YouTube2Text

Международное обозрение 11.09.2026 — Transcript

by Международное Обозрение · 7,353 words · 1,211 segments · language en · Watch on YouTube

Full transcript

  1. 0:02Hello, this is International Review. In
  2. 0:04the studio is Fyodor Lukyanov.
  3. 0:07Today on International Review. Events
  4. 0:12of the week, chronicle, facts,
  5. 0:13commentary. A restart of diplomatic
  6. 0:18efforts. Trump's emissaries visited
  7. 0:21Moscow and Kyiv. The negotiation
  8. 0:23process—a new round. A
  9. 0:27quarter-century since the attacks in
  10. 0:29America. What did the fall of the Twin
  11. 0:31Towers change? The War on Terror. Are
  12. 0:33there any winners? A political
  13. 0:38earthquake in Germany. The far-right
  14. 0:41has won an election. In our program
  15. 0:44today. A quarter-century ago, on the
  16. 0:52morning of September 11, 2001, Eastern
  17. 0:55Time, the whole world watched in shock
  18. 0:57at a scene that had previously been
  19. 1:00imaginable only in movies through
  20. 1:02special effects. Huge passenger
  21. 1:07airliners, hijacked by suicide
  22. 1:09terrorists, crashed into both World
  23. 1:11Trade Center towers in New York and the
  24. 1:14Pentagon building in Washington. A
  25. 1:18fourth plane, presumably heading for
  26. 1:20the White House, crashed in
  27. 1:22Pennsylvania when passengers, realizing
  28. 1:24what was happening, fought back against
  29. 1:27the terrorists. That, at any rate, is
  30. 1:29the official version. Cynics at the
  31. 1:32time suggested that the plane was
  32. 1:34simply shot down once it became clear
  33. 1:36where it was heading. Who organized the
  34. 1:39attacks and how, and why they became
  35. 1:41possible, has been written and said
  36. 1:43countlessly over 25 years. Conspiracy
  37. 1:45theories have accompanied the topic
  38. 1:47throughout all this time. The events
  39. 1:50were just too astonishing. But whatever
  40. 1:53lay behind them, one thing is
  41. 1:55indisputable. They had a profound
  42. 1:57impact on the system of international
  43. 1:59relations. And although the
  44. 2:02socio-political avalanche that has
  45. 2:04struck the world in the 21st century
  46. 2:06has pushed September 2001 into the
  47. 2:08background, the turning point happened
  48. 2:10right then. The global war on terror,
  49. 2:15proclaimed by a shocked American
  50. 2:17administration, was supposed to unite
  51. 2:20humanity, since everyone saw where true
  52. 2:23evil originated. Well, it turned out
  53. 2:26differently. The goal of the
  54. 2:29anti-terrorist coalition, as understood
  55. 2:32by George W. Bush, was not just to
  56. 2:34eradicate the most hardcore extremists,
  57. 2:37but to reshape the whole world in the
  58. 2:39interest of U.S. national security.
  59. 2:43There have indeed been no attacks like
  60. 2:479/11 in the United States since then.
  61. 2:50But the world, and primarily the Middle
  62. 2:53East, has turned into a much less
  63. 2:56stable and far more dangerous place.
  64. 3:03The George W. Bush administration's
  65. 3:05concept of the war on terror was
  66. 3:07formulated almost immediately after the
  67. 3:09September 11, 2001, attacks. It was
  68. 3:12announced by the U.S. president himself
  69. 3:14in a radio address to the nation on
  70. 3:16September 15. This time we face a
  71. 3:18different type of conflict against a
  72. 3:20different type of enemy. This is a
  73. 3:22conflict that will not have
  74. 3:24battlefields or beachheads. A conflict
  75. 3:27in which our adversaries think they are
  76. 3:29invisible. Victory over terrorism will
  77. 3:32not be the result of a single battle,
  78. 3:35but of a whole series of decisive
  79. 3:37actions against terrorist organizations
  80. 3:39and those who harbor and support them.
  81. 3:43In George W. Bush's view, the fight
  82. 3:45against terrorism was conceived as a
  83. 3:47global existential conflict between the
  84. 3:49so-called civilized world and the
  85. 3:51forces of evil. The Axis of Evil was
  86. 3:55declared to include not only
  87. 3:56military-political groups like the
  88. 3:58Taliban and Al-Qaeda, but also all
  89. 4:00political regimes hostile to the U.S.,
  90. 4:02primarily in Iran, Iraq, Syria, Libya,
  91. 4:04North Korea, and several other
  92. 4:06countries. Six days later, on September
  93. 4:1021, Bush delivered his second address
  94. 4:12to the nation. In it, he stated that
  95. 4:15the confrontation could be long and
  96. 4:17difficult. The enemy would be punished,
  97. 4:20as would those who support them. At the
  98. 4:23same time, he issued an appeal to
  99. 4:24governments around the world: "Either
  100. 4:26you are with us, or you are with the
  101. 4:27terrorists." In reality, it was not
  102. 4:31about ensuring the safety of United
  103. 4:33States citizens, but about reshaping
  104. 4:36the world to eliminate potential
  105. 4:38sources of danger for America once and
  106. 4:40for all. The 2002 National Security
  107. 4:44Strategy, timed to the anniversary of
  108. 4:47the September 11 attacks, stated that
  109. 4:49the U.S. reserves the right to act
  110. 4:52alone. And beyond fighting terrorists,
  111. 4:56the document also proclaimed the goal
  112. 4:58of spreading democracy and human rights
  113. 5:01worldwide and expanding joint actions
  114. 5:03with partners, including Russia. It is
  115. 5:06noteworthy that Russia was mentioned in
  116. 5:08the document 19 times. Iran and North
  117. 5:11Korea were declared America's main
  118. 5:14enemies, posing a threat in terms of
  119. 5:16nuclear weapons proliferation. Syria,
  120. 5:20Cuba, Belarus, Myanmar, and Zimbabwe
  121. 5:22were classified as despotic regimes. In
  122. 5:262001, just a few days after the
  123. 5:28September 11 attacks, the U.S.
  124. 5:30president declared a war on terror and
  125. 5:33began Operation Enduring Freedom in
  126. 5:36Afghanistan. In 2003, Washington
  127. 5:39unveiled its strategy for promoting
  128. 5:41democracy in the Middle East and began
  129. 5:44implementing it. That was when the
  130. 5:47United States invaded Iraq. And they
  131. 5:49overthrew the regime of Saddam Hussein.
  132. 5:52Following the assassination of Lebanese
  133. 5:54Prime Minister Rafic Hariri in 2005,
  134. 5:56the U.S. pressured Syria and forced it
  135. 5:58to withdraw its troops from Lebanon.
  136. 6:01And in Lebanon itself, the Cedar
  137. 6:04Revolution took place. The U.S.
  138. 6:11response to 9/11 permanently destroyed
  139. 6:14relations with the Islamic world; it
  140. 6:16simply put an end to them. The process
  141. 6:19began many years before 9/11, back in
  142. 6:21Afghanistan in the eighties. I was
  143. 6:24serving there at the time and
  144. 6:25interacted with all the active forces,
  145. 6:28including Osama bin Laden. The main
  146. 6:30change occurred during that very period
  147. 6:32when radical Salafist groups
  148. 6:34infiltrated Afghanistan. This radically
  149. 6:37changed the nature of coexistence
  150. 6:38between different groups. After all, if
  151. 6:41you look at Kandahar before the war,
  152. 6:43Sufis were predominant, and the
  153. 6:44mujahedeen belonged to that movement.
  154. 6:47The same applied to the northern and
  155. 6:49northwestern territories, but now there
  156. 6:51are uncompromising Wahhabis and
  157. 6:53Salafists everywhere. Thus, it was the
  158. 6:56initiative of Zbigniew Brzezinski, who
  159. 6:58convinced President Carter to recruit
  160. 7:00radical Islamists to Afghanistan, that
  161. 7:02laid the foundation for the events of
  162. 7:042001. I remember going to Saudi Arabia
  163. 7:08and telling them: "Which of those you
  164. 7:10support truly care for their people and
  165. 7:12communities?" But there are others,
  166. 7:16like Gulbuddin Hekmatyar. They pose a
  167. 7:18threat not only to their own people,
  168. 7:21but to European cities as well. I
  169. 7:23warned back then that it would all end
  170. 7:25with explosions in Western cities. I
  171. 7:27went to Washington and said the very
  172. 7:29same thing there.
  173. 7:31Alastair Crooke knows what he is
  174. 7:32talking about. As a British
  175. 7:35intelligence officer, he spent a lot of
  176. 7:37time in Afghanistan during the
  177. 7:39anti-Soviet jihad, which was supported
  178. 7:41by the West. Back then, I tried to
  179. 7:45explain in Washington that a nuanced
  180. 7:47understanding and a differentiated
  181. 7:49approach to various Islamic movements
  182. 7:51were necessary. And, of course, the
  183. 7:54events of 9/11 put an end to any hopes
  184. 7:57of better understanding and realizing
  185. 7:59what is happening in the Islamic world,
  186. 8:01why it is happening, and how this
  187. 8:04situation could be better managed. As a
  188. 8:07result, the situation developed in such
  189. 8:09a way that engaging in dialogue with
  190. 8:10Islamists became practically impossible
  191. 8:12. A complete rejection of diplomacy and
  192. 8:15the total demonization of many groups
  193. 8:16that they had previously tried to use.
  194. 8:19This trend persists to this day. In
  195. 8:25August 2021, the U.S. and its NATO
  196. 8:28allies completed the withdrawal of
  197. 8:30troops from Afghanistan, ending the
  198. 8:32longest military campaign in American
  199. 8:34history. Operation Enduring Freedom
  200. 8:38began after the 9/11 attacks and lasted
  201. 8:4120 years, twice as long as the war in
  202. 8:43Iraq. During this time, tens of
  203. 8:46thousands of civilians and more than
  204. 8:492,500 American soldiers died. The
  205. 8:51campaign was far too expensive.
  206. 8:53According to analysts 'estimates,
  207. 8:55Washington spent more than 300 million
  208. 8:57dollars daily on the war in Afghanistan
  209. 9:00over two decades. In 2011, there was
  210. 9:02serious talk in the White House about
  211. 9:05reducing the contingent. Barack Obama
  212. 9:08promised that American troops would
  213. 9:10finish the operation in 3 years and
  214. 9:12leave the country. But this plan was
  215. 9:15never implemented. By the end of 2014,
  216. 9:18there were still about 10,000 American
  217. 9:21soldiers in Afghanistan under Operation
  218. 9:24Freedom's Sentinel, which later evolved
  219. 9:26into the NATO mission Resolute Support.
  220. 9:31In 2017, Trump, by contrast, allowed
  221. 9:34military commanders in the region to
  222. 9:36increase troop numbers without prior
  223. 9:39White House approval, officially for
  224. 9:42training, advising, and assisting
  225. 9:44Afghan forces. As a result, by 2018,
  226. 9:49the number of the American contingent
  227. 9:52had grown to 15,000. In February 2020,
  228. 9:56the U.S. and the Taliban signed a peace
  229. 9:59agreement which, among other things,
  230. 10:01obligated the U.S. and NATO to withdraw
  231. 10:04troops from Afghanistan within 14
  232. 10:06months of signing the document,
  233. 10:08provided the Taliban met their
  234. 10:10obligations. In 2021, under Biden, the
  235. 10:15parties set a deadline of August 31.
  236. 10:19And even though the date was known in
  237. 10:21advance, the withdrawal of American
  238. 10:23troops turned out to be poorly
  239. 10:25organized. The American military left
  240. 10:27Afghanistan in a hurry, abandoning
  241. 10:29weapons and equipment. In a British
  242. 10:32Times cartoon, a soldier resembling Joe
  243. 10:34Biden says as he flies away that he is
  244. 10:37leaving the country in the same state
  245. 10:39it was in. According to the Pentagon,
  246. 10:42when leaving Afghanistan, the U.S. left
  247. 10:447 billion dollars worth of military
  248. 10:46equipment to the Taliban. On July 30,
  249. 10:49as part of Operation Allies Refuge,
  250. 10:52aircraft evacuated U.S. embassy staff
  251. 10:55and Afghan citizens—primarily
  252. 10:57military translators who faced the
  253. 10:59threat of reprisals—from the country.
  254. 11:03People were flown out on C-17 cargo
  255. 11:06planes amidst complete chaos. Crowds of
  256. 11:09those wishing to leave Kabul stormed
  257. 11:11the airport. The US military fired
  258. 11:14warning shots and used stun grenades.
  259. 11:18And although US troops managed to
  260. 11:20withdraw on time, not all Americans
  261. 11:23were evacuated. The destabilization of
  262. 11:30the Middle East began with September 11
  263. 11:32and Washington's reaction to it. With
  264. 11:35one hand, the United States destroyed
  265. 11:37terrorists, and at the same time,
  266. 11:39regimes they disliked that had nothing
  267. 11:41to do with terror. With the other, they
  268. 11:44created an environment for the
  269. 11:46emergence of new extremist forces.
  270. 11:48Osama bin Laden was liquidated, and
  271. 11:50Al-Qaeda was radically weakened. The
  272. 11:53Islamic State was defeated, albeit with
  273. 11:55great difficulty. However, the Islamist
  274. 11:58environment, while changing forms,
  275. 12:00persisted and spread. Perhaps the most
  276. 12:03striking trajectory is that of Syria.
  277. 12:06On September 11, 2001, it was a fairly
  278. 12:09stable and relatively prosperous
  279. 12:12secular authoritarian state, having
  280. 12:15normal relations with almost everyone.
  281. 12:20Twenty-five years later, it is a ruined
  282. 12:22country with unclear borders, governed
  283. 12:25by people who started their careers in
  284. 12:27Al-Qaeda, but are now recognized by all
  285. 12:30as a democratic government. The bloody
  286. 12:34phantasmagoria that reigned between
  287. 12:36these two points with the active
  288. 12:38participation of external forces is not
  289. 12:40even worth remembering. Before 2001,
  290. 12:46terrorism was most often considered a
  291. 12:48local or regional problem. Sometimes it
  292. 12:52was viewed as a tool of national
  293. 12:54liberation struggle, which meant that
  294. 12:57in certain cases it could even be
  295. 12:59perceived neutrally or positively. That
  296. 13:02is, terrorists could be treated with
  297. 13:04understanding. An example is the
  298. 13:07so-called Irish Republican Army in
  299. 13:09Great Britain, which fought for the
  300. 13:12liberation of Northern Ireland. Or a
  301. 13:15similar situation existed with the
  302. 13:17Basques in Spain and their terrorist
  303. 13:19group. Separately stood numerous groups
  304. 13:23in the Middle East, but among them,
  305. 13:26Fatah, the movement for the liberation
  306. 13:28of Palestine, which also used terrorist
  307. 13:31methods, stood out. But its leader,
  308. 13:34Yasser Arafat, even received the Nobel
  309. 13:36Peace Prize for his efforts aimed at
  310. 13:39achieving peace in the Middle East,
  311. 13:41sharing it with Israeli politicians.
  312. 13:44However, everything changed abruptly
  313. 13:46after the September 11 attacks. The
  314. 13:49attitude toward terrorism changed
  315. 13:51completely. In the US, Europe, and most
  316. 13:54developed countries, it began to be
  317. 13:56perceived as an existential threat to
  318. 13:58all civilized society, which, moreover,
  319. 14:00has no borders. In most countries of
  320. 14:04the world, security measures were
  321. 14:05tightened, and citizens agreed to them.
  322. 14:08Surveillance cameras appeared
  323. 14:09everywhere. In airports, a ban on
  324. 14:11carrying liquids in carry-on luggage
  325. 14:13was introduced. However, Russia
  326. 14:16encountered international terrorism.
  327. 14:18Even earlier. Back in September of '99,
  328. 14:21during the counter-terrorist operation
  329. 14:23in the North Caucasus, Prime Minister
  330. 14:26Putin declared that there would be no
  331. 14:28negotiations with terrorists.
  332. 14:30We will pursue the terrorists
  333. 14:31everywhere. At the airport. At the
  334. 14:33airport, so, you'll have to excuse me,
  335. 14:35we'll catch them in the toilet, we'll
  336. 14:36waste them in the outhouse, in the end.
  337. 14:38That's it, the matter is closed once
  338. 14:40and for all.
  339. 14:40This phrase, "Waste them in the
  340. 14:42outhouse," became a catchphrase in
  341. 14:44Russia long before September 11.
  342. 14:47Meanwhile, after the 9/11 attacks, on
  343. 14:50October 26, 2001, the US Congress
  344. 14:52passed, and President Bush signed, the
  345. 14:55so-called Patriot Act. The document,
  346. 14:59over 340 pages long, significantly
  347. 15:02expanded the powers of security
  348. 15:04agencies. Over time, their capabilities
  349. 15:07only expanded. In May 2026, the Trump
  350. 15:10administration broadened the very
  351. 15:12concept of terrorism. It now includes
  352. 15:15Latin American drug cartels and
  353. 15:17left-wing radicals. But average
  354. 15:20Americans see the dangers in a
  355. 15:21completely different way. According to
  356. 15:25recent polls by services like Gallup
  357. 15:28and Pew, seven in ten Americans
  358. 15:30consider the spread of misinformation
  359. 15:33online to be their primary threat, not
  360. 15:36terrorism. The main global political
  361. 15:44significance of September 11 is the
  362. 15:47pivot away from the end of history, a
  363. 15:50period when the United States held a
  364. 15:52near-monopoly on global influence after
  365. 15:55the Cold War. The September 11 attack
  366. 16:01occurred during a unipolar moment when
  367. 16:03the U.S. was the only great power on
  368. 16:05the planet. Classical great-power
  369. 16:09politics did not exist as such, because
  370. 16:11there were no rivals of that caliber
  371. 16:13capable of competing with each other. A
  372. 16:17small group called al-Qaeda, which
  373. 16:20hated American policy in the Middle
  374. 16:23East, found a way to strike the United
  375. 16:26States and cause it serious damage,
  376. 16:28sparking a global war on terror. This,
  377. 16:32in turn, led to a series of endless
  378. 16:35wars that we were dragged into,
  379. 16:37primarily in Afghanistan and Iraq. Both
  380. 16:40of these wars turned out to be a
  381. 16:42disaster. Our reaction to the events of
  382. 16:45September 11 was deeply flawed. As
  383. 16:51early as January 2002, the U.S. claimed
  384. 16:54that Saddam Hussein might have weapons
  385. 16:56of mass destruction and was ready to
  386. 16:58hand them over to terrorist
  387. 17:00organizations. Therefore, on March 20,
  388. 17:032003, the U.S. and its allies invaded
  389. 17:06Iraq. In total, the coalition included
  390. 17:0949 countries, with the total number of
  391. 17:12troops exceeding half a million. France
  392. 17:14and Germany did not participate in the
  393. 17:16invasion. The Iraqis expected an attack
  394. 17:18from the NATO country of Turkey. But at
  395. 17:21the last moment, the Turkish parliament
  396. 17:23refused, and the offensive began from
  397. 17:25Kuwait. Major cities in Mesopotamia,
  398. 17:28including Basra, were surrounded. This
  399. 17:31is where the events from the book
  400. 17:33Generation Kill, which later became a
  401. 17:34series about U.S. Marines, took place.
  402. 17:37The main force moved toward Baghdad.
  403. 17:40Its goal was to dash through the narrow
  404. 17:42corridor between Lake Milh and the
  405. 17:44Euphrates near Karbala. This is where
  406. 17:47the defenders could have put up a fight
  407. 17:49, and the Americans seriously feared
  408. 17:51the use of chemical weapons. But the
  409. 17:53Iraqis were too late. The attack by the
  410. 17:56Iraqi Medina and Nebuchadnezzar
  411. 17:58divisions turned into a slaughter, and
  412. 18:00U.S. troops broke through to Baghdad.
  413. 18:03There was no clear plan for taking the
  414. 18:05capital; it was probed with military
  415. 18:08raids. On April 9, Marines toppled the
  416. 18:11statue of Saddam Hussein in Firdos
  417. 18:13Square, and this finally broke the
  418. 18:15Iraqi will to fight. Saddam Hussein
  419. 18:18fled from Baghdad. He was captured on
  420. 18:20December 13 not far from the city of
  421. 18:22Tikrit. Three years later he was
  422. 18:25executed, but weapons of mass
  423. 18:26destruction were never found in Iraq.
  424. 18:29On May 1, aboard the aircraft carrier
  425. 18:31Abraham Lincoln, George Bush
  426. 18:33triumphantly declared victory. This
  427. 18:36event marked the beginning of the Iraqi
  428. 18:38saga, which lasted more than 20 years.
  429. 18:41A civil war between Sunnis and Shiites
  430. 18:43began in Iraq. The Americans took the
  431. 18:46side of the Shiite government in 2006.
  432. 18:50As a result of the merger of radical
  433. 18:52Sunni factions with Al-Qaeda, the
  434. 18:54Islamic State terrorist group emerged.
  435. 18:58It was joined by many former army and
  436. 19:00intelligence officers who were left
  437. 19:02unemployed after the overthrow of
  438. 19:04Saddam Hussein, as well as former
  439. 19:05Ba'ath Party officials who had passed
  440. 19:07through American prisons in Iraq.
  441. 19:10Largely thanks to their assistance and
  442. 19:13experience, the terrorist group managed
  443. 19:15to seize vast territories in Iraq and
  444. 19:17Syria. And the group itself became
  445. 19:20known as the Islamic State of Iraq and
  446. 19:23the Levant. ISIS was only pushed out of
  447. 19:26the captured lands and largely defeated
  448. 19:28in the second half of the 2010s with
  449. 19:29the active participation of the armed
  450. 19:31forces of Russia and the United States.
  451. 19:34The U.S. withdrew its troops from Iraq
  452. 19:37in stages. In August, Barack Obama
  453. 19:40withdrew at least half of the American
  454. 19:42contingent. At the same time, 50,000
  455. 19:45troops remained to train the Iraqi army
  456. 19:48and police. The second phase of the
  457. 19:50withdrawal began only in April 2020,
  458. 19:53after one of the leaders of the Islamic
  459. 19:55Revolutionary Guard Corps, General
  460. 19:57Qasem Soleimani, was killed at Baghdad
  461. 20:00airport. And this was done at the
  462. 20:02demand of the Iraqi parliament. The
  463. 20:04Americans limited their presence to two
  464. 20:06bases. One is Al-Harir, near the city
  465. 20:10of Erbil in Iraqi Kurdistan. The other
  466. 20:13is Ain al-Asad in Anbar province, 180
  467. 20:16km from Baghdad. In January 2026, U.S.
  468. 20:20troops left it. Can one say that
  469. 20:28September 2001 marked the beginning of
  470. 20:30the end of this very unipolar world? I
  471. 20:35think so. The nineties were the heyday
  472. 20:37of the unipolar moment. Russia remained
  473. 20:40in a terrible, extremely weakened state
  474. 20:42throughout that decade, right up until
  475. 20:45Putin came to power, just at the very
  476. 20:47end of the nineties. That was when he
  477. 20:49began the geopolitical resurrection of
  478. 20:51Russia. By 2001, China was not yet
  479. 20:54showing excessively rapid growth either
  480. 20:56, but it was just then that China
  481. 20:58joined the WTO, and its economic growth
  482. 21:01rates accelerated sharply. Throughout
  483. 21:05the nineties, up until about 2001-2002,
  484. 21:07the United States was an incredibly
  485. 21:09powerful country. But after September
  486. 21:1311, things began to decline quite
  487. 21:15quickly, and the next milestone was the
  488. 21:182008 financial crisis, which hit
  489. 21:20Americans hard. During the period of
  490. 21:24the unipolar world, the U.S. had much
  491. 21:26more freedom to interfere in the
  492. 21:28affairs of other states, since there
  493. 21:30were no competitors among the great
  494. 21:32powers, and they could freely get
  495. 21:33involved in all sorts of trouble in
  496. 21:35places like Afghanistan and Iraq. But
  497. 21:39then multipolarity arrived, and now the
  498. 21:42United States has to worry primarily
  499. 21:44about competing great powers. One could
  500. 21:48talk about the political consequences
  501. 21:50of September 11 for a very long time.
  502. 21:52In many ways, they shaped the modern
  503. 21:54world. But above all, it was a huge
  504. 21:58human tragedy. Almost 3,000 people died
  505. 22:01. Our regular contributor Dmitry
  506. 22:03Vershinin reports on the memory of this
  507. 22:05event. American flags along the roads.
  508. 22:11In front of the perfect lawns by the
  509. 22:13houses, the bright morning sun bathes
  510. 22:14the meadows and farms of western
  511. 22:16Pennsylvania. It is not yet autumn, but
  512. 22:18no longer summer. Mid-September. An
  513. 22:20idyllic time in this part of the
  514. 22:22country. United Flight 93 departed from
  515. 22:24Newark Airport for San Francisco with a
  516. 22:26delay. So, when the terrorists hijacked
  517. 22:29the plane and turned it around near
  518. 22:30Cleveland toward Washington, the
  519. 22:32passengers on the flight understood the
  520. 22:34situation pretty quickly. Tom Burnett,
  521. 22:37seat 4B, a Minnesota native, made four
  522. 22:39cell phone calls to his wife in
  523. 22:40California. Back then, cell service
  524. 22:43worked during flights. Tom Burnett is a
  525. 22:46hero in Minnesota. He was born not far
  526. 22:49from the town where I lived. And,
  527. 22:51naturally, I wanted to know everything
  528. 22:52about the last minutes of his life. His
  529. 22:55wife informed the authorities that
  530. 22:56their flight had been hijacked and that
  531. 22:58it was likely part of a massive attack
  532. 23:00on America. The decision he made in a
  533. 23:02matter of minutes: to storm the cockpit
  534. 23:05. Sean Macan is drawing a chalk
  535. 23:07portrait of Tom Burnett. It is part of
  536. 23:09a global project to help America
  537. 23:10remember the victims of the events from
  538. 23:12a quarter-century ago. I want to bring
  539. 23:15him back to life, for a moment to give
  540. 23:18people a chance to feel that he is one
  541. 23:20of us, that his soul is somewhere here.
  542. 23:23The country's best graffiti artists are
  543. 23:25drawing portraits of all 40 passengers
  544. 23:27and crew members of Flight 93. The
  545. 23:29project's author, Eric Greenwald, was a
  546. 23:3123-year-old budding illustrator for
  547. 23:33Pittsburgh's main newspaper at the time
  548. 23:35of the tragedy.
  549. 23:36My wife's mother called me. I was
  550. 23:39working nights back then and sleeping
  551. 23:40late. She woke me up and said, "Turn on
  552. 23:43the TV immediately." The shock, the
  553. 23:46tragedy that happened that day. I was
  554. 23:48assigned to create an illustration for
  555. 23:49the front page of the newspaper's
  556. 23:51special edition. It was already clear
  557. 23:53then that the world would never be the
  558. 23:54same.
  559. 23:55For his portrait, Eric Greenwald chose
  560. 23:57a Pennsylvania native, a toy warehouse
  561. 23:59manager and powerlifter named Louis
  562. 24:01Nacke. It is believed he was one of
  563. 24:03those who broke down the cockpit door
  564. 24:05and tried to level the plane in the
  565. 24:07final seconds before the crash. He was
  566. 24:27passionate about comics, science
  567. 24:28fiction, and action movies, especially
  568. 24:30Superman. He had a Superman tattoo, and
  569. 24:34in a sense, he became a Superman
  570. 24:36himself. The event marking the
  571. 24:38quarter-century anniversary of the
  572. 24:39tragedy is held under the slogan "We
  573. 24:41Will Remember Forever." However, an
  574. 24:43entire generation of people born after
  575. 24:452001 has grown up in the world. They
  576. 24:47have never seen a world without metal
  577. 24:49detectors. They don't know that you
  578. 24:51could call the ground during a flight,
  579. 24:53and they didn't see the collapse of the
  580. 24:55Twin Towers in Manhattan live on air
  581. 24:57with their own eyes. Yeah. Ah,
  582. 25:05and our task is to pass the information
  583. 25:13to teachers so they can tell the
  584. 25:15children. There are young teachers who
  585. 25:18were born after 2001. They have to talk
  586. 25:21about an event they didn't see
  587. 25:22themselves, as they weren't even born
  588. 25:25yet. The walls of the memorial are
  589. 25:27built so that one can only see the
  590. 25:28plane's trajectory in the final seconds
  591. 25:30before it crashed. The Tower of Voices,
  592. 25:33which plays whimsical melodies
  593. 25:34depending on the direction and strength
  594. 25:36of the wind. And the answering machine
  595. 25:39recordings at the local museum, voice
  596. 25:40notes from the past that even today
  597. 25:42bring a lump to one's throat.
  598. 25:44I listened to the recordings on
  599. 25:46old-fashioned answering machines, left
  600. 25:47by passengers of that flight for their
  601. 25:49loved ones before they died. I was able
  602. 25:51to listen to them once. My heart breaks
  603. 25:55when I think that these people became
  604. 25:57heroes and saved the lives of tens of
  605. 25:59hundreds of others, knowing they were
  606. 26:01already doomed. These recordings are
  607. 26:04just as hard to listen to today as they
  608. 26:06were in 2001.
  609. 26:07And there are 40 flags behind the fire
  610. 26:09station in Shanksville, the closest
  611. 26:10town to the crash site. It was from
  612. 26:12here that paramedics first arrived at
  613. 26:15the giant crater. All these symbols are
  614. 26:17reminders of the tragedy. But what to
  615. 26:19do when a tragedy? inexorably becomes
  616. 26:22the past. Dmitry Vershinin for
  617. 26:24International Review, Shanksville,
  618. 26:26Pennsylvania. It is notable that Trump
  619. 26:33supporters were already comparing
  620. 26:35themselves to the passengers of Flight
  621. 26:3793, who sacrificed themselves to save
  622. 26:39other people and the country, during
  623. 26:41the 2016 campaign. "Let us perish
  624. 26:46politically," wrote Trump ideologue
  625. 26:48Michael Anton at the time, "but we must
  626. 26:50at least try to turn America away from
  627. 26:53the ruinous course of radical Democrats
  628. 26:55that leads to catastrophe." Anton, by
  629. 26:59the way, did not stay long in either
  630. 27:02the first or the second Trump
  631. 27:03administration. Routine devours
  632. 27:06ideological fighters. We will continue
  633. 27:10after the break. In the American
  634. 27:17tradition, writing dates means the
  635. 27:20month number first, then the day. Hence
  636. 27:22the designation of those terrorist
  637. 27:23attacks as 9/11. In recent European
  638. 27:27history, this is also a landmark date,
  639. 27:29only in Europe the day comes first,
  640. 27:31then the month. So, here 9/11 is
  641. 27:34November 9th, the day the Berlin Wall
  642. 27:39fell in '89. the main symbol of the
  643. 27:42collapse of the socialist bloc and the
  644. 27:44unification of Germany. This week, a
  645. 27:46political earthquake happened there.
  646. 27:49The Alternative for Germany party
  647. 27:51completely crushed Friedrich Merz's
  648. 27:54ruling CDU in the state parliamentary
  649. 27:56elections in Saxony-Anhalt. The
  650. 28:00far-right fell just short of an
  651. 28:01absolute majority that would have
  652. 28:03allowed them to form their own
  653. 28:04government. But a major political
  654. 28:07crisis has effectively been launched,
  655. 28:09and not just in a specific state, but
  656. 28:11at the national level in Germany. The
  657. 28:14old party system has begun to crumble.
  658. 28:21Marilena Nardi from Italy and her work
  659. 28:23titled "Movement in the Opposite
  660. 28:25Direction." Chancellor Merz is
  661. 28:27literally drowning in the Alternative
  662. 28:30for Germany party emblem, and the arrow
  663. 28:32points in the other direction. Anne
  664. 28:35Derenne from France. Victory of the AfD
  665. 28:39in the elections. The result is
  666. 28:41demonstrated on road signs. The left
  667. 28:45one is a turn to the right, and the
  668. 28:46other sign is a turn for the far-right,
  669. 28:48but essentially a U-turn. Marian
  670. 28:51Kamensky from Slovakia does not lower
  671. 28:53the heat of the struggle. Heroic
  672. 28:55Chancellor Friedrich Merz is building
  673. 28:57an anti-fascist wall to protect Germany
  674. 29:00from a far-right victory. One should
  675. 29:03not forget that the country already had
  676. 29:05one wall in its history. Oliver Schopf
  677. 29:08from Austria. The drawing is called "
  678. 29:10Under Pressure." The CDU lost the
  679. 29:13municipal elections to Alternative for
  680. 29:15Germany. Chancellor Merz says: "I will
  681. 29:18not back down from my reform course,
  682. 29:20but the chair has already been kicked
  683. 29:22out from under him." Christo
  684. 29:24Komarnitski from Bulgaria, Chancellor
  685. 29:26Friedrich Merz and the supposedly
  686. 29:28Russian drones found in Leipzig. In
  687. 29:31this case, they also feature the AfD
  688. 29:33party symbol. A direct hint that Moscow
  689. 29:36is to blame for all of Germany’s
  690. 29:39troubles. We will talk about the
  691. 29:46political prospects of the AfD later.
  692. 29:48There will be plenty of opportunities
  693. 29:49to do so. The most interesting aspect
  694. 29:51right now is the one that concerns us
  695. 29:53directly. Attempts by German
  696. 29:56authorities to portray the Alternative
  697. 29:58as nearly a tool of Russian hybrid
  698. 30:01warfare aren't working yet. The scandal
  699. 30:04drummed up before the elections,
  700. 30:06accusing Russia of a sabotage attempt
  701. 30:09at Leipzig airport, only added votes to
  702. 30:12the far-right. However, the
  703. 30:14fear-mongering about a war with Russia
  704. 30:16is not stopping; on the contrary, it is
  705. 30:18being ratcheted up even further.
  706. 30:21General Carsten Breuer, Inspector
  707. 30:23General of the Bundeswehr—the highest
  708. 30:25officer position in Germany—spoke at
  709. 30:28length on Wednesday in an interview
  710. 30:30with Sandra Maischberger on the ARD
  711. 30:32channel. Russia does not perceive war
  712. 30:37as a set of separate intermediate
  713. 30:38states that we usually distinguish.
  714. 30:41That is, Russia does not divide the
  715. 30:44situation into peace, crisis, and war,
  716. 30:46but views it all as a single continuum
  717. 30:49that can be used at its discretion for
  718. 30:52both escalation and de-escalation.
  719. 30:55Moreover, as a rule, actions are
  720. 30:57structured to remain just below the
  721. 30:59threshold that would allow for
  722. 31:00unambiguous attribution of
  723. 31:02responsibility, or below the level that
  724. 31:04triggers NATO’s Article 5 on
  725. 31:05collective defense. The goal is to sow
  726. 31:10uncertainty among the German population
  727. 31:12, as well as to test how far they can
  728. 31:14go and create opportunities for
  729. 31:15penetration, to see how we react, so
  730. 31:17that in the event of a real attack,
  731. 31:19they know exactly what reaction to
  732. 31:21expect.
  733. 31:24You just swell with self-respect. How
  734. 31:26cunning and calculating we are. I
  735. 31:30believe that Russia, using the methods
  736. 31:32it currently employs, acts as a clear
  737. 31:35adversary specifically in the sphere of
  738. 31:37hybrid warfare. As an adversary, it
  739. 31:40demonstrates to us time and again that
  740. 31:42cooperation with it is impossible at
  741. 31:44the moment and that we should be
  742. 31:46prepared for the fact that this
  743. 31:47escalation I just mentioned may
  744. 31:49continue further. I do not want to
  745. 31:52think in terms of enemies, as I believe
  746. 31:54it prevents us from soberly assessing
  747. 31:56what is happening. Well, at least
  748. 31:59thanks for that. Although General
  749. 32:02Breuer does not want to think in terms
  750. 32:04of enemies, he sees the prospects of
  751. 32:06war clearly. I would warn against
  752. 32:10projecting everything we are doing now
  753. 32:12solely onto the situation in Ukraine.
  754. 32:15The war in Ukraine may be a lesson, but
  755. 32:17it is not a ready-made template for the
  756. 32:19future. The war of the future, on which
  757. 32:23we place the main emphasis in our
  758. 32:25military strategy, along with a clear
  759. 32:27definition of threats, will combine all
  760. 32:29known elements, for example, trench
  761. 32:30warfare or those "kill zones" we
  762. 32:32currently observe due to the use of
  763. 32:34drones and autonomous weapon systems.
  764. 32:37As well as something that awaits us in
  765. 32:38the future. This means that right now
  766. 32:41—and we have factored this into our
  767. 32:44military strategy and capability
  768. 32:46requirements—we must strike a balance
  769. 32:48, or rather ensure continuity, by
  770. 32:50innovating while simultaneously
  771. 32:53building up our forces by 2029 to a
  772. 32:55level that can withstand a conflict,
  773. 32:57and then gradually develop further,
  774. 32:59evolving into one of the most modern
  775. 33:02armies capable of successful operations
  776. 33:04in such a war. From the Inspector
  777. 33:09General's perspective, it is in 2029
  778. 33:11that Russia will gain the capability to
  779. 33:13attack Europe. And since it will gain
  780. 33:15that capability, one must assume it
  781. 33:17will attack. During the interview, the
  782. 33:20host pointed out to the general that
  783. 33:22voters, specifically those who voted
  784. 33:25for the AfD, want the government to
  785. 33:27spend money on social programs and
  786. 33:29welfare rather than on guns. The
  787. 33:32general, understandably, retorted that
  788. 33:34there is no social welfare without
  789. 33:36security. But something else is
  790. 33:39interesting. Our position is perfectly
  791. 33:42clear. We do not demonize weapons
  792. 33:45production as such, because later, when
  793. 33:47conducting a large-scale re-migration
  794. 33:49and deportation campaign, we will, of
  795. 33:52course, need the appropriate means.
  796. 33:56They are necessary for ensuring
  797. 33:57internal security, maintaining
  798. 33:59stability, and for the country’s
  799. 34:00defense. We understand this perfectly
  800. 34:03well. All of this does not come out of
  801. 34:06nowhere.
  802. 34:08The head of the Alternative for Germany
  803. 34:10party in Saxony-Anhalt, Ulrich Siegmund
  804. 34:11, the main election winner, assured
  805. 34:13that his party is not against
  806. 34:15militarization. Admittedly, its main
  807. 34:19target is not Russia, but migrants, for
  808. 34:21whose deportation a well-armed army and
  809. 34:24police force will be needed. But here,
  810. 34:27it would be a case of a gun on the wall
  811. 34:30, and it can be aimed at different
  812. 34:32targets. Interesting times are coming.
  813. 34:35Germany is returning to itself. It
  814. 34:39seems that the agendas of politicians
  815. 34:41busy preparing for a military
  816. 34:43confrontation and citizens concerned
  817. 34:45about their own well-being and wallets
  818. 34:48are diverging. Our author is Boris
  819. 34:51Friedel. Reports from the field. Today
  820. 34:57we are visiting Antje. The woman is
  821. 34:59having a stove installed. And, as the
  822. 35:01craftsmen say, they are currently
  823. 35:03overwhelmed with clients. Erik Pasow is
  824. 35:05a second-generation stove-setter.
  825. 35:07Demand for his work is growing every
  826. 35:09day, but he tries to give attention to
  827. 35:12every customer. We do everything: from
  828. 35:14the reconstruction of old buildings to
  829. 35:16work on new construction sites. The
  830. 35:19main flow of orders now comes from
  831. 35:20people who want to create an additional
  832. 35:22source of heat at home. They want to be
  833. 35:26sure that if there is a power grid
  834. 35:28failure or the heating goes out in
  835. 35:29winter, they won't freeze. As you can
  836. 35:32see, there was already a stove here
  837. 35:34before. In fact, there were four of
  838. 35:37them in this house. On the model I
  839. 35:40ordered, you can even cook.
  840. 35:44Why specifically a stove-top? Because
  841. 35:47when the heating cuts out or the lights
  842. 35:49go out, in most homes, standard stoves
  843. 35:51stop working too. But with a fireplace
  844. 35:54or a stove, you can at least boil a
  845. 35:56kettle or fry some potatoes. Fear of
  846. 35:59the unknown. Will they be able to pay
  847. 36:02their electricity and gas bills next
  848. 36:04year? forces Germans to tighten their
  849. 36:07belts. Everyone hopes to stay warm
  850. 36:09without going broke. Meanwhile, home
  851. 36:12improvement stores are thriving. Scared
  852. 36:15by the crisis, grandmothers are
  853. 36:17sweeping shelves clean in hopes of
  854. 36:19saving at least a little electricity.
  855. 36:21Although, with prices having
  856. 36:23skyrocketed, the question remains: will
  857. 36:24they actually manage to save anything?
  858. 36:27We are working a lot in old houses
  859. 36:29right now, because in some places,
  860. 36:31chimneys have still been preserved. We
  861. 36:33are also renovating houses where there
  862. 36:35are no chimneys or never were any at
  863. 36:37all. We build them from scratch and
  864. 36:39then install a fireplace. Depending on
  865. 36:43when and with whom contracts were
  866. 36:45signed—whether in trade, industry, or
  867. 36:47the private sector—rates can jump as
  868. 36:49much as fivefold. For many, this will
  869. 36:51become a heavy burden. A whole range of
  870. 36:55German businesses, institutions, and,
  871. 36:57honestly, a significant portion of
  872. 36:59ordinary families simply won't be able
  873. 37:01to afford it; as a result, debts and
  874. 37:03bankruptcies are rising. People really
  875. 37:07have to shell out. Due to material
  876. 37:10shortages, high production costs, steel
  877. 37:12prices, and high demand, the equipment
  878. 37:15itself has become significantly more
  879. 37:16expensive. You have to budget
  880. 37:20significantly more for a purchase today
  881. 37:22than you did before. This energy crisis
  882. 37:27we find ourselves in is one we created
  883. 37:29for ourselves.
  884. 37:30Well, I would say that yes, we are to
  885. 37:32blame ourselves. It shouldn't have come
  886. 37:35to this. Russia is part of Europe, and
  887. 37:37we shouldn't have pushed it to the
  888. 37:39sidelines with our policy. And this
  889. 37:42process dragged on for years. We simply
  890. 37:44stopped trying to get things back on
  891. 37:47track. And Europe practically cannot
  892. 37:49exist without Russia. We have turned
  893. 37:51into some kind of American puppets. In
  894. 37:54any case, that is exactly how it feels.
  895. 37:57And I’m not the only one who thinks
  896. 37:59so. Just as Antje’s apartment once
  897. 38:02had stoves, Germany recently had a
  898. 38:04developed gas infrastructure with
  899. 38:06storage facilities all across the
  900. 38:08country. The only thing is, they mostly
  901. 38:11belonged not to Germany, but to a
  902. 38:13Russian company. And in April 2022,
  903. 38:16they were expropriated. Politicians
  904. 38:19prefer to buy liquefied gas from the
  905. 38:21USA. This is shale gas, which just a
  906. 38:24couple of years ago was considered an
  907. 38:26absolute evil in Germany. It was called
  908. 38:29dirty gas that destroys the climate and
  909. 38:31causes methane emissions. But now we
  910. 38:34are buying this very fracked gas from
  911. 38:36the USA. In the media, it is now
  912. 38:39proudly called liquefied natural gas,
  913. 38:41or LNG. It is a blatant deception and a
  914. 38:43substitution of concepts. Yes, we no
  915. 38:46longer buy gas from Russia. Instead,
  916. 38:48our money is flowing in a massive
  917. 38:50stream to the United States. While
  918. 38:54politicians play their games, we wish
  919. 38:56for Antje to heat her stove only for
  920. 38:58warmth and comfort, not to cook food on
  921. 39:00it out of desperation. After all,
  922. 39:03firewood isn't cheap these days either.
  923. 39:14While Europe prepares for war, America
  924. 39:16seems to be making efforts for a
  925. 39:17peaceful resolution regarding Ukraine.
  926. 39:20Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner have
  927. 39:23made another trip for this purpose. The
  928. 39:26diplomatic flywheel is spinning once
  929. 39:28again according to the same pattern,
  930. 39:30but the attempts are commendable. The
  931. 39:36flight of US presidential envoys Steve
  932. 39:39Witkoff and Jared Kushner to Moscow
  933. 39:41broke a Flightradar record. 6,000
  934. 39:44people were tracking their movement in
  935. 39:47real time simultaneously. For Witkoff,
  936. 39:50this visit to Russia was his eighth,
  937. 39:52and for Jared Kushner, his third. But
  938. 39:55for the first time, they arrived in
  939. 39:57Moscow not on a business jet, but on a
  940. 39:59Boeing designated for top government
  941. 40:01officials. Following tradition, the
  942. 40:05American diplomats traveled in black
  943. 40:07Russian Aurus limousines and, before
  944. 40:09negotiations at the Kremlin, visited
  945. 40:11the famous Spaso House, the US
  946. 40:13ambassador's residence, after which
  947. 40:15they held a three-hour business lunch
  948. 40:17on Trubnaya Square with Kirill Dmitriev
  949. 40:19, head of the RDIF and the president's
  950. 40:22special envoy for investment and
  951. 40:23economic cooperation with foreign
  952. 40:25countries. The details, like the
  953. 40:29essence of the conversation over the
  954. 40:31meal, remained a secret, but it is
  955. 40:33known that the guests were served
  956. 40:34dishes from a special menu. A modern,
  957. 40:37original interpretation of Russian
  958. 40:39cuisine. Last August, before
  959. 40:41negotiations with Vladimir Putin, the
  960. 40:43American leader's special envoy had
  961. 40:45breakfast in Zaryadye Park with a giant
  962. 40:47cheburek filled with lamb and beef. And
  963. 40:50during his previous visit in December,
  964. 40:52Jared Kushner discovered posekunchiki,
  965. 40:55traditional Ural fried pies. True, they
  966. 40:58were served not with meat, but with
  967. 41:01Kamchatka crab. The guests were treated
  968. 41:04to dumplings with wild mushrooms, shchi
  969. 41:06soup with pineapples, and venison,
  970. 41:08which had been marinated for two days
  971. 41:10in vodka, onions, and herbs. A more
  972. 41:13modest reception was provided to Donald
  973. 41:15Trump's special envoys by the Ukrainian
  974. 41:17side. In the dining car of the
  975. 41:21so-called express train to Kyiv from
  976. 41:23the Polish city of Rzeszow, Witkoff and
  977. 41:26Kushner were offered bread from a
  978. 41:28bakery, spicy meze, Bakhchisaray
  979. 41:30shashlik, and khoshob, a compote made
  980. 41:33from dried fruits. The set of dishes
  981. 41:36was ostensibly Ukrainian, but in
  982. 41:38reality, it was Crimean Tatar cuisine.
  983. 41:40The enclosed menu stated that they were
  984. 41:42from free Ukrainian Crimea and
  985. 41:44reflected the heritage of the entire
  986. 41:46Crimean peninsula. The attempt to feed
  987. 41:49the distinguished guests with a hidden
  988. 41:51agenda sparked a good deal of irony on
  989. 41:52social media. While Moscow bets on
  990. 41:55tradition, Kyiv bets on provocation.
  991. 41:58Geneva remains committed to neutrality.
  992. 42:02In Switzerland, where tripartite talks
  993. 42:04on Ukraine were held previously,
  994. 42:06delegates were offered a classic buffet
  995. 42:08with French pastries and cheeses. With
  996. 42:16a full stomach, diplomacy is more
  997. 42:17cheerful, even if there are no results.
  998. 42:19If there are any. Why is the White
  999. 42:21House so persistent, a quality that is
  1000. 42:23not actually inherent to Trump? It is
  1001. 42:27China, not Russia, that is the real,
  1002. 42:29equally powerful, and dangerous rival
  1003. 42:31to the US. But Russia remains a great
  1004. 42:34power. Everyone acknowledges this. And
  1005. 42:37I believe that is precisely why the
  1006. 42:39United States attaches such great
  1007. 42:41importance to the war in Ukraine. The
  1008. 42:44reason President Trump is interested in
  1009. 42:46stopping or ending the war in Ukraine
  1010. 42:49and establishing good relations between
  1011. 42:51Russia and the United States is that he
  1012. 42:53understands: Russia is a great power,
  1013. 42:56and it would be much wiser for the U.S.
  1014. 42:58to be allied with Russia against China,
  1015. 43:00or at least to secure Russia’s
  1016. 43:02neutrality, rather than creating a
  1017. 43:04situation where we are effectively
  1018. 43:06pushing the Russians into the arms of
  1019. 43:09the Chinese. After all, if you imagine
  1020. 43:13life in a multipolar world where there
  1021. 43:15are three great powers, as the United
  1022. 43:18States, you want Russia on your side.
  1023. 43:21But instead, because of our unwise
  1024. 43:23policy regarding Ukraine, we have
  1025. 43:25pushed the Russians into the arms of
  1026. 43:27the Chinese ourselves. The conflict
  1027. 43:31surrounding Ukraine is very sharp and
  1028. 43:33profound. A diplomatic settlement is a
  1029. 43:35most difficult task. It is a feat only
  1030. 43:38for true titans. Of this type of
  1031. 43:41activity.
  1032. 43:45The Count of Equilibrium, the Coachman
  1033. 43:47of Europe, the devil's assistant, and
  1034. 43:49the greatest of liars. Austrian
  1035. 43:52diplomat Klemens von Metternich defined
  1036. 43:54the policy of the Habsburg monarchy for
  1037. 43:57almost 40 years. Ambassador of Austria
  1038. 43:59to Paris, and later Minister of Foreign
  1039. 44:01Affairs and Chancellor. After the
  1040. 44:03defeat by France, he arranged the
  1041. 44:06marriage of Napoleon Bonaparte to the
  1042. 44:08Austrian Princess Marie Louise and won
  1043. 44:10a strategic pause for Vienna. And
  1044. 44:13before Napoleon’s campaign against
  1045. 44:15Russia in 1812, he formalized an
  1046. 44:17alliance with France. While at the same
  1047. 44:20time assuring Alexander I that the
  1048. 44:22Austrian army would avoid combat
  1049. 44:24operations. In 1813, during nine-hour
  1050. 44:27negotiations in Dresden, he personally
  1051. 44:30tried to convince Bonaparte to make
  1052. 44:32peace, but was refused and joined the
  1053. 44:34anti-French coalition, which decided
  1054. 44:36the outcome of the war. The Congress of
  1055. 44:40Vienna he convened formed a collective
  1056. 44:43security system that gave Europe
  1057. 44:45several decades of relative peace.
  1058. 44:48France's interests at that congress
  1059. 44:50were represented by Charles Maurice de
  1060. 44:52Talleyrand. His name became a household
  1061. 44:55word, a synonym for cunning, dexterity,
  1062. 44:57and lack of principle. The father of
  1063. 45:00lies and the lame devil, as
  1064. 45:01contemporaries wrote of him, managed to
  1065. 45:04serve three regimes as Minister of
  1066. 45:05Foreign Affairs, and after the collapse
  1067. 45:08of Napoleon's empire, even as Prime
  1068. 45:09Minister. He personally took part in
  1069. 45:13drafting the Declaration of the Rights
  1070. 45:15of Man and of the Citizen and
  1071. 45:17contributed to the signing of the
  1072. 45:18Tilsit Peace Treaty, advantageous for
  1073. 45:20France, under which Russia recognized
  1074. 45:22all of Napoleon's conquests. The first
  1075. 45:25Chancellor of the German Empire, Otto
  1076. 45:28von Bismarck, is still considered one
  1077. 45:30of the most controversial and
  1078. 45:31influential politicians of the 19th
  1079. 45:33century, a diplomat and reformer. He
  1080. 45:36unified Germany as a result of three
  1081. 45:38bloody wars, and then effectively led
  1082. 45:40the country single-handedly for 20
  1083. 45:42years. Under him, German flags appeared
  1084. 45:46in Namibia, Togo, Cameroon, and New
  1085. 45:48Guinea, and Bismarck traded Zanzibar
  1086. 45:51for the island of Heligoland. Being a
  1087. 45:54staunch Protestant, he introduced the
  1088. 45:56Kulturkampf, a struggle against the
  1089. 45:57Vatican for the cultural unification of
  1090. 45:59Germany, and achieved the establishment
  1091. 46:01of state control over education. But at
  1092. 46:04the same time, this conflict served as
  1093. 46:06the cause for the alienation of an
  1094. 46:08entire generation of Catholics from the
  1095. 46:10national life of Germany. His Serene
  1096. 46:13Highness and State Chancellor Alexander
  1097. 46:15Gorchakov, author of the famous phrase
  1098. 46:18"Russia is not sulking, Russia is
  1099. 46:20gathering its strength," served in the
  1100. 46:23diplomatic field for 65 years, rising
  1101. 46:25from a staffer at embassies in London,
  1102. 46:28Rome, Berlin, and Vienna to head the
  1103. 46:30Foreign Ministry of the Russian Empire.
  1104. 46:34After the crushing defeat in the
  1105. 46:36Crimean War, Gorchakov gradually
  1106. 46:37managed to annul the humiliating
  1107. 46:39articles of the Treaty of Paris and
  1108. 46:41restored the country's right to the
  1109. 46:43Black Sea Fleet. He also expanded the
  1110. 46:45empire's policy beyond the continent.
  1111. 46:48Under his tenure, Russia sold Alaska to
  1112. 46:50the U.S., exchanged the Kuril Islands
  1113. 46:52for Sakhalin, and provided support to
  1114. 46:54Lincoln's government during the Civil
  1115. 46:56War. Benjamin Franklin was the only
  1116. 46:59Founding Father to sign all three key
  1117. 47:01documents in U.S. history: the
  1118. 47:03Declaration of Independence, the Treaty
  1119. 47:06of Paris, and the U.S. Constitution. A
  1120. 47:10scientist who proved the electrical
  1121. 47:12nature of lightning, invented the
  1122. 47:15lightning rod, and was the first to map
  1123. 47:17the Gulf Stream, he led a mission to
  1124. 47:20Paris in July 1776 and secured military
  1125. 47:23aid from Louis XVI, which decided the
  1126. 47:26outcome of the War of Independence. We
  1127. 47:33asked John Mearsheimer, a living
  1128. 47:35classic of international relations: "
  1129. 47:37What if Metternich or Talleyrand, the
  1130. 47:40benchmarks of diplomatic mastery, were
  1131. 47:42alive today? Would they be able to
  1132. 47:46solve the Ukrainian puzzle?"
  1133. 47:48Well, they were definitely great
  1134. 47:50diplomats. And speaking of the war
  1135. 47:52being waged by Ukraine and Russia, they
  1136. 47:55would go to great lengths to try to
  1137. 47:57resolve the conflict. But I don't think
  1138. 47:59they would have succeeded. I very much
  1139. 48:01doubt that the war in Ukraine can be
  1140. 48:04settled by diplomatic means at all. I
  1141. 48:06think it will be decided on the
  1142. 48:08battlefield because Russia's goals are
  1143. 48:10unacceptable to Ukraine, and Ukraine's
  1144. 48:13goals are unacceptable to Russia. Thus,
  1145. 48:15you see that the Russians and
  1146. 48:17Ukrainians are in direct conflict on
  1147. 48:19key issues, on which they are unwilling
  1148. 48:22to compromise. So, the question is how
  1149. 48:25to find a diplomatic solution, and the
  1150. 48:28answer is: you can't. This war will be
  1151. 48:30fought on the battlefield, and the
  1152. 48:32final outcome will be determined by
  1153. 48:34whoever wins.
  1154. 48:36A rather poor conclusion for
  1155. 48:38peacemakers. So, what does that mean?
  1156. 48:40Are all the efforts of the Trump
  1157. 48:41administration, the travels of Kushner,
  1158. 48:43Witkoff, and others just a waste of
  1159. 48:45time? I think, by and large, that is
  1160. 48:48the case. Regarding the Trump
  1161. 48:49administration, it is important to
  1162. 48:51emphasize the following. The president
  1163. 48:53himself has the right instinct. He
  1164. 48:55wants to resolve the confrontation in
  1165. 48:57Ukraine and establish good relations
  1166. 48:59between the U.S. and Russia. There is
  1167. 49:02no doubt that his intuition on this
  1168. 49:04matter is correct. But there are two
  1169. 49:07problems. One of them is structural,
  1170. 49:09which I have just spoken about. The
  1171. 49:11goals of the warring parties are
  1172. 49:12irreconcilable. The second is that
  1173. 49:14President Trump is an unskilled
  1174. 49:16negotiator. He considers himself a
  1175. 49:20brilliant master of deal-making,
  1176. 49:22believing he can easily end the
  1177. 49:23conflict, at least in his own mind, but
  1178. 49:26in reality, everything is exactly the
  1179. 49:28opposite. He is a clumsy, inept
  1180. 49:31diplomat, and because of his
  1181. 49:33incompetence, he hasn't even come close
  1182. 49:35to ending this war. John Mearsheimer is
  1183. 49:40a very charming man, but extremely
  1184. 49:42harsh in his judgments. Even though his
  1185. 49:45contribution to the study of
  1186. 49:46international relations is the theory
  1187. 49:48of offensive realism, which is ruthless
  1188. 49:50toward its actors. Let’s make an
  1189. 49:53allowance and hope that diplomacy still
  1190. 49:55has at least some kind of a chance.
  1191. 50:02Exactly on the twenty-fifth anniversary
  1192. 50:04of the September 11 attacks, a BRICS
  1193. 50:05summit gathered in New Delhi. This
  1194. 50:08acronym, originally BRIC, turns a
  1195. 50:10quarter-century old in November. It is
  1196. 50:12almost the same age as the war on
  1197. 50:14terror. Only it was invented by
  1198. 50:16investment bankers for the purpose of
  1199. 50:18advertising emerging markets. But now
  1200. 50:21it is a community of the most
  1201. 50:22influential non-Western countries,
  1202. 50:25whose goal is to try and establish an
  1203. 50:27international system, one that is
  1204. 50:29fairer than the one that began to
  1205. 50:32rapidly crumble after the 9/11 shock.
  1206. 50:35We are crossing our fingers that they
  1207. 50:38succeed. Especially since, in the
  1208. 50:40modern world, keeping your fists ready
  1209. 50:42is generally useful. This was the
  1210. 50:44International Review. See you next time
  1211. 50:46.

About this transcript

This page contains the full transcript of Международное обозрение 11.09.2026 by Международное Обозрение, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 7,353 words across 1,211 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.

What you can do with it

Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.

Free YouTube transcript tool

YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.