гаспар ноэ: режиссер твоих кошмаров — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00The year 2002. The Cannes Film Festival
- 0:02. People walk out of a film screening
- 0:05in horror.
- 0:13It was the film Irreversible, by the
- 0:15then-unknown French director Gaspar
- 0:16Noé. That year, European film buffs
- 0:19weren't ready for a 10-minute,
- 0:21single-take scene of Monica Bellucci
- 0:23being raped on screen. Everyone had the
- 0:25same logical question: why the hell
- 0:27would you film that? Is it provocation
- 0:28for the sake of provocation, or is this
- 0:30bald, cunning man trying to tell us
- 0:32something through such extreme measures
- 0:33? And what if it's both? Alright, let's
- 0:51start by understanding who we're
- 0:53actually dealing with. Gaspar Noé is a
- 0:55prominent representative of so-called
- 0:57French transgressive cinema. This term
- 0:59describes films that explore a human or
- 1:01societal crisis by realistically
- 1:02depicting sex, violence,
- 1:04self-destruction, and other things that
- 1:06YouTube doesn't like. The plot of his
- 1:07films can be described in literally one
- 1:09sentence without missing much. Look.
- 1:11Irreversible is the story of a guy who
- 1:13goes to avenge the rape of his
- 1:15girlfriend. And it's all shot in
- 1:16reverse order. In Enter the Void, the
- 1:18police kill a young junkie, and his
- 1:20spirit begins to wander through neon
- 1:21Tokyo. I refuse to describe what
- 1:23happens after that. In Climax, someone
- 1:25spikes the dancers 'sangria with LSD at
- 1:27a party, and all hell breaks loose. And
- 1:29so on. You get the gist. And even
- 1:31though they are incredibly simple, damn
- 1:33, are they stylishly shot. The first
- 1:39thing that caught my eye when watching
- 1:41Noé's films is their visuals. And
- 1:42there is plenty here for the eye to
- 1:44catch. The camera is constantly either
- 1:45following someone or flying around. The
- 1:46colors change as if it were your little
- 1:48sister's coloring book. And there are
- 1:50always huge titles too. Always written
- 1:52in the Futura font. So, from the
- 1:53outside, it looks like some kind of
- 1:55colorful, acid-trip music video. But
- 1:56reducing it all simply to drug use
- 1:58would be completely wrong, even if Noé
- 2:00is a junkie. Noé's cinematography is
- 2:02dominated by a tracking camera. It
- 2:03mimics the characters' movement and
- 2:05constantly follows them. If they stand,
- 2:07the camera stands. If they walk
- 2:08somewhere, the camera follows them. If
- 2:10a character is shaking wildly, well,
- 2:12you see for yourself. In short, all
- 2:14this works to pull us into the
- 2:15experience. It's as if we ourselves are
- 2:17in the scene, observing everything from
- 2:18the sidelines. But while this technique
- 2:20is far from new or original, the
- 2:22dizzying camera flights are definitely
- 2:24his signature. In this case, the camera
- 2:26movement can reflect madness, show the
- 2:27flight of the soul, its transition
- 2:29between spaces, and literally turn the
- 2:31characters 'world upside down. But
- 2:33ultimately, Noé's calling card is his
- 2:35use of color. Over the years of
- 2:36tormenting audiences, he has developed
- 2:38a unique design code. So, each color
- 2:40for him means something specific. Red
- 2:42is associated with aggression, danger,
- 2:44and chaos. We see it in the subway
- 2:45underpass, which triggers PTSD in*
- 2:47Irréversible*. In the club where
- 2:48someone is about to get their skull
- 2:50cracked on the dance floor, in sangria,
- 2:51and many other places. Noé's red is a
- 2:53visual trigger that either warns you
- 2:55that something's about to happen, or
- 2:57that, well, it already has. Yellow in
- 3:00Noé's films exists, to some extent, by
- 3:02default. It can fill any space the
- 3:04characters are in, be it dark streets,
- 3:06apartments, or corridors. Usually,
- 3:08yellow is about warmth and comfort, but
- 3:10with Noé, it's dim and evokes no sense
- 3:11of comfort at all. Under yellow lamps,
- 3:13all other colors are distorted, and
- 3:15what happens on screen starts to feel
- 3:17somewhat sickly. And, of course, calmer
- 3:19colors like green are far less common
- 3:21in his films. Green sometimes marks
- 3:23safe zones where a shred of sanity
- 3:25still remains. For instance, on the
- 3:27lawn where Monica Bellucci is hanging
- 3:29out, unaware of what the bald pervert
- 3:30is about to do to her. Sometimes it’s
- 3:32not even the color itself that matters,
- 3:33but its saturation. Thanks to this,
- 3:35it’s quite easy to trace the line
- 3:36between chaos and normalcy. In*Enter
- 3:38the Void*, the characters are immersed
- 3:39in a world of clubs, sex, and drugs, so
- 3:41the action takes place at night, and
- 3:43natural light is replaced by garish,
- 3:44flamboyant neon. The protagonist's
- 3:46childhood memories, by contrast, are
- 3:48desaturated and shot in natural light.
- 3:50In*Love*, vivid memories of past love
- 3:52overshadow the dull reality where the
- 3:53protagonist lives with a girl he
- 3:55doesn't love. The walls of his
- 3:57apartment are painted in safe whites
- 3:59and greens, symbolizing a peaceful
- 4:00family life. But he finds it nauseating
- 4:02. In short, I could ramble on about
- 4:04lighting in Gaspar's work for a long
- 4:05time, but I think you get the point. He
- 4:07loves color, and he loves there to be a
- 4:09lot of it. And he absolutely adores
- 4:10strobe lights, just to finish off any
- 4:12survivors in the theater. But I, on the
- 4:13other hand, love it when you, the
- 4:15viewers, like my videos. I don't get
- 4:16any financial gain from them. So, if
- 4:17you wouldn't mind, there are links in
- 4:19the description where you can support
- 4:21me. Anyway, sorry, I won't distract you
- 4:22anymore. Noé loves giant, full-screen
- 4:24letters just as much. The title
- 4:26sequences in his films are truly a
- 4:27separate art form, really. He loves to
- 4:28show off and design his credits to
- 4:30match the concept of the film. In*
- 4:31Irréversible*, which is shot in
- 4:33reverse chronological order, the titles
- 4:35, of course, scroll at the beginning
- 4:36and in reverse, and then their movement
- 4:38is even picked up by the camera. *Enter
- 4:40the Void*, where young dudes do drugs
- 4:42in neon-lit Tokyo, opens accordingly.
- 4:44It’s probably one of the most iconic
- 4:46openers I've ever seen in cinema in
- 4:47principle. The cool thing is that they
- 4:49didn’t just throw a bunch of random
- 4:50fonts together; they styled each cast
- 4:52member individually to fit their
- 4:54personality. Not everyone puts in that
- 4:55much effort, of course, but my favorite
- 4:57title sequence belongs to the film
- 4:58Climax. It’s cool that it’s
- 5:00designed in a nineties style to match
- 5:01the film's setting. But what sent me
- 5:03into an inexplicable state of awe
- 5:05during my first watch was that Noé
- 5:06dropped the titles forty-six minutes
- 5:08into the film. And when someone drops
- 5:10the opening credits in the middle of a
- 5:11movie, it automatically becomes a
- 5:12masterpiece. I’m sorry, but I
- 5:14didn’t make the rules. But in all
- 5:16seriousness, that’s Noé’s elegant
- 5:17way of splitting the film into two
- 5:18parts. By the end of the first part,
- 5:20everyone is tripping on sangria laced
- 5:21with a "surprise," and the real
- 5:22nightmare begins in the second. That
- 5:24bald guy is basically saying: "If you
- 5:26want to, the movie ends for you right
- 5:27here—you can leave." But if you’re
- 5:29ready for what comes next, then for you
- 5:31, the movie is only just beginning.
- 5:32That said, I can't help but mention
- 5:34that no matter how provocative or
- 5:35repulsive Noé is to the masses, they
- 5:37still end up gravitating toward him. He
- 5:39directs commercials for Saint Laurent,
- 5:41helms a segment for Travis Scott’s
- 5:42Circus Maximus, and makes music videos
- 5:44for The Weeknd, Keem, Placebo, Animal
- 5:46Collective, and so on. Basically,
- 5:48thanks to his style and vision, the guy
- 5:50is in high demand. Alright, colorful
- 5:52pictures are all well and good, of
- 5:53course. No argument there, but damn,
- 5:55what is he actually making movies about
- 5:57? Interestingly, the title of Noé’s
- 6:01second feature film essentially defined
- 6:03the main theme of his body of work. His
- 6:05works may be based on different ideas,
- 6:07but the irreversibility of things is
- 6:09always present in them. They are all,
- 6:10one way or another, dedicated to the
- 6:12experience of some kind of traumatic
- 6:13event. The main kicker of Irreversible
- 6:15is its central event: the assault on
- 6:17the protagonist’s girlfriend. Before
- 6:19that, Monica Bellucci is reading a book
- 6:20, enjoying life with Vincent Cassel,
- 6:22and is pregnant by him. It’s all
- 6:24filmed statically and measuredly, just
- 6:26like the life of the young couple is
- 6:27unfolding. After that, it's a nightmare
- 6:29. Vincent and his friend desperately
- 6:31try to find the attacker. It’s all at
- 6:32night, amidst a bunch of degenerates.
- 6:34On top of that, the cinematographer
- 6:35seems to be having a seizure. But
- 6:36Gaspar said, "Screw it, keep it in." In
- 6:38Enter the Void, what proves
- 6:39irreversible is the death of the
- 6:40protagonist, a young junkie named Oscar
- 6:42. You might think, "Well, he died, so
- 6:43what?" But then you realize his younger
- 6:45sister, just as much of an outcast, is
- 6:47left without his protection. They slid
- 6:49to the very bottom of society because
- 6:51their parents died in a car crash. No
- 6:53guardianship, a dysfunctional
- 6:54environment. Well, it’s all pretty
- 6:55clear. And when you watch Oscar
- 6:57desperately cling to life and say, "Mom
- 6:59, I don't want to die." Damn, it’s
- 7:01just sad. And this happens at the
- 7:16twenty-fifth minute of the film. For
- 7:17the next two hours, his soul wanders
- 7:19between past and present, unable to
- 7:21find peace. In the film Love, the end
- 7:23of love is irreversible, while in
- 7:24Vortex, dedicated to an elderly couple
- 7:26where the wife suffers from dementia,
- 7:28old age and, ultimately, death are
- 7:30irreversible. Anyway, you get the point
- 7:31. All his works are about the fragility
- 7:33of human existence. They are about how
- 7:36a single event or decision can deeply
- 7:37affect or even break a person's life.
- 7:40No matter how hard we try to control
- 7:42our lives, there are always things
- 7:43beyond that control. You can wake up
- 7:46calmly, go about your usual business,
- 7:48but in the evening, something can
- 7:49happen that divides your life into
- 7:51before and after, and you never know
- 7:53when it will happen. A scary thought, I
- 7:55know, but even in this hopelessness,
- 7:56there is a little light. If you look
- 7:59closely, love is present in almost
- 8:01every Noé film. Yes, not just in the
- 8:03film of the same name. All this filth
- 8:05and horror he shoves right in our faces
- 8:07coexists with rather tender moments. In
- 8:09Irreversible, it's the morning scene of
- 8:11intimacy. In Enter the Void, it's the
- 8:12relationship between brother and sister
- 8:13. In Love. Well, kind of, yes. And
- 8:15Vortex is perhaps his most sentimental
- 8:17film of all. At the same time, it is
- 8:19still not light at all, and the
- 8:20relationships between the characters
- 8:21are very complex. All these films are
- 8:23harsh, unpleasant, and dark, but even
- 8:25they have room for love. Moreover,
- 8:27Noé's script fits on just a few pages,
- 8:29and all these complex emotions are
- 8:30conveyed primarily by non-professional
- 8:32or little-known actors. Big names like
- 8:34Bellucci or Cassel are one-time events,
- 8:36but he emphasizes improvisation and
- 8:38deprives not only his characters but
- 8:40also his actors of control. In Love,
- 8:42the sex scenes were not simulated. I
- 8:44mean, the guy was literally filming
- 8:45porn. In Vortex, Dario Argento, who is
- 8:47actually a director himself, refused to
- 8:49work from pre-written lines. And in
- 8:51Climax, real dancers were cast, most of
- 8:53whom had no acting experience. That is
- 8:56exactly the film I want to talk about
- 8:58separately. For me personally, Gaspar
- 9:03Noé's cinema fully revealed itself in
- 9:04Climax. Retelling films is a thankless
- 9:06task, but in short, it's about a group
- 9:08of dancers rehearsing their routine in
- 9:11a remote, closed-down school. The
- 9:12rehearsal goes well, and to celebrate,
- 9:14they decide to party. Their
- 9:16choreographer brings a bowl of sangria,
- 9:17and they all start drinking. But there
- 9:19is one catch. Someone spikes the
- 9:20sangria with LSD, and after that, chaos
- 9:22ensues. Some are enjoying it, some are
- 9:24in terror, some are looking for who did
- 9:26it, and others show their true faces.
- 9:28And as always, first and foremost, god,
- 9:30how cool it is shot. I was absolutely
- 9:32indifferent to dance, but here it's
- 9:34filmed so mesmerizingly that you can't
- 9:36look away. Wait, there's a soundtrack
- 9:38too. What kind? Giorgio Moroder, Daft
- 9:39Punk, Aphex Twin, Dopplereffekt,
- 9:41etcetera. Well, pretty decent stuff.
- 9:43Secondly, for me, this is Noé's least
- 9:45exhausting film. It runs for only an
- 9:46hour and a half and is quite dense with
- 9:48events compared to his other work. And
- 9:50finally, besides Irreversible, Noé
- 9:52talks about social issues here. In
- 9:54general, that's always hovered in the
- 9:56background, but his previous films were
- 9:58more about the existential. Here, there
- 9:59is direct criticism. And Noé is
- 10:01specifically criticizing society,
- 10:03French society to be exact. This is
- 10:04indicated by the diversity among the
- 10:06dancers, featuring white, black, gay,
- 10:07lesbian, and transgender people. As
- 10:09Russian people, we condemn all of this.
- 10:10God is with us. It's pointed to even
- 10:12more explicitly by the giant French
- 10:13flag hanging on stage. And against that
- 10:15background, they even shout: "Bleu."
- 10:19Wait, hold on, I've heard that
- 10:21somewhere before. And to make it
- 10:22perfectly clear, the film greets us
- 10:24with a title card, presenting a French
- 10:26film and being proud of it. It’s
- 10:28basically pure irony. Throughout the
- 10:30film, we can observe three levels of
- 10:31frankness between people. The first we
- 10:33see during the interviews at the start
- 10:34of the film. In them, the dancers act
- 10:36restrained, control their answers, and
- 10:38even praise each other after a
- 10:39successful rehearsal.
- 10:40Working with a choreographer like you
- 10:44is a great chance, and it will help me
- 10:47grow. I’m ready for anything.
- 10:49The second level manifests in private
- 10:50conversations between the characters.
- 10:52Everyone breaks off into groups and
- 10:54starts discussing others in a
- 10:55comfortable setting. Often in a
- 10:57not-so-positive light. Check out that
- 10:59chick. I banged her yesterday.
- 11:02You stand next to that David, and
- 11:04you'll end up being drugged. I'm
- 11:06telling you,
- 11:07I’d nail her so hard, the shaft would
- 11:09go right through and poke out her
- 11:10throat.
- 11:11And the third level, when everyone gets
- 11:12high. Then the models of behavior
- 11:14imposed by society are erased, and all
- 11:16real thoughts and desires come out. In
- 11:18the end, it turns into a real horror.
- 11:19You are lost. Around you are nothing
- 11:21but psychos ready to kill the culprit.
- 11:23Screams, the space is flooded with
- 11:24sickening colors, and the music won't
- 11:26stop pounding. As a viewer, I just
- 11:28don't want to be in that place. When
- 11:30you look at all this, you realize that
- 11:31the group of dancers is a reflection of
- 11:33society. Dissolving into an elegant
- 11:35group dance, they create an image of
- 11:37friendliness and cohesion. But as soon
- 11:38as a stressful situation occurs, the
- 11:40collective falls apart and the witch
- 11:42hunt begins. Of course, this applies
- 11:44not only to France. Such a thing can
- 11:46happen in a group of any scale. And all
- 11:48this is due to a simple lack of trust
- 11:49and wild paranoia. But honestly, Climax
- 11:51is actually more about the fear of
- 11:53losing control. And do you know why?
- 11:54Because everything I said here about
- 11:56French society is total [ __ ]. If we
- 11:58read the interviews, we'll see the cast
- 12:00was chosen by who could dance best, and
- 12:02the flag was just a random touch. Their
- 12:04site just had red, gray, and blue rags,
- 12:06and they were like, "Lol, that looks
- 12:08like a French flag, let's keep it." So,
- 12:11there’s actually no planned political
- 12:13subtext here, but that interpretation
- 12:15feels natural just because the details
- 12:17pointing to it are present. And even so
- 12:19, Noé still added that title card at
- 12:21the beginning. And god, how I hate that
- 12:24pretentious prick. I don’t even like
- 12:29Gaspar Noé's films, how’s that for a
- 12:31plot twist? They are incredibly
- 12:32stifling, monotonous, and stretch
- 12:34simple ideas over two hours. Take
- 12:35Irréversible, for example, I told you
- 12:37the whole plot in one paragraph. And
- 12:39that’s basically it, nothing else
- 12:40happens in the movie. It was edited in
- 12:42reverse not because it’s some clever
- 12:43move, but because Noé watched
- 12:45Nolan’s Memento. And in the end, it
- 12:46was just easier to sell the film to
- 12:47investors that way. Do you know what
- 12:49else he did when releasing the film
- 12:50Love? He made it in 3D so you’d put
- 12:52on glasses, and then show you an
- 12:54erection [ __ ] at you full screen.
- 12:56Like some kind of teenager. Probably
- 12:57sat there giggling when he came up with
- 13:00that. And when he released Climax, he
- 13:01made this poster. You despised I Stand
- 13:04Alone. You hated Irréversible,
- 13:05couldn't stand Enter the Void, and
- 13:07cursed Love. Now try Climax. And
- 13:09there’s Noé sitting at the bottom.
- 13:11You think you’re so damn cool, yet
- 13:12you make such disgusting movies. And
- 13:14his full-screen text. God, that’s a
- 13:16whole other topic. At the end of that
- 13:17same Irréversible, a strobe light
- 13:18starts, and he writes across the screen
- 13:20: "Time destroys everything." [ __ ],
- 13:22what a ground-breaking thought. His
- 13:23words contain letters. Why did I waste
- 13:25an hour and a half on this? Existence
- 13:26is an elusive illusion. Life is a
- 13:28collective impossibility. Death is a
- 13:29unique experience. Damn it, just shut
- 13:31up already. Fine, I can't say I don't
- 13:36like his films at all. Rather, I can't
- 13:39fully enjoy them, if that’s even
- 13:41possible in the first place. Visually,
- 13:43I really love his style, but most of
- 13:44his filmography is honestly boring to
- 13:46watch. In my opinion, anyway. The
- 13:48visual spectacle gets tiresome at some
- 13:49point because you simply don't feel a
- 13:51deep connection to what’s happening.
- 13:53The plot doesn't boast a wealth of
- 13:54events, and there are few
- 13:55well-developed characters. That's
- 13:57exactly why I genuinely like Climax,
- 13:59because at the center is a group that
- 14:00doesn't really need much fleshing out.
- 14:02There’s a lot of uncomfortable [ __ ]
- 14:03happening, and the runtime isn't
- 14:04stretched thin. In other words, it's a
- 14:06concentrated Gaspar Noé experience.
- 14:07But then another question arises: why
- 14:09even watch Gaspar Noé films at all?
- 14:14Personally, I’ve answered that
- 14:16question this way: Noé's work
- 14:18shouldn't be seen as standard films,
- 14:19but as a transmission of specific
- 14:21sensations through audiovisuals. You
- 14:23shouldn't expect deep drama from him.
- 14:25These are raw, unprocessed sensations
- 14:26and emotions that we can actually feel
- 14:28through the screen. Even when I wasn't
- 14:30always captivated by the content of
- 14:31Noé's films, I always experienced some
- 14:33kind of emotion while watching them. I
- 14:35felt massive discomfort, experiencing
- 14:37what the victims go through in
- 14:38Irréversible. And believe me, it is
- 14:40perhaps one of the most terrifying
- 14:41scenes I have ever seen. In principle,
- 14:43I’ve never been particularly
- 14:44impressed by dance, but in Climax, it
- 14:46mesmerized me. Watching the intimate
- 14:47scenes in Love, I truly felt their
- 14:49entire intimacy, and so on. You might
- 14:51like it or you might not, but you
- 14:53definitely won't remain indifferent.
- 14:55That’s where the monotony comes from.
- 14:56Gaspar Noé doesn't savor violence, sex
- 14:58, or drug trips; he shows them in their
- 15:00full duration and makes them repulsive.
- 15:03And there’s a certain honesty in that
- 15:04duration, I suppose. What do I mean by
- 15:06that? Usually, time in cinema is always
- 15:08artificial. Minutes, hours, or days can
- 15:10fly by in seconds for us thanks to
- 15:11editing. And conversely, seconds can be
- 15:13stretched into whole minutes, but Noé
- 15:15practically never does that. If the
- 15:17characters are having sex, it’ll be
- 15:19for ten minutes without a single cut.
- 15:20If a character is tripping, the trip
- 15:22will last for six minutes. And we’ll
- 15:24even watch its aftereffects. If the
- 15:25characters are jacking each other off,
- 15:27that will get three minutes, also
- 15:28without a single cut. And when I said
- 15:30Noé was criticizing something in
- 15:32Climax, that wasn't true precisely
- 15:33because he never gives you concrete
- 15:35answers. He immerses you into a
- 15:37specific situation. He brings you face
- 15:39to face with unpleasant things. He
- 15:41wants to show that they are real and
- 15:42it's pointless to hide them; what you
- 15:44take from that is entirely up to you.
- 15:46In short, as you’ve gathered, my
- 15:47relationship with Gaspar Noé is
- 15:49complicated, but the point is that's
- 15:50perfectly normal. This is experimental
- 15:52cinema showing disturbing things, so it
- 15:54would be weird if anyone actually
- 15:55enjoyed it. But he is quite the troll,
- 15:57honestly. And when you think about it,
- 15:59it turns out pretty funny. I accuse him
- 16:00of pretentiousness, yet I find meaning
- 16:02in colorful rags that isn't even there
- 16:04in the end. Perhaps there is nothing
- 16:05pretentious about him, and the man is
- 16:07just doing what he enjoys. He just sits
- 16:09in the director's chair and goes, "Yeah
- 16:10, I can make a movie about love
- 16:12bordering on porn." Sure, I can hang
- 16:14French flags everywhere, but in the end
- 16:15, it won't be about politics or
- 16:17anything like that. Like, what are you
- 16:18going to do to me? Anyway, I haven't
- 16:20been inside his head. I can only guess.
- 16:21What can I say for sure? It's that
- 16:23Gaspar Noé is the kind of director who
- 16:25doesn't compromise his vision. He
- 16:27rarely makes films, but he always does
- 16:28it on his own terms. And that ambiguity
- 16:30is exactly why he's interesting to me.
- 16:32It's easy to understand why people
- 16:33watch good movies. But controversial
- 16:35ones are much harder to figure out.
- 16:36Whether Gaspar Noé makes good or bad
- 16:38cinema is ultimately up to you to
- 16:40decide. Hey
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of гаспар ноэ: режиссер твоих кошмаров by jpegviolence, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,493 words across 544 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.