Функции и ответственность бригады/прораба и компании при строительстве дома. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03Listen, you were watching, where were
- 0:05you even looking?
- 0:06The human factor is the most important
- 0:08thing.
- 0:09Why don't we go with something cheaper?
- 0:11Is he getting square footage or is he
- 0:13getting a peaceful life?
- 0:1590%is work organization, as well as
- 0:18technical client functions.
- 0:26Let's move to the block where we have
- 0:28the client. And we have construction of
- 0:33the site, meaning it moves to the site
- 0:35manager, to this part, and the site
- 0:37manager directly oversees everyone
- 0:39under him during the house construction
- 0:40. So, you need to tell us what a site
- 0:46manager's functions are, what you
- 0:48perform, what you cover.
- 0:50In my 9 years of work experience, I
- 0:53went from foreman to chief engineer.
- 0:56And at every stage of my profession,
- 0:58there were always different functions,
- 1:00but someone was always missing. When I
- 1:02was a site superintendent, there was a
- 1:05foreman or there wasn't, a chief
- 1:06engineer, or there wasn't a site
- 1:08superintendent and so on. So, my
- 1:10functions shifted a little bit into
- 1:12each other. I no longer see a clear
- 1:15boundary. Now I will tell you how the
- 1:17structure works specifically for you.
- 1:20Is that good or bad? I'll say that
- 1:25given my extensive experience, it comes
- 1:27easily to me here, but in reality, if I
- 1:29were a novice site manager, I probably
- 1:31wouldn't have managed.
- 1:33Because right now, for you, a site
- 1:35manager is everything.
- 1:37Yes.
- 1:38He's technical supervision, he's a
- 1:40foreman, he's a procurer, he handles
- 1:43logistics, and also technical
- 1:44documentation.
- 1:46Yes, how I combined everything into one
- 1:49.
- 1:49Yes, a site manager, yes. Professional
- 1:52report.
- 1:56The first main task is organizing the
- 1:58workflow.
- 1:59Uh-huh.
- 2:00That is, I receive and study the design
- 2:02working documentation and bring it to
- 2:05the crew.
- 2:07The site manager develops and
- 2:09coordinates the action plan and the
- 2:10work schedule. To ensure there's no
- 2:15downtime, let's say, so he always
- 2:17monitors this schedule and corrects it
- 2:19in time. Next, he works with the
- 2:24surveyor on the layout of the
- 2:26structures and ensures the supply of
- 2:28materials to the site, and accordingly
- 2:30organizes the construction site. That's
- 2:35it, work begins. The second main task
- 2:38is his control. Quality control of the
- 2:41work performed. This includes checking
- 2:44hidden work, like reinforcement, rebar
- 2:47diameter, the mesh, these are physical
- 2:49parameters, everything must comply with
- 2:52the design. There are moments when
- 2:55there is a discrepancy between what is
- 2:57on paper and what is on site. For this,
- 2:59the site manager must promptly work
- 3:01with the designers, make changes,
- 3:03provide a solution, and so that the
- 3:05work doesn't stop, you need to see
- 3:07everything in advance. So, the crew are
- 3:11the hands that perform the work, and
- 3:13the site manager is the person who
- 3:15manages these hands and organizes this
- 3:17work.
- 3:20He effectively acts as a liaison
- 3:22between the manager, which is himself,
- 3:24the technical customer, the designers,
- 3:27and the crew itself. He is accountable
- 3:30to everyone.
- 3:31The third function, his main task, is
- 3:33the handover of the project. This
- 3:35involves submitting the completed work
- 3:37to the technical supervisor and
- 3:38preparing all the as-built
- 3:40documentation, such as passports, test
- 3:41reports, certificates, and diagrams he
- 3:43prepared in advance with the engineer.
- 3:45Why do you think the crew's cost is
- 3:47lower while yours is higher? I mean, it
- 3:50increases automatically, doesn't it?
- 3:53I still believe it comes down to
- 3:55responsibility, especially if he is
- 3:57representing an organization. If I were
- 4:01to look ahead, I would choose a company
- 4:03. A company that has its own cameras.
- 4:06What client pain points does a site
- 4:08manager address? I mean, what exactly
- 4:11do you handle? Do clients even have any
- 4:13pain points?
- 4:15Of course, I save them from having to
- 4:17be on-site every day to supervise. I
- 4:20take those functions upon myself.
- 4:23Do you think a site manager for the
- 4:24building envelope and one for interior
- 4:26finishing should be different? Can it
- 4:28be the same person, or do they lack the
- 4:30necessary expertise?
- 4:31Well, if they have the experience, then
- 4:34yes. If the building category isn't a
- 4:38frame house or something simple, with a
- 4:40budget of 12 to 15 million, I think it
- 4:42can be managed. But if the house costs
- 4:4725 million or more, it’s better to
- 4:49separate them, right?
- 4:52Well, that’s just like general
- 4:54handymen. When everyone specializes in
- 4:56their own area, that’s the best
- 4:58option. Did I understand correctly that
- 5:02a general construction manager and an
- 5:04interior finishing manager are two
- 5:06different people because the expertise
- 5:08for the exterior envelope is specific,
- 5:09while the interior is completely
- 5:11different? And there are thousands of
- 5:15nuances involved there.
- 5:17A general construction manager is
- 5:19called that precisely because they
- 5:21oversee everything from start to finish
- 5:23, from the foundation to the handover.
- 5:28Their job isn't necessarily to know
- 5:30everything to absolute perfection.
- 5:33Everything. Their job is to control the
- 5:36processes.
- 5:39These are the ideal conditions where,
- 5:40as Alexander said, you have an elite
- 5:42team, and you need to have all those
- 5:44specialized crews on hand. But when we
- 5:49look at the reality, when we start a
- 5:51project, the client usually wants to
- 5:52save money. So they bring in crews that
- 5:57might be cheaper. And accordingly, in
- 6:01that case, the manager has to get
- 6:02hands-on and know every nuance and
- 6:04detail, because what else can they do
- 6:06when the claims start coming in?
- 6:09Wait, we are talking about houses
- 6:11around 200 square meters, right? I mean
- 6:13, good, high-quality houses, really
- 6:15good quality ones.
- 6:17What kind of cost savings are we
- 6:18talking about here? About 90%savings on
- 6:22the projects we worked on. I mean,
- 6:25every foreman, oh, every client wants
- 6:28to save money when building a 200 m²
- 6:30house. Even though he knows he’ll
- 6:35sell it for millions, he really wants
- 6:37to save and squeezes the crews and
- 6:38everyone else to the max. That's all.
- 6:43Because he understands he has 10 rubles
- 6:45today. And tomorrow he wants to sell it
- 6:47for 20. But he needs to save at this
- 6:49very stage, and that's it. And so, in
- 6:54my worldview, I understand that a
- 6:56structural foreman is for general
- 6:57construction, while a finishing foreman
- 6:59is a completely different skill set and
- 7:01a completely different person. No
- 7:05matter how many people I’ve seen or
- 7:07noticed, sure, ask Alexey if he can
- 7:09build monolithic houses exactly as well
- 7:12as I can. No, but ask Alexey if he can
- 7:14do the finishing perfectly. Yes, he can
- 7:17. 100%.
- 7:21So, we should better explain why it’s
- 7:22better for the client to separate these
- 7:24things and why it’s better to turn to
- 7:26one group for general construction and
- 7:28another for interior finishing. Or if
- 7:32it’s a company, then maybe go with a
- 7:34company. I’ll split this function
- 7:40again: a structural foreman is a person
- 7:42who needs a qualified foreman or master
- 7:44beneath him to perform their function
- 7:46perfectly.
- 7:50Well, let’s put it this way. I worked
- 7:52as a technical supervisor. There were
- 7:54four of us technical supervisors for
- 7:55one project. Four technical supervisors
- 7:58for one project. And each of us
- 7:59performed our own function. There was
- 8:01general construction. That’s
- 8:03foundations and everything related to
- 8:05concrete and walls. There was a
- 8:07technologist. All pipelines, gas, water
- 8:10, steam, and everything else. And then
- 8:14there was an electrical technical
- 8:16supervisor who covered all the
- 8:17electricity. And there was also an
- 8:20instrumentation and control specialist,
- 8:22so four supervisors for one building,
- 8:24you see? And that’s how it works; if
- 8:27we take the structure, here we have "
- 8:29divide and conquer." We separated the
- 8:32tasks and got a good result. So
- 8:35we are talking now about hiring a
- 8:37company to build a house.
- 8:40We are talking now about a foreman with
- 8:42a crew. We are not talking about a
- 8:44company right now. We are talking about
- 8:46the fact that if a client approaches a
- 8:50foreman with a crew.
- 8:52Foremen are different. Most likely, the
- 8:56foreman they find without a company
- 8:57will simply act as a crew leader. He
- 9:01will just supervise the execution of
- 9:03work and that’s it. And all other
- 9:07tasks, like supply chain management and
- 9:09documentation compliance or adjustments
- 9:11, will fall on the client.
- 9:14So, it doesn't rise to that level here,
- 9:17right? Meaning the foreman won't get
- 9:19involved in the projects, won't think
- 9:21about how to save the client money or
- 9:23what the best technology is. We’ve
- 9:26never actually worked with a company,
- 9:28because, as you say, the client is
- 9:29always trying to save money. They see
- 9:32that we’re taking on certain
- 9:33functions, so a company here—well,
- 9:36back in the day, let's say—a company
- 9:38wasn't needed by the client here. And
- 9:44so, we often resort to either hiring a
- 9:46foreman with his own crews, or I’ve
- 9:48had the experience of just hiring
- 9:50people at the bottom of the market rate
- 9:52, because the client—well, it wasn't
- 9:54lawful back when we were building the
- 9:56first site. That is, of course, an
- 10:01incredible headache in every way. Next,
- 10:04we’ll take the foreman, the foreman,
- 10:05the foreman for the Roseni, as was
- 10:07already mentioned here. What you just
- 10:09said, Alexander, those are the
- 10:11requirements the company has for you,
- 10:13and you’re ready to fulfill them. But
- 10:15how do you distinguish a foreman you
- 10:17picked up on the market—just some guy
- 10:19who, for example, built a house for
- 10:21someone I know—when he arrives,
- 10:23construction starts, he brings you a
- 10:25crew, and that’s where the split
- 10:27between a "normal" and "not normal"
- 10:29foreman begins. A normal person, and I
- 10:31know guys like this, takes a project,
- 10:33analyzes it first, approaches it
- 10:34scrupulously, and says: "Guys, there
- 10:36are these specific nuances, this part
- 10:38is unfeasible, and for this, let's look
- 10:40here, let's tweak that, and so on."
- 10:42That’s the first type of person. He
- 10:44can also take on all the procurement.
- 10:47Of course, we understand that
- 10:48procurement costs a certain amount on
- 10:50his end. He earns money on that, but
- 10:53it's also a great function that the
- 10:55client shouldn't have to take on at all
- 10:57. Right. And the second side is when
- 11:00the foreman isn't really a foreman but
- 11:02a middleman; he has several different
- 11:04crews he’s already worked with. He
- 11:06knows who to put on this site, who on
- 11:08that one, and who on the other. He sets
- 11:10up the crew. His task is to draw up an
- 11:13estimate and push it to the client. The
- 11:16crew arrives at the site and
- 11:18construction begins. It’s important
- 11:22to talk about how much the foreman
- 11:24controls, and how information is passed
- 11:26from the client directly to the crew,
- 11:28right? It should only happen through
- 11:31the foreman. But it often happens that
- 11:34when the foreman arrives at the site
- 11:35with a crew and the crew starts working
- 11:37, you already see mistakes. Well, for
- 11:40instance, as professionals in this
- 11:42field, we see the mistakes, we stop
- 11:44them. This, this, and this. You can’t
- 11:47do it like that. The foreman looks at
- 11:49the situation and says, "Oh, well, it's
- 11:51being controlled here, so I’m not
- 11:53needed." And that’s when the guy
- 11:57starts getting pushed off the project,
- 11:59when the client controls the crew. The
- 12:02client will then hold the foreman
- 12:03accountable, and the foreman will say,
- 12:05"Look, you were watching, where were
- 12:07you looking?" This shifting of blame,
- 12:08I’m just saying that this is exactly
- 12:10what shouldn't be called a foreman.
- 12:13This is a middleman with a crew who
- 12:15makes his margin but does absolutely
- 12:17nothing on-site, and you can’t get
- 12:19anything out of him.
- 12:21Ouch,
- 12:22you won't be able to hold him
- 12:23accountable for anything later. It will
- 12:25be a guaranteed conflict, you’ll try
- 12:27to confront him, but what will he say:
- 12:29"What about me? You were watching,
- 12:30weren't you? You seem like a
- 12:32knowledgeable person, right?" That’s
- 12:34it. So, this is exactly the bottom of
- 12:36the topic we’re discussing, the
- 12:38bottom of this foreman-with-a-crew
- 12:40setup. And there are truly competent
- 12:43foremen who essentially replace a
- 12:45construction company for you, who
- 12:47manage the project precisely and
- 12:48scrupulously, but there are only a few
- 12:50of them, and they are always referred
- 12:52by word of mouth. Right. And here it is
- 12:57important to discuss what the client
- 12:59wants to save a little on in the market
- 13:01, how it differs from a company, and
- 13:03how much higher their price is compared
- 13:05to a company's. This is the main market
- 13:10competition between a great foreman
- 13:12with well-established crews who manages
- 13:15a project clearly, and companies which,
- 13:17as clients think, have bloated staff,
- 13:19maybe no responsibility, a $ 10,000
- 13:22charter capital, and so on. So, this
- 13:25I will answer your question right now.
- 13:28How did I do it? You take this
- 13:30artificial intelligence,
- 13:31Uh-huh.
- 13:32You log your functions into it for two
- 13:34months, what you do. And every day you
- 13:36come and say that I did this, this,
- 13:38this, and this. And at the end of two
- 13:43months, you get the result of that
- 13:44analysis. And based on that analysis,
- 13:48unfortunately, or fortunately, 90%, for
- 13:51example, for me, is organizing the work
- 13:53. And also, these are the functions of
- 13:55a technical supervisor. That is what we
- 13:57are arriving at. So we are saying now
- 13:59that in this structure, we need another
- 14:01person, either a technical supervisor,
- 14:03like Yevgeny mentioned. If a foreman is
- 14:08willing to take on the role of a
- 14:09technical client and organize
- 14:11subcontractors, then yes, then it would
- 14:13be possible to compete with a company,
- 14:15provided he assumes those
- 14:16responsibilities. But if that person is
- 14:21willing to do it all for a minimum cost
- 14:23, when in fact 15%should be allocated
- 14:25for technical oversight, that’s an
- 14:27issue.
- 14:28Look, those are two different sides,
- 14:30right? The technical client is on the
- 14:32client's side, while the foreman is on
- 14:34the contractor's side. Those are two.
- 14:35Well, you need to understand who is
- 14:37working for what, right, and whose
- 14:38interests they are actually looking out
- 14:39for here. Right. And if the technical
- 14:41client acts on behalf of the client and
- 14:43puts pressure on the contractor, then
- 14:45the contractor will say he’s taken on
- 14:47those functions. He’ll claim he’s
- 14:50taken them on, but he will be defending
- 14:51his own position. If a client wants to
- 14:55get the highest quality and find
- 14:57nuances they can't get out of the
- 14:58foreman, the foreman will just push
- 15:00back against them. That is
- 15:04everywhere we talk about the fact that
- 15:05the human factor is the most important
- 15:07thing. And here you have to realize
- 15:11that there are foremen who understand
- 15:13that they want to work every single day
- 15:14. If they do a good job for the client,
- 15:19they will be referred to others. So, if
- 15:23I walk onto a site and see that my
- 15:24project has retaining walls with
- 15:26three-meter wide footings, and I
- 15:28realize that physically this isn't
- 15:29necessary because the project came from
- 15:31who knows where and it's completely
- 15:33useless, then I will tell the client
- 15:35about it. And I will say it because I
- 15:39am acting on the client's side here,
- 15:40because I know that tomorrow they will
- 15:42refer me to one more person and then
- 15:43another. And in this case, my family
- 15:46will always be fed, because I will
- 15:48always have work, and I will fulfill my
- 15:50functions and complete my task. And
- 15:53that's it. But now we have returned,
- 15:56perhaps, to the point where we need to
- 15:58ask: how do you distinguish a
- 15:59high-quality foreman from a low-quality
- 16:01one? Well, we usually torture them. And
- 16:08there are different methods of torture.
- 16:10What’s the first torture?
- 16:13The first torture is that we show other
- 16:14foremen how we are torturing one of
- 16:16them. 98 percent leave immediately.
- 16:21Well, understanding that the same thing
- 16:23is about to happen to them.
- 16:24Well, at least by a checklist and by
- 16:26the spine, yes. We run through all of
- 16:28that there. If we're being serious, I
- 16:32don't check foremen anymore; I have a
- 16:34technical director who handles that
- 16:36issue.
- 16:37Uh-huh.
- 16:39We’ll just delve deeper now and move
- 16:41on to the company structure, who is
- 16:43responsible for what, and what my role
- 16:45is there now.
- 16:46and what I actually know and what I
- 16:48don't know.
- 16:48Uh-huh.
- 16:49That's why what I started with just now
- 16:51before, when you were checking foremen,
- 16:52was there anything?
- 16:54Well, I checked via photos. Like, on a
- 16:57Nokia, you know, I’d look at what
- 16:59work had been done. Yeah. And only in
- 17:01practice, only in practice. Like, right
- 17:03away, I’d just start them. And it's
- 17:06also important, by the way, if a
- 17:08foreman from a crew came to me, I’d
- 17:10look at their gear, what they were
- 17:12wearing, what tools they had or didn't
- 17:14have, what they arrived in—that’s
- 17:16the primary thing I could see. And
- 17:19there is this illusion. A foreman
- 17:22arrives. Let's say in a Land Cruiser
- 17:26200, right? Oh, basically, a
- 17:29double-edged situation can arise for
- 17:32the client, right,
- 17:33the client.
- 17:34Like, it's expensive—since he drives
- 17:36such a car, he must be charging a ton.
- 17:40But you could reason differently, that
- 17:42he, um, well, he takes care of his car.
- 17:47The car is clean, yes, it's expensive,
- 17:49and he knows his own worth and the
- 17:51worth of his work, and that's the other
- 17:54side of the coin, actually.
- 17:57He has a lot of work.
- 17:58And he has a lot of work, that's true.
- 18:01The reason I’m telling you this is
- 18:03that I’ve been in that situation
- 18:05myself, when I arrived there in...oh, I
- 18:07see.
- 18:08And you have an Infiniti,
- 18:11I see.
- 18:122.5 liters, right? Well, not started
- 18:16yet.
- 18:17Let's add, Evgeny, um, you need to look
- 18:20at it in at least two layers. The
- 18:23technical layer and the ethical layer.
- 18:27Technically, we can check him somehow,
- 18:29right: by talking to him, asking him
- 18:31some professional questions, bringing
- 18:33him to the site for that first week, or
- 18:35at least, I don't know, giving him some
- 18:37project so he can explain if he
- 18:39understands anything at all or not. Uh,
- 18:42give him a situation that actually
- 18:44happened on your site, how he would
- 18:46solve it, and so on. So, just listen,
- 18:48in principle, to that story. The
- 18:50ethical layer. Well, you know, like, in
- 18:53any case, someone is interviewing this
- 18:56person there. And the client themselves
- 18:58is also the one who is interviewing.
- 19:00They look the person in the eye, at the
- 19:02very least. You know, well, your eyes
- 19:04will never deceive you. If you really
- 19:08want to understand who is standing in
- 19:09front of you, you know it from the
- 19:11first minute. The price he quotes might
- 19:16just outweigh all these stories, making
- 19:18you think: "What if it doesn't?" Maybe
- 19:21let's go for something cheaper. "And,
- 19:23well, this is an important point. And
- 19:25ethically, it will be tested further
- 19:27down the line in the work,,well, later
- 19:29on. And here I would suggest setting
- 19:31checkpoints as soon as possible. That
- 19:33is, as soon as we reach a certain
- 19:35checkpoint, that first clash of
- 19:37interests occurs, and we see how he
- 19:39delivers that work, how responsibly he
- 19:41acts, whether he is on the client's
- 19:43side, or if he is just covering himself
- 19:45as much as possible, just trying to get
- 19:47it done quickly:" Give me the money,
- 19:49sign the acts, and we're off. "That's
- 19:51it. So, this is the only way to check
- 19:53it.
- 19:54I mean, until you start, you can't
- 19:56verify it.
- 19:56You're unlikely to check the ethical
- 19:58side otherwise. Again, I’ll say,
- 20:00there has to be a certain level of
- 20:02discernment. The technical supervisor
- 20:04should also take this upon themselves.
- 20:06The technical supervisor’s role
- 20:08involves a high level of discernment
- 20:11regarding foremen, team leaders, other
- 20:13people, suppliers, and so on. And they
- 20:15can spot a lie from a mile away. So,
- 20:18this will save the end client, who is
- 20:20paying the money, from these problems.
- 20:23May I, as the client, draw my own
- 20:25conclusions after all your discussions?
- 20:28Look, here is what I want to see first
- 20:30and foremost as a client. Think of it
- 20:34like a simple analogy, like buying a
- 20:36car. I need to see a concrete base, for
- 20:42instance, the cost of work by stages,
- 20:44that is the base for the client. And
- 20:49second, almost mandatory, is the cost
- 20:51of materials by stages. And then the
- 20:55extras, because trying to cram
- 20:57everything into 100 rubles, as you
- 20:59initially discussed for the total cost,
- 21:01well, that's just competing with
- 21:03independent crews. And in some areas,
- 21:07yes, a construction company will
- 21:09perform the work more efficiently and
- 21:11quickly because they have qualified
- 21:13specialists. Based on my company's
- 21:17experience, one person working for a
- 21:19year can produce 10 items an hour,
- 21:21while a newcomer might only produce one
- 21:23. Yes, a construction company saves
- 21:27money on this and does it with higher
- 21:29quality. So, regarding the extras. The
- 21:31first is the materials purchaser. As
- 21:40builders or manufacturers, you can
- 21:42offer the client the option to hire,
- 21:44whether on a salary or per-job basis, a
- 21:46purchaser from your staff or a
- 21:48contractor who will calculate the
- 21:50preliminary estimate for me and try to
- 21:52save costs at various stages of
- 21:54construction. Meaning, it shows me that
- 22:03by the time we got to this point, the
- 22:05materials have become cheaper. Or I
- 22:07found a better material, or found a
- 22:09different manufacturer, so let's swap
- 22:11them. And that would be fair for the
- 22:14client. Oh, so this material purchaser
- 22:17should manage the budget for the client
- 22:19throughout the entire construction
- 22:21phase. And next, we return to the site
- 22:24manager or other specialists. Honestly,
- 22:27I’m getting confused by your
- 22:28abbreviations. Is it a site manager, a
- 22:31technical supervisor, or just a project
- 22:34manager? So, they should provide
- 22:38periodic reports to the client. It
- 22:43could be daily or weekly, by agreement,
- 22:45and they must answer questions because
- 22:47the client can't be an expert in your
- 22:49field. I saw a hole in the wall. As the
- 22:53client, whether I visited the site or
- 22:55saw it online, they showed it to me. I
- 22:57have to ask," What is this hole for? "
- 22:59And they should give me an answer. Or
- 23:02take a pause, ask the person who made
- 23:04the hole, and then give me an answer?
- 23:07That would be fair. So, that is the
- 23:09site manager's primary function. It’s
- 23:11not that the site manager must know
- 23:13everything, like why expensive
- 23:14materials were delivered or why they
- 23:16weren't on time. The purchaser should
- 23:18be responsible for that. So, I hire the
- 23:20site manager for a specific fee as well
- 23:23. If you quoted me a price and said,"
- 23:25Either you be the site manager yourself
- 23:27or pay us for one, "that would be fair.
- 23:30And it would be clear to me how much
- 23:31this site manager is making off me.
- 23:37I’m just looking at it like this: in
- 23:39most cases, you hold round tables and
- 23:41always look from one side; as
- 23:43manufacturers and specialists, you
- 23:45speak your own technical language, but
- 23:47you probably need to invite more people
- 23:49who are your potential clients. And you
- 23:56will see the other side of the coin,
- 23:58completely without any grievances.
- 24:01People will just explain what it is
- 24:02that I actually want. It’s like going
- 24:07to a doctor and saying," You know, a
- 24:09pandemic is coming, what should we do?
- 24:14"And you’re sitting there talking
- 24:16about how you need to close things off,
- 24:18lock things down, isolate people, and
- 24:20so on. But ask the people if they even
- 24:24want to be isolated. And, I will be
- 24:28brief. Lastly. I’ve already suggested
- 24:31this to Vitaly and Matvey at some point
- 24:33. This involves creating a user manual
- 24:38for the house or product you've built,
- 24:40including warranties for specific
- 24:42equipment or systems, and handing it
- 24:44over to the client. It's a great
- 24:49concept: for instance, if I build a
- 24:51pool, I just hand over a folder. It
- 24:55could be in digital format, or it could
- 24:57be printed, it doesn't matter. Nowadays
- 25:00, with artificial intelligence, it can
- 25:02be done quickly, so you don't end up in
- 25:04a situation where someone asks:" Where
- 25:06are your wires hidden? "" Which side
- 25:08can I install extra light fixtures on?
- 25:11"And I have no idea. Then the testing
- 25:13with the drill begins. Did I hit it or
- 25:15not? Oops, okay, it's fine. The
- 25:18painting is hung.
- 25:18I will answer your question now. How
- 25:20are we doing this now? We have as-built
- 25:23documentation that tracks how we build
- 25:25the house from start to finish. We also
- 25:29have a 3D scanner, a 3D laser scanner,
- 25:32which we use once the electricians and
- 25:34plumbers have installed all their
- 25:36systems. This device is set up. It
- 25:38costs about 100,000 rubles. That's what
- 25:41the team charges. They use this scanner
- 25:44to create a complete as-built survey of
- 25:46all the wires present, which is then
- 25:47handed over to you and overlaid onto
- 25:49the existing floor plans. So, this pain
- 25:53point exists for clients, but it is now
- 25:55solvable. The only question is whether
- 25:57the client is willing to pay 100,000–
- 26:00150,000 rubles upfront. For having
- 26:01their 200 m² house fully scanned in 3D
- 26:04to provide them with an as-built survey
- 26:06. That's all there is to it. But I
- 26:07think in this case, it's much cheaper
- 26:09than damaging a very expensive
- 26:11renovation. It's way cheaper,
- 26:12significantly so.
- 26:13Well, there are two options here. I
- 26:15started with this at the very beginning
- 26:17. When buying a car, you either take
- 26:19the base model and say:" I need this, I
- 26:21need that, but I don't need this. "
- 26:23Uh-huh.
- 26:24Or you say:" Give me the highest trim
- 26:26level you have, calculate how much it
- 26:28costs. "But you still have to break
- 26:31down the costs for the foreman, the
- 26:33procurement officer, and, I don't know,
- 26:35the creation of a brand book. To avoid
- 26:42any issues with the client, we now
- 26:44break everything down to the last screw
- 26:46and provide an estimate for a specific
- 26:47stage of work, making it much easier to
- 26:49work with them later and sign off on
- 26:51the volumes of work. This includes the
- 26:57foreman's work as well. He reports on
- 27:00the actual work done at the site,
- 27:01whether it's excavation, other tasks,
- 27:03or providing as-built documentation,
- 27:05which the teams submit themselves.
- 27:07Everything is transparent and honest.
- 27:10It’s better for us to earn a
- 27:11percentage here; this percentage is set
- 27:13, and the client either accepts it or
- 27:15they don't. And then he understands
- 27:18that we are trying to be on his side,
- 27:20because if we save money here, he will
- 27:22be able to finish the house. And that
- 27:25means that, uh, internally we will get
- 27:27the result we wanted. We want to
- 27:30eventually be able to visit him and
- 27:31have tea or coffee together. That’s
- 27:33all. I mean, that is our position. As
- 27:36for the photos, he didn't mention it,
- 27:37but we provide a daily photo and video
- 27:39report, and we show what we did and how
- 27:41we did it, right down to using a tape
- 27:43measure. Then, when they want to
- 27:47inspect us, which happens sometimes, a
- 27:48technical supervisor is called in, they
- 27:50arrive, we immediately give them the
- 27:52full folder, they look through it and
- 27:54can see at every stage whether
- 27:56everything is done correctly or not,
- 27:57and that's it. So we provide the full
- 28:00picture here. But here, perhaps, we
- 28:02didn't start talking about it, as it's
- 28:04more for companies. Most likely, this
- 28:07is when you come to a company and it
- 28:08provides you with such a service.
- 28:11That’s how it seems to me.
- 28:12Plus a general estimate, uh, let's say,
- 28:15broken down by specific specialists, so
- 28:18as not to compete, again, with the
- 28:20crews. You wanted 100 rubles. Here is
- 28:22100 rubles. It's budgeted, right? You
- 28:25wanted add-ons, here is what the
- 28:26add-ons cost. This will allow you in
- 28:28the future, uh, to separate things, as
- 28:30in the joke you told—it's not that
- 28:32the whole suit is bad, but that
- 28:34specifically this foreman sewed the
- 28:36buttons on poorly. And you, uh, having
- 28:39figured it out, let's say, at internal
- 28:42meetings, who did what wrong, you won't
- 28:44tell everyone that, guys, we built a
- 28:46bad house. But specifically, you,
- 28:49foreman, failed to do your job in this
- 28:51spot. Take financial or disciplinary
- 28:52responsibility, I don't know, maybe a
- 28:54pat on the back. Yes, that works pretty
- 28:56well too.
- 28:57Not bad.
- 28:58You were talking about crews and
- 29:00responsibility. A crew is only
- 29:01responsible for its own scope of work.
- 29:03Whatever was provided to us, that's
- 29:05where we install the windows. If
- 29:07there’s no flat surface, we can’t
- 29:09just bend the windows to match the wall
- 29:11or anything else. But in my opinion,
- 29:15you didn't touch on the issue that when
- 29:18there are many crews, or if a foreman
- 29:20comes in with their own scope of work
- 29:22with their own crews and then others
- 29:24come in, well, in the end, first, it's
- 29:26impossible to find who is responsible,
- 29:28who messed up, at what moment, and who
- 29:30is to blame. And second is the presence
- 29:36of materials on-site; who is
- 29:38responsible for them, who holds the
- 29:40financial liability. A crew arrives,
- 29:44they drop something, maybe there were
- 29:46glass sets worth 15 million there. Then
- 29:50plasterers or welders come and ruin
- 29:52them. Who is to blame here? Whose
- 29:55responsibility is it? Is it the
- 29:56client's responsibility for not
- 29:58covering it up? Or is it the welders,
- 30:00who should have covered it for some
- 30:02reason? Uh, with some kind of tarp, but
- 30:04they didn't do it, or maybe they
- 30:06weren't supposed to. Who should do what
- 30:08there is absolutely unclear. And now,
- 30:14as we smoothly transition to companies,
- 30:16that zone of responsibility will become
- 30:18clearer, as well as what the client
- 30:20actually receives: do they just get
- 30:22square footage, or do they get a
- 30:24peaceful life during these months of
- 30:26construction and, in the near future,
- 30:28for many years to come while their
- 30:30family lives there? 22 years ago, in
- 30:352004, one of the first cottages we were
- 30:38building, we came in hungover in the
- 30:41morning and made a mistake of 0.4
- 30:43meters. We set the foundation, we set
- 30:48the foundation 40 cm too low.
- 30:51We dug too deep,
- 30:53yes, we made the cushion, set the slabs
- 30:55, reached the zero level, and realized
- 30:57that our zero was 40 cm lower. So, yes,
- 31:04a nuance, a simple nuance. And in the
- 31:09end, I used the money I had earned from
- 31:11that job to buy bricks, raised the
- 31:13plinth by 40 cm, and on top of that,
- 31:15backfilled it with sand to the required
- 31:17level.
- 31:19You really got into a mess there.
- 31:21Yes, that was one of my first major
- 31:23blunders, where I really lost a
- 31:25significant amount of money. But it
- 31:28taught me a lot and gave me great
- 31:30experience. You could have run away.
- 31:33I could have, I could have run away and
- 31:35not paid, yes. But the fact is that,
- 31:38perhaps thanks to this, the client told
- 31:40others about me, and I ended up
- 31:42building almost 12 houses in that area.
- 31:45There you go.
- 31:45We also messed up on the 7024 Muar
- 31:48color, or 7024 usually isn't Muar, but
- 31:50we let the client down, and they
- 31:52probably won't give us any more
- 31:54projects there until it's fixed. So, do
- 31:59I understand correctly that you
- 32:00installed the windows, cleared them
- 32:02with the site manager, and it turned
- 32:04out that...
- 32:05Well, that's exactly the company vs.
- 32:07non-company, crew vs. non-crew issue.
- 32:09We communicated with the site manager.
- 32:11We didn't have access to the client
- 32:13because they were someone very
- 32:14important, very serious, and there was
- 32:16no access to them. We coordinated with
- 32:19the site manager and signed everything.
- 32:21But when we brought the structures, the
- 32:22client came out and said the color was
- 32:24wrong. It was 7024, but not Muar, and
- 32:26it was supposed to be Muar. And as a
- 32:28result, we had to take these structures
- 32:29back for repainting and reworking.
- 32:31Minus 600,000.
- 32:32Who provided the technical
- 32:33specifications? The site manager.
- 32:34The site manager, yes.
- 32:35And the site manager said," What about
- 32:37me? He doesn't like it, goodbye. "
- 32:38That is not a site foreman.
- 32:40Well, that’s something for..." Moiré
- 32:41"and" Non-moiré "won't understand a
- 32:43thing. It’s either just shiny or
- 32:45it’s not shiny. Right?
- 32:47Matte or shiny windows. That’s the
- 32:49whole difference. Also, colleagues,
- 32:52we’re talking about these zones of
- 32:54responsibility, saying the crew is
- 32:56responsible, and that’s it. Well,
- 32:58that’s like living in certain
- 33:00illusions. Like hoping, or relying on
- 33:03some probability that this crew...
- 33:05it’s an uncontrollable process,
- 33:07really. A crew or a foreman with a crew
- 33:11will come, and they will be responsible
- 33:13to some degree. Or they won't. The
- 33:20client, the customer, will project
- 33:22themselves onto them, thinking" I am
- 33:24responsible, I have this level of
- 33:26standards, so they must be the same or
- 33:28higher. "But that is an illusion. You
- 33:32can easily make a huge mistake here,
- 33:34and it’s just one click from
- 33:36enchantment to disappointment. Well,
- 33:40the same goes for companies—if
- 33:41we’re talking about Krasnodar, there
- 33:43are so many developers who built houses
- 33:45for sale. And when you can see the
- 33:47street through the gaps between the
- 33:48blocks, well, the company built that
- 33:50too, so much for" responsibility. "You
- 33:52can harbor illusions about a company,
- 33:54too.
- 33:55But does a company have specific goals?
- 33:57Goals to build as cheap as possible and
- 33:59sell as dear as possible.
- 34:00Exactly. Are there other goals?
- 34:03I’m not against it, I’m just saying
- 34:05illusions can exist there and here.
- 34:06That’s all true. Actually,
- 34:08listen, this battle, it gets more views
- 34:10. Come on, come on, fight, fight, fight
- 34:12on camera!
- 34:13No, no, we’re not actually talking
- 34:15about different things here. We’re
- 34:16talking about the same thing.
- 34:18Interacting with a foreman who is
- 34:19competent and understands what we’re
- 34:21talking about and what I’m taking
- 34:22money for, rather than a customer who
- 34:24has to prove why it’s 100,000 more
- 34:26expensive, roughly speaking, and why,
- 34:27and what I’m providing for that.
- 34:29Wait, you’ve already taken 600,000
- 34:31from the foreman. No, no, well, I agree
- 34:34, the experience is already there. The
- 34:37result—that’s not experience,
- 34:39that’s the result of cooperation,
- 34:40we’re still working with him, just
- 34:42next time I’ll be...
- 34:43minus 600,000.
- 34:45The signatures next time will be more
- 34:47attentive. Meaning you signed, I took
- 34:48the responsibility off myself, and then
- 34:50, well, I can’t do anything about it.
- 34:52Well, that was the foreman’s
- 34:54responsibility that was...
- 34:55Yes, yes, the foreman is like...not to
- 34:58harbor illusions. But the foreman is
- 34:59responsible. So what? And I have the
- 35:01construction and the lost sum of money,
- 35:03because we signed it in the contract.
- 35:05Wait, let's. What if you had received a
- 35:08technically correct assignment from the
- 35:10company at that moment? We are talking
- 35:13about doing the job right now.
- 35:15The question is, who is going to be
- 35:17held responsible? The signatures are
- 35:19there, but in the end, I have a 15
- 35:21million project and I’m still short
- 35:23500,000. And it turns out that, just
- 35:25like you described yourself, I put in
- 35:27my own revenue just to at least recover
- 35:29the costs for the product.
- 35:31You just said whether it’s more
- 35:33convenient for you to work with a site
- 35:35manager or a company. That’s what I
- 35:37want to tell you.
- 35:38He is much more comfortable working
- 35:39with a site manager,
- 35:40because it would have been the same
- 35:41story with the client. The client would
- 35:43have just said," Basically, I don’t
- 35:44know what Moire is. "What do you mean?
- 35:46What do you mean? I didn't understand
- 35:47what Moire was, roughly speaking, yes.
- 35:49I thought matte was Moire. There.
- 35:51A site manager's company. The main
- 35:52thing is that the competence is
- 35:53sufficient for the technical assignment
- 35:54. Pete should have enough, and the
- 35:56person who handles the transfer of the
- 35:57technical assignment should too.
- 35:58Transferring a technical assignment is
- 36:00always an interpretation. That is, damn
- 36:01it, the most difficult part.
- 36:03Evgeny, you are talking about a site
- 36:05manager being a person, and he says a
- 36:07company is easier for me. You say, it's
- 36:09easier for me to work with a site
- 36:11manager.
- 36:12For him, the best thing is a company
- 36:14and site managers. So not the client,
- 36:17it turns out. Your client is
- 36:23the site manager and the company.
- 36:25The company, yes.
- 36:26Not the direct client.
- 36:27Not the direct client, yes.
- 36:29That also has a right to exist.
- 36:31That’s normal. Okay.
- 36:32And it's actually even better, I'll
- 36:34tell you.
- 36:34Well, it's better in terms of the fact
- 36:36that I
- 36:36have less of a headache. I mean, I
- 36:39received a clear assignment, provided a
- 36:41quote without any nitpicking or
- 36:43anything else.
- 36:45You just didn't understand each other.
- 36:47Yes, because the client takes up much,
- 36:49much more time than that. Yes, because
- 36:52the company has it organized.
- 36:56I want to say something completely
- 36:57different: does it matter if there is
- 36:59one idiot or 100 idiots?
- 37:04Do you understand, or one smart person
- 37:07and 100 smart people in a company? Uh,
- 37:10huge knowledge, meaning when we take an
- 37:12error and multiply it, we get one
- 37:14continuous error. And if this site
- 37:19manager is initially incompetent, toxic
- 37:21, or unethical, they grow into a
- 37:22company and build the same kind of
- 37:24company. If the same mess arises around
- 37:28them, it doesn't matter if they worked
- 37:30alone as a foreman, as a site manager
- 37:32with two or three crews, or as a
- 37:34company with estimators, technical
- 37:36supervisors, lawyers, and so on. We are
- 37:38talking about something a little
- 37:39different. Meaning the structure,
- 37:42meaning increasing the structure does
- 37:44not mean increasing competence,
- 37:45responsibility, technical literacy, or
- 37:47ethical standards. It makes absolutely
- 37:51no difference. There are strong
- 37:53companies, strong site managers, strong
- 37:55crews, and so on. That is, well, it's
- 37:58really a conversation about completely
- 38:00different levels. We need to talk about
- 38:03the professional and ethical level. In
- 38:06any case, we must look at the
- 38:07professional and ethical layers. It
- 38:09doesn't matter what level a company, a
- 38:12crew, a site manager, or a specialist
- 38:14is at—anyone at all. You know, people
- 38:17often talked about being in a situation
- 38:19where someone else solved it. I say,"
- 38:21Why didn't you just run away? "
- 38:23I mean, you could have spent 40 minutes
- 38:26, or you could have spent another
- 38:28600,000, while others, I had 25 million
- 38:30. Well, you could have just disappeared
- 38:33, probably, and gone somewhere for that
- 38:35kind of money. You certainly could have
- 38:37run away, but no, it's not like that.
- 38:43And in fact, as I say, the client only
- 38:45faces this when they are already
- 38:47committed, meaning behind the nice
- 38:49words, there should be results. If
- 38:56those results aren't there, the client
- 38:58can't really verify how high-quality
- 39:00the work is.
- 39:03Right away.
- 39:03Well, first of all, right away, and
- 39:05later on as well. Is this hole here a
- 39:07hole, or is it a technological opening?
- 39:10A hole in one spot.
- 39:12Will it be there forever, or is it just
- 39:13there while the work is being done? And
- 39:15then, you know, everyone leaves, but
- 39:17the hole stays. I think, damn, why
- 39:19didn't I ask sooner? Maybe it should
- 39:21have just been patched up. But everyone
- 39:23just forgot, or left, or something
- 39:24happened—anyway, it’s that kind of
- 39:26story. And he just thinks," Damn, "and
- 39:29no one is going to answer that question
- 39:31for him." They definitely left it for
- 39:33the air conditioner. "Just keep
- 39:34thinking that, right?
- 39:36But our air conditioner is in a
- 39:37different spot. Uh, I guess I'll sum it
- 39:40up now. If, uh, a client wants to work
- 39:44with a site manager who comes with his
- 39:46own crews, they need to realize they
- 39:48might run into the fact that there's
- 39:50only one manager, and if he gets sick,
- 39:52the same chaos will start on the site.
- 39:57If the manager takes on two or three
- 39:59projects, he won't have enough time to
- 40:01manage this one. There are likely no
- 40:05guaranteed crew replacements, or
- 40:07perhaps a lack of full expertise. How a
- 40:09project is handled from beginning to
- 40:11end. Uh, maybe, once again, we’ll
- 40:15come back to the human factor. He might
- 40:19be a technically competent specialist,
- 40:21but he is a very poor manager, and
- 40:22consequently, he cannot properly
- 40:24organize the work. And often,
- 40:27construction foremen think that they
- 40:28don't need technical supervision. In
- 40:31other words, they see him as the person
- 40:33who creates problems for them. But in
- 40:35fact, it is the exact opposite. Well,
- 40:38there is a lack of understanding and a
- 40:39lack of training, I think.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Функции и ответственность бригады/прораба и компании при строительстве дома. by 37Pro, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,717 words across 1,064 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.