed for far longer than we can
- 31:51currently document? Not enslaved, not
- 31:54openly controlled, simply cultivated,
- 31:58left to develop, to feel, to accumulate,
- 32:00and then periodically harvested in ways
- 32:02that leave us functional and largely
- 32:04unaware.
- 32:06What would that mean for our
- 32:07understanding of who we are and why
- 32:09we're here?
- 32:10I want to close with Harold Wexler
- 32:12because that's where I began.
- 32:14And because of something he said
- 32:16in his very last recorded session with
- 32:19Carol Anspach,
- 32:21he'd been talking about the beings he
- 32:23encountered, describing them in his
- 32:24measured farmer's way, without
- 32:26embellishment, without drama.
- 32:29And Anspach asked him, "Did they seem
- 32:31malevolent? Did they mean him harm?"
- 32:35Harold was quiet for what the recording
- 32:37suggests was a long time.
- 32:40Then he said,
- 32:41"No, I don't think they meant me harm
- 32:44any more than I mean harm to my field
- 32:46when I bring in the harvest. They
- 32:48weren't cruel about it.
- 32:50They were just doing what they do,
- 32:52the way I do what I do, the way I do
- 32:55what I do." He paused again.
- 32:58And then he said something that Carol
- 32:59Ann Sback underlined three times in her
- 33:01notes, and that I have thought about
- 33:03almost every day since I first read it.
- 33:06"What bothered me wasn't what they took.
- 33:09What bothered me was how practiced they
- 33:11were.
- 33:12How practiced they were."
- 33:13Not surprised by him.
- 33:15Not studying him with the curiosity of
- 33:17an explorer encountering the unknown.
- 33:21Moving through the encounter with the
- 33:22efficiency of a process performed not
- 33:25dozens of times, but thousands.
- 33:27Millions, maybe.
- 33:29On how many people? Over how many
- 33:31centuries? Harold Wexler went back to
- 33:33his farm after those four sessions. He
- 33:36grew grain for 22 more years.
- 33:39He never spoke publicly about what had
- 33:41happened to him.
- 33:42His children, he had three, say they
- 33:45knew something had occurred, but that
- 33:46Harold had made it clear the subject was
- 33:48closed.
- 33:50He died in April 1994,
- 33:52a quiet death in the house he'd lived in
- 33:55his whole life.
- 33:57His daughter Ruth told me in a phone
- 33:59conversation in 2021 that in his final
- 34:02weeks, when Harold was in and out of
- 34:03consciousness,
- 34:05he kept saying something she couldn't
- 34:06quite make out.
- 34:08She leaned close once, and she thought
- 34:10she heard him say,
- 34:12"They'll be back."
- 34:14Not as a threat, she was clear about
- 34:16this.
- 34:17Not with fear, with a certainty that was
- 34:19somehow worse than fear. "They'll be
- 34:21back. I've spent years in this. I want
- 34:24to be honest about what I've arrived at,
- 34:26which is not a conclusion, but a wait. A
- 34:28weight of accumulated detail that
- 34:30refuses to resolve into either
- 34:33comfortable belief or comfortable
- 34:35dismissal.
- 34:37I don't know if Harold Wexler
- 34:38encountered extraterrestrial beings in a
- 34:40Nebraska field
- 34:42in 1971.
- 34:45I don't know if Ingrid Solberg lost 2
- 34:47hours and 40 minutes to something we
- 34:48have no framework to describe. I don't
- 34:51know if Gaza Mendez's registry from Cali
- 34:54documented a real phenomenon or a
- 34:56psychological contagion or some third
- 34:59thing we don't yet have words for.
- 35:02What I know is that the accounts exist,
- 35:05that they're consistent in ways that
- 35:07shouldn't be possible given the
- 35:08separations of culture and language and
- 35:11time.
- 35:12That the documentation around them has a
- 35:14habit of disappearing. That the
- 35:16researchers who pursued this question
- 35:18with the most rigor ended up
- 35:19consistently in silence, voluntary or
- 35:22otherwise.
- 35:23And I know that the thing being
- 35:25described, if it is a thing, if it is
- 35:27real, is not what we were told to look
- 35:29for. We were told to look for lights in
- 35:32the sky,
- 35:33for recovered craft, for biological
- 35:35samples and government cover-ups and
- 35:37military programs.
- 35:39And maybe all of that is real.
- 35:41Maybe some of it is.
- 35:43But running underneath all of it,
- 35:45quieter and older and somehow more
- 35:47disturbing,
- 35:49is this other thing.
- 35:51This harvesting.
- 35:52This practiced, patient, organized
- 35:55removal of something we carry inside us
- 35:57and barely understand ourselves.
- 36:01What is human emotional experience
- 36:03worth?
- 36:04What would it be worth to a civilization
- 36:06with the technology to collect it?
- 36:09Why would such a civilization need it?
- 36:11What does it lack or what does it want
- 36:13to understand or what does it want to
- 36:16feel that it cannot generate on its own?
- 36:20These are questions I can't answer.
- 36:24These are questions that may not be
- 36:25answerable with anything we currently
- 36:27have.
- 36:28But, I think they are the right
- 36:29questions. I think they are the
- 36:31questions that once asked make the whole
- 36:35landscape of this subject look
- 36:37different.
- 36:39Make the sightings and the recoveries
- 36:41and the congressional hearings look like
- 36:43foreground.
- 36:44Interesting, dramatic,
- 36:46attention-consuming foreground.
- 36:48While the real story moves quietly in
- 36:51the background.
- 36:52While it has always moved quietly in the
- 36:55background.
- 36:57While we've been looking up at the
- 36:58lights and failing to notice what it is
- 37:00we're actually providing.
- 37:03Harold Wexler was a farmer.
- 37:05He understood better than most of us
- 37:08that you don't ask the wheat what it
- 37:09thinks about the harvest.
- 37:11You just wait for it to ripen, and then
- 37:13you come back.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of A 1971 Abductee Exposed What Aliens Harvest From Humans — It’s Far Worse Than We Were Told by Inside Area 51, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,137 words across 1,000 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.