YouTube2Text

내가 팔면 오르는 주식, 월가 18년 차는 매매 기준을 이렇게 세웁니다 | 댄 하 대표 [얘기좀합시다] — Transcript

by 머니인더트랩 · 9,110 words · 1,606 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:00Are you worried about your kids '
  2. 0:01financial education? How about a
  3. 0:03Saturday afternoon family finance class
  4. 0:05?
  5. 0:06John Lee, Kim Kyung-il, and current
  6. 0:08teachers will be joining us. Apply via a
  7. 0:11search for "Nol Ticket" or the pinned
  8. 0:14comment below the video for a special Q
  9. 0:16&A session with Dong-ju So.
  10. 0:31>> Yes.
  11. 0:35I came here because I was so curious
  12. 0:36about the difference between analyzing
  13. 0:38the market and taking responsibility for
  14. 0:40clients' money.
  15. 0:41We will invite CEO Dan Ha, who started
  16. 0:43as an analyst on Wall Street and now
  17. 0:45leads an asset management firm, to talk
  18. 0:47with us. Hello, CEO. Yes.
  19. 0:49>> Hello. Yes.
  20. 0:50>> You're already quite famous, but could
  21. 0:52you please introduce yourself briefly?
  22. 0:54Ah, yes. I'm Dan Ha, and I run Karani
  23. 0:57Management.
  24. 0:58>> Yes.
  25. 0:59>> I'm in my 18th year of working on Wall
  26. 1:02Street.
  27. 1:03I graduated from college in 2009, joined
  28. 1:05Bank of America, and started my career
  29. 1:07on a team that managed a global equity
  30. 1:10fund.
  31. 1:12I eventually left to start a new company
  32. 1:14when the opportunity arose, and I've
  33. 1:16been running Karani Management ever
  34. 1:18since.
  35. 1:20>> Yes.
  36. 1:21You've been on Wall Street for 18 years
  37. 1:23.
  38. 1:23>> That’s right. Yes. You've been there for
  39. 1:25a very long time. When you work there
  40. 1:26...
  41. 1:27>> If you say you've worked on Wall Street
  42. 1:28for 18 years, do people usually say, "
  43. 1:30Wow, that's a long time"? Or is it more
  44. 1:31like, "That's how long you need to be
  45. 1:33there to be recognized"? What is it like
  46. 1:36? How is it received?
  47. 1:38>> Honestly, looking at others in the
  48. 1:40industry, I don't feel like 18 years is
  49. 1:42a very long time.
  50. 1:44>> Oh, really? Because the investment
  51. 1:46industry is actually something you can
  52. 1:49keep doing as long as your mind is sharp
  53. 1:52. It’s that kind of work. That’s right.
  54. 1:55>> Warren Buffett, for instance—though he’s
  55. 1:57stepped back now—has shown it’s work you
  56. 2:00can do well into your 90s, and when I
  57. 2:03was around my 15th year, a friend asked
  58. 2:05me: "Now that you've been doing this for
  59. 2:0815 years, do you see how it's done?"
  60. 2:10>> Yes. What do you think?
  61. 2:11>> Yes.
  62. 2:12To answer honestly, if I said I could
  63. 2:15see exactly how it should be done, that
  64. 2:17would be a lie.
  65. 2:19It would be an exaggeration.
  66. 2:20>> Yes.
  67. 2:21>> But after about 15 years,
  68. 2:24>> I did start to see what*not*to do. I had
  69. 2:27said something like that before.
  70. 2:29>> Yes. Now, about three years since then,
  71. 2:33my feelings are still the same.
  72. 2:36>> I’d like to ask you about that in detail
  73. 2:38later, but can you tell me roughly how
  74. 2:40many things there are?
  75. 2:42The things you shouldn't do—are there
  76. 2:43about ten?
  77. 2:44>> Oh, there are a lot. A lot? There are so
  78. 2:46many.
  79. 2:47>> Yes. It’s hard to put a number on it.
  80. 2:50But figuring out what not to do is
  81. 2:52actually very important, because I
  82. 2:54believe avoiding big mistakes is half of
  83. 2:57the success in stock investing.
  84. 3:00It might even be more than half.
  85. 3:02>> Yes.
  86. 3:03>> Uh, so I believe that identifying things
  87. 3:06you should not do is, um, quite, uh,
  88. 3:09valuable in its own right.
  89. 3:12>> I see. Oh, the point about only needing
  90. 3:15to avoid big mistakes really resonates
  91. 3:18with me.
  92. 3:18>> Oh, is that so? Yes.
  93. 3:20Small mistakes can somehow be recovered
  94. 3:23from with little impact, but a big
  95. 3:25mistake can leave you reeling.
  96. 3:27Yes.
  97. 3:28>> Understood. Yes. I’d like to ask my
  98. 3:31first question. I heard that you entered
  99. 3:33Wall Street right before the financial
  100. 3:35crisis. That’s right. I started my
  101. 3:37internship right around then. Yes. Yes.
  102. 3:39>> Yes. Back then, when you were interning
  103. 3:41at Merrill Lynch, were there any moments
  104. 3:43you witnessed on the scene that still
  105. 3:45influence your investment decisions
  106. 3:47today?
  107. 3:48Were there any such moments?
  108. 3:50>> Hmm.
  109. 3:51So, I had the great opportunity to
  110. 3:53intern at Merrill Lynch in 2007 and 2008
  111. 3:56.
  112. 3:57>> Hmm.
  113. 3:58>> It’s true that my first taste of Wall
  114. 3:59Street began before the financial crisis
  115. 4:01.
  116. 4:02Because the summer of 2007 was a time
  117. 4:04when all Wall Street firms were
  118. 4:06recording their absolute best
  119. 4:08performance.
  120. 4:09Yes.
  121. 4:10>> Yes. I first entered then, and when I
  122. 4:13returned a year later, the atmosphere
  123. 4:15was very different.
  124. 4:17>> Hmm.
  125. 4:18>> Because by the summer of 2008, the S&P
  126. 4:21had already started to drop, but
  127. 4:23>> Yes.
  128. 4:24>> Bear Stearns had already collapsed,
  129. 4:26>> Yes.
  130. 4:27It was that March, and by the summer of
  131. 4:302008, stocks like Merrill Lynch, Lehman
  132. 4:33, and Morgan Stanley had already fallen
  133. 4:37by more than 50%, so
  134. 4:39>> Yes.
  135. 4:39>> The atmosphere was already quite bad,
  136. 4:42>> you could say.
  137. 4:43>> Yes. Yes.
  138. 4:44>> But the part I still remember and apply
  139. 4:47to my investments is that after I
  140. 4:49finished my Merrill Lynch internship, as
  141. 4:51you might know, in the U.S., regarding
  142. 4:54employment,
  143. 4:56>> that internship you do in your junior
  144. 4:57year of college is essentially your
  145. 4:59ticket to a job.
  146. 5:00>> Right. As long as you don't cause any
  147. 5:03problems and finish it well,
  148. 5:05>> you get an offer to return after
  149. 5:07graduation once the summer ends.
  150. 5:09I finished my summer internship at
  151. 5:12Merrill Lynch in August 2008.
  152. 5:14>> Yes.
  153. 5:15>> And a month later, Merrill Lynch was
  154. 5:18urgently sold to Bank of America.
  155. 5:21Yes.
  156. 5:21>> Well, it was sold and survived, but in
  157. 5:23reality, the company had failed. And
  158. 5:25Lehman wasn't chosen, so it collapsed.
  159. 5:28>> Right.
  160. 5:31I left just one month before that
  161. 5:33happened to the firm, but at least among
  162. 5:35those I dealt with and spent time with,
  163. 5:38no one thought the company would go
  164. 5:40under.
  165. 5:43>> Oh, so it hadn't really sunk in yet.
  166. 5:45>> Right?
  167. 5:46>> Even just a month before.
  168. 5:47>> So, looking back on it now,
  169. 5:49>> Yes.
  170. 5:50>> it was a situation that had reached the
  171. 5:52very edge.
  172. 5:53>> Yes.
  173. 5:54Of course, I was just an intern, so the
  174. 5:57CEO and CFOs
  175. 6:00>> might have been
  176. 6:01>> preparing for this in secret. If I had
  177. 6:04spoken with them, maybe I would have
  178. 6:06known.
  179. 6:08But a lot of time has passed, and the
  180. 6:10circumstances at the time have been
  181. 6:12revealed in books and interviews, but
  182. 6:14yeah.
  183. 6:15>> I think they didn't know either.
  184. 6:17>> They must have been in denial.
  185. 6:18>> Right. Back then, the managing directors
  186. 6:21and such at the group said, "Anyway,
  187. 6:23have a good final year," and, um, "
  188. 6:26>> We'll be in touch," and that's how we
  189. 6:28parted ways.
  190. 6:30>> So, the point I find important there is
  191. 6:33that even people inside a company don't
  192. 6:36know the realm of the future.
  193. 6:40>> Because
  194. 6:41>> Yes.
  195. 6:42>> I mean, people inside a company can
  196. 6:44provide information.
  197. 6:46They can certainly tell you about the
  198. 6:49present, the company's atmosphere, or
  199. 6:52its culture, but I don't think
  200. 6:54predicting tomorrow is a matter of
  201. 6:57information.
  202. 6:58>> Then what realm is it?
  203. 7:01Because, honestly, since we are
  204. 7:02outsiders, from an outside perspective,
  205. 7:04one might ask, "How could you not have
  206. 7:05known?"
  207. 7:06Especially when it was just a month
  208. 7:07prior.
  209. 7:08>> Then when did they know? Did they know a
  210. 7:10week before? Did they know three days
  211. 7:11before? Did they know the day before?
  212. 7:13Yeah. These kinds of things
  213. 7:16>> Right. It might depend on what position
  214. 7:18you hold in the company,
  215. 7:21>> but as an investor, that's what I think
  216. 7:23. It is extremely difficult to predict
  217. 7:27the future, yet we make an effort to try
  218. 7:30, right? Investors do.
  219. 7:32>> Right. Constantly.
  220. 7:33>> But honestly, I think the future isn't
  221. 7:35something you predict, but something you
  222. 7:37prepare for.
  223. 7:38>> Yes. Yes.
  224. 7:40>> So I invest that way, and if you ask, if
  225. 7:42predicting the future isn't a realm of
  226. 7:45information, what is it then?
  227. 7:47>> Yes.
  228. 7:48>> I can only answer that it's a matter of
  229. 7:51belief.
  230. 7:51>> Ah.
  231. 7:53>> You invest in the future with a belief
  232. 7:55based on information and analysis. Um.
  233. 8:00>> I think it’s very dangerous to invest
  234. 8:02with the absolute certainty that the
  235. 8:04future will turn out a certain way.
  236. 8:08>> So, it's a matter of
  237. 8:10>> that
  238. 8:10>> part, not necessarily a
  239. 8:13>> question of faith. In a way, even
  240. 8:16without such conviction,
  241. 8:18>> to give you an example, everyone tries
  242. 8:20to pick a company they think will do
  243. 8:22well. When investing.
  244. 8:24>> Right? Yes. Let's say there's a
  245. 8:26structure where you can bet only on the
  246. 8:28top students in each school. These days
  247. 8:30, there are prediction markets, so maybe
  248. 8:32that could actually happen.
  249. 8:34>> But
  250. 8:35>> looking at the top students, while not
  251. 8:39all of them do, most continue to do well
  252. 8:42even after graduating high school.
  253. 8:45>> Yes.
  254. 8:46Suppose, for example, there’s a certain
  255. 8:49statistic, and you take that data, using
  256. 8:51the framework of what has been factual
  257. 8:54up until now, and assume that, looking
  258. 8:56at the whole picture, these things will
  259. 8:58continue to do well in the future.
  260. 9:01>> That isn’t really a forecast, is it?
  261. 9:03Right?
  262. 9:03>> That’s right.
  263. 9:04In our case, while there are certainly
  264. 9:06people on Wall Street who work hard at
  265. 9:08forecasting,
  266. 9:09>> we always think about the future in
  267. 9:11terms of probabilities.
  268. 9:13>> Ah.
  269. 9:13>> Yes.
  270. 9:15So we think probabilistically, select
  271. 9:17stocks based on that, build a portfolio
  272. 9:20, and then look at the win rate of that
  273. 9:22portfolio.
  274. 9:24"You must buy this stock.""This will go
  275. 9:27up." Saying things like that—
  276. 9:29>> people ask me that a lot. My friends,
  277. 9:31acquaintances, family; they ask, "What
  278. 9:33should I buy?""What should I buy these
  279. 9:35days?"
  280. 9:36I can't pinpoint just one thing to buy,
  281. 9:39because even Warren Buffett can get it
  282. 9:41wrong if you ask him to pick a single
  283. 9:44stock.
  284. 9:45>> Right.
  285. 9:46>> So who am I to—
  286. 9:47>> Hmm.
  287. 9:48>> I don’t think I’ve found an investment
  288. 9:51target yet that I have enough conviction
  289. 9:54in to point at one stock and say, "You
  290. 9:56must buy this."
  291. 9:59There was a time when I thought I had
  292. 10:00found one in the past.
  293. 10:01>> Yes. Around when was that? How many
  294. 10:03years into your career?
  295. 10:04>> About five years in.
  296. 10:06>> Five years in? Wow. Yes.
  297. 10:08>> But looking back, it turned out to be a
  298. 10:10very wrong judgment. I don’t have any
  299. 10:12expectation of finding one in the future
  300. 10:14, either.
  301. 10:14>> Hmm.
  302. 10:15>> However, constructing a portfolio with a
  303. 10:18high probability of winning, bringing
  304. 10:20together various stocks to build that
  305. 10:22portfolio, is something I can do well.
  306. 10:26>> You're doing this work because you’re
  307. 10:28confident in that, right?
  308. 10:30>> Yes.
  309. 10:31I think people who work on Wall Street
  310. 10:33generally work with that kind of mindset
  311. 10:35.
  312. 10:36We did random interviews on the street
  313. 10:39yesterday, and people of all ages and
  314. 10:41genders were saying similar things.
  315. 10:44So, they said don't follow trends,
  316. 10:47>> and that if you're an average person,
  317. 10:49you should invest in indices,
  318. 10:51>> or get consulting from an expert; they
  319. 10:54talked a lot about a more conservative
  320. 10:56approach. Hmm. Yes. Yes. So it was a
  321. 10:59sentiment I could fully resonate with. I
  322. 11:01think that’s what it was.
  323. 11:03>> Then, CEO, while you were studying
  324. 11:05finance,
  325. 11:06>> Yes.
  326. 11:07>> You must have gone there with a lot of
  327. 11:09dreams and expectations in mind. There
  328. 11:12must have been some differences between
  329. 11:14the Wall Street you imagined and the
  330. 11:16reality you saw when you actually got
  331. 11:18there. What were they?
  332. 11:20To be honest, when I went there as an
  333. 11:23intern, it wasn't that different from
  334. 11:26what I had imagined.
  335. 11:29>> Hmm.
  336. 11:30>> If anything, it was more fascinating
  337. 11:32than I had imagined,
  338. 11:33>> Yes.
  339. 11:34>> and so cool, that I just thought, "I
  340. 11:36want to graduate soon and go work there
  341. 11:38." Honestly, that was about all I felt.
  342. 11:41I don’t think I had any deep experience
  343. 11:44where I felt, "I imagined it would be
  344. 11:47like this, but the reality is different
  345. 11:49."
  346. 11:50You just mentioned having a heart full
  347. 11:53of excitement.
  348. 11:54>> If anything, that excitement only grew,
  349. 11:57and I just had a really great experience
  350. 12:00overall.
  351. 12:00>> However,
  352. 12:03>> now that I've been here for 18 years,
  353. 12:07>> Right. there are aspects that are
  354. 12:09different from what I first imagined.
  355. 12:11That’s only natural. Of course, there
  356. 12:13are.
  357. 12:13>> Hmm. It was either similar to what I
  358. 12:15thought or even cooler.
  359. 12:16>> Exactly. Because I didn’t really have
  360. 12:18any specific expectations. So, just...
  361. 12:20just...
  362. 12:21>> That’s exactly what that is.
  363. 12:23>> Just "Wow, that's cool."
  364. 12:24>> That’s why you do it. "I want to be
  365. 12:26there, too."
  366. 12:28>> Ah,
  367. 12:28>> And for instance, in 2008, I interned in
  368. 12:32the trading field, so I had to go to
  369. 12:35work very early.
  370. 12:37>> I mean, it's probably the same in
  371. 12:38Yeouido or anywhere else in Korea.
  372. 12:40>> What time did you usually get to work?
  373. 12:41>> Back then, everyone had to be in before
  374. 12:447 AM, but since I was an intern,
  375. 12:46>> I was even
  376. 12:47>> more diligent and got there even earlier
  377. 12:48. I would wake up early, head to Wall
  378. 12:53Street,
  379. 12:54>> and watching myself walk there, I felt
  380. 12:58really proud.
  381. 12:59>> Like an out-of-body experience, watching
  382. 13:01myself from above.
  383. 13:02>> Exactly. Right.
  384. 13:04But at that time, everything looked good
  385. 13:06and I gained a lot of energy because,
  386. 13:09even though I thought I was ready so
  387. 13:11early, people already out there running
  388. 13:14breakfast shops or selling newspapers
  389. 13:16were there even earlier.
  390. 13:19>> Right.
  391. 13:20So, looking at them, I thought, "I
  392. 13:23thought I was working hard, but there
  393. 13:25are so many people in this world working
  394. 13:28harder than me," and I’d get inspired by
  395. 13:31that and head into work.
  396. 13:33>> Right.
  397. 13:33>> Yes. It was just like that.
  398. 13:36In 2008, Merrill Lynch's stock was
  399. 13:38already down 50%, but what did I know?
  400. 13:42I just had a good experience, and as I
  401. 13:44mentioned, no one at the company was
  402. 13:46saying, "Are you crazy?"
  403. 13:49The atmosphere wasn't like, "Look at the
  404. 13:51state of the company right now." They
  405. 13:53were also looking at their monitors,
  406. 13:54thinking, "The stock is falling, but...
  407. 13:55"
  408. 13:56"
  409. 13:56>> We’ll probably survive," is what
  410. 13:58everyone was thinking.
  411. 14:00>> Because we tend to imagine guys like
  412. 14:02Leonardo DiCaprio being there,
  413. 14:05>> cursing and throwing documents around,
  414. 14:09>> with rough men working away—that’s the
  415. 14:11kind of image we have.
  416. 14:13But we interviewed in front of JP Morgan
  417. 14:16yesterday, and it wasn't like that at
  418. 14:17all; it was very quiet. Exactly. Right.
  419. 14:20I also...
  420. 14:23>> I wasn't here in the 80s so I don't know
  421. 14:25, but the movie*The Wolf of Wall Street
  422. 14:27*is set around the 80s, I believe.
  423. 14:30>> It was wild back then. That’s just
  424. 14:31stories I’ve heard, too. Back then,
  425. 14:33those kinds of things really happened.
  426. 14:34>> Oh, they say so.
  427. 14:36>> Everything was done by phone back then,
  428. 14:37so they'd break monitors with phones and
  429. 14:39leave work early that day.
  430. 14:41That person, that...
  431. 14:45>> I don't know exactly what they did, and
  432. 14:46I didn't come here thinking about that.
  433. 14:49>> Ah.
  434. 14:50>> But the Wall Street I experienced was
  435. 14:53either similar to what I imagined, or I
  436. 14:55didn't think much of it at the time, so
  437. 14:57everything just looked good.
  438. 14:59>> Right.
  439. 15:01Then, CEO, you used to work as an
  440. 15:04analyst at a large financial firm, and
  441. 15:07now you're running your own firm, so I
  442. 15:10imagine there must be significant
  443. 15:13differences between then and now.
  444. 15:16Hmm.
  445. 15:17>> There are.
  446. 15:18First, many people think it's different
  447. 15:20, but let me tell you about what isn't
  448. 15:22different.
  449. 15:25>> Many people think that being at a big
  450. 15:27company gives you a lot of resources for
  451. 15:29investing.
  452. 15:31>> Naturally.
  453. 15:33But I don't know if it was just Bank of
  454. 15:35America where I worked, but as I worked
  455. 15:38here and got to know people around me
  456. 15:40and heard from acquaintances, they were
  457. 15:42all pretty similar.
  458. 15:44I see.
  459. 15:45>> Of course, the company's total resources
  460. 15:47are huge.
  461. 15:48>> But our team's resources weren't
  462. 15:51actually that abundant.
  463. 15:53I mean, Bank of America has a huge
  464. 15:55number of research analysts.
  465. 15:57>> Yes.
  466. 15:59>> I expected to work with them and hear
  467. 16:01their insights, but in reality, we...
  468. 16:05>> Sometimes we had almost no interaction
  469. 16:08with them at all.
  470. 16:09>> Oh, really?
  471. 16:11No matter how big the company we were at
  472. 16:13, our investment team was always three
  473. 16:15to four people, five at most.
  474. 16:19>> Oh, that's a very small number of people
  475. 16:21. Yes.
  476. 16:23We operated as such a small team, and in
  477. 16:25fact, when at such a large firm, if I
  478. 16:28wanted to do something, I had to get
  479. 16:30permission.
  480. 16:32>> Like, "This research is supposed to be
  481. 16:33really good lately.""I...""
  482. 16:35>> I'd like to buy and read this research.
  483. 16:36" Even if I asked, I couldn't decide it
  484. 16:38myself; I needed approval from above,
  485. 16:39and if they said, "The budget is tight
  486. 16:41this year," then I just couldn't see it
  487. 16:43.
  488. 16:43>> That's how it was.
  489. 16:45That's why, even though we're out on our
  490. 16:49own now, there's almost no difference in
  491. 16:53terms of research or investing; in a way
  492. 16:57, I can now more freely choose the
  493. 17:00resources I need, which could be
  494. 17:03considered an advantage.
  495. 17:06But if you ask what the biggest
  496. 17:09difference is, it's freedom. It's
  497. 17:13freedom. I mean...
  498. 17:15>> When it comes to investing or research,
  499. 17:17they’d say, "Your overall investment
  500. 17:19risk-taking direction for this time
  501. 17:21should be like this."
  502. 17:23>> Hmm. "
  503. 17:23>> Otherwise, you can't." Even if we
  504. 17:25thought that now wasn't the time to
  505. 17:27reduce risk, but rather to increase it
  506. 17:30...
  507. 17:30>> Yes.
  508. 17:30>> If they said no from above...
  509. 17:33>> It was a situation where we couldn't do
  510. 17:34anything. That is why...
  511. 17:36>> That must have been frustrating.
  512. 17:37>> It’s not about just doing whatever I
  513. 17:39want, but being able to make the best
  514. 17:41investments for our clients, as I see
  515. 17:43fit, without having to ask for anyone’s
  516. 17:45permission.
  517. 17:46Hmm. Hmm.
  518. 17:47>> I think that is the biggest plus.
  519. 17:50However, there are some downsides that
  520. 17:52come with it that I have to bear.
  521. 17:54>> Yes.
  522. 17:56>> But I believe the gains are greater, so
  523. 17:58this is how I operate.
  524. 18:00>> Hmm. In a way, you could say that the
  525. 18:02differences and similarities are
  526. 18:04connected. Ultimately, it’s data and
  527. 18:06freedom.
  528. 18:06>> That’s right. Exactly.
  529. 18:08>> Yes. They are connected.
  530. 18:09>> Yes. Then, CEO, I’d like to ask you
  531. 18:11about this as well.
  532. 18:13The fact that the U.S. economy is good
  533. 18:15and the decision to buy U.S. stocks are
  534. 18:17actually two different things; just
  535. 18:19because the economy is good doesn’t mean
  536. 18:21you have to jump in and buy stocks, and
  537. 18:23vice versa.
  538. 18:24I’m curious about what criteria you use
  539. 18:27to judge that difference.
  540. 18:28>> Hmm. They are deeply related, but in the
  541. 18:31end, they are different issues, and the
  542. 18:34way we view the economy is...
  543. 18:37>> We don’t look at it to guess what the
  544. 18:39economy will be like in the future.
  545. 18:42>> Yes. Hmm.
  546. 18:43>> Ultimately, whether the economy goes one
  547. 18:46way or another, we are buying the
  548. 18:48scenario already reflected in the stock
  549. 18:51price.
  550. 18:52>> Ah.
  551. 18:54>> Because every stock price reflects
  552. 18:56certain expectations about the company's
  553. 18:59future.
  554. 19:00>> Right.
  555. 19:01However, the reason we must analyze the
  556. 19:03economy is, for instance, there are
  557. 19:05consumer companies.
  558. 19:07That consumer company, no matter how
  559. 19:09well it does—if the GDP is, say, 3%—
  560. 19:11that company, at best, will do GDP plus
  561. 19:142, or maybe just 3.
  562. 19:17>> It’s a business model that can only do
  563. 19:19up to that much.
  564. 19:20>> Hmm.
  565. 19:21>> But if the company is too popular, if
  566. 19:23the stock is too popular,
  567. 19:24>> Yes.
  568. 19:25And the expectations are already
  569. 19:27reflecting, for example, that much.
  570. 19:31>> If the market is already predicting that
  571. 19:33it will bring over 6%growth.
  572. 19:37Then we take a look at that situation.
  573. 19:40We lay out a few scenarios for what the
  574. 19:42U.S. economy might look like in the
  575. 19:45future, and judge how much better the
  576. 19:47company’s performance could actually be
  577. 19:50if it outperforms those expectations.
  578. 19:54>> Or, if the economy takes a turn for the
  579. 19:57worse, we must judge how the company’s
  580. 19:59performance will turn out and how much
  581. 20:01worse that is compared to the
  582. 20:03expectations.
  583. 20:06>> So, we look at the economy, how much a
  584. 20:09specific industry is influenced by the
  585. 20:12economy, and judge how large the entire
  586. 20:15industry pie will be under scenario A,
  587. 20:18or how much it will shrink under
  588. 20:21scenario B. Because we view the economy
  589. 20:24from that perspective, there is no need
  590. 20:27to decide that the economy and stocks
  591. 20:30are separate issues.
  592. 20:32We start with the stock price first.
  593. 20:34>> We identify what expectations are
  594. 20:36reflected in the stock price through
  595. 20:38analysis,
  596. 20:40>> and since we compare how realistic this
  597. 20:42is through economic and industry
  598. 20:44analysis,
  599. 20:46>> Yes. you could say that’s how we
  600. 20:48approach the economy.
  601. 20:49>> When you analyze stocks like that, you
  602. 20:51look at the numbers, right? Like, in
  603. 20:54this case, it seems it’s already priced
  604. 20:56in. In this case, it seems we can raise
  605. 20:57expectations a bit more. You must build
  606. 21:00various scenarios, but how many
  607. 21:02scenarios should you typically create?
  608. 21:05Hmm. There isn’t a fixed number. It’s
  609. 21:08not just us; if you look at many
  610. 21:10sell-side reports on Wall Street, they
  611. 21:14don’t strictly stick to just three—a
  612. 21:17bull case, a bear case, and a base case
  613. 21:20.
  614. 21:20>> Right.
  615. 21:21>> The reason I said it’s about preparing
  616. 21:24for the future, not predicting it, is
  617. 21:25that
  618. 21:26>> Yes.
  619. 21:28when we analyze a stock, a "
  620. 21:29double-or-nothing" situation doesn't
  621. 21:32really hold much meaning for us.
  622. 21:36For instance, if someone presents a
  623. 21:39stock to us saying it could go up 50%if
  624. 21:42things go well and drop 50%if they don't
  625. 21:45,
  626. 21:46>> Right.
  627. 21:47>> that’s not a stock I’m particularly
  628. 21:49interested in. Because we don’t know
  629. 21:51what the future will look like anyway,
  630. 21:53>> Yes. + 50%if it goes well and -50%if it
  631. 21:57doesn't—sorry, I'm using English. My
  632. 22:01Korean is a bit rusty; it’s a binary
  633. 22:04outcome. Just one of the two.
  634. 22:08>> So, when we look at a stock, we don't
  635. 22:10have a view that "this stock will go up
  636. 22:13" or "this stock will go down," but
  637. 22:15rather that this stock could, for
  638. 22:17example, rise up to 40%when things go
  639. 22:19well.
  640. 22:21Ah,
  641. 22:22>> and maybe drop about 20%when they don't
  642. 22:25.
  643. 22:26>> If the downside—well, when looking at a
  644. 22:29few scenarios—if it turns out that way,
  645. 22:32then that stock is very attractive to us
  646. 22:34.
  647. 22:35>> It’s a stock we like. People in our
  648. 22:37field talk a lot about winning rates, or
  649. 22:40probability. Like,
  650. 22:42>> Right.
  651. 22:43saying things like, "I think there's a
  652. 22:4670%chance of success and 30%failure," or
  653. 22:50"90%and 10%," but we actually don't
  654. 22:53think that's very meaningful.
  655. 22:56>> Ah.
  656. 22:57>> Because either way, it’s going to go up
  657. 22:59or it’s going to go down, one of the two
  658. 23:01.
  659. 23:01>> Exactly.
  660. 23:02>> So, when we construct our entire
  661. 23:04portfolio, we build it assuming that
  662. 23:06we’ll be right 50%of the time and wrong
  663. 23:0950%of the time.
  664. 23:10>> Right. Hmm.
  665. 23:12>> But as I mentioned earlier, if every
  666. 23:15stock in our portfolio can go up by 30,
  667. 23:1840, or 50%when things go well, but when
  668. 23:21they don't,
  669. 23:24>> uh, well,
  670. 23:25>> If it drops by 10, 20, or 30 percent,
  671. 23:27>> and you assume that half of it is right
  672. 23:29and half is wrong,
  673. 23:30>> when you look at the whole picture, it
  674. 23:32is designed to rise. Structurally.
  675. 23:36That doesn't mean we guarantee it will
  676. 23:38happen that way, but since we build
  677. 23:40portfolios based on a framework, we
  678. 23:42don't know either.
  679. 23:44I mean, even the employees at Merrill
  680. 23:46Lynch didn't know what would happen to
  681. 23:48Merrill Lynch the next month. So, I also
  682. 23:51>> I also
  683. 23:52>> Yes.
  684. 23:52>> don't know what will happen to the U.S.
  685. 23:54stock market tomorrow or next month.
  686. 23:55>> I don't know.
  687. 23:56>> I don't know what will happen to the
  688. 23:58U.S. economy or oil prices either.
  689. 24:00However, our role is to analyze how much
  690. 24:03we can earn if things go well and how
  691. 24:06much we could lose if they don't.
  692. 24:10>> Hmm. Ah, I see exactly what you mean.
  693. 24:13Thank you. Yes. Then, I'd like to ask
  694. 24:15you a little bit about the market as
  695. 24:17well.
  696. 24:18>> So, in a way, you might judge that "Oh,
  697. 24:21things will be good for a while."
  698. 24:23But it could go poorly or differently
  699. 24:26than expected. In such cases, there
  700. 24:28might be times you think, "If I wait a
  701. 24:30little longer, it will go according to
  702. 24:32my scenario." Or there might be times
  703. 24:34you think, "Oh, I must have been
  704. 24:36completely wrong," and decide to adjust
  705. 24:38your strategy. How do you decide on that
  706. 24:41timing? Hmm.
  707. 24:44>> I think that must be a very difficult
  708. 24:45thing to do.
  709. 24:46>> I really can't do that. Of course, I
  710. 24:48don't work on Wall Street. That's such a
  711. 24:50relief. I'm just constantly failing on
  712. 24:53my own.
  713. 24:54>> Sadly, it really is a very difficult
  714. 24:56thing. To be very honest, I think the
  715. 24:59only way is to do your best every time.
  716. 25:02>> Ah, so the mindset is the same. I do
  717. 25:05have that, too.
  718. 25:06>> But, speaking more realistically, that's
  719. 25:09why having a process is extremely
  720. 25:11important.
  721. 25:12Ah.
  722. 25:13>> So, when a certain criteria is met, I
  723. 25:17will sell this. Of course, those
  724. 25:21criteria can change over time.
  725. 25:24We also have such criteria, or what we
  726. 25:27call a checklist, and we keep updating
  727. 25:29it.
  728. 25:30After experiencing a major bear market,
  729. 25:33we think, "To avoid making this mistake
  730. 25:36again, we should make this change to our
  731. 25:39checklist."
  732. 25:40Most people probably do that, right? But
  733. 25:43we don't use that newly updated
  734. 25:45checklist right after experiencing a
  735. 25:47bear market.
  736. 25:48>> Oh, really? Why?
  737. 25:50Because usually, the changes made to the
  738. 25:53checklist after experiencing a bear
  739. 25:54market are often of a certain type.
  740. 25:58I mean, it's things like, "From now on,
  741. 26:00in this situation, I will definitely
  742. 26:02sell."
  743. 26:02>> Right? "
  744. 26:03>> From now on, if these conditions are met
  745. 26:05, I will sell no matter what."
  746. 26:08Because there are many things like that
  747. 26:10, and since your heart is quite closed
  748. 26:12off at that moment—
  749. 26:14>> Yes. Yes. If you immediately use an
  750. 26:17updated checklist in that situation,
  751. 26:20when you actually need to be more
  752. 26:23courageous, you might
  753. 26:25>> become overly inhibited.
  754. 26:25>> You can become inhibited. Because you
  755. 26:27might end up being overly cautious,
  756. 26:30>> we save the updates made after
  757. 26:33experiencing a downturn
  758. 26:36>> to be used in the following upturn, in a
  759. 26:39way.
  760. 26:40>> Yes.
  761. 26:42Likewise, if you make changes to the
  762. 26:44checklist after experiencing an upturn,
  763. 26:46you don't use it right away,
  764. 26:49>> but rather
  765. 26:50>> use it in the next downturn? That is
  766. 26:52>> for example, if you missed the bottom.
  767. 26:54>> Yes.
  768. 26:55>> Then, when it’s going up, you diligently
  769. 26:58update the checklist.
  770. 27:00Saying, "Next time, if the stock price
  771. 27:02drops by this much, I'll definitely buy
  772. 27:04."
  773. 27:05>> Or, "If these conditions are met, I'll
  774. 27:07hold on longer."
  775. 27:08>> Hmm.
  776. 27:09You update these items, but if you apply
  777. 27:12them immediately and use them
  778. 27:13incorrectly, even though you should be
  779. 27:15selling and getting out now, you might
  780. 27:18think, "No, my newly updated checklist
  781. 27:20>> said to be courageous."
  782. 27:22>> Ah.
  783. 27:22>> And so on.
  784. 27:24>> It's a human error where you keep
  785. 27:25holding at the wrong time.
  786. 27:28Because that happens, it's very
  787. 27:30important to pay attention to what my
  788. 27:33current state is, what I've experienced
  789. 27:36, and what kind of biases I might
  790. 27:39currently have because of those
  791. 27:41experiences.
  792. 27:44>> Thinking about that is crucial, and
  793. 27:47having a process is important because
  794. 27:51while following any process in this
  795. 27:54world, there are naturally cases of
  796. 27:58false positives.
  797. 28:00>> That's right.
  798. 28:01>> Because it involves the future, how
  799. 28:03could it be 100%correct every time?
  800. 28:06>> That's right.
  801. 28:07>> However, just because there is a false
  802. 28:09positive doesn't mean the process itself
  803. 28:12is wrong.
  804. 28:12>> When it's based on a process you can
  805. 28:15trust, and on data and experience,
  806. 28:18>> Yes. "
  807. 28:19>> Yes, following this might lead to
  808. 28:21occasional misses."
  809. 28:24"You might occasionally sell by mistake
  810. 28:27at the bottom."
  811. 28:30But if you can reach the conviction that
  812. 28:33you are right more often than you are
  813. 28:35wrong when following it, I think it's
  814. 28:38very important to consistently follow
  815. 28:41that process.
  816. 28:42>> Yes. Hmm. So, in conclusion, a checklist
  817. 28:46is clearly necessary to make judgments,
  818. 28:48specifically for timing.
  819. 28:51>> And you're saying that this checklist is
  820. 28:54created by synthesizing the mistakes
  821. 28:56made during downturns and upturns, but
  822. 28:59when to apply it depends on the
  823. 29:01situation.
  824. 29:03>> Exactly. Yes. That's difficult. It
  825. 29:05sounds easy when I hear it like this,
  826. 29:07but if I think about actually putting it
  827. 29:09into practice, it seems like a very
  828. 29:11difficult thing to do.
  829. 29:13>> So we also spend a significant amount of
  830. 29:16time designing our processes,
  831. 29:18identifying our weaknesses, and creating
  832. 29:21systems to compensate for those
  833. 29:24weaknesses.
  834. 29:25>> Hmm.
  835. 29:26>> I mean, we certainly spend a lot of time
  836. 29:29analyzing companies and watching the
  837. 29:31market,
  838. 29:32>> Yes.
  839. 29:34but I’d say we probably spend half our
  840. 29:37time developing processes to perform
  841. 29:40better next time and to avoid repeating
  842. 29:43past mistakes.
  843. 29:46>> That wouldn't be an exaggeration.
  844. 29:48Ah, I think this is a really important
  845. 29:51point because many people think that
  846. 29:53since AI is so advanced these days, even
  847. 29:56individual investors can buy
  848. 29:59high-quality data and perform analysis
  849. 30:02at a level comparable to those on Wall
  850. 30:04Street, potentially leveling the playing
  851. 30:07field between Wall Street experts and
  852. 30:10individual investors.
  853. 30:13But after listening to you today,
  854. 30:16>> I’m starting to think that’s not really
  855. 30:18the case.
  856. 30:19>> You are incredibly systematic in how you
  857. 30:21build these processes and checklists.
  858. 30:24Yes. Yes. That’s right. One of the many
  859. 30:27misconceptions
  860. 30:29>> that people outside of Wall Street
  861. 30:30>> often hold
  862. 30:32>> is the tendency to believe that we have
  863. 30:35a massive advantage when it comes to
  864. 30:37information.
  865. 30:39>> Of course, there is some information
  866. 30:40advantage. We might come across things
  867. 30:43faster,
  868. 30:43>> and meeting many people through our
  869. 30:45networks means we hear a lot more as
  870. 30:47well.
  871. 30:47>> Exactly. That’s right. And since people
  872. 30:50like us are always focused on that, we
  873. 30:53may see things sooner.
  874. 30:55>> Yes.
  875. 30:56However, I don’t believe that difference
  876. 30:59in information is what ultimately
  877. 31:01determines success or failure.
  878. 31:03Ultimately, what determines the outcome
  879. 31:05isn't that I have more information than
  880. 31:08you, but that I
  881. 31:10>> have more experience than the other
  882. 31:12party and the judgment that comes from
  883. 31:15that experience—and that judgment, in
  884. 31:17the end, is about having a process that
  885. 31:20reflects all of that: buying when
  886. 31:22certain conditions are met and selling
  887. 31:25when others are fulfilled.
  888. 31:28>> And no matter how confident I am,
  889. 31:31>> Right.
  890. 31:32>> I don't take on risks beyond a certain
  891. 31:35level; assembling those elements into a
  892. 31:37good portfolio is what we do, and that
  893. 31:40is the difference between a professional
  894. 31:43and a non-professional.
  895. 31:45It’s not like we have some information
  896. 31:47that the world doesn’t know.
  897. 31:48"
  898. 31:48>> Oh, they already know everything and are
  899. 31:50moving accordingly." No, well...
  900. 31:52>> You know...
  901. 31:53>> Of course, there’s a lot of that. Yes. "
  902. 31:55>> Wall Street did this."
  903. 31:57"Institutions came in and moved the
  904. 31:58Korean market."
  905. 32:00Things like that.
  906. 32:00>> Right. If someone were to ask, "How
  907. 32:03would you know, given you've only been
  908. 32:05doing this for 17 or 18 years?"
  909. 32:07I actually interviewed Professor Aswath
  910. 32:09Damodaran recently, and...
  911. 32:10>> Yes.
  912. 32:11>> I think he’s been doing this for over 40
  913. 32:13years. He has.
  914. 32:14>> But he said something to me, too.
  915. 32:17While we were interviewing, he said that
  916. 32:19so-called "smart money," money that
  917. 32:21moves early or has some sort of power,
  918. 32:24>> he said he hasn't found any such money
  919. 32:28yet.
  920. 32:28>> Is there only "dumb money"?
  921. 32:30No, no, people talk about those things,
  922. 32:32but he just said, "I haven't found it
  923. 32:35yet." But I agree with him on that. I
  924. 32:37mean, I haven't found it yet, and he
  925. 32:40hasn't found it either.
  926. 32:42>> When I started working full-time in 2009
  927. 32:45, I went to visit a friend's house, and
  928. 32:47his older brother,
  929. 32:49>> an acquaintance, was saying things like
  930. 32:51that. He said, "Everyone on Wall Street
  931. 32:53knew." Uh, "
  932. 32:54>> They all knew the financial crisis was
  933. 32:56coming and had already prepared for it.
  934. 32:59"
  935. 32:59>> Right.
  936. 33:00>> But for example, I asked, "Then why did
  937. 33:02Merrill Lynch go under?""
  938. 33:03>> Why did Bear Stearns go under?""Why did
  939. 33:05Lehman go under?"
  940. 33:05>> You were there at that time, too.
  941. 33:07>> Right? I told him. "Ah, they didn't know
  942. 33:09.""Even the people there." Right.
  943. 33:11>> But then, people often say things like
  944. 33:12that, don't they? "Oh, Goldman Sachs
  945. 33:14knew."
  946. 33:16Since Goldman Sachs didn't get hit too
  947. 33:17hard and managed to get out of it
  948. 33:19relatively unscathed.
  949. 33:21>> Right.
  950. 33:22They might have known, but personally, I
  951. 33:24don't think so. So, what made them
  952. 33:27different?
  953. 33:28They managed risk better than other
  954. 33:30companies,
  955. 33:31>> Ah.
  956. 33:33>> They prepared better than any other firm
  957. 33:36on Wall Street, and because that kind of
  958. 33:39preparedness was deeply embedded in
  959. 33:41their corporate culture for a long time
  960. 33:44, yes,
  961. 33:47>> people who were there say they were able
  962. 33:49to overcome that situation better than
  963. 33:52others, and I think so too, but if
  964. 33:54someone still says, "That guy doesn't
  965. 33:57know what he's talking about," if
  966. 33:59someone says to me, "Goldman Sachs is '
  967. 34:01Government Sachs,' so they already knew
  968. 34:04everything,"
  969. 34:06>> well, I have nothing to say to that. Yes
  970. 34:09.
  971. 34:09>> Exactly. Some people only believe what
  972. 34:12they want to believe.
  973. 34:13>> So, this is a side note, but I have a
  974. 34:15question.
  975. 34:16>> People call it a "bull market." And they
  976. 34:19call it a "bear market."
  977. 34:20>> A bull market is the bull, right? The
  978. 34:22bull.
  979. 34:23It's a bull, and when they attack, they
  980. 34:25thrust their horns upward, so it's a
  981. 34:27rising market, and bears strike downward
  982. 34:29, so it's a falling market; is that
  983. 34:31right?
  984. 34:32>> Yes. That is the most widely accepted
  985. 34:34theory.
  986. 34:35>> Oh, is it?
  987. 34:36>> As far as I know,
  988. 34:37>> I heard it somewhere and thought, "I
  989. 34:39should ask about this here on Wall
  990. 34:40Street," so I brought it up. As far as I
  991. 34:43know, the exact origin is not really
  992. 34:46known. But that is the most plausible
  993. 34:49theory.
  994. 34:49>> I am also aware of that.
  995. 34:52>> So even those on Wall Street don't
  996. 34:54exactly know how it started.
  997. 34:56Ah, I was curious about that. Right?
  998. 34:58Then, I’d like to ask you something; I
  999. 35:00went to your website to study up on it.
  1000. 35:03On your website, terms like "culture
  1001. 35:06practice" and "corporate culture"
  1002. 35:09appeared frequently, so I saw that you
  1003. 35:12place a lot of importance on corporate
  1004. 35:15culture.
  1005. 35:17I was curious about what that really
  1006. 35:19means, because some companies might just
  1007. 35:21project a good image to investors, while
  1008. 35:24others actually have a good corporate
  1009. 35:26culture, and I'm curious how you
  1010. 35:28distinguish between the two.
  1011. 35:30Yes. In fact, the idea that corporate
  1012. 35:33culture is important
  1013. 35:35>> is something many fundamental investors
  1014. 35:37would agree with.
  1015. 35:39However, a frustrating part that hasn't
  1016. 35:42been resolved is that for people in our
  1017. 35:44line of work, the primary source of
  1018. 35:46information
  1019. 35:48>> Yes.
  1020. 35:49>> is the company itself. We get a lot of
  1021. 35:51information through the company's
  1022. 35:52executives or the IR team.
  1023. 35:54>> Yes.
  1024. 35:54>> I get a lot of information through them
  1025. 35:56, and as I’ve been doing this,
  1026. 35:59>> I have met hundreds of CEOs, CFOs, and
  1027. 36:03other high-level company officials,
  1028. 36:06>> Yes.
  1029. 36:07>> but not a single person has ever said, "
  1030. 36:09Our company's corporate culture
  1031. 36:11>> is really garbage or terrible."
  1032. 36:15>> I suppose not.
  1033. 36:17The only ones who say, "It's really bad
  1034. 36:19and needs to change," are newly
  1035. 36:21recruited CEOs.
  1036. 36:23>> Ah.
  1037. 36:24>> Yes, CEOs brought in to fix problems
  1038. 36:26because something is wrong with the
  1039. 36:28company sometimes say that. "These are
  1040. 36:30our current problems.""We have to fix
  1041. 36:32them." So, what that means is
  1042. 36:35>> that we can't get the answers we want
  1043. 36:37from management anyway.
  1044. 36:39>> Yes.
  1045. 36:40So, we’ve always pondered how we can
  1046. 36:42actually get this information; it’s not
  1047. 36:44like we just woke up one day and decided
  1048. 36:46that corporate culture is important.
  1049. 36:50>> We gradually worked on it, but starting
  1050. 36:52around the 2010s, a phenomenon began to
  1051. 36:54occur where data transparency regarding
  1052. 36:56corporate behavior
  1053. 36:58>> Yes.
  1054. 36:59>> began to increase; for example, ESG was
  1055. 37:03a huge trend, even if people don't talk
  1056. 37:06about it as much these days.
  1057. 37:10For over 10 years, the ESG trend has
  1058. 37:13been very helpful to us; as ESG became
  1059. 37:16popular, companies started voluntarily
  1060. 37:19releasing data on their behavior as a
  1061. 37:21corporation—whereas in the past they
  1062. 37:24only published financial statements—and
  1063. 37:27a significant amount of data on how they
  1064. 37:30act started to emerge, along with social
  1065. 37:33media and the internet.
  1066. 37:37>> For example, in Korea, there are
  1067. 37:39platforms where employees can leave
  1068. 37:40anonymous reviews, right?
  1069. 37:43At first, those sites were just for
  1070. 37:46people who either loved or hated a
  1071. 37:49company, but now that they've become
  1072. 37:52more common and have more data, they
  1073. 37:55actually serve as a very useful database
  1074. 37:58for us.
  1075. 38:01>> And also, consumer reviews and other
  1076. 38:03types of reviews are becoming more
  1077. 38:05frequent, aren't they?
  1078. 38:07They accumulate, and we have been
  1079. 38:09consistently trying to get a glimpse
  1080. 38:13into corporate culture through such data
  1081. 38:16.
  1082. 38:17>> Hmm.
  1083. 38:18So, you mentioned corporate behavior or
  1084. 38:20transparency, but in a way, those can be
  1085. 38:22decisions and actions made by the
  1086. 38:24management.
  1087. 38:27But I feel like there must have been
  1088. 38:29moments where, observing those decisions
  1089. 38:31or actions, you felt that these people
  1090. 38:34are trustworthy even if the company hits
  1091. 38:36a rough patch.
  1092. 38:38Hmm. Yes, yes.
  1093. 38:39>> Yes. Were there any use cases like that
  1094. 38:42?
  1095. 38:42>> Right. As I mentioned, our investments
  1096. 38:44are ultimately based on belief backed by
  1097. 38:46data and experience.
  1098. 38:47>> Yes.
  1099. 38:49>> It's not a blind belief that a company
  1100. 38:51will do well without any grounds, or
  1101. 38:53thinking, "I met the CEO and he's so
  1102. 38:55charismatic." It's not that kind of
  1103. 38:57belief. "
  1104. 38:58>> This person is so great."
  1105. 38:59>> Right. Right. "This person is so great.
  1106. 39:01" Yes.
  1107. 39:02We look very closely at whether the
  1108. 39:06company's past actions, its stated
  1109. 39:10direction, or its claims about how it
  1110. 39:15operates match its actual decisions and
  1111. 39:19the results they produce.
  1112. 39:24So when they match,
  1113. 39:26>> Yes.
  1114. 39:27>> that's when we invest,
  1115. 39:29>> with the belief that they will continue
  1116. 39:32to do so in the future, and because we
  1117. 39:35invest based on that, even if we firmly
  1118. 39:38believed they would follow through,
  1119. 39:42>> Yes.
  1120. 39:43>> and then they don't, resulting in poor
  1121. 39:45performance,
  1122. 39:46>> those kinds of risks can exist.
  1123. 39:49But since that's not an area we can
  1124. 39:50analyze anyway, I believe that's
  1125. 39:52something to be handled through risk
  1126. 39:54management in our portfolio.
  1127. 39:56So, in terms of selecting stocks,
  1128. 39:58>> Yes. if
  1129. 40:00>> there is a belief that this company will
  1130. 40:02do well, where does that belief come
  1131. 40:05from?
  1132. 40:06You can gain that belief by looking at
  1133. 40:10how the company has acted so far, but
  1134. 40:13since investing requires belief, putting
  1135. 40:17everything into one place is too risky,
  1136. 40:20so effectively managing that risk at the
  1137. 40:24portfolio level is another one of my
  1138. 40:27roles.
  1139. 40:29So, in the end, when a company has a
  1140. 40:31very clear management philosophy and
  1141. 40:34vision, and reinforces that vision and
  1142. 40:36philosophy through various real-world
  1143. 40:39decisions, we can conclude that the
  1144. 40:41company has a good corporate culture.
  1145. 40:44>> That's right. Exactly. There's this US
  1146. 40:46company called Old Dominion.
  1147. 40:47>> Hmm.
  1148. 40:48>> It's a trucking company.
  1149. 40:50>> Yes.
  1150. 40:51We didn't initially start analyzing that
  1151. 40:54company because we were interested in
  1152. 40:56trucking.
  1153. 40:58We have certain metrics we always look
  1154. 41:00at, and this company just happened to
  1155. 41:03show up on our radar.
  1156. 41:05A trucking company.
  1157. 41:07When we looked closer, its stock
  1158. 41:09performance over the last 10 or 20-plus
  1159. 41:11years was incredible.
  1160. 41:13>> Right.
  1161. 41:14>> So we dug deeper and found the reason
  1162. 41:16why this company had such good returns.
  1163. 41:18>> Oh, what is it? Well, they're just
  1164. 41:19really good at what they do.
  1165. 41:20>> Ah.
  1166. 41:21>> For example, their on-time delivery rate
  1167. 41:24is the best among their peer group.
  1168. 41:27>> Or the percentage of lost or damaged
  1169. 41:30cargo is...
  1170. 41:31...
  1171. 41:31>> extremely low.
  1172. 41:32>> Exactly. Much better than their
  1173. 41:34competitors.
  1174. 41:35>> Yes.
  1175. 41:36>> Ultimately, those things led to their
  1176. 41:38strong performance.
  1177. 41:40>> Right.
  1178. 41:41>> Looking at that, we became very curious
  1179. 41:43.
  1180. 41:44>> Why are they so good? Because it’s not
  1181. 41:46like they have better trucks, you know.
  1182. 41:49>> Right?
  1183. 41:50>> All trucks are basically the same.
  1184. 41:51>> They're similar.
  1185. 41:53>> So we dug deeper, and other factors
  1186. 41:56behind the company's operational success
  1187. 42:00started to emerge.
  1188. 42:03For instance, the founding family is
  1189. 42:05currently running it in its third
  1190. 42:07generation.
  1191. 42:09>> Yes.
  1192. 42:09>> And they are still the largest
  1193. 42:10shareholders.
  1194. 42:11>> Oh.
  1195. 42:11>> But they aren't the controlling
  1196. 42:13shareholders.
  1197. 42:14>> I see. It’s just that a large portion of
  1198. 42:16their wealth is tied up in the company.
  1199. 42:19So they still operate the company very
  1200. 42:21much like a family business, and since
  1201. 42:23the corporate culture is good...
  1202. 42:25>> Yes.
  1203. 42:25>> It's not just that they claim to have a
  1204. 42:27good culture. We don't just take their
  1205. 42:29word for it; we look at actual employee
  1206. 42:31turnover.
  1207. 42:32Their resignation rate is lower compared
  1208. 42:36to their peer group.
  1209. 42:38>> People work there longer.
  1210. 42:40>> Those kinds of things are definitely in
  1211. 42:42the realm of culture.
  1212. 42:44>> There must be aspects like employee
  1213. 42:45benefits involved as well.
  1214. 42:46>> That's right.
  1215. 42:47>> Yes.
  1216. 42:48Because of that, we judge that as long
  1217. 42:52as this company maintains these
  1218. 42:55principles, it’s highly likely that they
  1219. 42:59will continue to outperform their peer
  1220. 43:03group in the future.
  1221. 43:07>> And that’s how we make the decision on
  1222. 43:08whether or not to invest in the stock.
  1223. 43:11>> Right.
  1224. 43:11>> Yes.
  1225. 43:12I’d say that those factors have a huge
  1226. 43:15influence on selecting companies that
  1227. 43:17are likely to do well.
  1228. 43:20>> So, thinking about it, there must be
  1229. 43:22cases where you don't invest because
  1230. 43:25even if the performance and such are
  1231. 43:27great, the management's words or actions
  1232. 43:29are a bit off.
  1233. 43:31No matter how good the performance is.
  1234. 43:32>> Hmm. That's right. Exactly.
  1235. 43:34>> For example, there was this one company
  1236. 43:37, a very large mining company in Africa
  1237. 43:40.
  1238. 43:40>> Yes. They said they discovered a huge
  1239. 43:43copper mine.
  1240. 43:43>> Yes.
  1241. 43:45>> So, a sell-side analyst presented it to
  1242. 43:47us as their best idea, saying that just
  1243. 43:50by mining and selling that copper, the
  1244. 43:52value would be much higher than the
  1245. 43:54current market cap.
  1246. 43:57But in such a case, if you only look at
  1247. 43:59the numbers, you would be right to
  1248. 44:01invest. Because, as I mentioned earlier
  1249. 44:04, the upside is huge when things go well
  1250. 44:07, and since the stock price is already
  1251. 44:09down, the downside is not...
  1252. 44:12>> Well, compared to the upside.
  1253. 44:15>> It’s small, so it fits our investment
  1254. 44:17style, but the reason we didn't end up
  1255. 44:19investing was because, while researching
  1256. 44:22the company, a real veteran in the
  1257. 44:23mining industry told us that we
  1258. 44:25shouldn't get involved with the CEO who
  1259. 44:27was running it.
  1260. 44:30>> Yes.
  1261. 44:31>> The founder—he told us it’s better not
  1262. 44:33to get involved with that person.
  1263. 44:35>> Yes.
  1264. 44:36>> But just because you get involved
  1265. 44:38doesn't necessarily mean things will go
  1266. 44:41wrong.
  1267. 44:41>> That's true.
  1268. 44:42The problem that arose there was that
  1269. 44:45while we could be somewhat confident
  1270. 44:47about the downside if things didn't work
  1271. 44:50out, we also needed a guarantee that we
  1272. 44:52would get a fair share of the upside if
  1273. 44:55things went well.
  1274. 44:57>> Right.
  1275. 44:58>> We judged that as long as that person is
  1276. 45:01the leader, even if things go well, we
  1277. 45:04might not actually see the upside we
  1278. 45:06expected.
  1279. 45:08>> That was our judgment.
  1280. 45:09>> Yes.
  1281. 45:10Because of that, the downside and the
  1282. 45:13upside we originally saw—after we
  1283. 45:15adjusted for that, it became a bit of a
  1284. 45:17gamble.
  1285. 45:19>> Like a 50-50 chance.
  1286. 45:20>> Yeah, once it becomes that kind of
  1287. 45:23situation, it’s no longer an attractive
  1288. 45:26investment for us.
  1289. 45:28And it wasn't just relying on one
  1290. 45:31person's word; that person had run
  1291. 45:34several companies in the mining industry
  1292. 45:38before, and looking at their track
  1293. 45:41record, if you look at the companies
  1294. 45:44they ran—for mining companies, for
  1295. 45:47instance, safety records are often
  1296. 45:50public.
  1297. 45:51>> Yes.
  1298. 45:52>> If they had truly run the company well
  1299. 45:55and with a good corporate culture, it
  1300. 45:57should have been safer than the average
  1301. 46:00. That would make sense. But that wasn't
  1302. 46:03the case either.
  1303. 46:05>> So, looking at it from that perspective
  1304. 46:08, strictly by the numbers, it was the "
  1305. 46:11down is up" scenario I mentioned earlier
  1306. 46:14, but I decided not to invest based on
  1307. 46:17the judgment that reality could just be
  1308. 46:20a "down turn is an up turn."
  1309. 46:25But talking with you today, I definitely
  1310. 46:28feel that even if we knew, there must
  1311. 46:30have been an extensive checklist and the
  1312. 46:33processes you mentioned prepared in
  1313. 46:36advance.
  1314. 46:37>> Right. And those processes are only
  1315. 46:39meaningful if they are prepared
  1316. 46:40beforehand. When things are happening
  1317. 46:42immediately—to use an American
  1318. 46:43expression, we're putting out fires—
  1319. 46:46>> you can't prepare then, so we share the
  1320. 46:48same mindset of preparing in advance. So
  1321. 46:51that when a situation like this comes
  1322. 46:54again, we can move immediately.
  1323. 46:58Then, if you go anywhere here on Wall
  1324. 47:01Street, including your firm, are these
  1325. 47:05contingency plans for worst-case
  1326. 47:08scenarios, like a financial crisis, now
  1327. 47:11very highly developed?
  1328. 47:15>> Mm. Mm. Looking at it from this point in
  1329. 47:17time,
  1330. 47:18>> I haven't worked at those companies, so
  1331. 47:20I'm not entirely sure. But I do want to
  1332. 47:22say this. Just because they have them
  1333. 47:24doesn't mean they always follow them.
  1334. 47:25>> Ah, that's another issue entirely.
  1335. 47:27>> Exactly. During the financial crisis,
  1336. 47:29Merrill Lynch, Bear Stearns, and Lehman
  1337. 47:31Brothers all had their own risk
  1338. 47:33management processes.
  1339. 47:34>> Right.
  1340. 47:36However, I think the first question is
  1341. 47:38how robust those risk management
  1342. 47:40processes were, and even if they were
  1343. 47:43robust, as you know from investing, no
  1344. 47:45matter how much you resolve and tell
  1345. 47:48yourself, "Next time, if these
  1346. 47:50conditions are met, I will definitely do
  1347. 47:52this,"
  1348. 47:54>> when the actual situation hits,
  1349. 47:56>> Yes.
  1350. 47:56>> there are so many cases where you don't
  1351. 47:59do it. I relate to that so much.
  1352. 48:01Actually, a week ago, I swore to myself
  1353. 48:03that I would never average down again.
  1354. 48:07>> I made that vow, but I'm in the U.S. now
  1355. 48:10, and SK Hynix hasn't been doing well
  1356. 48:12lately.
  1357. 48:14So, as it dropped to the 1.2 million won
  1358. 48:16range, I ended up averaging down again.
  1359. 48:19>> So I had a contingency plan. I had a
  1360. 48:21plan that I would absolutely never do it
  1361. 48:23, that in such cases I wouldn't do it,
  1362. 48:25but I ended up breaking it.
  1363. 48:26>> Yes. Right. Yes. Even on Wall Street,
  1364. 48:30many banks think, "Oh, Goldman Sachs is
  1365. 48:32doing it that way, so we should learn
  1366. 48:34from them."
  1367. 48:35>> Then they might recruit someone from
  1368. 48:38there,
  1369. 48:39>> Yes.
  1370. 48:39>> and that person sees how they handle
  1371. 48:41risk management and comes here to apply
  1372. 48:43it just like that.
  1373. 48:44>> They would do that, right?
  1374. 48:45>> Yes.
  1375. 48:47But the reason it doesn't always work is
  1376. 48:49that, in the end, every company has its
  1377. 48:52own long-standing culture, and those
  1378. 48:55cultures don't change easily.
  1379. 48:57>> Yes.
  1380. 48:59>> So, no matter how many times Warren
  1381. 49:01Buffett tells investors "this is how you
  1382. 49:03should invest," there are those who
  1383. 49:05actually do it.
  1384. 49:08>> And while some may resolve to "do it
  1385. 49:09like that next time," there are others
  1386. 49:12who fail to follow through when the next
  1387. 49:14opportunity arrives. That would also be
  1388. 49:16included in the corporate culture you
  1389. 49:18observe, right?
  1390. 49:19>> That’s right. Indeed.
  1391. 49:21Corporate culture doesn't change easily
  1392. 49:24, so for example, betting that a culture
  1393. 49:26will shift because someone comes in to
  1394. 49:29restructure a company that has had
  1395. 49:31long-standing issues—well, those
  1396. 49:33problems are usually already embedded
  1397. 49:36deep in the culture.
  1398. 49:38>> Exactly.
  1399. 49:39And for a new CEO to come in and
  1400. 49:42suddenly change that.
  1401. 49:44There are successful cases, of course,
  1402. 49:47but as I mentioned before, no process is
  1403. 49:49without false positives, so just because
  1404. 49:52there are a few success stories...
  1405. 49:55...
  1406. 49:55>> does not mean...
  1407. 49:58...
  1408. 49:58>> it provides a sufficient basis to break
  1409. 50:01the rule.
  1410. 50:02>> Hmm. When you look at it from a
  1411. 50:03probabilistic standpoint, that would be
  1412. 50:04true. Yes. Right. Lastly, I would like
  1413. 50:07to ask you a little bit about yourself,
  1414. 50:10sir. You've been on Wall Street for what
  1415. 50:13I consider a very long time.
  1416. 50:15I’m sure your investment skills were
  1417. 50:18excellent, but there must be another
  1418. 50:20reason you've been able to sustain a
  1419. 50:23career for 18 years.
  1420. 50:26>> If there is one characteristic of yours
  1421. 50:28that you could share with us.
  1422. 50:30>> Yes. Hmm.
  1423. 50:31>> Yes. Diligence was already mentioned
  1424. 50:33earlier. Earlier.
  1425. 50:35>> Well. For me, well. I don’t think
  1426. 50:38there’s anything...
  1427. 50:41...
  1428. 50:41>> particularly special, but if I had to
  1429. 50:43name a common trait among those who last
  1430. 50:46a long time, it’s that they didn't take
  1431. 50:49excessive, dangerous risks.
  1432. 50:51Ah.
  1433. 50:53>> Of course, if someone takes a huge risk
  1434. 50:56once, succeeds, makes a lot of money,
  1435. 50:59and gets out, we don't know what would
  1436. 51:02have happened if they had kept investing
  1437. 51:05that way. Since they already cashed out
  1438. 51:07.
  1439. 51:07>> Right?
  1440. 51:09But I think taking risks that could be
  1441. 51:12fatal if they go wrong is like walking
  1442. 51:14through a minefield.
  1443. 51:16>> Ah.
  1444. 51:17>> I mean, I’ve never actually crossed a
  1445. 51:20minefield.
  1446. 51:20>> But just...
  1447. 51:21>> It would be very nerve-wracking.
  1448. 51:22>> Right?
  1449. 51:23You might cross it without stepping on
  1450. 51:25one.
  1451. 51:26>> Hmm.
  1452. 51:29But just because you made it across once
  1453. 51:31doesn’t mean it’s "doable," and if you
  1454. 51:35keep walking across it, you might avoid
  1455. 51:37them the second or third time, but
  1456. 51:40eventually, you will hit one, so that
  1457. 51:42...
  1458. 51:44>> Yes.
  1459. 51:45>> As a professional, it’s really not easy
  1460. 51:49to sustain a career if you take risks
  1461. 51:52that could be fatal.
  1462. 51:55Even if you succeed once or twice.
  1463. 51:57>> Yes.
  1464. 51:58>> So, it’s not that I’ve never made big
  1465. 52:02mistakes myself, but fortunately, I’m
  1466. 52:06still here and surviving.
  1467. 52:10>> Well, so far, I haven't made any fatal
  1468. 52:13mistakes that would be game over.
  1469. 52:15>> Hmm.
  1470. 52:16And to avoid making such fatal mistakes
  1471. 52:19in the future, I think it's very
  1472. 52:22important to keep those things in mind
  1473. 52:25when building a portfolio and to
  1474. 52:28actually put them into practice. Yes.
  1475. 52:31>> Hmm.
  1476. 52:32It seems to be in line with what the
  1477. 52:34masters always say, that not losing is
  1478. 52:37the most important thing.
  1479. 52:38>> Exactly. Yes. Yes. Yes.
  1480. 52:41>> It’s like, making a huge bet or, for
  1481. 52:44example, going all-in because I'm so
  1482. 52:47sure about this.
  1483. 52:48>> Yes.
  1484. 52:50It might look cooler to go all-in and
  1485. 52:53hit the jackpot, but reality isn't like
  1486. 52:56that.
  1487. 52:58>> In reality, I sometimes use this
  1488. 53:00expression: I build a structure to
  1489. 53:02ensure that my clients 'money is not
  1490. 53:04lost significantly.
  1491. 53:06So, we don't prepare for home run plays
  1492. 53:08. If I were a baseball manager, for
  1493. 53:10example, relying on home runs...
  1494. 53:12>> Yes.
  1495. 53:14I think it's better to devise a strategy
  1496. 53:17where you can win with base hits, and if
  1497. 53:20you keep hitting those, sometimes you'll
  1498. 53:22connect perfectly and a home run will
  1499. 53:25happen.
  1500. 53:27Therefore, a strategy or portfolio that
  1501. 53:30relies on home runs......
  1502. 53:32>> if that's the case, then...
  1503. 53:34...
  1504. 53:34>> I think that is a bit of a dangerous
  1505. 53:37strategy. Yes.
  1506. 53:38>> Hmm.
  1507. 53:39You've shared many things, and lastly,
  1508. 53:41I'd like to ask you something because
  1509. 53:43there are many individual investors in
  1510. 53:45Korea who invest in U.S. stocks.
  1511. 53:47They are probably watching this
  1512. 53:49broadcast today.
  1513. 53:51>> If those people could take away just one
  1514. 53:54thing from your experience after hearing
  1515. 53:57all these stories today, is there a key
  1516. 54:00point you would really want them to
  1517. 54:02remember? Yes. Yes. I think it would be
  1518. 54:06good to think in terms of probability.
  1519. 54:09Thinking in terms of probability means
  1520. 54:11it's better not to have too much
  1521. 54:13certainty about the future.
  1522. 54:15>> Yes.
  1523. 54:16>> I’ve mentioned that the future is not
  1524. 54:19something to predict, but something to
  1525. 54:21prepare for.
  1526. 54:23>> Yes.
  1527. 54:24>> I wish more people would think that way
  1528. 54:26.
  1529. 54:27>> Hmm.
  1530. 54:28>> Because how can you predict the future?
  1531. 54:30>> Exactly. Also, in stock investing, I
  1532. 54:34think too many people are focused only
  1533. 54:37on what will go up or what will go down
  1534. 54:40.
  1535. 54:40>> Yes.
  1536. 54:41>> The market is, quite literally, a market
  1537. 54:43.
  1538. 54:43>> Right.
  1539. 54:44It's really like a supermarket, a place
  1540. 54:49set up so you can easily buy countless
  1541. 54:53companies, and I think you should just
  1542. 54:57go into that market and buy what you
  1543. 55:01need right now.
  1544. 55:04So when you're investing and building
  1545. 55:06your portfolio, for example, if someone
  1546. 55:08says, "The most important thing for me
  1547. 55:10right now is the highest return," then
  1548. 55:12they should go to the market and work
  1549. 55:14hard to find things that can provide the
  1550. 55:17best returns.
  1551. 55:18>> Exactly.
  1552. 55:19However, you must understand the risk
  1553. 55:22that in searching for them, you might
  1554. 55:25pick a dud that yields the worst returns
  1555. 55:29; in our case, while we have AI-related
  1556. 55:32stocks, we also have very boring
  1557. 55:34consumer stocks in our portfolio.
  1558. 55:38>> Oh, really?
  1559. 55:39>> So, do we hold those consumer stocks
  1560. 55:42because we think they will perform
  1561. 55:44better than the AI stocks in the future
  1562. 55:46?
  1563. 55:47That’s not the case.
  1564. 55:49We have an overall portfolio, a desired
  1565. 55:52risk level, and a target balance, and we
  1566. 55:55need to include other items to achieve
  1567. 55:57that necessary balance.
  1568. 56:00>> Yes.
  1569. 56:01>> So, if people look at the market in that
  1570. 56:05way, wouldn't it be helpful for many
  1571. 56:08people?
  1572. 56:10But to do that, you need to know what's
  1573. 56:12in the market.
  1574. 56:12>> That's right.
  1575. 56:15If you are good at it yourself, or even
  1576. 56:17if you aren't but enjoy doing it, you
  1577. 56:19can handle it directly; but if you don't
  1578. 56:21know how to go about it, in that case,
  1579. 56:23you can get help from an expert,
  1580. 56:26>> or
  1581. 56:27>> you can receive their guidance.
  1582. 56:29>> Yes.
  1583. 56:30>> I believe that thinking this way can
  1584. 56:33create a healthier investment culture.
  1585. 56:37Yes.
  1586. 56:37>> Yes.
  1587. 56:38CEO, thank you so much for sharing your
  1588. 56:40long stories and experiences today.
  1589. 56:43Listening to you, I realized we really
  1590. 56:45need to think more in terms of
  1591. 56:47probabilities, and I felt a bit of
  1592. 56:49remorse for having such easy convictions
  1593. 56:52; it was a truly valuable time that gave
  1594. 56:54me a lot to think about. Thank you, CEO
  1595. 56:57.
  1596. 56:57>> Yes. Oh, thank you.
  1597. 57:00>> Are you worried about your child's
  1598. 57:01financial education?
  1599. 57:03How about a Saturday afternoon economics
  1600. 57:04class for the whole family?
  1601. 57:06John Lee, Kim Kyung-il, and active
  1602. 57:09teachers will join you.
  1603. 57:11Including a special Q&A session with So
  1604. 57:13Dong-ju, please apply via the No Ticket
  1605. 57:15search or the pinned comment below the
  1606. 57:16video.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of 내가 팔면 오르는 주식, 월가 18년 차는 매매 기준을 이렇게 세웁니다 | 댄 하 대표 [얘기좀합시다] by 머니인더트랩, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 9,110 words across 1,606 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.