하락장 적립식 투자, 나스닥 40년 돌려 보니 답은 '언제'가 아니라 '얼마씩'이었습니다 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00Once I retired, things changed. Now, my
- 0:01account has to pay me a monthly salary.
- 0:05I set aside living expenses once a year
- 0:07through self-dividends and withdraw only
- 0:08what I need, but with a market downturn
- 0:10hitting right after I retired, I
- 0:12immediately worried about how much I
- 0:13should take out next year.
- 0:16We may not know the future, but can’t we
- 0:18use the past to help inform our
- 0:20decisions?
- 0:21So, I ran 40 years of data, and when I
- 0:24applied the 4%rule to 214 hypothetical
- 0:26retirees who put all their assets into
- 0:28the Nasdaq, 25 of them ran out of money
- 0:30midway through.
- 0:33And even for those who set aside two
- 0:34years of cash in advance, the number of
- 0:36people who went broke remained the same
- 0:38. Then, what was it that protected the
- 0:39accounts of those who retired
- 0:41successfully to the very end?
- 0:44If you are planning your retirement,
- 0:45want to retire early, or are already
- 0:47retired like me and need to withdraw
- 0:49money to live on, please watch this
- 0:50video until the end to see my thoughts
- 0:52and experiences regarding retirement.
- 1:01This is Team Leader Song, helping you
- 1:02retire with the Nasdaq. "Team Leader,
- 1:03should I keep up with dollar-cost
- 1:05averaging even in a market downturn like
- 1:07this?"
- 1:08That is a question I’ve been getting a
- 1:09lot lately. If you keep investing during
- 1:11a downturn like this, the losses in your
- 1:13account grow every time you add more
- 1:15money, so it must feel quite burdensome
- 1:16to keep buying.
- 1:18It’s understandable, because even though
- 1:20the Nasdaq 100 rebounded slightly last
- 1:22week, it is still down over 9.4%
- 1:23compared to its high at the beginning of
- 1:25October. It’s been a while, so I’m
- 1:27sharing an update on the Tri-Pod status
- 1:28. It has dropped quite a bit recently.
- 1:30From January 2 to November 12 of this
- 1:32year, the Max version is at 6.4%, the
- 1:34Core version is at 10.1%, and the Base
- 1:37version is at 9.3%. Assuming you just
- 1:39held them for the same period, QQQ is at
- 1:4212.6%, QLD is at 16.6%, and TQQQ is at
- 1:4516.5%.
- 1:47The Tri-Pod is not a dollar-cost
- 1:48averaging method. It is a trading method
- 1:50based on signals, and for the Max
- 1:52version, it has an annual average return
- 1:55of 32.1%over 35 years since 1991, with a
- 1:57maximum drawdown of -62%.
- 2:00For the last 10 years, the annual
- 2:02average is 34.7%with a 53.3%max drawdown
- 2:05, and since 2020, the annual average is
- 2:0728.9%with a 53.3%max drawdown.
- 2:11Since I’ve received requests to devise a
- 2:14method based on the last 3 to 5 years
- 2:16rather than the entire 35-year period, I
- 2:19think I will likely add a new version
- 2:22soon.
- 2:23Getting back to dollar-cost averaging.
- 2:26When people ask me if they should keep
- 2:28doing it, strangely enough, it makes me
- 2:30look back on my own situation.
- 2:33The fact is, since I’ve retired, I’m no
- 2:34longer someone who puts money into an
- 2:36account, but rather someone who,
- 2:37conversely, withdraws money every month
- 2:39to use as living expenses.
- 2:42Once you retire, it’s as if your account
- 2:44starts paying you a salary, but just
- 2:47when I went to withdraw money, I ran
- 2:49into a market downturn.
- 2:51I’ve been cutting back on travel and
- 2:53major expenses, but I’m in a position
- 2:55where I withdraw money about once a year
- 2:57to budget it out.
- 2:59With stocks falling like this, I wonder
- 3:01if I should spend my living expenses as
- 3:03usual this month, and with the year
- 3:04coming to an end, what about next year?
- 3:07These kinds of realistic worries started
- 3:09to weigh on me.
- 3:10Thinking about it, we’re all equally
- 3:12anxious about the market dropping, but
- 3:15the nature of our concerns differs
- 3:17depending on our situation.
- 3:19Those who are busy building their assets
- 3:21might be wondering if they should keep
- 3:23investing right now.
- 3:24Those on the verge of retirement might
- 3:26be thinking, "Shouldn't I cash out some
- 3:27money before it drops any further?"
- 3:29I’m sure you’re having thoughts like
- 3:30that. And for those who have already
- 3:32retired like me, the concern is: at what
- 3:34frequency and how much should I withdraw
- 3:36so that my account doesn't run dry? This
- 3:38is likely your main concern. Are you
- 3:40currently in the stage of putting money
- 3:42in? Or are you in the stage of taking
- 3:43money out to spend? It would be great if
- 3:44you could share your situation in the
- 3:46comments.
- 3:47We may not know the future, but we do
- 3:49know the past. There have always been
- 3:52major crises like this in the past.
- 3:54So today, I’ll run the numbers using 40
- 3:56years of actual Nasdaq data to find
- 3:59answers to these three concerns.
- 4:01Whether you’ve been investing directly
- 4:03in QQQ or holding domestic Nasdaq 100
- 4:06ETFs, the underlying index is the same,
- 4:08so these principles apply equally. The
- 4:10conclusion is quite unique. I’ll tell
- 4:12you in advance.
- 4:13Trying to time the market, whether it’s
- 4:15when you start investing or when you
- 4:18withdraw your retirement funds, actually
- 4:20led to losses.
- 4:22Therefore, those currently investing
- 4:24have absolutely no reason to stop just
- 4:25because the market is down.
- 4:28And for those considering starting, if
- 4:29you’re thinking about long-term
- 4:31investment, you really didn't need to
- 4:32worry at all.
- 4:34Those approaching retirement also didn't
- 4:37need to sell stocks and cash out years
- 4:38in advance.
- 4:41What actually determined the outcome
- 4:43wasn't this timing, but the amount of
- 4:45money you withdraw from your account
- 4:47after retirement.
- 4:49Let’s break down why this conclusion was
- 4:51reached, starting with the stories of
- 4:52those currently investing.
- 4:54It’s a perfectly natural instinct to
- 4:56hesitate to make automatic monthly
- 4:57deposits when stocks are falling.
- 5:00But if you turn back the clock just a
- 5:02little, you’ll see that we aren’t the
- 5:03only ones who have had this worry.
- 5:06It’s the 2008 financial crisis. Even
- 5:08during this financial crisis, there were
- 5:09worries.
- 5:10Back then, a craze for installment funds
- 5:13swept our country, so every payday,
- 5:14office workers would set up automatic
- 5:16transfers.
- 5:18But as soon as the financial crisis hit
- 5:20, starting from a peak in June, the
- 5:22number of installment fund accounts
- 5:24began to drop for 15 straight months.
- 5:27By October, 386,000 accounts had
- 5:29vanished in just one month. But the
- 5:32really interesting part comes after that
- 5:34. More accounts were closed in 2010,
- 5:37when the market had almost fully
- 5:39recovered, than during the massive crash
- 5:42when values were halved.
- 5:45In 2010 alone, a staggering 2.46 million
- 5:47accounts were withdrawn.
- 5:50While many stopped their installments
- 5:52out of fear during the crash, far more
- 5:54people left the market when the stock
- 5:57price finally recovered and they broke
- 5:59even, thinking, "Thank god, I'm out."
- 6:02Was it really a wise choice to stop
- 6:04installments or sell off at the
- 6:05break-even point back then? Rather than
- 6:08explaining it in words, comparing the
- 6:10numbers will make it clear immediately.
- 6:13Imagine two people investing in the
- 6:14Nasdaq 100, each putting in 500,000 won
- 6:17monthly and gradually increasing the
- 6:19amount in line with inflation.
- 6:21The goal was to build a retirement fund
- 6:23that would allow them to withdraw 4%
- 6:25annually, providing 2 million won per
- 6:27month after taxes.
- 6:29The only difference between them is the
- 6:30date they started their installments.
- 6:32The first person was a bit unlucky.
- 6:35They started their very first
- 6:37installment in March 2000, right at the
- 6:39peak of the dot-com bubble.
- 6:42On the other hand, the second person
- 6:44started in October 2002, at the bottom
- 6:46after the bubble had completely burst.
- 6:49How much difference in time did it take
- 6:51for the person who started at the peak
- 6:53and the one who started at the bottom to
- 6:55reach the same retirement goal?
- 6:56Surprisingly, the person who started at
- 6:58the top of the dot-com bubble took 21.7
- 7:00years.
- 7:01The person who started at the bottom of
- 7:03the crash took 21.3 years. The
- 7:06difference between the two was only four
- 7:08months. Why is that? In installment
- 7:10investing, the money put in during the
- 7:12first month is just a tiny fraction of
- 7:14the total investment.
- 7:15Ultimately, it’s the money consistently
- 7:17added every month for over 20 years that
- 7:19produces the result.
- 7:22Whether you started at the peak or the
- 7:24bottom, the time to reach the final
- 7:26destination was virtually the same.
- 7:29Of course, these two points could be a
- 7:31coincidence, so I tested every 10-year
- 7:33installment period starting from 1986.
- 7:36Since it's a 10-year installment, the
- 7:38most recent final point is October 2016
- 7:40.
- 7:40That makes a total of 370 periods. First
- 7:43, I counted the frustrating cases where
- 7:44, despite saving diligently for 10 years
- 7:46, the balance was still below the
- 7:48principal after a decade.
- 7:51Those who started investing when the
- 7:53index was near its previous high saw a
- 7:5431%chance—or three out of every ten
- 7:56people—of failing to recover their
- 7:58principal after 10 years.
- 8:01Many of those who started during the
- 8:03major bull market from 1997 to 2000 were
- 8:05included in this group as they later
- 8:07faced the dot-com bubble burst.
- 8:09On the other hand, for those who started
- 8:12investing when the index was down by 5%
- 8:14to 20%from its peak, like today, the
- 8:16probability of falling short of the
- 8:18principal after 10 years dropped to 13%
- 8:20, or about one in ten.
- 8:23In other words, those who entered when
- 8:24the market had pulled back a little were
- 8:26much less likely to lose money. This
- 8:28naturally leads to a certain temptation
- 8:30.
- 8:31"If buying when the market is down is
- 8:33advantageous, wouldn't it be better to
- 8:35wait with cash in hand until a 30%or 40
- 8:37%crash happens before starting to hit
- 8:39the jackpot?"
- 8:41Unfortunately, the data suggests
- 8:43otherwise.
- 8:44I compared the median values of how many
- 8:46times the assets grew compared to the
- 8:47principal after 10 years of investing.
- 8:50It was 1.53 times the principal when
- 8:53starting near the peak, 2.16 times when
- 8:56starting during a 5%to 20%dip like today
- 8:59, and 2.60 times when starting after a
- 9:0220%to 40%drop.
- 9:05However, when waiting until a massive
- 9:07crash of over 40%from the peak to start
- 9:09, the return actually dropped to 2.02
- 9:12times.
- 9:15This is because if you wait for too deep
- 9:17a bottom, you miss out on time and
- 9:19opportunities to participate in the
- 9:21market, resulting in smaller gains than
- 9:23expected.
- 9:25Statistically, the correlation
- 9:27coefficient between how much the market
- 9:30had fallen when I started investing and
- 9:33the return after 10 years is only -0.06
- 9:35. It essentially means there is no
- 9:37relationship. But this raises a question
- 9:41. Everyone saved for the same 10 years,
- 9:43yet some couldn't even recover their
- 9:44principal, while others earned two or
- 9:45three times their initial investment.
- 9:47If the starting date isn't the cause,
- 9:49what exactly created this huge
- 9:51difference?
- 9:52The answer lies not in the start date,
- 9:54but in the final day when the saving
- 9:56period ends.
- 9:58When we color the same 370 data curves
- 10:00based on whether the market was in a
- 10:03bull or bear phase on the final day of
- 10:05the 10-year period, the returns diverge
- 10:07sharply depending on the state of that
- 10:09end point.
- 10:11The correlation coefficient skyrockets
- 10:13to 0.68.
- 10:15I thought about the reason, and it's
- 10:17quite simple. When we save 500,000 won
- 10:19every month, in the first year, there is
- 10:21only a few million won accumulated in
- 10:23our account.
- 10:24At this stage, even if stocks drop by 20
- 10:26%, the impact is minimal.
- 10:28But by the 8th, 9th, and 10th years, the
- 10:30account would have grown significantly,
- 10:31boosted by the principal and the
- 10:33compound returns accrued over time.
- 10:37Whether you face a market crash or a
- 10:38bull market at that final moment when
- 10:40your money has piled up the most—that is
- 10:41what determines the report card for your
- 10:4310-year harvest.
- 10:45So, for those of you currently
- 10:47contributing, the first conclusion is
- 10:49clear.
- 10:51There is absolutely no reason to stop
- 10:53your monthly contributions or try to
- 10:54time the bottom just because we are in a
- 10:56bear market right now.
- 10:58If you are investing long-term, there is
- 11:00no mathematical correlation whatsoever.
- 11:02The timing of your contribution right
- 11:04now will not have much impact on the
- 11:05results 10 or 20 years down the line.
- 11:07Just stay at ease and keep collecting
- 11:09consistently as you have been; that is
- 11:11the wisest approach. I just told you
- 11:12that for dollar-cost averaging, the
- 11:14state of the market on your final day is
- 11:16what separates the results. So, those of
- 11:18you who are a few years away from
- 11:19retirement will naturally think this.
- 11:22"Oh, since it would be a disaster to hit
- 11:24a market crash on my retirement day, I
- 11:26should just sell my stocks little by
- 11:28little starting 3 to 5 years before
- 11:30retirement and move them safely into
- 11:31cash, deposits, or bonds."
- 11:34Now, in reality, the media and the
- 11:35financial industry actually recommend
- 11:37this as the standard procedure.
- 11:39There was even an article like this in
- 11:40the Financial News on November 2nd.
- 11:43"A 56-year-old manager, Mr. Kim, who is
- 11:45four years away from retirement, sharply
- 11:47reduced the equity portion of his
- 11:49retirement pension from 70%to 40%."
- 11:52Examples like this appear. It’s treated
- 11:54almost like common sense that you should
- 11:56move to safe assets as you get closer to
- 11:58retirement.
- 11:59But has this common sense actually
- 12:01protected our money?
- 12:03Well, I compared 250 different cases of
- 12:06investing in the Nasdaq 100 for 20 years
- 12:08, comparing those who withdrew
- 12:10everything at the very last month
- 12:13against those who moved their money into
- 12:15cash in monthly installments over the
- 12:18final 3 or 5 years.
- 12:20The results were the exact opposite of
- 12:21our common sense.
- 12:23Withdrawing in stages over the 3 years
- 12:25before retirement was only beneficial in
- 12:2711%of the total cases.
- 12:30For those who withdrew in stages over 5
- 12:32years, it was only beneficial in a
- 12:34measly 7%of cases.
- 12:36Simply put, eight or nine out of ten
- 12:38people sold their stocks to play it safe
- 12:40, only to end up missing out on the
- 12:43compounding gains that burst forth
- 12:45during these last 3 to 5 years when
- 12:47their account size was at its largest.
- 12:51Even when running the numbers on 100
- 12:52years of U.S. stock market data,
- 12:54withdrawing in stages beforehand was
- 12:56only better in 17%to 19%of cases.
- 12:58Even when encountering the worst,
- 13:00unluckiest periods, the performance of
- 13:01those who cashed out in advance was
- 13:03worse in the Nasdaq.
- 13:05People often say, "Taking profit is
- 13:07always right." But taking profit out of
- 13:10fear before retirement has, in most
- 13:13cases, come at a very high cost.
- 13:16But honestly, the calculation of
- 13:18withdrawing everything at maturity that
- 13:20I just mentioned contains some
- 13:22unrealistic assumptions.
- 13:24In reality, no one clears out their
- 13:26brokerage account and cashes out their
- 13:27entire fortune on the morning of their
- 13:29retirement.
- 13:32Retirement in reality is not an event
- 13:34where you sell all your stocks on a
- 13:36specific date, but a very long-term
- 13:38investment where you gradually withdraw
- 13:40money from that account over the next 20
- 13:42to 30 years.
- 13:44Ultimately, for those nearing retirement
- 13:47or those already retired like me, the
- 13:49truly important question shouldn't be
- 13:50when to sell stocks for cash, but rather
- 13:53how much to withdraw every month and
- 13:54under what rules to ensure my account
- 13:56survives even through a market downturn
- 13:58.
- 14:01Now, let's dive into the topic of
- 14:02post-retirement withdrawals, which is my
- 14:04biggest concern lately.
- 14:06Whenever the topic of withdrawing
- 14:07retirement funds comes up, the number
- 14:09that always appears is the "4%rule." It
- 14:11states that if you withdraw 4%of your
- 14:13total assets in the first year of
- 14:15retirement and increase the withdrawal
- 14:17amount only by inflation thereafter,
- 14:19your account will not run dry for 30
- 14:21years.
- 14:22This is a famous rule, which means if
- 14:24you have 600 million won in retirement
- 14:26funds, you start by withdrawing 4%in the
- 14:28first year, which is 24 million won, or
- 14:302 million won per month.
- 14:32Now, once we are retired, we need to be
- 14:34skeptical about everything. Let's first
- 14:37look at where this "4%" number
- 14:39originated.
- 14:40It is a figure first published in a
- 14:43journal in 1994 by an American financial
- 14:45planner named William Bengen.
- 14:49The prerequisite for his calculation was
- 14:51the result of running a portfolio mixed
- 14:5350/50 with U.S. large-cap stocks and
- 14:55intermediate-term government bonds from
- 14:571926 to 1992.
- 15:00He also performed this back-test using
- 15:01historical data. It was never a figure
- 15:03based on 100%allocation in
- 15:05high-volatility tech stocks like the
- 15:06Nasdaq from the start.
- 15:08Of course, in reality, it is rare for
- 15:10someone to retire with 100%of their
- 15:11entire assets in the Nasdaq.
- 15:13In my case, I even use leverage with the
- 15:15Nasdaq 100, so I cannot speak based on
- 15:17my own standards either.
- 15:19We will discuss mixing in bonds a bit
- 15:21later, but first, I intentionally set up
- 15:23the most extreme conditions to see what
- 15:26determines the returns of an account.
- 15:29I ran a simulation for a case where
- 15:31someone retires with all their assets in
- 15:33the Nasdaq 100. This covers a total of
- 15:35214 people who retired one by one every
- 15:38month from January 1986 to October 2003
- 15:41.
- 15:41The maximum period we can track this
- 15:44with data is 23 years, and when we
- 15:46followed these people for 23 years, 25
- 15:48of those who withdrew according to the 4
- 15:51%rule—which is 11.7%—went bankrupt.
- 15:54Their accounts could not survive the 23
- 15:56-year period and went bust.
- 15:58If you retire with 600 million won and
- 16:00withdraw 2 million won monthly, adjusted
- 16:03for inflation, one in ten will see their
- 16:05account balance hit zero during their
- 16:07retirement.
- 16:09When we looked at who these 25 people
- 16:11who went bankrupt were, it turned out
- 16:13they all retired between 1999 and 2001,
- 16:15right around the peak of the dot-com
- 16:17bubble.
- 16:20In accumulation investing, the market
- 16:22state on the final day, when the most
- 16:24money has piled up, determines the
- 16:26outcome, whereas in retirement
- 16:28withdrawals, hitting a market crash in
- 16:30the first few years, when your balance
- 16:32is at its highest, is decisive.
- 16:35That is why people use what is called a
- 16:37cash bucket, setting aside some money in
- 16:39advance.
- 16:39This cash bucket strategy is widely used
- 16:41; the Financial News article we saw
- 16:43earlier also introduces methods of
- 16:45setting aside funds for three to five
- 16:46years of post-retirement living expenses
- 16:48in principal-guaranteed products or
- 16:50short-term bonds.
- 16:52So, how effective is this cash bucket
- 16:54really? The rules are as follows. From
- 16:57your retirement funds, you set aside one
- 16:59, two, or three years 'worth of living
- 17:01expenses in a separate cash account.
- 17:03You usually sell stocks to cover living
- 17:06expenses, but in months where the Nasdaq
- 17:08plummets by over 20%from its previous
- 17:10high, you never sell stocks and instead
- 17:12draw living expenses from the cash
- 17:14account.
- 17:16Then, when the stocks recover to their
- 17:19previous high, you sell stocks to refill
- 17:21the cash account; it sounds like a
- 17:23rational approach since you're selling
- 17:25stocks when they're expensive.
- 17:28However, when you actually look into it
- 17:30, the results are quite different.
- 17:32When we withdrew 4%from stocks without a
- 17:35cash account, there were 25 bankruptcies
- 17:37.
- 17:38But even when one year of living
- 17:40expenses was kept in cash, the number of
- 17:43bankruptcies was still 25, and with two
- 17:45years, it remained at 25.
- 17:47Even if you set aside three years' worth
- 17:49of cash, the number of bankruptcies only
- 17:51drops by one, to 24. I wondered if this
- 17:53was unique to the Nasdaq, so I ran the
- 17:55same test using 100 years of U.S. S&P
- 17:57500 data, and the results were even more
- 18:00shocking.
- 18:02For people withdrawing 4%from a 100%
- 18:05stock portfolio, the bankruptcy rate was
- 18:093.9%, but with a 1-year cash bucket, it
- 18:12rose to 4.6%, 6.5%for 2 years, and 8.1%
- 18:16for 3 years.
- 18:18This means the more cash you set aside,
- 18:20the higher the probability that your
- 18:22account will run dry.
- 18:23This is not a calculation error on my
- 18:26part. I thought something might be wrong
- 18:27too, so I looked into it and found a
- 18:29similar research paper. Professor Javier
- 18:31Estrada at IESE Business School in Spain
- 18:34published a paper in 2019 that conducted
- 18:37the same verification using 115 years of
- 18:39data from 21 countries around the world
- 18:42.
- 18:44Even there, the group holding a cash
- 18:46bucket showed a higher failure rate than
- 18:48the group that went 100%into stocks.
- 18:51And there is a prominent retirement
- 18:53researcher in the U.S. There is someone
- 18:55named Michael Kitces, and he even went
- 18:57so far as to call this cash bucket
- 18:59strategy a "mirage of asset allocation.
- 19:01"
- 19:02Why did this happen?
- 19:04It's not that the cash account did
- 19:06nothing at all.
- 19:07If you actually count the months when
- 19:10one had to sell stocks at a loss due to
- 19:12a lack of cash when the Nasdaq was down
- 19:14more than 20%from its peak, the person
- 19:16without cash had to sell at low prices
- 19:18for 159 months, while for someone
- 19:20holding two years 'worth of cash, this
- 19:22significantly dropped to 121 months.
- 19:25Based on the U.S. S&P 500, this drops
- 19:28from 37 months to zero months.
- 19:31However, after the dot-com bubble burst
- 19:34, the Nasdaq stayed more than 20%below
- 19:36its previous peak for over 13 years.
- 19:40If a downturn lasts that long, the
- 19:42two-year cash account runs out long
- 19:43before, and in the end, you have to sell
- 19:45stocks at the bottom just the same.
- 19:48Furthermore, setting aside a large sum
- 19:50of money as cash from the start consumes
- 19:52the opportunity cost of stock growth
- 19:54during bull markets, and while a cash
- 19:56bucket prevents selling stocks during
- 19:57downturns, it doesn't mean you're buying
- 19:59the dip to grow your assets later.
- 20:02Because that money is our living
- 20:03expenses that we have to spend.
- 20:05A cash bucket definitely protects our
- 20:07mental state because it keeps us from
- 20:09selling stocks at rock-bottom prices
- 20:11during a market crash.
- 20:14Peace of mind is also of immense value
- 20:15in investing, so I don't think those who
- 20:17already have a cash bucket necessarily
- 20:18need to get rid of it.
- 20:20However, if you look at it coldly based
- 20:22only on the numbers, having two or three
- 20:24years of cash does not mean your account
- 20:26is safe.
- 20:27You shouldn't think that way. Now,
- 20:28retirees, you know why I’m speaking so
- 20:31bluntly, right?
- 20:32We cannot afford a single slip-up. It
- 20:34means we must walk on a truly safe
- 20:36bridge.
- 20:37Then, what is the key to truly reducing
- 20:39the risk of bankruptcy that even a cash
- 20:41bucket couldn't lower?
- 20:43The answer is a bit anticlimactic, but
- 20:45it lies in the amount you withdraw.
- 20:47Just like when we diet, eating a little
- 20:49less at every meal lasts much longer
- 20:52than extreme methods like starving
- 20:54ourselves for days. Retirement accounts
- 20:56were exactly the same.
- 20:58If we set aside a little bit of our
- 21:00greed early in retirement when we have
- 21:02the most money and withdraw less, even
- 21:03if a market crash comes.
- 21:05The sheer number of stocks being sold
- 21:07off decreases significantly.
- 21:09Take a look at how the numbers change.
- 21:11If you start by withdrawing only 3%
- 21:13instead of 4%from the beginning, the
- 21:15number of people who run out of money
- 21:16drops from 25 to 12—cut by more than
- 21:18half in an instant.
- 21:21Even if you start at 4%, if you simply
- 21:23tighten your belt—reducing your living
- 21:26expenses by about 25%only during tough
- 21:28times when the market is down more than
- 21:3020%from its peak—the number of
- 21:32bankruptcies drops to 14.
- 21:36If you start at 3%from the beginning and
- 21:38tighten your belt when stocks fall by
- 21:40more than 20%, the number of
- 21:42bankruptcies decreases to seven out of
- 21:44214 people.
- 21:45That’s about one in 30.
- 21:48And those one in 30 are all people who
- 21:50retired near the peak of the worst
- 21:52bubble between January and September
- 21:542000.
- 21:56Using this method with 100 years of U.S.
- 21:58S&P 500 data, not a single person went
- 22:00bankrupt over a 30-year period. If you
- 22:02convert this to the 600 million won
- 22:04retirement fund mentioned earlier,
- 22:05you'll get a clear idea: 4%of 600
- 22:07million won is 2 million won a month in
- 22:08the first year, but lowering it to 3%
- 22:10means you withdraw 1.5 million won per
- 22:12month.
- 22:13And in a bear market where the index has
- 22:15fallen more than 20%from its peak, you
- 22:17save an additional 25%on top of that and
- 22:19get by on 1.125 million won per month.
- 22:21Of course, retirees also have pensions,
- 22:23so those should be kept separate, as
- 22:25that's a matter for each individual. For
- 22:27reference, the safe withdrawal rate
- 22:29suggested by global rating agency
- 22:30Morningstar over the past five years,
- 22:32reflecting future market outlooks, was
- 22:34also between 3.3%and 4%.
- 22:37Since future market returns may not be
- 22:39as high as they were over the past 40
- 22:41years, it means starting conservatively
- 22:44at the 3%level is much safer.
- 22:46Of course, you might think, wouldn't it
- 22:48be safe to withdraw 4%if we mixed in
- 22:50U.S. Treasury bonds instead of just the
- 22:52Nasdaq 100?
- 22:54In fact, if you gave 214 retirees since
- 22:561986 a portfolio of 60%Nasdaq and 40%10
- 22:59-year U.S. Treasury bonds, the number of
- 23:01bankruptcies would indeed drop to just
- 23:03one out of 214, even with 4%withdrawals
- 23:06.
- 23:07However, the bond-mix method has a
- 23:09pitfall related to the era.
- 23:12Since 1986, U.S. interest rates have
- 23:14been trending downward for decades,
- 23:16causing bond prices to rise continuously
- 23:18; in a way, it was a golden age for
- 23:20bonds.
- 23:23Conversely, if you run the 100-year U.S.
- 23:25data including retirees from the 1960s,
- 23:28when inflation soared and interest rates
- 23:30spiked, the group with 40%bonds actually
- 23:33saw more bankruptcies than the group
- 23:35that held 100%stocks.
- 23:38Bonds are subject to the dual cycles of
- 23:41inflation and interest rates, but
- 23:43adjusting the amount you withdraw is the
- 23:45most realistic survival strategy that
- 23:47works regardless of the cycle.
- 23:50You might naturally ask, "But with
- 23:52prices rising, how can I live on 1.12
- 23:55million won a month?" You are 100%
- 23:57correct.
- 23:59So, I will continue to provide videos on
- 24:01realistic ways to prepare for retirement
- 24:04, and I am currently preparing a website
- 24:06where I plan to post summarized key
- 24:08points.
- 24:10Retirement preparation is something
- 24:11everyone needs to do, but there is
- 24:13hardly anyone who actually teaches it.
- 24:15So, after I personally went through
- 24:16retirement, I really wished there had
- 24:18been someone to guide me.
- 24:20I will still cover market conditions
- 24:22occasionally, but I plan to focus on
- 24:25discussing ways to invest well so that
- 24:27we can retire at 60 or even earlier,
- 24:29instead of 65.
- 24:31So, for those who are curious, please
- 24:33subscribe to receive stories and
- 24:34information that can help you retire
- 24:36sooner.
- 24:37Now, I will neatly summarize the
- 24:39conclusions based on 40 years of Nasdaq
- 24:41data, tailored to investors in three
- 24:43different situations. First.
- 24:46For those whose retirement is still a
- 24:48long way off and who are accumulating
- 24:50assets monthly through a savings plan,
- 24:52there is no need to be afraid of market
- 24:55downturns, stop your contributions, or
- 24:57try to time the market to find a deeper
- 24:59bottom.
- 25:00As the data proves, the start date or
- 25:02market downturns during the accumulation
- 25:05period had a negligible impact on the
- 25:07final performance.
- 25:08In fact, those who contributed during
- 25:10periods like now, when the market is
- 25:12down 5%to 20%from its peak, saw much
- 25:14better results than those who bought at
- 25:16the peak. Therefore, the winning
- 25:18strategy is to just silently continue
- 25:19accumulating your shares as you have
- 25:21been doing. Of course, a savings plan
- 25:22doesn't necessarily guarantee the best
- 25:24possible rate of return.
- 25:26I’m suggesting that a consistent savings
- 25:28plan is fine because it’s often
- 25:30difficult for regular investors to use
- 25:32other trading methods.
- 25:33Second.
- 25:35Those who are about five years away from
- 25:37retirement are likely afraid of hitting
- 25:39a market crash right before they retire
- 25:41.
- 25:42You might consider mechanically selling
- 25:44stocks and moving to cash a few years in
- 25:46advance, but according to my analysis, I
- 25:48do not recommend that.
- 25:50As I mentioned, for eight or nine out of
- 25:52ten people, this leads to eroding the
- 25:53compounding effect just when their
- 25:55accounts would have grown the most.
- 25:59I want those preparing for retirement to
- 26:00know that retiring doesn't mean you have
- 26:02to close your accounts overnight or
- 26:03completely change your investment
- 26:05strategy.
- 26:07This is a situation I am personally
- 26:08experiencing after my own recent
- 26:09retirement, so I hope it serves as a
- 26:10helpful reference. I realized that
- 26:11retirement is actually the beginning of
- 26:13another phase of asset management. It
- 26:15would be helpful to remember that it is
- 26:16the starting line for a new investment
- 26:18journey where you gradually withdraw
- 26:19funds over several decades.
- 26:22Third, for those like me who are already
- 26:23retired and withdrawing a monthly "
- 26:25salary" from their accounts, keeping a
- 26:27few years' worth of living expenses in
- 26:29cash may provide immediate peace of mind
- 26:30, but it doesn't prevent our accounts
- 26:32from being depleted.
- 26:34The only thing that truly protects our
- 26:36accounts to the end is not being greedy
- 26:38and keeping the initial withdrawal rate
- 26:40low. Something in the 3%range rather
- 26:41than 4%. Also, when the market drops
- 26:44significantly by over 20%from its peak,
- 26:46you need the mindset to tighten your
- 26:47belt, cut back on spending, and endure
- 26:49it together.
- 26:51Well, that's all for the video I
- 26:52prepared today. If you're curious about
- 26:54investment information to accelerate
- 26:55your retirement, please subscribe and
- 26:57turn on notifications. This was Team
- 26:58Leader Song from "Retiring with Nasdaq.
- 26:59" Thank you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 하락장 적립식 투자, 나스닥 40년 돌려 보니 답은 '언제'가 아니라 '얼마씩'이었습니다 by 송팀장, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 4,846 words across 794 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.