Переговоры почти уже успешны — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Hello, dear friends. Nevertheless,
- 0:02negotiations are ongoing. Even if you've
- 0:04already forgotten about such things as
- 0:06negotiations, negotiations are ongoing.
- 0:08Moreover, they've taken an interesting
- 0:11turn.
- 0:13The thing is, you remember the recent
- 0:15negotiations, and we weren't expecting
- 0:16anything at all from them.
- 0:18Not that we weren't expecting anything,
- 0:20but even no matter how loudly I
- 0:21proclaimed it, nothing would happen.
- 0:22Well, there'll be a prisoner exchange,
- 0:24they'll come to an agreement, and that's
- 0:25it. And what's the big deal?
- 0:27But the negotiations are interesting for
- 0:29others because they've been split into
- 0:30two days. And territorial issues have
- 0:33been moved to the second day because
- 0:35they remember that in previous cases,
- 0:37that's where the biggest snags arose.
- 0:39That's why the round lasted only an hour
- 0:41and a half. On the very first day,
- 0:43humanitarian issues and so on were on
- 0:44the agenda.
- 0:46So, discussing humanitarian issues is a
- 0:48piece of cake.
- 0:50But moving on to specifics on
- 0:51territorial issues is where the problem
- 0:54begins.
- 0:56The Russian Federation, meanwhile,
- 0:58already acknowledges that it will be
- 1:00necessary to talk to Europe as well.
- 1:02And these aren't just my words; they're
- 1:05conclusions drawn from statements.
- 1:08Because EU representatives held
- 1:09consultations with Ukraine and the
- 1:11United States in Abu Dhabi before the
- 1:13delegations left to talk to the Russians
- 1:15. The Russians are sending extremely
- 1:18contradictory signals.
- 1:21They believe that Europe is behind
- 1:23Ukraine's intransigence and that they
- 1:25themselves can achieve their goals
- 1:27militarily.
- 1:29But then, every now and then, they say
- 1:31they're ready for dialogue. So what's
- 1:33that? Are they ready or not?
- 1:37But there's also the possibility that
- 1:38this is a kind of trolling on the part
- 1:40of the Russian Federation, because you
- 1:42remember, I had an entire video
- 1:44dedicated to their inability to even
- 1:45select a representative.
- 1:48And it's entirely possible that the
- 1:50Russian Federation is simply watching as
- 1:52Europe appoints this representative but
- 1:54can't agree among themselves. That is,
- 1:56some say, "This is the representative,"
- 1:58others say, "We will."
- 1:59And a third representative, and so on.
- 2:01In short, there can't be as many as 18
- 2:04representatives at these negotiations.
- 2:08As Trump's son-in-law said, if Europe
- 2:10could identify one person to speak on
- 2:12its behalf, it would be a greater
- 2:14achievement than getting the Russians to
- 2:16include it in the negotiations.
- 2:20And the debate on this issue is so
- 2:22fierce that even the Estonian prime
- 2:25minister, or whoever he is, joked that a
- 2:28TV show could be made about it.
- 2:31Europe is divided into three camps. The
- 2:33first proposes Kossuth as the
- 2:35representative.
- 2:36He is the President of the European
- 2:38Council.
- 2:39That is, his figure seems to suit
- 2:41everyone, but France and Germany, the
- 2:43two largest economies in the EU, don't
- 2:45want to give up their place at the table
- 2:47to Brussels, which they occupied during
- 2:50the Minsk agreements.
- 2:53Plus, France says we are the only ones
- 2:55in the EU that have nuclear weapons.
- 2:58Britain is not in the EU. Then there is
- 3:00the third group—the freaks.
- 3:03The freaks who say Kaja Kallas are just
- 3:05right.
- 3:06But Kaja Kallas is such a complete
- 3:08character that even the Europeans
- 3:10themselves are avoiding her.
- 3:13And this mum-mu-mutata has been going on
- 3:15for a long time.
- 3:18They can't choose representatives, and
- 3:19Russia keeps saying, "Well, we don't
- 3:21really want to talk to you."
- 3:23And then suddenly it declares, "Well,
- 3:25we're not against talking, choose your
- 3:26representatives." Do you understand?
- 3:28Kaja Kallas says that Russia doesn't
- 3:30want to see me because it needs weak
- 3:33negotiators.
- 3:35She's a strong negotiator; you know, she
- 3:36achieved significant success in the
- 3:38Ukraine negotiations.
- 3:40Of course, there are some unique
- 3:42individuals who justify her by saying
- 3:44that Putin would have done the same,
- 3:47choosing the person you least want to
- 3:49talk to.
- 3:51Well, if the last person they want to
- 3:53talk to is Kallas and that's the idea,
- 3:54then they simply won't talk to her, and
- 3:56that's it, they'll say, "To hell with
- 3:58her."
- 3:59Let her talk to herself, look in the
- 4:01mirror.
- 4:02She's a beautiful girl.
- 4:05Let her talk to herself.
- 4:07Others are even saying, "Why do we even
- 4:09need this?"
- 4:10European Commission President Ursula von
- 4:12der Leyen has disappointed everyone.
- 4:14Because while some countries were
- 4:16opposed to engaging in dialogue on
- 4:19security architecture, she suddenly
- 4:22allowed it to happen. This is sheer
- 4:25disarray and confusion. This disarray
- 4:28and confusion isn't limited to just some
- 4:31Brussels agencies.
- 4:33It's spreading to NATO, because NATO has
- 4:35drastically reduced its meetings. The
- 4:37summit scheduled for 2027 was cancelled
- 4:40.
- 4:41Ukraine isn't the only reason, because
- 4:43there's also the war in Iran and
- 4:45conflicts over defense spending.
- 4:49Somehow, an agreement was reached in
- 4:51Dublin on a negotiating format of the EU
- 4:52plus the E5, now.
- 4:55Because in addition to EU
- 4:57representatives, France, Germany, Italy
- 4:59, Poland, and the UK, which isn't even a
- 5:02member of the bloc, are sending envoys.
- 5:05That's how it is. So, I'm telling you,
- 5:07we'll have a delegation there of
- 5:09probably 80 people.
- 5:12We know that the ones who have made the
- 5:14most progress in negotiations with the
- 5:16Russian Federation are Stubb, no matter
- 5:18how much anyone likes him, and Norwegian
- 5:20Prime Minister Støre, because he and
- 5:22Stubb called the Kremlin.
- 5:24They were criticized, but Ursula even
- 5:26ended up thanking them.
- 5:28So instead of gratitude, they were told
- 5:31, well, smell the cheese, as they say.
- 5:34And they're not even mentioned at all.
- 5:36So, Poland is there, we're there, these
- 5:37guys, these guys, these guys, we're
- 5:39there, and Italy, for some reason. Why
- 5:40Italy?
- 5:42That's it. And they've simply been
- 5:43completely forgotten.
- 5:45The question also arises: will such
- 5:47negotiations really be sincere?
- 5:50Because just recently they were shouting
- 5:52that Russia would be defeated by about
- 5:542030, but could still attack NATO.
- 5:58Which is why we shouldn't make peace,
- 5:59but urgently need to build tanks, a
- 6:01Ukrainian shield for Europe,
- 6:03blah-blah-blah. And then suddenly
- 6:04something changes. What do you mean?
- 6:06Were they afraid of the protests and the
- 6:08right-wing politicians coming to power,
- 6:10or did they think that rearmament would
- 6:12require too much money and years, and
- 6:13most likely, there aren't any—neither
- 6:15the money nor the years.
- 6:17Or maybe it's all a bluff.
- 6:20I mean, when you observe all this, guys
- 6:22, well, let's just put aside all this
- 6:24fussing, right?
- 6:26The issue is peace in Europe.
- 6:29Ukraine, ending the war, stopping the
- 6:31hundreds of thousands of people from
- 6:32dying.
- 6:33And then suddenly this nonsense. Maybe
- 6:35it's all a bluff?
- 6:37Bluff, because Zelenskyy once traveled
- 6:39the world and said, "I want to talk to
- 6:40Putin," and he doesn't want to, so that
- 6:41means he doesn't want peace.
- 6:44Do you understand? You mean
- 6:47making demands that are certain to be
- 6:49rejected, and then saying, "See this?"
- 6:51Do you see?
- 6:53And now the general narrative is that
- 6:55Russia has made completely unacceptable
- 6:56demands in Abu Dhabi, demands that can't
- 6:58even be discussed.
- 7:01According to The New York Times, Russia
- 7:04has allegedly revived its pre-war
- 7:06ultimatum that NATO must cease expansion
- 7:08and return to the 1997 level, meaning
- 7:11withdraw from Poland and the Baltic
- 7:13states.
- 7:16The Alliance must also cease all
- 7:18military activity in the South Caucasus
- 7:20and Central Asia and cease all aid
- 7:22supplies to Kyiv.
- 7:25The Washington Post obtained a copy of
- 7:27the document, which contains new
- 7:29proposals.
- 7:31Moscow wants France and Great Britain to
- 7:33renounce the joint use of nuclear
- 7:35weapons, and wants Ukraine not only to
- 7:37never join NATO, but to amend its
- 7:39Constitution to this effect, but also to
- 7:41be banned from participating in EU
- 7:43collective defense measures altogether,
- 7:45even if it does become an EU member.
- 7:49It also specifies limits on the number
- 7:50of Ukrainian Armed Forces, and all sorts
- 7:52of other things.
- 7:54Overall, it seems as if this document is
- 7:56limitless.
- 7:57And whoever it ends up in, it keeps
- 7:59going to more and more editors—yes, the
- 8:01editors of some important publications—
- 8:03and they're reading something new into
- 8:05it. Because Britain's The Telegraph
- 8:17says Putin wants London to stop
- 8:20providing its nuclear umbrella to
- 8:22Europeans.
- 8:24Whether the German tabloid even
- 8:26discovered such a document is unknown,
- 8:29because we've previously been told that
- 8:31Russia proposed border changes, changes
- 8:34to the borders of Donbas, so that with
- 8:37the changed borders, Russia could, well
- 8:39, the Russian leadership could report to
- 8:42voters, "We captured Donbas."
- 8:46And this was announced by the Americans
- 8:48through their representatives to Kyiv,
- 8:50and then other publications, citing
- 8:52sources in the Ukrainian delegation,
- 8:54wrote that territorial concessions were
- 8:55never discussed and will not be
- 8:57recognized by Kyiv.
- 8:59So, where do such insider information
- 9:01come from in that case? Now a new
- 9:03narrative has emerged that in the
- 9:05Ukrainian, um, well, basically,
- 9:06delegation, there were two opinions—
- 9:08Arakhamia and Budanov—they have
- 9:10different approaches to resolving the
- 9:12Donbas issue.
- 9:15Well, Arakhamia suggests forgetting
- 9:16about Donbas altogether until the issue
- 9:18of peace guarantees in Europe is
- 9:20resolved, while Budanov suggests the
- 9:22parties agree on a demarcation line that
- 9:24will be acceptable to the army and
- 9:25society.
- 9:27Meanwhile, nothing insiders are saying
- 9:30is confirmed; well, what insiders are
- 9:32saying isn't officially confirmed.
- 9:36But, uh, as follows from the official
- 9:38information, Zelenskyy actually wants to
- 9:40maintain an 800,000-strong army after
- 9:42the war.
- 9:44What an 800,000-strong army is, and how
- 9:46much money it would require, according
- 9:48to the most basic estimates, you, my
- 9:50friends, can calculate.
- 9:52I've done the calculations, and the
- 9:54figures are approaching a trillion over
- 9:55several years.
- 9:58Hmm, what will it take from Ukrainian
- 10:01society for an 800,000-strong army to
- 10:03rotate?
- 10:06You get the idea, right? The TCC will
- 10:07increase, well, their staff will
- 10:10probably increase by a factor of 100.
- 10:12Because 800,000 will need to be
- 10:14constantly rotated.
- 10:16Well, still. Or, of course, we could
- 10:18introduce a completely different story
- 10:19into the Constitution: if you join the
- 10:21army, you can't leave. That's also a
- 10:23topic.
- 10:24Regarding the possible withdrawal of
- 10:26troops from Donbas, Zelenskyy says the
- 10:28US offered him this in exchange for NATO
- 10:31membership.
- 10:33This is very strange, because Trump was
- 10:35categorically opposed to Ukraine joining
- 10:38NATO.
- 10:39The most they are willing to provide is
- 10:41guarantees consistent with NATO's
- 10:42Article 5. Well, that's it.
- 10:46Zelenskyy rules out enshrining
- 10:47neutrality in the Constitution. Along
- 10:49with him, members of European countries
- 10:51began responding to points of this plan
- 10:54that no one has even seen. Well, the
- 10:56most, well, real members. Because the
- 10:59President of Lithuania stated that it is
- 11:00impossible to fulfill the demand for the
- 11:02withdrawal of NATO troops.
- 11:04Well, because it is clear where we will
- 11:05get our food from, yes, without all
- 11:07these military bases.
- 11:09French President Macron, with a 14%
- 11:10rating, says that Ukraine's place is in
- 11:13NATO, and those who want to cut aid to
- 11:15it are weakening all of Europe.
- 11:18Zelenskyy supported him and once again
- 11:20repeated the idiotic phrase that Russia
- 11:22only respects force.
- 11:24So, did they achieve much with that
- 11:25force back then? Well, they used force.
- 11:28It's flying, flying, flying every night
- 11:30. And what's Russia doing? Saying, "
- 11:32That's it, we respect you now, or what?
- 11:34"
- 11:35I only noticed that Peskov suddenly
- 11:37started calling Zelenskyy president. So
- 11:39is he president or the leader of the
- 11:41regime?
- 11:42Because, well, the people who repeated
- 11:44the narrative constantly coming from the
- 11:46Kremlin and the federal media that he's
- 11:48not really president look a little
- 11:49strange now.
- 11:51Guys, make up your mind. For me, this
- 11:54jerk is definitely not president.
- 11:56He wasn't elected for this term. Well,
- 11:58and the most powerful politicians out
- 12:00there, see Johnson, are saying that
- 12:02Ukraine's accession to NATO is the only
- 12:04way to end the war.
- 12:06What was that guy he said? Just fight.
- 12:09New sanctions against Russia are being
- 12:10prepared these days; they've already
- 12:12been imposed on many people, and entry
- 12:14is being banned for Russian athletes.
- 12:17Here, by the way, I absolutely must
- 12:19pause and congratulate Mira Andreeva on
- 12:21her convincing victory over that, what's
- 12:24her name, our compatriot, yes, who is
- 12:26simply a scumbag, in my opinion, who
- 12:29didn't shake hands after the game and
- 12:31refused to have her picture taken.
- 12:34You can just go now and not have your
- 12:36picture taken at all. And how
- 12:38outstanding is this nineteen-year-old
- 12:41athlete in the world? Yes, as she said,
- 12:43she says, congratulations, she did well
- 12:46there and all that. And she didn't even
- 12:47say a word. She's 12 years older. You
- 12:49jerk, you redneck, quit tennis already,
- 12:51get the hell out of here. That's it. And
- 12:54all the best to Mira, and she's a good
- 12:55girl. Sanctions should be slapped on her
- 12:57, and yet here she's winning. Why did I
- 12:59mention sanctions? This also shows
- 13:02Europe's willingness to negotiate. More
- 13:05tankers of the shadow fleet are being
- 13:07inspected again.
- 13:08Again, despite Belgium's dissatisfaction
- 13:10, they're talking about confiscating the
- 13:12Central Bank's assets. That is, it shows
- 13:15that they will act by force.
- 13:17Costa, the same one who is expected to
- 13:20represent Europe in negotiations with
- 13:22Russia, accused the Kremlin of
- 13:23destroying the security architecture in
- 13:25Europe.
- 13:26But before Russia intervened, everything
- 13:29was fine. What does this mean? It means
- 13:32that Romanian ships cannot even defend
- 13:34themselves in the nearby waters.
- 13:37Well, is this how Article 5 works? NATO
- 13:40infrastructure is already being attacked
- 13:43. NATO ships are already being attacked
- 13:45. So what? Something is happening.
- 13:48It turned out to be a fake gun that was
- 13:50hanging on the wall, but it turned out
- 13:52to be a fake and cannot fire.
- 13:55Huh? Maybe they're using all this, I
- 13:57don't know, to show off before the
- 13:59meeting between Putin, Trump, and Xi on
- 14:02the sidelines of the APEC summit.
- 14:04According to the latest information, the
- 14:05parties were unable to agree on an
- 14:07agenda. And this means that there will
- 14:08be more than just some boilerplate
- 14:10statements, but real negotiations. And
- 14:12the fate of Europe itself will be
- 14:14largely decided at these negotiations.
- 14:16That's perhaps why European leaders want
- 14:19to be seen as actors, not empty spaces.
- 14:22Like, to attract attention.
- 14:25But they've only attracted Moscow's
- 14:27attention, and Moscow is irritated
- 14:29because Moscow says no one invited
- 14:30Europe to the talks, and their
- 14:32participation wasn't discussed with
- 14:34Trump's special representatives either.
- 14:37Although, it's hard to understand the
- 14:40Russian leadership, as Peskov denied
- 14:43media reports that Russia is demanding
- 14:45Finland leave NATO.
- 14:48It's completely unclear.
- 14:50So, if Russia is demanding a rollback to
- 14:53the status quo and a guarantee of
- 14:55non-expansion, well, Russia demanded
- 14:57that in 2021, and after that, two
- 14:59countries joined NATO in a dangerous way
- 15:01, bringing NATO closer to the borders of
- 15:03the Russian Federation.
- 15:06So, will they turn a blind eye to this,
- 15:09or will they return to the level of 2021
- 15:11? And now they're like, "Well, they're
- 15:12already in." But back then, the same
- 15:14demand was made, and they did.
- 15:17So we won't be surprised if today
- 15:18Kremlin representatives refuse to deal
- 15:20with the EEU, with whom they claim
- 15:22there's nothing to discuss, and actually
- 15:24want to go to the border of the
- 15:25Zaporizhzhia and Kherson regions and
- 15:27send a delegation tomorrow.
- 15:29Meanwhile, the US is clearly
- 15:31demonstrating how they intend to end the
- 15:34war by force, to impose their desire for
- 15:36the war to be ended by force, because,
- 15:39well, Starlink has started acting up
- 15:41again.
- 15:42The speed has dropped to 160 km again.
- 15:44They say 100%of operations are disrupted
- 15:46.
- 15:47Moreover, if we believe Zelenskyy, the
- 15:49outages affected uncontrolled
- 15:50territories, while in the rest, service
- 15:51is normal.
- 15:52Oh, what a disaster. What happened?
- 15:55Maybe they shouldn't have made jokes
- 15:57ahead of time, when the Democrats won in
- 15:59Congress, huh?
- 16:02Maybe Zelenskyy shouldn't have written
- 16:04off Trump's team so quickly?
- 16:07You know how today you take a under
- 16:08someone's door, and tomorrow you're just
- 16:10surprised... "Why doesn't he invite me
- 16:11over?"
- 16:12That's it. That's the story with these
- 16:15negotiations.
- 16:16And of course, the whole situation
- 16:18partially resembles a comedy, if they
- 16:20weren't still taking people to the front
- 16:21lines on the streets of Ukraine and
- 16:23bringing them back without legs, without
- 16:25arms, or in sacks.
- 16:27The negotiations are ongoing, my friends
- 16:29, and soon, soon, everything will be
- 16:31agreed upon, yes. You believe, right? I
- 16:33believe. Subscribe so you don't miss a
- 16:35thing. We will, we will believe together
- 16:37. Bye.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of Переговоры почти уже успешны by Анатолий Шарий, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 2,692 words across 474 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.