YouTube2Text

Боги Финикии и Угарита, родина Библии? — Transcript

by Кыштымский Карлик · 8,924 words · 1,373 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Greetings to you, dear viewers. You are
  2. 0:02on the Kyshtym Dwarf channel. A
  3. 0:04disclaimer. Everything stated by the
  4. 0:06author is his personal fantasy, as well
  5. 0:08as excerpts from official sources. Any
  6. 0:10resemblance to real persons is purely
  7. 0:12coincidental. Remember, the channel is
  8. 0:14for entertainment purposes and does not
  9. 0:16claim to be the truth. The author may
  10. 0:18be mistaken in his conclusions. Today,
  11. 0:21I will try to introduce you, dear
  12. 0:23viewers, to some very interesting
  13. 0:25materials that may shed light on the
  14. 0:27origins of modern religion as such. We
  15. 0:31are talking about Phoenicia and Ugarit.
  16. 0:34To give you the right associations
  17. 0:36right away, a few words about these
  18. 0:38names. Phoenicia is one of the most
  19. 0:42ancient regions on Earth from a
  20. 0:44historical perspective, stretching
  21. 0:46along the eastern coast of the
  22. 0:47Mediterranean Sea. In this territory,
  23. 0:51there were city-states that engaged in
  24. 0:54trade, fishing, maritime transport, and
  25. 0:56shipbuilding. Moreover, the Phoenicians
  26. 1:00had their own colonies that stretched
  27. 1:02along the shores of the Mediterranean,
  28. 1:04all the way to Spain. Even the Egyptian
  29. 1:08pharaohs commissioned the Phoenicians
  30. 1:09to build ships. According to one
  31. 1:13version, the name Phoenicia comes from
  32. 1:15the word Fenekhu, which means
  33. 1:16shipbuilder. Cities such as modern
  34. 1:19Baalbek, Beirut, Byblos, Tyre, and
  35. 1:22Tripoli are familiar to anyone
  36. 1:24interested in religion, mythology, and
  37. 1:27history. Yes, the Phoenicians lived on
  38. 1:30the territory of modern Lebanon and,
  39. 1:33accordingly, traded in Lebanese cedar,
  40. 1:35and also built their ships from it. The
  41. 1:39city of Byblos is known for being the
  42. 1:41main hub for trade with Egypt. Among
  43. 1:44many goods, Byblos also traded in
  44. 1:46Egyptian papyrus, which was at a
  45. 1:48certain point in history the main
  46. 1:50material for recording various texts.
  47. 1:54Another trading partner of Phoenicia
  48. 1:56was Greece, which actively bought
  49. 1:58Egyptian papyrus. Thanks to this, the
  50. 2:01name of the city of Byblos entered the
  51. 2:03Greek language. And thus appeared the
  52. 2:06word Biblion, which means book. And
  53. 2:09since the Jews, neighbors of the
  54. 2:11Phoenicians, borrowed not only their
  55. 2:13alphabet but also their religious myths
  56. 2:16, it is clear why Jewish writings were
  57. 2:18later named the Bible, that is, a
  58. 2:20collection of books. It is also worth
  59. 2:24mentioning that the Phoenician land was
  60. 2:26actually called Canaan, and the
  61. 2:28Phoenicians called themselves
  62. 2:29Canaanites. Canaan is the son of that
  63. 2:34very Ham who was Jupiter to the Romans,
  64. 2:36Amon or Hammon to the Egyptians, and
  65. 2:38Egypt itself was called the land of Ham
  66. 2:41. It was from here that the Jews came
  67. 2:45to the land of Canaan and allegedly
  68. 2:47destroyed the Canaanites by the order
  69. 2:49of Yahweh. Besides the Phoenicians, the
  70. 2:51Amorites also lived on this land. I
  71. 2:54have already said that such a
  72. 2:55resemblance to the word "sea"(morye)—
  73. 2:57referring to the Mediterranean, by
  74. 2:59which they actually lived—is not
  75. 3:01accidental. And the Amorites are an
  76. 3:03analog of the Pomors, that is, a people
  77. 3:06living along the shores of the sea.
  78. 3:08Actually, back in the 19th century, it
  79. 3:10was known that Slavic peoples lived on
  80. 3:12the lands of Canaan. So, the
  81. 3:15Phoenicians and the Amorites were
  82. 3:17related peoples, like Russians and
  83. 3:19Ukrainians today. It is possible that
  84. 3:23these peoples are also related to the
  85. 3:25Etruscans, so it is quite possible that
  86. 3:27Slavs once lived in this region. But
  87. 3:30scientists classify the Phoenicians as
  88. 3:33a Semitic people. And some of them, on
  89. 3:36this basis, say that the Slavs are
  90. 3:37descendants of the Jews. Personally, I
  91. 3:40categorically disagree with this and
  92. 3:42believe that the Slavs simply lived
  93. 3:44next to the Semites on the territory of
  94. 3:47Phoenicia. Now about Ugarit. In our
  95. 3:51time, in Northern Syria in 1928, a
  96. 3:53farmer accidentally discovered a stone
  97. 3:56slab that turned out to be a tomb cover
  98. 3:58. French archaeologists rushed to the
  99. 4:02site immediately. Why French? Simply
  100. 4:06because Syria and Lebanon were under
  101. 4:08French rule at that time. French
  102. 4:11Masonic scientists were very fond of
  103. 4:13excavating ancient settlements and
  104. 4:15extracting artifacts from them. And so,
  105. 4:19next to the ancient cemetery, a hill
  106. 4:21called Ras Shamra was discovered, which
  107. 4:24means "fennel cape." They excavated it.
  108. 4:28And thus, the famous city of Ugarit,
  109. 4:30mentioned in ancient Egyptian documents
  110. 4:32, was discovered. Ugarit is interesting
  111. 4:35to us because, among other things, clay
  112. 4:37tablets with writing were discovered
  113. 4:39there. Cuneiform text was inscribed on
  114. 4:42these tablets. But, to the surprise of
  115. 4:45archaeologists and linguists, this text
  116. 4:47was not an analogue of Sumerian. Unlike
  117. 4:50Mesopotamian clay tablets, which had
  118. 4:52hundreds of different signs, there were
  119. 4:55fewer than thirty signs in Ugarit. Then
  120. 4:58it became clear that the scientists
  121. 4:59were dealing with alphabetic writing.
  122. 5:02The tablets were deciphered quite
  123. 5:04quickly, revealing ancient poems and
  124. 5:06mentioning gods known from the Bible
  125. 5:09and the works of Philo of Byblos.
  126. 5:12Scientists found that the Ugaritic
  127. 5:14texts are earlier than the Phoenician
  128. 5:16ones. They began to be called Canaanite
  129. 5:19myths in scientific literature.
  130. 5:22Ugaritic tablets are also important
  131. 5:24because they exist in their original
  132. 5:26form, whereas Phoenician legends and
  133. 5:28myths are known to scientists
  134. 5:29exclusively from the works of later
  135. 5:31writers from Egypt, Greece, and Rome.
  136. 5:34Where did the Phoenician texts in their
  137. 5:36original form go? There is a
  138. 5:39supposition that they simply crumbled
  139. 5:41to dust, as they were recorded on
  140. 5:43Egyptian papyrus, which deteriorated
  141. 5:45very quickly in the conditions of
  142. 5:47coastal lands. Perhaps this is so, but
  143. 5:50historians describe the difficult fate
  144. 5:52of the Phoenician land. Many peoples
  145. 5:56attempted to seize it, as it was
  146. 5:58fertile and a key center of trade in
  147. 6:00the entire Mediterranean region. Canaan
  148. 6:05was under the control of Egyptians,
  149. 6:07Assyrians, Hittites, Persians, and many
  150. 6:09others. Even Alexander the Great
  151. 6:12himself conquered these lands.
  152. 6:14Therefore, in such a restless place
  153. 6:16from a political point of view, large
  154. 6:18libraries could hardly have been
  155. 6:20preserved. They were either taken away
  156. 6:23to the same Egyptian Alexandria or
  157. 6:25burned and destroyed. In general, the
  158. 6:28history of Phoenicia and Ugarit is very
  159. 6:30interesting. And for anyone who wants
  160. 6:33to learn more, I recommend Yulia
  161. 6:34Tsirkin's book "Myths of Ugarit and
  162. 6:36Phoenicia." So, let us turn directly to
  163. 6:39the mythology of Phoenicia. It must be
  164. 6:42said immediately that, for the reasons
  165. 6:44mentioned above, Phoenicia was never a
  166. 6:47single state. Accordingly, each city
  167. 6:50and people living in those territories
  168. 6:53at various times had their own deities
  169. 6:55and religion. Yes, they were very often
  170. 6:59similar to one another, but differences
  171. 7:01still existed. Therefore, hundreds of
  172. 7:05years of layering myths upon myths led
  173. 7:07to names, functions, and stories of
  174. 7:09some gods intertwining with others. In
  175. 7:14this regard, even scholars find it
  176. 7:16difficult to clearly and concisely
  177. 7:18explain which god was primary, which
  178. 7:20replaced him, and how these myths
  179. 7:22entered the Bible. We, however, will
  180. 7:25simply acquaint ourselves with some
  181. 7:27characters of Phoenician and Ugaritic
  182. 7:29mythology and try to find familiar
  183. 7:31plots. Unfortunately, I haven't made a
  184. 7:36video about Kabbalah yet, but I know
  185. 7:38that ancient Jews treated their
  186. 7:40alphabet and names with great reverence
  187. 7:42, believing that letters and words
  188. 7:44could influence the astral world, which
  189. 7:46itself is a reflection of the divine
  190. 7:48world, that is, the world of ideas.
  191. 7:52Behind every letter, word, and name
  192. 7:55stands a number. And numbers, as is
  193. 7:58well known, are the expression of
  194. 8:00divine law and order. Where there is a
  195. 8:03number, there is order, and thus the
  196. 8:05Creator is present. The Phoenicians,
  197. 8:09likely aware of Kabbalistic science,
  198. 8:11were convinced that knowing the name of
  199. 8:13a person or deity granted power over
  200. 8:15them. This is, of course, directly
  201. 8:19related to magic. It is precisely for
  202. 8:22this reason that the Phoenicians were
  203. 8:24forbidden from pronouncing the true
  204. 8:26names of deities. Only a priest in a
  205. 8:29temple could do this according to
  206. 8:31strict rules. To somehow solve this
  207. 8:33problem, the Phoenicians used epithets
  208. 8:36or replacement words instead of the
  209. 8:38true names of deities. Thus appeared
  210. 8:42the words "El," meaning deity in
  211. 8:44general, and "Baal," meaning lord or
  212. 8:46master, as well as "Adon" or "Adonai,"
  213. 8:49meaning Lord or master. That is why to
  214. 8:53this day we use a religious system that
  215. 8:55, in principle, does not function as it
  216. 8:58should. After all, one must address a
  217. 9:02deity by its own name to achieve the
  218. 9:04desired result, as the mages and magi
  219. 9:07of antiquity did. The authors of the
  220. 9:10Old Testament did everything to deprive
  221. 9:12the ancient Vedic world of the
  222. 9:14knowledge of the names of the divine
  223. 9:16pantheon. So, each city had its own
  224. 9:18patron deities, but at the same time,
  225. 9:21the Phoenicians did not shy away from
  226. 9:23using their neighbors 'deities for
  227. 9:25their own purposes. That is why they
  228. 9:29could have several dying and
  229. 9:30resurrecting deities at once, which
  230. 9:32later transformed into Jesus Christ.
  231. 9:36The veneration of high mountains and
  232. 9:38the deities who rule them also finds
  233. 9:40its origins in Ugarit. We know of Mount
  234. 9:44Sapan or Tsaphon, a sacred mountain on
  235. 9:46which its ruler Baal, or Baal-zephon,
  236. 9:49fought a monster. The counterpart of
  237. 9:52Baal-zephon, the Casius Zeus, fought
  238. 9:54the monster Typhon on Mount Tsaphon.
  239. 9:57Some scholars believe that Tsaphon and
  240. 9:59Typhon are one and the same. We, for
  241. 10:02our part, can interpret this as the
  242. 10:04struggle of air or spirit against the
  243. 10:06mountain or matter. Furthermore, the
  244. 10:09Semites believed that trouble would one
  245. 10:11day come to the land from the north. It
  246. 10:14is possible that this refers to the
  247. 10:16northern sky, with the mountain serving
  248. 10:18as an allegory for the celestial axis
  249. 10:20pointing to the Pole Star. As you may
  250. 10:23recall, many mythologies speak of the
  251. 10:26importance of this axis to the fate of
  252. 10:28our world. Along with mountains, the
  253. 10:32Phoenicians also venerated special
  254. 10:34stones called baetyls, from "bet-el,"
  255. 10:36meaning dwelling of the deity. And
  256. 10:41although scholars tell us today that
  257. 10:43stone worship is a legacy of ancient
  258. 10:45fetishism, there is reason to believe
  259. 10:47that ancient people knew how to inhabit
  260. 10:49stones with real spirits, whether a
  261. 10:51deceased ancestor or some other entity.
  262. 10:55This was done for both religious and
  263. 10:57practical reasons. The spirit could
  264. 11:00assist in various affairs. Special
  265. 11:03animals were also venerated in
  266. 11:04Phoenicia. For example, the bull served
  267. 11:07as a symbol of the god El and his son
  268. 11:10Baal, as a powerful and fertile animal.
  269. 11:12Meanwhile, the boar was considered an
  270. 11:14accursed animal. Hence the Semitic
  271. 11:16aversion to pork. As mentioned earlier,
  272. 11:20Phoenician land was conquered by many
  273. 11:22neighboring nations. Because of this,
  274. 11:25foreign deities were often adopted into
  275. 11:27the Phoenician pantheon or simply
  276. 11:29identified with local gods. In
  277. 11:31antiquity, there were generally far
  278. 11:33fewer disputes regarding religion. No
  279. 11:36one killed their neighbor because they
  280. 11:38worshipped Zeus Kasios while we
  281. 11:40worshipped Baal-Zaphon. Religious
  282. 11:44intolerance only began to appear with
  283. 11:46the first seeds of monotheism and the
  284. 11:48emergence of the concept of a chosen
  285. 11:50people. It is worth noting that there
  286. 11:55were attempts in antiquity to organize
  287. 11:57Phoenician mythology and sort out the
  288. 11:59pantheon of deities. I have already
  289. 12:01mentioned in one of the videos a
  290. 12:03certain Sanchuniathon. This writer
  291. 12:06lived in the ancient Phoenician city of
  292. 12:09Berytus, now Beirut, and recorded
  293. 12:11sacred texts from the temple of the god
  294. 12:13Ieuo. It was this work that the
  295. 12:17aforementioned Philo of Byblos used to
  296. 12:19create his own History of Phoenicia.
  297. 12:22Neither the first nor the second work
  298. 12:24has, unfortunately, survived to this
  299. 12:27day. And here is an interesting point.
  300. 12:29It is known that Sanchuniathon himself
  301. 12:31received information from the ancient
  302. 12:34sage Taautus. And in Egypt, this
  303. 12:37Taautus was known as the god Thoth. We
  304. 12:40know very well that the god Thoth is
  305. 12:42Hermes Trismegistus, or Hermes
  306. 12:44Thrice-Great. It turns out that many
  307. 12:48Phoenician figures seem to merge with
  308. 12:50mythological characters. And this is
  309. 12:54not the only example. For instance, the
  310. 12:56King of the Phoenician city of Tyre was
  311. 12:58Hiram the Great. The very same Hiram
  312. 13:01who helped Solomon build the great
  313. 13:03temple. Hiram supposedly also built the
  314. 13:06temple of Melqart in Tyre. And Melqart
  315. 13:09is the patron god of navigation for the
  316. 13:12Tyrians. In Greece, he was identified
  317. 13:16with Heracles, which is why the
  318. 13:17Phoenicians called the Pillars of
  319. 13:19Hercules in the Strait of Gibraltar the
  320. 13:21columns of Melqart. Given what has been
  321. 13:25said, I personally have a strong
  322. 13:27suspicion that in ancient times,
  323. 13:28heavenly and earthly history were not
  324. 13:31separated from each other. Meaning that
  325. 13:33, at the very least, kings traced their
  326. 13:35lineage not from humans, but from gods
  327. 13:38and demigods. Some peoples have legends
  328. 13:40that their ancestors came from the
  329. 13:42stars. Personally, I do not believe
  330. 13:45that any aliens flew to Earth and
  331. 13:47populated it. It is more of an allegory
  332. 13:51, a simplified way of telling the story
  333. 13:53of how life began on our planet. But
  334. 13:57nevertheless, that is often how the
  335. 13:59legends go. And in general, a
  336. 14:02distinctive feature of ancient
  337. 14:04religions is the absence of strict
  338. 14:06dogmas in them. Legends could take
  339. 14:09various forms, gods could swap places,
  340. 14:11and a kind of chaos reigned, supported
  341. 14:14by the peoples themselves. But at the
  342. 14:17same time, the wise knew that once,
  343. 14:19many thousands of years before the
  344. 14:21Phoenicians themselves, a unified
  345. 14:23knowledge existed that encompassed
  346. 14:26culture, religion, and science. Echoes
  347. 14:30of this lost knowledge are found in
  348. 14:32Kabbalah, which, of course, did not
  349. 14:34originally belong to the Jews, but was
  350. 14:37obtained by them from Egypt through
  351. 14:39Moses or Chaldean priests, and
  352. 14:40subsequently lost again. Therefore, the
  353. 14:45main goal of many ancient authors was
  354. 14:47the work of restoring this knowledge
  355. 14:49and bringing order to myths and legends
  356. 14:51. So, let us return to mythology.
  357. 14:56Despite the abundance of deities among
  358. 14:58the Phoenicians and Ugaritians and the
  359. 15:00complexity of the divine pantheon, a
  360. 15:02certain foundation still existed. Thus,
  361. 15:06the supreme god of Ugarit was Ilu,
  362. 15:08meaning God; in principle, he was
  363. 15:10depicted sitting on a throne, which
  364. 15:12indicated that Ilu did not interfere in
  365. 15:15the petty affairs of people on Earth.
  366. 15:18He was, as it were, in a state of calm,
  367. 15:21observing the affairs of men and other
  368. 15:23deities. The word of Ilu has the force
  369. 15:26of law, and no one, including the
  370. 15:28deities, can contradict it. It would
  371. 15:31seem that this is the image of the one
  372. 15:33Christian God the Father. But in Ugarit
  373. 15:37, it was believed that due to his old
  374. 15:39age, Ilu could succumb to persuasion
  375. 15:41and manipulation by his own sons, and
  376. 15:43this does not fit the Christian concept
  377. 15:45at all. Furthermore, in Ugarit, there
  378. 15:49was another god above Ilu—the Father
  379. 15:51of Ilu. As you remember, in Zurvanism,
  380. 15:54there was the exact same situation,
  381. 15:56where above the supreme god Zurvan, who
  382. 15:59himself gave birth to the good and evil
  383. 16:01gods of our universe, stood Father
  384. 16:04Zurvan. What this father of Ilu is,
  385. 16:06mythology does not say, or such
  386. 16:08information simply has not been found
  387. 16:11yet. But one of the legends tells us
  388. 16:13the following. Next is an excerpt from
  389. 16:16the book by Yuli Tsirkin, "Myths and
  390. 16:18Legends of the Peoples of the World."
  391. 16:20Volume twelve. Western Asia. Quote. The
  392. 16:23Phoenicians told of the creation of the
  393. 16:25Universe in different ways. Some
  394. 16:27believed that at the beginning of all
  395. 16:29things there was a dark air, like the
  396. 16:31wind, and an equally dark chaos. And so
  397. 16:34it was always, and they had no end. But
  398. 16:37then the air, also known as the spirit,
  399. 16:40fell in love with itself. And desire
  400. 16:43appeared, and then Mot. This was both
  401. 16:46death and rebirth from it. This Mot was
  402. 16:50either mud or a watery rot. From it
  403. 16:54came the seeds of every creature, of
  404. 16:56every creation, in a word, of
  405. 16:58everything that exists. Then appeared
  406. 17:02creatures that did not yet have any
  407. 17:04senses, and from them evolved other
  408. 17:05creatures possessing reason, and they
  409. 17:07received the name of guardians of the
  410. 17:09sky. In their shape, they resembled an
  411. 17:13egg. At the same time, the sun, moon,
  412. 17:17stars, and great luminaries also
  413. 17:19emerged, and then both the mud and all
  414. 17:21celestial bodies ignited. From such
  415. 17:24ignition, everything became permeated
  416. 17:26with light, and from this light, the
  417. 17:28seas and lands caught fire. As a result
  418. 17:31, everything heated up, the air was set
  419. 17:33in motion, from which the winds
  420. 17:35originated. Clouds gathered in the
  421. 17:37heavens, which poured down upon the
  422. 17:39earth in powerful torrents. The earth,
  423. 17:42having heated up, began to erupt. And
  424. 17:45powerful earthquakes shook the universe
  425. 17:47. And everything whirled in a mighty
  426. 17:50vortex, in which a wide variety of
  427. 17:52things and creatures collided with one
  428. 17:54another. From their collisions, thunder
  429. 17:57and lightning were born. The roar was
  430. 17:59such that the guardians of the sky, who
  431. 18:01had been sleeping until then, now awoke
  432. 18:03and began to move, and with them,
  433. 18:05everything else began to move as well.
  434. 18:08From the union of all this, men and
  435. 18:10women came into being. They gave names
  436. 18:13to the winds, hallowed the fruits of
  437. 18:15the earth, and began to worship them.
  438. 18:17End of quote. So, you have heard that
  439. 18:21before our universe and any matter at
  440. 18:23all appeared, there existed only chaos
  441. 18:25and spirit or air. This concept is
  442. 18:28already familiar to us. And when the
  443. 18:31spirit has a desire, it immediately
  444. 18:33leads to the appearance of death or the
  445. 18:35god Mot, as they believed in Ugarit.
  446. 18:38And it is said that this mud was filth
  447. 18:40or silt. Here I can refer to the fact
  448. 18:43that the Canaanite language was
  449. 18:45considered Slavic. And the name Illu is
  450. 18:48nothing other than divine matter. We
  451. 18:51remember well that matter was called
  452. 18:53clay or dust of the earth in ancient
  453. 18:55texts. And the word' il 'in some
  454. 18:58languages is translated exactly that
  455. 19:01way: clay. That is, in essence, we have
  456. 19:04a certain allegory that tells us that
  457. 19:06matter appeared at the moment when the
  458. 19:08spirit, hovering over the ocean of
  459. 19:10chaos, fell in love with itself. And
  460. 19:14thus appeared matter, as the sediment
  461. 19:16of Ilil at the bottom of that very
  462. 19:18primordial ocean of Chaos. Perhaps this
  463. 19:22was that very ancestral Ilu. His
  464. 19:24descendant, the Ugaritic god Ilu, lives
  465. 19:27already in the center of the universe.
  466. 19:30According to Canaanite notions, the
  467. 19:32world consisted of an upper ocean,
  468. 19:34where deities live, including
  469. 19:36Baal-Hammon, and a lower or
  470. 19:38subterranean ocean, and in the center
  471. 19:40was the Earth. It is noted that the Sun
  472. 19:44, Moon, and Stars are located beneath
  473. 19:46the celestial ocean. That is, the
  474. 19:49cosmos is not the celestial ocean, but
  475. 19:51mere matter. And now, attention, an
  476. 19:54interesting point. The god Ilu lives
  477. 19:57between these two oceans, which
  478. 19:58originate at the source of a sacred
  479. 20:00river. When God created the universe,
  480. 20:04he separated the water above the
  481. 20:06firmament from the water below the
  482. 20:08firmament, after which the sky formed
  483. 20:10above, the sea below, and the earth in
  484. 20:12between. In Phoenicia, the water flow
  485. 20:15was symbolized by a serpent. The spirit
  486. 20:20that hovered over chaos at the
  487. 20:22beginning of creation and fell in love
  488. 20:24with itself could, according to Philo
  489. 20:26of Byblos, be represented as a serpent
  490. 20:29devouring its own tail—the familiar
  491. 20:31Ouroboros. And now, a quote from a book
  492. 20:35by Yuli Tsirkin. El's enemy was a
  493. 20:40mighty serpent, and two armies—one
  494. 20:42led by El and the other by the serpent
  495. 20:44—fought stubbornly against each other
  496. 20:46, but neither side could secure a
  497. 20:49victory. And so, the two leaders made a
  498. 20:53pact. According to its terms, the army
  499. 20:56whose warriors fell into the ocean and
  500. 20:58were consumed by it would be considered
  501. 21:00defeated, while their opponents would
  502. 21:02rule the sky and the whole world. And
  503. 21:05that is what happened. The serpent's
  504. 21:08warriors were swallowed by the ocean's
  505. 21:10waters, and El became the master of the
  506. 21:12sky, while his companions became the
  507. 21:14gods who rule the universe with him.
  508. 21:18El's victory gave the universe its
  509. 21:20final form. End of quote. So, what do
  510. 21:22you think of this turn of events? It
  511. 21:25turns out that the god El fights the
  512. 21:27Ouroboros. And once again, the dilemma
  513. 21:30arises of defining what is good and
  514. 21:32what is evil. After all, judging by the
  515. 21:35story of El’s battle with the serpent
  516. 21:37, the latter is a true fallen angel or
  517. 21:39Satan. And the end of the world will
  518. 21:45come when El finally defeats this
  519. 21:46serpent, which the Jews identified with
  520. 21:48Leviathan. That is the kind of complex
  521. 21:52cosmogony they had in Phoenicia. Unlike
  522. 21:56the Jewish God the Father, the Ugaritic
  523. 21:58El had a wife named Athirat, who held
  524. 22:01the title Ilat—simply "goddess"—and
  525. 22:03the epithet "Sea" as the patroness of
  526. 22:06fishing. Athirat, or Asherah, should
  527. 22:09not be confused with Astarte, another
  528. 22:12goddess who was the wife of Baal.
  529. 22:15Asherah was either the wife or the
  530. 22:16daughter of El. This can be explained
  531. 22:20by the fact that Asherah is likely the
  532. 22:22creative hypostasis of El, who directly
  533. 22:25creates all living things. And the
  534. 22:28epithet "Sea" was given to her because
  535. 22:30she conquered the watery chaos. But it
  536. 22:33turns out that God El had more than one
  537. 22:35wife. His second spouse, named Rahmayu,
  538. 22:40meaning "maiden," ranked even higher
  539. 22:42than Asherah and presided not over
  540. 22:44fishing, but over hunting. I suspect
  541. 22:48that she is the one who later
  542. 22:50transformed into the goddess Ishtar,
  543. 22:52and even later into Venus. If we think
  544. 22:55in terms of symbolism, hunting acts as
  545. 22:57a synonym for the cosmos. Therefore,
  546. 23:01the children of Rahmayu and El were
  547. 23:03Shahar and Shalim. You have surely
  548. 23:06heard about these two gods from me and
  549. 23:08from other researchers. I identified
  550. 23:11them with sugar and salt. Some believe
  551. 23:15that Satan is hidden within one of
  552. 23:16these brothers. Scholars, however,
  553. 23:19believe that Shahar and Shalim are the
  554. 23:22morning and evening stars, that is,
  555. 23:24Venus. One could guess endlessly here,
  556. 23:27for, as I have already said, Phoenician
  557. 23:29mythology is very intricate, with one
  558. 23:32layer superimposed upon another. But if
  559. 23:36we extrapolate this Phoenician myth to
  560. 23:38other sacred texts, it may well turn
  561. 23:40out that Shahar and Shalim are the
  562. 23:42equivalents of Ahura Mazda and Ahriman,
  563. 23:45or Ulgen and Erlik. Moreover, if it is
  564. 23:50known that the evil god was born before
  565. 23:52the good one and is older, then,
  566. 23:54accordingly, in the Shahar-Shalim pair,
  567. 23:56it is the first brother, Shahar, who is
  568. 23:59the evil one. And the second, Shalim or
  569. 24:03Salim, is that very good god who was
  570. 24:05initially worshipped in Jerusalem—
  571. 24:07that is, in the city built by the god
  572. 24:10Salim. As has already been stated by
  573. 24:13other researchers, Shahar is mentioned
  574. 24:15in the Book of Isaiah. where there is
  575. 24:19the expression Helel Ben-Shahar, that
  576. 24:21is, the light-bringer or the shining
  577. 24:23son of Shahar, which is essentially
  578. 24:25similar to the epithet of Lucifer or
  579. 24:27the Morning Star. However, scholars
  580. 24:32have yet to reach a consensus regarding
  581. 24:34the god Shahar, who also had a son,
  582. 24:36Attar, who, depending on the need, was
  583. 24:39depicted in either a male or female
  584. 24:41form. And, accordingly, the name Attar
  585. 24:45transformed into Ashtar or Ishtar, that
  586. 24:48is, the name of Venus. But
  587. 24:50gender-switching by deities is not such
  588. 24:52a rare occurrence in mythology,
  589. 24:54especially Semitic. Moving on. One of
  590. 24:57the most frequent characters in various
  591. 25:00tales, legends, and myths is the
  592. 25:02blacksmith. He constantly fights
  593. 25:04against evil forces, fiends, devils,
  594. 25:07and demons. In Ugaritic mythology, such
  595. 25:09a blacksmith, as well as a craftsman
  596. 25:12god, went by the name Kothar-wa-Khasis.
  597. 25:15One day, the god Ilu summoned Kothar
  598. 25:17and ordered him to build a palace for
  599. 25:19his favorite, the god Yamu. The fact is
  600. 25:23that the god Yamu, or Yam, was the lord
  601. 25:25of the seas and rivers, which is why he
  602. 25:27was officially worshipped in Ugarit.
  603. 25:32And since the supreme god Ilu lives at
  604. 25:34the source of the two oceans, Yamu
  605. 25:36becomes his favorite. So Ilu forces the
  606. 25:41blacksmith god to build a palace for
  607. 25:43Yamu. But Kothar-wa-Khasis does not
  608. 25:47wish to do so, as he supports Yamu's
  609. 25:49rival, the god Baal. This motive of
  610. 25:53building a palace later entered
  611. 25:55Christian sacred texts as the story of
  612. 25:57the construction of King Solomon's
  613. 25:59palace by Hiram Abiff. As I have
  614. 26:02already suggested earlier, a palace is
  615. 26:04a symbol of the celestial system, where
  616. 26:06the blacksmith or craftsman god is the
  617. 26:09archetype of the North Star.
  618. 26:11Accordingly, if Yamu, the god of watery
  619. 26:13chaos, dreamed of erecting a palace for
  620. 26:15himself, there is a probability that a
  621. 26:18black hole was meant to appear at the
  622. 26:20center of the world. But the craftsman
  623. 26:23god was on the side of the light god
  624. 26:25Baal. And when Baal appealed
  625. 26:28unsuccessfully to Ilu, and later openly
  626. 26:31spoke out against Yamu at the assembly
  627. 26:33of the gods, the craftsman god Kothar
  628. 26:36forged two miraculous clubs for him,
  629. 26:38Yagrush and Aymur, with which Baal
  630. 26:40defeated evil. Some scholars suggest
  631. 26:45that the ancient Greek god Hephaestus
  632. 26:47is hidden behind the guise of
  633. 26:49Kothar-wa-Khasis, and in the Egyptian
  634. 26:51version, he is the equivalent of the
  635. 26:53god Ptah. The point is that later in
  636. 26:57the Ugaritic myths, Kothar builds a
  637. 26:59palace for Baal out of gold, silver,
  638. 27:01and cedar, and also makes a window
  639. 27:03through which Baal's rains can fall.
  640. 27:08And thus, the smith god was called the
  641. 27:10one who opens a window for Baal. At the
  642. 27:13same time, in the Egyptian language,
  643. 27:16the name of the god Ptah corresponded
  644. 27:18to the Semitic root PT, meaning to open
  645. 27:20. Mongolian legends also point to a
  646. 27:24connection between many divine smiths
  647. 27:26and either a stone or a well lid that
  648. 27:29lock and unlock celestial waters.
  649. 27:32Therefore, it is quite possible that
  650. 27:34Kothar-wa-Khasis is that very mythical
  651. 27:37smith who fights against demons and
  652. 27:39devils, the servants of the wicked Yamm
  653. 27:41. Now let us recall what I said about
  654. 27:44the struggle of the god El with the
  655. 27:46serpent. According to Ugaritic texts,
  656. 27:49Lotan is a serpent god. Personifying
  657. 27:52primordial chaos, whom Baal defeats.
  658. 27:57Lotan is the prototype of the Leviathan
  659. 27:59in the Bible, and Yamm, the god of the
  660. 28:01sea and chaos, was sometimes identified
  661. 28:04with this very Lotan. And so it seems
  662. 28:08that either one myth was superimposed
  663. 28:10on another, or we are talking about
  664. 28:12different serpents, since in the second
  665. 28:14case, this serpent, that is the god
  666. 28:16Yamm, is a favorite of the supreme god
  667. 28:19El. He surely could not have been
  668. 28:22fighting his own favorite. According to
  669. 28:24the main version of the myth, El and
  670. 28:26his wife stand above all gods and do
  671. 28:28not rule the world directly. Governance
  672. 28:32happens at a lower level, and,
  673. 28:34strangely enough, two factions are
  674. 28:36fighting for the right to rule the
  675. 28:38world. The first consists of the gods
  676. 28:41Yamm, Attar, and Mot. The second
  677. 28:44includes Baal, Anat, Kothar-wa-Khasis,
  678. 28:47and Shapash. And they are constantly
  679. 28:50battling for the right to govern the
  680. 28:51world and people. A motif that in
  681. 28:54Greece and Rome takes on the name of
  682. 28:56the war of the gods. Yamm, as mentioned
  683. 28:59above, is the god of the sea and the
  684. 29:01watery element. At the same time, he is
  685. 29:04also called the river judge. And this,
  686. 29:07again, points to his similarity to the
  687. 29:09Hindu Yama and the Turkic Erlik, who
  688. 29:11judge the souls of the dead. Yamm also
  689. 29:15represented for the Ugaritians the
  690. 29:17embodiment of world chaos, that is,
  691. 29:19disorder. It is obvious that this is
  692. 29:22one of the opposing world forces. Mot
  693. 29:25is the god of death, whose one lip
  694. 29:27reaches the heavens and the other the
  695. 29:29earth. And his tongue touches the stars
  696. 29:32. If someone, for example God's
  697. 29:34messengers, approached him, he could
  698. 29:37swallow them. He generally consumes
  699. 29:39everything that is around him. Thus,
  700. 29:42this character is very similar to the
  701. 29:45description of a black hole, since Mot
  702. 29:47kills not only people but also gods.
  703. 29:50And only a black hole is capable of
  704. 29:52consuming planets and stars. But
  705. 29:55scholars have a problem with defining
  706. 29:57Attar. This is one of the most
  707. 29:59mysterious deities in Ugaritic
  708. 30:01mythology. It is possible that he is
  709. 30:03the male hypostasis of Astarte, as well
  710. 30:05as a god of the desert and sterility.
  711. 30:08But at the same time, in the Sabaean
  712. 30:10Kingdom, he was revered as a patron god
  713. 30:12. Most interesting is his hypostasis
  714. 30:14under the name Attar-Sharkan. Sharkan
  715. 30:17or sarkan is nothing more than a dragon
  716. 30:20. And the dragon is an ancient
  717. 30:23constellation that revolves around the
  718. 30:25north celestial pole and the Pole Star.
  719. 30:28The dragon is a participant in many
  720. 30:30myths and legends, for it guards
  721. 30:32heavenly treasures or sacred fruits.
  722. 30:36According to the Ugaritic myth, when
  723. 30:38Baal was wounded by Mot's spear, he
  724. 30:40feared the fearsome god and agreed to
  725. 30:42become his slave. Then Mot kills Baal,
  726. 30:45and the position of king of the earth
  727. 30:47becomes vacant. Baal's wife, with the
  728. 30:50help of the sun goddess Shapash, finds
  729. 30:53her husband's body and takes it to
  730. 30:55Mount Zaphon, where she buries him.
  731. 30:58Then she goes to the supreme god El and
  732. 31:00his wife and tries to reproach them for
  733. 31:02Baal's death. But El and Asherah decide
  734. 31:06that someone else should become the new
  735. 31:08king of the earth. So, they appoint
  736. 31:11Athtar as king. After all, he is
  737. 31:13submissive to the gods, but towards
  738. 31:15people, he commits violence. Such a
  739. 31:18king suits El and his wife very well.
  740. 31:21And this circumstance shows us once
  741. 31:23again that the supreme god El did not
  742. 31:25care at all about the fate of humanity.
  743. 31:28It did not interest him much at all. So
  744. 31:31, Athtar sits on the throne of the
  745. 31:33world, but it turns out to be too big
  746. 31:35for him. Athtar looks very ridiculous
  747. 31:38on the throne. This plot, if we assume
  748. 31:42that Athtar-Šarkan is the
  749. 31:44constellation of the Dragon, might hint
  750. 31:46that the Polestar was once one of the
  751. 31:48stars of the dragon, namely the star
  752. 31:50Thuban, which means serpent. And the
  753. 31:56death of Baal and his subsequent
  754. 31:58resurrection on Mount Zaphon, when his
  755. 32:00wife Anat killed and cut the god Mot
  756. 32:02into pieces, remind us of other legends
  757. 32:05about a dying and rising god, for
  758. 32:07example, Shamash or Osiris. Thus, Baal,
  759. 32:11by resurrecting, defeats the serpent
  760. 32:13dragon Athtar-Šarkan. And in general,
  761. 32:17this whole trio of Baal's opponents,
  762. 32:20represented by Yamm, Mot, and Athtar,
  763. 32:22hinders only one thing: the celestial
  764. 32:25order or the stability of the solar
  765. 32:27system. Another distinctive feature of
  766. 32:31Ugaritic myths was that the bright god
  767. 32:33Baal was not the son of the supreme god
  768. 32:35El. The Philistines who came to the
  769. 32:39Palestinian land considered the father
  770. 32:41of Baal to be the god Dagan or Dagon.
  771. 32:44And it was Dagon who was their supreme
  772. 32:46god. There is, of course, a great
  773. 32:49temptation here to identify Dagon with
  774. 32:51Saturn. Dagon was depicted as half-man,
  775. 32:54half-fish, and this hints at a
  776. 32:56connection with the Hindu Manu or the
  777. 32:58Slavic Kroda, also known as
  778. 33:00Cronus-Saturn. But the ancient author
  779. 33:03Philo of Byblos compared Dagon not with
  780. 33:06Cronus, that is, with Saturn, but with
  781. 33:09Chronos, the god of time, who himself
  782. 33:11gives birth to ether, chaos, and
  783. 33:13darkness, or fire, air, and water.
  784. 33:16Therefore, let us leave Baal's father
  785. 33:18and return to other deities. Especially
  786. 33:21since there is a possibility that Dagon
  787. 33:23and El are one and the same person. I
  788. 33:26made a separate video about the god
  789. 33:28Balu or Baal titled "The Mystery of
  790. 33:30Baal." In my opinion, Baal or Bel is
  791. 33:34the sun. Although in the mentioned
  792. 33:36religions, solar deities are embodied
  793. 33:38in separate characters. Nevertheless,
  794. 33:40in Ugarit, it was believed that Ba'al
  795. 33:43rode upon the clouds, his voice was the
  796. 33:45thunder, and his weapon was lightning
  797. 33:47or a writhing spear. Ba'al himself
  798. 33:49resides on Mount Tsapan or Tsaphon,
  799. 33:51which links him to the description of
  800. 33:54Ahura Mazda. After all, both lived on
  801. 33:57the summit of the world, which were
  802. 33:59Mount Tsaphon, Sumeru, or Meru. But
  803. 34:03again, there is an important difference
  804. 34:05between Ugaritic mythology and
  805. 34:07Zoroastrianism. Ba'al is not
  806. 34:09subordinate to the supreme god El. He
  807. 34:12is constantly in conflict with him. El
  808. 34:14tries in every way to undermine Ba'al
  809. 34:16and deprive him of his kingdom. He even
  810. 34:19sends his wife to seduce Ba'al. That is
  811. 34:22, in essence, the fate of the earth and
  812. 34:24humanity is not important to El. He
  813. 34:26would be happy if the whole system
  814. 34:28collapsed, and the world were ruled by
  815. 34:30Mot, the god of death, or Yam, the god
  816. 34:32of the underworld or the ocean. And yet
  817. 34:35it was the god El, El Eloah, who later
  818. 34:38transformed into the Islamic Allah and
  819. 34:40the Christian God the Father. Such is
  820. 34:43the Ugaritic phenomenon. It turns out
  821. 34:46that it is exclusively Ba'al who
  822. 34:48worries about the fate of people on
  823. 34:49earth. You might think that El is not
  824. 34:52at all the God the Father that exists
  825. 34:54in Christianity. But no, it is El who
  826. 34:58can send prophecies to people, either
  827. 35:00himself or through angels. And often it
  828. 35:03is Ba'al himself who conveys the will
  829. 35:05of El to the people and defends them
  830. 35:07before the Supreme God. So, this very
  831. 35:11God was the archetype for God the
  832. 35:13Father in Christianity. Here I must
  833. 35:16also voice another opinion. In
  834. 35:18Tsirkin's book, there is such a
  835. 35:20hypothesis. Quote: "The King of Alalakh
  836. 35:23, one of the states of Northern Syria
  837. 35:26and Idrimi, in the second half of the
  838. 35:2815th century BC calls the sky the main
  839. 35:30god, accompanied by other gods of sky
  840. 35:33and earth." End of quote. Some scholars
  841. 35:37believe that El is merely the son of
  842. 35:40the sky god, and the sky itself is an
  843. 35:42analogue of the ancient Greek god
  844. 35:44Uranus. Thus, Al-ilah is the supreme
  845. 35:49heavenly God, who is above El and Ba'al
  846. 35:51. Perhaps, but then what are we to do
  847. 35:55with El the father and the spirit that
  848. 35:57hovered over the chaos? In general, the
  849. 35:59question is interesting and
  850. 36:01controversial. Another important
  851. 36:03character in Ugaritic myths is Ba'al's
  852. 36:05wife or sister, Anat. Anat or Anatu is
  853. 36:09the goddess of springs. She is
  854. 36:11simultaneously both a mother and a
  855. 36:13virgin. She bore a son from Ba'al,
  856. 36:16Amurru, who became the progenitor of
  857. 36:18the Amorites. Although this goddess was
  858. 36:21a goddess of fertility, at the same
  859. 36:23time she was very warlike and cruel. In
  860. 36:26particular, there is an account of an
  861. 36:28incident where Anat destroys people in
  862. 36:30a rage. And afterwards, having returned
  863. 36:33home, she smashes all the furniture in
  864. 36:35a fit of fury. And thus she is very
  865. 36:38similar to the fierce Hindu goddess
  866. 36:40Kali. Although in other sources her
  867. 36:43image is undoubtedly connected with the
  868. 36:45Moon. And here I simply cannot avoid
  869. 36:48the question regarding the Jewish god
  870. 36:50Yahweh. I believe it is precisely in
  871. 36:54Ugaritic-Phoenician mythology that we
  872. 36:56must look for the moment when Yahweh
  873. 36:58replaced Baal and El. I will provide a
  874. 37:02few quotes from different sources.
  875. 37:04Anat-Yahu is mentioned in the
  876. 37:06Elephantine papyri among the deities
  877. 37:08worshipped by the Jews of Elephantine.
  878. 37:12Given that the chief deity of the
  879. 37:14Elephantine Jews' pantheon was
  880. 37:16Yahweh-Yahu, it is assumed that Anat
  881. 37:18could have been considered his consort,
  882. 37:20which completely contradicts the Old
  883. 37:23Testament, where the almighty creator
  884. 37:25hated any idols of deities created by
  885. 37:27people. Furthermore, in the opinion of
  886. 37:32some researchers, during the transition
  887. 37:34to monotheism, the ancient Jews
  888. 37:36considered Yahweh the only god, yet one
  889. 37:39having a consort. According to some
  890. 37:42sources, for example the Elephantine
  891. 37:45papyri, she was Anat, according to
  892. 37:47others, Asherah. The Old Testament
  893. 37:50mentions the ancient Jews 'worship of
  894. 37:52the Queen of Heaven, against which the
  895. 37:54prophet Jeremiah fought. Among the
  896. 37:58Phoenicians, he was known by the name
  897. 38:00Yau and in the Bible by the name Yehu
  898. 38:02or Yehaweh. He was responsible for the
  899. 38:06sea element and was considered the
  900. 38:08patron of the city of Beirut, where
  901. 38:10texts dedicated to Yau were discovered,
  902. 38:13undoubtedly created under the influence
  903. 38:15of myths about Baal-Hadad, the storm
  904. 38:17god, son of the Ugaritic El. The name
  905. 38:21of the latter passed into Hebrew in a
  906. 38:23common noun form meaning God. And the
  907. 38:26functions of El were absorbed by Yahweh
  908. 38:28. In Palestine, he was considered the
  909. 38:31patron of the ancient Israelite tribal
  910. 38:33union and, likely, the patron of Edom.
  911. 38:36He fights against Yam, the sea, and
  912. 38:39Leviathan and wins the victory. In
  913. 38:42Ugarit and Canaan, Yau was called by
  914. 38:45the name Yam, the sea god defeated in
  915. 38:47the struggle with Baal. Furthermore, in
  916. 38:52Ugaritic ritual prayers, Yau was
  917. 38:54identified with El or called the son of
  918. 38:56El. It is assumed that in the general
  919. 39:00West Semitic pantheon, Yau was the
  920. 39:02master of the water element. Possibly,
  921. 39:05he corresponds to the god Ea in
  922. 39:07Sumerian-Akkadian mythology. And also
  923. 39:10in the Bible, Baal is one of Yahweh's
  924. 39:12main rivals. In Carthage, he was
  925. 39:15worshipped as Baal-Hammon, and in Tyre
  926. 39:17as Melqart. Gideon destroyed his altar,
  927. 39:20for which he received the name
  928. 39:21Jerubbaal. Let Baal contend. The cult
  929. 39:24of Baal-Melqart was fostered in Israel
  930. 39:27by Jezebel, the wife of King Ahab. And
  931. 39:29the prophet Elijah competed with his
  932. 39:31priests on Mount Carmel. Mount Zion is
  933. 39:34identified with Zaphon. The Psalmist
  934. 39:36claims that the thirst of all nations
  935. 39:39for a place on earth where one can
  936. 39:41experience the presence of God is
  937. 39:42fulfilled in Mount Zion, the true
  938. 39:44Zaphon. Baal is deposed from the throne
  939. 39:48, and Yahweh took his place. Perhaps
  940. 39:50the most remarkable case of identifying
  941. 39:53Zion with the cosmic mountain of
  942. 39:55assembly is Psalm 48: 3, where Zion,
  943. 39:57the sacred mountain of Yahweh, is
  944. 39:59called the far north. End of quote. So,
  945. 40:02what do we have? Baal and Yahweh are
  946. 40:05unambiguously rivals. If Baal-Hammon
  947. 40:08and Melqart are one and the same, then
  948. 40:11we understand that Melqart, aka
  949. 40:13Heracles, is unambiguously the sun.
  950. 40:16Especially since the dwelling place of
  951. 40:18God is directly indicated, the world
  952. 40:20mountain Zaphon or Tsapanu. It is
  953. 40:23stated directly that Yahweh threw Baal
  954. 40:25off the throne. And at the same time,
  955. 40:27there is a connection between Yahweh
  956. 40:29and Yam. More detailed texts state that
  957. 40:33the name Yahweh first appears in texts
  958. 40:35no earlier than 1200 BC. However,
  959. 40:40Yahweh does not specifically appear in
  960. 40:42West Semitic sources. This deity came
  961. 40:45to the West Semitic peoples from the
  962. 40:47outside. At one time, the cult of Baal
  963. 40:50and the cult of Yahweh existed hand in
  964. 40:52hand. Yahweh himself is described in
  965. 40:56the Psalms as one of the sons of the
  966. 40:58god El. Then he becomes the greatest of
  967. 41:01the sons, and later absorbs the
  968. 41:03functions of the supreme god Ilu
  969. 41:05himself. Here is another interesting
  970. 41:08point. All the great gods of antiquity
  971. 41:11have epic stories about their battles
  972. 41:13with enemies. Both Baal and the
  973. 41:16Sumerian Marduk have such epics, but
  974. 41:19Yahweh does not. However, the Old
  975. 41:22Testament contains some of the stories
  976. 41:25that are found in Ugaritic, Sumerian,
  977. 41:27and other epics. This may indicate that
  978. 41:31Yahweh is the result of a synthesis of
  979. 41:33several pagan gods. There is also a
  980. 41:37version that the Edomite god Qos, which
  981. 41:39means bow, is a double of Yahweh or one
  982. 41:42of his hypostases. And this could point
  983. 41:45to the solar nature of the deity. After
  984. 41:48all, a bow is primarily a symbol of a
  985. 41:50rainbow. Scientists still cannot say
  986. 41:53for sure which pagan god is the
  987. 41:55prototype of Yahweh. But they have
  988. 42:00found plenty of evidence that, by
  989. 42:02toppling Baal from the world mountain,
  990. 42:04Yahweh absorbed not only his attributes
  991. 42:06but also many functions of the supreme
  992. 42:08god Ilu or El. And when Jewish texts
  993. 42:13were finally codified as the Old
  994. 42:15Testament, the place of the Supreme God
  995. 42:17already belonged to Yahweh. Although,
  996. 42:21if you read the whole Bible, you will
  997. 42:23constantly encounter repetitions and
  998. 42:25contradictions. And the roles of God
  999. 42:27the Father and his son will be
  1000. 42:29constantly intertwined. But in Ugaritic
  1001. 42:32mythology, the roles are clearly
  1002. 42:34defined. Ilu and his consort are the
  1003. 42:37lawmakers, and worldly affairs are
  1004. 42:39ruled by Baal, who is constantly
  1005. 42:41hindered by the enemies of the demonic
  1006. 42:43world. It is clear that many Ugaritic
  1007. 42:46gods could not make it into the Old
  1008. 42:47Testament. For example, the
  1009. 42:49aforementioned goddess Shapash or
  1010. 42:51Shapashu personified the sun in Ugarit.
  1011. 42:55Compare her description with the
  1012. 42:56characteristics of Baal and the Greek
  1013. 42:58Apollo. Shapashu was considered a great
  1014. 43:01mistress. All the stars in the sky were
  1015. 43:04considered her host. She connected
  1016. 43:06heaven with earth. When necessary,
  1017. 43:08Shapashu conveys the will of the
  1018. 43:11supreme god Ilu to all the other gods.
  1019. 43:13She lives in the east and travels from
  1020. 43:15there to the west. When she is in the
  1021. 43:19underworld at night, she communicates
  1022. 43:21with the world of the dead, which
  1023. 43:22allows her to be a source of secret
  1024. 43:24divination and prophecy. That is, in
  1025. 43:28this description of the goddess
  1026. 43:30Shapashu, we see both the oracle of
  1027. 43:32Apollo and Sabaoth, the Lord of the
  1028. 43:34Heavenly Host. Here is another example
  1029. 43:37of the elimination of Ugaritic deities
  1030. 43:39by monotheism. In the pre-Islamic era,
  1031. 43:42the Arabs venerated three daughters of
  1032. 43:44Allah. Allat, Al-Uzza, and Manat.
  1033. 43:48Compare the name Al-Lat with the title
  1034. 43:50of Ilu's wife, which sounded like Ilatu
  1035. 43:53, meaning simply "goddess." Al-Lat is
  1036. 43:56also a goddess in translation from
  1037. 43:59Arabic, but in Ugarit, the god Baal had
  1038. 44:01three daughters: Pidray, Tallay, and
  1039. 44:04Arsay, who symbolized, respectively,
  1040. 44:07heavenly dew, divine light, and the
  1041. 44:09fruitful earth. It is clear that in
  1042. 44:14later times, both in the Arab religion
  1043. 44:16and among the Jews, these characters
  1044. 44:18dissolved into a single deity and
  1045. 44:20ceased to be worshipped separately, as
  1046. 44:22the new religions were exclusively
  1047. 44:24patriarchal, and the role of women in
  1048. 44:26them became very insignificant. Next,
  1049. 44:30despite the fact that we have already
  1050. 44:32mentioned the god of death Mot and the
  1051. 44:34master of the subterranean ocean Yam,
  1052. 44:36there was another god of evil in Ugarit
  1053. 44:38named Rashapu. Among the Semites, he
  1054. 44:41also had the name Resheph, which means
  1055. 44:43lightning or flame. Since his consort
  1056. 44:46was also Baal's wife Anat, one can
  1057. 44:48assume that a formidable hypostasis of
  1058. 44:50a solar deity was hidden under the
  1059. 44:53guise of Resheph. After all, Resheph is
  1060. 44:55, first and foremost, a destroyer, a
  1061. 44:58god of war who sends down plagues. In
  1062. 45:00other religions, he was correlated with
  1063. 45:03Nergal, the lord of the underworld, or
  1064. 45:05with Apollo, striking with his arrows.
  1065. 45:08Rashapu likewise struck down people on
  1066. 45:10earth with his bow. In addition to the
  1067. 45:14main gods, like many other peoples, the
  1068. 45:16Phoenicians and Amorites knew of the
  1069. 45:18existence of minor spirits living
  1070. 45:20between heaven and earth. Among them,
  1071. 45:23as usual, were both evil and good
  1072. 45:25spirits. Therefore, the attitude toward
  1073. 45:28them varied, from worship and
  1074. 45:30sacrifices to fear. So, we have
  1075. 45:33examined the most important gods
  1076. 45:35primarily worshipped in Ugarit. When
  1077. 45:39Ugarit was destroyed, some of these
  1078. 45:41deities remained in Phoenicia, some
  1079. 45:43disappeared, and some acquired a less
  1080. 45:45significant status. This means that the
  1081. 45:48evolution of religion was constantly
  1082. 45:50occurring in this region. The names of
  1083. 45:52the deities also changed. Ilu became El
  1084. 45:55, and Balu became Baal. The role of El
  1085. 45:57in Phoenicia noticeably declined. Baal
  1086. 46:00Shamin took his place. Shamin means sky
  1087. 46:03. It was he who began to be worshipped
  1088. 46:05as the supreme God. And this
  1089. 46:07circumstance may explain what I said
  1090. 46:09earlier about Yahweh. Many researchers
  1091. 46:13say that Yahweh could not have been Yam
  1092. 46:15or Yamm, because Yahweh is a god of
  1093. 46:17thunderstorms, storms, and wind. But in
  1094. 46:21Phoenicia, the aforementioned Baal
  1095. 46:23Shamin, who came to be worshipped more
  1096. 46:25than the god El, was considered a
  1097. 46:27patron of seafaring, that is, he was
  1098. 46:29connected to the sea. It is possible
  1099. 46:32that this is the very moment when
  1100. 46:34Yahweh, under the name Baalshamin,
  1101. 46:36replaced the god El. And in his
  1102. 46:38entourage appeared the moon god Aglibol
  1103. 46:41and the sun god Malak Bel. Malak means
  1104. 46:43king, and the title Bel is already
  1105. 46:45known to us. Thus, this is one more
  1106. 46:48fact to add to the argument that Yahweh
  1107. 46:50could initially have been the god of
  1108. 46:52the subterranean ocean, Yam. If so, it
  1109. 46:56becomes clear why the Jewish Yahweh has
  1110. 46:58so much anger toward people. But this
  1111. 47:01is just a hypothesis. Although, here is
  1112. 47:04another excerpt from Tsirkin's book,
  1113. 47:07quote: "The veneration of Baal-Shamem
  1114. 47:09penetrates into Egypt as well, and
  1115. 47:11Pharaoh Ramesses II says that his heart
  1116. 47:13trembled like Baal in the heavens." In
  1117. 47:17Egypt, they revered Baal,
  1118. 47:19distinguishing him from Baal-Zephon,
  1119. 47:22Baal-Zaphon, and identifying him with
  1120. 47:24their god Seth. End of quote. I
  1121. 47:27understand that it can be confusing,
  1122. 47:29but let's break it down again. In Egypt
  1123. 47:32, the two gods Horus and Seth were
  1124. 47:34adversaries. Horus is the sun; Seth is
  1125. 47:37the god of evil and the desert.
  1126. 47:42Accordingly, if the author writes that
  1127. 47:44the Egyptians distinguished Baal from
  1128. 47:47Baal-Zephon and compared the former to
  1129. 47:49their Seth, then it means they are a
  1130. 47:51dualistic pair similar to Ahura Mazda
  1131. 47:54and Ahriman, Ulgen and Erlik, Yen and
  1132. 47:56Omael. That is, Jesus Christ and Satan.
  1133. 48:02And essentially, if Baal-Zephon
  1134. 48:04defeated Seth and took his place, then
  1135. 48:07today he is the one who became the
  1136. 48:09supreme god of the Jews. However, I
  1137. 48:12came to the same conclusion a long time
  1138. 48:14ago when I made several videos about
  1139. 48:16Yahweh himself. Moving on. One cannot
  1140. 48:19fail to mention one of the most
  1141. 48:21important and revered goddesses of
  1142. 48:23Phoenicia. If in Ugarit it was Anat,
  1143. 48:25the wife and sister of Baal, as well as
  1144. 48:27Yahweh, then among the Phoenicians this
  1145. 48:29role was filled by Astarte. This is the
  1146. 48:33same mother and maiden who had the name
  1147. 48:35Ishtar among the Sumerians. She was
  1148. 48:38worshiped by very many peoples, from
  1149. 48:40Syrians and Palestinians to Egyptians.
  1150. 48:43Phoenicia, in general, was entirely
  1151. 48:45dedicated to this goddess. Family and
  1152. 48:48childbirth, marriage and order. This is
  1153. 48:51what Astarte patronized. Furthermore,
  1154. 48:53Venus was implied under Astarte.
  1155. 48:56Sometimes she was considered a moon
  1156. 48:58goddess, although the Phoenicians had a
  1157. 49:00separate lunar deity. But, in all
  1158. 49:02likelihood, the name Astarte is
  1159. 49:04connected to stars in general. And thus
  1160. 49:08she acquires the title of supreme
  1161. 49:10goddess, managing all the affairs of
  1162. 49:12the Universe, from the stars to human
  1163. 49:14health. It is possible that this
  1164. 49:17transformation is linked to Astarte
  1165. 49:19being endowed with the functions of the
  1166. 49:21second wife of the supreme god El. When
  1167. 49:25the Jews began to implement the idea of
  1168. 49:27monotheism, it was the cults of Astarte
  1169. 49:29and Baal that were subjected to the
  1170. 49:31harshest eradication. After all,
  1171. 49:35according to some myths, Astarte bore
  1172. 49:37seven daughters to the god El, among
  1173. 49:39whom was Tanit, the goddess of the Moon
  1174. 49:42, who later began to push her mother
  1175. 49:44Astarte off the throne. Separately, it
  1176. 49:47must be said that the symbol of Astarte
  1177. 49:49in antiquity was an unhewn stone. It
  1178. 49:52was precisely such a stone that was
  1179. 49:54once revered by pre-Islamic Arabs. And
  1180. 49:57according to some reports, it was
  1181. 49:59precisely Venus and Baal under the name
  1182. 50:01Hubal, which means "good god," that the
  1183. 50:03Arab tribes worshiped in the original
  1184. 50:06Kaaba. Many viewers know that an
  1185. 50:09aerolite stone in a frame of a certain
  1186. 50:11shape is mounted in the corner of the
  1187. 50:13Kaaba. So, Astarte's daughter Tanit was
  1188. 50:17very often depicted as a rhombus, as a
  1189. 50:20figure associated with birth and growth
  1190. 50:22. That is, it is a symbol of the yoni.
  1191. 50:26Another significant deity of Phoenicia
  1192. 50:28became Baal-Hammon. We have already
  1193. 50:30talked about him several times. He also
  1194. 50:33absorbed the functions of various gods.
  1195. 50:35Baal-Hammon is both the sun, the lord
  1196. 50:37of the underworld, and the protector of
  1197. 50:40the earth. In principle, he is another
  1198. 50:43candidate for the role of the later
  1199. 50:45Yahweh, who at a certain point turned
  1200. 50:47into Zeus Ammon. There were other gods
  1201. 50:51in Phoenicia, whom you can learn about
  1202. 50:53on your own by reading Yuli Tsirkin’s
  1203. 50:55book. And at the end of our story, I
  1204. 50:59would like to turn once again to
  1205. 51:01Cosmogony. Next is a quote from
  1206. 51:03Tsirkin’s book. Wind Kolpi and his
  1207. 51:06wife Baau gave birth to Aeon and
  1208. 51:08Protogonus. These were the first mortal
  1209. 51:11humans. They felt hungry. And then Aeon
  1210. 51:15devised a way to gather food from trees
  1211. 51:17. They had a son and a daughter who
  1212. 51:20settled in Phoenicia. These first
  1213. 51:23settlers on the Phoenician coast also
  1214. 51:25became the first sun worshipers. They
  1215. 51:28called him Baal-Shamem, that is, the
  1216. 51:31lord of the heavens. The other children
  1217. 51:33of Aeon and Protogonus were light, fire
  1218. 51:36, and flame. They were the first to rub
  1219. 51:39pieces of wood together and thereby
  1220. 51:41kindle fire. Later, when other mortal
  1221. 51:45humans appeared, they taught them how
  1222. 51:47to do all this. At that time, there
  1223. 51:50were already many women on Earth.
  1224. 51:53Marriage did not exist then. Men and
  1225. 51:56women loved each other freely. End of
  1226. 51:59quote. In this continuation of
  1227. 52:01Phoenician cosmogony, we already see
  1228. 52:03hints of Gnostic teaching. And how
  1229. 52:05could it be otherwise? If the Old
  1230. 52:07Testament itself and, accordingly, the
  1231. 52:09first sprouts of Judaism emerged from
  1232. 52:12Phoenician soil, then Gnostic teaching
  1233. 52:14could not have appeared from nowhere.
  1234. 52:17Its echoes must be sought in the same
  1235. 52:19place. Therefore, Aeon, the female
  1236. 52:22hypostasis, and Protogonus can be
  1237. 52:24viewed as prototypes of the Gnostic
  1238. 52:27Aeon Sophia and her son Yaldabaoth, the
  1239. 52:29demiurge of our universe. Here is what
  1240. 52:33is said about him in the Orphic hymn.
  1241. 52:36Quote: "O Protogonus, two-natured,
  1242. 52:38great, soaring through the ether, you
  1243. 52:40were born from a golden egg,
  1244. 52:42golden-winged race, bellowing like a
  1245. 52:44bull, announcing to the world, blissful
  1246. 52:47progenitor of mountain gods and
  1247. 52:49yearning mortals whose lives are finite
  1248. 52:51. Wondrous seed, sprouted from strong,
  1249. 52:54abundant offspring. Ericapaeus, rushing
  1250. 52:57with a whistle? cutting through the
  1251. 52:59ether. Ineffable, heating the black
  1252. 53:02cloud with a storm, an eternal wanderer
  1253. 53:04who, with the beating of his wings,
  1254. 53:06brings down to earth tangible light,
  1255. 53:08and for that is called the immaculate
  1256. 53:10Phanes. End of quote. So, the Phanes
  1257. 53:14mentioned in the hymn is the demiurge
  1258. 53:16deity in Orphic cosmogony. He is
  1259. 53:19four-eyed, with golden wings, with a
  1260. 53:21snake on his head, and with phallus on
  1261. 53:23his backside. He roars like a lion and
  1262. 53:26lows like a bull. It was Phanes who was
  1263. 53:28called Protogonus, that is, the
  1264. 53:30firstborn or primogenital son. It is
  1265. 53:34Phanes who is the creator and king of
  1266. 53:36all gods and the first people. Then he
  1267. 53:39passes power to the sun, and only later
  1268. 53:41does Zeus absorb the power of
  1269. 53:43Protogonus and create the world. Why
  1270. 53:46does Zeus come after Protogonus?
  1271. 53:49Because Protogonus himself, in the
  1272. 53:51opinion of ancient writers, is not the
  1273. 53:53universe, but only a paradigm or a
  1274. 53:55model for all universes and the cosmos.
  1275. 53:58And a couple more variations of the
  1276. 54:00creation of the world. Quote. But the
  1277. 54:02people of Sidon told the story of the
  1278. 54:04beginning of the universe a little
  1279. 54:06differently. At the beginning of all
  1280. 54:08things were time, passion, and a cloud.
  1281. 54:11Passion and the cloud fell in love, and
  1282. 54:13from them were born air and breath. And
  1283. 54:16from them, the world egg came into
  1284. 54:18existence. When this egg split open,
  1285. 54:21its upper part became the sky, and the
  1286. 54:23lower part the earth. But some thought
  1287. 54:26otherwise. Before the world, they said,
  1288. 54:30there existed ether and air. From them
  1289. 54:33was born Ulom, meaning the age, the
  1290. 54:35embodiment of all-consuming time. But
  1291. 54:37sometimes it was said that two winds
  1292. 54:40were born first: the south and the
  1293. 54:42north, and only then Ulom. The
  1294. 54:44offspring of Ulom were Husor and the
  1295. 54:46world egg. Husor split the egg and from
  1296. 54:50its upper half created the sky, and
  1297. 54:51from the lower half the earth. There is
  1298. 54:54another story as well. In the beginning
  1299. 54:57of all things was the eternal sea,
  1300. 54:59which apparently rose like a dome. And
  1301. 55:02this sea first of all gave birth to
  1302. 55:04Husor. Husor was a mountain, the
  1303. 55:06embodiment of dry land. From the
  1304. 55:08mountain, a world river began to flow,
  1305. 55:11the Great Euphrates. And on the summit
  1306. 55:13of the mountain grew a mighty cedar,
  1307. 55:15the world tree. After this, the sea
  1308. 55:18brought forth seven eggs, from which
  1309. 55:20seven gods came into the world. One of
  1310. 55:23them dove into the sea and emerged from
  1311. 55:25it again as fast as an arrow. And that
  1312. 55:27is why people later called him the
  1313. 55:29arrow. This was the god Resheph, who in
  1314. 55:32Ugarit was also called the lord of
  1315. 55:34arrows. Other gods were the bow, the
  1316. 55:37lightning, and the wreath. There was
  1317. 55:39also another god by the name of day and
  1318. 55:41night, or otherwise, the 24-hour cycle.
  1319. 55:43And in this series of deities, sprung
  1320. 55:46from the seven eggs produced by the sea
  1321. 55:48, were also the lady of the world and a
  1322. 55:50youth, two cosmic beings, the first
  1323. 55:52pair in the world. After this, the
  1324. 55:56wreath descended upon the sea, and it
  1325. 55:58became flat. And then all these gods
  1326. 56:02created the world that exists today,
  1327. 56:04and the sea is still the supreme god.
  1328. 56:08End of quote. So, in summary, we can
  1329. 56:11assume that if the Ugaritic and
  1330. 56:13Phoenician myths are not the prototype
  1331. 56:15for many religions of neighboring
  1332. 56:17peoples, such as the Jews, Egyptians,
  1333. 56:19Greeks, Persians, and Romans, then at
  1334. 56:22the very least they appeared no later
  1335. 56:24than the latter. In the provided
  1336. 56:27passages, one can easily find motifs
  1337. 56:29from the Bible, ancient Greek myths,
  1338. 56:31and myths of the peoples of Europe and
  1339. 56:33Asia. That same god Resheph, who dives
  1340. 56:36to the bottom of the sea, immediately
  1341. 56:39reminds us of the story of the two duck
  1342. 56:41gods, one of which dove to the bottom
  1343. 56:43of the sea in search of Earth. Under
  1344. 56:45the symbols of the lightning, the bow,
  1345. 56:48and the wreath, most likely lie Zeus,
  1346. 56:50Apollo, and Ouroboros or the God Amun.
  1347. 56:53Ether, chaos, the world egg, and the
  1348. 56:55world ocean are generally an integral
  1349. 56:58part of all world religion. Therefore,
  1350. 57:02I am not asserting it, but it is very
  1351. 57:04possible that a large part of the Old
  1352. 57:06Testament was written using Phoenician
  1353. 57:08and Ugaritic mythology. And the Judean
  1354. 57:12god, whose name must not be spoken, was
  1355. 57:15once a rival of the god Baal, the lord
  1356. 57:17of the subterranean ocean or, as stated
  1357. 57:20above, simply the sea. And having
  1358. 57:23concluded a covenant with the Jews, he
  1359. 57:25destroyed the cult of Baal, Astarte,
  1360. 57:28and the supreme god El. absorbing their
  1361. 57:31characteristics and functions. That is
  1362. 57:34how we got the Christian god Yahweh.
  1363. 57:37However, I could be wrong. That is all
  1364. 57:39for now. Be sure to write your thoughts
  1365. 57:42in the comments, and criticize using
  1366. 57:44counterarguments. I wholeheartedly
  1367. 57:46thank the viewers who donate to the
  1368. 57:48life and development of the channel.
  1369. 57:50The card number for donations is under
  1370. 57:52the video. I wish all my viewers health
  1371. 57:55, strength, and peace of mind. All the
  1372. 57:58best and see you again on the channel,
  1373. 58:00Lemky Dwarf.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Боги Финикии и Угарита, родина Библии? by Кыштымский Карлик, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,924 words across 1,373 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.