Почему хорошая жизнь стала недоступна даже образованным? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00In 2013, Google did something that was
- 0:03hard to believe. The company, which is
- 0:07harder to get into than Harvard,
- 0:08announced: "GPA and test scores no
- 0:10longer matter for hiring." Following
- 0:14suit were Apple, IBM, Tesla, Bank of
- 0:16America, and Walmart—the world's
- 0:18largest employers that top graduates
- 0:20once fought to join. Global media
- 0:22outlets wrote about this as the end of
- 0:24the higher education era. For the
- 0:26parent generation, these statements
- 0:28sounded impossible. After all, in their
- 0:30youth in the eighties, getting into
- 0:32college was a major family event. They
- 0:34would prepare for it for years. Those
- 0:35who received a higher education moved
- 0:37into a different social class. In
- 0:38former Soviet countries, the word "
- 0:40engineer" meant a guaranteed job and a
- 0:42better future for one's children. It
- 0:44was the same in America, where workers
- 0:46saved for years to send their kids to
- 0:48college. And within a generation, the
- 0:50family would move into their own
- 0:51suburban home. There was simply no
- 0:53other way to get ahead back then. And
- 0:55adults who followed that path continue
- 0:56to repeat the same thing to their own
- 0:58children. Study hard, get into college,
- 1:00get your degree, and everything will
- 1:02work out. Only the rules between these
- 1:03two generations have changed
- 1:04drastically. Today, that
- 1:06thirty-year-old advice leaves young
- 1:08people with debt, four wasted years,
- 1:10and the feeling that they were deceived
- 1:12. Meanwhile, universities keep raising
- 1:14their prices year after year. Top
- 1:16programs are becoming exponentially
- 1:17more expensive, while parents take out
- 1:19loans and go into debt just to get
- 1:20their child through freshman year.
- 1:22Today, we'll figure out if it's even
- 1:23worth spending four years of your life
- 1:25and a fortune on a university degree
- 1:26now. What happened to the social ladder
- 1:28that used to work so reliably? Are
- 1:30those who went straight to work instead
- 1:31of college right? And who is actually
- 1:33making billions while millions of
- 1:35families lose time and money? Friends,
- 1:37before we continue, a quick reminder.
- 1:38On our Telegram channel, Falcon Finance
- 1:40, we follow major economic events and
- 1:42explain in simple terms what they mean
- 1:44for your money and daily life. The link
- 1:46will be in the description below this
- 1:47video. The QR code is on the screen.
- 1:49Make sure to drop by and subscribe. And
- 1:51we begin. So, it all started back in
- 1:53June 2013. Laszlo Bock, then head of
- 1:56People Operations at Google, gave an
- 1:59interview to the New York Times and
- 2:01said: "GPA is worthless as a hiring
- 2:03criterion.""Test scores are also
- 2:06worthless, and the proportion of people
- 2:08without any college education is
- 2:09growing every year." No one expected
- 2:11such a public statement from a
- 2:13corporation of that scale. Three years
- 2:15later, IBM picked up the torch. Their
- 2:18CEO, Ginni Rometty, introduced a new
- 2:20term: "New Collar Jobs." These were
- 2:23specialists who had completed
- 2:24short-term courses, bypassing the
- 2:26university entirely. Before that moment
- 2:28, 95%of positions at IBM formally
- 2:29required a bachelor's degree. By 2021,
- 2:32that share had fallen to 50%. Then, a
- 2:35domino effect began. IBM was followed
- 2:37by Apple, Tesla, Bank of America,
- 2:39Walmart, Accenture, Ernst&Young, and
- 2:41they all announced similar changes.
- 2:43Each one covering hundreds of positions
- 2:45. By the beginning of the twenties, it
- 2:46looked like a massive shift in the
- 2:48global labor market. Global
- 2:49publications wrote about it as a
- 2:51turning point. The era of the degree
- 2:52had ended, and the era of skills had
- 2:54begun. And now, in 2024, a group of
- 2:56researchers decided to verify what
- 2:58actually happened over these 10 years
- 3:00of loud statements. Harvard Business
- 3:03School, together with the Burning Glass
- 3:05Institute, took a database of 65
- 3:07million resumes from American workers
- 3:09over 10 years. 11,000 job openings from
- 3:12large companies between 2014 and 2023.
- 3:15They wanted to find out if anything had
- 3:16actually changed in real hiring after
- 3:18the companies 'public statements. The
- 3:19first figure looked encouraging. Over
- 3:2210 years, 3.6%of positions really did
- 3:24get rid of the degree requirement. This
- 3:27is a massive undertaking and a serious
- 3:29change. But then the questions began.
- 3:31Within those roles where the degree
- 3:33requirement was dropped, the share of
- 3:35candidates without a degree grew by
- 3:37only 3.5 percentage points. That is,
- 3:39where they officially dropped the
- 3:41credential, companies continued to hire
- 3:43people specifically with one. Out of 77
- 3:45million annual hires, only 97,000
- 3:47people were hired without a degree. The
- 3:50most interesting part is that of all
- 3:52the companies that publicly announced
- 3:54the removal of the requirement, 45%did
- 3:56not hire a single new employee without
- 3:58a degree. They simply removed the
- 3:59requirement from the job posting, and
- 4:01everything else stayed the same.
- 4:02Automated resume screening programs
- 4:04continued to give preference to those
- 4:05who have a degree. Live HR managers
- 4:07made the same choices during interviews
- 4:09. So, after all these loud statements,
- 4:11press releases, and headlines about the
- 4:13end of the higher education era, and 10
- 4:15years of talk, the actual labor market
- 4:17in the US has practically not budged.
- 4:19Stop. But why then do corporations that
- 4:22publicly renounced the degree still
- 4:24continue to require it? Why even make a
- 4:26big deal out of it if they weren't
- 4:27going to change anything? To figure
- 4:29this out, we have to go back 70 years,
- 4:31to the moment when the degree was just
- 4:33starting to become a social elevator.
- 4:36On June 22, 1944, President Roosevelt
- 4:38signed the Servicemen's Readjustment
- 4:40Act, known as the GI Bill. Under this
- 4:44law, any veteran returning from the war
- 4:46could receive 500 dollars a year for
- 4:48tuition at any college. Given that the
- 4:51average cost of a year of study then
- 4:52was 200-400 dollars, plus a monthly
- 4:54stipend, a low-interest housing loan,
- 4:55and insurance for the first year of
- 4:57work. Almost half of the 16 million
- 5:00returning veterans took advantage of
- 5:01the educational part of the program and
- 5:03went to college at the state's expense.
- 5:05It was this that created what was later
- 5:07called the greatest generation and the
- 5:09American middle class. People from
- 5:11working-class families, whose fathers
- 5:12toiled in factories and mines, received
- 5:14higher education on a mass scale for
- 5:15the first time in history. Within a
- 5:17generation, they were already living in
- 5:18their own suburban homes, and their
- 5:20children were heading to top
- 5:21universities out of family habit. The
- 5:23economic impact was such that the
- 5:25program is still called one of the most
- 5:26successful investments the American
- 5:27government has ever made in its own
- 5:29citizens. It cost the budget 14.5
- 5:32billion dollars. But over time, the
- 5:34program brought the state roughly seven
- 5:36times that amount through taxes paid by
- 5:37its graduates. And who were the
- 5:39veterans that received higher education
- 5:41through this program? They later
- 5:42included three US presidents, three
- 5:44Supreme Court justices, 14 Nobel
- 5:46laureates, and 24 Pulitzer Prize
- 5:47winners. Something similar was
- 5:49happening in the Soviet Union. The
- 5:50state provided mass higher and
- 5:51specialized secondary education for
- 5:53free. A child from an ordinary family
- 5:55in a remote village could get an
- 5:56engineering degree and move to the city
- 5:58. Two or three generations have passed,
- 6:00and here is what mass higher education
- 6:02leads to today, using a specific
- 6:03example. Last year, the Russian portal
- 6:05Deti Mail.ru published a series of
- 6:07interviews titled: "Why didn't my
- 6:09career work out?" One of the subjects,
- 6:11Dmitry, is 27, and he did well in
- 6:13school, so his parents, teachers, and
- 6:14he himself had no doubts that he should
- 6:16apply to a top university. Ultimately,
- 6:18he got into the Higher School of
- 6:20Economics for IT management on a
- 6:21state-funded spot, studied, went on a
- 6:23foreign exchange, and completed an
- 6:24internship at a prestigious company. On
- 6:26one hand, he met all expectations, but
- 6:28in that same interview, Dmitry says he
- 6:31was just imitating smart people; he
- 6:32succeeded at everything, but felt empty
- 6:35inside. During his internship, he
- 6:37prayed that they wouldn't hire him.
- 6:38Today, at 27, he is still searching for
- 6:40his place. Yes, his diploma helped him
- 6:42learn methods, but it didn't help him
- 6:44understand why he went to university in
- 6:45the first place. Because everyone
- 6:47around him said he had to, and then he
- 6:48discovered that behind this "have to,"
- 6:50there was nothing there. And it wasn't
- 6:52just about him. It's about what has
- 6:54happened to the diploma itself over the
- 6:55last 70 years. Anyway, before moving on
- 6:58, I’ll make a small digression. Look,
- 7:00I've been involved in crypto for almost
- 7:0210 years, but I fully understand that
- 7:03for most people, it's still some kind
- 7:05of uncharted territory. Therefore, if
- 7:07you are just starting out, even the
- 7:08path from registering on an exchange to
- 7:09your first trade might seem complicated
- 7:11and confusing to you. Actually, that's
- 7:13why, specifically for those who want to
- 7:14dive into this industry, understand
- 7:16what opportunities exist here, and how
- 7:17to earn money from it, I spent my own
- 7:19time digitizing the most important
- 7:20experience into three short, free
- 7:22lessons. You can watch these three
- 7:23lessons in just one evening to
- 7:25understand where to start, what to do
- 7:27in this market, and how not to lose
- 7:28your money. I think, in modern
- 7:30realities, this is an essential
- 7:31foundation for anyone interested in the
- 7:33crypto market who actually wants to
- 7:34earn from it. Be sure to stop by and
- 7:36study them. Access is completely free.
- 7:38The link will be in the description
- 7:39below this video. The QR code is on the
- 7:40screen. And we are moving on. In 1950,
- 7:43only 6%of Americans over 25 held a
- 7:46bachelor's degree. By 2024, that share
- 7:50had grown to 38%. Higher education
- 7:53became mass-market. So, what does a
- 7:56diploma actually give an employer if
- 7:57almost one in three people has one
- 7:59today? The answer to this question was
- 8:02found in 1973. A young American
- 8:04economist, Michael Spence, published an
- 8:07article in an academic journal titled "
- 8:09Job Market Signaling." Twenty-eight
- 8:11years later, he would receive a Nobel
- 8:13Prize for it. Spence's idea was this.
- 8:16When an employer hires a new employee,
- 8:18they cannot verify their abilities,
- 8:20diligence, or reliability in a one-hour
- 8:22interview. Some external reference
- 8:25point is needed to make an assumption.
- 8:27A bachelor's degree turned out to be
- 8:28the perfect reference point. It costs a
- 8:30lot of money, four years of time, and
- 8:32requires perseverance and the ability
- 8:34to handle tasks. If a person earned it,
- 8:36it means they are capable of going the
- 8:38distance. It makes no difference to the
- 8:39employer what exactly they were taught.
- 8:41The main thing is that they studied for
- 8:42four years and earned the diploma. This
- 8:44means the employer values the diploma
- 8:45for the ability to obtain it. The
- 8:47content of the studies is unimportant
- 8:49to them. This theory has confirmation.
- 8:51It is called the parchment effect, from
- 8:53the old practice of printing diplomas
- 8:55on sheepskin. Let's take two young
- 8:57people. Suppose they both studied at
- 8:58the same university for four years in
- 9:00the same major. One has a diploma, and
- 9:02the second did not defend their thesis
- 9:03and left at the last moment without the
- 9:05degree. It is logical that their
- 9:07knowledge and experience are the same.
- 9:08Yet, the average salary gap for their
- 9:11first job is 20-30%in favor of the one
- 9:13with the degree. This means the
- 9:15employer pays specifically for the fact
- 9:16of receiving the diploma. The content
- 9:18of the studies and the years spent at
- 9:19university are secondary to them. But
- 9:21since a diploma no longer sets you
- 9:23apart, employers instinctively raise
- 9:25the bar. Previously, a bachelor's
- 9:26degree was enough for a position. Now,
- 9:27for the same job, they ask for a
- 9:30master's, and top vacancies require a
- 9:32PhD. Each subsequent generation is
- 9:34forced to study 2-3 years longer to get
- 9:36the same job their parents did 30 years
- 9:38ago. That is exactly why corporations
- 9:41cannot simply drop the diploma
- 9:42requirement, even when they loudly
- 9:44claim they have. The diploma has become
- 9:45a weak signal for them. But until an
- 9:47equivalent replacement appears, it
- 9:49remains the best benchmark, and the
- 9:51price of a degree has continued to
- 9:53outpace both inflation and wages for
- 9:55five decades in a row. What exactly
- 9:57this costs families and whose pockets
- 9:58this money goes into is what we will
- 10:00examine next. In the US, the numbers
- 10:02are the most striking. By March 2026,
- 10:04the total student debt of Americans
- 10:07exceeded 1.8 trillion dollars. This is
- 10:10the second-largest category of personal
- 10:12debt in the country after mortgages.
- 10:14Behind this debt are 42,800,000 people,
- 10:169 million of whom are already in
- 10:18default. The average debt after
- 10:20graduation is about 40,000 dollars.
- 10:23Women hold 60%of this entire amount.
- 10:26The most interesting part is the speed
- 10:27at which this debt has grown. Since
- 10:301980, the cost of tuition in American
- 10:32colleges has increased 12-fold.
- 10:34Meanwhile, general inflation over the
- 10:36same period was about 300%, meaning
- 10:38prices rose roughly fourfold.
- 10:41Georgetown University produced an even
- 10:43more precise calculation. Over the last
- 10:4540 years, the real cost of college in
- 10:46the US, adjusted for inflation, has
- 10:48grown by 169%. During the same time,
- 10:52the real wages of young workers aged 22
- 10:54to 27 have grown by only 19%. It turns
- 10:57out that a degree costs significantly
- 10:59more, while the job it provides pays
- 11:01almost the same, and the gap is covered
- 11:02only by loans. In Russia, the figures
- 11:04are different, but the trajectory is
- 11:05the same. Moreover, the growth rate in
- 11:07the last two years is no less than in
- 11:08America. Let’s look at top Moscow
- 11:10universities. MIPT raised the price tag
- 11:11for the Applied Mathematics and
- 11:13Computer Science program for the 2025
- 11:15intake from 467,000 to 767,000 rubles.
- 11:20And for the most expensive majors, like
- 11:22the modern business school with Sber, a
- 11:23year of study already costs over 2
- 11:25million rubles. The Higher School of
- 11:27Economics raised its average
- 11:28undergraduate price tag by 22%, and
- 11:30humanities programs became 40%or more
- 11:32expensive. The average cost of a paid
- 11:35bachelor's degree in the country this
- 11:37year is about 225,000 rubles. In Moscow
- 11:39, the annual increase was nearly 16%
- 11:41with general national inflation at
- 11:43about six. And behind all these figures
- 11:45are specific families. In the Russian
- 11:47press and on parent forums, the same
- 11:49thought keeps coming up. Free higher
- 11:51education has turned from a mass norm
- 11:53into the lot of the few. Previously, it
- 11:55was accessible to everyone who did well
- 11:57in school. Today, it has become a
- 11:58luxury for those who have enough money.
- 11:59And families deal with this in
- 12:01different ways. Some save for the first
- 12:02year for decades, some sell a
- 12:04three-room apartment and move to a
- 12:06two-room, some take out consumer loans
- 12:08at rates that are now reaching 30%per
- 12:10annum. The main question arises: why do
- 12:12universities continue to raise prices
- 12:14year after year if everyone says that a
- 12:15degree no longer works, that the labor
- 12:17market has changed, and that
- 12:18corporations don't require a degree in
- 12:20job postings? The fact is that the
- 12:22demand for a degree has not gone
- 12:23anywhere. Parents will still send their
- 12:25child to their first year of university
- 12:27at any price. Even if they know the
- 12:29degree has become a weak signal and the
- 12:30post-grad salary doesn't even cover the
- 12:32cost of the studies. Because they
- 12:34believe that without a degree, you're
- 12:35nobody these days. There are only five
- 12:37to seven top-tier universities in the
- 12:38country. Everyone wants to get in there
- 12:40. This means top universities can set
- 12:42any price they want. The government
- 12:43helps out with funding. Subsidized
- 12:44student loans at 3%. This means that
- 12:47even a price unaffordable for a family
- 12:48becomes manageable. Just spread out
- 12:49over a 15-year installment plan. And
- 12:51finally, starting in 2026, the
- 12:52government has gained the right to
- 12:54regulate not just state-funded, but
- 12:56also tuition-based enrollment. For
- 12:57fifty majors, mostly in humanities and
- 12:59economics, the number of paid spots is
- 13:01being cut. That means the remaining
- 13:02ones will keep getting more expensive.
- 13:03Less supply with the same level of
- 13:05demand. But where do all these tuition
- 13:07fees paid by families actually go? Here
- 13:10is a vivid example from the USA. In
- 13:122024, the head of Johns Hopkins
- 13:14University, Ron Daniels, received
- 13:16nearly 6 million dollars for one year
- 13:18of work, including all bonuses. And a
- 13:21few years earlier, Thomas Jefferson
- 13:22University president Stephen Klasko did
- 13:24as well. According to The Chronicle of
- 13:28Higher Education, over fifty university
- 13:30presidents earn two to four times more
- 13:33than the US President. At the same time
- 13:35, top US universities are amassing
- 13:36massive capital. Every major American
- 13:38university has its own fund, where
- 13:40donations from alumni, wealthy patrons,
- 13:42and large companies flow for decades.
- 13:44The university invests this money in
- 13:46stocks, bonds, and real estate. Such
- 13:48funds are called endowments, and they
- 13:50act as perpetual sources of income.
- 13:52From what is accumulated, they usually
- 13:54spend about 5%per year on scholarships,
- 13:56research, and professor salaries. The
- 13:58rest continues to accumulate and grow.
- 14:01Harvard's endowment, for instance, is
- 14:03currently nearly 57 billion dollars,
- 14:05the largest in the world. The 12
- 14:07wealthiest US universities have amassed
- 14:09365 billion combined, yet tuition price
- 14:11tags keep rising every year. In Russia,
- 14:14the scale is more modest, but the logic
- 14:15remains the same. According to 2024
- 14:17declarations, rectors of top Moscow
- 14:19universities, including MIPT, MIREA,
- 14:21and Bauman MSTU, earn about 1.5 million
- 14:23rubles per month. Meanwhile, the
- 14:25average salary of a university lecturer
- 14:27, according to Rosstat, is about
- 14:28120,000 rubles. per month. Parents all
- 14:31over the world have to pay more and
- 14:32more for a degree. At the same time,
- 14:33the degree itself is working less
- 14:34effectively. But the problem isn't just
- 14:36the price. Even if a family can't
- 14:37afford to pay for education, getting a
- 14:39free spot is becoming increasingly
- 14:41difficult. That is exactly what is
- 14:42happening in Russian universities right
- 14:44now. Guys, before we continue, a quick
- 14:46digression. It is certainly important
- 14:48to understand economics and the reasons
- 14:50behind current events, but the next
- 14:51step is learning to apply this
- 14:53knowledge in practice when it comes to
- 14:54your own money. My team and I have been
- 14:57developing our trading community for
- 14:58five years now, created to help you
- 15:00earn in the crypto market through
- 15:01trading and investments. What exactly
- 15:03is inside? First, our team includes
- 15:05traders with many years of experience.
- 15:07They trade themselves and post their
- 15:08deals in the channel so you can follow
- 15:10them and copy those trades if you wish.
- 15:12Second. If you want to make more trades
- 15:14but don't have time to sit at the
- 15:16charts, you can connect our ready-made
- 15:18trading strategies via bots. You choose
- 15:20a strategy, connect it in a few clicks,
- 15:22and the robot trades for you from there
- 15:23. Moreover, all statistics are open, so
- 15:25the results of each strategy can be
- 15:27viewed in advance. Third. Inside, there
- 15:29is a chat with over 8,000 traders.
- 15:31Every day, members share their trades
- 15:33and results there. There is also a
- 15:35trader ranking. You can choose those
- 15:37whose trading you like best, follow
- 15:38their trades, copy them, or simply use
- 15:40them as inspiration for your own ideas.
- 15:43Most importantly, guys, all these tools
- 15:44are absolutely free for you, with no
- 15:46subscriptions and no hidden sales. So,
- 15:48be sure to follow the link in the
- 15:50description or the QR code on the
- 15:51screen, join us, learn, and trade with
- 15:53us. And we continue. The Unified State
- 15:56Exam was created in the early 2000s
- 15:58specifically to provide an opportunity.
- 16:00A child from a village in the Irkutsk
- 16:01region with high scores in Russian and
- 16:03math could enter MSU for free, just
- 16:05like a Muscovite. It was a tool for
- 16:06social mobility in its purest form. And
- 16:08for the first 15 years, it truly worked
- 16:11. But then, the elevator started
- 16:12working worse and worse. By the end of
- 16:14the twenties, the picture is very
- 16:15different from what it was when the
- 16:17exam launched. This happened for
- 16:18several reasons. First: access to
- 16:20state-funded spots has decreased. The
- 16:22number of students entering paid
- 16:23education has grown by nearly a quarter
- 16:25over the last three years. The number
- 16:27of state-funded spots has barely
- 16:28increased in those same three years.
- 16:30The state enrolls roughly the same
- 16:31number of state-funded students
- 16:33annually, about 400,000, while the
- 16:34number of fee-paying students has risen
- 16:36by 50,000. In parallel, the priority
- 16:38admission stage has expanded. Russian
- 16:40universities have a separate queue for
- 16:42enrollment before the general
- 16:43competition. It includes beneficiaries,
- 16:45targeted program students, and
- 16:46competition winners. They used to take
- 16:48about 16%of state-funded spots, but now
- 16:51they take about a quarter. That means
- 16:53every fourth state-funded spot in the
- 16:54country is taken outside the general
- 16:56competition. And there are universities
- 16:57where this share is much higher. At
- 16:58MGIMO this year, about 57%of
- 17:00state-funded spots were taken by
- 17:02beneficiaries and winners before the
- 17:04general competition even began. On some
- 17:06flagship programs at MGIMO, not a
- 17:07single spot remained for the general
- 17:09competition at all. MIPT has roughly
- 17:10the same situation. More than half of
- 17:12the budget spots went to priority
- 17:13applicants. This summer, an incident
- 17:15occurred at the Financial University
- 17:17that was discussed in every parent chat
- 17:19. The applicant scored exactly 310
- 17:21points—100 for each of the three
- 17:22Unified State Exam subjects plus an
- 17:24additional 10 points for individual
- 17:26achievements. A truly impressive result
- 17:28. He applied to the International
- 17:31Economics and Trade program with
- 17:32Chinese language studies but didn't get
- 17:34in because he ended up ninety-third on
- 17:36the enrollment list. Yet, there were
- 17:38only 52 state-funded spots in the
- 17:39program. The number of Olympiad winners
- 17:42admitted without entrance exams alone
- 17:44exceeded the total number of
- 17:45state-funded spots. And there were over
- 17:474,000 applications in total. And this
- 17:49is what happens. A child from a family
- 17:51without connections, without Olympiad
- 17:53diplomas, but with maximum exam scores,
- 17:54enters the general competition and
- 17:56discovers there are almost no spots
- 17:57left because priority applicants have
- 17:58taken the state-funded ones. The family
- 18:00has no money for tuition, so they are
- 18:01left with a regional university. And a
- 18:03regional university means a completely
- 18:04different life after graduation. The
- 18:06difference in salaries for graduates of
- 18:08the same major from different
- 18:09universities can be several times over
- 18:11today. What will we talk about next?
- 18:12According to the June ranking by SuDob
- 18:15and Roscosmos, the average salary for
- 18:17MIPT graduates working in IT in Moscow
- 18:19is 350,000 rubles. per month. ITMO and
- 18:22MIFI are at 300, while MSU, Bauman, and
- 18:24HSE are at 290. This is the top tier.
- 18:27But what is happening at the bottom?
- 18:28According to Habr Career data, the
- 18:30median salary for an IT specialist in
- 18:32the regions at the end of 2025 is
- 18:34159,000 rubles. , and 230,000 in Moscow
- 18:36. Within the SuDob and Roscosmos
- 18:38ranking itself, the difference between
- 18:40the leader and the bottom is as follows
- 18:42. At the top is MIPT with a salary of
- 18:44350,000. At the bottom are regional
- 18:47technical universities like Samara and
- 18:49Tomsk, with salaries around 165,000. A
- 18:52difference of more than double. And if
- 18:54you consider that graduates of regional
- 18:55universities usually work in their own
- 18:57regions, where salaries are a third
- 18:59lower than in Moscow, the real gap can
- 19:00reach three times or more. The same
- 19:02line on a diploma yields salaries that
- 19:04differ by several times. And a diploma
- 19:06does still offer some value, but not
- 19:08just any diploma. Let’s take one of
- 19:09the most striking examples of how a
- 19:11diploma actually works. Artem Oganov, a
- 19:12Russian scientist of world renown,
- 19:14dreamed of becoming a scientist. He got
- 19:16hooked at the age of 4. His mother
- 19:17taught him to read early and kept
- 19:18providing him with popular science
- 19:20books. This interest never left him
- 19:21throughout school and his entire
- 19:22student life. He graduated from the
- 19:24Faculty of Geology at MSU, moved to
- 19:25London, where he lived on 20 dollars a
- 19:27month for the first few months. He
- 19:28defended his PhD there, then his
- 19:30doctorate in Zurich, and worked in the
- 19:31USA. He invented a method that allows a
- 19:34computer to predict the properties of a
- 19:35substance that has not yet been created
- 19:37. Today, thousands of scientists around
- 19:39the world use this method. In 2026,
- 19:41Oganov received the Chinese State Award
- 19:43for his contribution to computational
- 19:45chemistry. He is currently a professor
- 19:46at Skoltech. Oganov's story is a case
- 19:48where the diploma worked exactly as
- 19:50promised in the eighties. It opened a
- 19:52path for a person exactly to where they
- 19:53had been heading since childhood. But
- 19:55how many such stories are there in
- 19:57reality? For how many graduates is a
- 20:00degree actually useful? According to
- 20:02Rabota.ru, only 35%of Russians
- 20:03currently work in the specialty listed
- 20:05on their diploma. About the same
- 20:07percentage work in fields completely
- 20:08unrelated to their education. The rest
- 20:10fall somewhere in between. For 40%of
- 20:11those who left their field, there is
- 20:13one reason: low pay in the profession.
- 20:15The breakdown by age is even more
- 20:17interesting. More than half of people
- 20:19over 65 work in the specialty listed on
- 20:21their diploma. For young people aged 18
- 20:24to 24, this figure is closer to
- 20:26one-third. In just one generation, the
- 20:28link between a degree and real work has
- 20:29weakened significantly. And even among
- 20:31those who found work in their specialty
- 20:33, a significant portion works in
- 20:35positions that formally require higher
- 20:37education, but do not actually need it.
- 20:39In the US, according to the Federal
- 20:41Reserve Bank of New York, about 40%of
- 20:42recent graduates are employed in jobs
- 20:44that do not require their degree. In
- 20:46Russia, the picture is roughly the same
- 20:48. According to research by the Higher
- 20:49School of Economics, 35%of Russian
- 20:51university graduates work in positions
- 20:53that do not require higher education.
- 20:55In some regions, this share reaches 50%
- 20:57. It turns out to be a rather strange
- 21:00situation. A diploma can still
- 21:01significantly impact future salary, but
- 21:03only if it comes from the right
- 21:04university, in the right specialty, and
- 21:06follows the right career path after
- 21:08graduation. For the rest, it
- 21:09increasingly proves to be an expensive
- 21:11pass to a profession that offers no
- 21:12guarantee of being hired. But if a
- 21:14university is no longer the only way to
- 21:16get a good job, what happens to those
- 21:19who don't go to university at all?
- 21:21There are countries where a
- 21:22full-fledged alternative has long
- 21:24existed. Let's start with Germany.
- 21:26There, a so-called dual system of
- 21:28vocational education exists. A teenager
- 21:30signs a contract with a specific
- 21:31company. For 3-4 days a week, they work
- 21:33in real production under mentorship.
- 21:36For 1-2 days, they study theory at a
- 21:37specialized college. In 2-3 years, they
- 21:39gain a profession, work experience, a
- 21:41record in their employment history, and
- 21:43receive a salary the whole time, even
- 21:45if it is small. In Germany in 2023,
- 21:481,220,000 people were studying under
- 21:51this program. Half a million new
- 21:53contracts were signed in one year. 50%
- 21:55of German youth choose this path
- 21:57instead of university. There are 327
- 21:59officially recognized professions, from
- 22:02bank clerk to massage therapist. As a
- 22:04result, youth unemployment in Germany
- 22:06is 5.8%, one of the lowest in Europe.
- 22:1168%of program graduates receive a
- 22:13permanent contract from the same
- 22:14company where they trained. Germany has
- 22:17maintained a separate path for those
- 22:18who do not want to or cannot go to
- 22:19university. And this path works. Now
- 22:22for South Korea. It took a different
- 22:24path. Korea is the world record holder
- 22:25for the share of youth with higher
- 22:26education. Everyone goes to college,
- 22:28everyone becomes a degree-holding
- 22:30specialist. And here is what that led
- 22:31to. A whole category of young people
- 22:33appeared in the country called "resting
- 22:35youth." These are people who are
- 22:37physically healthy but have stopped
- 22:38looking for work. In April 2026, nearly
- 22:40800,000 Koreans aged 25 to 29 were not
- 22:43participating in the labor market at
- 22:46all. Of those, 230,000 are officially
- 22:49classified as "resting." And here is
- 22:51the main detail. Nearly half of young
- 22:54Koreans who are neither working nor
- 22:56studying have a university degree. For
- 22:59comparison, the average across OECD
- 23:01countries is 18%. The average time it
- 23:04takes to find a first job after
- 23:05graduation in Korea is 11 months. Every
- 23:07second unemployed graduate cannot find
- 23:09a job for over a year, and every fifth
- 23:10one for over 3 years. Demographics have
- 23:12also reacted. Koreans have coined the
- 23:15word "sampo," which translates roughly
- 23:17to giving up on three things: dating,
- 23:19marriage, and children. The fertility
- 23:21rate in Korea today is 0.8. It is one
- 23:25of the lowest on the planet. And now,
- 23:27China. In 2025, Chinese universities
- 23:29graduated 12,220,000 people, and in
- 23:332026, 12,700,000—a record in the
- 23:36country's history. At the same time,
- 23:39youth unemployment in China, according
- 23:41to official data in the summer of 2026,
- 23:43was about 18%. In June 2023, it reached
- 23:4621%. After that, Chinese statistics
- 23:49authorities suspended the publication
- 23:51of these figures for half a year. They
- 23:52resumed with a new methodology, where
- 23:53students were removed from the count.
- 23:55Chinese youth also have their own word,
- 23:57"tangping," which translates to "lying
- 23:59flat." This is a movement of opting out
- 24:01of the rat race. Not buying property,
- 24:03not getting married, not building a
- 24:04career, just lying down. Russia today
- 24:07is closer to the Korean-Chinese
- 24:08scenario than to the German one. This
- 24:10is worth understanding when planning
- 24:11your own future or that of your
- 24:13children. But what does this mean in
- 24:15practice for someone who needs to
- 24:16enroll right now? Let's start with the
- 24:18simple part. Advising everyone to drop
- 24:20out of university is just as much of a
- 24:21mistake as advising everyone they must
- 24:23attend. For a doctor, a diploma is
- 24:24essential. For an engineer, almost
- 24:26always. For many professions, the
- 24:28university still provides knowledge
- 24:30that is simply indispensable later on.
- 24:32But there is a huge number of cases
- 24:33where 4 years of study and several
- 24:35million rubles buy not a profession,
- 24:37but only the right to write its title
- 24:39on a resume. And it seems it's time to
- 24:40change the question itself: not "do I
- 24:42need a diploma," but "what exactly will
- 24:43I get for 4 years and a lot of money?"
- 24:45And asking this question is especially
- 24:47important now because, for the first
- 24:48time in decades, the diploma has real
- 24:50competitors. University hasn't gone
- 24:52anywhere, but online schools have grown
- 24:53up alongside it, preparing people for
- 24:55IT, design, or marketing in six months
- 24:56to a year. Previously, this used to
- 24:58take 4 years. And, by the way,
- 24:59graduates of these schools do find work
- 25:01. According to the online courses
- 25:03themselves, approximately 70-80%. And
- 25:05in the last couple of years, artificial
- 25:07intelligence has been added to all of
- 25:08this. Previously, to master a new
- 25:10profession, you had to go to courses or
- 25:12a university. Today you can dive into
- 25:13neural networks, get the hang of them
- 25:15in a couple of months, and start
- 25:16practicing. Some professions that
- 25:18required a degree five years ago are
- 25:20slowly starting to disappear. And those
- 25:22appearing in their place aren't being
- 25:24taught in any university yet.
- 25:25Everything used to be clear. Enroll,
- 25:27study, get a degree, start working, and
- 25:29live better than your parents. Today,
- 25:31none of these steps work on their own
- 25:34anymore. Everyone has to use their own
- 25:35head, and you'll have to decide for
- 25:37yourself. Neither the state, nor the
- 25:39university, nor your parents' advice
- 25:41will make this choice for you. And now
- 25:43a question for you, friends. If you
- 25:45were 18 again today, would you choose
- 25:47four years of university or go straight
- 25:49into work, a career, and experience?
- 25:51What would you choose? And most
- 25:53importantly, would your choice change
- 25:55if you had to pay for university
- 25:56yourself? Be sure to write about it in
- 25:57the comments, I'd be interested to read
- 25:58them. That’s all for now, friends. Be
- 26:00sure to share this video with your
- 26:01friends and see you in the next
- 26:02episodes. Bye-bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Почему хорошая жизнь стала недоступна даже образованным? by Falcon Finance, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,273 words across 834 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.