YouTube2Text

657 Sayılı Kanuna İmza Atmadan Diyanet İmamlığı Yapılabilir mi? | Halis Bayancuk Hoca — Transcript

by Halis Bayancuk Hoca · 3,783 words · 581 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Go ahead, brother.
  2. 0:04>> Peace and mercy of God be upon you too.
  3. 0:06Welcome, brother İlyas.
  4. 0:07>> Thank you. May Allah be pleased with you
  5. 0:08. Praise be to God, teacher. How are you
  6. 0:10?
  7. 0:10>> May Allah be pleased with you. Thank you
  8. 0:12.
  9. 0:12>> Uh, with your permission, I have a
  10. 0:13question, teacher.
  11. 0:14>> With all my heart, please go ahead.
  12. 0:16>> Uh, teacher, lately some of our imam
  13. 0:19friends say that before starting their
  14. 0:21duty at the Presidency of Religious
  15. 0:23Affairs, they definitely did not sign
  16. 0:26the Law No. 657.
  17. 0:27>> Mmhmm.
  18. 0:30>> And they claim that when they started
  19. 0:31working, they did not speak falsehoods
  20. 0:33in the sermons and did not conceal the
  21. 0:35truth.
  22. 0:39And because of this, they say that the
  23. 0:41people of Tawhid are being unfair to
  24. 0:43them and oppressing them.
  25. 0:45They specifically asked us to pose this
  26. 0:47question to you.
  27. 0:49As a former imam, are these friends of
  28. 0:52mine right in their complaints?
  29. 0:54How should we evaluate this situation?
  30. 0:56>> Yes.
  31. 0:58>> Uh, teacher, before asking this, I did
  32. 1:00some research on this topic. I mean,
  33. 1:03really, because in our time, they made
  34. 1:06us sign Law No. 657. And that is how we
  35. 1:09became imams. Uh, the Diyanet recruits
  36. 1:11imams more or less every year or every
  37. 1:13two years
  38. 1:13>> Mmhmm.
  39. 1:14>> according to their needs.
  40. 1:16>> Mmhmm.
  41. 1:17>> Uh, most recently, they conducted a
  42. 1:18recruitment this year in May. They hired
  43. 1:213209 imams.
  44. 1:22>> Mmhmm.
  45. 1:23>> And among these application requirements
  46. 1:26, there is a clause stating they must
  47. 1:28meet the requirements of Article 48 of
  48. 1:30Law No. 657.
  49. 1:33The reason they put this in is because
  50. 1:35they will still make them sign Law No.
  51. 1:37657 when they become imams.
  52. 1:39>> Mmhmm.
  53. 1:40>> Uh, so they put it in the announcement.
  54. 1:42>> When you became one, did you take a
  55. 1:44verbal oath, or did you sign something?
  56. 1:46Because sometimes they make them take a
  57. 1:47verbal oath, and sometimes they make
  58. 1:49them sign. Both practices exist.
  59. 1:50>> I had signed it, teacher. They made us
  60. 1:52sign it at the mufti's office.
  61. 1:54>> All right. How many years has it been
  62. 1:56since you left, brother İlyas?
  63. 1:57>> Uh, teacher, 3 years.
  64. 1:59>> It has been 3 years. Praise be to God.
  65. 2:03Now, regarding this question, uh, a few
  66. 2:06imam brothers visited me as well.
  67. 2:09From different parts of Turkey, in
  68. 2:11different ways.
  69. 2:12Uh, now there is a matter like this.
  70. 2:14First, let me explain that, God willing
  71. 2:17. Now, things have been changing in
  72. 2:19Turkey over the last 10 years.
  73. 2:21But they are changing quietly. However,
  74. 2:23this is not a change in the system. For
  75. 2:26example, there are some changes that a
  76. 2:28provincial mufti has made by taking the
  77. 2:30initiative. For instance, like what?
  78. 2:32I mean, this is also something I have
  79. 2:34witnessed myself. For example, let's say
  80. 2:37the imam tells the mufti, "Uh, I don't
  81. 2:39want to sign.""I mean," he says, "this
  82. 2:41is against my religion.""I don't want to
  83. 2:43sign this." And the mufti says, "Then
  84. 2:45don't sign." He says, "If you don't want
  85. 2:46to sign, then don't." But look, this is
  86. 2:48not a change in the state. This is an
  87. 2:50official in a region taking initiative,
  88. 2:52and due to his initiative, the person
  89. 2:54does not sign that document; or, for
  90. 2:56example, I witnessed something like this
  91. 2:58...In health, uh, not in the imamate,
  92. 2:59but in health services. For example, the
  93. 3:01man says, "I won't sign this.""I will
  94. 3:03definitely not sign this." And he says,
  95. 3:05"Sign this." I do not accept this. He
  96. 3:07says, "I do not accept this part.""This
  97. 3:09is contrary to Islam." He says, "Then
  98. 3:11write down that you do not accept it
  99. 3:13while signing." Exactly like this, just
  100. 3:15like this. And the man writes, "I do not
  101. 3:16accept this part.""I am signing the rest
  102. 3:18," he says, for example. This exists,
  103. 3:20but how many examples are there in
  104. 3:22Turkey? Two, or one—I only know of one,
  105. 3:24but let's say there are two or three
  106. 3:26examples. Or let me tell you what one of
  107. 3:28the imams who visited me said, for
  108. 3:30example. He asked me a question. He said
  109. 3:32, "Teacher, I had signed it back then."
  110. 3:34"I had no consciousness of Tawhid at all
  111. 3:36," he said. "I learned Tawhid," he said
  112. 3:38. Okay. "Now I have repented.""I mean, I
  113. 3:40have repented.""I reformed.""I reformed
  114. 3:42my state and I declared it.""I went and
  115. 3:44stood before the congregation.""I told
  116. 3:46the congregation that these things are
  117. 3:48wrong.""These are things that break the
  118. 3:49bond between a person and Allah.""I mean
  119. 3:51, on top of that, I declared it.""I
  120. 3:53explained it." And he brought something
  121. 3:55like a notebook. Where he wrote his
  122. 3:57sermons and speeches.
  123. 3:59It's more or less similar to the topics
  124. 4:01discussed in any Tawhidic mosque.
  125. 4:04Now he asks, "Why is there such an
  126. 4:06attitude towards me among the people,
  127. 4:09among the Muslims?"
  128. 4:12Now look, let me ask a question first.
  129. 4:14How many mosques are there in Turkey?
  130. 4:16There are approximately 90,000 mosques
  131. 4:18in Turkey. What is the average number of
  132. 4:20Diyanet personnel in Turkey? 140,000 to
  133. 4:22150,000—if it has changed, I don't know
  134. 4:25, but as far as I last knew, there are
  135. 4:27140,000 to 150,000. There are 140,000 to
  136. 4:30150,000 personnel. How many of these,
  137. 4:33let's say, serve as imam or preacher?
  138. 4:35When we say imam, there should be at
  139. 4:37least nearly 90,000 imams, considering
  140. 4:40the number of mosques. Let's call it
  141. 4:4270,000; let's lower it even more, let's
  142. 4:45even say 50,000. Out of 50,000 imams,
  143. 4:47how many have the consciousness of
  144. 4:49Tawhid?
  145. 4:50How many of them did what we just
  146. 4:52mentioned?
  147. 4:53How many of them see this as a problem?
  148. 4:55Meaning, they think that taking such an
  149. 4:57oath is a problem.
  150. 4:59How many of them repented and then went
  151. 5:01out and declared their repentance?
  152. 5:03For instance, there is an imam in the
  153. 5:05Southeast; an investigation was opened
  154. 5:07against him because of this. As far as I
  155. 5:09understand, some people locally handled
  156. 5:11it there, so he continues his duty. Fine
  157. 5:13, but how many of these are there? If
  158. 5:14you gather them all, if everyone’s
  159. 5:16testimony were brought together, there
  160. 5:18are fewer people than fingers on one
  161. 5:20hand.
  162. 5:22Now, are we to interpret the issue of
  163. 5:24imamate, the Diyanet, and the system
  164. 5:26corrupting society through the Diyanet—
  165. 5:29a project to secularize society,
  166. 5:31democratize it, make society compatible
  167. 5:33with the new Kemalist system, and break
  168. 5:35the bond with the Ottomans—by looking at
  169. 5:38these 10 imam friends, an institution
  170. 5:40for which those who founded it, the
  171. 5:42state, and the Constitutional Court all
  172. 5:44have rulings?
  173. 5:46I mean, while explaining this topic and
  174. 5:48warning society, should we drop
  175. 5:50everything and focus on those 10 imams?
  176. 5:52What would be the ruling regarding those
  177. 5:5310 imams? Now, if what is said is truly
  178. 5:55the case, this turns into a matter of
  179. 5:57fiqh (jurisprudential) preference. I
  180. 5:58mean, I would still say don't do it. I
  181. 6:00have my own reasons for that. I say
  182. 6:02don't do it. I don't want to elaborate
  183. 6:03because this is not the right place for
  184. 6:05it. But when a ruling is explained to
  185. 6:06society, it is not explained through
  186. 6:08exceptions. When a ruling is explained
  187. 6:10to society, it is explained through the
  188. 6:12essence of the matter, through its
  189. 6:13prevalent state. Now, our Islamic
  190. 6:15scholars have derived many rules by
  191. 6:17looking at the Quran and the Sunnah.
  192. 6:19They have said, for instance:
  193. 6:21A ruling is always based on the
  194. 6:22predominant state.
  195. 6:24They have said, for example. That which
  196. 6:26is rare or an exception is considered
  197. 6:28non-existent. Meaning, you treat it as
  198. 6:30if it doesn't exist. Why?
  199. 6:33Because all the texts that Islam has
  200. 6:35preached to us show that rulings
  201. 6:36function based on what is predominant
  202. 6:38and widespread.
  203. 6:40Actually, this is not just about this
  204. 6:42topic; we have a general problem in
  205. 6:44Turkey regarding*dawah*(invitation to
  206. 6:46Islam). There is a general issue
  207. 6:48regarding this subject. For example, let
  208. 6:50me give you an example. Let's say you
  209. 6:52have a society in front of you.
  210. 6:57You tell this society that sovereignty
  211. 6:59belongs to Allah, that democracy is a
  212. 7:01religion, and that just as the most
  213. 7:02prominent symbol of Islam is prayer, the
  214. 7:05greatest ritual of the religion of
  215. 7:06democracy is elections, that the purpose
  216. 7:08and goal of elections is to give the
  217. 7:10right of sovereignty not to Allah but to
  218. 7:12the people, and that it doesn't matter
  219. 7:14what you call it because the owners of
  220. 7:16this system have already named it and
  221. 7:18assigned a meaning to it.
  222. 7:22Just as the ruling on a named act of
  223. 7:24disobedience, like alcohol or adultery,
  224. 7:26doesn't change when you call it by
  225. 7:28another name, in the same way, a creed
  226. 7:30of disbelief has emerged, and those who
  227. 7:32preach this creed have stated that this
  228. 7:34is what elections mean. You giving it a
  229. 7:36different meaning is just you deceiving
  230. 7:38yourself. "I am choosing the lesser of
  231. 7:40two evils.""My goal is this, let them
  232. 7:42build roads, etc." Now, someone there
  233. 7:45says to you, "Brother," he says, "for
  234. 7:47instance, there is this 90-year-old
  235. 7:49grandmother in a village in Bingöl." Yes
  236. 7:51. He says this grandmother doesn't know
  237. 7:53how to read or write. She has never
  238. 7:54stepped out onto the street in her life
  239. 7:55. She hasn't watched television. She has
  240. 7:57no idea about the outside world. In
  241. 7:59places like Bingöl and Erzurum, there
  242. 8:01are indeed such elderly aunts. Their
  243. 8:03children take them by the arm, take them
  244. 8:05, and make them vote, for example. "Is
  245. 8:07this aunt also included in this ruling?
  246. 8:09"
  247. 8:10But my brother, should I really explain
  248. 8:12the greatest problem of the Islamic
  249. 8:14Ummah through this 90-year-old
  250. 8:15grandmother in the Yamaç village of
  251. 8:17Bingöl?
  252. 8:19Is your intellect really this mature? Do
  253. 8:21you really understand this little about
  254. 8:23Islamic*dawah*? Should I drop everything
  255. 8:25and not speak about the disbelief,
  256. 8:27polytheism, Westernization,
  257. 8:28democratization, and secularization that
  258. 8:31millions of people are turning towards?
  259. 8:35Am I to describe an institution that
  260. 8:37corrupts all Muslims based on the
  261. 8:39situation of a 90-year-old auntie in
  262. 8:41some village in Bingöl, or based on an
  263. 8:43imam in a village in Ağrı who didn’t
  264. 8:46sign something, an imam who speaks the
  265. 8:48truth, or an imam from Diyarbakır, or, I
  266. 8:50don't know, an imam in a village in
  267. 8:52Edirne?
  268. 8:54Is such a thing even possible? Is the
  269. 8:56Islamic call, as we call it, something
  270. 8:58like that? Look.
  271. 9:00The Islamic call never proceeds based on
  272. 9:02exceptions. When an exception comes
  273. 9:04before you, you judge the exception.
  274. 9:06That is, as you go through life, as you
  275. 9:08continue, an exceptional personality
  276. 9:10comes your way. For instance, such an
  277. 9:12imam comes along. You talk about his
  278. 9:14ruling then, but the essential thing is
  279. 9:15to speak based on the general and
  280. 9:17dominant situation. Now, the Islamic
  281. 9:19Ummah has gone through three great
  282. 9:20fitnas. It has gone through three great
  283. 9:22fitnas in terms of creed. The Islamic
  284. 9:23Ummah also has three major political
  285. 9:25fitnas. I am talking about the creedal
  286. 9:27ones. First, the apostasy (Ridda) events
  287. 9:28that began during the Prophet's life and
  288. 9:30continued during the time of Abu Bakr (
  289. 9:32may Allah be pleased with him). Second,
  290. 9:34the trial of the Islamic Ummah that
  291. 9:36began during the time of Imam Ahmad
  292. 9:38regarding the belief that "the Quran is
  293. 9:40created," the second issue. Third, the
  294. 9:42issue of the democratization,
  295. 9:43secularization, and mental defeat of the
  296. 9:46Islamic Ummah to the Western world that
  297. 9:48began with the fall of the Caliphate.
  298. 9:50These three are not political problems.
  299. 9:52These three are all related to creed, an
  300. 9:54issue concerning creed. In the first
  301. 9:56case, for example, during the time of
  302. 9:58Abu Bakr (may Allah be pleased with him
  303. 10:00), according to the majority of Islamic
  304. 10:02scholars, not all of the people he
  305. 10:03fought against were apostates.
  306. 10:06There were some among them who were
  307. 10:08apostates.
  308. 10:09There were also those among them who
  309. 10:11were not apostates. Then why do we not
  310. 10:12see this in the style of the Sahaba? Why
  311. 10:14do we read the Ridda events through the
  312. 10:16lens of apostasy rather than through
  313. 10:18those who were exceptional, had their
  314. 10:20own interpretations, were not apostates
  315. 10:22, and only had economic problems with
  316. 10:23the Islamic state? Because the Sahaba
  317. 10:25put them all in the same basket. They
  318. 10:27issued a judgment on all of them based
  319. 10:29on the general and dominant situation
  320. 10:30and treated them accordingly. Until when
  321. 10:32? When one of those exceptions appeared
  322. 10:34before them and said, "By Allah, I do
  323. 10:36not believe this. By Allah, I do not do
  324. 10:38this." They singled him out. They
  325. 10:40continued to treat the rest as they had
  326. 10:41before. They did not say, "Oh, look,
  327. 10:43there are such people among them too. If
  328. 10:44there are such people, let us watch our
  329. 10:46language, let us watch our style. Let us
  330. 10:47be careful while fighting." They did not
  331. 10:49say that. That is, they acted based on
  332. 10:51the general, not on the exception. Think
  333. 10:53of the era of Imam Ahmad. For example,
  334. 10:55they said, "Whoever says 'The Quran is
  335. 10:56created' is a disbeliever." In other
  336. 10:57words, the imams of that era drew a very
  337. 10:59clear line against this creedal
  338. 11:00deviation. "Whoever says, 'The Quran is
  339. 11:02created' is a disbeliever, and whoever
  340. 11:03does not call him a disbeliever is also
  341. 11:04a disbeliever," they said. A clear line
  342. 11:05. So, here is the question. Did they
  343. 11:07view everyone who said, "The Quran is
  344. 11:08created," as a disbeliever? No. Even
  345. 11:10Imam Ahmad himself says, "I did not
  346. 11:11understand this issue for many long
  347. 11:12years," he says. "I did not understand
  348. 11:14it for many long years," he says. Then
  349. 11:16he says, when I saw such and such verses
  350. 11:18of Allah Almighty, I realized that "the
  351. 11:19Quran is created." He says I understood
  352. 11:21that saying this means that Allah's
  353. 11:22knowledge is created, and that saying
  354. 11:24this is disbelief. Now, is it possible
  355. 11:26for Imam Ahmed to carry out such a chain
  356. 11:28of excommunication over an issue he
  357. 11:29himself understood later? This is an
  358. 11:31issue that remained obscure even to Imam
  359. 11:33Ahmed. Well, we see many scholars of the
  360. 11:35Salaf saying the following when an
  361. 11:36exception is in question. "The one who
  362. 11:38says this while understanding this issue
  363. 11:39is a disbeliever." Look, there is a
  364. 11:41caveat there. But when we read the books
  365. 11:43of Sunnah and books of creed, we do not
  366. 11:45see these caveats very often. We rarely
  367. 11:47encounter these caveats. Why? Because
  368. 11:49Islam is taught based on general
  369. 11:51principles. If a society is flocking to
  370. 11:53disbelief in droves, you do not dilute
  371. 11:55the matter by reminding them of
  372. 11:57exceptions. You establish the monotheism
  373. 11:59(Tawhid) to protect people from that
  374. 12:00disbelief and that polytheism (Shirk).
  375. 12:02You warn people against polytheism. You
  376. 12:04warn people against worshipping the
  377. 12:05Taghut (false deities). Then, in the
  378. 12:07course of life, you come across a man. "
  379. 12:09The Quran is created." He hasn't fully
  380. 12:10understood what it means to say this. He
  381. 12:12has uttered these words. You explain it
  382. 12:14to him, remove the doubt of that
  383. 12:15exception, and save him. But you cannot
  384. 12:17say, "Oh look, one person turned out
  385. 12:19like this, so others might be the same.
  386. 12:21""I better be careful when I speak from
  387. 12:22now on.""I should always say it like
  388. 12:24this.""Meaning, saying the Quran is
  389. 12:25created is disbelief, but let me give a
  390. 12:2745-minute lecture.""Let me explain in
  391. 12:29the first 3 minutes of the lesson that
  392. 12:30saying the Quran is created is disbelief
  393. 12:31.""In the remaining 40 minutes of the
  394. 12:33lesson, let me divide these into 8 or 9
  395. 12:35categories.""Let me confuse the minds of
  396. 12:37the people.""Let me make them think
  397. 12:38after listening to the lecture that this
  398. 12:40issue is probably not that important,
  399. 12:42since it has 7-8 categories, we
  400. 12:43shouldn't care too much." Can there be
  401. 12:45such a language, such a style of
  402. 12:46presentation? Such a presentation is a
  403. 12:48style that does not exist in our Salaf.
  404. 12:50Now, isn't coercion (ikrah) an obstacle
  405. 12:52to entering disbelief among all of us?
  406. 12:54Isn't coercion an obstacle to entering
  407. 12:56disbelief among the entire Islamic Ummah
  408. 12:58? When you read the Quran, how many
  409. 12:59verses on coercion are there? One. What
  410. 13:01are all the remaining verses explaining
  411. 13:03? They explain that a person who
  412. 13:04associates partners with Allah will not
  413. 13:06be forgiven by Allah, that a person who
  414. 13:07associates partners with Allah will
  415. 13:09remain in the fire eternally, that
  416. 13:10Paradise is made forbidden for the
  417. 13:11person who associates partners with
  418. 13:13Allah, that the person who associates
  419. 13:14partners with Allah is ritually impure (
  420. 13:16najis), and that all the deeds of a
  421. 13:17person who associates partners with
  422. 13:18Allah will be in vain. But that
  423. 13:20exception, that coercion, which is
  424. 13:21something that can happen to some people
  425. 13:23in life, is explained in one verse in
  426. 13:25Surah an-Nahl, it is explained, and then
  427. 13:27it ends. Now, some people want us to do
  428. 13:29this today. Let us not explain
  429. 13:31monotheism, but let us explain people's
  430. 13:33excuses. Let us not explain monotheism,
  431. 13:36but let us explain the exceptions in
  432. 13:38life. In fact, we sometimes encounter
  433. 13:40this in such conversations. Let's say
  434. 13:42someone says, "But if you don't explain
  435. 13:44these, then the fitna (sedition) of
  436. 13:46excommunication (takfirism) arises.""Or
  437. 13:48the issue of extreme, improper
  438. 13:50excommunication arises." You say, "
  439. 13:51Brother, how many people are there who
  440. 13:53you say are doing this extreme, improper
  441. 13:54excommunication?" Look, even when you
  442. 13:56speak, you say "3-5 bums." Even when you
  443. 13:58speak, you say "3-5 takfiris." On one
  444. 14:01side, millions of people are heading
  445. 14:02toward disbelief. On one side, 3-5
  446. 14:04people make mistake after mistake. And
  447. 14:07you tell me to leave the mistakes of
  448. 14:09millions aside. And focus on the issues
  449. 14:11of those 3-5 people. Use a language to
  450. 14:13correct them, a language to set them
  451. 14:15straight.
  452. 14:17The Islamic call has never been
  453. 14:18conducted through exceptions. The
  454. 14:20Islamic call is always built on
  455. 14:22principles—the common, the dominant, and
  456. 14:24the language that protects society from
  457. 14:27danger. Are there exceptions, though?
  458. 14:28There are exceptions in every matter.
  459. 14:30When do they arise? When the person who
  460. 14:32falls into that exception comes before
  461. 14:34you. When the person who holds that
  462. 14:35specific concession comes before you.
  463. 14:37Then, you speak about their specific
  464. 14:39ruling and their specific exception.
  465. 14:42That’s why you always see this, for
  466. 14:43instance. For years, they said this. We
  467. 14:46have all witnessed this. They said this
  468. 14:48is no way to invite to the faith. They
  469. 14:50said society turns away from this call
  470. 14:52because it is done this way. And at the
  471. 14:54point we have reached, it has turned out
  472. 14:55that this was also a lie.
  473. 14:57I mean, that language of exceptions—
  474. 14:59that constant "if this happens, then
  475. 15:01that happens"—has already dragged
  476. 15:04society into a religious vortex.
  477. 15:08Normally, throughout history, religion
  478. 15:10came to guide life and gave direction to
  479. 15:12people within life. For the first time
  480. 15:14in our era, religion has turned into a
  481. 15:16factor that confuses people's minds.
  482. 15:19Because there are 50 different views on
  483. 15:21religion, instead of providing guidance
  484. 15:23, religion has become something that
  485. 15:25overwhelms people. Religion should have
  486. 15:27a clear language today.
  487. 15:29It should tell people clearly what is
  488. 15:31faith, what is disbelief, what should be
  489. 15:34avoided, and what should be done.
  490. 15:37But unfortunately, this language of
  491. 15:39exceptions causes millions of people to
  492. 15:41be confused just to prevent 2-3 people
  493. 15:43from making mistakes.
  494. 15:45So, I don't know, if the people you call
  495. 15:48friends come, they are welcome. I would
  496. 15:50host them, too. I would discuss this
  497. 15:52topic with them as well. I encounter
  498. 15:53them from time to time anyway. There are
  499. 15:55both my own old friends and people from
  500. 15:57our circle. I tell them as well. I say,
  501. 15:59"If you have such a situation, this is
  502. 16:01an exceptional case." Let no one explain
  503. 16:03it through exceptions. Take October 29th
  504. 16:05, for example. Think of the sermon, this
  505. 16:07year, October 29th, 2026. You saw the
  506. 16:10sermon; you saw what it was about. The
  507. 16:11question is this. How many imams in
  508. 16:13Turkey said to the public while reading
  509. 16:15this sermon, "No, this is wrong"? "This
  510. 16:18is not a holiday.""Because this is the
  511. 16:20destruction of Islam and the
  512. 16:21establishment of a new order in its
  513. 16:22place.""It is never permissible for us
  514. 16:24to celebrate such a holiday or to pray
  515. 16:26for mercy for the people who built it."
  516. 16:28"The truth is this," they said. Let’s
  517. 16:30say there are three imams. What are we
  518. 16:32going to do about the remaining 90,000
  519. 16:33mosques? Should we talk about the issue
  520. 16:35through the three mosques that didn't do
  521. 16:37this, instead of warning society through
  522. 16:39the 90,000 mosques? That would be an
  523. 16:41injustice. I think my friends in this
  524. 16:44situation, instead of whining, sulking,
  525. 16:46or telling Muslims not to oppress them,
  526. 16:48should take the real responsibility and
  527. 16:50start a movement, and we will follow
  528. 16:52them. I mean, let them come out and
  529. 16:54defend their rights. Why is it called
  530. 16:56censorship when a journalist is told not
  531. 16:58to say this or to say that, but when the
  532. 17:00state applies censorship to a clergyman
  533. 17:02through laws, statutes, and regulations
  534. 17:04, it isn't called censorship? Why can
  535. 17:06everyone else express their opinions
  536. 17:08freely, but a clergyman or a religious
  537. 17:11scholar has to speak while remaining
  538. 17:13bound by laws, regulations, statutes,
  539. 17:15and the 657 Civil Servants Law? We
  540. 17:17reject this. Why, when I become an imam
  541. 17:19, a teacher, or a municipal worker, am I
  542. 17:21forced to swear that I will remain
  543. 17:23secular, democratic, and loyal to the
  544. 17:26principles and reforms of Atatürk? What
  545. 17:28kind of connection do Atatürk's
  546. 17:29principles and reforms have with the
  547. 17:31religious knowledge I will provide or
  548. 17:33explain in a sermon? What kind of
  549. 17:34connection does the construction work I
  550. 17:36do have with Atatürk's principles and
  551. 17:37reforms while I'm cleaning up trash,
  552. 17:39cleaning the neighborhood, or building a
  553. 17:41structure? Take this kind of oath from
  554. 17:42me instead. Make me swear in the name of
  555. 17:44God that I will perform my profession in
  556. 17:46the best possible way, that I will never
  557. 17:48betray the money I earn, and that I will
  558. 17:50never take a bribe. At least let it
  559. 17:51serve a purpose. I mean, let it
  560. 17:53encourage me to do something in my work
  561. 17:55.
  562. 17:56If these brothers are going to do
  563. 17:58something, I think it will be an example
  564. 18:00for people working in other fields as
  565. 18:01well.
  566. 18:03Let them start an initiative that will
  567. 18:04save them from this doctrinal dilemma as
  568. 18:06well. And we should stand by their side
  569. 18:08, with everything we have, our lives,
  570. 18:10and our spirit, and give them our
  571. 18:12support. But in the face of such a huge
  572. 18:14problem, acting childishly—saying "oh,
  573. 18:16don't oppress us" or "I'm just reading
  574. 18:18what's in the sermon"—is, in my opinion
  575. 18:21, not the right attitude. As I said, if
  576. 18:23they want to come, they are more than
  577. 18:24welcome. I will take care of them
  578. 18:26personally, God willing.
  579. 18:27>> May God be pleased with you, teacher.
  580. 18:28>> All right. May God be pleased with you
  581. 18:30too, brother. You're welcome.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 657 Sayılı Kanuna İmza Atmadan Diyanet İmamlığı Yapılabilir mi? | Halis Bayancuk Hoca by Halis Bayancuk Hoca, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,783 words across 581 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.