10 Things You Should Never Tell ChatGPT: AI Chatbots Can’t Keep Your Secrets Like You Think — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00I have spent a number of years telling
- 0:03employees to assume every email, every
- 0:06text message, every social media post,
- 0:09recording, and more could become an
- 0:12exhibit at trial. Be careful what you
- 0:15put in writing.
- 0:17I never imagined I'd have to add ChatGPT
- 0:21to the list, but here we are.
- 0:23So, I'll just tell you the bottom line
- 0:25is that you should assume everything you
- 0:28write could someday become evidence.
- 0:32Technology changes, but the rule of law
- 0:35does not.
- 0:37A federal judge recently issued a
- 0:39decision. I'm going to share what
- 0:41happened.
- 0:42A man was under federal criminal
- 0:45investigation
- 0:46and used an AI chatbot, in this this
- 0:49case it was Claude, to help organize
- 0:52information and prepare documents that
- 0:54he intended to share with his lawyer.
- 0:58Now, he prepared the documents,
- 1:00but his lawyer didn't know he was doing
- 1:02that. His lawyer certainly didn't tell
- 1:04him to use chat the chatbot to prepare
- 1:08the documents.
- 1:09And the person included information that
- 1:13he got from his lawyer and asked
- 1:16Claude how he should respond. He
- 1:19discussed legal strategy with Claude.
- 1:22Claude shared its comments,
- 1:24told him what, you know,
- 1:26he suggested or it suggested. Now, when
- 1:29the FBI executed a search warrant at
- 1:32Hepner's home, they seized his
- 1:35electronic devices, which included all
- 1:38that information that he shared with
- 1:41Claude. And of course, they wanted to be
- 1:43able to use it at trial. I mean, that's
- 1:46that's golden. Now, of course, the
- 1:49prosecutors were, you know, gung-ho.
- 1:51It's like you have no privilege. We are
- 1:54entitled to to documents. And Halpner's
- 1:58uh attorneys argued,
- 2:00"No.
- 2:01This the these documents are protected
- 2:04by attorney-client
- 2:06privilege."
- 2:07And at first glance, you would
- 2:08absolutely think that's a no-brainer. Of
- 2:11course.
- 2:12When people come see me just for legal
- 2:14representation, and I don't represent
- 2:17them yet, they're coming to me to seek
- 2:19advice,
- 2:20uh find out whether they have a case,
- 2:22they are automatically protected by the
- 2:25attorney-client privilege. So, why not
- 2:27in this case? What What was the problem
- 2:29with this case?
- 2:31Well, the judge said, "No. No
- 2:33attorney-client privilege attaches." And
- 2:36why is that? Well, first, the judge
- 2:38said, "You know what? He's not
- 2:39communicating with his attorney." And
- 2:41you know what? That's a really great
- 2:43point. Sometimes I have people copy me
- 2:46on emails. I don't know anything about
- 2:48what's going on, but they'll copy me on
- 2:50it cuz they want my name on it as an
- 2:53attorney, and thinking, you know, that's
- 2:55sufficient to have uh to to get the
- 2:57attorney-client privilege. But anyway,
- 3:01uh the judge said, "No, you're not
- 3:02talking to your attorney in this case.
- 3:04You're talking with Claude. You're
- 3:06communicating with an AI platform."
- 3:09And according to the court, once you
- 3:11voluntarily share information with a
- 3:14third party,
- 3:16you may lose attorney-client privilege.
- 3:18And that is absolutely true. The judge
- 3:21said, "You know, Claude is a third
- 3:22party. Claude is not your attorney. It's
- 3:25somebody that has nothing to do with
- 3:27this case." And that's very true. When I
- 3:30am communicating with a client, and
- 3:31sometimes they want to bring a friend
- 3:33in, um I say, "No, because you lose
- 3:37attorney-client privilege
- 3:39uh in that case." Now, that's um
- 3:42you know, sometimes I will If there's a
- 3:44mediation, and they want to bring a
- 3:45family member in, and I'm not concerned
- 3:48about any information that we're
- 3:49sharing, uh because we're going to be
- 3:51sharing it with the other side anyway,
- 3:53then that's okay. But, if there's
- 3:55something between you and your lawyer
- 3:57that you want to keep private, then you
- 3:59need to leave any other party out of it.
- 4:02And apparently, that includes AI
- 4:04chatbots.
- 4:06Think about that. People treat ChatGPT
- 4:09like it's their therapist, their lawyer,
- 4:12their diary, their best friend. The law
- 4:15doesn't necessarily see it that way.
- 4:18So, the judge ended up showing that, um
- 4:22none of the requirements for privilege
- 4:25or attorney work product to attach
- 4:28actually applied in this case.
- 4:30Uh namely, he wasn't talking to his
- 4:32attorney.
- 4:33Uh he was not working at the behest of
- 4:36his attorney.
- 4:37He was having a conversation with
- 4:38somebody, namely Claude, not party to
- 4:41the litigation. So, none of the thing
- 4:42none of the requirements applied.
- 4:45Um it's, you know, it's an interesting
- 4:47decision. This is a developing area of
- 4:50law. Nothing is ever as cut and dry as
- 4:53it seem.
- 4:54Uh but, the thing you can take away from
- 4:56this case is, you know, it's dangerous
- 4:59to be talking too much to AI chatbots,
- 5:03Claude, ChatGPT, Grok, whatever. Be
- 5:06careful with that.
- 5:08I mean, I want to explain something
- 5:09that's even bigger than this case, the
- 5:11Helphner case, uh because that was a
- 5:14loser for that uh person, Helphner.
- 5:18You know, it's it's bad enough that you
- 5:20have to respond to what's going on in
- 5:23the case. You're a defendant. You're
- 5:24you're criminal defendant. But then, you
- 5:27put all that out there, how you might
- 5:30respond to the questions they have.
- 5:33That's just bad, you know, your your
- 5:35whole strategy is just out there. So,
- 5:37you can forget that. And if you were
- 5:39thinking in the least bit about being
- 5:41shady,
- 5:43um even if you change your strategy,
- 5:45that doesn't stop the prosecutor from
- 5:47sa- from bringing that up. So, that's
- 5:49just, you know, that that's just too
- 5:51much.
- 5:52So, later on in the video, I'm going to
- 5:54share with you 10 things you absolutely
- 5:56should never share with chat GPT,
- 5:59Claude, Grok, any of the AI group.
- 6:03But before I do, I want to remind you to
- 6:06please subscribe to my channel because
- 6:08it means a whole lot. It helps a whole
- 6:11lot
- 6:12uh in getting information out there to
- 6:14uh employees. We need that information.
- 6:17Please also remember to go to
- 6:19amazon.com, check out my books. I have
- 6:22three. I have uh
- 6:24my most recent book, Let Me Think About
- 6:26It. It just tells you how how to pause
- 6:30uh and to not be pushed into
- 6:32making decisions and quite honestly, it
- 6:34applies outside of work, too. Check that
- 6:37book out. Uh I have my Document
- 6:40Everything book that's been there
- 6:42uh for a while. You need to be
- 6:44documenting everything that happens to
- 6:45you at work, and you don't need to just
- 6:47write a diary. Follow the uh steps that
- 6:52I suggest in this book, and um you'll
- 6:55create a nice insurance policy for
- 6:57yourself in case something goes wrong.
- 7:00And finally, I have my Regina's 22 rules
- 7:03for leveling up, the latest edition.
- 7:05Make sure you check that out. If you
- 7:07need to get in touch with me cuz you
- 7:08want me to weigh in on your case, the
- 7:11information for reaching out to me and
- 7:13scheduling appointments is in the
- 7:15description of this video. All this
- 7:17information is in the description of
- 7:18this video. So, let's continue. Now, a
- 7:21lot of employees think that evidence
- 7:23includes only emails,
- 7:26um
- 7:27memos, that text messages, that type of
- 7:30thing. But let me tell you something.
- 7:31Discovery is incredibly broad, and I
- 7:34could give you so many nightmares about
- 7:37this. Yeah, let me just tell you one
- 7:39thing. Sometimes I get off on these
- 7:40tangents, but I have to tell you what
- 7:42I'm thinking of things. Sometimes
- 7:45employees will sue an employer after
- 7:48they've left and found another job, and
- 7:51that is a great way to do it.
- 7:53Um but let me tell you what some really
- 7:55nasty employers will do.
- 7:57They will start writing to your new
- 8:00employer. Now, they know good and well
- 8:01your new employer has no information
- 8:04that would help out the case against
- 8:07your former employer. But, they do it to
- 8:10put pressure on you because discovery is
- 8:12incredibly broad. And just to make sure
- 8:15we're on the same page, discovery is
- 8:17that point in litigation. It usually
- 8:19starts right after you file the lawsuit,
- 8:21and it goes on for 4 to 6 months,
- 8:24depending on whether you're in state or
- 8:25federal court, and it's the time where
- 8:27we seek information to support or defend
- 8:31our claims. So, if you're the plaintiff,
- 8:33you're telling the employer to turn over
- 8:35everything. Turn over personnel files.
- 8:38You are taking uh testimony from people.
- 8:41You are getting witness statements.
- 8:43You're doing everything to build your
- 8:44case, and they are doing the same thing.
- 8:47And so, it's discovery. That's what we
- 8:49call that period and the process of
- 8:52gathering facts, gathering witnesses to
- 8:55support um our case.
- 8:58Now, when I say it's incredibly broad, I
- 9:00mean it's ridiculously broad. I have
- 9:03seen employers abuse the process in the
- 9:06worst way. You know, checking your past
- 9:09rental history, checking how well you
- 9:12pay your debts. I mean, it's ridiculous.
- 9:15And you have to really really be strong
- 9:19to stop employers from taking advantage
- 9:22of this. But anyway,
- 9:23um discovery is
- 9:26you know, sometimes can be
- 9:28your best friend and sometimes it can be
- 9:30your worst enemy.
- 9:31If you sue your employer or they sue
- 9:34you, lawyers can request text messages,
- 9:37Facebook messages, Instagram DMs,
- 9:39private or not, it does not matter. And
- 9:43I have personally been one of those
- 9:44lawyers just digging into um text
- 9:47messages and that type of thing because
- 9:50that's where all the true true
- 9:52information is. I mean, people will
- 9:55misrepresent facts because, you know,
- 9:58they're under pressure. But when you
- 10:00look at things that they
- 10:02um wrote at a time when they had no
- 10:04reason to be dishonest, that's why we
- 10:08issue subpoenas for social media posts.
- 10:11Even your private DMs because you're
- 10:15telling the truth.
- 10:16You have no reason to make up things.
- 10:18And so, you know, be careful what you
- 10:20put in writing. And this includes
- 10:23LinkedIn messages, Slack messages,
- 10:25Teams, WhatsApp, it doesn't matter. All
- 10:27of that. Any place where we can look to
- 10:30find out what you truly truly mean. You
- 10:33know, some people claim that they were
- 10:35going through all this emotional
- 10:36distress because a job created it. And
- 10:39then you start looking at their private
- 10:41DMs and you realize, oh, wait a minute,
- 10:43she's going through a divorce. And she's
- 10:45complaining about the divorce being the
- 10:47reason she suffered all this mental
- 10:50anguish.
- 10:51Well, there you go. That's how we dig
- 10:53into things like that. So, you really
- 10:56have to be careful. And remember,
- 10:58deleted messages can still be recovered.
- 11:02I had a case where
- 11:04oh my gosh, the case was a hot mess.
- 11:06>> [laughter]
- 11:08>> I I um there was a female supervisor who
- 11:11was pursuing the girlfriend of her uh
- 11:14direct report.
- 11:16Now, I represented the two girlfriends.
- 11:20Um one was
- 11:21um African-American, one was white, and
- 11:25they were probably in their early 20s.
- 11:27The supervisor was a white female and
- 11:30she was in her mid-30s. So, this was
- 11:33kind of a love triangle of sorts among
- 11:36those three women. The
- 11:39female supervisor, white female
- 11:41supervisor, was obsessed with the young
- 11:44black girl who was in the relationship
- 11:46with her direct report. They all worked
- 11:47at the same place and
- 11:50it was a very challenging case.
- 11:52Everyone was difficult to work with,
- 11:55especially
- 11:56>> [laughter]
- 11:56>> my own clients.
- 11:59>> [gasps]
- 11:59>> Yeah, they were very young and the judge
- 12:03kept having to get on them for, you
- 12:05know, showing up late for court and
- 12:07sleeping through hearings when they did
- 12:09show up. It was a mess. Anyway,
- 12:13the supervisor
- 12:15kept, you know, refused to turn over her
- 12:17text messages. She kept saying that
- 12:20there were none, that they didn't exist.
- 12:22Now, my client told me that they did
- 12:24exist and that they would prove how much
- 12:27she was pursuing this other this young
- 12:30black female at work.
- 12:32After issuing a number of subpoenas to
- 12:35the phone company and everybody else, I
- 12:37finally got the text messages and they
- 12:40actually confirmed what my clients had
- 12:43been saying. So, that's really good
- 12:45that's really good evidence to have
- 12:47these text messages where you have a
- 12:49supervisor pursuing this young girl. She
- 12:52was in a different department, but they
- 12:54worked for the same company. And
- 12:57as a result of those text messages, the
- 12:59case finally settled. But, let me tell
- 13:01you something, it settled for a lot less
- 13:04than it should have because
- 13:07wow,
- 13:08what can I say? See, lawyers have to
- 13:10evaluate their clients and determine
- 13:13whether they would make good witnesses.
- 13:15I mean, we're looking at our clients,
- 13:17the other the lawyer for the employer is
- 13:19looking at the the witnesses. I mean, it
- 13:22is just you have to to evaluate
- 13:25constantly how they would present to a
- 13:28jury. I mean, I've seen people who had
- 13:31doctorate degrees
- 13:33just start lying.
- 13:35>> [laughter]
- 13:37>> Yeah, you just start making stuff up
- 13:39whole cloth.
- 13:40>> [laughter]
- 13:41>> People get under oath and just Oh man,
- 13:45it's it it yeah.
- 13:47>> [laughter]
- 13:48>> So, it it's not an education thing. It's
- 13:51not even an age thing. Sometimes people
- 13:55don't react well under pressure.
- 13:57You know, like I said, my my clients had
- 13:59difficulty showing up on time. They were
- 14:03getting on the judge judge's nerves, on
- 14:05my nerves.
- 14:06I mean, I was having to send people to
- 14:07pick them up.
- 14:09>> [laughter]
- 14:09>> Send an Uber to go get them and bring
- 14:12them while we I mean, we're sitting
- 14:13there waiting for hours.
- 14:15It was just, you know, that's how it
- 14:17was.
- 14:18And then, the final straw for me was,
- 14:22you know, litigation lasts a long time.
- 14:23So, remember, a lot of time is passing
- 14:26while the case is going on. But, the
- 14:28final straw for me was when the black
- 14:30girl in the relationship showed up to a
- 14:33hearing very pregnant.
- 14:35>> [laughter]
- 14:39>> I didn't understand.
- 14:41>> [laughter]
- 14:42>> And I'm like, okay. Here I am arguing
- 14:46that this love triangle
- 14:49which included three women, you know,
- 14:52that this supervisor did so much to
- 14:54destroy the relationship between these
- 14:57two girls and
- 15:00one of them shows up pregnant. And I'm
- 15:01like, okay, there's another person
- 15:02involved.
- 15:04>> [laughter]
- 15:05>> And it's not the supervisor. She didn't
- 15:08do that.
- 15:09>> [laughter]
- 15:09>> So, anyway, I finally just had to get
- 15:12the most I could to settle the case.
- 15:14Surprised that I could get anything, but
- 15:17I got it because of those text messages.
- 15:19So, what can I say? I have a lifetime of
- 15:22stories about interesting cases.
- 15:25Even information sitting on your phone
- 15:28is dangerous when it comes to lawsuits.
- 15:31I mean, I have been in depositions, you
- 15:33know, where they're sitting under oath,
- 15:35and the lawyer says, "Do you have your
- 15:37phone with you?" Yes. "Can I see it?"
- 15:39>> [laughter]
- 15:40>> Now, of course, if you have a good
- 15:41lawyer, the answer is no.
- 15:43>> [laughter]
- 15:44>> But, don't think they won't ask. So,
- 15:46I've seen people turn it over. Turn over
- 15:48their phones. That's just, you know,
- 15:50that's nonsense. But, anyway, um be
- 15:53careful what you put in writing. And now
- 15:55here we are, AI conversations could
- 15:58become part of the discussion, too. I
- 16:01mean, you're putting it in writing, and
- 16:03um just like if you do a Google search,
- 16:06um
- 16:06all of that stuff is something that we
- 16:09can discover,
- 16:11um request during the discovery period,
- 16:14and get it. And usually, it does not
- 16:16help your case. Here's the mistake
- 16:18people make, especially when they're
- 16:20talking to ChatGPT. I mean, you know,
- 16:22ChatGPT is my boy.
- 16:24>> [laughter]
- 16:24>> I get it. You become friends. They are
- 16:28always there when you need them.
- 16:30ChatGPT, Claude, Grok. I get it. But,
- 16:34people make the mistake of thinking the
- 16:35conversations are private. They're not.
- 16:39Well, keeping that in mind, here are 10
- 16:42things you should never share with an AI
- 16:45chatbot, whether it's ChatGPT, Grok,
- 16:48whoever.
- 16:49Number one, your secrets. Don't treat AI
- 16:53like your therapist, your diary, or your
- 16:56best friend, even though it might feel
- 16:58like it at times. If you wouldn't post
- 17:00it on a billboard, don't type it in a
- 17:02chatbot. Number two, your personal
- 17:05information. Never share your social
- 17:07security numbers, bank account
- 17:09information, credit card numbers,
- 17:10passwords, driver's license numbers,
- 17:13passport information, your home address.
- 17:17Identity theft is hard enough. Don't
- 17:20make it easier. Number three, photos and
- 17:23biometric data.
- 17:25Be very careful about uploading photos
- 17:28of yourself, your children, or your
- 17:30family members. Unlike a password, you
- 17:32cannot change your face. Well, maybe you
- 17:35can, but you cannot change your
- 17:37fingerprints. You can't change your
- 17:39voice. Biometric information is among
- 17:42the most sensitive data you have.
- 17:45Number four, medical questions that
- 17:47require a doctor. AI can explain medical
- 17:51concepts. It cannot examine you. It
- 17:53cannot order test. It cannot exercise
- 17:57clinical judgment. So, if you're having
- 18:00a medical problem, see a licensed health
- 18:03care provider. And remember, when you
- 18:05put that information there, it's there.
- 18:08Number five, legal problems that require
- 18:11a lawyer. This one should surprise
- 18:13absolutely no one coming from me. AI can
- 18:16help you understand the legal concepts.
- 18:19It should never replace legal advice. It
- 18:22can misunderstand facts and misstate
- 18:25them all together.
- 18:27Sure have seen it. Lawyers writing
- 18:29briefs
- 18:31uh or actually having ChatGPT or one of
- 18:34those AI chatbots write a brief and it's
- 18:36just wrong. I mean, some of the lawyers
- 18:38have gotten in trouble for that. I mean,
- 18:40seriously. Number six, confidential
- 18:43workplace information. Never upload
- 18:46personnel files, internal
- 18:48investigations, customer information,
- 18:50trade secrets, business strategies,
- 18:53confidential company information. Once
- 18:56confidential information leaves your
- 18:58control, you can't always get it back.
- 19:01Number seven, major life decisions.
- 19:04Don't let AI decide whether to quit your
- 19:07job,
- 19:09leave your marriage, invest your
- 19:11retirement, move across the country. AI
- 19:14can help you think.
- 19:16It shouldn't do the thinking for you.
- 19:19Number eight, anything illegal. Don't
- 19:23ask AI how to commit crimes.
- 19:26Don't ask how to destroy evidence, how
- 19:29to hack systems, and how to evade law
- 19:32enforcement. Yeah, people are asking
- 19:34these questions. Don't be one of them.
- 19:37Number nine, client information. If
- 19:40you're a lawyer, doctor, therapist, or
- 19:42anyone with confidentiality obligations,
- 19:45think twice before uploading client
- 19:48information. And number 10, anything you
- 19:51wouldn't want to become an exhibit at
- 19:53trial. This is the biggest lesson.
- 19:56Discovery, once again, is very broad.
- 19:59Lawyers can and do request everything.
- 20:03We are so nosy.
- 20:05>> [laughter]
- 20:06>> But it's because that's where that's
- 20:08where we find the truth, in your
- 20:10internal private thoughts, and that's
- 20:12exactly what we go for.
- 20:15So again, assume everything you write
- 20:18could someday become evidence.
- 20:20Technology changes, the rule of law
- 20:23doesn't.
- 20:24See you next shift.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 10 Things You Should Never Tell ChatGPT: AI Chatbots Can’t Keep Your Secrets Like You Think by Employee Rights Attorney | Regina Molden , generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 3,085 words across 514 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.