7 motivos pelos quais vendi Fundos Imobiliários (FIIs) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Guys, a few days ago I uploaded a video
- 0:01to the channel explaining why, if I
- 0:03were to start investing today, I
- 0:04wouldn't have real estate investment
- 0:06trusts (REITs) and why I've lost a lot
- 0:08of money with this product over the
- 0:09years. And I confess I was negatively
- 0:11surprised by some of the comments. I'll
- 0:14ask Caio to put the video on the screen
- 0:16. People had to exert a great deal of
- 0:18effort to defend the thesis of REITs,
- 0:20but they did so in the worst way
- 0:22imaginable. I saw many people repeating
- 0:24that old story that the loss only
- 0:26exists when the sale is finalized,
- 0:28which is obviously not true. And
- 0:31regarding the point that with REITs,
- 0:33the focus should be on income and not
- 0:34appreciation. It's always good to
- 0:37remember that it's no use receiving 1%
- 0:39per month if the share price falls 50,
- 0:4260, 70%, as happened with some REITs.
- 0:45Even more than that. Also, a large
- 0:47number of comments caught my attention
- 0:49saying that you are basically obligated
- 0:52to have REITs to be well diversified,
- 0:54because people have the wrong idea that
- 0:57diversification means having everything
- 1:00, which is not true. And, man, I know
- 1:02that 90%of the comments were positive,
- 1:04but I honestly didn't understand some
- 1:06of the people who came from the rate,
- 1:07you know? At no point did I say it was
- 1:10an easy decision or that it happened
- 1:12overnight, right? It was a decision
- 1:14that I built up over time after calmly
- 1:17looking at each part of the FIS (Real
- 1:19Estate Investment Funds) thesis and
- 1:21realizing that, for me, it no longer
- 1:23made sense, you know? Note that I was
- 1:26talking to myself, not to you or anyone
- 1:28else. This channel is precisely to make
- 1:30you reflect, understand the points, and
- 1:32maybe you'll come to the same
- 1:34conclusion, continue investing, but I
- 1:36think it's worth reflecting on, right?
- 1:38I knew that video would bother a lot of
- 1:40people, because real estate investment
- 1:42funds are almost a religion in Brazil,
- 1:44but I don't want to convert or
- 1:45unconvert anyone. For those who are
- 1:47just arriving here, I'm Rafael Zatar, I
- 1:50was elected top analyst in Brazil by
- 1:53AMB, professor of finance, professor of
- 1:56finance for doctors at PUC Paraná. And
- 1:58in the last video I only talked about
- 2:01what I did, why I did it. In this video
- 2:03, I'm going to present seven concrete
- 2:05reasons why I stopped liking real
- 2:07estate investment trusts (REITs) in
- 2:09general, and not just one or two
- 2:10specific tickers, as many people
- 2:12suggested, implying I only sold because
- 2:14I bought the wrong ones. Well, I don't
- 2:16want you to agree with me, but at least
- 2:18it's important to understand the
- 2:19different rationale than what's
- 2:21preached out there. If you can, please
- 2:23like the video, consider subscribing to
- 2:25the channel so we can reach 50,000
- 2:27subscribers, and let's go. Many people
- 2:34invest in REITs because it's a more
- 2:35liquid way to have real estate in their
- 2:37portfolio, but just because you can
- 2:39trade on the stock exchange doesn't
- 2:41mean you can buy or sell whenever you
- 2:43want at a good price. Almost always
- 2:45when you want. That's true, the problem
- 2:47is the good price. I say this because
- 2:49on a day when the market is stressed, a
- 2:51day when you really need to sell, there
- 2:53will be far fewer buyers on the other
- 2:55side of the table than you imagine. And
- 2:58there will certainly be a much higher
- 3:00volume of sales than the market usually
- 3:02handles. In that case, you have two
- 3:04options. Either you accept selling at a
- 3:06disadvantage relative to the asset's
- 3:08net asset value, or you'll be stuck
- 3:10with the asset waiting for the market
- 3:12to improve. But that can take a very
- 3:14long time. And I'm not even going to
- 3:16talk about setipulated real estate
- 3:18funds here. In fact, if you don't know
- 3:19what a setipulated real estate fund is,
- 3:21take a look on Google. But going back,
- 3:23some people here will remember that in
- 3:26March 2020, when the market plummeted,
- 3:28as well as on several other dates, many
- 3:30real estate funds, especially the
- 3:32smaller ones with less daily volume,
- 3:34went through a liquidity crisis. We saw
- 3:37funds that were considered stable and
- 3:40low-volatility plummeting 30, 40%. And
- 3:44the problem is that the moment of
- 3:46crisis is exactly the moment when you
- 3:48need liquidity the most, whether to
- 3:50cover an unforeseen event, to rebalance
- 3:52the portfolio, or simply to take
- 3:54advantage of, I don't know, some
- 3:56opportunity in another asset, and to be
- 3:59fair, let's say. Real estate funds are
- 4:01showing improvement in this regard, and
- 4:03liquidity is increasing as both the
- 4:05level of investor interest and the
- 4:06total size of these funds continue to
- 4:08grow. Even so, in fixed income,
- 4:10depending on the option, you can exit a
- 4:13highly liquid stock on the same day,
- 4:15even if the price also suffers. After
- 4:18all, it would be a time of crisis and
- 4:20such, so you are able to sell or
- 4:22acquire your positions with a much
- 4:23greater level of ease. The second point
- 4:31that bothers me about real estate funds
- 4:33is precisely a tax issue, and perhaps
- 4:36the most bothersome is the fact that
- 4:38this is a product that people sell as
- 4:41efficient. This is because everyone
- 4:43knows that dividends from real estate
- 4:45funds are exempt from income tax for
- 4:47individuals, and they keep comparing
- 4:49that to the fact that money from rent
- 4:51enters as taxable income. But capital
- 4:53gains in real estate funds, that is,
- 4:55the profit when you sell the share
- 4:57above the price you paid, are taxed at
- 5:0020%. Now compare that with other
- 5:02options in the financial market and
- 5:04forget about physical real estate for a
- 5:06moment, right? In the stock market,
- 5:08there's an exemption of up to R $
- 5:0920,000 on sales of R $ 1,000 per month.
- 5:11In other words, for individuals who
- 5:13don't trade in very high volumes, it's
- 5:15possible to have capital gains on
- 5:17stocks practically without paying tax.
- 5:20And in fixed income, depending on the
- 5:22term, the tax rate reaches 15%.
- 5:24Remember that stock dividends are also
- 5:26tax-exempt, right? So, in this tax
- 5:28sense, stocks are much more efficient,
- 5:31as long as you don't receive more than
- 5:33R $ 50,000 per month in dividends from
- 5:36a single company. That's for now, right
- 5:38? We know that sooner or later both
- 5:40will be taxed, and in smaller amounts
- 5:43as well. That is, today it's like this:
- 5:45if you bought for R $ 100 and sold for
- 5:47R $ 120, you'll pay R $ 4 in tax per
- 5:49share. It doesn't matter if you sold
- 5:5210,000 or 100,000, 1,000 will be a 20%
- 5:54profit either way. And the worst part
- 5:56is that I'm sure many people don't even
- 5:58know this; they accumulate shares for
- 6:01years, thinking they're making a
- 6:02tax-efficient investment, and only find
- 6:05out when they're about to sell. Or
- 6:06maybe they don't even find out, right?
- 6:08They don't pay the DAF (tax withholding
- 6:09statement) the following month. And
- 6:10then, my friend, things get complicated
- 6:11. The third reason, I'm absolutely
- 6:18certain, is the one that will keep you
- 6:21up at night when you realize what was
- 6:23happening with the dividends. There's a
- 6:26practice in some real estate funds that
- 6:28, in my opinion, borders on dishonesty
- 6:30towards shareholders, where the manager
- 6:33looks at the fund, sees what it
- 6:35generated, let's say, 0.074 per share
- 6:39in distributable income for the month.
- 6:41But the historical or average dividend
- 6:44of the fund is 9 cents. So, the manager
- 6:46knows that if they pay 0.074, people
- 6:50will complain, the share price will
- 6:52fall, people will sell, and they'll
- 6:54have problems. So what do they do? They
- 6:56pay the 9 cents anyway. Then you ask,
- 6:58okay? Where does the 0.016 difference
- 7:02come from? From the fund's assets, that
- 7:04is, your money. This is called capital
- 7:07amortization and is completely legal
- 7:10from a regulatory standpoint, but I see
- 7:12it as a red flag, right? Because what
- 7:15looks like a large or stable dividend,
- 7:17in this case, is actually the fund
- 7:18returning part of its own capital to
- 7:20pretend that the operation is more
- 7:22consistent than it really is. And the
- 7:24shareholder who doesn't follow the
- 7:26management report carefully doesn't
- 7:28notice, because the information is
- 7:30there making it very clear that the
- 7:32fund, for example, used part of the
- 7:34accumulated reserves to maintain a
- 7:36distribution. Then you continue
- 7:37reinvesting the dividends, accumulating
- 7:40more shares, but the fund is shrinking
- 7:42or growing less than it should. And you
- 7:44can't even say it's happening behind
- 7:46the scenes, because it's public
- 7:47information. And it's no use saying
- 7:49that it's one or two funds that do this
- 7:51because it isn't. This is a practice
- 7:53that every real estate fund investor
- 7:55who reads the manager's monthly letter
- 7:57knows and has noticed. They just often
- 7:59don't pay attention to what this means
- 8:02in the long term. Regarding the fourth
- 8:09reason why I wouldn't buy real estate
- 8:11investment trusts (REITs), there's a
- 8:13regulatory peculiarity: according to
- 8:15CVM (Brazilian Securities and Exchange
- 8:17Commission) rules, a REIT is only
- 8:18required to commission a technical
- 8:20appraisal of its properties once a year
- 8:22. This means that the net asset value
- 8:24you see published by the fund may be
- 8:27based on a property appraisal done
- 8:29months ago–six, eight, or ten months
- 8:31ago. Of course, the net asset value
- 8:33changes month to month due to other
- 8:35factors, such as cash flow, liabilities
- 8:37the fund has to pay, and other
- 8:39financial transactions, but the bulk of
- 8:41it–the properties themselves–
- 8:42remains frozen. And that's where the
- 8:44problem lies, because when the real
- 8:47estate market is down, the fund may be
- 8:49showing you an inflated net asset value
- 8:52relative to the new reality. Do you
- 8:54understand? You analyze the P/BV (
- 8:56Price-to-Book Value), that indicator
- 8:57that compares the share price with the
- 8:59net asset value, and you think you're
- 9:01buying at a discount, but the discount
- 9:04may not actually exist. Of course,
- 9:06anyone who is an analyst and follows
- 9:08various funds can understand that, for
- 9:10example, if several logistics funds
- 9:13have experienced a drop in new reports,
- 9:15it's likely that others in the same
- 9:17segment will go through the same thing.
- 9:20But this is very technical for the
- 9:22individual investor who is mainly
- 9:24looking at the dividend, right? Most
- 9:26end up making investment decisions
- 9:28based on a standard that will always be
- 9:30outdated, because the evaluation is
- 9:31done today. Next week the market has
- 9:33already changed. This, for me, is a
- 9:34risk that is difficult to calculate,
- 9:36you know? Have you ever wondered what a
- 9:43company, for example, does when it
- 9:44needs money to grow? Most borrow money
- 9:46from the bank, or if it's a large
- 9:49listed company, it even issues its own
- 9:51debt and lets investors buy and finance
- 9:53the operation. When a real estate fund
- 9:56wants to raise more money, it issues
- 9:58new shares, which in theory is a good
- 10:01thing, because the fund grows,
- 10:02diversifies its portfolio, and buys
- 10:05better assets. But that's in theory,
- 10:07right? Not in Excel, not in the
- 10:09published report. In practice, issuing
- 10:12shares isn't always good for existing
- 10:14unit holders, because it's very common
- 10:16for some asset managers to issue shares
- 10:19below their net asset value; that is,
- 10:21they issue shares cheaper than the
- 10:23existing net asset value per share, or
- 10:26very close to it, which immediately
- 10:28dilutes the value for existing unit
- 10:30holders, who now have a smaller share
- 10:32of assets that grew incorrectly. If
- 10:35that were all, it would already be bad
- 10:37enough, but it gets worse because with
- 10:38all this new cash, the asset manager
- 10:40needs to invest in something, right?
- 10:42And let's face it, if the market is
- 10:44tough, the best assets will already be
- 10:47in someone's hands, right, or expensive
- 10:49in the market. So, what happens is that
- 10:51the fund grows in size, the asset
- 10:53manager charges management fees on
- 10:55larger assets, and unit holders end up
- 10:57with a portfolio that is, on average,
- 10:59worse than what they had before. When
- 11:01we talk about receivables funds, it's
- 11:04much easier to see this because of the
- 11:06average market rate advocated in the
- 11:08report, but when it's real estate, man,
- 11:10it gets a little more difficult. And
- 11:12that's why, many times, growth for the
- 11:14sake of growth in relation to a real
- 11:16estate fund isn't even growth, it's
- 11:18dilution, you know? The fund as a whole
- 11:20is growing in net worth and number of
- 11:22shareholders and everything else, but
- 11:24the old shareholder is being diluted.
- 11:31Perhaps this sixth reason is one of the
- 11:33most technical arguments of the set,
- 11:35right? But it's also one of the most
- 11:37important, even though it stems from a
- 11:39very simple question. How much more do
- 11:41you need to earn to justify the risk of
- 11:43being in a real estate fund instead of
- 11:45a fixed income investment? The only
- 11:47logic that exists for investing in
- 11:49variable income is to have an
- 11:51expectation of a higher return than
- 11:53fixed income, that is, a risk premium.
- 11:55This applies to real estate funds as
- 11:57well as stocks, Bitcoin. And the
- 11:59question is precisely this: how much
- 12:01premium do you require to move from a
- 12:04long-term bond to buy a real estate
- 12:06fund? Because you must factor in that
- 12:08there are risks in buying REITs, right?
- 12:11There's volatility, there's the weight
- 12:13of managers 'decisions, there's the
- 12:15market cycle itself with increased
- 12:17vacancy rates, for example. Besides
- 12:19everything I've already listed in other
- 12:20points of this video. The problem is
- 12:22that many people still only look at the
- 12:25Selic rate, but the SELIC rate isn't
- 12:27the only benchmark. In fact, the SELIC
- 12:29rate shouldn't even be a major
- 12:31benchmark, you know? In a context where
- 12:34we have Treasury bonds and fixed-income
- 12:36securities maturing in 32 years paying
- 12:388.3%, and 2040 bonds paying almost 8%
- 12:40with practically zero credit risk–you
- 12:42just hold until maturity and that's it,
- 12:44you're not guaranteed anything, right?
- 12:46And then you look at a real estate
- 12:48investment trust with contracts indexed
- 12:50to the IPCA (Brazilian inflation index)
- 12:52, paying IPCA plus 9.5%at a
- 12:53market-to-market rate and think: "Wow,
- 12:55great, I'm earning 1.3%more than the
- 12:57Treasury bond." However, that little
- 12:59extra you earn is a premium for
- 13:01assuming the credit risk of the fund's
- 13:03debtors, management risk, liquidity
- 13:06risk, and dilution risk. You even run
- 13:08the risk that, after these bonds mature
- 13:10, the management won't reallocate them
- 13:13at good rates. So, what do I think? Is
- 13:15it really worth it to compensate for
- 13:17all that? To me, the math doesn't add
- 13:18up. And the worst part is many
- 13:20investors don't even do this math or
- 13:22compare. If we talk about, for example,
- 13:24CDBs, LCIs, LCAs, you can find an
- 13:26intermediate rate between the Treasury
- 13:28and the real estate fund rate, but with
- 13:30very low credit risk as well. What's
- 13:33not lacking at the moment are CDBs
- 13:35paying 8.8%or even almost 9%, never
- 13:38more. That's without even mentioning
- 13:40the dubious banks. Of course, this
- 13:42won't be the reality of a bank like
- 13:44Itaú, for example, but there are other
- 13:46good and reliable banks distributing
- 13:48intermediate rates, right, between the
- 13:50Treasury and paper-based real estate
- 13:52funds. But people look at the fund's
- 13:54dividend as if it exists in a vacuum,
- 13:56without comparing it to what the fixed
- 13:58income market is offering in a safer
- 14:00way. And finally, and no less important
- 14:07, the seventh reason that made me sell
- 14:09real estate funds is the excessive
- 14:11turnover of these funds' portfolios.
- 14:12The funny thing is that the selling
- 14:14point of real estate funds has always
- 14:17been that you invest indirectly in real
- 14:19estate and are therefore exposed to the
- 14:21real estate market without having to
- 14:23buy an entire property and still
- 14:25receive income over time. But there's a
- 14:28problem with this story, because if you
- 14:29look at a fund's portfolio today, it's
- 14:31very different from what it was a year
- 14:33ago and will be different a year from
- 14:35now as well. So, if you look, for
- 14:38example, at the May 2025 report, HGLG11
- 14:41had 28 properties in six states with a
- 14:45gross leasable area of 1.6 million m².
- 14:49Now, in over 2026, the fund had 40
- 14:50properties in seven states with a gross
- 14:52leasable area (GLA) of 2 million square
- 14:54meters, so the geographical
- 14:56distribution has changed a lot, man.
- 14:58Even the participation in Rio, which is
- 15:00a historically problematic state for
- 15:02real estate funds, has increased
- 15:03because managers buy and sell
- 15:05properties at a much faster rate than
- 15:07investors imagine, which isn't always
- 15:09bad, obviously, right? Sometimes it's
- 15:11worth recycling the portfolio, but
- 15:13what's bothersome is seeing managers
- 15:14exit an asset before it fully matures,
- 15:16whether to realize profits, generate
- 15:18cash, or maintain dividends, which
- 15:20happens perhaps because the investment
- 15:22thesis has changed, right? And then you
- 15:24, who bought a share of the fund
- 15:25thinking you were exposed to a specific
- 15:28set of properties, end up realizing
- 15:29that the fund is completely different
- 15:31from what it was. And again, so as not
- 15:33to cause controversy, this isn't
- 15:35necessarily wrong on the part of the
- 15:36manager, especially since active
- 15:38management exists and is paid for
- 15:39precisely that. The problem arises when
- 15:41there's a mismatch between the thesis
- 15:43that was sold and what actually happens
- 15:45within the fund. Do you understand the
- 15:46point? There was a not-so-recent case
- 15:48of a fund that boasted excessively
- 15:50about only having triple-A properties,
- 15:52meaning properties of the highest
- 15:54quality, and suddenly started including
- 15:56double-A properties and lost its thesis
- 15:58. So it's always good to remember that
- 16:00when you invest in a real estate fund,
- 16:02you're not buying a part of those
- 16:04properties, you're buying part of a
- 16:07fund, and the fund, depending on the
- 16:09manager's wishes, decides which
- 16:11properties will remain or not in the
- 16:13long term. If that manager frequently
- 16:15rotates the portfolio, you'll never
- 16:17have the stability that the thesis of
- 16:19real estate funds promises. Well, folks
- 16:22, these were the reasons that made me
- 16:23question this asset class. I respect
- 16:25those who like it, those who will
- 16:27continue investing. This isn't advice
- 16:29to stop investing in real estate funds,
- 16:31but only the reasons that made me avoid
- 16:33this asset class, okay? Did you enjoy
- 16:35the video? Don't forget to like and
- 16:37subscribe to this channel, because
- 16:39we're very close to reaching 50,000
- 16:40subscribers. And look, as I mentioned,
- 16:43these seven reasons weren't clickbait
- 16:45or anything, they're real things I
- 16:47analyzed. So I hope you leave here with
- 16:50at least a different perspective,
- 16:52understanding the pros and now the cons
- 16:54of the effects. A hug and see you next
- 16:56time.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 7 motivos pelos quais vendi Fundos Imobiliários (FIIs) by Rafael Zattar - CARTEIRA Z, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,105 words across 470 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.