ПОЧЕМУ ЧАЙКИ СЛАБЕЙШИЙ ТАЙТЛ | КОГДА ПЛАЧУТ ЧАЙКИ — Transcript

Full transcript

1. 0:15Hello everyone. I recently decided to
2. 0:17read the "Umineko When They Cry" manga.
3. 0:19I got curious about what kind of
4. 0:20powerful verse it really is. And now
5. 0:22you will find out what the deal with
6. 0:24the seagulls is, actually. Before we
7. 0:25start the main topic, don't forget to
8. 0:27subscribe to Boosty. Because the fight
9. 0:29between Satoru Gojo and Madara, as well
10. 0:31as a video about Batman, are already on
11. 0:33Boosty. So, in the comments under my
12. 0:35videos, people often wrote to me about
13. 0:36Featherine and the Umineko characters.
14. 0:38Allegedly, they are super strong. I
15. 0:40started reading the manga. And imagine
16. 0:43my disappointment when I read the first
17. 0:45episode, and it was just a story about
18. 0:48a murder on an island. I thought, "Well
19. 0:50, in the second part, there will be
20. 0:52something fun." The second episode
21. 0:54begins, and they reset the story and
22. 0:56start it over, showing the characters '
23. 0:58relationships from a different angle
24. 1:01and presenting the story differently.
25. 1:03The locations where people are killed
26. 1:05change, and the sequence of deaths
27. 1:07changes. At the same time, Battler, who
28. 1:10supposedly died in the first episode,
29. 1:12denies the existence of magic and
30. 1:13witches and sits in a room with
31. 1:15Beatrice. Battler, even seeing a
32. 1:17supposed witch in front of him, refuses
33. 1:19to believe in her. Then Beatrice starts
34. 1:22playing games and highlighting the
35. 1:24facts she speaks in red. These facts
36. 1:27are 100%reliable. After Battler solved
37. 1:31the mystery of how the killer managed
38. 1:33to pull off the murder in the chapel,
39. 1:35it becomes clear that there is no magic
40. 1:36in this universe, as all murders are
41. 1:38committed by a person or group of
42. 1:40people. It’s just that Battler,
43. 1:42because he doesn't want to suspect any
44. 1:44of the eighteen people who were on the
45. 1:46island, cannot find the killer. While
46. 1:48reading the second part, I was confused
47. 1:50by the fact that Kanon and Shannon
48. 1:52started using magic, since by that
49. 1:54moment I had already realized there was
50. 1:56no magic in the verse. These two really
51. 1:59confused me. So, there are no mages in
52. 2:01the story at all. This is an ordinary
53. 2:03detective story. Moreover, all magical
54. 2:05murders can be explained, as the
55. 2:07killings are committed by ordinary
56. 2:08people. Plus, as I understood from the
57. 2:11restart in the second part and the
58. 2:13beginning of the third, subsequent
59. 2:14parts will reset the story, changing
60. 2:16the locations for the murders and the
61. 2:17sequence of the murders themselves.
62. 2:20Since the manga follows the visual
63. 2:22novel, I dare to assume that each of
64. 2:23these restarts is an alternative plan
65. 2:25for eliminating the family. Also, based
66. 2:28on the fact that the servants in the
67. 2:30house were so insistently proving the
68. 2:31existence of this Madame Beatrice back
69. 2:33in the first part, one of the servants
70. 2:35is cooperating with the killer, helping
71. 2:37them eliminate the others, and then
72. 2:39becoming a victim themselves. It is
73. 2:41also said in the first part that
74. 2:43Beatrice might be Kinzo's illegitimate
75. 2:45child. Apparently, Kanon and his sister
76. 2:47are Kinzo's illegitimate children, and
77. 2:49they are eliminating their relatives.
78. 2:52While writing the script for this video
79. 2:53, I googled information about the canon
80. 2:55, and everything fell into place. Kanon
81. 2:57, Shannon, and Beatrice are
82. 2:59personalities of the same person. There
83. 3:01is one more personality that I haven't
84. 3:03seen in the manga yet, but I will get
85. 3:05to it. Just as I thought, the murders
86. 3:06are committed by ordinary people. There
87. 3:08is no magic in the verse. I certainly
88. 3:10suspected that the characters weren't
89. 3:12anything serious, but for the witches
90. 3:14themselves to be mere fantasies of a
91. 3:16mentally ill girl—that is just too
92. 3:18much. I managed to read a little bit of
93. 3:20the third part. There, Beatrice started
94. 3:23saying that for a witch of infinity,
95. 3:24the concepts of life and death do not
96. 3:26exist. Naturally, they don't. She is
97. 3:29just an alternate personality in the
98. 3:30girl's head. Even the manga itself
99. 3:33gives a heavy hint that everything
100. 3:34happening on the island is just a
101. 3:35fabrication. That is, the events we see
102. 3:38and the witches are purely Sayo's
103. 3:40fantasies. We have already been shown
104. 3:43two other witches who interact with
105. 3:45Beatrice. They are Lambdadelta and
106. 3:47Bernkastel. I will finish reading the
107. 3:49story in the manga, and then I'll
108. 3:50probably play the visual novel, which I
109. 3:52have already downloaded. Something
110. 3:53tells me that all these witches are
111. 3:55simply alternate personalities inside
112. 3:57people's heads. If that is true, then
113. 3:59naturally, there are no power levels in
114. 4:01the verse, and the verse itself is
115. 4:03infinitely overrated and not even worth
116. 4:04considering in terms of power scaling.
117. 4:07The most interesting thing is that the
118. 4:09title explicitly states through
119. 4:10Battler's words that there is no magic
120. 4:12and that every action can be explained
121. 4:13without using magic if one finds the
122. 4:15right perspective. Battler would have
123. 4:17found a normal explanation for all this
124. 4:19, but because he does not want to
125. 4:21believe that one of the house's
126. 4:22residents is a killer, he remains
127. 4:24confused and even gives in to Beatrice,
128. 4:26only to pull himself together later and
129. 4:28continue the fight. So, the work itself
130. 4:30, through the struggle between Battler
131. 4:32and Beatrice, shows the battle between
132. 4:34fantasy and reality. The manga drops
133. 4:36heavy hints that the majority of the
134. 4:38events on the island and in the story
135. 4:40as a whole are pure fiction, having
136. 4:42nothing to do with reality. I don't
137. 4:45know why no one else notices this. Or
138. 4:47maybe they just don't want to notice.
139. 4:49The story itself isn't the worst,
140. 4:51actually. Although I am not a big fan
141. 4:53of detective stories, I will definitely
142. 4:55finish the manga and make another video
143. 4:57about this title. I am noticing a trend
144. 5:00where supposedly strong universes
145. 5:02become weak or even fall apart into
146. 5:03pieces when you actually get to know
147. 5:05them. With that, this video has come to
148. 5:07an end. Like the video and subscribe to
149. 5:09the channel.