알면 이해하고, 이해하면 벗어납니다 : 231125 웃따마 3 — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:03(Chanting) There’s a park near my
- 0:19house where I go for daily walks and
- 0:22meditation, and I went there to
- 0:25meditate during the day. I was focusing
- 0:29on my breathing and maintaining
- 0:31awareness, when I suddenly heard a
- 0:33rustling sound in the distance.
- 0:36Yes.
- 0:36I must have lost my focus at that
- 0:38moment. I looked over and saw a large
- 0:41dog biting and killing a cat.
- 0:43Oh, my. The moment I saw that, my mind
- 0:45was pulled into it, and I was
- 0:47completely stuck there.
- 0:50There was a large dog, like a shepherd,
- 0:53and it was biting a small black cat. I
- 0:58witnessed the whole thing right in
- 1:00front of me. But the
- 1:04The dog owner was standing right there,
- 1:06and I wished they would separate them,
- 1:08but they just kept watching without
- 1:10trying to stop it. I felt this surge of
- 1:14anger rising up inside me.
- 1:17I kept thinking they needed to separate
- 1:18that cat immediately.
- 1:20My heart started pounding and racing.
- 1:23Then I started to resent the dog owner.
- 1:27As that resentment rose, I wondered why
- 1:29they would let it go that far. They
- 1:31should have leashed the dog and
- 1:33separated them quickly, but instead,
- 1:36the owner kept saying things like, "Go
- 1:39ahead, finish it, bury it now," over
- 1:42and over.
- 1:44The moment I heard that, I don't know
- 1:46why, but I shouted something, and I
- 1:48found myself rushing out without even
- 1:50realizing it. So,
- 1:52After that, I completely lost my
- 1:55concentration, and I was just trembling
- 1:57all over. Even after I got home, my
- 2:00thoughts stayed stuck on that scene. I
- 2:02decided I couldn't go back to that spot
- 2:05anymore. That thought kept coming up.
- 2:10I spent the whole night trying to
- 2:12notice and acknowledge the thoughts,
- 2:14but the image kept popping back up
- 2:16repeatedly. Uh-huh.
- 2:19Even at home, I knew the thoughts were
- 2:24arising, but they kept tormenting me.
- 2:29So,
- 2:30I thought, "I can't meditate there
- 2:32anymore." I spent a day with that
- 2:34thought in my mind.
- 2:35Then, afterwards, I thought back. "
- 2:37If I don't go and meditate there, I'm
- 2:39the one losing out, and it's such a
- 2:42great place to meditate.""
- 2:43Why should I not go? Let me try going
- 2:45there just once." When I went back,
- 2:47contrary to my worries, everything went
- 2:49smoothly. Whenever the thought flashed
- 2:52through my mind, I would just
- 2:53acknowledge it and let it go. It felt
- 2:57like something had shaken my spirit,
- 3:00but as I kept watching the thoughts,
- 3:03they would appear and disappear; yet,
- 3:06they kept flowing in.
- 3:09So, I've been doing that, and while it
- 3:12has eased up a lot, I still have this
- 3:14feeling of a lingering knot in my heart
- 3:17. That’s what I’m experiencing. So,
- 3:19there’s still something left, and
- 3:21I’m wondering how I should deal with
- 3:23that.
- 3:24There’s no need to wonder what to do;
- 3:25you were doing fine, so why are you
- 3:26like this?
- 3:28You said you were just watching as
- 3:29things arose, right?
- 3:30Yes. Yes.
- 3:31What else is there to do besides that?
- 3:34Trying to "do" something about it is
- 3:36what’s wrong. You can’t help it
- 3:39when things arise. Right?
- 3:41The problem is not knowing when they
- 3:43arise. Things arising. You can’t do
- 3:45anything about things that just come up
- 3:47.
- 3:48I keep thinking, "Oh, the cat and that
- 3:49dog were just in a situation where that
- 3:51had to happen."
- 3:53There’s no need to even think about
- 3:54that.
- 3:55You’re rationalizing it.
- 3:56That’s just rationalizing it. You
- 3:57rationalize it to make yourself feel
- 3:59better. "Oh, it must be karma," you
- 4:01think. You rationalize it with all
- 4:03sorts of things. "
- 4:05Maybe that cat did something to that
- 4:06dog in a past life." This...
- 4:08You rationalize it like that. There’s
- 4:10no need to do that.
- 4:12When it arises, just see it as a
- 4:14phenomenon, as an object.
- 4:16It just happened.
- 4:18Yeah. It just happened, that’s all.
- 4:20That...
- 4:21Yes. The problem arises when you don't
- 4:24realize it when it happens.
- 4:27When you don't know it happened. So why
- 4:28wouldn't you know it happened? You know
- 4:30anger arose, but you lack mindfulness.
- 4:33Right? It means you don't realize it
- 4:36has happened. So if it happens and you
- 4:39know it happened, that is the best way.
- 4:43When you don't yet have an
- 4:44understanding of that phenomenon...
- 4:47Once you have understanding, it doesn't
- 4:48matter whether it happens or not. You
- 4:50aren't tainted by it at all. When it
- 4:52comes to something, let's call it a
- 4:57strong object. When something like that
- 5:01arises, if you just change your mindset
- 5:02, it's very helpful. Rather...If you
- 5:06change your mindset—your current
- 5:09mindset is what's wrong. "Why does this
- 5:11keep happening?""I shouldn't have
- 5:13watched that.""Why is this happening to
- 5:16me?""It shouldn't be happening"—that
- 5:19thought is completely wrong. If you
- 5:21just change your mindset there, it
- 5:23becomes an incredibly helpful object.
- 5:25It keeps happening for you, after all.
- 5:30Even if you didn't have mindfulness, it
- 5:31will appear as soon as that arises.
- 5:33Because it's so strong.
- 5:34Yes...
- 5:35Yes, how grateful you should be for
- 5:36that. You just need to change your
- 5:38mindset about such things. So when it
- 5:42arises, just knowing it arose— "Oh,
- 5:44I'm watching this right now." Knowing
- 5:46you are watching, knowing you are
- 5:48watching—there is nothing better than
- 5:50that. It's as good as it gets, but
- 5:55because you can't do that, the anger
- 5:57gets stronger; if you can just do that,
- 5:59it's excellent. Knowing you are
- 6:01watching...
- 6:01It was such a shock, but as I continued
- 6:04to practice, it became much calmer, and
- 6:06gradually, even if I go to that place,
- 6:08I don't think about it at all, and I
- 6:10just keep going as is.
- 6:12So, practitioners have a slight
- 6:14misunderstanding that it's good if
- 6:16things don't arise. I'm telling you,
- 6:19it's good to know when they do arise.
- 6:21Even defilements.
- 6:23If you practice just to make sure
- 6:24things don't arise, then why practice
- 6:26at all? Right? When an affliction
- 6:31arises, if you know it has arisen,
- 6:32there is nothing better than that.
- 6:34Thinking that you must not have
- 6:36afflictions is actually a very strong
- 6:38form of pride. That is not an area that
- 6:42you can control.
- 6:44All you can do is, once it has arisen,
- 6:46simply know that it has; that is the
- 6:49best method. Eventually, when you do
- 6:51that, an understanding of what arose
- 6:53will emerge. You break free through
- 6:55that understanding. It’s not that you
- 6:58understand and then decide to break
- 7:00free; understanding is liberation
- 7:03itself. Understanding is liberation.
- 7:07Yes. So, when something arises—like
- 7:10an angry heart—don’t view it as
- 7:12your own heart, right? View it as a
- 7:15phenomenon.
- 7:16Hmm.
- 7:17A phenomenon. It is a phenomenon. It
- 7:19has no essence. Whether it is greed,
- 7:23anger, or anything you can label, all
- 7:26of it is just a phenomenon. It has no
- 7:30reality. But ignorance, or not knowing,
- 7:32makes it look like it has substance. So
- 7:36, just see it as a phenomenon that has
- 7:38simply occurred. Hmm. When you know
- 7:43that you are seeing it, understanding
- 7:46eventually arises from there.
- 7:51Yes. In Korea, there is a common way
- 7:55people talk about mindfulness. They say
- 7:58to be mindful of the object, right? But
- 8:00mindfulness is not about being mindful
- 8:03of the object. If you think about it.
- 8:06Yes. The act of knowing that you are
- 8:09seeing—the perception—should be the
- 8:11object. That is mindfulness. We call
- 8:15that "knowing that you are seeing."
- 8:17Knowing that you are doing something.
- 8:19The "something" is the phenomenon being
- 8:22perceived, and the one perceiving is
- 8:24the one who is currently aware of it.
- 8:27That is why the part about "knowing
- 8:29that you are seeing" is what the Buddha
- 8:31called the one and only way. Knowing
- 8:34that you are seeing, being mindful of "
- 8:37such and such."
- 8:39Hmm.
- 8:41Being mindful of "such and such," but
- 8:43...
- 8:44Isn't the part about "knowing that you
- 8:47are seeing" a concept?
- 8:51Why would it be a concept?
- 8:53Is there no gap in knowing that you are
- 8:57seeing? Really? Is it known instantly?
- 9:02What is being seen right now is a
- 9:05concept. Right? The act of seeing is a
- 9:08paramattha. When you know you are
- 9:11seeing, you can distinguish between the
- 9:13seeing and the knowing. They become
- 9:16separated. You mentioned earlier that
- 9:18they were separated. But they don't
- 9:20separate right away. It’s about the
- 9:23momentum of mindfulness. So, when it is
- 9:24maintained...
- 9:27I explained this briefly yesterday; if
- 9:29mindfulness is correct—that is, right
- 9:32mindfulness—Then there is a moment of
- 9:34concentration and a moment of wisdom.
- 9:37They occur simultaneously. But why
- 9:39can't you separate them? It's because
- 9:41there is no concentration power yet.
- 9:44You need to build momentum.
- 9:46Hmm. For those who are just starting,
- 9:50it will probably be maintained for
- 9:51about two or three seconds. It’s good
- 9:53if you can keep it going, but if it
- 9:58only continues for a minute, the power
- 10:01of samadhi—if we look at it based on,
- 10:04say, two or three weeks—what should I
- 10:07call it? The strength doesn't move like
- 10:11this if it lasts for a minute. It moves
- 10:13like this. Like this. Hmm. The power of
- 10:16being awake is completely different.
- 10:19That’s why gaining momentum is so
- 10:21important. So, ask yourself constantly.
- 10:24Ask yourself, am I aware right now, am
- 10:26I aware? Is there awareness? There’s
- 10:28nothing else to do. Nothing else. So,
- 10:33seeing is paramattha. Knowing that you
- 10:36are seeing is also paramattha. This is
- 10:38a function. Due to this function,
- 10:41things that are seen arise. Things that
- 10:45are heard, anger, and greed arise—
- 10:48they are phenomena. They have no
- 10:51substance. But you mistake them for
- 10:54having one.
- 10:55Then, let me ask one more thing. If the
- 10:59object has become a concept, how do I
- 11:03view it as paramattha? You cannot see a
- 11:08concept as paramattha. Knowing a
- 11:10concept as a concept is wisdom. A
- 11:14pannatti cannot become paramattha. Just
- 11:18knowing it as a concept is wisdom. The
- 11:21problem is not knowing that pannatti is
- 11:23pannatti. It is knowing pannatti as
- 11:26pannatti. It will never happen that
- 11:30pannatti becomes paramattha. Yes. That
- 11:35is correct. So, whatever has arisen,
- 11:38anything you can name, that is all
- 11:42pannatti. But the seeing itself, that
- 11:47is paramattha. However, there are no
- 11:51properties like color, sound, smell,
- 11:53taste, or touch there. There are only
- 11:56functions. Because of those functions,
- 12:01something arises. They arise. Whatever
- 12:07arises is all pannatti. Everything you
- 12:10can name is. That’s right.
- 12:16The result is empty.
- 12:20You are probably focusing too much on
- 12:22what arises.
- 12:24Yes. So, you don't need to try to find
- 12:27it on purpose. If you just know that
- 12:30you are seeing, it starts there.
- 12:33Yes. Samadhi also begins, but because
- 12:36it isn't maintained and the power is
- 12:38weak, the separation hasn't happened
- 12:40yet. It won't separate. So, once it
- 12:42separates and you clearly understand it
- 12:45for yourself, you don't need to
- 12:47separate it on purpose. Now, if you
- 12:49think of it that way, it will happen.
- 12:52It will happen. With just one thought.
- 12:55Because you have experienced that
- 12:57separation before, it works. Because
- 12:59there is understanding there.
- 13:01Yes. You must continue to practice.
- 13:06One more thing I would like to say...
- 13:09When I sit, the...I have been
- 13:14continuously listening to the guided
- 13:15teachings of the monk. If I keep
- 13:17listening to those 10-minute guided
- 13:19sessions,
- 13:20when I follow the monk's words exactly,
- 13:23I find I can reach Samadhi. That
- 13:26thought becomes total and continues on,
- 13:31so I find myself listening to it
- 13:34constantly. While continuously
- 13:36listening to the guided teachings, and
- 13:38as the monk keeps...
- 13:40I keep knowing, so I wonder if I should
- 13:42keep listening to the guided talks, or
- 13:44if I should stop after listening once
- 13:46and just continue on my own.
- 13:49You will naturally let go of it
- 13:51yourself. You will have the thought, "
- 13:53Oh, I don't need to listen to this
- 13:55anymore." But if you feel that
- 13:57listening helps more, then keep
- 13:59listening. Yes. Later on, the nature of
- 14:03mindfulness itself will appear
- 14:06different to you.
- 14:09The mind remains whole and expands, and
- 14:11although I had heard of this before,
- 14:13listening to the guided talks makes it
- 14:15truly hit home.
- 14:17That's because when you listen to
- 14:18Dharma talks, it's bound to happen that
- 14:20way.
- 14:21So for now, you keep listening to
- 14:23things like "my mind is at ease," and
- 14:25you are practicing it on your own while
- 14:27listening. Mindfulness is constantly
- 14:30there while you listen. While listening
- 14:33. That is why the thought "Oh, I am at
- 14:36ease" arises. But when you reach that
- 14:38state where there is a mind that sees,
- 14:40a mind that knows, and a mind that
- 14:42watches,
- 14:43then this becomes cumbersome.
- 14:45This is better.
- 14:47The mind that sees, the mind that knows
- 14:48, the mind that watches
- 14:50is felt to be much more valuable. So
- 14:52you naturally stop listening to Dharma
- 14:54talks as much. Later, when you have
- 14:56some realization of your own, you might
- 14:58listen to a talk once in a while to
- 15:00find confirmation in it.
- 15:02Hmm. But you are bound to move past the
- 15:05state of thinking, "I must listen to
- 15:06this to maintain mindfulness." Once you
- 15:09understand the watching mind—because
- 15:12it is more subtle—it has much more
- 15:14power when it arises while you are
- 15:16practicing mindfulness on your own,
- 15:18rather than listening to this. Hmm.
- 15:22Right now, you are just dwelling in the
- 15:25state where you know the mind and the
- 15:27objects just arise and vanish.
- 15:29You need to come out of that.
- 15:32You have to come out of it and switch
- 15:34to knowing that you are seeing.
- 15:37You have to engage in true Vipassana by
- 15:40knowing that you are seeing. Simply put
- 15:42, what you have been doing so far is,
- 15:45in a way, just crawling around like a
- 15:48baby. Yes. You are just crawling. You
- 15:52should be able to stand up on your own
- 15:53now. You should stand up and start
- 15:55walking now. That is what knowing that
- 15:57you are seeing is. Knowing that you are
- 15:59seeing already includes the watching
- 16:01mind.
- 16:01Hmm.
- 16:03It’s just that you haven't felt its
- 16:05power yet. If you keep maintaining that
- 16:08, you will suddenly realize, "Oh, I am
- 16:10truly watching." Why did you find it so
- 16:12funny what you said earlier? Even when
- 16:13I lift my spoon to eat, I feel like I'm
- 16:15trembling so much. It doesn’t feel
- 16:16like you’re doing it. You are
- 16:18watching it from behind. That thing.
- 16:20Hmm. That’s how it should be.
- 16:22Sometimes you can see it once in a
- 16:24while. You do.
- 16:25Yes. Then you don’t get greedy. "I
- 16:28should keep this going." This kind of
- 16:29greed.
- 16:30It does arise, but
- 16:31you shouldn't.
- 16:32That’s why I’ve said, since the
- 16:34teacher says you shouldn’t keep being
- 16:37greedy,
- 16:38just let go of your heart.
- 16:41Instead of saying, "I have to keep this
- 16:44greed,"
- 16:45it’s about being curious, "How did
- 16:48this state come to be?"
- 16:50It will never work if you try to force
- 16:52it.
- 16:54When you just know you are observing
- 16:55without any thoughts, that’s when it
- 16:58works. When you have no thoughts, and
- 17:01then it gradually fades, you keep being
- 17:03aware because the state is good. Then
- 17:06the strength grows even more.
- 17:08And then it drops off significantly.
- 17:10The observing mind is over there, the
- 17:12object is over there, the knowing mind
- 17:13is here, and the watching mind is here;
- 17:15it feels like you can actually grasp
- 17:17them. When those minds and those
- 17:20functions become like that, the state
- 17:23ends. It doesn’t last long. In that
- 17:26moment, if you get greedy and try to
- 17:28maintain it, or try to force it back,
- 17:30it will never work. Think about it. How
- 17:34did this state come about? What caused
- 17:37this state to happen? There is only one
- 17:39result. It happens when you just take
- 17:41it in through awareness without any
- 17:43thoughts. Keep checking those things.
- 17:46Things like that. Yes. "Ah, this state
- 17:50is good." What are the conditions to
- 17:52maintain this state? Don't hope for a
- 17:56result, just set the conditions.
- 17:59The condition is simple. Just check
- 18:01your mindset and maintain awareness.
- 18:04And awareness is not just knowing the
- 18:05object, but
- 18:07when you know you are seeing the object
- 18:09.
- 18:10When you know you are seeing, you
- 18:11should keep shifting to that.
- 18:14But one day, suddenly, I thought I was
- 18:16looking at my gaze, and then suddenly
- 18:18the tree just popped in. Like this.
- 18:20Okay. That’s good too. Why are those
- 18:24two things different? Have you checked?
- 18:27Ask yourself that question. Why is that
- 18:31?
- 18:31Hmm. So I feel like my mind is focusing
- 18:35deeply like that.
- 18:37Yes. When it popped in, it just came in
- 18:41comfortably.
- 18:44It is true that you are seeing. It
- 18:46takes a lot of effort. Because you are
- 18:49interested in it, you focus and go
- 18:51straight in. You cannot be seeing
- 18:53without concentration. Concentration is
- 18:55there, but since the concentration is
- 18:57relatively lower than when you are
- 18:58actively looking, it feels like it is
- 19:00being shown to you. Just because it’s
- 19:03being shown doesn’t mean there’s no
- 19:04concentration. Without at least a
- 19:06little bit of focus, nothing will be
- 19:08visible.
- 19:09Yes. That’s right. You have to check
- 19:12those things. There must be a
- 19:13difference in force between what is
- 19:16shown and what you see. Clearly. You
- 19:18can feel that, right? Yes. "Oh, so when
- 19:21I relax my effort, the objects appear
- 19:23naturally like this.""I'm really
- 19:25letting go of the tension."
- 19:26Oh, and then you'll think again. "Oh,
- 19:28relaxing the effort is much more
- 19:30beneficial." If you force it, you get
- 19:34tense, and you start to...
- 19:36You’ve had a major realization. The
- 19:37force—
- 19:38You’ve grasped it, you've grasped it.
- 19:40Oh, applause!
- 19:44That’s how it happens.
- 19:46Yeah. But you have to understand that,
- 19:49too. Right.
- 19:51Earlier when I listened to the senior
- 19:54monk, he said to look as if you are
- 19:56looking at a fish net. So I’ve been
- 19:59trying to look that way.
- 20:02What do you mean by looking as if
- 20:04you're looking at fish in a net? What
- 20:07is that? Yeah.
- 20:09It means spreading your mind wide open.
- 20:11Overall.
- 20:12No, watching it overall, not a fishbowl
- 20:15—a fish net, with many fish in the
- 20:17net.
- 20:18Oh, yes, the fish net.
- 20:22The net—Sayadaw uses the analogy of a
- 20:26net a lot. Yes.
- 20:27Like pulling something in with a net.
- 20:30Now,
- 20:32In what sense did he mean that?
- 20:35Yes. In what sense and with what
- 20:38intention did Sayadaw use that
- 20:41expression?
- 20:46Otherwise, you’ll just keep thinking
- 20:47about a fishing net. Like, "What's this
- 20:49?""Do I need to go buy a net?" You'll
- 20:51probably think that.
- 20:52That’s not it.
- 20:53That's not it, but when I first came
- 20:54here, the monk said, "If you look at
- 20:56the fishbowl..."
- 20:57I didn't understand why he said it was
- 21:00all there. I didn't understand it then.
- 21:03But now, the net means spreading the
- 21:05mind wide, and by just keeping watch,
- 21:07everything that enters the mind is
- 21:10already contained within it. The
- 21:12objects.
- 21:13Okay. Good. So the objects—
- 21:15Are all already there. Right? Sights,
- 21:17sounds, smells, tastes, and bodily
- 21:20sensations are all within the net.
- 21:23But are you going to force them to come
- 21:25in?
- 21:26They are already there.
- 21:28They are already there.
- 21:30Right? They are already there. Sayadaw
- 21:32said, don't go wandering around looking
- 21:34for objects. Yes. Don't go looking for
- 21:38objects, because this entire space is
- 21:40already the net. Yes. This entire space
- 21:43is the fishbowl, or rather, the net we
- 21:46just mentioned. All the objects are
- 21:49already inside it.
- 21:50Right? So don't go looking for them.
- 21:52They are already there. Knowing that
- 21:54the objects are already there is all
- 21:57you need to do—isn't that so
- 22:00comfortable?
- 22:02Right. Don't go wandering around
- 22:07looking for them.
- 22:08I’m not looking for it, but I keep
- 22:10sensing that open mind.
- 22:11Okay. Right now, as a state of knowing
- 22:15that mind,
- 22:16you’ve understood that much,
- 22:17haven’t you? That everything right
- 22:18now is the mind. But rather than that,
- 22:22wisdom truly grows when you know you
- 22:24are seeing. If you go about it this way
- 22:28, things do get incredibly calm.
- 22:31It really becomes calm. But no
- 22:33understanding arises. You have to look
- 22:35at the function. The function.
- 22:37Only by looking at the function does
- 22:39understanding arise. To look at that
- 22:41function, you start seeing it the
- 22:43moment you know you are seeing.
- 22:46Yes. So, in a way, you need to upgrade
- 22:50it.
- 22:51Yes. Let’s upgrade.
- 22:53Let’s bump up the version. Yes.
- 22:56You’ve worked hard, though. You
- 22:59really worked hard.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 알면 이해하고, 이해하면 벗어납니다 : 231125 웃따마 3 by 마하보디선원 TV, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,389 words across 566 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.