YouTube2Text

女性専用車両を常設化すべき!【第80回 日本未来会議】 — Transcript

by 日本未来会議 · 3,817 words · 688 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Should we expand women-only cars? I
  2. 0:02don't see why not. If you make it so
  3. 0:04these incidents don't happen, they
  4. 0:06won't occur in the first place, so if
  5. 0:07you're really thinking about women, you
  6. 0:09should take more high-level measures.
  7. 0:11You don't understand how women feel.
  8. 0:13I’d be fine with "pervert-only" cars.
  9. 0:15Oh, that’s not good. I’ll end up
  10. 0:17having to apologize later.
  11. 0:26Japan Future Conference.
  12. 0:31This program is brought to you by the
  13. 0:33following sponsors. Alright, it has
  14. 0:35begun. Japan Future Conference. This
  15. 0:38time, it’s a debate session. These
  16. 0:41are the members who will liven up the
  17. 0:42discussion. Let's get started. Yes, so
  18. 0:48the penalty game will be replying in
  19. 0:50the comment section, so please do your
  20. 0:52best.
  21. 0:55Good luck.
  22. 0:57Now, today’s theme is this. Should we
  23. 1:01expand women-only cars?
  24. 1:05It has been over 20 years since
  25. 1:07women-only cars were introduced as a
  26. 1:09measure against groping. While they
  27. 1:13have some effect, they are also
  28. 1:14criticized for reverse discrimination
  29. 1:16and causing congestion. Can safety and
  30. 1:20fairness coexist? Expansion or
  31. 1:23abolition? We will debate it thoroughly
  32. 1:25.
  33. 1:27With that, we have already split into
  34. 1:28groups for and against. First, in favor
  35. 1:31is the Zosu team.
  36. 1:32Yes.
  37. 1:33Of course.
  38. 1:34Yes. So you are saying they should be
  39. 1:36expanded.
  40. 1:37Yes. And the opposition is the Noguchi
  41. 1:39team. What are you talking about?
  42. 1:41Doing that won't make you popular.
  43. 1:44Right, so sparks are already flying. As
  44. 1:49you all know well, during commuting
  45. 1:51hours, over 50%of all groping incidents
  46. 1:53occur during the morning rush.
  47. 1:59Women-only cars are currently set up
  48. 2:01for the morning and evening commutes.
  49. 2:08We are here to debate whether to expand
  50. 2:10them to all-day service—from first
  51. 2:12train to last—or whether that is the
  52. 2:14wrong approach. Yes. Now, our first
  53. 2:19sub-theme is this.
  54. 2:22We will discuss the idea that "the risk
  55. 2:24of groping isn't limited to commute
  56. 2:25times."
  57. 2:28Let's begin.
  58. 2:29Eh, is that right?
  59. 2:30Yeah.
  60. 2:31Do you have any counterarguments?
  61. 2:33Yeah.
  62. 2:33That is true, but...
  63. 2:35Are those on the opposition side saying
  64. 2:37we should get rid of women-only cars?
  65. 2:39Or should we expand them? I think
  66. 2:43women-only cars should be permanent,
  67. 2:45and it's obviously a good thing.
  68. 2:48But, maybe it's fine during the day?
  69. 2:52The discussion is whether it should be
  70. 2:54permanent, and in a world of both men
  71. 2:56and women, why are there no men-only
  72. 2:58cars? Why only women-only cars?
  73. 3:02Well, I wouldn't mind if there were
  74. 3:03men-only cars, actually. I think it
  75. 3:10would be fine to have a pervert-only
  76. 3:12car.
  77. 3:12Ah, that's not good.
  78. 3:13Why? Why not?
  79. 3:15How would a pervert-only car work?
  80. 3:17Then the people who want to grope and
  81. 3:18those who want to be groped could just
  82. 3:20ride together. Hey, that’s just a sex
  83. 3:21industry business.
  84. 3:22A concept sex service.
  85. 3:23Eh, what's wrong with that?
  86. 3:25What's wrong? That's what's wrong.
  87. 3:26I’m actually getting a little excited
  88. 3:28talking about it.
  89. 3:28No. Stop it.
  90. 3:29Yes. This conversation is over. Eh,
  91. 3:31isn't it interesting? Talking about it
  92. 3:33at a meetup or something...
  93. 3:34Every YouTuber would probably get in on
  94. 3:36it.
  95. 3:36Anyway, let's get back to the point.
  96. 3:38You want to make women-only cars
  97. 3:39permanent, right?
  98. 3:40Yes.
  99. 3:41Over 50%of incidents only happen
  100. 3:44between 6:00 and 9:00 AM. Do you know
  101. 3:47how many groping incidents occur? It's
  102. 3:49about 1,000 a year. Is the cost of
  103. 3:53maintaining women-only cars in all
  104. 3:5550,000 train cars worth eliminating 500
  105. 3:57incidents a year? You don't even know
  106. 4:04...wait, what was the number of
  107. 4:05incidents you just said? Per year?
  108. 4:09About 1,000.
  109. 4:10About 1,000. That’s just the number
  110. 4:12of reports filed, right? Exactly. Yeah.
  111. 4:15In fact, when I was in high school—
  112. 4:17the JK girls I know—they have all
  113. 4:19been victims of groping.
  114. 4:21Yeah. Yeah.
  115. 4:22And I have never seen a single one of
  116. 4:24them file a police report.
  117. 4:25So there could be millions of cases.
  118. 4:27Exactly. So it’s possible that the
  119. 4:29real number is 10, 20, or maybe even
  120. 4:31100 times higher. I understand the
  121. 4:33argument about making them permanent.
  122. 4:36The point is that most of it happens
  123. 4:37during commute times.
  124. 4:39So the question is, is it necessary to
  125. 4:41keep them all the time?
  126. 4:43If you're asking whether it's necessary
  127. 4:45or not, it is, isn't it?
  128. 4:47Because it eliminates the risk. Why
  129. 4:48wouldn't you? Yeah.
  130. 4:49I want to know the reason why you
  131. 4:51wouldn't do it.
  132. 4:51Because there are people like you out
  133. 4:53there. That’s why some people say
  134. 4:56it’s okay to grope women who aren't
  135. 4:57riding in the women-only cars. That’s
  136. 5:01not what’s being said. Wait.
  137. 5:02No, that’s wrong. Please put aside
  138. 5:04the "pervert-only car" idea you
  139. 5:05mentioned.
  140. 5:05No, I’m saying the pervert-only car
  141. 5:07exists...
  142. 5:08Shut up. Hey, don't ignore me. That—
  143. 5:10Wait a minute, wait a minute. Since
  144. 5:12we’ve set this up, I’d like to get
  145. 5:14back to the topic of dedicated cars.
  146. 5:16I want to return to that—for example,
  147. 5:18you talked about yourself and your
  148. 5:19friends earlier. Since I have two women
  149. 5:26here, I’d like to ask: based on your
  150. 5:27own experience or stories from friends,
  151. 5:29what proportion of groping incidents
  152. 5:31happen during morning commutes or
  153. 5:33school hours, versus other times during
  154. 5:35the day? Give me a rough estimate.
  155. 5:40About 80 or 90 percent in the morning.
  156. 5:45Some think that because 50 percent of
  157. 5:47cases happen in the morning, only the
  158. 5:49morning is necessary, but for women,
  159. 5:51it’s not just about the act of being
  160. 5:52groped, it’s a psychological issue.
  161. 5:56It’s the fear of the possibility of
  162. 5:58being groped that’s the problem. And
  163. 6:00I don’t think that’s limited to
  164. 6:02just 6:00 to 9:00 AM.
  165. 6:04Yeah.
  166. 6:04Yeah.
  167. 6:05Well, in this age of LGBT, there are
  168. 6:07people who identify as women groping
  169. 6:09other women, or people dressing up as
  170. 6:11women......to commit acts of groping.
  171. 6:13I think we can go by biological sex for
  172. 6:15that.
  173. 6:16If you are biologically female, then
  174. 6:18you are a woman. I think it’s fine to
  175. 6:20treat them as women, but those who are
  176. 6:22not biologically female shouldn’t be
  177. 6:23in the women-only cars. The rules can
  178. 6:25just be the same as they are for public
  179. 6:27baths, based on biological sex.
  180. 6:28Also, you probably don’t know since
  181. 6:30you don't take the train, but in the
  182. 6:32evening, there are, uh, women-only—
  183. 6:34not women-only, women’s appear—
  184. 6:36appearances. Yeah. Yes.
  185. 6:39There are many train lines that don't
  186. 6:40have women-only cars, and even though
  187. 6:42they get crowded in the evening,
  188. 6:43groping doesn’t really happen there.
  189. 6:46So, doesn't that suggest that we don't
  190. 6:48necessarily need them 24 hours a day?
  191. 6:50Ah, but they actually do have the
  192. 6:52women-only cars during the evening
  193. 6:53commute now.
  194. 6:54Wait, why not make them mandatory
  195. 6:56instead? It doesn't cost anything.
  196. 6:58I don't see why not. If it's mandatory,
  197. 7:00it becomes a rule, so it has to be done
  198. 7:03nationwide, right? I'm from Miyazaki,
  199. 7:05and we only have two cars per train.
  200. 7:06Yeah.
  201. 7:07So if one car is for women and one is
  202. 7:09for men, wouldn't that be awful? That,
  203. 7:11like—
  204. 7:12That might be true.
  205. 7:13But that’s what the rule would be.
  206. 7:14That’s what "mandatory" means, right?
  207. 7:16Then let's just ask them to add a third
  208. 7:17car. I wonder if that’s even possible
  209. 7:19.
  210. 7:19They wouldn't pay that cost.
  211. 7:20No, well, let's just stick to cities
  212. 7:22for this. I mean, come on.
  213. 7:24In Miyazaki, there are only two cars.
  214. 7:26If it's "mandatory," it means
  215. 7:28nationwide, so...
  216. 7:29There might even be places with just
  217. 7:30one car.
  218. 7:31You call women "jaw-dropping" or
  219. 7:33something?
  220. 7:34They have to protect their bodies, like
  221. 7:36when they're pregnant.
  222. 7:37So, as a society, we should be kind to
  223. 7:39women, treat them like princesses,
  224. 7:41right? Huh?
  225. 7:42You should treat women with special
  226. 7:44care.
  227. 7:44Oh, is that it?
  228. 7:45Yeah.
  229. 7:45Oh, it’s not just about birthdays.
  230. 7:47Well, is that enough?
  231. 7:49It's about creating a society where we
  232. 7:51cherish women.
  233. 7:52Um, we're debating in three groups now,
  234. 7:54so we don't need the car thing.
  235. 7:56Right. With that said, let's move on to
  236. 7:59the next topic. 2.
  237. 8:01Number two is this.
  238. 8:03The question is, isn't this reverse
  239. 8:05discrimination against men? As you were
  240. 8:08touching on earlier.
  241. 8:10Wait, do men even get molested?
  242. 8:12Never.
  243. 8:12It's not zero.
  244. 8:13But it's extremely rare compared to
  245. 8:15women, right?
  246. 8:15Yes. Extremely rare.
  247. 8:17Then isn't it fine to make women-only
  248. 8:19cars mandatory? Since it's so rare.
  249. 8:23When I heard the topic, the first thing
  250. 8:25I thought of was how many convenience
  251. 8:26stores have women-only stalls lately.
  252. 8:32Convenience stores have women-only
  253. 8:34toilets and unisex toilets, right?
  254. 8:36That's exactly it.
  255. 8:37You're waiting forever, right? I was
  256. 8:39waiting there. Then, just when I
  257. 8:40thought someone finally came out, it
  258. 8:42was a woman.
  259. 8:43I got so annoyed. So, if the same thing
  260. 8:46happens on a train...
  261. 8:48Wouldn't that be annoying? Your
  262. 8:50thoughts?
  263. 8:51If you say "anyone can ride in either
  264. 8:53one," the other one just gets crowded,
  265. 8:55right? So, I'd like to ask for
  266. 9:00counterarguments, excluding the opinion
  267. 9:02that it's unfair for only men to have
  268. 9:04to ride in crowded cars all the time.
  269. 9:08Well, but if there's a system to
  270. 9:09prevent false accusations, isn't that
  271. 9:11fine?
  272. 9:12Oh, I see the men's side too. I see it
  273. 9:14from the men's perspective a lot,
  274. 9:15That would be fine if only men rode in
  275. 9:17those other cars.
  276. 9:18But in the end, women will still get on
  277. 9:20, right? Even if it's a car for men,
  278. 9:22women will still board other cars, and
  279. 9:23false accusations will happen there too
  280. 9:25. So, does that mean we should just
  281. 9:27create cars specifically for men?
  282. 9:28No, because that’s...it’s just
  283. 9:30unpleasant.
  284. 9:32Look, the problem arises because no one
  285. 9:34knows who is doing what in a packed
  286. 9:35train, so to solve the root problem, we
  287. 9:37should increase the number of cars or
  288. 9:39trains to avoid overcrowding. Then
  289. 9:42molestation would naturally decrease,
  290. 9:44so isn't that a better way to solve it
  291. 9:46than separating men and women?
  292. 9:48But you know, I think dedicated cars
  293. 9:50are better to have, even if they aren't
  294. 9:52strictly necessary. I personally think
  295. 9:54we should have them.
  296. 9:55I don't think we need them.
  297. 9:57I don't think we need them. Right.
  298. 9:58The problem is the overcrowding, after
  299. 10:00all.
  300. 10:01Yeah.
  301. 10:03Admitting they exist, they are
  302. 10:05currently time-based, so for example,
  303. 10:07if they end at 11:00, are you going to
  304. 10:09say "Okay, get off" at 10:59?
  305. 10:14No, that's why there's no need for
  306. 10:16dedicated cars on trains. Since packed
  307. 10:24trains are what cause these problems—
  308. 10:26like things getting stolen from bags—
  309. 10:28wouldn't it be better for society to
  310. 10:30solve the issue by not creating those
  311. 10:32overcrowded conditions where you can't
  312. 10:33keep an eye on things?
  313. 10:36That costs too much, so within the
  314. 10:38existing assets—for example, if there
  315. 10:41are 12 cars, let's make 2 of them
  316. 10:43women-only. If just doing that lowers
  317. 10:45the risk of molestation for the time
  318. 10:47being,
  319. 10:48No, I think that costs more than just
  320. 10:50adding one more car. Because if you
  321. 10:53have 10 cars and make 2 of them
  322. 10:54women-only, that’s still overcrowding
  323. 10:56, right?
  324. 10:58Since men can't enter those empty cars,
  325. 11:00if you consider transport costs during
  326. 11:02those completely empty hours, I think
  327. 11:04it’s definitely better not to have
  328. 11:06them as just extra cars.
  329. 11:08I think it would pay for itself in
  330. 11:09terms of sales versus the costs
  331. 11:11involved. What’s interesting is that
  332. 11:14earlier, you mentioned that, let alone
  333. 11:15the sentiment, women-only cars are
  334. 11:17unnecessary to begin with.
  335. 11:21That’s why I’ve been saying from
  336. 11:23the start that the real problem is that
  337. 11:25by creating women-only cars, companies
  338. 11:26and society can act as if they’ve
  339. 11:28already taken measures. They should be
  340. 11:35thinking of separate mechanisms to
  341. 11:37prevent groping, but they make
  342. 11:38women-only cars because it’s the
  343. 11:40cheapest option, when really they
  344. 11:41should be introducing AI cameras or
  345. 11:43other methods. And yet
  346. 11:45Exactly, and that’s why the problem
  347. 11:47is that it creates a false sense of
  348. 11:49accomplishment; if they really cared
  349. 11:51about women, they should implement
  350. 11:53higher-level, more costly measures. So,
  351. 11:56the very idea of women-only cars is
  352. 11:58extremely childish.
  353. 12:01How should I put it? It's like saying,
  354. 12:03"It's cheap, so this should be fine."
  355. 12:05I want to get into this point, but how
  356. 12:07is it actually? They already exist now,
  357. 12:09don't they? Even if they aren't fully
  358. 12:11exclusive. Do you think this is
  359. 12:13discrimination?
  360. 12:14I don't think it's either.
  361. 12:15I don't think it's either. I don't
  362. 12:17think it’s discrimination; in the end
  363. 12:19, I think most people see it as a
  364. 12:21difference between equality and
  365. 12:22fairness, and view it as a fair move.
  366. 12:26So, as for whether this should be done
  367. 12:2824 hours a day, I really think that’s
  368. 12:30a negligible difference.
  369. 12:31Oh, that
  370. 12:32Is it okay to accept reverse
  371. 12:33discrimination just because it's for
  372. 12:35women?
  373. 12:35If whether or not to make it 24 hours
  374. 12:37is a negligible point, isn't this the
  375. 12:39real issue? Exactly.
  376. 12:40Earlier, when Kanda-san asked if
  377. 12:42groping by women against men exists,
  378. 12:44the response was, well, it’s not zero
  379. 12:46, but it does happen a little. And then
  380. 12:49there was the point that if it only
  381. 12:51happens a little, then it’s not
  382. 12:52really necessary, right? If we assume
  383. 12:59that incidents of molestation are
  384. 13:01mostly concentrated during morning and
  385. 13:03evening rush hours, then just like the
  386. 13:04argument that there’s almost no time
  387. 13:06when women are harassing men, what do
  388. 13:08you all think about the point of having
  389. 13:10women-only cars during the day when
  390. 13:11these incidents barely happen?
  391. 13:19I’ve heard the opinion that people
  392. 13:21who have experienced it, even once, are
  393. 13:23often mentally affected to the point
  394. 13:24where they get traumatized and can’t
  395. 13:26ride trains or buses anymore, so they
  396. 13:28can only ride women-only cars.
  397. 13:32And I think that, as you just said,
  398. 13:34really is a mental health issue.
  399. 13:38I understand that those people can’t
  400. 13:40ride them, but you know, outside of
  401. 13:42commuting, isn’t it still scary to be
  402. 13:44in the same space with men looking at
  403. 13:45you? Yeah.
  404. 13:50Well, since there are times reserved
  405. 13:52for women during commutes, is there
  406. 13:54really a need to go out of your way to
  407. 13:55ride at other times?
  408. 14:00But, you know, trains aren't just for
  409. 14:01commuting when you’re traveling, are
  410. 14:03they?
  411. 14:04I don’t think these issues should be
  412. 14:06discussed through individual cases. If
  413. 14:08we did that, even though molestation
  414. 14:09against men is very rare, if one of
  415. 14:11those people happened to be my friend
  416. 14:13who was groped and became a mess, then
  417. 14:15...Arguments like "please make a
  418. 14:17men-only car for him" would also become
  419. 14:19possible.
  420. 14:19Oh, okay.
  421. 14:20Okay.
  422. 14:21Yeah. Men-only, okay.
  423. 14:23I do think there’s a need for
  424. 14:24men-only cars for men, too. Then
  425. 14:26there’s probably a need for "pervert
  426. 14:28cars" as well. But these things are
  427. 14:29created because there is high demand,
  428. 14:31right?
  429. 14:31And there is a demand for women-only
  430. 14:33cars.
  431. 14:34But then, if that’s the case...
  432. 14:36Yes. So, with that said.
  433. 14:38From here on, it will be an open
  434. 14:40discussion. I won't set a specific
  435. 14:42topic, so based on the current
  436. 14:44discussion, feel free to speak your
  437. 14:45minds—hey, I’m talking because you
  438. 14:47were silent. I wasn't.
  439. 14:49I wasn't silent at all.
  440. 14:51Quiet, shut up.
  441. 14:53Hey, I haven't been holding back at all
  442. 14:55.
  443. 14:55You know, everyone here is being a bit
  444. 14:57too intellectual, rational, and
  445. 14:59clean-cut.
  446. 14:59Yeah.
  447. 15:01In this world, girls are princesses and
  448. 15:03are treated specially. Men just have to
  449. 15:06endure it. Uh, do you have a response
  450. 15:10to the pro-side's argument?
  451. 15:12Most of it comes out, anyway.
  452. 15:15If women need to be protected, it's
  453. 15:17because their social status has
  454. 15:19historically been lower, making it hard
  455. 15:21for them to speak up; when men are
  456. 15:22groped, everyone just treats it as a
  457. 15:24joke—it's happened to me, too.
  458. 15:27Back then, I just turned it into a
  459. 15:28funny story.
  460. 15:29But women don't have the option to turn
  461. 15:30it into a funny story like that. In
  462. 15:32short, there's no demand for it.
  463. 15:33Exactly.
  464. 15:34Yeah.
  465. 15:34You guys are idiots. Is it really okay
  466. 15:36to expand a discussion about things
  467. 15:38like women-only train cars into an
  468. 15:39argument about gender inequality? Will
  469. 15:40this video stay up?
  470. 15:41It's fine.
  471. 15:42Ah, you'll end up having to apologize
  472. 15:44later.
  473. 15:44I won't be doing that.
  474. 15:46I’m for equal opportunity between
  475. 15:48genders.
  476. 15:49Women were the weaker side to begin
  477. 15:51with, right? So even if there are
  478. 15:53arrests for groping here, the real
  479. 15:55number is probably tens of times higher
  480. 15:57. No, no, no, no—we haven't said a
  481. 16:00single word about not needing
  482. 16:01countermeasures against groping.
  483. 16:03I know. But jumping to extreme ideas
  484. 16:06like AI cameras is just wrong. Uh.
  485. 16:09Hmm. Then is this really the optimal
  486. 16:11solution for preventing groping?
  487. 16:13Then what about universalizing it? What
  488. 16:15if you universalized it and then
  489. 16:16installed AI cameras?
  490. 16:17No, that's why—
  491. 16:18So, should it not be universalized?
  492. 16:20Tell me why it shouldn't be
  493. 16:21universalized. You take taxis so you
  494. 16:23probably don't know, but on a 15-car
  495. 16:24train like the Sobu Line, if only, say,
  496. 16:26car number two were a women-only car
  497. 16:27and someone got groped there, the
  498. 16:29conversation would just end with people
  499. 16:30asking why they didn't ride in the
  500. 16:32women-only car. Is that okay with you?
  501. 16:33No one would say that.
  502. 16:34No, they would, they would. This
  503. 16:36problem will absolutely happen. So,
  504. 16:38does that mean it shouldn't be
  505. 16:39universalized?
  506. 16:40Look, you're just pointing out the
  507. 16:42flaws in universalization; you haven't
  508. 16:44given a single reason why it shouldn't
  509. 16:46be done. In other words, it should be
  510. 16:48universalized.
  511. 16:49Think about it.
  512. 16:50That’s why if you make women-only
  513. 16:51cars universal, people will say, "Why
  514. 16:53didn't you ride the women-only car when
  515. 16:55there was one?" That's all I'm saying.
  516. 16:57I get it. If women-only cars increase,
  517. 17:00it basically separates men and women.
  518. 17:02Yeah.
  519. 17:02Yeah. And then, you know, the
  520. 17:04interaction disappears, right? That's
  521. 17:06what I hate. Nobi-san, when you ride
  522. 17:09the train as a man, [do you look at] a
  523. 17:11girl's skirt or...
  524. 17:12You want to see stuff like that, right?
  525. 17:14That's not it.
  526. 17:15Yes, you do.
  527. 17:16Like a mixed-gender bath in Germany.
  528. 17:17That's not it at all. Well, that is...
  529. 17:22Well, we've heard enough about Nobby's
  530. 17:23opinion that women should be treated
  531. 17:25specially, and the opposing view that
  532. 17:27the women-only car system itself is
  533. 17:29wrong, so let's try discussing a
  534. 17:30different point.
  535. 17:35For me, I just want it to be one way to
  536. 17:37eliminate false accusations. That...
  537. 17:46For now, I just want at least one
  538. 17:47women-only car to exist to reduce false
  539. 17:50accusations against men. At least until
  540. 17:53AI cameras become widespread.
  541. 17:54Yeah.
  542. 17:55The reason is, there are all sorts of
  543. 17:57false accusations, right? Like that
  544. 18:01movie "I Just Didn't Do It," where
  545. 18:03someone was framed. In cases like that,
  546. 18:07if a woman says so, it's 99.9%game over
  547. 18:10.
  548. 18:10So, I really want to keep them
  549. 18:12separated.
  550. 18:13Yeah.
  551. 18:14By the way, if there's a women-only car
  552. 18:16and a regular one, which do you take?
  553. 18:19I take the women-only car.
  554. 18:20Absolutely.
  555. 18:23But what if the women's car is packed?
  556. 18:26Oh, I think I could still squeeze in. I
  557. 18:28want to take the women's car.
  558. 18:30Yeah. I'd take it whenever possible.
  559. 18:34It's just that there are time
  560. 18:35restrictions, like 6 to 9 AM, so I
  561. 18:37never know if I can use it, which is
  562. 18:39probably why it hasn't fully caught on.
  563. 18:42If we agree that having women-only cars
  564. 18:44is a good thing, then it should be more
  565. 18:46widely promoted. If they're going to
  566. 18:47exist.
  567. 18:48Make them stand out more—paint them
  568. 18:50pink, put roses on them or something.
  569. 18:51Sometimes they do. But men still end up
  570. 18:53getting in there, don't they?
  571. 18:55Shibuya Station is all pink. Also, the
  572. 18:58argument that cars are empty outside of
  573. 19:00those hours is wrong.
  574. 19:02I take the Marunouchi Line a lot, and
  575. 19:04it's packed almost until the very last
  576. 19:06train.
  577. 19:06That's because it's near the last train
  578. 19:08.
  579. 19:08No, it's always packed.
  580. 19:09Well, that's just because it's the
  581. 19:11Marunouchi Line.
  582. 19:11True.
  583. 19:12Yeah.
  584. 19:12Yeah.
  585. 19:13So, if you're worried about those risks
  586. 19:15and want to make every car women-only,
  587. 19:17well, Miyazaki Prefecture only has
  588. 19:19two-car trains anyway.
  589. 19:22In Miyazaki, just ride together.
  590. 19:25Well, the discussion has really heated
  591. 19:27up, so I'd like to move on to the final
  592. 19:29judgment. Before that, we'll take a
  593. 19:31short commercial break, so everyone try
  594. 19:33to guess who will win. Please also take
  595. 19:35this opportunity to subscribe to the
  596. 19:37channel.
  597. 19:37Professor?
  598. 19:39Still doing it?
  599. 19:40That's enough.
  600. 19:42The topic for today's Japan Future
  601. 19:44Conference is this. "Resolve call
  602. 19:46center staffing shortages with AI."
  603. 19:50There's no way current AI technology
  604. 19:52can handle complex call center tasks,
  605. 19:54right?
  606. 19:55No, we don't need any of that.
  607. 19:57I'll handle everything myself.
  608. 19:58No mistake about it.
  609. 19:59Mr. Noguchi, please give us the final
  610. 20:01verdict.
  611. 20:02It is passed.
  612. 20:03Right.
  613. 20:03Yes.
  614. 20:04Whether it's technical issues or sheer
  615. 20:06willpower, Callways can solve them.
  616. 20:08Really?
  617. 20:09Huh.
  618. 20:14For AI phone support, Callways is the
  619. 20:17answer. Search for "Callways" for more
  620. 20:23details.
  621. 20:25Alright, so we've been discussing
  622. 20:27whether women-only train cars should be
  623. 20:29permanent. Honestly, I’m still torn.
  624. 20:36To be fair, before we started, I didn't
  625. 20:38think it was necessary to have them
  626. 20:40during off-peak hours. However, after
  627. 20:48listening to Sarasa-san and Mi-san’s
  628. 20:49opinions, I was really moved by the
  629. 20:51point that women who have been
  630. 20:52traumatized by molestation even once
  631. 20:54need an environment where they can ride
  632. 20:56the train with peace of mind,
  633. 20:57regardless of whether it's crowded or
  634. 20:59not. So, the winner is here.
  635. 21:07And don't you dare give me a handicap.
  636. 21:12It's my turn, isn't it?
  637. 21:13Like hell it is.
  638. 21:16Well, as a moderator's privilege, I'd
  639. 21:18like to take this opportunity to share
  640. 21:20with you all that there is actually a
  641. 21:21rule that men in wheelchairs are
  642. 21:23allowed to ride in women-only cars. But
  643. 21:27, like, do you really think you can
  644. 21:28just ride it?
  645. 21:29No way.
  646. 21:31So, in the end, where are people in
  647. 21:33wheelchairs supposed to go on a packed
  648. 21:35train? The reality is that they still
  649. 21:38can't ride. So, while the question of
  650. 21:41whether to keep women-only train cars
  651. 21:43is an important issue, I’d really
  652. 21:45like for them to create a system where
  653. 21:47not only wheelchair users, but also
  654. 21:48those who need a cane to walk, can ride
  655. 21:50the train with peace of mind—even if
  656. 21:52we don’t go as far as having cars
  657. 21:54dedicated entirely to wheelchairs. Like
  658. 21:59for children, yes, exactly, those with
  659. 22:01strollers; or maybe separate cars for
  660. 22:03parents, or even stroller-only cars.
  661. 22:05Yes, exactly.
  662. 22:10Alright, so this time we've been
  663. 22:11discussing the topic of women-only
  664. 22:13train cars. I’m sure you all have
  665. 22:16various opinions, so please feel free
  666. 22:18to share them in the comments section.
  667. 22:21Also, if you found this program
  668. 22:22interesting, please don't forget to hit
  669. 22:24the like button and subscribe to the
  670. 22:26channel. With that said, I’ll see you
  671. 22:28all next time. Thank you very much.
  672. 22:31Redelivery should be a paid service. If
  673. 22:33you want a redelivery, it should cost
  674. 22:35something like 600 yen. You’re an
  675. 22:37adult; you said you’d receive it on
  676. 22:38this day, so just receive it.
  677. 22:39But what if you have a stomach ache and
  678. 22:41have to go to the bathroom?
  679. 22:42That’s true.
  680. 22:42Yeah, like registering that status on a
  681. 22:45logistics app.
  682. 22:46The Japan Future Conference is looking
  683. 22:48for sponsors and presenters to support
  684. 22:50us.
  685. 22:50Please check the description box for
  686. 22:52details on how to apply. Make sure to
  687. 22:53subscribe to the channel, too.
  688. 22:55We look forward to hearing from you.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 女性専用車両を常設化すべき!【第80回 日本未来会議】 by 日本未来会議, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,817 words across 688 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to translate the transcript into 100+ languages.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, translation to 100+ languages, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.