7 New Shocking Details in Nvidia Affair Scandal — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00In battle tech CEO Jensen Huang, the man
- 0:03at the center of an alleged Chinese spy
- 0:05affair with huge national security
- 0:07implications, has just resigned from
- 0:10Nvidia. [music] And this is on the heels
- 0:12of reports he has had multiple affairs.
- 0:15This is a big deal. And we ask, [music]
- 0:17as the FBI is reportedly looking into
- 0:19this, why exactly did Jensen Huang
- 0:22decide to leave [music] the company
- 0:23right now? We're bringing on national
- 0:26security expert and former [music] FBI
- 0:28agent and CIA officer Tracy Walder.
- 0:32Welcome to Sidebar, presented by Law &
- 0:34Crime. I'm Jesse Weber.
- 0:39Well, after news of this alleged honey
- 0:41pot involving a reported Chinese spy
- 0:44scandal took the world by storm, it is
- 0:47official. Tech giant Jensen Huang has
- 0:50announced that he is resigning from
- 0:52Nvidia. And to be clear, this is a very,
- 0:55very big deal because Jensen Huang, the
- 0:58co-founder, the chief executive of
- 1:00Nvidia, the large computing company that
- 1:02describes itself as making advanced
- 1:04chips, systems, software for AI that had
- 1:08a market cap of over $4 trillion, that
- 1:10has customers including Microsoft,
- 1:13Amazon, Google, Meta, Oracle, a guy who
- 1:16has the ear of the president of the
- 1:18United States as we're in this race for
- 1:21AI dominance against China,
- 1:23he steps down.
- 1:25Now, aside from the massive economic and
- 1:27financial implications, I mean, I'll
- 1:29give you an idea of it. When it was
- 1:30announced yesterday that the board may
- 1:32remove Jensen Huang, the stock dropped
- 1:348%. New York Post reporting that around
- 1:37$450 billion may have been wiped out
- 1:40from the company's market value after
- 1:42this story broke out. CBS saying that
- 1:45there could be $700 billion that's lost,
- 1:48but apparently that was for the whole
- 1:49month of November, not just after the
- 1:51announcement. But
- 1:53big picture here. You're talking about a
- 1:54guy who stepped down in the wake of this
- 1:58crucial race we're in against China, the
- 2:02AI race. And he is being accused of
- 2:05having an affair with a Chinese spy?
- 2:09I mean, if this is true,
- 2:11you could potentially have an asset of
- 2:12China feeding it information about one
- 2:15of our top tech and AI companies or even
- 2:19allegedly potentially influencing the
- 2:21decisions at Nvidia, even though it's
- 2:24not clear what information was shared or
- 2:25divulged, if any, or what decisions may
- 2:28have been affected by Alice Wong, if
- 2:30any, or in general what intelligence
- 2:33China may have gathered again, if any.
- 2:35And we'll talk more about Alice Wong in
- 2:36a second. But something to keep in mind
- 2:38here is that Jensen Wong had previously
- 2:40been pushing for more lax regulations on
- 2:42AI, to loosen restrictions on selling
- 2:45chips to China. The close relationship
- 2:47between Jensen Wong and President Trump,
- 2:49it is well documented with the New York
- 2:51Post reporting how he traveled with him
- 2:53to China last May and was invited onto
- 2:55Air Force One. So this news launched an
- 2:58FBI investigation according to President
- 3:00Trump. Republican chairs of three House
- 3:02committees have called for Jensen Wong
- 3:04to appear to come in later this month
- 3:06for an interview about this scandal. It
- 3:08raises a ton of legal and national
- 3:10security questions. We had a lawyer on
- 3:12last time talking about potential crimes
- 3:15that could be investigated here. And
- 3:16this comes after reports that Jensen
- 3:19Wong didn't just apparently have this
- 3:22affair with Alice Wong. No, now it's
- 3:25come out that he's had at least two
- 3:28alleged affairs within the company. So
- 3:30first the New York Times reported that
- 3:32Jensen Wong had a separate affair with
- 3:34Kimberly Powell, Vice President of
- 3:37Healthcare at the company. This is
- 3:38apparently based on the reports of five
- 3:40employees. And then it came out from
- 3:41Reuters today that Jensen Wong had a
- 3:44quote intimate relationship with a
- 3:46second Nvidia employee. Now currently as
- 3:50we're recording this, we do not know the
- 3:51identity of this second person, but
- 3:54that's significant to say the least. And
- 3:57one of the questions is, was this the
- 3:59breaking point, right? Is this why he
- 4:01resigned or was something else? Was
- 4:03something discovered in the last few
- 4:05days, potentially raising legal or
- 4:08national security concerns or issues
- 4:11that forced Jensen Huang to resign or
- 4:14caused him to resign? I mean, Nvidia's
- 4:16Board of Directors released a statement
- 4:17today. Reads in part, quote, Jensen
- 4:20Huang has resigned as president, chief
- 4:22executive officer, and member of the
- 4:24board effective immediately. Colette
- 4:26Kress, current executive vice president
- 4:28and chief financial officer of Nvidia,
- 4:30has agreed to serve as interim chief
- 4:32executive officer. The board is
- 4:33initiating a search for a permanent
- 4:36chief executive officer and will
- 4:37consider internal and external
- 4:39candidates. Interesting because I also
- 4:41saw a Newsweek article that said, you
- 4:43know, who would replace Jensen Huang as
- 4:45CEO? And it said nobody.
- 4:48And that perhaps it's better to have a
- 4:49team lead the company, that kind of
- 4:51management style. But it shows you how
- 4:53valuable he is to this. How this is a
- 4:55huge loss again in the middle of this AI
- 4:58race. But anyway, you go back to the
- 5:00statement. Says Colette has helped lead
- 5:02Nvidia through a period of extraordinary
- 5:03growth and has a deep understanding of
- 5:05our business, customers, operations, and
- 5:07financial position. Goes on to say the
- 5:09board has full confidence in Colette and
- 5:11the leadership team and we expect the
- 5:13company's operations, customer
- 5:14commitments, and product roadmap to
- 5:16continue without interruption. And then
- 5:19the statement from the board says
- 5:20Jensen's contributions to Nvidia are
- 5:22profound. Nvidia is one of the most
- 5:24consequential technology companies in
- 5:26the world. The board and the company
- 5:27thank Jensen for his immeasurable
- 5:29contributions to the company and the
- 5:31industry. Now, that feels a little bit
- 5:33different than the one we heard the
- 5:35other day because it was on Sunday when
- 5:37Jensen Huang released his own statement
- 5:39telling his employees about the affair,
- 5:40saying, quote, I owe my family and all
- 5:42of you an apology. I was unfaithful to
- 5:44my wife. By the way, didn't mention who
- 5:47the people were that he had an affair or
- 5:49affairs with, right? He didn't say
- 5:51affair or affairs. Interesting.
- 5:53My actions hurt her and our children.
- 5:55There is no excuse for what I did. I am
- 5:57deeply sorry. Throughout my life, my
- 5:59family has given me love and support.
- 6:02They deserve my honesty and loyalty.
- 6:04Instead, I let them down damaged the
- 6:06life we built together. I take full
- 6:08responsibility for what I did and the
- 6:09hurt I caused, and I accept the
- 6:11criticism that comes with it. To my wife
- 6:13and family, I love you. I know an
- 6:15apology cannot undo what I have done. I
- 6:17hope our family will heal and that over
- 6:19time I can earn back your trust. To my
- 6:22colleagues at NVIDIA, including those I
- 6:24have worked alongside for decades, and
- 6:26to our board, partners, and shareholders
- 6:27around the world, you deserve better
- 6:29from me. Leading NVIDIA is the privilege
- 6:31of my life, my responsibility is to
- 6:33serve you and be worthy of your trust. I
- 6:36have fallen short of that
- 6:37responsibility. I am fully committed to
- 6:39NVIDIA and will work to earn back your
- 6:41confidence regarding the national
- 6:42security concerns raised in news
- 6:44reports. NVIDIA's Board of Directors has
- 6:46initiated an independent investigation.
- 6:49I support the investigation and will
- 6:50cooperate fully. I love our country and
- 6:53our company. I am committed to
- 6:54protecting NVIDIA and supporting
- 6:56America's national security. I am proud
- 6:58and grateful to be an American. My
- 7:00family bears no responsibility for my
- 7:02choices. I do. Please give them privacy.
- 7:05Jensen. And then NVIDIA's Board of
- 7:07Directors issued a statement. Quote, the
- 7:10NVIDIA board is initiating an
- 7:11independent investigation in light of
- 7:13recent reporting that founder and CEO
- 7:15Jensen Huang has been the target of a
- 7:17foreign intelligence effort. A committee
- 7:19of independent directors assisted by
- 7:21outside independent counsel will oversee
- 7:23the investigation. The board prioritizes
- 7:25US national and economic security, which
- 7:27is paramount to the interest of NVIDIA
- 7:29and its shareholders. While the board
- 7:31has no reason to believe that either
- 7:32national security or NVIDIA secrets were
- 7:34compromised, the board's inquiry will
- 7:37examine all available information.
- 7:39Jensen fully supports the review and is
- 7:41committed to cooperating with it. The
- 7:42board has confidence in Jensen and his
- 7:45leadership team and will provide further
- 7:48updates as appropriate. And by the way,
- 7:51the board came out and said that it
- 7:52hired former acting US attorney for the
- 7:54Southern District of New York, Joon H.
- 7:56Kim, and his law firm, one of the most
- 7:58prominent Wall Street law firms in the
- 8:00world, Wachtell, Lipton, Rosen & Katz,
- 8:02to conduct this independent
- 8:04investigation. And now what? Just two
- 8:06days later, Jensen Wang resigned. What
- 8:09changed? You got to talk the national
- 8:10security implications of this, and I'm
- 8:12going to bring on former FBI, CIA
- 8:14officer Tracy Walder in a minute. And
- 8:16also there's a shareholder lawsuit going
- 8:18on, too. But while Jensen didn't mention
- 8:20who he had an affair with, reporting
- 8:22indicates that this woman is Alice Wang.
- 8:25To be clear, no relation to Jensen Wang,
- 8:27but someone who has been photographed
- 8:28alongside him numerous times. Photograph
- 8:31of them reportedly attending a dinner in
- 8:32Taipei, Taiwan on May 22nd, 2025.
- 8:35There's another one reportedly taken at
- 8:36an event during the Computex forum in
- 8:39Taipei, Taiwan on June 7th, 2024. This
- 8:41photo allegedly shared by Alice herself
- 8:44from WeChat feed, a Chinese social media
- 8:46platform. The Guardian is even reporting
- 8:48there's footage of his arm around her,
- 8:50her kissing him on the cheek. According
- 8:52to CNN, Alice Wang was apparently a
- 8:54journalist for Chinese state media, a
- 8:56figure in the tech industry with US
- 8:58Customs and Border Patrol records
- 9:00indicating that she's a 43-year-old
- 9:02Chinese citizen by the name of Wang Li.
- 9:04Alice Wang was an executive of Nvidia's
- 9:06reported business partner,
- 9:08Singapore-based Megaspeed between March
- 9:10and November of 2023. Megaspeed is a
- 9:13data center company, apparently sells
- 9:14computing power or capacity services,
- 9:17usually in the AI space, reportedly
- 9:19allowed its customers to rent out
- 9:21Nvidia's chips. Megaspeed, according to
- 9:23CNN, became one of the largest
- 9:25purchasers of Nvidia chips in Southeast
- 9:28Asia. And according to the New York
- 9:29Times, Megaspeed was accused of working
- 9:31to divert Nvidia's specialized chips to
- 9:34China, so going around US sanctions,
- 9:36essentially smuggling chips. And that's
- 9:39because the US has restricted exports of
- 9:41its most advanced chips to China due to,
- 9:43of course, national security issues. And
- 9:45Megaspeed denied allegations of
- 9:47wrongdoing, though it was reported by
- 9:49the New York Times on November 9th that
- 9:50the Justice Department is conducting a
- 9:52criminal investigation into Megaspeed.
- 9:55But US intelligence believes that Alice
- 9:57Wang was recruited to be a spy for
- 9:59China, namely by the country's Ministry
- 10:00of State Security. It's their top spy
- 10:02agency. And the New York Post reports
- 10:05that she has been under investigation
- 10:07since the end of President Biden's term.
- 10:09According to the BBC, electronic
- 10:10surveillance revealed a series of
- 10:12communications between Alice Wong and a
- 10:15US citizen that seemingly now has been
- 10:17identified as Jensen Wong. Not entirely
- 10:20clear when or how they met, but she's
- 10:22appeared alongside him at numerous
- 10:23occasions, numerous events. CNN saying
- 10:25they've been photographed together as
- 10:27early as 2024, which is what I
- 10:28mentioned. And the New York Times
- 10:29reports that President Trump was briefed
- 10:32about intelligence indicating Alice Wong
- 10:34may be a Chinese spy. In fact, CNN says
- 10:36sources say the FBI alerted US lawmakers
- 10:39about her allegedly providing
- 10:40information to China nearly a year ago.
- 10:43And we know that Jensen Wong traveled
- 10:45with the president to China earlier this
- 10:47year. And right now, reporting indicates
- 10:49that Alice Wong's whereabouts are
- 10:51unknown. For its part, China denies
- 10:54these spy allegations. But look, it's
- 10:57escalating. President announced the FBI
- 10:59is looking into all of this, too. So
- 11:01with the resignation of Jensen Wong, the
- 11:04timing of it's interesting. What is
- 11:05happening behind the scenes? What can we
- 11:07expect from this investigation? And is
- 11:10there weight
- 11:11to this alleged honey pot scandal? How
- 11:14exactly do these work? All right, I'm
- 11:15about to start a recorded interview, and
- 11:17before I do, this is before we recorded
- 11:19this before the news came out of an
- 11:22alleged third affair, the second
- 11:25employee at Nvidia. Just keep that in
- 11:27mind. Okay, I want to bring on somebody
- 11:29who I haven't seen in quite some time. I
- 11:31always miss her, always happy when she
- 11:32comes on.
- 11:34Former CIA Special Operations Officer,
- 11:36former FBI Special Agent, National
- 11:38Security Contributor at News Nation,
- 11:40Tracy Walder. Tracy, good to see you. I
- 11:44mean,
- 11:45you know, this is the topic that when we
- 11:47were like, who do we want, got to talk
- 11:49to you about it. Now, first, him
- 11:50resigning.
- 11:52Some would say, is it after the news of
- 11:54the second alleged affair or did
- 11:57something happen in the last few days?
- 11:59Was there information that was learned
- 12:01either during the course of the FBI or
- 12:03during the course of this internal
- 12:04investigation that raised certain legal
- 12:07or national security issues that maybe
- 12:09said there's no way he can stay on
- 12:12anymore? I mean, or it's him just trying
- 12:14to, you know, not be a distraction for
- 12:16the company. It's kind of a corporate
- 12:17question, but it also makes me think,
- 12:19did something happened in the last few
- 12:20days?
- 12:23>> I don't think so. I think once the news
- 12:25broke, he probably had every intention
- 12:28of resigning. It also, and again, I am
- 12:31not giving him any kind of pass for his
- 12:33behavior.
- 12:34Cheating and then having really poor
- 12:36judgment is terrible, but it does give
- 12:38me more credence to my belief that he
- 12:42probably didn't know that she was a spy
- 12:45until news broke that she was a spy. And
- 12:49he is a national security threat for his
- 12:51his country.
- 12:51>> what Somebody would look at that and say
- 12:53this guy's brilliant, okay? He's head of
- 12:55one of the biggest companies in the
- 12:57entire world. He's brilliant in the AI
- 12:59space. He doesn't know that the person
- 13:02that he is reportedly with is
- 13:04potentially a Chinese asset. How is that
- 13:06possible? Unless you tell me
- 13:08the techniques that are used are so good
- 13:11that no one would have any idea
- 13:13whatsoever.
- 13:14>> So I think I'm trying to say this in a
- 13:15way that doesn't alienate people, but
- 13:17there is a reason that men are targeted
- 13:20more in these kinds of operations than
- 13:23women. And I think some of it is is that
- 13:26every single person in this world has a
- 13:30weakness, has something that makes them
- 13:33susceptible to espionage, to to theft,
- 13:37to all of those things. And I think
- 13:39China
- 13:40had their sights on him because they
- 13:42wanted those chips that he had, right?
- 13:44And he was always a target. And I think
- 13:47they realized that one of his weaknesses
- 13:49and a way to get close to him was
- 13:52through women, especially with the news
- 13:53of the second um affair that he had. And
- 13:56that is a weakness that he has. It's a
- 13:59poor judgment call that he has.
- 14:02>> Problem is this is somebody, Alice Wang,
- 14:04who had a connection to China. She was a
- 14:09reported journalist for Chinese state
- 14:11media. She was part of this uh this
- 14:14company based in Singapore, um that had
- 14:17connections to China. It wasn't as if he
- 14:19had an affair with Jane Smith from
- 14:22Virginia, and you find out that she's a
- 14:24Russian asset and you would have no
- 14:25idea.
- 14:27He I mean, isn't there a level of due
- 14:29diligence that either he or the people
- 14:31around him should have known, hey,
- 14:34something you might want to keep a
- 14:35careful eye here?
- 14:37>> Yes and no. So again,
- 14:39when I worked at CIA, we have a
- 14:41non-fraternization policy with people
- 14:44from certain countries. I can't say
- 14:45which ones, but I'm sure we can guess
- 14:47which ones. And so I am very cognizant
- 14:50of the fact that we shouldn't be
- 14:53and people in certain positions
- 14:54shouldn't be close to people from other
- 14:56countries for those reasons. I'm not
- 14:58sure that everyone is. Also, we have to
- 15:00remember again, not giving him a pass on
- 15:01his behavior, but President Trump and
- 15:04Marco Rubio both had this information,
- 15:06right? That she was a spy for MSS, and
- 15:10they made the decision not to tell him.
- 15:12And the FBI did not provide him with any
- 15:15kind of intelligence assessment on her.
- 15:18And so the people close to him, they may
- 15:20have been telling him, hey, you
- 15:22shouldn't do this. But the bottom line
- 15:24is you just mentioned, he is the CEO of
- 15:26arguably one of the most powerful
- 15:28companies in the world, one of the most
- 15:30influential countries in the world.
- 15:32And the buck sort of stops with him. So
- 15:34people can advise him not to do things,
- 15:36but they they may not have a policy in
- 15:38place saying not to do it.
- 15:40>> All right, for anybody out there who
- 15:41runs a business, manages a business,
- 15:42owns a business, you don't need me to
- 15:44tell you that running a business is
- 15:45tough enough, but I got to say,
- 15:47why make it harder doing things manually
- 15:49or relying on dozens of apps that don't
- 15:51really talk to each other, right? That's
- 15:53where our sponsor Odoo comes in because
- 15:55Odoo is an all-in-one business
- 15:57management platform with a full suite of
- 16:00integrated apps that seamlessly connect
- 16:02all your operations from sales and
- 16:04accounting to manufacturing, even
- 16:05shipping. Odoo can automatically
- 16:07generate professional, sleek-looking
- 16:09sales orders, invoices, vendor bills. It
- 16:11can automatically assign sales teams. It
- 16:13can send email updates through each
- 16:15sales stage and even use AI to pull
- 16:18reports that are going to help with your
- 16:20decision making. For manufacturing,
- 16:22their apps can sync inventory with
- 16:24real-time production and purchase
- 16:25updates so you never run out of stock.
- 16:27And when it comes time for accounting,
- 16:28that's also fully automated. Odoo can
- 16:30create invoices, track expenses, and
- 16:33even summarize data with AI to save you
- 16:35hundreds of hours. You know what the
- 16:37best part is? You can choose your apps
- 16:39and even build custom workflows so it's
- 16:41all fully tailored to your business's
- 16:42needs. Take your business to the next
- 16:45level by consulting with an Odoo expert
- 16:47today for free at odoo.com/sidebar.
- 16:52Why would the US government not tell him
- 16:55or the company and why wouldn't someone
- 16:58stop the President of the United States
- 17:00from maintaining such a close
- 17:02relationship with him and making sure he
- 17:04doesn't come on US Air Force One unless
- 17:07there was something deliberate about
- 17:09that?
- 17:10>> So that is my biggest issue. That's
- 17:12always been my biggest issue sort of
- 17:14with this. From an intelligence side, I
- 17:16I see the idea of letting it continue,
- 17:19right? So that you can see who is else
- 17:21is Alice meeting with? What other
- 17:23targets does she have here in the United
- 17:25States? What other intelligence
- 17:27information can we glean with her? But
- 17:29in my opinion, given her closeness to
- 17:31him and given the like personal
- 17:33relationship that they had, not just the
- 17:34business relationship, I actually think
- 17:37it's a terrible idea to withhold that
- 17:39information. And the reason being is she
- 17:41could have given him any kind of gifts
- 17:43that were bugged with devices. She could
- 17:46have accessed his personal and home
- 17:47computers at any time. And I think that
- 17:50is the part that I think
- 17:52maybe people didn't think about or they
- 17:54did and made ultimately the wrong
- 17:56decision.
- 17:58>> Yeah, maybe. Part of me is like, you
- 18:00know, keep your friends close but your
- 18:01enemies closer.
- 18:03Were they monitoring her and monitoring
- 18:05his communications with her? And that
- 18:07becomes the question about the FBI. Like
- 18:09that's a big question I have. So the FBI
- 18:12President says is now looking into this.
- 18:13What does that mean? How are they
- 18:14investigating this? What are they doing?
- 18:17>> So the FBI we know from the reporting
- 18:19now that the
- 18:21the US had essentially confirmed that
- 18:23she was a spy and they and they
- 18:24confirmed that actually through
- 18:25surveillance of her. So they were
- 18:27already following her. Um and so the FBI
- 18:30now it's really not up for debate
- 18:32investigating whether or not she's a
- 18:33spy. We already know that. In my
- 18:36opinion, what I think the FBI is doing
- 18:37is what we call a damage assessment,
- 18:39right? How much was given to the
- 18:43Chinese? How was it given to the
- 18:45Chinese? Um and you know
- 18:48and that's through audit trails, that's
- 18:50through signals intelligence, and that's
- 18:52through interviewing him as well in
- 18:54terms of what devices did she have
- 18:56access to, not have access to. That's in
- 18:59my opinion what they're doing from an
- 19:00investigative standpoint.
- 19:02>> And they're obtaining warrants for all
- 19:04these electronic devices and
- 19:05communications and working probably with
- 19:07NVIDIA because I imagine there might be
- 19:08internal corporate communications as
- 19:10well.
- 19:11>> Well some of it I'm guessing he's
- 19:12handing I'm hearing that it's been
- 19:14reported that he's handing over some of
- 19:16it on on his own. So that's good because
- 19:19you get it much more quickly that way.
- 19:21Um but yes, I I am assuming and hoping
- 19:24that they have applied for warrants um
- 19:26to get they're going to need broader um
- 19:29access to NVIDIA as as a whole, I would
- 19:32assume. But at the same time, one thing
- 19:35I haven't talked about and I think we
- 19:36need to think about is the the flip side
- 19:39of this. So the fact that he was on Air
- 19:41Force One, the fact that he was that
- 19:43close, was there damage to the other
- 19:46side as well? And so we're really
- 19:47focusing on this damage to NVIDIA, but
- 19:49what other kind of damage did it have to
- 19:51the national security apparatus as a
- 19:53whole?
- 19:55>> Do they do agents match out? They say
- 19:57okay,
- 19:58allegedly this information was provided
- 20:00to her at this point in time and then
- 20:02they look within that period of time and
- 20:04say China did this or NVIDIA did this or
- 20:08they look at certain um commonalities
- 20:11and consistencies that perhaps certain
- 20:13actions were taken or communications
- 20:15happened that they it wouldn't have
- 20:16happened otherwise unless she had access
- 20:19to that. Does that make sense?
- 20:20>> Yes, you're You're pretty spot on with
- 20:22that. In the case that I worked, I
- 20:24worked Chinese espionage at the FBI was
- 20:27we actually figured it out in a very
- 20:29similar way because this very specific
- 20:32technology essentially we were
- 20:34monitoring China and they like randomly
- 20:37popped up with it, right? And we knew
- 20:39that technology was indicative to only
- 20:41the US. It was native to the US. There
- 20:43was only one company that was making it.
- 20:45And so we could then go back to that
- 20:46company, who was working on that
- 20:48account, what individuals had access to
- 20:50it, right? And so then that's how we
- 20:51were able to identify but in a backward
- 20:54way the actual Chinese spy that was
- 20:56working that. And so yes, they're 100%
- 20:58going to marry all of that up. It takes
- 21:00some time though but they're definitely
- 21:02going to do that.
- 21:03>> And this could be very well a case where
- 21:04he had no idea. He maybe was a victim of
- 21:06this espionage, this alleged espionage
- 21:08effort. The FBI though,
- 21:11what can we expect from a conclusion
- 21:14here? Like how long will it take them to
- 21:16review this material, make an analysis?
- 21:18Is it an internal FBI report? Are there
- 21:21arrests? Are there criminal charges? I
- 21:23mean, talk to me about what could result
- 21:26from the FBI being a part of this and
- 21:27when?
- 21:29>> So from a criminal perspective with him
- 21:31it's all going to come down to did he
- 21:32know, right? Did he know? And they are
- 21:35going to be investigating
- 21:37that part but I I know this sounds
- 21:39strange but just hear me out. My guess
- 21:41is that's probably the least of their
- 21:42concerns right now because the gig is up
- 21:44for him, right? He can't do any more
- 21:46damage in the in the the place that he
- 21:47is. He's not with the company anymore.
- 21:50My guess is what they are really needing
- 21:52to do is focus on the damage to NVIDIA
- 21:55and then to the US economy and then,
- 21:56right? To our that's probably what
- 21:58they're focusing on on first is that
- 22:01damage. Then they're going to go back
- 22:03and find out what did Jensen Huang know
- 22:06if anything and if he did know then
- 22:09absolutely he would be looking at
- 22:10espionage and and treason charges which
- 22:13are obviously incredibly serious but I
- 22:15mean the case that I worked at the FBI
- 22:17took
- 22:18almost seven years, I think to to wrap
- 22:21up. So I think this one's going to go a
- 22:23little faster because of the nature of
- 22:25the business and the the damage that it
- 22:27could do.
- 22:28>> And the fact that he's cooperating and
- 22:29assisting seems to suggest he really
- 22:31believes he was a victim and had no
- 22:32idea. Do you They can't find Alice
- 22:34Huang? They don't know where she is?
- 22:38>> I think and again I'm I'm going to what
- 22:40I used to do and what happened in that
- 22:42case she fled to China. We're never
- 22:44going to see or hear from her. Again I
- 22:48don't She's not even in Singapore
- 22:49because
- 22:50basically there they would have to hand
- 22:52her over to us because of our diplomatic
- 22:54relationship with Singapore. So in in
- 22:57the case that I worked there were three
- 22:58other conspirators and they fled to
- 22:59China before we could even get to them.
- 23:01We just got one of them. And so I think
- 23:03unfortunately that's where she is in
- 23:05China is absolutely not going to hand
- 23:06her over
- 23:07>> Does that And that would signify that
- 23:09yeah she is definitely a Chinese spy if
- 23:11she floated if she fled to China I mean
- 23:12you put two and two together that's
- 23:14pretty much what it is. So so explain to
- 23:15me how this would work this recruitment.
- 23:17Like is it typical that they look at her
- 23:20they say okay the way she looks, the
- 23:23fact that she was a journalist, the fact
- 23:25that she's part of Mega Speed like when
- 23:26would something when would a recruitment
- 23:29like this happen and how would it
- 23:31happen?
- 23:33>> So we have to remember with China versus
- 23:35the US we're dealing with two very
- 23:36different systems, right? You have
- 23:38freedom of choice, right Jesse? You and
- 23:40I have freedom of choice. If the
- 23:41government comes to you and says be a
- 23:42spy you can say no.
- 23:44This is not my job. I don't want to do
- 23:46that. It doesn't work that way in China.
- 23:48If the MSS comes to you and says we have
- 23:50a job for you you are doing that job. So
- 23:53in terms of identifying her I don't know
- 23:55because she would she works at the
- 23:57behest Everyone in China works at the
- 23:58behest of the government and what the
- 23:59government is telling them to do. She
- 24:01wouldn't have had a choice in the
- 24:02matter. But I do think because of her
- 24:05background um and because of the fact
- 24:08that you know she was a journalist, she
- 24:10was somewhat public, she is comfortable
- 24:13with speaking to people and getting
- 24:15involved that I think they decided she
- 24:18would be a good person for that. Um and
- 24:21then obviously they they put her in in
- 24:24the role but Mega Speed in and of itself
- 24:26is somewhat of a a shell company And I
- 24:28think they probably did that on purpose,
- 24:31put her there um with really out without
- 24:34that experience to get that commonality
- 24:36with Jensen Wang. I think Jensen Wang
- 24:39was a target to them long before they
- 24:41decided that Alice Wang would be the
- 24:43person to engage.
- 24:46>> Do you know about what the training is
- 24:47if like we you know honeypot, honey trap
- 24:50um the seduction methods? Do we know how
- 24:52China
- 24:54potentially trains assets like this?
- 24:57>> I don't and I mean obviously here in the
- 24:59US I'm not going to say the CIA is
- 25:01perfect and that we've never done
- 25:02anything immoral. We totally have. But
- 25:04um the one thing we absolutely don't do
- 25:06are honeypot uh
- 25:08traps and so I wouldn't even be familiar
- 25:10with that training cuz it's not training
- 25:12that we even provide.
- 25:14>> But you've seen commonalities and when
- 25:16these cases pop up what is it? Is it the
- 25:18idea you think like
- 25:20I I was I was interviewing um this woman
- 25:22who claims to be a former Russian asset.
- 25:24She said you know there's a thing you do
- 25:26like seven times you're you're you
- 25:28you're around a potential target seven
- 25:30times without them knowing so that when
- 25:32they officially do meet you
- 25:34there's like a sense of familiarity. Um
- 25:36but like I mean you know I don't know
- 25:38what the what the patterns are the
- 25:40techniques but if this is true it it it
- 25:42seemingly clearly worked. I guess the
- 25:44question also is if they can't find her
- 25:46okay they don't have her. But then they
- 25:48look at Jensen Wang and they have his
- 25:49communications. They know what her phone
- 25:51number is. Maybe they know what her
- 25:52email address is. Is there any way to
- 25:56investigate or look at those records if
- 25:58they don't actually have her device?
- 26:01>> Yes, of course. They can you know get
- 26:03both sides of the conversation. But just
- 26:04really quickly back to your question
- 26:06about you know the recruitment process I
- 26:09can't reveal too much about tradecraft
- 26:10but it's very similar to how we recruit
- 26:12just spies to work for us in general.
- 26:14It's just the classic spot, assess,
- 26:16develop, recruit. You spot someone so
- 26:19Jensen Wang I'm sure was on a list of
- 26:20individuals that they wanted, right, to
- 26:22spy on. They assess what are their
- 26:25weaknesses, what are their commonalities
- 26:27in terms of who are you going to put in
- 26:28front of this person to recruit them?
- 26:30Who is the best person to do that? Then
- 26:33you develop them. So it's my
- 26:34understanding they had a friendship
- 26:36before that. So they developed through a
- 26:39friendship and then you recruit them. So
- 26:40in our case it would have been, hey, do
- 26:43you want to come work for the CIA? In
- 26:44their cases, do you want to take this
- 26:46relationship to the next level, right?
- 26:47And so it's but that it's very similar
- 26:50throughout the world. It's just
- 26:52different ways of obviously utilizing
- 26:54that.
- 26:54>> That's a good point. I'm glad you you
- 26:56clarified that. But in terms of getting
- 26:59you know her digital information cuz I
- 27:01mean I would have know would that be the
- 27:04the way that she would have communicated
- 27:06alleged you know if this is true if she
- 27:08would that be the way that she
- 27:09communicated or passed along any of the
- 27:10information she learned or would it be
- 27:12in person? Would there be handlers?
- 27:14Would there be drop spots?
- 27:16>> So in the case I worked it was handlers.
- 27:18And the way we caught him was actually
- 27:21the guy took a drive like physically
- 27:22with him on an airplane to Beijing. We
- 27:24caught him at the airport obviously and
- 27:26he was arrested there. And even recently
- 27:28I don't know if you've seen in the news
- 27:29there's been some
- 27:31of individuals working for China that
- 27:32were taking drives with them. So yes,
- 27:35you've got the electronic and clearly
- 27:37she popped up on someone's radar
- 27:39electronically because she was being the
- 27:41the CIA or FBI whomever was already
- 27:44monitoring her when they found out about
- 27:46her relationship. So they were
- 27:48monitoring her from an electronic
- 27:50standpoint. But I think the the goods or
- 27:53the information I think was she was
- 27:56probably passing the old fashioned way.
- 27:58And one of the things they want to look
- 27:59at are her trips either to the US
- 28:02through Singapore or through any of
- 28:04those countries back to China. I think
- 28:06that's going to be really important.
- 28:07>> When we talk about this being a national
- 28:09security concern, can you just elaborate
- 28:11maybe generally why this is such a big
- 28:14deal as we are in an AI race
- 28:17and you know our chips are so valuable.
- 28:20They're so important to us. Why this is
- 28:22such a big deal A, you know now we've
- 28:24lost
- 28:25a tech giant running one of the most
- 28:27important companies that we have. But
- 28:30you know in this AI race against China
- 28:32specifically, why this is such a big
- 28:34national security issue in terms of
- 28:36information that might have been relayed
- 28:38to uh
- 28:39Chinese spy agency or whether any
- 28:42actions were of NVIDIA were influenced
- 28:44because of Alice Wang or allegedly
- 28:46because of Alice Wang.
- 28:47>> I think this is
- 28:49in my opinion it's always been a
- 28:50national security threat because the
- 28:51case I worked was a private company. So
- 28:53I've I've seen this for a long time. I
- 28:56think the American people as a whole
- 28:58this surprises them, right? Because we
- 28:59think of national security in the
- 29:02military aspects, right? In a very
- 29:04conventional way and so that's
- 29:06definitely surprising.
- 29:08China does over $600 million
- 29:11of IP theft damage a year to the US. And
- 29:15if you think about the national security
- 29:16implications let's let's take the case
- 29:18that I worked. It was something called
- 29:20quiet electric electric drive. It made
- 29:22submarines quiet so they couldn't be
- 29:24picked up on sonar.
- 29:26And China just like got it.
- 29:28And that's bad. That's very bad from a
- 29:30technical it now puts us behind or the
- 29:33same because the whole idea in war and
- 29:35national security is you want the upper
- 29:37hand, right? You want the best
- 29:38technology, you want the best stuff, you
- 29:40want the best people. And when all of a
- 29:42sudden a country
- 29:44develops those literally overnight and
- 29:45didn't spend the time, the energy and
- 29:48the investment into the R&D, that is a
- 29:50problem.
- 29:52>> So what are the red flags? Like if I I
- 29:55don't know if companies, Fortune 500
- 29:57companies around the country or just big
- 29:59tech companies they're now saying okay,
- 30:01we got to have new training everybody.
- 30:03We got to talk about this. Like first of
- 30:05all maybe it's a whole thing don't have
- 30:06an affair.
- 30:07But this idea of
- 30:09if someone approaches you that looks at
- 30:11it your league just ignore them. I mean
- 30:13like what is what are the red flags? How
- 30:16do you prevent something like this
- 30:18happening again? And maybe it's not just
- 30:21companies, it's levels of government.
- 30:24You're in the military, intelligence
- 30:26agencies. Like how do you prevent
- 30:28something like this from happening if
- 30:30this is all true and what are the red
- 30:32flags?
- 30:34>> So I think and this might be a little
- 30:35bit controversial. I'm going to focus
- 30:36more on like the prevention piece than I
- 30:39guess the red flag piece if that's okay.
- 30:41And some of I get that some of my
- 30:42recommendations are
- 30:44unconventional, but I think they work.
- 30:46So at CIA, for example, if we even so
- 30:49much as talked to someone that was not a
- 30:51US national, it actually had to be
- 30:53documented and reported and then the CIA
- 30:55would run full background checks on
- 30:57those individuals. I'm not talking about
- 30:59profiling people because it's not bad to
- 31:01not be a US citizen. There's nothing
- 31:03wrong with that. We were all immigrants
- 31:04at one point. So I don't want people to
- 31:06think that that's how that's coming off.
- 31:09But I think that for for people at
- 31:11certain levels of private businesses, I
- 31:13don't know that it needs to be everyone,
- 31:15but at certain levels of private
- 31:16businesses, I think they need to have
- 31:18those same reporting rules. And I think
- 31:21companies might even if it's just
- 31:24certain countries that they've
- 31:25identified as being IP issues in terms
- 31:27of threats, then those need to be
- 31:29reported. I also, and again, I know this
- 31:32might be controversial, I think we need
- 31:34to think about potential lifestyle
- 31:36polygraphs for individuals at these
- 31:38large companies for certain certain
- 31:41people at certain levels of these
- 31:43companies because of their access,
- 31:46right, to information. I know that's
- 31:48time consuming. I know And again, we're
- 31:50not looking for perfect people. Everyone
- 31:52has a past, right? Even at CIA, we all
- 31:55have a past. I'm sure I've done things
- 31:57that were not legal growing up, but it
- 31:59was all about what makes you susceptible
- 32:01to blackmail. That's what the CIA wanted
- 32:03to know in that polygraph. And I think
- 32:05that that's something that would be very
- 32:06very beneficial, but I know that can be
- 32:09controversial.
- 32:10>> Wow, that move not a bad idea. I don't
- 32:12know if it would be widely accepted, but
- 32:14interesting to say the least.
- 32:15>> I know, but I think if we care enough
- 32:17about our national security and we care
- 32:20enough about our investments into
- 32:23these industries and we care enough
- 32:25about I guess winning this race, it's
- 32:27something we need to really start
- 32:29thinking about.
- 32:30>> Yeah. I mean, I can't disagree. You make
- 32:32a good point and we should all care.
- 32:34Tracy Walder,
- 32:36thank you so much. Really appreciate
- 32:38you.
- 32:38That's all we have for you right now
- 32:39here on Sidebar, everybody. Thank you so
- 32:41much [music] for joining us. I'm Jesse
- 32:42Webber. Speak to you next time.
- 32:46>> [music]
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 7 New Shocking Details in Nvidia Affair Scandal by Law&Crime Network, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,227 words across 939 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.