YouTube2Text

2014 Personality Lecture 13: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (Existentialism) — Transcript

by Jordan B Peterson · 12,359 words · 1,904 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:01it's possible that you guys have been
  2. 0:03following
  3. 0:04this political and economic news from
  4. 0:07the
  5. 0:09Ukraine
  6. 0:11so says here that this is off CBC in a
  7. 0:15clear warning to Ukraine Putin on
  8. 0:17Wednesday ordered massive military
  9. 0:19exercises involving most of the military
  10. 0:21units in Western
  11. 0:23Russia on Thursday as part of the
  12. 0:25exercises fighter jets were put on
  13. 0:27combat alert and were patrolling the
  14. 0:29Border Russia's defense Ministry said in
  15. 0:31the statement it didn't specify the
  16. 0:33areas where Patrol missions were being
  17. 0:36conducted the military also announced
  18. 0:38measures to tighten security at the
  19. 0:40headquarters of Russia's Black Sea Fleet
  20. 0:42on the Crimean peninsula in Southeastern
  21. 0:45Ukraine there's a rumor that I believe I
  22. 0:48believe it was brev gave the Crimea to
  23. 0:52the Ukraine when he was
  24. 0:55drunk the military Maneuvers prompted a
  25. 0:58sharp rebuke from us sec Secretary of
  26. 1:00State John Kerry who warned Russia that
  27. 1:02any military intervention in Ukraine
  28. 1:05would be a grave
  29. 1:08mistake
  30. 1:13so why did I tell you
  31. 1:17that well it's it's for the same reason
  32. 1:19that I've been conducting these last few
  33. 1:23lectures on phenomenological and
  34. 1:26existential ideas in Psychotherapy and I
  35. 1:29I think I mentioned to you that these
  36. 1:31ideas are often not covered anymore in
  37. 1:34personality classes but I think that's a
  38. 1:36big mistake because I think that these
  39. 1:38theories have more to tell us
  40. 1:41about what happened in the 20th
  41. 1:44century than any other theories that
  42. 1:46I've ever come across and that's very
  43. 1:49important
  44. 1:51because the the terrible mass movements
  45. 1:54of the 20th century occurred be because
  46. 1:58of the nature of people's personality
  47. 2:00and it's a mistake to concentrate
  48. 2:04on it's a mistake not to concentrate on
  49. 2:08factors that play that massive a role in
  50. 2:10determining the destiny of the entire
  51. 2:13world and you know it it may seem to you
  52. 2:16that the Soviet Union is a long ways
  53. 2:18away since it collapsed in
  54. 2:211989 but there's no evidence that we're
  55. 2:24done with it yet I mean Putin was a
  56. 2:27KGB officer and the kg B was the Soviet
  57. 2:31Secret Service and the Soviet Secret
  58. 2:33Service was one catastrophically awful
  59. 2:38organization and the tension that's
  60. 2:40occurring in the Ukraine right now that
  61. 2:42looks like it might explode into Civil
  62. 2:44War and hopefully not is still a
  63. 2:49consequence of the remnants of the
  64. 2:51pathologies that dominated the Soviet
  65. 2:55Union for for most of the 20th
  66. 2:58century
  67. 3:01it isn't clear to me that we've really
  68. 3:03learned what we had to learn from what
  69. 3:06happened in Nazi Germany say and in MA
  70. 3:08China which is obviously still run by
  71. 3:11the Communist party or in the Soviet
  72. 3:13Union even though there's been a
  73. 3:14reprieve for the last 35 years or
  74. 3:19so nche in
  75. 3:23particular predicted what was going to
  76. 3:26happen in the 20th century I'm going to
  77. 3:28read you something that he wrote I'm
  78. 3:29going to try to tell you
  79. 3:32today why the events in the 20th century
  80. 3:35happened so the mass genocidal movements
  81. 3:38in particular which were probably the
  82. 3:39defining characteristic of the 20th
  83. 3:41century and then
  84. 3:43also what that has to do with individual
  85. 3:46psychology my first degree was in
  86. 3:48political science and I was interested
  87. 3:50in political science because I was
  88. 3:51interested fundamentally in the reason
  89. 3:53that human societies went to
  90. 3:55war and when I was studying political
  91. 3:58science which is quite a long time ago
  92. 4:00the fundamental theory that underly
  93. 4:04political scientists explanations for
  94. 4:06conflict were economic people fight over
  95. 4:08resources and that never seemed
  96. 4:11reasonable to me because first of all
  97. 4:13obviously many wars are fought for other
  98. 4:15reasons than resources um two Central
  99. 4:18American countries I think it was
  100. 4:20Guatemala and the hondurus if I remember
  101. 4:22correctly went to war over a soccer game
  102. 4:25so the outcome of a a disputed the
  103. 4:28disputed outcome of a soccer soccer game
  104. 4:30and even if you do think that the reason
  105. 4:32that people groups of people engage in
  106. 4:35Conflict are for economic reasons that
  107. 4:37doesn't exactly explain much because
  108. 4:40that doesn't explain whether they're
  109. 4:41fighting for because of absolute
  110. 4:45differences in wealth or because of
  111. 4:48relative discrepancies in wealth and
  112. 4:50those those are very very different
  113. 4:51causal elements and then even if people
  114. 4:54do fight for economic reasons which
  115. 4:56means they're fighting for things that
  116. 4:57they value it isn't exactly clear why
  117. 4:59people people value what they value
  118. 5:01because different societies value
  119. 5:02different things so economics in the
  120. 5:05final analysis ends up being a shallow
  121. 5:07explanation and I pursued economic and
  122. 5:10political and sociological explanations
  123. 5:13for social conflict for a long time but
  124. 5:15eventually they became untenable to me
  125. 5:17and that's partly why I went and studied
  126. 5:19Clinical Psychology because it struck me
  127. 5:21that the right level of analysis for
  128. 5:23understanding mass movements like the
  129. 5:25Nazi movement or the or the the
  130. 5:27ideological possession
  131. 5:30that characterized the stalinist Soviets
  132. 5:32or or ma Communists or or or Paul Pott's
  133. 5:37Cambodian Communists or any of the
  134. 5:39dictators that you can talk about who
  135. 5:41were on the far left or the far right
  136. 5:43during the 20th century to me those were
  137. 5:46failings of individual personality and
  138. 5:49the most astute writers that I've ever
  139. 5:51read who described what they assumed to
  140. 5:55be the causes of these terrible
  141. 5:57conflicts made the same point which is
  142. 5:59why I'm having you read Victor Frankl
  143. 6:01and Alexander Solan niton because Solan
  144. 6:03niton is not generally regarded as a
  145. 6:05personality psychologist but he of all
  146. 6:08the people I've ever read he's the one
  147. 6:10who lays out the connection between the
  148. 6:14existential failure of the individual
  149. 6:16and the mass catastrophes of society and
  150. 6:19to me that's too important to link to
  151. 6:21overlook and it it also strikes me that
  152. 6:23it's the primary lesson of the 20th
  153. 6:25century I mean what one lesson for
  154. 6:28example is beware of ideologies and the
  155. 6:31reason I'm going to walk you through n
  156. 6:32and a bit of kard today is because these
  157. 6:36people in the late 19th century with
  158. 6:37their antennas up knew that the collapse
  159. 6:41one way of looking at it is the collapse
  160. 6:42of traditional Western values that's one
  161. 6:44way of looking at what set up the
  162. 6:47preconditions
  163. 6:48for the people's Humanity susceptibility
  164. 6:52to theologies in the 20th centuries in
  165. 6:54the 20th century the other way of
  166. 6:56looking at it in some sense is that as
  167. 6:58the world came together in the 19th
  168. 7:00century and ideas were passed
  169. 7:02around from culture to culture more
  170. 7:04rapidly than they had ever been passed
  171. 7:06around every culture suffered
  172. 7:08deculturation in some sense because if I
  173. 7:11believe something and you believe
  174. 7:12something and there's a long history
  175. 7:14behind both of our beliefs when we come
  176. 7:16into contact we'll we'll either fight
  177. 7:18and I'll try to destroy you or or if I
  178. 7:20don't if I take you seriously and you
  179. 7:22take me seriously then that's going to
  180. 7:23leave us both wondering exactly what's
  181. 7:26what's Rock Solid underneath us that's
  182. 7:28what n comments on on in this particular
  183. 7:32quote of what is great one either must
  184. 7:35be silent or speak with
  185. 7:38greatness with
  186. 7:40greatness that means cynically and with
  187. 7:42innocence what I relate is the history
  188. 7:44of the next two
  189. 7:46centuries I describe what is coming what
  190. 7:50can no longer come differently the
  191. 7:52Advent of
  192. 7:54nihilism nihilism is the belief in
  193. 7:58nothing or the belief that things have
  194. 8:00no meaning our whole European culture is
  195. 8:02moving for some time now with a tortured
  196. 8:05tension that is growing from decade to
  197. 8:07decade as towards a
  198. 8:10catastrophe restlessly violently and
  199. 8:12headlong like a river that wants to
  200. 8:14reach the end that no longer reflects
  201. 8:17that is afraid to
  202. 8:19reflect he that speaks here has
  203. 8:22conversely done nothing so far but to
  204. 8:24reflect as a philos philosopher and
  205. 8:26solitary by Instinct who has found his
  206. 8:29Vantage in standing
  207. 8:31aside
  208. 8:33outside why has the event Advent of
  209. 8:36nihilism become
  210. 8:39necessary because the values we have had
  211. 8:41hither to thus draw their Final
  212. 8:43Consequence because nihilism represents
  213. 8:46the ultimate logical conclusion of our
  214. 8:47great values and
  215. 8:49ideals because we must experience
  216. 8:51nihilism before we can find out what
  217. 8:53value those values really had we require
  218. 8:57at some time new values
  219. 8:59nihilism stands at the
  220. 9:02door whence comes this uncanny of all
  221. 9:07guests Point of
  222. 9:09Departure it's an error to consider
  223. 9:12social distress or physiological
  224. 9:14degeneration or Corruption of all things
  225. 9:17as the cause of
  226. 9:18nihilism ours is the most honest and
  227. 9:20compassionate age so n dispenses right
  228. 9:24away with sociological explanations for
  229. 9:27people's lack of belief in meaning in
  230. 9:30life you know and what a lot of what
  231. 9:33you're taught in universities is is
  232. 9:36sociological in its causal thinking and
  233. 9:39and the causal path is often that's it's
  234. 9:42the social conditions that people find
  235. 9:43themselves in that determine their
  236. 9:45response to the world but n stands
  237. 9:47violently against that perspective and
  238. 9:49this is 150 years ago even before in
  239. 9:51some sense it was thoroughly
  240. 9:52welldeveloped and the reason he stands
  241. 9:55against it is because he points out that
  242. 9:59wherever you're positioned in society
  243. 10:02your position can be made subject to any
  244. 10:06number of individual interpretations
  245. 10:09it's it's meaning like the meaning of
  246. 10:11being poor say or the meaning of being
  247. 10:13comparatively poor isn't a meaning
  248. 10:14that's etched in stone and so it has to
  249. 10:18be interpreted psychologically before it
  250. 10:20can become a causal factor and if it can
  251. 10:22be interpreted psychologically then it's
  252. 10:23not a fact like the existence of a
  253. 10:25mountain is a fact it's still an
  254. 10:28interpretation
  255. 10:30he says distress itself whether psychic
  256. 10:34psychological physical or intellectual
  257. 10:36also need not produce nihilism so he
  258. 10:39also rejects suffering itself as a cause
  259. 10:41of
  260. 10:43nihilism need not at all produce nalism
  261. 10:45that is the radical rejection of value
  262. 10:47meaning and desirability such distress
  263. 10:49always permits a variety of
  264. 10:51interpretations rather it is in one
  265. 10:54particular interpretation the Christian
  266. 10:57moral one that nihilism is rooted
  267. 10:59the end of Christianity at the hands of
  268. 11:02its own morality which cannot be
  269. 11:04replaced which turns against the
  270. 11:05Christian God the sense of truthfulness
  271. 11:08Highly developed by Christianity is
  272. 11:10nauseated by the falseness and
  273. 11:12mendaciousness of all Christian
  274. 11:13interpretations of the world and of
  275. 11:15History it's a rebound from God is the
  276. 11:18truth to the fanatical Faith all is
  277. 11:21false an act of Buddhism so it's a
  278. 11:23strange interpretation because niichi
  279. 11:26although he was violently anti-christian
  280. 11:29in his in his in his what in his
  281. 11:32self-presentation to the public was more
  282. 11:35like uh in my opinion was more like a
  283. 11:38beneficial critic of of the of the
  284. 11:41Western Christian tradition and because
  285. 11:44the first thing he realized was that the
  286. 11:47domination of the west by essentially by
  287. 11:49the Catholic church for something like
  288. 11:511900 years was necessary in order for
  289. 11:54for the European mind to become trained
  290. 11:58and focused so his his point was that
  291. 12:01you unless you learn to place an
  292. 12:03interpretive scheme on the world and
  293. 12:05interpret that world in a coherent
  294. 12:07manner through that scheme you don't
  295. 12:09have a trained mind and and and for ni
  296. 12:12in some sense it didn't really matter
  297. 12:14what the interpretive scheme was it was
  298. 12:17just that at some point you had to
  299. 12:18discipline yourself this would be
  300. 12:20something like a post-adolescent process
  301. 12:22you had to discipline Yourself by
  302. 12:24developing an adherence to some sort of
  303. 12:27coherent deep coherent View
  304. 12:29and the consequence of that at least in
  305. 12:31principle could be that you would be
  306. 12:33this you could come to be the sort of
  307. 12:35person that would that would be um
  308. 12:38respectful of the truth and also someone
  309. 12:41who was who regarded truth as a as a
  310. 12:44moral virtue as a higher order moral
  311. 12:46virtue but then n's point was that
  312. 12:49Christianity developed that sense in
  313. 12:51Europe to such a degree that the spirit
  314. 12:53of Truth seeking went after the axioms
  315. 12:55of Christianity and demolished them that
  316. 12:57was his view of what happened
  317. 13:00during the Enlightenment as a
  318. 13:02consequence of the interaction between
  319. 13:04science and religion
  320. 13:06so n's view was that the modern mind
  321. 13:10will say because we're speaking 150
  322. 13:12years later the modern mind had been
  323. 13:14trained rigorously to interpret things
  324. 13:17through a
  325. 13:18coherent structure and then once that
  326. 13:20training had occurred then it could use
  327. 13:23any number of coherent structures and
  328. 13:24then it could also use its its ability
  329. 13:27to form a relationship with the truth
  330. 13:29truth to criticize the very thing that
  331. 13:31gave rise to that mind and that and that
  332. 13:33nich's diagnosis of the 20th century
  333. 13:37individual a Pursuit Of Truth itself had
  334. 13:40undermined the structure that gave birth
  335. 13:42to The Pursuit Of Truth and that left
  336. 13:44people wide open it left them wide open
  337. 13:46on the one hand to nihilism and nihilism
  338. 13:48is the belief that nothing has meaning
  339. 13:50nothing has any final meaning and you
  340. 13:52the best way of expressing nihilism is
  341. 13:54what the hell difference is it going to
  342. 13:55make in a in a thousand years what we do
  343. 13:57today or in a hundred years for that
  344. 13:59matter and it's a it's a rational
  345. 14:02reduction of of all of the experiences
  346. 14:05of life to to to rational insignificance
  347. 14:10nothing has any final meaning and so the
  348. 14:13question of course that emerges from
  349. 14:14that is well why do anything and a
  350. 14:16deeper question that emerges for that
  351. 14:18from that is well why bear suffering and
  352. 14:22but that's not the only problem from an
  353. 14:24existential point of view because the
  354. 14:27existentialists and and and nich as well
  355. 14:30also believed that nihilism was actually
  356. 14:32unbearable because people suffer they
  357. 14:35have to have a framework of meaning in
  358. 14:37which to place the suffering because
  359. 14:39otherwise it undermines their ability to
  360. 14:41live and then and and and people can't
  361. 14:44move forward in that condition and so
  362. 14:47another one of n's prognostications was
  363. 14:50that nihilism would produce its
  364. 14:53counterpart which was totalitarianism
  365. 14:55and people would leap from their
  366. 14:56immersion saying in in
  367. 14:59in
  368. 15:00evolutionarily emergent systems of faith
  369. 15:04and jump headlong into
  370. 15:06rational utopian constructions of
  371. 15:10reality because you because people can't
  372. 15:12do without an interpretive
  373. 15:14framework so it wasn't as if the
  374. 15:16consequence of moving beyond religion
  375. 15:19was going to be a step into
  376. 15:21Enlightenment which is what materialist
  377. 15:24rationalists always presume they presume
  378. 15:26if you could just shed the superstitious
  379. 15:28clap trap that's a associated with your
  380. 15:30religious Heritage you'd instantly be
  381. 15:32enlightened but n's point was that is
  382. 15:35not what's likely to happen what's
  383. 15:37likely to happen is two things people
  384. 15:38will either give up on life completely
  385. 15:40and become cynical prematurely cynical
  386. 15:43which is certainly a disease of of young
  387. 15:45people and maybe it's always been a
  388. 15:47disease of young people but it's
  389. 15:48certainly been a disease of young people
  390. 15:50since say the end of World War II so
  391. 15:53they become nihilistic and not believe
  392. 15:55that anything has any meaning and that
  393. 15:57undermines their ability to strive or
  394. 15:59they'd fall prey to some sort of rigid
  395. 16:01ideology and nii also understood that if
  396. 16:05people fell prey to a religion to a
  397. 16:07rigid ideology or several rigid
  398. 16:09ideologies that the only plausible
  399. 16:12outcome of that would be like ex
  400. 16:15exceptionally intense Warfare and of
  401. 16:17course that's exactly what happened in
  402. 16:20the 20th
  403. 16:21century now ni also
  404. 16:23says this can't be
  405. 16:26reversed skepticism regarding moral it
  406. 16:29is what is
  407. 16:30decisive the end of the moral
  408. 16:32interpretation of the world which no
  409. 16:35longer has any sanction after it has
  410. 16:36tried to escape into some Beyond leads
  411. 16:38to nihilism all lacks meaning then he
  412. 16:42says the untenability of one
  413. 16:44interpretation of the world upon which a
  414. 16:47tremendous amount of energy has been
  415. 16:48lavished awakens the suspicion that all
  416. 16:51interpretations of the world are false
  417. 16:53so it's a brilliant observation because
  418. 16:56his point
  419. 16:57is I've seen this in
  420. 16:59in fundamentalist Christians for example
  421. 17:02who who I've taught in the past because
  422. 17:04I have a very biological view of things
  423. 17:07and these people I met more of them when
  424. 17:10I was in the United States they were
  425. 17:13more intelligent
  426. 17:15than than they were wise
  427. 17:18meaning the constraints within which
  428. 17:21their intellect was forced to operate
  429. 17:22which would be the Christian
  430. 17:23fundamentalist constraints were not
  431. 17:25sophisticated enough to encapsulate
  432. 17:27their intellect they were too smart for
  433. 17:28their own theories so they come to
  434. 17:30University and and and be exposed to
  435. 17:34ideas that were outside the scope say of
  436. 17:35Christian fundamentalism would just blow
  437. 17:37their fundamentalist presuppositions
  438. 17:39into bits and so then of course they
  439. 17:41fall into nothing but n says it's even
  440. 17:44worse than that it's not only that you
  441. 17:45fall into nothing it's that once one of
  442. 17:48your systems of belief has been
  443. 17:50destroyed you also learn that systems of
  444. 17:53beliefs themselves are unreliable and so
  445. 17:56you can't just move easily from one to
  446. 17:58another because it's like well you're in
  447. 18:02a boat and it's sunk and now you know
  448. 18:04that if you jump to the next boat that
  449. 18:06boat could also sink so it's it's not
  450. 18:09only that your boat has sunk It's now
  451. 18:11you know that all boats can sink and so
  452. 18:14that's part of the position of the
  453. 18:16modern person as far as n was concerned
  454. 18:18is that every one of us knows at least
  455. 18:20in principle that all the boats that we
  456. 18:23want to jump into could potentially sink
  457. 18:25and so n saw nihilism as the inevitable
  458. 18:30Consequence the inevitable rational
  459. 18:32consequence of that realization now I
  460. 18:34told you guys
  461. 18:35before Nisha was a very very influential
  462. 18:38person he influenced influenced haiger
  463. 18:40and haiger influenced Bing swanger and
  464. 18:42boss but Nish also influenced young as
  465. 18:46much as Freud did and Yung spent his
  466. 18:48whole career trying to solve the
  467. 18:50question that n posed one of the
  468. 18:52questions
  469. 18:57was
  470. 19:05because we must experience nihilism
  471. 19:07before we can find out what value these
  472. 19:09values really
  473. 19:10had
  474. 19:12so the collapse of a belief system makes
  475. 19:15all the values within
  476. 19:17it no longer tenable that that's the
  477. 19:20meaning of n's statement that God is
  478. 19:21dead he said if you take the central
  479. 19:23axom out of a system of belief you can't
  480. 19:27hold on to all the the things that were
  481. 19:29derived from that Axiom so here an
  482. 19:31example is this so for example in in
  483. 19:33modern Western Law there's a
  484. 19:35presupposition and the presupposition is
  485. 19:37that in some weird sense everyone is
  486. 19:39equal before the law and that's
  487. 19:41predicated on the idea that that even
  488. 19:44applies to someone who's a murderer or
  489. 19:45you're a m murderer and you and it's
  490. 19:47known you have to be treated with
  491. 19:49respect you know you have to be treated
  492. 19:51with respect by the legal system and
  493. 19:52that's a very very
  494. 19:54strange it's a miracle that that
  495. 19:56something like that ever emerged because
  496. 19:57it's so unlike
  497. 20:00so then you might ask well what is the
  498. 20:01idea that everyone has worth before the
  499. 20:04law grounded in where does that idea
  500. 20:07come from it comes from the idea of
  501. 20:08natural rights that we have natural
  502. 20:10rights and then you might ask well where
  503. 20:12do the idea of natural rights come from
  504. 20:15well then you're then you're starting to
  505. 20:17move beyond the realm of rational
  506. 20:19philosophy because natural rights the
  507. 20:21idea of natural rights has been
  508. 20:23something has been an idea that's been
  509. 20:24emerging for thousands and thousands of
  510. 20:27years you know it's it's grounded in
  511. 20:29Christianity at least to in the in the
  512. 20:34ma it's grounded in Christianity to the
  513. 20:37degree that one of the things that
  514. 20:39distinguishes Christianity is the idea
  515. 20:41that there's a universal faith and that
  516. 20:44everyone whether they're in that Faith
  517. 20:46or not has intrinsic
  518. 20:48value and so natural rights are grounded
  519. 20:51in the idea of the intrinsic value of
  520. 20:52the soul and then that's grounded in the
  521. 20:54idea that Consciousness itself
  522. 20:57participates in cre creation and say
  523. 20:59that's an idea that's embedded in
  524. 21:00Genesis and also in most creation
  525. 21:02stories so when you get rid of the
  526. 21:04religious
  527. 21:06underpinnings which which which ground
  528. 21:08the entire system in in a kind of
  529. 21:10dreamlike Mythology when you get rid of
  530. 21:12that there's no reason that what's left
  531. 21:16over rationally can survive and and and
  532. 21:19you can see that if you look at what
  533. 21:21happened in the 20th century because
  534. 21:23there were at least two major challenges
  535. 21:27to the to the civilizations that evolved
  536. 21:30and they weren't only Christian or
  537. 21:32Jewish civilizations the same thing
  538. 21:34happened in
  539. 21:36China there there was a replacement of
  540. 21:39these evolved moral systems that emerged
  541. 21:41over a tremendous amount of time that no
  542. 21:43one rationally created once people
  543. 21:46started to criticize them and to destroy
  544. 21:48the axioms on which they were built and
  545. 21:51move them aside then there was a gaping
  546. 21:53hole left and the hole was filled well
  547. 21:56it was filled most particularly either
  548. 21:58by naism which you know spread like mad
  549. 22:01throughout Central Europe or by
  550. 22:03communism which still possesses China so
  551. 22:07you know even though China came from a
  552. 22:09from a from a historical culture that
  553. 22:11was substantially different from say
  554. 22:13that of Western Europe once once once
  555. 22:16rationality emerged to the point where
  556. 22:17it could be used as a critical Force
  557. 22:20which happened in Europe that spread
  558. 22:21like mad and it it undermined the
  559. 22:24societies of China just like it
  560. 22:26undermined the societies of the West
  561. 22:29I mean Russia you can re you can read
  562. 22:31this if you read Tolstoy for example in
  563. 22:33tolstoy's confessions Russia was really
  564. 22:35the last country that underwent the the
  565. 22:39Transformations that were associated
  566. 22:40with the enlightenment so when Tolstoy
  567. 22:43was a young person in the late 19th
  568. 22:47century he L he said he could literally
  569. 22:49remember when the announcement spread
  570. 22:52through his school that God was dead now
  571. 22:56the E the Western Europeans had been
  572. 22:58working on that idea for a couple of
  573. 23:00hundred years you know with the dawn of
  574. 23:02the dawn of scientific thinking but the
  575. 23:05Russians were very backwards in some
  576. 23:07sense and they
  577. 23:10never they never they were never
  578. 23:13affected by the conflict between
  579. 23:15rationality and religion until it
  580. 23:18happened all at once and it happened all
  581. 23:21at once at the end of the 19 century and
  582. 23:23the consequence of that it's complicated
  583. 23:25but the consequence of that was that the
  584. 23:27monarchy exploded
  585. 23:28and then the consequence of that was
  586. 23:30that the Russians were left with nothing
  587. 23:32and the consequence of that was the
  588. 23:35bolik Revolution and then that was what
  589. 23:38started the entire Soviet
  590. 23:41nightmare you see very frequently that
  591. 23:43when a society loses its grounding say
  592. 23:46in its historical truths that it turns
  593. 23:48to something as an alternative you see
  594. 23:50the same thing happened in Quebec
  595. 23:52because Quebec didn't undergo the modern
  596. 23:55transformation until the late 1950s it
  597. 23:57was probably the last European Society
  598. 24:01to to go through the Enlightenment
  599. 24:03Revolution because the Catholic church
  600. 24:05was an incredibly dominant force in in
  601. 24:08in in Catholic Quebec until the late
  602. 24:101950s I mean the average family size
  603. 24:13during that time must have been in the
  604. 24:14neighborhood of 10 children and then all
  605. 24:17of a sudden in the late 1950s the
  606. 24:19quebecers just lost their Catholicism it
  607. 24:21was just gone and now for example the
  608. 24:23the kqu have the lowest marriage rate in
  609. 24:26the in the western world and and one of
  610. 24:28the lowest reproduction rates as well
  611. 24:30and there was a Gallop poll that was
  612. 24:31conducted I heard about this about must
  613. 24:35be 10 years ago now I don't know if this
  614. 24:37information has ever been made public
  615. 24:39but there was a Gallop poll that
  616. 24:40indicated that if you were a Catholic
  617. 24:42who had lost your faith so you you left
  618. 24:44the church you were 10 times more likely
  619. 24:46to be a
  620. 24:48separatist so you can see see the
  621. 24:51consequence of it is is that if one
  622. 24:53belief system disappears well nihilism
  623. 24:55is one possibility but another
  624. 24:57possibility is that you just adopt the
  625. 24:59next thing that's close that gives you
  626. 25:01structure and and nationalism of course
  627. 25:03is one of those
  628. 25:08things so n diagnosed the disease
  629. 25:12fundamentally and then the
  630. 25:13psychoanalysts like yung in particular
  631. 25:15they were trying to see n believe that
  632. 25:17if God died because God died people were
  633. 25:20going to have to take on the
  634. 25:22responsibility that was once God's so to
  635. 25:25speak as a
  636. 25:26personal problem so and thus spake zerra
  637. 25:30n said God is dead and we have killed
  638. 25:33him and we'll never find enough water to
  639. 25:35wash away the blood but he also said in
  640. 25:38order for people to withstand that
  641. 25:40catastrophe they would have to become
  642. 25:42Gods themselves
  643. 25:44essentially and well you can see how
  644. 25:46that might go wrong if you think about
  645. 25:48people like Stalin and Hitler
  646. 25:51but but the psychoanalysts also like the
  647. 25:55psychoanalyst especially Yung and then
  648. 25:58for for his part took that idea
  649. 26:00seriously and they Yung Yung said was
  650. 26:04trying to figure out well if we lose our
  651. 26:06historically conditioned values we no
  652. 26:08longer believe in them and if nihilism
  653. 26:11is the outcome on one hand and
  654. 26:12totalitarianism is the outcome on the
  655. 26:14other hand what's left and the Yan idea
  656. 26:18was well the revelation of the self is
  657. 26:21that the individual could not as a
  658. 26:24rational mind but the individual as a
  659. 26:26totality it's something that also
  660. 26:28believed the individuals at totality
  661. 26:30would be capable of bringing forth
  662. 26:33genuine values as a consequence of
  663. 26:35self-exploration and honesty something
  664. 26:37like that and that's associated with the
  665. 26:39existential idea of individual
  666. 26:43responsibility so the one of the upshots
  667. 26:45of of the Union theory is that to the
  668. 26:49degree you don't bear the responsibility
  669. 26:51for your own actions to the degree that
  670. 26:53you avoid responsibility or shunt them
  671. 26:56off onto say totalitarian or ideological
  672. 26:59system so by when you avoid
  673. 27:02responsibility for your own thought
  674. 27:04because if you're the follower of an
  675. 27:05ideological system you have avoided the
  676. 27:08responsibility of thinking for yourself
  677. 27:11and the consequence of that was
  678. 27:13continual catastrophe as those
  679. 27:15pathological rational systems unfolded
  680. 27:20themselves Sol
  681. 27:22niton wrote the gulag archipelago in a
  682. 27:25in published it in the early 19 7s
  683. 27:29and there were two things that made that
  684. 27:32book very striking one was the stories
  685. 27:35that he told were so unbelievably
  686. 27:37powerful that you couldn't read them and
  687. 27:41not believe it was true and that was
  688. 27:43even the case if you were a devoted
  689. 27:45Marxist and at that time in the
  690. 27:47universities and in many ways it hasn't
  691. 27:49changed that much the universities in
  692. 27:51the west were dominated by marxists and
  693. 27:54and to some degree that was ethically
  694. 27:57inexcusable because people had known
  695. 27:59since the 1950s especially since George
  696. 28:01Orwell wrote people had known since the
  697. 28:031950s that the stalinist state was
  698. 28:06murderous beyond belief so stellin for
  699. 28:08example killed 6 million ukrainians in
  700. 28:11the
  701. 28:121930s he starved them to death he took
  702. 28:15because all of the farmers had been
  703. 28:16collectivized at that point and what
  704. 28:18that meant was all the good Farmers had
  705. 28:20been killed and all the resentful
  706. 28:22Farmers had been given the land and then
  707. 28:24they collectivized the farms and then
  708. 28:26stellin took all the food to feed the
  709. 28:27cities
  710. 28:28or to or to starve the ukrainians
  711. 28:30depending on how you look at it and the
  712. 28:32edicts were so harsh that if you were a
  713. 28:35Ukrainian and you had a family and they
  714. 28:37were starving and you went into a field
  715. 28:39after it had been harvested and you
  716. 28:42picked out individual grains from the
  717. 28:44dirt to gather in a bowl to feed your
  718. 28:45family if you got caught then they would
  719. 28:48shoot
  720. 28:55you soier niton observed this and he he
  721. 28:58was very interested in how this system
  722. 29:00developed and his conclusion after
  723. 29:03Decades of thinking was that the reason
  724. 29:06the Russian system was able to maintain
  725. 29:08itself fundamentally was because
  726. 29:10individuals were willing to give up the
  727. 29:13responsibility of their own relationship
  728. 29:15to the truth to the state and constantly
  729. 29:18lie to themselves about everything and
  730. 29:21that if
  731. 29:23the if the individuals that composed the
  732. 29:25state had refused to accept things that
  733. 29:29they knew full well to be untrue that
  734. 29:32the state wouldn't have been able to
  735. 29:33survive and you know soit's case is very
  736. 29:36strong because in some sense he was the
  737. 29:38first person who told the truth about
  738. 29:40the gulag archipelago which was this
  739. 29:41chain of prison camps that the Soviets
  740. 29:43had erected on which their economy was
  741. 29:46essentially based he was the first
  742. 29:47person who really told the truth about
  743. 29:49that and he hit the foundations of
  744. 29:53Marxist theory so hard that well partly
  745. 29:58it collapsed and partly it went
  746. 29:59underground into movements like
  747. 30:02postmodernism so his his
  748. 30:05proposition it's a dovian proposition
  749. 30:07actually that one person who stopped
  750. 30:09lying could could overturn a
  751. 30:11tyranny it's a hard thing to believe but
  752. 30:14there's been multiple examples of that
  753. 30:16sort of thing in the 20th century it
  754. 30:18happened with Gandhi happened with vov
  755. 30:21of havl in Czechoslovakia happened with
  756. 30:23Nelson Mandela it happened with Soulja
  757. 30:25niton you know so those are pretty
  758. 30:27powerful examples of of the power of a
  759. 30:30single individual who refuses
  760. 30:33to accept the convention the
  761. 30:36conventional
  762. 30:40lie doeski was writing about the same
  763. 30:43time as N and doeski is a very
  764. 30:44interesting person he was an Orthodox
  765. 30:46Christian although he's a very
  766. 30:48intelligent man
  767. 30:50and doeski and N are twins in some sense
  768. 30:53so what nii wrote in philosophy doeski
  769. 30:56wrote in literature and do one of doss's
  770. 31:02primary statements was that if there's
  771. 31:04no God everything is permitted so it's
  772. 31:07it's a take on n's discussion of
  773. 31:10nihilism it's like well if there's no
  774. 31:12ultimate value of any sort then why
  775. 31:15can't you do exactly what you want and
  776. 31:17that's a themi explores to Great purpose
  777. 31:21in crime and
  778. 31:23punishment NE dov's conclusion was that
  779. 31:27the reason you can't do anything you
  780. 31:28want is because you actually come
  781. 31:29equipped with an inherent set of values
  782. 31:32that are real and that if you violate
  783. 31:34them to too great a degree you'll
  784. 31:36destroy your own structure as well as
  785. 31:38damaging the society that's around you
  786. 31:40so dovi was a big believer in some sense
  787. 31:43like the yans and the rogerians that
  788. 31:47there are the Locust of values within
  789. 31:49the human being and and and that it's an
  790. 31:51actual thing you can't disregard it
  791. 31:53without damage Doki was also a very
  792. 31:56powerful critic of reason and the reason
  793. 31:59for that
  794. 32:02was it was reason in some sense that
  795. 32:05brought down the house of cards so to
  796. 32:08speak that constituted classical faiths
  797. 32:10but the consequence of that rational
  798. 32:12destruction of values was the emergence
  799. 32:14of nihilism or totalitarianism and the
  800. 32:16consequence of those two things is
  801. 32:18either the inability live or the emerg
  802. 32:21emergence of the murderous state so
  803. 32:23doeski looked at that and thought okay
  804. 32:25well perhaps our belief that reason
  805. 32:28itself is the proper guide to reality is
  806. 32:32wrong and so this is one of the things
  807. 32:35he wrote in Notes from Underground when
  808. 32:36he was exploring this idea Notes from
  809. 32:39Underground by the way it's a very short
  810. 32:41book and it's very much worth reading
  811. 32:43it's a it's it's doeski wrote five books
  812. 32:45that are incalculably great and what
  813. 32:50happened to dovi I don't remember if I
  814. 32:52told you this or not but he was a
  815. 32:54student radical and he was he was
  816. 32:56arrested by the Zars men
  817. 32:58because of a riot or or a protest that
  818. 33:01him and his compatriots had come up with
  819. 33:03he was sort of a bit player in it but
  820. 33:05they put him in in prison when he was a
  821. 33:07young man and then he was in prison for
  822. 33:09quite a while and then one day they took
  823. 33:11him out into the courtyard and they shot
  824. 33:12him at dawn you know they had the
  825. 33:15soldiers line up and put them by a post
  826. 33:17and shot them but they used blanks but
  827. 33:20he didn't know that and it scared him so
  828. 33:22bad he had EP epileptic seizure and then
  829. 33:24he had epileptic seizures for the rest
  830. 33:26of his life and the kind of epileptic
  831. 33:28seizures he had were associated with
  832. 33:30mystical experience so dovi before he
  833. 33:33got a seizure would have this sense that
  834. 33:35he was experiencing the world in a more
  835. 33:37and more meaningful way until he was on
  836. 33:40the very dawn of sort of omnip
  837. 33:42omniscient knowledge and then he'd have
  838. 33:44a seizure but it wasn't until he was
  839. 33:47shot with blanks and then put in this
  840. 33:49terrible prison for a long period of
  841. 33:50time and had epilepsy that he became a
  842. 33:53great novelist it changed him in some
  843. 33:55way his early writings are really
  844. 33:57they're not good they're they're sterile
  845. 34:00and dry and his later writings the five
  846. 34:02Great novels in particular are they're
  847. 34:04in a they're in a class of their
  848. 34:06own so doeski the first thing doeski
  849. 34:10tried to come to grips with was the fact
  850. 34:12he didn't believe that life itself was
  851. 34:15rational that's an Enlightenment
  852. 34:17proposition that the structure of
  853. 34:18reality is in and of itself rational so
  854. 34:21it can be help it can be dealt with by
  855. 34:23rational means and that's been a very
  856. 34:25powerful Theory because it's enabled us
  857. 34:26to develop this the scientific Viewpoint
  858. 34:29and the technology that goes along with
  859. 34:31it but rationality is not the only mode
  860. 34:35of human knowing there's all sorts of
  861. 34:37other modes of human knowing and many of
  862. 34:39them those are associated with emotion
  863. 34:40and motivation they're more biologically
  864. 34:43instantiated say and less computational
  865. 34:46and rationality has a very difficult
  866. 34:49time even conceptualizing how those
  867. 34:51other modes of knowing might be real and
  868. 34:53so what it tends to do is denigrate them
  869. 34:55as mere opponents to rationality
  870. 34:58but the dovian perspective and this is
  871. 35:00also something that Rogers followed up
  872. 35:02on and Yung was that life itself is so
  873. 35:05irrational or experience itself is so
  874. 35:08irrational given its suffering and its
  875. 35:11and its absurdity that a mirely
  876. 35:14rationally formulated representation of
  877. 35:16life is
  878. 35:18insufficient it can't it can't manage
  879. 35:21the job and what rationality will there
  880. 35:25therefore do is cut away everything from
  881. 35:28Life cut away everything from its
  882. 35:31definition of reality that it can't
  883. 35:33actually
  884. 35:36encapsulate dovi
  885. 35:39said in short one may say anything about
  886. 35:41the history of the world anything that
  887. 35:43might enter the most disordered
  888. 35:45imagination the only thing one can't say
  889. 35:48is that it's
  890. 35:49rational the very word sticks in one's
  891. 35:53throat and indeed this is the odd thing
  892. 35:55that is continually happening they're
  893. 35:57ently turning up in life moral and
  894. 35:59rational persons sages and lovers of
  895. 36:02humanity who make it their object to
  896. 36:04live all their lives as morally and
  897. 36:05rationally as possible to be so to speak
  898. 36:08a light to their neighbors simply in
  899. 36:09order to show them that it is possible
  900. 36:12to live morally and rationally in this
  901. 36:14world and yet we all know that these
  902. 36:17very people sooner or later have been
  903. 36:19false to themselves so that's a
  904. 36:21precurser of Freudian
  905. 36:23ideas playing some queer trick often
  906. 36:27seemly one now I ask you what can be
  907. 36:31expected of man since he is a being
  908. 36:33endowed with such strange qualities
  909. 36:36shower upon him every Earthly blessing
  910. 36:40drown him in a sea of Happiness so that
  911. 36:42nothing but bubbles of bliss can be seen
  912. 36:44on the
  913. 36:45surface give him economic Prosperity so
  914. 36:48that he should have nothing else to do
  915. 36:50but sleep eat cakes and busy himself
  916. 36:53with the continuation of the species and
  917. 36:56even then out of in gratitude and spite
  918. 37:00man would play you some nasty
  919. 37:02trick he would even risk his cakes and
  920. 37:05would deliberately desire the most fatal
  921. 37:07rubbish the most uneconomical absurdity
  922. 37:11simply to introduce into all this
  923. 37:12positive Good Sense his fatal fantastic
  924. 37:16element it is just his fantastic dreams
  925. 37:19his vulgar Folly that he will desire to
  926. 37:21retain simply in order to prove to
  927. 37:23himself as if that was so necessary that
  928. 37:27men are still men and not the keys of a
  929. 37:30piano which the laws of nature threaten
  930. 37:32to control so completely that soon one
  931. 37:34will be able to desire nothing except by
  932. 37:37the calendar and that's not
  933. 37:40all even if man really were nothing but
  934. 37:42a piano key Even If This Were proved to
  935. 37:45him by Natural Science and Mathematics
  936. 37:47even then he would not become reasonable
  937. 37:49he would do purposefully do something
  938. 37:52perverse out of simple ingratitude
  939. 37:54simply to gain his point and if he does
  940. 37:57not find means he will contrive
  941. 37:58destruction and chaos and suffering of
  942. 38:01All Sorts only to gain his point he will
  943. 38:04launch a curse upon the world and as
  944. 38:07only man can curse it's his privilege
  945. 38:10the primary distinction between him and
  946. 38:12other animals Maybe by his curse alone
  947. 38:14he will detain his object that is to
  948. 38:16convince himself that he's a man and not
  949. 38:19a piano key and if you say that all of
  950. 38:21this too can be calculated and tabulated
  951. 38:23in chaos and darkness and curses so that
  952. 38:26the mere possibility of calculating it
  953. 38:28all beforehand would stop it
  954. 38:31all and reason would reassert itself
  955. 38:34then man would purposely go mad in order
  956. 38:36to be rid of reason and gain his point I
  957. 38:39believe in it I answer for it for the
  958. 38:41whole work of man really seems to
  959. 38:42consist in nothing but proving to
  960. 38:44himself every minute that he's a man and
  961. 38:46not a piano key it might be at the cost
  962. 38:49of his skin it might be by
  963. 38:51cannibalism and this being so can one
  964. 38:54help being tempted to Rejoice that it
  965. 38:55has not yet come off and that desire
  966. 38:57still depends on something we don't
  967. 39:00know you will scream at me that is if
  968. 39:03you condescend to do so that no one is
  969. 39:05touching my free will that all they're
  970. 39:07concerned with is that my free will
  971. 39:10should of itself of its own free will
  972. 39:12coincide with my own normal interests
  973. 39:14and the laws of nature and arithmetic
  974. 39:17good Heavens gentlemen what sort of Free
  975. 39:18Will is left when he when we come to
  976. 39:20tabulation and arithmetic when it will
  977. 39:22all be a case of twice two makes four
  978. 39:25twice two makes four without my will as
  979. 39:27if Free Will meant
  980. 39:30that that was written in the late 18
  981. 39:34late 1800s as well and dovi had already
  982. 39:37figured out by that point that the
  983. 39:40consequence of the new ideas swimming
  984. 39:42into Russia and undermining Orthodox
  985. 39:46Christianity which was the say the
  986. 39:47natural culture in some sense of Russia
  987. 39:50was going to be either nihilism or
  988. 39:52totalitarianism and he examined the
  989. 39:55propositions of total tarianism and the
  990. 39:58propositions of totalitarianism were
  991. 40:00essentially utopian the idea was accept
  992. 40:03it's like a cult accept this mode of
  993. 40:06being accept this interpretation of the
  994. 40:08world and Society will advance towards a
  995. 40:11point where well say in the case of
  996. 40:13Communism wealth is equally distributed
  997. 40:16and everyone is free it's a very very
  998. 40:18powerful idea obviously because it
  999. 40:21attracted hundreds of millions of people
  1000. 40:23each
  1001. 40:25according to each according to his need
  1002. 40:28from each according to his ability
  1003. 40:30sounds fair you get what you have you
  1004. 40:32get what you need to live and you
  1005. 40:34contribute what's in it what's in you to
  1006. 40:37contribute and when it was laid out in
  1007. 40:39the world it was an absolute catastrophe
  1008. 40:41and doeski criticized this before it
  1009. 40:43even happened he said look human beings
  1010. 40:47do not want Utopia we're too insane for
  1011. 40:51that if you if you had Comfort sterile
  1012. 40:55Comfort if you had everything you wanted
  1013. 40:57just given to you all you do is go crazy
  1014. 41:00just so that you wouldn't have to be
  1015. 41:01bored by all that Perfection you destroy
  1016. 41:04it so that the irrational element that's
  1017. 41:06inside of you this dionan element could
  1018. 41:09leap out and live and so whatever Utopia
  1019. 41:12is it's not the permanent solution to
  1020. 41:15all of your problems you don't even want
  1021. 41:17to live without
  1022. 41:21problems kard writing at a a little
  1023. 41:24earlier on but along the similar a
  1024. 41:27similar track of
  1025. 41:30ideas he's also criticizing the idea of
  1026. 41:34Utopia believing at least in part that
  1027. 41:36the meaning in in life is to be be found
  1028. 41:39within the struggle that constitutes
  1029. 41:42life and not in the solution to that
  1030. 41:45struggle which maybe is equivalent to
  1031. 41:47death and not to
  1032. 41:49Utopia it is about four years ago that I
  1033. 41:52got the notion of wanting to try my luck
  1034. 41:54as an author I remember it quite clearly
  1035. 41:57it was a Sunday yes a Sunday afternoon I
  1036. 42:00was seated as usual outside at the cafe
  1037. 42:03in the Fredericksburg Garden I'd been a
  1038. 42:05student for half a score of years
  1039. 42:07although never lazy all my activity
  1040. 42:10nevertheless was like a glittering
  1041. 42:11inactivity a kind of occupation for
  1042. 42:14which I still have a great partiality
  1043. 42:16and for which perhaps I even have a
  1044. 42:18little genius I read much spent the
  1045. 42:21remainder of the day idling and thinking
  1046. 42:23or thinking and idling but that was all
  1047. 42:25it came to so I sat there and I smoked
  1048. 42:28my cigar until I lapsed into thought
  1049. 42:30among other thoughts I remember these
  1050. 42:34you were going on I said to myself to
  1051. 42:37become an old man without being anything
  1052. 42:39and without really undertaking to do
  1053. 42:42anything on the other hand wherever you
  1054. 42:44look around you in literature and in
  1055. 42:46life you see the celebrated names and
  1056. 42:48figures the precious and much heralded
  1057. 42:50men who are coming into prominence and
  1058. 42:52are much talked about the many
  1059. 42:54benefactors of the age who know how to
  1060. 42:56benefit mankind by making life easier
  1061. 42:57and easier some by Railways others by
  1062. 43:01omnibuses and steamboats others by the
  1063. 43:03telegraph others by easily apprehended
  1064. 43:05compendiums and short recital of
  1065. 43:07everything worth
  1066. 43:09knowing and finally the true benefactors
  1067. 43:11of the age who make spiritual existence
  1068. 43:13in virtue of thought easier and easier
  1069. 43:15yet more and more significant and what
  1070. 43:18are you
  1071. 43:19doing here my Soliloquy was interrupted
  1072. 43:22because my cigarette was smoked out and
  1073. 43:24a new one had to be lit so I smoked
  1074. 43:26again and then suddenly this thought
  1075. 43:27flashed into my
  1076. 43:29mind you must do something but in as
  1077. 43:32much as with your limited capacities it
  1078. 43:33will be impossible for you to make
  1079. 43:35anything easier than it has already
  1080. 43:37become you must with the same
  1081. 43:39humanitarian enthusiasm as the others
  1082. 43:42undertake to make something
  1083. 43:46harder this notion pleased me immensely
  1084. 43:49and at the same time it flattered me to
  1085. 43:50think that I like the rest of them would
  1086. 43:52be loved and esteemed by the whole
  1087. 43:54Community for when all combin in every
  1088. 43:56way to make everything easier there
  1089. 43:59remains only one possible danger namely
  1090. 44:02that the ease will become so great that
  1091. 44:04it becomes allog together too
  1092. 44:06great then there's only one want left
  1093. 44:09although it is not yet a felt want when
  1094. 44:11people will want
  1095. 44:13difficulty out of love for mankind and
  1096. 44:15out of Despair at my embarrassing
  1097. 44:17situation seeing that I had accomplished
  1098. 44:19nothing and was unable to make anything
  1099. 44:22easier than it had already been made and
  1100. 44:24moved by a genuine interest in those who
  1101. 44:26make everything easy
  1102. 44:27I conceived it as my task to create
  1103. 44:29difficulties
  1104. 44:40everywhere KAG guard is often regarded
  1105. 44:43as an existentialist and one of the
  1106. 44:45ideas that runs its way through
  1107. 44:48existentialism is the idea that to be
  1108. 44:50human is to simultaneously be saddled
  1109. 44:53with an intrinsic responsibility a moral
  1110. 44:56responsibility that you are responsible
  1111. 44:58not only to yourself to your soul say
  1112. 45:01but also to the people around you and
  1113. 45:03that that
  1114. 45:04isn't an arbitrary imposition that's
  1115. 45:07imposed upon you by rationality or by
  1116. 45:09your fellow man for that matter but
  1117. 45:11something that's right at the heart of
  1118. 45:13the reality of existence itself such
  1119. 45:16that if you
  1120. 45:18thwart or fall short of bearing that
  1121. 45:21responsibility you'll pay a price in
  1122. 45:23guilt and in shame and in
  1123. 45:25suffering
  1124. 45:29bin swanger and BR boss working off
  1125. 45:31haider's lead said
  1126. 45:33that guilt and fear are debts to
  1127. 45:36possibility if you're guilty about
  1128. 45:38something well it's because you're not
  1129. 45:40upholding your responsibility whereas
  1130. 45:42for Freud that was often a form of
  1131. 45:45pathology excess guilt and of course
  1132. 45:47excess guilt can become pathological but
  1133. 45:50KAG guard's point is that guilt itself
  1134. 45:52isn't something to be cured it's it's
  1135. 45:55it's it's an integral necessary part of
  1136. 45:57reality just like disgust and despair
  1137. 46:00and fear and all the negative emotions
  1138. 46:02they alert you to your place in the
  1139. 46:04world and guide you towards the
  1140. 46:06unfolding of your
  1141. 46:09spirit failure to shoulder your
  1142. 46:12existential burden is what results in
  1143. 46:14neurotic guilt and
  1144. 46:19fear Ben swanger and boss also believed
  1145. 46:22that like existential anxiety and that's
  1146. 46:25the feeling of of nothing nothingness is
  1147. 46:28fear of loss of
  1148. 46:30world that the world that you inhabit
  1149. 46:33the conceptual world that you habit
  1150. 46:34inhabit can be destroyed at any moment
  1151. 46:36and that you're aware of that at some
  1152. 46:38level it's the same comment that n made
  1153. 46:40and and and N believed that this was
  1154. 46:42something that modern people were
  1155. 46:43particularly susceptible to because our
  1156. 46:45rationality is always capable of sawing
  1157. 46:47off the branch that we're sitting on
  1158. 46:49because no matter what you're doing even
  1159. 46:50if you're engaged in it deeply the
  1160. 46:52critical part of your mind can always
  1161. 46:54saywell what makes you think that's so
  1162. 46:55worthwhile and you know an answer could
  1163. 46:58be well it manifests itself as being
  1164. 47:01worthwhile and why should I pay
  1165. 47:03attention to those rational doubts but
  1166. 47:05that's not how we're trained we're
  1167. 47:07trained that rationality is the thing
  1168. 47:10that encompasses everything instead of
  1169. 47:12being trained that rationality is
  1170. 47:13something that's encompassed by
  1171. 47:15something else and so if doubts come up
  1172. 47:18that are rational we immediately believe
  1173. 47:20them because they're rational instead of
  1174. 47:22asking ourself well if the rational
  1175. 47:24doubt is undermining the meaning in my
  1176. 47:27life and making it difficult for me to
  1177. 47:29proceed maybe the thing to do is to
  1178. 47:31question whether or not that doubt is
  1179. 47:33valid now it depends in what you regard
  1180. 47:35as real because if it's re if it's the
  1181. 47:39rational argument itself that's real
  1182. 47:41then you can't dispense with the doubts
  1183. 47:43but if you say well rationality is too
  1184. 47:45Limited in its apprehension to deal with
  1185. 47:47the absurdity of life there are other
  1186. 47:49sorts of answers like music for example
  1187. 47:52or or art or or the kind of Engagement
  1188. 47:55that you that you experience when you're
  1189. 47:58involved in something that you're
  1190. 47:59incredibly interested in those are forms
  1191. 48:01of reality that are that you can regard
  1192. 48:05those as forms of reality that transcend
  1193. 48:08rationalism instead of being something
  1194. 48:10embedded inside rationalism that can be
  1195. 48:12destroyed by doubt and the problem with
  1196. 48:14doubt is that it can undermine you
  1197. 48:15completely that's nism but even worse
  1198. 48:18than that it can lay you open to
  1199. 48:20ideological
  1200. 48:21possession and that's that's satanic in
  1201. 48:25its in its in its
  1202. 48:32catastrophe well I'll talk to you a
  1203. 48:34little bit now about the Concentration
  1204. 48:36Camp concentration camps were
  1205. 48:38established there they were established
  1206. 48:40in England Germany Russia China Cambodia
  1207. 48:43and Yugoslavia and in the Soviet Union
  1208. 48:46the estimates these are estimates that
  1209. 48:48were derived by Soulja niton were that
  1210. 48:4966 million people died in internal
  1211. 48:52repression in the Soviet Union between
  1212. 48:541919 and 1959 that's a figure that's 10
  1213. 48:58times as great as the figures that are
  1214. 48:59commonly used to describe the the
  1215. 49:02genocide rate in the Holocaust which was
  1216. 49:03more like six million and Soulja niton
  1217. 49:05also estimated but no one knows that 100
  1218. 49:07million people died in China during Ma's
  1219. 49:11cultural revolution when Mao decided
  1220. 49:13that he was going to wipe out all of
  1221. 49:14Chinese tradition and destroyed much of
  1222. 49:16the much of the ancient artifacts that
  1223. 49:19characterized that tradition in a in a
  1224. 49:21like a riotous catastrophe that lasted
  1225. 49:24more than a
  1226. 49:25decade
  1227. 49:29soier niton says the imagination and
  1228. 49:33strength spiritual strength of
  1229. 49:34Shakespeare's evildoers stopped short at
  1230. 49:37a dozen corpses because they had no
  1231. 49:39ideology ideology that's what gives
  1232. 49:43evildoing its long-sought justification
  1233. 49:45and gives the evildoer the necessary
  1234. 49:47steadfastness and determination that's
  1235. 49:49the social theory which helps to make
  1236. 49:51his acts seem good instead of bad in his
  1237. 49:53own eyes and others this was how the
  1238. 49:56agent of the Inquisition fortified their
  1239. 49:58Wills by invoking Christianity the
  1240. 50:00Conqueror of foreign lands by extoling
  1241. 50:02the Grandeur of their motherland the
  1242. 50:04colonizers by civilization the Nazis by
  1243. 50:07race and the Jacobin early and late by
  1244. 50:10equality Brotherhood and the happiness
  1245. 50:12of future Generations without evildoers
  1246. 50:14there would have been no
  1247. 50:16archipelago the archipelago the gulag
  1248. 50:18archipelago is
  1249. 50:19solon's metaphor for the for the prison
  1250. 50:24camps like the prison camps that exist
  1251. 50:26now in North Korea in which millions of
  1252. 50:29people are starving and dying for the
  1253. 50:31for the prison camps that littered the
  1254. 50:33entire Soviet Union and those cultures
  1255. 50:36became so pathological that in East
  1256. 50:38Germany for example before the wall fell
  1257. 50:40down and East Germany was arguably one
  1258. 50:42of the more civilized parts of the
  1259. 50:44Soviet state one person out of three was
  1260. 50:47a government Informer so if you have a
  1261. 50:49family of five people there's a
  1262. 50:51reasonable probability that two of them
  1263. 50:53are going to tell a government agent
  1264. 50:55what you say and think
  1265. 50:57and that that was also portrayed as the
  1266. 50:59highest possible moral virtue because it
  1267. 51:01was much better for you to be a
  1268. 51:04admirable citizen of the state than say
  1269. 51:06a loyal daughter and that's what
  1270. 51:08children were taught in school that the
  1271. 51:10family was a defunct unit and that
  1272. 51:12individual relationships were secondary
  1273. 51:14and that all that mattered was adherence
  1274. 51:16to the Dogma that constituted the
  1275. 51:17central axioms of the
  1276. 51:21state this is soul nen's description of
  1277. 51:25how communist ideological uniformity was
  1278. 51:28enforced in the prison
  1279. 51:32camps an anonymous author is told how
  1280. 51:34executions were carried out at adak a
  1281. 51:36camp on the Petro River they would take
  1282. 51:38the opposition members with their things
  1283. 51:41out of the camp Compound on a prisoner
  1284. 51:43transport at night and outside the
  1285. 51:44compound stood the small house of the
  1286. 51:46third
  1287. 51:48section The Condemned men were taken
  1288. 51:51into a room one at a time and there the
  1289. 51:53camp guards sprang on them their mouths
  1290. 51:55were stuffed with something soft and
  1291. 51:57their arms were bound with cords behind
  1292. 51:58their backs then they were LED out into
  1293. 52:01the courtyard where harnessed carts were
  1294. 52:03waiting the bound prisoners were piled
  1295. 52:05on the carts from 5: to 7: at a time and
  1296. 52:08driven off to the Gorka the camp
  1297. 52:11cemetery on arrival they were tipped
  1298. 52:12into big pits that had already been
  1299. 52:14prepared and buried alive not out of
  1300. 52:17brutality no it had been
  1301. 52:20ascertained that when dragging and
  1302. 52:22lifting them it was much easier to cope
  1303. 52:24with living people than with corpses but
  1304. 52:26the work went on for many nights at adak
  1305. 52:29and that is how the moral political
  1306. 52:30Unity of our party was
  1307. 52:37achieved if you have a rigid belief
  1308. 52:39system and that's what an idiology is
  1309. 52:41because it its axioms are such that it
  1310. 52:43encompasses all of reality and then
  1311. 52:45there are details left outside that
  1312. 52:47don't seem to fit into that reality well
  1313. 52:50then you ignore them but what if they're
  1314. 52:51embodied what if they're people who are
  1315. 52:53objecting to the way you think well the
  1316. 52:56equivalent to repressing evidence that
  1317. 52:58runs contrary to your theory is the
  1318. 53:00murder of people who object to what you
  1319. 53:03say and those two things are linked much
  1320. 53:05tighter than you would think you know
  1321. 53:07you might think well I would never do
  1322. 53:09something like the Communists did in in
  1323. 53:11in in in the what the the evangelization
  1324. 53:16of my beliefs but the truth of the
  1325. 53:18matter is is that in general people will
  1326. 53:21do such things if they're granted the
  1327. 53:24opportunity and provided with the proper
  1328. 53:32apparatus this is Frankle from his
  1329. 53:34accounts of the concentration camps
  1330. 53:37under Nazi Germany the most ghastly
  1331. 53:40moment of the 24 hours of Camp life was
  1332. 53:42The Awakening when at a still nocturnal
  1333. 53:44hour the three shrill blows of a whistle
  1334. 53:46tore us pitilessly from our exhausted
  1335. 53:48sleep and from the longings in our
  1336. 53:50dreams we then began the tussle with our
  1337. 53:53wet shoes into which we could scarcely
  1338. 53:55Force our feet which were sore and
  1339. 53:57swollen with
  1340. 53:59edema and then there were the usual
  1341. 54:01moans and groans about Petty trouble
  1342. 54:02such as the snapping of wires which
  1343. 54:04replace shoelaces one morning I heard
  1344. 54:06someone whom I knew to be brave and
  1345. 54:08dignified cry like a child because he
  1346. 54:11finally had to go out to the snowy
  1347. 54:12marching fields in his bare feet as his
  1348. 54:14shoes were too shrunken for him to
  1349. 54:16wear in those ghastly moments I found a
  1350. 54:20little bit of comfort a small piece of
  1351. 54:22bread which I drew out of my pocket and
  1352. 54:24munched with absorbed
  1353. 54:27light so
  1354. 54:31niten many of the gulag camps contained
  1355. 54:35two classes of
  1356. 54:37prisoners rapists murderers and thieves
  1357. 54:39who were very well organized in Russia
  1358. 54:41and the Soviet Union and political
  1359. 54:43prisoners and because the Soviets
  1360. 54:45believed that the reason that people
  1361. 54:47were thieves murderers and rapists was
  1362. 54:49because of the appalling sociological
  1363. 54:52conditions that they grew up into they
  1364. 54:55believed they were socially friendly
  1365. 54:56elements who could still be
  1366. 54:58redeemed so they put them in charge of
  1367. 55:00the camps and so the political prisoners
  1368. 55:03were at the bottom of the
  1369. 55:06hierarchy the prisoners ran the camps
  1370. 55:08with minimal
  1371. 55:10supervision and the camps were often
  1372. 55:13forced labor camps and forced labor
  1373. 55:15meant do something difficult and
  1374. 55:17pointless until you die it didn't mean
  1375. 55:20it meant only secondarily produce
  1376. 55:24something of potential value to the
  1377. 55:25state you saw this this with Nazi
  1378. 55:26Germany too the Nazis when they started
  1379. 55:30to lose the second world
  1380. 55:32war they could have sto their Holocaust
  1381. 55:35machinations and used the people they
  1382. 55:37had imprisoned to build Implements to
  1383. 55:40further the war effort which they did to
  1384. 55:41some degree so they could have used them
  1385. 55:43as slaves so this would be the logic
  1386. 55:45take the slaves make the Munitions win
  1387. 55:48the war then after you've won the war
  1388. 55:51you can run around and mop everybody up
  1389. 55:52but that isn't what the Nazis did when
  1390. 55:54they started to lose instead of doing
  1391. 55:57what you think would be rational in the
  1392. 55:59pursuit of what was hypothetically their
  1393. 56:01goal they amped Up The
  1394. 56:04Killing and and took resources away from
  1395. 56:07the war itself and so the conclusion
  1396. 56:10that's reasonable to draw from that is
  1397. 56:12that the killing was the purpose of the
  1398. 56:14war all the rest of it was just window
  1399. 56:17dressing and exactly as a soliton
  1400. 56:20described in the earlier quotes that I
  1401. 56:22told you was that ideology was only
  1402. 56:24there to allow the people who were fund
  1403. 56:26Mally Mo motivated towards genocide and
  1404. 56:28destruction to pretend to themselves
  1405. 56:31that they hadn't become rot to the
  1406. 56:33absolute core but when push came to
  1407. 56:35shove and they had to show where their
  1408. 56:37allegiances lie they weren't even they
  1409. 56:40weren't even valid followers of the Nazi
  1410. 56:44party because they put the continued
  1411. 56:47Pursuit Of Death above their own
  1412. 56:49Survival even as an ideology and that's
  1413. 56:52how ideology degenerates and part of the
  1414. 56:53reason for that is that the narrower the
  1415. 56:56box that you stuff yourself into the
  1416. 56:59weaker your character becomes because
  1417. 57:02there's nothing left of you you're just
  1418. 57:03a shell that has demons in it and but
  1419. 57:06you're still the sort of thing that can
  1420. 57:08suffer and so if you cram everything you
  1421. 57:10are into a a box a small tight box and
  1422. 57:13you get rid of everything that doesn't
  1423. 57:14fit you get rid of everything in you
  1424. 57:16that makes life bearable and then life
  1425. 57:18becomes unbearable and then if life
  1426. 57:20becomes unbearable well then of course
  1427. 57:22you're motivated to do nothing but to
  1428. 57:23take revenge on it because why wouldn't
  1429. 57:26you if all you were doing was suffering
  1430. 57:29stupidly and
  1431. 57:30meaninglessly how could you positively
  1432. 57:32how could you possibly show a positive
  1433. 57:35face to yourself and to the rest of
  1434. 57:37humanity in cold lower than 60° below
  1435. 57:41zero work days were written off in other
  1436. 57:44words on such days the records showed
  1437. 57:46that the workers had not gone out to
  1438. 57:48work they were often digging canals on
  1439. 57:51the Frozen Siberian Prairie by hand
  1440. 57:56there was one Canal I think it was on
  1441. 57:58the vulga river but I I can't remember
  1442. 58:02precisely so Stalin killed 300,000
  1443. 58:05people in a single winter digging it by
  1444. 58:08hand and when it was done it was so
  1445. 58:10shallow that no ships could use
  1446. 58:14it the record showed that the workers
  1447. 58:16had not gone out to work but they chased
  1448. 58:18them out anyway and whatever they
  1449. 58:19squeezed out of them on those days was
  1450. 58:20added to the other days thereby raising
  1451. 58:22the percentages and the cile medical
  1452. 58:25section wrote off those who froze to
  1453. 58:27death on such cold days on some other
  1454. 58:29basis and the ones who were left who
  1455. 58:30could no longer walk and were straining
  1456. 58:32every senu to crawl Along on all fours
  1457. 58:34on the way back to Camp the Convoy
  1458. 58:36simply shot so that they wouldn't Escape
  1459. 58:38before they could come back to get
  1460. 58:40them this is from William
  1461. 58:43Blake oh Rose though art sick the
  1462. 58:46invisible worm that flies in the night
  1463. 58:48in the howling storm have found out thy
  1464. 58:51bed of crimson joy and His Dark Secret
  1465. 58:54Love does thy life destroy
  1466. 58:58this is Soulja nson
  1467. 59:00fire fire the branches crackle in the
  1468. 59:03night wind of late Autumn blows the
  1469. 59:04flame of the bonfire back and forth the
  1470. 59:06compound is dark I'm alone at the
  1471. 59:09bonfire and I can bring it still some
  1472. 59:11more Carpenter shavings this compound
  1473. 59:13here is a privileged one so privileged
  1474. 59:16that it's almost as if I were out in
  1475. 59:17Freedom this is an island of paradise
  1476. 59:20this is the marfino
  1477. 59:22shashka a scientific Institute staffed
  1478. 59:25by engineers
  1479. 59:28staffed with prisoners in its most
  1480. 59:29privileged period no one is overseeing
  1481. 59:31me calling me to a cell chasing me away
  1482. 59:33from the bonfire and even then it is
  1483. 59:35chilly in the penetrating wind but she
  1484. 59:39who has already been standing in the
  1485. 59:41wind for hours her arms straight down
  1486. 59:44her head drooping weeping and then
  1487. 59:46growing numb and still and then again
  1488. 59:48she begs piously Citizen Chief please
  1489. 59:51forgive me I won't do it
  1490. 59:55again the wind carries her moan to me
  1491. 59:57just as if she were moaning next to my
  1492. 59:59ear The Citizen Chief at the gate house
  1493. 1:00:02fires up his stove and does not answer
  1494. 1:00:05this was the Gat House of the camp next
  1495. 1:00:07door to us from which workers came into
  1496. 1:00:08our compound to lay water pipes and
  1497. 1:00:11repair the old ramshackle seminary
  1498. 1:00:13building across from me beyond the
  1499. 1:00:16artfully intertwined many stranded
  1500. 1:00:18barbed wire barricade and two steps away
  1501. 1:00:21from the Gat house beneath a bright
  1502. 1:00:23Lantern stood the punished girl head
  1503. 1:00:25hanging
  1504. 1:00:26the wind tugging at her gray work skirt
  1505. 1:00:29her feet growing numb from the
  1506. 1:00:31cold and a thin scarf over her head it
  1507. 1:00:35had been warm during the day when they
  1508. 1:00:36had been digging a ditch on our
  1509. 1:00:38territory and another girl slipping down
  1510. 1:00:40into a ravine had crawled her way to the
  1511. 1:00:42vadino highway and escaped the guard had
  1512. 1:00:45bungled and Moscow city buses ran right
  1513. 1:00:48along the highway when they caught on it
  1514. 1:00:50was too late to catch her they raised
  1515. 1:00:52the alarm a mean dark major arrived and
  1516. 1:00:56shouted that if they failed to catch the
  1517. 1:00:58girl the entire Camp would be deprived
  1518. 1:00:59of visits and Parcels for a whole month
  1519. 1:01:02because of her
  1520. 1:01:04escape and the women briers went into a
  1521. 1:01:06rage and they were all shouting one of
  1522. 1:01:08them in particular who kept viciously
  1523. 1:01:10rolling her
  1524. 1:01:11eyes oh I hope they catch her the
  1525. 1:01:14I hope they take scissors and clip clip
  1526. 1:01:16take off all her hair in front of the
  1527. 1:01:19lineup this wasn't something she had
  1528. 1:01:20thought of herself this is the way they
  1529. 1:01:22punished women in the gag but the girl
  1530. 1:01:24who was now standing outside the gate
  1531. 1:01:25house house in the cold had sighed and
  1532. 1:01:28said
  1533. 1:01:29Instead at least she can have a good
  1534. 1:01:31time out in Freedom for all of us the
  1535. 1:01:33Jailer overheard what she said and now
  1536. 1:01:35she was being punished everyone else had
  1537. 1:01:37been taken off to the camp but she had
  1538. 1:01:39been set outside there to stand at
  1539. 1:01:40attention in front of the gate house
  1540. 1:01:42this had been at 6:00 p.m. and it was
  1541. 1:01:45now 11: p.m. she tried to shift from one
  1542. 1:01:48foot to another but the guard struck out
  1543. 1:01:50his head and shouted stand at attention
  1544. 1:01:53or it will be worse for you and
  1545. 1:01:56now she was not moving only
  1546. 1:01:59weeping forgive me Citizen Chief let me
  1547. 1:02:02into the camp I won't do it anymore but
  1548. 1:02:06even in the camp no one was about to say
  1549. 1:02:08to her all right idiot come on in the
  1550. 1:02:10reason they were keeping her out there
  1551. 1:02:12so long was that the next day was Sunday
  1552. 1:02:14and and she would not be needed for
  1553. 1:02:17work such a straw blonde naive un
  1554. 1:02:20uneducated slip of a girl she had been
  1555. 1:02:24imprisoned for some spool of
  1556. 1:02:26thread what a dangerous thought you
  1557. 1:02:29expressed there little sister they want
  1558. 1:02:30to teach you a lesson for the rest of
  1559. 1:02:33your
  1560. 1:02:34life fire fire we fought the
  1561. 1:02:38War and we looked into the bonfires to
  1562. 1:02:40see what kind of Victory would be the
  1563. 1:02:42wind wafted a glowing husk from the
  1564. 1:02:46bonfire to that flame in you girl I
  1565. 1:02:49promise the whole wide world will read
  1566. 1:02:51about
  1567. 1:02:54you from Milton
  1568. 1:02:56this is from Paradise Lost Milton wrote
  1569. 1:02:58Paradise Lost just before the rise of
  1570. 1:03:00the nation states and Milton also had
  1571. 1:03:02the intuition that there was something
  1572. 1:03:05wrong with rationality and he identified
  1573. 1:03:08rationality with the mythology of Satan
  1574. 1:03:11and in the mythology of Satan Satan
  1575. 1:03:14was represented as the highest angel in
  1576. 1:03:17God's Heavenly Kingdom so you can think
  1577. 1:03:19about that as the highest psychological
  1578. 1:03:21function who had rebelled against God
  1579. 1:03:23and that and was then cast into hell and
  1580. 1:03:26the idea there's an idea that's being
  1581. 1:03:27expressed by Milton he was he was one of
  1582. 1:03:29the most he was one of the foremost
  1583. 1:03:33poetic Geniuses of the English language
  1584. 1:03:35Milton and Shakespeare and what Milton
  1585. 1:03:38was trying to understand was what is the
  1586. 1:03:40nature of evil and his
  1587. 1:03:43representation gathered up the dreamlike
  1588. 1:03:46theories of evil that had been collected
  1589. 1:03:48around all of Western Civilization for
  1590. 1:03:50thousands of years and his hypothesis
  1591. 1:03:52was this evil is the force that believes
  1592. 1:03:56that its knowledge is complete and that
  1593. 1:03:59it can do without the Transcendent and
  1594. 1:04:01as soon as it makes that claim it ex
  1595. 1:04:03instantly exists in a place that's
  1596. 1:04:06indistinguishable from hell and it could
  1597. 1:04:09get out merely by admitting its error
  1598. 1:04:11and it will never do
  1599. 1:04:15that for whence but from the author of
  1600. 1:04:18all ill could spring so deep a malice to
  1601. 1:04:21confound the race of mankind in one root
  1602. 1:04:24and Earth with hell to mingle and and
  1603. 1:04:26involve done all to spite the great
  1604. 1:04:31Creator this is from Richard the thir
  1605. 1:04:35Shakespeare I shall despair there is no
  1606. 1:04:37creature loves me and if I die no soul
  1607. 1:04:40will Pity Me Nay wherefore should they
  1608. 1:04:42since that I myself find in myself no
  1609. 1:04:45pity to
  1610. 1:04:49myself soier niton describes the
  1611. 1:04:51reactions and actions of Communist party
  1612. 1:04:53members who were devoured by the system
  1613. 1:04:55because that of happened the the the the
  1614. 1:04:57prison system the gik system was very
  1615. 1:05:00indiscriminating you could land there
  1616. 1:05:02for good reasons or bad and the bad
  1617. 1:05:04reasons were probably better because the
  1618. 1:05:05punishment was more severe if you were
  1619. 1:05:07imprisoned for your innocence and
  1620. 1:05:10Communist party members often got
  1621. 1:05:11vacuumed up and this was ontologically
  1622. 1:05:14and existentially intolerable for them
  1623. 1:05:16because they committed their whole soul
  1624. 1:05:17to the ideological dogma and then it's
  1625. 1:05:20its tyrannical aspect picked them up and
  1626. 1:05:23destroyed them like they were worth
  1627. 1:05:25nothing
  1628. 1:05:26to say that things were painful for them
  1629. 1:05:28is to say almost nothing they were
  1630. 1:05:30incapable of assimilating such a blow
  1631. 1:05:33such a downfall and from their own
  1632. 1:05:34people too from their own dear party the
  1633. 1:05:37typical arrest was you're at home with
  1634. 1:05:39your family in your bed and it's 3:00 in
  1635. 1:05:43the morning and the doors kick down and
  1636. 1:05:45they take you out of your bed and
  1637. 1:05:47whatever you happen to be wearing and
  1638. 1:05:49they tell you to say goodbye to your
  1639. 1:05:50family and give you like 25 seconds to
  1640. 1:05:53pack and then you're gone and no one no
  1641. 1:05:55one sees you again they take you to the
  1642. 1:05:57prison they take off all your clothes
  1643. 1:06:00they shave your head they have you pick
  1644. 1:06:02out some random clothes from a pile of
  1645. 1:06:03clothes hopefully they don't fit and
  1646. 1:06:06then you're tried you confess if you
  1647. 1:06:09will and you're off to the prison camp
  1648. 1:06:12to say that things were painful for them
  1649. 1:06:14is to say almost nothing they were
  1650. 1:06:15incapable of assimilating such a blow
  1651. 1:06:18such a downfall and from their own
  1652. 1:06:19people too from their own dear party and
  1653. 1:06:22from all appearances for nothing at all
  1654. 1:06:25after all they had been guilty of
  1655. 1:06:26nothing as far as the party was
  1656. 1:06:27concerned nothing at all it was painful
  1657. 1:06:31to them to such a degree that it was
  1658. 1:06:33considered taboo among them uncom radly
  1659. 1:06:36to ask what were you imprisoned for H
  1660. 1:06:39they were the only squeamish generation
  1661. 1:06:40of prisoners the rest of us with our
  1662. 1:06:42tongues hanging out couldn't wait to
  1663. 1:06:44tell the story to every chance newcomer
  1664. 1:06:46we met and to the whole cell as if it
  1665. 1:06:48were an
  1666. 1:06:49anecdote here's the sort of people they
  1667. 1:06:52were Olga seberg's husband had already
  1668. 1:06:55been arrested and they had come to carry
  1669. 1:06:57out a search and arrest her too the
  1670. 1:06:59search lasted 4
  1671. 1:07:01hours and she spent those four hours
  1672. 1:07:04sorting out the minutes of the Congress
  1673. 1:07:06of the bristle and brush industry of
  1674. 1:07:09which she had been the secretary until
  1675. 1:07:10the previous day the incomplete state of
  1676. 1:07:13the minutes troubled her more than her
  1677. 1:07:14children who she was now leaving forever
  1678. 1:07:17even the interrogator conducting the
  1679. 1:07:19search could not resist telling her come
  1680. 1:07:21on now say farewell to your
  1681. 1:07:23children here's the sour sort of people
  1682. 1:07:26they were a letter from her 15-year-old
  1683. 1:07:28daughter came to yelizaveta tetova in
  1684. 1:07:32the Kazan prison for long-term prisoners
  1685. 1:07:35Mama tell me write to me are you guilty
  1686. 1:07:38or not I hope you weren't guilty because
  1687. 1:07:40then I won't join the Comm all which was
  1688. 1:07:42the young communist organization and I
  1689. 1:07:44won't forgive them because of you but if
  1690. 1:07:48you guilty I won't write you anymore and
  1691. 1:07:49I will hate you and the mother was
  1692. 1:07:51stricken by remorse in her damp grave
  1693. 1:07:53likee cell with its dim little lamp how
  1694. 1:07:56could her daughter live without the
  1695. 1:07:58commum wall how could she per be
  1696. 1:08:00permitted to hate Soviet power better
  1697. 1:08:02that she should hate me and so she wrote
  1698. 1:08:04I am guilty enter the
  1699. 1:08:07cumal how could it be anything but hard
  1700. 1:08:10it was more than the human heart could
  1701. 1:08:11bear to fall beneath the Beloved Axe and
  1702. 1:08:15then to have to justify its wisdom but
  1703. 1:08:17that's the price a man pays for
  1704. 1:08:19entrusting his god-given soul to human
  1705. 1:08:21Dogma even today any Orthodox communist
  1706. 1:08:24will affirm that set kovak acted
  1707. 1:08:25correctly even today they cannot be
  1708. 1:08:28convinced that this is precisely quote
  1709. 1:08:30the perversion of small
  1710. 1:08:33forces that the mother perverted her
  1711. 1:08:35daughter and harmed her soul here's the
  1712. 1:08:37sort of people they were YT gave sincere
  1713. 1:08:40testimony against her husband anything
  1714. 1:08:42to Aid the party oh how one could pity
  1715. 1:08:45them if they at least had come to
  1716. 1:08:48comprehend their former wretchedness
  1717. 1:08:50this whole chapter could have been
  1718. 1:08:51writing qu quite differently if today at
  1719. 1:08:53least they had forsaken their earlier
  1720. 1:08:54views but it happened the way Maria
  1721. 1:08:57danielin had dreamed it would if I leave
  1722. 1:08:59here someday I'm going to live as if
  1723. 1:09:02nothing had taken place loyalty in our
  1724. 1:09:05view it's just plain pigheadedness those
  1725. 1:09:08devotees to the theories of development
  1726. 1:09:10construed loyalty to that development to
  1727. 1:09:12mean renunciation to any personal
  1728. 1:09:14development whatsoever as Nikolai
  1729. 1:09:17adamovich villan chuk said after serving
  1730. 1:09:1917 years we believed in the party and we
  1731. 1:09:22were not mistaken is this loyal y or
  1732. 1:09:26pigheadedness no it was not for show and
  1733. 1:09:28not out of hypocrisy hypocrisy that they
  1734. 1:09:30argued in the C in defense of all the
  1735. 1:09:32government's actions they needed
  1736. 1:09:34ideological arguments in order to hold
  1737. 1:09:35on to a sense of their own
  1738. 1:09:38rightness otherwise Insanity was not far
  1739. 1:09:41off this is from Paradise
  1740. 1:09:46Lost so in this scene Satan is cast into
  1741. 1:09:50hell and it's because of his Rebellion
  1742. 1:09:53against the transcend
  1743. 1:09:56his idea that he himself is sufficient
  1744. 1:09:59this is his statement to his crew
  1745. 1:10:02farewell happy
  1746. 1:10:04Fields where Joy forever dwells hail
  1747. 1:10:07Horrors hail infernal world and thou
  1748. 1:10:10profoundest hell receive thy new
  1749. 1:10:13possessor one who brings a mind not to
  1750. 1:10:16be changed by place or
  1751. 1:10:19time the mind is its own place and in
  1752. 1:10:21itself can make a heaven of Hell or Hell
  1753. 1:10:23of Heaven what matters where
  1754. 1:10:25if I be still the
  1755. 1:10:27same and what I should be all but less
  1756. 1:10:31than he whom Thunder hath made greater
  1757. 1:10:33here at least we shall be free the
  1758. 1:10:36almighty hath not built here for his
  1759. 1:10:37Envy will not drive us hence here we may
  1760. 1:10:40Reign secure and in my choice to Reign
  1761. 1:10:44is worth ambition though in Hell better
  1762. 1:10:47to reign in Hell than serve in
  1763. 1:10:54heaven
  1764. 1:11:05the existentialists of the late 19th
  1765. 1:11:07century attempted to
  1766. 1:11:09diagnose the pathology of the human
  1767. 1:11:12personality at a deeper level I believe
  1768. 1:11:15than anyone else had ever
  1769. 1:11:16attempted and their fundamental
  1770. 1:11:19conclusion was
  1771. 1:11:24that
  1772. 1:11:30the destruction by rationality of the
  1773. 1:11:33evolved systems of meaning that people
  1774. 1:11:36had previously lived
  1775. 1:11:39within had
  1776. 1:11:43undermined the psychological strength of
  1777. 1:11:45each
  1778. 1:11:46individual divorced from their own
  1779. 1:11:50history that led them to be to gravitate
  1780. 1:11:54towards either n
  1781. 1:11:55ISM or as a counterposition to gravitate
  1782. 1:11:58towards
  1783. 1:12:01totalitarianism the whole 20th century
  1784. 1:12:04played out the pendulum swing between
  1785. 1:12:06nihilism and totalitarianism and in the
  1786. 1:12:09background the existentialists and the
  1787. 1:12:11psychodynamic theorists were putting
  1788. 1:12:13forward a theory which was that if
  1789. 1:12:16people lived up to their own possibility
  1790. 1:12:20and held on to their own experience as
  1791. 1:12:22if it were true and did not substitute
  1792. 1:12:25for that ideological and consensual
  1793. 1:12:29beliefs that it would be possible for
  1794. 1:12:32each person to find a Wellspring of
  1795. 1:12:34meaning that would be a sufficient
  1796. 1:12:36replacement for what had been lost
  1797. 1:12:38historically without having to fall into
  1798. 1:12:41the pitfalls of nihilism or
  1799. 1:12:42totalitarianism and so you might say
  1800. 1:12:45well nihilism well that's one thing
  1801. 1:12:48because mostly that affects you although
  1802. 1:12:50if you're nihilistic then everyone
  1803. 1:12:51around you is going to be pulled down as
  1804. 1:12:53well but totalitarian ism is a whole
  1805. 1:12:55different issue because what we know now
  1806. 1:12:57is that once Things become ideologically
  1807. 1:13:00totalitarian the next step is mass
  1808. 1:13:03murder and and it it's the next step is
  1809. 1:13:06mass murder in in a manner that makes it
  1810. 1:13:08appear that the purpose for the
  1811. 1:13:10ideological rigidification to begin with
  1812. 1:13:13was the opportunity to participate in
  1813. 1:13:15mass murder so you know how Hitler died
  1814. 1:13:19Hitler lost faith in the German people
  1815. 1:13:21because they were losing the war and so
  1816. 1:13:25he concluded in the waning stages of
  1817. 1:13:29World War II that Germany should just be
  1818. 1:13:32destroyed in Fire and everything else
  1819. 1:13:34that he could possibly consume would go
  1820. 1:13:36with him and so he died in a bunker
  1821. 1:13:37underneath Berlin when it was in Flames
  1822. 1:13:39he committed suicide when Europe was in
  1823. 1:13:42flames and Hitler was a worshipper of
  1824. 1:13:44the kind of fire that purifies he used
  1825. 1:13:48that mythology of cleansing fire
  1826. 1:13:51to to enter into a terrible PCT with the
  1827. 1:13:54with the entire nation that he followed
  1828. 1:13:57and led and
  1829. 1:14:00Stalin Stalin just didn't just kill
  1830. 1:14:03individuals that he pulled off the
  1831. 1:14:05streets he killed like all the engineers
  1832. 1:14:08and all the doctors because he believed
  1833. 1:14:10they were Wreckers they killed all the
  1834. 1:14:12good
  1835. 1:14:13Farmers they killed six million
  1836. 1:14:15ukrainians they moved whole nations of
  1837. 1:14:18people into Siberia and let them die and
  1838. 1:14:21there's every EV every bit of evidence
  1839. 1:14:24that is suggests that what Stalin was
  1840. 1:14:27doing was practicing murderous genocide
  1841. 1:14:31on an Ever larger scale and hoping that
  1842. 1:14:35it would culminate in a a thermonuclear
  1843. 1:14:39war and we escaped that just by a
  1844. 1:14:43thread the existentialists make the
  1845. 1:14:46claim which I think is a remarkable and
  1846. 1:14:48Powerful claim
  1847. 1:14:50that the way out of those catastrophic
  1848. 1:14:54situations is not through political
  1849. 1:14:57action per se or it's not going to be
  1850. 1:15:00resolved by one party defeating another
  1851. 1:15:03or one position defeating
  1852. 1:15:05another that's a continuation of the
  1853. 1:15:07same process that produces the
  1854. 1:15:11problem the existential and the
  1855. 1:15:13psychodynamic answer to this problem is
  1856. 1:15:16that it's more a disease of the Soul
  1857. 1:15:18than a disease of the state and that the
  1858. 1:15:21way to address it is to ensure that you
  1859. 1:15:24live in a manner that makes you neither
  1860. 1:15:27nihilistic nor susceptible to
  1861. 1:15:29ideological
  1862. 1:15:31possession Soul
  1863. 1:15:37Jetson and and other other thinkers like
  1864. 1:15:40him like
  1865. 1:15:43Frankle believed that this that Society
  1866. 1:15:46was a macrocosm of the
  1867. 1:15:49individual not the other way around not
  1868. 1:15:51that the individual is a subelement of
  1869. 1:15:53society believe believ that the choice
  1870. 1:15:56that each individual made was
  1871. 1:15:59potentially so powerful in relationship
  1872. 1:16:01to pathological Behavior or or honest or
  1873. 1:16:05honest and thoughtful behavior that a a
  1874. 1:16:08single individual properly developed
  1875. 1:16:10could stand up against a tyranny and
  1876. 1:16:12win and it seems to me and I thought
  1877. 1:16:15about this for a very long time that the
  1878. 1:16:17lesson of the 20th century
  1879. 1:16:19is that a single individual can stand up
  1880. 1:16:23against a tyrant and
  1881. 1:16:27win and each of us are single
  1882. 1:16:29individuals and the danger of tyranny
  1883. 1:16:32and the danger of nihilism are not
  1884. 1:16:35passed and so as inheritors of the
  1885. 1:16:39catastrophic Legacy of the 20th century
  1886. 1:16:42and as inhabitants of the New Millennium
  1887. 1:16:45part of your
  1888. 1:16:47responsibility is to live your own life
  1889. 1:16:50and to live it honestly and to pay
  1890. 1:16:52attention to your own experience and not
  1891. 1:16:55take the easy way out that ideological
  1892. 1:16:57systems offer you they're destined to
  1893. 1:17:01transform themselves into rigid and
  1894. 1:17:03murderous pathologies and you offload
  1895. 1:17:06your responsibility for thinking and
  1896. 1:17:08acting to
  1897. 1:17:10them and then you have to ask yourself
  1898. 1:17:12well what are
  1899. 1:17:15they well all the evidence suggests that
  1900. 1:17:17they're not the sort of thing that you
  1901. 1:17:19want to have in your
  1902. 1:17:23head
  1903. 1:17:30the grades are up we'll see you on
  1904. 1:17:37Tuesday

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 2014 Personality Lecture 13: Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn (Existentialism) by Jordan B Peterson, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 12,359 words across 1,904 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.