21st ICC International Mediation Competition – Finals — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:36That's
- 1:59How you doing?
- 2:03>> It's going to be it's going to be all
- 2:04sorts of horrors I don't know about yet.
- 2:06But there we are.
- 2:41History
- 3:36the end of the board.
- 5:49Hallelujah.
- 8:16We didn't have a chance.
- 8:19>> Nice to see you.
- 8:20>> Nice to see you.
- 8:21>> How you doing?
- 8:23>> Well, yeah. It's all going to prove to
- 8:25be untrue.
- 8:28realize what complete
- 9:52Correct.
- 10:20Just to make it smaller.
- 10:23Are you okay with that?
- 10:24>> Sure.
- 10:24>> Okay, great.
- 10:25>> We can't post it up, can we?
- 10:27>> No. Okay. Now, you see what I mean?
- 10:28That's all I want the audience. That's
- 10:30all. But anyway, that's great.
- 10:31>> Yeah. Okay, great. Thank you, sir.
- 12:26Are you ready?
- 12:53That was
- 14:18Hi, your name
- 15:04Good morning everyone and welcome to the
- 15:0721st International Commercial Mediation
- 15:09Competition. vision.
- 15:11[applause]
- 15:17[applause]
- 15:18>> We are so thrilled all of you could join
- 15:20us this morning and thrilled for all of
- 15:22you to be cheering on our two competing
- 15:24teams, the University of Auckland
- 15:33and Vererius Law School.
- 15:36[applause]
- 15:42Mediating today we have Bill Wood
- 15:46[applause]
- 15:50and on our panel of judges we have Alan
- 15:54Roy
- 15:58[applause] Tat Limila
- 16:05Porter
- 16:06>> [applause]
- 16:10>> Mary Mlan
- 16:12[applause]
- 16:15and Anisha Bjon.
- 16:18[applause]
- 16:22>> All right. I want to just say once
- 16:24again, thank you to all of you for
- 16:25traveling all this way, for joining us,
- 16:27for all the professionals in the
- 16:29audience, for the volunteers in the
- 16:30audience, the teams. We could not have
- 16:32this without every one of you. And so
- 16:34now let's turn it over to the session
- 16:36supervisor, Anella.
- 16:41[applause]
- 16:48>> Good morning everyone. My name is Angela
- 16:52Bodru. I am your mediation session
- 16:53supervisor for this day. Um the
- 16:57mediation session will h last like every
- 17:00time 85 minutes. I will hold 10 minutes
- 17:04sign when there are 10 minutes left and
- 17:06five minute sign when there are five
- 17:08minutes left. I will make sure that you
- 17:10all see this. Um does anyone have any
- 17:13questions before we start? You're good.
- 17:16You're familiar with the rules by now.
- 17:19Um so uh please note that the use of
- 17:22calculators and watches are allowed. Um
- 17:26uh tablets and laptops are allowed for
- 17:29judges only to access the mediation uh
- 17:32competition platform. Accessing any
- 17:34other sources of sources of electronic
- 17:36information is prohibited for everyone
- 17:38else in the room. Um please turn off
- 17:42your mobile phones or put them in
- 17:44airplane mode so that both you uh will
- 17:47not get distracted and um everyone else
- 17:51is having their full attention on you.
- 17:54Um and note that no advice,
- 17:57communication or assistance uh is to
- 17:59occur between the coaches or
- 18:01non-competing uh h team members and the
- 18:05competing teams.
- 18:08The time will go according to my uh
- 18:11clock. Um you have 1 hour and 25
- 18:14minutes. I'm here for you.
- 18:17You may start.
- 18:21>> Good morning. Um, my name is Bill Wood.
- 18:24Uh, I'm a mediator from London and it's
- 18:26my privilege to be mediating the dispute
- 18:28between Fay and Yan this morning. Um, we
- 18:31do some introductions first. If we could
- 18:32just introduce ourselves.
- 18:34>> Good morning, Bill. Good morning, Bill.
- 18:36My name is Fay. I am the um, owner of
- 18:40Cool Bags, the co-founder of Fab Cool.
- 18:42And I would like to confirm I do have
- 18:45um, complete authority to settle today.
- 18:48>> Good morning, Bill. My name is Chloe and
- 18:51I am FA's in-house counselor today.
- 18:54>> Good morning everyone. My name is Yan
- 18:56and I am the owner of Fab Fashion.
- 19:01>> Good morning from me as well. My name is
- 19:02Anna. I'm legal counsel of Yan.
- 19:05>> Anna, thank you. Um I'm very happy to be
- 19:08called Bill. It sounds as if everybody
- 19:09else is prepared to work on firstname
- 19:11terms. Is that okay? Is that okay?
- 19:14>> Um you need to know I speak extremely
- 19:16fast.
- 19:18Uh uh so when I tell you that it's going
- 19:21to be important today that we make sure
- 19:22we understand each other and that we
- 19:24speak slowly and acknowledge that there
- 19:26may be people here whose first language
- 19:27is not English, I'm probably talking
- 19:29principally to myself as the one who
- 19:30needs that advice. Um
- 19:35there are ground rules that I think it's
- 19:37worth stating though both both teams are
- 19:39extremely well advised by their lawyers
- 19:41and I'm sure this has already been
- 19:42covered but under the terms of the ICC
- 19:45mediation agreement that you have signed
- 19:46this is a strictly confidential process
- 19:49so that all of us all five of us are
- 19:52required to keep private from the
- 19:53outside world everything that is said
- 19:55today uh and everything that's been
- 19:57written for the purposes of today.
- 20:00We're also talking without prejudice,
- 20:01which means something slightly
- 20:02different. It means that if we can have
- 20:04a negotiation today and people can make
- 20:06offers and refer to other people's
- 20:07offers and respond. Those exchanges can
- 20:10take place without you worrying that
- 20:12somebody later is going to say you've
- 20:14made a concession of some kind. They
- 20:15can't do that. They can't refer at all
- 20:17to those negotiations uh because of the
- 20:19without prejudice principle. And the
- 20:21last thing I need to say about the
- 20:22ground rules is that if we if we do
- 20:24caucus and I'm with one team on their
- 20:27own, uh I will treat all the information
- 20:29that team shares with me as confidential
- 20:32to that team unless I'm specifically
- 20:34authorized to communicate it to the
- 20:36other side.
- 20:38Um
- 20:42there are proceedings in the background
- 20:43here. Uh both both sides have have made
- 20:46claims in proceedings. Uh and you are of
- 20:49course free when you leave here to
- 20:51pursue those proceedings and take them
- 20:53to court. You have as I've said got
- 20:56extremely good legal teams. It will be a
- 20:58superb trial if you want to have it. But
- 21:01clearly, you've signed a mediation
- 21:03agreement. So, I'm going to make the
- 21:04assumption, and it's the only assumption
- 21:05I'm going to make this morning. I'm
- 21:06going to make the assumption that you're
- 21:07prepared to commit time and energy to
- 21:09considering whether there are
- 21:10alternatives to litig litigating out uh
- 21:14the issues between them. And that's the
- 21:17work really we're engaged in. The work
- 21:18we're engaged in is trying to make sure
- 21:20that you make good choices, you're able
- 21:22to make good choices against the widest
- 21:24possible perspective of the position.
- 21:26The cliche for mediators is that you you
- 21:28act on your real interests, not
- 21:29necessarily on the narrow legal issues.
- 21:32Okay? Um, I'll help you with questions.
- 21:36I'll help you possibly with suggestions,
- 21:38but this is your discussion. Sometimes
- 21:41I'm dealing with the chief executives of
- 21:42big companies, but here I'm dealing with
- 21:44two individuals. So, I I don't really
- 21:46need to ask you whether you've got
- 21:47authority because Fey and Yan, this is
- 21:49your dispute. And if it's a settlement,
- 21:51it's going to be your settlement. Okay?
- 21:54So, um, le let's begin the conversation.
- 21:56I think I'm talking to the requesting
- 21:58party first. If you'd like to say
- 22:00anything you want to.
- 22:02>> Thank you, Bill.
- 22:04Yan, [sighs] Anna, thank you for
- 22:06accepting my request for a mediation
- 22:08today.
- 22:10I am genuinely heartened that we can
- 22:12have this discussion today and I look
- 22:14forward to it being an open and
- 22:17unprejudiced one. As you said, Bill
- 22:20Yan, our partnership was something
- 22:23special. Fab Cool captured the hearts
- 22:28around the world through iconic brands
- 22:31like My Sweetie and Cloudy. Brands
- 22:34celebrated for their elegance, their
- 22:37craftsmanship, and their quality
- 22:40construction.
- 22:42We were so successful, Yan. And looking
- 22:45back, I think our success came from the
- 22:49fact that we were so different.
- 22:52You were the pragmatist, Yan. You took
- 22:56my designs and turned them into a
- 22:59multinational reality.
- 23:01With your accounting expertise and the
- 23:04distribution engine to match, you scaled
- 23:07this venture into a thriving business.
- 23:11And then there was me, the artist.
- 23:15For 20 years, I have poured myself into
- 23:19this craft. Every stitch, every curve,
- 23:24every fabric and weave mattered to me. I
- 23:27was obsessive about quality because that
- 23:31was the work.
- 23:33And in hindsight, I can see that that
- 23:36tension between us, between vision and
- 23:39pragmatism, it wasn't a weakness. It was
- 23:43the very engine of our success.
- 23:47But to be honest,
- 23:50this balance has been broken for quite
- 23:53some time now. As sales dipped, I began
- 23:58to feel unheard.
- 24:00Instead of innovating together, the
- 24:03response was pressure to cut costs,
- 24:07cheaper materials,
- 24:09compromised standards.
- 24:12To me, this wasn't just a business
- 24:14decision. It felt like a rejection of my
- 24:19life's work.
- 24:22But then it went even further.
- 24:25Yan, you accused me of artificially
- 24:28inflating costs, of trying to drain the
- 24:31joint venture for my own gain.
- 24:35Hearing that you believed this so deeply
- 24:38that you hired independent auditor
- 24:40auditors was deeply painful. And in my
- 24:44anger and in my hurt, I couldn't bring
- 24:48myself to sign the audit accounts that
- 24:50followed.
- 24:53What I never expected
- 24:55was what came next.
- 24:58To my shock,
- 25:00you sued me for breach of director's
- 25:03duties and petitioned to wind up this
- 25:07dream that we built together.
- 25:11But worst of all,
- 25:14I discovered
- 25:16that you sent private investigators to
- 25:19stalk my personal life in Pandagonia.
- 25:23trying to collect evidence to support
- 25:26suspicions that had no foundation.
- 25:30Yan, that crossed a line
- 25:35and it absolutely destroyed the last
- 25:38shred of trust and loyalty that I had
- 25:42left.
- 25:44In that moment of utter betrayal,
- 25:47I truly believed I could never work with
- 25:50you again.
- 25:53My heart has been telling me to walk
- 25:56away,
- 25:57to take my my precious brands, my
- 26:00creations
- 26:02with me, and to leave this pain behind.
- 26:06And yet, despite everything,
- 26:09I am here because I still believe there
- 26:13may be a way to salvage the dream that
- 26:16we built together.
- 26:19We are standing at a fork in the road.
- 26:22Yan,
- 26:24one path is separation.
- 26:28If despite our very best efforts today,
- 26:31that is where we end up, then so be it.
- 26:35But that path is no longer about shared
- 26:38growth or shared success.
- 26:41It becomes about dismantling,
- 26:45allocating value rather than creating
- 26:47it, deciding who takes what.
- 26:52And I must be clear, Yan, if you take
- 26:56the brands alone, you lose the artistry
- 27:00and the manufacturing excellence that's
- 27:03required to turn them into reality, the
- 27:06skills that truly bring them to life.
- 27:10But there is another path, the path of
- 27:14partnership.
- 27:17That path requires honest communication
- 27:21and openness as you mentioned, Bill. It
- 27:24requires us to confront fears that are
- 27:27not grounded in reality, like
- 27:30accusations of me draining the company.
- 27:33It requires us to openly address our
- 27:36different approaches to quality and to
- 27:39cost. Not as enemies, but as partners
- 27:44who once knew how to balance that
- 27:46tension.
- 27:48If we can restore that balance between
- 27:52your pragmatism and my artistry,
- 27:55then I believe Fab Cool can reach new
- 27:59heights once again.
- 28:02My guiding interests for me in this
- 28:04conversation
- 28:06are the following.
- 28:08First,
- 28:10value protection.
- 28:13Maximizing our shared success if we
- 28:16choose to stay or ensuring that my
- 28:20contributions are fully realized should
- 28:24we move towards a buyout.
- 28:27Second, artistic legacy.
- 28:32maintaining total creative control over
- 28:35my sweetie and cloudy to ensure that
- 28:39they remain the untarnished embodiment
- 28:42of my artistry.
- 28:45And lastly, operational stability.
- 28:50That looks like managing any solution
- 28:53we've reached today to ensure that
- 28:56whether we stay or separate, day-to-day
- 28:59operations can continue until the
- 29:02situation is stabilized.
- 29:05We stand at a fork in the road.
- 29:09I'm asking that we at least try the path
- 29:13less traveled, the path of partnership.
- 29:18Thank you. And with that, I'd like to
- 29:20hand over to Chloe to speak more to our
- 29:22legal standing.
- 29:30Yan Fay,
- 29:33I am encouraged that you are both here
- 29:35today at the table.
- 29:39It's a positive starting point for
- 29:41resolving what has clearly become a
- 29:44difficult and deeply personal commercial
- 29:47dispute.
- 29:49FA has just spoken to the long and
- 29:52productive history of the joint venture.
- 29:54I have advised my client that mediation
- 29:57provides the confidential and efficient
- 30:00forum to properly surface interests
- 30:04address mistrust because we are here
- 30:06without prejudice and explore outcomes
- 30:09that litigation simply cannot deliver.
- 30:13I'm here today to work alongside Bill
- 30:16and Anna to help guide this process and
- 30:20help us develop this wider perspective
- 30:23of our dispute.
- 30:25Above all else, I am here to advocate
- 30:28for and protect FA's interests.
- 30:33Yan, I do need to be clear about the
- 30:36legal landscape against which this
- 30:38mediation is taking place.
- 30:41If this dispute does not resolve today,
- 30:45the parties remain on a litigation track
- 30:48involving allegations of breach of
- 30:52director's duties, a petition for just
- 30:55and equable winding up and competing
- 30:58applications for a compulsory buyout.
- 31:02FA is prepared to defend these
- 31:04proceedings.
- 31:07However, I understand both parties have
- 31:10been advised that court proceedings in
- 31:12Lemania are slow,
- 31:15costly, and highly disruptive.
- 31:19During that period, the joint venture
- 31:22remains in a functional deadlock.
- 31:26That deadlock has real and immediate
- 31:29consequences.
- 31:31Strategic decisions cannot be made,
- 31:33including decisions around productive d
- 31:36product, investment, and brand
- 31:39stewardship.
- 31:41Operational trust would continue to
- 31:43deteriorate, making dayto-day governance
- 31:46increasingly difficult.
- 31:49And critically, the value of Fabcool's
- 31:52most important assets, its brands and
- 31:55associated IP,
- 31:58is exposed to ongoing risk through the
- 32:00dilution of creative vision.
- 32:04Litigation may eventually impose an
- 32:06outcome, but it does so slowly,
- 32:09publicly, and without preserving value.
- 32:12It also removes from both parties any
- 32:15meaningful control over timing,
- 32:17structure or commercial nuance.
- 32:21And what a court cannot do, what no
- 32:23order can compel is ongoing artistic
- 32:27contribution,
- 32:29design vision, or creative partnership.
- 32:33While the path to litigation exists, it
- 32:36is not the path that my client prefers
- 32:38today.
- 32:40Mediation offers something fundamentally
- 32:42different. The ability to move
- 32:44efficiently, privately, flexibly, and to
- 32:48design an outcome that reflects this
- 32:50commercial reality rather than legal
- 32:53default positions.
- 32:56As FA has already noted, the parties are
- 32:58at a fork in the road.
- 33:00We suggest that today's agenda is
- 33:03structured to include that reality
- 33:06directly and honestly.
- 33:09Firstly, we propose to discuss
- 33:12operational difference
- 33:14to confirm whether sufficient trust,
- 33:17governance structure and clarity can be
- 33:20restored for the parties to continue
- 33:22together somehow
- 33:24or whether separation is the only
- 33:28realistic and responsible outcome today.
- 33:32Second, value maximization,
- 33:38recognizing that this discussion will
- 33:40necessarily look very different
- 33:42depending on the path that the parties
- 33:44feel they should explore.
- 33:46If the parties determine that separation
- 33:48is required, value maximization focuses
- 33:51on how each party exits with a viable
- 33:54future without unnecessary destru
- 33:57destruction of goodwill or brand value.
- 34:01If however there is scope for trust to
- 34:04be rebuilt, value maximization shifts
- 34:08toward reimagining the joint venture,
- 34:12restoring confidence and protecting
- 34:14long-term value.
- 34:17Bay comes to this table prepared to
- 34:19engage constructively with both
- 34:21possibilities. There is no predetermined
- 34:24outcome to being imposed today.
- 34:27There is however a genuine intention to
- 34:30test whether resolution can be reached
- 34:33and to do so with commercial discipline
- 34:36and good faith. Thank you Bill. I'll
- 34:38pass back to
- 34:39>> Chloe. Thank you. Yan.
- 34:42>> Thank you very much Fay and Chloe for
- 34:45these um kind first words. I also want
- 34:48to thank you Bill for mediating the
- 34:50session today and I think helping us
- 34:53find a mutually beneficial solution.
- 34:56FA I really appreciate your invitation
- 34:59as a sign to find a constructive and
- 35:02collaborative agreement. I've just heard
- 35:05from you that you have been troubled
- 35:07that the tension that once was the
- 35:09engine as you said is has somehow turned
- 35:13into a weakness in our collaboration.
- 35:17You said high standards are really
- 35:19important to you because they reflect
- 35:21your craftsmanship and what your life
- 35:24is. So your life's work is about is that
- 35:27artistry that is so much so much
- 35:30empowering and part of your personality
- 35:33as an artist. What I gather from you is
- 35:36that you seek to achieve an open and
- 35:38unprejudiced solution and to explore
- 35:41options to salvage the dream that we've
- 35:44built. and I'm happy that we're sitting
- 35:46here to find such a solution, especially
- 35:49after the last three years. I appreciate
- 35:51that insight in your perspective and I
- 35:54respect your thoughts on the matter.
- 35:57To be honest, before we receive that
- 35:59invitation, I had but three possible
- 36:02options in mind. Objectively there is
- 36:05number one we wind up fab cool alto
- 36:08together number two I achieve a buyout
- 36:11of your shareholding shareholdings and
- 36:14number three you buy out my shares now
- 36:18that you have invited us to a more
- 36:20constructive approach the pallet of
- 36:23solutions has become a lot more powerful
- 36:27how I'm sorry a lot more colorful of
- 36:29course however before we spoil the
- 36:32painting I I think we need to talk about
- 36:35what actually brought us here. And after
- 36:38you've just talked about the lines that
- 36:41were crossed that shredded any trust
- 36:43that
- 36:45basically any trust was left, I am
- 36:46convinced there's a mutual need for
- 36:48conversation.
- 36:50I agree with you that since 2019,
- 36:53Fabcool has been on a roller coaster of
- 36:56success. With great speed, we were
- 36:59reaching skyrocketing numbers. After
- 37:02only four years, we made a revenue of
- 37:05almost $1 billion.
- 37:08However, today we are past the pinnacle
- 37:11of our relationship.
- 37:13Not only our numbers are on the
- 37:15downfall, but the very foundation of our
- 37:18collaboration. Our partnership is at an
- 37:22all-time low.
- 37:24I cannot forget how you belittleed and
- 37:28humiliated me in front of our managing
- 37:31staff. I cannot oversee the little
- 37:35confidence you have in my abilities as a
- 37:38business partner and I will not tolerate
- 37:41this disrespect toward me any longer
- 37:44after all I've personally put into this
- 37:47endeavor.
- 37:48However, there is one convincing reason
- 37:51I wish I want to note to attend this
- 37:53mediation today and that is the
- 37:55responsibility I feel for our staff. The
- 37:59number of people who rely on us has
- 38:01increased from 10 to 80 80 people whose
- 38:06job depend on whose jobs depend on us.
- 38:10Coming from a family business
- 38:12background, I promised myself I will not
- 38:15leave this room today if these people
- 38:17were to end up on the streets. So let us
- 38:20use this meeting as an opportunity to
- 38:23find an agreement that reflects the
- 38:25past, the present, and a reasonable
- 38:28future.
- 38:30In order to help you understand our
- 38:31perspective, Maloya Anna will now
- 38:34explain our legal standing on the
- 38:36matter.
- 38:38>> Thank you, Yan. And thank you FA and
- 38:42Chloe for sharing your perspectives
- 38:44first. From your opening remarks, I
- 38:48gather that we shared a common goal that
- 38:50everyone's use are fully understood. So
- 38:53this is a great starting point. Given
- 38:56the fact that English is not our native
- 38:58language, I also want to note at the
- 39:00very beginning that you please feel free
- 39:04to ask questions at any time if anything
- 39:06we say is unclear.
- 39:11Like you, we are confident that Bill can
- 39:13guide us in the session and lead us to
- 39:15mutually beneficial resolution to this
- 39:17dispute.
- 39:20Before addressing the legal aspects of
- 39:22this case, I want to acknowledge like
- 39:25you did that the joint venture has been
- 39:29very successful.
- 39:31It was a long and productive
- 39:33collaboration. And even though there was
- 39:36this difference between you, my client,
- 39:39the craftsmanship on the one hand and
- 39:42the pragmatism on the other, this
- 39:44collaboration has worked for a long
- 39:46time.
- 39:48But now that profits have turned into
- 39:51debts and there was an imbalance created
- 39:55as you have put it, we have to focus on
- 39:59the following three points that are
- 40:02important to my client.
- 40:05First, we would like to address what we
- 40:08considered a breach of your director
- 40:11duties.
- 40:13Second, we want to look at what the
- 40:16future of the joint venture could look
- 40:18like. And thirdly, we have to ensure
- 40:22that the employees interests are
- 40:24considered in this mediation.
- 40:28Turning first to the director duties,
- 40:32I've heard from you that
- 40:35you were very sad and quite frankly
- 40:38shocked that Yan has called your duties
- 40:42and your the way you handled the
- 40:45situation into question and we can
- 40:48understand that. However, let me explain
- 40:51where this this claim where these even
- 40:55stem from.
- 40:59For Yan, the breach of duties were
- 41:01twofold.
- 41:03On the one hand, you sourced very
- 41:06luxury, excessive luxury materials.
- 41:11I've heard from you that this stems from
- 41:14your 20 years of craftsmanship that you
- 41:17have perfected, that you appreciate and
- 41:20that you really like those valuable
- 41:23materials.
- 41:25However, this what what is in principle
- 41:28an artistic choice has its limits where
- 41:31the joint venture cannot sustain itself
- 41:34financially.
- 41:35Because if that's the case, without this
- 41:38balance of your artistic freedom and
- 41:42Jan's pragmatism, it's not able, we are
- 41:46not able to share the stream of sharing
- 41:50those bags with other people.
- 41:53So your decision to threaten those
- 41:56specific materials threatened the
- 41:58business model and ultimately
- 42:02led to the fact that Jan had to take on
- 42:05personal debts to sustain the stream.
- 42:10On the other hand, you refused to sign
- 42:13off the audited accounts of Fabcool.
- 42:16I've gathered your from your opening
- 42:18statement that this decision stemmed
- 42:20from anger and hurt and on a personal
- 42:24level I think we can see how this
- 42:27happened and we can understand that.
- 42:30However, to Yan, this looked like you
- 42:33did this in bad faith to undermine the
- 42:37ventures operability.
- 42:40And Jan interpreted this as a sign of an
- 42:44immense distrust to his abilities as
- 42:47accounts manager.
- 42:51Regarding the future of the joint
- 42:53venture,
- 42:54the basis for a joint venture is
- 42:56collaboration and we both have
- 42:58established that this balance and coal
- 43:02collaboration has been shaken.
- 43:05And you also stated that you felt like
- 43:07you
- 43:09um that that you felt like you wanted to
- 43:12walk away.
- 43:13And my client has stated initially that
- 43:18she only saw three options. And I think
- 43:21that those were the options that we
- 43:25could only see before mediation. Now
- 43:27that we are in mediation, there's a
- 43:29possibility to move beyond those three
- 43:32options.
- 43:34And today we have to figure out what
- 43:36paths remain open.
- 43:39Lastly, with regard to the joint
- 43:42ventures employees,
- 43:44growing up around the employees of Yan's
- 43:47family business, Yan has learned what
- 43:50responsibility for people's livelihoods
- 43:52actually means. And while the future of
- 43:57this joint venture is uncertain right
- 43:59now, it is important for YAN to gain
- 44:02clarity about what will happen to the
- 44:05employees. And I see that is an interest
- 44:08that you also share since you stated
- 44:10that you want to make sure that
- 44:12day-to-day operations remain possible.
- 44:17So having heard your opening remarks
- 44:20really made us I think hopeful that
- 44:23beyond the allegations we can find a
- 44:26reasonable future for both parties.
- 44:30So thank you Bill for supporting us in
- 44:33this process and we look forward to
- 44:36working with you FA and with you Chloe.
- 44:39In that spirit I would like to propose
- 44:42an agenda to ensure that we address all
- 44:45relevant aspects of this case.
- 44:49Firstly because I heard this is
- 44:52important to you as well. I think we
- 44:54should find a common understanding of
- 44:56what led us here. you
- 44:59called that operational differences to
- 45:01clarify that. I think that is a common
- 45:05common point we could put up on the
- 45:07board later. Secondly, it's important
- 45:10for my client to address liabilities.
- 45:14You have talked about value maximization
- 45:16and I think those two points tie
- 45:18together. We have to find out what are
- 45:22the economic possibilities to either
- 45:25wind up or to find out what we do with
- 45:28the shares.
- 45:30And lastly, we would like to explore
- 45:33what the future is in regards to the
- 45:36employees. And this is the last point I
- 45:39think we should also add on the agenda.
- 45:41Do you feel comfortable with this? Do
- 45:43you would like to add anything? Please
- 45:45feel free to share your thoughts.
- 45:48Thank you, Anna. Um, I've heard in
- 45:51regards to your first point about a
- 45:53common understanding and you mentioned
- 45:55earlier the breach of the director
- 45:57duties. I think that does come back to
- 46:00as you also mentioned the distrust in
- 46:02the room. So, I think speaking about
- 46:04those operational differences first
- 46:06really gives us a chance to address this
- 46:08distrust, ask the questions we need for
- 46:11that. So, I'm very happy with that being
- 46:12the first agenda point. Secondly,
- 46:16you've mentioned liabilities, we've
- 46:18mentioned value maximization. My
- 46:20understanding is that both of those are
- 46:22about the questions we need to ask to
- 46:24know what path we're going to take
- 46:26forward. So, I'm happy with that as
- 46:28well. And perhaps as a subpoint of that,
- 46:30we would have we would definitely
- 46:31address the employees that you've
- 46:32mentioned is important to you, Yan.
- 46:36>> It would be really helpful to myself and
- 46:38my client if we had that visualized.
- 46:39Would you agree?
- 46:41>> Yes, totally.
- 46:42>> Yes.
- 46:42>> All right.
- 46:43Um just just to be clear, what I think
- 46:46we're doing is mapping out some areas of
- 46:48discussion. I think the parties agree
- 46:51that uh the important thing to do is to
- 46:53work out to some extent what has gone
- 46:55wrong before we try to fix it. I'm
- 46:57absolutely sure that's the right course.
- 47:00Uh and operational differences is is a
- 47:03broad heading and obviously has a number
- 47:04of subcategories because there are
- 47:06effectively a number of allegations that
- 47:07have been made across between the two
- 47:09tables. But if I put operational
- 47:10differences on the board for the moment
- 47:12and then we just uh get some reactions
- 47:15to that and map a few things out. Is
- 47:18that okay?
- 47:18>> Yes, thank you.
- 47:19>> I'll do that.
- 47:20>> Is that okay?
- 47:39I'm happy to add further categories in
- 47:41due course but um when you talk about
- 47:44operational difficulties just tell me
- 47:46what you first of all you have in mind.
- 47:49>> I think for us it is really about
- 47:51clarifying where our paths crossed in
- 47:53the last um I'm sorry split in the last
- 47:56three years. I feel like there's some
- 47:58misunderstanding on where we want to go
- 48:01with this joint venture and this led us
- 48:04to this conflict. understand that.
- 48:08>> I agree. I think there are clearly some
- 48:10tensions that have arisen and I have
- 48:12some concerns. I've heard from you um
- 48:14Yan that you have some concerns as well
- 48:16and I I do feel it's important to
- 48:18address those before we can decide which
- 48:20of those future paths we take. I do also
- 48:23just want to take this opportunity to
- 48:26reflect on what I have heard from you,
- 48:28Yan. Thank you for being open. And I'm
- 48:30really encouraged to to hear that you
- 48:32are here in the spirit of collaboration
- 48:34and you may you know you came in here
- 48:36with those three potential um paths
- 48:39forward but to hear that you are open to
- 48:43seeing if there's a possibility of a
- 48:44fourth with us is quite heartening in
- 48:47today's discussion. Um, I do also note
- 48:50you said you felt belittled and
- 48:53humiliated in front of the staff and
- 48:55that stood out to me and I just want to
- 48:57take this opportunity first to apologize
- 48:59if my actions or my words made you feel
- 49:03that way. I think I I explained myself
- 49:06and Anna, I heard you reflect as well
- 49:08that it did come from a place of anger
- 49:10and shock at the allegation. So, I would
- 49:13like that out there and I hope that we
- 49:15do get to discuss it a bit more today.
- 49:17Thank you very much. I appreciate the
- 49:19apology and I think this is a step
- 49:21forward and I'm happy to discuss why we
- 49:25why we're sitting here apologizing. I
- 49:26think this is something that really
- 49:28needs some some further conversation.
- 49:31Thank you.
- 49:33>> So moving forward into this first agenda
- 49:37point, it would be very helpful for my
- 49:39client if we could under get an
- 49:41understanding of where this distrust
- 49:43comes from. What is the seed of this
- 49:45distrust?
- 49:48For me on a personal level it is really
- 49:51about that I feel like you don't trust
- 49:54me as a business partner when you sort
- 49:58of belitted me as an accountant clerk in
- 50:00front of our managing stuff staff. I
- 50:03really thought why I really thought that
- 50:06I I've always considered you a partner
- 50:08of mine and then you so suddenly turned
- 50:10your back on me and I was just wondering
- 50:13where does that sort of hatred even come
- 50:16from?
- 50:18And I can assure you it certainly was
- 50:20not a hatred. Um I'll be the first to
- 50:23admit I'm very passionate about my
- 50:25creations. All of these brands are not
- 50:28just bags to me. They're they're like my
- 50:30children. Um, and because of my 20 years
- 50:33of craftsmanship, I think that, you
- 50:35know, brings itself to why I I feel so
- 50:38passionate and I I said I was a little
- 50:40obsessive about the quality. I have
- 50:43appreciated your partnership for the
- 50:44last three years and I think you have
- 50:47been the commercial engine behind all of
- 50:49this. Um, and you know, bringing the
- 50:51strategy to life. when I started seeing
- 50:54things go wrong, I think that the
- 50:57differences that I valued before, I
- 50:59started to see as perhaps an issue and I
- 51:02thought that that misalignment was
- 51:05something that couldn't be salvaged. Um,
- 51:09>> FA, you were with Young incredibly
- 51:11successful. You were a brilliant
- 51:13combination. You've said that yourself.
- 51:15>> Uh, 950 million US dollars worth of
- 51:18turnover is uh a lot of handbags and you
- 51:21did a brilliant job. Thank you.
- 51:22>> Um,
- 51:24what was the beginning of the problem?
- 51:26What was the beginning of the end of the
- 51:28golden years that you were enjoying at
- 51:29that point? Or is is that a fair
- 51:31question? I mean,
- 51:32>> absolutely, Bill. I think, you know, my
- 51:36sweetie and Cloudy were so incredibly
- 51:38successful and the business was doing
- 51:40incredibly well. 950 million. Who
- 51:43wouldn't be incredibly happy with that?
- 51:46when when things started to go
- 51:48differently and we started seeing drops
- 51:51in sales with other brands I previously
- 51:54you know from the successes of those
- 51:56initial brands I thought that I could
- 51:58trust your strategy and to to maximize
- 52:01that value that is you know one of my
- 52:03interests here today but when I started
- 52:06seeing sales dropping I I thought that
- 52:08maybe we didn't align on those values
- 52:10anymore and perhaps I was more you know
- 52:13focused on on maximizing ing that value
- 52:16and and getting that success while Yan
- 52:20you were a little too focused on the
- 52:22financials and I understand the
- 52:25importance of focusing on that. I would
- 52:27not have been able to have the success
- 52:28without you being that driver behind
- 52:31that
- 52:33but I
- 52:34>> do you remember that moment that moment
- 52:35of the beginning of a decline and
- 52:37>> I I remember vividly that moment of the
- 52:40decline. It was just after the pandemic
- 52:42hit and yes I I remember that we started
- 52:46to struggle but I also remember my
- 52:48attempts to address the issue of of my
- 52:50lack of experience with so many brands
- 52:52with so with so many new marketing
- 52:54strategies and markets to explore were
- 52:57responded by you with by you with
- 53:00impatience and then you humiliated me in
- 53:03front of the managing staff at this time
- 53:06where I actually needed my partner more
- 53:08than ever. You you turned your back on
- 53:10me. Help me understand that, please.
- 53:14>> Yeah. And I I did say I apologize for my
- 53:17words and my actions. They were, you
- 53:19know, they came from a place of anger
- 53:21and and hurt and I guess vulnerability
- 53:24at seeing my creations perhaps not
- 53:28flourish in the way that I thought they
- 53:30would. Yan, is there
- 53:34what else can I say to to make you feel
- 53:36better? I'm hearing that this is a
- 53:37concern and I note you were belittled
- 53:39and humiliated. How can I regain that
- 53:42trust from you?
- 53:43>> I I accept your apology and I don't want
- 53:45to press on this humiliating moment any
- 53:47longer. However, you mentioned anger as
- 53:49well. Maybe maybe in order to to
- 53:52understand the apology, please help me
- 53:53where your anger actually stems from.
- 53:56Where is it that you saw the starting
- 53:58point? Because for of of the decline of
- 54:00our joint venture, for me it was the
- 54:02financial. Where exactly did it start to
- 54:05burden you?
- 54:06>> Yeah. And so the decline was deeply
- 54:07upsetting for me. I think where the
- 54:10anger more so started is when I found
- 54:12out that you were privately
- 54:14investigating me. So can you tell me a
- 54:17little more about why that decision was
- 54:18made?
- 54:22>> Yes. Um I understand that you were were
- 54:26shocked I think about the private
- 54:28investigation. To me, how this conflict
- 54:31sort of escalated was when
- 54:34when you started
- 54:37um producing at a very high cost, I felt
- 54:42like you were risking the profitability
- 54:44of both of us. I personally I would not
- 54:47source very expensive material, risk the
- 54:51profitability of my own business and
- 54:54then even incur personal liabilities,
- 54:56personal debt as you said. So I kept
- 54:59wondering what is it about that material
- 55:01that you would take such financial
- 55:03risks? Was there even a financial risk
- 55:06you took? I really didn't trust you in
- 55:07that. I'm sorry to say it.
- 55:09>> So just to clarify, the private
- 55:12investigations were looking into the
- 55:14source of the materials.
- 55:17>> I'm sorry this is a misunderstanding.
- 55:18the private investigation were into the
- 55:21personal debt because I didn't
- 55:23understand why you would keep sourcing
- 55:25these expensive materials when you were
- 55:28at the same time incurring personal
- 55:30liabilities. Maybe to clarify, we have
- 55:34to see how this whole situation came to
- 55:37be. The pandemic hit and this led to
- 55:43reduced communication.
- 55:45Yan was trying there was usually there
- 55:48were those two monthly by by monthly
- 55:51meetings where you two were sitting
- 55:53together and trying to find a way to
- 55:56collaborate.
- 55:57Then suddenly
- 55:59those commu the communication cut off.
- 56:03There was a difficulty for my client and
- 56:05that is one point that my client is
- 56:07trying to look into how that happened
- 56:10in in that scope. Then you decided to
- 56:15source increasingly expensive material
- 56:18and you've mentioned before that
- 56:21previously there was a balance between
- 56:23the creativity you provided and the
- 56:26business insight and Jan had. So when
- 56:29communication cut off and you sourced
- 56:33material where Yan believed that was not
- 56:36sustainable,
- 56:38Yan was wondering why you were doing
- 56:40that. and this lack of communication
- 56:44that sort of fostered that mistrust and
- 56:47when Jan was not able to get a hold of
- 56:50you that's when Yan kind of desperately
- 56:53tried to find information how this came
- 56:55to be. So that is the context we're
- 56:58finding ourselves in.
- 57:00>> Okay. I understand Yan and I can imagine
- 57:04this stems from you know your interest
- 57:06of responsibility towards not only the
- 57:08business but the employees and a desire
- 57:11to see it not only succeed but survive
- 57:14what I'm sure you saw as difficult
- 57:16times. I would like to clarify prices
- 57:20were not increasing. Um this all goes to
- 57:24my my value protection and my artistic
- 57:26legacy. the fabric, the materials, the
- 57:30the stitches, everything I use goes to
- 57:33the very heart and soul of the brand and
- 57:37and the quality. I've talked about the
- 57:40importance of the quality and the
- 57:41craftsmanship of the bags. That has
- 57:44always been important to me. You say
- 57:46that I haven't taken on any personal
- 57:49debt, but as a result of Fabcool being
- 57:52unable to pay for these supplies
- 57:54anymore, I have taken out personal IUS
- 57:58with suppliers, which
- 58:01>> I mean, is it safe? Should I tell them?
- 58:03Chloe, do you
- 58:06>> I'm really worried at the moment because
- 58:08these suppliers could come and ask for
- 58:10these debts back at any moment. And this
- 58:13dispute, the uncertainty that I'm facing
- 58:16at the moment threatens that even more
- 58:19and I think puts me and and puts Fab
- 58:22Cool in quite a vulnerable position.
- 58:26>> Thank you for sharing that with us and I
- 58:28I understand your concerns now a lot
- 58:30better. I've heard from you just that
- 58:33what really is integral to you is that
- 58:35craftsmanship, that artistry that is the
- 58:37very foundation sort of of the brands
- 58:39that we established. So maybe help me
- 58:43understand where exactly if if there was
- 58:46if the sky was the limit, where exactly
- 58:48do you see these brands in the next 5
- 58:50years? Where do you see yourself as an
- 58:52artist? What would be an ideal?
- 58:58>> Do you want to take some time? My client
- 59:00would like to answer that question
- 59:01fully. It's quite a large question. Our
- 59:03future strategic vision. I think it
- 59:06could be helpful if we had a private
- 59:07discussion with Bill first so then we
- 59:09could come back and fully answer that
- 59:11question for you with most transparency.
- 59:14If we could have a caucus please Bill.
- 59:15Thank
- 59:16>> you. Fine. Yes, we'll do that.
- 59:33>> Yes. Hi.
- 59:34>> Thank you. Thank you, Chloe, for calling
- 59:36that. Thank you, Bill. Um, Yan has, of
- 59:39course, asked me about where I see the
- 59:42business going, and I anticipate this
- 59:44line of questioning will begin to touch
- 59:46on my my future vision for Fab Cool and
- 59:50how I see that we can maximize value. I
- 59:54have some information, but I'm not quite
- 59:56sure if I'm ready to share it with Yarn
- 59:58at this stage.
- 59:58>> Okay. I have um engaged with business
- 1:00:03strategists to discuss the future of
- 1:00:06Fabcool and I don't want to lie to Yan.
- 1:00:08So I would like to discuss it with you
- 1:00:11first and I guess reality test the idea
- 1:00:13a bit.
- 1:00:14>> Um the reason I don't feel quite ready
- 1:00:17to share it with Yan is because I still
- 1:00:19don't know what the future of our
- 1:00:21relationship is going to look like.
- 1:00:23>> Sure. Um the business strategists have
- 1:00:25told me that with some strategy changes
- 1:00:28we can really turn the business around
- 1:00:30and start maximizing value in the next
- 1:00:33three years.
- 1:00:35On the one hand
- 1:00:37resol a resolution that we reach today.
- 1:00:41It could meet my interests for YAN to
- 1:00:43see this potential for long-term value
- 1:00:46increase. Um so I would want to tell it
- 1:00:49to her. On the other hand, if we do end
- 1:00:52up going our separate ways today and I
- 1:00:55end up buying Yarn out, I don't think
- 1:00:57it's in my best interest to tell her
- 1:00:59about this potential for the value to
- 1:01:01increase
- 1:01:01>> because it'll affect the price.
- 1:01:03>> Absolutely.
- 1:01:04>> I understand.
- 1:01:04>> Or even worse, if if Yan knows about it,
- 1:01:06then it could be the other way around
- 1:01:08and she might decide to hold out and and
- 1:01:11use it for her own good later on. So,
- 1:01:14I'd like to, you know, work with you and
- 1:01:16Chloe to think about when I should best
- 1:01:19disclose this to Yan. Do I risk being
- 1:01:22the first the first mover and maybe
- 1:01:24weakening my position or if I risk
- 1:01:28waiting too long? I think it's a
- 1:01:30valuable piece of information that could
- 1:01:32get missed. Chloe, what would you think
- 1:01:34about advising uh FA to indicate that
- 1:01:37it's a discussion for the future, that
- 1:01:40there are some private thoughts that
- 1:01:41she's had, but there they're not
- 1:01:43particularly fully formed at the moment,
- 1:01:45but that there is there are
- 1:01:46possibilities for growth and not
- 1:01:48actually commit to disclosing uh a
- 1:01:51structured proposal. I mean, that's
- 1:01:52seems to me you get the benefit for the
- 1:01:54purpose of energizing the negotiation
- 1:01:55we're having without actually giving up
- 1:01:58the negotiation position, which I see as
- 1:01:59a very real a real issue for you. But
- 1:02:02that's those would be my initial
- 1:02:03thoughts. It's a
- 1:02:04>> No, thank you, Bill. I think that's
- 1:02:06helpful. I think this stems from the
- 1:02:08fact that coming here today, we didn't
- 1:02:09know if the relationship was going to be
- 1:02:11over. And if it the relationship is
- 1:02:13going to be over, then we don't know
- 1:02:15what that will look like.
- 1:02:16>> Understand?
- 1:02:17>> I think you're right. That's good advice
- 1:02:19that if we discuss that we have
- 1:02:22opportunities for future growth, that
- 1:02:24could really streamline us to maybe
- 1:02:26getting to that point of do we want to
- 1:02:28take that path? Do we still trust each
- 1:02:30other? We've heard from them the
- 1:02:33mistrust it developed from the sourcing
- 1:02:35of materials. Perhaps we need to
- 1:02:37clarify.
- 1:02:37>> Think those were good exchanges. Do you
- 1:02:39think I think we may be near the end of
- 1:02:41those exchanges? We might be beginning
- 1:02:42to
- 1:02:44>> talk about brand value in various ways.
- 1:02:46But that your sense too?
- 1:02:48>> I I think so, Bill. I think um I've
- 1:02:52tried to address Jan's concerns about,
- 1:02:55you know, where the sources of that
- 1:02:56mistrust lie. I do have a few more
- 1:02:59concerns about, you know, how I see
- 1:03:01Jan's business strategy going. So, I
- 1:03:04might have [snorts] a few more questions
- 1:03:05about that, but I agree with Chloe. I I
- 1:03:08don't I still don't know without getting
- 1:03:10those answers where this will go in the
- 1:03:12next
- 1:03:13>> I suppose hour.
- 1:03:14>> I think I think it would be a fair and
- 1:03:15truthful answer to say this is a
- 1:03:17discussion you and I need to have if we
- 1:03:19go forward together. There are all sorts
- 1:03:21of possibilities. uh some of them are
- 1:03:23quite promising, but you know, we're
- 1:03:24going to need to that's not really
- 1:03:26you're not going to write out a strategy
- 1:03:27today on agree.
- 1:03:29>> No,
- 1:03:29>> we've got a more general problem to
- 1:03:32solve.
- 1:03:32>> Okay.
- 1:03:33>> Um so then maybe once once you FY ask uh
- 1:03:38your further clarification, we jump to
- 1:03:39that point of really addressing are we
- 1:03:42which path are we taking and then that
- 1:03:43can dedicate how we spend the rest of
- 1:03:44this mediation.
- 1:03:46>> Yeah.
- 1:03:46>> Okay. I think that's a good idea. Bill,
- 1:03:49how
- 1:03:50>> do you want do you want when they come
- 1:03:51back in again, how do you want to play
- 1:03:52that? Do you shall shall I say that
- 1:03:56you'd now like to give some answers to
- 1:03:57the question Yan asked when we last word
- 1:04:00together? Something like that.
- 1:04:02>> Yeah, I think if you can make some space
- 1:04:03for me to
- 1:04:04>> Okay, I'll do that about that. Thank
- 1:04:06you.
- 1:04:21>> [snorts]
- 1:04:38>> Yeah. Hi. Thank you for that. Um, uh, I
- 1:04:40think, uh, you posed a question when you
- 1:04:42were last in the room, and I think Fay
- 1:04:44was going to give some responses to
- 1:04:46that.
- 1:04:47>> Thank you, Bill. Thank you, Yan and
- 1:04:49Anna, for giving us that time. Um,
- 1:04:52Yanni, you wanted to know what my vision
- 1:04:54is for the future of Fab Call and where
- 1:04:56I see, you know, the the value
- 1:04:59maximization coming from.
- 1:05:01Those are things that I have thought
- 1:05:04about and I do feel hopeful for the
- 1:05:07future. But it does still depend on
- 1:05:11whether we will be able to address the
- 1:05:14concerns that both of us have. And I
- 1:05:17hope that in answering your questions, I
- 1:05:19have been able to clarify where you know
- 1:05:22your sources of mistrust have come from
- 1:05:24and assure you that I was in this as a
- 1:05:28real partner. Before I can talk about
- 1:05:32exactly what I would like to do for the
- 1:05:34future because I think that's also a
- 1:05:35conversation that we should be having
- 1:05:36together, I do have some more questions
- 1:05:39about my concerns um in what has gone in
- 1:05:42the last few years. So if it's all right
- 1:05:44with you, I would like to ask you a
- 1:05:45couple more questions.
- 1:05:47>> Of course.
- 1:05:48>> Thank you. Um so the legitimate concerns
- 1:05:51that remain which I think stem from the
- 1:05:54different attitudes that we may have
- 1:05:56taken regarding cost verse quality and
- 1:05:59the value that we placed on those
- 1:06:00respective factors. Um
- 1:06:04what do you think are the main issues
- 1:06:07that you have regarding the current
- 1:06:10business strategy?
- 1:06:13For me, it is really that the financial
- 1:06:16setbacks we experienced troubled me.
- 1:06:19There were soaring production costs with
- 1:06:21an sort of unsustainable marketing
- 1:06:23budget. There were huge endorsement fees
- 1:06:26for celebrity um product ambassadors and
- 1:06:30some of the design turned out to be less
- 1:06:33popular than we had anticipated.
- 1:06:36Um so I do acknowledge my my marketing
- 1:06:40mistakes and my misjudgment in the past.
- 1:06:42So maybe given that for me it was the
- 1:06:46financial setbacks. I think for you the
- 1:06:48the the marketing aspect might be more
- 1:06:50important. So do you see any future with
- 1:06:53us with respect to my maybe my my lack
- 1:06:56of experience in that regard that I do
- 1:06:58acknowledge.
- 1:06:59>> Thank you for that openness and and
- 1:07:01acknowledging I suppose a lack of
- 1:07:03experience. I too have a lack of
- 1:07:05experience when it comes to maybe the
- 1:07:07the commercial side or the the
- 1:07:09accounting side of this. Um you
- 1:07:12mentioned that the concerns are
- 1:07:15financial. They you know stem from
- 1:07:18financial setbacks as well as marketing.
- 1:07:21Do you have any numbers that you're able
- 1:07:23to give me regarding those concerns?
- 1:07:27Yes, I think we have seen the we we've
- 1:07:31missed the target of the mi mini tote um
- 1:07:35by 40% and I do acknowledge that not
- 1:07:39replacing that product was a marketing
- 1:07:41mistake I made and I sincerely apologize
- 1:07:43for that. In hindsight, it was a mistake
- 1:07:46that I didn't anticipate. However, we've
- 1:07:49missed a sales target and that really
- 1:07:51troubled us. These are the numbers I can
- 1:07:53give you.
- 1:07:53>> Right. So, you're referring to the drop
- 1:07:56in sales we saw for the magic tote. Um,
- 1:07:59and no, that's okay. And when I
- 1:08:01suggested that we replace it with the
- 1:08:03mini cute bag, um, and those that
- 1:08:06suggestion, I suppose, was rejected, but
- 1:08:08thank you for acknowledging that, you
- 1:08:10also mentioned the marketing side. Um,
- 1:08:13do you think that those marketing
- 1:08:15concerns or financial concerns could be
- 1:08:17mitigated in the future if we do, you
- 1:08:20know, if we reduced costs in the
- 1:08:22marketing areas perhaps? I know we've
- 1:08:25you've worked on some celebrity um
- 1:08:27campaigns in the past. Can you speak to
- 1:08:30the success of those perhaps?
- 1:08:33>> Um, so you're wondering whether our
- 1:08:35financial setbacks might be mitigated if
- 1:08:37we just reduced cost in terms of
- 1:08:39celebrity product ambassadors. Um I have
- 1:08:42not looked into the numbers of that. I
- 1:08:44think any mitigation of costs might be
- 1:08:47helpful looking in the future. What I'm
- 1:08:49wondering is just whether you actually
- 1:08:52trust in my abilities to to
- 1:08:56well to come up with the right marketing
- 1:08:59strategies. What I've understood so far
- 1:09:01is that this is really important to you
- 1:09:02the marketing of the of the artistry in
- 1:09:05these brands. And I well I think my
- 1:09:08pragmatism as you put it might not be
- 1:09:12fit to to your needs in that sense.
- 1:09:16I think on the issue of moving forward
- 1:09:19we should discuss how we want to move
- 1:09:20forward and the path we'll take. I'll
- 1:09:22just I'll summarize where we are now
- 1:09:25because we have covered a lot. I think
- 1:09:27it's very positive that we've discussed
- 1:09:29the mistrust. We discussed the private
- 1:09:32investigation and that you wanted to
- 1:09:34know what the debts were being incurred
- 1:09:36on both sides for the sourcing of the
- 1:09:39goods, the materials and the costs.
- 1:09:41We've talked about that my client has
- 1:09:44creative and exciting opportunities in
- 1:09:46the future for growth. But to discuss
- 1:09:49that together will really depend on what
- 1:09:50path we take moving forward.
- 1:09:53Additionally, we've acknowledged that
- 1:09:55the main difference the main issue
- 1:09:57between you two is your difference in
- 1:09:58vision and strategy. I think there was
- 1:10:00some promising discussion that you were
- 1:10:02very transparent and kind Yan that there
- 1:10:05have been some marketing mistakes and
- 1:10:07there does need to be learning there in
- 1:10:09the future. What you two represent I
- 1:10:11think are two two talents on each side
- 1:10:13of the spectrum. We have Jan with the
- 1:10:15accounts and the financials and FA with
- 1:10:17the creativity and the craftsmanship.
- 1:10:20And if you wanted to explore this
- 1:10:21partnership going forward, I see a lot
- 1:10:23of value in perhaps having a balanced
- 1:10:26third party coming in and balancing
- 1:10:28those two sides of the spectrum to
- 1:10:30really build your protect your value and
- 1:10:33build your uh operational stability.
- 1:10:35>> I agree. I think maybe that's even an
- 1:10:37option that we can note down for later,
- 1:10:39Bill or Chloe. Um Yan, you asked, you
- 1:10:43know, specifically about the trust and
- 1:10:44moving forward in the future and whether
- 1:10:46I do see a possibility in trusting you
- 1:10:49again. I think that your transparency
- 1:10:51and your openness and admitting where
- 1:10:53things went wrong and apologizing as
- 1:10:56well has gone a long way in that. So
- 1:10:59perhaps with this significant trust
- 1:11:01behind us and you know the respective
- 1:11:04concerns resolved I would say in the
- 1:11:06time that we have left today do you
- 1:11:08think it would be um more valuable to
- 1:11:11prioritize exploring moving forwards
- 1:11:13towards a continued partnership or still
- 1:11:16going our separate ways?
- 1:11:18There's I think um there there has been
- 1:11:20a lot of information I've heard about
- 1:11:22third parties coming in and I think
- 1:11:23there are a lot options to explore.
- 1:11:25There's just one thing that I think
- 1:11:27needs further discussion and this is I
- 1:11:29appreciate very much that you're so
- 1:11:31confident in my abilities as an
- 1:11:32accountant. However, there are some um
- 1:11:37you didn't sign off the um the finance
- 1:11:41um statements that we made this year.
- 1:11:43The accountant accounting Yeah. Um maybe
- 1:11:48can we clarify why that happened before
- 1:11:51we move on? Um just to clarify we have
- 1:11:54heard from you in the beginning that
- 1:11:56this has happened because you were
- 1:11:59angered and there were a lot of feelings
- 1:12:01involved so you didn't sign but try
- 1:12:03client is now trying to figure out is
- 1:12:06there any other reason beyond those
- 1:12:09feelings that were involved that would
- 1:12:11hold you back now to sign off those
- 1:12:13statements and I've also heard you talk
- 1:12:16about that you were shocked that we
- 1:12:17involved a third party the auditor so
- 1:12:21two questions Is there anything holding
- 1:12:23you back? And what is your concern
- 1:12:25regarding the auditor?
- 1:12:27>> We just break that down one at a time.
- 1:12:29>> Thank you. Um that was a few questions
- 1:12:31in one. Um yes, you're right. The reason
- 1:12:34I did not sign was because I was
- 1:12:37angered. Um I I had just found out about
- 1:12:40the private investigation and I was hurt
- 1:12:42and I felt betrayed and that is why I
- 1:12:44didn't I did not sign them. There was no
- 1:12:47other reasoning or intention behind that
- 1:12:50um or concerns.
- 1:12:52>> Chloe, what what
- 1:12:53>> can I just can I just make a point? I
- 1:12:55think I think this has been a re really
- 1:12:57useful exchange. Um there's probably a
- 1:13:00further question to answer about the
- 1:13:01accounts, but I think you've you've
- 1:13:02you've indicated the main point. Um uh
- 1:13:06eventually the uh the mediation center
- 1:13:08where we're sitting will be closing for
- 1:13:09the night. So we there are some time
- 1:13:11constraints upon us. We may we can meet
- 1:13:13again in due course. um in early course
- 1:13:16I suggest if we if we don't complete our
- 1:13:18discussions tonight but I just want to
- 1:13:19get as far as we we can um and I want to
- 1:13:22ask you one question which is that Khloe
- 1:13:24at at the beginning pointed out the
- 1:13:27damage that we've done to the brands by
- 1:13:28the disruption of this litigation which
- 1:13:30would take some time do you remember her
- 1:13:32making that point does that accord with
- 1:13:34your views on your side and your advice
- 1:13:36to your client as well
- 1:13:39>> yes similarly to the other party my
- 1:13:42client is also worried about lengthy
- 1:13:44proceedings. So I think this is a common
- 1:13:47interest that my client and FA share. We
- 1:13:51do not want to proceed in court. We
- 1:13:53would like to find an amicable solution
- 1:13:56here. Um however there unless those very
- 1:14:01important interests are met for example
- 1:14:03like the employees um then there we
- 1:14:07might consider litigation. But I think
- 1:14:11we all favor a solution here today
- 1:14:15instead of going to court.
- 1:14:17>> Well, is it is it time to put some
- 1:14:19headings on the board relating to
- 1:14:21outcomes and uh course we take from here
- 1:14:24on?
- 1:14:25>> I think we're at that fork in the road
- 1:14:26now. Um so I'll put my question again,
- 1:14:29Yan. Um, Bill, you mentioned we don't
- 1:14:32have much time left today. And while I
- 1:14:34acknowledge we may not reach a final
- 1:14:37agreement, I would like to use what time
- 1:14:40we have left efficiently. Um, so Yan, at
- 1:14:43this stage, do you feel it's better to
- 1:14:46prioritize discussing a potential path
- 1:14:49forward together or separately?
- 1:14:52This um is a very broad question that
- 1:14:55you put here but I feel like we have
- 1:14:56cleared we have with what we have
- 1:14:58established so far there is there's a
- 1:15:00lot of trust that is sort of rebuild and
- 1:15:02I think what we agree on is that a lack
- 1:15:04of communication is really what troubled
- 1:15:07this relationship a lot given that we're
- 1:15:10on the two sides of the spectrum. You've
- 1:15:12mentioned a third party that might work
- 1:15:14as a facilitator in that communication.
- 1:15:16So maybe we explore that as an option
- 1:15:19looking forward together because I do
- 1:15:21not see us as the two of us
- 1:15:23collaborating to be honest.
- 1:15:26That's good to hear Yan. Thank you. And
- 1:15:28I have noted that as an option to
- 1:15:30discuss later, but perhaps then if we're
- 1:15:34looking towards the questions needing to
- 1:15:36be asked, should we separate? Um should
- 1:15:40FA buy out your shareholding just to
- 1:15:43gather some sense of what would go
- 1:15:45forward. Um, what would you need for an
- 1:15:47amicable separation?
- 1:15:51>> If SH was to if FA was to buy out my
- 1:15:54shareholdings, um, I would
- 1:15:59I'm sorry. I would love to at least get
- 1:16:03um get the the um licenses for my
- 1:16:07sweetie and for Cloudy so I can keep
- 1:16:11distributing these as these have been
- 1:16:13the most valuable
- 1:16:16um brands that we've established
- 1:16:18together
- 1:16:19>> and then on the alternative should you
- 1:16:21buy out FA shareholding uh what value do
- 1:16:24the brands you've mentioned two of them
- 1:16:27my sweetie and cloudy in addition the 10
- 1:16:29others is what value do these brands
- 1:16:32share to you?
- 1:16:35>> Likewise, I think for me it is most
- 1:16:36important of sorts to keep a sort of
- 1:16:39hold on these valuable um on these
- 1:16:42valuable brands
- 1:16:45>> and is that is you know holding on to
- 1:16:48those valuable brands you've mentioned
- 1:16:50their value a couple of times. Is that
- 1:16:52more about the the profit that you
- 1:16:54derive from them or wanting to, you
- 1:16:57know, is it something more meaningful?
- 1:16:59Because in my, you know, from my
- 1:17:02perspective, my sweetie and Cloudy
- 1:17:03represent that artistic legacy that I'm
- 1:17:06talking about and what I'm trying to
- 1:17:08protect here today.
- 1:17:10>> I think we can agree that you're the
- 1:17:12artistic hat of this joint venture and
- 1:17:15these brands just have been the most
- 1:17:16popular with our customers. So far I
- 1:17:19have no other artist on hand who could
- 1:17:21provide me with likewise successful
- 1:17:23brands. So we would need these brands to
- 1:17:26remain in business also.
- 1:17:28>> And what I'm also hearing from you is
- 1:17:30because your interest is predominantly
- 1:17:32financial, you would also be should we
- 1:17:36separate, you would be interested in
- 1:17:38finding a way to still maintain a
- 1:17:40manufacturing relationship potentially
- 1:17:44even though the joint venture itself may
- 1:17:46separate.
- 1:17:49I've not thought about this option
- 1:17:52concretely, but this sounds reasonable.
- 1:17:54So, however, right now, I cannot see how
- 1:17:58this would alter relationship.
- 1:18:00>> Sorry, I'll clarify. I don't you
- 1:18:01mentioned I heard from you then that the
- 1:18:03reason you wanted the two licenses to my
- 1:18:06sweetie and cloudy was for their value
- 1:18:08and that you don't have other designers
- 1:18:11to give you more value. So that's
- 1:18:13something of interest that looking
- 1:18:14forward you would need a pathway for
- 1:18:16more value ad more value creation.
- 1:18:20>> Yes. Or I was actually hoping for a sort
- 1:18:23of license that I would keep could keep
- 1:18:25distributing as sort of my exclusive
- 1:18:28right these two brands so you would
- 1:18:30retain the trademarks but I could keep
- 1:18:32distributing them in the market in my
- 1:18:34market. So maybe to summarize, we have
- 1:18:37talked about either of the parties
- 1:18:41buying out the shares of the other and
- 1:18:44we've talked about a possible future
- 1:18:46collaboration.
- 1:18:48What we've also established is that the
- 1:18:51way the coal collaboration has worked
- 1:18:53with you being on the opposite ends of
- 1:18:56the spectrum, we would need a third
- 1:18:57party. So I think if we continue to
- 1:19:01explore um that option of a future
- 1:19:05collaboration in this joint venture with
- 1:19:08the two parties present, we would need a
- 1:19:10third party. Regarding the other two
- 1:19:13options, what I've heard is that if you
- 1:19:16were to buy out the shares of my client,
- 1:19:19there of course needs to be some
- 1:19:22compensation for those shares. So um how
- 1:19:26does that compensation looks like? my
- 1:19:28client is open to discuss. If we do it
- 1:19:31the other way around that my client is
- 1:19:34to buy out your shares, we would also
- 1:19:36need to figure out a way of compensation
- 1:19:38and what you would like to keep since
- 1:19:41you have also mentioned that you would
- 1:19:42like to be creatively connected to your
- 1:19:45bags.
- 1:19:45>> Okay, deep breath. Let's all take a deep
- 1:19:48breath because we've quite quite quickly
- 1:19:51and quite suddenly gone into um quite
- 1:19:55specific bargaining. Uh and and you've
- 1:19:57done that, no doubt, in response to my
- 1:19:59urging to get on with it and get out get
- 1:20:02out before they close the lights. Um I
- 1:20:05think what what the solution would need
- 1:20:08to be to the to the process from now on
- 1:20:11is that you should end up each of you
- 1:20:14with a a sufficiently clear idea of
- 1:20:18option one and option two to make a
- 1:20:20choice between them or indeed to choose
- 1:20:22option three which is to do neither and
- 1:20:24carry on and litigate. So option one is
- 1:20:26that you improve and redesign the joint
- 1:20:28venture company. Option two is that you
- 1:20:32take over completely one of you takes
- 1:20:33over completely the the um joint venture
- 1:20:36company presumably paying some compens
- 1:20:38compensation and we're you're beginning
- 1:20:39to map that out now. Is that is that the
- 1:20:43is that the kind of landscape you now
- 1:20:44want to explore those those two choices
- 1:20:47>> precisely Bill and I think they are two
- 1:20:50very difficult landscapes and difficult
- 1:20:52choices. Anna, you did a great job of,
- 1:20:54you know, summing up their complexities.
- 1:20:57I think regardless of which path we
- 1:20:59take, there will be several things to
- 1:21:01discuss. So perhaps some discussion
- 1:21:04about how we can navigate that,
- 1:21:07>> Chloe. Um, if we do decide,
- 1:21:13if we do decide to part ways, thank you,
- 1:21:16Bill. There are of course a lot of
- 1:21:20factors that would need to be discussed.
- 1:21:22I mentioned in my opening it's
- 1:21:23>> sure you got I think you've got two
- 1:21:25Chloe you got two
- 1:21:27>> yes
- 1:21:29>> I it's I'm the least important person
- 1:21:31you have that
- 1:21:32>> well we do have a lot of a lot of
- 1:21:34factors making up the joint venture that
- 1:21:36would need to be discussed um of course
- 1:21:39I think these are all things that we
- 1:21:41need to touch on in the discussion if
- 1:21:44it's a situation of splitting up perhaps
- 1:21:48using this to look at what we need to
- 1:21:50address who takes what. Um,
- 1:21:55alternatively, if we are going to
- 1:21:57continue together, we've mentioned there
- 1:21:59is a tension and we are on two ends of
- 1:22:01the spectrum and I think that there will
- 1:22:03need to be significant changes in how
- 1:22:06the joint venture is managed. So perhaps
- 1:22:08this is also a way then to look at the
- 1:22:11different factors of that relationship
- 1:22:13and how we can alter each one to make it
- 1:22:17uh more successful and to really protect
- 1:22:19the value of the brand and ensure that
- 1:22:22the operational stability that I'm
- 1:22:24looking for and of course make sure that
- 1:22:26your responsibility our shared
- 1:22:28responsibility to the joint venture and
- 1:22:30to the employees is protected as well.
- 1:22:36>> Okay. Um thank you for the clarifying um
- 1:22:41handout. Um so what I've heard from you
- 1:22:43is a lot of option that we very quickly
- 1:22:46explored. However, um right now I'm not
- 1:22:49I have not fully understood right now
- 1:22:51what you would prefer actually. Are you
- 1:22:53looking into options to separate? You've
- 1:22:55asked many questions about that and what
- 1:22:56I would sort of prefer in these times,
- 1:22:59but what is it actually that you would
- 1:23:01prefer? You mentioned a third party
- 1:23:02coming in as an option to keep
- 1:23:05collaborating.
- 1:23:06What however is it that you want to
- 1:23:09separate or keep working together?
- 1:23:12>> I think at the end of the day, I
- 1:23:15mentioned the bags represent my
- 1:23:18children. I'm not willing to completely
- 1:23:20walk away from them. I understand that
- 1:23:22Yan, you see the value in Cloudy and My
- 1:23:25Sweetie, but those are not brands I'm
- 1:23:28simply willing to give up. um I do have
- 1:23:30an interest in retaining them and
- 1:23:33protecting their value and the artistic
- 1:23:35legacy, my artistic legacy that I think
- 1:23:38lies directly with them. Um perhaps I'm
- 1:23:43you know thinking out loud perhaps at
- 1:23:45this stage if that's something that we
- 1:23:46we do see eye to eye on you know the
- 1:23:48value of those brands and the additional
- 1:23:50brands of course maybe exploring a way
- 1:23:53that we can continue this together and
- 1:23:55collaborate but not forgetting that
- 1:23:58there will need to be significant
- 1:23:59changes clearly some things have not
- 1:24:01worked in the past and we need to
- 1:24:03explore how we can change those to
- 1:24:05ensure they work in the future. So my
- 1:24:08suggestion would be that that you look
- 1:24:09at the possibility of improving the
- 1:24:11joint venture company and making some
- 1:24:13changes to it under no obligation to
- 1:24:15then do that deal under no obligation to
- 1:24:17then take that course but you can look
- 1:24:19at it knowing that you have the
- 1:24:21alternatives of um the more radical
- 1:24:24separation if you wanted that would be a
- 1:24:26recommendation from me Yan you could
- 1:24:27take take it forward however you wish
- 1:24:29>> I appreciate that faith in our
- 1:24:31collaboration however um I think what
- 1:24:34we've seen in the past is just that the
- 1:24:36two of us cannot really work together
- 1:24:38just the two of us. You've mentioned
- 1:24:40that third party and I'm sorry I'm
- 1:24:42coming back to it so often, but is there
- 1:24:44someone you do have in mind or at least
- 1:24:46some some quality that you think we
- 1:24:48together lack that someone else could
- 1:24:50provide?
- 1:24:53>> There's two points to that Yan and I'll
- 1:24:55answer for transparency and then perhaps
- 1:24:57it would be time to bounce options
- 1:24:59against each other to really iron out
- 1:25:01those details. In regards to the third
- 1:25:03party, there isn't someone pre-selected.
- 1:25:06As we said, there's no pre-planned uh
- 1:25:09plans coming here today because we
- 1:25:11really needed to explore the
- 1:25:12relationship between both of us.
- 1:25:14However, we brought that up to ask you
- 1:25:17if you would feel comfortable walking
- 1:25:19away from that strategy role and we
- 1:25:23acknowledge that you have a financial
- 1:25:24role, FA has a creative role, and if
- 1:25:26that strategy role could perhaps be
- 1:25:28passed to someone else. We've gathered
- 1:25:31your response to that which is very
- 1:25:32helpful and again we can discuss in
- 1:25:34options. Additionally, in regards to how
- 1:25:38that third party would be judged by
- 1:25:41quality, we think an objective criteria
- 1:25:44of when we're sourcing this person, they
- 1:25:47have a blind questionnaire that really
- 1:25:50when they're filling it out, it makes
- 1:25:52clear that we have these two priorities
- 1:25:54and artistic legacy, craftsmanship, and
- 1:25:57commercial sustainability. so that they
- 1:25:59see all of that and we can really assess
- 1:26:01them objectively and see how they
- 1:26:03balance between these interests. We
- 1:26:06wouldn't want to get someone who's
- 1:26:07biased to one side too because then we
- 1:26:09won't be balancing the the spectrum
- 1:26:11between us.
- 1:26:12>> Yes, I think this sounds like a like an
- 1:26:14actually very forward-looking plan and I
- 1:26:16think some this is an idea I I do feel
- 1:26:19comfortable with comfortable with.
- 1:26:21However, there's one issue that just
- 1:26:23comes to my mind when I'm mapping out
- 1:26:25this as a concrete option because I feel
- 1:26:27like what we were really lacking in our
- 1:26:29relationship in the past three years and
- 1:26:31I know the pandemic hit and this is
- 1:26:32something we could not influence.
- 1:26:34However, we lacked communication. So
- 1:26:36maybe we also need to get into how we
- 1:26:39make sure that if there is even a third
- 1:26:41party coming in, we have this very
- 1:26:45intense and neat network of
- 1:26:48communication.
- 1:26:49Yeah. Do you have any thoughts on that?
- 1:26:53>> That's that's another great option. I
- 1:26:56think we should get into tossing some
- 1:26:58options uh towards each other in a
- 1:27:01pingpong type style. And just to clarify
- 1:27:04before we do that, we uh FA has one more
- 1:27:07point on the numbers which will then
- 1:27:08inform options that we can put on the
- 1:27:10table shortly after.
- 1:27:13>> Thank you. Thank you, Chloe. Yan, I'm
- 1:27:15aware you've talked about having to take
- 1:27:17out a personal debt. Um my knowledge is
- 1:27:21that this this the number that was given
- 1:27:23to me was 15 million. Um are you able to
- 1:27:26disclose any more information around
- 1:27:28that? Maybe clarification on the amount
- 1:27:30and also when it might be due.
- 1:27:33>> Yes. So I think we're comfortable enough
- 1:27:35now after the many apologies. Um,
- 1:27:38actually I've I've had to mortgage my
- 1:27:40house and I took on bank debts in the
- 1:27:42height of $15 million to to keep this
- 1:27:46joint venture afloat because I really
- 1:27:48believed in this as something looking
- 1:27:50forward and this is really something
- 1:27:52that I need to get well that really
- 1:27:55concerns me.
- 1:27:56>> Right. And was that full I mean sorry
- 1:28:00first needing to mortgage your house.
- 1:28:02I'm surprised to hear that, but thank
- 1:28:05you for your openness and I'm sorry that
- 1:28:06it did need to come to that. Um, this
- 1:28:10$15 million figure perhaps did this all
- 1:28:14go towards the joint venture. Can you
- 1:28:16give me a breakdown of how that was
- 1:28:17used?
- 1:28:19It was um so when you were starting to
- 1:28:23source these expensive materials, we
- 1:28:25could not cover the cost of that, the
- 1:28:27production cost, the the that they sort
- 1:28:29of inflated the price on on these
- 1:28:32imports from Pandagonia. And um that was
- 1:28:36that was burdening sort of fabul. And
- 1:28:39since I really believed in this, I guess
- 1:28:41it was my pragmatism that made me
- 1:28:43mortgage my house just to keep going
- 1:28:46with this joint venture. Right.
- 1:28:50And just the final question, when is
- 1:28:53that loan due back to the bank?
- 1:28:56>> Do you have that information with you?
- 1:28:58>> I'm sorry. I cannot give you this
- 1:29:00information.
- 1:29:02>> Well, in that case,
- 1:29:03>> I think I think there are some things
- 1:29:05that we should bank here in the sense of
- 1:29:08elements of a proposed ongoing
- 1:29:10structure. Is it worth just putting ne
- 1:29:14neutral third party and improved
- 1:29:16communications on on the on the board
- 1:29:18which I've heard?
- 1:29:18>> Thank you.
- 1:29:19>> I think FA you you sound as if you're
- 1:29:21beginning to tackle these financial
- 1:29:23claims and I'm happy for you to do that.
- 1:29:24But just while you're pursuing that, let
- 1:29:27me just put those items up on this.
- 1:29:29>> Thank you, Bill. I think that will be
- 1:29:30really helpful to have the those
- 1:29:32potential options up there for us.
- 1:29:37Hey, uh Yan, you mentioned, you know,
- 1:29:39concerns about the communication lapsing
- 1:29:41and needing to put something in place to
- 1:29:43ensure that doesn't happen again. Um do
- 1:29:46you have any ideas on how we can ensure
- 1:29:50um that the communications don't lapse
- 1:29:52again in the future?
- 1:29:54>> I think as long as we were meeting
- 1:29:56regularly and really focusing on a joint
- 1:29:58strategy, everything was going well.
- 1:30:01The issue sort of occurred when when we
- 1:30:04were separated um also in terms of also
- 1:30:08location wise and we were not able to
- 1:30:11meet regularly. I think with so
- 1:30:13different people as we are which can be
- 1:30:16um the engine of this joint venture as
- 1:30:18you mentioned at the very beginning um
- 1:30:21maybe we just need to make sure that we
- 1:30:23understand each other. I know that you
- 1:30:25were very concerned about your health.
- 1:30:27However, I didn't really understand the
- 1:30:29scope. So maybe we can get into how we
- 1:30:32make sure that we also on a personal
- 1:30:33level we communicate in a way that
- 1:30:35everyone feels comfortable with but that
- 1:30:37really all matters are on the table.
- 1:30:40>> Thank you Yan. And I I understand that
- 1:30:43and I think that we probably share that
- 1:30:46interest in having probably what we can
- 1:30:48call a commitment to
- 1:30:51um to communication moving forward. And
- 1:30:54I mean if we have this option of a third
- 1:30:56party as well I'm sure the entire
- 1:30:58structure will look different. So that's
- 1:30:59something that we can iron out and make
- 1:31:02sure we are on the same page for. Um
- 1:31:04Yan, do you have any more, you know,
- 1:31:06concerns about the potential for moving
- 1:31:09forward that you would like to clarify
- 1:31:10or do you think that it would be a good
- 1:31:12time to maybe move on and start
- 1:31:14exploring what it would actually look
- 1:31:16like?
- 1:31:17>> Um let me cut in first before we move
- 1:31:19forward. The reason why my client asked
- 1:31:22about your health, I know this is a very
- 1:31:24sensitive uh issue, very personal, was
- 1:31:27we have talked about that we want to
- 1:31:29improve communication and my client was
- 1:31:32trying to figure out whether the reason
- 1:31:35behind the lack of communication during
- 1:31:38or after the pandemic was purely because
- 1:31:41of health concerns or whether there was
- 1:31:44another underlying reason that is not
- 1:31:48here anymore.
- 1:31:50I understand that Anna and I think you
- 1:31:52know having that shared commitment to
- 1:31:55communication going forward would
- 1:31:56probably go a long way if you have that
- 1:31:58certainty that there was nothing else I
- 1:32:01guess looming um and causing that. Um it
- 1:32:05was you know a very difficult time the
- 1:32:07pandemic in Lmania and I was concerned
- 1:32:09about having to travel to I guess
- 1:32:12infectious zones. So that is why I
- 1:32:14stopped the visits but you know we were
- 1:32:16able to continue online for a while. Um
- 1:32:20I'm of the opinion that it it's quite
- 1:32:22difficult online. I think we're very
- 1:32:23privileged even here today being able to
- 1:32:26be in the same room across the table
- 1:32:28from each other. It's I think the
- 1:32:30quality of the conversation and the
- 1:32:32communication is really enhanced when
- 1:32:33that does happen. So when we did have to
- 1:32:35go online it was difficult to manage and
- 1:32:38you know different time zones were also
- 1:32:40difficult but you know there was nothing
- 1:32:43else um that was making me not want to
- 1:32:46communicate with you. Thank you for
- 1:32:49saying that. I think this really helps
- 1:32:50my client. Um in the interest of moving
- 1:32:55forward and because we have talked about
- 1:32:57the third party a lot. Um please help me
- 1:33:00to understand what the role what the
- 1:33:02role is my client will play in that
- 1:33:05regard. We have talked about what a
- 1:33:07possible third party could do but what
- 1:33:09is the remaining role of my client in
- 1:33:11that option?
- 1:33:13I think that depends on, you know, both
- 1:33:16my strengths and and Yan's strengths and
- 1:33:19really thinking how we can maximize
- 1:33:21those
- 1:33:22while not perhaps overbearing one or the
- 1:33:25other with areas of the joint venture
- 1:33:28that go beyond our
- 1:33:33strengths. Um
- 1:33:36perhaps that goes a bit more towards
- 1:33:38Yan, where do you think your strengths
- 1:33:40would lie with the joint venture? What
- 1:33:41sort of involvement would you want to
- 1:33:43have?
- 1:33:45>> I think um the distribution and
- 1:33:48establishing this and expanding the
- 1:33:49retail network is something I I I can
- 1:33:53help with and where I can contribute to
- 1:33:55my very best as well as the numbers.
- 1:33:58However, I think we all know by now that
- 1:34:01marketing and is not really my strong
- 1:34:04suit. And I guess this is exactly the
- 1:34:06position that we needed to fill with
- 1:34:09another person. Do you agree?
- 1:34:11>> I think that's a great idea and I think
- 1:34:14my strengths of course lie in the the
- 1:34:16creative input and if you're comfortable
- 1:34:19managing the the distribution networks
- 1:34:22that's of course what you were your
- 1:34:23family business started out as before we
- 1:34:25even met long ago. um maybe having that
- 1:34:28third neutral party that can balance
- 1:34:31both of those and think about the
- 1:34:32marketing which I acknowledge you admit
- 1:34:34is not one of your strengths but making
- 1:34:36sure that they think about marketing
- 1:34:39with regards to the specific
- 1:34:40distribution networks that you will
- 1:34:42provide and the the numbers and what we
- 1:34:44need to reach there and also maximizing
- 1:34:46that marketing for the specific designs
- 1:34:49and artistic legacy that I'm trying to
- 1:34:51protect.
- 1:34:52>> I think this sounds like a good option.
- 1:34:54maybe even a person who could facilitate
- 1:34:56communications where we, you know, do
- 1:34:58not speak each other just thinking out
- 1:35:00loud here. However, since we're looking
- 1:35:02into options for the future and giving
- 1:35:04the little time remaining, we do have we
- 1:35:06do have death depth that somehow need to
- 1:35:10be covered. So maybe we focus on this
- 1:35:11one point because I've heard from you
- 1:35:13that this is really a pressing matter
- 1:35:14since you um you might you've said that
- 1:35:19it is really that time is of essence in
- 1:35:21that regard.
- 1:35:23>> Yeah. So I think you're wanting to know
- 1:35:25what we can do immediately about the
- 1:35:27debts that have been incurred by both of
- 1:35:30us at this stage as a result of the
- 1:35:31breakdown.
- 1:35:33As I've mentioned, I have, you know, $10
- 1:35:36million
- 1:35:38that will probably be recalled by the
- 1:35:40suppliers very soon. I'm aware you've
- 1:35:43acknowledged the $15 million mortgage
- 1:35:45you've had to take out on your house. I
- 1:35:47think in the spirit of collaboration and
- 1:35:50moving forward perhaps if we can reach
- 1:35:52that amicable um resolution today that
- 1:35:56might be something that we can agree to
- 1:35:58wave. Chloe, do you think that's a good
- 1:36:01idea?
- 1:36:03We can I'll put an option on the table
- 1:36:07and we don't have to evaluate it but
- 1:36:10just so that it's expressed. Um should
- 1:36:14Yan sell their shares to Fay? Um then
- 1:36:19the
- 1:36:21the sharehold the business is currently
- 1:36:24valued at 50 million. Yes. So 50% of
- 1:36:27that is 25 million
- 1:36:30and the
- 1:36:33should yet yan sell 50% of their shares
- 1:36:37what my client could do is pay off 15
- 1:36:41million over a 2 to fouryear time period
- 1:36:47and pay off the other 10 million of that
- 1:36:5025 by assigning to Yan the licenses for
- 1:36:53all 10 minor brands within the joint
- 1:36:55venture.
- 1:36:59So maybe could you help us maybe note
- 1:37:03that down or clarify um what the option
- 1:37:07the other party has presented right now
- 1:37:09is and how do we arrive at that numbers?
- 1:37:13So what I heard Khloe say was that
- 1:37:16envisioning a a buyout of Jans shares by
- 1:37:20FA uh rec recognizing a value of 25
- 1:37:24million uh that there would be uh she
- 1:37:27would pay 25 million
- 1:37:2915 million of it over a period of years
- 1:37:32and the remainder to be satisfied the
- 1:37:34remaining 10 million to be satisfied by
- 1:37:35assigning to Yan what are called the
- 1:37:38minor brands. So
- 1:37:41that's what was proposed.
- 1:37:44>> I do believe um from the
- 1:37:47instant liquidity isn't necessarily in
- 1:37:49each of our interests. My understanding
- 1:37:50of mortgage payments is that they're st
- 1:37:52they're scheduled and so that could
- 1:37:54align with a scheduled payment over the
- 1:37:57next two to four years perhaps.
- 1:37:59>> So we would retain the licenses for the
- 1:38:0210 minor brands to two to four years.
- 1:38:05Well, I understand your need for the um
- 1:38:10you've mentioned that my sweetie and
- 1:38:11cloudy are your babies, but they are or
- 1:38:14some like your children, but these are
- 1:38:17very integral for me to distribute them
- 1:38:20because I've mentioned I'm not really a
- 1:38:22marketing expert. So, these minor
- 1:38:23brands, I'm just afraid that they cannot
- 1:38:26really they're not really that valuable
- 1:38:28for me given that it is only two to four
- 1:38:30years. Maybe we agree to only the two
- 1:38:32years, but I would have an exclusive
- 1:38:35license for my sweetie and cloudy. Is
- 1:38:37this something we could agree on? And
- 1:38:38then I would um sell my shares to FA. Is
- 1:38:43this a possible option for two years?
- 1:38:46>> Just to clarify the option you're
- 1:38:48proposing. So that would be selling your
- 1:38:50shares for the proposed scheduled
- 1:38:54payments that we said. But in addition,
- 1:38:56uh the option you're putting on the
- 1:38:58table is to have a license over My
- 1:39:01Sweetie and Cloudy for two years.
- 1:39:04>> Yes, exactly.
- 1:39:07>> All right.
- 1:39:09Would you like to propose another
- 1:39:10option?
- 1:39:13>> Thank you. Um,
- 1:39:18I think another option, of course, just
- 1:39:21if we're throwing them all out there,
- 1:39:23um, I am interested in protecting the
- 1:39:26artistic value and the legacy of my
- 1:39:28brand. So, I would be interested in
- 1:39:31retaining the license to all of my my
- 1:39:34children, as I called them. Um, and, you
- 1:39:38know, establishing what you would need
- 1:39:41um to agree to give them all to me.
- 1:39:43Excuse
- 1:39:45me. What was the ending of your
- 1:39:48>> establishing what um you would like YAN
- 1:39:51in exchange for me retaining um all of
- 1:39:54the licenses?
- 1:39:55>> So the discussion a moment ago was about
- 1:39:58the the difference between you seemed to
- 1:39:59be about how you dealt with 10 million
- 1:40:01gap between 25 million value of the 50%
- 1:40:06shareholding and the uh 15 million that
- 1:40:09could be paid in in cash. over time. Uh
- 1:40:12there are two rival suggestions, but
- 1:40:14yours yours involved, as I understand
- 1:40:16it, a two-year license over the two main
- 1:40:18brands for unacceptable to you. Is that
- 1:40:20is that the position? I think that by
- 1:40:22implication from what you just said,
- 1:40:24that's giving too much away. Is that
- 1:40:26right?
- 1:40:26>> I think just, you know, to clarify that
- 1:40:29is of course an ideal option that I
- 1:40:31would like. I understand that Yan, you
- 1:40:33do have an interest in retaining the
- 1:40:34value for my sweetie and cloudy. Of
- 1:40:38course, my concerns would be in the
- 1:40:41artistic legacy um that is tied in with
- 1:40:44those bags as I mentioned. So, if we
- 1:40:46were to agree to some sort of l
- 1:40:48exclusive licensing that you're looking
- 1:40:49for, I would like some distinction for
- 1:40:53the duration of of that licensing that
- 1:40:57it's something, you know, a distinction
- 1:40:59between the original manufacturer of
- 1:41:01those bags and the licensed products
- 1:41:04just to ensure that the integrity is
- 1:41:06protected.
- 1:41:07I think this is something we can
- 1:41:09achieve. It is if this is merely about
- 1:41:12integrity. I think um I would have I
- 1:41:15would have no issue really making sure
- 1:41:17that people understand that you are the
- 1:41:18artist of these bags.
- 1:41:22Just to just to clarify, I think my
- 1:41:24client's concern more so was that over
- 1:41:26the two years, if we were to evaluate
- 1:41:29this now, over the two years where you
- 1:41:31have a license to my sweetie and cloudy,
- 1:41:34it would be my client's artistic legacy
- 1:41:37concern and how, as you've said,
- 1:41:40currently the sales and the marketing
- 1:41:42are not succeeding. and over those two
- 1:41:45years where you have the license to
- 1:41:47continue selling those bags, we wouldn't
- 1:41:49want their value to drop through
- 1:41:52continuing issues we have. But again
- 1:41:54maybe within this we bring in the third
- 1:41:56party that can provide assurance to my
- 1:41:58client that over those two years where
- 1:42:00you license the bags their value will be
- 1:42:03protected the operations will be stable
- 1:42:05when we split up roles and then uh after
- 1:42:09the two years my understanding is that
- 1:42:11you would assign them to my client
- 1:42:13fully.
- 1:42:14>> Now this is this is very good very
- 1:42:16constructive stuff. Of course licenses
- 1:42:18could be filled with conditions about
- 1:42:20preserving brand value and so on. I just
- 1:42:22want to be clear. We're talking, are we,
- 1:42:24about an exchange here that happens
- 1:42:27instead of or with the introduction of a
- 1:42:30third party. I'm just just for my
- 1:42:32purposes, I'm a little confused.
- 1:42:34>> There would definitely need to be a
- 1:42:35third party if my client licenses the
- 1:42:38products to them because at this stage
- 1:42:40now, the sales and the marketing is not
- 1:42:41succeeding. So, we would need a third
- 1:42:43party to keep that value.
- 1:42:45>> I understand that. But Yan would have
- 1:42:46ceased to be a shareholder, wouldn't
- 1:42:47she, at that point?
- 1:42:49>> Yes. So what I've gathered is that we're
- 1:42:53now exploring an option where you
- 1:42:55getting YAN shares and in exchange we
- 1:42:59look to um a license that covers the 10
- 1:43:03million that's compensated for the
- 1:43:05license of those 10 bags and the
- 1:43:09remaining 50 million is to be paid by
- 1:43:12some installment of sorts. Um this can
- 1:43:16be achieved for example by or this can
- 1:43:18be compensated for by making sure that
- 1:43:22my client has for two years the
- 1:43:24exclusive license to um distribute those
- 1:43:28bags and because you're concerned that
- 1:43:31the value of the bags will drop. That's
- 1:43:33where third party comes in. Am I correct
- 1:43:36in that assumption?
- 1:43:37>> Yes. To preserve the artistic legacy and
- 1:43:39the value protection. Um, additionally,
- 1:43:42because your time is up,
- 1:43:45congratulations.
- 1:43:47[applause]
- 1:43:56[applause]
- 1:44:06[cheering and applause]
- 1:44:07>> Congratulations to both teams for a
- 1:44:09wonderful job. Thank you to our mediator
- 1:44:12and our judges. At this time, we would
- 1:44:15like everyone to stay seated. There's a
- 1:44:17short video that will play in just a
- 1:44:18moment. And in the meantime, I'd like to
- 1:44:20ask our five judges to please gather
- 1:44:22your things and follow Anela to the
- 1:44:25scoring room, please.
- 1:44:34>> That was very fun.
- 1:44:36>> So, you may want to go and talk to Jod,
- 1:44:38who's down there, who wrote the problem.
- 1:44:40>> Oh.
- 1:44:41She give her a hard time.
- 1:44:44>> I would love to chat with her.
- 1:45:06>> Oh, I'm wrong. Maybe you can stay here.
- 1:45:07I don't know. Maybe. Of course, it's the
- 1:45:09judges who have to return. Yeah.
- 1:45:11>> Okay. [laughter]
- 1:45:14>> I think I think I think
- 1:45:16>> the five of us in a photograph
- 1:45:19program focused on international
- 1:45:21arbitration. The idea of this program is
- 1:45:25to provide with a very in-depth
- 1:45:28education on all kind of dispute
- 1:45:30settlement applied in the international
- 1:45:33arena. What sets the LLM apart from
- 1:45:35other comparable degrees has to be two
- 1:45:38main elements. One, it is not your
- 1:45:40traditional LLM that you do after
- 1:45:42graduating from law school. It is an LLM
- 1:45:45that you do when you're ready to take
- 1:45:47the next step in your career [music]
- 1:45:49with intention. And that intention being
- 1:45:52practicing international dispute
- 1:45:54settlement with experience and with a
- 1:45:56level of maturity that we ensure by
- 1:45:59requiring a minimum work experience uh
- 1:46:02for all applicants. Then the second
- 1:46:04aspect is that these professionals are
- 1:46:06dealing mostly with other professionals.
- 1:46:08We have a lot of institutional workshops
- 1:46:10in our program such as the workshop in
- 1:46:13exit or PCA or IC. The ICC1 takes place
- 1:46:17in the headquarters of Paris and it
- 1:46:19gives students a great opportunity to
- 1:46:21speak to people who work here to explain
- 1:46:24to the students how the teams how the
- 1:46:26organization of the whole institution is
- 1:46:28placed and how the rules of this
- 1:46:30institutions are significant what they
- 1:46:32have specific in them. We also every
- 1:46:35year have a study trip to HEG where we
- 1:46:37go to PCA to the peace palace inside of
- 1:46:40which we have a very similar sessions
- 1:46:43with the practitioners with the people
- 1:46:44who are working inside of the peace
- 1:46:46palace explaining to us the history the
- 1:46:48significance the rules of this place and
- 1:46:51why is it important and relevant to
- 1:46:53international dispute resolution. One of
- 1:46:55the most interesting opportunities that
- 1:46:58the LLM offers in terms of career
- 1:47:00advancement is that as part of the LLM,
- 1:47:03students are required to do an
- 1:47:05internship in one arbitration practice
- 1:47:07or in one arbitration institution. They
- 1:47:10can also choose to do a thesis. the
- 1:47:12university will facilitate to the
- 1:47:15students finding that placement that
- 1:47:17internship in the different law firms
- 1:47:19and very often that creates the first
- 1:47:22step into the future career of the
- 1:47:24students.
- 1:47:24>> What really stood out to me about the
- 1:47:26program was that the slate of professors
- 1:47:28and practitioners who had been called in
- 1:47:31to teach our course were really really
- 1:47:32excellent. They were really on the
- 1:47:34cutting edge of new ideas and working on
- 1:47:36high value disputes and uh I think most
- 1:47:39importantly they were very willing to
- 1:47:41speak to students and to offer
- 1:47:43suggestions on how one could get their
- 1:47:44career started in arbitration in Paris
- 1:47:46which is such a competitive market. To
- 1:47:48summarize how the LLM has contributed to
- 1:47:50my academic and professional life. It
- 1:47:52really allowed me to pivot from
- 1:47:54litigation into international
- 1:47:55arbitration not only in terms of
- 1:47:57learning the hard law but also in terms
- 1:47:59of networking opportunities. I think
- 1:48:01that actually the Tatm represented an
- 1:48:04amazing bridge between my previous
- 1:48:06background and my current position at
- 1:48:09the World Bank. All the competencies
- 1:48:11acquired here about investor state
- 1:48:13dispute and commercial arbitration had
- 1:48:16been essential in order to get a good
- 1:48:18understanding of the practice nowadays
- 1:48:21of arbitration. We are now entering into
- 1:48:23a new era of international litigation
- 1:48:26where it's very important for whoever is
- 1:48:30involved in international litigation to
- 1:48:32be aware of different fields. public
- 1:48:35international law, private international
- 1:48:37law, interstate arbitration,
- 1:48:40dispute settlement before permanent
- 1:48:42courts like the international court of
- 1:48:44justice, investor state arbitration,
- 1:48:47commercial arbitration, and the tax is
- 1:48:50just about all that. I
- 1:48:52>> am currently a fifth year associate at
- 1:48:54Scatterenarps in New York. I still refer
- 1:48:57to my LLM notes all the time and so I
- 1:48:59think it has been a huge use to me in my
- 1:49:02profession and it's sometimes just to
- 1:49:03remind myself of the case law of the
- 1:49:05rules in arbitration whether it's
- 1:49:07investor state or commercial arbitration
- 1:49:09part of the reason why I chose the
- 1:49:12spoilm was that half of the course is
- 1:49:14actually taught elsewhere meaning that
- 1:49:16you get to learn directly in the law
- 1:49:19firms in the institutions that are here
- 1:49:21in Paris the mecca of European
- 1:49:23arbitration and interact and do
- 1:49:25workshops to learn concepts in practice.
- 1:49:28My current position where I am for 5
- 1:49:30years now in Switzerland, I have had the
- 1:49:34pleasure to meet my current employer as
- 1:49:36a guest lecture in one of the classes
- 1:49:38that I was taking at school. So I would
- 1:49:41certainly not be where I am right now
- 1:49:43without the Teds LM.
- 1:49:45>> The TS LLM has been really successful
- 1:49:48from many perspective. One of those
- 1:49:50perspective is the origin of our
- 1:49:53candidates. We have had a third of our
- 1:49:55candidates coming from Asia, a third of
- 1:49:58the students coming from Latin America
- 1:50:00and the other third coming from Europe,
- 1:50:03North America, Africa, the rest of the
- 1:50:05world. So this balance in the origin of
- 1:50:08our students show that it's a real
- 1:50:11global program and if we look at the
- 1:50:13careers after the LLM is the same. There
- 1:50:16are many of them working in the most
- 1:50:18important law firms or institutions, but
- 1:50:21they are also all over the world. We
- 1:50:23have former students working now
- 1:50:25applying what they learn and what they
- 1:50:27have the opportunity to to know here in
- 1:50:29Paris.
- 2:21:46If I could ask everyone to please take
- 2:21:48their seats. Excellent.
- 2:22:33Thank you all for your patience. The
- 2:22:36judges have done their scoring
- 2:22:38and here to give you further news on
- 2:22:40that topic is uh the security general
- 2:22:44DRS director dispute resolution services
- 2:22:46DRS management Alex Vesses.
- 2:22:50[applause]
- 2:22:58I just realized you're wearing dashingly
- 2:23:00blue um uh sorry pink shoes. I I wish I
- 2:23:04well clearly clearly I feel a little bit
- 2:23:07underdressed. Good morning everyone. Um
- 2:23:09it's not my intention to monopolize uh
- 2:23:12your attention uh this morning. I think
- 2:23:14there are bigger and greater things
- 2:23:15waiting for uh for you after I finish
- 2:23:18speaking. Um earlier this week I was
- 2:23:21visited by one of the professionals who
- 2:23:23participated in the uh competition this
- 2:23:25year. It's been participating for many
- 2:23:26years. a former intern at the ICC many
- 2:23:30years ago who is currently writing um a
- 2:23:34monograph
- 2:23:35on conflict prevention and uh what we
- 2:23:38learn on it uh through mythology
- 2:23:42particularly Greek mythology. So you
- 2:23:43will allow a slight digression for the
- 2:23:45obvious reason.
- 2:23:50Menaus was married to Helen.
- 2:23:55um Paris from Troy visited the Palopines
- 2:23:58and fell in love with Helen and they
- 2:24:00decided to elope.
- 2:24:02Menelaus was not very happy conflict.
- 2:24:07Um Menelaus had a big brother,
- 2:24:09Agamemnon, the chief king of the Greeks,
- 2:24:13warm-blooded as many Greeks are.
- 2:24:16And uh thus started the 10-year Trojan
- 2:24:20War
- 2:24:22conflict.
- 2:24:26On year nine, there was discord
- 2:24:30within the um Greek army. Achilles, one
- 2:24:35of the kings um and arguably probably
- 2:24:38their best fighter um had a fallout with
- 2:24:42Agamemnon
- 2:24:44conflict
- 2:24:46and he decided to withdraw his troops
- 2:24:49from the war.
- 2:24:51his second in command
- 2:24:54decided to um take Achilles armor and
- 2:25:00fight for the Greeks disguised as
- 2:25:03Achilles.
- 2:25:05And he was challenged by the chief
- 2:25:08warrior of the Trojans, Hector, another
- 2:25:12conflict. And he did not survive that
- 2:25:16challenge.
- 2:25:18and Hector took over the um armor of
- 2:25:22Achilles as a trophy.
- 2:25:24That conflict and the loss of his
- 2:25:27beloved companion led Achilles to
- 2:25:29reconsider and decide to rejoin the
- 2:25:34fight. Now Achilles was a demigod and
- 2:25:38his mother Thetis pleaded to um the
- 2:25:42equivalent of Vulcan High Festus, the um
- 2:25:46god who was in charge of um among many
- 2:25:49other things uh minerals and um and
- 2:25:52craftsmanship
- 2:25:53to forge a new armor for her son so that
- 2:25:58he would be able to challenge Hector and
- 2:26:01ultimately win the battle and win the
- 2:26:02war. and Hifesus did that in record time
- 2:26:05as gods do.
- 2:26:08One of the notable things that Homer
- 2:26:10does in one of the rapsides of the Iliad
- 2:26:13is describe in great detail
- 2:26:17the um set of arms that Highfesters
- 2:26:20forged for this battle.
- 2:26:24And many many verses in that rapsid are
- 2:26:27dedicated to the description of the
- 2:26:30various um the iconography on the shield
- 2:26:35that high fesus forged for Achilles. And
- 2:26:39central to that is a panel where again
- 2:26:43we see conflict but not armed conflict.
- 2:26:46We see two men arguing and a third man
- 2:26:51in the middle.
- 2:26:54One man is a killer, someone who
- 2:26:57murdered a member of the other man's
- 2:26:59family. And under divine religious law
- 2:27:02of the time, the family of the victim
- 2:27:06had a right of retribution.
- 2:27:10They were therefore very interested in
- 2:27:13taking the life of the murderer.
- 2:27:16But then there is this middle man and
- 2:27:18the middleman is described by Homer by a
- 2:27:20name. His name is Easter
- 2:27:23and again I won't give a lecture on
- 2:27:25ethmology here today but that is a name
- 2:27:29uh that actually comes from the same
- 2:27:30family that gave us history historians
- 2:27:32and so on and so forth and if we try to
- 2:27:36translate that name in modern English
- 2:27:39probably it's a combination of the
- 2:27:42the knowledgeable communicator therefore
- 2:27:45the person who knows and is is in a
- 2:27:48position probably in a best suited
- 2:27:49position to avoid conflict and find just
- 2:27:53settlement. Now, unfortunately, we don't
- 2:27:56know what the outcome of that early form
- 2:27:59of mediation was, but it actually shows
- 2:28:02us, I think, an important path, and this
- 2:28:04is why I'm mentioning it here this
- 2:28:06morning. It tells us of how ultimately
- 2:28:10bigger problems between disputing
- 2:28:13parties can actually be avoided in ways
- 2:28:16other than just enforcing rights, but by
- 2:28:20approaching the conflict on the basis of
- 2:28:23interests and ways in which those
- 2:28:25interests can potentially be aligned and
- 2:28:28ultimately wider conflict avoided. And
- 2:28:30it is actually for this reason, dear
- 2:28:33friends, that this competition exists
- 2:28:36and why IC is committed to hosting it
- 2:28:40year after year and now of course uh
- 2:28:43over its 23rd edition. So why mediation
- 2:28:47and why today? I mean clearly and I'm
- 2:28:51probably stating the obvious here
- 2:28:53because it strengthens access to justice
- 2:28:57and it provides a fast or a faster and a
- 2:29:01fair and efficient resolution and we
- 2:29:03have the data to show it. Let's just
- 2:29:05compare the average amount of time the
- 2:29:07average duration of a mediation compared
- 2:29:10to that of litigation or indeed
- 2:29:12arbitration. And the same can go is my
- 2:29:14time up?
- 2:29:15>> Oh, okay. I'll probably have to
- 2:29:17accelerate. No, it's fine. It's fine. I
- 2:29:19tend to I tend to babble on and on. It
- 2:29:23also increases economic efficiency and
- 2:29:25again I'm stating the obvious. And it
- 2:29:28the same way it reduces waste. Um
- 2:29:33successful or mediated settlements
- 2:29:35actually lead to fewer dispute disputes
- 2:29:37having to be written off as losses and
- 2:29:40that's extremely important for
- 2:29:42businesses. Uh it also allows for better
- 2:29:45enforcement of contracts and also Of
- 2:29:48course, the takeaways of a good
- 2:29:49mediation can then be um reinvested into
- 2:29:52whatever further contractual
- 2:29:54arrangements either or both of the
- 2:29:56parties will uh commit to later on and
- 2:29:59importantly at this day and age it um
- 2:30:02alleviates some of the strain on supply
- 2:30:04chains and importantly on trade flows.
- 2:30:09Now it also protects and to a certain
- 2:30:12extent may even restore commercial uh
- 2:30:15relationships and again I would like to
- 2:30:17emphasize the focus on interestbased
- 2:30:21outcomes. Let's try to find a way in
- 2:30:23which we can move away from this and
- 2:30:25continue our business relationship
- 2:30:28rather than the enforcements of
- 2:30:30rightsbased outcomes. I have a right
- 2:30:32under this contract to claim damages and
- 2:30:34you have an obligation to pay for them.
- 2:30:37It reduces inequality in access to
- 2:30:40justice because mediation is by far more
- 2:30:42flexible than other forms of dispute
- 2:30:44settlement. It actually requires less of
- 2:30:48a procedural burden and of course again
- 2:30:51lower cost.
- 2:30:54Importantly it enhances international
- 2:30:57cooperation.
- 2:31:00Let's think about the work that has been
- 2:31:02done on the Singapore convention even if
- 2:31:04that work is very much still in
- 2:31:05development. Let's think of the EU
- 2:31:08directive on mediation. Let's also think
- 2:31:10of the work uh on mediation that has
- 2:31:12been done by anrol and indeed the
- 2:31:16plethora of procedural solutions and
- 2:31:19tools that have been put forward by um
- 2:31:21dispute settlement institutions
- 2:31:23including the ICC international center
- 2:31:25for rad.
- 2:31:27um it it fosters innovation and I think
- 2:31:30this is al also an area of development
- 2:31:32in the future we will see a lot more
- 2:31:34tech enabled AI enabled and digitally
- 2:31:36enabled solutions being put forward in
- 2:31:40um mediation in the years to come and
- 2:31:42perhaps something that we don't
- 2:31:44necessarily think of it reduces carbon
- 2:31:47footprints of dispute the carbon
- 2:31:49footprint of dispute resolution fewer
- 2:31:52flights potentially fewer in-person
- 2:31:55meetings or hearings and of course less
- 2:31:58of an administrative overload. And all
- 2:32:01of that, dear friends, means one thing.
- 2:32:04Mediation
- 2:32:06works.
- 2:32:07And we know that because again, data
- 2:32:09tells us that if we manage to put the
- 2:32:11parties ac um join the parties on the
- 2:32:14table with a mediator, there's a 70 to
- 2:32:1775% chance that there will be a
- 2:32:20settlement of at least part of their
- 2:32:23dispute. And therefore we have a boost
- 2:32:24of user satisfaction and we have a lot
- 2:32:27more confidence restored in private
- 2:32:30dispute resolution and this is extremely
- 2:32:32important particularly at this day and
- 2:32:34age
- 2:32:36and we therefore ensure a continuity.
- 2:32:39Now that is why we at ICC are committed
- 2:32:42to mediation and that is why we are
- 2:32:45resolved to seeing businesses to
- 2:32:48supporting businesses worldwide by
- 2:32:50advocating for mediation.
- 2:32:54I feel that the mediation competition
- 2:32:57has been a truly exceptional forum over
- 2:32:59the past 21 years.
- 2:33:02Um there is a sustained commitment uh
- 2:33:05from a number of individuals and I would
- 2:33:07like of course to mention the host of
- 2:33:10professionals who have dedicated their
- 2:33:13time and also who have very generously
- 2:33:16contributed by sharing their expertise
- 2:33:21to you the students and of course the
- 2:33:23biggest thank you must come or must be
- 2:33:26given rather to the students. Now, um
- 2:33:31before I go there, I would like to and I
- 2:33:33it's not really my custom to um give
- 2:33:36specific shoutouts to individuals, but I
- 2:33:37would like to make one exception here if
- 2:33:40you will indulge me. And I would like to
- 2:33:43take a minute to salute um two
- 2:33:46individuals, do Joy Davis and Greg Bond
- 2:33:50for uh their uh decadesl long commitment
- 2:33:54to the uh mediation competition. They
- 2:33:57have served uh this forum through
- 2:34:01various positions and I think most
- 2:34:04notably uh through the revamp of the uh
- 2:34:08rules and uh helped us in improve the
- 2:34:12overall quality of this competition year
- 2:34:16in year out. And while they have decided
- 2:34:19to step down from that institutional
- 2:34:21function that they have served and for
- 2:34:23which we're extremely thankful, we're
- 2:34:25equally thankful that they will remain
- 2:34:28attached to this competition and
- 2:34:30continue to instill it with their
- 2:34:32expertise.
- 2:34:36[applause]
- 2:34:46Now I mentioned the students and I would
- 2:34:48like to finish with the students. So to
- 2:34:50all of you enthusiastic wonderful
- 2:34:53students uh who have participated this
- 2:34:55year very well done. You have
- 2:34:59demonstrated commitment,
- 2:35:02mutual respect and a willingness to
- 2:35:07grow. And these qualities I believe will
- 2:35:11serve you well beyond this competition.
- 2:35:15So please take a moment to appreciate
- 2:35:18what you have achieved and hopefully
- 2:35:21this experience
- 2:35:23will carry uh you forward uh in the
- 2:35:25years to come. And so truly remember
- 2:35:28that sky is the limit.
- 2:35:32[applause]
- 2:35:41Now I think I must now pass the mic on
- 2:35:44to uh Mary Tat and and Bill I believe
- 2:35:48for for a few words. So two of our
- 2:35:49judges and our wonderful mediator who
- 2:35:51also partied last night I I would like
- 2:35:53to notice.
- 2:35:58>> Alex, thank you. Um, I just want to take
- 2:36:01a second or two before you hear from the
- 2:36:03important people, uh, to say thank you
- 2:36:06to everybody for giving me the enormous
- 2:36:08privilege and honor of mediating the
- 2:36:10final to give voice to the obvious
- 2:36:14unspoken thought of all of us in this
- 2:36:15room for the last hour and a half. I am
- 2:36:18prepared to accept the appointment as
- 2:36:19chairman of Fabcool. I know that's what
- 2:36:23I know that's what everybody would just
- 2:36:24wanted to say. [applause and cheering]
- 2:36:28Lots of genuine post mediation emotions.
- 2:36:30Have I done enough? Have I done too
- 2:36:32little? Should I have said this? On the
- 2:36:33train home shortly, I'll be thinking of
- 2:36:35all the brilliant lines I didn't use.
- 2:36:37But the teams were very gentle with me.
- 2:36:39I'm very grateful to them. They were
- 2:36:41worthy finalists and it was an absolute
- 2:36:43honor to work with them today.
- 2:36:47[applause]
- 2:36:52[applause]
- 2:36:53Hello everybody. I'm Mary Mlan and I'm
- 2:36:56from San Francisco. I've been coming
- 2:36:58here for approximately 18 years uh and
- 2:37:01it's a privilege to to see all of you
- 2:37:05and I wanted to give general comments
- 2:37:07today. I wanted to first congratulate
- 2:37:09the two teams. I thought it was an
- 2:37:11excellent uh demonstration of advocacy
- 2:37:14in mediation. Uh seamlessly you worked
- 2:37:18together. You used wording that was uh
- 2:37:22open and willing and got the process
- 2:37:24rolling. I want to speak generally to
- 2:37:27also all the teams that came here. Do
- 2:37:30you know there were 58 teams from 34
- 2:37:33countries? Look around you. What we hope
- 2:37:36for you, all of you, is that these five
- 2:37:40days that you've spent in Paris,
- 2:37:42probably it was longer than five days,
- 2:37:4457, um that they're going to be
- 2:37:47cherished memories that bring you back
- 2:37:51no matter, you know, 20, 30 years from
- 2:37:54now. and that you will always remember
- 2:37:56this wonderful competition and all the
- 2:37:59people that you have made friends with.
- 2:38:02So, I know a lot of the teams that
- 2:38:06competed didn't end up at the final
- 2:38:08stage, but you're all winners for being
- 2:38:10here, and you've demonstrated such
- 2:38:13wonderful, skillful uh skills for
- 2:38:17mediation. And we need more of this in
- 2:38:20the world right now because there are so
- 2:38:22many sad events happening. But yet we
- 2:38:24come together from 34 countries and a
- 2:38:27short amount of time and we want to
- 2:38:31continue this legacy and we hope that
- 2:38:34you all enjoy your final day here and
- 2:38:37and thank you all for coming. Uh this
- 2:38:39competition is because of you. Thank
- 2:38:42you.
- 2:38:43[applause]
- 2:38:50>> Well uh morning everyone. My name is T.
- 2:38:53Uh I'm from Asia um Singapore and um
- 2:38:56it's my privilege to be here I think
- 2:38:59maybe for the 11th or 12th time. Uh I've
- 2:39:03been tasked to um provide maybe a little
- 2:39:05bit of granularity on how the judges um
- 2:39:08see the competition the final uh and uh
- 2:39:12not to speak too long because I know
- 2:39:13that you know of course what stands
- 2:39:15between me and after after what I've
- 2:39:17said is the is the outcome that all of
- 2:39:19you are waiting for. But let me just
- 2:39:20keep it to three points. I think the
- 2:39:23first is to acknowledge the brilliance
- 2:39:24of my colleague um Bill Wood. I think
- 2:39:27that a lot of you um you know the the
- 2:39:30word that comes to me as you know he's
- 2:39:32doing his craft uh is that you know a
- 2:39:35brilliant mediator actually gives you
- 2:39:38the impression that actually less is
- 2:39:39more. Uh delicate question summary
- 2:39:42summary that says uh both parties want
- 2:39:45to know what went wrong before they try
- 2:39:47and fix a problem. uh immediately that
- 2:39:49statement crystallizes the conversations
- 2:39:52and dialogue has been going on between
- 2:39:53the parties. uh when asking a question,
- 2:39:56you know, he says, "Is that a fair
- 2:39:57question?" He poses, you know, the
- 2:39:59character of the question and asks the
- 2:40:01parties to consider whether what he's
- 2:40:04saying makes sense. Again, the hallmark
- 2:40:06of a mediator knowing that there's a
- 2:40:08whole rich layers behind the dialogue.
- 2:40:10That's what's going on. And then even
- 2:40:12when he's posing a question to council,
- 2:40:15he asks uh what would you think of
- 2:40:17advising your client on a particular
- 2:40:20thing? What would you think of advising
- 2:40:22your client? Posing to the a question
- 2:40:24for the council to think about my role
- 2:40:26as a mediation advocate? Uh is this the
- 2:40:30right time? What should I be thinking
- 2:40:31of? Does that accord with your views? I
- 2:40:34mean th those are brilliant uh things
- 2:40:36that I wrote down Bill so that I might
- 2:40:38use it on a future occasion. But you
- 2:40:41know um to Bill Wood uh I would say that
- 2:40:44that was a brilliant demonstration of
- 2:40:46fantastic mediation uh by a uh
- 2:40:50well-renowned mediator. The second thing
- 2:40:53that I think is worth talking about um
- 2:40:55is what perhaps the the judges thought
- 2:40:59uh might be worth thinking about
- 2:41:01especially for uh those of you who uh
- 2:41:04have seen the start and the end of this
- 2:41:07uh mediation process. uh all the judges
- 2:41:09I think were unanimous in that both
- 2:41:11sides delivered a wonderful opening
- 2:41:14statement with all the richness and with
- 2:41:17all the nuance of what a great opening
- 2:41:20statement should be. Uh I think the
- 2:41:22judges were also of the view that
- 2:41:25perhaps you know there could be some
- 2:41:27consideration of what a great closing
- 2:41:30would look like. I know of course that
- 2:41:32we are in a forum where uh it's an
- 2:41:34artificial construct that we only have a
- 2:41:36limited amount of time. Uh but one needs
- 2:41:39to consider when a mediator sounds out
- 2:41:41that you know we would shortly be coming
- 2:41:42to an end that you need to immediately
- 2:41:45look to the future and ask those
- 2:41:46questions among the parties and council.
- 2:41:49What next beyond this right? Should we
- 2:41:51be talking about next steps? Uh should
- 2:41:53we be asking the mediator for next
- 2:41:55appointment? What are the things that we
- 2:41:56need to do in order to be better
- 2:41:58prepared for the next round? Should we
- 2:42:00be entering into anou terms of
- 2:42:02references? I mean those are the things
- 2:42:03which are not artificial construct but
- 2:42:06they truly are the kind of things that
- 2:42:07lawyers would think about when you see
- 2:42:10the time running out and you do want to
- 2:42:12continue with the conversation. Um very
- 2:42:14important thing. So a great opening must
- 2:42:17result in a a great landing, a great
- 2:42:19closing. The the last thing I I kind of
- 2:42:22want to talk about is really what stood
- 2:42:24out for me personally and I'm sure for
- 2:42:25the judges as well. And what stood out
- 2:42:28for me uh is the level of sophistication
- 2:42:31in the communication. Uh I practice both
- 2:42:34as a mediator as well as a mediation
- 2:42:36advocate as as council and and I'm very
- 2:42:39impressed by what I've seen uh in
- 2:42:42display in this competitions but
- 2:42:44especially in this finals. And I just
- 2:42:46want to quickly hit on five things that
- 2:42:48stood out to me. The first thing I
- 2:42:50thought was uh in terms of communication
- 2:42:52was the pace. the pace of the
- 2:42:55communication was well judged uh uh and
- 2:42:57more important allowing the listener to
- 2:43:00follow the discussion and to reflect on
- 2:43:03what's being said. So often in these
- 2:43:05competitions I know that students want
- 2:43:07to speak very quickly because there's a
- 2:43:08limited time and I find myself racing
- 2:43:12finding it hard to follow what's going
- 2:43:14on. uh when the mediation advocacy is
- 2:43:17paced, it allows the listener to say
- 2:43:20right that's a great point. What exactly
- 2:43:23is underlying that point? What's my
- 2:43:25response to that point? The listener
- 2:43:27understands and is able to compose an
- 2:43:29understanding that's richer than if you
- 2:43:31are raising trying to keep up with the
- 2:43:34speaker. The second was uh the tone of
- 2:43:37both teams were collaborative and
- 2:43:39constructive. The expressions of intent
- 2:43:42were framed with a very important
- 2:43:44forward-looking perspective. Words like,
- 2:43:47"I feel hopeful for the future." Uh, but
- 2:43:50I hope I can clarify the source of your
- 2:43:52mistrust. Putting out what was of
- 2:43:54concern, but also with an eye on what
- 2:43:57the future looks like. Right. Third, the
- 2:44:00language used was measured and yet clear
- 2:44:02and in my view very effective. The
- 2:44:05fourth what I thought was really stood
- 2:44:07out for me is when questions were posed,
- 2:44:09when questions were raised, they were
- 2:44:10not only open-ended but they were uh
- 2:44:13clear and articulate uh can you speak uh
- 2:44:17to the success of I mean I thought was
- 2:44:20brilliant because it opens up so much
- 2:44:22that can be said in response. Uh what
- 2:44:25options do you prefer? Um again it opens
- 2:44:28up the possibility that there will be a
- 2:44:31a a great discussion on the options that
- 2:44:35work for both sides. Uh and so lastly uh
- 2:44:38I thought the other you know final point
- 2:44:41that really stood out for me in this
- 2:44:42competition is the appreciation by both
- 2:44:45teams of not only what information what
- 2:44:49interest needs to be shared but also
- 2:44:52what
- 2:44:54information interest should perhaps be
- 2:44:56held back until the appropriate time. uh
- 2:45:00and you know I thought it was really
- 2:45:01sublime that uh both teams knew what
- 2:45:04they were after but you know uh in one
- 2:45:06of the teams they decided to hold back a
- 2:45:09particular information and test that
- 2:45:11with the mediator. Fantastic use of the
- 2:45:13mediator because when they were with the
- 2:45:16mediator the words used is I would like
- 2:45:19you Bill um you know at the end to make
- 2:45:22some space for us for me to ask a few
- 2:45:27different things. They they are just
- 2:45:29wonderful choice words. I mean I don't
- 2:45:31think I could you know better construct
- 2:45:33words like that in a mediation process
- 2:45:36where when you present those words the
- 2:45:38listener immediately understands right
- 2:45:40you know what are you talking about is
- 2:45:42to provide a visual representation of
- 2:45:45what that dialogue would look like in a
- 2:45:48wonderful collaborative process that's
- 2:45:51designed to find common interest and uh
- 2:45:54give give parties the best shot at
- 2:45:56getting a good outcome. So those are you
- 2:45:58know the points which I thought really
- 2:46:00stood out to me. But the the litmus test
- 2:46:02really for me is would this be a round
- 2:46:05that in real life I would find you know
- 2:46:07great degree of encouragement and the
- 2:46:09short answer for me sitting there is
- 2:46:11yes. This is such a fantastic round. uh
- 2:46:14in in real life I think this would be
- 2:46:15probably one of the best mediations uh
- 2:46:18that I've and and I don't say this
- 2:46:19lightly because I have seen many
- 2:46:22different spectrums of of performances
- 2:46:24in competitions like this but this was
- 2:46:26truly a brilliant round. So on that note
- 2:46:28I congratulate both parties and everyone
- 2:46:31who's here. Thank you.
- 2:46:34[applause]
- 2:46:41Thank you very much uh Mary and Tat and
- 2:46:44one last um order of thanks I think is
- 2:46:46due and that is to our sponsors and our
- 2:46:49wonderful supporters. I uh will limit uh
- 2:46:53perhaps uh one uh specific emphasis to
- 2:46:58spo who have again um uh uh hosted us in
- 2:47:02this magnificent amphitheater today. So
- 2:47:04thank you to and thank you to uh
- 2:47:07professor Fernandez for having done
- 2:47:09that.
- 2:47:15So I think we have some awards to give
- 2:47:16out now. The order will be as follows.
- 2:47:20Um and I would like everyone's attention
- 2:47:22in that regard. We are going to start
- 2:47:23with a joint third. We will then move to
- 2:47:26the first and we will conclude with the
- 2:47:30second.
- 2:47:32Clear?
- 2:47:32>> Clear. All right. So, um, joint third,
- 2:47:36and this is no surprise to them because
- 2:47:38I think they know that already. Of
- 2:47:39course, the finalists, the two
- 2:47:41semi-finalists that, um, are in the
- 2:47:43third position are the, uh, University
- 2:47:47of New South Wales and the University of
- 2:47:51Vienna.
- 2:47:53[applause]
- 2:47:58I like
- 2:48:01[applause]
- 2:48:11[applause]
- 2:48:16[applause]
- 2:48:32Very well done.
- 2:48:34>> Congratulations.
- 2:48:46Allet Suzan
- 2:48:49[applause]
- 2:48:56[applause]
- 2:49:01now top position. Oh.
- 2:49:12for the David Plant First Prize,
- 2:49:26Oakland
- 2:49:28[applause]
- 2:49:36>> [applause]
- 2:49:45[applause]
- 2:49:53>> Thank you very much.
- 2:50:06>> [applause]
- 2:50:15>> Excellent. And that means that for the
- 2:50:17um Teri second prize, we have the uh
- 2:50:22Buserius School of Law. [applause]
- 2:50:31>> [applause]
- 2:50:36[applause]
- 2:50:41[cheering]
- 2:50:44[applause]
- 2:51:00[applause]
- 2:51:09>> That is it from us. We look forward to
- 2:51:11seeing you again next year for the 22nd
- 2:51:13competition. Please enjoy the cocktail
- 2:51:16and refreshments that await for you
- 2:51:18outside. And please enjoy the semi-warm,
- 2:51:22semi sunny Parisian Saturday. Thank you
- 2:51:26all very very much. [cheering]
- 2:51:28[applause]
- 2:52:13All right.
- 2:52:36Hallelujah.
- 2:53:28It's perfect.
- 2:53:30>> I know.
- 2:54:05I'm not good.
- 2:54:06>> I can stay.
- 2:54:16Yes.
- 2:54:30Everybody
- 2:55:24I don't want
- 2:55:49Please don't hurt
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 21st ICC International Mediation Competition – Finals by International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 18,384 words across 2,855 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.