2. Foundations: This Is Your Brain — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:12Professor Paul Bloom: We're going to begin the class
- 0:17proper, Introduction to Psychology, with a discussion
- 0:20about the brain. And, in particular,
- 0:23I want to lead off the class with an idea that the Nobel
- 0:28Prize winning biologist, Francis Crick,
- 0:32described as "The Astonishing Hypothesis."
- 0:36And The Astonishing Hypothesis is summarized like this.
- 0:42As he writes, The Astonishing Hypothesis is
- 0:44that: You, your joys and your
- 0:46sorrows, your memories and your ambitions, your sense of
- 0:49personal identity and free will are in fact no more than the
- 0:52behavior of a vast assembly of nerve cells and their associated
- 0:56molecules. As Lewis Carroll's Alice might
- 0:59have phrased it, "you're nothing but a pack of
- 1:02neurons." It is fair to describe this as
- 1:05astonishing. It is an odd and unnatural view
- 1:09and I don't actually expect people to believe it at first.
- 1:13It's an open question whether you'll believe it when this
- 1:17class comes to an end, but I'd be surprised if many of
- 1:21you believe it now. Most people don't.
- 1:23Most people, in fact, hold a different view.
- 1:28Most people are dualists. Now, dualism is a very
- 1:32different doctrine. It's a doctrine that can be
- 1:36found in every religion and in most philosophical systems
- 1:40throughout history. It was very explicit in Plato,
- 1:43for instance. But the most articulate and
- 1:46well-known defender of dualism is the philosopher Rene
- 1:50Descartes, and Rene Descartes explicitly
- 1:55asked a question, "Are humans merely physical
- 1:59machines, merely physical things?"
- 2:01And he answered, "no." He agreed that animals are
- 2:06machines. In fact, he called them "beast
- 2:09machines" and said animals, nonhuman animals are merely
- 2:13robots, but people are different.
- 2:16There's a duality of people. Like animals,
- 2:19we possess physical material bodies, but unlike animals,
- 2:24what we are is not physical. We are immaterial souls that
- 2:29possess physical bodies, that have physical bodies,
- 2:33that reside in physical bodies, that connect to physical
- 2:37bodies. So, this is known as dualism
- 2:39because the claim is, for humans at least,
- 2:42there are two separate things; there's our material bodies and
- 2:46there's our immaterial minds. Now, Descartes made two
- 2:50arguments for dualism. One argument involved
- 2:54observations of a human action. So, Descartes lived in a fairly
- 3:00sophisticated time, and his time did have robots.
- 3:04These were not electrical robots, of course.
- 3:06They were robots powered by hydraulics.
- 3:09So, Descartes would walk around the French Royal Gardens and the
- 3:13French Royal Gardens were set up like a seventeenth-century
- 3:16Disneyland. They had these characters that
- 3:19would operate according to water flow and so if you stepped on a
- 3:23certain panel, a swordsman would jump out with
- 3:26a sword. If you stepped somewhere else,
- 3:29a bathing beauty would cover herself up behind some bushes.
- 3:32And Descartes said, "Boy, these machines respond in
- 3:36certain ways to certain actions so machines can do certain
- 3:41things and, in fact," he says,
- 3:43"our bodies work that way too. If you tap somebody on the
- 3:45knee, your leg will jump out. Well, maybe that's what we are."
- 3:49But Descartes said that can't be because there are things that
- 3:53humans do that no machine could ever do.
- 3:56Humans are not limited to reflexive action.
- 4:00Rather, humans are capable of coordinated, creative,
- 4:04spontaneous things. We can use language,
- 4:07for instance, and sometimes my use of
- 4:09language can be reflexive. Somebody says, "How are you?"
- 4:13And I say, "I am fine. How are you?"
- 4:15But sometimes I could say what I choose to be,
- 4:19"How are you?" "Pretty damn good."
- 4:21I can just choose. And machines,
- 4:23Descartes argued, are incapable of that sort of
- 4:26choice. Hence, we are not mere machines.
- 4:30The second argument is, of course, quite famous and
- 4:34this was the method. This he came to using the
- 4:37method of doubt. So, he started asking himself
- 4:40the question, "What can I be sure of?"
- 4:43And he said, "Well, I believe there's a God,
- 4:46but honestly, I can't be sure there's a God.
- 4:50I believe I live in a rich country but maybe I've been
- 4:53fooled." He even said,
- 4:55"I believe I have had friends and family but maybe I am being
- 5:00tricked. Maybe an evil demon,
- 5:02for instance, has tricked me,
- 5:04has deluded me into thinking I have experiences that aren't
- 5:08real." And, of course,
- 5:10the modern version of this is The Matrix.
- 5:12The idea of The Matrix is explicitly built upon
- 5:15Cartesian--Descartes' worries about an evil demon.
- 5:18Maybe everything you're now experiencing is not real,
- 5:21but rather is the product of some other, perhaps malevolent,
- 5:25creature. Descartes, similarly,
- 5:28could doubt he has a body. In fact, he noticed that madmen
- 5:33sometimes believe they have extra limbs or they believe
- 5:35they're of different sizes and shapes than they really are and
- 5:38Descartes said, "How do I know I'm not crazy?
- 5:41Crazy people don't think they're crazy so the fact that I
- 5:44don't think I'm crazy doesn't mean I'm not crazy.
- 5:47How do I know," Descartes said, "I'm not dreaming right now?"
- 5:51But there is one thing, Descartes concluded,
- 5:54that he cannot doubt, and the answer is he cannot
- 5:57doubt that he is himself thinking.
- 5:59That would be self-refuting. And so, Descartes used the
- 6:03method of doubt to say there's something really different about
- 6:08having a body that's always uncertain from having a mind.
- 6:13And he used this argument as a way to support dualism,
- 6:18as a way to support the idea that bodies and minds are
- 6:23separate. And so he concluded,
- 6:26"I knew that I was a substance, the whole essence or nature of
- 6:29which is to think, and that for its existence,
- 6:32there is no need of any place nor does it depend on any
- 6:35material thing. That is to say,
- 6:38the soul by which I am, when I am, is entirely distinct
- 6:43from body." Now, I said before that this is
- 6:46common sense and I want to illustrate the common sense
- 6:49nature of this in a few ways. One thing is our dualism is
- 6:53enmeshed in our language. So, we have a certain mode of
- 6:57talking about things that we own or things that are close to us
- 7:01– my arm, my heart, my child,
- 7:03my car – but we also extend that to my body and my brain.
- 7:07We talk about owning our brains as if we're somehow separate
- 7:12from them. Our dualism shows up in
- 7:14intuitions about personal identity.
- 7:17And what this means is that common sense tells us that
- 7:21somebody can be the same person even if their body undergoes
- 7:26radical and profound changes. The best examples of this are
- 7:31fictional. So, we have no problem
- 7:34understanding a movie where somebody goes to sleep as a
- 7:38teenager and wakes up as Jennifer Garner,
- 7:41as an older person. Now, nobody says,
- 7:44"Oh, that's a documentary. I believe that thoroughly true"
- 7:48but at the same time nobody, no adult, no teenager,
- 7:52no child ever leaves and says, "I'm totally conceptually
- 7:55confused." Rather, we follow the story.
- 8:01We can also follow stories which involve more profound
- 8:05transformations as when a man dies and is reborn into the body
- 8:10of a child. Now, you might have different
- 8:13views around--People around this room will have different views
- 8:16as to whether reincarnation really exists,
- 8:19but we can imagine it. We could imagine a person dying
- 8:22and then reemerging in another body.
- 8:24This is not Hollywood invention. One of the great short stories
- 8:28of the last century begins with a sentence by Franz Kafka:
- 8:31"As Gregor Samsa woke one morning from uneasy dreams,
- 8:34he found himself transformed in his bed into a gigantic insect."
- 8:38And again, Kafka invites us to imagine waking up into a body of
- 8:43a cockroach and we can. This is also not modern.
- 8:47Hundreds of years before the birth of Christ,
- 8:51Homer described the fate of the companions of Odysseus who were
- 8:56transformed by a witch into pigs.
- 9:00Actually, that's not quite right.
- 9:01She didn't turn them into pigs. She did something worse.
- 9:05She stuck them in the bodies of pigs.
- 9:08They had the head and voice and bristles and body of swine but
- 9:11their minds remained unchanged as before, so they were penned
- 9:14there weeping. And we are invited to imagine
- 9:17the fate of again finding ourselves in the bodies of other
- 9:21creatures and, if you can imagine this,
- 9:24this is because you are imagining what you are as
- 9:27separate from the body that you reside in.
- 9:31We allow for the notion that many people can occupy one body.
- 9:34This is a mainstay of some slapstick humor including the
- 9:37classic movie, All of Me--Steve Martin
- 9:40and Lily Tomlin – highly recommended.
- 9:42But many people think this sort of thing really happens.
- 9:46One analysis of multiple personality disorder is that you
- 9:50have many people inside a single body fighting it out for
- 9:54control. Now, we will discuss multiple
- 9:56personality disorder towards the end of the semester and it turns
- 10:00out things are a good deal more complicated than this,
- 10:03but still my point isn't about how it really is but how we
- 10:06think about it. Common sense tells us you could
- 10:09have more than one person inside a single body.
- 10:12This shows up in a different context involving exorcisms
- 10:15where many belief systems allow for the idea that people's
- 10:19behavior, particularly their evil or
- 10:22irrational behavior, could be because something else
- 10:25has taken over their bodies. Finally, most people around the
- 10:31world, all religions and most people in most countries at most
- 10:39times, believe that people can survive
- 10:42the destruction of their bodies. Now, cultures differ according
- 10:47to the fate of the body. Some cultures have the body
- 10:51going to--sorry--the fate of the soul.
- 10:53Some cultures have you going to Heaven or descending to Hell.
- 10:57Others have you occupying another body.
- 10:59Still, others have you occupying an amorphous spirit
- 11:02world. But what they share is the idea
- 11:04that what you are is separable from this physical thing you
- 11:08carry around. And the physical thing that you
- 11:12carry around can be destroyed while you live on.
- 11:18These views are particularly common in the United States.
- 11:22In one survey done in Chicago a few years ago,
- 11:25people were asked their religion and then were asked
- 11:28what would happen to them when they died.
- 11:31Most people in the sample were Christian and about 96% of
- 11:35Christians said, "When I die I'm going to go to
- 11:38Heaven." Some of the sample was Jewish.
- 11:41Now, Judaism is actually a religion with a less than clear
- 11:44story about the afterlife. Still, most of the subjects who
- 11:48identified themselves as Jewish said when they die they will go
- 11:52to Heaven. Some of the sampled denied
- 11:55having any religion at all--said they have no religion at all.
- 11:58Still, when these people were asked what would happen when
- 12:02they would die, most of them answered,
- 12:04"I'm going to go to Heaven." So, dualism is emmeshed.
- 12:09A lot rests on it but, as Crick points out;
- 12:12the scientific consensus now is that dualism is wrong.
- 12:18There is no "you" separable or separate from your body.
- 12:24In particular, there is no "you" separable
- 12:27from your brain. To put it the way cognitive
- 12:30scientists and psychologists and neuroscientists like to put it,
- 12:35"the mind is what the brain does."
- 12:37The mind reflects the workings of the brain just like
- 12:42computation reflects the working of a computer.
- 12:46Now, why would you hold such an outrageous view?
- 12:49Why would you reject dualism in favor of this alternative?
- 12:52Well, a few reasons. One reason is dualism has
- 12:55always had its problems. For one thing,
- 12:58it's a profoundly unscientific doctrine.
- 13:00We want to know as curious people how children learn
- 13:04language, what we find attractive or unattractive,
- 13:08and what's the basis for mental illness.
- 13:11And dualism simply says, "it's all nonphysical,
- 13:15it's part of the ether," and hence fails to explain it.
- 13:19More specifically, dualists like Descartes
- 13:22struggle to explain how a physical body connects to an
- 13:27immaterial soul. What's the conduit?
- 13:30How could this connection be made?
- 13:32After all, Descartes knew full well that there is such a
- 13:35connection. Your body obeys your commands.
- 13:39If you bang your toe or stub your toe you feel pain.
- 13:43If you drink alcohol it affects your reasoning,
- 13:46but he could only wave his hands as to how this physical
- 13:49thing in the world could connect to an immaterial mind.
- 13:57Descartes, when he was alive, was reasonable enough
- 14:02concluding that physical objects cannot do certain things.
- 14:07He was reasonable enough in concluding, for instance,
- 14:10as he did, that there's no way a merely physical object could
- 14:14ever play a game of chess because--and that such a
- 14:17capacity is beyond the capacity of the physical world and hence
- 14:21you have to apply--you have to extend the explanation to an
- 14:25immaterial soul but now we know--we have what scientists
- 14:28call an existence proof. We know physical objects can do
- 14:32complicated and interesting things.
- 14:35We know, for instance, machines can play chess.
- 14:38We know machines can manipulate symbols.
- 14:40We know machines have limited capacities to engage in
- 14:45mathematical and logical reasoning,
- 14:48to recognize things, to do various forms of
- 14:51computations, and this makes it at least
- 14:55possible that we are such machines.
- 14:58So you can no longer say, "Look. Physical things just can't do
- 15:02that" because we know physical things can do a lot and this
- 15:06opens up the possibility that humans are physical things,
- 15:10in particular, that humans are brains.
- 15:13Finally, there is strong evidence that the brain is
- 15:18involved in mental life. Somebody who hold a--held a
- 15:22dualist view that said that what we do and what we decide and
- 15:26what we think and what we want are all have nothing to do with
- 15:29the physical world, would be embarrassed by the
- 15:33fact that the brain seems to correspond in intricate and
- 15:37elaborate ways to our mental life.
- 15:40Now, this has been known for a long time.
- 15:44Philosophers and psychologists knew for a long time that
- 15:47getting smacked in the head could change your mental
- 15:50faculties; that diseases like syphilis
- 15:53could make you deranged; that chemicals like caffeine
- 15:57and alcohol can affect how you think.
- 16:00But what's new is we can now in different ways see the direct
- 16:03effects of mental life. Somebody with a severe and
- 16:08profound loss of mental faculties--the deficit will be
- 16:13shown correspondingly in her brain.
- 16:17Studies using imaging techniques like CAT scans,
- 16:21PET, and fMRI, illustrate that different parts
- 16:24of the brain are active during different parts of mental life.
- 16:30For instance, the difference between seeing
- 16:32words, hearing words, reading words and generating
- 16:36words can correspond to different aspects of what part
- 16:39of your brain is active. To some extent,
- 16:42if we put you in an fMRI scanner and observed what you're
- 16:46doing in real time, by looking at the activity
- 16:49patterns in your brain we can tell whether you are thinking
- 16:54about music or thinking about sex.
- 16:56To some extent we can tell whether you're solving a moral
- 17:01dilemma versus something else. And this is no surprise if what
- 17:05we are is the workings of our physical brains,
- 17:08but it is extremely difficult to explain if one is a dualist.
- 17:13Now, so what you have is--the scientific consensus is that all
- 17:18of mental life including consciousness and emotions and
- 17:22choice and morality are the products of brain activities.
- 17:27So, you would expect that when you rip open the skull and look
- 17:32at the brain; you'd see something glorious,
- 17:35you'd see – I don't know – a big, shiny thing with glass
- 17:40tubes and blinding lights and sparks and wonderful colors.
- 17:44And actually though, the brain is just disgusting.
- 17:47It looks like an old meat loaf. It's gray when you take it out
- 17:54of the head. It's called gray matter but
- 17:56that's just because it's out of the head.
- 17:59Inside the head it's bright red because it's pulsing with blood.
- 18:03It doesn't even taste good. Well, has anybody here ever
- 18:08eaten brain?
- 18:12It's good with cream sauce but everything's good with cream
- 18:16sauce. So, the question is,
- 18:19"How can something like this give rise to us?"
- 18:25And you have to have some sympathy for Descartes.
- 18:29There's another argument Descartes could have made that's
- 18:31a lot less subtle than the ones he did make,
- 18:33which is "That thing responsible for free will and
- 18:37love and consciousness? Ridiculous."
- 18:41What I want to do, and what the goal of
- 18:44neuroscience is, is to make it less ridiculous,
- 18:47to try to explain how the brain works, how the brain can give
- 18:52rise to thought, and what I want to do today is
- 18:56take a first stab at this question but it's something
- 18:59we'll continue to discuss throughout the course as we talk
- 19:03about different aspects of mental life.
- 19:05What I want to do though now is provide a big picture.
- 19:09So, what I want to do is start off small, with the smallest
- 19:12interesting part of the brain and then get bigger and bigger
- 19:16and bigger – talk about how the small part of the brain,
- 19:19the neurons, the basic building blocks of
- 19:22thought, combine to other mental structures and into different
- 19:25subparts of the brain and finally to the whole thing.
- 19:28So, one of the discoveries of psychology is that the basic
- 19:35unit of the brain appears to be the neuron.
- 19:40The neuron is a specific sort of cell and the neuron has three
- 19:44major parts, as you could see illustrated here.
- 19:47Neurons actually look quite different from one another but
- 19:50this is a typical one. There are the dendrites –
- 19:54these little tentacles here. And the dendrites get signals
- 19:59from other neurons. Now, these signals can be
- 20:03either excitatory, which is that they raise the
- 20:06likelihood the neuron will fire, or inhibitory in that they
- 20:10lower the likelihood that the neuron will fire.
- 20:13The cell body sums it up and you could view it
- 20:16arithmetically. The excitatory signals are
- 20:19pluses, the inhibitory ones are minuses.
- 20:23And then if you get a certain number, plus 60 or something,
- 20:27the neuron will fire and it fires along the axon,
- 20:30the thing to the right. The axon is much longer than
- 20:34the dendrites and, in fact, some axons are many
- 20:38feet long. There's an axon leading from
- 20:41your spinal cord to your big toe for instance.
- 20:45It is so shocking the lights go out.
- 20:50Surrounded--Surrounding--To complete a mechanical metaphor
- 20:54that would have led Descartes to despair-- Thank you,
- 20:58Koleen. Surrounding the axon is a
- 21:00myelin sheath, which is actually just
- 21:03insulation. It helps the firing work
- 21:06quicker. So, here are some facts about
- 21:09neurons. There are a lot of them –
- 21:12about one thousand billion of them – and each neuron can be
- 21:16connected to around thousands, perhaps tens of thousands,
- 21:20other neurons. So, it's an extraordinarily
- 21:24complicated computing device. Neurons come in three flavors.
- 21:29There are sensory neurons, which take information from the
- 21:32world so as you see me, for instance,
- 21:34there are neurons firing from your retina sending signals to
- 21:38your brain. There are motor neurons.
- 21:41If you decide to raise your hand, those are motor neurons
- 21:45telling the muscles what to do. And there are interneurons
- 21:49which connect the two. And basically,
- 21:52the interneurons do the thinking.
- 21:54They make the connection between sensation and action.
- 21:58It used to be believed, and it's the sort of thing I
- 22:02would--when I taught this course many years ago I would lecture
- 22:06on--that neurons do not grow back once you lose them.
- 22:10You never get them back. This is actually not true.
- 22:13There are parts of the brain in which neurons can re-grow.
- 22:17One interesting thing about neurons is a neuron is like a
- 22:22gun. It either fires or it doesn't.
- 22:25It's all or nothing. If you squeeze the trigger of a
- 22:29gun really hard and really fast, it doesn't fire any faster or
- 22:33harder than if you just squeezed it gently.
- 22:36Now, this seems to be strange. How could neurons be all or
- 22:41nothing when sensation is very graded?
- 22:45If somebody next to you pushed on your hand--the degree of
- 22:49pushing--you'd be able to notice it.
- 22:51It's not either pushing or not pushing.
- 22:53You can--Degrees of pushing, degrees of heat,
- 22:56degrees of brightness. And the answer is,
- 22:59although neurons are all or nothing, there are ways to code
- 23:02intensity. So, one simple way to code
- 23:04intensity is the number of neurons firing;
- 23:07the more neurons the more intense.
- 23:11Another way to increase intensity is the frequency of
- 23:18firing. So, I'll just use those two.
- 23:23The first one is the number of neurons firing.
- 23:25The second one is the frequency of firing in that something is
- 23:29more intense if it's "bang, bang, bang, bang,
- 23:32bang, bang" then "bang, bang, bang" and these are two
- 23:36ways through which neurons encode intensity.
- 23:40Now, neurons are connected and they talk to one another and it
- 23:45used to be thought they were tied to one another like a
- 23:49computer, like you take wires and you
- 23:52connect wires to each other, you wrap them around and
- 23:54connect them. It turns out this isn't the
- 23:57case. It turns out that neurons
- 23:59relate to one another chemically in a kind of interesting way.
- 24:03Between any neurons, between the axon of one neuron
- 24:06and the dendrite of another, there's a tiny gap.
- 24:10The gap could be about one ten-thousandths of a millimeter
- 24:14wide. This infinitesimal gap--and
- 24:16this gap is known as a synapse--and what happens is
- 24:20when a neuron fires, an axon sends chemicals
- 24:23shooting through the gap. These chemicals are known as
- 24:27neurotransmitters and they affect the dendrites.
- 24:30So, neurons communicate to one another chemically.
- 24:33These--Again, the chemicals could excite the
- 24:37other neuron (excitatory) bring up the chances it will fire,
- 24:42or inhibit the other neuron (inhibitory).
- 24:46Now, neurotransmitters become interesting because a lot of
- 24:52psychopharmacology, both of the medical sort and
- 24:56the recreational sort, consists of fiddling with
- 25:00neurotransmitters and so you could see this through some
- 25:04examples. There are two sorts of ways you
- 25:07could fiddle with neurotransmitters,
- 25:10and correspondingly two sorts of drugs.
- 25:13There are agonists. And what an agonist does is
- 25:16increases the effect of neurotransmitters,
- 25:19either by making more neurotransmitters or stopping
- 25:23the cleanup of neurotransmitters,
- 25:26or in some cases by faking a neurotransmitter,
- 25:28by mimicking its effects. Then, there are antagonists
- 25:31that slow down the amount of neurotransmitters,
- 25:34either because they destroy neurotransmitters or they make
- 25:38it hard to create more. Or in some cases they go to the
- 25:41dendrite of the neuron and they kind of put a paste over it so
- 25:45that the neurotransmitters can't connect.
- 25:47And it's through these clever ways that neurons can affect
- 25:51your mental life.
- 25:56So, for instance, there is a drug known as Curare
- 26:03and Curare is an antagonist. It's a very particular sort of
- 26:10antagonist. It blocks motor neurons from
- 26:14affecting muscle fibers. What this does then is it
- 26:18paralyzes you because your motor neurons--You send the command to
- 26:22your arm to stand, to lift up.
- 26:25It doesn't work. You send the command to your
- 26:27leg to move. It doesn't work.
- 26:29The motor neurons are deactivated and then,
- 26:33because the way you breathe is through motor neurons,
- 26:37you then die. There's alcohol.
- 26:40Alcohol is inhibitory. Now, this may be puzzling to
- 26:44people. It's mildly paradoxical because
- 26:47you may be thinking, "alcohol is not inhibitory.
- 26:50On the contrary, when I drink a lot of alcohol I
- 26:53lose my inhibitions and become a more fun person.
- 26:56I become more aggressive and more sexually vibrant and simply
- 27:01more beautiful. And so in what way is alcohol
- 27:06inhibitory?" Well, the answer is it inhibits
- 27:11the inhibitory parts of your brain.
- 27:15So, you have parts of your brain that are basically telling
- 27:17you now, largely in the frontal lobes, that are--"Okay.
- 27:20Keep your pants on. Don't hit me, buddy.
- 27:23Don't use bad words." Alcohol relaxes,
- 27:26shuts down those parts of the brain.
- 27:30If you take enough alcohol, it then goes down to inhibit
- 27:33the excitatory parts of your brain and then you fall on the
- 27:37floor and pass out. Amphetamines increase the
- 27:41amount of arousal. In particular,
- 27:45they increase the amount of norepinephrine,
- 27:48a neurotransmitter that's responsible for just general
- 27:52arousal. And so, amphetamines include
- 27:56drugs like "speed" and "coke." There are--Prozac works on
- 28:04serotonin. When we discuss clinical
- 28:08psychology and depression we'll learn the extent to which
- 28:12neurotransmitter disorders are implicated in certain disorders
- 28:16like depression. And one problem is that – for
- 28:20depression – is that there's too little of a neurotransmitter
- 28:25known as serotonin. Prozac makes serotonin more
- 28:30prevalent and so in some extent might help alleviate depression.
- 28:36Parkinson's disease is a disease involving destruction of
- 28:40motor control and loss of motor control, difficulty moving.
- 28:44And one factor in Parkinson's is too little of a
- 28:47neurotransmitter known as dopamine.
- 28:50The drug L-DOPA increases the supply of dopamine and so there
- 28:54is something to alleviate, at least temporarily,
- 28:57the symptoms of Parkinson's. So, you have neurons and
- 29:01they're clustered together and they fire and they communicate
- 29:04to one another. So, how does this all work to
- 29:07give rise to creatures who could do interesting things like talk
- 29:11and think? Well, again,
- 29:13it used to be believed that the brain is wired up like a
- 29:17computer, like a PC or a Mac or something
- 29:20like that, but we know this can't be true.
- 29:23It can't be true because there's two ways in which the
- 29:26brain is better than a computer. For one thing,
- 29:30the brain is highly resistant to damage.
- 29:35If you have a laptop and I persuade you to open it up for
- 29:40me and I take the pliers and kind of snip just about
- 29:44anywhere, your laptop will be destroyed
- 29:47but the brain is actually more resilient.
- 29:50You can take a lot of brain damage and still preserve some
- 29:54mental functioning. To some interesting sense,
- 29:57there's some sort of damage resistance built in to the brain
- 30:00that allows different parts of the brain to take over if some
- 30:04parts are damaged. A second consideration is the
- 30:08brain is extremely fast. Your computer works on wires
- 30:12and electricity but your brain uses tissue and tissue is
- 30:18extremely slow. The paradox then is how do you
- 30:22create such a fast computer with such slow stuff?
- 30:25And you can't. If the brain was wired up like
- 30:28a personal computer, it would take you four hours to
- 30:31recognize a face but, in fact, we could do things
- 30:35extremely quickly. So, the question then is how is
- 30:38the brain wired up? And the answer is,
- 30:41unlike manys, unlike commercially generated
- 30:44computers, the brain works through parallel processing,
- 30:49massively parallel distributed processing.
- 30:52There's a whole lot of research and this is research,
- 30:55some of which takes place outside psychology departments
- 30:58and in engineering departments and computer science
- 31:01departments, trying to figure out how a
- 31:04computer can do the same things brains can do.
- 31:09And one way people do this is they take a hint from nature and
- 31:13they try to construct massively distributed networks to do
- 31:17aspects of reasoning. So, there's a very simple
- 31:21computational network. That is interesting because it
- 31:25kind of looks to some extent like the way neurons look and
- 31:28this is often known as neural networks.
- 31:31And people who study this often claim to be studying neural
- 31:35network modeling to try to build smart machines by modeling them
- 31:39after brains. And in the last 20 years or so,
- 31:43this has been a huge and vibrant area of study where
- 31:46people are trying to wire up machines that can do brain-like
- 31:50things from components that look a lot like neurons and are wired
- 31:54up together as neurons are. One consideration in all of
- 31:58this is that this is a very young field and nobody knows how
- 32:03to do it yet. There is no machine yet that
- 32:07can recognize faces or understand sentences at the
- 32:11level of a two-year-old human. There is no machine yet that
- 32:15can do just about anything people can do in an interesting
- 32:18way. And this is,
- 32:19in part, because the human brain is wired up in an
- 32:22extraordinarily more complicated way than any sort of simple
- 32:25neural network. This is a sort of schematic
- 32:29diagram – you're not responsible for this – of
- 32:33parts of the visual cortex, and the thing to realize about
- 32:37this is it's extraordinarily simplified.
- 32:40So, the brain is a complicated system.
- 32:43Now, so, we've talked a little bit about the basic building
- 32:48blocks of the brain – neurons. We've then talked about how
- 32:52neurons can communicate to one another;
- 32:54then, turned to how neurons are wired up together.
- 32:59Now let's talk a little bit about different parts of the
- 33:02brain. Now, there's some things you
- 33:04don't actually need your brain to do.
- 33:07The study of what you don't need your brain to do has often
- 33:10drawn upon this weird methodology where--This was
- 33:13actually done in France a lot where they would decapitate
- 33:16people and when--After they decapitated people,
- 33:20psychologists would rush to the body of the headless person and
- 33:23sort of just test out reflexes and stuff like that.
- 33:26It's kind of gruesome but we know there are some things you
- 33:29don't need your brain for. You don't need your brain for
- 33:33newborn sucking, limb flexation in withdrawal
- 33:37from pain. Your limbs will pull back even
- 33:40if your head is gone. Erection of the penis can be
- 33:43done without a brain. Vomiting also is done without a
- 33:46brain. Oh.
- 33:47I need a volunteer. Very simple.
- 33:52This will not involve any of--excellent--any of the above.
- 33:54Could you stand up just--Okay. This is a new shirt so I want
- 33:59to stay away. Just--No.
- 34:00This is--If you'll hold out your hand and--one hand flat.
- 34:05Excellent. That's the textbook,
- 34:075th edition. Now.
- 34:10Perfect. What you'll notice is--Thank
- 34:13you very much. What you'll notice is this hit
- 34:16and this hand went back up. This is something automatic,
- 34:20instinctive, and does not require your
- 34:22brain. So your brain isn't needed for
- 34:25everything. What does your brain do?
- 34:28Well, some things that your brain does involve very
- 34:31low-level internal structures. And these are called
- 34:34subcortical structures because they're below the cortex.
- 34:38They're underneath the cortex. So, for instance,
- 34:42what we have here is a diagram of the brain.
- 34:44The way to read this diagram is it's as if it were my brain and
- 34:48I am facing this way. My head gets cut in half down
- 34:52here and then you could see the brain.
- 34:56So, this is the front over here. That's the back.
- 35:00Some key parts are illustrated here.
- 35:02The medulla, for instance,
- 35:05is responsible for heart rate and respiration.
- 35:09It's very deep within the brain and if it gets damaged you
- 35:13could--you are likely to die. The cerebellum is responsible
- 35:17for body balance and muscular coordination.
- 35:21And to give you, again, a feeling for the
- 35:23complexity of these systems, the cerebellum contains
- 35:26approximately 30 billion neurons.
- 35:29The hypothalamus is responsible here for feeding,
- 35:33hunger, thirst, and to some extent sleep.
- 35:37And here is the same brain parts in close-up.
- 35:41Now, all of these parts of the brains are essential and many of
- 35:47them are implicated in interesting psychological
- 35:50processes but where the action is is the cortex.
- 35:55Isn't this beautiful? The cortex is the outer layer
- 35:59and the outer layer is all crumpled up.
- 36:02Do you ever wonder why your brain looks wrinkled?
- 36:05That's because it's all crumpled.
- 36:08If you took out somebody's cortex and flattened it out,
- 36:12it would be two feet square, sort of like a nice--like a
- 36:17rug. And the cortex is where all the
- 36:21neat stuff takes place. Fish don't have any of that,
- 36:26so no offense to fish but it's--fish don't have much of a
- 36:29mental life. Reptiles and birds have a
- 36:32little bit about it--of it--and primates have a lot and humans
- 36:36have a real lot. Eighty percent of the volume of
- 36:40our brain, about, is cortex.
- 36:42And the cortex can be broken up into different parts or lobes.
- 36:50There is the--And, again, this is facing in
- 36:53profile forward. There is the frontal lobe,
- 36:56easy to remember. This part in front,
- 36:59the parietal lobe, the occipital lobe,
- 37:03and the temporal lobe. And one theme we're going to
- 37:08return to is--this is half the brain.
- 37:10This is, in fact, the left half of the brain.
- 37:15On the other half, the right half,
- 37:17everything's duplicated with some slight and subtle
- 37:20differences. What's really weird--One really
- 37:24weird finding about these lobes is that they include topological
- 37:29maps. They include maps of your body.
- 37:33There is a cartoon which actually illustrates a classic
- 37:36experiment by some physiologists who for some reason had a dog's
- 37:41brain opened up and started shocking different parts of the
- 37:45brain. You could do brain surgery
- 37:47while fully conscious because the brain itself has no sense
- 37:50organs to it. And it turns out that the
- 37:53dog--When they zapped part of its brain, its leg would kick
- 37:56up. And it took Dr.
- 37:57Penfield at McGill University to do the same thing with
- 38:02people. So, they were doing some brain
- 38:04surgery. He had a little electrical
- 38:06thing just on--I don't know how he thought to do this.
- 38:09He started zapping it and "boom."
- 38:11The person--Parts of their body would move.
- 38:14More than that, when he zapped other parts of
- 38:17the brain, people would claim to see colors.
- 38:21And he zapped other parts of the brain;
- 38:22people would claim to hear sounds;
- 38:25and other parts of the brain, people would claim to
- 38:29experience touch. And through his research and
- 38:33other research, it was found that there are
- 38:36maps in the brain of the body. There is a map in the motor
- 38:41part of the brain, the motor cortex,
- 38:44of the sort up on the left and the sensory cortex of the sort
- 38:48that you could see on the right and if you--and you could tell
- 38:52what's what by opening up the brain and shocking different
- 38:56parts and those parts would correspond to the parts of the
- 39:01body shown in the diagram there. Now, two things to notice about
- 39:06these maps. The first is they're
- 39:09topographical and what this means is that if two parts of
- 39:13the--two parts are close together on the body,
- 39:16they'll be close together on the brain.
- 39:19So, your tongue is closer to your jaw than it is to your hip
- 39:25in the body; so too in both the motor cortex
- 39:29and the somatosensory cortex. Also, you'll notice that the
- 39:34size of the body part represented in the brain does
- 39:37not correspond to the size of the body part in the real world.
- 39:42Rather, what determines the size in the brain is the extent
- 39:46to which either they have motor command over it or sensory
- 39:51control. So, there's a whole lot of
- 39:53sensory organs, for instance,
- 39:55focused along your tongue, and that's why that's so big,
- 39:58and an enormous amount on your face but your shoulder isn't
- 40:02even--doesn't even make it on there because,
- 40:05although your shoulder might be bigger than your tongue,
- 40:07there's not much going on. In fact, if you draw a diagram
- 40:11of a person, what their body is corresponding to the amount of
- 40:16somatosensory cortex, you get something like that.
- 40:20That's your sensory body.
- 40:28Now, so, you have these maps in your head but the thing to
- 40:32realize is--And these maps are part of your cortex,
- 40:35but the things to realize is that's an important part of what
- 40:40goes on in your brain but less than one quarter of the cortex
- 40:45contains these maps or projection areas.
- 40:48The rest is involved in language and reasoning and moral
- 40:53thought and so on. And, in fact,
- 40:55the proportion as you go from rat, cat, and monkey,
- 40:58humans--less and less of it is devoted to projection and there
- 41:02is more and more to other things.
- 41:04So, how do we figure out what the other parts of the brain do?
- 41:11Well, there's all sorts of methods.
- 41:12Typically, these are recent imaging methods like CAT scan
- 41:18and PET scan and fMRI which, as I said before,
- 41:22show parts of your brain at work.
- 41:25If you want to know which part of your brain is responsible for
- 41:30language, you could put somebody into a scanner and have them
- 41:35exposed to language or do a linguistic task or talk or
- 41:40something and then see what parts of their brain are active.
- 41:45Another way to explore what the brain does is to consider what
- 41:49happens to people when very bad things happen to their brain.
- 41:54And these bad things could happen through lesions,
- 41:58through tumors, through strokes,
- 42:00through injury. For the most part,
- 42:03neuropsychologists don't like helmet laws.
- 42:06Neuropsychologists love when motorcyclists drive without
- 42:09helmets because through their horrible accidents we gain great
- 42:12insights into how the brain works.
- 42:15And the logic is if you find somebody--Crudely,
- 42:18if you find somebody with damage to this part of the brain
- 42:21right here and that person can't recognize faces for instance,
- 42:26there's some reason to believe that this part of the brain is
- 42:29related to face recognition. And so, from the study of brain
- 42:33damage and the study of--we can gain some understanding of what
- 42:38different parts of the brain do. And so, people study brain
- 42:43damages--brain damage that implicates motor control such as
- 42:48apraxia. And what's interesting about
- 42:51apraxia is it's not paralysis. Somebody with apraxia can move,
- 42:55do simple movements just fine but they can't coordinate their
- 42:58movements. They can't do something like
- 43:01wave goodbye or light a cigarette.
- 43:03There is agnosia and agnosia is a disorder which isn't blindness
- 43:07because the person could still see perfectly well.
- 43:10Their eyes are intact but rather what happens in agnosia
- 43:15is they lose the ability to recognize certain things.
- 43:20Sometimes this is described as psychic blindness.
- 43:23And so, they may get visual agnosia and lose the ability to
- 43:26recognize objects. They may get prosopagnosia and
- 43:30lose the ability to recognize faces.
- 43:34There are disorders of sensory neglect, some famous disorders.
- 43:39Again, it's not paralysis, it's not blindness,
- 43:41but due to certain parts of your--of damaged parts of your
- 43:45brain, you might lose,
- 43:46for instance, the idea that there's a left
- 43:49side of your body or a left side of the world.
- 43:53And these cases are so interesting I want to devote
- 43:56some chunk to a class in the next few weeks to discussing
- 43:59them. There are disorders of language
- 44:02like aphasia. The classic case was discovered
- 44:06by Paul Broca in 1861. A patient who had damage to
- 44:10part of his brain and can only say one word,
- 44:14"tan," and the person would say,
- 44:17"tan, tan, tan, tan," and everything else was
- 44:22gone. There's other disorders of
- 44:24language such as receptive aphasia where the person could
- 44:28speak very fluently but the words don't make any sense and
- 44:31they can't understand anybody else.
- 44:34Other disorders that we'll discuss later on include
- 44:37acquired psychopathy, where damage to parts of your
- 44:40brain, particularly related to the
- 44:42frontal lobes, rob you of the ability to tell
- 44:46right from wrong. The final--I want to end--We're
- 44:49talking about neurons, connection between neurons,
- 44:52how neurons are wired up, the parts of the brain,
- 44:55what the different parts do. I want to end by talking about
- 44:58the two halves of the brain and ask the question,
- 45:02"How many minds do you have?" Now, if you look at the
- 45:06brain--If you took the brain out and held it up,
- 45:09it would look pretty symmetrical, but it actually is
- 45:12not. There are actual differences
- 45:14between the right hemisphere and the left hemisphere.
- 45:18How many people here are right-handed?
- 45:23How many people here are left-handed?
- 45:28How many people here are sort of complicated,
- 45:31ambidextrous, don't know, "bit of the right,
- 45:34bit of left" people? Okay.
- 45:36Those of you who are right-handed,
- 45:39which comprises about nine out of ten people,
- 45:43have language in your left hemisphere.
- 45:46And, in fact, we're going to be talking about
- 45:48right-handed people for the most part, making generalizations in
- 45:51what I'll talk about now. Those of you who are
- 45:54left-handed are more complicated.
- 45:57Some of you have language in your right hemisphere,
- 45:59some in your left hemisphere, some God knows where.
- 46:02It's complicated. Now, the idea is that some
- 46:05things are duplicated. So, if you were to lose half
- 46:09your brain, the other half can actually do a lot but some
- 46:13things are more prevalent and more powerful in one part of the
- 46:16brain than the other. And I want to show you a brief
- 46:19film clip from "Scientific American" that illustrates the
- 46:22differences between the hemispheres,
- 46:24but before doing that, I want to provide some
- 46:27introductory facts. Some functions are lateralized.
- 46:30So, typically, language in the left.
- 46:32Again, this is a right-handed centric thing but if you're
- 46:36right-handed – language on the left, math and music on the
- 46:40right. There is a crossover and this
- 46:42is important when we think about the studies that will follow but
- 46:45the crossover is that everything you see in the left visual field
- 46:49goes to the right side of your brain;
- 46:51everything in the right visual field goes to the left side of
- 46:54the brain, and similarly, there's a crossover in action.
- 46:58So, your right hemisphere controls the left side of the
- 47:00body. Your left hemisphere controls
- 47:02the right side of the body. Now, finally,
- 47:05the two halves are connected. They're connected by this huge
- 47:12web called the corpus callosum. And I'm just going to skip this
- 47:19because the movie illustration will go through some of this.
- 47:26This illustrates certain themes that are discussed in detail in
- 47:30the Gray book, concerning the lateralization
- 47:33of different parts of different mental capacities,
- 47:37some in the left hemisphere, some in the right hemisphere.
- 47:39But it also serves as a useful methodological development,
- 47:45which is a nice illustration as to how looking at people who are
- 47:50incredibly unusual, such as this man who had his
- 47:54brain bisected so his left hemisphere and his right
- 47:57hemisphere don't communicate with one another--how looking at
- 48:00such people, such extreme cases,
- 48:03can provide us with some understanding of how we normally
- 48:07do things. And this, again,
- 48:09is a theme we'll return to throughout the course.
- 48:12This is generally the general introduction of the brain that I
- 48:16wanted to provide, giving the framework for what
- 48:19I'll be talking about later on throughout the course so that I
- 48:23might later on make reference to neurons or neurotransmitters or
- 48:26the cortex or the left hemisphere and you'll sort of
- 48:29have the background to understand what I'm talking
- 48:32about. But I want to end this first
- 48:35real class with a bit of humility as to what
- 48:40psychologists know and don't know.
- 48:44So, the idea behind a lot of psychology – particularly a
- 48:47lot of neuroscience and cognitive psychology – is to
- 48:50treat the mind as an information processor,
- 48:52as an elaborate computer. And so, we study different
- 48:57problems like recognizing faces or language or motor control or
- 49:03logic. The strategy then often is to
- 49:06figure out how, what sort of program can solve
- 49:09these problems and then we go on to ask,
- 49:12"How could this program be instantiated in the physical
- 49:18brain?" So, we would solve--We study
- 49:21people much as we'd study a computer from an alien planet or
- 49:25something. And I think--This strategy is
- 49:28one I'm very enthusiastic about but there still remains what's
- 49:32sometimes called the "hard problem" of consciousness and
- 49:37this involves subjective experience.
- 49:40What's it like? So, my computer can play chess.
- 49:46My computer can recognize numbers.
- 49:50It can do math. And maybe it does it kind of
- 49:53the same way that I do it but my computer doesn't have feelings
- 49:58in the same sense. These are two classic
- 50:01illustrations. This is from a very old "Star
- 50:04Trek" episode. It illustrates angst.
- 50:06I think a starship's about to go into the sun or something.
- 50:09And that's my older kid, Max, who's happy.
- 50:14And so the question is, "How does a thing like that
- 50:18give rise to consciousness and subjective experience?"
- 50:21And this is a deep puzzle. And although some psychologists
- 50:25and philosophers think they've solved it, most of us are a lot
- 50:29more skeptical. Most of us think we have so far
- 50:32to go before we can answer questions like Huxley's
- 50:35question. Huxley points out,
- 50:37"How it is that anything so remarkable as a state of
- 50:40consciousness comes about as a result of irritating nervous
- 50:43tissue, is just as unaccountable as the
- 50:45appearance of the Djinn…" – of the genie – "…when
- 50:48Aladdin rubs his lamp." It seems like magic that a
- 50:52fleshy lump of gray, disgusting meat can give rise
- 50:55to these feelings. The second bit of humility
- 50:59we'll end the class on is I am presenting here,
- 51:01and I'll be presenting throughout this semester,
- 51:04what you can call a mechanistic conception of mental life.
- 51:08I'm not going to be talking about how beautiful it is and
- 51:10how wonderful it is and how mysterious it is.
- 51:12Rather, I'm going to be trying to explain it.
- 51:14I'm going to be trying to explain fundamental aspects of
- 51:17ourselves including questions like how do we make decisions,
- 51:21why do we love our children, what happens when we fall in
- 51:25love, and so on. Now, you might find this sort
- 51:29of project in the end to be repellant.
- 51:33You might worry about how this, well, this meshes with humanist
- 51:38values. For instance,
- 51:39when we deal with one another in a legal and a moral setting,
- 51:43we think in terms of free will and responsibility.
- 51:46If we're driving and you cut me off, you chose to do that.
- 51:50It reflects badly on you. If you save a life at risk to
- 51:54your own, you're--you deserve praise.
- 51:56You did something wonderful. It might be hard to mesh this
- 52:01with the conception in which all actions are the result of
- 52:04neurochemical physical processes.
- 52:06It might also be hard to mesh a notion such as the purported
- 52:10intrinsic value of people. And finally,
- 52:13it might be hard to mesh the mechanistic notion of the mind
- 52:17with the idea that people have spiritual value.
- 52:21Faced with this tension, there are three possibilities.
- 52:25You might choose to reject the scientific conception of the
- 52:28mind. Many people do.
- 52:30You may choose to embrace dualism, reject the idea that
- 52:33the brain is responsible for mental life, and reject the
- 52:37promise of a scientific psychology.
- 52:39Alternatively, you might choose to embrace the
- 52:42scientific worldview and reject all these humanist values.
- 52:46And there are some philosophers and psychologists who do just
- 52:49that, who claim that free will and responsibility and spiritual
- 52:53value and intrinsic value are all illusions;
- 52:56they're pre-scientific notions that get washed away in modern
- 53:00science or you could try to reconcile them.
- 53:04You could try to figure out how to mesh your scientific view of
- 53:08the mind with these humanist values you might want to
- 53:11preserve. And this is an issue which
- 53:13we're going to return to throughout the course.
- 53:15Okay. I'll see you on Wednesday.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 2. Foundations: This Is Your Brain by YaleCourses, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,791 words across 894 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.