YouTube2Text

放送作家はAIによって失業するか【第92回 日本未来会議】 — Transcript

by 日本未来会議 · 5,096 words · 895 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Will broadcast writers go into business
  2. 0:03with AI? The
  3. 0:03era in which program producers create
  4. 0:05programs by bouncing ideas off each
  5. 0:07other with AI is,
  6. 0:08well, like a shut-in. I don't think
  7. 0:10it's possible to leave everything to
  8. 0:11this guy alone. If
  9. 0:13talented people use AI, it can be a
  10. 0:16powerful force. It can really break
  11. 0:20down why it's interesting. Japan's
  12. 0:29Future. This program is brought to you
  13. 0:32by the sponsors you see here. Here we
  14. 0:36go. Japan Future Conference. Today, we
  15. 0:40have Osan as our guest again, following
  16. 0:43last week. Thank you for having me.
  17. 0:47Thank you for having me.
  18. 0:49Sorry. No,
  19. 0:50not at all. So, Kisan, what should we
  20. 0:52talk about today?
  21. 0:53Yes. Since you asked Osan, will
  22. 0:56broadcast writers go into business with
  23. 0:58AI?
  24. 1:00Yes. The
  25. 1:04evolution of generative AI is shaking
  26. 1:06up the creative scene. AI can now
  27. 1:11instantly create research, plans, and
  28. 1:14scripts. While some say that AI cannot
  29. 1:19understand human emotions or humor, AI
  30. 1:21can learn from vast amounts of data and
  31. 1:23generate countless ideas at low cost.
  32. 1:28Will broadcast writers 'jobs be taken
  33. 1:30over by AI? This will
  34. 1:33100%disappear.
  35. 1:34Oh, who's
  36. 1:37objecting here?
  37. 1:39But, these days, a lot of the main work
  38. 1:41of a broadcast writer is writing
  39. 1:43material for YouTubers. Yes. Yes. I
  40. 1:47think that's pretty big.
  41. 1:48So, that's fine. It's the same with the
  42. 1:51Yasuma program and things like that,
  43. 1:53but can I include all of that as a
  44. 1:55broadcast writer?
  45. 1:56Okay,
  46. 1:56all of it. Will the job of a broadcast
  47. 1:59writer disappear due to AI?
  48. 2:01Those who think it will disappear are
  49. 2:03in favor, and those who don't think it
  50. 2:05will disappear are against.
  51. 2:06So, what is the job of a broadcast
  52. 2:08writer? Simply put, it's to be a mentor
  53. 2:12to TV station producers and directors.
  54. 2:15Oh.
  55. 2:16Yeah. Their main
  56. 2:19job is to work with TV station
  57. 2:21producers and directors and, um, give
  58. 2:23them advice.
  59. 2:28My job is to give advice to
  60. 2:30Noguchi-san's work and improve the
  61. 2:32level of Nono's work. When it comes to
  62. 2:34broadcast works...
  63. 2:35That's right. Now, everyone, please
  64. 2:37submit your opinions at once.
  65. 2:39Who said they objected? Everyone said
  66. 2:41they
  67. 2:43objected. Yes. Yeah, that's
  68. 2:46amazing.
  69. 2:47First, let's start with Kanefuji-san,
  70. 2:49who is in favor.
  71. 2:50Yes. So, in today's terms, it's like a
  72. 2:53program producer, or rather, a writer,
  73. 2:55and I think the time is coming when a
  74. 2:57program producer of this standing
  75. 2:59position will bounce ideas off AI and
  76. 3:01create something. And if, for example,
  77. 3:03Suzuki O-san, who really relies on
  78. 3:05people, were still a broadcast writer,
  79. 3:08I think Suzuki Dai-san would just
  80. 3:10become a producer.
  81. 3:11Yeah. That's what we
  82. 3:12should do.
  83. 3:13Yeah. So I think the job of a writer
  84. 3:16will simply disappear.
  85. 3:19Now, let's start with Aochanpe. It's
  86. 3:23been said that AI is like an introvert,
  87. 3:25but I also update my TikTok every day.
  88. 3:27And I'm at a loss for material. So I
  89. 3:29try to throw information at AI and have
  90. 3:31it come up with something, but the
  91. 3:32material I come up with exactly as AI
  92. 3:34says it doesn't usually go viral. Why
  93. 3:36is that? It's like when everyone's
  94. 3:38having a great time and someone in the
  95. 3:39background thinks something funny and
  96. 3:41throws it out, and everyone goes silent
  97. 3:43. It's like a LINE message that's just
  98. 3:45a little bit boring, or something
  99. 3:46that's a little off. It's like it's 1mm
  100. 3:50off the mark. So even if you can have
  101. 3:54AI create bashing, you still need to
  102. 3:55make some changes to it or have someone
  103. 3:57with a good sense examine it. So I
  104. 4:01think that AI is like a shadowy figure,
  105. 4:03and it's impossible to leave everything
  106. 4:05to it alone. I think it's impossible
  107. 4:08for it to take over all the work that
  108. 4:09humans do. That might be
  109. 4:11true for current AI, but AI is
  110. 4:13constantly evolving, so I wonder if it
  111. 4:15will
  112. 4:16surpass it at some point. I don't
  113. 4:18know what the future holds, but my
  114. 4:20current opinion is this. Yes.
  115. 4:22I wrote that Suzuki O will never
  116. 4:24disappear, but I've actually been
  117. 4:26watching Suzuki O's YouTube videos for
  118. 4:28a long time now, and I've seen
  119. 4:30episodes where his passion for
  120. 4:31producing programs is just too much,
  121. 4:33like a crazy tool. When you have
  122. 4:37someone with such crazy passion who
  123. 4:39leads the show without rest, the people
  124. 4:41around them are influenced and the show
  125. 4:42ends up being great. AI can't do that.
  126. 4:48Of course, aside from Masono's skills
  127. 4:50and talent as a broadcast writer, his
  128. 4:52crazy passion and insane talent make
  129. 4:54people think, "If that person is
  130. 4:55working so hard, then we should too."
  131. 5:00The other actors, including the filming
  132. 5:02producers, get on board, and the
  133. 5:03passion for the program builds up,
  134. 5:05resulting in a great program that
  135. 5:07doesn't really go viral with AI. That's
  136. 5:11why I think broadcast writers with
  137. 5:13insane talent like Suzuki-san can still
  138. 5:15survive. He's had it for a long time.
  139. 5:17So many of them have been around for a
  140. 5:18long time? I see. It's not
  141. 5:21just me, but even people who aren't
  142. 5:23broadcast writers.
  143. 5:24For example, Terry Ito is like that.
  144. 5:26Yeah. That's right, but even people
  145. 5:28like Kataoka-san, who I worked with on
  146. 5:30the Tamecha series, and even
  147. 5:32celebrities, if they didn't have insane
  148. 5:34talent, they wouldn't have been
  149. 5:36successful. Yeah.
  150. 5:37Yeah.
  151. 5:37Oh, I see.
  152. 5:38Yeah.
  153. 5:39Nihon Mirai hasn't gone viral yet.
  154. 5:41Maybe it's because Yoki-kun isn't crazy
  155. 5:43.
  156. 5:43No, we're all struggling. It's true
  157. 5:46that Noguchi-san is
  158. 5:47crazy about the land and we are the
  159. 5:48ones who are being targeted and going
  160. 5:50crazy, but the
  161. 5:50organizer is crazy. It's not good for
  162. 5:52the organizer to be crazy. It's
  163. 5:54enthusiasm.
  164. 5:54Yeah. That's
  165. 5:55true.
  166. 5:56Now, Okada-san, please.
  167. 5:58I didn't know that, but if you said it
  168. 6:00was a mentor, then that means that if
  169. 6:02it becomes AI, then everything from the
  170. 6:04producer to everything else will
  171. 6:06definitely be unnecessary. That's
  172. 6:08my opinion, though.
  173. 6:09Yes. So, even if it can come up with
  174. 6:13small ideas, it's probably impossible
  175. 6:16to fill the gap of moving people's
  176. 6:17hearts, and that's where AI's
  177. 6:19limitations will continue forever. I
  178. 6:21don't think it can
  179. 6:22move people's hearts, as Yoi-kun
  180. 6:24mentioned earlier. It doesn't seem like
  181. 6:26AI will be able to do that in the next
  182. 6:28five years or so. Ultimately, it comes
  183. 6:30down to the fun of learning, and the
  184. 6:32real fun is that people who can capture
  185. 6:34the times are the ones who have never
  186. 6:35done it before, and they think, "What's
  187. 6:37this guy?" It's the same with Terry, or
  188. 6:40Egashira, who seems to be oversleeping,
  189. 6:42and then when they finish one round,
  190. 6:44everyone starts to like them. That's
  191. 6:47something that AI can't create, and
  192. 6:49only humans can create. Well, it's the
  193. 6:53same with performers and broadcast
  194. 6:55producers.
  195. 6:55Yeah. Now, if you
  196. 6:57ask AI about Zos on this stage, it
  197. 6:59won't do it. Because it would probably
  198. 7:01say, "This way, this way, this way."
  199. 7:03Hmm.
  200. 7:04Most commentators are against this,
  201. 7:06right? But Suzuki-san, no, you have to
  202. 7:09practice. You can say, "You'll lose to
  203. 7:11Air, so kick it." I think this is the
  204. 7:13greatness of humans, and it's
  205. 7:14not about probability theory. So, do
  206. 7:18humans want this AI to be more complete
  207. 7:20and beautiful? I like Toshihiko
  208. 7:25Tahara's slightly off-kilter singing,
  209. 7:27and I
  210. 7:28like the annoying way he always hits
  211. 7:30fly balls even though he's the fourth
  212. 7:31batter for the Giants. I think that
  213. 7:36humans will probably continue to seek
  214. 7:38that kind of human-like imperfect
  215. 7:40difference and incomplete system until
  216. 7:42the very end, but if even broadcasting
  217. 7:44is controlled by AI, humans will lose
  218. 7:46everything. Cheers.
  219. 7:51I have a completely different opinion,
  220. 7:52but I think that AI's level won't reach
  221. 7:54that level. That's also because, in the
  222. 7:57end, the main AI in the US and China,
  223. 7:59which is open AI, is weak in Japanese.
  224. 8:01AI. I run a translation company. When I
  225. 8:03was working at a
  226. 8:04translation company, I thought that
  227. 8:06translation work would disappear due to
  228. 8:07AI. On the
  229. 8:08contrary, it's increased. Yeah. Yeah.
  230. 8:10It
  231. 8:10can't even translate. AI is already the
  232. 8:13easiest, but that's not
  233. 8:14good enough. Japanese is too difficult,
  234. 8:17so as long as it's Japanese, it won't
  235. 8:19reach that level. It would be
  236. 8:20different if AI could create an AI
  237. 8:22unique to Japan. But there's not a
  238. 8:24single AI unique to Japan right now, so
  239. 8:26it still can't translate.
  240. 8:27Right now, it's not that big of a deal.
  241. 8:29Yes. I wonder if AI will improve that
  242. 8:32much.
  243. 8:32No, it will surpass humans.
  244. 8:34No, in Japanese.
  245. 8:36Yeah. Because it can do it in Japanese.
  246. 8:38It's
  247. 8:38Japanese logic, so in the end, it's
  248. 8:40definitely possible. 100%possible.
  249. 8:43No, I don't think I can do that. If
  250. 8:47you were still working as a broadcast
  251. 8:48writer, how would you use AI in your
  252. 8:50work? Basically, as a consultant. I've
  253. 8:56been listening to this opinion for a
  254. 8:58long time, but first of all, what is an
  255. 9:00important point? What is a broadcast
  256. 9:01writer?
  257. 9:02Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And
  258. 9:05Japan used to have a lot of writers.
  259. 9:07Yeah. Yeah.
  260. 9:08Yeah. That's partly because there was
  261. 9:11money to spare when it came to TV,
  262. 9:13but first of all, there were a lot of
  263. 9:15writers, and then at some point, when I
  264. 9:17was watching YouTubers, for example,
  265. 9:19when Mizutamari Bond became popular,
  266. 9:21Mizutamari Bond's Katou would have
  267. 9:23definitely become a broadcast writer in
  268. 9:25the past.
  269. 9:27So I thought at some point that people
  270. 9:28who become broadcast writers are
  271. 9:30becoming YouTubers.
  272. 9:31So if I were a high school student at
  273. 9:33that time, I think I would definitely
  274. 9:34have become a YouTuber. But it's
  275. 9:40interesting, and TV stations really
  276. 9:41hate it when you try to take a look.
  277. 9:43Like, "Oh, you've reached this level?"
  278. 9:45Yeah.
  279. 9:46For example, if I, a broadcast writer,
  280. 9:48could talk on the radio. They'd say
  281. 9:50things like, "What are you doing,
  282. 9:51you're just a broadcast writer?" For
  283. 9:53example, if I were to do something like
  284. 9:55a producer or direct, which is fine
  285. 9:57with me doing radio, people at TV
  286. 9:59stations would really hate it.
  287. 10:01Yeah.
  288. 10:01That was the trend back then. Yeah.
  289. 10:03That's why
  290. 10:05I really hate that culture in Japan.
  291. 10:08Yeah. Yeah.
  292. 10:09Literature, for example. I really
  293. 10:12hate the feeling that in literature,
  294. 10:14you're supposed to do this kind of work
  295. 10:15, but in Japan in particular, I feel
  296. 10:17like that's more the case than the
  297. 10:19media. That's why when Abe started, I
  298. 10:24asked him to let me call myself a
  299. 10:26director or producer.
  300. 10:29Yeah. I thought that wasn't what I was
  301. 10:33doing. That's why I
  302. 10:37thought the culture of really hating
  303. 10:39people who tried to step out of the
  304. 10:41role of a broadcast writer was so
  305. 10:43ridiculous. So if producers and
  306. 10:48directors are really good, they're
  307. 10:50really not needed.
  308. 10:51Yeah. I
  309. 10:52think the number of people in that
  310. 10:53field will gradually decrease.
  311. 10:54Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, when the number
  312. 10:57of people decreases, let's say someone
  313. 10:58like Mr. Kyūkyoku Akira is in his
  314. 11:0020s, and he has the ability to act.
  315. 11:03Oh, and he also has the composition
  316. 11:05skills. If someone like that uses AI,
  317. 11:07it's the
  318. 11:08best. I
  319. 11:09see. I see.
  320. 11:10Since last year, I had to do a drama no
  321. 11:12matter what, and when I was asked to do
  322. 11:14it, I decided to
  323. 11:16study AI as motivation to do dramas.
  324. 11:19Oh. So, first, I had AI read all of my
  325. 11:23past drama scripts, and I came to a
  326. 11:26conclusion. No, that's
  327. 11:29exactly what I said earlier, TikTok
  328. 11:3501 isn't that interesting right now.
  329. 11:37Yeah.
  330. 11:38But what you think is super interesting
  331. 11:40isn't necessarily the right answer.
  332. 11:44So, AI is really useful for increasing
  333. 11:46the success rate when you think it's
  334. 11:48super interesting. Oh, I see.
  335. 11:55So, when I think about what would be
  336. 11:57the best way to ask this, I know it's
  337. 11:59really
  338. 12:00annoying, but I'll write all the
  339. 12:02scripts that are perfect. Yeah.
  340. 12:04Yeah. Yeah. When you
  341. 12:05write something that's perfect, you
  342. 12:07praise it a lot, right? He
  343. 12:09praises her a lot. Like, "That's great.
  344. 12:11" And then he
  345. 12:11compliments her, but he also asks her
  346. 12:13to tell him her
  347. 12:14weaknesses.
  348. 12:14Yeah. And
  349. 12:16then she tells him. But she only
  350. 12:20vaguely understands them, and
  351. 12:24people don't really understand the
  352. 12:25structure of what they find interesting
  353. 12:27. I see.
  354. 12:30But then she breaks down the reasons
  355. 12:31why something is interesting.
  356. 12:33Yeah. I see. And when
  357. 12:35that happens, I realize, "Oh, this is
  358. 12:37why my writing is interesting." I get
  359. 12:41it.
  360. 12:41Yeah. And then I
  361. 12:44realized that I was doing a drama about
  362. 12:46competing with AI, and I had the
  363. 12:48actions of that crazy woman appear, but
  364. 12:50mine were way more interesting. The
  365. 12:55thoughts are interesting, but the
  366. 12:56motivations behind those actions and
  367. 12:58things like that are pretty annoying to
  368. 12:59write about in a drama, right?
  369. 13:01Yeah. Yeah. She's really good at
  370. 13:03getting assistance with things like
  371. 13:05that, or conversations over lunch
  372. 13:07before something happens. I see.
  373. 13:13So, what's
  374. 13:16interesting is that I think of myself
  375. 13:18as a human right now, and if
  376. 13:22talented people use AI, yeah.
  377. 13:26It's a great help to me.
  378. 13:28Yeah. And
  379. 13:31recently, there's been a movement where
  380. 13:33some really talented business owners in
  381. 13:35their 50s are working behind the scenes
  382. 13:37to
  383. 13:39create a lot of apps using AI.
  384. 13:42Oh. And they
  385. 13:43have experience in creating apps that
  386. 13:44they wanted to create, so yeah.
  387. 13:46I see. I see. They're really good.
  388. 13:48When I watch them, I see that when they
  389. 13:49lease apps without revealing their
  390. 13:51names, they often become hits.
  391. 13:53I think AI is incredibly useful for
  392. 13:55people with that kind of experience.
  393. 13:58Like I said earlier, if you say, "Just
  394. 14:00use TikTok," I can tell that it's not
  395. 14:02interesting, but if you say, "I'm
  396. 14:04really good at this, but I think this
  397. 14:06is a viral hit," I'm good at thinking
  398. 14:08about the reasons.
  399. 14:09Yeah. Oh. And there's
  400. 14:11something I find really interesting.
  401. 14:13When you search, yeah.
  402. 14:14If
  403. 14:14something doesn't exist, it won't come
  404. 14:16up. Yeah. Yeah.
  405. 14:17Hmm. There
  406. 14:18really aren't any really hits in the
  407. 14:20world, right?
  408. 14:21So, I see. There aren't any that aren't
  409. 14:24hits right now.
  410. 14:24It doesn't
  411. 14:25come up when you search for it. I see.
  412. 14:27I see. I see.
  413. 14:29But when something hits, it comes up a
  414. 14:30lot.
  415. 14:31Yeah. Yeah.
  416. 14:32So, that Money Tigers was started by
  417. 14:35Mr. Kurehara from Nippon Television and
  418. 14:37Mr. Horie from Hososaka, and I was on
  419. 14:39the show from the beginning, but
  420. 14:41now, for example, interesting investors
  421. 14:44come up a lot, but back then, they
  422. 14:46didn't need interesting investors, so
  423. 14:48they didn't
  424. 14:49come up on the internet at that time.
  425. 14:53So even if there was some content that
  426. 14:55would be a huge hit next year or so, it
  427. 14:57probably wouldn't come up now, which
  428. 14:59means that even AI can't think of it,
  429. 15:01so I
  430. 15:05think the profession of broadcast
  431. 15:06writer will definitely become
  432. 15:07unnecessary in the future. Yeah.
  433. 15:10Money is going down, and when you
  434. 15:12watch YouTube, you can see that if you
  435. 15:14can think of content,
  436. 15:17create it, and perform it, that's the
  437. 15:19best, but I think it's becoming more
  438. 15:20and more a genre race. Yeah. It's
  439. 15:23becoming
  440. 15:23more and more like it doesn't matter
  441. 15:25whether it's a performer or a defter. I
  442. 15:28think Mr. was the one who started that.
  443. 15:31But I feel like there will be more and
  444. 15:33more people like that, and Nishino's
  445. 15:35producer-like
  446. 15:37actions are pretty amazing, aren't they
  447. 15:39? But aren't there a lot of people who
  448. 15:41say things like, "It's annoying when
  449. 15:43Nishino does things like that?" But
  450. 15:45yeah. I
  451. 15:46think that's because he's so talented.
  452. 15:48Yeah. So in
  453. 15:52that sense, I think AI can't do the
  454. 15:54things that humans can think of right
  455. 15:56now, or the things that we find really
  456. 15:58interesting, but one thing is that when
  457. 16:00talented people create interesting
  458. 16:01things, they become really good at
  459. 16:03Reuters. But the job of a broadcast
  460. 16:11writer is really like that, and I think
  461. 16:13that if producers, directors, and
  462. 16:15performers use AI, they'll be the best.
  463. 16:20And I don't think they can edit things
  464. 16:22right now. Yeah. As far as
  465. 16:24I know, for example, if you take some
  466. 16:26footage and
  467. 16:28tell them to edit the footage like this
  468. 16:29, they won't do it.
  469. 16:31But I think they'll be able to do that
  470. 16:33in about a year. I'm sure there's a
  471. 16:35future where they'll be able to do it.
  472. 16:36And I think it'll happen surprisingly
  473. 16:38quickly. That's why I think it would be
  474. 16:41amazing if AI could also help ordinary
  475. 16:43people edit videos. Isn't editing the
  476. 16:47biggest concern for YouTubers these
  477. 16:49days?
  478. 16:49After all, YouTubers and others find
  479. 16:51editing a hassle, and once their videos
  480. 16:53become popular, they stop doing it, and
  481. 16:54then they end up arguing with the
  482. 16:56editors about how much money to share.
  483. 17:00That's a very common occurrence. But
  484. 17:03editing is really a hassle, so if AI
  485. 17:05were to do it, it would be another huge
  486. 17:07revolution. And then there's
  487. 17:14manga.
  488. 17:15Yeah.
  489. 17:15Manga can be written based on a certain
  490. 17:17proposal to some extent.
  491. 17:19Manga seems difficult. Manga itself can
  492. 17:22be written regardless of whether it's
  493. 17:23interesting or not. But as I mentioned
  494. 17:26earlier about translation, I heard that
  495. 17:28reading manga is extremely difficult.
  496. 17:31Huh? And that's
  497. 17:33because, for example, if Luffy punches
  498. 17:35someone, they'll fly 10 meters. That's
  499. 17:39not a theory. It's a collection of
  500. 17:42feelings. I think that's why
  501. 17:45I have the most difficulty translating
  502. 17:47manga. There are a lot of syllables and
  503. 17:50syllables.
  504. 17:55Yeah.
  505. 17:58I've heard that it's quite difficult to
  506. 18:00understand the words because of the
  507. 18:02images. That's why I can understand the
  508. 18:07nuances in the translation of manga and
  509. 18:10words. For example, when I write a
  510. 18:13script, there are times when the
  511. 18:15Japanese is strange and I wonder, "Why
  512. 18:16is this?" There's no reason why it's
  513. 18:19like this.
  514. 18:20Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
  515. 18:21But when I put it through AI, it just
  516. 18:23fixes it.
  517. 18:23Yeah.
  518. 18:24Yeah. And sometimes it says, "This is
  519. 18:26wrong." That's what I find interesting.
  520. 18:31Right now, I'm probably really bad at
  521. 18:33understanding things that are based on
  522. 18:35human sensibilities, but
  523. 18:39I don't know if it's just a matter of
  524. 18:41time.
  525. 18:41Yeah. This is just one thing, but I
  526. 18:44think the job of a broadcast writer is
  527. 18:46going to disappear. In the past,
  528. 18:49broadcast writers were given more
  529. 18:51recognition on TV shows, but I
  530. 18:54think the TV station people probably
  531. 18:56found it a bit annoying. In
  532. 18:58the past, broadcast writers were listed
  533. 19:00first in the credits, but at
  534. 19:02some point, the TV station people
  535. 19:03started appearing in front.
  536. 19:05Yeah. Yeah.
  537. 19:06That's because the TV station people's
  538. 19:07desire to be witnesses has gradually
  539. 19:08grown stronger. I think they're
  540. 19:11starting to think that broadcast soccer
  541. 19:13is nothing. The fact that there are
  542. 19:16quite a few people who think that way
  543. 19:18means that they're going to die out. I
  544. 19:19see. I'll tell you the inside story.
  545. 19:21Oshi. Hey, why is Suzuki-san
  546. 19:24such a big name, but he doesn't show
  547. 19:26any interest at all?
  548. 19:27What do you mean, "he doesn't show
  549. 19:29interest"?
  550. 19:29Well, actually,
  551. 19:30some big names have come. Like Horiemon
  552. 19:32. Yeah. He's really showing interest.
  553. 19:34Yeah. He's a nasty guy.
  554. 19:36Just a little bit.
  555. 19:37Oh, I get it. I get it. There are
  556. 19:41people who do things that you wouldn't
  557. 19:42do to someone who's your superior, and
  558. 19:44I get annoyed when they do that, but
  559. 19:46when they do that, I have zero
  560. 19:50respect for them.
  561. 19:51I've
  562. 19:52become a huge fan. Yeah.
  563. 19:55Thank you. But even now, even though
  564. 19:59they said they'd stopped doing
  565. 20:01broadcasts, and they're currently doing
  566. 20:03stage plays, they still love their job
  567. 20:09as broadcast writers. Broadcast writers
  568. 20:12love their jobs, but isn't it a
  569. 20:14different story when they disappear?
  570. 20:17Yeah.
  571. 20:18So I think we need to be strict about
  572. 20:19that.
  573. 20:20Yeah. I think we need to show them love
  574. 20:22, and when
  575. 20:24young people, and not just young people
  576. 20:27, have these kinds of opinions, I think
  577. 20:29, "Oh, I see."
  578. 20:32Yeah. I think so too.
  579. 20:34Esa is funny and really annoying,
  580. 20:38but even annoying opinions stay in your
  581. 20:40mind. I get it.
  582. 20:41No, it's not. I
  583. 20:43think, "What the heck is this?" But
  584. 20:45it's true that they stay in your mind.
  585. 20:49That's young. Their
  586. 20:50ideas are
  587. 20:52incredibly flexible. People who have
  588. 20:56achieved some level of success tend to
  589. 20:57cling to that, or rather, they've
  590. 20:59always had this power, but they're also
  591. 21:01learning a lot of new things.
  592. 21:03Yeah.
  593. 21:04Yeah. That's
  594. 21:05amazing. I really don't
  595. 21:07know what's going to happen next year.
  596. 21:09For example, what are you doing? What
  597. 21:11do you do for work? I'm on
  598. 21:12YouTube and in management.
  599. 21:14Yeah. So, for example, next year, with
  600. 21:16all sorts of things happening, it could
  601. 21:18be the seeds of an incredibly huge
  602. 21:20company.
  603. 21:23Yeah. Yeah.
  604. 21:24Yeah. And then, something happens, like
  605. 21:27when she starts using TikTok, and it
  606. 21:30could go viral.
  607. 21:32But it really could happen.
  608. 21:33Yeah.
  609. 21:34Yeah. After all, a song by UoKushion
  610. 21:37from 14 years ago could suddenly go
  611. 21:39viral worldwide, isn't it?
  612. 21:42That's right.
  613. 21:42So what are you doing now that you're
  614. 21:44over 50, Igu?
  615. 21:45Oh, yeah, designing and stuff. But what
  616. 21:48you're doing now is amazing. Maybe the
  617. 21:52moment you decide to do something new,
  618. 21:54there's a non-zero chance that
  619. 21:55something big will happen. So I've seen
  620. 22:01a lot of people suddenly become
  621. 22:02successful in a year, or entrepreneurs,
  622. 22:04and they came to me with their
  623. 22:05computers and said, "I want to explain
  624. 22:07this to you." When I opened my computer
  625. 22:11, I
  626. 22:11thought it was about the business I
  627. 22:13wanted to run, but it said, "I want to
  628. 22:14be a great person." Yes.
  629. 22:16But,
  630. 22:16yes. And then, after
  631. 22:18starting their business, they were
  632. 22:20doing really well in about two years.
  633. 22:22Yeah. Huh.
  634. 22:23But people who have that kind of pain,
  635. 22:25yes. Right. That's what I
  636. 22:27said was a crazy tool, and that's
  637. 22:28exactly what's important.
  638. 22:30When you get passionate about something
  639. 22:32and start
  640. 22:33moving forward, your current situation
  641. 22:35can change in three months. Yeah. So
  642. 22:40why are there so many young people like
  643. 22:42that? Well, there are
  644. 22:44really moments when miracles happen.
  645. 22:47Hmm, hmm, yeah.
  646. 22:48I've seen
  647. 22:49that happen over and over again, so I
  648. 22:51see. Well, including in the
  649. 22:53entertainment industry, I think I'd
  650. 22:55rank pretty high in the rankings of
  651. 22:57miracles I've seen. So I really
  652. 22:59believe in miracles. I
  653. 23:00believe in miracles. I
  654. 23:02want to believe in miracles.
  655. 23:05That's why when I made the program, I
  656. 23:07said I wanted to believe in miracles,
  657. 23:09but that only applies to people who
  658. 23:10seem like they could create miracles. I
  659. 23:14just feel like it would be a sin for us
  660. 23:16not to do it for people who seem like
  661. 23:17they could create miracles. It might be
  662. 23:21interesting if I told them to say this,
  663. 23:23but I want to see things that I've
  664. 23:24never seen before. It's not about
  665. 23:27creating it myself, it's about the
  666. 23:28future of everyone here today. The
  667. 23:30future will actually turn out like this
  668. 23:32in a year, or Jaou-san will become the
  669. 23:35governor of Tokyo in two years. Yeah,
  670. 23:40whatever. It's not
  671. 23:43zero, though. If Otake-san does
  672. 23:46something from now on, her popularity
  673. 23:48will skyrocket again.
  674. 23:50But that's definitely not zero.
  675. 23:51Yeah. So, it's interesting and
  676. 23:54life-like. There was something I
  677. 23:56experienced a little bit in my past
  678. 23:57year, about what Jaou-san said. In
  679. 23:59January of last year, a young person
  680. 24:01asked me if they could make a short
  681. 24:03video about Otake-san. I thought it
  682. 24:06would be nice since I already had an
  683. 24:07account, so I said I wanted to do it
  684. 24:09for overseas. I wanted to spread the
  685. 24:19word about this overly positive old man
  686. 24:21with no arms or legs.
  687. 24:24Well, I also thought I'd leave it to
  688. 24:26the sensibilities of young people with
  689. 24:27Hanshin Hangi, and the one that's been
  690. 24:29spinning the most right now is 150
  691. 24:31million. 150 million is
  692. 24:33amazing. It's interesting to leave it
  693. 24:35to the red guy, and you never know
  694. 24:37what's going to happen in a year. And
  695. 24:38when I go overseas, I get approached a
  696. 24:40lot. They ask me if I'm on TikTok,
  697. 24:43TikTok.
  698. 24:43No, they really are. And then again,
  699. 24:46in Japan, we're really vulnerable to
  700. 24:48black ships. Everyone is attracted to
  701. 24:49those who produce results overseas. So
  702. 24:51you never know what's going to happen.
  703. 24:53It's a
  704. 24:53great learning experience. And earlier,
  705. 24:57the person next to me said something
  706. 24:58like, "The moat is empty and the pond
  707. 25:00is empty," but that person's humility
  708. 25:02comes from believing in miracles,
  709. 25:04whether they're young or not. Stop
  710. 25:07hating Horie.
  711. 25:10Just listen to me. I
  712. 25:13said earlier that I only believe in
  713. 25:14miracles in people who can make
  714. 25:16miracles happen. I'd like to hear how
  715. 25:20you distinguish between those who seem
  716. 25:22like they could perform miracles and
  717. 25:24those who are just kids, who don't seem
  718. 25:26like they could.
  719. 25:29When
  720. 25:33SMAP disbanded, I lost my adrenaline.
  721. 25:36Oh,
  722. 25:38and they really did perform many
  723. 25:40miracles.
  724. 25:42Yeah. Yeah.
  725. 25:43For example, the most surprising thing
  726. 25:44was when they did the 27-hour TV
  727. 25:45program and they were supposed to
  728. 25:46perform a live show in front of 5,000
  729. 25:47people at the end, but they said they
  730. 25:49couldn't because of a typhoon. Yeah.
  731. 25:50Three hours before the show, the
  732. 25:52typhoon passed. I see. And they
  733. 25:54said they couldn't do the research
  734. 25:56volunteer work either,
  735. 25:57but they did. But we didn't
  736. 26:01give up until the very end. I think
  737. 26:04everyone's feelings were heard, but
  738. 26:05there were also times when they
  739. 26:08decided to quit right away. But no, I
  740. 26:12guess that part of believing until the
  741. 26:14end fits that picture.
  742. 26:18I see. That's right. Yeah.
  743. 26:20When Bad Hop disbanded and I offered to
  744. 26:23give him 10 million yen, T Pablo lost
  745. 26:25money gambling in Korea and wanted to
  746. 26:27go again, so I withdrew 1 million yen
  747. 26:29from my pocket and gave it to him.
  748. 26:32But he
  749. 26:33really did come back with 10 million
  750. 26:35yen.
  751. 26:36I see. So why is it? Maybe it's because
  752. 26:38I get excited about it.
  753. 26:40Yeah. In the person? In what they do?
  754. 26:42Which is it? It might be in what they
  755. 26:45do, but I also get excited when I give
  756. 26:47them 1 million yen or when I hear that
  757. 26:49a typhoon is coming and it might not.
  758. 26:54Maybe I invest because I like phenomena
  759. 26:57, including people's images. Yeah.
  760. 27:00That's
  761. 27:00true. To be
  762. 27:02honest, I used to underestimate
  763. 27:03broadcast writers. This is a really
  764. 27:05rude thing to say. I get it, I get it.
  765. 27:07They're people who get looked down on.
  766. 27:09Because
  767. 27:09unpopular comedians always lose. That's
  768. 27:13why I underestimated
  769. 27:14broadcast writers, so I'd like to
  770. 27:16apologize on behalf of everyone. I'm
  771. 27:19sorry.
  772. 27:20Why doesn't everyone think so?
  773. 27:22Sorry. Yes.
  774. 27:23So, Mr. Noguchi, what did you think of
  775. 27:25the various things we discussed with
  776. 27:27everyone?
  777. 27:28Today's topic at the Japan Future
  778. 27:30Conference is this. Solve the shortage
  779. 27:33of call center workers with AI. There's
  780. 27:36no way that current AI technology can
  781. 27:38handle the complexities of call center
  782. 27:40operations. It
  783. 27:41can't. We don't need that at all.
  784. 27:43I'll handle everything. Don't make a
  785. 27:45mistake.
  786. 27:46Mr. Noguchi, please give the final vote
  787. 27:49.
  788. 27:49Approved.
  789. 27:50Yes.
  790. 27:50Yes,
  791. 27:51Callways can solve both the technical
  792. 27:53issues and the need for determination.
  793. 27:55Really.
  794. 27:55Wow. If you want to use AI to
  795. 28:01handle phone calls, click here for
  796. 28:03Callways. Search for more information
  797. 28:09on Callways.
  798. 28:10Mr. Noguchi, what did you think of the
  799. 28:12various things we discussed with
  800. 28:14everyone? The path you've walked is
  801. 28:16truly amazing. It's really interesting
  802. 28:19how well you can put things into words,
  803. 28:21and the details are so deep. I think
  804. 28:24people who are really into that kind of
  805. 28:26thing tend to have really heavy words.
  806. 28:30By the way, if we're just talking about
  807. 28:32this topic, I'm not really sure what
  808. 28:34the answer was, but I guess it's still
  809. 28:36a crazy tool. It can be replaced by AI,
  810. 28:40but the
  811. 28:41good thing about it is that it's
  812. 28:42genre-less. Yeah. Yeah. So writing will
  813. 28:44disappear and most of it will remain
  814. 28:46the same, but probably jobs up to
  815. 28:48around 60 in the standard deviation can
  816. 28:50be done by AI, but all
  817. 28:52writing is fine, so the job of
  818. 28:53broadcast writer will be done by AI,
  819. 28:56but I think the
  820. 28:58crazy tool that broadcast writers have
  821. 29:00will not lose to AI. Right now, it's
  822. 29:04all genres. People who have a
  823. 29:06competition, and AI will create the
  824. 29:08common sense part here, and if you use
  825. 29:10that crazy tool to make it interesting,
  826. 29:12you can get something that gets 75
  827. 29:14points. That's AI's specialty,
  828. 29:16including music.
  829. 29:17Yeah. Right.
  830. 29:18Yeah. But for things that get 101 or
  831. 29:20120 points, you know, when you
  832. 29:23really feel like a stalker and you play
  833. 29:25the song that you're performing, right?
  834. 29:28Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. So that's
  835. 29:31exactly madness.
  836. 29:32The Japan Future Conference said that
  837. 29:33what was missing was madness. It's
  838. 29:34madness.
  839. 29:35It's Nobu's competition. I
  840. 29:37can't do it alone.
  841. 29:38Well, us.
  842. 29:39Ours,
  843. 29:39or maybe Mr. Sake. If there are any
  844. 29:44viewers who are parents listening to me
  845. 29:46today, I would like to convey this
  846. 29:47message to them. I think it's easy to
  847. 29:52feel anxious when your child deviates
  848. 29:54greatly from everyone else. You may
  849. 29:58want them to be the same as everyone
  850. 30:00else, and you may want them to be the
  851. 30:01same, but I think that approach is
  852. 30:03probably a value policy from an era
  853. 30:05before AI. I think you've understood
  854. 30:09this after listening to me today, but
  855. 30:11since A will do everything that
  856. 30:12everyone else does, I think we're
  857. 30:14entering an era where those who can
  858. 30:15create something different will survive
  859. 30:22. So if you think you want to be
  860. 30:24different, I think it might be better
  861. 30:25to stay different and give it a try.
  862. 30:27That's what I wanted to convey. That's
  863. 30:31a good idea. Oh, that's right. So, we
  864. 30:35welcomed Suzuki-san, and we've
  865. 30:37delivered this over two weeks. Thank
  866. 30:39you for today, Mr. Sake. Thank you very
  867. 30:41much.
  868. 30:41Now, everyone, please give this video a
  869. 30:43thumbs up and
  870. 30:44subscribe to the channel. Goodbye.
  871. 30:48Everyone, please listen. The number of
  872. 30:51subscribers to the Japan Future
  873. 30:53Conference channel has surpassed 25,000
  874. 30:55.
  875. 30:56Amazing. Amazing.
  876. 31:00And thanks to you, we've seen an
  877. 31:02increase of 10,000 in just the last 28
  878. 31:04days, which is amazing, but only
  879. 31:107%of people are actually subscribing to
  880. 31:12the channel and watching.
  881. 31:14Huh? That's so few?
  882. 31:15Yeah. Isn't that
  883. 31:16terrible? Please subscribe to the
  884. 31:19channel and give it a thumbs up.
  885. 31:21Please. Let's get to
  886. 31:22100,000. Let's start a political party
  887. 31:26that will reform Japan using the
  888. 31:28salaries of local assembly members.
  889. 31:29Local assembly members are unnecessary,
  890. 31:31so we don't need those kinds of people.
  891. 31:33That's
  892. 31:3310 million yen per person. That means
  893. 31:36100 people will earn 1 billion yen in a
  894. 31:38year. We can use that money to
  895. 31:41revitalize local areas.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 放送作家はAIによって失業するか【第92回 日本未来会議】 by 日本未来会議, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,096 words across 895 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.