АЛЕКСЕЙ СЕМИХАТОВ: ИНФОРМАЦИЯ В ОСНОВЕ ВСЕГО, ГОЛОГРАММА и ТЕЛЕПОРТАЦИЯ? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Could information lie at the foundation
- 0:02of the world? How did physicists
- 0:04teleport a particle 200 meters? What do
- 0:07a black hole and a closet have in
- 0:08common? What if at the bedrock of
- 0:10reality there is no matter, only zeros
- 0:12and ones? Is it true that entanglement
- 0:14is the glue of our world? And what if
- 0:17the entire universe is a quantum
- 0:19computer calculating itself? And if you
- 0:27enjoyed the video, don't forget to hit
- 0:28the like button. This helps YouTube's
- 0:30algorithms show the video to a wider
- 0:32audience, especially now, when every
- 0:33bit of support matters to us. For the
- 0:36bell icon, subscription, and comments,
- 0:37thank you personally from me. Hello,
- 0:39this is the Osnova project. My name is
- 0:40Boris Vidensky. Today is our 4th
- 0:42anniversary, so by tradition, we have
- 0:43physicist Alexei Semikhatov as our
- 0:45guest. Hello, Alexei. Hooray!
- 0:46>> Hello everyone. Boris, hello. Hello.
- 0:49Happy birthday. And I wish you all the
- 0:52best in general.
- 0:53>> Thank you. And to you as well.
- 0:55>> Thank you.
- 0:56>> Well, that's it. And you suggested an
- 0:58intriguing topic. Can information lie
- 1:01at the foundation of the world?
- 1:02>> Well, under your...What do you mean "
- 1:04suggested"? What do you mean "suggested
- 1:05"? Under your pressure, you practically
- 1:07twisted my arm, and I had to say
- 1:09something like that.
- 1:11>> Then allow me to start with a vulgar
- 1:12question. Do physicists actually detect
- 1:17any signs that we are in a matrix?
- 1:21>> Ah, no, the short answer. No, that's
- 1:24not really what it's about. Uh, but on
- 1:27the other hand, I can already feel that
- 1:28the intro will be "Are we in a matrix?"
- 1:30or something like that.
- 1:32>> Naturally.
- 1:32>> Naturally. But that's a different story
- 1:35. It comes from the fact that sometimes
- 1:37people come up and ask, "Well, it's
- 1:38obvious, isn't it?" They don't even ask
- 1:40, they say, "Well, it's clear that some
- 1:42informational field lies at the
- 1:44foundation of the world." And then some
- 1:46conclusions are drawn from this. The
- 1:49conclusions are very diverse depending
- 1:51on the speaker's mindset, like...
- 1:55reading information from the Universe,
- 1:57receiving some signals, and things like
- 1:59that. Well, there are varying degrees
- 2:02of fantasy, to put it mildly. But the
- 2:04idea itself is quite worth discussing.
- 2:07What could it be? What could an
- 2:09informational field be? And at first,
- 2:12it seems like nothing. And this,
- 2:14apparently...
- 2:15>> Wait, is "field" here meant like a
- 2:17gravitational field or a magnetic field
- 2:19in that sense? Well, you are asking
- 2:21absolutely correctly. A very good
- 2:23question. What is meant? In what way
- 2:25can something lie at the foundation of
- 2:27the world? In what sense is it a field?
- 2:29Well, that is your question hitting the
- 2:31nail right on the head. Absolutely
- 2:33correct. Look, our modern understanding
- 2:35—it might change someday, but our
- 2:37current understanding is that at the
- 2:38foundation of the world lie fundamental
- 2:40fields. There are about as many of them
- 2:43as there are entries in the Standard
- 2:44Model. You know, when people tell us,
- 2:47or draw particles of the Standard Model
- 2:49on t-shirts and mugs. Well, they do fit
- 2:53on a t-shirt: the electron, neutrinos,
- 2:56the muon, tau, quarks, and now the
- 2:58Higgs boson is added there too. But
- 3:02this Standard Model looks like a model
- 3:04of particles in such a picture. In
- 3:06reality, it is a model of fields. And
- 3:07each of these particles is a quantum of
- 3:09fundamental fields. That is, we accept
- 3:11as most fundamental what we have dug
- 3:13down to—that at the basis of the
- 3:15world lie certain entities that we,
- 3:17well, generally are better at
- 3:19describing mathematically than not, and
- 3:22we know how to derive a number of
- 3:24consequences from them. And it turns
- 3:26out that this Standard Model is the
- 3:28best-tested theory in the world. Where
- 3:30we can—and we certainly can't
- 3:32calculate everything—but where we can
- 3:34both calculate and measure, there is a
- 3:36truly fantastic agreement that leaves
- 3:39everything else far, far behind. What
- 3:41are these quantum fields? In general, a
- 3:43field is originally some kind of
- 3:44abstraction, right? Like, a rebel ship
- 3:47flies by with Luke Skywalker and
- 3:49Chewbacca, and suddenly it runs into
- 3:52some kind of field. I mean, before that
- 3:54, there was nothing. But as soon as the
- 3:56agent of the influence appeared, they
- 3:58feel it, they can't break free. Well,
- 4:00actually, it's the same with an
- 4:02electric field. If you are not an
- 4:04electric charge, and if you are neutral
- 4:06, for example, a neutron, you don't
- 4:08feel it. But if you are an electron,
- 4:10you suddenly start to feel it. So, a
- 4:12field is a kind of capacity to produce
- 4:14an action on what? On something that
- 4:17appears there and has a charge relative
- 4:19to this field. This last part is
- 4:21extremely important in this sense.
- 4:23Field. The next abstraction after force
- 4:26. It is what can produce a force when
- 4:28an agent appears. Now, conservation
- 4:31laws operate in nature. This is very
- 4:33important. Our world is not arbitrary
- 4:35because any interaction is an exchange
- 4:37—an exchange of energy and momentum.
- 4:39Well, billiard balls, for example, do
- 4:40this. Admittedly, they also exchange
- 4:42with the cloth, and that's why they
- 4:44slowly decelerate. If the cloth were
- 4:46perfect, and the bumpers were perfect
- 4:48too......if there were no losses, if
- 4:50all energy were returned by them and
- 4:51none turned into heat, then they would
- 4:53exchange energy and momentum between
- 4:55themselves forever. Well, if you're a
- 4:58good billiard player and you also add
- 5:00spin, then you're also dealing with
- 5:02angular momentum. And all our
- 5:05interactions, including the interaction
- 5:07of fields, respect these conservation
- 5:09laws. Therefore, when we talk about
- 5:13some physical influence, about some
- 5:15field existing in the universe, we need
- 5:18to describe how we can actually verify
- 5:21the existence of this field, how to be
- 5:23sure of it: that is, what it is ready
- 5:26to act upon and by what rules, and how,
- 5:29in fact, to understand from these rules
- 5:31, well, how one should organize
- 5:34something—an experiment, an
- 5:36observation, whatever you want—to
- 5:38make sure that this field is having an
- 5:41effect on something that I can observe.
- 5:43Well, exactly in this way, you see,
- 5:45exactly in this way I verify the
- 5:46existence of an electric field. I,
- 5:48notice, do not see it with my eyes. But
- 5:50I verify it because it moves an
- 5:53electric charge there. If it is a
- 5:56magnetic field, then notice, we all
- 5:58verify that it acts because the compass
- 6:00needle turns, right? Just walking along
- 6:04, it's a miracle, isn't it?
- 6:05Five-year-old Einstein said, he said to
- 6:07me: "My father gave me a compass." And
- 6:09I was absolutely—Einstein writes that
- 6:11he was absolutely impressed. Well,
- 6:13really, you can't see anything, you
- 6:15understand? The field is invisible.
- 6:16There. But you take this thing, and it
- 6:19behaves in a completely predictable way
- 6:21. Moreover, you can certainly ask: is
- 6:23this a property of what? The needle or
- 6:26the medium? But then you can simply
- 6:27study it in all sorts of ways. You can
- 6:29study at what points on Earth, where it
- 6:31points, which compass, how it reacts.
- 6:34Then, in the end, you see, if your
- 6:36needle is massive, it slowly, well, it
- 6:38slowly aligns to the necessary
- 6:40direction. And if it's light, then
- 6:43quickly. If you have an electric charge
- 6:45moving in an electric field and it is
- 6:47larger or smaller, it receives signals
- 6:49from the field differently. You are
- 6:51doing a very important thing. You are
- 6:53separating the properties of your
- 6:55little device, say a compass, from the
- 6:58properties of what you assume exists as
- 7:00a field. And everything that is left
- 7:03when you have removed the properties of
- 7:06the charge itself, the compass itself,
- 7:08or Wookiee Chewbacca, on the ship he is
- 7:10flying on. Like the Millennium Falcon.
- 7:12Understood. So, that is what is left,
- 7:15the field is what remains there. Okay.
- 7:17And what is the Standard Model? The
- 7:21Standard Model is not this little chart
- 7:24, but a list of formulas—quite, well,
- 7:26such dense formulas, looking a bit
- 7:29monotonous, but very dense, about a
- 7:31page and a half long. That is what they
- 7:35describe. They describe interactions,
- 7:37methods, they describe two things: the
- 7:39methods of propagation for each field
- 7:41and what is technically called a
- 7:43propagator, though it is somewhat
- 7:45hidden there, and the interaction of
- 7:47fields, because our entire world, we
- 7:49receive information about the world in
- 7:51general only through interaction.
- 7:53Therefore, as soon as you say, well, I
- 7:56believe that at the foundation of the
- 7:58world lies an information field. We say
- 8:03, excellent, we are with you, you and I
- 8:06, we are now temporarily on the same
- 8:08side, we want to figure out what that
- 8:11is. We tell you, you know, excellent,
- 8:13very good, perhaps that is even how it
- 8:16really is. As you wish, Professor, but
- 8:19you need to explain how it affects what
- 8:22. This is what you need to bring, and
- 8:27measure, and what effect will I see,
- 8:29since we already know that the world,
- 8:31as we understand it and describe it
- 8:33very well, is the standard, the
- 8:34standard model, you need to explain how
- 8:37this information field interacts with
- 8:39the fields of the standard model. But
- 8:41then everything will be clear. Then it
- 8:43will be clear from that, what
- 8:45sensitivity the setup must have in
- 8:47order for your so-called assumed field
- 8:50to manifest itself. How we can
- 8:53influence it, how it works, what
- 8:55effects it might produce. But as soon
- 8:57as you write that down, your field
- 9:00loses any meaning in being called "
- 9:02informational." Because it will be some
- 9:05kind of physical field with some rules
- 9:06for interacting with the fields of the
- 9:08standard model, transferring energy,
- 9:10momentum, and so on. And you, of course
- 9:12, can invent it, but right now it is
- 9:13simply not very necessary. People,
- 9:15believe me, people are looking for
- 9:16which fields are not captured by the
- 9:18standard model. That is a terribly
- 9:19interesting question. There are simply
- 9:21no signals for this at the moment.
- 9:23>> All right. But there is this physicist
- 9:25John Wheeler, who, if I understand
- 9:27correctly, coined, among other things,
- 9:30the term "black hole." And he has a
- 9:33statement in English that sounds like "
- 9:35it from bit,"
- 9:37>> right?
- 9:38>> Meaning, translated into Russian, "
- 9:39something from a bit," referring to a
- 9:42bit of information.
- 9:43>> Could you comment on what that means?
- 9:45>> It is very difficult to say what that
- 9:47means. Other than the fact that Wheeler
- 9:48had many sharp phrases. Wheeler was
- 9:50generally a great man, yes, a man who
- 9:52had a colossal influence on the physics
- 9:53of the 20th century. His students
- 9:55included Feynman, Bekenstein, whom we
- 9:57will mention today regarding black hole
- 9:59entropy. Bekenstein, as we call him,
- 10:02and Kip Thorne, whom we love, we love
- 10:04him for Interstellar, but he received
- 10:06the Nobel Prize for something else.
- 10:09Well, and a whole host of other quite
- 10:10significant people. And Everett was his
- 10:13student, who came up with the branching
- 10:16universe, parallel universes at the
- 10:18same point in space, Everettian
- 10:20universes. So, Wheeler was a man full
- 10:23of diverse ideas, and, uh, apparently,
- 10:27his students were never bored with him.
- 10:30For instance, one night he called
- 10:32Feynman and said, "Feynman, do you know
- 10:33why all electrons in the universe are
- 10:35identical?" Feynman, half-asleep, says,
- 10:37"Why?""Well, because it's the same
- 10:39electron running back and forth through
- 10:41time." When it runs forward in time,
- 10:42it's an electron, and backward in time,
- 10:43it's a positron. And so it manages to
- 10:45be everywhere. See what I mean? It’s
- 10:47a wild idea. But if such an idea
- 10:49suddenly describes the world, well, we
- 10:51accept it. I don’t know, take the
- 10:53Higgs field; it’s wild, but it
- 10:55describes a piece of the world. We use
- 10:57the concept of the Higgs field, and we
- 10:59found the Higgs boson. In short,
- 11:01Feynman was a great man too. Even
- 11:03though he was groggy, he said, "Uh,
- 11:05then the number of positrons and
- 11:07electrons in the observable universe
- 11:09would be equal." Because to be
- 11:11everywhere at once, it has to go
- 11:13forward in time, then back, and it must
- 11:15cross our time constantly as a positron
- 11:17. But that is obviously not the case.
- 11:19Or he said, "Well, alright, Feynman,
- 11:21goodnight." But a few years later,
- 11:23Feynman developed a formalism. But
- 11:27notice, after some time, Feynman
- 11:29developed the formalism for which he
- 11:31actually received the Nobel Prize,
- 11:33building quantum electrodynamics where
- 11:36this idea, albeit indirectly, appears,
- 11:38and that's cool. There you go. So, you
- 11:41see, it’s this sense of what one
- 11:44should think about, even if the idea
- 11:46isn't correct. Returning to "It from
- 11:49bit," he said that these words, uh, are
- 11:52ideas in search of a formulation. In
- 11:54search of formulation. He was trying to
- 11:57point out what one should be thinking
- 11:59about. Could there be some
- 12:00informational properties at the
- 12:02foundation of the world from which the
- 12:04world could be built? Well, first of
- 12:06all, it’s definitely not a bit. It
- 12:09really isn't, no matter what you do.
- 12:11Theorems like Kochen-Specker in quantum
- 12:14mechanics show that the world cannot be
- 12:17. The quantum world—it’s inherently
- 12:19quantum, after all. And the fields we
- 12:21talked about are quantum, with one
- 12:23important exception we will discuss.
- 12:26Keep that in mind, make a note of it.
- 12:30The world is inherently quantum, and in
- 12:32quantum mechanics, it’s impossible to
- 12:34describe quantum reality by assigning
- 12:36zeros and ones. To certain units, to
- 12:41certain entities that are there. Life
- 12:47is structured in such a way that there
- 12:49are situations where it doesn't matter
- 12:52how you assign specific values, that is
- 12:55, a bit,
- 12:56>> you will not be able to describe, uh,
- 13:00nature. Uh, that is, you, mm, you will
- 13:03encounter contradictions. Therefore, if
- 13:06Wheeler’s formula is to be understood
- 13:07at all, it should be understood as "it
- 13:09from qubit."
- 13:11>> Uh-huh.
- 13:11>> And that something comes from the qubit
- 13:14. And this is a big story. This will
- 13:16apparently be the end of our
- 13:18conversation today, because, uh, after
- 13:21I seemingly said that as soon as you
- 13:23want something informational, it
- 13:25involuntarily becomes physical, it
- 13:28turns into something physical. Well,
- 13:30you then simply have to explain some
- 13:32physical field, how it is structured,
- 13:34how it interacts with things, and so on
- 13:35. So, therefore, we simply close the
- 13:38idea of an information field as a field
- 13:40, as something separate. It is not
- 13:42discussed at all. There. Instead, more
- 13:45subtle questions are being discussed.
- 13:46Questions are being discussed, and this
- 13:49is a bit closer to Wheeler, whether
- 13:51information—jumping ahead, quantum
- 13:53information—is a good language for
- 13:56describing physical fields. Right,
- 13:59>> and this is a completely different way
- 14:00of framing the question. You still
- 14:01can't do without carriers. You see,
- 14:03when I transmit information to you, I
- 14:04must communicate something to you.
- 14:06Something in your head must change.
- 14:09Well, you can transmit information by,
- 14:11I don't know, yeah, a punch in the face
- 14:12. That also means that something,
- 14:14undoubtedly, has changed in the
- 14:15organism. Well, first of all, the
- 14:16center of gravity, right? But if I am
- 14:18telling you something, no matter what
- 14:21kind of information you receive, uh,
- 14:23your neurons reconfigure in a different
- 14:25way. That is, there is a physical
- 14:28impact, so the delivery of information
- 14:30—information always has physical
- 14:32carriers. This is, by the way, visible
- 14:34because our computer—I'll digress for
- 14:36a second—our computers cannot help
- 14:38but heat up. And although they heat up
- 14:41fantastically much compared to the
- 14:43theoretical limit right now, there is a
- 14:46theoretical limit to the extent to
- 14:48which they can remain cold. That is,
- 14:51they cannot not heat up at all. Yes, if
- 14:54you even make some completely fantastic
- 14:57device, absolutely ideal information
- 15:00erasure always dissipates, uh, a
- 15:02certain amount of energy and increases
- 15:05entropy. This is to say that
- 15:07information is not disembodied, but
- 15:10always has physical carriers. And we
- 15:12return to fields. We continue to think
- 15:16about fields, but take an interest in
- 15:19their informational content in a way
- 15:21and ask ourselves what that is. And
- 15:26this story began with the already
- 15:28mentioned Bekenstein, to whom Wheeler
- 15:31complained that he, Wheeler, felt like
- 15:34a criminal when he placed a cup of iced
- 15:37tea and hot tea next to each other in
- 15:40his office. Well, because they will
- 15:43exchange heat and become something else
- 15:46; one will cool down, the other will
- 15:48heat up, and they'll reach a middle
- 15:51state. And in the process, the entropy
- 15:53of the universe increases, which is, in
- 15:55general, pretty lousy. Meaning you
- 15:57contribute to the increase in the
- 15:59entropy of the universe. Uh
- 16:01>> everything around becomes more
- 16:04>> Yes. So, look, entropy—again, you
- 16:06keep provoking me into constant
- 16:08digressions, which is, without a doubt,
- 16:10pleasant. I'm not complaining, I'm just
- 16:12stating the fact. We just need to
- 16:14recall the previous subroutine from
- 16:16which we came. So, entropy is not so
- 16:18much—it’s not necessarily—it is
- 16:20very difficult to define entropy as
- 16:21disorder, because it’s unclear what
- 16:23disorder is without first defining
- 16:25entropy. Entropy is an information
- 16:27measure. It is a measure of our
- 16:28ignorance about what is happening.
- 16:30Let's return to this. We'll return to
- 16:31this if necessary. And then Wheeler
- 16:39says: "If a black hole floats by me,
- 16:41and I throw these cups of tea into it,
- 16:44the traces of my crime are completely
- 16:46erased because the black hole takes
- 16:48everything in and gives nothing back
- 16:50out." This is a black hole, mind you,
- 16:54an effect of gravity. It is
- 16:55super-strong gravity. It is not an
- 16:57object, it is a region of space from
- 16:58which nothing escapes. "Bekenstein
- 17:00didn't need anything else. He went away
- 17:03for a month and a half and didn't show
- 17:05up. After a month and a half, he came
- 17:08back and said:" You know, your crime
- 17:11will still be tracked because a black
- 17:13hole has entropy. "Bekenstein figured
- 17:17out—realized—that a black hole has
- 17:19entropy. And the development of these
- 17:23events was absolutely delightful
- 17:25because, when he published his article,
- 17:27Hawking, still a relatively young man
- 17:30then, together with Carter, I believe,
- 17:32they said this simply couldn't be, it
- 17:34was wrong, and they started writing a
- 17:37paper to refute it, well, because it
- 17:39was a very strange statement. And when
- 17:43they started writing the paper to
- 17:45refute it, they began doing
- 17:47calculations, diving into the problem,
- 17:49and realized that it was not only
- 17:51correct, but that one could say even
- 17:53more: that a black hole has not only
- 17:55entropy, but also something like a
- 17:57temperature. And if it has something
- 18:00like a temperature, then it must
- 18:02radiate according to our general laws
- 18:04of physics. And this radiation is
- 18:07Hawking radiation. So, Hawking
- 18:10radiation—the famous evaporation of
- 18:13black holes—originated as an attempt
- 18:15to refute Bekenstein's statement. So,
- 18:19black holes turned out to be a treasure
- 18:22trove. Not just a treasure trove, but a
- 18:25collection. They are gigantic
- 18:26storehouses of entropy. They contain a
- 18:29fantastic amount of entropy. Why?
- 18:32Because entropy is a measure of
- 18:33ignorance. You see, I am sitting here
- 18:35in a room at some temperature. If it
- 18:38gets a degree warmer in here, I'll
- 18:40probably feel it, because a very large
- 18:42number of molecules, a colossal amount,
- 18:45say, 10 to the 25th power, will start
- 18:47moving faster on average. But until
- 18:50that happens, until this macroparameter
- 18:52of temperature changes, I couldn't care
- 18:55less whether this specific molecule is
- 18:57moving a bit faster, or this one a bit
- 18:59slower, or vice versa, or anything like
- 19:02that. I honestly don't care about that
- 19:03at all. I see the same picture of the
- 19:06world, the same macroscopic picture,
- 19:08while inside it, these individual
- 19:10agents, tiny molecules, can arrange
- 19:12themselves in a fantastic number of
- 19:14ways. And it makes absolutely no
- 19:16difference to me. This number of ways,
- 19:18the number of microstates for them to
- 19:20organize their lives so that I don't
- 19:22notice the difference. Well, I mean,
- 19:25all our macroscopic instruments call it
- 19:28entropy. Well, the logarithm of the
- 19:31number of states is simply equal to
- 19:33entropy. You could also add some
- 19:36constant in there. So, entropy is a
- 19:39measure—it is what...
- 19:41>> It's the number of football formations
- 19:43a team can set up to keep the score 0-0
- 19:45.
- 19:46>> Well, for example, for example, only,
- 19:48you see, it's such a game...no, that's
- 19:50very good. No, Boris, let's, let's,
- 19:52let's develop this idea. It’s just a
- 19:55game where you only know the result and
- 19:58assume that one of these schemes was
- 20:00realized, but you only know the outcome
- 20:03. You don't see the schemes themselves.
- 20:05That's the point. So the coach knows
- 20:08them, but you read the newspaper, you
- 20:09have no TV or internet, and you only
- 20:11read the result in the paper the next
- 20:13morning and think:" Aha, so that means
- 20:15something like that must have happened.
- 20:18"Well yes, it's the number of ways to
- 20:21develop, the number of...well, not
- 20:23exactly the development of events,
- 20:25there's no literal time involved, but
- 20:28the number of ways to be arranged that
- 20:30realize the same picture. And I can't
- 20:33delve into them. You see, if I started
- 20:35recording everything they do, I would
- 20:38need a massive, a fantastic amount of
- 20:40information every microsecond. It truly
- 20:43is—and I don't even have anywhere to
- 20:44record it. I mean, it's not just that I
- 20:46can't model it on a computer; it's
- 20:48impossible. It sort of exists in the
- 20:50singular. So, the black—let’s
- 20:52return to the black hole. And because
- 20:55everything falls into it and it doesn't
- 20:57say anything in return, it has a very
- 20:58high entropy, because you can throw
- 21:00anything into it, and in Wheeler's
- 21:02words, a black hole has no hair. No
- 21:05hair.
- 21:06>> In other words, from outside a black
- 21:08hole, only three parameters are visible
- 21:10. Mass; that is the mass of everything
- 21:12researchers have thrown in there. Spin.
- 21:14Angular momentum. And although it is
- 21:18not a solid body, it possesses this
- 21:20characteristic, which is in its
- 21:22gravitational field, and electric
- 21:23charge. Feynman, the aforementioned
- 21:27student of Wheeler, for some reason
- 21:29considered the theorem stating that" a
- 21:31black hole has no hair "to be indecent,
- 21:33yet it caught on nonetheless. Well, it
- 21:36caught on conditionally. As it later
- 21:38turned out, there is quantum hair after
- 21:41all. This means the black hole shows
- 21:42nothing to the outside. But look, you
- 21:44can throw anything you want in there.
- 21:47If you want to throw in children's toys
- 21:49, antimatter, dark matter, or photons,
- 21:51please do; it is absolutely all the
- 21:53same to it. It recalculates the amount
- 21:57of energy you threw in as mass. And
- 21:59that is, essentially, the mass it
- 22:01demonstrates to you. But how? You
- 22:03cannot weigh it except through its
- 22:04gravitational field. How do we
- 22:06determine the mass of the Sun? Well,
- 22:08it's clear, isn't it, by how the
- 22:10planets move around it. Does it attract
- 22:12them strongly or weakly? It, the Sun,
- 22:14it, right? It is a star. Does this star
- 22:17have a strong pull or not? How did we
- 22:19calculate, or estimate, the mass of the
- 22:21supermassive black hole at the center
- 22:23of our galaxy? We saw stars rushing
- 22:25around a void, and roughly speaking, by
- 22:27how their trajectories curved, we said,
- 22:28" Well, there must be something of such
- 22:30and such a size there. "Notice that it
- 22:32doesn't touch them directly; it acts
- 22:33through a gravitational field, and they
- 22:35don't put it on a scale, right? And
- 22:36then, the next point. The development
- 22:39from Bekenstein to Hawking and
- 22:41reflecting on what happens there led to
- 22:44the following observations. Information
- 22:48about everything that fell into the
- 22:50black hole is hidden there, but the
- 22:53volume of this information is
- 22:55proportional to the surface area of the
- 22:58horizon.
- 22:58>> It is strange.
- 22:59>> This is exactly where we move on to the
- 23:01holographic idea.
- 23:02>> This is what the holographic idea grew
- 23:05from. Yes,
- 23:06>> it is strange. You see, in a sense,
- 23:10this means that the capacity of space
- 23:13is determined not by volume, but by
- 23:16surface area. Well, I start putting
- 23:19things into my closet, and if all
- 23:21dimensions of my closet are doubled,
- 23:23the volume of the closet increases
- 23:25eightfold, but the surface area only
- 23:27fourfold. So it turns out that every
- 23:31time I put something in the closet, I
- 23:34have to take a standard label and stick
- 23:36it on the surface of the closet—on
- 23:39the doors, the walls, the bottom, or
- 23:41the top. A spherical closet in a vacuum
- 23:44, so to speak. Exactly. And as soon as
- 23:46I've covered it,
- 23:47>> the QR code on the door exhaustively
- 23:49describes the contents of the closet.
- 23:51Yes. Uh, a valuable point. No, the QR
- 23:55code doesn't say what I put in. The
- 23:59fact that I put something in means I
- 24:01have to stick on a standard label, a
- 24:03label of a standard size. Once every
- 24:07bit of information I threw in there,
- 24:09once I've covered the entire surface,
- 24:12nothing else can be put inside.
- 24:16>> Well, that's how a black hole works.
- 24:18And it means that when I put something
- 24:19in, it increases the surface area. I
- 24:20throw in something else, it increases
- 24:22the surface area.
- 24:22>> This is very strange. It’s just
- 24:25>> not volume, not volume, but surface
- 24:26area again. So, the capacity of my
- 24:28closet is determined by its surface
- 24:31area. This is a gravity effect. And
- 24:33furthermore, whatever happens to black
- 24:35holes, the surface area of their
- 24:36horizon never decreases. This is very
- 24:39similar to entropy. And, in fact, the
- 24:40surface area is entropy. You have to
- 24:42divide the surface area by four. That
- 24:44is a coefficient that Bekenstein
- 24:45couldn't calculate. But Hawking did
- 24:47calculate it.
- 24:48>> Thanks to him for making our lives
- 24:49easier. Uh, so, you divide the surface
- 24:53area by four and by the Planck area to
- 24:57make it dimensionless, and you get the
- 25:00black hole's entropy. It turns out
- 25:04it’s not necessarily a black hole,
- 25:06but any volume of space, its capacity
- 25:08is limited by its surface area. Because
- 25:12if I take an arbitrary volume of space
- 25:15and try to stuff too much into it, the
- 25:17matter will turn into a black hole
- 25:19under its own gravity. And we return to
- 25:22the previous line of reasoning. And the
- 25:25surface area of the horizon will be
- 25:27proportional to information about
- 25:29everything, it will simply express its
- 25:31entropy. Information about everything
- 25:33that fell in and vanished. You know,
- 25:36the saying" what's lost is lost, "as I
- 25:37now understand, it's literally a saying
- 25:39. A saying about a black hole.
- 25:41Apparently, some far-sighted people
- 25:44foresaw this situation. There. But true
- 25:46, it's a classical saying, not a
- 25:48quantum one. We might get to its
- 25:50quantum, quantum correction. It turns
- 25:54out that if I take a volume of space
- 25:56and mentally draw a boundary, mentally,
- 25:58it turns out that a description of
- 26:00everything happening inside fits on the
- 26:03surface. So, I am rehabilitating your
- 26:06idea. I objected to something, yes, the
- 26:09QR code idea is good. Uh, this is the
- 26:11idea of holography. You have something
- 26:13happening in three dimensions, in our
- 26:15space. And it seems, you know, it seems
- 26:17volume is a much more capacious thing
- 26:20than surface. Well, because when you
- 26:22increase it like that, your volume
- 26:23grows proportional to the cube of the
- 26:25radius, but surface area is still
- 26:27proportional to the square. There. Well
- 26:29, like a big watermelon and a small one
- 26:31,
- 26:31>> yes. And it seems to us, well, it
- 26:33generally seems that way in life, right
- 26:35, that a box can hold more than a sheet
- 26:37of paper, as if.
- 26:38>> Well, absolutely correct. Exactly.
- 26:39Absolutely correct, yes. Even if you
- 26:41place little people on some small
- 26:43bodies and stick them to the contours
- 26:45of the box, you can still stuff more
- 26:47inside. So, it turns out that
- 26:50>> Listen, but that immediately creates a
- 26:52paradox. We have a box entirely covered
- 26:55in QR codes of what's inside,
- 26:57>> right? Then we take an A4 sheet of
- 26:59paper, right,
- 27:01>> with the same area as the entire
- 27:03surface area of this box.
- 27:06>> We cover it with the same QR codes.
- 27:08Then we take another sheet like it,
- 27:10cover it with different QR codes. Then
- 27:12we take another 100 sheets and put them
- 27:14all into this same box. It turns out
- 27:16there's more information inside the box
- 27:18than on its surface.
- 27:19>> No, no, we can't put them in the box.
- 27:21If, uh, if the box itself is already
- 27:23covered, completely sealed, then trying
- 27:26to put something else in it causes the
- 27:29box to expand. Well, the box isn't a
- 27:31box, but the surface area of a black
- 27:32hole's horizon. Meaning it, it
- 27:34increases. Meaning, and the surface
- 27:38>> the surface area increases
- 27:39proportionally to what you put inside.
- 27:43That is, if you put two A4 sheets in
- 27:45there, the surface area of your box
- 27:46must increase by the area of two A4
- 27:48sheets. Let's put it roughly this way,
- 27:52well, here, you see, uh, no metaphor is
- 27:55a precise statement, but I am ready to
- 27:58support the idea. Only, please,
- 28:02everyone must remember that a metaphor
- 28:03is not a precise statement; it can
- 28:05never be taken to the point of
- 28:06absurdity because, well, any metaphor,
- 28:08taken far enough, turns into absurdity.
- 28:12People then go around saying," You know
- 28:14, scientists are absurdists, because
- 28:15they explained this to me in such and
- 28:17such terms, but when I apply it over
- 28:19there, it yields completely wild things
- 28:20. "Well, you just shouldn't apply it,
- 28:23because you shouldn't confuse a
- 28:25metaphor with a metaphor explains some
- 28:27aspect of a process or some part of it,
- 28:29some fragment. These things are not
- 28:35just theoretical, they are also being
- 28:37worked on experimentally. I read that
- 28:40>> Well, that's a bold claim. That's a
- 28:42bold claim.
- 28:43>> Well, alright, give us your commentary.
- 28:45Uh, so, there was an experiment on the
- 28:47so-called creation of a small black
- 28:48hole. Clearly, this is not a black hole
- 28:51in the literal sense, but it is an
- 28:53attempt to recreate this mathematical
- 28:55model in reality. So what happened?
- 28:58They took super-cold atoms,
- 29:02>> yes, superconductors, yes,
- 29:03>> and around them created what is called
- 29:05an acoustic event horizon. Mhm.
- 29:07>> So, it has an event horizon. I
- 29:10understand the idea is that these atoms
- 29:12cannot move faster than the speed of
- 29:14sound. And that is why they get stuck,
- 29:16and some portion of the information
- 29:18simply cannot escape. Something along
- 29:20those lines. Could you comment on what
- 29:22this experiment is and how it helps us
- 29:24understand the theory?
- 29:25>> Aha, thanks. Well, that is a specific
- 29:27experiment. I am unlikely to comment on
- 29:30it in great detail right now, but such
- 29:31things are done, well, not exactly en
- 29:33masse, but from time to time. And then
- 29:36the journalistic cries begin:"
- 29:38Physicists recreate a black hole in the
- 29:40laboratory. "Yes. So, uh, the following
- 29:43is done. A quantum physical system is
- 29:46taken, and it is often converted, in a
- 29:49solid, by the way, also supercooled,
- 29:51near absolute zero. And it is taken and
- 29:55chosen, and conditions are created such
- 29:57that the physical regime you are
- 29:59interested in is described by equations
- 30:02that are the same as the equations for
- 30:05something near a black hole, for
- 30:07example.
- 30:09>> But that does not mean you are modeling
- 30:11a black hole. You are modeling the
- 30:15equations that describe a black hole.
- 30:18So this thing, not even once, for
- 30:19example, if you doubt that black holes
- 30:22exist in the universe, well, you have
- 30:24the right to doubt. You may think that
- 30:26this is a sort of solution to
- 30:27Einstein's equations. We still haven't
- 30:29found any deviations, but what if we do
- 30:31one day, and in principle, it could
- 30:33turn out that what we consider black
- 30:34holes are not quite black holes, not
- 30:36quite a solution to Einstein's
- 30:37equations. This is, in principle, an
- 30:39unlikely option, but theoretically
- 30:40possible. So, if you are doubtful about
- 30:44this, then what is done in the lab
- 30:46won't prove they exist in space,
- 30:48because what you are doing in the lab
- 30:50is reproducing, you are forcing another
- 30:53system to run, uh, well, to evolve in
- 30:55time in accordance with the equations
- 30:57that describe something black-hole-like
- 31:00. It is never the full Einstein
- 31:03equation—there are 10 partial
- 31:04differential equations there—but it
- 31:06is a certain regime to which Einstein's
- 31:08equations are reduced under certain
- 31:10assumptions. You can force these
- 31:13equations to create a physical system
- 31:14whose parts are subject to the same
- 31:16equations. So, what you are modeling
- 31:19here, honestly, is not very clear. You,
- 31:21uh, what are you training for? In the
- 31:23art. Well, first of all, it seems, in
- 31:25the art of controlling individual
- 31:28quantum systems. So, this is, so to
- 31:30speak, a parallel activity to creating
- 31:32a quantum computer or, say, quantum
- 31:35sensors. You control individual quantum
- 31:39elements, or perhaps in bulk, like in a
- 31:41superconductor where you create
- 31:44mesoscopic effects that also behave as
- 31:46quantum ones. They have something like
- 31:49an event horizon and so on. But the
- 31:52indicator is that instead of the speed
- 31:53of light, we have the speed of sound,
- 31:55which also needs to be understood in a
- 31:56very specific way. What kind of sound
- 31:59is this? What is it propagating through
- 32:01? What kind of vibrations are they? So,
- 32:02you are essentially modeling, you are
- 32:05setting up a living model of the
- 32:07equations.
- 32:08>> Am I correct in understanding that the
- 32:10idea here is that we can at least check
- 32:12whether this equation works, or is that
- 32:14not the goal?
- 32:14>> Well, not really check, because they
- 32:16behave only approximately. They only
- 32:18approximately obey these equations
- 32:20within a certain regime. Just nudge a
- 32:23laser tweezer slightly, or change the
- 32:25temperature, or something else, and it
- 32:28all falls apart. It is an artificially
- 32:31created piece of the world that, for a
- 32:34short time, behaves similarly to—well
- 32:36, it just models the solution to your
- 32:38equations. Sometimes it is interesting
- 32:41to see, well, how should I put it, it
- 32:43is satisfying that you invest something
- 32:46and force them to behave in accordance
- 32:48with the equations. The equations tell
- 32:51you that, I don't know, if you have
- 32:53this here, then you will have that over
- 32:55there. And you see that yes, this
- 32:57system demonstrates an analog of the
- 32:59same thing, well, until it falls apart
- 33:01and leaves the regime you artificially
- 33:03forced it into. This, let’s call it
- 33:07the black hole regime, inside, I don't
- 33:09know, a piece of a superconductor, for
- 33:11example.
- 33:16>> Right. Let’s return to the boundary
- 33:17of the black hole. The QR code is
- 33:19written on the boundary in the form of
- 33:21field theory. And this is the key issue
- 33:24right here. So,
- 33:26>> the whole story began with the fact
- 33:28that we have gravity; without it, there
- 33:30would be no black holes and none of
- 33:32this statement itself. So, we have
- 33:35space where some fields are running
- 33:37around, quarks, neutrinos, light is
- 33:39rushing about, and there is gravity.
- 33:41And notice right away that all fields
- 33:43in the Standard Model are quantum, but
- 33:45gravity is not. We do not know a
- 33:47quantum theory of gravity. Gravity is
- 33:49described by a classical field that
- 33:50accounts for the curvature of spacetime
- 33:52. It does not just account for it; it
- 33:55simply expresses a mathematical
- 33:56abstraction in the form of spacetime
- 33:58curvature. And a law of nature, well,
- 34:01one that appeared from somewhere,
- 34:03successfully guessed, thus best
- 34:05describes all the observable, all the
- 34:07currently observable effects of gravity
- 34:10. You somehow introduce space-time into
- 34:13mathematics, explain to yourself how it
- 34:15is curved for you, and project this
- 34:17mathematics in a certain way literally
- 34:19into what I was saying: into what is
- 34:22needed—who will fly where, who will
- 34:24accelerate how, how light will deflect
- 34:26around a star, what the horizon will be
- 34:28like, how two black holes will merge,
- 34:30how gravitational waves will radiate,
- 34:32and how these gravitational waves can
- 34:35be detected. Well, that is, something
- 34:37like a compass for a magnetic field;
- 34:39it's a completely different story there
- 34:40. And so on. Which means we have, uh,
- 34:43in our world, where we live, we have
- 34:45gravity and other fields, and we
- 34:47understand them well at the quantum
- 34:49level. But at the boundary, there is no
- 34:51gravity at all. And, uh, there is a
- 34:54completely different field theory there
- 34:56. Not one of those that we have here;
- 35:00it is a conformal field theory of a
- 35:02special kind. So, it's quite an amusing
- 35:05picture. The principles are the same
- 35:09principles of quantum field theory, but
- 35:11you don't take anything from what is in
- 35:14the Standard Model; instead, you take
- 35:16some other theory that isn't literally
- 35:19realized here in our Standard Model,
- 35:21and you remove gravity. And that, uh,
- 35:26gives you the content of the theory on
- 35:29the surface. This brings us to the
- 35:32question of information. Where you
- 35:35suddenly realize that you can use the
- 35:37word" information, "in a way that is
- 35:39still auxiliary for now, but no longer
- 35:41meaningless. Fields are no longer an
- 35:44invariant description, but the amount
- 35:47of information is, in a sense, the same
- 35:50. That is, you can calculate from the
- 35:52volume, from ours, to the surface, but
- 35:55this calculation, uh, is absolutely
- 35:58monstrous. It is truly similar to
- 36:00holography. Well, because in holography
- 36:03, one point of your figure, which is
- 36:05supposedly created in the volume, is
- 36:07encoded by the distribution of points
- 36:09across the entire holographic plate.
- 36:12This is what is called non-locality.
- 36:14Points in space generally cannot be
- 36:16mapped to points, well, it's not very
- 36:19clear how. Let's put it this way: to
- 36:21points on a plane. So, it's not very
- 36:23clear how to do that. And there is no
- 36:26talk of that here. Here, we are talking
- 36:28about the fact that the theory on the
- 36:31surface very non-locally, uh,
- 36:32re-encodes what is happening in the
- 36:35three-dimensional volume. And, uh, the
- 36:37impossibility of filling, uh, the
- 36:39impossibility of overfilling the
- 36:42three-dimensional volume. As we now
- 36:44understand, gravity is responsible for
- 36:46this. We removed it, and it no longer
- 36:49exists on the surface. So, gravity is,
- 36:51in a way, you know, quite an amusing
- 36:53picture. Gravity, on one hand, is about
- 36:57attraction, but gravity also makes our,
- 37:00so to speak, three-dimensional volume,
- 37:02well, in a way, sparse enough so that
- 37:05everything happening here could, in
- 37:07principle, be represented as QR codes
- 37:10scattered across the surface. And once
- 37:14again, because as soon as we try to
- 37:16pack in too much, gravity creates a
- 37:18black hole, and then the behavior of
- 37:20the black hole is such that everything
- 37:22is determined—all the information
- 37:23about everything that fell into it is
- 37:25determined by the surface. And that's
- 37:28when you start asking yourself
- 37:29questions.
- 37:30>> This is a clarifying question. What you
- 37:33just described is called by the scary
- 37:36acronym ADS/CFT. Did I get that right?
- 37:39CFT, because conformal field theory is
- 37:42indeed a conformal theory on the
- 37:44boundary. And AdS, well, yes, there is
- 37:47a catch here, of course. That is
- 37:50anti-de Sitter space. It's not the one
- 37:52we live in. Right. Well, there is a
- 37:55catch to this whole story. No, no, no,
- 37:57no. We actually live in de Sitter space
- 38:00. And de Sitter was a person, while
- 38:03anti-de Sitter is not a person. There
- 38:05was no such person as anti-de Sitter.
- 38:07Just like there was no Anti-Dühring.
- 38:09So, the jargon is well-established;
- 38:12it's a bit like de Sitter space. We are
- 38:15in this universe that is expanding in
- 38:18an accelerated way; it is
- 38:20asymptotically de Sitter, while anti-de
- 38:22Sitter is sort of de Sitter in reverse,
- 38:25it has an easier time with its boundary
- 38:27. And its boundary is a tricky thing.
- 38:31It means that as you move further and
- 38:34further away, fewer and fewer changes
- 38:37occur. And you can consider that when
- 38:41you look in a certain direction, as you
- 38:44move along, everything happening in the
- 38:46world stabilizes. And you start to
- 38:49associate each of these directions with
- 38:51a point on the boundary. So the
- 38:53boundary is sort of nowhere, but in a
- 38:55sense, you can draw it. This is,
- 38:57essentially, a property of the space.
- 39:00Anti—uh, AdS, anti-de Sitter, is that
- 39:02it has something, it has something like
- 39:05a boundary that can be defined, even
- 39:07though the space itself is not bounded
- 39:09by anything. It’s an infinite space,
- 39:13but the asymptotic regime is such that
- 39:15you can mathematically define this
- 39:17boundary and place your conformal field
- 39:19theory on it, and then say that there
- 39:21is a duality between them. So, ADS/CFT
- 39:23is exactly that—a duality. Ah, okay.
- 39:26To hell with de Sitter. Just to
- 39:27summarize our intermediate points, did
- 39:30I understand correctly that the idea is
- 39:32that we are assuming there are, I don't
- 39:35know, two realities? There is a quantum
- 39:38one, which sort of corresponds to this
- 39:41outer surface area. And there is the
- 39:44three-dimensional gravitational one in
- 39:46which we live. And so they exist in
- 39:49parallel, and they seem to correspond
- 39:51to each other very precisely. Well,
- 39:55there are just these two, and the
- 39:57correspondence is quite precise. It may
- 39:59be precise, it's just a very complex
- 40:01thing. What should correspond?
- 40:03>> Well, I mean, we can derive one from
- 40:04the other.
- 40:05>> Ah, well, that's a very good one, right
- 40:07? No, it's like this.
- 40:09>> A person who could actually sit down
- 40:11and calculate that would be a celebrity
- 40:13right now. I mean, the people who have
- 40:15managed to calculate at least something
- 40:17have already made quite a name for
- 40:18themselves. You see, as I said, quantum
- 40:21field theory is a thing where we can't
- 40:22calculate everything by a long shot.
- 40:24And the theory on the boundary is what
- 40:26is called" strongly coupled. "It is a
- 40:28strong coupling theory. Our methods,
- 40:30our perturbation theory, don't work
- 40:33there. That's why calculating it is
- 40:35very difficult. What do people do?
- 40:38People take certain observables and say
- 40:41:" Look, such and such an effect in our
- 40:45model or some story—in our 3D space,
- 40:49I can describe it with these other
- 40:53things distributed on the boundary. ""
- 40:58In that theory, I have to find
- 41:00operators whose quantum processing,
- 41:02according to the rules on the boundary,
- 41:04will yield the same numbers. "The ones
- 41:08I extract from the picture of what is
- 41:10happening here in our 3D space. And
- 41:13this is where, perhaps, the most
- 41:15interesting part of this story begins.
- 41:17These are, as it were, two languages.
- 41:19These are two very complex languages.
- 41:22Imagine you have a book written in one
- 41:23language, but you are not translating
- 41:25it word for word, even into some other
- 41:27language with a completely different
- 41:28structure. And not even sentence by
- 41:31sentence. You are not reading the book
- 41:34page by page at all; instead, some
- 41:37robot pierces through all the pages at
- 41:39once. It reads the typographical text;
- 41:44the needle senses how many times it
- 41:46touched the ink and how many times it
- 41:48didn't, and it records that in a
- 41:50separate way. This is not even a
- 41:53translation into another language; it
- 41:55is, in principle, a vastly different
- 41:56notation. Once again, this is a
- 41:58metaphor that just popped into my head.
- 41:59Don't take it as an absolute truth.
- 42:01There. But this is not a translation;
- 42:03it is definitely not a word-for-word
- 42:05translation. The question is, what is
- 42:07left? If this were a book after all—
- 42:11which is actually how this metaphor
- 42:13started—well, in a book, you see, you
- 42:15could read in Chinese, English, or
- 42:17Russian that Ivan Ivanovich came to
- 42:19visit John Smith and something happened
- 42:22to him, right? What is the invariant
- 42:25content? There. Well, something like
- 42:27the information in the book, right?
- 42:29After all, you learned some story while
- 42:31reading, that someone married someone
- 42:33else, or something else happened to
- 42:35these characters. Take War and Peace,
- 42:37for example. Right. So, uh, when you
- 42:42re-encode our three-dimensional world
- 42:45onto the boundary, the language changes
- 42:48completely. But what remains? Does some
- 42:52kind of content remain invariant? And
- 42:55that is when you say the word, well,
- 42:56probably information, because this
- 42:58whole story starts to revolve around
- 43:00information. That is, there is such a
- 43:03separate direction, or sub-direction,
- 43:06that is apparently fundamentally very
- 43:09important, if it is not just an
- 43:11artifact. Again, some things there can
- 43:14be proven, some can be traced, some can
- 43:18be argued convincingly, and so on. The
- 43:21picture is like this. Living on the
- 43:23surface, dealing with what is written
- 43:25on that surface, you can reconstruct
- 43:26the spacetime itself. Well, spacetime,
- 43:29I don't know, spac—that is a very
- 43:30strong statement. Well, you can
- 43:32reconstruct anti-de Sitter spacetime,
- 43:34right? That’s how it is. So, uh, you,
- 43:37uh, start, you see, when we live here,
- 43:40we say we have fields in space. Gravity
- 43:45is also a field that describes the
- 43:48curvature of this, well, spacetime. But
- 43:52, in general, we need something like
- 43:54space. We all agree that our matter is
- 43:57located in space. We are located in
- 44:00space. Note that we do not have a
- 44:02definition of space. And that is normal
- 44:04, because fundamental—we might have
- 44:05even talked about this sometime—
- 44:07fundamental concepts of physics are not
- 44:09defined, because otherwise it would be
- 44:10turtles all the way down. The Earth
- 44:12stands on a turtle, which stands on
- 44:14another turtle, which stands on yet
- 44:15another turtle. You have to stop
- 44:17somewhere. So, the definition of things
- 44:20stops at fundamental concepts that are
- 44:23not defined. We don't know what matter
- 44:26is. We cannot define it independently,
- 44:28and we cannot independently define what
- 44:29space is. Because what does it mean to
- 44:31independently define what space is? It
- 44:33means defining it through something
- 44:35that is not space at all. does not
- 44:38contain words like closer, further, or
- 44:41mutual position, or any other
- 44:42synonymous words involving something
- 44:44else entirely. We don't have that at
- 44:47Yes. Well, I will talk about where it
- 44:49might come from, but, so to speak, at
- 44:52the beginning of our story there is
- 44:54nothing like that, and yet physics
- 44:57works perfectly well.
- 44:58>> Space is what the measure of
- 45:00interaction in a field depends on, for
- 45:02example.
- 45:03>> Well, I don't know how to interpret
- 45:05that. I just don't know how, well, how
- 45:07to use it. And, how?
- 45:08>> Well, we have there, yes, divide by R²
- 45:10something. Most fields depend on R².
- 45:14>> Well no, not all fields, but gravity,
- 45:16right? Fine. What is What is R?
- 45:21>> Distance where? In space, that little
- 45:23thing.
- 45:24>> But we are going in circles. We are
- 45:25going in circles, yes. We are here No,
- 45:27look, what we do instead We never try
- 45:30to give a circular definition. We try
- 45:32not to do that. Instead, amazingly,
- 45:35physics works according to a different
- 45:37scheme. It successfully guesses the
- 45:40relationships between these undefinable
- 45:43concepts. Let me remind you, Newton's
- 45:46second law F = the trajectory predictor
- 45:48, with force on the left side. Force is
- 45:50one of the concepts that Newton does
- 45:52not define. You can wave your hands as
- 45:54much as you want. Saying:" Force is how
- 45:57I acted upon it. "I ask:" What do you
- 45:59mean, how? "You will say:" Well, with
- 46:01what force? "I ask, what does it mean
- 46:02to act upon. You will say:" Exerted an
- 46:04influence. "You will go in circles. So,
- 46:06force, notice, any physics problem,
- 46:08even a school one, well, and especially
- 46:11a school one, starts with, let's say,
- 46:13in mechanics, let's define the forces.
- 46:15After that, mathematics takes over.
- 46:17That's it. After that, mathematics
- 46:18takes over. You need to define the
- 46:20forces. But this second law of Newton
- 46:22is a connection, a fantastic,
- 46:23successful connection between force and
- 46:26acceleration. Force is the time
- 46:28derivative of momentum. Well, in simple
- 46:32language, F equals ma. There is a
- 46:34connection between them. Just as
- 46:35accurately, matter is in space. The
- 46:38electric field is connected to the
- 46:40magnetic one by a certain equation as
- 46:42well. From these equations follow ah
- 46:43well there a series of equations called
- 46:45Maxwell's equations. From this it
- 46:47follows that light propagates and light
- 46:50is described exactly by these waves and
- 46:52so on. Returning to holography, here we
- 46:56suddenly begin to aim for William our
- 46:58Shakespeare. We say, well, let's
- 47:03reconstruct not only the gravitational
- 47:08field here in 3D, but space itself. But
- 47:12how, how is that even to be understood?
- 47:15And you need to define something at the
- 47:19boundary that can be interpreted as the
- 47:23emergence of three-dimensional space.
- 47:27Here, things quickly become
- 47:29overwhelming, both in terms of
- 47:32imagination and mathematics. It is
- 47:35quite difficult. Mathematically, this
- 47:38is also a complex story. And the art of
- 47:41progress consists in choosing such
- 47:43simplifying assumptions, asymptotic
- 47:45regimes, while maintaining overall
- 47:48credibility. At the boundary, you take
- 47:50a certain quantum phenomenon called
- 47:53entanglement entropy.
- 47:54>> Oh, my.
- 47:55>> No need to panic. Don't panic. Entropy,
- 47:58we have already practiced that. We
- 48:01already know, we already know that it
- 48:03is a measure of ignorance.
- 48:04>> Now, what is entanglement entropy? So,
- 48:07if I have some quantum...
- 48:08>> entanglement, we are talking about
- 48:09quantum entanglement.
- 48:10>> Quantum entanglement, right? Yes. If I
- 48:12have some, yes, right now, yes, right
- 48:14away, easily. So, I have some quantum
- 48:17system, and it has two subsystems, well
- 48:18, say, a right one and a left one. And
- 48:21there can be correlations between them,
- 48:24deep quantum correlations. which are
- 48:27supported by this phenomenon called
- 48:30quantum entanglement. As long as these
- 48:32correlations exist. Well, in the system
- 48:35, I observe that there are correlations
- 48:37. I walk around quite happy. I measured
- 48:39something on the right. The subject is
- 48:41two particles.
- 48:41>> Well, two particles, or two sets of, or
- 48:44maybe 10 times two particles. 20 here,
- 48:4720 there, or...
- 48:49>> or the vacuum of quantum field theory,
- 48:52in which there are, as it were, virtual
- 48:55quanta. And they are also on one side
- 48:57and on the other side of an imaginary
- 48:59line. That is, any quantum system that
- 49:02is capable of quantum behavior. Quantum
- 49:05behavior is not something that can be
- 49:06easily visualized. This is a really
- 49:07important thing. Quantum objects, I'm
- 49:09already tired of saying this, are not
- 49:11specks of dust, not particles; they
- 49:12don't fly somewhere, they aren't
- 49:14located just there. They are more
- 49:16complex images. But if you have a
- 49:18system of two parts, and you make a
- 49:20measurement in one on something, and a
- 49:22measurement on the other, if you
- 49:24understand what you're doing, you can
- 49:26organize a very good correlation. You
- 49:28see, here you measured an electron spin
- 49:30up. Here it will always be down, and if
- 49:32down here, it is always up there. Like
- 49:34there is a connection between them,
- 49:35>> like there is a correlation between
- 49:37them, yes, there is no drive belt
- 49:38between them, but there is a
- 49:40correlation between the measurement
- 49:41results. There is a correlation between
- 49:43them, between how they manifest
- 49:45themselves. So, if I forget about one
- 49:49of these parts, I no longer see any
- 49:51order, any good correlations at all. I
- 49:55see some chaotic phenomena in the
- 49:57remaining system. One measurement shows
- 49:59this, another shows that, and so on.
- 50:02That is, a certain degree of ignorance
- 50:04arises in the system regarding how
- 50:06these things behave there. Quantum
- 50:09stuff is generally complex quantum
- 50:11theory, but there's an additional
- 50:13degree of uncertainty and ignorance
- 50:15about what's in this system because I'm
- 50:18ignoring the second half that is
- 50:19entangled with it. This information
- 50:22measure is called entropy, entanglement
- 50:27entropy. It is called entanglement
- 50:29entropy. That is, it shows, uh, well,
- 50:34in a way, how much I don't know about
- 50:37the system until I'm told how its parts
- 50:40are entangled with something else. And
- 50:45since I know nothing about that second
- 50:48half with which it is entangled, I,
- 50:50well, technically this is called taking
- 50:52the trace of the density matrix. But
- 50:56how can I put that into words? I am
- 50:58averaging over it. I assume that, on
- 51:00average, everything possible has
- 51:02happened there. And because of this,
- 51:04here in the part of the world I'm
- 51:06observing, well, in a way, additional
- 51:09chaos arises because I don't control
- 51:11how what I have here is correlated with
- 51:13what is there, since I don't know what
- 51:16is there. About entanglement. Since
- 51:24you've already started, well, first of
- 51:27all, back in '26 there was that news
- 51:29about successfully teleporting a photon
- 51:32. Tell me what actually happened there.
- 51:35So, do I understand correctly that they
- 51:37didn't actually teleport a photon, but
- 51:39its state, and with a certain level of
- 51:40precision?
- 51:41>> Well, that's an excellent question. So,
- 51:43well, many things have been teleported
- 51:45for a long time now. And here,
- 51:47apparently, they just teleported a
- 51:48photon over a long distance. What's
- 51:50teleported is the state. Teleportation
- 51:52is not a way to deliver cargo to Mars.
- 51:55That's one thing, and it's not, uh, a
- 51:57way, not even a way for
- 51:59faster-than-light signaling, that's two
- 52:01. But it's a rather amusing story. You
- 52:04use the resource of entanglement. That
- 52:06is, you take two entangled particles,
- 52:08one with me, the other with you. And we
- 52:12must take care in advance that they,
- 52:14right here in the middle of the table,
- 52:16one reaches me, the other reaches you,
- 52:18and along the way they shouldn't" talk
- 52:21"to anyone, so we carefully store them,
- 52:23uh, and don't let them interact with
- 52:25anyone. This is experimentally quite
- 52:27difficult, because the universe is all
- 52:29around, the environment, the
- 52:30environment, everything in the world,
- 52:32the Earth's magnetic field, incoming
- 52:34neutrinos, alpha particles, residual
- 52:35air molecules. We, of course, have to
- 52:37live in a vacuum for this, and so on.
- 52:38Nevertheless, uh, there is a
- 52:40correlation between them. A correlation
- 52:43between what? There is no constant
- 52:46drive belt between them. But if I make
- 52:48a measurement, and then you do, and
- 52:50then we lay out the cards with these
- 52:52measurements, show each other the
- 52:53results, we will see a correlation.
- 52:56Well, uh, there are options here as to
- 52:58how this is carried out. Nevertheless,
- 53:00there is a correlation there, even up
- 53:01to a complete match. And now, if I want
- 53:05to teleport something to you, I take
- 53:09another particle from our operator. An
- 53:12electron. Let it be an electron. An
- 53:14electron in a certain state, in a spin
- 53:17state. This means that in it, in its
- 53:20spin state, two numbers are hidden, two
- 53:23complex numbers. Actually one, well,
- 53:28let's say two real numbers, which
- 53:31cannot even be measured, cannot be
- 53:34looked at, cannot be known, but they
- 53:36are precisely defined, mathematically
- 53:39precisely defined by the way he
- 53:42prepared this state. Mathematically
- 53:46precisely defined. A mathematically
- 53:49precise number is not 2.33005915. It is
- 53:57, perhaps, some infinite decimal
- 53:58fraction, which in principle contains,
- 53:58in a sense, an infinite number of
- 53:58decimal places. And this mathematically
- 54:05precise number I can embed into the
- 54:07electron that you have. And this is
- 54:10called teleportation. To do this, I
- 54:13perform on my two electrons. The one we
- 54:16originally had, which is entangled with
- 54:18yours, and the one the operator gave me
- 54:21, I perform some measurements, after
- 54:23which yours turns out to be—a
- 54:25measurement is a thing that affects the
- 54:28entire system at once, including your
- 54:30electron. But
- 54:33>> a measurement gives unpredictable
- 54:35results, and I can get one of four
- 54:36results for my two particles. Both
- 54:39spins turn out to be up, one up and the
- 54:41other down, vice versa, and both spins
- 54:44down.
- 54:46>> And, uh, depending on what happened to
- 54:49me, your electron will end up in a
- 54:51state similar to that of the electron I
- 54:54received from the operator, the
- 54:57original one that needs to be
- 54:59transferred. But not exactly the same.
- 55:03An adjustment needs to be made; for
- 55:05example, you don't know where spin-up
- 55:06is, where spin-up is, but, for instance
- 55:08, you need to flip spin-up and
- 55:10spin-down. What do I do? I, uh, take a
- 55:13piece of paper, a carrier pigeon, and I
- 55:16write, I tie a message to its leg about
- 55:19what result I obtained. It flies to you
- 55:22. The pigeon, I emphasize, this is not
- 55:24faster than light. That is, I send you
- 55:25a radiogram, call you on the phone,
- 55:27tell you, but this is not fast...That
- 55:28is, if we imagine that we are far from
- 55:30each other, then this is not faster
- 55:32than light. And when you get this
- 55:34result, you know what needs to be done,
- 55:36what transformation you need to perform
- 55:39on your electron. And then, after this
- 55:42single transformation, you are
- 55:44guaranteed to have, in it, in your
- 55:46electron, the same mathematically
- 55:48defined numbers embedded in its state.
- 55:51But I didn't send you that at all. I
- 55:54sent you what would seem to be much
- 55:56less content, two bits. I told you it's
- 55:59this, this, this, or this. That is, I
- 56:02told you which of the four options: the
- 56:04first, second, third, or fourth? That
- 56:06is two bits. So for two bits, you
- 56:08received quite a lot because of the
- 56:10quantum resource of entanglement. But
- 56:13you still cannot look at it. You simply
- 56:16know they are there. Now, of course,
- 56:18you want it to be a cat, not an
- 56:20electron spin state. What needs to
- 56:23happen for it to teleport? Well, a cat
- 56:25is not good. That is very cruel. A
- 56:27tardigrade, yes. They are hardy, so you
- 56:29take a tardigrade. You know what? Let's
- 56:31even take molecules. Well,
- 56:32Schrödinger's tardigrade. I am still
- 56:35waiting for the appearance of not
- 56:37Schrödinger's cat, but tardigrades
- 56:38lived on board the ISS for a week or
- 56:40however long, a month, and a whole 10%
- 56:42didn't die. That is actually a lot. Try
- 56:46living in space on the surface of the
- 56:48ISS. There. So anyway, I'm waiting for
- 56:51Schrödinger's tardigrade. It will be
- 56:53interesting with it. That can be
- 56:54discussed separately. But let me
- 56:57teleport a molecule. Not one electron,
- 57:00but a molecule. It has a certain number
- 57:02of atoms, and these atoms have
- 57:04electrons. These electrons, they are,
- 57:06uh, shared. Well, what holds molecules
- 57:09together? It's because these electrons
- 57:11are in common ownership between these
- 57:12atoms, that's how it all happens. I
- 57:15need to transfer the exact quantum
- 57:17state of my molecule to your identical
- 57:20molecule. But in reality, a molecule
- 57:23has a lot—an electron with spin only
- 57:25has two, up and down, and any linear
- 57:27combination of them. But a molecule has
- 57:30a great many base reference states.
- 57:33Terribly many, just unimaginably many.
- 57:36Much more than it seems at first glance
- 57:38. As a result, it needs to be done like
- 57:40this. You and I know in advance which
- 57:43molecule I will be teleporting.
- 57:46Therefore, we first need to entangle
- 57:48the two molecules. Moreover, entangle
- 57:51every state of my molecule with every
- 57:53state of yours. Distribute them between
- 57:55us. Then I take the same molecule from
- 57:59the operator, I perform—I don't know
- 58:02how technologically—a very clever
- 58:04measurement that matches a state
- 58:06element in his molecule with the same
- 58:09element in mine, and then I send you a
- 58:12radiogram regarding what result I got.
- 58:16The story here is as follows. If this
- 58:18happens naively, then a molecule of
- 58:22about 270 atoms will require a number
- 58:25of corrective operations. Uh-huh.
- 58:29>> You will need to perform one of the
- 58:31corrective operations. We send a pigeon
- 58:34.
- 58:34>> That is when I send you information via
- 58:36pigeon. Yes, yes, yes. How much did I
- 58:38show you there? If it was an electron
- 58:40spin, I sent two bits of information.
- 58:41If it is a molecule, then it's a bit
- 58:43more. Well, it's still a certain
- 58:45message, but you will need a number.
- 58:47You must have prepared in advance a
- 58:49number of operations greater than the
- 58:51number of atoms in the universe.
- 58:52>> Uh-huh.
- 58:53>> End of story.
- 58:55>> Uh-huh.
- 58:56>> Quantum systems have an extraordinary
- 58:59depth within themselves. This is called
- 59:02the dimension of the Hilbert space. The
- 59:04dimension of the state space in which
- 59:06the wave function lives. This is
- 59:09exactly the phrase because of which
- 59:11Feynman said:" There is a lot of space
- 59:14at the bottom. "Feynman proposed
- 59:17building quantum computers, saying that
- 59:19down there at the bottom of the world
- 59:21it is very spacious, there are large
- 59:23spaces. That refers to state space. And
- 59:26Feynman's original idea was not, uh,
- 59:28quantum, not breaking codes, uh, not
- 59:30hacking the internet with a quantum
- 59:32computer, but modeling quantum with
- 59:34quantum. This is an illustration of the
- 59:37fact that when we try to accurately
- 59:39model something quantum with a
- 59:41classical computer, the state space
- 59:42swells up like this. That is, ah, there
- 59:45are about 100 atoms, whether 90, or 100
- 59:48, or 80. That is all the computing
- 59:51power on Earth. But with 270, their
- 59:53complete quantum modeling...To record
- 59:56their state in classical terms would
- 59:58require all the atoms in the universe.
- 1:00:01That is where the prospects for our
- 1:00:03teleportation end. Can you,
- 1:00:05>> after this, say that we do not live in
- 1:00:07an informational world?
- 1:00:08>> No. The prospects for teleportation end
- 1:00:11at very small molecules. Wait, if you
- 1:00:16are a representative of a very advanced
- 1:00:18civilization and say:" We have
- 1:00:20something like teleportation, "then you
- 1:00:23will tell me that you first freeze the
- 1:00:26object, or this molecule, to
- 1:00:28microkelvins, to absolute zero, to
- 1:00:30freeze out all states, to know that
- 1:00:33certain states there the electrons
- 1:00:35definitely do not occupy and the nuclei
- 1:00:38do not—they are inaccessible to them.
- 1:00:42Then teleportation will almost always
- 1:00:45be successful. Well, because after all,
- 1:00:46what does completely inaccessible mean?
- 1:00:48There is a possibility that something
- 1:00:50might slip somewhere due to some
- 1:00:52fluctuation, but in general, it will
- 1:00:54almost always work. And there are also
- 1:00:57atomic nuclear spins. Things are more
- 1:01:00complicated with them; they can't be
- 1:01:01frozen by temperature, but you could
- 1:01:03place your frozen object into a
- 1:01:05super-strong magnetic field. They will
- 1:01:07all be oriented, so there will be no
- 1:01:09randomness in them. They will all lie
- 1:01:11in the same direction, but the trouble,
- 1:01:13the real trouble, is elsewhere. The
- 1:01:15trouble lies in the conformational
- 1:01:17states. They cannot be frozen. Complex
- 1:01:20molecules have several spatial ways to
- 1:01:22organize themselves. Each of them is an
- 1:01:26energy minimum. That is, the molecule
- 1:01:28is conditionally stable in each of them
- 1:01:30. But because this is all quantum,
- 1:01:32there can be transitions between them.
- 1:01:34This happens directly with all sorts of
- 1:01:37our sugars and biological molecules. It
- 1:01:40happens with a colossal number of
- 1:01:42molecules. And these conformational
- 1:01:44transitions are not related to
- 1:01:45temperature, and they cannot be
- 1:01:47suppressed. And there still turn out to
- 1:01:49be quite a lot of them. So, even with
- 1:01:51average molecules, your teleportation
- 1:01:54will simply choke.
- 1:02:01>> So, what does the boundary have to do
- 1:02:02with it?
- 1:02:04>> Every region on which some quantum
- 1:02:05field theory is defined has a boundary.
- 1:02:09I choose a spot on the boundary. I have
- 1:02:11selected a spot on the boundary. Like
- 1:02:12pressing a hand, getting ink on my palm
- 1:02:15and printing it on the boundary. That
- 1:02:17is the spot. And a quantum field theory
- 1:02:20lives there. The very same conformal
- 1:02:21one on the boundary. But it doesn't
- 1:02:23know that I've chosen some spot. It
- 1:02:25just lives on its own. Therefore, this
- 1:02:28region has a certain measure of
- 1:02:31entanglement entropy. It is calculated
- 1:02:34using the contents of this quantum
- 1:02:36field theory. Quantum field theory
- 1:02:40contents on the boundary are needed,
- 1:02:42but it can be calculated. And then it
- 1:02:44turns out that it can be calculated in
- 1:02:46another way. You can, uh...Trace the
- 1:02:51spot I put on the boundary, outline the
- 1:02:54contours of my spot, and stretch a
- 1:02:57surface across these contours that
- 1:02:59extends into the bulk from the boundary
- 1:03:02—stretch a membrane that protrudes
- 1:03:05into the space. Moreover, it must be
- 1:03:09stretched in a very specific way.
- 1:03:11>> Uh, this anti-de Sitter space has a
- 1:03:13certain curvature. This surface must
- 1:03:16have a minimum area. Minimum area in
- 1:03:20curved space—that's a separate story.
- 1:03:22What surface has the minimum area in
- 1:03:24curved space? I must, as it were, seal
- 1:03:28the boundary of my spot with a membrane
- 1:03:30that looks inward, leaves the boundary,
- 1:03:32and enters the three-dimensional space.
- 1:03:36Out of all such membranes, choose the
- 1:03:38one that has the minimum area. This
- 1:03:41will result in the entanglement entropy
- 1:03:43on the boundary. It turns out that by
- 1:03:47going through all possible, well, one
- 1:03:50can look at this as optimistically as
- 1:03:52possible, that in principle, by going
- 1:03:55through all possible spots that I can
- 1:03:57place on the boundary, I can
- 1:03:59reconstruct and determine their
- 1:04:01entanglement entropy. It is a kind of
- 1:04:04information measure in a way. I am
- 1:04:07re-encoding the very same information
- 1:04:10into all possible, well, a large number
- 1:04:12of diverse surfaces passing through the
- 1:04:15volume here. I can consider the volume
- 1:04:19to be non-primary, perhaps, and instead
- 1:04:22say that the volume is simply
- 1:04:24everything these surfaces pass through.
- 1:04:29That is, when I am interested in some
- 1:04:31point in my three-dimensional space, I
- 1:04:34will think of it as the intersection of
- 1:04:37several specially chosen surfaces,
- 1:04:39thereby deriving the very existence of
- 1:04:42points here in three-dimensional space
- 1:04:44from something distributed along the
- 1:04:47boundary.
- 1:04:48>> If you want to make it easier now, then
- 1:04:51go ahead.
- 1:04:51>> Well, I don't know how well that will
- 1:04:53work. If you don't want to do that, I
- 1:04:54have a question, there will be a
- 1:04:55question.
- 1:04:55>> A small one. Let's—perhaps a question
- 1:04:57is also fine, just a small summary
- 1:04:58first. Uh, a conformal field theory
- 1:05:01lives on the boundary, a strange one,
- 1:05:03not like ours. And it has a quantum
- 1:05:06measure that tells us how each region,
- 1:05:08to what extent each region is entangled
- 1:05:10with everything else, with the rest of
- 1:05:12the surface. So, I can re-encode this
- 1:05:16entanglement entropy into surfaces
- 1:05:18drawn not on the boundary anymore, but
- 1:05:22extending from the boundary into our
- 1:05:25three-dimensional space here. In a way,
- 1:05:28an optimistic view of this is that I
- 1:05:32can reconstruct space based on quantum
- 1:05:36information. It is an informational
- 1:05:38characteristic. On the boundary. There
- 1:05:42are many complexities here because the
- 1:05:45quantum theory on the boundary is such
- 1:05:49that this entanglement entropy doesn't
- 1:05:52—doesn't exist. I mean, I just said
- 1:05:55that I take it, but quantum field
- 1:05:57theory is an amazing thing. At the
- 1:05:59beginning of our conversation, I hinted
- 1:06:01that we generally understand quantum
- 1:06:03field theory, but it is a great art. In
- 1:06:05quantum field theory, whatever you
- 1:06:06touch, it diverges. If you perform
- 1:06:09calculations naively, you get infinite
- 1:06:11answers. In our usual one, in our
- 1:06:13quantum electrodynamics. It is the most
- 1:06:16accurate theory in the world, but if
- 1:06:18you act naively, you get a foolish,
- 1:06:20meaningless, sort of infinite answer.
- 1:06:22There is a whole scheme of actions that
- 1:06:24allows extracting an exact result from
- 1:06:26a formally infinite answer. It is
- 1:06:29amazingly called renormalization. To
- 1:06:31obtain an exact result that perfectly
- 1:06:33corresponds to the experiment. On the
- 1:06:35boundary, some tricks and caution are
- 1:06:39needed. You need to take some relative
- 1:06:42—let me correct this statement. You
- 1:06:45need to take relative entropy. You need
- 1:06:48to compare a certain state, so the
- 1:06:51statement I made initially is a bit
- 1:06:54naive; more mathematical and meaningful
- 1:06:57statements are what actually allow us
- 1:07:00to develop further. They are about this
- 1:07:04kind of informational measure. How much
- 1:07:07does a certain state of the field on
- 1:07:10the boundary differ from the vacuum
- 1:07:13state? So, I need to subtract something
- 1:07:16, I need to have a basis, I need to say
- 1:07:18that I am measuring from a certain
- 1:07:20vacuum state on the boundary. And this
- 1:07:23relative increment of my entanglement
- 1:07:26entropy, that is meaningful. And it is
- 1:07:28recalculated here into three dimensions
- 1:07:31. And it turns out that the laws
- 1:07:33regarding entropy in two dimensions,
- 1:07:36those laws that we love about entropy
- 1:07:39—that it doesn't, well, roughly
- 1:07:41speaking, that it doesn't decrease—
- 1:07:44turn, with some, well, with some
- 1:07:46sleight of hand, a harmless sleight of
- 1:07:49hand, into Einstein's equations, well,
- 1:07:51linearized Einstein's equations for
- 1:07:54gravity. In other words, you recreate
- 1:07:56something that we value and love here.
- 1:07:59Well, first of all, our space and,
- 1:08:01secondly, gravity, to a certain extent
- 1:08:04gravity within it, through the
- 1:08:07information content on the boundary.
- 1:08:09That is very cool. And there are
- 1:08:12remarkable additional aspects here,
- 1:08:14because gravity itself, due to the fact
- 1:08:17that it is a peculiar kind of gauge
- 1:08:19theory, also does not allow you to
- 1:08:21define everything. And you need, you
- 1:08:24are going to be delighted now, you need
- 1:08:26some kind of choice. For this
- 1:08:29correspondence, the reproduction of
- 1:08:31gravity in space based on the boundary,
- 1:08:34to make sense, you need to make some
- 1:08:36kind of choice. Physicists call it:
- 1:08:39observer choice. Heaven forbid you
- 1:08:42think you need a person with a brain,
- 1:08:44but you need to make a certain choice,
- 1:08:46something like a way of measuring time,
- 1:08:48to choose some clocks that serve as a
- 1:08:50reference for you. And then the world
- 1:08:54recreated in this way becomes
- 1:08:56approximately ours. It becomes
- 1:09:00meaningful to talk about gravity in it.
- 1:09:04This is if you don't assume its
- 1:09:06existence at the start. That is, you
- 1:09:09can pretend that you are not just an
- 1:09:11alien, but a person from another
- 1:09:13universe. You take a theory on the
- 1:09:16boundary, you perform not-so-simple
- 1:09:18mathematical tricks with it. You have
- 1:09:21to move from type III von Neumann
- 1:09:24factors, which are terrible, to a type
- 1:09:27II-infinity von Neumann factor or some
- 1:09:31other. This is, you understand, this is
- 1:09:34exactly what I said at the beginning—
- 1:09:36it is complicated, both ideologically
- 1:09:38complex and mathematically highly
- 1:09:40technical. And surprisingly, the things
- 1:09:44that the great von Neumann worked on
- 1:09:46when he was simply studying what
- 1:09:48quantum theories can be, how good or
- 1:09:51bad they can be, in the sense of what
- 1:09:54things we want to exist and what can be
- 1:09:56defined in them, versus what cannot,
- 1:09:59come into play here. He created a
- 1:10:01certain classification. You take these
- 1:10:05precautions, you act very carefully,
- 1:10:08mathematically, and then, uh, if you
- 1:10:10choose something like, you say:" This
- 1:10:13is how I will measure time. These will
- 1:10:17be my clocks in this three-dimensional
- 1:10:19space. "" Then the entire
- 1:10:20three-dimensional space will emerge for
- 1:10:22you. "That is, the slogan-like part of
- 1:10:24this is terrible, because you need an
- 1:10:26observer for the three-dimensional
- 1:10:28space to emerge. An observer does not
- 1:10:31mean a human observer, like a PhD, or
- 1:10:34even a student, or any sentient being
- 1:10:36at all. Observer means you need to
- 1:10:39decide relative to what method you need
- 1:10:41a reference, which way of measuring
- 1:10:44time you have chosen here. This is
- 1:10:47related to the general covariance of
- 1:10:49the theory of gravity, because to it,
- 1:10:51to the theory itself, it absolutely
- 1:10:53does not matter, it makes no
- 1:10:55distinction. You need, you need to
- 1:10:57choose a certain way, a certain base in
- 1:11:00order to grow three-dimensional space
- 1:11:03from the boundary upon it. Well, you
- 1:11:06know, clocks, for example, or something
- 1:11:08similar. And to sum up briefly, I see
- 1:11:10your question, just hang in there, a
- 1:11:12little bit more to go. So, there are a
- 1:11:15large number of both mathematical
- 1:11:18subtleties and complexities, and not
- 1:11:24everything is proven and established,
- 1:11:26but the idea that information content
- 1:11:29is a bridge between, uh, what is done
- 1:11:32on the boundary and what is done in the
- 1:11:35space here, including the space itself,
- 1:11:38sounds more and more convincing. And
- 1:11:42this does not mean that there is an
- 1:11:44information field in the world or
- 1:11:45anything like that. It means that
- 1:11:48information is becoming a language that
- 1:11:51, perhaps, we will someday learn to
- 1:11:53speak, and then such a quantum field
- 1:11:56theory here plus gravity or conformal
- 1:11:59field theories on the boundary will
- 1:12:02become translations of this information
- 1:12:05content into very, very different
- 1:12:08languages. What is happening in the
- 1:12:11space is encoded on the boundary with
- 1:12:13some redundancy, but with a large
- 1:12:14redundancy.
- 1:12:15>> Mhm.
- 1:12:17>> This is how quantum error-correcting
- 1:12:20codes work in quantum computers.
- 1:12:23>> That is why they are based on
- 1:12:24entanglement. Through entanglement in
- 1:12:27quantum computers, they are susceptible
- 1:12:29, this is a completely different story,
- 1:12:30but it is also a story about quantum
- 1:12:32behavior. Because they are physically
- 1:12:34susceptible to failures, you need to
- 1:12:36create redundancy somehow. But you
- 1:12:38cannot create redundancy with normal
- 1:12:40means, because in quantum mechanics,
- 1:12:42you cannot copy a wave function without
- 1:12:44destroying the original. That is, there
- 1:12:46is that teleportation where
- 1:12:48Schwarzenegger goes into a booth, and
- 1:12:50then he comes out in another place, but
- 1:12:52the first one remains, and his wife
- 1:12:53ends up with two husbands. You remember
- 1:12:55that movie, right? They first beat each
- 1:12:57other up, and then...well, what movie
- 1:12:59is it? Two Schwarzeneggers, and then
- 1:13:01they find out that they both exist, but
- 1:13:03it all ends. Then together they beat up
- 1:13:05the main bad guy. Well, naturally, it
- 1:13:07all ends. And then, somehow, they make
- 1:13:09up. One decides to fly away somewhere,
- 1:13:11and the other, well, you know. And the
- 1:13:13wife, kind of, also doesn't
- 1:13:14>> and the wife doesn't either; it's all
- 1:13:16handled so delicately, so well. But the
- 1:13:19main thing is that the focus is on the
- 1:13:20fact that they offed the main bad guy.
- 1:13:22So, this is impossible, because in
- 1:13:23quantum mechanics it is impossible to
- 1:13:25create—there's a direct ban, a direct
- 1:13:27ban, ban, ban. Therefore, when you put
- 1:13:29redundant information into a quantum
- 1:13:30computer, you do it using entanglement.
- 1:13:33And here on the boundary, we have
- 1:13:35entanglement of different regions with
- 1:13:37each other, through which
- 1:13:39three-dimensional content is reproduced
- 1:13:41. That is why people have started
- 1:13:44saying that, well, this is a slogan.
- 1:13:46Three-dimensional space is a quantum
- 1:13:49code. Quantum error correction code.
- 1:13:52Quantum error correction code on the
- 1:13:54boundary. And, perhaps, what lies
- 1:13:58behind this phrase is also an emphasis
- 1:14:01on information content, because you are
- 1:14:04saying that the information I
- 1:14:06distributed (well, not that I
- 1:14:09distributed, but which is scattered
- 1:14:12among some [], which I read as
- 1:14:14distributed along the boundary), well,
- 1:14:17it—its alternative restatement takes
- 1:14:20the form of space with, and also with
- 1:14:24something very similar to Einsteinian
- 1:14:26gravity. It's quite a long way from
- 1:14:30there to full gravity, but the
- 1:14:32linearized Einstein equations turn out
- 1:14:35to be a consequence of how entropy
- 1:14:37behaves on the boundary, taking into
- 1:14:39account a large number of subtleties,
- 1:14:42precision, corrections, some
- 1:14:43approximations, and so on.
- 1:14:51>> I have a few more clarifying questions
- 1:14:52about entanglement. How common of a
- 1:14:54phenomenon is this, generally? Are
- 1:14:58there many entangled particles around
- 1:15:00us, or is it something special that we
- 1:15:02have to—practically everything,
- 1:15:04absolutely practically any quantum
- 1:15:06interaction creates entanglement.
- 1:15:09Entanglement is simply, for example, a
- 1:15:11consequence of conservation laws. If I
- 1:15:12have something that wasn't rotating and
- 1:15:14it splits into two, the angular
- 1:15:16momentum of those two must be opposite.
- 1:15:18But exactly how, I don't know. That's
- 1:15:20entanglement. But the problem in our
- 1:15:22world is that if you and I want to do
- 1:15:25an experiment with entangled particles,
- 1:15:27mine, on its way from the point of
- 1:15:29creation to me, talked to a few others
- 1:15:31and became entangled with them. And the
- 1:15:34entanglement immediately spread
- 1:15:35throughout the entire medium, because
- 1:15:37they don't wait and collide with other
- 1:15:39molecules. As a result, for you and me
- 1:15:42to confirm that entanglement manifests
- 1:15:44itself through correlations, to make
- 1:15:46sure that these correlations exist, we
- 1:15:48need to track down all the molecules
- 1:15:50that they interacted with, everyone
- 1:15:52they interacted with, and perform
- 1:15:54measurements on them. That is just as
- 1:15:58unthinkable a task as that. This is
- 1:16:00where entropy begins to play a role,
- 1:16:02because remember, we said that entropy
- 1:16:04is that monstrous amount of information
- 1:16:06that I cannot track, nor is it within
- 1:16:08my power to track, and so on. So, to
- 1:16:11verify,
- 1:16:12>> wait, so it turns out, it turns out
- 1:16:14that they have a memory of the
- 1:16:15interaction with all those billions of
- 1:16:17particles they encountered on their
- 1:16:19path.
- 1:16:20>> Well, what, what does memory mean? They
- 1:16:22have quantum evolution according to
- 1:16:24Schrödinger. To read this memory in
- 1:16:28any sense is roughly like blowing up a
- 1:16:30perfume factory and then catching the
- 1:16:33perfume molecules and stuffing them
- 1:16:35back into the bottles. Not only to
- 1:16:38create the bottles, but to put the
- 1:16:40whole scent, to put each scent into its
- 1:16:42own bottle. This is roughly, this is an
- 1:16:44entropic thing. This is exactly an
- 1:16:46entropic thing. Approximately the same
- 1:16:47thing is happening here.
- 1:16:48>> Oh, so it's not memory, it's the
- 1:16:49current state, which is conditioned by
- 1:16:51billions of interactions.
- 1:16:53>> No, that's not it. Well, wait. I mean,
- 1:16:54you said it absolutely correctly: our
- 1:16:56current state is determined by the
- 1:16:57previous history. The world is evolving
- 1:16:59, it didn't just appear out of nowhere.
- 1:17:01It is defined; before this, there was a
- 1:17:03previous one. The previous state of
- 1:17:05evolution is the development of
- 1:17:07something in time. Well, in this sense,
- 1:17:09everything has a memory of everything,
- 1:17:12but this word is meaningless if
- 1:17:13understood as a memory that can be read
- 1:17:15, used, and so on.
- 1:17:17>> Yes, yes, yes, I understood everything.
- 1:17:18Uh-huh. Okay. And then here's a
- 1:17:21question. I read a statement and need
- 1:17:24your comment. Entanglement is the glue
- 1:17:27of space. What does that mean?
- 1:17:29>> It is exactly about the story we were
- 1:17:31discussing. When you try to define
- 1:17:34space through something that is not
- 1:17:36space, one of the possibilities—and
- 1:17:39holography pushes towards this—And
- 1:17:42this statement is close in idea and
- 1:17:44spirit to holography. You can say that
- 1:17:49high entanglement is close, and weak
- 1:17:52entanglement is far. Only in this case,
- 1:17:56you, of course, don't have particles;
- 1:17:57you have certain quantum states. You
- 1:17:59must postulate some quantum fields. And
- 1:18:03here is the difficulty, because as soon
- 1:18:05as you just usually describe a quantum
- 1:18:08field, it is already in space. Well,
- 1:18:11let's, how shall we borrow, let's
- 1:18:13borrow from ourselves. I don't know who
- 1:18:15we will borrow from. A field and its
- 1:18:18vacuum state, which, well, kind of,
- 1:18:21sort of, isn't directly tied to space.
- 1:18:25Not everything is clear to me here, so
- 1:18:27I cannot comment on everything here.
- 1:18:29And then we say that when there is
- 1:18:31little entanglement, it is far, and
- 1:18:33when there is a lot of entanglement, it
- 1:18:36is close. In this sense, it is the glue
- 1:18:39of space. So, let's say that if we
- 1:18:42could just switch off quantum
- 1:18:43entanglement like that, space would
- 1:18:46cease to be connected. This is
- 1:18:49partially just verbal. I don't really
- 1:18:53understand to what extent this can be
- 1:18:55translated into formulas. I mean, not
- 1:18:57literally, but maybe there are some
- 1:18:59semi-convincing formulas where this
- 1:19:01could be done, but they are just like
- 1:19:02that.
- 1:19:03>> But the image is very sticky, I would
- 1:19:05say. This is closer to" It from Qubit,
- 1:19:08"but only in relation to space. Let’s
- 1:19:11round this off, let's close the loop,
- 1:19:14because you have a quantum system that
- 1:19:17is defined in some abstract way, and
- 1:19:19you can think that through entanglement
- 1:19:23it begins to create space. There are
- 1:19:26many complexities here because you
- 1:19:28somehow need to separate things. One is
- 1:19:31entangled with another. This means you
- 1:19:33need to look at its state space and try
- 1:19:36to break it down into some kind of
- 1:19:38tensor product. There is a long and
- 1:19:42complex history here, but, uh, this is,
- 1:19:45if you like, one of the modern
- 1:19:47spin-offs of the" It from Qubit "idea.
- 1:19:57>> About the 2025 Nobel Prize. John Clarke
- 1:20:01, Michel Devoret, John Martinis.
- 1:20:05>> Martinis. Martinis, yes.
- 1:20:07>> Martinis.
- 1:20:08>> Ah, yes. If I understand correctly, the
- 1:20:11idea is that they showed that quantum
- 1:20:14laws work not only with tiny particles,
- 1:20:17but also with larger objects, uh, quite
- 1:20:19observable, even almost optically. That
- 1:20:23is, they were able to show the
- 1:20:25tunneling effect. We discussed this in
- 1:20:27our very first episode, friends. You
- 1:20:29can take a look, uh, about the fact
- 1:20:31that electrons know how to walk through
- 1:20:32a wall. So, they showed that larger
- 1:20:35objects, uh, in the form of large
- 1:20:38molecules, can also fly through a wall.
- 1:20:42Did I understand that correctly? And
- 1:20:43explain how such a...
- 1:20:44>> Well, more or less, more or less, yes.
- 1:20:45It's just that these are quite old
- 1:20:47works. By now, all of this has long
- 1:20:50become a classic. And this is, you know
- 1:20:52, the Nobel Committee paying off old
- 1:20:54debts. They should have done it earlier
- 1:20:55, actually. And besides, in part, this
- 1:20:58underlies, well, very similar things
- 1:21:00lie at the heart of quantum computers,
- 1:21:02superconducting qubits. The idea is as
- 1:21:04follows. Once you are in quantum
- 1:21:06mechanics, the following is true. As
- 1:21:08soon as you try to put something in a
- 1:21:11confined volume, discreteness arises.
- 1:21:13This is the main property of an atom,
- 1:21:16that each atom shines with very
- 1:21:18specific spectral lines because
- 1:21:20electrons near the nucleus can only
- 1:21:23settle to live on certain energy floors
- 1:21:25. At the same time, their state is of
- 1:21:27an abstract nature. They have no
- 1:21:29position in space, they have no
- 1:21:31velocity. They have certain discrete
- 1:21:33energies, floors, and the elevator does
- 1:21:35not stop between floors. You cannot
- 1:21:38place an electron in an atom with just
- 1:21:39any intermediate energy. More or less,
- 1:21:41the same thing happens here. These are
- 1:21:43the so-called quantum dots; artificial
- 1:21:45atoms are the same story. You take a
- 1:21:49crystal so small that discrete states
- 1:21:51emerge within it due to its dimensions.
- 1:21:55And it's called an artificial atom
- 1:21:57because you can likely manipulate it.
- 1:22:00An atom emits light of a certain color
- 1:22:03depending on the distance between these
- 1:22:05energy levels. In a crystal, you can
- 1:22:08adjust the distance between these
- 1:22:09discrete levels so it glows the color
- 1:22:11you want. It is nice, it is cute, and
- 1:22:13for many, it is a very controllable
- 1:22:15method. So, they showed, for example,
- 1:22:19that discreteness arises when you force
- 1:22:21current to run, uh, well, roughly in a
- 1:22:24circle. That is, you don't take a
- 1:22:28single electron potential, but take a
- 1:22:30mesoscopic state, that is, a certain
- 1:22:33number of electrons moving, of course,
- 1:22:36through a superconductor, and you
- 1:22:38create for them something that is very
- 1:22:41similar to what is currently a
- 1:22:43superconducting loop in a
- 1:22:45superconducting quantum computer. What
- 1:22:48is that? To simplify things entirely.
- 1:22:52It is a ring in which there are
- 1:22:54discrete levels, and in which current
- 1:22:56can flow because it is closed and
- 1:22:59cannot leak out anywhere. Well, at
- 1:23:02least it doesn't leak for now. Very
- 1:23:03roughly speaking, current can flow at
- 1:23:05this strength, or higher, or even
- 1:23:07higher. But these are also jumps. Well,
- 1:23:09magnetic flux or something else is
- 1:23:11actually measured there. But it is
- 1:23:13important that the state cannot change
- 1:23:15smoothly. It can only change in jumps.
- 1:23:19They showed this. And so, essentially,
- 1:23:22these very jumps—two states, one and
- 1:23:24another separated from it by a jump—
- 1:23:26are what constitute the qubit in this
- 1:23:28quantum computer platform. There are
- 1:23:31other states as well. They try to
- 1:23:32ensure these don't get mixed up with
- 1:23:34the others, because as soon as they
- 1:23:36jump there, it will be an error. And
- 1:23:37these two are the ones we control. And
- 1:23:39that is how quantum computers are built
- 1:23:40. Furthermore, they demonstrated the
- 1:23:43tunneling effect: if you create a gap
- 1:23:45through which current cannot flow, then
- 1:23:47in quantum terms—that is, from the
- 1:23:49perspective of these electrons—there
- 1:23:51is a wall they cannot overcome. A wall,
- 1:23:54because you would need too much energy
- 1:23:56to jump over it. But, uh, the jumping,
- 1:23:59heaven forbid, does not happen in
- 1:24:01ordinary space, but in energy space.
- 1:24:04People always say:" It jumped over the
- 1:24:06potential barrier, "and it seems as if
- 1:24:08it really climbed out of a hole
- 1:24:09surrounded by a rim and fell out. But
- 1:24:11that is a metaphor; simply put, there
- 1:24:14is also a certain potential barrier
- 1:24:17here. So, when there isn't enough force
- 1:24:21to get out, not enough energy to jump
- 1:24:24over the wall, a quantum system can
- 1:24:26tunnel. And they showed that this
- 1:24:30mesoscopic system tunnels. It impressed
- 1:24:34their contemporaries because it wasn't
- 1:24:36the wavefunction of a single electron
- 1:24:38that was tunneling, but a tricky thing.
- 1:24:41Well, there’s superconductivity,
- 1:24:42it’s complicated. Electrons hate each
- 1:24:45other there; they are fermions, but in
- 1:24:47a superconducting state, they are glued
- 1:24:49into pairs by phonons. And pairs are
- 1:24:53bosons. They can start—they are like
- 1:24:55party-goers, they can start getting
- 1:24:57along, and the superconducting state
- 1:24:59means they have a common wavefunction.
- 1:25:01But it is a common wavefunction, yes,
- 1:25:02they are completely devoid of
- 1:25:04individuality there. You absolutely
- 1:25:05cannot tell which one is where. A lot
- 1:25:07of things are based on this. There is
- 1:25:10no separateness for any electron
- 1:25:12included in this superconducting state.
- 1:25:15And yet, there are many of them. And
- 1:25:17this whole thing can end up on the
- 1:25:20other side of this transition, what is
- 1:25:22for them a wall, a potential barrier.
- 1:25:26But they demonstrated this directly by
- 1:25:28measuring, by performing electrical and
- 1:25:30magnetic measurements. It was a great
- 1:25:33achievement. That's why now it is, you
- 1:25:37know, everywhere, but back then these
- 1:25:39were foundational works that, in a
- 1:25:41sense, opened up, well, in some ways
- 1:25:43opened up the modern era. They showed
- 1:25:47that it is possible, for example, to
- 1:25:49build a superconducting platform for
- 1:25:51quantum computers. One of them, I think
- 1:25:59, worked or still works at Google; in
- 1:26:03short, these are the people who
- 1:26:06continued this work and brought it to
- 1:26:10its current state.
- 1:26:13>> Well, and for the national economy,
- 1:26:14this is a quantum computer, right? That
- 1:26:15is, like in" Ivan Vasilievich, "to open
- 1:26:17one wall, but opening the second wall
- 1:26:19isn't possible yet. Quantum computers,
- 1:26:22quantum sensors. Uh, so, to feel what
- 1:26:24is behind the wall is also good. Uh, in
- 1:26:27general, look. This is
- 1:26:30>> at what distance?
- 1:26:31>> Uh, it's not about distance, it's about
- 1:26:33the strength of the magnetic field.
- 1:26:35Well, for example, the magnetic field
- 1:26:37in our brain is so weak that the
- 1:26:39Earth's magnetic field drowns it out.
- 1:26:42But if you have such quantum sensors,
- 1:26:44they are capable of sensing the
- 1:26:45slightest, slightest things against
- 1:26:47that background. And you can, for
- 1:26:49example, read what is going on in your
- 1:26:51head. Yes. Yes, in principle, whether
- 1:26:54it will happen or not, you have to ask
- 1:26:56the people who are doing it. Well, uh,
- 1:26:59it's just that quantum behavior,
- 1:27:00individual quanta are very delicate,
- 1:27:02and they are susceptible to everything.
- 1:27:05You need to make it so that you can
- 1:27:08somehow read the signal from them that
- 1:27:11you are interested in. This quantum
- 1:27:14sensing is currently something that,
- 1:27:16well, it runs parallel to quantum
- 1:27:18computers and is developing very
- 1:27:20quickly. You get the ability to detect,
- 1:27:23practically to a level of magic, things
- 1:27:25like magnetic fields or the presence of
- 1:27:27other molecules, and so on. There you
- 1:27:30go. So for the national economy, this
- 1:27:32is useful, and fundamentally it was
- 1:27:34important. And technologically, this
- 1:27:37quantum computer is the intersection of
- 1:27:40technology and fundamental things. They
- 1:27:44really go hand in hand here. And to
- 1:27:47round it off, to finalize—maybe this
- 1:27:50is more of a question for an IT
- 1:27:52specialist—but if we imagine that we
- 1:27:54are all in a giant information system,
- 1:27:57in a mega-flash drive, does everything
- 1:27:59we've described look more like an
- 1:28:02interesting data storage and processing
- 1:28:04system, or is it just some redundant
- 1:28:06junk? Look, I am against the"
- 1:28:10mega-flash drive "idea for the reason
- 1:28:13that I partially described. Classical
- 1:28:16recording of our quantum states, even
- 1:28:19for small trifles like a molecule of
- 1:28:21270 atoms, under our conditions,
- 1:28:23requires all the atoms in the universe
- 1:28:26for a classical recording. So, in order
- 1:28:29to record even a small piece of our
- 1:28:32quantum world—a tiny piece—onto a
- 1:28:36flash drive, you would need several
- 1:28:39universes. And beyond that, it is not
- 1:28:43very clear who could manage such a
- 1:28:45flash drive and how. I don't understand
- 1:28:48what could be attractive about the idea
- 1:28:50that we live in the Matrix. The idea is
- 1:28:52that we live inside a quantum computer.
- 1:28:55That might be somewhat plausible, but
- 1:28:56then you just have to understand that
- 1:28:58the universe itself is our quantum
- 1:28:59computer. It computes itself every
- 1:29:02millisecond, every nanosecond. As
- 1:29:05befits a quantum computer, it simply
- 1:29:07evolves. And that is basically all
- 1:29:08there is to it. That is, the universe
- 1:29:10as a quantum computer simply means that
- 1:29:12it has a wave function. And if you want
- 1:29:15to model a piece of the world well, you
- 1:29:18need to model the quantum world with
- 1:29:20another quantum world. And, well, it
- 1:29:24turns out that, for example, the
- 1:29:26behavior of complex molecules, which
- 1:29:28are described so terribly in classical
- 1:29:31terms, could in principle be crammed
- 1:29:33into a functioning, full-scale—not
- 1:29:35like the ones now, but a large-scale,
- 1:29:38error-tolerant—quantum computer. The
- 1:29:41evolution of qubits is not the same
- 1:29:43thing as the evolution that happens
- 1:29:45when a drug binds to a protein and the
- 1:29:47protein somehow reconfigures. These are
- 1:29:49different things. But, well,
- 1:29:52intermolecular potentials can be
- 1:29:54encoded within a quantum computer and
- 1:29:56use quantum resources, because quantum
- 1:29:59resources also have a vast number of
- 1:30:01states. So, quantum computers, when
- 1:30:05they start working—not a flash drive,
- 1:30:07as you put it, but a real, actual
- 1:30:09quantum computer—that will be more or
- 1:30:12less the first time, well, the second,
- 1:30:14when we describe a piece of nature
- 1:30:16using a piece, an identical piece of
- 1:30:18nature. Right now, whether something
- 1:30:20quantum is happening, or water is
- 1:30:22flowing, or even something classical.
- 1:30:24We describe it using our, uh, using
- 1:30:26flash drives, as you said, using our
- 1:30:28digital computers. There, almost
- 1:30:30nothing of nature remains, except for
- 1:30:32the equations that we simulate. But
- 1:30:33here, we set nature itself in motion.
- 1:30:36Why did I say that, I meant to say it's
- 1:30:38the first time, or maybe the second,
- 1:30:40because the first time man did this was
- 1:30:42when he started purposefully bashing
- 1:30:44one stone against another. He used a
- 1:30:47piece of nature to—well, primitive
- 1:30:49man—he used a piece of nature, a
- 1:30:51stone, to get something from nature, to
- 1:30:53do something to another stone, for
- 1:30:56example, to split it. We simulate—
- 1:31:02well, we write something on paper, or
- 1:31:05we solve it on our digital computers.
- 1:31:08If when we build a full-fledged quantum
- 1:31:11computer, it will be a piece of nature,
- 1:31:13a literal piece of nature, working to
- 1:31:16emulate another piece of nature by the
- 1:31:18same laws, and not by artificial ones.
- 1:31:21>> Alexey Semikhatov, thank you most
- 1:31:23sincerely and warmly.
- 1:31:25>> Thank you for the invitation once again
- 1:31:26. Uh, happy birthday, good luck, and
- 1:31:29success to the project. Hello everyone,
- 1:31:31>> friends. And to not miss the next
- 1:31:33episodes, don't forget to click like,
- 1:31:34subscribe, and hit the bell. This is
- 1:31:36the Osnova project. My name is Boris
- 1:31:37Idenskiy. See you in them. Working for
- 1:31:40you. Take care. And
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of АЛЕКСЕЙ СЕМИХАТОВ: ИНФОРМАЦИЯ В ОСНОВЕ ВСЕГО, ГОЛОГРАММА и ТЕЛЕПОРТАЦИЯ? by ОСНОВА, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 15,054 words across 2,348 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.