هل تطور الإنسان من قرد؟ جمال نظرية التطور | حيران له أصحاب (6) مع أ. عمرو عبد الجليل ( مدبلج ) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:05In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the
- 0:06Most Merciful.
- 0:07Now, the next question is a tricky one.
- 0:11It says: Did we really evolve from apes?
- 0:13I mean, were we originally apes and then
- 0:16evolved into humans?
- 0:17All praise to Allah, and peace be upon the
- 0:20Prophet, his family, companions, and followers.
- 0:22And now, to proceed.
- 0:23This is a question of so-called scientific
- 0:25atheism—the ABCs of it.
- 0:27That's what they call scientific atheism,
- 0:29science, and all that.
- 0:30Honestly, this is ignorant atheism, not scientific.
- 0:33Yes, really.
- 0:34To be honest with you, this question contains
- 0:36several fallacies, and it's the method that
- 0:38atheists use to approach young people with it.
- 0:40The first fallacy or problem with this whole
- 0:42story is that it's all based on a purely
- 0:45hypothetical mental assumption, instead of
- 0:47scientific research.
- 0:49Yeah.
- 0:49Scientists have been researching all types of
- 0:52rocks for one hundred sixty years,
- 0:54sedimentary rocks, sandstone, and all kinds
- 0:57of deserts and oceans, trying to find
- 1:00evidence for this topic.
- 1:03There's a very famous person named Bernard
- 1:05Wood, a professor at George Washington
- 1:07University,
- 1:08He carried out extensive scientific research
- 1:10on the ancient fossilized remains known as
- 1:12human ghosts.
- 1:14He spent twenty years working on a single
- 1:16fossil site called Mohapleth, examining every
- 1:19part of it,
- 1:21and after spending his whole life on this story,
- 1:23he published a paper in the world's top
- 1:25scientific journal, Nature.
- 1:28He specifically wrote, stating there is not
- 1:30one single definitive fossil that we can call
- 1:32an evolutionary ancestor of human beings.
- 1:34All these fossils are highly questionable and
- 1:36open to debate.
- 1:38Thank you.
- 1:38That's the heart of the story.
- 1:40Yes.
- 1:41The greatest professor of Darwinism in the
- 1:42last century came and took hold of the whole story.
- 1:45His name is Ernst Mayr.
- 1:47He wrote a book called 'What Makes Biology Unique.'
- 1:51An impressive book on this subject.
- 1:53So he said it to you with absolute clarity.
- 1:56Between humans and apes, there is a gulf with
- 1:59no fossils in it.
- 2:01There is nothing intermediate at all.
- 2:03Upon reviewing the entirety of the narrative,
- 2:05he said, 'Okay, let's examine this matter at
- 2:07the genetic level since there are no fossils
- 2:10available.'
- 2:12Let's look deep inside the human being,
- 2:13inside the human genome itself.
- 2:15Is it possible for genes themselves to evolve
- 2:18through mutations that turn an ape into a human?
- 2:23So he started extensively researching this
- 2:25topic and found that for just a single
- 2:26mutation to occur and become fixed in one generation...
- 2:29We would need more than one hundred million
- 2:32years —wow , more than one hundred million years.
- 2:36But between humans and apes, there are
- 2:38actually more than sixty million distinct
- 2:40genetic differences.
- 2:43So we would need millions or billions of
- 2:45times the age of this universe.
- 2:46So this is science fiction, not science.
- 2:49Yeah.
- 2:50So the research tells you no, evolution
- 2:52doesn't work, and glory be to God, he said,
- 2:54'So how do we wrap up this story?' So at a
- 2:58very famous American university,
- 3:00the University of Michigan, they said, 'We're
- 3:02going to create evolution inside the lab.'
- 3:04We're going to settle this story once and for all.
- 3:08How does evolution happen?
- 3:09They said evolution happens through random
- 3:11mutations over thousands of years, Millions
- 3:15of years, So why don't we just do these
- 3:17mutations, but in a concentrated, intensive
- 3:20way, so that the mutations that would take a
- 3:23million years, we do them in a month.
- 3:25I think that's something astonishing.
- 3:27Yeah, it's a challenge for every person in the world.
- 3:30And then for every monkey.
- 3:31And everyone will prove the story.
- 3:33Yeah, that his origin was a monkey.
- 3:35So they used bacteria.
- 3:36which
- 3:37is the easiest thing to evolve.
- 3:38They put bacteria into small flasks inside the lab.
- 3:43And they exposed them to deliberate mutations.
- 3:46What does 'deliberate' mean?
- 3:47Chemicals, radiation, and a very long story, really.
- 3:50And these mutations continued for thirty years.
- 3:55This process led to 60,000 generations of
- 3:57bacteria—trillions of bacteria, I mean, an
- 4:00incredibly massive and vast number.
- 4:02And the equivalent of 1,000,000 years of
- 4:05evolution passed.
- 4:061,000,000 years.
- 4:08All condensed into just 30 short years.
- 4:10So, what was the final result?
- 4:12After all these experiments, the University
- 4:14of Michigan reported to us that not a single
- 4:16new type of bacteria appeared —we are not
- 4:19even talking about humans and monkeys here.
- 4:21Even more astonishing, they stated that not
- 4:23even one single new protein appeared during
- 4:26the entire process.
- 4:28Just a protein.
- 6:05The example of Jesus to God is like that of Adam.
- 6:08People in the past used to say, how could
- 6:11Jesus, peace be upon him, be born without a father?
- 6:14Well, It's something people just don't understand.
- 6:17So what did God say to them?
- 6:18The example of Jesus to God is like that of Adam.
- 6:21So if Adam, according to the proponents of
- 6:23the theory, came from other creatures,
- 6:26something like humans or something similar,
- 6:29then there is no argument in this verse.
- 6:32But the verse is telling me no.
- 6:34Adam was created directly, without being
- 6:37descended from a previous creature.
- 6:39Likewise, the Messiah, peace be upon him,
- 6:42came into being without being descended from
- 6:44another creature.
- 6:45So the argument here is settled—what is the matter?
- 6:48No, this is a direct divine creation, of course.
- 6:51So this is science, research, paleontology,
- 6:54genetics, and laboratories.
- 6:56And this is the Book of the Lord of the Worlds.
- 6:58So why would a young Arab Muslim today defend
- 7:01such a theory?
- 7:02You should say, 'Bring your proof if you are
- 7:05truthful.' We've spent years searching,
- 7:08researching, and excavating.
- 7:10As for me, for example, I—Haitham—have read,
- 7:12by the grace of God, thousands of scientific papers.
- 7:15If I found even a single scientific paper
- 7:17that directly supports the theory,
- 7:19I'd be ashamed.
- 7:19I'd be too shy to talk.
- 7:21I'd have to respond.
- 7:22It's as if I were responding to science.
- 7:24So the criticism is directed, not at me, but
- 7:26at the religion.
- 7:28Exactly.
- 7:28At that point, I wouldn't be able to speak anymore.
- 7:32So what makes you so confident and say, I challenge.
- 7:36I challenge anyone in the whole world.
- 7:38to bring me a single type of living creature
- 7:42that has transformed into another type.
- 7:45Evolved.
- 7:45And became a new creature.
- 7:46A different creature.
- 7:47My professor, he would tell you very simply
- 7:50what they do.
- 7:52They find two creatures that look alike,
- 7:54resemble each other.
- 7:56They put an arrow between them.
- 7:57And say, 'This one came from that one.'
- 7:59I'm sorry, really, professor, but that arrow
- 8:01is a leap of faith for you.
- 8:02That's a religious belief you have.
- 8:05An atheistic belief, I mean.
- 8:06That's faith, not science.
- 8:08So that arrow is interpretive philosophy,
- 8:11you're assuming that just because this one
- 8:13looks like that one, it must have come from it. No,
- 8:16that's a mental assumption on your part.
- 8:17Interpretive philosophy.
- 8:19Hallucinations.
- 8:20Hallucinations.
- 8:20Essentially.
- 8:21It's true, hallucinations.
- 8:22Yes.
- 8:23And then he asks, 'So why do they teach this
- 8:26stuff in universities?'
- 8:28Why teach this in uni?
- 8:29That's right.
- 8:30This is actually one of the topics that was
- 8:31answered by the pioneer of Darwinism himself.
- 8:34Richard Lewontin answered this question. Yes.
- 8:36Richard Lewontin, the pioneer of modern Darwinism.
- 8:40He said, 'We make scientific assumptions that
- 8:42seem ridiculous.' These aren't my words,
- 8:45they're his.
- 8:45Yes, a scientific assumption that seems
- 8:47ridiculous, like a living organism— And I'll
- 8:49give you an example, honestly, of this: the
- 8:51transformation of one organism into another.
- 8:54But we put forward these ridiculous
- 8:56assumptions because they're the only support
- 8:59for our materialistic worldview.
- 9:00It's just because we're atheists.
- 9:04It's one of two things: either direct divine
- 9:07creation or evolution, So as long as the
- 9:11world has become materialistic and the
- 9:13perspective is atheistic, then we are forced
- 9:16to advocate for evolution.
- 9:18Yes, so this is a belief we have—a prior
- 9:20belief in materialism.
- 9:22Yes, not because we've proven these assumptions;
- 9:23these are just assumptions.
- 9:25Yes, these are assumptions.
- 9:26I'll give you an example of this so you can
- 9:28see just how unconvincing the matter really
- 9:30is, to be honest.
- 9:32I mean, that's the most appropriate word to use.
- 9:34For example, they tell you—and this is one of
- 9:36the most famous pieces of evidence for the
- 9:37theory— They say there was a dog called
- 9:38Pakicetus, like a dog, basically.
- 9:40I'm sorry—excuse me for saying this—but it
- 9:42turned into a whale.
- 9:44So, where did all the whales on earth come from?
- 9:46From the dog.
- 9:46From this dog, Pakicetus.
- 9:48Sorry, but how is that even possible?
- 9:50They say, 'Well, it's easy—over thousands of years.'
- 9:52Millions of years.
- 9:53Just a reason?
- 9:54Hind legs fused, the nose shifted up, its
- 9:56body streamlined, and breathing began.
- 9:58And it stopped barking.
- 9:59Yeah.
- 10:00It stopped.
- 10:01Barking.
- 10:02And then it developed an echolocation system
- 10:04and all that story.
- 10:05So, sir, how exactly did you build this argument?
- 10:10They say, 'We found in the inner ear of
- 10:12Pakicetus a structure called the involucrum,
- 10:14which allows it to hear underwater.' Oh my God.
- 10:17Such profound philosophy, honestly.
- 10:19That's what they say—I'm not making this up, really.
- 10:21How can you build such a grand philosophy
- 10:24that the dog became a whale just because of
- 10:27this little structure?
- 10:29What is quite amazing is that they discovered
- 10:31the exact same structure in an animal that is
- 10:33much like a goat.
- 10:34So then they said, 'Well, is the whale
- 10:36descended from a dog or from a goat?' Now
- 10:39they've got a problem.
- 10:39Of course.
- 10:40The second problem is that they found this
- 10:42little structure doesn't even allow it to
- 10:43hear underwater.
- 10:44It's just naturally present in it to begin with.
- 10:47Yeah.
- 10:48So the fundamental issue I have here is, for
- 10:50a dog to eventually turn into a whale...
- 10:52And this is research done by one of the most
- 10:55prominent and leading scientists in the
- 10:56West—he explicitly stated that we would need
- 10:59fifty thousand distinct changes, and each
- 11:01change would require thousands of
- 11:03intermediate creatures.
- 11:03So you would actually need literally millions
- 11:06and millions of intermediate creatures
- 11:08between a dog and a whale.
- 11:09Honestly, we don't have a single intermediate
- 11:11creature at all.
- 11:11There's not a single creature between the dog
- 11:14and the whale.
- 11:15So, I'm sorry, but if I were telling my
- 11:17little son, I'd say: 'The dog's legs stuck
- 11:19together, its nose went up, and its body
- 11:21became streamlined.'
- 11:23He'd say, 'Dad, I'm too old for your
- 11:24stories.'
- 11:25He'd tell me, 'I'm really too old for this
- 11:26talk.' Yes, this is a belief they follow,
- 11:29they teach it in universities, and it's
- 11:31widespread because it's the only alternative
- 11:33to divine creation.
- 11:35And that's why, sir, what I'm telling you
- 11:37here made one of the leading advocates of the
- 11:40philosophy of science—an atheist, not a
- 11:42Muslim, not a Christian, not a priest—
- 11:44He's an atheist named Karl Popper.
- 11:47He explicitly stated that the theory of
- 11:49evolution is a metaphysical leap.
- 11:51It is a metaphysical belief, in much the same
- 11:55way as anyone claiming there is a scarecrow,
- 11:57a dragon, or an alien.
- 11:58A metaphysical belief, just as you have, and
- 12:01he said—the very final words that he ever
- 12:03wrote before he died—he said the theory of
- 12:05evolution is nothing more than a tautology.
- 12:08Meaning, excuse me, it's just empty talk,
- 12:10people rambling with each other.
- 12:12And these are the very words of Karl Popper.
- 12:14He stated that even the biggest, most
- 12:16prominent proponents of the theory, like
- 12:18Ronald Fisher and C. H.
- 12:19Waddington, admit this.
- 12:21They say, indeed, that the whole theory is
- 12:24just a set of imaginary conjectures.
- 12:26Conjectures and illusions.
- 12:28Honestly.
- 12:28This is recklessness, not evolution.
- 12:30Honestly, it starts with recklessness.
- 12:32Michael Denton, and he's an atheist biology
- 12:34professor, an Australian atheist.
- 12:36I don't know, in 1985 he wrote the book
- 12:39'Evolution: A Theory in Crisis.' And he said
- 12:43frankly, every species of living creature has
- 12:45a complete barrier between it and the next species.
- 12:48Each species is independent and has its own
- 12:51dietary system.
- 12:52Its own biological system.
- 12:54Its own reproductive system.
- 12:56An independent world, with a barrier between
- 12:59each species and the next.
- 13:00Thirty years after that, in twenty fifteen,
- 13:05he wrote the second book.
- 13:06Evolution: A Theory Still in Crisis.
- 13:09So he said, the same problems still exist,
- 13:11and we've even added more problems to them.
- 13:13We discovered that even organs appear
- 13:15suddenly, not just individual transitions.
- 13:18Organs inside the living being, like flowers
- 13:21and the placenta, and it's a long story.
- 13:23So organs also appear suddenly.
- 13:25So why are you so insistent on this theory, brothers?
- 13:28The issue has a very big problem.
- 13:29And indeed, there have been many retractions
- 13:32among some scientists.
- 13:33But the issue, or rather the question my
- 13:35professor raised, is that they have to study
- 13:37the theory because, as I said, it's the only
- 13:39alternative to divine creation—it's either
- 13:42creation or evolution.
- 13:43So, since we are materialist atheists, how
- 13:45can we say it's divine creation?
- 13:47Even though by doing so, we've dismissed the
- 13:49entire school of thought, so evolution remains.
- 13:52So, is there any argument?
- 13:54No, it's all assumptions and imaginations.
- 13:56Shares between creatures, and a dog became a
- 13:59whale, and the dinosaur became...
- 14:01By the way, birds, for example, kept jumping.
- 14:03Literally, it kept jumping until it reached
- 14:05the edge of the sky.
- 14:07So, honestly, if a little child heard this,
- 14:09he'd say, 'Dad, can we stop with this
- 14:10nonsense and just move on from this topic a
- 14:12bit?' Let's just skip this level.
- 14:15There is no god but Allah.
- 14:16The next question says: Well, isn't it
- 14:20possible that some living creatures evolved
- 14:22and became other creatures over time, just
- 14:25like you were saying?
- 14:26The idea is that a living being transforms
- 14:28into another entity.
- 14:30Say, 'Bring your proof.' Yes.
- 14:32Do you have any evidence for that?
- 14:33Has anyone ever researched this matter
- 14:36scientifically, paleontologically,
- 14:38biologically, or genetically and come up with
- 14:40this conclusion?
- 14:42Impossible.
- 14:42So what's the whole story?
- 14:43It's just hypothetical speculation.
- 14:45Illusions.
- 14:46Yes, and that's what prompted so many of them
- 14:48to begin to investigate the topic and then
- 14:49reconsider, research further, and then go back.
- 14:53And if we get into the details of these
- 14:55people, there are so many of them.
- 14:57For example, someone just wrote a book, and
- 14:58he used to be a Darwinist atheist.
- 15:00He said, what did Darwin get wrong?
- 15:02In the introduction of the book, he said,
- 15:04'I'm an atheist and I'm not against the
- 15:06theory, but the theory really does have fatal
- 15:07flaws.' This is someone who is actually a
- 15:10proponent of atheism.
- 15:12So if the topic were researched
- 15:14scientifically, honestly, we would all be at
- 15:16ease with each other.
- 15:17If the topic were researched and based on
- 15:19evidence, we would all be at ease with each other.
- 15:21But don't impose your philosophy on me by
- 15:23calling this science.
- 15:24No, it's not science.
- 15:26Ignorance.
- 15:26This is just your personal opinion.
- 15:28That's just because you're an atheist.
- 15:30So it's because he's struggling.
- 15:32Because he has atheism.
- 15:33So he feels compelled to accept this.
- 15:34Yeah.
- 15:35But if you put this on the table for testing,
- 15:37research, and scrutiny—
- 15:39He lets go.
- 15:40Of course.
- 15:41Yeah, absolutely.
- 15:42Glory be to God.
- 15:42Yes.
- 15:43Now, for the next question: why is it that
- 15:46there are living creatures that look so very
- 15:47much alike?
- 15:48Creatures resembling each other—it's the main
- 15:50argument for the theory.
- 15:51Take the monkey and the human;
- 15:54you find creatures with similar profiles.
- 15:57And some have no resemblance.
- 15:58Let's move on.
- 15:59There's a massive distinction between the
- 16:00monkey and the human.
- 16:02Sixty thousand genetic differences.
- 16:03That's a lot.
- 16:04Totally different.
- 16:05Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 16:07Glory be to God, there's actually something
- 16:08that was done which shows you that this whole
- 16:11idea is actually wrong.
- 16:12We have something called the gray wolf.
- 16:15Yes, a wolf—a type of wolf—and the Tasmanian
- 16:18gray wolf is a placental mammal.
- 16:20Meaning, like us, it is born inside the womb,
- 16:22completes its development inside the womb,
- 16:25and is born fully formed, just like a human.
- 16:26And then there's the Tasmanian wolf, which is
- 16:29a marsupial, like the kangaroo—the kangaroo
- 16:32gives birth inside the womb.
- 16:33Its development is completed in a pouch.
- 16:36An external pouch.
- 16:37Yeah.
- 16:38They also discovered that even though the
- 16:41gray wolf is identical to the Tasmanian wolf
- 16:43in appearance, skeleton, and everything else,
- 16:46they found that there is a placental squirrel
- 16:48and a marsupial squirrel.
- 16:49They look the same, even their jump is the same.
- 16:52Everything.
- 16:53The animal world is full of this.
- 16:54This placental mammal matches the marsupial.
- 16:56Yeah.
- 16:57Even the theory's proponents, upon
- 16:59examination, found no connection between them at all.
- 17:03They found that the placental squirrel is
- 17:05genetically closer to the whale and the
- 17:07elephant than to the marsupial.
- 17:09Its genetic makeup.
- 17:10Yeah.
- 17:12Well, if you were going by similarity, you
- 17:14would have said that this one came from that one.
- 17:17So since similarity failed here, why do you
- 17:19insist on proving it in other creatures?
- 17:22Yes.
- 17:22They look alike.
- 17:23Yeah, even they themselves have a problem,
- 17:25even with the resemblance—honestly, there are
- 17:27creatures that are identical to each other.
- 17:29And yet, they tell you there's no
- 17:30evolutionary relationship between them at all.
- 17:33Yeah.
- 17:33Well, thank you.
- 17:34This way, you've proven to me that similarity
- 17:37is not an argument, since it failed here.
- 17:39So why do we insist on proving it with other creatures?
- 17:42Yes, of course.
- 17:43No, evolution really does have a problem.
- 17:44And if we treat evolution as science and research...
- 17:48The challenge is open in this discussion.
- 17:50Maybe someone will respond.
- 17:52Yes, bring me a scientific paper that proves
- 17:55the transition of one species to another
- 17:57among the three million species that exist on
- 17:59Earth today.
- 18:00Just one—show me one that transitioned to
- 18:03another in a fossil study.
- 18:05There was a study on 'submissive adaptation'
- 18:09showing that every time they thought there
- 18:11was a transition between species, it was wrong.
- 18:14Each species is independent, with dietary and
- 18:17reproductive systems completely separate from others.
- 18:20So, there is no transition from one species
- 18:22to another.
- 18:23What's the issue?
- 18:24Guesses and hypothetical arrows.
- 18:26Ask them, 'Prove the transition from one
- 18:29species to another,' and they'll say, 'It
- 18:32takes millions of years for that transition.'
- 18:34Alright, but statistically speaking, sir.
- 18:36Who will live for millions of years to prove it?
- 18:38To prove it.
- 18:39Nonsense.
- 18:40Even statistically.
- 18:41Yeah, even taking millions of years.
- 18:42With millions of species, a new one should
- 18:45appear every few days.
- 18:46Statistically, yes, but it isn't.
- 18:48Sir.
- 18:49Of course.
- 18:50So we've proven that evolution has failed in
- 18:51the laboratory.
- 18:53It failed in genetic studies.
- 18:54It failed in paleontology.
- 18:57And the Quran clearly states that the
- 18:59creation of humans was a direct creation.
- 19:01Of course.
- 19:02So if you believe in evolution, that's your
- 19:04issue, not ours.
- 19:05That's just a belief you have, like those who
- 19:07believe in dragons or aliens—it's up to you.
- 19:11May God grant you success.
- 19:12May God bless you.
- 19:15God, Professor, thank you very much.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of هل تطور الإنسان من قرد؟ جمال نظرية التطور | حيران له أصحاب (6) مع أ. عمرو عبد الجليل ( مدبلج ) by د. هيثم طلعت Dr. Haitham Talaat, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,135 words across 523 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.