3 Christians Vs 3 Muslims: Did Jesus Teach The Trinity? — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00These statements of Jesus would be
- 0:02divine claims, which nobody can say cuz
- 0:04it would be shirk.
- 0:05>> Right. Is that a Let me finish, bro.
- 0:07Control yourself. If we can show
- 0:09>> You haven't spoken about a trinity
- 0:10whatsoever. All you did was try to prove
- 0:12Jesus is God. And you didn't do [music]
- 0:13that either.
- 0:14>> Yeah, let's Yeah, let's not play this
- 0:15game, bro.
- 0:16>> The Messiah is a they/them.
- 0:17>> All right, and Allah is a he/they. And
- 0:18Allah he might be a he/she.
- 0:20>> cool.
- 0:20>> Constantly we're going back to this
- 0:21circle. If it agrees with Islam,
- 0:23therefore we can [music] accept it. If
- 0:24it doesn't, we reject it. We find some
- 0:27ad hoc reason to do it.
- 0:28>> The servant is the Messiah, but [music]
- 0:29>> I asked you.
- 0:30>> But he says what he doing.
- 0:31>> I already
- 0:33>> Okay, prove it.
- 0:34>> Oh, well.
- 0:34>> No, okay. Prove it.
- 0:37>> I had to go to the back with my pliers
- 0:39and force that tooth out of your [music]
- 0:41mouth for you to finally say
- 0:45Did the historical Jesus teach the
- 0:48trinity?
- 0:49So, as Muslims, we would be looking at
- 0:51the historical accounts of Jesus, which
- 0:53arguably could be the synoptics and
- 0:55John. And from that, we would say that
- 0:57nowhere in the synoptics and John is
- 0:59there anything where Jesus is teaching
- 1:01any kind of triune
- 1:03doctrine that you guys believe in.
- 1:05>> So, just to be clear, we agree historic
- 1:07Jesus, we're going to go to the gospels
- 1:09and
- 1:10to understand who that was.
- 1:12>> Yeah, just just the Jesus quotation
- 1:14material. We're not granting that
- 1:15necessarily that the disciples actually
- 1:16wrote the gospels.
- 1:17>> That's what's fine. Red letters. Red
- 1:18letters.
- 1:19>> Right. So, we can agree that's where
- 1:20we're going to go. That's right. Sound
- 1:21good to you?
- 1:21>> That sounds excellent.
- 1:23>> excellent. That's what we were hoping.
- 1:24>> Yeah, so
- 1:25>> Uh do
- 1:26>> Yeah, specifically if it could be
- 1:27corroborated through them. So, there are
- 1:28certain aspects like that we're not
- 1:30going to grant as it pertains to the red
- 1:32letter stuff, but we'll get to that when
- 1:34you guys get to those arguments.
- 1:35>> So, would would you agree that Jesus
- 1:36does teach there's one God?
- 1:39>> Of course. It says the Shema, yeah.
- 1:41>> Okay, so then you would also agree that
- 1:43he teaches the Father is God, right?
- 1:46Okay, good. So, so far fine. So, then
- 1:49the question then becomes is teaches
- 1:50there's one God, says the Father is God.
- 1:52Is there a place he teaches that he is
- 1:54God and that the Holy Spirit is God is
- 1:55really what we need to talk about.
- 1:57>> Uh
- 1:58real No, not necessarily because you
- 1:59would also have to show that he's saying
- 2:01that they're co-equal, co-eternal. This
- 2:02is the
- 2:03the doctrine of the Trinity, right? You
- 2:05know, you're not subordinationists,
- 2:06you're not Arians, you're not this,
- 2:08you're not that. You guys hold to
- 2:09co-equal, co-eternal. So, that would be
- 2:11what would be expected within the
- 2:12scripture, right? Which that's what
- 2:14we're arguing is not found.
- 2:16>> Okay. So, let's let's start with it
- 2:17first thing. Does Jesus teach that he is
- 2:19God?
- 2:20>> You You can give your argument, right?
- 2:21And after we can we're one.
- 2:23>> I mean, there are still several places
- 2:25where Jesus demonstrates that he is God.
- 2:27So, for example, uh for in Mark chapter
- 2:312, he says that he is the Lord of the
- 2:32Sabbath, okay? We know from Exodus that
- 2:35Yahweh was the Lord of the Sabbath. So,
- 2:37whoever is Lord of the Sabbath is
- 2:38Yahweh. And that's the earliest
- 2:40possible. In the synoptic material, we
- 2:42have him claiming a divine title called
- 2:44Lord Lord, kyrie kyrie. And as scholars
- 2:46like Robert Bowman Jr. have pointed out,
- 2:47that is a title only attributed to
- 2:49Yahweh in Greek texts from that time or
- 2:51prior throughout the Septuagint, some
- 2:53apocryphal texts. Jesus claims that
- 2:55title for himself. And then, of course,
- 2:56in John, it opens by saying that he is
- 2:58God, and then he affirms that he is
- 2:59places like John 5 where he or
- 3:01John 5 where he has the same abilities
- 3:05that got the Father has, or John 8.
- 3:08Anything you want to add? Do you two
- 3:09want to add?
- 3:10>> Should we Should we break it point by
- 3:11point and start?
- 3:12>> Yeah, maybe places to start. Okay.
- 3:13>> Sure, why not?
- 3:13>> Yeah, I think some just general
- 3:15responses one would be when in Mark 2
- 3:17when Jesus says that he's Lord over
- 3:19Sabbath, the Son of Man is Lord over
- 3:21Sabbath, we just would say historically
- 3:23speaking in the Palestinian first
- 3:25century context, he's referring to the
- 3:26Son of Man just generally refers to
- 3:27humanity because then we see in Mark
- 3:292:23-27,
- 3:31he starts quoting halakhic tradition
- 3:32like in Mark 2:27 when he says that the
- 3:35that even man is made over
- 3:37the Sabbath is made for man, not man
- 3:39made for Sabbath. He's quoting Yoma 85b
- 3:41and other like texts that can be found
- 3:43like Dead Sea Scrolls have the same
- 3:45implied meaning. Next, we see you
- 3:47referenced um
- 3:49the double or the kyrios kyrios in
- 3:51Matthew 7.
- 3:52>> Kyrie kyries, yeah.
- 3:53>> Um we we were
- 3:54>> just say it would say it's a double
- 3:55vocative. It's not actually saying it's
- 3:57Adonai Yahweh. You have to assert that
- 3:58Jesus actually elsewhere claims that
- 4:00he's first divine for that
- 4:01interpretation of that to actually be
- 4:03Adonai Yahweh. Otherwise, we would just
- 4:04say that he's just saying Lord referring
- 4:06to himself as a human Lord twice.
- 4:08>> Okay, so let's start with the Mark
- 4:09thing. So,
- 4:11Mark 2.
- 4:12How does it How does it open? It opens
- 4:13with the story of uh Jesus healing a
- 4:15paralyzed man. Does he identify himself
- 4:17as the son of man in Mark 2?
- 4:19>> Yeah, in Mark 2, he can identify himself
- 4:21as the son of man um
- 4:23in places, but in as a general reference
- 4:25to himself or humanity as a whole.
- 4:28>> Okay, so where does Jesus ever
- 4:29specifically say son of man refers to
- 4:32humanity as a whole?
- 4:33>> So, I'm aware that the gospel authors
- 4:35use the son of man and reinterpret it to
- 4:37explicitly be about Jesus. However,
- 4:39we're arguing from a historical context,
- 4:41and in the historical context in a
- 4:43first-century Palestinian uh or Aramaic
- 4:46language, as we see multiple scholars
- 4:47like April DeConick so and I can talk.
- 4:50>> So, we have to still go to the gospels
- 4:51to understand how they use
- 4:52>> But we're arguing with it from a
- 4:53historical aspect, not how the gospel
- 4:56authors have now uh reinterpreted these
- 4:58sayings.
- 4:58>> How do you know they reinterpret this?
- 5:01>> Uh if we're going to be in reference if
- 5:02we're going to be looking at that, then
- 5:03we'd be looking at like, you know, the
- 5:04gospel source material and and how
- 5:06>> How do you know they reinterpret it?
- 5:07Because everywhere when Jesus talks
- 5:09about the son of man, he's referring to
- 5:10himself. There's no explicit indication
- 5:12where he refers to the son of man as
- 5:14someone distinct from himself. There
- 5:15I'll grant you there are places where
- 5:17it's vague, but there are explicit
- 5:19places where Jesus talks about the son
- 5:21of man where it's clearly himself. Like
- 5:22in Mark 2.
- 5:23>> Right. I I I don't I don't deny that in
- 5:24sometimes that the son of man can be in
- 5:26reference to himself. However, we see
- 5:27that in Mark 2, the most plausible
- 5:30contextual reading would just be that
- 5:31it's written in reference to humans
- 5:32because he then literally starts quoting
- 5:34Jewish midrashic statements talking
- 5:36about how men are made over the Sabbath.
- 5:38So, there's no reason for for him to
- 5:40think that it's specifically Jesus alone
- 5:42when he already tells us in Mark 23 to
- 5:4327 that it's in reference to all
- 5:45humanity.
- 5:45>> So, you said in Mark 2, Jesus does
- 5:47identify himself as the son man. Where
- 5:50in the chapter does he show that that
- 5:52context switches?
- 5:53>> listen. I literally just explained in
- 5:54Mark 23:27, he explains that the the
- 5:58ruling on on men being over Sabbath is
- 6:00general to all of humanity.
- 6:01>> say that. So, he just did. He gave an
- 6:03argument for why that is.
- 6:04>> I already gave an argument.
- 6:05>> So, it doesn't say that man is over the
- 6:06Sabbath. He just says that the Sabbath
- 6:08was created for man to to accommodate
- 6:11them, not that man is over the Sabbath
- 6:12because they man is subject to the
- 6:14Sabbath. They have to have to follow it.
- 6:16But, he does say distinguishing the son
- 6:18of man, he says, "Consequently, the son
- 6:20of man is lord even of the Sabbath."
- 6:24Which, as he pointed out earlier in the
- 6:26context, we see that Jesus explicitly
- 6:27refers to himself as the son of man.
- 6:30Where contextually do you get this idea
- 6:32that Jesus is now changing when he
- 6:34refers to the son of man, and it's it's
- 6:36not himself now, but it's everybody.
- 6:38>> Yeah, so like I said, when he when he's
- 6:40when he's quoting in Mark 27, that even
- 6:42men are or I don't know the exact verb
- 6:44I'm quoting.
- 6:45>> He's quoting um
- 6:46>> I'll read it.
- 6:46>> I'll call it Yeah, if you
- 6:47>> Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's it's right here.
- 6:48It says, um
- 6:50Hmm.
- 6:52And Jesus was saying to them, "The
- 6:54Sabbath was made for man, and not man
- 6:57for the Sabbath." Right? So,
- 6:58consequently, the son of man is lord
- 7:00even of the Sabbath.
- 7:00>> This quotation can also be found
- 7:02verbatim found in Jewish Midrashic
- 7:04statements and texts that predate Jesus
- 7:06like the Dead Sea Scrolls with they have
- 7:07the same quotation and the same
- 7:09theology. And their theology entails
- 7:11that men are over Sabbath as in they
- 7:13they can do certain things like picking
- 7:15grain for emergency if they have to eat.
- 7:17Um and so that's why and like I said, in
- 7:18the historical context of the
- 7:20first-century Palestinian Aramaic
- 7:22speaker, son of man, bar enash, can also
- 7:24just mean humanity. So, we have no
- 7:26reason to explicitly be taking this as
- 7:29only Jesus. And that's the problem that
- 7:31we're having here because remember, we
- 7:32talked about the historical Jesus and
- 7:34you guys appealed to the Synoptic
- 7:36Gospels and John. And so when
- 7:37>> But, we don't know the authors though.
- 7:39So, we're very specific there. We're not
- 7:41saying
- 7:41>> You said the Synoptic Gospels.
- 7:42>> No, no, no, no. Yeah, in so far as the
- 7:44red letters it was in part red letters.
- 7:46>> That's my point, sir, but
- 7:47>> From a historical aspect or is it all
- 7:49better from a historical aspect?
- 7:50>> Red letters in the synoptic gospels, you
- 7:52have Mark 2 where Jesus in context
- 7:55refers to himself as the son of man and
- 7:58continues the conversation. So, you you
- 8:01said that you have no reason to think or
- 8:03to conclude that Jesus is referring to
- 8:05himself alone as the son of man being
- 8:08Lord of the Sabbath, which you do
- 8:09contextually that's what he's talking
- 8:10about.
- 8:10>> So, I want to be very clear. When we're
- 8:12saying that we're granting the gospel
- 8:13material, we're talking about the Jesus
- 8:15material from a historical aspect.
- 8:16That's why I made it very clear. We're
- 8:17not saying that the disciples actually
- 8:19wrote the gospels because we're viewing
- 8:21the gospels from a historical
- 8:23standpoint. And if we're viewing it from
- 8:25a historical standpoint, then the
- 8:26argument would show that the son of man
- 8:28here is not in reference to Jesus alone,
- 8:30especially because historically speaking
- 8:31the earliest gospel material never had
- 8:33son of man or reference.
- 8:34>> Do you agree
- 8:35Do you agree that the Gospel of Mark
- 8:37identifies Jesus as the son of man?
- 8:39>> Yeah, I we already We never We never
- 8:41argue anything about what the authors of
- 8:44the text view. I don't I I don't even
- 8:46care what the author of Mark that views
- 8:47Jesus as cuz that's not anything to do
- 8:49with the discussion of
- 8:50>> Do you agree Do you agree the author of
- 8:52Mark 2 has Jesus
- 8:53>> nothing to do with It has nothing to do.
- 8:54>> Listen Listen to what he's saying. Do
- 8:55you agree that Mark 2 in the whole
- 8:57chapter
- 8:58Jesus explicitly identifies himself in
- 9:01the son of man when he's healing the
- 9:02paralyzed man?
- 9:03>> I'm saying on topic.
- 9:04>> That's not a very relevant point.
- 9:05>> No, it's not cuz that's the whole point
- 9:07is that we're talking about the historic
- 9:08Jesus, not the interpretation of the
- 9:10historic Jesus as it pertains to Mark
- 9:12not to the ancient church.
- 9:14>> How do you How do you know who the
- 9:15global Jesus is?
- 9:16>> Just before we continue, you already
- 9:17agreed that fine, we'll go with the red
- 9:20letters.
- 9:20>> Red red letters.
- 9:21>> That's what you We We agreed.
- 9:22>> He's asking a quick
- 9:24>> You you said you said we'll go to that.
- 9:25And then he clarified there's going to
- 9:26be in in in reference to the historical
- 9:29things that can be predated back to
- 9:30Christ, right? So, when you reference
- 9:32back the synoptics in general and you
- 9:33say here what what what do we need to
- 9:35know about Christ? He's sort of like
- 9:36pedaling back onto that standard.
- 9:38>> No, I'm going on what Jesus explicitly
- 9:40said about himself, which you agree. If
- 9:42you don't think he actually identified
- 9:44himself as the son of man, why are you
- 9:45appealing to Mark where Jesus identifies
- 9:47himself as the son of man in there?
- 9:48>> We we're not appealing to that. You guys
- 9:49brought it up.
- 9:51>> I'm I'm okay. Yeah, so I'm I'm lost. So,
- 9:53we we go back to the back back to the
- 9:55question. Yeah. Where do we get the
- 9:56historical Jesus from?
- 9:59>> Yeah, right.
- 10:00>> Yeah, we can get
- 10:01uh relevant data from the Bible over the
- 10:03historical Jesus, but there's also other
- 10:05gospel material that that's going to
- 10:06have it as well. Like I know I know IP
- 10:08is familiar with the canonical Gospel of
- 10:09Thomas also having Q quotes and the
- 10:11consensus of scholarship in
- 10:12>> Wait a second century best.
- 10:14>> Well, the consensus of scholarship holds
- 10:15that it has uh pre-synoptic independent
- 10:17material from the synoptics. So, it's
- 10:19not dependent on the synoptics. So, even
- 10:21if it even if we said that the Gospel of
- 10:23Thomas every part of it was made in the
- 10:26second century, boo hoo, because it's
- 10:28still independent of the synoptics. This
- 10:29is irrelevant to the main subject.
- 10:31That has absolutely
- 10:32He's
- 10:33asking
- 10:34He's asking us where do we get our
- 10:35historical information of Jesus?
- 10:37>> Yes.
- 10:37>> I just told you the Gospel of Thomas has
- 10:39historical information of Jesus and it's
- 10:41independent of the Gospels. So, Gospel
- 10:43Your four canonical Gospel of Jesus I
- 10:45don't even need to go to the four
- 10:46canonical Gospels to look at any of
- 10:47them.
- 10:47>> Is Gospel of Thomas a correct
- 10:49>> It doesn't exist. It's not a Is it a
- 10:50thing to rely on?
- 10:51>> No, that yeah, exactly. What we're
- 10:52talking
- 10:52>> Not a thing that you rely on, is it?
- 10:54>> Yeah, so it's qualified.
- 10:56>> Cuz the Gospel of Thomas where we can
- 10:58get our true
- 10:58>> It has relevant historical
- 11:00>> So, does it Does it give Does it have
- 11:01super
- 11:01>> I don't know why you keep going with
- 11:02this.
- 11:03>> Let me tell you something.
- 11:03>> I'm not getting a clear answer.
- 11:05>> Give us your I got you. Yeah, so
- 11:06>> Hold on, guys. Did you know that over
- 11:0880% of people that watch these videos
- 11:11are not subscribed? And that's the best
- 11:13way to support this channel. So, let's
- 11:16give the audience a second to subscribe.
- 11:19And if they want to financially support
- 11:21us, they could become a member.
- 11:23All right. Now, let's get back to the
- 11:26discussion.
- 11:26>> Does the Gospel of Thomas give us
- 11:28correct historical information of Jesus?
- 11:30>> it's not going to be a yes or no. That
- 11:32will be a false dichotomy. It will be
- 11:33qualified. Meaning, for example, Gospel
- 11:35of John. Gospel of John has some that
- 11:37can be corroborated. Doesn't mean that
- 11:39the entire Gospel is not true? No,
- 11:41right? So, what that means is that if
- 11:42it's if it is corroborated, we can refer
- 11:44it back to it, right? If it's not
- 11:45qualified, if it can't be corroborated,
- 11:47then we can reject it.
- 11:49>> Good. For example, for example, if I
- 11:50could just add on to his point, when the
- 11:51Quran says that Jesus was born of a of a
- 11:53virgin, and that's true, it doesn't now,
- 11:55according to you, mean that everything
- 11:57in the Quran is now true because
- 11:58something that's true.
- 11:59>> I want to use a phrase you guys love to
- 12:00use. Now, we need a symmetry breaker
- 12:02here. So, how do we know what is the
- 12:05good historical information in the
- 12:06Gospel of Thomas, and what isn't?
- 12:09>> Uh well, the material that it that
- 12:10parallels with Q.
- 12:12>> Okay, so now Q is the authority on who
- 12:14this is. So, is Q the author- the
- 12:16hypothetical Q that we have no documents
- 12:18for that some scholars have sort of put
- 12:19together what they think it is. That is
- 12:21now the authority on who this is.
- 12:22>> Even if we granted your understanding of
- 12:24it being a hypothetical document that we
- 12:25can't just actually
- 12:27obtain and and get a holistic view of
- 12:29it, that you would still be appealing
- 12:30that Matthew uses source material
- 12:32outside of Mark that's as old as Mark.
- 12:35>> I'm I'm I'm fine with Let's just move
- 12:36with it. So,
- 12:37>> So, we're clearly we're appealing to the
- 12:38historical source materials that the
- 12:39Gospel authors are using.
- 12:41>> So, if we go through Mark, and we go,
- 12:42"Okay, well, Jesus clearly came to be
- 12:43the son of man." How do we know he
- 12:45actually said that? What is What is the
- 12:48actual foundation, the authority we can
- 12:50use to determine who the historical
- 12:52Jesus was so we can know what he taught?
- 12:54>> Uh if you're asking specifically from
- 12:56our perspective and not just the
- 12:58argument at hand cuz if the argument at
- 12:59hand isn't from our actual perspective,
- 13:01we're just giving an argument. But from
- 13:03our actual perspective, you're asking us
- 13:05what is the historical Jesus material we
- 13:07would get? It's that the source material
- 13:08that the Gospel authors used, the
- 13:10synoptics, which we can get based upon
- 13:12the fact that we know that they're
- 13:13anonymous independent works, and they
- 13:14use they independently both use the same
- 13:17source material. They use Mark as a
- 13:18medial, and they have a secondary source
- 13:20material that they have a literary
- 13:21dependence on, which we know based upon
- 13:23their literary details, the the way that
- 13:25they they're quoting it.
- 13:25>> It's weird.
- 13:26>> I'll go first. I'll go first.
- 13:27>> Thank you. Well, well, there's no I'm
- 13:28I'm building up what he's saying is is
- 13:30correct. But to render it down to the
- 13:32simplest point is going to be the
- 13:34historical critical method, aka that
- 13:36which can be corroborated, earlier
- 13:37tested to, right? That which has we can
- 13:40apply the criteria of the similarity
- 13:41which I believe you should be you should
- 13:42be familiar with. If all these criteria
- 13:44can be implemented upon a text, right?
- 13:46Then we can determine that text to be
- 13:47reliable.
- 13:48>> Okay. So,
- 13:49what is the source that we can go to
- 13:52to get the accurate historical
- 13:54information about Jesus so we can know
- 13:55what he said and actually start this
- 13:56conversation.
- 13:57>> Is your question more of like one
- 13:59specific folks that will
- 14:00>> Well, no, cuz we use four.
- 14:02>> No, I mean we use Matthew, Mark, Luke,
- 14:03and John.
- 14:04Saying no, no, no and they're using
- 14:06Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, right?
- 14:07What are you guys using?
- 14:08>> Yeah, we're we're using the relevant
- 14:10historical data.
- 14:11Yeah, literally any source that could be
- 14:13corroborated as it pertains to
- 14:14>> Just name one.
- 14:16>> Let me Let me explain to you something.
- 14:17>> So, you guys are working off of Q.
- 14:19>> Yeah.
- 14:19>> Okay.
- 14:20>> [laughter]
- 14:21>> I I'm by the way
- 14:23we can go on to Mark, Matthew, Luke, and
- 14:24John but issue. But it's not going to be
- 14:25unqualified.
- 14:26>> Okay, so we can get where Q is going to
- 14:28where we get the the Q that was Q,
- 14:29teachings of Jesus. Can we do that? Can
- 14:31we start there?
- 14:31>> No, no, but real quick before we move on
- 14:32to that I have no such thing as Mark,
- 14:33too. There's no such thing as that,
- 14:35right? We can adjust that.
- 14:35>> What?
- 14:36>> Um specifically regarding Mark, Matthew,
- 14:39Luke, and John they can't contain
- 14:40historical information, right? And you
- 14:41would agree for example,
- 14:43um I don't know if you would but there
- 14:44would be some aspect of John for example
- 14:46that wouldn't be reliable, right? Right?
- 14:48>> I wouldn't agree with that. I still
- 14:49>> Okay, that's fine but that's reliable
- 14:51gospel. That's That's That's what the
- 14:52scholarship says, right? But the point
- 14:53is we we can go ahead and just Mark,
- 14:55too. Um no no issue with that, right?
- 14:57So, someone bearing the name Yahweh,
- 14:59right? Does that make them Yahweh?
- 15:00>> Yeah, it means that they are.
- 15:01>> Yes. Okay, so in every
- 15:03>> No, no one No one has the name Yahweh
- 15:04except Yahweh alone. That's in Nehemiah
- 15:069:6.
- 15:07>> Okay, so when it comes to Exodus, when
- 15:09it comes to
- 15:10other prophets, when when it says that
- 15:12Yahweh would do something and the
- 15:14prophets do that thing, right? Does that
- 15:15make him Yahweh?
- 15:16>> That's agency.
- 15:17>> Okay, so what is the distinction in in
- 15:18Christ being an agent of the Father?
- 15:20>> Because very good. Cuz Christ isn't just
- 15:22an agent of the father, but he claims
- 15:24himself to be Yahweh himself.
- 15:26>> very kind question. You finish.
- 15:28>> I know. I know, but you asked me, all
- 15:29right?
- 15:29>> So
- 15:29>> We we can discuss that. But I'm giving
- 15:31you the difference between an agent and
- 15:33Jesus, right? So an agent cannot claim
- 15:36to be Yahweh himself, cannot claim the
- 15:38prerogatives of Yahweh, but Jesus does.
- 15:41>> That's the symmetry breaker.
- 15:42>> So you'll never see like for example
- 15:44Aaron when you know the example where
- 15:46Aaron takes the staff and when he always
- 15:48says I'll do it, Aaron does it. You'll
- 15:50never see Aaron say I'm Yahweh or claim
- 15:52to be Yahweh or you know whatever. Jesus
- 15:54does.
- 15:55>> Well, yeah, I mean they're they're
- 15:57familiar with it clearly. Obviously they
- 15:58know that whenever the verse is being
- 16:00quoted it says that Yahweh is literally
- 16:01the one who's holding the rod in his
- 16:03hand, but obviously it's Aaron the one
- 16:04who's holding the rod in his hand. So we
- 16:06would just say that's divine
- 16:07>> agency agency, yeah.
- 16:08>> Yeah. But but back to what CMA was
- 16:10saying you would have to obviously show
- 16:12first that that Jesus actually does
- 16:13claim any kind of divinity for then for
- 16:16then to be a differential.
- 16:17>> Of course. So you guys you do agree that
- 16:19that is a symmetry breaker, though,
- 16:20right?
- 16:20>> No. Because for example we like when you
- 16:22say divine prerogatives you mean divine
- 16:24properties?
- 16:25>> Yes of God. So like um the you know
- 16:27being all powerful, all knowing, um
- 16:30judge of heaven and earth.
- 16:32>> So all right.
- 16:32>> Resurrecting the dead, first and last.
- 16:35>> So when when when it comes to knowing
- 16:36all things, would you give that as a
- 16:37divine prerogative, right?
- 16:38>> Yes. And so that's what I'm asking like
- 16:40if if Jesus is claiming to have the
- 16:42divine attributes and prerogatives of
- 16:43God like the the things only God does.
- 16:46Um the claims that only God can make.
- 16:48Would you agree that that would be a
- 16:49symmetry breaker between an agent of
- 16:51Yahweh and Yahweh himself?
- 16:52>> No, because we see other we see other
- 16:54instances where others other than
- 16:56Yahweh, other than Jesus, right? Would
- 16:58uh quote unquote be picked up with these
- 16:59prerogatives. For example first John
- 17:002:20 said that disciples know all
- 17:02things.
- 17:03>> No.
- 17:03>> It says that.
- 17:04>> No, that's qualified.
- 17:05>> Okay. Let's let's bring it out.
- 17:06>> That's qualified, yep. So
- 17:08what we're trying to say is that if
- 17:09Jesus claims to be Yahweh, okay? That
- 17:12could only mean he is either lying,
- 17:14ignorant, or he is actually Yahweh.
- 17:17>> Or there's a fourth option. That
- 17:21Jewish monotheism is in the first
- 17:23century,
- 17:24the legal status, the status of a sender
- 17:26is the same as a an agent.
- 17:27>> But the sender, the agent agent the the
- 17:31can never claim to be the king as he
- 17:33knows. He can never claim to be Yahweh.
- 17:35>> He has the same exact status of it. For
- 17:37example, in in Jewish
- 17:39I'm quoting you actual reference. This
- 17:41is found in like Nedarim 72b. This is
- 17:43These are midrashic
- 17:44>> I don't care about that.
- 17:47>> The thing is we're I'm saying there's a
- 17:48fourth option you could say from Jewish
- 17:50monotheism that's agency still because
- 17:53Jewish monotheism allows this.
- 17:55Which I would If I can just finish, you
- 17:57guys.
- 17:58We can find this example in 1 Samuel 25
- 18:01when David wants to go marry Abigail and
- 18:04so he sends his servants and then the
- 18:05servants go to Abigail and Abigail
- 18:07prostrates and speaks in the singular in
- 18:09the Hebrew as if you're speaking to
- 18:10David but you're speaking to the
- 18:12servants because the servants have been
- 18:14sent by David so they have the exact
- 18:16same status as David while not actually
- 18:18being him.
- 18:19>> Do the servants claim to be David?
- 18:20>> It doesn't
- 18:22Do the servants claim to be David?
- 18:23>> They are called David.
- 18:25Do the servants claim claim to
- 18:26>> Not in this instance but it was exactly
- 18:27>> Exactly. If they did, what would happen
- 18:28to them?
- 18:29>> Nothing. Why are we skipping over this?
- 18:30>> If the servants claimed Wait, sorry. If
- 18:33the servants claimed to be the king, you
- 18:35said nothing would happen to them?
- 18:35>> No.
- 18:36>> That That's That's called What was it
- 18:38called?
- 18:39Treason. Treason. There you go. That's
- 18:41treason, dude. You can't Your servant
- 18:43cannot claim to be a king. You'll be put
- 18:44to death.
- 18:45>> Only in the sense of of his status.
- 18:47>> So we see there there's You don't You're
- 18:49bringing up examples where people
- 18:51represent the king but they are not the
- 18:53king themself. They cannot claim to be
- 18:54the king themself. So this is we're not
- 18:57we're not When it comes to Jesus, Jesus
- 19:00is not claiming to just be a servant of
- 19:02the Father. He claims to be God. He
- 19:05claims to have the divine prerogatives
- 19:06that only God has, the titles that only
- 19:08God has, actions that only God has. So
- 19:11would you agree that this is a symmetry
- 19:14breaker between a mere agent so you so
- 19:17an agent can claim to be God?
- 19:19>> I'm giving the example that he should
- 19:20even first time you're right where she
- 19:22calls
- 19:23the
- 19:24the people the servants he says my
- 19:26servant. So she identifies them as
- 19:28David. She says that that David although
- 19:30David isn't actually present. Okay, so
- 19:32that's number one.
- 19:32>> Can you bring up the reference to that?
- 19:34>> Yeah, I was going to say
- 19:34>> First Samuel 25:39 to 41.
- 19:36>> Let's let's read that and what's your
- 19:38point in this?
- 19:38>> Uh and then the point is that she calls
- 19:41them David although David isn't present.
- 19:42So they they battling David they
- 19:44identified as David although David isn't
- 19:46there.
- 19:46>> Yeah, can you Okay, so there's two
- 19:48different things here. Number one
- 19:49>> read it?
- 19:50>> Yeah, yeah, go ahead and read it.
- 19:51>> Okay, and so then David sent word to
- 19:53Abigail.
- 19:54>> Sorry, sorry, let me let me let me go
- 19:55along with you.
- 19:56>> Yeah.
- 19:57>> Hey, quick break from the conversation.
- 19:58I want to give a big shout-out to Logos.
- 20:01So Logos is an app that helps people
- 20:04study the Bible. They also have courses,
- 20:06books, all types of materials that can
- 20:09help you learn and get deeper in your
- 20:12faith. So Logos is offering everyone
- 20:16that subscribes to this channel a free
- 20:1860-day subscription. So all you need to
- 20:21do whether you're Catholic, Orthodox, or
- 20:23Protestant go to the link in the
- 20:25description of this video, sign up for
- 20:28Logos for 60 days it's 100% free. You
- 20:31can learn the Bible way better than
- 20:34watching YouTube videos. It can even
- 20:36help you break down the words that you
- 20:38see in your Bible all the way back to
- 20:40the original Greek. So again, if you
- 20:42want to support this page or you just
- 20:44want to learn and get deeper with your
- 20:46faith, go sign up for Logos and now
- 20:49let's get back to the episode.
- 20:51>> Then David sent sent word to Abigail
- 20:53asking her to become his wife. His
- 20:54servants went took a camel and said to
- 20:57Abigail, David has sent us to take you
- 20:59to become his wife. She bowed down with
- 21:02her face to the ground and said, I am
- 21:03your servant and I'm ready to serve you
- 21:06and wash the feet of my lord's servants,
- 21:08right? So she identifies the people as
- 21:10the servants.
- 21:10>> Well, well, I'm I'm confused. Hold on,
- 21:11let me see. So
- 21:13the servants then the servants of David
- 21:15came to Abigail at Carmel and spoke to
- 21:17her saying, "David has sent us to you to
- 21:20take you as his wife." And she arose and
- 21:23bowed with her face to the ground and
- 21:24said, "Behold, your maidservant is a
- 21:27servant woman to wash the feet of my
- 21:30lord's servants." Then Abigail hurried
- 21:33and arose and she rode on a donkey with
- 21:36her five young women who went about with
- 21:39with her and she sent and she went after
- 21:42the messengers of David and became his
- 21:44wife. Where Where does it say that she
- 21:46called him David?
- 21:47>> On the knees. It said she said she bowed
- 21:49down with her face to the ground and
- 21:51said, "I am your servant."
- 21:53>> Uh-huh.
- 21:53>> So they addressed the people as a
- 21:54singular servant, which is David.
- 21:56>> Well, no, where does it say No, see
- 21:58this is why we got to read, bro. You
- 22:00just You You said that she called them
- 22:02David.
- 22:03>> No, I said Who's the servant to this
- 22:05>> The The servants are the messengers that
- 22:07David sent and she's the and she's their
- 22:09servant.
- 22:10>> Wait, servant with a with a singular.
- 22:12Who's the servant?
- 22:13>> It says this.
- 22:13>> What it represents?
- 22:14>> Look, this is what it says. She says,
- 22:16uh it says,
- 22:17"David sent us ya ya ya." Let's go to
- 22:19where she said, "Behold, she says,
- 22:21"Behold, your maidservant."
- 22:24Servant is singular. She's the servant.
- 22:26>> Yeah, to who?
- 22:27>> To the servants of of David.
- 22:29>> But you is a singular. It's not a It's
- 22:30not a plural.
- 22:31>> So the you So the you is in reference to
- 22:33only David. No, it's not. Let me Let me
- 22:35go ahead and respond to this because in
- 22:36Exodus 20 in Exodus 20 when it says,
- 22:39"You shall have no other gods before
- 22:40you." That you is in the singular, but
- 22:42it's referring to the nation of Israel,
- 22:44correct?
- 22:44>> Yeah, that's just because Israel can be
- 22:46referred to as a one. Yeah.
- 22:47>> So So So you can have you can have the
- 22:50servants be referred to as one even
- 22:52though it's referring to a plurality of
- 22:53persons.
- 22:54>> But the thing is you see a difference.
- 22:55You see because
- 22:56after the thing is when they're speaking
- 22:58on the behalf of David, Abigail refers
- 23:00to them as one, but then after that then
- 23:02refers to them as plural servants. So So
- 23:05while accepting they're multiple people
- 23:07whenever they're speaking on the behalf
- 23:08of David, she only calls them one
- 23:10person. Now whenever she's speaking or
- 23:12when she's speaking to warming
- 23:13>> Yes, that's why they use that's why they
- 23:15use a singular in the Hebrew.
- 23:16>> I just gave you Okay, so then but then
- 23:18all of a sudden then it goes to plural
- 23:19when she's when they're not acting on
- 23:21the behalf of David.
- 23:22>> And we're going to use this argument,
- 23:23then you're going to have to say then
- 23:25when Yahweh is told Israel, "You should
- 23:27have no other gods before me." That you
- 23:29there in Hebrew is in the masculine
- 23:30singular. So
- 23:33but it's
- 23:34Right, right, that's my point. So is so
- 23:36is Exodus 20. Is that the the you is
- 23:39singular when God is talking to the
- 23:40nation of that has a plurality of
- 23:43individuals. So just because the you
- 23:45will be singular and we have to check
- 23:46this, but even if the you is in the
- 23:48singular form
- 23:50>> Wait a minute, the servant the word for
- 23:51servants
- 23:55So even if the you is in the singular
- 23:57there, it can refer to a a community or
- 24:00a a a plurality a corporate entity. So
- 24:02the servants on David's behalf will be a
- 24:04corporate entity. They can she can use
- 24:06the you there singularly. That she
- 24:08nowhere here does it say that she's
- 24:09calling
- 24:10>> It's not about the you. It's about the
- 24:11fact that it's
- 24:12Yeah, it's about that and it says
- 24:13servant.
- 24:14>> She No, she
- 24:16Look, brother.
- 24:17But see it Hold on. Yes.
- 24:19If she's the servant it says behold your
- 24:21maid servants.
- 24:23Your maid servant is a
- 24:24>> I am your servant.
- 24:26>> Yes.
- 24:28>> Who's your servant, too?
- 24:29>> To To the servants of David.
- 24:31>> And it represents David, right?
- 24:33>> So So they're representing
- 24:34>> Right, they represent David.
- 24:35>> They represent
- 24:35>> Technically David.
- 24:37>> So
- 24:38So can we agree here that she does not
- 24:40refer to the servants of David?
- 24:42>> It does. He said he is.
- 24:43>> No, I didn't.
- 24:44>> No, you said yes.
- 24:45>> I'll I'll explain it.
- 24:46>> You just said yes to the servants of
- 24:47David.
- 24:47>> No, he didn't.
- 24:48>> When the servants are speaking on the
- 24:50behalf of David, she refers to them as a
- 24:52singular because she's referring to
- 24:53David because in Jewish monotheism which
- 24:56you have first century Jewish
- 24:57attestation, the legal status of a
- 25:00sender is this or of the of the sender
- 25:02is the same as an agent. So, the reason
- 25:04why is that it is is in the reference to
- 25:06>> This is like not
- 25:07>> Yeah, but I'm saying we have first
- 25:08century Jewish attestation. So, I'm
- 25:10saying it in in comparison with the
- 25:11historical argument on how we would
- 25:13compare this with Jesus, we would look
- 25:14at it in for a first century Jewish lens
- 25:16that Jesus is just
- 25:18an agent because he has the same legal
- 25:20authority as Yahweh while not actually
- 25:22being Yahweh.
- 25:22>> Can we go back to the point though? Does
- 25:24>> servant claim to be the king or David?
- 25:28>> It's simple.
- 25:28>> No, they don't but they don't need to.
- 25:30>> Yeah, no no.
- 25:31>> They don't need to. Because here's the
- 25:32symmetry breaker. The symmetry breaker
- 25:34is Jesus does. And so, if Let me ask you
- 25:36>> Okay, but now what you're doing is
- 25:37you're just
- 25:38>> Hold on. Hold on. If an agent claimed to
- 25:41be like let's say for these servants, if
- 25:43they claimed to be the king, would they
- 25:45be wrong?
- 25:46>> Yeah, they would not be wrong because
- 25:47the same way where where Moses claims to
- 25:49be Elohim, doesn't mean he's literally
- 25:51Elohim.
- 25:51>> Where does Moses claim to be Elohim?
- 25:52>> Where when when he's made Elohim to
- 25:54>> Does Moses claim that?
- 25:55>> Well,
- 25:56he's not the author he's not the author
- 25:57of Exodus.
- 25:58>> Brother, is Moses the one saying I am
- 26:00Elohim?
- 26:00>> Well, who's doing Exodus? Who's speaking
- 26:02the
- 26:02>> Who's the who's he quoting?
- 26:04>> Who's he speaking?
- 26:04>> Who's he quoting?
- 26:06>> Who's he Why you asking so many
- 26:07questions?
- 26:07>> No, I'm the one who asked the question.
- 26:08>> I gave you a question.
- 26:09>> I know cuz you asked the question with a
- 26:11question. Don't tell me that
- 26:12>> I've been asking the question.
- 26:13>> Okay, so I asked is I asked did Moses
- 26:17claim to be Elohim? Did he claim that
- 26:19himself? And the answer is
- 26:21>> Right, he's the author of the
- 26:22Pentateuch.
- 26:22>> And who's he quoting in the
- 26:24in the Pentateuch?
- 26:25>> Sorry, he's quoting God while
- 26:26>> So, he himself is not claiming to be
- 26:27Elohim. He's saying this is what God
- 26:29said and
- 26:29>> If you're going to use those kind of
- 26:30arguments, it's going to be the exact
- 26:32same sense with any time Jesus is
- 26:33speaking, it's actually a revelation
- 26:34from God that he's only speaking because
- 26:36God told him to speak because he has no
- 26:37will of his own. So, if you're trying to
- 26:39use that kind of argument
- 26:40>> Aaron, this is bad because I'm not
- 26:41talking No, this is what this is what
- 26:42I'm saying, okay? Cuz you have where
- 26:44Moses talks and you have where Moses
- 26:46quotes Yahweh, right?
- 26:48>> Right.
- 26:49>> Yes.
- 26:49>> You have peaks in Exodus.
- 26:50>> You have Jesus where Jesus speaks. You
- 26:52have Jesus where he quotes the Father.
- 26:54And we actually see when the Father
- 26:56speaks back to the Son, right? So, I'm
- 26:59we know when a person is speaking,
- 27:00context will tell us, "Yada yada yada."
- 27:02My point is is that never ever do you
- 27:05see an agent of Yahweh claim to be
- 27:08Yahweh.
- 27:09You'll never see that. It's so with
- 27:11Jesus with Jesus, he's not just merely
- 27:14an agent, which is why this conversation
- 27:16we're having. He's not just an agent. He
- 27:18claims to be Yahweh. He claims to be
- 27:20God. And that's where we need to get to.
- 27:22>> So, and we would just be saying that
- 27:24that's okay because as an agent, he has
- 27:26the same status as the sender and his
- 27:28sender is Yahweh. But he makes it very
- 27:30clear throughout the gospels that he
- 27:32doesn't do anything on his own accord.
- 27:33He has things given to him. He seeks
- 27:35someone else's will. These are all
- 27:37things that you would suspect and expect
- 27:39in
- 27:40Jewish agency, but you wouldn't say
- 27:46Exactly because we're having historicity
- 27:49and we're making an
- 27:50>> Oh, the point from a historical
- 27:51standpoint, first-century Jewish
- 27:53monotheism is completely compatible with
- 27:56these texts.
- 27:56>> I disagree
- 27:58because according to first-century
- 27:59Judaism, first of all, when you even
- 28:01talk to they they don't even know who
- 28:03the angel of the Lord is. They don't
- 28:05they
- 28:06Depending on which Jews you're asking
- 28:07about, the angel of the Lord is a
- 28:09problem. He's a problem because the
- 28:12angel of the Lord doesn't claim to be an
- 28:13agent of Yahweh. He claims to be Yahweh
- 28:15himself. He says, "I am the God of your
- 28:17fathers, the God of Abraham, Isaac, and
- 28:19Jacob." He says, "I'm the one I'm the
- 28:21one who makes the covenant with you." He
- 28:22says you to Abraham, "You did not
- 28:24withhold your son from me."
- 28:26Right? So, Yahweh So, Yahweh continues,
- 28:30the angel of the Lord continues to claim
- 28:31to be Yahweh while with agents, you'll
- 28:33see Gabriel says, "This is what Yahweh
- 28:35said. I'm a messenger from Yahweh."
- 28:37You'll see Abra-
- 28:38Moses and Aaron and all the other
- 28:41prophets, "Thus says Yahweh." You don't
- 28:43see that with the angel of the Lord.
- 28:45>> I bring you up on that because you said
- 28:46both the the title and the divine
- 28:48prerogatives. You said that one 1 John
- 28:502:20 was qualified.
- 28:52Where where was that qualified exactly?
- 28:53Because it says here
- 28:54It says
- 28:56uh and have you an anointed from the
- 28:58holy one and know all things.
- 29:01>> You said uh 1 John what?
- 29:02>> 2:20
- 29:02>> 2:20 Yeah, 2.
- 29:03>> Okay.
- 29:07All right, watch this.
- 29:08>> [clears throat]
- 29:09>> Verse 18.
- 29:11Children, it is the last It is the last
- 29:13hour and just as you heard that
- 29:15Antichrist is coming.
- 29:17Even now many Antichrist have appeared.
- 29:19From this we know that it is the last
- 29:22hour. So, what is the know knowledge of?
- 29:24The signs of the last hour.
- 29:25>> Again
- 29:26>> So
- 29:26>> Let me finish up. Yeah.
- 29:28>> They went out from us, but they were not
- 29:30really of us. For if they were of us,
- 29:33they would have remained with us, but
- 29:35they went out so that it would be
- 29:36manifested that they all are not of us.
- 29:40But you have an anointing from the holy
- 29:41one and you all know. Well, in your
- 29:44version it says you
- 29:45>> know all things.
- 29:45>> All things, right? So, what is the
- 29:46qualification? Because I even if I'm
- 29:48going with your rendition of the verse,
- 29:49the qualification is the knowledge of
- 29:51the of the signs of the last hour and
- 29:53the Antichrist and the false believers.
- 29:56Okay, that's it. It's qualified.
- 29:57>> I I understand that it mentioned that
- 29:58prior. Okay, but just because it
- 30:00mentioned that prior doesn't mean that
- 30:01it must now disqualify that entire So,
- 30:03you would say that the disciples now
- 30:04know all things in a sense? Can you say
- 30:05that?
- 30:05>> Sure, in in the context of them knowing
- 30:07all the
- 30:08regard regarding the last hour.
- 30:10Regarding the last hour, the signs of
- 30:11the hour, the Antichrist, the
- 30:13disbelievers that's going out from them.
- 30:15That's That's in the sense of
- 30:16>> So, what what when of course Christ
- 30:18knowing all things
- 30:20uh uh for example in John 16 and it's
- 30:22the context of revelation about what's
- 30:23to come give it uh and the Holy Spirit.
- 30:25Would you say that this means that now
- 30:26Christ doesn't actually know everything
- 30:28and it doesn't mean that
- 30:29>> Please show me where it qualifies it.
- 30:31>> Yeah, in John 16 uh let me pull up the
- 30:33verse. 16:14 I believe. It says all that
- 30:36belongs to the Father's mind. That That
- 30:37is why I said the Spirit will receive
- 30:38from me what he will make known to you.
- 30:41>> You hear that? So, all that the Father
- 30:43has Real quick. And and it says
- 30:46and it says that that which I received
- 30:48that will be the Holy Spirit will now
- 30:50tell you. And what is the what is it the
- 30:51Holy Spirit teaching us?
- 30:52>> So notice. So the Holy Spirit gives them
- 30:54revelation, gives them guidance. So
- 30:55beautiful.
- 30:56>> Right.
- 30:56>> Beautiful.
- 30:57>> So what is qualified?
- 30:58>> Well well well this is what he this is
- 30:59what we're saying here. With Jesus he
- 31:01says all things that the Father has
- 31:03mine.
- 31:04>> Does the son beget?
- 31:06Does the son beget?
- 31:06>> No. Focus. That's not what we're talking
- 31:08about. I was just
- 31:11His point His point is that if it's so
- 31:13restricted all, okay, if it's an
- 31:15unrestricted all, then it's the case
- 31:17that you're saying everything that the
- 31:18Father possesses the Son also possesses.
- 31:20Is that the case?
- 31:21>> Yeah. Everything that the Father Let me
- 31:23let me go ahead and answer you in full.
- 31:24Everything that the Father has are but
- 31:27they belong to Jesus. What is this
- 31:28talking about? This is talking about
- 31:30this This is talking about every This is
- 31:32talking about everything, right, in
- 31:34regards to creation, in regards to
- 31:36sustaining the universe.
- 31:38This is everything that the Father has
- 31:40is is his. This is talking
- 31:41>> Where are you getting that qualification
- 31:42though? Because now now saying
- 31:45No because the verse the verse is
- 31:46qualified by revelation as he just read
- 31:49for you regarding the Holy Spirit. Okay.
- 31:51So as it pertains and by the way if you
- 31:53say that the Holy Spirit is only
- 31:54receiving revelation in this case and
- 31:56it's not all things that also belong to
- 31:57the Holy Spirit and you're going to
- 31:59still have the same issue of Jesus
- 32:00preaching this Trinity which is the
- 32:02topic by the way.
- 32:03>> Wait what what about Because we promised
- 32:04them.
- 32:04>> Because the Holy Spirit you're saying
- 32:06that in this context he's only receiving
- 32:08the revelation aspect. Yes.
- 32:09>> No I'm not receiving the revelation but
- 32:11he's
- 32:11>> He's getting it. He's getting it. Yes.
- 32:12Getting it. Yeah. He's receiving it from
- 32:14Jesus and giving it to the others.
- 32:15That's what the verse says, no?
- 32:16>> It's it's talking about how he was he's
- 32:17going to take what is mine and declare
- 32:19it to you.
- 32:19>> Right. Receiving it and giving it to
- 32:21others. We're saying that that's the
- 32:22only thing that he's getting in so far
- 32:24as from Jesus. Correct?
- 32:26>> What I'm what I'm saying is is that if
- 32:27you you're talking about the Holy Spirit
- 32:28right now? Yeah the the Holy Spirit is
- 32:30taking the message and and and
- 32:33of Jesus making it known to the
- 32:35disciples.
- 32:36>> Okay. So the context regarding the Holy
- 32:38Spirit is revelation, correct? Okay, so
- 32:40why is it all of a sudden that the
- 32:42context is not in regards to revelation
- 32:44as it pertains to Jesus and the Father
- 32:46in that same one verse?
- 32:47>> Well, you don't see where it says that
- 32:49Jesus is the one that's receiving
- 32:51revelation. You see that he's the one
- 32:53giving it. And so, especially when it
- 32:55talks about if he says all things that
- 32:57the Father has in mind, I would have If
- 32:58you're saying that would include
- 32:59revelation, so all revelation belongs to
- 33:02Jesus. It means he knows all things. All
- 33:04things to be revealed is is is in his
- 33:06knowledge.
- 33:06>> Okay, him being granted knowledge,
- 33:08that's not an issue.
- 33:09>> say.
- 33:09>> Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. Okay, I'll
- 33:11get to that. Amos chapter 3 verse 7 it
- 33:13says that God or the Lord I think it
- 33:15says the Lord does nothing without
- 33:17revealing his prior plans to his
- 33:18servants the prophets, right? So there's
- 33:20no issue in him telling him all of these
- 33:22things that are going to occur whether
- 33:23it be past, present, future, anyway. So
- 33:25that
- 33:26>> What would that be What would that be
- 33:27consisting of?
- 33:29>> What do you mean consisting of?
- 33:30>> When he says When he says that he
- 33:31doesn't do something without
- 33:33>> It says his plans. So prophecy, etc.,
- 33:36etc.
- 33:36>> All right, you said uh
- 33:37>> Amos 3:7
- 33:39>> Okay, so let's read this really quick.
- 33:41Um I'm going to read a little bit in
- 33:43context here. Hear this Hear this word
- 33:45which Yahweh
- 33:46has Now this is in context Yahweh speaks
- 33:48against Israel. Hear this word which
- 33:50Yahweh has spoken against you, sons of
- 33:52Israel, against the entire family which
- 33:54he brought up out of the land of Egypt
- 33:55saying, "You only have I known all among
- 33:58the among all the families of the earth.
- 34:00Therefore, I will punish you for all
- 34:02your iniquities. Do two men walk
- 34:05together unless they are made in
- 34:06appointment? Does a lion roar in the
- 34:08forest when it has no prey? Does a young
- 34:11lion give forth its voice from its den
- 34:14unless it has captured something? Does a
- 34:17bird fall into a trap on the ground when
- 34:19there is no bait in it? Does the trap
- 34:21spring up from the earth when it when it
- 34:24captures nothing at all? If a trumpet is
- 34:26blown in a city, will not the people
- 34:28tremble? If a calamity happens in a
- 34:30city, has not Yahweh done it? Surely the
- 34:33Lord Yahweh does nothing unless he
- 34:36reveals his secret counsel to his slaves
- 34:39the prophets. A lion has roared, who
- 34:41will not fear? The Lord Yahweh has
- 34:43spoken, who who can but prophesy? Make
- 34:46it heard in the citadels in Ashdod and
- 34:48and on the citadels in the land of Egypt
- 34:50and say, "Gather yourselves on the
- 34:52mountains of Samaria and see the great
- 34:54confusions within her and the
- 34:56oppressions in her midst, but they do
- 34:58not know how to do what is right,"
- 35:00declares Yahweh. "These who hoard up
- 35:03violence and and devastation in their
- 35:04citadels. Therefore, this is what the
- 35:06Lord says, an adversary even one
- 35:08surrounding the land will pull down your
- 35:10strength from you and your citadels will
- 35:13be plundered." So, notice what this is
- 35:14in context of. In context, this is
- 35:16talking about when God before God
- 35:18destroys Israel, he lets them know.
- 35:19>> Yeah.
- 35:20>> That's what it's talking about.
- 35:22>> For for Israel.
- 35:23>> Through who?
- 35:24>> Through his prophets.
- 35:25>> Okay, good. So, the verse says God does
- 35:27nothing without revealing his plans to
- 35:29the
- 35:30>> Regarding the destruction of Israel.
- 35:32>> Good. Good. Okay.
- 35:33>> So,
- 35:33>> in regards to many different context.
- 35:35First of all, this is Hold on. I'm I'm
- 35:37I'm getting through. Okay. What you
- 35:38believe is that Jesus is coming calling
- 35:40to the kingdom of God is the entirety of
- 35:42his message, correct?
- 35:43>> That's part of it.
- 35:44>> Or part of it, yeah, sure. Fine.
- 35:46Part of that message that he's giving
- 35:47regarding the kingdom, he preaches to
- 35:49the people that there is going to be a
- 35:51destruction that's going to approach
- 35:52them, correct? Which destruction Sorry,
- 35:54destruction is that?
- 35:55>> 70 AD.
- 35:56>> Right, exactly. So, part of that message
- 35:58is that he's preaching to them regarding
- 36:00the things that are coming to the
- 36:01future. So, back to John 16:15, what the
- 36:04context is specifically, it doesn't have
- 36:06to be negated regarding revelation is
- 36:08what is being given to Jesus by God,
- 36:11okay?
- 36:11>> Where do you see that?
- 36:12>> Because the context of the verse is
- 36:14literally the Holy Spirit receiving in
- 36:16so far as revelation. Why would Hold on.
- 36:18Hold on. Why would I qualify for Jesus
- 36:21more than just revelation? Because if
- 36:23we're going to go with any other
- 36:24interpretation that you're giving, If
- 36:26going to go with any other
- 36:27interpretation you're giving, we're
- 36:28going to say all is unqualified here,
- 36:30then the question is just simply going
- 36:31to be, okay,
- 36:33the Father possesses particular divine
- 36:35making properties and all of these
- 36:36things that the Son and the Spirit don't
- 36:37possess. Does the Son now possess them?
- 36:39>> Yeah, sure. So,
- 36:41uh um two things I think are the issue
- 36:43here. One is is a conflation of context.
- 36:46We see in Amos 3, it's in context of
- 36:47destruction of Israel. So, God never
- 36:49does he never destroys Israel without
- 36:51letting them know through his prophets.
- 36:52You're now linking this with John 16,
- 36:55which has nothing to do with the
- 36:56destruction of Israel.
- 36:57>> It's the revelation of John 16
- 36:59specifically.
- 36:59>> Well, hold on. But, specifically
- 37:01revelation to his apostles and guiding
- 37:03them in all truth in building the church
- 37:05and spreading the message of Jesus.
- 37:07>> Right.
- 37:07>> It's about their ministry work. So, this
- 37:09has nothing to do with the destruction
- 37:11of Israel. And but, notice what it says
- 37:13there. It says when Jesus is talking,
- 37:15they say, "Now you are speaking plainly.
- 37:17Now we know that you know all things and
- 37:19that you came from God." And what does
- 37:22he say? You You now now you believe?
- 37:24>> Because he gave them revelation, right?
- 37:26>> Huh?
- 37:26>> Because he gave them revelation.
- 37:27>> Yes, good.
- 37:28>> Because he gave them revelation.
- 37:29>> Beautiful. It's qualified.
- 37:30>> So, well, hold on. Well, so their their
- 37:32their awareness now that, "Wow, he knows
- 37:36all things and we know he came from
- 37:37God." And not come from God meaning that
- 37:39he's just sent, meaning that he's came
- 37:41cuz he could continues, "I came down
- 37:43from heaven. I came from the Father and
- 37:46entered the world. Now I'm leaving the
- 37:48world and going back to the Father." So,
- 37:50this isn't just some, "Oh, I've sent."
- 37:52But, he was in heaven with the Father
- 37:54pre-existing his human birth and has
- 37:57come into the world from the Father
- 37:58showing that he had that he's divine and
- 38:01knows all things. They're getting this
- 38:02revelation now.
- 38:03>> Mhm. Beautiful.
- 38:04>> Well, let me respond to that. So, you
- 38:06see how what you're saying is, you're
- 38:07saying that, hey, in the context of John
- 38:1016, John 16:25 and John 16:15, is that
- 38:13he tells them these things are about to
- 38:14happen, gives them this revelation, and
- 38:16then they say they were told back and
- 38:17say back,
- 38:18"Wow, you know all things." Right? They
- 38:20say that he knows all things due to the
- 38:22fact that he gave them revelation,
- 38:23right? Now, the answer they give about
- 38:26the example that we brought,
- 38:28I believe it was what was it? Amos 3:7?
- 38:30Amos 3:7, right? You said that, "Hey,
- 38:33God tells us what's about to happen,
- 38:35right? And then he he then tells us that
- 38:37he reveals these plans to the prophets."
- 38:39And then he said, "No, no, no, no. When
- 38:40he reveals these plans to the prophets,
- 38:42it's only in relation to the destruction
- 38:43of the second temple, 70 AD." Well, you
- 38:45see how you're narrowing down this He
- 38:46didn't even say that. Hold up. No, he
- 38:49>> destruction in general.
- 38:51But what? In the context of the result
- 38:53of 16, because that's something extra.
- 38:54>> So, let me finish. I'll I'll I'll let
- 38:55you take take it back, right? So, what
- 38:57we see is is that he still gives an
- 38:59example of how God knows all things, and
- 39:01then he
- 39:02>> Jesus.
- 39:02>> And then he qualifies that, right? So,
- 39:04when when Christ said he know all
- 39:05things, why don't you take the same
- 39:07approach and say that this is in
- 39:08reference to revelation and that he
- 39:09doesn't actually mean all things? Right?
- 39:12What what did he say to you, Break? And
- 39:13I gave you John 1 John 2:20, where the
- 39:15disciples know all things. How did you
- 39:16qualify it? You read the context that it
- 39:17was about revelation. The context is a
- 39:19revelation is that they know all things.
- 39:21Oh, that was only about revelation. Why
- 39:23can't we do the same thing with Jesus?
- 39:24>> So, here's why. Notice what he says it
- 39:27says in verse 20. Now, the disciples
- 39:28say, "Ah, now we know you are speaking
- 39:30plainly and not using figurative
- 39:32speech." So, what did he
- 39:34exaggerate? It's not hyperbolic.
- 39:36Plainly, we now you know we now we know
- 39:39you know all
- 39:39>> Which verse was it? What was that?
- 39:41>> Which verse did you use the quote? Verse
- 39:4230.
- 39:42>> Verse 29 is what I read, and then 30,
- 39:44and then So, 29 and 30 together. And
- 39:46then Jesus doesn't
- 39:47He just He says, "Oh, so now you
- 39:49believe."
- 39:49>> Yeah. Confirming that yeah.
- 39:51>> But in verse 25, he said he was speaking
- 39:52in figuratively earlier.
- 39:54>> When he said that in verse 15. Verse 25,
- 39:56let me read that then. Okay, so I have
- 39:57said these things
- 39:59to you in figures of speech. The hour is
- 40:00coming when I will no longer speak to
- 40:01you in figures of speech, but will tell
- 40:03you plainly about the Father.
- 40:05>> But right now, John 10:15
- 40:06>> 10:15 was figurative.
- 40:07>> Prior to that, he says, "Yeah, I spoke
- 40:08in figures of speech. Now I'm not going
- 40:10to talk about the Father." And then the
- 40:12disciples say, "Oh, yeah, now you're
- 40:13speaking plainly. You know all You know
- 40:15all things." And then he says, "Oh, so
- 40:17you now believe basically."
- 40:18>> You're in agreement with us now. In John
- 40:2016:15 when he says that he says all
- 40:22things, it's figurative. It's not
- 40:23literal.
- 40:24>> That's after or after
- 40:25>> Verse 29 30.
- 40:2729 30.
- 40:28Read 29 30.
- 40:29>> Yeah, yes, yes, yes.
- 40:30>> See, so he's there. There you go. Now
- 40:31you absolutely agree with us. That's
- 40:32awesome. Excellent.
- 40:33>> No, no. It's not I didn't say I agree
- 40:34with this. I don't agree with that. I
- 40:35didn't say I agree. I just said that I I
- 40:36was misquoting you.
- 40:38Here's another layer to this because
- 40:39like I said, there's another example
- 40:40where this is brought up in in uh
- 40:43chapter 20 of John where
- 40:46uh Jesus is asking Peter after the
- 40:47resurrection, he's asking Peter, "Do you
- 40:49love me?" All right? And Peter gets sad
- 40:51because he asked him three times. He's
- 40:52like, "You You know that I love you." He
- 40:54He's asked him like to finally he says,
- 40:56"Do you love me? Feed my sheep." Peter
- 40:58gets sad and says, "Lord, you know all
- 41:01things. You know that I love you." Now,
- 41:03why is this relevant? And I would say
- 41:05even it's probably even more powerful
- 41:06than this one because
- 41:08uh Peter's love for Jesus is in his
- 41:10heart. All right? This is a This is
- 41:13appealing to his heart. When the Bible
- 41:15will says that it's Yahweh who searches
- 41:17the hearts of men.
- 41:18Man doesn't know the hearts of men or
- 41:19nor the mind of men, but it's Yahweh who
- 41:21knows the mind and the hearts of men.
- 41:23And yet Peter is acknowledging that
- 41:25Jesus knows his heart and his mind.
- 41:27>> So this would just be like illogical
- 41:29predication. The same way that you say
- 41:30for example that um Yahweh alone creates
- 41:32or Yahweh alone forgives, right? These
- 41:34are things that are due to God alone,
- 41:36right? Or you can see instances where
- 41:37the disciples forgive sins. Christ
- 41:39himself forgives sins, right? So him
- 41:41knowing the heart of a specific person
- 41:42through revelation that God has informed
- 41:44him doesn't mean that he now knows all
- 41:45the hearts of all men universally which
- 41:47would be an omniproperty, right? So
- 41:49you'd have to substantiate that. You
- 41:50have to prove that. What What What How
- 41:51do you make that jump? Just one second.
- 41:52How do you make that jump that him
- 41:53knowing the heart of this specific
- 41:54disciple This means that he now knows uh
- 41:57something that only belongs to God alone
- 41:58which is knowing the hearts of all men.
- 42:00>> So can you show us somewhere in
- 42:01scripture where someone other than
- 42:03Yahweh or Jesus can read hearts?
- 42:05>> No, I don't I don't think it works so
- 42:06what we see It's the burden of proof So
- 42:08the the burden of proof would be upon
- 42:09you. Why? Because you're saying that,
- 42:10"Hey, he has this omniproperty because
- 42:12he knows the heart of one man. That
- 42:14doesn't follow.
- 42:15>> No, no, right?
- 42:16>> That's just one example.
- 42:18Okay, do you have an example where you
- 42:19said that he knows the hearts of all
- 42:20men?
- 42:20>> Well, so
- 42:21>> Do you Would you have that or not?
- 42:22>> I'll give you an example. I know you're
- 42:24a couple.
- 42:25There's Mark 2, what he brought up,
- 42:28where it says that they were saying in
- 42:29their hearts
- 42:31that only God can forgive sins and this
- 42:33man, who does he think he is? And Jesus
- 42:36knowing their hearts
- 42:38responds to them and says, is it easy
- 42:40for me to say their sins is forgiven?
- 42:43>> Who told him that? That they're saying
- 42:45that in their heart? Like Jesus, is that
- 42:46enough?
- 42:47>> Wait, hold on.
- 42:47>> So you're going to The author of Mark
- 42:49wrote that they said that in their
- 42:50heart.
- 42:50>> So we can't trust Mark, but we can trust
- 42:52the words that Mark
- 42:53>> I'm just wondering like who told Mark
- 42:54that in their hearts they're saying
- 42:56this.
- 42:56>> Jesus.
- 42:57>> Did Jesus
- 42:57>> Jesus
- 42:58>> Jesus He's getting this from Peter.
- 43:00Peter is a disciple of Jesus, so this is
- 43:02why this all
- 43:02>> So so then Peter Jesus told Peter, hey
- 43:05by the way, they were saying this in
- 43:06their hearts. That's why I gave that
- 43:07response. Jesus was there.
- 43:09>> That's what I'm saying.
- 43:09>> Well, that could be just revelation
- 43:10straight from the Holy Spirit.
- 43:11>> Oh, okay.
- 43:12>> From Peter. Yeah, it's cuz the
- 43:13>> Revelation was in the Holy Spirit,
- 43:14right?
- 43:15>> Yep, absolutely.
- 43:16>> So So we have So we have examples where
- 43:18there's a multitude of men that have a
- 43:21heart issue and Jesus knows exactly what
- 43:23they're thinking in their hearts and
- 43:24responds to it. That's um one example.
- 43:27Another example would be um where there
- 43:30were people that was following Jesus,
- 43:31right?
- 43:32>> There's people who follow Jesus. Jesus
- 43:33is giving miracles. I think it's in
- 43:33Luke. I forget the exact verse. I can
- 43:36pull it up.
- 43:36>> Before you give the Luke example, just
- 43:37because it is a little bit of a
- 43:38difference, right?
- 43:39This example that you give in John 20 is
- 43:41going to be post resurrection, correct?
- 43:43>> Yes.
- 43:44>> Okay. So we're we're talking about the
- 43:45historical Jesus. This is This word
- 43:47historians don't speak of
- 43:49both sides of the
- 43:52They did again. We literally clarified
- 43:54in the beginning saying post
- 43:55resurrection, we're not accepting those
- 43:56narratives.
- 43:57>> Why?
- 43:57>> Because that's not historical.
- 44:00Well, it's cuz it can't be qualified.
- 44:02You guys are saying that this individual
- 44:03is no longer a human.
- 44:05>> It sounds like you're saying order to
- 44:06reject the parts of the Gospels we don't
- 44:07like cuz they disagree with Islam and
- 44:09we're only going to accept the person
- 44:10arguing historicity.
- 44:12>> We're arguing historicity if you want to
- 44:13be very, very minute.
- 44:14>> Then give us some standards.
- 44:16>> Give us some standards. I'll go to the
- 44:17specific one the post-resurrection
- 44:18events, right? We can give us like a
- 44:20simple argument why the
- 44:21post-resurrection things wouldn't be
- 44:22historical to Christ, right? We see that
- 44:24for example, you have the passion
- 44:27narrative of Christ of him predicting
- 44:28his resurrection is on a line, right?
- 44:30And we see this in Luke 24, we see it in
- 44:32Matthew as well.
- 44:34Now, we can easily argue against why
- 44:35this wouldn't be historical. Why?
- 44:37Because we see that in the synoptics
- 44:39that the disciples upon them witnessing
- 44:41the crucifixion, what do they say,
- 44:43right? They they they proclaim that they
- 44:46don't believe that this would be that
- 44:48Christ wouldn't be he failed in
- 44:50restoring Israel, right? So, what we see
- 44:52is is that although the expectation is
- 44:54for him to be crucified, what we see is
- 44:56is that they're surprised, right?
- 44:57They're surprised. They see a failed
- 44:58Messiah, right? So, an easy explanation
- 45:00to posit post the unaliving of Christ is
- 45:03that they simply saw that that Messiah
- 45:05and they wanted to reconcile this. This
- 45:07is why we have the quote-unquote passion
- 45:09narrative quotations references about
- 45:11the prophecies of Christ to be unalived
- 45:13unalived and resurrected. It simply
- 45:14requires less assumption and is the easy
- 45:16explanation.
- 45:18>> Did he explicitly state the resurrection
- 45:19throughout the synoptics?
- 45:20>> No, no.
- 45:22No, he didn't. No, I know it says that,
- 45:23right? But I don't know if it's
- 45:24historical, right?
- 45:24>> Okay, you don't know that. So, he didn't
- 45:25explicitly predict that.
- 45:26>> No.
- 45:27>> So, so let's use the historical criteria
- 45:29on Mark's 8. So, let's go to Mark 8. So,
- 45:31so can you respond to the argument I
- 45:32just gave?
- 45:33>> I'm good.
- 45:34>> Yeah. Using his Using your method
- 45:35historical criteria. So, let's go Let's
- 45:37go Let's read this. Okay. So,
- 45:39at the end of Mark Mark 8. Okay. So,
- 45:42uh he says the Son of Man
- 45:45um
- 45:45is going to be put to death basically.
- 45:48So, we know so he began to teach that
- 45:50the Son of Man must suffer many things
- 45:51and be rejected by the elders and the
- 45:52chief priests and the scribes and be
- 45:53killed and after 3 days rise again. And
- 45:56he said this plainly. And Peter took him
- 45:59aside and began to rebuke him. But
- 46:00turning and seeing his disciples he
- 46:02rebuked Peter and said, "Get behind me
- 46:04Satan, for you are not setting your mind
- 46:05on the things but on the things of men."
- 46:07So, that answers your That answers your
- 46:08argument right then and there. They
- 46:10didn't believe him because they didn't
- 46:12expect that in their background culture,
- 46:14but he said it plainly. They're going to
- 46:19>> Three questions. The Is the Old
- 46:20Testament adamant on a on a life and
- 46:22goal of the Messiah?
- 46:22>> Yeah, okay.
- 46:23>> Real quick.
- 46:23>> Yeah, yeah.
- 46:24>> Beautiful. It's clear, right? Beautiful.
- 46:26Is the New Testament clear about that
- 46:27the Messiah is going to be alive? Is
- 46:28that clear?
- 46:29>> Yep. Yeah.
- 46:29>> Beautiful. So, when it comes to the
- 46:30disciples, if it is clear to them, and
- 46:32again, you bringing us this example of
- 46:34uh of explaining away how they would
- 46:37they would they wouldn't be surprised or
- 46:38they would be surprised, sorry, is
- 46:39irrelevant because that's the very thing
- 46:41in question. The expectation is that
- 46:43they wouldn't be surprised. Why? Because
- 46:46according to you, the Old Testament and
- 46:48New Testament teaches that it's going to
- 46:49happen, right?
- 46:50>> Yeah, but
- 46:50>> So, real quick, I I follow the mag.
- 46:52And the New Testament So, if it is the
- 46:54case that he was crucified, would that
- 46:56increase their belief in Christ or
- 46:58decrease it?
- 46:58>> Uh well, the answer to that is it would
- 47:00increase it. Now, let me tell you why.
- 47:02>> So, what So, why did they reject it?
- 47:03>> Let me tell you why.
- 47:04>> Mhm.
- 47:04>> Let me tell you why. And here's And
- 47:05here's the proof of it. Um uh what age
- 47:07are we in? We're in the age of the
- 47:09church, are we not?
- 47:09>> Yeah, that's true. We are, yeah.
- 47:10>> Why Why are we in the age of the church?
- 47:12Because Jesus was crucified and then
- 47:13they saw him alive again later on. So,
- 47:15it increased their faith. They went from
- 47:17cowards running away uh of when Jesus
- 47:20was was was in prison and and then all
- 47:22of a sudden they're boldly preaching
- 47:24that they saw the risen Lord. So, what
- 47:26did it do? It increased their faith
- 47:28coupled with the resurrection.
- 47:30>> Yeah, beautiful.
- 47:30>> And so now now I want to I'm going to
- 47:32let you continue, but I wanted to touch
- 47:34on this because you guys are talking
- 47:34about post and after. Now, it's it's it
- 47:36seems arbitrary talking about uh you
- 47:38know, after resurrection like you guys
- 47:40just don't take that.
- 47:40>> I'm telling you why it's not.
- 47:41>> It's very convenient, but this is
- 47:43post-resurrection. Before the
- 47:45resurrection, this is John chapter 2
- 47:46where it says
- 47:47>> So, let me address his point.
- 47:48>> Well, just real quick. I I promise I'll
- 47:49let I'll do it now. This is This is
- 47:51ain't even long. It says, uh John
- 47:53chapter 2 verse 23, "Now when he was in
- 47:55Jerusalem at the Passover feast, many
- 47:57believed in his name when they saw the
- 47:59signs that he was doing. But Jesus on
- 48:02his part did not entrust himself to them
- 48:04because he knew he knew all people and
- 48:08needed no one to bear witness about man
- 48:11for he himself knew what was in man. So
- 48:14in in other translation says what was in
- 48:16the heart of man. So here we have
- 48:18>> Is that about
- 48:19>> before the resurrection.
- 48:21>> that about specifically?
- 48:22>> It's about Jesus.
- 48:22>> About who?
- 48:23>> This is this is about Jesus.
- 48:24>> addressing?
- 48:25>> Huh?
- 48:26>> Who's he addressing? Who's he Who's he
- 48:27about to knows the man?
- 48:28>> It's about Jesus.
- 48:29>> Yeah, but the point the problem is that
- 48:30this isn't Jesus speaking. This is
- 48:32somebody else
- 48:32>> Neither now now
- 48:33>> No, who is he who is he who is he who is
- 48:34the man that he knows the hearts of? Who
- 48:36is the audience?
- 48:36>> Men, mankind, human beings.
- 48:38>> Okay, so it says human beings. So the
- 48:40context isn't about specific
- 48:41>> He said it says human beings.
- 48:42>> Okay, but
- 48:43>> So let me finish.
- 48:44>> Go ahead, finish.
- 48:45>> So number one, even in the the the
- 48:47example I gave you it was Peter who said
- 48:48that you know all things.
- 48:49>> But in regards to this conversation he's
- 48:51having with
- 48:51>> Exactly.
- 48:52>> So why didn't Jesus say that about the
- 48:53conversation with Jesus?
- 48:55>> But notice, none of this is about
- 48:57>> Can I finish?
- 48:58>> That was the whole point of what I'm
- 48:58saying. That was the whole point
- 48:59>> I I told you can I finish one more?
- 49:00>> Yeah, you can finish but the whole point
- 49:01is that this discussion as he said from
- 49:02the beginning it was red
- 49:04>> You're like to interrupt.
- 49:04>> So is this red letter?
- 49:05>> Yeah, it is kind of weird they keep
- 49:06jumping around there. So so so notice
- 49:08this. You guys were you know arguing
- 49:11post resurrection. Oh yeah, we don't
- 49:12take that you know conveniently enough.
- 49:14I noticed now now it's oh well, you
- 49:16know, Jesus isn't saying this in John in
- 49:18in John 2.
- 49:19>> Or we've been arguing
- 49:20>> This is what I'm talking about him.
- 49:22>> But it was the apostles in John cuz you
- 49:24went to John 16
- 49:25>> Right.
- 49:25>> and appealed to the apostles talking
- 49:26about Jesus saying he knows all things.
- 49:28So it wasn't us, it was him. So when he
- 49:31did this we went along with his
- 49:32criteria, with his consistency and we're
- 49:35showing where the apostles and others
- 49:37are saying Jesus knows all things even
- 49:39knowing the hearts of man. So if this is
- 49:41not is if you guys can't take this then
- 49:44don't even quote John 16.
- 49:45>> No no no I'm going to get to that but we
- 49:47need to address IP's argument.
- 49:48>> Sure.
- 49:49>> And and your argument too cuz you you
- 49:50did jump in, right? Regarding the
- 49:52historical attestation fully
- 49:53post-resurrection sayings, right? And he
- 49:56said, "Oh, how do you determine and this
- 49:57arbitrary that we we don't know how it
- 49:59is." I give you the argument very
- 50:00clearly. He said that if they see the
- 50:01crucifixion, it should increase them in
- 50:03belief. Then he switches to
- 50:05>> I said coupled with the resurrection.
- 50:06>> I'm I'm I'm clarifying. And then you
- 50:08said coupled with the resurrection, it
- 50:10would increase in faith.
- 50:12The issue that you have is is that if
- 50:14the crucifixion was very clear and clear
- 50:16in the Old Testament, clear in the New
- 50:17Testament, the event of the crucifixion
- 50:20by itself should increase them in faith.
- 50:22That's what they expected.
- 50:23>> No.
- 50:24>> Let me Let me Let me finish.
- 50:26The fact that it's after the
- 50:27resurrection, there can be a better
- 50:29hypothesis to explain this away. That
- 50:31the Jews had a failed Messiah and they
- 50:33had to reconcile a failed Messiah with
- 50:36what they had to work with. And the best
- 50:37way to do this is to simply include
- 50:39these {quote} "passion predictions."
- 50:41That is the best way to explain it and
- 50:42include this ad hoc belief that, "Oh,
- 50:45no, they knew all along." Right? But
- 50:47somehow they were
- 50:49because they believe that the
- 50:50crucifixion but increase them in the
- 50:51resurrection. It doesn't make sense.
- 50:52Why? Because you guys believe that the
- 50:54crucifixion and the resurrection were
- 50:56both clear. Right? If it is clear, we'd
- 50:59expect it to increase them in belief
- 51:01once they see the crucifixion and even
- 51:03more with the resurrection. But it can't
- 51:04be decreasing with the crucifixion and
- 51:05then increasing with the resurrection.
- 51:06It doesn't make sense.
- 51:07>> Okay, so the problem is what you're
- 51:08doing. You keep equivocating on two
- 51:09things. What the scriptures taught, what
- 51:11the disciples believed in that instance.
- 51:14As we said earlier, they're fallible
- 51:15men. They're getting things wrong.
- 51:17That's what we're seeing in this. This
- 51:18is what you know, the criteria of the
- 51:20Old Testament. God, let me finish. This
- 51:22meets the criteria of the embarrassment.
- 51:23What I just read about him taking Peter
- 51:25aside and rebuking him saying, "Get
- 51:27behind me, Satan." As historians know,
- 51:28this is one of the most reliable places
- 51:30in Mark because it meets criteria of
- 51:32embarrassment, criteria of
- 51:33dissimilarity, criteria of historical
- 51:35congruence. It meets all of these
- 51:36various things here. So, what we have
- 51:39here is we have Jesus knowing the
- 51:40scriptures and saying, "Yes, I'm going
- 51:42to die. They're going to kill me and
- 51:44then I'm going to resurrect." And the
- 51:45disciples just being fallible, not
- 51:47getting it. So, that's why they did not
- 51:50They did not increase until they saw the
- 51:52resurrection after. So, that's what's
- 51:54going on. It's a stop equivocating on
- 51:55what the scriptures taught and what the
- 51:56disciples believed.
- 51:58>> You would agree that the reason why they
- 51:59increased them in belief in the
- 52:01resurrection is because that was
- 52:02prophesied, right?
- 52:04Right? And they expected that.
- 52:06>> I I I wouldn't necessarily say that. I
- 52:07would I would say that seeing who you
- 52:10You you saw this man die,
- 52:11>> Right.
- 52:12>> and then you see him alive again. Well,
- 52:13that That right there
- 52:15>> I said but part of the reason is because
- 52:16that's that's what was expected to be
- 52:19according to
- 52:19>> I I I would say that I would say that as
- 52:21they got understanding more so later on,
- 52:23that that can that continued to solidify
- 52:25their belief
- 52:26>> Amazing.
- 52:27>> cuz that's what you see. You see them
- 52:28begin to quote Old Testament like, "Oh,
- 52:30yes, this is what he meant and this is
- 52:31what he said after they give
- 52:32revelation."
- 52:33>> Amazing. So, according to you guys, the
- 52:34the the disciples are saying, "Hey, this
- 52:36is what he meant." So, according to you
- 52:38guys, for the disciples it was unclear
- 52:41prior to the resurrection, right? Now,
- 52:42>> No. No. No.
- 52:43>> Was it clear or unclear?
- 52:44>> For for them, they're misunder- So,
- 52:46look, we can look at the scripture and
- 52:47we can see what Jesus is saying. It's
- 52:48pretty clear. But for the disciples,
- 52:50it's They did not understand it. It
- 52:52wasn't They They missed They were
- 52:54missing the mark.
- 52:55>> Yeah, beautiful.
- 52:55>> But he's asking how if if the Old
- 52:57Testament
- 52:58>> They're fallible.
- 52:59>> It's that's a really, really poor
- 53:01argument. So, I'm aware that the the sky
- 53:03is blue and the grass is green, and I'm
- 53:04very well studied on this, but I think
- 53:06that the grass is actually blue and the
- 53:08sky is actually red. That's just very,
- 53:10very absurd. If it's very, very well
- 53:12understood, you wouldn't just expect the
- 53:14opposite.
- 53:14>> There are flat-earthers.
- 53:16>> Yeah, there's flat-earthers.
- 53:17>> Okay, yeah. See, there there are It's
- 53:18very clear the earth is round, and yet
- 53:19there are still people that believe the
- 53:20earth is flat. Some people just believe
- 53:22stupid
- 53:23>> They're low-key
- 53:24>> [laughter]
- 53:25>> They're low-key?
- 53:26>> Yeah.
- 53:26>> Yeah.
- 53:27>> Wow,
- 53:28wow, man.
- 53:29That's crazy.
- 53:29>> The disciples were low-key stupid.
- 53:31>> Israel was low-key stupid. Israel was
- 53:33>> Uh Israel was tripping. When when God
- 53:35when God came to Egypt and showed his
- 53:38power and his magnificence, and they
- 53:39still went to Egypt
- 53:41>> You can could this is a clip all you Are
- 53:42you what? This is
- 53:43This is starting to pop, bro. You
- 53:44talking about Israel. Israel was
- 53:46freaking dumb. When God would reveal
- 53:48themselves in in in Egypt, showed his
- 53:50power, brought them out of
- 53:52a slavery, gave them food from heaven,
- 53:55and they still griped against him. They
- 53:57still spoke against God. They were dumb.
- 54:00>> text is trying to show.
- 54:01>> It's just really weird your earliest
- 54:02Christians all just completely rejected
- 54:04that notion and all understood the
- 54:05thing.
- 54:06Irenaeus he he understands the disciples
- 54:08are very very educated. They're not
- 54:09ignorant.
- 54:10>> What is the
- 54:11>> Irenaeus Irenaeus says that the Jesus
- 54:13chose the disciples because you wouldn't
- 54:15go to a sick man for medication. You go
- 54:17to a doctor for medication. He chose the
- 54:19right people that know what they're
- 54:21talking about to spread his word.
- 54:23>> Where does Irenaeus say that they were
- 54:24not
- 54:24>> have the I don't know the exact quote.
- 54:27Just like you you referenced a man for a
- 54:30book.
- 54:31You referenced a man for a book.
- 54:34Uh after like 30 minutes of Google.
- 54:37>> [laughter]
- 54:39>> After 30 minutes.
- 54:40>> It took me a while, but I brought it up.
- 54:42>> I could do it in 30 seconds. Just give
- 54:43ME 5 MINUTES.
- 54:45DO IT.
- 54:46>> OKAY. It All right. Does Does this like
- 54:47change the fact about we we're
- 54:49acknowledging the disciples are
- 54:51>> ignorant.
- 54:51>> I don't think historically speaking that
- 54:53passes now with the Christian
- 54:56>> I just quoted Irenaeus.
- 54:56>> Then things change. Now they're being
- 54:58led by the Holy Spirit.
- 54:59>> So you would agree You would agree that
- 55:01the sign of Jonah was before the the
- 55:03argument from the sign of Jonah that the
- 55:05same way that the these
- 55:06Jonah was in the belly of the whale for
- 55:073 days and 3 nights, so was the sign of
- 55:10That's before the
- 55:11resurrection, correct?
- 55:12>> That when he when Jesus gave the sign,
- 55:13is that what you're asking? Yeah, he
- 55:15gave that sign.
- 55:15>> Okay. Is that clear?
- 55:17>> Uh yeah, I mean if you're saying that
- 55:19yes. If you're saying just like Jonah
- 55:21was in the belly of the whale
- 55:22>> Just like he was in the belly of
- 55:23Leviathan.
- 55:24>> So if it is clear, we'd expect disciples
- 55:25to understand that, right?
- 55:26>> What's that?
- 55:27>> If it is clear, we'd expect the
- 55:28disciples to understand.
- 55:29>> Not necessarily.
- 55:30>> Okay. For example, let me let me
- 55:31let me let me ask you this.
- 55:33>> Um is it clear from the Quran that you
- 55:35need the Sunnah?
- 55:36>> Yes.
- 55:37>> Okay. Do are there Muslims out there
- 55:39maybe might not consider them Muslim?
- 55:40Are there Muslims that will read that
- 55:41Quran and read the clear Quran and say,
- 55:43"Uh you don't need the Sunnah."
- 55:44>> I got you. So yeah, there is a minority
- 55:46group. However, we're talking about the
- 55:47disciples in their entirety. So that's
- 55:49the sample size. We have all the
- 55:51disciples in this case. You don't have
- 55:53all the Muslims who read the Quran come
- 55:54to the conclusion that you don't need
- 55:55the Sunnah. So it would be disanalogous.
- 55:57>> No, so
- 55:58the the principle was about clearness
- 56:00and understanding of people.
- 56:02>> If you had everyone missing it, that
- 56:05kind of raise a question. Wow. I'll tell
- 56:07you because you don't have every Muslim
- 56:08who reads the Quran come to the
- 56:10conclusion that hey, you only read the
- 56:11Quran. But with this example, you have
- 56:13every single disciple missing the mark
- 56:15when it says that the same way that
- 56:17Jonah was in the belly of the whale for
- 56:183 days and 3 nights, so the son of man.
- 56:20Right? So that's one point. Secondly,
- 56:23regarding the historicity of that, we're
- 56:24making an argument of historicity, aka
- 56:26it's inductive. We're saying that
- 56:28there's an easier explanation for the
- 56:29data. And an explanation that requires
- 56:31less presupposition.
- 56:33>> There's no presupposition in the text.
- 56:35says they didn't understand it.
- 56:35>> I'm saying that the easy explanation
- 56:38that can dismiss your your narrative is
- 56:40that it's simply going to be the case
- 56:42that there was a failed Messiah and they
- 56:44had they had to reconcile their being a
- 56:46failed Messiah with the text. Simple. So
- 56:48that therefore therefore we'd expect
- 56:49that for that to be passion predictions.
- 56:51So again, them all of them missing the
- 56:53mark, that's absurd.
- 56:55>> Okay, can I respond to this? Yeah, I I
- 56:56think that that's I think that that's
- 56:58your presupposition. Just because uh 12
- 57:00people who followed Jesus misunderstand
- 57:03what he's saying when all through this,
- 57:05we see that they're misunderstanding
- 57:06what he's saying and what we what we
- 57:08what we really quick. And we even see in
- 57:10Acts where it identifies John and Peter
- 57:13as being unlearned. These aren't
- 57:15scholars.
- 57:16>> And if they're not learning, it means
- 57:17that you don't understand it like
- 57:18>> They're they're not knowledgeable.
- 57:20They're not They're not
- 57:21They're not educated. Hold on, let me
- 57:22let me finish. I'm I'm I'm building the
- 57:24case here that these aren't scholars
- 57:26that Jesus picked out. They were
- 57:27fishermen. Okay? And so for you to say
- 57:30that oh, it's it just it's in it's
- 57:32unfathomable. It doesn't make any real
- 57:34sense that the 12 disciples who are not
- 57:37scholarly
- 57:38were not scholarly, who even acknowledge
- 57:40that Jesus is speaking in figurative
- 57:41language, and even when he speaks
- 57:42plainly, they still don't understand
- 57:44them, that oh, that these fallible men
- 57:46don't understand Jesus until he
- 57:48resurrects.
- 57:49>> Did Did they understand
- 57:51>> He resurrects, and then it clicks for
- 57:53them. And they were like, oh, this is
- 57:54what he meant by the This is what he's
- 57:56saying. That makes sense. And that's
- 57:58exactly what it says. It says they
- 58:00didn't understand. They didn't
- 58:02understand. They didn't understand.
- 58:04>> That's the hardest thing to overcome. It
- 58:06requires more data requires me more
- 58:08presuppositions. Did any Jew prior to
- 58:10the disciples believe that the Messiah
- 58:11was supposed to be on the third day and
- 58:12raised back on the third day?
- 58:13>> I I'm not Yeah, yes, but
- 58:16>> Did Did anyone do that?
- 58:17>> So, are are you asking for a group?
- 58:19>> An individual or group?
- 58:20>> I wouldn't be able to reference a
- 58:21particular group of prophets.
- 58:23>> missed it. All of the Jews missed it.
- 58:24>> That's not what I'm saying.
- 58:24>> Okay, so that's what I asked you. Are
- 58:25you talking about
- 58:26>> Right, so now we have a bigger sample
- 58:28size. We're just We don't only have the
- 58:3012 disciples, every single Jew that read
- 58:32the Torah and the and the Tanakh not
- 58:33come to the conclusion that only the
- 58:35post-resurrection data points to.
- 58:38>> Yes, that's what I'm trying to say.
- 58:39>> I'm I'm only I'm making an argument. I'm
- 58:41I'm only saying that
- 58:42>> But that's not what I'm saying.
- 58:43>> That's fine. I'm I'm only making an
- 58:44argument.
- 58:45>> Okay, so for example, if the prophets
- 58:46are saying that Jesus that the Messiah
- 58:48is going to be crucified and rise again
- 58:49on the third day.
- 58:49>> And he's going to stand up.
- 58:50>> This is in there. I I I would agree I
- 58:52would say that yes, Jews did understand
- 58:54that the Messiah like Targum Jonathan,
- 58:56for example. Targum Jonathan says that
- 58:58that the suffering servant is the
- 59:00Messiah. And so, the Messiah is
- 59:02>> say the suffering servant.
- 59:03>> Yes, he does.
- 59:04>> Not the suffering servant.
- 59:04>> Yes, sir. The suffering servant in the
- 59:06suffering servant passages in Isaiah 52
- 59:08and 53, Targum Jonathan says that that's
- 59:11about the Messiah.
- 59:12>> You're You're misquoting him. Yes, he
- 59:13says that that there's a Messiah in
- 59:15Isaiah 53, but he doesn't say the
- 59:16suffering servant is the Messiah. Can
- 59:18you show me anywhere where Targum
- 59:19Jonathan attributes any kind of
- 59:20suffering towards the Messiah?
- 59:23Because he never never attributes
- 59:24suffering to the Messiah.
- 59:25>> Yes, he does. In In In Targum Jonathan,
- 59:27in in the at the end towards the end of
- 59:30of uh Isaiah 52, verses 13 to 15, that
- 59:33same servant who was highly exalted
- 59:35after being marred beyond human uh uh
- 59:38resemblance and all that kind of stuff,
- 59:39he applies that to the Messiah. He says
- 59:41this is about the Messiah.
- 59:43>> All right, so check that out. Do Can Can
- 59:45we get a reference to that?
- 59:47>> Targum Jonathan on Isaiah on Isaiah 52
- 59:49and 53.
- 59:49>> So, like the last verse or what or
- 59:51what's up?
- 59:51>> Uh that's verses 13 and 15.
- 59:53>> Okay.
- 59:54>> Wasn't it 7th century?
- 59:56>> No, it's 6th century.
- 59:57>> Yes, but that's after the Jews.
- 59:58>> Yeah, but that's afterwards though, so.
- 1:00:00>> It's 6th century, but it's
- 1:00:01>> He's Wait, he I mean what I'm really
- 1:00:02asking you is essentially, when it comes
- 1:00:04to this particular thing, right? Is
- 1:00:06there anybody prior that actually held
- 1:00:08to this belief to begin with? That they
- 1:00:10thought that the Christ or Messiah,
- 1:00:12whatever, is going to die and on the
- 1:00:14third day resurrect. Okay.
- 1:00:16>> Yeah. Or after 3 days resurrect.
- 1:00:17>> Yeah, that's See, that's that's that's
- 1:00:18like an argument from silence, right?
- 1:00:20>> It's a good argument, but that's the
- 1:00:21point.
- 1:00:21>> I don't I don't think so because like
- 1:00:24for example, we we can point to
- 1:00:25individuals like Zechariah, for example,
- 1:00:27um Elizabeth and Mary, who who
- 1:00:30identified Jesus as their savior from
- 1:00:32their sins. And so, where are they
- 1:00:34getting this from? Revelation and the
- 1:00:36scriptures about the Messiah in Isaiah
- 1:00:3853, obviously, and other passages where
- 1:00:41the Messiah saves them from their sins
- 1:00:43uh through sacrifice.
- 1:00:44>> Lions.
- 1:00:44>> So,
- 1:00:45>> Cool.
- 1:00:46>> To put it up.
- 1:00:46>> Nothing Nothing here says that in Targum
- 1:00:48Jonathan. I don't
- 1:00:48>> Yes, it does.
- 1:00:49>> I don't I don't I I had it right here in
- 1:00:50front of me. I read it out for you.
- 1:00:51>> It's It's referring to the house of
- 1:00:52Israel. It's not referring to a single
- 1:00:54person.
- 1:00:54>> No, no, no, no. Please go to Targum
- 1:00:56Jonathan.
- 1:00:57>> Right, well, I don't know.
- 1:00:57>> Specifically.
- 1:00:58>> I have it. I'm reading verse 13, verse
- 1:01:0014, verse
- 1:01:01>> Give us the specific verse. Read it out
- 1:01:02for us.
- 1:01:02>> Yeah, yeah. Starting from what? Verse
- 1:01:0353?
- 1:01:04>> Are you Isaiah in Isaiah 52?
- 1:01:07>> Yeah. Is Isaiah 52, right?
- 1:01:08>> Yeah, Isaiah 52.
- 1:01:10>> Give us the specific verse.
- 1:01:11>> Verses 13 and 15.
- 1:01:12>> Yeah, yeah. So, so when it says "Just as
- 1:01:13many were appalled at him and so marred
- 1:01:15was his appearance," let's see what he
- 1:01:17has to say. "As the house of Israel."
- 1:01:19>> But
- 1:01:19>> It's in reference to a group of people
- 1:01:21in Targum Jonathan.
- 1:01:22>> No. Who does he refer to as the Messiah
- 1:01:24the servant?
- 1:01:24>> But that doesn't mean that this verse
- 1:01:26when the when it's referring to who is
- 1:01:27marred he said
- 1:01:28>> as the house of Israel.
- 1:01:29>> But no, no, he's saying the house of
- 1:01:31Israel is being marred.
- 1:01:33>> Let me read verses 13 in desire.
- 1:01:35>> Yeah.
- 1:01:36>> As the house of Israel anxiously hope
- 1:01:38for him any day which were not unlike
- 1:01:39the more their appearance and their
- 1:01:40brightness. Their appearance and their
- 1:01:41brightness.
- 1:01:41>> Can you read verses 13 What is it What
- 1:01:43is it their appearance and their
- 1:01:44>> Who does he say Who does he say the
- 1:01:46servant is?
- 1:01:46>> He says their appearance and their so
- 1:01:48it's a referring to plural group of
- 1:01:50people not one. So it's their appearance
- 1:01:52being marred not his appearance being
- 1:01:53marred.
- 1:01:54>> In in
- 1:01:54>> No, I don't think you understand what
- 1:01:55I'm saying.
- 1:01:55>> In verse 13
- 1:01:56>> No, no, you don't understand what I'm
- 1:01:57saying.
- 1:01:57>> Hold on. What does it say?
- 1:01:58>> Their appearance was marred is that
- 1:02:00there?
- 1:02:01>> In verse 13 who does he say it's about?
- 1:02:05>> He says that He says the the servant is
- 1:02:08the Messiah.
- 1:02:08>> Thank you.
- 1:02:09>> But he says what he does. I already the
- 1:02:12Hey, from the very beginning I said that
- 1:02:14Targum Jonathan does take Isaiah 53 to
- 1:02:16be about a Messiah but he never once
- 1:02:17attributes any suffering towards the
- 1:02:19Messiah.
- 1:02:21>> Who is the servant?
- 1:02:21>> The suffering is always attributed to
- 1:02:23the house of Israel in which Targum
- 1:02:25Jonathan either has the Messiah praying
- 1:02:27for them or advocating and intercessing
- 1:02:29for them but he's never he's never once
- 1:02:31partaking in the suffering. And
- 1:02:32scholarship also is
- 1:02:35I know it's the house of Israel.
- 1:02:37>> He really said as the house of Israel
- 1:02:38>> That's what it says their faces not his
- 1:02:40face. So I didn't say their face.
- 1:02:41>> He identified because one
- 1:02:43>> I didn't I didn't know the Messiah is a
- 1:02:45is a they/them.
- 1:02:45>> Well,
- 1:02:46well, I'm sorry you didn't know that but
- 1:02:48>> Oh, wait. So the Messiah is a they/them.
- 1:02:50>> According to the scripture actually you
- 1:02:51have the Messiah being identified as
- 1:02:53Israel. Did you know that?
- 1:02:55>> Did you know that?
- 1:02:55>> No, I'm just asking. Is it a they/them?
- 1:02:56>> So did you did you know that the Messiah
- 1:02:57is a Thank you. So with the Messiah
- 1:02:59being identified as Israel as itself
- 1:03:01Hold on. Let me finish. With I With
- 1:03:03Israel Well, Allah is a they/them.
- 1:03:06>> Nice two bouquets. Nice two bouquets.
- 1:03:08You don't believe in Allah like
- 1:03:09>> Good. Good job.
- 1:03:11>> Good job.
- 1:03:13>> Good job.
- 1:03:14>> Yeah, let's Yeah, let's Let's play this
- 1:03:15game, bro.
- 1:03:15>> The Messiah is a they/them.
- 1:03:17>> Yep.
- 1:03:17>> All right, and Allah is a he-they.
- 1:03:18>> All right.
- 1:03:19>> Fine. You got it.
- 1:03:20>> Yeah, I wanted it to bring you back to
- 1:03:21the other
- 1:03:21>> And Allah Allah, he might be a he-she.
- 1:03:23>> All right, cool. Can we can we talk
- 1:03:24about the other point now? So, when it
- 1:03:26comes to what he was saying, as we were
- 1:03:27saying before you guys were trying to
- 1:03:29read the verse, what he's saying is is
- 1:03:31that you guys just claimed that this is
- 1:03:32something which was clear in the
- 1:03:34scripture, Old Testament, New Testament,
- 1:03:36correct? Okay.
- 1:03:38If it was clear, we would expect that
- 1:03:40there's going to be at least an
- 1:03:42individual, a group of people, even if
- 1:03:44it's small. That's like the basis,
- 1:03:46that's based off of your understanding
- 1:03:48or your presupposition regarding what
- 1:03:50the text is saying.
- 1:03:50>> Zechariah. Zech-
- 1:03:52>> Yeah, thank you for proving my point.
- 1:03:53>> Yeah, the presupposing.
- 1:03:54>> I'm not presupposing. I can actually
- 1:03:55give you an example in the video.
- 1:03:56Zechariah only said
- 1:03:58>> That leads you to the answer.
- 1:03:59>> The
- 1:03:59>> No, I'm saying Zechariah in so far as a
- 1:04:02Messiah dying and resurrecting after 3
- 1:04:05days for the sake of your soul.
- 1:04:06>> Oh, so so this is what I I understand
- 1:04:08now. What you guys are asking for is
- 1:04:10where does an individual in our text
- 1:04:12verbatim say, "Hey, the Messiah is going
- 1:04:15to suffer and in 3 days rise again."
- 1:04:18>> I'm not saying in the text.
- 1:04:19>> Who read the text and came to that
- 1:04:20conclusion?
- 1:04:21>> Zechariah.
- 1:04:22>> Oh my god.
- 1:04:23>> Dude, that the Zechariah is the text.
- 1:04:25>> Zech- So, no, Zechariah is not the text,
- 1:04:27bro.
- 1:04:28>> He's a character from the New Testament.
- 1:04:30Two Zechariahs.
- 1:04:30>> I I understand what the we're talking
- 1:04:32about historical precedence of the
- 1:04:33interpretation.
- 1:04:34>> Zechariah.
- 1:04:36>> I'm going to say before the disciples,
- 1:04:37bro.
- 1:04:37>> Zechariah.
- 1:04:39>> [laughter]
- 1:04:39>> Zech- This is This is This Zechariah was
- 1:04:41there when Jesus was a baby. Do you know
- 1:04:42who Zechariah is?
- 1:04:43>> No, he is a Is it in the New Testament,
- 1:04:44right?
- 1:04:45>> about this. Yes.
- 1:04:45>> Which gospel Which gospel was it in?
- 1:04:47>> Luke.
- 1:04:47>> Right.
- 1:04:48>> Excellent.
- 1:04:50>> Again, Luke's writing is still post the
- 1:04:52resurrection.
- 1:04:53>> need a source.
- 1:04:54>> Let me finish. Let me finish.
- 1:04:55>> You think these gospels are going to say
- 1:04:57can't use
- 1:04:57>> Let me finish. If it's post the
- 1:04:58resurrection, then the argument still
- 1:05:00fails. Then you could have just went to
- 1:05:01the disciples.
- 1:05:01>> Oh, wait. Wait. So, because because the
- 1:05:03writing is post the resurrection, that
- 1:05:04means the argument it don't work cuz
- 1:05:06it's after the resurrection.
- 1:05:08>> So, because it's still post because it's
- 1:05:10still post resurrection
- 1:05:11>> Bye-bye history.
- 1:05:12>> Let me finish. But no, it's it's
- 1:05:14qualified.
- 1:05:14>> By by by as well I'm bad post
- 1:05:16resurrection.
- 1:05:16>> It's what it's qualified history.
- 1:05:17>> The Quran is post resurrection.
- 1:05:19>> Thank you for that homes. I'm going to
- 1:05:20respond now. So let me finish. Again,
- 1:05:22you went to a point that's about someone
- 1:05:24after the resurrection account which the
- 1:05:26critique already grants. The critique
- 1:05:29that I'm giving already allows for
- 1:05:31things after the resurrection of claims
- 1:05:33of the Messiah being on life. It already
- 1:05:35comes right. You could have just went to
- 1:05:36the disciples.
- 1:05:37>> No no what you just said is what I mean
- 1:05:38by player.
- 1:05:38>> Let me finish. You you could have just
- 1:05:40went to the disciples. That would have
- 1:05:41been the same critique, right? But
- 1:05:42that's the very thing in question. Who
- 1:05:45before the supposed resurrection
- 1:05:48interpreted as you did?
- 1:05:49>> Nobody.
- 1:05:50>> Notice what you did. You just went
- 1:05:51nuclear. Now we can know nothing about
- 1:05:53the historical Jesus cuz all our texts
- 1:05:55are post resurrection. So throw out
- 1:05:57Mark, throw out hypothesize Q, throw out
- 1:05:59John, the the texts you've been using
- 1:06:01here, throw out everything now. So you
- 1:06:03just destroyed your argument. You can't
- 1:06:05know anything about the historical
- 1:06:06Jesus.
- 1:06:06>> Beautiful. So I don't think you want to
- 1:06:07attack my critique specifically. My
- 1:06:09critique
- 1:06:09>> So we do the whole time.
- 1:06:10>> My critique is that the hypothesis that
- 1:06:12the Christ predicted is
- 1:06:14resurrection and crucifixion. And I
- 1:06:16hypothesize that this would have been
- 1:06:17explained away and reconciled
- 1:06:19by the Jews in order to better explain
- 1:06:21away the data. I'm saying that my
- 1:06:23explanation requires less
- 1:06:24presupposition. It's a very simple
- 1:06:25critique. Now, when you go and say well
- 1:06:27Zechariah believes this or Luke, Mark,
- 1:06:29Matthew, Luke believe this, this two
- 1:06:30post resurrection and the critique still
- 1:06:32fails. That doesn't mean I know I become
- 1:06:34an epistemic analyst regarding history.
- 1:06:35It means that it's qualified. So again,
- 1:06:38if it is the case that it is clearly the
- 1:06:40Old and New Testament, right? That this
- 1:06:42is supposed to happen, the crucifixion
- 1:06:43is supposed to happen, the resurrection
- 1:06:45is supposed to happen according to Luke
- 1:06:4624:46. It says that the scripture say
- 1:06:49the Messiah is supposed to be on life
- 1:06:50and raised back on the third day. How
- 1:06:52come we don't have any historical
- 1:06:53precedence of this? So it's expected.
- 1:06:55>> So so we can't use any sources posted
- 1:06:58the resurrection cuz they could just get
- 1:06:59it from the disciples after the fact.
- 1:07:00Great. Can't know anything about
- 1:07:01historical Jesus.
- 1:07:02>> So no no response. Wonderful.
- 1:07:04>> They got that from the disciples.
- 1:07:07>> So so what
- 1:07:08>> So all everything you use to argue for
- 1:07:10the historical Jesus is coming from the
- 1:07:11disciples post resurrection. So you're
- 1:07:13just cherry picking even our arguments.
- 1:07:15>> is the Quran says so.
- 1:07:16>> Yeah.
- 1:07:16>> It aligns with Islam.
- 1:07:18Yeah. If it doesn't align with Islam
- 1:07:21>> Where else do you get any claims about
- 1:07:22Jesus?
- 1:07:22>> Well we're not talking about
- 1:07:23>> That's different because we have we have
- 1:07:25we have
- 1:07:26not only historical justification, we
- 1:07:28have metaphysical justification because
- 1:07:30we can prove the Quran to be true. It's
- 1:07:31independent.
- 1:07:33>> [laughter]
- 1:07:34>> Okay.
- 1:07:34>> Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank
- 1:07:35you.
- 1:07:35>> Here we go. Thank you.
- 1:07:37>> So I got
- 1:07:38this is this is like a whole shift on
- 1:07:39the Quran. If you don't want to know why
- 1:07:41I believe the Quran to be true, we can
- 1:07:42have a discussion about that.
- 1:07:44>> It's post resurrection.
- 1:07:45>> Real quick. Real quick.
- 1:07:45>> It's post resurrection. It says so in
- 1:07:47the Quran.
- 1:07:48>> If you if you can show that the Mark,
- 1:07:50Matthew, Luke, and John are
- 1:07:51metaphysically true, sure you can try
- 1:07:54and do that. I'm I'm pretty sure you're
- 1:07:55going to fail. But if you can't
- 1:07:56demonstrate that it's going to be a
- 1:07:57symmetry break between how we believe
- 1:07:59the Quran to be true and why we believe
- 1:08:01the Bible to be false.
- 1:08:02>> Yeah. Very simple.
- 1:08:03>> So your argument is the Quran is true.
- 1:08:05Therefore anything we see in the gospels
- 1:08:06that agrees with the Quran is therefore
- 1:08:08true. If it doesn't, we reject it. So
- 1:08:10this is circular. This is circular.
- 1:08:12>> Can I can I respond? You you should be
- 1:08:14able to get any statements I'm going to
- 1:08:15use now. So there's a difference between
- 1:08:16for example historical certainty and
- 1:08:18metaphysical certainty. You would agree
- 1:08:20that metaphysical certainty grants us
- 1:08:22and yields higher probability, higher
- 1:08:24levels of certainty than merely
- 1:08:25historical certainty. You would agree
- 1:08:26with that.
- 1:08:27>> That's historical certainty.
- 1:08:28>> Let me
- 1:08:30let me finish. Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:08:31Thank you. So if we can
- 1:08:33what we're going off of the data we have
- 1:08:34is is the historical certainty regarding
- 1:08:36the
- 1:08:37Let me finish. Regarding the crucifixion
- 1:08:39and the resurrection, right? Is that Let
- 1:08:41me finish, bro. Control yourself. If we
- 1:08:42can show that this can be historically
- 1:08:44undermined, it has no clue to the Quran
- 1:08:46because when it comes to the Quran, we
- 1:08:47can have metaphysical certainty. We can
- 1:08:49prove Muhammad to be a true prophet of
- 1:08:50God and therefore the claims are going
- 1:08:52to be true. They're going to correspond
- 1:08:53to reality. There's a clear symmetry
- 1:08:55break. If you can show me that Mark,
- 1:08:57Matthew, Luke, and John are
- 1:08:57metaphysically true and certain, Then
- 1:09:00fine, this argument is done. But you
- 1:09:01can't do that.
- 1:09:02>> So now wake up, man. I know you went to
- 1:09:04sleep. over there. I I
- 1:09:05I know now it's about metaphysical
- 1:09:07reality.
- 1:09:10Well, okay. We're talking about
- 1:09:12historical. The is the Quran give you
- 1:09:14historical certainty on the on the life
- 1:09:17of Jesus?
- 1:09:17>> The Quran is not historical looking at
- 1:09:18our Jesus.
- 1:09:19>> Okay, so you can't So so you can't use
- 1:09:21the Quran So you can't use the Quran to
- 1:09:23get historical information from Jesus.
- 1:09:25True historical information as a ground.
- 1:09:26>> You get you get the details about Jesus
- 1:09:28because we attain metaphysical
- 1:09:29certainty.
- 1:09:30>> From what what from What is your
- 1:09:31historical source that you use for it?
- 1:09:33Cuz you just you just said it's not
- 1:09:34>> Let me clarify my position.
- 1:09:36We don't believe This is very clear. Do
- 1:09:38not believe that the Quran is historical
- 1:09:41looking at our Jesus. That's insane.
- 1:09:42>> Does it make historical claims about
- 1:09:43Jesus?
- 1:09:43>> Wait. Wait. It makes claims and the way
- 1:09:45that we verify these claims is because
- 1:09:47we can ascertain metaphysical certainty.
- 1:09:49>> Okay, but okay, I've got you because you
- 1:09:51believe it's from God. But that's not my
- 1:09:53So you don't do it historically.
- 1:09:54>> Yeah, so you got We We We Wait. Wait.
- 1:09:55Hold on.
- 1:09:56>> There's no historical evidence for
- 1:09:57>> Did we ever say real quick? Real quick.
- 1:09:59[laughter] Real quick. Did we ever say
- 1:10:00Let me show you the difference now. Did
- 1:10:01we ever say that the Quran is historical
- 1:10:02looking at Jesus? Did we ever say that?
- 1:10:04>> It can't be.
- 1:10:04>> No. Is the Are the Gospels historical
- 1:10:06looking
- 1:10:06>> Wait. Wait. Can it be?
- 1:10:07>> If no.
- 1:10:08>> Does the Quran make historical claims
- 1:10:10>> Wait. Wait.
- 1:10:13>> Does it make historical claims on Jesus?
- 1:10:15Yes or no?
- 1:10:16>> I got you. The Quran makes claims about
- 1:10:19Jesus. Let me Let me finish up. And the
- 1:10:21reason that we can attain certainty
- 1:10:24>> I just asked if it makes historical
- 1:10:25claims on Jesus. Yes or no?
- 1:10:27>> I'm about to answer you, bro. So it's
- 1:10:28very simple. The Quran makes claims
- 1:10:30about Jesus. This is how I'm going to
- 1:10:31answer you. Let Let me finish, bro. Same
- 1:10:33thing with Abraham, no Moses, Noah,
- 1:10:35Jacob. If you mean by historical that
- 1:10:37the Quran claims that it's
- 1:10:39contemporary to Jesus, then no.
- 1:10:41>> I didn't say that.
- 1:10:42>> [laughter]
- 1:10:43>> 45
- 1:10:43>> history
- 1:10:44>> Let me finish. Let
- 1:10:45>> contemporary to the person
- 1:10:46>> Just let me finish. But if you mean by
- 1:10:47historical that it makes claims about a
- 1:10:50person who's called Jesus, then yes, it
- 1:10:52does do that.
- 1:10:53>> Okay, how do you corroborate those those
- 1:10:55claims historically?
- 1:10:55>> Let me finish up. Again, I am the I've
- 1:10:58never claimed that the Quran gives us
- 1:11:00historical certainty regarding these
- 1:11:02texts. What I said was is that it gives
- 1:11:04us metaphysical certainty. Let Let me So
- 1:11:05>> So hold on, bro. You you got to let me
- 1:11:07No, no, no. Bro, you keep going on and
- 1:11:09on and on. You got to let us engage in a
- 1:11:10rapport with what you're saying.
- 1:11:11>> I'm going to I'm answering. I can finish
- 1:11:13the objective and you can respond.
- 1:11:14>> Oh, please, like in 30 seconds, man.
- 1:11:15>> Let Let me show you the difference
- 1:11:16between what I'm saying and what they're
- 1:11:17saying. You guys are claiming that the
- 1:11:19resurrection, the crucifixion, they are
- 1:11:21historical to Christ. The passion
- 1:11:24prediction that is historical to Christ.
- 1:11:26Not merely that they're going to be
- 1:11:28something that can
- 1:11:29be proven metaphysically to be true,
- 1:11:31right? The difference is I am not
- 1:11:33claiming that. I am As a Muslim, I'm not
- 1:11:35claiming that the Quran is historical to
- 1:11:37Jesus. What I'm saying is is that its
- 1:11:39claims regarding things that we don't
- 1:11:40have epistemic access to can be verified
- 1:11:43metaphysically because we have
- 1:11:44independent reason to believe Islam is
- 1:11:46true. It's very simple.
- 1:11:47>> pause there. Thank you. So, can the
- 1:11:49claims that the Quran makes about Jesus,
- 1:11:50the historical Jesus, can they be
- 1:11:52historically verified? Yes or no?
- 1:11:54>> Uh no, they don't.
- 1:11:55>> Thank you. Okay.
- 1:11:58So so what we
- 1:11:59>> Go ahead. Finish up. Finish up.
- 1:12:00>> So so No, no, no.
- 1:12:02Thank you.
- 1:12:04>> THAT'S THAT'S MY POSITION, BROTHER.
- 1:12:06>> RELAX, GUYS. RELAX.
- 1:12:08We're just talking.
- 1:12:09>> Did we Did we forget the topic?
- 1:12:10[laughter]
- 1:12:11>> We forgot the topic now?
- 1:12:13>> We just had to be a little bit attached.
- 1:12:15That's all. So, where are we So, where
- 1:12:17we are now cuz I just I just wanted to
- 1:12:19make sure we all
- 1:12:21attached.
- 1:12:22>> Hey, man, what's the topic?
- 1:12:22>> It's It's my habibti. It's my
- 1:12:24>> Hey, you're from the Isma.
- 1:12:26>> Watch yourself. Your habibti is over
- 1:12:27there.
- 1:12:29>> [laughter]
- 1:12:30>> All right, bro.
- 1:12:30>> All right, look. So, where we're at what
- 1:12:32we what we just established is that you
- 1:12:35as Muslims, using your paradigm with the
- 1:12:37Quran, have no historical basis on the
- 1:12:40life of Jesus. The historical claims
- 1:12:43that the Quran makes cannot be
- 1:12:44historically verified. And so therefore,
- 1:12:47the Quran is
- 1:12:49out of the out of the equation.
- 1:12:50>> Beautiful argument.
- 1:12:52Hold on. Hold on. Is that I don't I
- 1:12:53didn't mean that disrespect, bro.
- 1:12:55>> No, you're good.
- 1:12:55>> Okay. So, it's it's just out of the
- 1:12:57equation, right? Put to the side cuz it
- 1:12:59cannot be historically verified. Yet, it
- 1:13:02makes historical claims on Jesus. So,
- 1:13:04now where we're at is is that you're
- 1:13:06using our book that gives you historical
- 1:13:10claims and historical corroboration on
- 1:13:12the life of Jesus. And so, when your
- 1:13:14Quran makes claims that's opposite to
- 1:13:16the historical source, guess who's
- 1:13:18wrong?
- 1:13:18>> Beautiful.
- 1:13:19>> Your Quran.
- 1:13:20>> Beautiful.
- 1:13:20>> we see from the historical sources,
- 1:13:22Jesus was crucified. From the historical
- 1:13:24sources, Jesus was resurrected. From the
- 1:13:26historical sources, Jesus teaches that
- 1:13:28the that that the Father, Son, and Holy
- 1:13:29Spirit are one in essence and one God.
- 1:13:32>> That's got an argument.
- 1:13:33>> Exactly. But but the historical sources
- 1:13:35teach that.
- 1:13:36>> Let me Let me Let me adjust that. So,
- 1:13:37real quick. Notice, for example, with
- 1:13:38Christians, Avery IP, what they believe
- 1:13:41is that
- 1:13:43well, that they that Adam and Eve
- 1:13:45existed, right? But how do Christians
- 1:13:47verify that Adam and Eve existed? You do
- 1:13:50it through metaphysical certainty by
- 1:13:52proving that Moses and his prophets are
- 1:13:54true prophets, right, Bo?
- 1:13:55>> Sure.
- 1:13:55>> Good. So, although
- 1:13:57the Bible makes historical claims about
- 1:13:59Adam and Eve, they're unverifyable. But
- 1:14:02guess what? Guess why Muslims don't
- 1:14:04don't jump in and say, "Hey, that's bad.
- 1:14:06You can't actually verify that Adam and
- 1:14:07Eve existed." I'm about to land. We say
- 1:14:08that this can still be true because you
- 1:14:10can have metaphysical certainty. When it
- 1:14:12comes to epistemology, there's different
- 1:14:13ways of ascertaining the knowledge. It
- 1:14:15can be through historicity or it can be
- 1:14:16verifying the means or the sources of
- 1:14:18the person speaking. If he's a true
- 1:14:19prophet, we can believe his claims about
- 1:14:21Adam and Eve. If he's not a true
- 1:14:22prophet, we don't have to believe him.
- 1:14:24It would be different if I as a Muslim
- 1:14:25came and said, "Hey, the Quran is a
- 1:14:27historical document about Jesus and it's
- 1:14:29historically verifiable." Guess what,
- 1:14:30Avery? That's not the claim. The claim
- 1:14:32is that
- 1:14:33Let me finish. The claim is is that
- 1:14:35we're saying that the Quran can be can
- 1:14:37give us certainty metaphysically by
- 1:14:39verifying the source. Now, the reason
- 1:14:41why this is different is because you are
- 1:14:43on the fence. You believe that the
- 1:14:45resurrection and the quote-unquote
- 1:14:47passion predictions are historical.
- 1:14:49>> And metaphysically certain.
- 1:14:50>> Yes. Okay, prove it.
- 1:14:51>> Oh.
- 1:14:51>> No, okay.
- 1:14:52>> Prove it.
- 1:14:54>> Cuz what you said was really important.
- 1:14:55You're bringing up you're comparing the
- 1:14:57fact that we can't verify Adam and Eve
- 1:14:59and Moses existed except through
- 1:15:01metaphysics. Fine. The difference is
- 1:15:03that the Quran is not is not just not
- 1:15:06being able to verify historical Jesus,
- 1:15:09it's completely contradicting historical
- 1:15:11Jesus.
- 1:15:11>> Exactly.
- 1:15:15>> The Bible is not contradicting
- 1:15:17historical Adam, Eve, and Moses. It's
- 1:15:20just ambiguous and you cannot verify it.
- 1:15:22That's the difference. So, you can't
- 1:15:23bring that example.
- 1:15:24>> is where we are. Adam and Eve, there's
- 1:15:26no issue
- 1:15:27about the stories. Why? Because we can't
- 1:15:29we don't have epistemic access, right?
- 1:15:31>> Sure.
- 1:15:31>> Beautiful.
- 1:15:32>> That was your argument.
- 1:15:32>> Beautiful. Now, I'm saying the same
- 1:15:34thing about Jesus. We do not have
- 1:15:36epistemic access and actually we can
- 1:15:37give arguments to why the quote unquote
- 1:15:39the son of man sayings and the
- 1:15:41predictions and the
- 1:15:42quote unquote crucifixion resurrection,
- 1:15:44they're also historical. So, guess what?
- 1:15:46Adam and Eve are on the
- 1:15:47>> This conversation is over.
- 1:15:48>> Let me finish.
- 1:15:48>> You
- 1:15:50just said
- 1:15:51YOU DON'T HAVE FAITH.
- 1:15:51>> LET ME FINISH.
- 1:15:52>> BUT now you're saying you can don't have
- 1:15:54faith.
- 1:15:54>> Let me finish.
- 1:15:55Hold on. Hold on. So, the same way they
- 1:15:57have the same way they have don't have
- 1:15:58epistemic access to Adam and Eve to
- 1:16:00verify whether or not the Bible
- 1:16:01contradicts them, is the same exact way
- 1:16:03where the passion predictions don't have
- 1:16:06historical attestation and therefore
- 1:16:08they're on the same level.
- 1:16:08>> So, what passion
- 1:16:09>> Exactly.
- 1:16:10>> So, is he trying to say that it doesn't
- 1:16:11have historical attestation?
- 1:16:12>> That's what he's saying.
- 1:16:13>> Right.
- 1:16:13>> So, so so notice so notice how
- 1:16:16>> We just had to we just had to do this.
- 1:16:17>> So,
- 1:16:18the prediction Wait, I just want to
- 1:16:19clarify something. Sorry. What The
- 1:16:21passion doesn't have attestation or what
- 1:16:23does it
- 1:16:24>> The passion predictions predictions.
- 1:16:25>> predictions
- 1:16:26>> Right.
- 1:16:27>> It's that the authors insert that into
- 1:16:29the mouth of Jesus. It's not that they
- 1:16:31authors
- 1:16:31>> When you have Christ saying that, "Hey
- 1:16:33guys, I'm going to be unalived and
- 1:16:34resurrected." This is a historical.
- 1:16:36Right.
- 1:16:37>> What what what are you talking
- 1:16:39about?
- 1:16:39>> You would historical Jesus
- 1:16:41>> Because you didn't quote it. I got you.
- 1:16:43>> No, no, no. I turn to talk.
- 1:16:44>> You said we can know the historical
- 1:16:46Jesus didn't teach the Trinity. But now
- 1:16:49you're saying we can't know anything
- 1:16:50about the historical Jesus. All these
- 1:16:52sources are post-resurrection. We can't
- 1:16:54use any of them. So again, you just go
- 1:16:56back to well, we we don't think Jesus
- 1:16:57did because we're metaphysically certain
- 1:16:59about the Quran, therefore he didn't.
- 1:17:00Circular.
- 1:17:01>> Go ahead. Notice how they didn't adjust
- 1:17:02the argument from historicity. Oh, well
- 1:17:03they
- 1:17:04Real quick, let let let let
- 1:17:05>> How are we
- 1:17:06How are we
- 1:17:06>> How are we doing this?
- 1:17:07>> It's okay. It's okay, Brian. We're going
- 1:17:08to get through this.
- 1:17:09>> All we have is
- 1:17:10All we have is is you guys saying,
- 1:17:12"Well, hold on now. You went to the
- 1:17:14argument of the sayings of Christ
- 1:17:16post-resurrection. Guess what? If we
- 1:17:18argue about the historical Christ and we
- 1:17:20can give a case to what a historical
- 1:17:21Christ saying of Christ after
- 1:17:23resurrection a historical, then the
- 1:17:25argument would follow. It's very simple.
- 1:17:26So therefore, this is why we went down
- 1:17:28the whole trail of proving that the
- 1:17:30statements and sayings of Christ
- 1:17:31post-resurrection are ahistorical. Guess
- 1:17:33what?
- 1:17:33>> Based on what?
- 1:17:35>> Based on the arguments that I gave that
- 1:17:37the expectation if if this if they saw a
- 1:17:40historical crucifixion and a
- 1:17:41resurrection, it would increase them in
- 1:17:42belief.
- 1:17:42>> So So if No, no, no, you asked me a
- 1:17:44question. Because they didn't believe
- 1:17:46it, therefore it's not historical?
- 1:17:47>> That's
- 1:17:48Because we would expect for them to be
- 1:17:50increased in belief and because we would
- 1:17:52>> According to who?
- 1:17:53>> Let me Let me land, bro. Let See, please
- 1:17:55>> Well, you've been talking this whole
- 1:17:56time.
- 1:17:56>> The thing is you can't ask me a question
- 1:17:57then don't let me speak. Now you can't
- 1:17:58do that. Please, right? So because we
- 1:18:00know that it would increase them in
- 1:18:02belief, right? And because we know that
- 1:18:04um
- 1:18:06all the Jews prior to Christ, they
- 1:18:08didn't believe in this expectation. What
- 1:18:09I must say is supposed to be unaware of
- 1:18:10this raising on the third day.
- 1:18:11Therefore, we can make a good argument
- 1:18:13from silence that if if it did teach
- 1:18:14that, we would expect evidence. So we
- 1:18:16don't have evidence, therefore we didn't
- 1:18:18teach that.
- 1:18:18>> So let's go back then to the the very
- 1:18:20beginning.
- 1:18:21>> Right.
- 1:18:21>> What sources do we use to find the
- 1:18:23historical Jesus?
- 1:18:25>> Right. So probably when comes to
- 1:18:26something that is before the
- 1:18:27resurrection, it'll be more reliable,
- 1:18:29right?
- 1:18:29>> What sources?
- 1:18:31>> Can we both be clear?
- 1:18:32>> What What sources for history?
- 1:18:35>> We mentioned Q. And
- 1:18:36>> So Q [laughter] is Q Let me finish. Let
- 1:18:38me finish.
- 1:18:39>> Q
- 1:18:40Can you let me finish?
- 1:18:42I don't even know. No. Can Can I finish?
- 1:18:44Thank you. So, we can do we can still
- 1:18:46use Mark, Matthew, and John, right? So,
- 1:18:48for example, when you have the
- 1:18:49statements of Christ doing something
- 1:18:50that can be corroborated, right? There
- 1:18:52is no issue with that. But, I'm saying
- 1:18:54that these statements post-resurrection
- 1:18:55have to be ahistorical due to this
- 1:18:57argument, which you still can't address.
- 1:18:59>> So, can we use Q to find the historical
- 1:19:01Jesus then, according to you?
- 1:19:02>> Yeah.
- 1:19:03>> Finally. Thank you. All right.
- 1:19:05>> Let's go after all of that.
- 1:19:06>> So, in [laughter] So, you would you
- 1:19:08would say that Jesus
- 1:19:11uh you would say that Allah sent Jesus
- 1:19:13as a prophet, right?
- 1:19:14>> Right.
- 1:19:15>> Okay.
- 1:19:16Who sends prophets? Allah?
- 1:19:18>> Uh according to Isla- Islamic theology
- 1:19:20and Islamic understanding, yes. That's
- 1:19:21all.
- 1:19:21>> Okay, great. Why in Q, according to all
- 1:19:23the reconstructions like John
- 1:19:24Kloppenborg, does Jesus in Q say, "I
- 1:19:27send you prophets and sages, and you
- 1:19:28will kill some of them." So, you've just
- 1:19:30acknowledged that according to Q, Jesus
- 1:19:31would be Allah.
- 1:19:33>> That was tough.
- 1:19:33>> You want to spell it out?
- 1:19:34>> Sorry, what reference are you referring
- 1:19:35to?
- 1:19:35>> That's in Q. I can pull it up. Do you
- 1:19:36want me to? I'm going to try
- 1:19:37Where did you say? You said that uh
- 1:19:39>> That in Q, Jesus Jesus uh says that he's
- 1:19:42the one who sends uh you
- 1:19:44>> Yeah. Uh so, this is in Jordan and John
- 1:19:46Kloppenborg, Q 11:49-51.
- 1:19:48Therefore, also, uh I will send them
- 1:19:51prophets and sages, and some of them
- 1:19:52they will kill and persecute.
- 1:19:54>> So, it's saying So, Jesus is the one who
- 1:19:55sends prophets according to your Islamic
- 1:19:57theology. Obviously, it's God who sends
- 1:19:59prophets. So, would you agree that Jesus
- 1:20:01is claiming to be God as he's the one
- 1:20:02who sends the prophets?
- 1:20:03>> wouldn't follow because what you're
- 1:20:04saying is Is that What you're saying is
- 1:20:05that we have Islamic theology, and
- 1:20:07because it's not compatible with Islamic
- 1:20:08theology, this was happening. Therefore,
- 1:20:10must be compatible with trinitarian
- 1:20:11theology. What he's What What we have to
- 1:20:13take into account is is that there's a
- 1:20:15bunch more theology within that that it
- 1:20:17can still be compatible with, and guess
- 1:20:19what? It doesn't increase the
- 1:20:20probability of straight prophets. Let me
- 1:20:21finish. Let me finish. And it doesn't
- 1:20:23increase probability of trinitarian
- 1:20:24theology. So,
- 1:20:25>> prophets?
- 1:20:25>> Let me finish. Let me land.
- 1:20:26>> I thought you did.
- 1:20:27>> I already answered that word. I don't
- 1:20:28know why you're asking again.
- 1:20:28>> You said God, right?
- 1:20:29>> I already answered. Why ask again?
- 1:20:30>> So, if Jesus says, "I send prophets."
- 1:20:31Who does that make So, again, just
- 1:20:33because Just let me finish. Just because
- 1:20:35you believe that's incompatible with
- 1:20:36Islamic theology,
- 1:20:38it then doesn't follow that it must be
- 1:20:39compatible with Trinitarian theology.
- 1:20:41>> Let's do this Let's do this now.
- 1:20:45>> Phase one.
- 1:20:45>> Who sends the prophets?
- 1:20:47>> He's going to what? He's going to
- 1:20:48explain it to you.
- 1:20:48>> Right. So, you can explain it and then
- 1:20:49again, I can speak after. Go ahead.
- 1:20:50>> Who sends the prophets?
- 1:20:51>> God. McDogan.
- 1:20:52>> Who sends them?
- 1:20:53>> Who said Allah sends them?
- 1:20:54>> God. Okay.
- 1:20:55>> He has God sends the prophets.
- 1:20:56>> Yep. God sends the prophets.
- 1:20:58>> Who said that he sends the prophets?
- 1:20:59>> Well, Jesus said it.
- 1:20:59>> Jesus said he sends the prophets.
- 1:21:00Therefore, Jesus is God.
- 1:21:02>> Therefore. Therefore.
- 1:21:04What's that?
- 1:21:04>> Q the quote.
- 1:21:05>> John It's in John.
- 1:21:06>> So, according to Q, Jesus
- 1:21:08>> I'm going to get to the Q I saw. I'm
- 1:21:09going to I'm going to respond now.
- 1:21:10>> So, again,
- 1:21:11>> Hold on. Let's let me clear up here.
- 1:21:12>> All right.
- 1:21:13>> Yeah.
- 1:21:13>> Q Q 11:49-51.
- 1:21:15>> So, Jesus teaches his divinity even in
- 1:21:16the Q source that you guys say is the
- 1:21:18historical information we can get.
- 1:21:19>> And now you guys are rejecting it.
- 1:21:20>> You guys
- 1:21:21I'm accepting it.
- 1:21:22>> Wait. Let's have a rejection.
- 1:21:23>> No, I I accept this argument that you're
- 1:21:24giving me. I'm about to respond to it.
- 1:21:26>> Accept Q?
- 1:21:26>> Right. I don't know what
- 1:21:28>> Okay. You can just go ahead.
- 1:21:28>> So, again, the argument being made is
- 1:21:29that Christ does some of the things that
- 1:21:31God does. Okay? Now, just because you
- 1:21:34show that this is incompatible with
- 1:21:36Islamic theology,
- 1:21:38we're not talking about Islam.
- 1:21:39>> You just asked me who sends prophets. I
- 1:21:41didn't say in Islam. What I just asked
- 1:21:42when I broke down the verses. I'll do it
- 1:21:43again.
- 1:21:44>> Who sends the prophets?
- 1:21:46>> Are you asking a Muslim?
- 1:21:46>> I'm asking you.
- 1:21:47>> As a Muslim,
- 1:21:48>> No, no. Just period.
- 1:21:49>> Wait. Wait. What?
- 1:21:49>> Just period.
- 1:21:51>> Who sends the prophets?
- 1:21:51>> I will ask you as a Muslim.
- 1:21:53>> Who sends the prophets?
- 1:21:53>> He spoke. I'm going to make my argument.
- 1:21:55He spoke already. You made the argument.
- 1:21:56So, again, obviously he's asking me as a
- 1:21:57Muslim. So, obviously as a Muslim, I'm
- 1:21:59going to say that God ultimately sends
- 1:22:01prophets. But we can understand
- 1:22:03>> So, by your understanding, this would be
- 1:22:04a divine work.
- 1:22:04>> So, I I need Yeah. I'm coming with to
- 1:22:05finish off.
- 1:22:06I'm about I'm about to land the point.
- 1:22:08So, when we have other theologies, such
- 1:22:10as Arians and other non-Trinitarians
- 1:22:13that they would argue that this is found
- 1:22:14within their model of their belief and
- 1:22:17it would entail {quote} {unquote}
- 1:22:18>> But it wouldn't be.
- 1:22:19>> Let me Let's Let me finish.
- 1:22:20>> Right.
- 1:22:20>> And because it's compatible with their
- 1:22:22belief through agency or for example,
- 1:22:25for example, what God says that God can
- 1:22:26give sins and you have people forgiving
- 1:22:28sins. It doesn't work. That doesn't mean
- 1:22:29that they're now God. It doesn't work.
- 1:22:31>> So, let me finish, bro. So, because you
- 1:22:33showed that it's incompatible with
- 1:22:34Islamic theology, it doesn't mean that
- 1:22:36it raise the probability of it being
- 1:22:37compatible with Unitarian theology.
- 1:22:38>> No, no, can we can we agree here that
- 1:22:41the Jesus the historical Jesus is
- 1:22:42teaching opposite of Islamic theology?
- 1:22:45>> It doesn't mean that he's Yahweh,
- 1:22:46though.
- 1:22:46>> No, no,
- 1:22:47so just to be clear, so the historical
- 1:22:49Jesus teaches something
- 1:22:51>> Hold on. Hold on. Hold on.
- 1:22:52>> I'll pull up the citation.
- 1:22:53>> So, so the historical Jesus teaches
- 1:22:55something against Islamic theology,
- 1:22:56correct?
- 1:22:57>> I don't believe that he can still be
- 1:22:58reconciled with Islamic theology. That
- 1:22:59he simply
- 1:23:00>> Oh, so it does go with Islamic theology.
- 1:23:02>> Right. Of course he can be an agent of
- 1:23:03Allah. An agent of God. That sounds
- 1:23:05perfect.
- 1:23:05>> So, in Islamic theology, an agent of
- 1:23:07Allah can send prophets?
- 1:23:08>> No, no, again, it's very simple.
- 1:23:09>> No, no, yes, no, yes, yes, no, no, yes,
- 1:23:11no.
- 1:23:12>> Bro, it's religion. It's the fourth,
- 1:23:13man.
- 1:23:13>> It's like It's like you don't want to
- 1:23:14answer.
- 1:23:15>> Bro, you're you're giving me multiple
- 1:23:16>> It's like you don't want to answer.
- 1:23:17>> Somebody can be
- 1:23:18>> So, someone can be an agent, right? And
- 1:23:20Allah is the one that's the ultimate
- 1:23:22cause behind this specific thing that's
- 1:23:23sending the prophets, right? But he can
- 1:23:25ask it He can ask God to do that. It's
- 1:23:26very simple.
- 1:23:27>> So, can in your in Islamic theology, can
- 1:23:29anyone other than Allah in agent Just
- 1:23:31one second. Can an agent of Allah send
- 1:23:34prophets?
- 1:23:35>> If the agent says request God to send
- 1:23:37the prophet as an agent
- 1:23:39>> He doesn't say that.
- 1:23:40He doesn't say
- 1:23:41>> It says the wisdom of God.
- 1:23:42>> I'll do it again.
- 1:23:42>> He's quoting one specific scholar on
- 1:23:44their specific understanding of Q. It's
- 1:23:46not the actual Q.
- 1:23:47>> It is. It is.
- 1:23:48>> No, it's not
- 1:23:48>> And and guess what?
- 1:23:49>> For it to be in Q, it has to be both
- 1:23:50found in Matthew and in Luke. It's only
- 1:23:52in Matthew.
- 1:23:52>> I got you. So, I'm sorry.
- 1:23:54>> It's not even in Q.
- 1:23:55>> According to the Q source, he says
- 1:23:57>> He's quoting John Kloppenborg.
- 1:23:58>> He says that he's So, John Kloppenborg's
- 1:24:00unreliable.
- 1:24:00>> No, no, is he unreliable?
- 1:24:02>> Because when John Kloppenborg
- 1:24:03reconstructs Q, he doesn't just
- 1:24:04reconstruct it strictly from the
- 1:24:06doublets of Matthew and Luke, but he
- 1:24:08also assumes sometimes from the same
- 1:24:10like if it has a theology that can be
- 1:24:11found in Q, then he'll be like, "Yeah,
- 1:24:13just even so that Luke omitted this or
- 1:24:15Matthew omitted it, it could possibly
- 1:24:17still be found in Q." But it's still in
- 1:24:19Q.
- 1:24:20>> No, I don't agree.
- 1:24:20>> Okay, so now we don't know what's in Q.
- 1:24:21Now we don't know what's in Q.
- 1:24:23>> IT IS.
- 1:24:25>> THERE'S SO MANY DIFFERENT
- 1:24:26RECONSTRUCTIONS
- 1:24:27>> UNDERSTANDING, OKAY, LOOK, I'll give you
- 1:24:28my understanding then. It's what's
- 1:24:29double referenced in Matthew and Luke
- 1:24:30independently. But this isn't double
- 1:24:32referenced in Matthew and Luke
- 1:24:33independently. It's double referenced.
- 1:24:34Okay, but the way it's referenced in
- 1:24:35Luke is that it's the wisdom of God.
- 1:24:37It's not Jesus who sends us.
- 1:24:38>> Okay, wait. So so whose wisdom?
- 1:24:41>> Uh it depends on what it's depending on
- 1:24:42what.
- 1:24:43>> Like
- 1:24:43>> Okay,
- 1:24:44therefore also wisdom said, "I." So
- 1:24:47wisdom is a person speaking saying that
- 1:24:49they're the ones who
- 1:24:50>> See this how wisdom teaches in his Q.
- 1:24:52Jesus is a wisdom teacher in his
- 1:24:53>> So is wisdom Jesus?
- 1:24:54>> teaches himself.
- 1:24:55>> Okay, I'll ask it again. Whose wisdom?
- 1:24:58>> Wisdom wisdom uh it depends on like if
- 1:25:00you're if you're speaking on it from
- 1:25:02like the Old Testament language that
- 1:25:03could be like a like a like a power of
- 1:25:06God.
- 1:25:07>> So who is it because it's not just a
- 1:25:09a power and it
- 1:25:10>> Well, Jesus is a wisdom teacher
- 1:25:11>> So then whose the whose wisdom speaking?
- 1:25:14>> Who is a he's a teacher himself.
- 1:25:15>> So whose wisdom whose wisdom
- 1:25:17>> What else do you have person with the
- 1:25:18argument?
- 1:25:18>> Yeah, I don't know whose
- 1:25:19>> I don't see the
- 1:25:19>> personhood is that the is that wisdom is
- 1:25:21claiming to be the one who sends or
- 1:25:22prophets and and is interacting with
- 1:25:25Israel in real time in history. No, it's
- 1:25:27not just like in Proverbs. In Proverbs
- 1:25:29is
- 1:25:29>> No, like when David's spirit speaks as
- 1:25:31well. It doesn't mean that David's
- 1:25:32spirit is a whole separate on
- 1:25:34whole spirit with the
- 1:25:35>> That's Psalm is language. That's poetry
- 1:25:36language.
- 1:25:38You don't have this on wisdom poetry
- 1:25:40language
- 1:25:41wisdom poetry You don't have this. You
- 1:25:42don't have this poetry language.
- 1:25:44>> How do you know that? How do you
- 1:25:45>> Can I can I finish? It's called context.
- 1:25:47So in the in the context
- 1:25:50Who's the one speaking saying that
- 1:25:51they're going to send the prophets?
- 1:25:53>> Uh I'm not That doesn't undermine it
- 1:25:54being poetic.
- 1:25:55>> Who answered the question?
- 1:25:56>> Yeah, I'm saying it doesn't undermine it
- 1:25:57being poetic.
- 1:25:58>> Who's the one speaking?
- 1:26:00>> Which verse? I don't know what verse it
- 1:26:01is.
- 1:26:02>> I
- 1:26:02>> No, we can't even
- 1:26:03>> Jesus is a wisdom He can be a teacher
- 1:26:05because it's NOT DOUBLE REFERENCED.
- 1:26:08>> WE DON'T KNOW WHAT Q IS. WE DON'T KNOW
- 1:26:10what Jesus said. We don't know what
- 1:26:11wisdom is.
- 1:26:12>> We know nothing anymore. Let's argue it
- 1:26:13out.
- 1:26:13>> Okay, double reference. All things have
- 1:26:15been handed over to me by my father and
- 1:26:17no one knows
- 1:26:18>> acceptable. We That's That's totally
- 1:26:20>> Holy things?
- 1:26:21>> If he's handed over things, that doesn't
- 1:26:23mean he's not allowed to give us Come
- 1:26:24on.
- 1:26:25>> All things have been handed over to me
- 1:26:27by my father and no one knows the son
- 1:26:29except the father and no one knows the
- 1:26:31father except the son and anyone to whom
- 1:26:34>> And whoever the son chooses to reveal,
- 1:26:36right.
- 1:26:36>> That does not sound Trinitarian at all.
- 1:26:38>> So, whoever the son chooses to reveal to
- 1:26:40now, do they now know the father?
- 1:26:42>> Yep.
- 1:26:43>> Right. So, what do you mean it's not
- 1:26:44Trinitarian at all? I mean humans can
- 1:26:45have the exact same knowledge that the
- 1:26:47that the son has.
- 1:26:48>> Okay, but
- 1:26:49can
- 1:26:50>> I'm saying it's not Trinitarian at all.
- 1:26:52>> How Why is How is it not?
- 1:26:53>> Because whatever whatever the son gives
- 1:26:55whatever the son If I chose to reveal to
- 1:26:57Brian DeVille right now, now Brian
- 1:26:58DeVille now knows the father.
- 1:27:00>> Yeah, but but hold on.
- 1:27:01>> So, what How is that Trinitarian?
- 1:27:03Is he Is he Does he have some special
- 1:27:04divine relationship to Yahweh now?
- 1:27:06>> Can I answer you?
- 1:27:07>> Yeah.
- 1:27:07>> Okay. Would you So, according to the
- 1:27:09verse
- 1:27:09>> You don't answer me. You ask me a
- 1:27:10question.
- 1:27:10>> I I am. I'm not even I'm not even asking
- 1:27:12you a question. Just listen and pay
- 1:27:14attention.
- 1:27:14>> You'll be able to catch up.
- 1:27:16>> According to the verse, Jesus says, "All
- 1:27:18things that the father has in mind,
- 1:27:20right? No one knows No one knows the son
- 1:27:24except the father and no one knows the
- 1:27:26father except the son and whom the son
- 1:27:29chooses to reveal him." So, the one who
- 1:27:31makes the father known to individuals is
- 1:27:33the son. He's the only one who can bring
- 1:27:35this knowledge of the father.
- 1:27:37>> But he has no will of his own. It's not
- 1:27:38that he's just doing it on his own
- 1:27:39accord. The father directly told him to
- 1:27:41do it and Jesus being a good agent
- 1:27:43follows the father.
- 1:27:44>> How do people come to knowledge of the
- 1:27:46son?
- 1:27:46>> Because the son chose to reveal it.
- 1:27:48>> No, nope. Jesus says that no one comes
- 1:27:50to the son unless it's the father who
- 1:27:52draws him. So, we see there's a mutual
- 1:27:54revelation. It's the son who reveals the
- 1:27:56father and it's the father who reveals
- 1:27:58the son. Why? Because there's a unique
- 1:28:00divine relationship between father and
- 1:28:02son that nobody has.
- 1:28:03>> I don't know if that's a big stretch,
- 1:28:04right?
- 1:28:04>> Oh, really? Okay. So, can you give me an
- 1:28:06example where somebody else can go
- 1:28:08Matter of fact, let me just let me just
- 1:28:10uh with you guys. Can someone say, "No
- 1:28:12one knows me except Allah"? And you
- 1:28:14blasphemy. know No, this is
- 1:28:16No, cuz this is No, cuz you're denying
- 1:28:18everything. Yeah, so let's go with your
- 1:28:19Let's Let's see if you guys are
- 1:28:20consistent. Let's see if you're
- 1:28:21consistent. No, it's a No, you know,
- 1:28:23you're you're not You're not going to be
- 1:28:24an atheist where you can just deny,
- 1:28:25deny, deny. You're going to have to
- 1:28:26stand for something. Hold on a second.
- 1:28:28So, can Can anybody say Can anybody say
- 1:28:31um Can anybody say,
- 1:28:34"No one knows Allah except me and and no
- 1:28:37one know Oh, sorry. No one knows me
- 1:28:39except Allah
- 1:28:40and no one knows Allah except me and
- 1:28:43whoever I choose to reveal him"? Can
- 1:28:44somebody make that claim?
- 1:28:48Answer the question, please, and then
- 1:28:49explain what you're doing.
- 1:28:51So, no, you're not going to answer.
- 1:28:54Just answer yes, no,
- 1:28:58So, you're not going
- 1:29:07Uh now, all of a sudden, can be applied
- 1:29:09to the Trinity. That doesn't follow,
- 1:29:10right? I don't I don't know why this
- 1:29:12can't get through you, but just because
- 1:29:13uh Christ has some sort of ontological
- 1:29:15status or is given virtues, it doesn't
- 1:29:18mean that he's not ontologically equal
- 1:29:19to Yahweh, co-equal, co-eternal,
- 1:29:21co-substantial, aka of the same
- 1:29:22substance. Just because he shows some
- 1:29:24qualities that he has, it doesn't mean
- 1:29:26that he's going to be Yahweh. So, you
- 1:29:28showing that it's incompatible with
- 1:29:29tawhid, Avery, doesn't mean that it must
- 1:29:32be compatible with the Trinity. I don't
- 1:29:34know why you keep doing that. I got you.
- 1:29:35So, notice, you didn't answer my
- 1:29:36question.
- 1:29:40Quiet. Yeah, yeah, there you go. He
- 1:29:41said, "I can choose not to answer." So,
- 1:29:43he said he was going to answer but then,
- 1:29:45just a minute he chose not to answer.
- 1:29:47Thank you so much. I appreciate
- 1:29:49We We appreciate it. So, now let me
- 1:29:51break down to you what you're doing,
- 1:29:52okay? So, what you're doing is acting
- 1:29:54like an atheist and saying, "No, no, no,
- 1:29:56no, no." Deny, deny, deny, deny, deny as
- 1:29:59if you do not have a theology that you
- 1:30:00hold to to be consistent. Let me finish.
- 1:30:03Let me finish. It's almost like saying
- 1:30:05It's almost like arguing with an atheist
- 1:30:07on the morality of God when an atheist
- 1:30:09is acknowledging morality while denying
- 1:30:11a substance for morality. That's what
- 1:30:13you're doing. You're you have a theology
- 1:30:15but are saying, "No, no, no, no, no,
- 1:30:16this doesn't work."
- 1:30:17>> theology under question?
- 1:30:18>> Let me finish.
- 1:30:19>> Is the point about top eight?
- 1:30:20>> me finish. Allow me to finish. What I'm
- 1:30:23What I'm showing you is I'm showing you
- 1:30:25that even by your own Islamic standards,
- 1:30:27these statements in in Q, these
- 1:30:30statements in Matthew, Mark, Luke, and
- 1:30:31John would be divine statements even by
- 1:30:33your standards.
- 1:30:34>> But what you're saying is
- 1:30:35>> is Hold on a second. Hold on a second.
- 1:30:37All right.
- 1:30:38Cuz these Well, it doesn't mean he's
- 1:30:39Yahweh. Because only Yahweh can make
- 1:30:41these claims. It's only Yahweh that says
- 1:30:43the prophets. It's only Yahweh that
- 1:30:45knows the hearts. That's in Psalms.
- 1:30:47That's in Isaiah.
- 1:30:48Well, you're asking me. You're asking
- 1:30:50So,
- 1:30:51So, what I'm showing you Let me Let me
- 1:30:52land, please.
- 1:30:53>> Go ahead, bro.
- 1:30:53>> Thank you. So, what I'm demonstrating to
- 1:30:55you is that even according to your own
- 1:30:58theology, according to your Quran and
- 1:31:00Islamic standards, these statements of
- 1:31:02Jesus would be divine claims which
- 1:31:05nobody can say cuz it would be shirk.
- 1:31:07So, even you acknowledge that these are
- 1:31:09divine claims that are that's not
- 1:31:11compatible with tawhid. Why is it not
- 1:31:13compatible with tawhid? Because Allah in
- 1:31:15tawhid is only one person. The reason
- 1:31:17why this is not compatible because Jesus
- 1:31:19is claiming divinity for himself.
- 1:31:21>> No, it doesn't follow. So, again, I'm
- 1:31:23not going to I'm not going to respond to
- 1:31:24you now. Again, we have other models
- 1:31:27within Christianity that can account for
- 1:31:30Christ having these
- 1:31:32attributes.
- 1:31:32>> Give it.
- 1:31:33>> Give what?
- 1:31:33>> Give it. Give the model.
- 1:31:34>> Yeah, so with example with the example
- 1:31:36that you gave regarding him, for
- 1:31:36example, knowing the Father, right? Can
- 1:31:38you give me the argument why knowing the
- 1:31:40Father in this case is going to be
- 1:31:41ontologically equal? What's the argument
- 1:31:42for
- 1:31:43>> Sure. It It show It shows that the
- 1:31:45knowledge of God that Matter of fact,
- 1:31:47it's all about knowledge and fully
- 1:31:48understanding God, the intimate
- 1:31:50relationship with God. And so, Christ is
- 1:31:52saying the same way that no one knows me
- 1:31:54except the Father.
- 1:31:55>> Right.
- 1:31:56>> Right? Meaning that the Father knows all
- 1:31:58things about the Son, has intimate
- 1:31:59relationship knowledge of the Son, and
- 1:32:01vice versa, right? Benny goes and says
- 1:32:04that no one can know the Father unless I
- 1:32:06reveal him, right?
- 1:32:08>> So So, notice this. Notice this. So,
- 1:32:10there's a divine unique union in the
- 1:32:12Father
- 1:32:13>> and relationship with the Father and the
- 1:32:15Son.
- 1:32:15>> But with the relationship
- 1:32:16>> No one has. No, this is This isn't
- 1:32:18revealed to Jesus. This is what he has
- 1:32:19already.
- 1:32:19>> So, he says he says no one can know it,
- 1:32:21correct?
- 1:32:21>> He says that no He says that no one
- 1:32:23knows the Father except the Son. No one
- 1:32:25knows the Son except the Father.
- 1:32:27>> can know it is if the
- 1:32:28>> Is if Is if Jesus makes him known to us.
- 1:32:30>> the same knowledge. The Holy Spirit
- 1:32:31doesn't have the
- 1:32:32>> This isn't talking about the Holy
- 1:32:32Spirit. But, if you
- 1:32:34If you want me to talk about the Holy
- 1:32:35Spirit, I can talk about him. But, what
- 1:32:36He said He said no one, right?
- 1:32:37>> It says no one.
- 1:32:38>> So, yeah, talking about men.
- 1:32:40>> Okay. Okay. But, where do you get that
- 1:32:41from?
- 1:32:41>> The context.
- 1:32:42>> Okay, the context But, the context
- 1:32:44doesn't tell us that. All it says
- 1:32:45>> Yes, it does, cuz he's literally Okay,
- 1:32:47he's talking to humans. So, so So, let
- 1:32:48let's let's Beautiful.
- 1:32:49>> So, when it's talking to humans,
- 1:32:51we we we can take the context of these
- 1:32:53divine making claims to be applied to
- 1:32:55that context, right?
- 1:32:56>> That's what we just said. It's a divine
- 1:32:57making claim in the context.
- 1:32:58>> Amazing. So, if it is the case that you
- 1:33:00agree One second. If it is the case that
- 1:33:02a creature can have can have knowledge
- 1:33:04of the Father, then according to they
- 1:33:06would be ontologically equal to the
- 1:33:07Father,
- 1:33:08>> Well, that's not what we argued.
- 1:33:09>> Oh my goodness.
- 1:33:10>> What? You know what you're arguing?
- 1:33:11You're saying that the reason makes him
- 1:33:12know is because he knows the Father,
- 1:33:14right?
- 1:33:14>> In the same way that the Father knows
- 1:33:16him.
- 1:33:16>> But, and and that can can that knowledge
- 1:33:18be given to creatures?
- 1:33:19>> Not Not the same way.
- 1:33:20>> Okay. But, there's there is Why do you
- 1:33:21say not the same way? Why do you say
- 1:33:22that?
- 1:33:23>> Beca- Okay. So, when he says, "No one
- 1:33:25knows the Son except the Father."
- 1:33:27>> Right.
- 1:33:28>> Right?
- 1:33:28>> Right.
- 1:33:28>> So, and then he qualifies
- 1:33:30>> Cuz he doesn't. He doesn't qualify it.
- 1:33:32>> So, what does he say next?
- 1:33:33>> He just He says, "No one knows the the
- 1:33:35the Son except the Father."
- 1:33:37>> What does that What does that mean?
- 1:33:38>> No, finish your thoughts.
- 1:33:39>> He
- 1:33:39And no one knows the Son and the Father
- 1:33:41except the Son.
- 1:33:42>> And then
- 1:33:42>> And whom the Son chooses to reveal.
- 1:33:45>> Beautiful.
- 1:33:45>> So, my question is, when he says, "No
- 1:33:47one knows the Son except the Father."
- 1:33:49What does that mean?
- 1:33:50>> Yeah, in that context, as long as they
- 1:33:51don't know the knowledge of the Father,
- 1:33:52right?
- 1:33:53>> As long as they don't don't know what?
- 1:33:54>> They don't know They They don't have
- 1:33:55knowledge of the Father. But, if if
- 1:33:57Christ is granting that knowledge and
- 1:33:59they have the same knowledge as the Son,
- 1:34:00then according to you that they are
- 1:34:01ontologically equal to the Son. That's
- 1:34:02not what he says. So, where does it
- 1:34:03qualify the difference?
- 1:34:04>> What What does it mean?
- 1:34:05>> You ask my question.
- 1:34:06>> That no one knows the Son except the
- 1:34:07Father. Why is it that no one knows the
- 1:34:09Son except the Father?
- 1:34:09>> Right. Prior to them getting that
- 1:34:11revelation.
- 1:34:12>> Prior to them getting what revelation?
- 1:34:13>> According to the next part of the verse
- 1:34:15which says that they have the same
- 1:34:16knowledge as the Father.
- 1:34:17>> It has to do about the Father.
- 1:34:18>> What I'm saying is is according to you
- 1:34:19what the Father knows the Son and the
- 1:34:20Son knows the Father and this knowledge
- 1:34:22can be granted to creatures. Now, you're
- 1:34:25saying that because the Son it knows
- 1:34:27[clears throat] the Father is going to
- 1:34:28be ontologically equal. Why come this
- 1:34:29doesn't follow when it's applied to the
- 1:34:31creatures?
- 1:34:32>> Let me show you Let me show you two
- 1:34:33things. Number one, because this is a
- 1:34:34knowledge that Jesus and the and the
- 1:34:36Father have together. And so, this is a
- 1:34:38knowledge that they can choose to share
- 1:34:40with creatures, right? They can make
- 1:34:41themselves known.
- 1:34:42>> Beautiful. So, at the very beginning can
- 1:34:44be shared.
- 1:34:44>> Let me finish.
- 1:34:45>> Thank you.
- 1:34:45>> They can make themselves known to
- 1:34:46creatures. Now, they have a a limited
- 1:34:49capacity to what they know.
- 1:34:50>> What does it say that?
- 1:34:51>> The intimate knowledge
- 1:34:52>> No, what does it say that? The limit.
- 1:34:52>> Finish, bro.
- 1:34:53>> The limit. What does it say that?
- 1:34:54>> Can I finish?
- 1:34:55>> Okay, I need to ask a question. Go
- 1:34:56ahead.
- 1:34:56>> answer me. I asked you what does it mean
- 1:34:58that the Father only the Father knows
- 1:34:59the Son. You did not answer.
- 1:35:00>> Because the context is completely dodged
- 1:35:02that. So, now I'm explaining and
- 1:35:04breaking down the verse to you. You need
- 1:35:05to listen up, bro.
- 1:35:06>> Right.
- 1:35:06>> Okay, thank you. So, when you have Jesus
- 1:35:09who's able to reveal or make known the
- 1:35:11Father to creatures, that does not
- 1:35:13entail that they have the same exact
- 1:35:15knowledge of the Father that the Father
- 1:35:17but it shows that the Father that the
- 1:35:18Son makes known or exegetes the Father
- 1:35:21just as it says in John 1:18 that it's
- 1:35:24the only begotten God who's at the
- 1:35:26Father's side or in the Father's bosom,
- 1:35:28he's the one who declares him, makes him
- 1:35:31known, reveals what he wants from us and
- 1:35:33his character.
- 1:35:34>> Beautiful. So, can we can we both agree
- 1:35:35>> Let me land. Let me land. So, my
- 1:35:37question is with this,
- 1:35:40are even by your own standards
- 1:35:41>> I want to critique your response.
- 1:35:43>> You will in a sec.
- 1:35:44>> ahead.
- 1:35:44>> You will in a sec. Even by your own
- 1:35:47standards, because you guys got away
- 1:35:48from from the sitting the prophets, the
- 1:35:51knowledge and the intimate knowledge of
- 1:35:53Can anybody say, can any prophet say
- 1:35:57I that no one knows me except Allah?
- 1:36:00>> You see how he goes back to his
- 1:36:01theology?
- 1:36:02You're going to have to stand up. This
- 1:36:03is not going to work.
- 1:36:03>> You're going to have to stand up.
- 1:36:04>> You have to Can anyone say
- 1:36:08Got it.
- 1:36:09>> And when I land this, it's with a
- 1:36:10question. You answer the question,
- 1:36:11please.
- 1:36:11>> Right, but I'm going to critique you
- 1:36:12first. I'm going
- 1:36:13>> No, no, no, no, no, no, please just
- 1:36:14answer the question.
- 1:36:14>> I don't want I don't want to forget the
- 1:36:15critique.
- 1:36:16>> You're not going to forget the critique.
- 1:36:17Just answer the question. Answer the
- 1:36:18question.
- 1:36:19>> Just answer the question.
- 1:36:20>> Can any Can
- 1:36:21>> It's It's clear enough.
- 1:36:22>> Can a mere prophet claim and say
- 1:36:26that no one knows Allah, I'm sorry, no
- 1:36:28one knows me except Allah, and no one
- 1:36:31knows Allah except me and who I choose
- 1:36:34to reveal Allah? Can any straight-up
- 1:36:36prophet say that?
- 1:36:37>> I will also let you know, so within
- 1:36:38Quranic framework, within the Islamic
- 1:36:40framework, it doesn't allow for this to
- 1:36:42be to
- 1:36:43Let me finish. It doesn't allow for this
- 1:36:44to be
- 1:36:45>> Why?
- 1:36:45>> Can I Can you let me finish?
- 1:36:46>> You said you
- 1:36:46>> You said you would let me finish. Yeah,
- 1:36:48because the Quran doesn't qualify that
- 1:36:49others can have the same thing. That's
- 1:36:51the point.
- 1:36:51>> So
- 1:36:52>> So let me finish. Let me finish now. So
- 1:36:53because So because the Quran doesn't
- 1:36:54qualify that but Allah would does that
- 1:36:56creatures can have that, it would follow
- 1:36:58it would then follow that it doesn't
- 1:36:59prove Christ to be Yahweh. And now
- 1:37:01Notice how every single time we keep
- 1:37:03jumping back to the Bible, what the
- 1:37:05Bible teaches historically. The biblical
- 1:37:06framework, for some odd reason, he wants
- 1:37:09to talk about tawhid. My tawhid is on
- 1:37:11the question. My Islamic theology is not
- 1:37:13on the question. Now, the question to
- 1:37:14you is very simple. Does the verse that
- 1:37:15you just quoted now, regarding no one
- 1:37:17the father and no one the son and the
- 1:37:18son and no one the father and no one the
- 1:37:19son, does it qualify that the knowledge
- 1:37:21that the creatures receive is limited?
- 1:37:23Can you show me that?
- 1:37:23>> Yeah, yeah. In just a second, I'm about
- 1:37:25to respond to what you just said.
- 1:37:26>> Show me where it says that because
- 1:37:26you're trying to No, can I answer my
- 1:37:28question?
- 1:37:28>> Yes, yeah. Notice what you did. You're
- 1:37:30trying to do this to dodge what what we
- 1:37:31just
- 1:37:32>> No, I addressed it and I responded
- 1:37:33>> But you're dodging because you're not
- 1:37:34the direct
- 1:37:35>> didn't address it?
- 1:37:35>> No, not really.
- 1:37:36>> I disagree with it. It's not It's not
- 1:37:38allowed.
- 1:37:38>> All you said was is that in the Islamic
- 1:37:40paradigm
- 1:37:41>> It's not allowed.
- 1:37:42>> It It's different from this. That's all
- 1:37:44you're saying. So I That's not I'm not
- 1:37:46asking
- 1:37:46>> That was my response.
- 1:37:48>> Okay, so
- 1:37:49>> when you say that it's not allowed, what
- 1:37:51is the reason? Why can't a prophet make
- 1:37:54the claim that I'm the only one who
- 1:37:56knows Allah and the only one who knows
- 1:37:57me is Allah and the only one if you only
- 1:38:00you only know Allah if I reveal him to
- 1:38:01you.
- 1:38:02>> That was the Quranic language isn't the
- 1:38:05same thing as the language that we find
- 1:38:07in the Bible.
- 1:38:07>> But why can't nobody say that Islamic
- 1:38:09>> Because when it comes to the Quranic
- 1:38:10language, when it comes to metaphors,
- 1:38:12right? We only introduce metaphors if
- 1:38:14the text allows it. Why doesn't Quran
- 1:38:16allow I'm teaching you I'm I'm teaching
- 1:38:18you right now, right? The Quranic
- 1:38:19framework we take everything on the
- 1:38:21apparent unless there's reason to
- 1:38:23believe otherwise. The difference that
- 1:38:24you have is within the Bible. The Bible
- 1:38:26does give that metaphorical language
- 1:38:28that allows it to be for other than
- 1:38:29Yahweh. Wait,
- 1:38:31let me finish now. So now I addressed
- 1:38:33it.
- 1:38:33>> No, you didn't. No, I didn't. I
- 1:38:34literally did. No.
- 1:38:35>> Okay,
- 1:38:36if you don't like the answer that's
- 1:38:37fine. I have to adjust my critique.
- 1:38:39Where does the Where does the verse
- 1:38:40Where does the verse say that you quoted
- 1:38:42that they're getting away from this? I
- 1:38:43promise Okay, you can
- 1:38:45>> You can't
- 1:38:46>> You can address my critique and then we
- 1:38:47can we can jump back in this, right? So
- 1:38:49we're getting away from Where does the
- 1:38:50verse say that the knowledge that they
- 1:38:51receive is limited?
- 1:38:53>> Okay, thank you for asking that. So
- 1:38:54according to you said that the current
- 1:38:55>> Oh, no.
- 1:38:56>> You can only go with what the
- 1:38:57>> Can we Can we
- 1:38:58>> You said that you can only go with what
- 1:39:00the Quran allows for metaphorical and
- 1:39:02analogies.
- 1:39:02>> No, no, no.
- 1:39:04>> So thank you So then what are you
- 1:39:05saying? This If someone says If someone
- 1:39:08says Let me just ask you straight away
- 1:39:10like this. If someone says
- 1:39:11>> I already answered the question.
- 1:39:12>> No, this is If someone says If someone
- 1:39:14says that no one knows me except Allah
- 1:39:18and no one knows Allah except
- 1:39:21and no one knows Allah
- 1:39:22No one knows Allah except me and who I
- 1:39:25choose to reveal Allah to. Would that
- 1:39:28statement be a statement of shirk?
- 1:39:29>> Beautiful. So again, I already answered
- 1:39:31you that within the Quranic I'm I'm
- 1:39:32answering you. You don't want Do you
- 1:39:33want to answer or no?
- 1:39:34>> It's a yes or no and explain.
- 1:39:35>> I'm telling you within the Quranic
- 1:39:37framework it's not allowed.
- 1:39:38>> Is it shirk?
- 1:39:39>> It's not allowed to say.
- 1:39:40>> Is it shirk? Why? Why? Beautiful.
- 1:39:42>> Beautiful. saying it's not allowed is
- 1:39:43not giving a why.
- 1:39:44>> give you Let me give you the why. Let
- 1:39:45Let me give you the why. The reason why
- 1:39:47>> The reason why is because the Quranic
- 1:39:48framework, the Quranic language, isn't
- 1:39:51going to be metaphorically in its
- 1:39:53nature.
- 1:39:53>> Would it be shirk?
- 1:39:54>> Can I Can I let me finish? Just another
- 1:39:55question.
- 1:39:55>> No, it's the same one.
- 1:39:56>> So, I'm I'm going to ask you the why.
- 1:39:57>> It's the same question.
- 1:39:58>> No, if if it's the reason why you
- 1:39:59wouldn't want to say it, then first say
- 1:40:00it. Now, is it shirk?
- 1:40:01>> You said, "Now, is it shirk?" Yes or no?
- 1:40:02>> Are you saying Are you
- 1:40:03>> If If it's applied within the Quran,
- 1:40:05within the Quranic framework, if we take
- 1:40:06upon the apparent, it would entail some
- 1:40:07sort of shirk. Yes.
- 1:40:08>> Thank you.
- 1:40:09>> Thank you.
- 1:40:09>> So, now let's clap it up.
- 1:40:11So, now let's clap it up for
- 1:40:12>> You're going to let me So, you just
- 1:40:13>> You're going to let me finish.
- 1:40:14>> Yeah, yeah, go ahead and finish. I'll
- 1:40:15show you how you buried yourself.
- 1:40:16>> Beautiful. So, now we know that the
- 1:40:17Quranic framework doesn't allow for this
- 1:40:18because it's apparent, and we only take
- 1:40:20metaphors if the text allows for it to
- 1:40:22be. But within the Bible, we know that
- 1:40:24the Bible allows for this metaphorical
- 1:40:25interpretation. Why? Because it can be
- 1:40:26applied to creatures. So, now since I
- 1:40:29addressed Avery, hopefully he's going to
- 1:40:30address me. Where does the verse say
- 1:40:32that it's when the laws that they
- 1:40:33receive that the the creatures receive,
- 1:40:34it's limited? What does it mean it's not
- 1:40:36a qualification? Can you give it to me,
- 1:40:37please, now?
- 1:40:37>> Sure. Creatures are limited. Now, let me
- 1:40:39show you
- 1:40:40>> Does the verse say anything in the Quran
- 1:40:41that says
- 1:40:41>> Let me Let me show you Let me show you
- 1:40:43how you just butchered yourself. So, we
- 1:40:46finally I had to pull your teeth each I
- 1:40:48had to pull the I had to go in the
- 1:40:50>> This is good.
- 1:40:50>> and just snatch the tooth out of your
- 1:40:52mouth
- 1:40:52>> Beautiful.
- 1:40:52>> to force you to finally say
- 1:40:54please.
- 1:40:54>> Go ahead. Please.
- 1:40:55>> Thank you. I had to go to the back and
- 1:40:58with my pliers and force that tooth out
- 1:41:01of your mouth for you to finally say you
- 1:41:04The reason why we can't say this The
- 1:41:05reason why no good prophet can say this
- 1:41:07is because it would be shirk.
- 1:41:09>> No, but shirk
- 1:41:10>> Shirk, ladies and gentlemen, let me
- 1:41:11finish. You just said it, it's on
- 1:41:12camera. So, now why is this a problem?
- 1:41:15How does this just butcher you? How is
- 1:41:16this a stab in the heart? Because shirk,
- 1:41:19ladies and gentlemen, is in associating
- 1:41:21a partner with Allah. You are making
- 1:41:23someone
- 1:41:25on the same level as Allah and and
- 1:41:27making them divine. Having divine
- 1:41:29prerogatives, putting them on the same
- 1:41:30level as Allah. So, what you just
- 1:41:32admitted is that when Jesus says, "No
- 1:41:35one knows the Son except the Father
- 1:41:37And no one knows the father except the
- 1:41:39son except who the son chooses to
- 1:41:41reveal. Jesus committed shirk by
- 1:41:43associating himself with the father.
- 1:41:46>> Yes.
- 1:41:46>> Therefore, it's Unitarian theology.
- 1:41:48>> It doesn't work because the biblical
- 1:41:50framework allows for the space where
- 1:41:53Christ can be
- 1:41:53>> Trinity, yes.
- 1:41:54>> No. No. [laughter] For for your personal
- 1:41:56idea of God, right? Where you can say
- 1:41:58this and yet it wouldn't entail that
- 1:41:59he's ontologically equal to the father.
- 1:42:01>> No, it doesn't.
- 1:42:01>> Let me finish. Now, notice that the
- 1:42:03reason about what proving whether or not
- 1:42:04Christ committed a shirk, the argument
- 1:42:07is proving that Christ is Yahweh.
- 1:42:08>> Right. So, to be Would it shirk if he's
- 1:42:10Yahweh?
- 1:42:10>> Let me finish. That's that's irrelevant.
- 1:42:11You see it's not You're You're very
- 1:42:13slick, Avery. You're very slick. But the
- 1:42:15answer that I gave is that the Quranic
- 1:42:17framework doesn't allow for this.
- 1:42:18>> Would it be shirk if he's Yahweh?
- 1:42:19>> No, you're not You're not going to ask
- 1:42:20another question, right? So, can we both
- 1:42:21agree that the verse that you quoted
- 1:42:23doesn't say that the those who received
- 1:42:25the knowledge that it's a limited
- 1:42:26knowledge? Can we agree to
- 1:42:27>> It doesn't say that verbatim. But I do
- 1:42:28agree that it teaches that. It's what it
- 1:42:29teaches, yeah.
- 1:42:30>> Beautiful. In both frameworks, it would
- 1:42:32be it would be claiming
- 1:42:33>> No, within the biblical framework it
- 1:42:34wouldn't be shirk.
- 1:42:35>> Yes, it is. That's That's the point. It
- 1:42:36is claiming to be God.
- 1:42:37>> That is the exact point. That's the very
- 1:42:39thing in question that is other than
- 1:42:40God.
- 1:42:42>> Then it would be it would be
- 1:42:42blasphemous.
- 1:42:43>> Yeah, right. You know, from a biblical
- 1:42:44As a truth there, and how convenient.
- 1:42:46>> Oh, well, it's the very thing in
- 1:42:47question right now.
- 1:42:49You're not able to debate it. You just
- 1:42:50keep asserting that it is.
- 1:42:51>> Yeah.
- 1:42:52>> But you're asserting that that this
- 1:42:53verse doesn't tell that in the Bible
- 1:42:55with the very thing in question is in
- 1:42:56the in the Bible.
- 1:42:57>> Biblical framework.
- 1:42:58>> This is allowed. That's the very thing
- 1:43:00in question right now.
- 1:43:01>> Only God
- 1:43:01>> That's the very thing in question right
- 1:43:02now.
- 1:43:03>> Show us where it's not in the
- 1:43:03>> That's the whole thing that we have
- 1:43:05>> That's the That's the very thing in
- 1:43:05question
- 1:43:06in the Bible.
- 1:43:07>> Show us where it's not in the Bible.
- 1:43:08>> Show us where a creature sins prophets.
- 1:43:10Show us where Show us where a
- 1:43:11>> Well, it doesn't say that. It says God
- 1:43:13in his wisdom.
- 1:43:15>> Avery, Q is whatever they want it to be.
- 1:43:17They can dismiss whatever they want. It
- 1:43:18says God in his wisdom. With that very
- 1:43:21same logic, you're you're you're telling
- 1:43:22us that Q is whatever you want it to be.
- 1:43:24But no one agrees with
- 1:43:26Nobody agrees with Yeah, but you said
- 1:43:28this is in Q when it's not in Q.
- 1:43:30>> No, you said
- 1:43:31>> You would only use Q. You said in Q.
- 1:43:34>> Jesus says, "I will send the prophets."
- 1:43:37He does not say in Q.
- 1:43:38>> Where's Where's her quote in Q?
- 1:43:40>> Uh yeah, I think it
- 1:43:41>> Okay, that's what we've been talking
- 1:43:42about for the last hour.
- 1:43:44>> I peace is not in Q.
- 1:43:46>> I know, BUT WE'VE BEEN TALKING about her
- 1:43:47thing for an hour. And now you're going
- 1:43:49back to Hank cuz
- 1:43:50>> I was I was differently.
- 1:43:52>> And we said
- 1:43:53>> This is important. Go ahead and say
- 1:43:54>> I peace quote, fine, is not in Q because
- 1:43:56we
- 1:43:57>> According to John No.
- 1:43:58>> Because I guess now we define Q
- 1:44:00differently.
- 1:44:01>> We define Q however we want to define Q.
- 1:44:02>> What do you mean?
- 1:44:03>> How do we define Q?
- 1:44:04>> How do you define Q?
- 1:44:05>> So now
- 1:44:06>> How do we define Q?
- 1:44:07>> How would you
- 1:44:08>> No, no, you said we're defining Q
- 1:44:10differently. How do you define Q?
- 1:44:11Because you're telling us we're defining
- 1:44:13it differently. I'm asking Isabelle
- 1:44:14because
- 1:44:15No, I'm asking Isabelle because she said
- 1:44:16we're defining it differently.
- 1:44:17>> Yeah, we're we're the same team.
- 1:44:18>> I don't think Belle understands what Q
- 1:44:19is.
- 1:44:20>> scholarly You said we have to go to what
- 1:44:21the scholars are saying about the
- 1:44:23historical Jesus and you brought up Q.
- 1:44:25Great, I brought up John Kloppenborg.
- 1:44:26This is his reconstruction of Q. It's a
- 1:44:28very popular one.
- 1:44:30Again,
- 1:44:30we're clearly identifying Jesus as God.
- 1:44:33>> Well, that's not it.
- 1:44:34>> I will send the prophets. It says God in
- 1:44:36his wisdom.
- 1:44:38You're misquoting it.
- 1:44:39>> You're misquoting it. It says God in his
- 1:44:41wisdom.
- 1:44:42>> No, it doesn't.
- 1:44:42>> We've It does.
- 1:44:43>> No, it doesn't.
- 1:44:43>> Uh Luke 11:49, God in his wisdom.
- 1:44:46>> Q in the in the Q construction doesn't
- 1:44:48>> In the Q construction goes by Luke, not
- 1:44:50by Matthew. What? Who says Q goes by
- 1:44:52Matthew?
- 1:44:53>> According to Also, wisdom said, "I will
- 1:44:56I send them prophets."
- 1:44:57>> Therefore, wisdom says, "Yep, right."
- 1:44:58That's what I thought.
- 1:45:01IT'S IT'S NOT THAT
- 1:45:02NO, YOU SAID, "I WILL send it."
- 1:45:04>> Wisdom says. It doesn't say God.
- 1:45:06>> Originally, it was I said it, but in
- 1:45:08Luke's account, it's God in his wisdom.
- 1:45:10And Q, it's wisdom. It's not that it's
- 1:45:12Jesus is God's wisdom because
- 1:45:15>> We see if you would let me speak.
- 1:45:17>> We see in Q that Solomon has his own
- 1:45:19wisdom. And Solomon's wisdom isn't
- 1:45:21Jesus. He doesn't have Solomon's Jesus.
- 1:45:25Is this Jesus's wisdom? So, when it says
- 1:45:27it's God's wisdom in his wisdom.
- 1:45:31That's what it says in Luke. Therefore
- 1:45:32all of Luke's wisdom said And these are
- 1:45:33those supposedly saying
- 1:45:36God and his wisdom
- 1:45:38Yeah, but it says in in Luke's
- 1:45:41So I said wisdom, it's God's wisdom.
- 1:45:43>> So now wait, hold on. So now is it
- 1:45:44Luke's account that's the the authority
- 1:45:46on what is said and what Jesus said?
- 1:45:48>> Luke has always been what what Q is
- 1:45:49based off of.
- 1:45:50>> But is isn't it based off of what Luke
- 1:45:52and Matthew agree on?
- 1:45:53>> Yeah,
- 1:45:53but the Q document is is pertaining
- 1:45:55closer to Q because Luke
- 1:45:57>> But it pertains to both of them on the
- 1:45:58statements they agree, right?
- 1:45:59>> We don't we don't go off Matthew's
- 1:46:00quotes for
- 1:46:01>> Scholars do not just say, "Well, if it's
- 1:46:03in both therefore it's therefore it's in
- 1:46:05Q."
- 1:46:06>> Yeah.
- 1:46:06>> Q is there's some stuff in Matthew
- 1:46:08that's in Q according to these
- 1:46:09hypothetical instructions. Sometimes
- 1:46:11it's only in Matthew, sometimes it's
- 1:46:13only in Luke. Yes.
- 1:46:15>> The double tradition that's what you're
- 1:46:17saying there's Q statements which is
- 1:46:19what you reconstruct from a double
- 1:46:20tradition is only statements found in
- 1:46:22Matthew.
- 1:46:22>> off what the scholars that you guys
- 1:46:24wanted to bring up
- 1:46:24>> They don't say this stuff.
- 1:46:26>> So, keep You don't have documented up Q.
- 1:46:28We don't have a document. So we have to
- 1:46:29go on this hypothetical reconstruction
- 1:46:31of what the scholars say. They will say
- 1:46:34there are sometimes when you're going to
- 1:46:35the Q document, there will be parts of
- 1:46:37it will only be in Matthew, parts of it
- 1:46:39will only be in Luke. It's not just
- 1:46:40doublet.
- 1:46:41>> Right, that's what I'm saying. What I
- 1:46:42was saying is I don't agree with you
- 1:46:43when you're saying that Matthew 23:34 is
- 1:46:45in Q because it's not a double. I was
- 1:46:47saying I don't agree with that.
- 1:46:48>> scholars not saying
- 1:46:49>> Just because you have a quote one single
- 1:46:51random It's not random. I'm familiar
- 1:46:52with this quote. It's Copan Brehm.
- 1:46:53>> Yeah, go on.
- 1:46:54>> Copan Brehm says it's it's wisdom. It
- 1:46:55doesn't say I will send it.
- 1:46:56>> Let's move to a closing statements.
- 1:46:59>> Why you guys go first?
- 1:47:00>> Okay. I just want to re
- 1:47:02>> According to Q document, Jesus said I
- 1:47:04will send you prophets. You used to
- 1:47:05reiterate this again. But again, we
- 1:47:06don't have Q, we only have the Gospels
- 1:47:08and in the Gospels Jesus says that. So
- 1:47:11it's his statement. You said we have to
- 1:47:13go to the Q document to know the
- 1:47:14historical Jesus's. I did, you clearly
- 1:47:16said something that demonstrates he
- 1:47:17would have to be God. So that's the
- 1:47:19point I'm bringing up here. But at the
- 1:47:20end of the day, you guys wanted to say
- 1:47:22the historical Jesus didn't teach the
- 1:47:25Trinity. Surprisingly, the way you
- 1:47:26worded the prompt makes you puts
- 1:47:28yourself in the positive claiming. You
- 1:47:30didn't actually demonstrate that because
- 1:47:32you went nuclear and destroyed any
- 1:47:34source we can use on who the historical
- 1:47:36Jesus was at the end of the day. So, at
- 1:47:38the end of the day, this was not even
- 1:47:39justified because every time we bring up
- 1:47:41a source, you're like, "Well, we're
- 1:47:42going to throw that out. We're going to
- 1:47:43throw that out. We're going to throw
- 1:47:44that out." Constantly we're going back
- 1:47:45to this circle. If it agrees with Islam,
- 1:47:47therefore we can accept it. If it
- 1:47:49doesn't, we reject it.
- 1:47:50>> We find some ad hoc reason to do it. So,
- 1:47:52yeah, this was this was ridiculous at
- 1:47:54the end of the
- 1:47:54>> Oh, add on to that. So, with the Q
- 1:47:56source, okay? So, yeah, we kept on
- 1:47:58throwing things out throwing things out.
- 1:48:00Finally, we're at the Q source. Now,
- 1:48:02earlier he brought up that Q and so now
- 1:48:04you're saying that Q is defined as when
- 1:48:06it's doubled, right? Fine, I guess you
- 1:48:09if we can't use the sending prophets
- 1:48:11verse or the wisdom thing, fine, let's
- 1:48:13just throw that out for argument's sake.
- 1:48:15Now, we're at the verse with the
- 1:48:16revealing the father and the son. And
- 1:48:19then you actually said that through that
- 1:48:21verse, that's what shows that the
- 1:48:24biblical framework doesn't allow the
- 1:48:25Trinity. And here, the that verse, that
- 1:48:28Q doubled verse, does allow for an
- 1:48:31element of the Trinity.
- 1:48:33However, that's the whole point. The
- 1:48:35biblical the biblical sources, it's a
- 1:48:39it's a it's a case built up with
- 1:48:42multiple elements of the Trinity. So,
- 1:48:44what you guys do is you guys literally
- 1:48:46get one little verse from this Q and
- 1:48:48then you guys say, "This is the only
- 1:48:50thing you have to work off of it." And
- 1:48:52so, I just don't understand why you guys
- 1:48:54brought this prompt because you guys
- 1:48:57would also have to prove that the
- 1:48:58historical Jesus didn't teach the
- 1:49:00Trinity. And you guys can't have that
- 1:49:02cuz we all just dismissed all of these
- 1:49:05all these sources. And from right, and
- 1:49:08from Q
- 1:49:09from just let's just just take the Q
- 1:49:11sources. You guys still cannot prove
- 1:49:13that Jesus did not preach the Trinity.
- 1:49:16>> Therefore, do we because we're going to
- 1:49:17close? Uh
- 1:49:19whatever
- 1:49:20>> our good thing we say comes from God or
- 1:49:22whatever bad thing we say is comes from
- 1:49:23Allah.
- 1:49:23>> Mhm.
- 1:49:24>> Okay.
- 1:49:24>> That That is awkward for right. Got to
- 1:49:26say that. Okay, my apologies. But
- 1:49:28>> Um yeah, so for a closing, I'd say um
- 1:49:31yeah, just a first like the main thing
- 1:49:33that we were really referencing is
- 1:49:34whether the Bible like the biblical
- 1:49:36narrative allows for this, which we were
- 1:49:37giving Jewish references in the first
- 1:49:39century, and we were quoting the Bible
- 1:49:40to also support this like 1 Samuel 25,
- 1:49:44pairing that with first-century Jewish
- 1:49:45attestation that shows that this is an
- 1:49:48allowed Jewish belief, and therefore we
- 1:49:50can apply this first-century belief onto
- 1:49:52the gospel, including the Gospel of
- 1:49:53John, to show that this wouldn't
- 1:49:54necessitate a Trinitarian belief, but
- 1:49:57rather can also show a first-century
- 1:49:59Jewish monotheism. And uh
- 1:50:02I know that IP went over some quotes in
- 1:50:04Q and stuff, but not only do I disagree
- 1:50:06that it's in Q because it's in Matthew's
- 1:50:08quote, but Matthew's redacting what Luke
- 1:50:09says because we have the the the quote
- 1:50:12in Luke, and all scholars are going to
- 1:50:13agree that Luke is the one who preserves
- 1:50:15Q better. Um but IP's argument was to
- 1:50:18just quote one single scholar,
- 1:50:19Kloppenborg, and his attestation of it,
- 1:50:21which Kloppenborg doesn't even quote it
- 1:50:23the way IP says it. But furthermore,
- 1:50:25Kloppenborg thinks that Q teaches that
- 1:50:26Jesus is only just a prophet, not God
- 1:50:29himself. So the own scholars he's
- 1:50:31quoting wouldn't agree with him on his
- 1:50:32understanding of these passages he's
- 1:50:34citing. So uh there's no reason to think
- 1:50:36even from Q that Jesus is God because
- 1:50:38everything we see in Q, as well as
- 1:50:40Kloppenborg agreeing that Jesus is
- 1:50:42assumed up into heaven alive, is found
- 1:50:43in Islam.
- 1:50:45So there's no reason There's no reason
- 1:50:46to say that Q teaches your Trinitarian
- 1:50:48beliefs. When the own your own scholars
- 1:50:50you're you're trying to quote don't
- 1:50:51agree with you on that.
- 1:50:53>> Bro.
- 1:50:54>> Yeah, um topic was historical Jesus
- 1:50:57preaching a Trinity. No Trinity found
- 1:50:59today. The only God's, you know, certain
- 1:51:01vague verses about, "Oh, is this Does
- 1:51:04this mean that he's divine or not
- 1:51:06divine?" We're talking about the By the
- 1:51:07way, barely mentioned the Holy Spirit. I
- 1:51:09think I was the one who mentioned the
- 1:51:10Holy Spirit. Nothing from you three.
- 1:51:12Um when it comes to your trinitarian
- 1:51:15doctrine, what we agreed on from the
- 1:51:17beginning is that you believe they are
- 1:51:18co-equal, co-eternal. You've not
- 1:51:20substantiated any of that throughout the
- 1:51:22entirety of the discussion. All you did
- 1:51:24was try to appeal to the idea of Jesus
- 1:51:26possibly being divine and also
- 1:51:27disagreeing with that. Nothing in this
- 1:51:30actually talked about the Trinity
- 1:51:31whatsoever.
- 1:51:32Um in addition to that, yes, we did make
- 1:51:35this prompt and rightfully so because we
- 1:51:37didn't get any response regarding the
- 1:51:38Trinity. Um we don't have to prove a
- 1:51:41negation, right? All we would have to
- 1:51:42show is because obviously we're talking
- 1:51:44about the historical Jesus, which by the
- 1:51:45way you guys kept talking about the
- 1:51:46Islamic concept. Nowhere did any of us
- 1:51:49appeal to Islam. That was you that
- 1:51:50brought that up, I think, or you.
- 1:51:52Um
- 1:51:53when it comes to the historical Jesus
- 1:51:55and what he says, we're going based off
- 1:51:57of a recollection of all of the data
- 1:51:59that we could find and seeing what can
- 1:52:00be corroborated the most. If it's the
- 1:52:02case these statements can be
- 1:52:04corroborated, okay, and they can be
- 1:52:06understood in this lens, then that's
- 1:52:08fine. We haven't been substantiated with
- 1:52:10that. You haven't spoken about a Trinity
- 1:52:12whatsoever. All you did was try to prove
- 1:52:13Jesus is God. And you didn't do that
- 1:52:15either.
- 1:52:16No.
- 1:52:17>> Oh yeah, just um I mean, it's painted as
- 1:52:19if we dismissed everything. That's not
- 1:52:21true. We granted Mark, Matthew, Luke,
- 1:52:22and John, and Q in the sense where they
- 1:52:25are historical, right? So, if you have
- 1:52:26something within Mark that is
- 1:52:28ahistorical, that can be rejected. If it
- 1:52:29is historical and can be corroborated
- 1:52:30regarding the historical critical
- 1:52:31method, it can be accepted, right? So,
- 1:52:34it's not that we threw everything out.
- 1:52:35It's just that we were strict with our
- 1:52:36criteria to the point where you guys
- 1:52:38weren't able to substantiate the
- 1:52:39historical Jesus.
- 1:52:39>> actually teach in a Trinity. And I did
- 1:52:41want to get to the point where we talk
- 1:52:43about the negation side where Christ
- 1:52:45didn't teach it that way, but um
- 1:52:47yeah, maybe next time. Bye.
- 1:52:49>> Sweet, that was awesome. That was so
- 1:52:51good.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 3 Christians Vs 3 Muslims: Did Jesus Teach The Trinity? by The Way with Brian Davila, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 26,762 words across 4,307 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.