Алексей Савватеев | Крах концепции абиогенеза — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, dear viewers. Today in our
- 0:02studio, we have Corresponding Member of
- 0:04the Russian Academy of Sciences Alexey
- 0:06Vladimirovich Savvateev. And although
- 0:08he is primarily a well-known
- 0:09mathematician, we will not be talking
- 0:11entirely about mathematics today; we
- 0:13will talk about the origin of life. The
- 0:16concept of abiogenesis, that is, the
- 0:18origin of life from non-living matter
- 0:20>> for material reasons. Abiogenesis is a
- 0:23theory.
- 0:23>> But I hadn't finished. You interrupted
- 0:25me there. Well, that's fine. That's
- 0:27normal. Naturally, this concept
- 0:30includes the premise that no
- 0:33intelligent creator exists. Well, at
- 0:37the very least, they don't participate
- 0:39in this process. And this concept is
- 0:42effectively a pillar of atheism. One of
- 0:45the pillars, at the very least.
- 0:46>> Yes, philosophically, I think you are
- 0:48right. Philosophically, you are right.
- 0:50Although, of course, not all our
- 0:51opponents will use that language. Some
- 0:53will simply say that everything has a
- 0:55scientific explanation, and the origin
- 0:57of life must have one, too. As the
- 1:00father said in the novel—or in that
- 1:03wonderful little story "Nadya's
- 1:05Crocodile," where a girl took wild
- 1:08animals into the house. Yes.
- 1:11>> I remember, I remember.
- 1:12>> Right. And the dad, who suddenly ended
- 1:14up with a talking cat, sat down and
- 1:16said, "Alright, stay calm, there must
- 1:18be a scientific explanation for
- 1:20everything we see in the world." I was
- 1:24already chuckling at that moment,
- 1:25because in reality, there is no
- 1:27scientific explanation for a great many
- 1:29things. And abiogenesis is just one of
- 1:32the phenomena that...But did you notice
- 1:34, did you observe that in your own
- 1:37words, the concept of a scientific
- 1:39reason already separates God from
- 1:41consideration?
- 1:42>> Well, yes. That is, the question is,
- 1:43how do we perceive science in general?
- 1:45Do we include the possibility of a
- 1:47Creator's existence within it? Notice
- 1:50that from an ideological point of view,
- 1:52those people who speak in the name of
- 1:54science have effectively usurped the
- 1:57right to decide what is science and
- 1:59what is not science.
- 2:00>> That is true. And so today, I want to
- 2:03warn everyone right away: this
- 2:05conversation will be philosophical. It
- 2:07is no coincidence that you mentioned I
- 2:09am a Corresponding Member of the RAS,
- 2:10but did not specify in which field.
- 2:12>> In economics.
- 2:12>> In economics. At the same time, I am a
- 2:14Doctor of Physics and Mathematics.
- 2:15>> In mathematics.
- 2:16>> Yes. And, accordingly, for me in life,
- 2:19I have always been interested in
- 2:21various sciences. In childhood, I loved
- 2:23chemistry and performed experiments
- 2:25with the "Young Chemist" kit. Perhaps
- 2:27you remember such a kit?
- 2:28>> Well, I did them too. I also released
- 2:31pure chlorine on the balcony. Yes, that
- 2:34was wonderful. And so, I really loved
- 2:37chemistry. I mean, I knew it quite well
- 2:40. At least back then. Then, in my final
- 2:43year of school, I became absolutely
- 2:45obsessed with physics. I passed it with
- 2:47an A at School 57, I passed the physics
- 2:49exam with an A. It's there, well, it's
- 2:52like I don't want to brag. We shouldn't
- 2:54, like, get proud here, right,
- 2:56zealously. No, no, no. I just got very
- 2:58interested and learned it well enough
- 3:00for an A. Today, of course, I remember
- 3:02physics poorly, but I recently started
- 3:04reading Feynman, the multi-volume set,
- 3:07uh, The Feynman Lectures on Physics.
- 3:09I'm already on the third volume. And in
- 3:12general, I don't believe that no one
- 3:14has the right to knock on other
- 3:16sciences and figure out what's going on
- 3:19there. That's a very convenient opinion
- 3:22, because in any biology, chemistry, or
- 3:25physics, any kind of sect can be
- 3:27created. And if you aren't "one of us,"
- 3:29then how can you even discuss it? Oh,
- 3:31come on, you have no right, we'll sort
- 3:32it out ourselves here. But the problem
- 3:35is that if some kind of ideological
- 3:38>> pressure,
- 3:39>> pressure, if such an ideological sect
- 3:41has been created, where you can't speak
- 3:43out of turn, then you can't resolve
- 3:45this situation with internal forces at
- 3:48all. Why?
- 3:49>> Gödel's theorem?
- 3:50>> Well, there are analogies for
- 3:52everything, but in this case, it's
- 3:54clear what's happening. People sitting
- 3:56inside a given field have honors
- 3:59granted by certificates from that field
- 4:01, which, among other things...You
- 4:03respect me, I respect you. We are
- 4:05respectable people.
- 4:06>> We are respectable people, yes. Well,
- 4:08in general, everyone inside is like,
- 4:10well, they are holders of various
- 4:12titles, which, among other things,
- 4:14determine their job opportunities and
- 4:16income, well, their position in this
- 4:18society where it's important for them
- 4:20to be. And an attempt to doubt
- 4:24something, even completely, well,
- 4:26obviously, like some obviously absurd
- 4:29statements, to doubt their truth, leads
- 4:32to the loss of honors or to a potential
- 4:35theoretical loss.
- 4:38>> The reality of truth. A fairy tale is a
- 4:40lie, but you can't tell what is what. A
- 4:44fairy tale based on real events, aimed
- 4:46at an adult audience. Characters
- 4:50familiar from childhood will appear in
- 4:52a different light. Koschei suffers from
- 4:55anhedonia, Gorynych grows cabbage, and
- 4:58a Secret Society prepares a revolution
- 5:00in the Faraway Kingdom. Zmey Gorynych,
- 5:04Dobrynya Nikitich, and Koschei, who
- 5:06joined them.
- 5:11>> Well, at the very least, a loss of
- 5:13authority.
- 5:13>> Perhaps they'll look at you the wrong
- 5:14way.
- 5:15>> Well, the loss of auth—
- 5:15>> that's already enough. Loss of
- 5:17authority. loss of...like there will be
- 5:19a label, a label that, well, he's, you
- 5:21know, drifted toward creationism, right
- 5:23? He's drifting somewhere over there,
- 5:27he's asking uncomfortable questions
- 5:28about the theory of evolution. Maybe
- 5:30something is wrong with him. Maybe we
- 5:32won't give him the next prize, maybe
- 5:34that's it. Yes.
- 5:35>> Well, we're spending too much time on
- 5:37this. I am explaining why, in reality,
- 5:39science cannot be organized so that
- 5:42only members of a specific field have
- 5:44the right to judge it. It cannot,
- 5:46otherwise it will stagnate within these
- 5:48little circles.
- 5:49>> Well, the fact is that there is an
- 5:51argument in your favor in the context
- 5:53of our conversation that is much
- 5:55stronger. The point is that, in the end
- 5:57, if you really get down to it, what is
- 5:59biology? Biology can ultimately be
- 6:02reduced to molecules, and molecules to
- 6:04atoms. And ultimately, these are laws
- 6:06of physics. Physics.
- 6:08>> Exactly. Abiogenesis is not their field
- 6:11. That’s exactly the point, that
- 6:14strictly speaking, nothing can be
- 6:16reduced solely to the top level of
- 6:17abstraction. If we ask, as Dostoevsky
- 6:20said, the ultimate questions, if we go
- 6:22deep into causality, then in the end,
- 6:25like it or not, we will arrive at
- 6:27physics at the very least. And where
- 6:29there is physics, there is mathematics
- 6:31and probability theory. And that is
- 6:33where you are a specialist. No, in the
- 6:36most direct sense. Here, no one can say
- 6:39that you came from the outside. You
- 6:41didn't come from the outside.
- 6:42>> They will say that I am calculating the
- 6:43wrong probabilities. But we can easily
- 6:45handle that, as is usually done in
- 6:48science. Please, let's have a
- 6:50discussion. If you know how to
- 6:52calculate
- 6:53>> those mathematical probabilities,
- 6:55>> please, go ahead and show your
- 6:57calculations.
- 6:57>> Well, okay, we are gradually getting to
- 6:59the essence of the problem, right? But
- 7:02before I finally move on to the essence
- 7:05, I want to emphasize once again, first
- 7:08of all, that abiogenesis is not a
- 7:11sphere of biology. Just as one friend
- 7:16of mine, an anonymous friend, an
- 7:18anonymous friend of mine, says: "Asking
- 7:21biologists about the origin of a cell
- 7:23is like asking a chef about the fate of
- 7:26the fish he is frying, where it grew up
- 7:29. how it developed, in what oceans it
- 7:33swam and
- 7:34>> how it was caught,
- 7:35>> how they caught it."
- 7:37>> That is, the whole,
- 7:37>> you understand, right? I mean, this is,
- 7:40as I said, we are regressing causality
- 7:42in the other direction, and we move
- 7:45away from blood, from the heart, from
- 7:47the kidneys, from Darwinism. We arrive
- 7:50at quantum physics. In the end, perhaps
- 7:52,
- 7:52>> yes, it must be understood that in
- 7:54science there are a whole series of
- 7:55laws at different levels. For instance,
- 7:57the second law of thermodynamics, that
- 7:58is precisely not the reduction of one
- 8:00physics to another. But once again, we
- 8:02are stating that abiogenesis is a very
- 8:05multidisciplinary problem that does not
- 8:07belong only to biology, at the very
- 8:09least. That is to say,
- 8:11>> let's clarify once again that
- 8:12abiogenesis is precisely the
- 8:13transformation, well, the concept,
- 8:15>> transformation
- 8:17>> from non-living to living without the
- 8:19involvement of an intelligent
- 8:20>> Creator. According to material,
- 8:22strictly material involvement of an
- 8:24intelligent Creator. That is, of
- 8:26something immaterial. This is already
- 8:28clear,
- 8:28>> right? Well, this is, accordingly, such
- 8:31a concept, right? This concept, whether
- 8:33it is a theory, a framework, a paradigm
- 8:35, a hypothesis, and so on. I,
- 8:37unfortunately, am not skilled in
- 8:39philosophy. We need a philosopher here,
- 8:40and one will likely be here. I think
- 8:42it's interesting, but that's
- 8:43interesting for another time. I still,
- 8:45I myself wonder about its status. Well,
- 8:49the status, at the very least, what I
- 8:51can guarantee is that it does not have
- 8:53the status of a proven, well,
- 8:55established truth. And everyone
- 8:57acknowledges this, including all our
- 8:59concepts.
- 8:59>> But we will talk about that now. The
- 9:01fact is that, well, if we are to speak,
- 9:03as you do, you claim, you use the term
- 9:05philosophy,
- 9:05>> right,
- 9:06>> well, you could put it differently.
- 9:08Intellectual foundation. Abiogenesis is
- 9:10, firstly, a theory, because it is
- 9:12formulated simply as the origin of one
- 9:14from another, and also a hypothesis
- 9:17when it comes to a specific mechanism,
- 9:19>> when specific mechanisms arise,
- 9:21>> yes, that is, in the narrow sense
- 9:22>> hypothetical mechanisms,
- 9:24>> a hypothesis, and in the broad sense it
- 9:26is a theory, or perhaps a concept,
- 9:28after all. Well, we're dragging this
- 9:30out, let's analyze it specifically. You
- 9:32are a mathematician, let's take your
- 9:34mathematician. I look at this field as
- 9:35a mathematician,
- 9:36>> right? You dissect this theory,
- 9:38hypothesis, and so on. I dissect it as
- 9:39a mathematician.
- 9:40>> And what is it that doesn't satisfy you
- 9:41?
- 9:42>> I immediately paid attention to Eugene
- 9:44Koonin's article from 2006, I believe,
- 9:47or 2007.
- 9:48>> Third in the world ranking of
- 9:50biologists.
- 9:52>> Our compatriot who moved to America,
- 9:53works there, and writes everything in
- 9:55English.
- 9:56>> Sciences,
- 9:57>> without a doubt, possessor of
- 9:59absolutely all. Well, that is, this is
- 10:01a generally recognized scientist,
- 10:03number, well, number three. This is
- 10:05just absolute top tier. a luminary, yes
- 10:07, who at some point wrote an article,
- 10:09and published it quite specifically. He
- 10:12says that the stages, well, the
- 10:14emergence of a cell, well, there are
- 10:16three stages. The first is, in
- 10:18principle, to come up with some kind of
- 10:20most—I'm saying again, now biologists
- 10:22can correct me there, but I think
- 10:24everyone will agree that, in general,
- 10:26the picture is presented, well, without
- 10:28strong distortions.
- 10:29>> The first, yes, a simplified picture
- 10:31without strong, already, yes, a rough
- 10:32one. The first is the so-called RNA
- 10:34world. This is a world where, you know,
- 10:37well, there emerges some kind of very,
- 10:38very small self-replicating machine,
- 10:40replicating itself, unwanted.
- 10:42>> Well, actually, no. Here, you see, this
- 10:44is the very cornerstone of all
- 10:46problematic discussions. Dead or alive.
- 10:49>> Biologists will never tell you at what
- 10:51moment life began. They simply won't
- 10:53say it. They will say, "Look, this is
- 10:54already a cell." But the thing is, this
- 10:56"already a cell" just isn't there.
- 10:57There is just some machine that
- 10:58replicates itself in a certain way
- 11:00there. And here, chemists will explain
- 11:02in detail why the processes that occur
- 11:04in these Q45s and others that were
- 11:06recently discovered,
- 11:07>> what is Q45?
- 11:10>> It's a large polymer that can replicate
- 11:11itself, though with a very large, you
- 11:13know, loss, a percentage of loss such
- 11:15that within a few generations it all
- 11:16just goes to zero. And so, well, the
- 11:19presence of such, like,
- 11:20semi-replicating machines can be sold
- 11:22to someone, well, who is not
- 11:24knowledgeable in the subject, that, in
- 11:26fact, a key step on the path of
- 11:28biogenesis has already been taken. But
- 11:30even regarding this Q45, there were
- 11:32already announcements, disclaimers,
- 11:34that you shouldn't think we have
- 11:35explained life. We just came up with
- 11:37some strange machine. Funny.
- 11:39>> Did they come up with it or find it?
- 11:40>> Well, built it there, made it, came up
- 11:41with it, found it. Made it in the
- 11:42laboratory, made it.
- 11:43>> Somehow or other, they made it. Yes.
- 11:45Here, by the way, philosophically, if
- 11:48we try to play with philosophy a little
- 11:51bit, there are several such obvious
- 11:54conflations. Meaning, the conflation of
- 11:56"made in the laboratory" and "happened
- 11:58on its own." And here, on the path from
- 12:01here to there, there is a whole linear
- 12:03sequence of decreasing human
- 12:04involvement. And when, for example, a
- 12:07person only triggers certain reactions
- 12:10at the precisely calculated moments, it
- 12:12is presented as a success. By
- 12:15enthusiasts of abiogenesis, it is
- 12:17presented as a success, that is, a
- 12:19process that, well, supposedly happens
- 12:21on its own. We only created conditions
- 12:22similar to the primordial Earth. But in
- 12:24reality, at the right moments one thing
- 12:26is turned on, at another right moment
- 12:27another, and also,
- 12:28>> in reality, this is far from being the
- 12:29same thing. Nothing like self-emergence
- 12:32in completely uncontrolled conditions
- 12:34exists or has existed. But okay, let's
- 12:37assume this is the first point, right?
- 12:38The first is that it was made in the
- 12:40laboratory or could have emerged on its
- 12:41own. This is the first place where the
- 12:43deception lies, when it is presented,
- 12:45well, when it is presented to the
- 12:46general public, at this point an
- 12:48optimistic deception is always made,
- 12:49that it's just about to happen. The
- 12:52second, so, when we talk—I will, I
- 12:54will definitely return to Koonin now,
- 12:55but before that, I will list the other
- 12:57points of deception. The second point
- 13:00is a sort of rhetorical trick. It’s,
- 13:02"Aha, a creator." Well yes, sure, we
- 13:04can't figure anything out, so it must
- 13:06be a creator, right? But who created
- 13:08your creator? Nobody. So you don't know
- 13:10who created him? Well then, go home. In
- 13:12other words, here is what they do. If
- 13:14we can't answer the question: who
- 13:16created the creator? Then we are
- 13:19anti-scientific morons who aren't worth
- 13:21talking to. But meanwhile, the original
- 13:23question remains unanswered. How could
- 13:24it have arisen on its own?
- 13:25>> Substitution of the thesis.
- 13:26>> Well, I don't know what that philosophy
- 13:28is called. Substitution.
- 13:29>> It's logic. It’s a substitution of
- 13:30the thesis.
- 13:31>> Substitution. Well, substitution, or
- 13:33rather, I’d say in Russian, it’s
- 13:35passing the buck. "You have a hole
- 13:38there, too." If you have a creator,
- 13:40it's unclear who created him. Actually,
- 13:42we don't have a hole. We have a big
- 13:44hole. Well, we could say the hole
- 13:46consists in the fact that far from
- 13:48everything is scientifically provable,
- 13:50and not all questions can be formulated
- 13:52in science at all. For them, that's the
- 13:54end, because they are scientists, but
- 13:56for us, it's completely normal. It's a
- 13:58different approach to science. And so,
- 14:00well, a creator can be included in
- 14:01science or not, depending on the
- 14:03definition of science. But we allow him
- 14:05as an external cause, while they don't
- 14:08allow it at all. Consequently, the
- 14:10rhetorical technique is to immediately
- 14:11shift the field: "Ah, who created your
- 14:12Creator?""Ah, you don't know." And
- 14:14that's it. Therefore, we are doing
- 14:16abiogenesis because you don't know who
- 14:18created the creator. Meaning, we are
- 14:19building a perpetual motion machine
- 14:21because you don't know who invented
- 14:22this mechanism. Therefore, we claim it
- 14:24just spins around by itself right here.
- 14:26That's the second one. The third
- 14:28substitution is that
- 14:30>> Well, you yourself are saying
- 14:32substitution. Substitution,
- 14:33>> yes, the third, yes, the third
- 14:35philosophical substitution is that the
- 14:37argument for abiogenesis is the fact
- 14:39that we are talking here. This has been
- 14:42used repeatedly, when a person says: "
- 14:44Well, look, according to your
- 14:45probabilities, it's still impossible to
- 14:46understand how this could have happened
- 14:48within the
- 14:49>> time of the universe." Well, how? We
- 14:50are talking to each other, so it must
- 14:52have happened.
- 14:52>> And that is a logical fallacy.
- 14:54>> Well, that's it, you can basically end
- 14:56any discussion right there. I mean, if
- 14:58the argument
- 15:00>> is just repeating your own thesis, and
- 15:02that's it. So, the initial postulate of
- 15:06our opponents is that one must not
- 15:09appeal to a Creator. And since you
- 15:11can't, our very existence proves
- 15:13abiogenesis.
- 15:14>> Well, yeah,
- 15:14>> understandable. No mechanisms, nothing
- 15:16at all. But we exist, don't we? And
- 15:18this is also fed to the public. This is
- 15:20, by the way, even fed into scientific
- 15:21publications. Sometimes it's discussed.
- 15:24There is a publication stating that
- 15:26abiogenesis must have happened very
- 15:27quickly. And it's titled exactly that.
- 15:30It was a very fast process. But then it
- 15:31turns out that, actually, no one knows
- 15:33if it happened or not, but they explain
- 15:35that life must have already existed 4
- 15:36billion years ago. And therefore, this
- 15:38process was fast. Another completely
- 15:40brilliant deceptive move. And the
- 15:42fourth, um, such obvious deception is
- 15:45when they begin to attribute religious
- 15:47theories of one kind or another to the
- 15:50existing Creator. That is, they say: "
- 15:53Creator God," that is, yes, God, God,
- 15:55God. Well, you have one God, but
- 15:56Muslims have another, right? And over
- 15:58there, even Catholics have a third one.
- 15:59And in general, there are thousands of
- 16:01religious movements. So you guys figure
- 16:03out first what kind of God you have,
- 16:04and then come talk about the Creator.
- 16:07This is a rhetorical substitution of
- 16:10the issue, imposed by the subsequent,
- 16:13so to speak, agenda. That is, the
- 16:16agenda now is that this is not only a
- 16:18common prime cause for everyone, but
- 16:20also some kind of religious subject
- 16:21with whom we can build a relationship.
- 16:24God as the religious origin of
- 16:26everything, as, well, you know, God. We
- 16:28usually assume that we are discussing
- 16:30moral issues with Him. This is called,
- 16:32again, a substitution of the thesis,
- 16:34because we are discussing abiogenesis,
- 16:36not
- 16:37>> how to relate to the interpretation of
- 16:39the Bible.
- 16:40>> So this is, in fact, purely a
- 16:41substitution of the thesis. Right now,
- 16:43we are not even in the realm of biology
- 16:45,
- 16:46>> but logic. The most ordinary logic,
- 16:48which has been known for thousands of
- 16:50years.
- 16:51>> Well, yes. And the fifth is creationism
- 16:53. What is creationism? Well, for our
- 16:56opponents, it's a bogeyman. Such a word
- 16:58, bogeyman. If a person is a
- 16:59creationist, that's it, he's not a
- 17:00scientist, he must be excluded from
- 17:01everything. There. But what is a
- 17:03creationist? If it is a person who
- 17:06simply says that from existing data and
- 17:08existing scientific laws it directly
- 17:10follows that abiogenesis equals a
- 17:12perpetual motion machine, then we must
- 17:13look for other explanations, for
- 17:15example, the presence of an external
- 17:17cause in the form of a Creator.
- 17:20>> Alexeyevich.
- 17:20>> And this is what is called creationism.
- 17:22But no, attention. Then at this moment
- 17:26you are necessarily told that a
- 17:28creationist is the same thing as a
- 17:30flat-earther. Must believe in
- 17:33reptilians,
- 17:34>> in reptilians, in a flat earth, in the
- 17:36absence of Americans on the Moon, in
- 17:38the absence of the climate change
- 17:40agenda, and in tin foil hats for NATO.
- 17:43And then the whole list follows, right,
- 17:456000 years. In 6000 years, meaning
- 17:47everything about the Earth being 6000
- 17:49years old. So, as soon as we suggested
- 17:51that science has obviously hit a wall
- 17:53regarding an external cause, and we
- 17:55state this, we say: "Let's discuss this
- 17:57." Yes, the theory of intelligent
- 17:59design. She says: "That's creationism."
- 18:01You—it’s all clear. "You are in the
- 18:02same place as those—you are in the
- 18:04same place as the flat-earthers."
- 18:05>> Yes, that’s clear. These are methods
- 18:08of moral pressure. This happens when
- 18:10there are no real arguments.
- 18:12>> Yes. That’s exactly what we want to
- 18:14say, that they don't have any.
- 18:15>> Well, that is the most important thing.
- 18:17Let's return to my question. You are a
- 18:19mathematician, you open the mathemati
- 18:21—
- 18:21>> Koonin.
- 18:22>> Yes, I open it.
- 18:22>> You started with—
- 18:24>> And I read, yes, I read that he
- 18:26honestly states that no transitions
- 18:28from the RNA world to a protein one are
- 18:30visible.
- 18:31>> What does math have to do with it?
- 18:32>> Here’s what. The fact is that while
- 18:36Q-beta could have self-created for
- 18:38combinatorial reasons—chemically, in
- 18:41one of our future broadcasts, a chemist
- 18:44will explain what Q-beta is and how it
- 18:47works. But at least combinatorially,
- 18:49for random reasons somewhere in the
- 18:51world, this combination could, in
- 18:52principle, have occurred once in the
- 18:54entire history of the universe. But if
- 18:56we are talking about the emergence of
- 18:58the entire replication system,
- 19:00requiring complex proteins, then Koonin
- 19:02says that 1,800 nucleotides must be
- 19:05strictly arranged in a single row. And
- 19:07the probability of this, well, in the
- 19:09sense of a clearly understood structure
- 19:11, exactly, yes, exactly understood,
- 19:12exactly one sequence. The probability
- 19:14of what is equal to 10 to the power of
- 19:15-18? According to his estimates, that
- 19:19probability, taking into account the
- 19:21wildly exaggerated assumptions about
- 19:22the rate of attempts in favor of
- 19:24biogenesis—meaning, quite a lot, yes,
- 19:26maximally in favor.
- 19:27>> Let's pin that down. So that is one
- 19:30chance in how many?
- 19:32>> 10 to the 118th power—unfortunately,
- 19:35our opponents are often poor with
- 19:38figures and numbers. It means you
- 19:41divide by 10 more than 1,000 times in a
- 19:45row. Well, unity.
- 19:48>> Well, unity, yes, there was one earth,
- 19:50it was divided into 10 pieces, it
- 19:52became Russia. It was divided into 10
- 19:55pieces, it became, let's say, Yakutia.
- 19:57Well, even, even, even less. Divided
- 19:59into 10 more pieces, it became Karelia.
- 20:01That’s me dividing it three or four
- 20:02times, right? Then I divided Karelia
- 20:04three or four more times by 10, and I
- 20:06already had a patch of land there that
- 20:07I could run across in a few minutes
- 20:09myself. Then I divided by 10 another 10
- 20:12times. I ended up with this barely
- 20:14noticeable little speck. And when I
- 20:16divided it by 10 another 25 times, I
- 20:18got an atom. And that was only dividing
- 20:21by 10 about 40 times or less, while
- 20:23here you need to divide by 10 a
- 20:25thousand times. No one can do that.
- 20:27Even among our opponents, well, many
- 20:30don't understand what kind of number
- 20:33that is.
- 20:34>> Wait, let's use an illustrative
- 20:36metaphor,
- 20:37>> please. A tennis ball.
- 20:38>> No, let me do it, and you help me if
- 20:41I'm wrong. Let's not talk about a ball.
- 20:42We have a coin, heads or tails. Well,
- 20:45yeah.
- 20:45>> Two options. A person bets on heads,
- 20:47and there are two options. Well, the
- 20:49probability is 1/2.
- 20:51>> 3,000 times in a row.
- 20:52>> No, no, no. So, let's suppose we have
- 20:5710 playing cards. 10. They are all
- 21:00different. I bet, for example, that,
- 21:02well, there's definitely a six of clubs
- 21:04in there. That’s a 1/probability. But
- 21:08there is
- 21:08>> out of cards 1/36.
- 21:09>> No, I mean 10 in total. 10 in total.
- 21:12And we know in advance that there are
- 21:13exactly 10. Well, yes. The favorable
- 21:16outcome we need is 1/10. But if we take
- 21:20, say, a blind method with some number
- 21:23of objects, and only one fits, and I
- 21:25pull one out with my eyes closed, then
- 21:28in your case, how many items would have
- 21:31to be in that virtual bag?
- 21:34>> Well, not even one would fit in that.
- 21:36Well,
- 21:36>> no, no, say that number again.
- 21:38>> 10 to the power of, but not a power of
- 21:4118, those are too small. Well,
- 21:43currently there are just 10 ^ 80 atoms
- 21:44in the entire universe.
- 21:46>> Okay, one more time. All the atoms in
- 21:48the universe total 10 ^ 80.
- 21:50>> Yes, yes, yes. This cannot be discussed
- 21:51as a scientific theory by anyone, ever.
- 21:53Just by no one, ever.
- 21:55>> Yes. Therefore, this is closed, and he
- 21:59says himself: "The protein world could
- 22:01not have emerged on its own, of course,
- 22:04but," he says, "Eureka, the multiverse.
- 22:06" The second and final part of the
- 22:10duology about Zmey Gorynych. The True
- 22:13Master begins the implementation of his
- 22:16next sinister plan. Meanwhile, Gorynych
- 22:18is starting a family. The shapeshifter
- 22:21Sokol Sokolovich heads abroad, and
- 22:24Koschei longs for his homeland. An epic
- 22:28battle is looming: the Master's iron
- 22:31will against the Faraway Kingdom. How
- 22:34will the characters from the first
- 22:36novel behave in these new circumstances
- 22:38? What role will the Lernaean Hydra,
- 22:41Count Dracula, Dukeham, and other
- 22:43characters play? You will find out
- 22:47about this by reading the geopolitical
- 22:49thriller "Zmey Gorynych, Hero of the
- 22:51Faraway Kingdom." The story is aimed at
- 22:54an adult audience. It contains scenes
- 22:57of violence, alcohol, and tobacco use.
- 23:03We live in one of an infinite number of
- 23:07universes,
- 23:08>> exactly the one where this emerged.
- 23:10>> Where has anyone seen these universes?
- 23:11Nowhere and by no one. This is the only
- 23:14way to avoid the logical contradiction,
- 23:16yes, from what he said before. But that
- 23:19is, one external cause, one creator, is
- 23:22replaced by 10 to the power of a
- 23:25thousand, or an infinite number of,
- 23:28universes that are seen by no one and
- 23:31recorded nowhere.
- 23:32>> Well,
- 23:34>> well, for a cell you'd have to take an
- 23:36infinite amount, because a cell is even
- 23:38worse, as a cell...to justify the
- 23:40existence of one universe, one has to
- 23:42admit that a scientific argument exists
- 23:44,
- 23:45>> yes, and this is a scientific article,
- 23:46that's the thing. So, instead of just
- 23:49writing it directly and clearly—guys,
- 23:51let's just be honest with ourselves,
- 23:53there are no chemical causes, and those
- 23:55of us who have studied chemistry
- 23:57understand this. Combinatorial causes
- 24:01are impossible. This combination, never
- 24:03in the time...did you re-read it, did
- 24:04you do your own calculations?
- 24:05>> I did. I suggested, I suggested
- 24:08nucleotides pairing at the speed of
- 24:11light throughout the history of the
- 24:13universe, which...
- 24:15>> 14 billion years at every point in this
- 24:18empty universe.
- 24:19>> And what was the result?
- 24:21>> 10 to the power of -960.
- 24:23>> Oh, so it was a thousand. You improved
- 24:25it just a little bit.
- 24:26>> It is all...No, everyone who has worked
- 24:27with numbers understands this perfectly
- 24:28well. This is zero. This is, this is
- 24:30zero. This is impossible. But here is
- 24:31this 10 to the thousandth power. Well,
- 24:33there you go. And a trillion is how
- 24:35much? 10 to the 12th power,
- 24:37>> yes, a trillion. And when people speak
- 24:40abstractly about the biggest number in
- 24:42the world, well, abstractly, 10 to the
- 24:43100th is still...
- 24:44>> 10 to the 100th, right? And this is 10
- 24:46to the, well, let's round it to the
- 24:48thousandth,
- 24:49>> yes,
- 24:49>> power. So, there,
- 24:51>> well, that is, that is, it's like,
- 24:52there's no...unfortunately, yes, but
- 24:53for those to whom numbers are given,
- 24:55they are given, and to those they
- 24:56aren't, they aren't. But could it have
- 24:58happened simply or by some other way,
- 25:02right? If you invite, say, some other
- 25:05defenders of this idea, they will say:
- 25:07"No, no, no, of course, we can't just
- 25:08...That, that, of course, wasn't how it
- 25:10was. Koonin is very pessimistic. Of
- 25:13course, it all happened through an
- 25:15evolutionary path." So, they toss,
- 25:17Panchen really loves this, they toss a
- 25:19few coins onto the table. Those that
- 25:21land on heads are selected,
- 25:22>> survived. Survived.
- 25:24>> Yes. Tails, we toss again. But the
- 25:26question is: what laws of chemical
- 25:28evolution do you know? Answer: none. So
- 25:31, let's clarify what "selected" means.
- 25:33That is, stabilized, did not disappear.
- 25:34>> Well, for some reason, the heads didn't
- 25:36disappear, but the tails did. This is
- 25:39cited as why we calculate probabilities
- 25:41incorrectly. They say: "We are
- 25:43calculating probabilities incorrectly,
- 25:44because we need to fix the heads, and
- 25:46chemical evolution will select them."
- 25:47>> That is,
- 25:48>> attention, no one has ever seen any
- 25:50chemical evolution.
- 25:51>> Are you sure? Invite chemists, because
- 25:55I can, well, some biologist might say:
- 25:58"Well, we could consider this to be
- 26:00chemical evolution." We need a chemist
- 26:03here who will explain why chemical
- 26:06processes differ radically from
- 26:08biological ones. There are some
- 26:10potentials of Gibbs, something like
- 26:11that there. These questions shouldn't
- 26:13be asked to a biologist.
- 26:14>> They should be asked to chemists. I am
- 26:15stating,
- 26:16>> I am announcing. I am announcing. We
- 26:18will have a series of programs. A
- 26:20scientist chemist will be here. Follow
- 26:23this series. We will have a separate
- 26:26playlist about abiogenesis.
- 26:27>> Everyone interested will be able to
- 26:30watch, I think, the most comprehensive
- 26:32approach. We will have many, many such
- 26:34broadcasts.
- 26:35>> Yes, there will also be
- 26:36>> who will it be or in what field? Let's
- 26:39get
- 26:39>> there will be, there will be. It's the
- 26:41genetic code, after all.
- 26:42>> Well, exactly, we will get to DNA later
- 26:44.
- 26:44>> Yes, yes, yes, yes. It will be very
- 26:45interesting there. Well, in short, I,
- 26:47as the person who is initiating this,
- 26:49>> yes, well, you are the headliner, yes,
- 26:51as a headliner I declare that Koonin's
- 26:53calculations are correct, and the
- 26:55explanation via the multiverse does not
- 26:57stand up to any scientific cri-
- 26:59>> Alright, wait. Okay, just a minute,
- 27:00just a minute. Let's assume, let's
- 27:02assume,
- 27:03>> they are right, and we are supporters
- 27:05of biogenesis,
- 27:06>> and they say that these tails were
- 27:08re-flipped, and the heads were selected
- 27:10, and this increases the probability of
- 27:12appearance.
- 27:13>> No, that's fine, go ahead.
- 27:14>> But by how much does it increase? No,
- 27:15does this immediately make everything
- 27:17fully possible, right? No, it's just,
- 27:19well, what they are saying is
- 27:20completely inexplicable,
- 27:22>> absolutely nothing, right? I mean, how
- 27:25could tails be selected at a level
- 27:26where there is only blind chemistry?
- 27:29But the chemist will talk about that
- 27:31here. And then they say the following:
- 27:34"Well, you are only calculating the
- 27:36probability of a specific type of
- 27:38replication-protein system. But what if
- 27:41there are 10 to the power of 999 types
- 27:44of systems?" that could theoretically
- 27:47work.
- 27:47>> There is only one answer to this. This
- 27:49is the only answer.
- 27:51>> If "ifs" and "buts" were candy and nuts
- 27:53, we'd all have a Merry Christmas. If,
- 27:57in order to justify your model and
- 27:59somehow contradict Koonin and me—who
- 28:02confirmed his calculations—you are
- 28:04forced to invent the hypothetical
- 28:06existence of biological organizations,
- 28:09nucleotides in the amount of 10—well,
- 28:11many, many, many, like 980—just so
- 28:14that the remaining probability could be
- 28:17realized somewhere at least, you are
- 28:19either just, well, a soul-talker, right
- 28:22, that is, well, a chatterbox, a person
- 28:24who, well, makes things up out of thin
- 28:28air. Or you are obliged to present at
- 28:31least some evidence for such a theory,
- 28:35>> because speculative theories cannot be
- 28:37an explanation for biogenesis,
- 28:38otherwise we are not playing on a
- 28:40scientific field. What is faith? Faith
- 28:45is, uh, faith is the assurance of
- 28:47things invisible, uh,
- 28:50>> of things unverifiable.
- 28:51>> No, well yes, and the hope for what is
- 28:53promised, right? Yes. That is, well,
- 28:55it's like an assurance of the invisible
- 28:57, a hope. Well, it sounded something
- 28:58like that. So, for them, this turns out
- 29:00to be pure faith for people who are
- 29:03>> believing that there will be a huge
- 29:05number of options for how life can
- 29:07function. But, of course, you can't
- 29:09fool Koonin with that. He is a
- 29:10scientist. And he saw the only loophole
- 29:13, because if he hadn't seen it, what
- 29:15would he have had to admit? Guys, we
- 29:18have to put a cross on biogenesis once
- 29:20and for all. A big, big cross. One like
- 29:23this. Give me one second. I'm going to
- 29:25play on their field for a little bit
- 29:27now. I'm going to play on their field
- 29:28for a little bit now. The fact is, it's
- 29:31too early to put a cross on biogenesis.
- 29:33On biogenesis in the narrow sense, in
- 29:36the technology that is currently being
- 29:39proposed, maybe yes, but perhaps there
- 29:42were other ways of turning the dead
- 29:44into the living. Therefore, this
- 29:47passage of yours does not put a cross
- 29:48on it yet. It does not put a cross on
- 29:50it. That is, so if we are not seriously
- 29:53considering such hypotheses as the idea
- 29:55that life could theoretically exist in
- 29:57an insanely quantitative way, roughly
- 29:59speaking, no matter how life is put
- 30:01together.
- 30:02>> There was such a version, right? Well,
- 30:05no matter how life is put together, it
- 30:07works, right? But this is not confirmed
- 30:09by anything at all. One.
- 30:10>> Yes. Then one simply has to say that
- 30:13your approaches are faith. One could
- 30:17even, in a sense, call it religion. It
- 30:19is religion. Religion. And biogenesis
- 30:21is such a religion that science will
- 30:22explain it anyway.
- 30:23>> That is, actually, what it is. Science
- 30:24will explain it anyway. They say it
- 30:26like this,
- 30:26>> science will explain it in the end
- 30:27anyway. It has never given up, has it?
- 30:30Wait, guys, it has given up. We will
- 30:32certainly never explain the Big Bang,
- 30:34of course. That is perfectly clear. No,
- 30:36they will say: "We will explain it." I
- 30:37say: "How?" I know how.
- 30:39>> I have no idea.
- 30:40>> I will tell you how: with multiverses
- 30:41that existed before this. Well, in what
- 30:43sense? In what sense, multiverses? That
- 30:45before this Big Bang, well,
- 30:47conditionally, there existed, you know,
- 30:49they talk about these sausages, you
- 30:52know, appearing and disappearing into a
- 30:54point, which directly contradicts the
- 30:57laws of physics. No, the multiverse can
- 30:59only explain the precise tuning of
- 31:01constants. So, if we are moving on to
- 31:03this part, yes, we need to invite Burov
- 31:05; unfortunately, he is not in Russia.
- 31:07Will there only be in-person shows, or
- 31:09not?
- 31:09>> Yes, it can be done remotely.
- 31:10>> We need to with Burov
- 31:11>> we will do it.
- 31:12>> There. Uh, he will explain about
- 31:13multiverses. Burov. There. But that is
- 31:15about something else. The Big Bang is a
- 31:17long topic; we will get carried away
- 31:19and drift in another direction. Well, I
- 31:21just mean that science has already
- 31:22surrendered, and surrendered for good.
- 31:24Therefore, there is nothing new in this
- 31:26. They just, well, sort of, they didn't
- 31:28notice, apparently they missed this Big
- 31:29Bang. So, moving on. What else? What
- 31:32remains? We have chemical
- 31:35transformations, right? But chemistry
- 31:37has existed for 150 years, and no
- 31:39miracles, as my chemist friend says,
- 31:41have been discovered. So it is faith
- 31:43again.
- 31:44>> 150 years is a very short time.
- 31:45>> Well, no. Well then, it is faith that
- 31:48some chemical processes, of which no
- 31:50one has the slightest clue, will start
- 31:52up, something will start in the next
- 31:54tin can. Well, that is, abiogenesis
- 31:56constantly runs into a strong faith
- 31:58that someday, something that cannot
- 32:00even be imagined today will be
- 32:02discovered and shown.
- 32:04>> This has, in my view, this has, in my
- 32:07view, all the signs
- 32:08>> of mystical concepts.
- 32:10>> Yes. Yes. Yes.
- 32:11>> There. But, but since—just a second
- 32:15—since in the modern world it is
- 32:17somewhat awkward to speak the language
- 32:19of mysticism, in their interpretation,
- 32:21there will never be the word "mage,"
- 32:24there will be the word "genius," for
- 32:26example, or in their interpretation,
- 32:28there will not be some divine power. It
- 32:32will be some kind of natural force, but
- 32:34in their description, it will have the
- 32:36same features as a divine or
- 32:37otherworldly force because it cannot be
- 32:39measured. Yes.
- 32:40>> Yes, yes, yes. Nowadays, theories very
- 32:43often write: "Abiogenesis occurred
- 32:44according to the laws of
- 32:45self-organization of matter."
- 32:47>> Yes. According to what laws?
- 32:49>> What other laws? We are simply
- 32:50introducing such a law of
- 32:51self-organization of matter.
- 32:52>> Well, as they used to say, I believe,
- 32:54in ancient times, nature abhors a
- 32:55vacuum. If it is empty, nature does not
- 32:57tolerate the absence of life. There is
- 32:59such a law. Well, if that law is
- 33:00considered science, then I give up.
- 33:02Then, of course, we can explain
- 33:03absolutely anything we want.
- 33:04>> No, well, there is no need for us to
- 33:05give up. We just need to clearly,
- 33:07clearly understand what
- 33:08>> we are dealing with. That is, people
- 33:11speak in the name of science, people
- 33:13speak scientism. Well, you expect, you
- 33:16really expect that, well, since that's
- 33:18the case, then everything is strictly
- 33:20as accepted in science. But they always
- 33:22speak from the podium of scientificity.
- 33:24That is what is important. They have
- 33:25science, and those who are against it
- 33:26have fantasies. Yes,
- 33:28>> yes, and here everything is the
- 33:29opposite. Here science ruthlessly says:
- 33:30"There is no perpetual motion machine,
- 33:32and there is no abiogenesis." By the
- 33:34way, the same thing is happening with
- 33:35homeopathy. The parallels are very
- 33:37clear. They themselves dismiss
- 33:39homeopathy, yes. But at the same time,
- 33:42homeopathy as a field of knowledge has
- 33:44all the same signs as abiogenesis. That
- 33:47is, mechanisms are invented there, er,
- 33:49well, the excuses are all the same. We
- 33:52are sitting here, so, abiogenesis
- 33:53happened, someone is helped by
- 33:55something, so, homeopathy. At the same
- 33:57time, I am completely, right now I am,
- 33:59I am, I am intentionally stirring the
- 34:00pot. Why? Because I myself have
- 34:03defended homeopathy from the lines of
- 34:06reasoning used against it. Against it,
- 34:08well, the most, the most sophisticated
- 34:10arguments were applied. And their main
- 34:14thesis is that the fact that it helps
- 34:16cannot be an argument. And here is an
- 34:19exactly parallel thesis: the fact that
- 34:21we exist becomes an argument. That is,
- 34:24there is even, my friend compiled a
- 34:26whole table, there is complete
- 34:28parallelism, complete. One could write
- 34:29an article about this. Parallels of
- 34:31homeopathy, abiogenesis, but the
- 34:33parallel with a perpetual motion
- 34:34machine works even better. My chemist
- 34:36friend says it clearly, exactly like a
- 34:38perpetual motion machine. That's it.
- 34:40>> You know, here I will take it: a motor
- 34:42hasn't generated money for 150 years,
- 34:44but for abiogenesis, it’s easy.
- 34:46>> That is understandable. But I will
- 34:48object: there is still a specific
- 34:50approach, a scientific law that shows
- 34:52and proves that a perpetual motion
- 34:54machine cannot exist; energy does not
- 34:56appear from nothing. It is the same
- 34:58thing here. And a chemist will tell you
- 35:00this,
- 35:00>> right? The same thing, wait a minute. A
- 35:03small probability and zero probability
- 35:05are not the same thing. Reasoning from
- 35:07a ten-minute timeframe is not allowed.
- 35:09It is, it is absolutely, it is
- 35:11completely anti-scientific.
- 35:13>> But wait, now,
- 35:14>> I still insist on this. It is
- 35:18impossible. I know, Mikhail Gelfand
- 35:20likes to do that. So what? I laid out a
- 35:22deck of cards. It has, well, it has
- 35:25zero probability of being exactly that
- 35:27way before it was dealt. So this
- 35:30argument destroys any scientific, well,
- 35:32any concept of a scientific explanation
- 35:34whatsoever. It's the same as just
- 35:36admitting that we never knew it.
- 35:37>> Alexey Vladimirovich, here is what I am
- 35:38insisting on, you probably don't
- 35:40understand me,
- 35:40>> right?
- 35:41>> There is a logical difference between a
- 35:43probability equal to zero and a
- 35:45probability not equal to zero.
- 35:47>> A physicist would say no.
- 35:48>> Why? In physics, chemistry, or biology,
- 35:50it is basically not accepted to use
- 35:52explanations where the probability is
- 35:54below a certain threshold.
- 35:55>> A new mathematician. I am speaking to
- 35:57you as a mathematician.
- 35:58>> No, no, no, no. Abiogenesis is not just
- 36:00a mathematical problem, so it cannot be
- 36:02discussed here.
- 36:03>> And why is such a probability not
- 36:05accepted?
- 36:06>> Well, simply because no scientific
- 36:08theory assumes that something could
- 36:10have arisen with such a probability. No
- 36:13, it's just generally accepted.
- 36:14>> Well, it's a postulate.
- 36:15>> It's a postulate of science, yes.
- 36:16>> A postulate of science. So that is what
- 36:18they say. This is very important.
- 36:20Uh-huh. So. Except for Gelfand, none of
- 36:24them say that it just happened by
- 36:26itself, thank God. No one. Only Gelfand
- 36:28, only once. In fact, he only used this
- 36:31argument once in that dispute with the
- 36:34American preacher. Actually, in later
- 36:37disputes, I think he himself said that,
- 36:40of course, we cannot, this cannot be
- 36:42considered as such. That's interesting.
- 36:44It would be interesting to really
- 36:46collect a selection of statements from
- 36:48recognized biologists, meaning the
- 36:50leading lights, where they say: "We
- 36:52cannot base our work on such a
- 36:53probability,
- 36:55>> it's unscientific." That would be
- 36:56interesting. It exists, Markov has
- 36:59indications of which theories, yes, we,
- 37:01well, when a population evolves,
- 37:04evolution, yes, by the way, the sixth
- 37:06substitution, I forgot,
- 37:09>> but it relates not to abiogenesis, but
- 37:11to evolution. Well,
- 37:13>> when we start talking about the
- 37:15problems of evolution, they say: "Oh,
- 37:17you deny speciation, you deny that
- 37:19species are changeable." So the
- 37:22substitution is that Darwin's theory
- 37:24about the evolutionary origin, the
- 37:27material origin of all existing
- 37:28diversity of species, is replaced by
- 37:31microevolution, which everyone has
- 37:33observed and which is not in the
- 37:35slightest, so to speak, in doubt for
- 37:37anyone. So, when they calculate these
- 37:40evolutionary models in a population,
- 37:42when population genetics comes into
- 37:44play, and they write that, well, if
- 37:46there are 100 of these and 20 of those,
- 37:49then given certain parameters, it's 100
- 37:51%certain that this one will win. 100%
- 37:53starts at 10 to the minus 20th, or even
- 37:5510 to the minus 10th.
- 37:57>> Is that correct?
- 37:58>> Yes, of course it's correct, because it
- 38:00will simply never happen in the
- 38:01observable universe.
- 38:02>> Uh-huh.
- 38:02>> That's it. No, everything is clear here
- 38:04. You shouldn't joke with probabilities
- 38:05. Probabilities like that are
- 38:06effectively zero. This is very
- 38:08important, because once again, this is
- 38:09your field, where you are a doctor of
- 38:11science. I want to emphasize that. You
- 38:13are not here as a 100%biased person.
- 38:15>> And why not talk about interesting
- 38:18questions?
- 38:18>> Why not talk about the fact that one
- 38:21tennis ball...
- 38:23>> Yes, what about the ball?
- 38:25>> The whole universe, everything, even to
- 38:27the farthest stars, not just the Earth,
- 38:28but the entire universe, all the way to
- 38:30the most distant stars, is stuffed with
- 38:31tennis balls. My friend even came up
- 38:34with this, packed tightly against each
- 38:36other. You pick one at random and find
- 38:39that you picked the one ball that has a
- 38:42note, the one single one with a note.
- 38:46You cross yourself and do it 12 more
- 38:48times. 11, 12 times in total.
- 38:51>> 12 in a row.
- 38:53>> In a row. What is important?
- 38:55>> Well, I would say it’s completely
- 38:56unimportant, because even one ball is
- 38:58clear enough. No, that’s not even
- 39:00worth discussing. Not worth discussing.
- 39:02Small probabilities are zero. And that
- 39:03is scientifically recognized. None of
- 39:05them would ever argue otherwise. That
- 39:07is why they still cling to chemical
- 39:09evolution. But it is impossible for
- 39:11other reasons, for chemical reasons. We
- 39:13keep chasing them, right, you catch one
- 39:15here and he says: "Well, well, it just
- 39:17happened on its own, what are you
- 39:18talking about?""It just happened and
- 39:20that's it." Yes, he says: "Wait, but
- 39:22here and here and here in your own
- 39:24science, in biology, everything below
- 39:2610 to the minus...oh, damn, never mind.
- 39:29" Well, chemically, chemistry comes in
- 39:31and says: "It couldn't have happened
- 39:32chemically," and then next they say: "
- 39:34Damn, well, then, you know, we must be
- 39:35seeing a new law of nature.""It's the
- 39:38self-organization of matter." And so
- 39:39you chase them, you hunt them down like
- 39:41that, and every time they change their
- 39:43story and try to give us something new.
- 39:46>> Well, this indicates that here, of
- 39:48course, it is necessary—as cliché
- 39:50and hackneyed as it may sound—to use
- 39:52a complex approach. Well, that is
- 39:54exactly what it is, meaning an
- 39:55interdisciplinary one. Everything needs
- 39:57to be gathered here. If one parameter
- 39:58is fulfilled, then the second parameter
- 40:00is definitely not fulfilled. They are
- 40:01interconnected by the principle of
- 40:03>> negative optimization, right? You
- 40:05either increase one, which means the
- 40:06other decreases, or vice versa. Right?
- 40:08>> Well, I don't really understand what
- 40:10exactly you're talking about.
- 40:11>> I'll tell you what. That is, you can
- 40:14explain something, explain some
- 40:16parameter by, well, by the fact that
- 40:18you stretch the blanket over yourself
- 40:20so much that the others become
- 40:22impossible. I just didn't understand at
- 40:25first. See, that is optimization based
- 40:26on mutually exclusive parameters.
- 40:29Something was happening in the furnace,
- 40:30and one of the pebbles, after repeated
- 40:32melting and heating, suddenly turned
- 40:34into something resembling a brick. And
- 40:37you say: "So, that means this building
- 40:39could have built itself."
- 40:41>> Uh-huh. Yes.
- 40:43>> The Pyramid of Cheops will assemble
- 40:44itself.
- 40:45>> Yes. Well, here already
- 40:46>> and that's how it is here. But the
- 40:48uninitiated don't understand that. The
- 40:50uninitiated think: "Well, since a brick
- 40:52, something like a brick, came out of
- 40:53the furnace by itself." Well, that
- 40:55means all the others gathered together
- 40:56and all this
- 40:56>> they don't notice that there is a break
- 40:58in continuity here, right?
- 41:00>> The uninitiated don't see it. I'm more
- 41:02interested in why the initiated don't
- 41:04tell the truth. That's what I'm more
- 41:06interested in. This is extremely strong
- 41:08ideological pressure. It's impossible
- 41:11to even find people there who would
- 41:12sign some kind of appeal, nothing at
- 41:14all. It gives the impression that this
- 41:17is the greatest deception in the
- 41:19history of all science throughout its
- 41:21entire existence. Abiogenesis is the
- 41:25biggest deception.
- 41:27>> I believe the biggest deception lies in
- 41:29something else: that there is no God.
- 41:31>> Now that is the biggest deception. And
- 41:33everything else follows from this as
- 41:36isolated cases. But, of course, I am
- 41:38giving grounds right now for comments
- 41:40to say that two religious obscurantists
- 41:41have gathered here, and that's exactly
- 41:43where we'll catch you if you write that
- 41:45, because it's a substitution of the
- 41:46thesis. We are not discussing our own.
- 41:49Well,
- 41:49>> yes, actually we are discussing—yes,
- 41:51that was just a philosophical remark
- 41:52just now. But when a person really
- 41:57encounters the need for an external
- 41:59cause, and this, of course, hints that,
- 42:02as it turns out, one needs to study
- 42:04something else besides science, the
- 42:07person becomes so distressed that they
- 42:09simply start brazenly deceiving their
- 42:12listeners. And
- 42:14>> and this is very bad. It is very, very
- 42:16bad.
- 42:16>> Yes, well, that's the realm of
- 42:17psychologists.
- 42:18>> That is, we won't go into that, so to
- 42:20speak. We are not moralists. I just
- 42:23suggest that someday an official
- 42:25document should be released stating
- 42:27that abiogenesis is recognized as
- 42:28impossible with current scientific
- 42:30knowledge.
- 42:32>> Well, who could issue such a document?
- 42:33>> The RAS, of course, the RAS. Only the
- 42:36RAS.
- 42:37>> That is, to make a decision similar to
- 42:38the one made back in the day regarding
- 42:40perpetual motion machines, like, patent
- 42:42applications for perpetual motion
- 42:43machines are not accepted.
- 42:44>> Yes, exactly.
- 42:46>> Well, that is, essentially, I am making
- 42:49this proposal seriously.
- 42:50>> That's the goal. That is effectively
- 42:51your ultimate goal, right?
- 42:52>> Uh-huh. Well, yes. It's a goal we
- 42:55haven't approached yet.
- 42:57>> I see, understood. We are only just
- 42:59starting our series of programs. As the
- 43:01saying goes, the road is made by
- 43:03walking. Whether a document will appear
- 43:05or not, we don't know. But we will do
- 43:07our part.
- 43:07>> We will do our job. We have discussed
- 43:09everything. I stand by everything I
- 43:11said today. I stake my reputation on it
- 43:13. I might have mixed up a few terms,
- 43:15but I stand by the fact that this
- 43:17picture has been presented adequately.
- 43:20I don't think any of them will object
- 43:21that I presented this adequately. They
- 43:24will simply argue, saying: "Well, no,
- 43:26we have the right to invent hypotheses,
- 43:29that's also science." That's how it is.
- 43:31That will be the dispute. Understood?
- 43:33Well,
- 43:34>> it's interesting whether, besides the
- 43:36swearing and insults, which will
- 43:37certainly be here,
- 43:39>> will there be anything,
- 43:41>> anything of substance? I'm interested
- 43:44to see what will be of substance.
- 43:46>> We will see it all. Yes,
- 43:48>> I repeat once again, there will be a
- 43:50playlist,
- 43:50>> yes,
- 43:51>> on this concept, theory, and so on, the
- 43:53paradigm of abiogenesis; perhaps we
- 43:55will even call it "Abiogenesis." Within
- 43:58the framework of this playlist, there
- 44:00will be many broadcasts. The first one
- 44:03is yours,
- 44:05>> but that doesn't mean that
- 44:06>> Alexey Vladimirovich won't come back.
- 44:08He will, but there will be other
- 44:10broadcasts after this one. You
- 44:12suggested inviting a chemist, a
- 44:14geneticist, a cyberneticist. Who else
- 44:16would you recommend? We will invite
- 44:18everyone and conduct interviews with
- 44:20everyone,
- 44:21>> interviews,
- 44:22>> conversations, if the opponents want to
- 44:24arrange a discussion.
- 44:26>> Easily.
- 44:27>> We have a special form of discussion.
- 44:29We use chess clocks. Where each person
- 44:33can only speak during their own time,
- 44:36managed by the host, so there's no
- 44:38physical fighting, and each person
- 44:40spends their time as they wish. They
- 44:43can spend a long time discussing or
- 44:44reasoning on a short question,
- 44:45>> right? That's the format we had with
- 44:47Panchin when we were discussing.
- 44:49>> We have already done this many times,
- 44:51using chess clocks. It disciplines
- 44:53people very well; it prevents bickering
- 44:55and shouting. And if a person has spent
- 44:57their time, and the opponent has time,
- 44:59then the opponent can keep talking and
- 45:01talking. That's all part of it. So, I
- 45:03also invite opponents to meet for a
- 45:06discussion with you, yes, if you can.
- 45:10>> No, unfortunately, I am infinitely busy
- 45:11, so there should be a discussion
- 45:13specifically with, well, a chemist, for
- 45:15example, about, well, like that. But in
- 45:18reality, we just had some wonderful
- 45:20debates, Oleg Starovoitov and Mikhail
- 45:23Nikitin, they managed without clocks.
- 45:26They spoke very well, and Oleg simply
- 45:29pointed out specifically to Mikhail
- 45:31where the chemical laws stand, which
- 45:33you know, scientific discussions are
- 45:35usually not limited to one meeting,
- 45:37right, on air or otherwise.
- 45:39>> Yes, of course, it must be continued,
- 45:41naturally. Whether they want to or not,
- 45:44whether it works out or not, we will
- 45:45see. I am waiting for you; do find some
- 45:48time, look for it. I am waiting for
- 45:50your colleagues to join me. No, debates
- 45:53in that sense. The fact that I go into
- 45:56debates with people like Panchin or
- 45:57Nikitin, that isn't obvious. This
- 46:00endeavor is definitely beneficial
- 46:01simply because it draws attention to
- 46:03the problem. But they easily corner me
- 46:06with their terminology. So, it's kind
- 46:09of a losing scenario. Someone who knows
- 46:11their science should go. That is
- 46:13correct. Because otherwise, how [can
- 46:15one say], "Wait, what did you say about
- 46:17this chemical impossibility?" Right.
- 46:20Right. "And, well, which theory of this
- 46:22or that scientist are you basing this
- 46:24on?" Well, you see, right? And they
- 46:26bury the truth, which is visible to the
- 46:29naked eye, in trivialities, they start
- 46:30burying it in such nitpicking details.
- 46:34Therefore, the person who should go to
- 46:36the debate must be from the exact same
- 46:37field of knowledge as the opponents we
- 46:39invite. Otherwise, it just won't, well,
- 46:41be...
- 46:42>> Wait, hold on. Since you talked about
- 46:44probabilities, a mathematician could
- 46:45come out against you and say, "No, you
- 46:47calculated the probabilities
- 46:48incorrectly." There you go, but he
- 46:51won't be there.
- 46:52>> Well, that's fine.
- 46:54>> No, simply not...well, please, if any
- 46:56mathematician is ready to come out and
- 46:57explain something other than just a
- 46:59card game analogy, which is itself,
- 47:00well, that's...
- 47:02>> We aren't just a channel; we are a
- 47:04discussion platform.
- 47:05>> Uh-huh. Therefore, we have already
- 47:09decided, proponents of the hypothesis
- 47:13or abiogenesis will come, if they do
- 47:18come, we, for our part,
- 47:20>> as they say, will treat them with full
- 47:22respect.
- 47:22>> There. Well,
- 47:24>> yes, the seed has been planted. That's
- 47:25it, we've provided the starting point.
- 47:26>> Goodbye. In the studio was
- 47:28Corresponding Member of the Russian
- 47:30Academy of Sciences, Doctor of
- 47:32Mathematical Sciences Alexey Savvateev,
- 47:34>> Corresponding Member of the RAS for the
- 47:36economics section, Doctor of Physics
- 47:38and Mathematics Alexey Savvateev.
- 47:39>> He said, Doctor of Sciences. That’s
- 47:41all, goodbye. Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Алексей Савватеев | Крах концепции абиогенеза by Книжный Центр × Delib, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,758 words across 1,435 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.