11. De la reconstruction aux grands ensembles — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:15So, I have titled this presentation "
- 0:17From Reconstruction to Large Housing
- 0:18Projects," and I have subtitled it "
- 0:20Triumph and Deviation of the Principles
- 0:22of Modern Architecture and Urban
- 0:24Planning." So, why "from reconstruction
- 0:25to large housing projects"? First,
- 0:27because these are two periods—
- 0:29reconstruction and the large housing
- 0:30projects—that are often confused. It
- 0:33is true that they partially overlap in
- 0:35time. The operation of the large
- 0:37housing projects began while
- 0:38reconstruction was not yet finished.
- 0:41But these are two periods with
- 0:42completely different stakes, and as we
- 0:45will see, where the modern movement was
- 0:47called upon in very different ways. And
- 0:50that is why I titled it—or rather,
- 0:52why I used the subtitle "Triumph and
- 0:53Deviation of the Principles of Modern
- 0:55Architecture and Urban Planning."
- 0:56Because this moment of transition from
- 0:59reconstruction to large housing
- 1:01projects also seems to me to be the
- 1:03moment when modern architecture
- 1:05transitioned from the avant-garde
- 1:07status it held between the wars to a
- 1:09status of dominant architecture. And
- 1:12this status of dominant architecture,
- 1:15it would not keep for very long, since
- 1:17by the mid-1970s, the very principles
- 1:19of the modern movement were being
- 1:21challenged, and even the death of the
- 1:23modern movement—I will end with that
- 1:26shortly—was proclaimed in the mid-70s
- 1:28. So, this issue of moving from
- 1:31reconstruction to large housing
- 1:33projects, this privileged moment, is
- 1:35also an important moment for the life
- 1:38of the modern movement itself. And it
- 1:40is this dual aspect that I would like
- 1:43to address this evening. So, to truly
- 1:46understand this issue, which
- 1:49essentially takes place between 1953
- 1:53and 1973, we must, however, go back
- 1:58further, notably to the 1930s and to
- 2:00what Le Corbusier calls a "broken
- 2:03equilibrium." I will speak often of Le
- 2:06Corbusier because he is, first of all,
- 2:08a major player in the emergence of the
- 2:10principles of the modern movement and
- 2:12also because of the works he left
- 2:14behind. But also because Le Corbusier
- 2:17has this very practical trait: he
- 2:19published over 50 books, gave an
- 2:21incredible number of lectures and
- 2:22articles, and thus expressed himself on
- 2:24just about every subject, and he is
- 2:26certainly the architect who has
- 2:27published the most in the entire
- 2:29history of architecture since the
- 2:31beginning of time. And so in 1921, Le
- 2:34Corbusier declares in one of his texts:
- 2:36"The mechanism is profoundly disrupted,
- 2:39swaying between an important
- 2:41improvement or a catastrophe.""The
- 2:43various active classes of society no
- 2:45longer have suitable shelter, neither
- 2:47the worker nor the intellectual." And
- 2:49what is already interesting in this
- 2:51sentence is that Le Corbusier presents
- 2:53the situation as being the situation of
- 2:55housing and housing for the greatest
- 2:57number. And we will see that the issue
- 2:59of this transition from reconstruction
- 3:01to large housing projects is
- 3:02essentially the issue of housing. It's
- 3:04not just an urban problem. Le Corbusier
- 3:07puts it in very harsh terms, in very
- 3:10threatening terms, since he speaks of a
- 3:13deeply disrupted mechanism, he speaks
- 3:16of an imminent catastrophe. And it's
- 3:19true that the housing situation for the
- 3:21French in the 20s, and throughout the
- 3:23interwar period for that matter, is
- 3:26absolutely catastrophic. The images you
- 3:29have here are images taken in Paris
- 3:31between 1910 and the mid-to early 30s.
- 3:35The caravans we see on the right were
- 3:36taken, well, the photo was taken near
- 3:38the Porte d'Italie. We are either
- 3:42facing urban centers in a state of
- 3:45decay and absolutely catastrophic
- 3:47unsanitary conditions, or urban
- 3:50peripheries and areas that are
- 3:52shantytowns, with quite makeshift
- 3:55construction, or at best, extremely
- 3:58mediocre housing. And this situation
- 4:01persists throughout the interwar period
- 4:03, and Le Corbusier will return to it
- 4:05very, very often. He is not the only
- 4:07one, as we will see, but he will return
- 4:08very often to this issue. In 1935, the
- 4:10sentiment is roughly the same. When he
- 4:13says a million men live in the hopeless
- 4:15slums of old Paris, another million
- 4:17endure the hard life of the hopeless
- 4:19suburbs. And this situation, as we can
- 4:22still see with this snapshot, also
- 4:24taken near the Porte d'Italie, is truly
- 4:30an extremely harsh situation, and a few
- 4:32figures allow us to better understand
- 4:34and grasp it. There were 87 deaths per
- 4:38year per 10,000 inhabitants in Holland
- 4:41in the mid-30s. And at the same time in
- 4:44France, it was 153 deaths per year per
- 4:4610,000 inhabitants. France was probably
- 4:49, at that time, the so-called developed
- 4:52country with one of the highest
- 4:54mortality rates in the world. And this
- 4:58is largely due to tuberculosis and the
- 5:01unsanitary conditions in urban centers
- 5:04and on the outskirts of large cities.
- 5:08And this situation, in fact, this
- 5:11broken balance that Le Corbusier speaks
- 5:14of, probably dates back to the 19th
- 5:16century with the consequences of the
- 5:19Industrial Revolution and the
- 5:22population shifts and migrations it
- 5:24caused. So, the situation is quite
- 5:29catastrophic, and yet the French state
- 5:34and French local authorities have taken
- 5:37a certain number of measures. There
- 5:39were a number of laws, starting with
- 5:42the Siegfried Law in 1894, the first
- 5:44law on social housing, then the Ribot
- 5:46Law, the Bonnevay Law, and others. The
- 5:49Loucheur Law also in 1928. The Loucheur
- 5:53Act is certainly remembered as one of
- 5:55the most significant, as it remains in
- 5:57the collective memory of our parents or
- 6:00grandparents; we still talk about it
- 6:02because it allowed for the construction
- 6:05of 230,000 homes in France over roughly
- 6:0710 years, between 1928 and the war,
- 6:09which is significant. But, as we shall
- 6:14see, compared to the needs of the
- 6:16French territory, which would truly be
- 6:18addressed after the Second World War,
- 6:20these 230,000 homes would seem
- 6:22completely insignificant. So, there are
- 6:26laws, but these laws are relatively
- 6:28poorly adapted and they do not allow,
- 6:30at least quantitatively and also
- 6:32qualitatively of course, to meet this
- 6:34challenge. That is why we can speak of
- 6:37a neglected issue. Obviously, there are
- 6:40a certain number of actions being taken
- 6:44, and we notably think of what is
- 6:46happening in the Paris region with the
- 6:49work led by Henri Sellier, but that is
- 6:52truly not enough to address this
- 6:55housing issue. In France, between 1919
- 7:00and 1925, there were 18,000 or so new
- 7:03HBM-type homes. At the same time, in
- 7:07Germany, there were 808,000 homes, 75%
- 7:09of which were built with public
- 7:11subsidies. The major German cities
- 7:14established architecture and urban
- 7:16planning departments and entrusted
- 7:18architects of the modern movement to
- 7:21build large housing estates. The same
- 7:23is true in Holland, but that is
- 7:25absolutely not the case in France. And
- 7:27we even see that in Belgium, which is
- 7:29much smaller than France and has far
- 7:31fewer inhabitants, 152,000 social-type
- 7:33homes were built during that same
- 7:34period. So we are really completely
- 7:37behind, and this is due to several
- 7:39reasons, notably the freezing of rents
- 7:41between the two wars. First granted to
- 7:44the soldiers to help them, it was then
- 7:46eventually extended to the entire
- 7:48housing stock. And to the fact that
- 7:51these laws are not well-designed, so
- 7:54the private sector doesn't invest in
- 7:57housing either, and the state doesn't
- 7:59really consider it one of its missions
- 8:02to tackle the issue of social housing.
- 8:06Now, some people are obviously becoming
- 8:09aware of this difficulty and the need
- 8:11to change scale. To move from isolated
- 8:14operations. There have been operations,
- 8:17we know of them as early as the 19th
- 8:19century, where a certain segment of the
- 8:21business world tried to set up a number
- 8:23of housing developments in the east of
- 8:26France or in the north of France. Then
- 8:28there are all the private foundations,
- 8:30the Saint-Ger, Polignac, Rothschild
- 8:32foundations, and so on. But each time,
- 8:35these are operations involving a few
- 8:37dozen or even a few hundred, 200 or 300
- 8:39units at most. But these are isolated
- 8:43operations with no real effect on the
- 8:45housing situation. And that is why
- 8:48others are now considering a change in
- 8:50scale. And the term "grands ensembles"
- 8:54appears for the first time in*
- 8:56L'Architecture d'aujourd'hui*, in issue
- 8:59number 6 from June 1935, written by
- 9:01Maurice Rotival, an urban planner who
- 9:04was not part of the CIAM, nor the
- 9:06avant-garde of reformist urban planners
- 9:09, but a skilled planner who worked in
- 9:12France and abroad. And in this long
- 9:15article, in an issue almost entirely
- 9:18devoted to the question of social
- 9:20housing, Maurice Rotival uses the
- 9:22notion of "grand ensemble" for the
- 9:24first time and provides an initial
- 9:26definition. As we see in the arguments
- 9:28he develops for this definition, one of
- 9:31them is linking the question of housing
- 9:33to the question of urban planning.
- 9:36Building low-cost housing means doing
- 9:38urban planning at the same time. It
- 9:41means creating the city. It is no
- 9:42longer about acting through isolated
- 9:44operations, identifying a plot, and
- 9:46building a structure on it. It is about
- 9:48thinking of housing in relation to the
- 9:50entire city, its development, and the
- 9:53facilities that must also accompany it.
- 9:56It is therefore a complete change in
- 9:58scale that is proposed through this
- 9:59definition of "grand ensemble." Another
- 10:02argument put forward, though it boils
- 10:04down to the first, is to avoid partial
- 10:06developments. Inscribing operations
- 10:10into concerted development plans,
- 10:11meaning truly anticipating the growth
- 10:13of the city and even the territory. The
- 10:17planning ideas of territory planning
- 10:20and urban planning were concepts
- 10:22championed in the 30s by a number of
- 10:24architects, urban planners, and
- 10:26politicians, from both left-wing and
- 10:28right-wing circles. And so, the
- 10:32question of "grands ensembles" must,
- 10:34for Maurice Rotival, fit into an even
- 10:37broader vision at the territorial scale
- 10:39. We also find in the arguments used by
- 10:44Maurice Rotival points that are shared
- 10:47by avant-garde urban planners, even
- 10:49those of the Athens Charter. For
- 10:53example, hierarchy of traffic routes:
- 10:56this actually means truly opening the
- 10:58city and its development to automobile
- 11:01traffic, integrating the automobile
- 11:03into urban planning and the design of
- 11:06our cities, and freeing cities from all
- 11:09commercial elements. Behind this idea,
- 11:14it is also a way of talking about
- 11:16zoning, a term we find in the division
- 11:19based on the Athens Charter. He also
- 11:23speaks of concentrating services in the
- 11:25vicinity of motorways. It is still this
- 11:29idea of organizing the city based on
- 11:32car traffic and also separating
- 11:34functions, and therefore planning a
- 11:37city that is now very mobile, where
- 11:39services—both shops and public
- 11:42services—must be next to major
- 11:44traffic routes. And finally, laying out
- 11:48numerous sports grounds; it is the idea
- 11:50of a green city that can also be found
- 11:52in the Athens Charter, which is
- 11:53expressed here. And it is also the idea
- 11:57that building housing is inseparable
- 12:00from simultaneously building sports
- 12:03grounds, cultural buildings, local
- 12:06services, shops, and planning traffic
- 12:09flow. So, in the work proposed by
- 12:12Rotival, there is already a separation
- 12:14of functions, but at the same time, the
- 12:17desire to take all functions into
- 12:19account once you tackle this issue. And
- 12:22the conclusion of Maurice Rotival's
- 12:25article is that this is how we will
- 12:27manage to restore the morale of the
- 12:29working population in large cities and
- 12:32avoid gradually turning the inhabitants
- 12:34into true rebels. We see where the
- 12:37stakes lie. The stakes are enormous.
- 12:39That is to say that slums, unsanitary
- 12:41blocks, and the peripheries of large
- 12:44cities appear as places of insecurity
- 12:47and a real social threat. And to
- 12:49overcome these difficulties, the
- 12:51solution of so-called "grands ensembles
- 12:53" is proposed. What is quite
- 12:55paradoxical is that today everything
- 12:57has reversed, since the "grand ensemble
- 13:00" is considered the new place of
- 13:02insecurity and potential revolt. And in
- 13:06the threat found in Maurice Rotival's
- 13:08conclusion, there is an echo of the
- 13:10phrase Le Corbusier had already uttered
- 13:13back in 1923, perhaps with a bit more
- 13:15effectiveness, when he said: "The
- 13:17social cog, deeply disturbed,
- 13:19oscillates between a project of
- 13:21historical importance or a catastrophe.
- 13:23""It is a question of building that is
- 13:27the key to the disrupted balance today:
- 13:29architecture or revolution." And this
- 13:33choice—this alternative between "
- 13:35architecture or revolution," which
- 13:38almost became the title of Le
- 13:40Corbusier's first work, *Toward an
- 13:42Architecture*—clearly shows what Le
- 13:45Corbusier's major stake is for
- 13:47contemporary architecture: the question
- 13:49of housing, the housing of the greatest
- 13:52number, and the contemporary city (they
- 13:54go together). And I would say that the
- 13:58future, or rather the perspective we
- 14:00now have on the 20th century, has shown
- 14:02that these reformist architects were
- 14:04right. The question of housing was the
- 14:07major issue of 20 th-century
- 14:08architecture. It is around the issue of
- 14:11housing that the evolution of
- 14:12contemporary architecture, and modern
- 14:14architecture in particular, took place.
- 14:16And today, housing remains a major
- 14:19challenge. We can clearly see this with
- 14:21a global population that has only
- 14:23recently become majority urban, and a
- 14:25global population that is growing
- 14:26exponentially. So the analysis they
- 14:29made was correct. Architecture or
- 14:32revolution; we see this threat there
- 14:34too, and it is a threat that was really
- 14:36felt during the interwar period and
- 14:39even before; one only needs to reread
- 14:41the novels of Émile Zola. We see
- 14:44clearly in Zola’s stories, within the
- 14:47French bourgeoisie, this fear of the "
- 14:49grand soir," this fear of a revolution.
- 14:53So, there is really this fear behind it
- 14:55, and then there is also, above all,
- 14:58this fantastic utopia contained in this
- 15:00alternative: architecture or revolution
- 15:03. Le Corbusier does not answer "let's
- 15:06have a revolution"; on the contrary, he
- 15:07says "we will respond with architecture
- 15:09and urban planning." We can avoid the
- 15:11revolution. And that is the great
- 15:13utopia of the modern movement. And the
- 15:16great utopia of these proposals is to
- 15:19think that through architecture and
- 15:21quality urban planning, we can
- 15:23alleviate difficulties and avoid social
- 15:26revolt. So it is giving architecture
- 15:30and urban planning an extremely
- 15:31powerful political reach. Therefore,
- 15:35the stakes are truly significant in the
- 15:37initial definition, I would say, of
- 15:39these large housing projects. So, Le
- 15:42Corbusier is one of the major players
- 15:45in the reflection on modern urban
- 15:48planning during this interwar period.
- 15:51The first of these works is*Urbanisme*
- 15:53in 1925. In*Precisions on the Present
- 15:57State of Architecture and City Planning
- 15:59*, published in 1929, there isn't just
- 16:01urban planning; there are important
- 16:02elements, notably the definition of the
- 16:04"green city" concept, which he would
- 16:06later dedicate a work to with*The
- 16:08Radiant City*or*Green City*, which
- 16:09would appear in 1932. But, beyond these
- 16:14works, in reality, Le Corbusier never
- 16:16stopped talking about this modern
- 16:18urbanism and was truly the spokesperson
- 16:20for this reformist and modern urbanism
- 16:23up until the Athens Charter, which
- 16:25explains why today, Le Corbusier is
- 16:27very often used as a scapegoat whenever
- 16:29there is a problem. And as proof, in
- 16:332005, when the riots occurred in the
- 16:35suburbs, you remember, Jean-François
- 16:37Copé, who was government spokesperson
- 16:39at the time, stated on France Inter
- 16:41that it was Le Corbusier's fault, and
- 16:43he repeated it a year later, when we
- 16:45talked about those riots again in 2006.
- 16:49Thus, a direct link is established
- 16:51between large housing complexes and the
- 16:53modern movement, and Le Corbusier in
- 16:56particular. That is why it is
- 16:58interesting to look back at a certain
- 17:00number of elements from Le Corbusier's
- 17:03texts. And I will return more
- 17:05specifically to a chapter which is, in
- 17:07fact, an "anti-urbanism." It is a
- 17:12little-known chapter that I believe
- 17:13isn't talked about enough, and it is a
- 17:15very curious chapter because the text,
- 17:17as you can see, is very short. It’s
- 17:20three paragraphs, no more. And most—
- 17:23well, not most—all of the
- 17:25illustrations, I’ll show a few, are
- 17:27taken from this work, which is a
- 17:29natural history and biology book by
- 17:31Gaston Bonnier, and this book is in the
- 17:34library of the Le Corbusier Foundation.
- 17:37Le Corbusier had bought it, and so this
- 17:41article is illustrated exclusively with
- 17:44anatomical plates or plant biology
- 17:47plates. And behind it lies a message
- 17:51that, in my opinion, is one of Le
- 17:53Corbusier's essential messages
- 17:54regarding contemporary urbanism. And
- 17:56already in the very short introductory
- 17:58text, there is this sentence that seems
- 18:01essential to me, which says, "The whole
- 18:03only lives through the cell.""The cell
- 18:05derives its efficiency from the fact
- 18:07that it is admissible within the whole.
- 18:09" And what Le Corbusier means by this
- 18:11is that close relationship which, for
- 18:14him, is essential in his architecture
- 18:17but also in modern urbanism. This
- 18:19relationship between the individual and
- 18:21the collective. Meaning that this
- 18:23balance between the individual and the
- 18:25collective must be at the heart of
- 18:27reflection on the city, and that one
- 18:28cannot think about an element without
- 18:30thinking about the whole; that one
- 18:32cannot think about housing without
- 18:34thinking about the city; that one
- 18:35cannot think about the city without
- 18:37thinking about regional planning. It is
- 18:39also that dimension. And all the plates
- 18:43confirm this statement and foreshadow
- 18:46the elements that would be in the
- 18:48Athens Charter. He notably publishes
- 18:52this representation of the digestive
- 18:55system and, from this, what he draws is
- 18:59: "Precise, characterized organ,
- 19:01logical sequencing of operations." It
- 19:05is, in fact, a definition—the best
- 19:07possible definition—of functionalism.
- 19:10Functionalism cannot be reduced to
- 19:12Sullivan’s "form follows function"
- 19:15formula, which, in my opinion, had
- 19:17absolutely nothing to do with what we
- 19:19think of it today; the true origin of
- 19:22this term is, in reality, biological
- 19:24and medical. It was people like Darwin,
- 19:28like Lamarck, who first spoke of
- 19:31functionalism by presenting the
- 19:33relationship that unites, or rather the
- 19:36autonomy that each organ has within an
- 19:39organism. Each organ is treated and
- 19:41designed to respond to a precise
- 19:43function, with a shape, a material, and
- 19:45a color that serves its function. And
- 19:47then, each organ occupies a precise
- 19:50place within the organism. And so,
- 19:52proper functioning depends on this
- 19:54relationship between the organ and the
- 19:55organism. From this, Le Corbusier would
- 19:58essentially draw a lesson in
- 20:00functionalist urbanism by defining the
- 20:03concept of zoning. Meaning that you can
- 20:06imagine a city here with its various
- 20:08functions. So each one is treated
- 20:10separately, but if you don't have a
- 20:12connection between the organs, it
- 20:14doesn't work, and therefore you cannot
- 20:17treat one organ independently of the
- 20:19others. So we clearly have the concept
- 20:22of zoning, the question of the
- 20:23relationship of the unit to the whole,
- 20:25and also incidentally, here we will
- 20:27speak more about architecture. For him,
- 20:30this drawing represents the abandonment
- 20:32of the notion of classical composition.
- 20:35Meaning that this organism is not
- 20:37governed by the right angle, symmetry,
- 20:40or any specific order. The organs are
- 20:43where they need to be. They have the
- 20:46shape they must have and therefore
- 20:48escape any rule of harmonic composition
- 20:50as taught at the School of Fine Arts.
- 20:53This is what Le Corbusier also finds in
- 20:55a car engine, hence the machinist
- 20:57analogy as well. Another plate from
- 21:01this urbanism appendix is this
- 21:03representation of the heart and lungs.
- 21:06It's how the vital central organ
- 21:08distributes the green zones that are on
- 21:10the sides. Direct and precise
- 21:12relationship between two independent
- 21:13functions. We sleep at night in the
- 21:15garden cities. Undisturbed harmony. So
- 21:18it is always this question of the
- 21:19relationship of the element to the
- 21:21whole and of zoning. And then he also
- 21:24reproduces this plate. Here is the
- 21:26plate in Bonnie's book. You can even
- 21:28see, I don't know if you can see it
- 21:30from afar, the outline Le Corbusier
- 21:32made for the printer so they would know
- 21:34exactly how to reproduce this drawing.
- 21:37And here is the entire importance of
- 21:39circulation. It will be one of the
- 21:42chapters of the Athens Charter. The
- 21:43importance of flows, and also the
- 21:45hierarchy of flows, from the heart to
- 21:48the capillaries, passing through the
- 21:50arteries and veins. And he adds the
- 21:52legend: transport, motor center,
- 21:54collector, main cross-route,
- 21:56marshalling yard, service. That is what
- 21:58he sees in this plate. So, these are
- 22:01all the principles of an organic or
- 22:03functionalist urbanism—the two terms
- 22:05are interchangeable—that are
- 22:07implemented in this appendix. And Le
- 22:10Corbusier would translate this in the
- 22:1350s into the famous 7 V rule, which
- 22:15ranges from the V1, the major
- 22:17interurban highway, to the V7, which is
- 22:20the internal street within the housing
- 22:23units. These principles can be found
- 22:26partly in the Athens Charter, which was
- 22:28drafted by the CIAM, not just by Le
- 22:31Corbusier. And the CIAM program and the
- 22:34various congresses that took place
- 22:37confirm the major interest of these
- 22:40architects in the issue of housing. The
- 22:43first congress in '29 focused on the
- 22:47minimum dwelling, the very cell of
- 22:51human habitat. In 1930 in Brussels, the
- 22:54scale changed from the cell to the
- 22:57housing development. Then, in 1933,
- 23:00came the Athens Charter, which served
- 23:01as the charter for urbanism. We changed
- 23:04scale again to the design of the entire
- 23:06city. And in '37, the last congress
- 23:10before the war, the theme was housing
- 23:13and leisure, meaning what we put at the
- 23:16foot of the buildings—what Le
- 23:18Corbusier called "extensions," which he
- 23:21considered inseparable from the housing
- 23:23itself. You cannot create housing
- 23:26without also creating its extensions at
- 23:28the foot of the building; hence,
- 23:30housing and leisure. The whole thing is
- 23:34largely summarized in the Athens
- 23:36Charter, an important text that would
- 23:38truly establish itself as a
- 23:40foundational book for architects and
- 23:43urban planners after World War II. It
- 23:46was drafted in 1933 during the CIAM
- 23:49Congress on the boat taking them to
- 23:51Athens. It was then rewritten and
- 23:54revised by Le Corbusier, published
- 23:56under his name in 1943, and has since
- 23:59been constantly edited and translated
- 24:01around the world. So, it really is a
- 24:04major work. The Athens Charter is
- 24:07divided into five chapters, but
- 24:09curiously, people generally only ever
- 24:11talk about four of them. They always
- 24:15forget the last one titled "Heritage,"
- 24:17which is the perspective the modern
- 24:19movement architects had on the existing
- 24:22city and heritage. That is not the
- 24:25theme I will develop here, but it is
- 24:27important to point out that we always
- 24:29forget that the modernists also had a
- 24:31discourse on existing heritage. The
- 24:34charter is then divided into articles.
- 24:38There are a little over 90 articles,
- 24:39and there are a few points of doctrine
- 24:41presented at the beginning. And the
- 24:45first article is actually extremely
- 24:46interesting, as it says the city is
- 24:48only part of an economic, social, and
- 24:50political whole that makes up the
- 24:51region. So, this is about the city
- 24:55charter, but from the start, the city
- 24:57is conceived as an element of a larger
- 25:00whole and therefore of regional
- 25:02planning. Uh, so once again, we cannot
- 25:05take the element without considering
- 25:07the whole. 2nd article: "Life only
- 25:11flourishes to the extent that it
- 25:13conforms to the forces governing human
- 25:15personality, the individual, and the
- 25:17collective.""And we find this question
- 25:21of the balance between the individual
- 25:23and the collective expressed very
- 25:25clearly. And in this equation, Le
- 25:28Corbusier and the modernists always put
- 25:30the individual first and the collective
- 25:32second. It's about how the city, how
- 25:37services can contribute to human
- 25:40happiness, and ensuring their private
- 25:43cell, their private sphere, within the
- 25:46habitat first. So, this question of the
- 25:50relationship of man in the city and the
- 25:52relationship of the habitat to the city
- 25:54as a whole is an essential point of the
- 25:57doctrine of reformist urbanism and the
- 25:59Athens Charter, and is an essential
- 26:01point—perhaps the essential point—
- 26:03that will not be addressed, or will be
- 26:05poorly addressed, in the question of
- 26:07large housing projects. Article 71. I'm
- 26:10skipping a little further ahead because
- 26:12it's an important article. Uh, the
- 26:14violence of private interests causes a
- 26:16disastrous imbalance between the push
- 26:18of economic forces on one hand, and the
- 26:20weakness of administrative control and
- 26:22the impotent social solidarity on the
- 26:23other. And the conclusion is: private
- 26:27interest will be subordinate to the
- 26:28collective interest. That is still an
- 26:31extremely important point. It is not
- 26:34about a collectivization of
- 26:36architecture, the city, the land, etc.,
- 26:39but rather about conditioning, or
- 26:41rather building, a society of
- 26:43solidarity and a city of solidarity
- 26:45where the collective serves the
- 26:47individual. That is an absolutely
- 26:51essential point in the approach of
- 26:53these architects. So the first chapter
- 26:56is devoted to housing; it's the major
- 26:58point. And each time in the Athens
- 27:01Charter, there is always a two-part
- 27:03construction. A first part, which is
- 27:05the diagnosis of the existing state,
- 27:08then a second part, which is that of
- 27:10the proposals. And the CIAM architects
- 27:13would later translate this, from a
- 27:15methodological point of view, into a
- 27:17grid—the CIAM grids—where they
- 27:18would cross-reference the first four
- 27:20chapters of the Athens Charter with a
- 27:22certain number of other criteria to
- 27:24have an approach that aims to be as
- 27:26rational as possible regarding
- 27:27evaluation and, subsequently, the
- 27:29proposal for the city. So, housing: the
- 27:33assessment. The densest neighborhoods
- 27:36are found in the least favored areas.
- 27:38Poorly oriented slopes and areas
- 27:40overtaken by fog. Industrial gas
- 27:42subject to flooding. A condemnation of
- 27:46mixing functions, on one hand, and we
- 27:48saw with Bhopal in India or, more
- 27:50recently, fortunately with fewer
- 27:52victims, the AZF problem in Toulouse,
- 27:54that this mixing of functions can
- 27:56indeed be detrimental nonetheless. And
- 28:00behind this, there is, I would say,
- 28:02militant action for a genuine land
- 28:05policy, for land reserves and quality
- 28:07plots, so that social housing is not
- 28:10pushed to the outskirts, so that social
- 28:13housing, these important neighborhoods,
- 28:15are not abandoned or marginalized from
- 28:18the city. Article 23. Residential
- 28:22districts must henceforth occupy the
- 28:24best locations in urban space, taking
- 28:26advantage of topography, making use of
- 28:29the climate, and having the most
- 28:31favorable sunlight and appropriate
- 28:33green spaces. There is therefore a real
- 28:36land-use ambition, a very significant
- 28:38architectural and urban ambition. So,
- 28:42to summarize this first chapter, it is
- 28:44a matter of securing the best land,
- 28:47having a land policy, seeking the best
- 28:49placement, and defining what Le
- 28:51Corbusier calls the heliothermic axis,
- 28:53that is to say, the best orientation
- 28:55for building placement to have maximum
- 28:58sunlight in the dwellings, while
- 29:00favoring through-units, incidentally.
- 29:03So, the heliothermic axis, roughly
- 29:05speaking, is placing the building's
- 29:07main axis almost parallel to the
- 29:09north-south axis so that apartments are
- 29:11lit from the east and west. We will see
- 29:15in a number of examples that when large
- 29:18housing projects were built, this
- 29:20concern faded in favor of other worries
- 29:23or lines of thought. Refusing alignment
- 29:27with traffic thoroughfares. And so,
- 29:28this is an important decision; it is
- 29:30the death of the street. The point,
- 29:33precisely to have this better
- 29:35orientation, is not to keep the concept
- 29:37of the street, but to decouple the
- 29:39placement of buildings from the
- 29:41alignment of traffic routes; to set
- 29:43buildings apart to ensure good lighting
- 29:45, and also to space the buildings from
- 29:48one another so that at any time of the
- 29:50year, they do not cast shadows on each
- 29:52other. There is a whole discourse by
- 29:57the modernists about the street as a
- 29:59place of every vice, a place of every
- 30:01depravity, as well as a place of
- 30:03insalubrity, which is totally
- 30:05caricatural but which explains these
- 30:07proposals. Also, a final point
- 30:13regarding this chapter: avoid urban
- 30:15sprawl and therefore propose
- 30:17densification in height, meaning a
- 30:19de-densification of the city footprint
- 30:22but a densification of buildings in
- 30:24height so as to free up maximum ground
- 30:26surface; the second chapter is
- 30:28dedicated to leisure. It involves open
- 30:32ground areas that become public space
- 30:35rather than private space, which are
- 30:38then put to the benefit of the entire
- 30:41population. It is about installing
- 30:44kindergartens, schools, youth centers,
- 30:47and all the facilities and public
- 30:50buildings—churches, chapels, etc.—
- 30:52that are essential for the life of the
- 30:55group and its inhabitants. This leads
- 30:59to a new ratio, completely reversing
- 31:02that of the traditional city, with 15%
- 31:05housing—where the building occupies
- 31:0715%of the ground—and the remaining 85
- 31:10%in greenery, where those famous
- 31:12extensions are located. If we look at a
- 31:16typical plan of a Le Corbusier" Cité
- 31:20Radieuse, "where we see the residential
- 31:23buildings in a zigzag pattern to get
- 31:26the best possible lighting, and we
- 31:29color all the green surfaces, we end up
- 31:33with this quite telling image. Le
- 31:38Corbusier also illustrated this with a
- 31:40comparison between the traditional city
- 31:43—that of the block, the closed, dark,
- 31:46and unhealthy block where light and air
- 31:49do not enter or enter poorly—and the
- 31:51street, a place of social interaction,
- 31:54which Le Corbusier preferred to cast
- 31:57aside in favor of hygienic
- 31:59considerations. Next to it is the new
- 32:03city with its hierarchy of traffic
- 32:05lanes adapted to automobile circulation
- 32:07and the separation of functions between
- 32:08office zones, for example, and
- 32:10residential zones, which we see here at
- 32:12the bottom right. So, for the leisure
- 32:17chapter, it is about never dissociating
- 32:20housing from these extensions. It is
- 32:23about preserving the balance between
- 32:25the individual and the collective, and,
- 32:28using Corbusian terms, ensuring
- 32:30facilities for the essential joys,
- 32:32meaning the cultivation of both body
- 32:35and mind. All this boils down to
- 32:37creating what Le Corbusier calls the
- 32:39green cities. An expression he borrowed
- 32:42from Russian theories he observed,
- 32:45which date back to 1932. The third
- 32:50chapter is dedicated to work. This is
- 32:53where Le Corbusier and the CIAM
- 32:55particularly develop the question of
- 32:57zoning and the distribution of
- 32:59functions. The model being this
- 33:03biological model of a functionalist
- 33:06city where functions are separated. But
- 33:09even if they are separated, they are
- 33:10always considered in conjunction with
- 33:12one another. It is not a matter of
- 33:14building residential complexes without
- 33:15building the rest alongside them. One
- 33:17does not go without the other. grouping
- 33:21administrative services, and obviously
- 33:24grouping polluting zones or factories
- 33:26in specific areas at a distance from
- 33:29homes, but not too far either, to avoid
- 33:32these traffic problems, to avoid these
- 33:35flow issues that would prevent the
- 33:37organism from functioning
- 33:39satisfactorily. Therefore, avoiding all
- 33:44this urban transhumance from suburb to
- 33:46suburb to get to work, a theme that is
- 33:48at the heart of the debate that was
- 33:50presented on the Grand Paris here just
- 33:53a few weeks ago. Finally, the 4th
- 33:57chapter, since I will not be speaking
- 33:59about the last one, circulation. In
- 34:02fact, for Le Corbusier, it is about
- 34:04integrating the automobile. The
- 34:06automobile can kill the city, and on
- 34:08the contrary, the automobile must be a
- 34:10constituent element of the city. And so
- 34:13, we must adapt the city to the
- 34:16automobile, adapt traffic lanes to the
- 34:19rhythm of cars, avoid breaks in rhythm,
- 34:23properly adapt speed to use, and
- 34:26therefore properly adapt the lanes to
- 34:29the usage reserved for them. So this
- 34:34notion of circulation is directly
- 34:37illustrated by the plate he had
- 34:39published in L'Urbanisme. So these are
- 34:44the main chapters of the Athens Charter
- 34:47that Le Corbusier illustrates, even if
- 34:49this plate predates the Athens Charter,
- 34:51illustrates in an almost
- 34:53anthropomorphic way. We slip quite
- 34:55easily from the biological analogy to
- 34:58the anthropomorphic analogy with the
- 35:01plan of the Radiant City, where we see
- 35:03the head, the place of decision-making
- 35:06centers; the heart, here, with all the
- 35:09services; the lungs, with the housing
- 35:11in the green zones; and then the feet,
- 35:14where the factories are found,
- 35:16everything that makes the city function
- 35:19, everything that brings it to life,
- 35:21and all this, of course, connected by a
- 35:24highly hierarchical system of
- 35:26circulation. This system of circulation
- 35:29being orthonormal in the case of Le
- 35:31Corbusier's plans, but one can very
- 35:33well imagine a completely different
- 35:34layout, of course. So these proposals
- 35:39for a contemporary urbanism, for a
- 35:42reformist urbanism, did not really take
- 35:45hold in reality between the two wars.
- 35:49Obviously, I have spoken about a
- 35:51certain number of laws, there are also
- 35:53a certain number of operations, and
- 35:55major operations which leave
- 35:56significant traces in the landscape,
- 35:58and notably here in the Parisian
- 36:00landscape. But, as Maurice Rotival
- 36:03himself says, using this illustration
- 36:06to make his point about the HBM belt
- 36:08around the city of Paris, we are
- 36:10already in a completely ossified system
- 36:12, with density that is far too high,
- 36:14with buildings placed too close
- 36:16together; ultimately, we aren't yet at
- 36:18the urbanism of the Athens Charter,
- 36:20we're more in a" Haussmann-style "
- 36:22urbanism. A first explosion, but one
- 36:28that does not respond, neither
- 36:30qualitatively nor especially
- 36:31quantitatively, to the housing
- 36:33challenges facing the city at that time
- 36:35. And this photo is quite beautiful, I
- 36:38think, because on either side of this
- 36:40wall, where the old fortifications used
- 36:43to be, we have Paris on one side and
- 36:45the" zone "on the other. We have all
- 36:48this suburbia made up of shacks,
- 36:50trailers, poor-quality houses,
- 36:52self-built structures—everything that
- 36:55these modern architects and urban
- 36:58planners were precisely denouncing.
- 37:02Large-scale operations are very few and
- 37:04far between. There are, in fact, only
- 37:05four of them. I don't believe there are
- 37:07many more, and we always end up coming
- 37:09back to these same examples. The best
- 37:12known is perhaps the Drancy estate, by
- 37:15Beaudouin and Lods in the early 30s,
- 37:17around '32-'33, which is an interesting
- 37:20estate but only partially fulfills the
- 37:23function expected of it, since it
- 37:25contains only housing and lacks
- 37:28surrounding services. And the photo,
- 37:31here too, is quite beautiful because it
- 37:32shows the complete cultural disconnect
- 37:34between these large housing complexes
- 37:36and their suburbs. You get the
- 37:37impression that this large complex fell
- 37:40from the sky onto these suburbs. There
- 37:42is no connection between the two. And
- 37:45this estate, which is interesting on a
- 37:47technical level for the comfort it
- 37:49provides in its apartments, is also an
- 37:51estate that had, I would say, a tragic
- 37:53destiny. Since, as we know, this
- 37:56U-shaped section here is where the
- 37:58Drancy internment camp was located;
- 38:01therefore, this image is one that will
- 38:03also haunt the reputation of these
- 38:05large housing projects. Beaudouin and
- 38:08Lods also built the Cité des Oiseaux
- 38:10in Bagneux, in the southern suburbs of
- 38:11Paris. These are operations of about
- 38:141,000 housing units. So, there is a
- 38:16fairly significant change in scale. And
- 38:19apart from these two operations, there
- 38:21are two others in the Lyon region from
- 38:23exactly the same period. There is the
- 38:27Cité des États-Unis by Tony Garnier,
- 38:29begun as early as 1917 but completed in
- 38:311934, which is interesting because
- 38:33quantitatively, it's over 1,000 housing
- 38:35units; it is also 1,000 homes, but also
- 38:37shops at the foot of Avenue des
- 38:39États-Unis and a certain number of
- 38:41facilities, notably schools. And
- 38:44architecturally, it doesn't completely
- 38:47belong to the avant-garde. It is
- 38:50modernity as Tony Garnier already
- 38:52imagined it before the First World War.
- 38:57And then, perhaps the most interesting
- 38:59project, but which is not valued enough
- 39:01in my opinion in the history of
- 39:02architecture in France, is the Cité
- 39:04des Gratte-ciel by Maurice Leroux and
- 39:06Jean Flory in Villeurbanne, so just a
- 39:08few hundred meters or barely a few
- 39:10kilometers from the Cité des
- 39:11États-Unis. It was inaugurated just
- 39:14days apart, but it was built very
- 39:16quickly in barely two years and it is a
- 39:19complex of over 1,000 homes which owes
- 39:21its name, I would say, to the
- 39:23skyscraper at the entrance that gives
- 39:25it its image. These are quite
- 39:27high-performance buildings from a
- 39:28technical standpoint with a steel
- 39:30framework that can be guessed at here
- 39:31with the grazing light at night. But
- 39:35beyond the housing, which is quite
- 39:37spacious and very comfortable—
- 39:39certainly nothing like the shacks where
- 39:41the residents who moved into this
- 39:43estate from the mid-30s onwards came
- 39:46from. And then, it is a real piece of a
- 39:50city; it is not just housing. First of
- 39:53all, it is in the very center of the
- 39:54city of Villeurbanne. It is not on the
- 39:56periphery; it is the heart of
- 39:57Villeurbanne. The aerial photo on the
- 40:00right, here, is taken from the terraces
- 40:02of the—of, of, of—the palace of...
- 40:04No, not the courthouse, of the...of...
- 40:06I'm not going to get it, the city hall.
- 40:11So, which was built exactly at the same
- 40:13time. And behind the city hall is a
- 40:16square, and beyond the square, the
- 40:18Théâtre National Populaire that we
- 40:20know, which had its glory days after
- 40:22the Second World War. So there is the
- 40:25public building, the housing, the
- 40:27theater. At the foot of these buildings
- 40:30, all along the street, there are shops
- 40:32. And go for a walk in Villeurbanne,
- 40:33you will see how lively it is and that
- 40:35it still works very, very well today.
- 40:37These shops are flourishing, and around
- 40:39them, there is also a clinic, there are
- 40:40schools, there was a stadium that was
- 40:42planned, which was started but was
- 40:44never finished. So it is a true piece
- 40:46of a city that was designed. Not just
- 40:491,000 social housing units. It is still
- 40:51social housing today, and it is
- 40:53constantly 100%full. Everyone wants to
- 40:56live in this city center. So, there was
- 40:59an extremely important ambition there
- 41:01that took into account every dimension
- 41:03of the issue, which unfortunately was
- 41:05not imitated afterward. But apart from
- 41:10those three or four large-scale
- 41:12operations, we have no other operations
- 41:14of this type before World War II. Well,
- 41:19World War II is really going to be, I
- 41:22would say, the trigger, because due to
- 41:24the destruction, it will force the
- 41:27French State to address the issue of
- 41:30housing for the masses and also, at the
- 41:32same time, call into question the issue
- 41:35of the city and its development. And
- 41:39the destruction is extremely
- 41:40significant. This poster, which dates
- 41:42back to the reconstruction, illustrates
- 41:44this well. It is a poster inspired by
- 41:47an American one that was made after the
- 41:50destruction of a dam in the United
- 41:52States, where there was, likewise, an
- 41:55entire region to rebuild. And the
- 41:58destruction actually covers the entire
- 42:00French territory, unlike the First
- 42:02World War, where the destruction was
- 42:05very localized. We can see it on the
- 42:07map of France; practically no region
- 42:10escaped destruction. Obviously,
- 42:12Normandy, the North, and the East of
- 42:14France are particularly affected, but
- 42:16there is practically no department
- 42:18where there aren't areas to be rebuilt.
- 42:20Sometimes it’s just around the train
- 42:22station where a neighborhood was
- 42:23destroyed. But sometimes it is more
- 42:25significant, and sometimes entire
- 42:26cities have to be rebuilt. The final
- 42:28toll is, in fact, pardon, nearly 2
- 42:32million homes to be rebuilt. And to be
- 42:36able to tackle this task, the French
- 42:39state must equip itself with tools to
- 42:42respond to the scale of the destruction
- 42:46. The MRU, the Ministry of
- 42:49Reconstruction and Urbanism, was
- 42:51created in late 1944 while the fighting
- 42:53was still ongoing. There were still
- 42:57areas of French territory that had not
- 42:59yet been liberated, but the point was
- 43:00not to wait. And this MRU, which is in
- 43:04fact the first ministry dedicated to
- 43:07the issue of urban planning and housing
- 43:09in France—there hadn't been one
- 43:11before. This MRU is largely a takeover
- 43:15of a structure that had been created
- 43:17during the war by the Vichy government,
- 43:19which was the DGen, the General
- 43:21Directorate for National Equipment. And
- 43:24the MRU took over roughly the same
- 43:26administrative structure and kept the
- 43:28same people. You don't reconstitute an
- 43:30administrative elite in just a few
- 43:32weeks or months. And so the MRU owes a
- 43:36lot to the DGE and above all represents
- 43:39an awakening at the highest level of
- 43:43the State. Therefore, the MRU is a
- 43:46continuation of the DGEN, and the
- 43:48watchword is to foresee, unify, and
- 43:51plan. Besides, it is no longer just a
- 43:53matter of carrying out a few operations
- 43:55, housing people here and there through
- 43:58the HBM offices as we did before. It is
- 44:01primarily about rebuilding this country
- 44:02, all the infrastructure, the housing,
- 44:04and therefore all the facilities. And
- 44:06for that, we must look at the scale of
- 44:08the entire territory. The French State
- 44:11will equip itself with tools, not just
- 44:14a ministerial or administrative tool,
- 44:16but practical work tools or by
- 44:18reclaiming existing ones that were not
- 44:20sufficiently used. This is the case
- 44:23with AFNOR, the French Standardization
- 44:25Association, created in 1926, which had
- 44:28not truly reached its full potential
- 44:30before the Second World War. And after
- 44:32the Second World War, there is a need
- 44:34to standardize. We are moving much more
- 44:37toward the industrialization of
- 44:38building, and therefore we must
- 44:40calibrate, I would say, not only
- 44:42housing but all areas of production
- 44:44across the territory. INSEE, there too,
- 44:48is not a structure created after the
- 44:50war. Well, it was created, INSEE was
- 44:52created in 1946, but there had already
- 44:54been a national statistics service
- 44:56since 1940. To know what the needs are,
- 45:00how many schools we need, how many
- 45:02hospitals, etc., we need a status of
- 45:05France, a portrait of the territory and
- 45:09the inhabitants. And so INSEE is the
- 45:12necessary analytical tool. It is only
- 45:16after the Second World War that we will
- 45:17really work with this type of
- 45:19organization in France. Whereas in
- 45:21other European countries, for example
- 45:23in Germany, there have been statistical
- 45:25institutes for much longer, working
- 45:27truly closely with large municipalities
- 45:29or the German State. The CSTB, the
- 45:32Scientific and Technical Center for
- 45:35Building, created in 1947, is there
- 45:37precisely to control what has been
- 45:39standardized and what is produced, the
- 45:41new materials, the new standards, how
- 45:44they are implemented, etc. So there you
- 45:46have it, an entire arsenal of
- 45:48structures that are necessary to really
- 45:50change scale, and there will also be
- 45:53financial organizations, which I will
- 45:55talk about again. So, what is the
- 45:58doctrine of reconstruction? Well, there
- 46:00is no doctrine of reconstruction. While
- 46:04in 1919, in the framework law for
- 46:06reconstruction, it was specified that
- 46:08reconstruction would be identical, or
- 46:11at least reflect the characteristics of
- 46:14regional architecture. In 1945, however
- 46:17, no formal stylistic directive was
- 46:23given to the architects. The Ministry
- 46:28of Reconstruction and Urban Planning,
- 46:30or MRU, is indeed setting up an
- 46:32architectural committee to work for two
- 46:34years, between 1944 and 1946. This
- 46:38committee is composed of architects and
- 46:41urban planners from all different
- 46:43backgrounds. There are conservative
- 46:46architects, people like Maraste, but
- 46:49also more avant-garde architects like
- 46:51Auguste Perret or Le Corbusier. And so,
- 46:54from this rather eclectic group,
- 46:56something had to emerge. And in 1946, a
- 46:59booklet was published, titled" Guiding
- 47:02Principles for Reconstruction. "It is
- 47:05by no means a framework law or a
- 47:07precise set of specifications; it is a
- 47:10collection of advice, truly presented
- 47:12as a brochure. It’s a small,
- 47:14landscape-oriented booklet, about that
- 47:16big, with twenty or thirty pages, I
- 47:18don't recall exactly. In these" Guiding
- 47:21Principles for Reconstruction, "well,
- 47:23there’s practically no text, just
- 47:25plates. For example, it’s a bit about
- 47:28common sense; they show a closed block,
- 47:31which obviously shouldn't be done, so
- 47:34it's crossed out. You have to let light
- 47:37and air into the city. They show a
- 47:40neighborhood with mixed functions—
- 47:42factories and housing—with the
- 47:44housing under the factory smoke, marked
- 47:46with a red cross. You shouldn't do that
- 47:49; it’s not good. It has an almost
- 47:51childlike, simplistic side, which
- 47:53perhaps reflects Le Corbusier's way of
- 47:55speaking. Take this plate he made
- 47:59during a 1929 conference to condemn
- 48:00period styles; he would angrily strike
- 48:02through them with a red cross,
- 48:04condemning the styles and proposing
- 48:05another architectural language made of
- 48:07simple forms. We might see a Corbusian
- 48:10influence in this type of presentation.
- 48:13And then, here are other plates as well
- 48:14. This one, in a way, takes up the
- 48:18chapter from the Athens Charter on the
- 48:20hierarchy of traffic routes, but almost
- 48:23like a comic strip. We see the mother
- 48:26with her little boy and the pram, then
- 48:28we move on to pedestrians, then cars,
- 48:30ending with trucks. So, it is
- 48:32appropriate to organize and separate
- 48:34traffic flows so that the mother with
- 48:36her pram does not cross paths with
- 48:38large trucks. There is a side that is
- 48:42very, very simplistic, almost in its
- 48:44presentation, and we are really at the
- 48:46stage of advice, and absolutely not
- 48:48precise directives, or like this plate,
- 48:50" The right angle is the natural rule
- 48:52of the plan. "It satisfies both the
- 48:55mind and the economy. Acute and obtuse
- 48:57angles will only be permitted
- 48:58accidentally. You would think it was an
- 49:00aphorism from Perret. and just as much
- 49:03in the style of the text as in the
- 49:05drawings that accompany it. It is
- 49:08likely that the Perret school is behind
- 49:10this, imposing the idea of the right
- 49:12angle and a kind of structural
- 49:14classicism that one can discern in this
- 49:16drawing. So, it is a brochure that I
- 49:19think did not have a very strong impact
- 49:22on the architects and urban planners of
- 49:25this reconstruction. Since the work of
- 49:28Anatole Kopp several decades ago, we
- 49:30are accustomed to presenting this
- 49:32reconstruction in three groups. I will
- 49:35use them because it is quite practical.
- 49:37We talk about—even if the terminology
- 49:39is not very good in my opinion—we
- 49:41talk about identical reconstruction,
- 49:43but there is no identical
- 49:44reconstruction in France. There may
- 49:47have been some in certain districts of
- 49:49Warsaw or Saint Petersburg where they
- 49:50truly rebuilt identically. But in
- 49:52France, we drew inspiration from the
- 49:55old ones. We were inspired by old
- 49:58architecture. We see Gien here,
- 50:00Saint-Malo here. We take the spirit, we
- 50:03take the forms, we take the skyline, we
- 50:05take the dimensions, we take a form of
- 50:07aesthetics with the materials, even if
- 50:09they are not necessarily the original
- 50:10materials. But it is not an identical
- 50:13reconstruction, rather a historical
- 50:16reconstruction mixed with regionalism.
- 50:20We also have, and this is the most
- 50:22common case, what is called either an
- 50:24average reconstruction, which is a
- 50:26really poor term, or we also speak of
- 50:29the MRU style. Which is completely
- 50:32inaccurate since the MRU did not impose
- 50:34any style. But let's say it is an
- 50:36architecture. We see here some examples
- 50:38in Caen, in Yvetot, a small town
- 50:41between Le Havre and Rouen, or here in
- 50:44Saint-Lô. It is an architecture that
- 50:46most of the time takes up the
- 50:48principles of classical architecture,
- 50:50but a classical architecture that has
- 50:52become commonplace, tinged with
- 50:54regional culture in each area. So, we
- 50:58have a hierarchy of levels with a first
- 51:00floor treated with a certain scale, a
- 51:02standard floor, a sort of attic story,
- 51:04the pitched roof, bays, a form of order
- 51:06rhythmically punctuated by the entrance
- 51:09doors, a small sculpture above. We are
- 51:13here in a simplified classical
- 51:14architecture or a mix of regional
- 51:16architecture and rationalist principles
- 51:18with the expression of the structure,
- 51:20but we are absolutely not in modern
- 51:22architecture. Even though this
- 51:27architecture, both here and there, is
- 51:29one that, as Jo Abraham—who, by the
- 51:32way, came 2 years ago to speak about
- 51:34this period—explains well, is
- 51:36architecture that is modernizing,
- 51:38meaning that inside, most of the time,
- 51:40we have concrete structures. Inside, we
- 51:44have much larger spaces. Uh, inside, we
- 51:47have modern comforts. Water, gas,
- 51:49electricity, it seems obvious,
- 51:51commonplace to us, but in a small town
- 51:53like Saint-Lô, before the war, I don't
- 51:54know, there must have been perhaps
- 51:5610,000 inhabitants in Saint-Lô, no
- 51:58more, there was one bathroom. So there
- 52:01was an enormous amount of progress to
- 52:02be made in this regard, and the
- 52:04reconstruction would be an opportunity
- 52:06to modernize the buildings. But for all
- 52:08that, we do not use the language of the
- 52:10modern movement. Nothing to do here
- 52:13with the architecture of Manestevin, of
- 52:15the U.R.S.A., of Le Corbusier, of Mies
- 52:17van der Rohe, of Gropius, well, of all
- 52:19those who created the modern movement
- 52:21in the 20s. And that is really the case
- 52:24for the majority of reconstructed
- 52:26cities in France. And then there is
- 52:29some so-called modern reconstruction,
- 52:31even if it is not completely based on
- 52:33the principles of the Athens Charter,
- 52:35but the reconstruction of Le Havre is
- 52:38an extremely interesting example of
- 52:40rational architecture, of concrete
- 52:42architecture, of architecture where the
- 52:44construction grid plays a major role.
- 52:48But if Le Havre is a case, it is not an
- 52:51example. What I mean by that is that Le
- 52:54Havre was absolutely not reproduced
- 52:55anywhere else in France. It is an
- 52:58exceptional situation, completely
- 53:01unique. Apart from Le Havre, we have
- 53:03the reconstruction of Maubeuge, done by
- 53:05the U.R.S.A., which also has accents of
- 53:07modernity. We can also speak of Royan,
- 53:09which I know quite well, but with
- 53:11another form of modernity. But this
- 53:14architectural modernity is, at heart,
- 53:16totally absent or very little present
- 53:18during the reconstruction period. The
- 53:22reconstruction is the period of
- 53:24awareness, the period of modernization,
- 53:26the period of change of scale in the
- 53:28construction work. A period where we
- 53:31begin to industrialize building, where
- 53:34we modernize architecture, where we
- 53:36also modernize the city. Now, not in
- 53:38the manner of Le Corbusier, mind you,
- 53:40not in the manner of the Saint-Dié
- 53:41plan which Le Corbusier, incidentally,
- 53:43did not carry out. A plan that was an
- 53:45exemplary, practically iconic
- 53:47application of the Athens Charter with
- 53:50the separation of functions, housing
- 53:53concentrated in residential units, a
- 53:55city center with facilities. It wasn't
- 53:59realized because, first of all, Le
- 54:01Corbusier had no mandate for Saint-Dié
- 54:03, and also because the population
- 54:05refused this type of urban architecture
- 54:07. But even if the principles of modern
- 54:11reformist urbanism were not applied,
- 54:14the urbanism of the reconstruction is
- 54:16interesting and incorporates a great
- 54:18many elements of modernity. We can take
- 54:23a single example with Saint-Lô,
- 54:25rebuilt by the urban planner Brio de La
- 54:29Jardière, and the chief architect was
- 54:32Louis Arretche. When comparing the plan
- 54:36before destruction and the plan after
- 54:37construction, at first glance, one gets
- 54:39the impression that it's the same plan,
- 54:41that Brio de La Jardière did nothing.
- 54:44But when you look closer, well, it
- 54:46might not be easy on the projection,
- 54:48but you realize that while Brio de La
- 54:51Jardière kept the main routes—
- 54:53because these routes were historically
- 54:55intelligent, I mean, because we are by
- 54:57the sea, by the ocean, and so we must
- 55:00protect ourselves from the winds—
- 55:02these routes both followed the terrain
- 55:04and allowed for protection from the
- 55:06prevailing winds. So, La Jardière had
- 55:10the intelligence to reuse these layouts
- 55:12, but they were widened and enlarged to
- 55:15facilitate the passage of cars, even if
- 55:17in Saint-Lô, it remains very modest.
- 55:20And then we especially see the layout
- 55:22of the blocks, which was greatly
- 55:24simplified. The number of plots was
- 55:27reduced by an extremely significant
- 55:30figure. I don't know exactly here, but
- 55:32in Saint-Lô, as in all the
- 55:34reconstruction cities, there is first
- 55:36an extremely important urban land
- 55:38consolidation process that allows for
- 55:41the rationalization of land, that
- 55:43allows for the removal of unsanitary
- 55:45blocks, and that allows for opening up
- 55:47the blocks. Therefore, we have many
- 55:50solutions of completely open blocks
- 55:52where you enter on one side and exit
- 55:54the other, or semi-open blocks, open on
- 55:56one side or partially open. Very often
- 55:59on the side, there is just a garage
- 56:01level. So it allows air and light to
- 56:04enter. So, plenty of solutions for
- 56:07opening up and modernizing the city.
- 56:10But we are not at all into the
- 56:12separation of functions. We are not in
- 56:14the modern city. We are not at the
- 56:16death of the street either. We are
- 56:18truly in the conservation of ancient
- 56:21principles. So it is an important
- 56:27period, a period of awareness, a period
- 56:30of changing scale, but it is not a
- 56:33period where the modern movement is
- 56:36used and co-opted to rebuild. There
- 56:39were indeed a certain number of
- 56:41experimental competitions. The MRU was
- 56:43organizing planning competitions, or
- 56:46more precisely, competitions for major
- 56:48housing developments in
- 56:50Villiers-Saint-Georges, Creil,
- 56:52Compiègne, and so on. And perhaps the
- 56:55most well-known is the one for the
- 56:57Rotterdam district in Strasbourg. In
- 57:00the 1951 issue of L'Architecture
- 57:01d'Aujourd'hui, it states that the
- 57:06essential purpose of this competition
- 57:08is to lower construction costs and
- 57:11improve execution times. So the
- 57:14objective is clear. It's about finding
- 57:17the most efficient ratio possible
- 57:19between financial investment and the
- 57:21number of square meters built. It's
- 57:25also about finding industrialization
- 57:28solutions that would allow for lower
- 57:30costs and achieving these goals. Also,
- 57:35reducing project time, because we are
- 57:37facing challenges—those of rebuilding
- 57:40for millions of people—which are
- 57:42significant. When we also look at this
- 57:45article, it's quite interesting. Well,
- 57:47there is this illustration. But how
- 57:50does the journalist who wrote the
- 57:52article compare...what does the
- 57:55journalist compare the Baudouin-Lods
- 57:57operation to? He speaks of a new Parc
- 58:00Monceau. He does not compare it to the
- 58:02principles of the Athens Charter, he
- 58:04doesn't compare it to modern urbanism;
- 58:06he compares it to Parc Monceau, meaning
- 58:08a group of homes around a beautiful
- 58:09park. But you can see that the model is
- 58:12absolutely not one of contemporary
- 58:14urbanism. However, there are principles
- 58:18here close to those of the Athens
- 58:20Charter, with a liberation of the
- 58:22ground and densification. There are
- 58:25also some extremely interesting
- 58:27architectural elements, with housing
- 58:29that I would call high-quality—
- 58:31meaning it's not up to today's
- 58:33standards at all, but it represents an
- 58:35extraordinary gain in comfort for the
- 58:38future residents: with a bathroom, and
- 58:40separate bedrooms for the children and
- 58:42parents. They are no longer together,
- 58:45offering a level of comfort that most
- 58:47French people did not possess. The
- 58:49aesthetics of these buildings borrow
- 58:52from modern architecture. Baudouin and
- 58:54Lods were among the young—not of the
- 58:56first generation, but of a second
- 58:58generation from the 30 s—to take up
- 59:00the principles of the modern movement.
- 59:03The interplay is relatively simple,
- 59:06with an alternating rhythm in the
- 59:08openings. It remains very modest, but
- 59:11the expression is that of modern
- 59:12architecture. We are no longer in what
- 59:15we just saw for the reconstruction. But
- 59:18as much in the housing, in their
- 59:21distribution, their extremely poor or
- 59:24even non-existent spatial design, and
- 59:27the architectural language, we are very
- 59:30far from spatial and distributive
- 59:33research. and formal artistic research
- 59:37that defined the architects of the
- 59:40modern movement in France and Europe
- 59:42between the wars. So it is, all the
- 59:44same, an impoverished version that is
- 59:46presented. There are experimental
- 59:49competitions, there are also
- 59:50experimental building sites, that is to
- 59:53say, buildings entrusted directly to a
- 59:55few architects to experiment with
- 59:57either new techniques or new layout
- 59:59modes. And obviously among these
- 1:00:03experimental sites, the best known, and
- 1:00:05perhaps one of the most interesting in
- 1:00:08terms of ideas and the ambition it
- 1:00:10carries, is the Marseille housing unit
- 1:00:12entrusted to Le Corbusier directly by
- 1:00:15the ministry. Many ministers will
- 1:00:19succeed one another, from Raoul Dautry
- 1:00:22to Claudius-Petit, whom we see here
- 1:00:24with Le Corbusier. All will continue to
- 1:00:28support this project, particularly
- 1:00:30Raoul—Claudius-Petit. A project that
- 1:00:34is constantly exempt from regulations,
- 1:00:37I believe there are 300 exemptions
- 1:00:39granted for this project, and it
- 1:00:41proposes a new type of housing that is
- 1:00:43not just a housing block but much more
- 1:00:45than that. In a few words, the cell,
- 1:00:50therefore the individual, the housing
- 1:00:53unit is the literal application of this
- 1:00:56principle of balance between the
- 1:00:59individual and the collective to which
- 1:01:02Le Corbusier aspires. Each family can
- 1:01:07therefore have an apartment which is a
- 1:01:09dual-aspect apartment made up of three
- 1:01:11modules itself. The entrance module
- 1:01:14with the kitchen. Obviously, it would
- 1:01:17be simpler if we went to visit the
- 1:01:19apartment reconstructed in the gallery
- 1:01:22of contemporary architecture, but we
- 1:01:24aren't going to move right now. So the
- 1:01:26living room module, which is a
- 1:01:29double-height module. So here too, a
- 1:01:32gain in space quality, this duplex,
- 1:01:34this double height that brings a
- 1:01:36completely different breathing space
- 1:01:38than what one can find in ordinary
- 1:01:41housing. There is a generosity, or
- 1:01:44rather a search for quality in the
- 1:01:46Corbusian project that one does not
- 1:01:48necessarily find in the rest of social
- 1:01:50housing. So the second module is that
- 1:01:54of the parents 'bedroom, the bathroom,
- 1:01:56the toilets, and the storage. And then
- 1:01:59the third module, which allows the
- 1:02:02apartment to be dual-aspect, therefore
- 1:02:04a double orientation and thus constant
- 1:02:07natural light, in any case, natural
- 1:02:09light permanently in this dwelling. So
- 1:02:13the third module, which is that of the
- 1:02:15children's bedrooms; I do not propose
- 1:02:17this model as the absolute model.
- 1:02:20Simply, there are a certain number of
- 1:02:22spatial qualities there, notably, that
- 1:02:25one does not necessarily find in the
- 1:02:27social housing of that era. And then
- 1:02:30there is this idea of the balance
- 1:02:31between the individual and the
- 1:02:33collective, which is already expressed
- 1:02:34in the modularity. How, from three
- 1:02:37elements, can we combine—well, how
- 1:02:39can we create combinations and 23
- 1:02:41different types? Here is another board
- 1:02:43taken from urban planning. How do we
- 1:02:45move from the cell to the more complete
- 1:02:47organism? It is the direct application
- 1:02:50here. And then it is also an
- 1:02:52organization of space around internal
- 1:02:56streets. So there are no—we can see
- 1:02:58it on the section here of the unit—
- 1:02:59there are no corridors, or rather,
- 1:03:01internal streets at each level. But the
- 1:03:04apartments are arranged head-to-tail,
- 1:03:06with downward-facing apartments. So you
- 1:03:10enter from the top, at the level of the
- 1:03:13parents' bedroom, and go down to the
- 1:03:15living room, and upward-facing
- 1:03:17apartments that allow for interlocking,
- 1:03:19thus creating a rather complex
- 1:03:21combination. This housing unit is an
- 1:03:26incredible interlocking of volumes of
- 1:03:28different types in relation to one
- 1:03:31another. And beyond the spatial quality
- 1:03:35, or at least the intentions within
- 1:03:38this project, there is also the
- 1:03:40collective aspect with the shopping
- 1:03:42street, which is located on the 8th
- 1:03:44floor. It is also at this level that
- 1:03:48there is a hotel to welcome visitors
- 1:03:50coming to see the families living there
- 1:03:52. And then on the roof, a number of
- 1:03:55collective facilities shared by the
- 1:03:58residents, initially in the form of an
- 1:04:00association—I mean, it is truly
- 1:04:03reserved for the residents of the unit.
- 1:04:07The nursery school with three
- 1:04:09classrooms and its garden, mineral of
- 1:04:11course, and the small pool for the
- 1:04:13children to splash in. The small gym
- 1:04:18for sports, which today has become a
- 1:04:20private gym, and then way over here,
- 1:04:23the kind of pediment for theater, or at
- 1:04:26least for events so that people could
- 1:04:29gather in a time when there was no
- 1:04:31television yet. And all around, a sort
- 1:04:35of track that allows you to run and
- 1:04:37exercise while having a view of the
- 1:04:39Alpilles on one side and the
- 1:04:40Mediterranean on the other. So once
- 1:04:44again, I am not proposing this as a
- 1:04:46model, but there is simply a richness
- 1:04:48of intention here, an ambition not
- 1:04:50necessarily found elsewhere, which was,
- 1:04:52in fact, the hallmark of this
- 1:04:53experimental site. So, the assessment
- 1:04:57of the reconstruction in 1955. 800,000
- 1:05:01homes have already been rebuilt. So we
- 1:05:04are not quite at the halfway point, but
- 1:05:05it is moving relatively quickly. 8 to
- 1:05:0810 years to rebuild 800,000 homes in a
- 1:05:10completely devastated country where it
- 1:05:12already took at least 3 or 4 years to
- 1:05:14rebuild roads, bridges, and all the
- 1:05:16economic mechanisms, factories, and so
- 1:05:19on, and the ports. So reconstruction is
- 1:05:24moving along well, but it is moving
- 1:05:26with the principles of a rather
- 1:05:28conservative architecture, in any case
- 1:05:31in the continuity of the 1930s, the
- 1:05:33dominant architecture of the 30s, but
- 1:05:36absolutely not a modern architecture,
- 1:05:38even if it is modernizing. And the
- 1:05:42images I showed of Paris in the early
- 1:05:4520s, so on the outskirts of Paris or
- 1:05:47even within Paris, remained in the 50s.
- 1:05:51Here are some photos from the 50s that
- 1:05:53are completely relevant. The issue of
- 1:05:56reconstruction is being handled well,
- 1:05:59but there is also the question of slums
- 1:06:01and housing that were already
- 1:06:03insufficient or in a deplorable state
- 1:06:05before the Second World War. And here,
- 1:06:09the views you see are no longer in the
- 1:06:10Paris region but in the Lyon region.
- 1:06:13That there is a slum where lived, uh,
- 1:06:16Azouz Begag, who is a writer and who
- 1:06:19held responsibilities at one point in a
- 1:06:22government. And the photos here were
- 1:06:26taken near Lyon, near Villeurbanne,
- 1:06:28near Givors. And it's not far. The
- 1:06:31little girl you see there must be my
- 1:06:33age today. The sheep behind, I don't
- 1:06:35know. But we are really talking about
- 1:06:37close proximity. It seems very, very
- 1:06:39far to us, but in reality, it is not at
- 1:06:41all. And so this is what led Claudius
- 1:06:44Petit, who was certainly the main
- 1:06:46minister of reconstruction we have had,
- 1:06:49to declare this. First, due to his
- 1:06:52longevity, several years, when most
- 1:06:53reconstruction ministers stayed only a
- 1:06:55few months or sometimes even a few days
- 1:06:57. It was the Fourth Republic. So things
- 1:07:00shifted quite rapidly. But Claudius
- 1:07:01Petit managed to survive several
- 1:07:03governments and therefore had a lasting
- 1:07:05impact. And Claudius Petit was someone
- 1:07:08very close to the circles of the modern
- 1:07:10movement who, as early as the
- 1:07:12Resistance, from the time of the
- 1:07:14Resistance in which he was fully
- 1:07:16involved in Algiers when preparations
- 1:07:18were already underway within the
- 1:07:20National Council of the Resistance for
- 1:07:22reconstruction and the post-war period.
- 1:07:25Uh, Claudius Petit was already
- 1:07:27campaigning in those years, as early as
- 1:07:291943-44, for a construction policy, a
- 1:07:32housing policy. And he would never stop
- 1:07:35, when he became minister, repeating
- 1:07:37this, but without truly managing to
- 1:07:40launch this policy. He would, I would
- 1:07:43say, bring it to the baptismal font, he
- 1:07:44would allow for an awareness to grow,
- 1:07:46but he is not the one who would launch
- 1:07:48it. And in 1953, he had this phrase
- 1:07:51that sums up his desire well. I tried
- 1:07:53to explain, he said, that it wasn't
- 1:07:55just the victims of the war, that the
- 1:07:57latter were after all only 1.5 million,
- 1:08:00while regarding the victims of life, it
- 1:08:02was 13 million dwellings that needed to
- 1:08:04be replaced. It was therefore necessary
- 1:08:06to have a construction policy, not just
- 1:08:08a reconstruction policy. So, it was
- 1:08:11finally tackling what a few politicians
- 1:08:14, though not many, and some rather
- 1:08:17avant-garde architects and urban
- 1:08:19planners of the modern movement had
- 1:08:22been explaining during the interwar
- 1:08:24period. In January 1954, Abbé Pierre
- 1:08:29launched his famous appeal, which would
- 1:08:32be heard and echoed throughout France
- 1:08:34for several years. And it is often said
- 1:08:38that it was Abbé Pierre who launched
- 1:08:40all these construction programs, and
- 1:08:42that he was the one who sensitized the
- 1:08:44State to this construction policy. This
- 1:08:47is actually false, since the Courant
- 1:08:49Law, which would launch what we later
- 1:08:51call the policy of large housing
- 1:08:53estates, dates back to 1953. Pierre
- 1:08:57Courant was the successor at the
- 1:08:59ministry to Jean Claudius-Petit. And so
- 1:09:02, in fact, the mechanism was already
- 1:09:04set in motion when Abbé Pierre made
- 1:09:07his appeal. But Abbé Pierre's appeal
- 1:09:09had the immense merit of making the
- 1:09:12French population aware of this totally
- 1:09:15unacceptable situation, thereby
- 1:09:17mobilizing energy and facilitating the
- 1:09:20work initiated by the government. At
- 1:09:23the same time, it had a perverse effect
- 1:09:25, which was to pressure the government
- 1:09:28due to public sentiment. To prioritize
- 1:09:33emergency operations, and therefore to
- 1:09:36lower quality and reduce standards in
- 1:09:38order to increase quantity and
- 1:09:40accelerate the pace of construction.
- 1:09:43And there was a very important debate,
- 1:09:45not only within the government but also
- 1:09:47in every city where housing was being
- 1:09:49built. Between these two approaches:
- 1:09:53should we maintain a certain level of
- 1:09:55construction quality and quality
- 1:09:57standards, even if it means moving
- 1:09:59relatively slowly, to create
- 1:10:01sustainable housing? Or should we move
- 1:10:05faster, respond to the emergency
- 1:10:07because there is a real social crisis,
- 1:10:10and consequently lower standards to
- 1:10:12build lower-quality housing that will
- 1:10:15degrade much faster? And it was this
- 1:10:18second solution that was predominantly
- 1:10:20adopted. So, what were the principles
- 1:10:23of this construction policy? We were
- 1:10:25not yet talking about a policy of large
- 1:10:26housing estates. Pierre Dumont, a great
- 1:10:29administrator who wrote a report for
- 1:10:30the Economic Council, said:" From a
- 1:10:32social and human point of view, is it
- 1:10:34necessary to point out that a
- 1:10:36considerable number of families are
- 1:10:37homeless or poorly housed, crowded into
- 1:10:39unsanitary dwellings, which are
- 1:10:41generators of disease and condemnable
- 1:10:43from a social standpoint? "So, the
- 1:10:45primary objective: respond to
- 1:10:47unsanitary conditions. Already serious
- 1:10:49a few years ago, the problem has become
- 1:10:52all the more difficult to solve as the
- 1:10:54decrease in the number of deaths and
- 1:10:56the increase in births require an even
- 1:10:58greater number of homes. We are in the
- 1:11:00midst of the baby boom. From an
- 1:11:02economic standpoint, is it necessary to
- 1:11:04point out that the rebirth of
- 1:11:06construction is the only healthy and
- 1:11:08lasting way to revive economic activity
- 1:11:10? So, we see there are three major
- 1:11:12objectives. A goal of public health
- 1:11:15that dates back largely to the 19th
- 1:11:18century. The entire hygienist discourse
- 1:11:20of the 19th century was already
- 1:11:21denouncing this situation. A social
- 1:11:24objective, architecture or revolution
- 1:11:25in a certain way. We must avoid social
- 1:11:29chaos, respond with a standardization
- 1:11:32of social housing and an economic
- 1:11:34objective; this policy of mass housing
- 1:11:37will help support economic activity
- 1:11:40after the war and after the initial
- 1:11:43period of infrastructure reconstruction
- 1:11:46. So, this reconstruction policy will
- 1:11:50go through a certain number of stages
- 1:11:51or dates. You see, as early as 1951,
- 1:11:55the Planning Commission called for the
- 1:11:57construction of 320,000 homes per year
- 1:11:59for 30 years, when we were at 75,000
- 1:12:01outside of reconstruction. But this
- 1:12:04goal was absolutely not met. In 1953,
- 1:12:07when the Courant law was voted on. We
- 1:12:10were at around 80,000, I believe. In
- 1:12:131954, the Abbé Pierre appeal was an
- 1:12:15important moment. And in 1958, it was
- 1:12:17the end of the MRU. The ministry did
- 1:12:20not disappear, but it was renamed. And
- 1:12:23renamed the Ministry of Construction.
- 1:12:26And this change of name is in itself
- 1:12:28extremely symbolic. It clearly shows
- 1:12:31that reconstruction is not finished,
- 1:12:33but it is no longer the priority
- 1:12:35objective. It is, in any case, doubled
- 1:12:39by a second objective, which is to
- 1:12:41build housing not for war victims, but
- 1:12:43for those who for generations and
- 1:12:45generations have had no housing or no
- 1:12:47decent housing. And so '58 really marks
- 1:12:52an important date as well.
- 1:12:56Reconstruction continued, of course,
- 1:12:58beyond that, since the final operations
- 1:13:01were completed starting around 1965;
- 1:13:04some went even further, and even the
- 1:13:06issue of war damages, which allowed for
- 1:13:09the financing of the operations, was
- 1:13:11only settled in the late 1990s and
- 1:13:14early 2000s. You see? So it is really a
- 1:13:17matter that was not finished, but let's
- 1:13:19say that by '58 things were well
- 1:13:21underway. This construction policy will
- 1:13:25also involve a policy of standards, or
- 1:13:27the creation of standards lower than
- 1:13:30those of HLM housing, notably the
- 1:13:32Lopofa standards—popular family
- 1:13:34housing—and other standards that
- 1:13:36allow for faster, cheaper construction.
- 1:13:41We are also going to launch a model
- 1:13:42policy. We will have architects working
- 1:13:44starting in '53. On standard models for
- 1:13:47individual and collective housing. And
- 1:13:50some of these models will then be
- 1:13:52applied. When I worked at the French
- 1:13:56Institute of Architecture in the
- 1:13:58archives on Rue Tolbiac, as mentioned
- 1:14:00earlier, I saw several times in the
- 1:14:02archives of architects who participated
- 1:14:04in these operations, tracing papers
- 1:14:06where the project label had been
- 1:14:08scraped off. You could still see the
- 1:14:11razor blade marks, and the name of
- 1:14:13another project was written over it. So
- 1:14:15they were reusing the exact same plans
- 1:14:17for a different project. Emergency land
- 1:14:20policy. After World War II,
- 1:14:24particularly in the Paris region, a
- 1:14:26land reserve policy was initiated,
- 1:14:29acquiring land for an ambitious housing
- 1:14:31policy and quality sites. But faced
- 1:14:36with urgency and public pressure, this
- 1:14:39land policy was completely abandoned,
- 1:14:42and they opportunistically took
- 1:14:44whatever land became available to build
- 1:14:47these large housing estates. Some far
- 1:14:51too remote, some poorly served or not
- 1:14:54served at all, some that would wait for
- 1:14:58access to to public transport, sorry.
- 1:15:04for years. And so this construction
- 1:15:08policy was carried out by lowering
- 1:15:11standards and was essentially
- 1:15:13quantitative in nature. And we can see
- 1:15:15this through a few figures. In 1948,
- 1:15:1740,000 housing units were built
- 1:15:20annually. In 1953, when the Courant Act
- 1:15:25was passed, we exceeded 120,000 units
- 1:15:28per year. By '55, we had already
- 1:15:31surpassed 200,000. In '59, we passed
- 1:15:34300,000 and then 400,000. Then, in fact
- 1:15:37, at the beginning of the 70s, we would
- 1:15:40even exceed 500,000 housing units
- 1:15:43annually. This should be compared with
- 1:15:46the figures from the Loucheur Act,
- 1:15:48those 200,000 to 300,000 units built
- 1:15:51over 10 years. Finally, the
- 1:15:54quantitative needs of the French people
- 1:15:57were being addressed. And the question
- 1:16:01has still not been resolved, since
- 1:16:03today this issue of social housing is
- 1:16:05still a current issue, a major
- 1:16:07political stake. Even if the figures we
- 1:16:11might cite—when Le Petit spoke of 13
- 1:16:14million homeless—fortunately, France
- 1:16:16is not in that situation today, but the
- 1:16:19situation remains significant
- 1:16:21nonetheless. And so between '54 and '75
- 1:16:25, more than 8 million housing units
- 1:16:27were built throughout France. And you
- 1:16:30can well imagine, 8 million homes leave
- 1:16:32a mark. It truly has an impact on the
- 1:16:36landscape of our cities and our
- 1:16:39peripheries. It truly shapes the French
- 1:16:42landscape in a significant way,
- 1:16:44regardless of the quality of this
- 1:16:46housing, of course. So, we finally
- 1:16:50answered that question, but we answered
- 1:16:53it essentially in quantitative terms.
- 1:16:57To judge the quality a bit, I will take
- 1:17:00an example: the operations conducted by
- 1:17:04the SCIC. The SCIC, which is the real
- 1:17:08estate subsidiary of the Caisse des
- 1:17:10Dépôts et Consignations. And for that
- 1:17:14, I will rely heavily on a work that I
- 1:17:16cite in my bibliography, which is the
- 1:17:19work—currently a thesis—by Paul
- 1:17:21Landauer, which was defended not long
- 1:17:24ago, just 4 or 5 years ago, and which
- 1:17:26should soon result in a book, and I
- 1:17:29really hope this book is published soon
- 1:17:31. The SCIC played a truly major role in
- 1:17:37the policy of large housing estates,
- 1:17:39both as a financing body, since the
- 1:17:41Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations
- 1:17:44has that objective. Since the 19th
- 1:17:47century, it has been an organization
- 1:17:49that collects public funds and makes
- 1:17:51them available to the State for
- 1:17:53operations, not only for housing, and
- 1:17:55even until '54, for very little housing
- 1:17:58. It participated somewhat in the
- 1:18:00Loucheur Act, but it was not one of its
- 1:18:03main activities. But in '54, the State
- 1:18:06asked the Caisse des Dépôts to set up
- 1:18:09a real estate subsidiary. And so, the
- 1:18:14SCIC was created, which would be
- 1:18:16structured by engineers and not by
- 1:18:18architects, and which would quickly
- 1:18:21establish itself both as an essential
- 1:18:24financing body and an organization that
- 1:18:27was not just there to provide money,
- 1:18:29but would create a structure for
- 1:18:32consulting, organization, and project
- 1:18:34management. So the SCIC would truly be
- 1:18:39at the root of a number of operations,
- 1:18:42surrounding itself with a certain
- 1:18:44number of architects it would select,
- 1:18:46and it would really be a player in
- 1:18:48urban planning and housing policy
- 1:18:50during that period. To such an extent
- 1:18:53that by 1958, so between '54 and '58,
- 1:18:56the SCIC already represented 10%of
- 1:18:59social housing production in France and
- 1:19:0250%of projects in the Paris region.
- 1:19:05That goes to show its impact, and this
- 1:19:08impact would be even greater over the
- 1:19:10years, not just through the operations
- 1:19:12it conducted itself, but through the
- 1:19:14exemplary nature it would represent.
- 1:19:19Meaning that the method implemented by
- 1:19:21the SCIC, which is an unrelenting
- 1:19:23method of rationalizing these
- 1:19:25operations, would be taken as a model
- 1:19:28by other organizations to finance,
- 1:19:30organize, and structure other housing
- 1:19:32projects in France. So the SICE will
- 1:19:36also establish itself as a model, a
- 1:19:38methodological model, and that impact
- 1:19:40will be significant. That is why the
- 1:19:43statements made by the leaders of the
- 1:19:46SIC have a value I would call exemplary
- 1:19:48for other operations. So what exactly
- 1:19:53does François Bloch-Lainé, the
- 1:19:55president of the Caisse des Dépôts et
- 1:19:58Consignations in '54, say? Uh,
- 1:20:01Bloch-Lainé instructs: popular housing
- 1:20:06for which aesthetic considerations must
- 1:20:08necessarily remain in the background.
- 1:20:11And I stop here because it is quite
- 1:20:13baffling. Why should aesthetic
- 1:20:15considerations necessarily remain in
- 1:20:17the background when it comes to popular
- 1:20:20housing? There is, therefore, an a
- 1:20:23priori, a starting bias that borders on
- 1:20:26cynicism, and which is an extremely
- 1:20:29important element in the definition of
- 1:20:33these large housing projects. So,
- 1:20:36aesthetic considerations that must
- 1:20:38remain in the background. It was better
- 1:20:40, it seems—excuse me, it was better,
- 1:20:42it seems—to turn to architects known
- 1:20:45for their long experience as builders?
- 1:20:48What does that mean beneath the surface
- 1:20:49? And this is the work of Paul Landauer
- 1:20:51, who highlights it well. Uh, it means
- 1:20:54that the SIC will never surround itself
- 1:20:56with disruptive architects. It will
- 1:20:59never go see Le Corbusier. Even
- 1:21:02Baudouin will work on SIC operations,
- 1:21:04but not called by the SIC, called by
- 1:21:06the municipalities who want to work
- 1:21:08with him. The SIC prefers to work with
- 1:21:13quality architects, architects who have
- 1:21:15good experience as builders, as is said
- 1:21:18there, architects who are completely in
- 1:21:21a logic of rationalization but who
- 1:21:23won't be too much into research and
- 1:21:26into endless discussion, I would say—
- 1:21:28I am caricaturing, of course—with the
- 1:21:31client. And François Bloch-Lainé adds
- 1:21:35:" In popular housing, it is important
- 1:21:37above all to achieve the highest
- 1:21:39possible utilization coefficient, and
- 1:21:41on this point, it seems that we can no
- 1:21:43longer hope for great progress. "And
- 1:21:46construction sites, like that of the
- 1:21:48Rotard competition, of the Rotterdam
- 1:21:50housing project in Strasbourg, which
- 1:21:52was already focused on the search for
- 1:21:54the most efficient ratio possible, have
- 1:21:56allowed to to obtain, to move toward
- 1:22:00this goal. And for François
- 1:22:03Bloch-Lainé, for the SIC, theories of
- 1:22:05the modern movement, this
- 1:22:07simplification of forms, this
- 1:22:09radicalization of architectural
- 1:22:11language into simple geometric shapes,
- 1:22:13this suppression of decoration, all
- 1:22:15these elements, this preoccupation with
- 1:22:17industrialization that was already
- 1:22:19present among the moderns appear as the
- 1:22:22possible elements of a doctrine for
- 1:22:24this construction policy. And so, the
- 1:22:28large-scale housing policy would seize
- 1:22:30upon the theories of the modern
- 1:22:32movement, but by oversimplifying them
- 1:22:35and filtering them through a
- 1:22:37quantitative policy that was,
- 1:22:38admittedly, necessary. A lot of money
- 1:22:42was put into this large-scale housing
- 1:22:45policy, but only just enough money, not
- 1:22:48a cent more. And that is what lies
- 1:22:50behind these phrases from François
- 1:22:52Blcléné. Another interesting quote
- 1:22:55comes from Léon Paul Leroi, who we see
- 1:22:57here. Léon Paul Leroi, an engineer who
- 1:23:01is completely absent from the history
- 1:23:03of 20 th-century architecture in France
- 1:23:05, yet is a key figure in this
- 1:23:06large-scale housing policy. He is the
- 1:23:09director of the Sy and as such, it was
- 1:23:11really he who defined this method of
- 1:23:16work, its objectives, and who stuck to
- 1:23:19it absolutely and who is of a
- 1:23:25unheard-of radicalism. From the point
- 1:23:27of view of the design of these
- 1:23:29complexes, says Léon Paul Leroi, two
- 1:23:31theses were firmly established. In fact
- 1:23:33, they were dogmas. The first dogma: we
- 1:23:35did not want to see the anarchic
- 1:23:37suburbs that prevailed between the two
- 1:23:39wars. And behind this critique, it is
- 1:23:42the critique of the suburban houses and
- 1:23:44the sprawl, of the poor-quality
- 1:23:47subdivisions in the suburbs of large
- 1:23:49cities, and particularly of Paris, that
- 1:23:52is being condemned. And then the second
- 1:23:55argument: we must adopt firm
- 1:23:56architectural stances, that is to say,
- 1:23:58things that are, roughly speaking,
- 1:24:00squares or rectangles, whatever the
- 1:24:02case may be. So here again, we see it,
- 1:24:06the formal and aesthetic discourse, the
- 1:24:09spatial, architectural, and
- 1:24:10distributive quality is absolutely not
- 1:24:13considered in these operations. It is a
- 1:24:16secondary question. The modern movement
- 1:24:20provides a language perfectly adapted
- 1:24:22to industrialization, to the
- 1:24:23standardization of buildings, and to
- 1:24:25rapid construction. Let us use it. And
- 1:24:29here, I have shown again the vocabulary
- 1:24:32of primary forms and invariants that Le
- 1:24:35Corbusier proposed since his purist
- 1:24:37manifesto, since" Toward an
- 1:24:39Architecture. "It is this language that
- 1:24:41is being taken up. But the language of
- 1:24:44the modern movement is one based on the
- 1:24:46balance of form, based on a very fine,
- 1:24:48very subtle plastic language. If you
- 1:24:52use it in a mediocre way, it very
- 1:24:54quickly becomes indigestible, and that
- 1:24:56is unfortunately what happened in most,
- 1:24:59perhaps not all, but most of these
- 1:25:02large-scale housing operations. So, the
- 1:25:05architectural vocabulary of these large
- 1:25:07complexes could almost be reduced to a
- 1:25:10few images. Here, these are photos
- 1:25:13taken in the Champ de Manœuvre housing
- 1:25:16estate. It's a residential area near
- 1:25:18Angoulême, designed by Louis Simon,
- 1:25:20one of the architects involved in the
- 1:25:22reconstruction of Royan. So he worked
- 1:25:25on Royan, where he built things like
- 1:25:27the covered market with its concrete
- 1:25:29shells. He conducted a lot of formal
- 1:25:31and technical research of great quality
- 1:25:33, while simultaneously working on the
- 1:25:35Champ de Manœuvre estate. And the
- 1:25:38Champ de Manœuvre estate—these
- 1:25:39aerial views clearly show the typology
- 1:25:41of large housing projects being reduced
- 1:25:43. Basically, and I’m simplifying a
- 1:25:45bit here, the block, the slab, and the
- 1:25:48tower. And here, we have just about all
- 1:25:51the compositional elements of these
- 1:25:54large housing projects. Aesthetically,
- 1:25:57from a distance like this, it obviously
- 1:26:00resembles modern architecture, but it's
- 1:26:02what I’d call the language stripped
- 1:26:05down to its barest essentials. The
- 1:26:08apartments themselves are often of good
- 1:26:10quality. That is the case in Angoulême
- 1:26:13, by the way—apartments that offer, I
- 1:26:15repeat once again, comfort and space
- 1:26:18that separates different functions.
- 1:26:21Here too, we don't mix everything
- 1:26:23together, but they lack any particular
- 1:26:25spatial quality, with very few
- 1:26:26exceptions. And there are exceptions,
- 1:26:28of course, and there are also large
- 1:26:30housing projects that don't look like
- 1:26:31the ones I just showed. There's what
- 1:26:33Emilio did, for example, but that's
- 1:26:35totally marginal in the production of
- 1:26:37these large housing projects. So we are
- 1:26:40very, very far from the qualities
- 1:26:41proposed by those modern movement
- 1:26:43architects of the 20s and 30s, even in
- 1:26:45their research into" minimum housing, "
- 1:26:47where there was often much more design
- 1:26:49work than what we see here. The policy
- 1:26:53for these large housing projects was
- 1:26:56driven by heavy prefabrication, which
- 1:26:59was not what the modern movement
- 1:27:01architects proposed; they were more
- 1:27:03interested in the prefabrication of
- 1:27:06structural elements—relatively light
- 1:27:09concrete or steel parts to be assembled
- 1:27:11on-site. Instead, very quickly—under
- 1:27:15pressure from the large construction
- 1:27:18firms selected for these projects—we
- 1:27:20shifted toward heavy prefabrication
- 1:27:23solutions using entire panels,
- 1:27:25transported by truck to the sites. So
- 1:27:28all of this has a cost and is quite far
- 1:27:31from the proposals put forward in the
- 1:27:331920s. A logic that isn't functional or
- 1:27:37functionalist, but rather a network
- 1:27:39logic—essentially a logic of economy.
- 1:27:44How to lay out water, gas, electricity,
- 1:27:46sewage, and so on in the most rational
- 1:27:49way possible. And this network logic,
- 1:27:53uh, naturally reflects on the master
- 1:27:55plan of these operations. The logic of
- 1:27:59the crane path with the simplicity and
- 1:28:01rationalization of the construction
- 1:28:03site it provides. So we see it here in
- 1:28:06an operation, well, in Angoulême or
- 1:28:08even here in Strasbourg. And then the
- 1:28:11triumph of cement, uh, the architects
- 1:28:13of the modern world were not all and
- 1:28:16solely focused on concrete. Far from it
- 1:28:18. And, moreover, in 1930-31, when"
- 1:28:20L'Architecture d'Aujourd'hui "begins to
- 1:28:22be published, it starts with a major
- 1:28:24survey on which materials, uh, you
- 1:28:26would choose if you were building
- 1:28:28housing and important buildings. And it
- 1:28:31is the modern architects who respond,
- 1:28:33and almost unanimously, they all answer
- 1:28:35metal as a priority because they see in
- 1:28:37metal a much more flexible material
- 1:28:39that is easier to use in a
- 1:28:40prefabricated way. So cement was not a
- 1:28:44material that was necessarily essential
- 1:28:46to impose. In any case, the modern
- 1:28:49movement did not call solely for cement
- 1:28:51. And then, above all, there is the
- 1:28:54logic of" the lowest bid, "meaning
- 1:28:56constantly, in these operations,
- 1:28:59selecting the contractors who offer the
- 1:29:01lowest quotes, leading to a constant
- 1:29:04decline in quality. So, we see it, the
- 1:29:08ideas of the modern movement are taken
- 1:29:10and oversimplified most of the time,
- 1:29:12but they are not the only ones being
- 1:29:14summoned. And what seems quite curious
- 1:29:17to me is that these large housing
- 1:29:19projects were created not just by
- 1:29:21taking the ideas of the modern movement
- 1:29:23and distorting them, but also by using
- 1:29:25ideas from the Beaux-Arts culture. And
- 1:29:28paradoxically, it is Candilis who gives
- 1:29:30us one of the keys to interpretation in
- 1:29:32an article for" L'Architecture
- 1:29:34d'Aujourd'hui. "He says the point of
- 1:29:36contact between the urban planner and
- 1:29:38the architect, the point where the
- 1:29:40urban planner stops and the architect
- 1:29:42begins, excuse me, is the master plan.
- 1:29:46And he adds that open spaces cease to
- 1:29:48be corridor spaces between built
- 1:29:50volumes. The harmonic interplay between
- 1:29:53solids and voids, between successive
- 1:29:55open spaces, between material, form,
- 1:29:57and color, between the site and the
- 1:29:59master plan gives architects an
- 1:30:01inexhaustible range of research and
- 1:30:03solutions. So we can clearly see the,
- 1:30:06uh, plastic dimension, the, uh, even, I
- 1:30:09would almost say, the notion of
- 1:30:11composition remains present in, uh, the
- 1:30:14work of these modern architects. It is
- 1:30:17significant that, as an illustration
- 1:30:20for this article, Candy reuses this
- 1:30:23image—the plan of the Acropolis of
- 1:30:26Athens drawn by Auguste Choisy, which
- 1:30:29was—pardon—adopted by Le Corbusier
- 1:30:32in*Towards a New Architecture*. It
- 1:30:36shows not the classical composition of
- 1:30:40urbanism and architecture, but another
- 1:30:43type of composition where the elements,
- 1:30:46the Parthenon, the Erechtheion, and the
- 1:30:49various temples on the hill, are
- 1:30:52arranged according to paths, viewpoints
- 1:30:55, and visual effects, following a logic
- 1:30:59entirely different from that of
- 1:31:02alignment or perspective with a
- 1:31:04vanishing point. This harmonic
- 1:31:08interplay is present quite deeply, even
- 1:31:11in the*Barth*culture within the
- 1:31:13composition of large housing estates. I
- 1:31:17will take two examples, or rather,
- 1:31:20three. The first is a neighborhood unit
- 1:31:24in Marly-le-Roi; the term" neighborhood
- 1:31:27unit "itself evokes the" unité
- 1:31:29d'habitation "and the Corbusian
- 1:31:31vocabulary. This neighborhood unit was
- 1:31:34created by Lods, Bodiansky, and
- 1:31:36Honegger, who were authentic modern
- 1:31:38architects, along with the
- 1:31:40Arsène-Henry brothers, young
- 1:31:41architects convinced by the ideas of
- 1:31:44the Modern Movement. This project is
- 1:31:47located here—we see it in yellow
- 1:31:49within this ring, which is actually the
- 1:31:51road that circles the large estate—
- 1:31:54situated near Versailles, Marly-le-Roi,
- 1:31:56and Saint-Germain-en-Laye. In an
- 1:32:00article dedicated to this project, the
- 1:32:04authors establish a direct, admitted,
- 1:32:07and fully acknowledged lineage to the
- 1:32:11Athens Charter. It was important, they
- 1:32:15say, to adopt a course of action based
- 1:32:17on indisputable principles. We decided
- 1:32:19to adopt those of the Athens Charter.
- 1:32:21The work is now considered an authority
- 1:32:23. These conclusions summarize the work
- 1:32:25of the most qualified professionals
- 1:32:26from around the world. So, for them,
- 1:32:29their work truly follows in the
- 1:32:31continuity of the Athens Charter.
- 1:32:34Moreover, the article's illustrations
- 1:32:36clearly show this excerpt from a grid.
- 1:32:39We find the chapters of the Athens
- 1:32:41Charter: housing, work, recreation,
- 1:32:44circulation, and in the columns,
- 1:32:46questions dealing with the environment,
- 1:32:49land use, building volume, aesthetics,
- 1:32:52and so on. So, a very rational analysis
- 1:32:54; that is the grid. We can also see on
- 1:32:57the site plan where I have highlighted
- 1:32:59the residential blocks in yellow. They
- 1:33:01are all aligned on the same axis,
- 1:33:03practically parallel to the north-south
- 1:33:06axis, providing the best possible
- 1:33:08orientation and, presumably,
- 1:33:10dual-aspect apartments. These are truly
- 1:33:13principles derived from the Athens
- 1:33:14Charter, along with this hierarchy of
- 1:33:16circulation routes featuring that
- 1:33:18peripheral road. Cars do not enter the
- 1:33:20housing estate. Uh, pedestrian paths or
- 1:33:23bicycle lanes are what allow access. On
- 1:33:25the other hand, there are underground
- 1:33:28parking lots that provide access to
- 1:33:30both residential buildings and a few
- 1:33:33services, such as schools, supermarkets
- 1:33:36, etc., located within the estate. And
- 1:33:39then here is another diagram that
- 1:33:41allows us to see problems with sunlight
- 1:33:43according to the different times of the
- 1:33:46year. So everything is rationally
- 1:33:49designed. And then when we continue
- 1:33:51reading the article, we find other
- 1:33:54interesting sentences. The plateau on
- 1:33:56which our land extends is an admirable
- 1:33:58base, but it is only that. We can then
- 1:34:01think, without excessive pretension,
- 1:34:03that the creation on its surface of a
- 1:34:05set of buildings and gardens must
- 1:34:06generate a new perspective. Why
- 1:34:09shouldn't it be as beautiful as the old
- 1:34:11one? And we see here these architects,
- 1:34:15starting from the Athens Charter,
- 1:34:17wanting to compete with classic
- 1:34:19compositions like those of Versailles,
- 1:34:22Marly-le-Roi, or Saint-Germain; they
- 1:34:24continue by saying one must adopt a
- 1:34:26mindset identical to that of our
- 1:34:28predecessors. So they are truly placing
- 1:34:32themselves in this logic, and the site
- 1:34:35plan—or rather the location plan they
- 1:34:37present—where they place their
- 1:34:39neighborhood unit within the setting of
- 1:34:42Versailles, Marly, and Saint-Germain,
- 1:34:44shows that they want to compose with
- 1:34:46these three entities. So they do it,
- 1:34:49but it’s visible from an airplane,
- 1:34:51though it will never be seen from the
- 1:34:52ground. And he explains it. Shouldn't
- 1:34:56we strive to keep the mindset of those
- 1:34:58who, throughout previous eras, worked
- 1:35:00on different themes? The principles of
- 1:35:02composition will remain the same. The
- 1:35:05elements of composition will be
- 1:35:06different. So these architects put back
- 1:35:09into the Athens Charter, put back into
- 1:35:11these functionalist concerns,
- 1:35:13compositional concerns that are not
- 1:35:15entirely absent from the Athens Charter
- 1:35:17, of course, but are absolutely not the
- 1:35:19essential element. And we even see them
- 1:35:22using the term" parti, "which is not a
- 1:35:24term used by architects of the modern
- 1:35:26movement. And we see here the whole
- 1:35:29succession of different" partis ";
- 1:35:32there are 27 that were studied to
- 1:35:34arrive at the final design, with
- 1:35:37buildings sometimes even being
- 1:35:39realigned along axes that are no longer
- 1:35:42the axes of optimal sunlight. So we see
- 1:35:46that these formal, aesthetic, and site
- 1:35:49planning concerns come to mingle and
- 1:35:51can even take precedence over other
- 1:35:54considerations. The general spirit
- 1:35:57remains a spirit derived from the
- 1:35:58Athens Charter, and we also see other
- 1:36:00interesting elements like here, the
- 1:36:02luminous area under the building, which
- 1:36:04shows that the buildings are raised on
- 1:36:07pilotis. So that is also an important
- 1:36:09element of urban fluidity. But the
- 1:36:12decision is there and so there is
- 1:36:14another type of composition. The second
- 1:36:17example I will cover is Jean
- 1:36:19Failleton’s for Chevilly-Larue. Jean
- 1:36:22Failleton is someone who worked a lot
- 1:36:24for the SICE, an excellent architect
- 1:36:26whose archives we recovered at the
- 1:36:28French Institute of Architecture; he
- 1:36:30was an architect of very high quality
- 1:36:32and a great expert in metal, even
- 1:36:34before the Second World War. And Jean
- 1:36:38Failleton, well, created this plan for
- 1:36:39Chevilly-Larue. We see where north is
- 1:36:42here, and we immediately realize that,
- 1:36:44while at first glance it looks like
- 1:36:47modern architecture and modern urban
- 1:36:49planning with a certain densification
- 1:36:51of buildings, communal facilities
- 1:36:53nearby, and a certain hierarchy of
- 1:36:56traffic routes. However, we see that in
- 1:36:59terms of the layout, well, there are
- 1:37:01buildings a bit in every direction, and
- 1:37:03clearly, some buildings do not have the
- 1:37:06best orientation, and we are ultimately
- 1:37:08as much in a plastic game of balancing
- 1:37:10masses as we are in a functionalist
- 1:37:12logic. And I can make this comparison,
- 1:37:15which is a bit easy, but one in which,
- 1:37:17moreover, I see no historical
- 1:37:19connection. I do not establish any
- 1:37:21connection between Failleton’s work
- 1:37:23and the painting by Bart van der Leck.
- 1:37:26And between this geometric abstraction
- 1:37:28of the De Stijl movement and this type
- 1:37:30of plan, there is an identical effort
- 1:37:33to balance masses—balancing the large
- 1:37:35block and the smaller ones that are
- 1:37:37there, which are orthogonal and then
- 1:37:39themselves punctuated by four small
- 1:37:42plots. And we see how all of this comes
- 1:37:44to balance out in a logic that is no
- 1:37:47longer at all a purely rational and
- 1:37:49functional or functionalist logic. So
- 1:37:52these concerns of planning organization
- 1:37:56often take precedence over other
- 1:37:58concerns. The last example is by Paul
- 1:38:04Herbé, who was a major post-war
- 1:38:06architect and who built a great deal
- 1:38:09after the Second World War. And here in
- 1:38:13Villeneuve-la-Garenne, he creates a
- 1:38:15large housing complex. Here again, the
- 1:38:18first glance gives an impression of a
- 1:38:19certain connection, and it does exist
- 1:38:21with the Athens Charter and the modern
- 1:38:23movement. Starting with the zoning, we
- 1:38:27see here the residential area in green
- 1:38:30—a green city—the work areas with
- 1:38:34this yellow grid, and a leisure area
- 1:38:37along the river, along the Seine. So we
- 1:38:41do have a separation of functions and
- 1:38:42an entire organization of fairly
- 1:38:44hierarchical roads, with a highway even
- 1:38:46passing through to distribute the
- 1:38:47entire area. So it works perfectly. But
- 1:38:51when you look at how it's organized,
- 1:38:54you have the meander of the Seine, and
- 1:38:56you see that the main axis for
- 1:38:58organizing this large complex and all
- 1:39:01its annexes is along this line that
- 1:39:03falls right at the lowest point of the
- 1:39:06meander, as if by chance. The second
- 1:39:10axis starts off perpendicularly. The
- 1:39:13third is based on a 30 °/60 °
- 1:39:16division. So, a very, very conventional
- 1:39:19division. And if you hadn't understood
- 1:39:23that this third axis is in that ratio,
- 1:39:25well, Paul Herbé places a round
- 1:39:28building here that marks the angle. A
- 1:39:32bit like how I learned in elementary
- 1:39:34school to mark angles when drawing a
- 1:39:36geometric shape. So we have something
- 1:39:40quite artificial here, and for good
- 1:39:42measure, to balance this curved
- 1:39:44building, he puts another one there,
- 1:39:46and another one here. Then these two
- 1:39:49small curved buildings that are facing
- 1:39:50one another. So, on the site plan, it
- 1:39:53balances out well. On the ground, you
- 1:39:56never see it. That is to say, it's
- 1:39:58everything the Modern Movement and Le
- 1:40:00Corbusier condemn regarding urban
- 1:40:02planning done from a human perspective.
- 1:40:06I mean, urban planning must be done for
- 1:40:08the human eye and not for an aerial or
- 1:40:10bird's-eye view. And here, that is
- 1:40:12exactly the case. At the human scale,
- 1:40:15you absolutely cannot perceive these
- 1:40:18balances and compositions, but it is a
- 1:40:20certain satisfaction for these urban
- 1:40:23planners. And so, we see that this
- 1:40:25culture borrowed from the Modern
- 1:40:28Movement is not so so pure as that, and
- 1:40:32that it mixes with other references.
- 1:40:34Now, examples of urban planning closer
- 1:40:36to functionalist models and the models
- 1:40:39of the Athens Charter do exist. I will
- 1:40:42take just one. They are not very
- 1:40:44numerous, but I will take just one. It
- 1:40:47is a complex I work on a lot, which is
- 1:40:50the Firminy-Vert complex located here,
- 1:40:52where Le Corbusier built the cultural
- 1:40:55center, the stadium, the church—even
- 1:40:58though it was built after his death—
- 1:41:00and a housing unit. And we must also
- 1:41:03add the swimming pool, which was built
- 1:41:05by Wogenscky. Initially, it was Le
- 1:41:07Corbusier who was supposed to do it,
- 1:41:09but he only made a tiny sketch for the
- 1:41:11site plan. So it is really a project by
- 1:41:13Wogenscky. And the plan for Firminy, so
- 1:41:171,000 homes here too, is a No, 10,000
- 1:41:23homes, sorry. No, 1,000 homes, no,
- 1:41:25that's right. It's a plan that isn't by
- 1:41:28Le Corbusier, but by André Sive and
- 1:41:30Marcel Roux, and Charles Delfond also
- 1:41:32worked on it. They were younger
- 1:41:35architects than Le Corbusier. These
- 1:41:37were people who had read the Athens
- 1:41:38Charter and claimed it, even if they
- 1:41:40didn't want to apply it to the letter.
- 1:41:42André Sive himself, who we see here,
- 1:41:45came to France. He was of Hungarian
- 1:41:47origin because he admired Le Corbusier
- 1:41:49and wanted to come work in the country
- 1:41:51where Le Corbusier lived. And so there
- 1:41:54is this filiation, and Firminy as a
- 1:41:56whole is interesting with housing
- 1:41:58concentrated in only 15 buildings. So,
- 1:42:02a true densification in height, a
- 1:42:04peripheral circulation route that
- 1:42:06closes the composition and which, at
- 1:42:08the same time, allows the whole city to
- 1:42:10be accessed without entering it. Uh
- 1:42:14here, afterwards, secondary circulation
- 1:42:16routes that come to distribute only the
- 1:42:19housing and which are also equipped
- 1:42:21with parking and garages. And all
- 1:42:26around, a set of green spaces with even
- 1:42:28a large green corridor that runs
- 1:42:31through the whole city, and then in
- 1:42:33blue, all the public facilities that go
- 1:42:36with the housing. The mayor of this
- 1:42:40city is Claudius-Petit, and
- 1:42:41Claudius-Petit wants to make an example
- 1:42:43in Firminy of what he could not achieve
- 1:42:45as Minister of Reconstruction. And so
- 1:42:47there is not only the housing estate,
- 1:42:50but there is a house of culture, the
- 1:42:53stadium, a church, a swimming pool, uh
- 1:42:56a shopping center, housing of course,
- 1:42:58and also schools. So it is really a
- 1:43:01complete piece of city that is designed
- 1:43:04globally. But this example will remain
- 1:43:09extremely rare in the context of the
- 1:43:11reconstruction, sorry, of the large
- 1:43:13housing projects. This period of the
- 1:43:1750s and 60s is not only the period of
- 1:43:19the triumph, in quotes, of the modern
- 1:43:21movement and at the same time its
- 1:43:23deviation within the large housing
- 1:43:25projects. It is also the period of the
- 1:43:28triumph of the modern movement within a
- 1:43:31certain number of more prestigious
- 1:43:33programs, whether individual houses
- 1:43:35like here in Royan, churches, or large
- 1:43:37sports facilities like here in Tokyo
- 1:43:39with Kenzo Tange or the opera house.
- 1:43:43Finally, the modern movement, the ideas
- 1:43:45of the modern movement with extremely
- 1:43:47varied styles, by the way, triumphed
- 1:43:49during this same period. But even if
- 1:43:52these works are of very high quality,
- 1:43:55and some are now beginning to be listed
- 1:43:57as world heritage, the image that will
- 1:43:59remain essentially is that of this mass
- 1:44:01production of housing and this
- 1:44:03functionalist city, or in any case
- 1:44:05starting from functionalist principles,
- 1:44:07which was created in this 20-year
- 1:44:09period. In March 1973, Olivier Guichard
- 1:44:15brought an end to this policy of
- 1:44:17large-scale housing projects. Social
- 1:44:22housing would obviously continue to be
- 1:44:24built, but using different methods with
- 1:44:27a much greater mix of functions. We
- 1:44:31began to rediscover the values of the
- 1:44:33traditional city, but the era of these
- 1:44:36large housing complexes ended with that
- 1:44:38circular from Olivier Guichard. Yet the
- 1:44:42image of the modern movement remains
- 1:44:45permanently imprinted by it. And I will
- 1:44:48conclude with this somewhat paradoxical
- 1:44:51image, which I like very much, and the
- 1:44:53legend associated with it. Peter Blake,
- 1:44:56an American architect and critic, said
- 1:45:00in one of his works:" Modern
- 1:45:02architecture died in St. Louis,
- 1:45:05Missouri, on July 15, 1972, at 3:32
- 1:45:08p.m., or thereabouts. "He’s not
- 1:45:11entirely sure. And it’s interesting
- 1:45:13for more than one reason, first of all
- 1:45:15because what was actually destroyed? In
- 1:45:18St. Louis, Missouri? A housing project,
- 1:45:21the Pruitt-Igoe complex, designed by an
- 1:45:23architect named Yamasaki, which was
- 1:45:26presented in the United States as the
- 1:45:28European model of the modern movement.
- 1:45:32The very archetype itself. And it was a
- 1:45:35complex with many qualities, notably
- 1:45:37the spatial quality of the apartments
- 1:45:39and the intermediate spaces between
- 1:45:40public and private realms. But a policy
- 1:45:44, I would say of ghettoization, caused
- 1:45:49this place to become a site of high
- 1:45:51crime, one of the most dangerous places
- 1:45:54in the United States. And it was one of
- 1:45:56the first large housing complexes—as
- 1:45:58it happens, in the United States—to
- 1:46:00be destroyed. Which allowed Peter Blake
- 1:46:03, clearly showing that the modern
- 1:46:05movement is somewhat equated with this
- 1:46:08policy of large complexes, or at least
- 1:46:10these large housing structures, to
- 1:46:12claim that modern architecture died in
- 1:46:15St. Louis, Missouri, on July 15, 1972,
- 1:46:17at 3:32 p.m. Obviously, the modern
- 1:46:19movement did not die that day, and we
- 1:46:22are still living with its legacy, even
- 1:46:25if we are currently facing a
- 1:46:27contemporary eclecticism built upon the
- 1:46:29foundations of that modern movement.
- 1:46:32These ideas are still here. Its primary
- 1:46:33shapes and geometric forms are still
- 1:46:35our own. The pitched roof has not
- 1:46:38returned, nor has ornamentation, apart
- 1:46:40from a few isolated projects, of course
- 1:46:43. But we are still within that legacy.
- 1:46:46Where this image is interesting is that
- 1:46:49it clearly shows this assimilation,
- 1:46:51illustrating both the triumph and the
- 1:46:53deviation of this modern movement. But
- 1:46:56at the same time, it is also
- 1:46:59interesting because in the destruction
- 1:47:02of that tower, there is a new paradox.
- 1:47:07Modernist architects were heavily
- 1:47:09criticized for their utopian view that
- 1:47:12modern architecture or urban planning
- 1:47:14could solve society's problems. In
- 1:47:17other words, they produced a
- 1:47:19therapeutic form of urbanism,
- 1:47:20attempting to save society through
- 1:47:22urban planning. It was a powerful,
- 1:47:25major utopia, and one that also brought
- 1:47:27many very positive things to the modern
- 1:47:28movement. And today, to address the
- 1:47:32societal ills now embodied by these
- 1:47:34large housing projects, what are we
- 1:47:35doing? Well, we are tearing down those
- 1:47:37large housing projects. In any case,
- 1:47:38that is one of the most frequently used
- 1:47:40solutions. And so, we are repeating the
- 1:47:43same utopia by thinking that simply
- 1:47:45destroying and changing architecture
- 1:47:48and urban planning is enough to fix
- 1:47:50societal issues and solve the new
- 1:47:52problems these projects created. We are
- 1:47:55falling back into the same paradox that
- 1:47:56defined the utopia of the architects
- 1:47:58and urban planners of the modern
- 1:48:00movement. That is all, thank you. M.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 11. De la reconstruction aux grands ensembles by Cité de l'architecture et du patrimoine, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 16,039 words across 2,586 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.