모두가 흔들리는 장에서 빌 애크먼은 오히려 지갑을 열었습니다… 변동성이 터질 때마다 주워 담은 종목 [구루 11월 - 빌 애크먼] — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00It is Bill Ackman, making an appearance
- 0:01after a long time. Bill Ackman’s
- 0:02strategy, ever since the AI rally began
- 0:04, has essentially been to buy Big Mill.
- 0:05He buys whenever Big Tech stocks fall.
- 0:07He states that he views CapX positively
- 0:08regarding the reasons why Big Tech is
- 0:10currently being criticized. Regarding
- 0:12the investment spending currently taking
- 0:14place, he said that Big Tech is
- 0:15originally a tiger, but now they are
- 0:17trying to grow wings.
- 0:19People ask, "Why are people going all-in
- 0:20on Big Tech when they are spending so
- 0:22much money and not hearing good news?"
- 0:30>> Now, finally, who is it?
- 0:33>> Yes, it is Bill Ackman, making an
- 0:35appearance after a long time.
- 0:37Bill Ackman said that times like this
- 0:39are actually the right time to invest,
- 0:41so let's find out why he calls it the
- 0:43right time and what he himself has
- 0:44invested in.
- 0:46Yes, Bill Ackman is a famous figure. To
- 0:48summarize in one word, he is annoying,
- 0:50but he invests incredibly well.
- 0:53So, I would like to point out that even
- 0:54though he is annoying, we cannot help
- 0:56but listen to his story.
- 0:58Next, why is now the opportunity? Bill
- 1:01Ackman argues that increased volatility
- 1:02presents an opportunity.
- 1:03He states that this volatility is not
- 1:05merely expanding in the short term, but
- 1:07has structurally increased, and
- 1:09therefore, this type of volatility will
- 1:11continue in the future.
- 1:14So, what exactly is the structural
- 1:15problem? Bill Ackman points to passive
- 1:17investing and day trading as the causes
- 1:19.
- 1:20Passive investing has become the
- 1:21mainstream trend, hasn't it?
- 1:22Yes, based on the stock market over the
- 1:24past 25 or 24 years, passive investing
- 1:26accounts for 60%of the US stock market.
- 1:28Therefore, passive investing essentially
- 1:30means buying the index exactly as it is
- 1:32. The point is that passive investing
- 1:34lacks the corrective effect of saying, "
- 1:35This stock is too expensive, so I'll
- 1:37sell it," or "This one is cheap, so I'll
- 1:38buy it."
- 1:40Consequently, the number of major
- 1:42investors who make such corrections has
- 1:44decreased significantly.
- 1:47Then, what about active investing? Among
- 1:49the remaining investors capable of
- 1:50making such corrections, how are they
- 1:52investing?
- 1:53They are engaging only in day trading,
- 1:54using heavy leverage. Isn't it accurate
- 1:56to say that this is the current trend on
- 1:58Wall Street? Anyway, isn't it? That's
- 2:00right.
- 2:01Ultra-short-term trading, represented by
- 2:03hyper-consecutive trading, is becoming
- 2:04the mainstream through such algorithmic
- 2:06trading.
- 2:08However, because investors are investing
- 2:09in the short term, they use a lot of
- 2:11leverage to inflate returns.
- 2:14Consequently, if you look at it these
- 2:15days, even if earnings come out well, if
- 2:17guidance is released even slightly
- 2:18disappointing, the stock price can slash
- 2:19by 10%or 20%in a single day.
- 2:21>> Hmm.
- 2:22>> That is precisely due to the
- 2:23characteristics of active investing.
- 2:24Because capital is concentrated in the
- 2:26short term and leverage is heavily
- 2:28applied, if even the slightest thing
- 2:30goes wrong, volatility explodes like
- 2:31this. People are saying that the market
- 2:33has become structured in this way. As a
- 2:35result, isn't there a lot of talk about
- 2:36high concentration in the market right
- 2:38now? The weight of the market has become
- 2:39too high in a few stocks.
- 2:41In particular, semiconductors were at a
- 2:44peak until June; until then, the weight
- 2:46of semiconductors was extremely high.
- 2:50It was as if people were flocking to the
- 2:51shovel and pickaxe.
- 2:52The reason for this is that people are
- 2:54all going passive, while those remaining
- 2:56are flocking only to stocks they think
- 2:58will rise or are considering good.
- 3:00As a result, concentration is increasing
- 3:02in this way. That is why people are
- 3:03saying that the current market structure
- 3:04has inevitably become a situation where
- 3:06high volatility is unavoidable.
- 3:07>> Yes.
- 3:08>> So, if we look at the actual numbers,
- 3:10the return of the S&P 500 through the
- 3:12third quarter is 13%.
- 3:13However, if we look at the average
- 3:15return of individual stocks, it is 1%.
- 3:17>> Aha.
- 3:17>> Also, half of the S&P 500 have declined
- 3:20; 250 stocks have fallen. Next, what
- 3:22about earnings? 85%of companies exceeded
- 3:24expectations, based on the third quarter
- 3:26earnings announcements.
- 3:28And the S&P 500's average annual EPS
- 3:30growth rate is 10%. However, as of the
- 3:32third quarter, the median value has
- 3:33already reached 10%. So, growth rates
- 3:35are expected to be higher than usual.
- 3:37Consequently, even though stock prices
- 3:39are low, earnings are rising across the
- 3:41board. As a result, 70%of S&P 500
- 3:43companies are seeing their P/E ratios
- 3:45fall compared to the beginning of the
- 3:46year.
- 3:47>> Hmm. From
- 3:48>> Bill Common's perspective, this
- 3:49situation is practically a feast laid
- 3:51out.
- 3:52It represents tremendous opportunities
- 3:54spread out like a vast plain.
- 3:56It means, "I couldn't buy shares of
- 3:57companies I like because they were too
- 3:59expensive, but whenever volatility
- 4:00explodes and they are cheap, I will
- 4:01scoop them up right then and there." It
- 4:02means he intends to "snatch up the
- 4:03>> dips." That is
- 4:04>> correct. This is the portfolio he
- 4:06disclosed. Now, the investment strategy
- 4:08Bill Leck Money mentioned is as follows
- 4:10.
- 4:11The area marked with a red box shows the
- 4:13Forward PR and Bill Leck Money's
- 4:14projected average annual EPS growth rate
- 4:16for the next 3 to 5 years for the stocks
- 4:18in his portfolio.
- 4:20If you look, the S&P 500's Forward PR is
- 4:22around 20 based on the data compilation
- 4:24standards at that time.
- 4:26The forward PR of Bileg Kman's portfolio
- 4:28is also around 20. Instead of matching
- 4:30the PR with the market, the S&P 500 is
- 4:32projected to have an annual average EPS
- 4:34growth of about 13%over the next 3 to 5
- 4:36years, whereas the growth of the stocks
- 4:38Bileg Kman forecasts is around 10 to 20
- 4:40%.
- 4:41So, the idea is to match the price to
- 4:42the market while maintaining a high
- 4:44growth rate.
- 4:45It is a strategy of securing a margin of
- 4:47safety while driving high growth, and
- 4:49the key here is hyper-scale.
- 4:52The weight of the top four stocks
- 4:54exceeds 50%.
- 4:56Even excluding Uber, Microsoft, Meta,
- 4:58and Amazon account for nearly 40%of the
- 5:00portfolio.
- 5:02He has gone all-in on Big Tech to this
- 5:04extent; you might ask why he is going
- 5:06all-in on Big Tech when they are
- 5:07spending so much money and not hearing
- 5:09good news about them.
- 5:11Bileg Kman's strategy, ever since the AI
- 5:13rally began, has essentially been to buy
- 5:14Big, Big Mill. He buys whenever Big Tech
- 5:16stocks fall.
- 5:17Regarding this strategy, he states that
- 5:19he views CapX positively, arguing that
- 5:21this is why Big Tech is currently being
- 5:23criticized.
- 5:26He explains that there are two types of
- 5:28CapX: defensive investments that
- 5:30structurally increase capital
- 5:32concentration to maintain operations and
- 5:34keep the company afloat, or aggressive
- 5:36investments aimed at securing high
- 5:38future returns.
- 5:39He believes that Big Tech currently
- 5:41falls into the latter category.
- 5:44However, since the market views them as
- 5:46the former, he argues that their
- 5:47valuations emphasize only costs while
- 5:49overlooking growth.
- 5:51In fact, this graph shows the market's
- 5:53projected revenue growth rates for
- 5:55Microsoft, Meta, and Amazon, compared to
- 5:57CapX's growth rate.
- 5:59Even looking at Microsoft alone, its
- 6:01revenue growth rate for this fiscal year
- 6:03is 18%, and it is expected to remain at
- 6:0518%next year.
- 6:07However, CapX grew by 65%this year and
- 6:10is projected to grow by 51%next year. In
- 6:13terms of revenue, CapX accounts for 44%
- 6:16of sales this year, and it will exceed
- 6:18half next year.
- 6:19Market expectations predicted that while
- 6:22revenue wouldn't grow significantly,
- 6:25expenses would increase, but that is
- 6:27incorrect.
- 6:29This is because they will generate
- 6:30growth commensurate with the money spent
- 6:32.
- 6:33Regarding this current investment, I
- 6:35have stated that while Big Tech is
- 6:37traditionally a tiger, they are now
- 6:38trying to grow wings.
- 6:40People currently assume they are
- 6:42investing to survive and secure a
- 6:43competitive advantage so they don't fall
- 6:44behind in AI. However, going further, I
- 6:46believe that this technological
- 6:48superiority leverages the existing
- 6:49strengths of Big Tech.
- 6:51Amazon has a massive distribution
- 6:52network, and the other Big Tech
- 6:53companies also have huge lock-in effects
- 6:55, as seen in platforms like YouTube.
- 6:58And needless to say, they have an
- 6:59enormous amount of data accumulated.
- 7:00I believe that if these factors create
- 7:03synergy with technological superiority,
- 7:05significant revenue growth will emerge.
- 7:08>> Yes.
- 7:08>> So, looking at individual companies,
- 7:11Amazon's Q3 earnings showed that AWS's
- 7:13growth rate was nearly 40%.
- 7:15>> So, the
- 7:15>> backlog has increased by almost 100%or
- 7:17more, reaching $ 600 billion.
- 7:20>> Yes.
- 7:21>> And does Amazon just stop at AWS? No,
- 7:24they have created something called
- 7:26MedLock, which primarily assists
- 7:28enterprises with AI inference services.
- 7:30They have selected foundation models to
- 7:33enable companies to build AI within them
- 7:35. And don't they make their own chips?
- 7:37They also develop agents. There is an
- 7:39e-commerce agent called Alexa for
- 7:42Shopping used in Amazon Commerce, and
- 7:44thanks to this, e-commerce performance
- 7:46has been quite good.
- 7:48>> Hmm. In
- 7:49>> this way, they are approaching AI almost
- 7:51entirely from a full-stack perspective,
- 7:53from chips to agents.
- 7:55Microsoft is also making a huge amount
- 7:57of money from its cloud business, and by
- 7:59integrating its AI services into
- 8:01first-party channels like Office 365,
- 8:03which are used directly by corporate
- 8:05customers, efficiency has improved
- 8:07tremendously.
- 8:09If you look at M365, the license growth
- 8:12rate more than doubled in six months
- 8:14after the introduction of Co-Pilot.
- 8:16>> Ah.
- 8:18>> In addition to investing in OpenAI,
- 8:20Microsoft also developed its own
- 8:22Foundation model.
- 8:25Furthermore, they manufacture Microsoft
- 8:27chips; they created the Maya chip and
- 8:29are also pursuing security-related
- 8:31projects. We are ushering in an AI era
- 8:32accessible to the general public. By
- 8:34taking a full-stack approach in this
- 8:35manner, they are generating massive
- 8:37revenue.
- 8:38In the case of Meta, revenue increased
- 8:40by 26%as AI has made ad matching and
- 8:42content recommendation algorithms more
- 8:44sophisticated. Also, wasn't Muse a major
- 8:47topic of conversation? It is a leader in
- 8:49commerce agents, and among the companies
- 8:51currently vying to become agents, none
- 8:53possess the capital strength comparable
- 8:56to Meta's.
- 8:58Nor do any other companies have a user
- 8:59base on par with Meta's.
- 9:01Meta simply needs to distribute its 4
- 9:04billion users.
- 9:06Moreover, among the companies publicly
- 9:08seeking to sell agents, no other company
- 9:10possesses the computing power to provide
- 9:12agent services to such a large number of
- 9:14users.
- 9:16Therefore, Meta is taking the lead
- 9:18unrivaled. Looking at this, aren't they
- 9:20all growing tremendously? As seen
- 9:22earlier, the market is ignoring this
- 9:23growth potential. They dismiss it by
- 9:25saying, "Isn't it just about spending
- 9:25money?" The
- 9:27>> money is going out right now, and they
- 9:28know they will be drained in the future
- 9:29, but they don't care about the future
- 9:31and just don't want the money to go out
- 9:32. That is
- 9:32>> correct.
- 9:33That is why Amazon, for instance,
- 9:35internally projects that AWS growth will
- 9:38exceed 40%by 2027 or 2028. They believe
- 9:40this aligns with their own calculated
- 9:42forecasts.
- 9:43The reason Big Tech is expected to
- 9:45maintain such high growth rates in the
- 9:47future is that, unlike traditional
- 9:48technological innovation, it was David
- 9:50killing Goliath.
- 9:52You know Bill Gates 'famous quote? He
- 9:54said that Microsoft's rivals right now
- 9:56are not other Silicon Valley
- 9:57conglomerates, but the startups
- 9:59currently operating in garages somewhere
- 10:00.
- 10:01That is because software doesn't require
- 10:04that much capital.
- 10:06That is how today's Big Tech companies
- 10:08started, too. Meta started that way as
- 10:10well. However, AI is a technology that
- 10:13requires a lot of money.
- 10:15It requires electricity, semiconductors
- 10:18, and data centers. That is why the
- 10:20prediction is that this time, it is not
- 10:22David who will kill Goliath, but Goliath
- 10:24who will kill David. Therefore, looking
- 10:26at their capital power, Big Tech is
- 10:28already the Goliath, so there are no
- 10:29challengers. Also, as I mentioned
- 10:31earlier in the Ray Dalio section, hasn't
- 10:33politics become a very important factor
- 10:35?
- 10:35Lobbying and negotiating with political
- 10:38circles regarding AI regulations is a
- 10:40very familiar task for Big Tech.
- 10:42>> Yes, they have always been doing it.
- 10:43That is
- 10:43>> correct. As regulations become
- 10:45increasingly strict, the landscape is
- 10:47shifting in a way where only Big Tech
- 10:49can survive.
- 10:50Furthermore, while people ask about the
- 10:52large investment amounts and why so much
- 10:53is being invested in data centers, I
- 10:55argue that I consider data centers to be
- 10:57a low-risk investment. A data center can
- 10:59be divided into buildings and equipment
- 11:00, excluding the building and land. The
- 11:02building is the primary component, and
- 11:03the equipment consists of things like
- 11:04servers and networks. In the case of the
- 11:05building, the investment amount is
- 11:06concentrated within the initial two-year
- 11:08period. For the remaining 30 years, the
- 11:10building can be used simply by
- 11:11performing minimal maintenance.
- 11:14While equipment still needs to be
- 11:15replaced continuously, you only need to
- 11:17purchase it a few months before
- 11:19operation begins.
- 11:20Consequently, the inventory risk
- 11:22associated with buying too much and then
- 11:24having excess stock due to failed demand
- 11:26forecasting is relatively low.
- 11:28From a Big Tech perspective, the
- 11:30lifespan of a server is 5 to 6 years;
- 11:35the first 3 years are for cost recovery
- 11:36—a break-even period—while the remaining
- 11:383 years are for generating cash flow,
- 11:39and the growth rate in this area is
- 11:40tremendous. In fact, if you look at
- 11:42Amazon, they currently have servers
- 11:44spanning five to six generations.
- 11:46Since Amazon's building investment is
- 11:48complete, the total investment amount is
- 11:50decreasing because, in their existing
- 11:51data centers, only the servers need to
- 11:53be replaced as generations repeat.
- 11:55However, as server performance continues
- 11:57to improve, profitability is increasing
- 11:58.
- 11:59Given this situation, the argument is
- 12:01that once the revenue growth rate
- 12:03surpasses the growth rate of incremental
- 12:05capital expenditure (Cap X), surplus
- 12:07cash and the ROIC—which is currently
- 12:09being pointed out as a weakness—will
- 12:11increase explosively.
- 12:14So, the Amazon CEO mentioned this
- 12:15recently, didn't he? That the payback
- 12:16period for AWS is getting shorter.
- 12:18>> Yes.
- 12:20So, in a way, it’s like investing
- 12:22heavily to build an oil refinery; once
- 12:24the refinery is actually finished, there
- 12:26are no additional costs involved, but as
- 12:28revenue starts to come in, profits
- 12:30suddenly improve.
- 12:32That is the scenario that could unfold.
- 12:34Actually, regarding when that point
- 12:36would be, I originally thought it could
- 12:37happen this year.
- 12:39There was talk that if memory prices
- 12:41hadn't risen this much and we hadn't
- 12:42been in a situation where we had to
- 12:44generate higher-than-expected profits
- 12:45from CapX, that could have happened this
- 12:47year.
- 12:51Anyway, it didn't happen this year, and
- 12:52while we don't know what will happen
- 12:53next year, looking back, it will
- 12:54eventually turn into money, right? Yes.
- 12:56>> This is the traditional approach of Big
- 12:58Tech, isn't it? Create demand first, and
- 13:00then if profits arise, add them later as
- 13:03needed. They are still making
- 13:04investments in this manner. They
- 13:06>> also mentioned that customers themselves
- 13:07don't know what they are lacking.
- 13:09>> So, while Big Tech buys whenever they
- 13:11fall behind like this, what else have
- 13:12they invested in besides that?
- 13:14Break One has invested very aggressively
- 13:16. They focus on concentrated investment
- 13:17, don't they? Their style involves
- 13:19carefully selecting stocks and investing
- 13:21in large quantities;
- 13:25they added seven new stocks in the third
- 13:26quarter alone, and reportedly added one
- 13:26more in the fourth quarter already.
- 13:28They have recently purchased eight new
- 13:30stocks, and among them, Uber is
- 13:32currently facing the unfair stigma that
- 13:34it will be replaced by autonomous
- 13:36driving and delivery agents.
- 13:39However, regarding autonomous driving,
- 13:41Uber has already independently launched
- 13:43and is expanding its own services.
- 13:45They are partnering with autonomous
- 13:46driving companies.
- 13:49As for delivery agents, there are
- 13:50concerns that the delivery platform Uber
- 13:52Eats will be replaced.
- 13:54But if you think about it, an agent
- 13:56doesn't just stop at placing an order,
- 13:58does they?
- 13:59>> That's right. They have to
- 14:00>> match customers, restaurants, and
- 14:01delivery drivers. That is the only way
- 14:03we can know things like, "Oh, when is
- 14:04the pizza coming?"
- 14:07This is a role that requires a platform
- 14:08. Since it cannot be replaced by a
- 14:11single agent, agents actually operate on
- 14:13the Uber Eats platform; the question is
- 14:14, would Uber Eats be replaced because of
- 14:16the agents?
- 14:18He said, "That makes no sense," pointing
- 14:20out that despite growing by 35%this year
- 14:22due to this factor, the forward P/E
- 14:24ratio is only 16. That is why he spoke
- 14:26highly of Uber and invested in Netflix
- 14:28again.
- 14:28He had previously invested in Netflix
- 14:30and lost about 30%, so he is making a
- 14:32fresh attempt.
- 14:33In the case of Netflix, it is currently
- 14:34facing criticism due to the negative
- 14:36factor of declining viewing time.
- 14:38However, Bill Ackman argues that the
- 14:40stage where it can be evaluated solely
- 14:41on viewing time has passed. This is
- 14:43because Netflix is now offering diverse
- 14:45content such as live streaming and games
- 14:47, and is transforming into a
- 14:48comprehensive content company; therefore
- 14:54, it is difficult to assess Netflix's
- 14:54value based on the traditional criterion
- 14:55of "Oh, I watched X hours of video."
- 14:55Furthermore, they are launching low-cost
- 14:57advertising plans and other initiatives
- 15:00, which is boosting revenue growth.
- 15:06On the other hand, Netflix is reducing
- 15:07the growth rate of its content spending
- 15:08, essentially saying, "We will spend
- 15:09less on creating content."
- 15:11Because they are saying that if this
- 15:13trend continues—where revenue increases
- 15:15while costs decrease—they are saying
- 15:18that EPS will grow at an annual average
- 15:20rate in the 20%range.
- 15:22However, since the forward P/E ratio is
- 15:24currently around 17, it implies that
- 15:25Netflix is undervalued. That is why they
- 15:27are saying they have re-entered the
- 15:28market.
- 15:29In addition, there are foodservice
- 15:30companies represented by Burger King.
- 15:32Burger King and Tim Hortons had been
- 15:34experiencing sluggish growth for a while
- 15:35, but their growth rates have risen
- 15:37again. In the case of Burger King, they
- 15:39succeeded in an internal improvement
- 15:41project.
- 15:41However, since the market has not yet
- 15:43reflected this in the price, they were
- 15:45also viewed as undervalued. As for Visa
- 15:46and Mastercard, there were concerns
- 15:48about agent replacement.
- 15:49People asked, "If agents replace them,
- 15:51people won't use credit cards, so won't
- 15:52these card companies go bankrupt?"
- 15:55However, the essence of these companies
- 15:57is not card companies but global payment
- 15:59networks. They are network companies.
- 16:01Therefore, agents operate on Visa and
- 16:02Mastercard payment platforms; would they
- 16:04really create their own payment
- 16:05platforms independently?
- 16:07So, it is said that they actually
- 16:09acquired Visa and Mastercard while
- 16:11claiming to be providing support.
- 16:13>> It is difficult to assume that agents
- 16:14will build the payment systems just
- 16:16because they are emerging. I think the
- 16:18question regarding what already exists
- 16:19is very important. It concerns what
- 16:21agents can and cannot replace. So, while
- 16:23it would be good to think about what
- 16:25agents can create, if we assume that the
- 16:27business models Visa and Mastercard have
- 16:28built up over the years will not be
- 16:30destroyed, I think there might be
- 16:31investment opportunities.
- 16:33>> Also, regarding ICE, as I mentioned last
- 16:34time following the war in Iran, there is
- 16:36a high possibility that the energy
- 16:37supply chain will be reorganized. Isn't
- 16:39it a representative commodity exchange?
- 16:41Consequently, commodity trading volume
- 16:42has increased significantly.
- 16:44That is why I said that it will benefit
- 16:46from geopolitical and international
- 16:48political factors. As for S&P Global, it
- 16:50is a credit rating agency, and since AI
- 16:52investments are currently being made
- 16:53through bond issuance, the demand for
- 16:55credit ratings is bound to increase. So
- 16:57, they are benefiting from this. In the
- 16:58case of S&P Global, they buy back 4%of
- 17:00their own shares annually.
- 17:03Considering these benefits and their
- 17:05strong shareholder returns, I bought
- 17:07Ford because I thought its PR was 20
- 17:08times cheap. Alcon is a representative
- 17:10ophthalmology company. It manufactures
- 17:12lenses and ophthalmic surgical equipment
- 17:14.
- 17:15In this case, the company's own earnings
- 17:16were good, but the sector it belongs to
- 17:18showed overall weakness, so it declined
- 17:20along with them.
- 17:22So, the sector is bad, but this company
- 17:24is doing well; yet Ford's PR is low
- 17:26relative to its growth, so I stated that
- 17:28I bought Alcon as well.
- 17:30>> Hmm.
- 17:31I've revealed quite a lot of stocks at
- 17:33once. Yes.
- 17:34>> That is all for Ekman's discussion. To
- 17:36add a little more of my thoughts: if
- 17:38shareholders are selling off cheap
- 17:39companies due to volatility, why aren't
- 17:41they buying semiconductors?
- 17:43Semiconductor valuations have become
- 17:45incredibly cheap right now, so of course
- 17:46, they could have bought them. The
- 17:48company they newly purchased in the
- 17:49fourth quarter could indeed be a
- 17:50semiconductor stock. However,
- 17:51considering what Bill Ackman has said in
- 17:53the past and the fact that he didn't buy
- 17:54even when semiconductors were cheap in
- 17:55the third quarter, it is highly likely
- 17:56that it wasn't semiconductors. There are
- 17:58two main reasons why he didn't buy. This
- 18:02is a phenomenon that has long been
- 18:03observed among value investors: he
- 18:05didn't enter the market even though the
- 18:07Forward PR was low and it seemed like he
- 18:08should.
- 18:10This is because the Forward PR is an
- 18:12indicator based on market revenue
- 18:13forecasts.
- 18:15However, if the market itself is
- 18:16overheated, then the market's revenue
- 18:18forecasts are bound to be inflated as
- 18:20well. Therefore, he is saying that he
- 18:22cannot trust the forward PR at face
- 18:23value. The second reason is the issue of
- 18:26demand destruction. In short, he is
- 18:28questioning where the economic moat is
- 18:30anymore. Since semiconductors are making
- 18:32a huge amount of money, many companies
- 18:33are thinking, "I want to get a piece of
- 18:34the pie too."
- 18:35In the past, even just regarding memory
- 18:37semiconductors, it was an oligopoly
- 18:38dominated by Samsung, SK Hynix, and
- 18:39Micron, but now there are reports of
- 18:41Tera fabs coming out. Companies like
- 18:42Changxin from China are also emerging,
- 18:44and aren't there many companies saying,
- 18:45"Hey, let me jump on the bandwagon"? As
- 18:47a result, if competition intensifies,
- 18:49and in the case of Cerabrass, they might
- 18:51decide to use an entire wafer, the more
- 18:53expensive semiconductor prices become—
- 18:55you know, there is a phenomenon called "
- 18:57demand destruction" in raw materials.
- 19:00When raw materials become too expensive
- 19:01, demand decreases or substitute demand
- 19:03arises, causing prices to drop; this can
- 19:05also happen in the semiconductor
- 19:07industry.
- 19:08Usually, what prevents this is an
- 19:09economic hazard, but regarding
- 19:10semiconductors, he says he doesn't know
- 19:12. That is because Virek Kman is not
- 19:14someone with insight into cards. That is
- 19:16why he avoided it, and it is
- 19:17>> right not to do things you don't know
- 19:18well. That is
- 19:19>> correct. On the other hand, he has
- 19:20insight in this area. In the future, the
- 19:22number of spoons will increase
- 19:23significantly.
- 19:24For example, if I used to share a pizza
- 19:25with three people, but now eight people
- 19:27share it, my share decreases, but the
- 19:28pizza size becomes ten times larger.
- 19:31Even though eight people share it, my
- 19:32portion is larger than when I shared it
- 19:34with three people.
- 19:35So, such a phenomenon could occur. So,
- 19:37if you have insight into this kind of
- 19:39situation, the upside is actually higher
- 19:41when there is uncertainty. I wanted to
- 19:43mention that point.
- 19:45Next, regarding Bea Reckman's investment
- 19:47method, it is actually a method I have
- 19:49greatly enjoyed using since the end of
- 19:51last year.
- 19:53Honestly, I believe directional betting
- 19:55is difficult in a market like this.
- 19:58Usually, people bet on direction by
- 19:59buying when they think the market is
- 20:01going to rise, and either not investing
- 20:02or selling when they think it will fall
- 20:04for a while. However, it is difficult to
- 20:06predict the market right now. This graph
- 20:08shows the following: the blue bar graph
- 20:09represents days when the market moved up
- 20:11or down by more than 3%, and the gray
- 20:12bar graph represents days when it moved
- 20:14by more than 5%.
- 20:16Looking at the period from 1999 to the
- 20:18present, this year is arguably the most
- 20:21volatile year in the last 27 years
- 20:23>> in the US. That is
- 20:24>> correct. The market is currently highly
- 20:26volatile, and the KOSPI is likely no
- 20:28different.
- 20:28>> In fact, even if the KOSPI moved by more
- 20:30than 10%, the results would probably
- 20:32still look like this.
- 20:33Yes.
- 20:34It has truly been a ridiculous year.
- 20:36That is
- 20:37>> correct.
- 20:39The volatility is so high right now that
- 20:41betting on the direction of the market
- 20:43doesn't yield a high success rate, in my
- 20:45opinion.
- 20:47So, instead of betting based on whether
- 20:48the index will rise, whether the market
- 20:50will be good or bad, or whether it will
- 20:52go up or down, if volatility explodes
- 20:53and you think, "Oh, this is a company I
- 20:55really like with strong fundamentals,
- 20:57and it has become very cheap," buying at
- 20:58that moment could be a good choice.
- 21:01Alternatively, if you intend to bet on
- 21:02direction in that way, you should set a
- 21:04very short time horizon. One of the
- 21:06characteristics of the market these days
- 21:07is that while volatility is high, if,
- 21:09for example, the US market opens and you
- 21:10set the direction upward, the direction
- 21:13tends to stay one way without changing
- 21:15midway—at least for that day's direction
- 21:17.
- 21:18So, unless you are going to engage in
- 21:20day trading or set a very short time
- 21:21horizon, rather than betting on
- 21:22direction, it is better to think
- 21:24long-term: "Oh, this is a good company
- 21:25that has become cheap." I think deciding
- 21:27to buy at this moment would be a good
- 21:29strategy.
- 21:30>> Yes. So, rather than following the trend
- 21:32, the idea is to buy when the price is
- 21:33low.
- 21:34>> Yes, that is correct. Also, Ekman placed
- 21:35a great deal of emphasis on agents.
- 21:38So, regarding the current landscape of
- 21:40agents, I believe we are seeing the
- 21:42emergence of three main types of
- 21:44entities. The first are companies that
- 21:46possess both a platform and proprietary
- 21:48models or agents. These are Big Tech
- 21:49firms. They have their own proprietary
- 21:51platforms and have also developed their
- 21:52own independent agents. The second type
- 21:54consists of companies that have a
- 21:55platform but lack a proprietary model.
- 21:57Companies like Salesforce or Robinhood
- 21:59have dominant platforms but lack
- 22:01unrivaled AI technological capabilities
- 22:03. The third type consists of companies
- 22:04that do not have a platform but possess
- 22:05a proprietary model. Companies like
- 22:07OpenAI or Entropic fall into this
- 22:09category.
- 22:10So, regarding the goals these companies
- 22:12are pursuing, first, the first group—
- 22:14Big Tech firms—are defending their own
- 22:15territory and then attempting to expand
- 22:17their territory outward.
- 22:19In the case of Meta, they first intend
- 22:21to embed agents within their internal
- 22:23services to improve efficiency, and then
- 22:26sell it externally.
- 22:27That is why Amazon rejected Meta's
- 22:29partnership offer, isn't it? Their
- 22:31approach is essentially, "Do you think
- 22:31I'm crazy enough to use your agents? We
- 22:32need to build our own agents and protect
- 22:34our voice first. We can sell our Alexa
- 22:35agents externally later."
- 22:39Secondly, since these companies possess
- 22:41platforms but lack their own proprietary
- 22:43models, they tend to leverage external
- 22:44models to firmly secure their voice.
- 22:46Salesforce is a dominant service in
- 22:48customer management, isn't it?
- 22:51However, they have now created an agent
- 22:53service called Agentforce, and this is
- 22:54significantly boosting revenue.
- 22:57It is experiencing a boom, with agent
- 22:59usage increasing by triple-digit
- 23:01percentages on a quarter-on-quarter
- 23:03basis.
- 23:04Here is how this service was created.
- 23:07For standardized questions that are easy
- 23:09to answer, we use open-weight models to
- 23:11process them at a low cost, and when
- 23:12some inference is required, we utilize
- 23:14frontier models in combination to
- 23:15optimize costs to the lowest possible
- 23:17level. That
- 23:18>> depends on the difficulty of the
- 23:19question.
- 23:20>> That is how we utilize external models
- 23:21to build agents and firmly defend our
- 23:23position in Seongwoo. The third models,
- 23:25however, are trying to break into other
- 23:27companies' castles just by receiving an
- 23:28Entry listing report. They are
- 23:29essentially attacking, saying, "Hey, you
- 23:30guys buy our agent service. Buy ours."
- 23:32That is correct. So, looking at it this
- 23:34way, Number 1 and Number 3 are bound to
- 23:36clash in external territories when it
- 23:37comes to sales.
- 23:38>> Hmm.
- 23:39>> So, when this showdown occurs, while
- 23:41performance is important, who can
- 23:43control costs better will likely be the
- 23:44deciding factor in the competition
- 23:46between Number 1 and Number 3.
- 23:50>> Good.
- 23:51I have been thinking about how to invest
- 23:53now that the era of agents has arrived.
- 23:57>> Yes, that is correct. I mentioned Ray
- 23:58Dalio, didn't I? Birken Mondo wasn't
- 24:00overly worried about the political
- 24:02midterm elections. He wasn't concerned;
- 24:04rather than a complete ban, the
- 24:05discussion revolved around whether they
- 24:06would actually ban it.
- 24:08In fact, from an economic perspective,
- 24:10the data center issue is a perfect
- 24:12example of an externality.
- 24:15If you look at it, the profits generated
- 24:17solely from data centers are taken by
- 24:18giant Big Tech corporations, while local
- 24:20residents bear the burden of rising
- 24:22electricity bills, noise pollution, and
- 24:23environmental destruction.
- 24:26That is why, when such externalities
- 24:28occur, they are usually not eliminated
- 24:30entirely but undergo an adjustment
- 24:32process.
- 24:33So, regarding data center regulations,
- 24:35this isn't about the Democratic Party
- 24:37blocking all data centers; rather, it
- 24:39will likely become a matter of adjusting
- 24:41externalities—balancing profits and
- 24:43losses.
- 24:44For instance, if you look at the bill
- 24:45recently passed in the Senate, it
- 24:47accelerates power and infrastructure
- 24:48services and grants permits immediately
- 24:50.
- 24:51However, it includes provisions
- 24:52requiring the data center business and
- 24:55local residents to properly share the
- 24:57profits and losses. Therefore, people
- 24:59keep worrying, asking, "If the
- 25:00Democratic Party comes into power, won't
- 25:01we be unable to build data centers?"
- 25:03Rather than that, you should view it as
- 25:04a process of adjusting for external
- 25:05effects. I think it is safe to
- 25:07>> assume that while the direction is
- 25:09maintained, the pace might slow down a
- 25:11bit.
- 25:11>> When looking at tech regulations, when
- 25:13this topic first emerges, the political
- 25:15sphere attacks them very harshly.
- 25:17They summon Big Tech executives and CEOs
- 25:19, beat them up, and promise extremely
- 25:20strict regulations, but when you look at
- 25:22the bills that actually pass, the
- 25:24intensity of the regulations often ends
- 25:25up being significantly weaker.
- 25:27>> Yes. It would be
- 25:28>> good to keep this pattern in mind.
- 25:30>> Understood. Today, Eric and I had a
- 25:32conversation about the masters for the
- 25:34first time in a while.
- 25:35In particular, I hope you will take note
- 25:38of the wisdom of Howard Marks and the
- 25:40stocks recommended by figures like Bill
- 25:42Ackman when making your investments.
- 25:45I will see you again next time. Thank
- 25:48you.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 모두가 흔들리는 장에서 빌 애크먼은 오히려 지갑을 열었습니다… 변동성이 터질 때마다 주워 담은 종목 [구루 11월 - 빌 애크먼] by 이효석아카데미, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 5,059 words across 873 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.