6 Bar vs 9 Bar: The Impact on Espresso — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00what's up everyone Lance Hedrick here to
- 0:02bring you yet another hot
- 0:05[Music]
- 0:08controversy you see anecdotes all over
- 0:10the place from home Barista to Reddit to
- 0:12different manufacturers chiming in as
- 0:14well as Baristas across the world who
- 0:16have set their espresso machines to a
- 0:18certain bar and they feel convicted that
- 0:20what they did was correct or was better
- 0:22or showcase their coffee a bit more
- 0:25don't worry about this part I'm going
- 0:26let it's very easy to be want to be
- 0:27drawn into these new trends that that
- 0:30seem cool or have sound logic behind it
- 0:32or have a big movement that's propelling
- 0:34it Forward I know that six bar shots got
- 0:37quite famous I guess you could say after
- 0:39the turbo shop paper a few years ago
- 0:41which I did a video two or 3 years ago
- 0:44so I wanted to really look into it and
- 0:46see if there was something more than
- 0:47just confirmation bias or flawed
- 0:50perception or hype that might surround
- 0:53something does it make lighter roasted
- 0:56coffee taste better is it more
- 0:57consistent does it do something very
- 1:00different to your recipe to the way you
- 1:02should grind your coffee is the end
- 1:04result really any different than a nine
- 1:06bar
- 1:07shot I called my buddy houie who helps
- 1:10me with a lot of my testing he's the
- 1:11Portuguese national barista champion
- 1:14good pallette good coffee skills brought
- 1:16him over and we did a lot of shop
- 1:17pulling a lot of refracting and a vomit
- 1:21amount of
- 1:23tasting of course before we go into it I
- 1:25have all of the raw data Down Below in
- 1:27the caption on a web page for anyone to
- 1:29access feel free to go check it out you
- 1:31can run it through your own charts blah
- 1:32blah blah blah blah but that's what
- 1:34we're going to be looking at today I did
- 1:37three different coffees they were all
- 1:38lightly roasted from my friends list up
- 1:41in Bordeaux France they graciously
- 1:43donated this coffee for testing purposes
- 1:45so we used the three different coffees
- 1:47that they gave us one of them was the
- 1:49natural Ethiopia kado one of them was a
- 1:51wash Colombia the Leon aabi and the last
- 1:53was a washed Ethiopia
- 1:55alaka so we used these we doed them in
- 1:59and we did some blind t
- 2:02tests the way I set this up was not with
- 2:05any intent of debunking completely the
- 2:07claims that some people make or of
- 2:08proving the claims that people make
- 2:10because this is nowhere near enough
- 2:12sensory participants but I do think it's
- 2:14a pretty solid experiment that I can
- 2:17present to you the conclusions of which
- 2:18should maybe give you a little bit of a
- 2:20head
- 2:21scratcher I would take my linear mini R
- 2:24which has a nice little screw on top
- 2:26where I can switch easily between nine
- 2:27bar and six bar of pump pressure
- 2:30and I use a Cofe monolith with the ssw
- 2:33burs because I don't want to worry about
- 2:35heat up times with a cheaper grinder so
- 2:37that I don't have to worry about Duty
- 2:38Cycles and things like that to skew
- 2:40[Music]
- 2:43shots so we took each coffee and we
- 2:45tasted them independently the first one
- 2:47we did was the natural Ethiopia kado
- 2:50dialed it in at nine bar I did 20 G in a
- 2:5320 G VST basket 50 g out and I did that
- 2:57in about 27 is seconds
- 3:00hulie would take the measurement the
- 3:02extraction yield Etc as I quickly
- 3:04switched it to six bar and pulled
- 3:06another shot I wanted as little time as
- 3:08possible between shots I got down to
- 3:11where I could turn the screw to six bar
- 3:12almost without having to use uh the
- 3:14pressure gauge we would oscillate it
- 3:17though in order to ensure as much
- 3:18randomization as possible so I did nine
- 3:20bar then six bar and then I had the next
- 3:22round of taste test we did six bar than
- 3:249
- 3:25bar and I did not want a temperature
- 3:27offset in the taste test because that is
- 3:29going to to be a dead giveaway for which
- 3:31one is which so I took my fluke
- 3:33thermometer with thermoprobe on it I
- 3:35shoved it into both of them and I
- 3:37ensured that I had equalized temperature
- 3:39now the way to get that is I did some
- 3:40extra stirring in one of them to allow
- 3:42the heat to
- 3:44dissipate I would also stir the other
- 3:46which would obviously lose some heat but
- 3:48it's because I wanted to oxidate it as
- 3:50well so they had at least similar levels
- 3:53of oxidation between the two and I
- 3:54figured that was a smaller difference
- 3:56between the two than obviously being
- 3:58able to tell which one is hotter
- 4:00[Music]
- 4:02I got it within 0.5 Centigrade of each
- 4:04other usually around 52° C when we were
- 4:07doing our taste tests and then we would
- 4:10do our tasting we were looking for
- 4:12acidity we were looking for finish for
- 4:14texture uh sweetness and we would notate
- 4:17what those different things were for
- 4:18each cup and then at the end we would
- 4:21count to three and we would point at the
- 4:22one that we preferred of course we had
- 4:24which one we preferred on paper so that
- 4:26we were independently writing away from
- 4:28each other so there was no bias
- 4:30instilled from one to the
- 4:32other with the natural curado which is
- 4:35the first one we tested the results were
- 4:37interesting and is also a bit of proof
- 4:39as to why I tend to never use Naturals
- 4:42when I do testing you can have one shot
- 4:43pull at 22 the next at 27 and you could
- 4:46do the same Puck prep it can be very
- 4:48erratic the extraction yields can be all
- 4:50over the place and the taste can be kind
- 4:52of wild that's why I usually use higher
- 4:54quality like washed colombias or
- 4:57something like that that tend to be
- 4:58easier on the extraction tend to be very
- 5:00uniform and that don't really have much
- 5:02differentiation between the cups they
- 5:04don't have any potential really defects
- 5:06like Quakers and things like that that
- 5:08are nearly as prevalent as they are in
- 5:11natural Ethiopia
- 5:12coffees two of them we did choose
- 5:14differently but overall it was
- 5:16completely
- 5:18random the six bar was a bit faster than
- 5:21the nine bar but I would not read too
- 5:23far into that again because this is only
- 5:25five shots you have a lot of fines
- 5:26production with Ethiopia so there may
- 5:28have been less fines migration in the
- 5:30six bar shot because there's less
- 5:31agitation during that ramp up but that's
- 5:34just speculative that's what lar zoko
- 5:36tends to say happens with six bar that's
- 5:38what some people have said but I don't
- 5:39even know if that's necessarily true
- 5:41there's no proof that findes migration
- 5:44is somehow more affected at 9 bar than
- 5:46six it could be at a threshold at four
- 5:48bar we don't really know there is
- 5:50texture differences but those seem to be
- 5:53more from not perfectly uniform
- 5:57extractions there was no real
- 5:59correlation between the results and
- 6:02anything to be done with the pressures
- 6:05so then we move on to the next round of
- 6:06tasting which we did the washed
- 6:09Columbia they pulled beautifully they
- 6:11looked identical and it was very
- 6:14difficult to tell the difference on
- 6:15paper between the two different shots
- 6:18they both pulled at the same times with
- 6:19a very tiny P
- 6:21value with the Ethiopia alaka just for
- 6:24fun I did a much faster shot something I
- 6:26would typically prefer when I'm pulling
- 6:28my espressos I did 22 seconds now that's
- 6:31not crazy fast but that's pretty fast
- 6:34for a 50 g output especially at 6 g a
- 6:36second flow rate and this time again the
- 6:39shots were very consistent between 21
- 6:41and 23 seconds or so whether it was six
- 6:43bar or nine bar the extraction yields
- 6:45again very similar the TDs is again very
- 6:48similar nothing significantly different
- 6:51you could have just imagined they were
- 6:52all the same pressure shots but every
- 6:56time H and I again were perfectly
- 6:58calibrated and we chose the nine bar
- 7:00shot over the six bar
- 7:02shot after the first three tastings we
- 7:05could straight up say this is the nine
- 7:06bar this is the six bar based off of the
- 7:09attributes the nine bar was giving us I
- 7:11think the biggest difference between
- 7:12those two shots is the simple fact I was
- 7:15doing such a fast extraction meaning the
- 7:18puck Integrity or the resistance
- 7:20potential of the puck was much lower
- 7:23than in the other shots where I had to
- 7:25grind finer to make it longer
- 7:27extractions so with this one we had a
- 7:29coer grind size we had the water flowing
- 7:31through a little bit more readily the
- 7:33resistance let up a lot more quickly and
- 7:37so you had a faster pressure drop and so
- 7:39it seems that it wasn't necessarily the
- 7:42pressure causing the big differences in
- 7:44the cup but the resistance the waning
- 7:47Puck resistance and the correlating flow
- 7:50rate going through the puck so it seems
- 7:52more so that the first two shots were
- 7:55essentially staying at their static
- 7:57pressure throughout the whole extraction
- 7:59we had ground finely enough to allow the
- 8:02same flow rate through the puck
- 8:04regardless of the pressure so the
- 8:06pressure could have been six could have
- 8:08been seven could have been eight could
- 8:10have been nine and that flow rate's not
- 8:12being affected the pressure doesn't have
- 8:14enough of an effect it would seem to
- 8:16change the flow rate through that puck
- 8:19maybe at 12 Bar it could have forced the
- 8:21water through at a quicker flow rate but
- 8:23I don't know I didn't test that now when
- 8:25the puck resistance is lower it does
- 8:27seem to have an effect the pressure does
- 8:29but it's less about the pressure and
- 8:31more about the pressure drop whenever
- 8:34you have a puck that is on the cuspus of
- 8:37losing its resistance that pressure can
- 8:40affect the paracity of it and the flow
- 8:42of the water through now this is
- 8:43definitely speculation but there has to
- 8:45be a reason why we chose 100% the same
- 8:48cup five times in a row on that washed
- 8:52alaka and because it peaked at that nine
- 8:55bar I think it quickly was dropping some
- 8:57of that pressure and allowing a
- 8:58quickening flow rate through the puck as
- 9:01it tries to maintain the pressure but it
- 9:02simply can't whereas with the six bar
- 9:05because six bar of pressure is not
- 9:07potentially deteriorating it as quickly
- 9:10because we are obviously at this cusp of
- 9:12deterioration where pressure could do
- 9:14something to it it is going to hold that
- 9:16six bar longer than the nine could hold
- 9:18nine so The Nine's dropping as that six
- 9:21is staying pretty static now again
- 9:23that's just a theory as to why the six
- 9:25bar had a rougher texture and had a
- 9:27worse finish which is what we
- 9:29consistently noted on all five but it is
- 9:31something to consider so it does seem
- 9:34like pressure at least in the 6 to n bar
- 9:36area is a red herring if you're pulling
- 9:39more traditional styles of shots and
- 9:42even when you're doing something outside
- 9:43of that it has less to do with the
- 9:45pressure and more to do with the flow
- 9:47rate going through the pressure being
- 9:48applied at 9 bar it's not necessarily
- 9:51the pressure that's deteriorating the
- 9:52puck but the quickening flow rate being
- 9:55forced through the puck in order to
- 9:57maintain the nine bar the flow rate
- 9:59coming through at the six bar is likely
- 10:02going to be a bit lower but more
- 10:03consistent as it's going through its
- 10:06shot you're never going to get 6
- 10:08milliliters a second out of the lar zoko
- 10:10that it has the 6 M Water debit when
- 10:13there's a puck in there and then as we
- 10:14see we hit that 9 bar and the output
- 10:16flow rate is going to and it seems to
- 10:18vary I've done tests on my Bianca with
- 10:19this where I'll open it to what I've
- 10:21measured at 3 m a second water debit and
- 10:24on some coffees it'll get up to 2.5 m a
- 10:26second on others it'll only hit 1 misec
- 10:28even if I run it for like 10 hours and I
- 10:30think some of that's from the inherent
- 10:32Puck Integrity so maybe the inherent
- 10:34Puck Integrity wasn't allowing a higher
- 10:36flow rate even though it was still
- 10:38trying with the higher pressure to go
- 10:39through which could have arguably messed
- 10:41with the resistance of the puck it could
- 10:43have allowed for more gentle application
- 10:46or I don't know we're just speculating
- 10:47it's going to let us maintain close to
- 10:49nine bar for the duration however long I
- 10:51want to run
- 10:52it the fill rate of the puck and the
- 10:55initial part of it has a big play on the
- 10:57final cup and then the pressure drop
- 11:00seems to have a big play on the Final
- 11:03Cut I don't think we should take these
- 11:05results and apply them outside of this
- 11:07for instance on a spring lever there are
- 11:09completely different dynamics that play
- 11:12there this is trying to maintain nine or
- 11:14six bar whatever I have it set at
- 11:17whereas a spring when it's fully
- 11:18compressed can do whatever the stated
- 11:21pressure is assuming you have sucked all
- 11:22the air out so it will Peak out of
- 11:24pressure but then immediately it will
- 11:26start losing pressure regardless of your
- 11:28grind size obviously it'll lose it a lot
- 11:30quicker with a coarser grind size than a
- 11:32really fine grind size but in the end
- 11:35it's going to be losing pressure even if
- 11:37the flow rate is static or even
- 11:39completely choked it will lose some
- 11:40pressure as long as there are drips
- 11:42coming out allowing the pressure to
- 11:45release and it would require a full
- 11:48different set of testing in order to do
- 11:50that unless I bought a second Argos into
- 11:52a six bar springin one and an eight bar
- 11:53Spring in the other but even that is not
- 11:55as good of a difference as 6 to9 which
- 11:57is what my preference would be in anyway
- 11:59for a nice testing to get a bigger range
- 12:01and to have direct comparison to this
- 12:06data but this seems to be further
- 12:08evidence that flow in its relation to
- 12:10resistance which does make up pressure
- 12:13is much more important than the pressure
- 12:15at the
- 12:16puck so if you're pulling shots at home
- 12:18and you're worried that oh my brevel
- 12:20dual boiler says it's 9.7 bar but stock
- 12:22says it'll be at 9 it's probably not
- 12:24going to taste any different my friend
- 12:27if you have a machine that's oh it's
- 12:28it's only Seven bar well that may be
- 12:31[Music]
- 12:35fine I did do a fourth coffee I did not
- 12:38do five shots of I physically was not
- 12:40able to It was a commercial coffee that
- 12:43was a very dark roasted blend and it's
- 12:45because I wanted to throw something into
- 12:46the mix that wasn't light medium like
- 12:48the one from Alchemist tasted it the two
- 12:51times were different the extractions
- 12:52were different but what can you expect
- 12:54from a probably a 47,000 Bean blend I
- 12:57don't know CH and I both preferred the
- 12:59nine bar over the six bar but as I was
- 13:01tasting it I wanted to sit on my palette
- 13:02to feel the weight to feel the texture
- 13:04swash it around a bit let it aate in my
- 13:06mouth on that second taste test um I
- 13:09literally gagged up the second shot I
- 13:12tasted and it was not a fake gag I was
- 13:14not being a drama queen even though I
- 13:16normally
- 13:17[Music]
- 13:21am I just Googled six first n Bar and I
- 13:24saw like 15 differ opinions all claiming
- 13:26they had scientific backing not a single
- 13:28one of them showed any type of testing
- 13:30or methodology or anything beyond we
- 13:32tasted this we tasted this this was
- 13:34different and in fact in some of them
- 13:36where they said they had a lot of
- 13:37tasters they admitted to dialing them in
- 13:40differently hello that doesn't make any
- 13:43sense of course if you dial one in
- 13:44differently it's going to taste
- 13:45different maybe you dialed it in
- 13:47better be careful with what you read
- 13:49online and even with mine take it with a
- 13:51grain of salt I did three sets of five
- 13:54so I guess 10 overall with each so 30
- 13:57even though we're both good tasters
- 13:58myself and the this uh this champion who
- 14:01actually had one of the highest scores
- 14:02at the World Championships first round
- 14:04in in Melbourne you know we can be wrong
- 14:07I'm not saying throw away your six bar
- 14:08Spring if you got one for the gaja I'm
- 14:10not saying stop pulling six bar shots at
- 14:12your shop if that's what you're pulling
- 14:13I'm not saying that at
- 14:15all thank you for watching this far I
- 14:17really appreciate it if you want to
- 14:19support the work that I do and some of
- 14:20this testing and being able to afford hu
- 14:22to come and pull a thousand shots with
- 14:24me I would really appreciate if you hit
- 14:26the patreon down below check that out
- 14:27maybe consider joining we have a cool
- 14:29robust Discord that goes along with it
- 14:31we also do competitions for all the
- 14:32equipment I buy using the patreon funds
- 14:34in order to um you get you a little
- 14:37something something that you can play
- 14:38with at home I also have my Instagram my
- 14:40Facebook my second YouTube channel and a
- 14:41lot of other links down below to check
- 14:43out and of course it would be really
- 14:45helpful if you hit the like and the
- 14:46Subscribe if you haven't already I
- 14:48assume if you watch this far you're
- 14:49probably someone already hitting likees
- 14:50but in case someone falls through the
- 14:52weeds please do that let's Converse down
- 14:54below
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 6 Bar vs 9 Bar: The Impact on Espresso by Lance Hedrick, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,009 words across 419 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.