Наслаждение у Лакана: удовольствие, страдание и повторение в психоанализе — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05When first encountering Lacan's works,
- 0:09it seems that the word "enjoyment"
- 0:12simply denotes intense pleasure. But it
- 0:16soon becomes clear that this isn't
- 0:18quite the case, or even anything but.
- 0:21Lacan's concept of jouissance itself
- 0:25proves to be one of the most complex
- 0:29and important in his entire theory. To
- 0:33begin to understand what jouissance is,
- 0:37it is necessary to distinguish it from
- 0:40pleasure as understood in
- 0:43psychoanalysis. According to Freud, the
- 0:47psychic apparatus, striving for a state
- 0:51of homeostasis, attempts to reduce
- 0:53internal tension. If hunger, thirst,
- 0:58anxiety, or sexual arousal arise, the
- 1:01body seeks a way to restore balance.
- 1:06And when tension decreases, a person
- 1:08experiences pleasure. This is why Freud
- 1:13spoke of the pleasure principle as the
- 1:16psyche's desire to minimize internal
- 1:20arousal. On the other hand, Freud also
- 1:24observed a strange thing that
- 1:26contradicts this principle. People seek
- 1:30pleasure, but not always. Their lives
- 1:34unfold in such a way that they
- 1:37repeatedly find themselves in
- 1:39situations that bring not pleasure, but
- 1:42suffering. They repeat destructive
- 1:45relationships, painful plots,
- 1:48re-enacting traumatic experiences over
- 1:51and over again, as if drawn there by
- 1:54something. This discovery led Freud to
- 1:58the idea of repetition compulsion and
- 2:01later to the concept of the death drive
- 2:03. Lacan goes one step further and says:
- 2:10"There is a special kind of
- 2:13satisfaction that lies beyond the
- 2:16pleasure principle and calls it
- 2:20enjoyment." Enjoyment is possible
- 2:25precisely beyond the pleasure principle
- 2:27. Therefore, it is not pleasure. If the
- 2:32pleasure of excitement limits, then
- 2:35enjoyment, on the contrary, is
- 2:37associated with going beyond this
- 2:40measure. It arises where pleasure
- 2:45ceases to function as a regulator.
- 2:49Enjoyment begins where the subject
- 2:51crosses the boundary established by the
- 2:54pleasure principle. Any pleasure taken
- 2:59to the extreme ceases to be pleasure,
- 3:02but can become enjoyment in its passive
- 3:06form. It is not by chance that we say:
- 3:11"Too sweet," too spicy, too long. Thus,
- 3:16enjoyment in its excess, in relation to
- 3:20pleasure, is almost always associated
- 3:23with pain. It's not at all obvious that
- 3:30people seek suffering for its own sake,
- 3:33but they are inclined to repeat this
- 3:36path, since suffering itself can
- 3:38contain enjoyment, a special
- 3:40satisfaction that the subject is
- 3:43unaware of. But psychoanalysts not only
- 3:47don't exclude this enjoyment, but, on
- 3:50the contrary, always assume it.
- 3:54Therefore, when examining a symptom,
- 3:57they always ask: "What kind of
- 3:59satisfaction does a person derive from
- 4:03it?" This question seems strange.
- 4:06Indeed, what kind of satisfaction can
- 4:09one derive from insomnia, panic attacks
- 4:12, or constant conflicts? But for Lacan,
- 4:15everything is clear, because it is not
- 4:18a question of pleasure, but of
- 4:20enjoyment through a symptom. A symptom
- 4:25not only causes suffering, but also
- 4:28provides the subject with a special way
- 4:31to deal with desire, anxiety, and
- 4:34internal conflicts. Therefore, it is
- 4:39not simply an illness to be eliminated,
- 4:42but a formation of the unconscious that
- 4:45, on the one hand, performs a specific
- 4:47function, and on the other, provides a
- 4:50strange, painful enjoyment. This
- 4:54explains why symptoms are so difficult
- 4:57to eliminate. In a certain sense, a
- 5:00neurotic symptom is a way to enjoy the
- 5:03unconscious. It sounds almost
- 5:07paradoxical, but if you look closely,
- 5:10you'll find numerous examples. One
- 5:13constantly complains about their job,
- 5:16but nothing changes for years and
- 5:18decades. Another endlessly talks about
- 5:22their partner's injustice, but chooses
- 5:25similar relationships again. A third
- 5:29constantly finds herself in the role of
- 5:32victim, as if there's something that
- 5:35keeps each of them in this place. This
- 5:40something is pleasure. But it's
- 5:44important to understand that pleasure
- 5:47is never a free choice. This repetition
- 5:51is orchestrated by the unconscious. A
- 5:54person doesn't say to themselves, "I
- 5:56want to suffer, and I will suffer."
- 5:58Consciously, they usually try to get
- 6:02rid of their symptoms, especially when
- 6:05they stop working. And this is, in fact
- 6:09, what people bring to psychotherapy
- 6:11and psychoanalysis. But the analyst
- 6:14understands that by complaining about
- 6:17their symptoms, the subject is actually
- 6:19complaining about their pleasure.
- 6:24Therefore, analysis is not limited to
- 6:27rational explanations, much less advice
- 6:30, but is focused on discovering the
- 6:33individual's way of enjoying the
- 6:35pleasure hidden within the symptoms.
- 6:40The most important property of pleasure
- 6:42is that it is connected to the body.
- 6:46Yes, the unconscious is an effect of
- 6:49the language and space of signifiers,
- 6:52which are often rather bizarrely and
- 6:56illogically organized as thoughts,
- 6:59memories, fantasies, but the signifier
- 7:02always leaves a trace on the body,
- 7:05which alone can enjoy. Symptoms,
- 7:11psychosomatic phenomena, obsessive
- 7:14behaviors, bodily tensions, sleep
- 7:17disturbances, certain forms of anxiety
- 7:20—including the way the body enjoys
- 7:23itself. In his later teachings, Lacan
- 7:29no longer speaks so much of the
- 7:31Freudian symptom organized through
- 7:34signifiers, but rather of the symptom
- 7:36and the pleasure associated with it, as
- 7:39a bodily event. The question of why a
- 7:44person is drawn, practically condemned
- 7:47to the search for pleasure associated
- 7:50with pain and repetition, is certainly
- 7:53not simple. This is one of the effects
- 7:56of the emergence of a speaking being,
- 7:59which, following Lacan, we will
- 8:01carefully examine in our course.
- 8:05Developing the concept and theory of
- 8:07pleasure, the late Lacan takes another
- 8:10step. While previously jouissance was
- 8:16viewed primarily as something forbidden
- 8:19, arising from law, he later spoke of a
- 8:23multiplicity of jouissances, which
- 8:26Jacqueline Miller then reduced to six
- 8:29paradigms of jouissance. Thus, Lacan
- 8:34distinguishes between phallic
- 8:36jouissance and what he calls the other.
- 8:41Jouissance. Phallic jouissance is
- 8:45linked to language, signifying
- 8:48limitations and law. That is, it can be
- 8:53reproduced as a practice. It is this
- 8:57that organizes subjects 'everyday lives
- 9:00. The other jouissance, however, is not
- 9:05entirely subject to the symbolic order,
- 9:09and therefore cannot be predicted or
- 9:12fully described in words. It cannot be
- 9:16fully narrated. The subject can only
- 9:20bear witness to it, but is incapable of
- 9:23making it a fully-fledged object of
- 9:26knowledge. Lacan associates the other
- 9:30jouissance with the feminine position,
- 9:33but this is precisely a structural
- 9:36position in relation to jouissance, so
- 9:39it cannot be said that it is accessible
- 9:42only to women. Of course, it is
- 9:45impossible to reveal the full
- 9:46complexity of Lacan's concept of
- 9:48jouissance in a few minutes. We have
- 9:51only outlined the basic guidelines. How
- 9:54does jouissance differ from pleasure?
- 9:57Why is it connected to repetition, the
- 10:00symptom, and the body? And why does it
- 10:03occupy a special place in Lacan's later
- 10:06teaching? If you're interested in
- 10:10delving deeper into this, understanding
- 10:13how the concept of jouissance evolved
- 10:16throughout Lacan's seminars, what folic
- 10:20and other feminine jouissances are,
- 10:23what the object is, what surplus
- 10:26jouissance, the bodily event, and how
- 10:29all these concepts work in clinical
- 10:32practice, I invite you to our course.
- 10:36Step by step, we'll follow Lacan's
- 10:39construction of his theory of
- 10:41jouissance. We'll turn to key seminars
- 10:45and texts and try to see how these
- 10:49ideas allow us to rethink the symptom,
- 10:53desire, and the work of psychoanalysis
- 10:57itself. Yeah.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Наслаждение у Лакана: удовольствие, страдание и повторение в психоанализе by LACANOD: психоанализ Жака Лакана, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 1,152 words across 195 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.