ИЗМЕНИЛАСЬ практика призыва срочников и запасников! — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:00I am glad to welcome everyone to my
2. 0:01channel. Today I would like to talk to
3. 0:04you about the practice of military
4. 0:06conscription regarding draftees, and we
5. 0:08will also touch upon the practice
6. 0:10concerning those in the reserves.
7. 0:14First of all, I would like to note that
8. 0:17our activities for dispatching draftees
9. 0:19began on October 1st and will end on
10. 0:21December 31st.
11. 0:25We immediately noticed here that
12. 0:27military commissariats are gaining
13. 0:29experience and have prepared quite well
14. 0:32regarding the draftees.
15. 0:36You could say so, because we have
16. 0:38examples where, two weeks after the
17. 0:41start of, let’s call them, military
18. 0:44dispatch activities, some military
19. 0:46commissariats had already met their
20. 0:49quota.
21. 0:50That is, theoretically, dispatching
22. 0:52should continue until December 31st, but
23. 0:55some military commissariats had their
24. 0:57quota filled as early as October 14th,
25. 0:59even though those activities supposedly
26. 1:01only started on October 1st.
27. 1:04Well, this can primarily be attributed
28. 1:06to the fact that draftees undergo all
29. 1:08necessary tests and examinations in
30. 1:10advance, before October, and accordingly
31. 1:13, they arrive all set.
32. 1:15They simply hear the final decision and
33. 1:17receive their summons for deployment to
34. 1:18the troops. And there was just such a
35. 1:21case, including with our client, when
36. 1:23two weeks later he was told that you
37. 1:25would receive a summons for the spring
38. 1:28because our dispatching is already
39. 1:30completed now.
40. 1:32The same theme continues, but on a
41. 1:35larger scale, so to speak, and more
42. 1:37cynically from the point of view of the
43. 1:40specialists we see in the military
44. 1:42commissariats: people with a real
45. 1:44diagnosis, with which one should by no
46. 1:47means be drafted into the army, become
47. 1:49fit, healthy, and, essentially, there
48. 1:52shouldn't be any problems with them from
49. 1:54the military commissariat’s perspective
50. 1:57.
51. 1:59We, in turn, continue to defend our
52. 2:01clients 'positions in such situations.
53. 2:06As before, we have not had a single case
54. 2:08where any of our clients were sent
55. 2:09anywhere against their will.
56. 2:11Well, unless they wanted to go
57. 2:12themselves.
58. 2:14Accordingly, the appeal process begins
59. 2:16pre-trial. We observe the reaction of
60. 2:18the higher-level military commissariat.
61. 2:20And, accordingly, if the district
62. 2:22decision remains in force, then we head
63. 2:24to court.
64. 2:26And even here we have our own
65. 2:27observations, since we work throughout
66. 2:30Russia, although we are based in the
67. 2:32city of Krasnoyarsk ourselves, that the
68. 2:34practice in Krasnoyarsk is one of the
69. 2:36toughest. That is, sometimes for our
70. 2:38clients to prove their actual health
71. 2:40problem, which is right there in the
72. 2:43documents, they simply need to move to
73. 2:45another city, register there, and sign
74. 2:47up with a different military
75. 2:49commissariat so that their problem gets
76. 2:52noticed.
77. 2:53Accordingly, there are also certain
78. 2:55nuances regarding the courts.
79. 2:57Whereas before we could easily conduct
80. 2:59an independent military medical
81. 3:01examination in court—and I am speaking
82. 3:03specifically about the practice in the
83. 3:05city of Krasnoyarsk—today we are even
84. 3:07facing situations where courts simply
85. 3:09refuse to conduct a judicial examination
86. 3:11, telling us: "Go and conduct a
87. 3:13pre-trial examination before coming to
88. 3:15court."
89. 3:17Even though it is our right to request
90. 3:19an examination and conduct it however we
91. 3:21wish, whether in a pre-trial or judicial
92. 3:23proceeding. Moreover, an examination
93. 3:24conducted during court proceedings
94. 3:25carries greater legal weight.
95. 3:28But such cases do occur, where courts
96. 3:31reject these motions to appoint an
97. 3:34examination.
98. 3:36Accordingly, this becomes another part
99. 3:37of our work, as we engage directly with
100. 3:39the court on this.
101. 3:41We have started changing our practice to
102. 3:43conduct pre-trial examinations, but the
103. 3:46question of cost arises, because often
104. 3:48in these situations, a pre-trial
105. 3:50examination costs 100,000, on average,
106. 3:52from 80,000 to 100,000.
107. 3:54So, if we go to court, the judge might
108. 3:56say, "Let's conduct a judicial one," and
109. 3:58then you have to pay again.
110. 4:01This is by no means affordable for
111. 4:03everyone, simply from a financial
112. 4:06standpoint.
113. 4:08At the same time, it must be kept in
114. 4:09mind that while an appeal is underway,
115. 4:11while you are disputing with the
116. 4:13military commissariat, a conscript
117. 4:14cannot be taken.
118. 4:17This rule remains in effect, holds its
119. 4:20power, and consequently, all our clients
120. 4:23are at home—some working, some studying
121. 4:26.
122. 4:27In general, they are going about their
123. 4:29routine daily affairs.
124. 4:31It should also be noted that many rush
125. 4:33and strive to get Category V as quickly
126. 4:35as possible. In reality, if you are not
127. 4:37given Category V, but you are a
128. 4:38conscript, it is in some sense a bonus
129. 4:40for you.
130. 4:41Because, well, I often tell my clients
131. 4:43this so that they think about it too: as
132. 4:45long as you haven't received Category V
133. 4:47, you are in the status of a conscript.
134. 4:50We don't know what might happen tomorrow
135. 4:51, a month from now, or a year from now.
136. 4:53What if there is some kind of
137. 4:55mobilization, something large-scale,
138. 4:57where criminal liability is introduced
139. 4:59for draft evasion?
140. 5:00In the status of a conscript, as long as
141. 5:02you have not been transferred to the
142. 5:03reserve, you cannot be mobilized.
143. 5:05Consequently, if you have received
144. 5:07Category V and have been transferred to
145. 5:09the reserve, you have solved the issue
146. 5:10of mandatory service, but you are now in
147. 5:12the reserve with Category V, and people
148. 5:14with Category V can be mobilized.
149. 5:16Therefore, if you are unable, in a sense
150. 5:18, to resolve the issue with the military
151. 5:20commissariat and they won't grant you
152. 5:21this "V" category, but you are
153. 5:23challenging the draft board's decision,
154. 5:24it can be said that it is advantageous
155. 5:26for you to remain in the status of a
156. 5:27conscript, because you are not being
157. 5:29called for active duty since you are in
158. 5:31a dispute with the military commissariat
159. 5:32, and they cannot mobilize you since you
160. 5:34are not in the reserves.
161. 5:37So, in that sense, you are, to some
162. 5:39extent, legally protected.
163. 5:42Regarding those in the reserves, it is
164. 5:44worth noting what has changed in
165. 5:45practice overall. From a legal
166. 5:47standpoint, everything remains the same
167. 5:50for us.
168. 5:51The level of liability is not being
169. 5:53increased; it remains, as before, a
170. 5:55maximum of administrative liability,
171. 5:57plus some restrictions.
172. 6:00At the same time, we have started to
173. 6:03notice that any changes occurring in
174. 6:06your life—for example, changing your
175. 6:09registration address, getting new
176. 6:11documents (like receiving a passport),
177. 6:14changing jobs—in all cases that are
178. 6:17significant, such as getting married or
179. 6:20divorced, you are summoned to the
180. 6:22military commissariat; that is,
181. 6:25draft notices arrive for data
182. 6:28verification.
183. 6:30Furthermore, in some cases when a person
184. 6:32actually shows up to verify their data—
185. 6:34well, such cases do happen where they
186. 6:35really do want to clarify something—a
187. 6:37summons for military training arrives a
188. 6:39few days later.
189. 6:42The military commissariat now takes any
190. 6:44changes in people's lives as a signal,
191. 6:47quite literally, to summon them.
192. 6:51So, keep this in mind.
193. 6:53If you are in the reserves and are
194. 6:55planning something, perhaps think: if
195. 6:57you are not being bothered, no summons
196. 6:59are arriving, and you are not being
197. 7:01called anywhere, maybe it is better not
198. 7:04to carry out any actions that are
199. 7:05officially registered or go through
200. 7:07databases for now.
201. 7:10That is all the information I wanted to
202. 7:12convey to you today.
203. 7:13If you have questions regarding
204. 7:15conscription, military service, or
205. 7:16perhaps some civil-legal matters, you
206. 7:18can reach out to us.
207. 7:19We also have a professional lawyer who
208. 7:21has joined our team.
209. 7:23If you have questions regarding criminal
210. 7:25cases and need assistance, you can also
211. 7:27reach out to us for that as well.
212. 7:29In the description of this video, there
213. 7:31is a link to our website and our email
214. 7:33address. If you go to our website, in
215. 7:35the Contacts section, you will find our
216. 7:37work numbers where you can write to us
217. 7:39or call us, whichever is convenient for
218. 7:41you, and we will discuss your matter. If
219. 7:43you want to stay up to date with the
220. 7:45latest information on judicial practice
221. 7:46, subscribe to the channel, as well as
222. 7:47to our page on Yandex.Zen, our VK group
223. 7:49, and our Telegram channel. Thank you
224. 7:51for your donations, for your views, for
225. 7:53your comments and likes. Bye everyone.