3. Foundations: Freud — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:12Professor Paul Bloom: Okay.
- 0:12The last class we talked about the brain.
- 0:15Now we're going to talk a little bit about some
- 0:17foundations. So today and Monday we're going
- 0:21to talk about two very big ideas and these ideas are associated
- 0:27with Sigmund Freud and B. F.
- 0:30Skinner and are psychoanalysis and behaviorism.
- 0:35And I want to talk about psychoanalysis today and
- 0:38behaviorism next week. Now, one of these things--One
- 0:42of the things that makes these theories so interesting is their
- 0:46scope. Most of the work we're going to
- 0:49talk about in this class--Most of the ideas are narrow.
- 0:52So, we're going to talk about somebody's idea about racial
- 0:56prejudice but that's not a theory of language acquisition.
- 1:00We'll talk about theories of schizophrenia but they're not
- 1:04explanations of sexual attractiveness.
- 1:08Most theories are specialized theories but these two views are
- 1:12grand theories. They're theories of everything,
- 1:15encompassing just about everything that matters,
- 1:18day-to-day life, child development,
- 1:20mental illness, religion, war,
- 1:22love. Freud and Skinner had
- 1:24explanations of all of these. Now, this is not a history
- 1:29course. I have zero interest in
- 1:30describing historical figures in psychology just for the sake of
- 1:34telling you about the history of the field.
- 1:36What I want to tell you about though is--I want to talk about
- 1:40these ideas because so much rests on them and,
- 1:44even more importantly, a lot of these ideas have
- 1:47critical influence on how we think about the present.
- 1:55And that's there. Now, for better or worse,
- 1:58we live in a world profoundly affected by Sigmund Freud.
- 2:03If I had to ask you to choose a--no, name a famous
- 2:06psychologist, the answer of most of you would
- 2:10be Freud. He's the most famous
- 2:12psychologist ever and he's had a profound influence on the
- 2:16twentieth and twenty-first century.
- 2:19Some biographical information: He was born in the 1850s.
- 2:23He spent most of his life in Vienna, Austria,
- 2:26but he died in London and he escaped to London soon after
- 2:31retreating there at the beginning of World War II as the
- 2:35Nazis began to occupy where he lived.
- 2:39He's one of the most famous scholars ever but he's not known
- 2:43for any single discovery. Instead, he's known for the
- 2:47development of an encompassing theory of mind,
- 2:50one that he developed over the span of many decades.
- 2:54He was in his time extremely well known, a celebrity
- 2:57recognized on the street, and throughout his life.
- 3:01He was a man of extraordinary energy and productivity,
- 3:04in part because he was a very serious cocaine addict,
- 3:07but also just in general. He was just a high-energy sort
- 3:11of person. He was up for the Nobel Prize
- 3:13in medicine and in literature; didn't get either one of them;
- 3:17didn't get the prize in medicine because Albert
- 3:20Einstein--Everybody loves Albert Einstein.
- 3:23Well, Albert Einstein really wrote a letter because they
- 3:25asked for opinions of other Nobel Prizes.
- 3:28He wrote a letter saying, "Don't give the prize to Freud.
- 3:30He doesn't deserve a Nobel Prize.
- 3:32He's just a psychologist." Well, yeah.
- 3:38Okay. While he's almost universally
- 3:41acclaimed as a profoundly important intellectual figure,
- 3:45he's also the object of considerable dislike.
- 3:49This is in part because of his character.
- 3:51He was not a very nice man in many ways.
- 3:53He was deeply ambitious to the cause of promoting
- 3:57psychoanalysis, to the cause of presenting his
- 4:00view and defending it, and he was often dishonest,
- 4:04extremely brutal to his friends, and terrible to his
- 4:08enemies. He was an interesting character.
- 4:11My favorite Freud story was as he was leaving Europe during the
- 4:16rise of the Nazis, as he was ready to go to
- 4:19England from, I think, either Germany or
- 4:22Austria, he had to sign a letter from the Gestapo.
- 4:26Gestapo agents intercepted him and demanded he sign a letter
- 4:30saying that at no point had he been threatened or harassed by
- 4:34the Gestapo. So he signs the letter and then
- 4:38he writes underneath it, "The Gestapo has not harmed me
- 4:41in any way. In fact, I highly recommend the
- 4:44Gestapo to everybody." It's--He had a certain
- 4:48aggression to him. He was also--He's also
- 4:52disliked, often hated, because of his views.
- 4:56He was seen as a sexual renegade out to destroy the
- 5:00conception of people as good and rational and pure beings.
- 5:04And when the Nazis rose to power in the 1930s he was
- 5:08identified as a Jew who was devoted to destroying the most
- 5:11sacred notions of Christianity and to many,
- 5:15to some extent, many people see him this way.
- 5:19And to some extent, this accusation has some truth
- 5:23to it. Freud made claims about people
- 5:26that many of us, maybe most of us,
- 5:29would rather not know. Well, okay.
- 5:32What did he say? Well, if you ask somebody who
- 5:35doesn't like Freud what he said, they'll describe some of the
- 5:39stupider things he said and, in fact, Freud said a lot of
- 5:43things, some of which were not very rational.
- 5:46For instance, he's well known for his account
- 5:50of phallic symbols, arguing certain architectural
- 5:54monuments are subconsciously developed as penile
- 5:58representations. And related to this,
- 6:01he developed the notorious theory of penis envy.
- 6:04And penis envy is an account of a developmental state that every
- 6:08one of you who is female has gone through,
- 6:11according to Freud. And the idea is that you
- 6:13discovered at some point in your development that you lacked a
- 6:17penis. This is not--This is a
- 6:20catastrophe. And so, each of you inferred at
- 6:23that point that you had been castrated.
- 6:26You had once had a penis but somebody had taken it from you.
- 6:32You then turn to your father and love your father because
- 6:36your father has a penis, so he's a sort of penis
- 6:40substitute. You reject your mother,
- 6:43who's equally unworthy due to her penis lack,
- 6:47and that shapes your psychosexual development.
- 6:52Now, if that's the sort of thing you know about Freud,
- 6:55you are not going to have a very high opinion of him or of
- 6:57his work, but at the core of Freud's
- 7:00declamation, the more interesting ideas,
- 7:04is a set of claims of a man's intellectual importance.
- 7:09And the two main ones are this. The two main ones involve the
- 7:12existence of an unconscious, unconscious motivation,
- 7:16and the notion of unconscious dynamics or unconscious conflict
- 7:20which lead to mental illnesses, dreams, slips of the tongue and
- 7:25so on. The first idea – the idea of
- 7:28unconscious motivation – involves rejecting the claim
- 7:33that you know what you're doing. So, suppose you fall in love
- 7:37with somebody and you decide you want to marry them and then
- 7:41somebody was asked to ask you why and you'd say something
- 7:44like, "Well, I'm ready to get married
- 7:46this stage of my life; I really love the person;
- 7:49the person is smart and attractive;
- 7:50I want to have kids" whatever. And maybe this is true.
- 7:56But a Freudian might say that even if this is your honest
- 8:00answer – you're not lying to anybody else –still,
- 8:04there are desires and motivations that govern your
- 8:08behavior that you may not be aware of.
- 8:11So, in fact, you might want to marry John
- 8:14because he reminds you of your father or because you want to
- 8:19get back at somebody for betraying you.
- 8:23If somebody was to tell you this, you'd say,
- 8:26"That's total nonsense," but that wouldn't deter a Freudian.
- 8:29The Freudian would say that these processes are unconscious
- 8:32so of course you just don't know what's happening.
- 8:34So, the radical idea here is you might not know what--why you
- 8:39do what you do and this is something we accept for things
- 8:44like visual perception. We accept that you look around
- 8:47the world and you get sensations and you figure out there is a
- 8:50car, there is a tree, there is a person.
- 8:52And you're just unconscious of how this happens but it's
- 8:55unpleasant and kind of frightening that this could
- 8:58happen, that this could apply to things
- 9:01like why you're now studying at Yale, why you feel the way you
- 9:06do towards your friends, towards your family.
- 9:10Now, the marriage case is extreme but Freud gives a lot of
- 9:14simpler examples where this sort of unconscious motivation might
- 9:18play a role. So, have you ever liked
- 9:21somebody or disliked them and not known why?
- 9:24Have you ever found yourself in a situation where you're doing
- 9:27something or you're arguing for something or making a decision
- 9:31for reasons that you can't fully articulate?
- 9:34Have you ever forgotten somebody's name at exactly the
- 9:37wrong time? Have you ever called out the
- 9:39wrong name in the throes of passion?
- 9:41This is all the Freudian unconscious.
- 9:45The idea is that we do these things--these things are
- 9:48explained in terms of cognitive systems that we're not aware of.
- 9:51Now, all of this would be fine if your unconscious was a
- 9:55reasonable, rational computer, if your unconscious was really
- 9:59smart and looking out for your best interest.
- 10:02But, according to Freud, that's not the way it works.
- 10:05According to Freud, there are three distinct
- 10:08processes going on in your head and these are in violent
- 10:12internal conflict. And the way you act and the way
- 10:15you think are products, not of a singular rational
- 10:19being, but of a set of conflicting creatures.
- 10:22And these three parts are the id, the ego, and the superego
- 10:28and they emerge developmentally. The id, according to Freud,
- 10:33is present at birth. It's the animal part of the
- 10:37self. It wants to eat,
- 10:39drink, pee, poop, get warm, and have sexual
- 10:42satisfaction. It is outrageously stupid.
- 10:47It works on what Freud called, "The Pleasure Principle."
- 10:50It wants pleasure and it wants it now.
- 10:53And that's, according to Freud, how a human begins – pure id.
- 10:58Freud had this wonderful phrase, "polymorphous
- 11:02perversity," this pure desire for pleasure.
- 11:06Now, unfortunately, life doesn't work like that.
- 11:08What you want isn't always what you get and this leads to a set
- 11:13of reactions to cope with the fact that pleasure isn't always
- 11:17there when you want it either by planning how to satisfy your
- 11:22desires or planning how to suppress them.
- 11:25And this system is known as the ego, or the self.
- 11:29And it works on the "Reality Principle."
- 11:33And it works on the principle of trying to figure out how to
- 11:37make your way through the world, how to satisfy your pleasures
- 11:42or, in some cases, how to give up on them.
- 11:45And the ego – the emergence of the ego for Freud--symbolizes
- 11:49the origin of consciousness. Finally, if this was all there
- 11:53it might be a simpler world, but Freud had a third
- 11:57component, that of the superego. And the superego is the
- 12:01internalized rules of parents in society.
- 12:05So, what happens in the course of development is,
- 12:07you're just trying to make your way through the world and
- 12:09satisfy your desires, but sometimes you're punished
- 12:13for them. Some desires are inappropriate,
- 12:15some actions are wrong, and you're punished for it.
- 12:19The idea is that you come out; you get in your head a
- 12:23superego, a conscience. In these movies,
- 12:26there'd be a little angel above your head that tells you when
- 12:31things are wrong. And basically your self,
- 12:34the ego, is in between the id and the superego.
- 12:39One thing to realize, I told you the id is
- 12:42outrageously stupid. It just says,
- 12:44"Oh, hungry, food, sex, oh,
- 12:46let's get warm, oh."
- 12:48The superego is also stupid. The superego,
- 12:52point to point, is not some brilliant moral
- 12:55philosopher telling you about right and wrong.
- 12:57The superego would say, "You should be ashamed of
- 12:59yourself. That's disgusting.
- 13:01Stop doing that. Oh."
- 13:03And in between these two screaming creatures,
- 13:06one of you; one of them telling you to seek
- 13:09out your desires, the other one telling you,
- 13:11"you should be ashamed of yourself," is you,
- 13:14is the ego. Now, according to Freud,
- 13:16most of this is unconscious. So, we see bubbling up to the
- 13:21top, we feel, we experience ourselves.
- 13:25And the driving of the id, the forces of the id and the
- 13:28forces of the superego, are unconscious in that we
- 13:32cannot access them. We don't know what--It's like
- 13:36the workings of our kidneys or our stomachs.
- 13:39You can't introspect and find them.
- 13:42Rather, they do their work without conscious knowledge.
- 13:47Now, Freud developed this. This is the Freudian theory in
- 13:51broad outline. He extended it and developed it
- 13:54into a theory of psychosexual development.
- 13:58And so, Freud's theory is, as I said before,
- 14:01a theory of everyday life, of decisions,
- 14:04of errors, of falling in love, but it's also a theory of child
- 14:08development. So, Freud believed there were
- 14:11five stages of personality development, and each is
- 14:16associated with a particular erogenous zone.
- 14:19And Freud believed, as well, that if you have a
- 14:23problem at a certain stage, if something goes wrong,
- 14:26you'll be stuck there. So, according to Freud,
- 14:29there are people in this room who are what they are because
- 14:32they got stuck in the oral stage or the anal stage.
- 14:34And that's not good. So, the oral stage is when you
- 14:40start off. The mouth is associated with
- 14:42pleasure. Everything is sucking and
- 14:45chewing and so on. And the problem for Freud is
- 14:49premature weaning of a child. Depriving him of the breast,
- 14:53could lead to serious problems in his personality development.
- 14:58It could make him, as the phrase goes,
- 15:01into an oral person. And his orality could be
- 15:05described literally. Freud uses it as an explanation
- 15:10for why somebody might eat too much or chew gum or smoke.
- 15:14They're trying to achieve satisfaction through their mouth
- 15:17of a sort they didn't get in this very early stage of
- 15:21development. But it can also be more
- 15:23abstract. If your roommate is dependent
- 15:26and needy, you could then go to your roommate and say,
- 15:30"You are an oral person. The first year of your life did
- 15:35not go well." A phrase even more popular is
- 15:38the anal stage and that happens after the oral stage.
- 15:42And problems can emerge if toilet training is not handled
- 15:48correctly. If you have problems during
- 15:50those years of life, you could become an anal
- 15:53personality, according to Freud,
- 15:55and your roommate could say, "Your problem is you're too
- 15:59anal." And, according to Freud,
- 16:01literally, it meant you are unwilling to part with your own
- 16:04feces.
- 16:08It's written down here. I know it's true.
- 16:10And the way it manifests itself, as you know from just
- 16:14how people talk, is you're compulsive,
- 16:16you're clean, you're stingy.
- 16:18This is the anal personality. Then it gets a little bit more
- 16:22complicated. The next stage is the phallic
- 16:25stage. Actually, this is not much more
- 16:27complicated. The focus of pleasure shifts to
- 16:30the genitals and fixation can lead to excessive masculinity in
- 16:36females or in males or if you're female a need for attention or
- 16:43domination. Now, at this point something
- 16:46really interesting happens called the "Oedipus Complex."
- 16:50And this is based on the story, the mythical story of a king
- 16:55who killed his father and married his mother.
- 16:58And, according to Freud, this happens to all of us in
- 17:03this way. Well, all of us.
- 17:05By "all of us," Freud meant "men."
- 17:09So, here's the idea. You're three or four years old.
- 17:13You're in the phallic stage. So, what are you interested in?
- 17:17Well, you're interested in your penis and then you seek an
- 17:21external object. Freud's sort of vague about
- 17:24this, but you seek some sort of satisfaction.
- 17:27But who is out there who'd be sweet and kind and loving and
- 17:30wonderful? Well, Mom.
- 17:35So the child infers, "Mom is nice,
- 17:39I love Mom." So far so--And so this is not
- 17:43crazy; a little boy falling in love
- 17:46with his mother. Problem: Dad's in the way.
- 17:51Now, this is going to get progressively weirder but I will
- 17:55have to say, as the father of two sons,
- 17:58both sons went through a phase where they explicitly said they
- 18:02wanted to marry Mommy. And me – if something bad
- 18:04happened to me that wouldn't be the worst thing in the world.
- 18:07So, there's this. But now it gets a little bit
- 18:13aggressive. So, the idea is the child
- 18:16determines that he's going to kill his father.
- 18:19Every three- and four-year-old boy thinks this.
- 18:22But then because children, according to Freud,
- 18:25don't have a good sense of the boundary between their mind and
- 18:30the world, which is a problem – the
- 18:32problem is they don't – they think their father can tell that
- 18:37they're plotting to kill him and they figure their father is now
- 18:41angry at them. And then they ask themselves,
- 18:44"What's the worst thing Dad could do to me?"
- 18:46And the answer is castration. So, they come to the conclusion
- 18:53that their father is going to castrate them because of their
- 18:57illicit love for their Mom. And then they say,
- 19:00"Dad wins" and then they don't think about sex for several
- 19:04years and that's the latency stage.
- 19:07The latency stage is they've gone through this huge thing
- 19:10with Mom and Dad, "fell in love with Mom,
- 19:12wanted to kill my father, Dad was going to castrate me,
- 19:16fell out of love with Mom, out of the sex business."
- 19:20And then, sex is repressed until you get to the genital
- 19:23stage. And the genital stage is the
- 19:25stage we are all in – the healthy adult stage.
- 19:30Now that you're adults and you've gone through all the
- 19:34developmental stages, where do you stand?
- 19:37You're not out of the woods yet because unconscious mechanisms
- 19:42are still--Even if you haven't got fixated on anything,
- 19:46there's still this dynamic going on all the time with your
- 19:50id, your ego and your superego. And the idea is your
- 19:54superego--Remember, your superego is stupid.
- 19:58So, your superego isn't only telling you not to do bad
- 20:02things, it's telling you not to think bad things.
- 20:07So, what's happening is your id is sending up all of this weird,
- 20:11sick stuff, all of these crazy sexual and violent desires,
- 20:15"Oh, I'll kill him. I'll have sex with that.
- 20:18I'll have extra helpings on my dessert."
- 20:23And your superego is saying, "No, no, no."
- 20:28And this stuff is repressed. It doesn't even make it to
- 20:31consciousness. The problem is Freud had a very
- 20:34sort of hydraulic theory of what goes on and some of this stuff
- 20:39slips out and it shows up in dreams and it shows up in slips
- 20:43of the tongue. And in exceptional cases,
- 20:46it shows up in certain clinical symptoms.
- 20:49So what happens is, Freud described a lot of normal
- 20:53life in terms of different ways we use to keep that horrible
- 20:58stuff from the id making its way to consciousness.
- 21:02And he called these "defense mechanisms."
- 21:05You're defending yourself against the horrible parts of
- 21:10yourself and some of these make a little bit of sense.
- 21:14One way to describe this in a non-technical,
- 21:17non-Freudian way is, there are certain things about
- 21:20ourselves we'd rather not know. There are certain desires we'd
- 21:23rather not know and we have ways to hide them.
- 21:26So, for instance, there's sublimation.
- 21:28Sublimation is you might have a lot of energy,
- 21:31maybe sexual energy or aggressive energy,
- 21:34but instead of turning it to a sexual or aggressive target what
- 21:38you do is you focus it in some other way.
- 21:40So, you can imagine a great artist like Picasso turning the
- 21:44sexual energy into his artwork. There is displacement.
- 21:52Displacement is you have certain shameful thoughts or
- 21:55desires and you refocus them more appropriately.
- 21:59A boy who's bullied by his father may hate his father and
- 22:03want to hurt him but since this would--this is very shameful and
- 22:08difficult. The boy might instead kick the
- 22:10dog and think he hates the dog because that's a more acceptable
- 22:14target.
- 22:22There is projection. Projection is,
- 22:25I have certain impulses I am uncomfortable with,
- 22:28so rather than own them myself, I project them to somebody
- 22:33else. A classic example for Freud is
- 22:36homosexual desires. The idea is that I feel this
- 22:39tremendous lust towards you, for instance,
- 22:42and--any of you, all of you, you three,
- 22:46and I'm ashamed of this lust so what I say is,
- 22:50"Hey. Are you guys looking at me in a
- 22:53sexual manner? Are you lusting after me?
- 22:55How disgusting," because what I do is I take my own desires and
- 22:59I project it to others. And Freud suggested,
- 23:01perhaps not implausibly, that men who believe other
- 23:05men--who are obsessed with the sexuality of other men,
- 23:08are themselves projecting away their own sexual desires.
- 23:12There is rationalization, which is that when you do
- 23:16something or think something bad you rationalize it and you give
- 23:20it a more socially acceptable explanation.
- 23:24A parent who enjoys smacking his child will typically not
- 23:28say, "I enjoy smacking my child."
- 23:31Rather he'll say, "It's for the child's own good.
- 23:33I'm being a good parent by doing this."
- 23:35And finally, there is regression,
- 23:37which is returning to an earlier stage of development.
- 23:41And you actually see this in children.
- 23:42In times of stress and trauma, they'll become younger,
- 23:47they will act younger. They might cry.
- 23:50They might suck their thumb, seek out a blanket or so on.
- 23:53Now, these are all mechanisms that for Freud are not the
- 23:56slightest bit pathological. They are part of normal life.
- 24:00Normally, we do these things to keep an equilibrium among the
- 24:05different systems of the unconscious, but sometimes it
- 24:09doesn't work. Sometimes things go awry and
- 24:13what happens is a phrase that's not currently used in psychology
- 24:19but was popular during Freud's time: hysteria.
- 24:23Hysteria includes phenomena like hysterical blindness and
- 24:27hysterical deafness, which is when you cannot see
- 24:29and cannot hear even though there's nothing physiologically
- 24:32wrong with you – paralysis, trembling, panic attacks,
- 24:36gaps of memory including amnesia and so on.
- 24:39And the idea is that these are actually symptoms.
- 24:43These are symptoms of mechanisms going on to keep
- 24:46things unconscious. It's a common enough idea in
- 24:51movies. Often in movies what happens is
- 24:53that somebody goes to an analyst.
- 24:55They have some horrible problem. They can't remember something
- 24:58or they have some sort of blackouts and so on.
- 25:00And the analyst tells them something and at one point they
- 25:05get this insight and they realize what--why they've
- 25:09blinded themselves, why they can't remember,
- 25:12and for Freud this is what happens.
- 25:14Freud originally attempted to get these memories out through
- 25:20hypnosis but then moved to the mechanism of free association
- 25:25and, according to Freud,
- 25:27the idea is patients offer resistance to this and then the
- 25:33idea of a psychoanalyst is to get over the resistance and help
- 25:38patients get insight. The key notion of
- 25:43psychoanalysis is your problems are--actually reflect deeper
- 25:50phenomena. You're hiding something from
- 25:53yourself, and once you know what's going on to deeper
- 25:57phenomena your problems will go away.
- 25:59I'm going to give you an example of a therapy session.
- 26:03Now, this is not a Freudian analysis.
- 26:06We'll discuss later on in the course what a Freudian analysis
- 26:09is, but this is not a pure Freudian analysis.
- 26:11A Freudian analysis, of course, is lying on a couch;
- 26:14does not see their therapist; their therapist is very
- 26:17nondirective. But I'm going to present this
- 26:20as an example here because it illustrates so many of the
- 26:24Freudian themes, particularly themes about
- 26:27dreams, the importance of dreams, about repression and
- 26:30about hidden meaning. So, this is from a television
- 26:34episode and the character's--Many--Some of you
- 26:37may have seen this. Many of you will not have.
- 26:40The character is suffering from panic attacks.
- 27:14Freud's contributions extend beyond the study of individual
- 27:19psychology and individual pathology.
- 27:22Freud had a lot to say about dreams as you could see in this
- 27:26illustration. He believed that dreams had a
- 27:29manifest content, meaning;
- 27:32"manifest" meaning what you experience in your dream.
- 27:35But dreams always had a latent content as well,
- 27:38meaning the hidden implication of the dream.
- 27:42He viewed all dreams as wish fulfillment.
- 27:45Every dream you have is a certain wish you have even
- 27:47though it might be a forbidden wish that you wouldn't wish to
- 27:50have, you wouldn't want to have. And dreams had--and this is an
- 27:53idea that long predated Freud. Dreams had symbolism.
- 27:57Things in dreams were often not what they seemed to be but
- 28:02rather symbols for other things. Freud believed that literature
- 28:07and fairy tales and stories to children and the like carried
- 28:13certain universal themes, certain aspects of unconscious
- 28:18struggles, and certain preoccupations of our
- 28:22unconscious mind. And Freud had a lot to say
- 28:25about religion. For instance,
- 28:27he viewed a large part of our--of the idea of finding a
- 28:32singular, all-powerful god as seeking out
- 28:36a father figure that some of us never had during development.
- 28:41What I want to spend the rest of the class on is the
- 28:45scientific assessment of Freud. So, what I did so far is I've
- 28:48told you what Freud had to say in broad outline.
- 28:51I then want to take the time to consider whether or not we
- 28:55should believe this and how well it fits with our modern science.
- 28:59But before doing so, I'll take questions for a few
- 29:02minutes. Do people have any questions
- 29:04about Freud or Freud's theories?
- 29:10Yes. Student:
- 29:14[inaudible] Professor Paul Bloom:
- 29:18So, that's some question. The question is:
- 29:22The conflicts in psychosexual development that Freud describes
- 29:27is--always assumes that a child has a mother and a father,
- 29:32one of each, in a certain sort of familial
- 29:34structure. And the question then is,
- 29:37"What if a child was raised by a single parent,
- 29:40for example?" What if a child was never
- 29:42breast fed, but fed from the bottle from the start?
- 29:45And Freudians have had problems with this.
- 29:49Freud's--Freud was very focused on the family life of the people
- 29:54he interacted with, which is rather upper class
- 29:57Europeans, and these sort of questions would have been
- 30:00difficult for Freud to answer. I imagine that what a Freudian
- 30:03would have to say is, you would expect systematic
- 30:06differences. So, you would expect a child
- 30:08who just grew up with a mother or just grew up to be a
- 30:11father--with a father to be in some sense psychologically
- 30:14damaged by that, failing to go through the
- 30:17normal psychosexual stages. Yes.
- 30:21Student: [inaudible]
- 30:24Professor Paul Bloom: The issue--The question is,
- 30:29"Do modern psychoanalysts still believe that women do not have
- 30:34superegos?" Freud was--As you're pointing
- 30:37out, Freud was notorious for pointing, for suggesting that
- 30:41women were morally immature relative to men.
- 30:44I think Freud would say that women have superegos,
- 30:47they're just not the sort of sturdy ones that men have.
- 30:50I think psychoanalysts and psychoanalytic scholars right
- 30:54now would be mixed. Some would maintain that there
- 30:56really are deep sex differences. Others would want to jettison
- 30:59that aspect of Freudian theory.
- 31:05Yes. Student:
- 31:08Do you define sublimation as being displacement?
- 31:10Does that make it sort of a subgroup of displacement?
- 31:14Professor Paul Bloom: Well, what sublimation is--A
- 31:16lot of these--It's a good question.
- 31:18The question is sort of, what is sublimation?
- 31:20How does it relate to the other defense mechanisms?
- 31:22A lot of defense mechanisms involve taking a desire and
- 31:28turning it. Now, what displacement does is
- 31:32it takes it from you to her. I'm angry at you but maybe
- 31:36that's forbidden for some reason, so I'll be angry at her.
- 31:39What projection does is takes a desire from me and then puts it
- 31:43on somebody else heading outwards.
- 31:46And what sublimation does is it just gives up the details and
- 31:50keeps the energy. So, you stay up--Your roommate
- 31:53stays up all night working and you say to your roommate,
- 31:56for instance, "That's just because you
- 31:58haven't had sex in a long time and you want to have sex so you
- 32:02devote all your energy to your math exam."
- 32:04And then you say, "That's sublimation.
- 32:07I learned that in Intro Psych." And your roommate would be very
- 32:12pleased. One more question.
- 32:23Yes. Student:
- 32:26What kind of evidence is there for cross-cultural variation?
- 32:30Professor Paul Bloom: The question is,
- 32:32which is related to the issue--extending the issue of
- 32:34the two-parent versus one-parent family is,
- 32:36"To what extent are these notions validated
- 32:39cross-culturally?" And that's such a good question
- 32:41I'm going to defer it. I'm going to talk about it in a
- 32:43few minutes because that's actually--That speaks to the
- 32:46issue of the scientific assessment of Freud so I'm going
- 32:49to try to get to your question in a little bit.
- 32:55Freudian theory is now, at this point of time,
- 33:00extremely controversial and there is a lot of well-known
- 33:05criticisms and attacks on Freud. This is just actually an
- 33:10excellent book on The Memory Wars by Frederick Crews,
- 33:14which--and Frederick Crews is one of the strongest and most
- 33:18passionate critics of Freud. And the problems with Freud go
- 33:24like this. There are two ways you could
- 33:28reject a theory. There are two problems with the
- 33:31scientific theory. One way you could reject a
- 33:34theory is that it could be wrong.
- 33:37So, suppose I have a theory that the reason why some
- 33:40children have autism, a profound developmental
- 33:43disorder, is because their mothers don't
- 33:45love them enough. This was a popular theory for
- 33:48many years. It's a possible theory.
- 33:52It just turns out to be wrong but another way--And so one way
- 33:57to attack and address a scientific theory is to view it
- 34:01as just to see whether or not it works.
- 34:05But there's a different problem a theory could have.
- 34:08A theory could be so vague and all encompassing that it can't
- 34:14even be tested. And this is one of the main
- 34:18critiques of Freud. The idea could be summed up by
- 34:22a quotation from the physicist Wolfgang Pauli.
- 34:26And Pauli was asked his opinion about another physicist.
- 34:30And Pauli said this: "That guy's work is crap.
- 34:35He's not right. He's not even wrong."
- 34:39And the criticism about Freud is that he's not even wrong.
- 34:44The issue of vagueness is summarized in a more technical
- 34:49way by the philosopher Karl Popper who described--who
- 34:54introduced the term of falsifiability.
- 34:58The idea of falsifiability is that what distinguishes science
- 35:03from non science is that scientific predictions make
- 35:07strong claims about the world and these claims are of a sort
- 35:12that they could be proven wrong. If they couldn't be proven
- 35:17wrong, they're not interesting enough to be science.
- 35:20So, for example, within psychology the sort of
- 35:22claims we'll be entertaining throughout the course include
- 35:25claims like, damage to the hippocampus
- 35:27causes failures of certain sorts of memory, or everywhere in the
- 35:32world men on average want to have more sexual partners than
- 35:36women, or exposure to violent
- 35:38television tends to make children themselves more
- 35:42violent. Now, are they true or are they
- 35:45false? Well, we'll talk about that,
- 35:47but the point here is they can be false.
- 35:50They're interesting enough that they can be tested and as such
- 35:54they go to--they might be wrong but they graduate to the level
- 35:59of a scientific theory. This should be contrasted with
- 36:03nonscientific programs and the best example of a nonscientific
- 36:08program is astrology. So, the problem with
- 36:11astrological predictions is not that they're wrong.
- 36:16It's that they can't be wrong. They're not even wrong.
- 36:18I did my--I got my horoscope for today on the web.
- 36:25"A couple of negative aspects could make you a little finicky
- 36:28for the next few days." Okay.
- 36:30I'm going to watch for that. "The presence of both Mars and
- 36:33Venus suggests you want to box everything into a neat,
- 36:35ordered, structured way but keeping a piece of jade or
- 36:38carnelian close will help you keep in touch with your fun
- 36:41side." And starting this morning I got
- 36:43from my wife a little piece of jade and I have been sort of in
- 36:45touch with my fun side. The problem is,
- 36:47a few days aren't going to go by and say, "God.
- 36:50That was wrong." It can't be wrong.
- 36:52It's just so vague. I got a better horoscope from
- 36:57The Onion actually: "Riding in a golf cart with
- 37:01snow cone in hand, you'll be tackled by two police
- 37:04officers this week after matching a composite caricature
- 37:06of a suspected murderer." Now, that's a good prediction
- 37:13because "wow." If it turns out to be true,
- 37:18I'm going to say, "Those guys really know
- 37:20something." It's falsifiable.
- 37:24Arguably, Freud fails the test because Freudian theory is often
- 37:30so vague and flexible that it can't really be tested in any
- 37:35reliable way. A big problem with this is a
- 37:38lot of Freudian theory is claimed to be validated in the
- 37:41course of psychoanalysis. So, when you ask people,
- 37:44"Why do you believe in Freud?" they won't say,
- 37:46"Oh, because of this experiment, that experiment,
- 37:47this data set and that data set."
- 37:49What they'll say is, "It's--The Freudian theory
- 37:51proves itself in the course of psychoanalysis – the success
- 37:55of psychoanalysis." But it's unreliable.
- 37:58The problem is, say, Freud says to a patient,
- 38:00"You hate your mother." The patient says, "Wow.
- 38:03That makes sense." Freud says, "I'm right."
- 38:07The patient--Freud says, "You hate your mother," and the
- 38:09patient says, "No, I don't.
- 38:11That's titillating. That's disgusting."
- 38:15Freud says, "Your anger shows this idea is painful to you.
- 38:17You have repressed it from consciousness.
- 38:18I am right." And the problem is the same
- 38:21sort of dynamic plays itself out even in the scientific debate
- 38:27back and forth. So Freud--Freudian
- 38:30psychologists--I'm putting Freud here but what I mean is
- 38:33well-known defenders of Freud will make some claims like:
- 38:36adult personality traits are shaped by the course of
- 38:39psychosexual development; all dreams are disguised wish
- 38:42fulfillment; psychoanalysis is the best
- 38:44treatment for mental disorders. Scientists will respond,
- 38:46"I disagree. There's little or no evidence
- 38:48supporting those claims." And the Freudian response is,
- 38:50"Your rejection of my ideas shows that they are distressing
- 38:53to you. This is because I am right."
- 38:55And this is often followed up, seriously enough.
- 38:58"You have deep psychological problems."
- 39:02And now, I don't want to caricature Freudians.
- 39:09A lot of Freudians have tried and made a research program of
- 39:13extending their ideas scientifically,
- 39:16bringing them to robust scientific tests.
- 39:20But the problem is, when you make specific
- 39:23falsifiable predictions they don't always do that well.
- 39:28So, for instance, there's no evidence that oral
- 39:30and anal characteristics, the personality characteristics
- 39:33I talked about – about being needy versus being stingy –
- 39:36relate in any interesting way to weaning or toilet training.
- 39:40And there's been some efforts cross-culturally,
- 39:42to go back to the question this young man asked before –
- 39:46looking at cross-cultural differences in toilet training
- 39:49and weaning, which are really big
- 39:51differences, to see if they correspond in any interesting
- 39:54way to personality differences. And there's been no good
- 39:58evidence supporting that. Similarly, Freud had some
- 40:01strong claims about sexuality, for why some people are
- 40:05straight and others are gay. These have met with very little
- 40:10empirical support. And the claim that
- 40:13psychoanalysis proves itself by being--by its tremendous success
- 40:17in curing mental illness is also almost certainly not true.
- 40:21For most--Maybe not all, but for most psychological
- 40:24disorders, there are quicker and more reliable treatments than
- 40:27psychoanalysis. And there's considerable
- 40:30controversy as to whether the Tony Soprano method of insight,
- 40:34where you get this insight and there's discovery,
- 40:38"Oh, now I know," makes any real difference in alleviating
- 40:42symptoms such as anxiety disorders or depression.
- 40:47This is why there's sort of--often sort of a sticker
- 40:50shock when people go to a university psychology department
- 40:55where they say, "Look.
- 40:56Hey. Where is--So I'm in Psych.
- 40:58How could I take classes on Freud?
- 41:00Who's your expert on Freud?" And the truth is Freudian
- 41:05psychoanalysis is almost never studied inside psychology
- 41:09departments. Not the cognitive or
- 41:11developmental side, not the clinical side.
- 41:14There are some exceptions but, for the most part,
- 41:17even the people who do study Freud within psychology
- 41:21departments do so critically. Very few of them would see
- 41:25themselves as a psychoanalytic practitioner or as a Freudian
- 41:29psychologist. Freud lives on both in a
- 41:32clinical setting and in the university but Freud at Yale,
- 41:36for instance, is much more likely to be found
- 41:38in the history department or the literature department than in
- 41:41the psychology department. And this is typical enough but,
- 41:45despite all of the, sort of, sour things I just
- 41:50said about Freud, the big idea,
- 41:53the importance of the dynamic unconscious, remains intact.
- 41:59We will go over and over and over again different case
- 42:03studies where some really interesting aspects of mental
- 42:07life prove to be unconscious. Now, there's one question.
- 42:12I'm actually going to skip over this for reasons of time and
- 42:17just go to some examples of the unconscious in modern
- 42:22psychology. So, here's a simple example of
- 42:27the unconscious in modern psychology: Language
- 42:32understanding. So, when you hear a sentence
- 42:36like, "John thinks that Bill likes him," in a fraction of a
- 42:42second you realize that this means that John thinks that Bill
- 42:47likes John. If you heard the
- 42:49sentence--Oops--"John thinks that Bill likes himself," in a
- 42:53fraction of a second you would think that it means "John thinks
- 42:57that Bill likes Bill." And as we will get to when we
- 43:00get to the lecture on language, this is not conscious.
- 43:02You don't know how you do this. You don't even know that you
- 43:05are doing this but you do it quickly and instinctively.
- 43:09So much of our day-to-day life can be done unconsciously.
- 43:13There are different activities you can do – driving,
- 43:17chewing gum, shoelace tying – where if
- 43:19you're good enough at them, if you're expert enough at
- 43:23them, you don't know you're doing them.
- 43:25I was at a party a few years ago for a friend of mine and we
- 43:29ran out of food so he said, "I'll just go pick up some
- 43:32food." An hour later he was
- 43:34gone--still gone and it was around the corner.
- 43:37And we called him up on his cell phone and he said,
- 43:40"Oh. I got on the highway and I
- 43:44drove to work." Yeah.
- 43:47He works an hour away but he got on the highway "drive drive
- 43:49drive." And these--some version of
- 43:52these things happen all of the time.
- 43:59Maybe more surprising, Freud's insight that our likes
- 44:03and dislikes are due to factors that we're not necessarily
- 44:08conscious of has a lot of empirical support--a lot of
- 44:12empirical support from research into social psychology,
- 44:17for example. So, here's one finding from
- 44:20social psychology. If somebody goes through a
- 44:25terrible initiation to get into a club, they'll like the club
- 44:32more. You might think they'd like it
- 44:34less because people do terrible things to them.
- 44:36But actually, hazing is illegal but a
- 44:40remarkably successful tool. The more you pay for something
- 44:45the more you like it and the more pain you go through to get
- 44:49something the more you like it. From the standpoint of politics
- 44:53for instance, if you want loyal people in a
- 44:57political campaign, do not pay them.
- 45:00If you pay them, they'll like you less.
- 45:03If they volunteer, they'll like you more.
- 45:07And we'll talk about why. There's different theories
- 45:10about why, but my point right now is simply that people don't
- 45:14necessarily know this but still they're subject to this.
- 45:18Another example is some weird studies done in a discipline of
- 45:23social psychology known as terror management which involves
- 45:28subliminal death primes. The idea of subliminal death
- 45:33primes is this. You sign up for your human
- 45:35subjects requirement and then you--they put you in front of a
- 45:39computer screen and then they tell you,
- 45:41"Oh, just sit in front of the computer screen and then we'll
- 45:44ask you some questions." And then the questions come out
- 45:46and they're questions like, "How much do you love your
- 45:49country?" "What do you think of Asians?"
- 45:52"What do you think of Jews?" "What do you think of blacks?"
- 45:55"What do you think of vegetarians?"
- 45:56"What do you think of people's political views different from
- 45:59yours?" Here's the gimmick.
- 46:01What you don't know is on that computer screen words are being
- 46:06flashed like that but they're being flashed so fast it looks
- 46:12like that--You don't see anything--words like "corpse,"
- 46:17"dead," "dying." The flashing of these
- 46:21subliminal words, "subliminal" meaning – a
- 46:24fancy term meaning below the level of consciousness,
- 46:28you don't know you're seeing them – has dramatic effects on
- 46:31how you answer those questions. People exposed to death primes
- 46:36become more nationalistic, more patriotic,
- 46:41less forgiving of other people, less liking of other races and
- 46:46people from other countries. Again the claim--the
- 46:49explanation for why this is so is something which we'll get to
- 46:53in another class. The point now is simply to
- 46:56illustrate that these sort of things can have--that things you
- 47:00aren't aware of can have an effect on how you think.
- 47:04The final example I'll give of this is a short demonstration.
- 47:09To do this, I'm going to cut the class in half at this point
- 47:13so you'll be on this side of the class,
- 47:15the right side, my right, and this will be on
- 47:20the left side, and I simply want everybody to
- 47:26think about somebody you love. So, think about somebody you
- 47:32love, your girlfriend, your boyfriend,
- 47:34your mom, your dad. Think about somebody you love.
- 47:37Just think. Okay.
- 47:40Now, on this screen is going to be instructions but I want to
- 47:45give the instructions to this half of the class .
- 47:48I'm going to ask everybody in this half of the class please
- 47:51either turn your head or shut your eyes.
- 47:53Okay? Teaching fellows too.
- 47:56Okay. And everybody on this half obey
- 48:02. Okay.
- 48:03Has everybody read that? Okay.
- 48:09Now, turn your head, this group. Now this group:
- 48:17Look at this and take a moment. You don't have to do it on
- 48:26paper but take a moment to do it in your head.
- 48:30You--Each group had instructions.
- 48:31Some people might have seen both instructions.
- 48:33Follow the instructions you got for you.
- 48:39Now, this was research done by Norbert Schwarz and here's the
- 48:45question I want you to ask yourself, "How much do you like
- 48:51this person?" And here's the effect:
- 48:54Half of you were asked to list three features of the person.
- 48:58Half of you were asked to list ten.
- 49:01The finding, which is not a subtle finding,
- 49:03is that liking goes up in the three group and liking goes down
- 49:08in the ten group. And here is why.
- 49:10I have to think about three positive features of somebody so
- 49:18I think about my girlfriend. I have a girlfriend.
- 49:22I think about my girlfriend, "but oh, she's smart,
- 49:24she's beautiful and she's kind. Good.
- 49:27How much do--What do I think of her?
- 49:30"Pretty, good, smart, beautiful,
- 49:32kind, smart, beautiful, oh,
- 49:33yeah." But the problem--;Now,
- 49:35Schwarz is clever though. He says, "List--" The other
- 49:38group gets ten positive features, "smart,
- 49:40beautiful, kind… really nice… good
- 49:45cook… punctual, smart… No,
- 49:51I mentioned that." The problem is nobody has ten
- 49:57positive features! And the effect of being asked
- 50:01to do ten positive features is people find this hard.
- 50:05And then those people, when asked, "How much do you
- 50:08like this person?" say, "Couldn't really make it
- 50:13that ten. I guess I don't like them very
- 50:16much." Now, the point of this
- 50:18illustration, again, is that it shows that
- 50:22you don't know this. Subjects who were asked to do
- 50:25ten positive features and then later ranked the person lower
- 50:29and then asked, "Why did you rank the person
- 50:31lower?" Don't say, "'Cause you told me
- 50:34to list ten." Typically, we are oblivious to
- 50:37these factors that change our points – what we like and what
- 50:41we dislike – and this is, in fact, a substantial and an
- 50:45important part of the study of psychology, and particularly,
- 50:48for instance, the study of racial and sexual
- 50:51prejudice. Where--One of the big findings
- 50:54from social psychology, and we'll devote almost an
- 50:56entire lecture to this, is that people have strong
- 51:00views about other races that they don't know about and that
- 51:05they don't know how to control their actions.
- 51:10So, to some extent, this rounds out Freud because
- 51:14to some extent the particulars of Freud are--for the most part
- 51:20have been rejected. But the general idea of Freud's
- 51:24actually been so successful both in the study of scientific
- 51:28psychology and in our interpretation of everyday life
- 51:32that, to some extent,
- 51:33Freud's been a victim of his own success.
- 51:36We tend to underestimate the importance of Freudian thought
- 51:40in everyday life because he's transformed our world view to
- 51:44such an extent that it's difficult for us to remember if
- 51:48there's any other way to think about it.
- 51:52So, to some extent, he's been the victim of his own
- 51:54success. We have time for some further
- 51:57questions about Freud and about scientific implications of
- 52:00Freud.
- 52:07I took a class once on how to teach when I was a graduate
- 52:10student. And I just remember two things
- 52:12from this class. One thing is never grade in red
- 52:16pen. Those--People don't like that.
- 52:18The second thing is never ask any questions,
- 52:21because presumably it is very frightening to ask,
- 52:23"Any questions?" and people find it's
- 52:25intimidating. I'm supposed to ask,
- 52:28"What are your questions?" So, what are your questions?
- 52:33Yes, in back. Sorry.
- 52:37Student: Did Freud believe in
- 52:39[inaudible] Professor Paul Bloom:
- 52:41Did Freud believe in [inaudible]
- 52:42Student: Medication Professor Paul
- 52:44Bloom: Medication. Freud had an--It's a good
- 52:47question. The question was,
- 52:49"Does--did Freud believe in medication?"
- 52:51Medication, of course, being a major theme of how we
- 52:54deal with certain disorders now, particularly depression and
- 52:57anxiety disorders. On the one hand,
- 52:59Freud made his start as a neuroscientist.
- 53:02Freud studied the mind and the brain and was intensely
- 53:07interested in the neural basis of thought and behavior.
- 53:12But the answer to your question in the end is,
- 53:14"no." Although Freud was very
- 53:16sensitive to the brain basis of behavior, Freud was totally
- 53:19convinced that the method through which to cure disorders
- 53:22like depression and anxiety would not be medication but
- 53:25rather through the sort of talk therapy and insight.
- 53:28Moreover, modern therapists, including some people who
- 53:33aren't psychoanalytically defined, will say,
- 53:37"Look. These drugs are all well and
- 53:40good but what they do is they mask the symptoms."
- 53:43So, if you have panic attacks, say, it's true that drugs might
- 53:47make the panic attacks go away, but the panic attacks are
- 53:51actually not your real problem. And by making them go away you
- 53:54don't get to the root of your problem.
- 53:57So, the answer is both Freud and modern day psychoanalysts
- 54:00would think that medications are substantially overused in the
- 54:03treatment of mental disorders. Yes.
- 54:06Student: Are there any [inaudible]
- 54:09Professor Paul Bloom: The question is,
- 54:12"What about research on dreams?"
- 54:15"Dreams" is such a fun topic that I'm going to devote half a
- 54:19class to sleeping and dreams. So, for instance,
- 54:22I will answer the question "What is the most common dream?"
- 54:25I will also answer the question "Who thinks about sex more in
- 54:28dreams, men or women, and what proportion of--" Oh.
- 54:31There's so many great questions I will answer.
- 54:33Dreams from a Freudian standpoint.
- 54:36There's been some evidence that dreams do, and some often do,
- 54:40have some relationship to what you're thinking about and
- 54:44worrying about through the day. But the strong Freudian view
- 54:48about symbolism and wish fulfillment has not been
- 54:51supported by the study of dreams.
- 54:56What are your other questions? Yes, whoever Erik is pointing
- 55:03to. Professor Paul Bloom:
- 55:04Purple shirt. Yes.
- 55:07Student: [inaudible]--Electra complex?
- 55:09Professor Paul Bloom: The Electra complex?
- 55:11The Electra complex is the penis envy story.
- 55:16Freud developed--This is a crude summary,
- 55:19but Freud developed the Oedipal complex, "Mom,
- 55:23I love Mommy, Dad."
- 55:25And then it's as if somebody reminded him,
- 55:28"Sigmund, there are also women."
- 55:30"Oh, yeah." And that story I told you with
- 55:33the penises and the penis envy and the replacement is sort of a
- 55:37very shortened version of the Electra complex.
- 55:40I think it's fair to say that the Electra complex was a sort
- 55:45of add-on to the main interest of Freud's Oedipal complex.
- 55:50One more, please. Yes.
- 55:54Student: [inaudible]
- 55:58Professor Paul Bloom: According to Freud,
- 56:05the--there's not a fixation in the stage, in the same sense as
- 56:10an oral or anal stage, but yes.
- 56:12The claim that Freud would make is that the woman's discovery
- 56:16that she lacks the penis plays a fundamental role later on
- 56:19determining her allegiances in life and in fact her own sexual
- 56:23preferences and interests. So, it's not the sort of thing
- 56:27that affects her just for a short period.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 3. Foundations: Freud by YaleCourses, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 8,104 words across 944 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.