1. Al-Ushul Min Ilmil Ushul - Dasar-Dasar Ilmu Ushul Fiqih | Ustadz Dr. Musyaffa' Ad-Dariny, M.A. — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:18In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious
- 0:20, the Most Merciful. Peace, mercy, and
- 0:22blessings of Allah be upon you.
- 0:25And peace, mercy, and blessings of
- 0:26Allah be upon you too. All praise is
- 0:29due to Allah. We praise Him, seek His
- 0:33help, and seek His forgiveness. And we
- 0:37seek refuge in Allah from the evils of
- 0:39our own souls and from our bad deeds.
- 0:42Whoever Allah guides, none can misguide
- 0:45; and whoever He misguides, none can
- 0:47guide. I bear witness that there is no
- 0:50god worthy of worship except Allah
- 0:52alone, with no partner, and I bear
- 0:55witness that Muhammad is His servant
- 0:57and messenger. O you who have believed,
- 1:03fear Allah as He should be feared and
- 1:07do not die except as Muslims. Indeed,
- 1:10the truest speech is the Book of Allah.
- 1:15And the best guidance is the guidance
- 1:17of Muhammad, may Allah’s peace and
- 1:18blessings be upon him. The worst
- 1:23matters are the newly invented ones,
- 1:25for every innovation is a misguidance,
- 1:27and every misguidance leads to the Fire
- 1:30. Beloved congregation, attendees, both
- 1:36men and women, my brothers and sisters
- 1:41in faith, may Allah protect me and you.
- 1:46Praise be to Allah, all praise is due
- 1:48only to Allah the Almighty, who has
- 1:53granted us the ease to gather here
- 1:55together in one of the places most
- 2:02beloved to Allah the Almighty, in the
- 2:07house of Allah the Almighty. I hope
- 2:12this gathering of ours truly brings
- 2:17blessings to all of us. I hope we gain
- 2:23beneficial knowledge, blessed knowledge
- 2:27, from this gathering. And I hope Allah
- 2:32the Almighty makes us all among those
- 2:38whom Allah describes as those who
- 2:40listen to the speech and follow the
- 2:45best of it. People who listen to words
- 2:52and follow the best among them. Not to
- 2:58forget, prayers and peace, as well as
- 3:00blessings and favors, may always be
- 3:02poured out upon the Great Prophet
- 3:04Muhammad, may Allah’s peace and
- 3:05blessings be upon him. Likewise, to all
- 3:10his family, all his companions, and all
- 3:13Muslims who follow him and his
- 3:15companions in righteousness until the
- 3:17end of days.
- 3:27My brothers and sisters in faith, may
- 3:30Allah have mercy on you. This session
- 3:36is the first session that will discuss
- 3:45one of the disciplines that is very
- 3:51important for us to study, namely the
- 3:58science of Usul Fiqh (Principles of
- 3:59Islamic Jurisprudence). And we will use
- 4:04as a reference a book that is
- 4:11considered a very fundamental book, a
- 4:15basic level of Usul Fiqh, written by
- 4:20Sheikh Muhammad ibn Salih al-Uthaymeen,
- 4:25may Allah have mercy upon him. This
- 4:34book, God willing, we will discuss from
- 4:38beginning to end. May Allah make it
- 4:41easy. And we will refer to the
- 4:47translation of this book which I have
- 4:56compiled, because the translations I
- 5:01saw in bookstores, well, were not very
- 5:10good, so, eventually I took the
- 5:16initiative to translate it myself.
- 5:20Hopefully, in the next meeting, we will
- 5:23be able to read that translation. For
- 5:31this first session, I would like to
- 5:36touch upon matters related to the
- 5:46science of Usul Fiqh in general. For
- 5:55example, regarding its definition, its
- 5:58virtues, and so on. Because before
- 6:06studying the science of Usul Fiqh, we
- 6:12must know the introduction to this
- 6:15science. And in the introduction to
- 6:21Usul Fiqh, several matters are usually
- 6:23discussed. The first matter usually
- 6:28discussed is the definition of Usul
- 6:30Fiqh. What is Usul Fiqh? We must get to
- 6:46know this science before we enter into
- 6:51it, so that we know what we will be
- 6:57learning in this field. Usul Fiqh is
- 7:06the science that discusses the legal
- 7:11evidences of Sharia in a general way,
- 7:19how to derive rulings from those
- 7:23evidences, and who is qualified to do
- 7:29so. This is the science of Usul Fiqh.
- 7:35Ushul Fiqh is the science that
- 7:37discusses Sharia evidence in a global
- 7:39manner. What is meant by global Sharia
- 7:45evidence? What is meant by global
- 7:50Sharia evidence is a discussion on
- 7:52whether something can be used as
- 7:55evidence or not. For example, can the
- 8:00Qur'an be used as evidence or not? This
- 8:05is a discussion in the science of Ushul
- 8:06Fiqh. Can the Sunnah be used as
- 8:11evidence or not? This is a global
- 8:16discussion in Ushul Fiqh. Discussions
- 8:18of evidence are conducted globally like
- 8:20this. Ijma, can it be used as evidence
- 8:25or not? Can Qiyas be used as evidence
- 8:29or not? Istihsan, can it be used as
- 8:37evidence or not? Istishab. Istislah.
- 8:46Qawl al-Sahabi, sadd al-dhara'i '. Can
- 8:51these be used as evidence or not? This
- 8:57is what is meant by discussing Sharia
- 8:59evidence globally. We do not discuss
- 9:04those evidences in detail. In detail
- 9:09means in terms of specific evidence.
- 9:15For example, what is the evidence for
- 9:16the obligation of prayer? We say, "Wa
- 9:19aqimu al-salah.""Establish the prayer."
- 9:27The words "wa aqimu al-salah" or the
- 9:29word of Allah "wa aqimu al-salah" is
- 9:31part of the Qur'an. This is detailed.
- 9:37This is not a discussion in Ushul Fiqh;
- 9:39it is a discussion in Fiqh. A
- 9:43discussion in Ushul Fiqh is global
- 9:45evidence; can the Qur'an generally be
- 9:47used as evidence or not? Only then, if
- 9:51we say it can be used as evidence. The
- 9:53application comes later in Fiqh. I am
- 9:57using this verse as evidence. Can the
- 10:01Sunnah globally be used as evidence or
- 10:04not? The Hadith of the Prophet, if we
- 10:08say yes, then we can use as evidence,
- 10:12for example, "Sallu kama ra'aitumuni
- 10:15usalli." The specific detail is in Fiqh
- 10:21, the global aspect is in Ushul Fiqh.
- 10:26So Ushul Fiqh explains the foundations
- 10:31of using evidence. Once we know the
- 10:36foundations of using evidence, we can
- 10:38apply it in the science of Fiqh. To
- 10:43provide evidence in Fiqh this. The
- 10:48first part that is very important in
- 10:51the science of Ushul Fiqh is the
- 10:53discussion of Sharia evidence globally.
- 10:58From this, we know which Sharia
- 11:00evidence is valid and which is not. For
- 11:06example, if someone uses the words of
- 11:08the Tabi'in as evidence, then we can
- 11:13explain that the words of the Tabi'in
- 11:15are not evidence. If someone uses the
- 11:19words of an Imam as evidence, we say
- 11:23the words of an Imam are not evidence.
- 11:26If someone uses dreams as evidence,
- 11:30saying, "I dreamt this and that, so the
- 11:34law is such and such." We say that a
- 11:37dream is not evidence. If someone uses
- 11:42feelings as evidence, "When I dhikr in
- 11:44this way, my heart feels at peace. my
- 11:50heart becomes content with the dhikr.""
- 11:59So dhikr in this way is recommended."
- 12:04We can say that feelings are not
- 12:06evidence. The evidence is the Qur'an,
- 12:11Sunnah, Ijma, Qawl al-Sahabi, Qiyas,
- 12:14and so on. Okay. The second core
- 12:20discussion in the science of Ushul Fiqh
- 12:24is how we derive Sharia law from valid
- 12:31evidence. How do we derive Sharia law
- 12:39from the evidence we just explained?
- 12:43This is valid evidence, strong evidence
- 12:45. This is not strong evidence. How do
- 12:49we extract law from that evidence? Here
- 12:53we will discuss commands. What
- 12:58instructions or laws are indicated by
- 13:01commands in Sharia? That is why we
- 13:07often hear that, by default, a command
- 13:09indicates an obligatory law. If there
- 13:16is a command and then another proof
- 13:19indicating it is only a suggestion, we
- 13:22say the command here indicates a
- 13:24recommendation. We will discuss the
- 13:28topic of commands later. Prohibitions
- 13:32will also be discussed in the science
- 13:34of Usul Fiqh. Later there will be
- 13:38general terms, words that mean "all" in
- 13:43Arabic, what are they? Words that mean
- 13:47"all" in Arabic are numerous. Not just
- 13:53kullu, jami'u, ajma, or ajma'un. Not
- 13:59only those, there are many words
- 14:01indicating the meaning of "all"
- 14:03discussed in Usul Fiqh. From there, we
- 14:07derive laws. There are specific terms,
- 14:12absolute terms, qualified terms,
- 14:15explicit meanings, implied meanings,
- 14:18and so on. This is the discussion of
- 14:22Usul Fiqh. This second discussion,
- 14:26brothers and sisters, may Allah have
- 14:28mercy on you, is difficult to
- 14:30understand for those who do not grasp
- 14:32Arabic. Because the discussion of this
- 14:37is related to the Arabic language. That
- 14:41is why Usul Fiqh is a rather heavy
- 14:45subject for laypeople. At the beginning
- 14:49, the discussion is still about law.
- 14:51What "haram,""wajib," and "mubah" mean
- 14:53is still easy to digest. The discussion
- 14:59that the Qur'an is evidence, the Sunnah
- 15:01is evidence, and Ijma is evidence. This
- 15:03is still easy. Many still attend. But
- 15:09when it comes to commands and
- 15:11prohibitions in Arabic, general terms,
- 15:15and specific terms, it starts to get
- 15:18difficult. Usually, only a quarter
- 15:21remain because it is indeed difficult
- 15:30if one does not understand Arabic. If
- 15:35one already understands Arabic, it
- 15:38becomes easy and enjoyable. This is
- 15:44different from the study of Fiqh maxims
- 15:47. The study of Fiqh maxims is lighter
- 15:51than the study of Usul Fiqh. Later we
- 15:55will know the difference between the
- 15:57two. Well. This is the second part, how
- 16:03to derive laws from the existing Sharia
- 16:06evidence. From here, we can derive laws
- 16:12for new issues that did not exist
- 16:14before. Even though the evidence is old
- 16:18. The evidence is just that. The Qur'an
- 16:21, Sunnah, Ijma, Qiyas, opinions of the
- 16:24Sahaba, and so on. The evidence has
- 16:26been the same for a long time. But we
- 16:30can answer the new issues that exist
- 16:33now. Why?
- 16:34Because we study how to derive laws
- 16:38from the existing Sharia evidence. Then
- 16:45the third part in Usul Fiqh is who has
- 16:48the right to do this? Who has the right
- 16:54to derive laws from existing Sharia
- 16:59evidence? What is the discussion about?
- 17:04The conditions for a Mujtahid. Who is a
- 17:09Mujtahid? What are the requirements?
- 17:13Who is allowed to perform Ijtihad? Not
- 17:16everyone is allowed to perform Ijtihad.
- 17:18They do not understand Arabic but
- 17:21already perform Ijtihad. They cannot
- 17:25read the Qur'an properly, yet they dare
- 17:26to perform Ijtihad. They read the
- 17:29Hadith of Prophet Muhammad SAW
- 17:31incorrectly but already dare to perform
- 17:34Ijtihad. This is not allowed. A person
- 17:37who performs Ijtihad must know Arabic
- 17:39and understand the Arabic language.
- 17:45After all, how can someone perform
- 17:47ijtihad if they don't even understand
- 17:49Arabic? Yet the sources of law in Islam
- 17:54are in Arabic. The Quran is in Arabic,
- 18:02its exegesis is in Arabic, the Hadith
- 18:05is in Arabic, the commentaries are in
- 18:07Arabic, the core books of ushul fiqh
- 18:12are in Arabic. All the core Islamic
- 18:18books use the Arabic language. That is
- 18:25why Islam cannot be separated from
- 18:29the Arabic language. In fact, I say
- 18:33Islam cannot be separated from the
- 18:35Arabs. When we follow the religion of
- 18:44Islam, we are required to love the
- 18:48Arabic language. We are required to
- 18:52love the Arabs. Because Allah chose the
- 18:57Arabic language for the Quran. Allah
- 19:04chose our Prophet Muhammad, peace be
- 19:06upon him, from the Arab nation. Allah
- 19:10chose the companions of Prophet
- 19:12Muhammad, peace be upon him, from the
- 19:15Arab nation. Indeed, there were
- 19:17companions who were not from the Arab
- 19:19nation. But their numbers were far
- 19:23fewer than the companions of Prophet
- 19:26Muhammad, peace be upon him, who were
- 19:29Arabs. And this was by the wisdom of
- 19:36Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala. We must not
- 19:41be envious of the Arab nation chosen by
- 19:47Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala as the nation
- 19:51from which the noblest prophet,
- 19:54Muhammad, peace be upon him, was sent.
- 19:59Just as we must not be envious of the
- 20:01city of Mecca. Why is the Kaaba there?
- 20:07We must not be envious of Medina. Why
- 20:10is the Prophet's Mosque there? We must
- 20:13not be envious of Palestine. Why is
- 20:16Al-Aqsa Mosque there? Allah is the one
- 20:20who determined it so. It is the same
- 20:25with this matter. Why must we love the
- 20:29Arab nation? Why must we learn the
- 20:36Arabic language? Because Allah has made
- 20:42Islamic Sharia inseparable from Arabic,
- 20:45and likewise inseparable from the Arab
- 20:48people. And we, as servants of Allah
- 20:54Subhanahu wa ta'ala, must accept the
- 20:57will of Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala. We
- 21:01simply follow it, we learn it. And in
- 21:07Islam, Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala treats
- 21:14all His servants equally. Inna
- 21:20akramakumallahi atqakum. Indeed, the
- 21:26most noble among you is the most pious.
- 21:34If there is an Arab and an Indonesian,
- 21:37and the Indonesian is more pious than
- 21:40the Arab, the Indonesian is nobler.
- 21:48That is how Islam is. Islam does not
- 21:52even look at lineage. There are people
- 21:57of noble birth, there are people of
- 22:01common descent. Those of common descent
- 22:05can be nobler than the descendants of
- 22:07kings. Imam Abu Hanifah, may Allah have
- 22:13mercy on him, was of common descent,
- 22:18yet he became an imam. There were
- 22:21descendants of kings who held a lower
- 22:24position than Imam Abu Hanifah, may
- 22:27Allah have mercy on him. And how many
- 22:31imams in Islam were of common descent.
- 22:35That is Islam. Very well. Our
- 22:44discussion earlier was about the third
- 22:47part of ushul fiqh, which is who has
- 22:49the right to derive Sharia laws from
- 22:55the existing evidence? The answer is a
- 22:59mujtahid. It will be mentioned there
- 23:02what the qualities of a mujtahid are.
- 23:06So we know if, in this era, there are
- 23:09still people who have the right to
- 23:11perform ijtihad based on that
- 23:14discussion. Later, there will also be a
- 23:18discussion about taqlid. Who is allowed
- 23:22to practice taqlid? Who is not allowed
- 23:25to practice taqlid. It is not like the
- 23:29people of this age, where everyone is
- 23:31told to practice taqlid. Everyone is
- 23:35told to practice taqlid. He sees
- 23:39everyone the same as himself. When he
- 23:43wants to practice taqlid, then everyone
- 23:45must practice taqlid. There are people
- 23:49in this day and age who are like that.
- 23:52Whereas, people's levels are actually
- 23:54different. Some are allowed to practice
- 23:57taqlid, some are not allowed to
- 23:59practice taqlid. Some are allowed to
- 24:03practice ijtihad, some are not allowed
- 24:05to practice ijtihad. That is why,
- 24:09respected congregation, may Allah
- 24:10protect you and have mercy on you,
- 24:11ijtihad is not always good just as
- 24:18taqlid is not always bad. Ijtihad is
- 24:24good for a person who is fit to perform
- 24:27ijtihad. Ijtihad becomes bad when the
- 24:32person is not fit to perform ijtihad.
- 24:37Taqlid is the same. Taqlid is good for
- 24:41a person who is fit to practice taqlid.
- 24:44It is permitted to practice taqlid.
- 24:47Taqlid becomes bad when he is actually
- 24:50not allowed to practice taqlid. He
- 24:53should have performed ijtihad. Yes,
- 24:56this is discussed in the third part of
- 24:58the science of usul fiqh. And usually,
- 25:03usul fiqh books follow that order. The
- 25:08first part is discussed at the
- 25:10beginning, the second part is discussed
- 25:13in the middle of the book. The third
- 25:16part is discussed at the end of the
- 25:18book. Alright. This is the science of
- 25:23usul fiqh. Yes. So, the science of usul
- 25:28fiqh is a science that discusses Sharia
- 25:32evidence globally, how to derive Sharia
- 25:35rulings from that evidence, and who has
- 25:38the right to do so. Meaning, performing
- 25:44the derivation of rulings from existing
- 25:46Sharia evidence. This is the definition
- 25:54of usul fiqh based on its discussions.
- 26:00The science of usul fiqh can also be
- 26:02defined by another definition. Some
- 26:07scholars define the science of usul
- 26:09fiqh with the wording: "al-ilmu
- 26:15bil-qawa'idillati""yutawassalu biha
- 26:21ilistinbati al-ahkam ash-shar'iyyati
- 26:24al-far'iyyati min adillatiha
- 26:26at-tafsiliyyati," which means the
- 26:29science of usul fiqh is the science
- 26:32that discusses the principles by which
- 26:35someone can reach or someone can derive
- 26:45fiqh rulings from Sharia evidence. A
- 26:53science that discusses the principles
- 26:56by which one is able to derive fiqh
- 26:59rulings from detailed Sharia evidence.
- 27:07This is the second definition of the
- 27:09science of usul fiqh. From this, we
- 27:12know that by studying the science of
- 27:15usul fiqh, we can more easily derive
- 27:17Sharia rulings from existing evidence.
- 27:29Alright. The second point, respected
- 27:33congregation, may Allah protect you and
- 27:35have mercy on you, which is usually
- 27:37discussed in the introduction to usul
- 27:39fiqh, is who was the originator of this
- 27:42science? Who was the first to compile
- 27:48the science of usul fiqh? The first to
- 27:54codify the science of usul fiqh.
- 27:58According to the most famous opinion,
- 28:00it is Imam Shafi'i rahimahullahu taala.
- 28:06Imam Shafi'i rahimahullahu taala, he
- 28:09was the person who first compiled the
- 28:14science of usul fiqh and his book
- 28:17reached us. There is another opinion
- 28:24from Hanafi scholars who say they were
- 28:27first. But it is not proven. Where is
- 28:31the proof that they were the first to
- 28:36compile the science of usul fiqh? It is
- 28:38not proven, because their book did not
- 28:41reach us. What is proven in reality is
- 28:49Imam Shafi'i rahimahullahu taala. And
- 28:55subhanallah, he compiled this science
- 28:59of usul fiqh because he was asked about
- 29:09how to interpret the Al-Qur'an. How to
- 29:16interpret the Al-Qur'an and what kind
- 29:22of hadiths can be accepted as proof and
- 29:29what kind of ijma can be used as proof.
- 29:36Because of such questions, he
- 29:38eventually wrote a book on usul fiqh
- 29:46known as Ar-Risalah. Ar-Risalah
- 29:51actually means letter. Ar-Risalah in
- 29:57Indonesian translates to letter. Why?
- 30:02Imam Syafi'i's book on usul fiqh is
- 30:04named a letter. Because it really was a
- 30:09letter. Someone asked a question, and
- 30:14he sent a letter back. But it was a
- 30:17long letter, not a love letter. It is a
- 30:22long, detailed letter. If the thahqiq
- 30:32the best edition, it is about 600 pages
- 30:34long, reaching up to 600 pages. That is
- 30:46Ar-Risalah, the first book ever written
- 30:51on usul fiqh. That is why this book's
- 30:56discussions are not entirely complete,
- 31:01because it was the first one. It was
- 31:06the very first. So it is natural, as
- 31:10the first book written on usul fiqh,
- 31:13that there are some discussions in the
- 31:16field not covered by Imam Syafi'i
- 31:19rahimahullahu taala. For instance, the
- 31:24first book written on mustalah hadith
- 31:28is usually incomplete. The first book
- 31:34on Ulumul Quran is usually not
- 31:36comprehensive. The first book on Arabic
- 31:39grammar is usually incomplete. The same
- 31:42applies to the Ar-Risalah written by
- 31:46Imam Syafi'i rahimahullahu taala. But
- 31:50even though there are topics not
- 31:55touched upon by Imam Syafi'i
- 31:59rahimahullahu taala in his book,
- 32:03Ar-Risalah is still sufficient to
- 32:07establish the foundations of usul fiqh.
- 32:14Most of the discussions in usul fiqh
- 32:17were already touched upon by Imam
- 32:19Syafi'i rahimahullahu taala in his book
- 32:22, Ar-Risalah. The third point often
- 32:38mentioned by scholars in the
- 32:41introduction to usul fiqh is the
- 32:44importance of usul fiqh. Explaining the
- 32:54importance of usul fiqh is crucial so
- 32:58that we may have great enthusiasm for
- 33:01studying this science. Okay. God
- 33:09willing, we will explain the point
- 33:11regarding the importance of usul fiqh
- 33:14after the adhan. Barakallahu fikum. In
- 33:34the name of Allah, the Most Gracious,
- 33:35the Most Merciful. Peace be upon you,
- 33:40and Allah's mercy and blessings.
- 33:42And peace be upon you, and Allah's
- 33:44mercy and blessings. Praise be to Allah
- 33:49, and peace and blessings be upon the
- 33:52Messenger of Allah, and upon his family
- 33:54, his companions, and those who follow
- 33:56him. We had previously reached the
- 34:02discussion on the importance of usul
- 34:10fiqh. The science of usul fiqh is very
- 34:22important for the Muslims in this era.
- 34:36That is why scholars have written so
- 34:48many books on this science of usul fiqh
- 34:50. Among the things that show the
- 34:58importance of usul fiqh: First, with
- 35:03this science, we can properly
- 35:09understand the texts of the Sharia.
- 35:17With this science, we can understand
- 35:19the word of Allah, and properly
- 35:25understand the hadith of Prophet
- 35:27Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam.
- 35:34And I remind all the congregation to
- 35:43set this intention when studying usul
- 35:49fiqh. Intend to be able to understand
- 35:56the word of Allah, and the hadith of
- 36:01Prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi
- 36:03wasallam properly. Because that is why
- 36:10usul fiqh was written, so that we can
- 36:17understand the Qur'an, and understand
- 36:26hadith in a proper way, just as Allah
- 36:32and His Messenger desire. Second, by
- 36:46studying usul fiqh, we can well
- 36:52understand why scholars have different
- 36:58opinions. Among the reasons is that
- 37:12they must follow the evidence according
- 37:20to how they understand it, and their
- 37:29understanding differs. Yes. their
- 37:34levels of understanding differ.
- 37:43Eventually, they have differing
- 37:45opinions. When we know this, we will
- 37:51understand and tolerate the existence
- 37:54of differing opinions among scholars.
- 38:05Both are experts in ushul fiqh. but
- 38:12they differ. Why can they differ?
- 38:19Because each person must follow the
- 38:21evidence they understand. And someone
- 38:29who is already able to understand
- 38:31evidence well may not taqlid (blindly
- 38:34follow) another. If the reality is like
- 38:42that, that is why differences of
- 38:45opinion will occur. Imam Syafi'i
- 38:51differed in opinion with his teacher.
- 38:58Imam Ahmad also differed in opinion
- 39:01with his teacher. Imam Syafi'i's
- 39:06teacher, Imam Malik. Why must they
- 39:10differ? Because these two people may
- 39:16not taqlid each other. Imam Syafi'i may
- 39:22not taqlid Imam Malik. Imam Malik also
- 39:27may not taqlid Imam Syafi'i. And both
- 39:33have different understandings of the
- 39:35existing evidence. That is why
- 39:39differences of opinion occur. Although
- 39:43they differ, they actually agree,
- 39:48namely, they agree to follow the
- 39:49evidence. In fact, Imam Syafi'i
- 39:57rahimahullahu ta'ala wrote wrote a book
- 40:05titled Ikhtilafu Malik Wasyafi'i. The
- 40:11disagreement of Malik
- 40:13and Syafi'i. He compiled the issues
- 40:16where there were differences between
- 40:19him and his teacher, Imam Malik
- 40:21rahimahullahu ta'ala. Likewise with
- 40:29Imam Ahmad. Imam Ahmad was a student of
- 40:35Imam Syafi'i. But there are many
- 40:38differences between the two. Why?
- 40:43Because these two people may not taqlid
- 40:45each other. Imam Ahmad may not taqlid
- 40:51Imam Syafi'i. Likewise, conversely,
- 40:54Imam Syafi'i may not taqlid Imam Ahmad.
- 40:59Both must follow the evidence, and both
- 41:02agree on this point. The point of the
- 41:06obligation to follow evidence. Both
- 41:08agree. And that agreement produces
- 41:12differences of opinion. Because every
- 41:16individual is obligated to follow their
- 41:19evidence. And I say, yes, this is for
- 41:24those who can already understand
- 41:26evidence well. Those who cannot yet
- 41:31understand evidence well, their
- 41:34obligation is
- 41:35taqlid. Fas'alu ahladikri in kuntum la
- 41:40ta'lamun. Ask the people of knowledge
- 41:48if you do not know, that is the mafhum
- 41:53mukhalafah or the reverse logic. If you
- 41:57know, you may not taqlid. Taqlid is for
- 42:04those who do not know. For those who
- 42:07know, it means they may not taqlid. So
- 42:14if we know this issue, we will
- 42:16understand why scholars have differing
- 42:18opinions. We can tolerate why they
- 42:22differ in opinion. Then the third, by
- 42:36studying the science of ushul fiqh, we
- 42:41will know which evidence is strong,
- 42:47which evidence is weak. We will also
- 42:53know which disagreement is muktabar (
- 42:55valid/respectable), which disagreement
- 43:01is not muktabar. So we can position
- 43:10ourselves when to be harsh, firm, when
- 43:16we must be soft. If the disagreement is
- 43:25muktabar, do not be aggressive. If the
- 43:31disagreement is not muktabar, only then
- 43:34may we be firm. which has been busy
- 43:44lately. The issue of qunut again. The
- 43:49issue of qunut is a muktabar
- 43:50disagreement from long ago. So do not
- 43:55make it too much of an issue. No need
- 43:58to be intense about it. Understand it
- 44:02well. Tolerate it. Be tolerant. Convey
- 44:12which one is strong according to us,
- 44:16but do not belittle other opinions.
- 44:23Convey this, that this opinion is the
- 44:26stronger one. The evidence is like this
- 44:29, like this, and like this. The other
- 44:33opinion, in my view, is less strong for
- 44:36such and such reasons. That is what has
- 44:40been conveyed by the scholars in books
- 44:42of jurisprudence. Let us not go so far
- 44:48as to say that those who perform Qunut
- 44:52in the dawn prayer are not following
- 44:53the Salaf methodology. Even though they
- 44:57perform the dawn Qunut, it is not due
- 44:59to blind imitation, but because they
- 45:01view the evidence as stronger. And that
- 45:05is entirely possible. It is possible
- 45:10for someone who follows the Salaf
- 45:12methodology to view the evidence for
- 45:13dawn Qunut as stronger. If that were
- 45:21not possible, we would have to say that
- 45:23Imam Shafi'i did not follow the Salaf
- 45:26methodology. So, regarding differences
- 45:36of opinion like this, there is no need
- 45:40for us to be harsh or belittle one
- 45:43another. I personally view the dawn
- 45:48Qunut as having weak evidence. It is
- 45:55even categorized as an innovation (
- 45:57bid'ah). Because that is my own view up
- 46:00to this moment. But that does not mean
- 46:05I must say that those who perform it
- 46:09are innovators. Because those who
- 46:14perform it view it as having stronger
- 46:16evidence in their opinion. Or perhaps
- 46:19the one performing it views themselves
- 46:22as a layman (muqallid). They must
- 46:25follow a learned scholar. And the one
- 46:28they follow views the evidence for dawn
- 46:30Qunut as stronger. Therefore, we must
- 46:34be tolerant here; there is no need for
- 46:35conflict. This disagreement has existed
- 46:44for a long time. And some companions of
- 46:48the Prophet Muhammad, may Allah's peace
- 46:50and blessings be upon him, also said
- 46:52that the dawn Qunut was an innovation.
- 46:54There is no problem. When we call it an
- 46:59innovation, it does not mean we are not
- 47:01tolerant of those who perform it. No.
- 47:05This is still within the realm of valid
- 47:09(mu'tabar) differences of opinion. Very
- 47:16well. If the difference of opinion is
- 47:22not valid, then we must be firm. We
- 47:26must take a strong stance. For example,
- 47:33there are people who say that those
- 47:38other than Muslims can also enter
- 47:39Paradise. This is not a valid
- 47:44difference of opinion at all. Some are
- 47:49of the opinion that LGBT is permissible
- 47:53, others are of the opinion that being
- 47:57transgender is permissible. These are
- 48:00not valid differences of opinion. These
- 48:03are disagreements where we say their
- 48:08opinions are truly false. Some are of
- 48:16the opinion that all religions are the
- 48:19same and can lead to the Paradise of
- 48:23Allah Subhanahu wa ta'ala. This is a
- 48:25false opinion. By studying the science
- 48:33of Usul Fiqh (legal theory), we will
- 48:36know when a difference is valid and
- 48:38when it is not. If you haven't studied
- 48:43the science of Usul Fiqh that discusses
- 48:46this, you will be confused as to when.
- 48:50Whether this difference is valid or not
- 48:52, we cannot judge. Yet from it, we know
- 48:57how to address the differences of the
- 49:01scholars. Alright. The next point,
- 49:10among those that show the importance of
- 49:12Usul Fiqh, is that this science can be
- 49:17applied to many disciplines. This
- 49:26knowledge can be used in many
- 49:28scientific fields. Such as, for
- 49:35instance, the science of creed, or
- 49:38Tawhid. Tawhid requires evidence. It
- 49:42does not require speculation. How do we
- 49:46provide evidence in matters of Tawhid
- 49:49with strong proof? The way is through
- 49:53the science of Usul Fiqh. With Usul
- 49:58Fiqh, we can strengthen our Tawhid. It
- 50:04can strengthen the arguments in matters
- 50:07of creed. Thus, Usul Fiqh is highly
- 50:12needed in the science of creed. The
- 50:16science of ushul fikih (principles of
- 50:17Islamic jurisprudence) is also greatly
- 50:19needed in the science of tafsir. Tafsir
- 50:25is the science of understanding the
- 50:27Qur'an. And without ushul fikih, tafsir
- 50:31cannot be done well. The science of
- 50:38ushul fikih is also highly needed in
- 50:40the science of hadith. To understand
- 50:43the hadiths of Prophet Muhammad. May
- 50:45the peace and blessings of Allah be
- 50:46upon him. Without the science of ushul
- 50:50fikih, many hadiths of Prophet Muhammad
- 50:52, may the peace and blessings of Allah
- 50:54be upon him, appear to contradict with
- 50:58one another, but thanks to the science
- 51:00of ushul fikih, those hadiths that seem
- 51:02contradictory can be reconciled. The
- 51:06science of ushul fikih is very
- 51:11important in the science of faraid (
- 51:15inheritance). Because in the science of
- 51:19faraid, there are also proofs discussed
- 51:22when scholars hold different opinions.
- 51:25In that aspect, the science of ushul
- 51:27fikih plays a very important role. This
- 51:31shows that this science of ushul fikih
- 51:34is truly essential because it can be
- 51:39applied to many Islamic disciplines.
- 51:46The science of ushul fikih, dear
- 51:48congregation—may Allah have mercy on
- 51:50you—can also influence a person's
- 51:52personality. And this is very apparent;
- 51:57a person who has a strong grasp of
- 52:00ushul fikih, he will be difficult, uh,
- 52:14he will be far from being fickle. He
- 52:21can what is the word for it? He can be
- 52:32consistent with his opinions because he
- 52:39holds opinions based on strong
- 52:42foundations. When someone forms an
- 52:46opinion based on strong foundations,
- 52:51then he will be far from being fickle.
- 52:55Sometimes leaning this way, sometimes
- 52:57that way. We find that people like that
- 53:01usually have a weak understanding of
- 53:03ushul fikih. Very well. The next point,
- 53:14dear congregation—may Allah have
- 53:16mercy on you—is the point of the
- 53:20difference between ushul fikih and
- 53:23qawaid fikih (legal maxims). Often a
- 53:31person cannot distinguish between the
- 53:35science of ushul fikih and the science
- 53:39of qawaid fikih. Because it is indeed
- 53:48subtle; ushul fikih is usually in the
- 53:57form of a rule. Qawaid fikih is also in
- 54:01the form of a rule. Both are rules. And
- 54:10when it is called a rule, it means it
- 54:14has many derivations. It covers many
- 54:17issues. So, ushul fikih maxims and
- 54:23qawaid fikih have similarities here.
- 54:28Both are rules. Both cover many issues.
- 54:39So often a person cannot distinguish
- 54:41between the two. What is the difference
- 54:45? The most striking difference is that
- 54:51ushul fikih rules are in the realm of
- 54:54dalil (evidence). Whereas qawaid fikih
- 55:00is in the realm of human actions. What
- 55:09is the difference? The realm of ushul
- 55:12fikih rules is what?
- 55:14Evidence (dalil).
- 55:14Evidence. So what is discussed in ushul
- 55:17fikih rules is the evidence. Whereas
- 55:21what is discussed in qawaid fikih is
- 55:23what?
- 55:24Human actions.
- 55:25Human actions. Let me give an example,
- 55:30for instance, if it is said: "Al-aslu
- 55:36fil amri yadullu alal wujub." Basically
- 55:40, a command implies an obligatory
- 55:42ruling. Is this an ushul fikih rule or
- 55:46a qawaid fikih rule? Ushul fikih.
- 55:49This is an ushul fikih rule because it
- 55:51relates to evidence. The meaning of
- 55:56this rule is that, basically, a command
- 55:58in the Sharia evidence indicates a
- 56:02ruling of
- 56:04obligation. Because the realm is
- 56:09evidence, this is an ushul fikih rule.
- 56:14It is different from qawaid fikih. Its
- 56:16realm is human action. For example, "
- 56:23Al-umuru bi maqasidiha." All matters
- 56:32depend on their purposes, depend on
- 56:35their intentions. All matters depend on
- 56:42their intentions. Whose intentions?
- 56:46Human intentions. Not the intention of
- 56:49the evidence. It can be distinguished,
- 56:53right? If, for example, there is a rule
- 56:57: "The Prophet's hadith is proof,"
- 57:06there is a rule that the Prophet's
- 57:07hadith is proof. Is this an ushul fikih
- 57:11rule or a qawaid fikih rule? Usul
- 57:13principle.
- 57:13Ushul. Because
- 57:15its realm is evidence, the evidence is
- 57:17what is discussed. It's different from
- 57:22certainty. La yazulu bisyaak. Certainty
- 57:27cannot be removed by doubt. Whose
- 57:30certainty?
- 57:32A person's. Not the certainty of the
- 57:33evidence. A person's certainty cannot
- 57:38be removed by doubt. This is the
- 57:46difference between Usul Fiqh principles
- 57:49and Fiqh principles. Usually, Fiqh
- 57:58principles are related to issues
- 58:03directly. That is why Fiqh principles
- 58:11can be used as direct evidence, to
- 58:15answer cases directly. This is
- 58:21different from Usul Fiqh principles.
- 58:23This is the second difference. But
- 58:25actually, this is a derivative of the
- 58:27first difference. With Fiqh principles,
- 58:34we can answer questions directly
- 58:36without using anything else. Usul Fiqh
- 58:42principles cannot. Why? Because Usul
- 58:47Fiqh principles are in the realm of
- 58:49evidence. While Fiqh principles are in
- 58:52the realm of action. They deal
- 58:58directly with the issue. That is why,
- 59:06when there is a question, "Ustaz, I
- 59:15prayed two raka'ats earlier. My
- 59:20intention was the Fajr sunnah prayer.
- 59:24My intention was the Fajr sunnah prayer
- 59:26.
- 59:32After praying, it turned out I went out
- 59:37of the house. It turned out the Fajr
- 59:43time had ended, Ustaz. But I am certain
- 59:48that the two raka'ats I prayed were
- 59:51still within the Fajr time.
- 59:59Can those two raka'ats count as the
- 1:00:01Fajr prayer, Ustaz?" We can answer by
- 1:00:07saying innamal a'malu
- 1:00:10bin niyat directly or al-umuru
- 1:00:13bimaqasidiha. Everything depends on its
- 1:00:18intention. Directly, we do not need to
- 1:00:23use other evidence. This principle can
- 1:00:26immediately be the answer.
- 1:00:30Your intention was Fajr sunnah, so it
- 1:00:32becomes Fajr sunnah. Al-umuru
- 1:00:34bimaqasidiha. Innamal a'malu bin niyat.
- 1:00:44With Usul Fiqh principles, it cannot be
- 1:00:45like that. For example, Ustaz, what is
- 1:00:53the ruling on Maghrib prayer?
- 1:01:02Then we answer by saying what? Or by
- 1:01:07using an Usul Fiqh principle. Al-aslu
- 1:01:10fil amri yadullu alal wujub. The origin
- 1:01:14of a command implies a mandatory ruling
- 1:01:16. Does that connect?
- 1:01:20If someone asks, "Ustaz, what is the
- 1:01:22ruling on Maghrib prayer?" We answer, "
- 1:01:26Al-aslu fil amri yadullu alal wujub."
- 1:01:30The origin of a command implies a
- 1:01:31mandatory ruling. This answer does not
- 1:01:36connect. We must say the ruling is
- 1:01:40mandatory because of Allah's words,
- 1:01:43hafizu alas-salawati was-salatil wusta.
- 1:01:49Guard your prayers, meaning the
- 1:01:51mandatory prayers and the middle prayer
- 1:01:54. Among the mandatory prayers is
- 1:01:58Maghrib. And a command in its origin
- 1:02:01indicates
- 1:02:02mandatory.
- 1:02:03Mandatory, then it connects. So Usul
- 1:02:08Fiqh principles cannot be used to
- 1:02:11answer case questions directly. Because
- 1:02:17its realm is not human action, its
- 1:02:19realm is evidence. So to answer a
- 1:02:25question or a case, we must mention the
- 1:02:30evidence, then we mention the Usul
- 1:02:34principle. Yes, we mention the evidence
- 1:02:40, then we mention the Usul Fiqh
- 1:02:42principle. If we only mention the Usul
- 1:02:46Fiqh principle, it becomes disconnected
- 1:02:49. It is different from Fiqh principles.
- 1:02:57If there is a question, Ustaz, I forgot
- 1:02:59earlier, Ustaz, has my wudu been
- 1:03:04invalidated or not? But what is clear
- 1:03:07is that I performed wudu, now I am in
- 1:03:11doubt whether I passed gas or not. We
- 1:03:17can answer that with "al-yaqinu la
- 1:03:18yazulu bisy-syak" directly. We answer
- 1:03:21it directly using a jurisprudence rule.
- 1:03:24Al-yaqinu la yazulu bisy-syak. You were
- 1:03:28certain before that you still had wudu.
- 1:03:31You were certain that you had already
- 1:03:33performed wudu. Now you are doubtful
- 1:03:36whether your wudu is broken or not. So,
- 1:03:40disregard this doubt. Hold firmly to
- 1:03:43your previous certainty. Al-yaqinu la
- 1:03:46yazulu bisy-syak. We can answer
- 1:03:49directly with a jurisprudence rule.
- 1:03:52That is not a principle of Usul Fiqh.
- 1:03:54Like that. For example, if someone asks
- 1:03:58, "Ustaz, is it permissible to trim a
- 1:04:03beard that has exceeded one fist's
- 1:04:06length?" We answer, "Qawlus Sahabi
- 1:04:12Hujjah." The opinion of a Companion can
- 1:04:18be used as proof. That is how we answer
- 1:04:21. Does that make sense? It does. But we
- 1:04:27must say it is permissible. Because the
- 1:04:32Companion Ibn Umar used to do it.
- 1:04:36Likewise, the Companion Abu Hurairah
- 1:04:40also did it. And "Qawlus Sahabi" is
- 1:04:43proof. Meaning that a Companion's
- 1:04:48opinion, if not contradicted by other
- 1:04:51Companions, can be used as proof. Yes,
- 1:04:55this is the difference between
- 1:04:57jurisprudence rules and Usul Fiqh. Some
- 1:05:07mention another difference. Usul Fiqh
- 1:05:17exists before deriving laws. Unlike
- 1:05:24jurisprudence rules. They usually come
- 1:05:29after laws have been derived. Yes, but
- 1:05:34this difference does not apply to
- 1:05:35everything. However, some or many
- 1:05:42scholars have mentioned it. So, before
- 1:05:46one derives a law, they must know the
- 1:05:49principles of Usul Fiqh. Without
- 1:05:53knowing the principles of Usul Fiqh,
- 1:05:55one cannot derive a law. On the other
- 1:06:02hand, there are many jurisprudence
- 1:06:05rules derived by scholars from the
- 1:06:10answers or fatwas of the scholars. So,
- 1:06:17when a problem arises, many scholars
- 1:06:20issue a fatwa with a certain ruling.
- 1:06:24Eventually, later scholars summarize
- 1:06:27them into a jurisprudence rule.
- 1:06:32Summarized into a jurisprudence rule.
- 1:06:34Yes, like the rule "al-yaqinu la yazulu
- 1:06:38bisy-syak." This was summarized by
- 1:06:43scholars, not just from texts but from
- 1:06:46various issues, then condensed into the
- 1:06:50conclusion "al-yaqinu la yazulu
- 1:06:52bisy-syak," although this is not the
- 1:06:55case for everything; not all
- 1:06:57jurisprudence rules are like that. But
- 1:07:02if it's a matter of Usul Fiqh
- 1:07:05principles that must exist before
- 1:07:07deriving a law, then that applies to
- 1:07:10all issues. Alright, brothers and
- 1:07:13sisters, may Allah protect and have
- 1:07:13mercy on you. This is what I can convey
- 1:07:18on this occasion. There is still one
- 1:07:22more point in the introduction to Usul
- 1:07:25Fiqh, which is the importance of
- 1:07:30finding a good teacher when studying
- 1:07:32the science of Usul Fiqh. And that, God
- 1:07:36willing, we will discuss together in
- 1:07:42the next meeting. We will discuss it
- 1:07:46together in the next meeting regarding
- 1:07:49the urgency of finding a good teacher
- 1:07:51in the science of Usul Fiqh. Why is
- 1:07:56that? We will provide the reasons in
- 1:08:00the next study. That is all I can
- 1:08:04convey. And Allah knows best. Wa
- 1:08:08sallallahu' ala Muhammadin wa 'ala
- 1:08:11alihi wa shahbihi. Walhamdulillahi
- 1:08:16Rabbil' alamin.
- 1:08:24Peace be upon you, Ustaz. May Allah
- 1:08:26reward you with goodness. And peace be
- 1:08:27upon you, and Allah's mercy and
- 1:08:29blessings. The question is about the
- 1:08:34Sunnah of keeping a beard. Does the
- 1:08:41Sunnah become void or invalid if
- 1:08:44someone uses a certain medication to
- 1:08:46grow a beard? Because the Sunnah is to
- 1:08:51leave it, not to grow it. Alright. the
- 1:09:08sunnah becomes invalid. Yes, that's not
- 1:09:11the case. We don't say that. We say
- 1:09:18such an act is an act of takalluf. You
- 1:09:24know what takalluf is, right?
- 1:09:26Huh? An act of takalluf is an act...
- 1:09:34uh...yes, an act that is...excessive,
- 1:09:46burdening oneself. an act that you
- 1:09:51actually...are not commanded to do, but
- 1:09:56you want to do it like...uh, what word
- 1:10:09represents takalluf?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 1. Al-Ushul Min Ilmil Ushul - Dasar-Dasar Ilmu Ushul Fiqih | Ustadz Dr. Musyaffa' Ad-Dariny, M.A. by Musyaffa Ad Dariny Channel, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,177 words across 960 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.