1) 2026 KPSS Vatandaşlık-Temel Hukuk Kav.–Sosyal Düzen Kuralları–Hukukun Yaptırımları–Erdal Kesekler — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:07My dear friends, hello to everyone once
- 0:09again. We are starting our 2026
- 0:11citizenship video lectures, dear
- 0:13friends. May 2026 be auspicious and
- 0:15beneficial for all of us. Let's begin.
- 0:18My dear friends, our first topic is
- 0:20basic legal concepts, and the first
- 0:22subject of basic legal concepts is the
- 0:25rules of social order. A question came
- 0:27from here in 2008 so far, but of course
- 0:29, friends, it is one of the fundamental
- 0:32topics. We will not skip it without
- 0:33going over it. It is an easy topic,
- 0:35friends. We can liken social order, or
- 0:38societal order, to this. Imagine it as
- 0:40a traffic network, friends. Think that
- 0:42in that traffic network there are no
- 0:44lights, no signs, friends. There are no
- 0:46lanes. And there are no speed limits.
- 0:47Everyone is going as they please. What
- 0:49would happen? There would be accidents,
- 0:50there would be deaths. It would be a
- 0:52complete environment of chaos. Well, in
- 0:53social life too, when there are no
- 0:55rules, friends, we encounter these
- 0:56things. What are the rules that
- 0:58regulate social life? They are the
- 1:00rules of religion, etiquette, morality,
- 1:02and law. Now, let's look at these
- 1:03briefly, friends. Yes, the first is
- 1:05religious rules, dear friends. Do you
- 1:07know what religious rules are? They are
- 1:09the commands and prohibitions set by
- 1:10God. They are delivered to us through a
- 1:12book and a prophet, friends. They are
- 1:14conveyed to us. It sets commands and
- 1:16prohibitions. Dear friends, what
- 1:17happens if we follow these rules? For
- 1:19example, by praying, fasting, or giving
- 1:22alms, we earn merit. If we don't follow
- 1:25them, we commit a sin, friends. For
- 1:27example, think of it this way. Stealing
- 1:29is forbidden both religiously and
- 1:31legally. Religiously, friends, what
- 1:33does a person who steals do? They
- 1:36commit a sin. In law, however, they
- 1:38commit a crime. Does the person who
- 1:39commits a sin see the sanction in this
- 1:41world, friends? No. They see it in the
- 1:43afterlife. That is, it has no worldly
- 1:45sanction. It has an otherworldly
- 1:46sanction. Since there is no sanction
- 1:49applied by the state, what do we call
- 1:50this, friends? We say there is no
- 1:53material sanction. We call it a
- 1:55spiritual sanction. Also, religious
- 1:57rules have a feature like this. These
- 1:59are immutable rules, friends. They do
- 2:01not change over time. They proceed by
- 2:03total acceptance or total rejection.
- 2:05Moving on, friends. The second is moral
- 2:08rules. Morality consists of good and
- 2:10bad value judgments established in a
- 2:12society. My dear friends, look, some
- 2:15call certain things right, while others
- 2:18call them wrong. According to whom?
- 2:20According to what? Thus, morality is
- 2:22divided into two, friends. Subjective
- 2:24morality. Subjective morality is a
- 2:26person's behavior according to
- 2:27themselves, my friends. Think of it
- 2:29like a road where everyone determines
- 2:31their own traffic rules, dear friends.
- 2:33Of course, subjective morality is not
- 2:36fully sufficient to ensure social order
- 2:38, friends. So, let's give an example,
- 2:41my dear friends. A man is walking down
- 2:43the street and sees a wallet, for
- 2:45instance, or sees money. He says, "If I
- 2:47take this money, it wouldn't be right."
- 2:49"If I find the owner," he says, "if I
- 2:50find the owner and return it to them,
- 2:52it would be more right," for example.
- 2:54That is, he might not even return it.
- 2:55No one sees him. He is doing what is
- 2:57right entirely between him and his
- 2:59conscience. What does he do? He takes
- 3:00it. He finds the owner and delivers it
- 3:02to them. So, subjective morality is a
- 3:04morality that changes from person to
- 3:05person. For some, lying is normal
- 3:08behavior. For others, it is behavior
- 3:10that is not right. Subjective morality
- 3:12is like this, friends. The sanction is
- 3:14the person's own remorse, my friends.
- 3:16It is them speaking with their own
- 3:18inner voice, my friends, and feeling
- 3:20remorse. Well, another set is the
- 3:22objective rules of morality. These,
- 3:24friends, are actually the generally
- 3:26accepted understanding of morality for
- 3:29that society. If you look at the world,
- 3:30it is the universal understanding of
- 3:32morality. It is the understanding of
- 3:33morality that forms the basis of legal
- 3:35rules. For example, human rights have
- 3:37derived from objective moral rules,
- 3:38friends. Today, wherever you go in the
- 3:41world, mistreating a child is frowned
- 3:42upon and condemned everywhere, friends.
- 3:45Helping others, charity, and so on
- 3:47appear before us as objective moral
- 3:50rules. For example, a young person gets
- 3:52on a bus. At that moment, friends,
- 3:54there are no empty seats left. Then
- 3:56elderly people get on, one after
- 3:57another. Everyone looks at him, friends
- 3:59. Such social pressure is formed. The
- 4:01youth feels forced to get up and gives
- 4:03his seat to an elderly person, friends.
- 4:04What do we call that? We call them
- 4:06objective moral rules, friends. Our
- 4:09behaviors toward ourselves and toward
- 4:12society also appear as objective moral
- 4:14rules. So, what is the sanction?
- 4:17Condemnation, disapproval, and so on,
- 4:19friends. Meaning, he saw that wallet,
- 4:21friends, and no one else saw it. He
- 4:22could have put it in his pocket and
- 4:24left, for example. Or, on the bus,
- 4:25friends, you are not actually forced to
- 4:27give your seat to anyone. But as
- 4:29required by moral rules, friends, he
- 4:31listens to the voice of his own
- 4:32conscience. And he also fears the
- 4:34reaction of others, friends. What does
- 4:36he do? He gets up, and so on. That was
- 4:38the second one. The third is etiquette
- 4:41rules. "Görgü"(etiquette) comes from
- 4:42"görmek"(to see), my friends. These
- 4:44are also rules that society has brought
- 4:46about. My dear friends, we call these
- 4:48rules of courtesy. We call them manners
- 4:50. Well, knowing how to sit, stand, eat,
- 4:53drink, and how to behave. For example,
- 4:56you enter a group, friends, by greeting
- 4:58them. You enter someone's room, friends
- 5:00, by knocking on the door. We are
- 5:02careful while eating, for instance. We
- 5:04do not disturb others, for example. We
- 5:06do not speak in loud voices, and so on,
- 5:08friends. Well, what happens to those
- 5:09who do not follow these rules? They are
- 5:11generally excluded from society and
- 5:12condemned. So here too, friends, the
- 5:14source is society, and the sanction is
- 5:16also society itself, friends. Well,
- 5:18let's come to the rules that are really
- 5:21important for us. To legal rules. Legal
- 5:24rules, friends, have authorized state
- 5:26bodies. The state's legislative,
- 5:28executive, and so on. They set the
- 5:30rules. These are the rules set by the
- 5:32state. Therefore, they are mandatory
- 5:34rules to be followed. They are the
- 5:36rules with the heaviest sanctions.
- 5:38Because it takes the power of the state
- 5:40behind it, it has a material sanction,
- 5:42that is, a penalty. "Müeyyide" means
- 5:44sanction, my friends. Well, if we do
- 5:46not follow legal rules, let me give you
- 5:49a legal rule, for instance. Turkish
- 5:51Penal Code article 81. Intentional
- 5:52killing requires a life sentence,
- 5:54friends. You took the man, what did you
- 5:55do? You killed him. Meaning it requires
- 5:58life imprisonment, a sentence for life.
- 6:01Well, what are the sanctions for these
- 6:03in order, friends? They appear as
- 6:05punishment, compensation, enforcement,
- 6:07invalidity, and cancellation, friends.
- 6:09These are mandatory rules that must be
- 6:12followed. That is why the sanction,
- 6:14friends, is material. For example,
- 6:16remember earlier, there are pedestrian
- 6:18crossings on the roads, as you know. I
- 6:22mean, drivers didn't stop much, friends
- 6:23, but when the penalties were increased
- 6:25, what did they do now? They all stop
- 6:27obediently. This is what we call a
- 6:29material sanction, my dear friends.
- 6:32Well, those outside of legal rules have
- 6:35moral sanctions. We say that legal
- 6:37rules have material sanctions. This, my
- 6:39friends, is their most important
- 6:40characteristic. We must pay attention
- 6:42to this. Because whose power does it
- 6:43have behind it? Behind it, it has the
- 6:47power of the state. We call them legal
- 6:49rules. Yes. Now let's move on. A
- 6:51question has come from here once. Which
- 6:53one is not a rule that regulates social
- 6:55life? Religion, etiquette, morality,
- 6:57law. And they made one up, friends. We
- 6:59will talk about it. Let's give an
- 7:01example. Ali wears headphones on the
- 7:03bus instead of listening to music
- 7:05loudly. Now, not listening to music
- 7:07loudly or not talking on the phone
- 7:08loudly, friends, is a rule of etiquette
- 7:10. I mean, there is no such punishment
- 7:12as "why are you listening to it" for
- 7:13this. So, what is the truly important
- 7:15thing here, friends? It is, you know,
- 7:17not to do what to society, friends? Not
- 7:19to disturb it. This is a rule of
- 7:20etiquette. He delivers a dropped wallet
- 7:23to its owner. Let's imagine, friends,
- 7:25that the driver hits the brakes
- 7:26suddenly and everyone gets jolted. A
- 7:28man's wallet, friends, drops in front
- 7:30of Ali. Nobody sees it. For example,
- 7:32you can imagine that Ali could pick it
- 7:34up and put it in his pocket. So let's
- 7:36look at what kind of regulations there
- 7:37are. For instance, Ali is afraid of
- 7:39this: If I take the wallet, I will be
- 7:40violating others 'rights. This man is a
- 7:43worker like me, what a pity, etc., he
- 7:45says. I will violate someone's rights.
- 7:46He fears it will confront him in the
- 7:48afterlife. What does he not do? He
- 7:49doesn't take it, friends. Another is
- 7:51the moral rule. He does what is right
- 7:53even if no one sees him. He picks up
- 7:54the wallet, friends. What does he do?
- 7:56He delivers it to its owner. Nobody saw
- 7:58it. Nothing happened, friends. He could
- 8:00have done what with that wallet, for
- 8:01example? He could have used it in a
- 8:02different way. Rule of etiquette. He
- 8:05listens to music at a low volume. He
- 8:06does not listen at a high volume,
- 8:07friends. This is also a requirement of
- 8:09etiquette. Another is the legal rule.
- 8:11If he had taken the wallet, friends, he
- 8:12would have committed a crime. He is
- 8:14afraid of that. To avoid committing a
- 8:15crime, what does he do, friends? He
- 8:17takes the wallet in his hand and, uh,
- 8:20delivers it to the owner. So, you see,
- 8:22in what way do the rules that regulate
- 8:25social life ensure social order? We saw
- 8:27it in an example, friends. Just like we
- 8:29said at the beginning of the lesson, we
- 8:31will compare this to a traffic network.
- 8:32No lights, no speed limits, etc., chaos
- 8:35, accidents, death, etc. So these, too,
- 8:37friends, do what? They provide social
- 8:40order in this way. Well, dear friends,
- 8:43we have come to our second topic.
- 8:45General characteristics of legal rules.
- 8:47For example, what are the general
- 8:48characteristics of laws? I gave
- 8:49examples. We will go in order. First,
- 8:51laws, friends, are for everyone. By "
- 8:54everyone," we don't mean that laws are
- 8:56applied to everyone in the same way.
- 8:57Dear friends, they are not applied the
- 8:59same way to a 3-year-old and a 40-
- 9:01year-old. They are applied in the same
- 9:02way to everyone in the same situation.
- 9:04For example, at a traffic light, all
- 9:06drivers must stop at the red light,
- 9:07friends. Look, generality. The second
- 9:10is abstraction, friends. Legal rules
- 9:13are not created for a specific concrete
- 9:15event, friends. A legal rule is applied
- 9:18to all similar events, friends. For
- 9:20example, it says engagement is a
- 9:22promise of marriage. This is not a rule
- 9:24brought for a special engagement. It
- 9:26applies to all engagements. For example
- 9:28, the rule that intentional homicide is
- 9:30a crime applies to every case of
- 9:31intentional homicide, friends. Third,
- 9:34look, we said abstraction, continuity,
- 9:36and generality. Third is continuity.
- 9:39Once a rule enters into force, it
- 9:41applies to all situations it will
- 9:43encounter until it is repealed, friends
- 9:45. For example, let's say a tax law
- 9:48binds taxpayers as long as it remains
- 9:50in force. Friends, there is an
- 9:52exception to this. The budget law. This
- 9:55is a law that is renewed every year.
- 9:57This is the only temporary law, friends
- 9:59. For other laws, we do not know when
- 10:00they will be repealed after they enter
- 10:02into force. It is valid as long as it
- 10:04remains in force. We call this
- 10:05continuity. Legal rules are impersonal.
- 10:09You will not find names like Ahmet,
- 10:10Mehmet, Ayşe, or Fatma in legal rules.
- 10:12It says the President is elected for 5
- 10:14years. It does not say that President X
- 10:16, Y, or Z, friends. It says whoever
- 10:18becomes president is elected for 5
- 10:20years. For example, it says everyone
- 10:22who has turned 18 has the right to vote
- 10:24, friends. Look, does it give a name?
- 10:26No. They are general, impersonal rules,
- 10:29friends. Another one, we also said they
- 10:32are impersonal. Another one, legal
- 10:34rules have material sanctions. If the
- 10:36sanction in legal rules were not
- 10:37material, friends, no one would follow
- 10:39them. I mean, imagine there are such
- 10:41rules but no sanctions. Then the strong
- 10:43would crush the weak very easily. They
- 10:45would seize their property, friends.
- 10:46They would touch their bodily integrity
- 10:47. They would do everything, friends.
- 10:48Unfortunately, if there were no legal
- 10:50rules, friends, what would happen?
- 10:52Nothing called order would remain, and
- 10:54there must be a sanction. If the
- 10:56sanction remained moral like others, it
- 10:58would truly be insufficient to maintain
- 11:00order, friends. So, punishment,
- 11:03compensation—what do people do to
- 11:05avoid facing these? They feel obligated
- 11:07to follow these rules, my friends. Well
- 11:09, these are the characteristics of
- 11:11legal rules. For example, the
- 11:12compensation of damages caused as a
- 11:14result of a tort. If there were no such
- 11:16obligation, friends, one would not be
- 11:19afraid and would harm people as they
- 11:21pleased. They would commit crimes as
- 11:22they pleased, friends. They would not
- 11:24pay their debts as they pleased, and so
- 11:25on. Well then. We have come to the
- 11:29purposes of law, friends. Now, why does
- 11:31law exist, friends? Why does law exist?
- 11:33We will always think positively like
- 11:34this, friends. Of course, negative
- 11:35things won't appear here, but sometimes
- 11:37we can make mistakes by thinking too
- 11:39positively, friends. I will draw your
- 11:41attention to one point, friends. Legal
- 11:43rules provide social order and peace.
- 11:45We mentioned traffic rules, for example
- 11:47. If there were no courts today, Murat,
- 11:48what would happen if everyone tried to
- 11:50seek their own rights? Chaos. Is that
- 11:52right? Think about it. Nothing called
- 11:55social peace would remain, friends. If
- 11:57courts didn't resolve disputes. Law
- 11:59provides security. There are laws
- 12:01established in advance. We know those
- 12:03laws. We act accordingly. The law does
- 12:05not surprise us. A traffic police
- 12:06officer cannot just stop us and do
- 12:08whatever he wants, friends. He cannot
- 12:09issue a ticket. Law provides freedom.
- 12:13What does freedom mean? It limits the
- 12:15powers of others. Limiting the powers
- 12:17of others means providing us with
- 12:19freedom. It also limits our powers. If
- 12:22we harm others with the rights we use,
- 12:24friends, our freedom ends there. So,
- 12:27what do we call the limitation of the
- 12:29state's powers and the limitation of
- 12:31individuals' powers? We call it
- 12:32providing freedom to us, friends. It
- 12:34does this through laws. Law meets
- 12:37social needs. Murat, let me ask you a
- 12:39question. Was there such a thing as
- 12:41internet fraud in the 1950s? But today,
- 12:43it's everywhere. Right? I mean, mobile
- 12:46fraud by phone, the internet, we just
- 12:48can't keep our heads above water. Right
- 12:50? We're afraid to answer a number from
- 12:52an unknown caller. Wondering what might
- 12:53happen to us. Well, friends, what does
- 12:56law do regarding social needs? It meets
- 12:59them. It creates new regulations. Uh,
- 13:02for example, back in the day, Murat,
- 13:04what was that thing that flies? A drone
- 13:07. A guy is delivering cargo with a
- 13:09drone, for example. Right? So now, you
- 13:11have to create a regulation regarding
- 13:13this. Meaning, it must produce rules
- 13:15that will respond to social needs,
- 13:17friends. Law provides equality, friends
- 13:20. But this equality, friends, is
- 13:22definitely not absolute equality. Pay
- 13:24attention to this. How could law
- 13:25provide absolute equality, friends?
- 13:28Absolute equality does not always bring
- 13:29justice. For example, if we treat a 5-
- 13:32year-old and a 40-year-old the same way
- 13:35in criminal law, is there justice there
- 13:37, my friends? If we treat a mentally
- 13:40ill person and a normal person the same
- 13:42way, is that absolute equality? If the
- 13:43law treats the rich and the poor the
- 13:45same way, it would be absolute equality
- 13:47. But, friends, what would it not be?
- 13:48It would not be justice, friends. So,
- 13:50there is equality in law, but there is
- 13:53no absolute equality, friends. Let's be
- 13:55careful about this. Look, because it
- 13:57doesn't bring justice. We continue. So,
- 13:59the duty of law is to ensure justice. I
- 14:01wonder how it ensures justice? My dear
- 14:03friends, there are two types of justice
- 14:04. Let's be careful about this. It was
- 14:06asked in the 2014 associate degree exam
- 14:08, my friends. It also came up in a
- 14:09district governor exam. Let's pay
- 14:11attention to these two types of justice
- 14:12. The first is treating everyone the
- 14:14same without considering their
- 14:16individual circumstances. The second is
- 14:18treating people according to their
- 14:20circumstances, friends. Meaning the
- 14:22person's financial situation, age,
- 14:24gender, etc. The first one is
- 14:26corrective justice, friends. Corrective
- 14:30justice is actually applying equal
- 14:31treatment regardless of personal
- 14:33differences. Meaning it is based on
- 14:35absolute arithmetic equality, friends.
- 14:38Sometimes absolute equality brings
- 14:39justice, but it doesn't always, friends
- 14:41. For example, in traffic, whoever
- 14:43violates a traffic rule receives the
- 14:46same penalty. Whoever it may be,
- 14:48friends. What else should we say, my
- 14:50friends? For example, let's say you
- 14:52caused damage to person X, friends. You
- 14:55caused harm. What will you do with the
- 14:56amount of damage you caused? You will
- 14:57pay exactly as much as the damage you
- 14:59caused, for instance. This is what we
- 15:01call absolute equality. But absolute
- 15:03equality, meaning corrective justice,
- 15:05does not always provide justice,
- 15:07friends. If you take the same tax from
- 15:10a mansion and a shack, that would be
- 15:12absolute equality. Meaning it would be
- 15:14corrective justice. But does corrective
- 15:17justice achieve justice here? No. Look,
- 15:19we said this corrective justice brings
- 15:21justice in traffic rules. But does it
- 15:24bring justice in the tax case I just
- 15:26mentioned, friends? It does not. So, a
- 15:28second type of justice was needed,
- 15:30friends. And what is that? Distributive
- 15:33justice. You need to know this well.
- 15:34This is important. It is treating
- 15:37people according to their personal
- 15:39circumstances, friends. It is treating
- 15:41people according to the circumstances
- 15:42of individuals. For example, treating
- 15:45based on age in criminal law, treating
- 15:47based on the power of discernment, or
- 15:48treating based on financial strength in
- 15:50tax law, friends. So what do we call
- 15:53that? We call it distributive,
- 15:55allocating justice, friends. It is
- 15:57taking action based on personal
- 15:59circumstances. If a transaction is
- 16:00performed regardless of personal status
- 16:02, it is corrective. If the arrangement
- 16:03is made according to personal
- 16:05situations, my friends, it is
- 16:06distributive. For instance, my dear
- 16:09Murat, let's put it this way. Giving
- 16:11everyone the same salary at a workplace
- 16:12is corrective. Right? But what do we
- 16:15call it when the salary increases or
- 16:17decreases according to a person's
- 16:19education, seniority, work performance,
- 16:22etc.? We call it distributive justice.
- 16:24Yes, you should interpret it this way,
- 16:26my friends. Then let's give our example
- 16:28. I apologize. Let's provide our
- 16:30example, friends. Corrective. And
- 16:32regarding distribution, we call the
- 16:33collection of taxes based on financial
- 16:35strength distributive justice. In
- 16:37traffic, applying the same sanctions to
- 16:39everyone who violates the rule,
- 16:41regardless of their personal status. We
- 16:43call this corrective justice. Let's
- 16:45keep this in the back of our minds as
- 16:46well. Well, let's solve some questions,
- 16:48friends. What did I tell you? We will
- 16:49solve plenty of questions, friends. By
- 16:51the way, I am solving these questions
- 16:52for the sake of thematic integrity, but
- 16:54let's say the topic is finished and
- 16:55there are questions behind it. I will
- 16:57not leave them for the next lesson,
- 16:59friends. Some lessons might be a tad
- 17:01long because of that, friends. Not too
- 17:03much, but they might be a bit long. The
- 17:05reason for that is to ensure thematic
- 17:07integrity. Let's say we finished the
- 17:08topic. We cannot leave the questions
- 17:09for the next video, friends, can we? We
- 17:10cannot solve them. Otherwise, it falls
- 17:12apart. Well, let's start. Which of the
- 17:14statements regarding rules of law is
- 17:15correct? One. It ensures social order.
- 17:18Yes. We have been talking about that
- 17:20for minutes. It has material sanctions.
- 17:22Yes, there is state support. Thirdly,
- 17:25it regulates human behavior. Of course,
- 17:28my friends, morality, law, religion,
- 17:30and etiquette are unique to humans. Do
- 17:32animals have morality, my dear Murat?
- 17:34Do they have religion? No, they don't.
- 17:36Who are all these for? They are for
- 17:38humans, my friends. Therefore, law is
- 17:40also for humans. The answer to the
- 17:43question is option E, my friends. Which
- 17:46of the following is not one of the
- 17:47rules regulating social life? My dear
- 17:49friends, this was the exam question
- 17:52from 2008, and the answer was physics
- 17:55rules. So, I changed it. I said
- 17:57philosophy rules. I said math rules,
- 17:59friends, it doesn't matter. Religion,
- 18:01morality, etiquette, and legal rules
- 18:03are the rules that regulate social life
- 18:05. But there are no philosophy rules.
- 18:07Who knows philosophy, anyway, friends?
- 18:09There was a famous philosopher on TRT 2
- 18:10. I used to listen to him. The man said
- 18:13, "My biggest mistake," he said, "was
- 18:14unfortunately, and I say unfortunately,
- 18:15writing my books in Turkish," he said,
- 18:17friends. Because no one in our society
- 18:19does what? Philosophy, yes,
- 18:21unfortunately, they are not interested
- 18:23in philosophy. But the man was truly a
- 18:25very good man, friends. He passed away.
- 18:27May he rest in peace. He said, "If I
- 18:30had done this in a different language,
- 18:31like English or something, maybe today
- 18:33I would be a..." World-renowned scholar
- 18:34. Yes. Which of the following is not
- 18:37one of the characteristics of legal
- 18:39rules? Friends, legal rules are general
- 18:41. They are for everyone, but abstract
- 18:43for everyone in the same situation.
- 18:44They are not specific to a certain
- 18:45event. They are applied to all events,
- 18:47all relevant events. They are not
- 18:50enacted for specific people by name.
- 18:52They are valid as long as they remain
- 18:53in force. But we say they have material
- 18:55, not spiritual sanctions, friends.
- 18:58Material sanction. There is state
- 19:00support. In legal rules. Moving on.
- 19:04Which of the following is not one of
- 19:05the purposes of law? It ensures justice
- 19:07. Yes. This is what's truly important.
- 19:09The scales of justice, my friends. May
- 19:11those scales never tip. It ensures
- 19:13social peace, prevents chaos, and
- 19:15provides security. It gives you
- 19:17assurance, friends. I said the law
- 19:18doesn't surprise you. A traffic cop.
- 19:20Cannot issue a ticket just because they
- 19:21feel like it, friends. They are bound
- 19:23by rules. The law sets you free. If
- 19:26there were no law, the strong would
- 19:28crush the weak. They would touch your
- 19:29property. They would touch everything
- 19:31you own. The state could do this,
- 19:33friends. Individuals could do it, too.
- 19:34So, the law doesn't just limit the
- 19:36powers of individuals. It also limits
- 19:38the powers of the state. That’s why
- 19:39we have our fundamental rights and
- 19:40freedoms in the constitution. So, the
- 19:41answer to this question is absolute
- 19:43equality. How can the law treat the
- 19:45worker and the loafer as equals,
- 19:47friends? How can it treat a 3-year-old
- 19:49and a 40-year-old the same? It’s
- 19:50impossible. Let's say those in the same
- 19:53situation benefit from the same rights.
- 19:56There is no absolute equality. My dear
- 19:58friends, there were two types of
- 19:59justice. One was treating everyone the
- 20:02same, regardless of personal
- 20:03circumstances. We called that
- 20:05compensatory or corrective justice.
- 20:07Everyone pays the same traffic fine,
- 20:09friends. And because that wasn't enough
- 20:12, there was distributive justice, where
- 20:14people were treated according to their
- 20:16situations. It distributed and
- 20:18allocated the burdens. We called that
- 20:21distributive justice, too. For example,
- 20:23taxes based on financial power,
- 20:25penalties based on age, and so on. We
- 20:27call that distributive as well. Now, if
- 20:30taxes are collected based on financial
- 20:32power, and salaries are given based on
- 20:34education, seniority, etc., what do we
- 20:36call this, friends? We call it
- 20:39distributive, or allocative, justice.
- 20:43Yes, this is important, my dear friends
- 20:45. I say let’s make sure we know this
- 20:47well. Now, my precious friends, our new
- 20:50topic is the sanctions of law. I will
- 20:52finish this topic completely and end
- 20:53the lesson by solving its questions,
- 20:55friends. That’s why I don’t want to
- 20:56leave it halfway. To maintain the unity
- 20:58of the topic, we have plenty of
- 20:59questions, friends. We will solve them.
- 21:02If we act against legal rules, we face
- 21:04certain sanctions. We face what are
- 21:06also called legal consequences. Friends
- 21:08, these consequences are coercive
- 21:10sanctions. We are not free to follow
- 21:12them or not. We have to follow them. We
- 21:13will either follow them or we will
- 21:15follow them, friends. There is no other
- 21:17option. Let me give you some tips
- 21:19before we get into the details, friends
- 21:21. Then we can get into the details. We
- 21:24have five basic sanctions. One is
- 21:26annulment. Annulment applies to
- 21:28administrative acts, friends. An
- 21:30administrative act was a question on
- 21:32this year's 2024 secondary education
- 21:35KPSS citizenship exam, friends. We call
- 21:38the mandatory acts of the
- 21:40administration based on public power,
- 21:42aimed at creating legal consequences,
- 21:44an administrative act. Who is the
- 21:45administration? It is the arm of the
- 21:47state that reaches us, friends. Not the
- 21:49parliament, not the courts. It is the
- 21:51arm of the executive branch of the
- 21:53state that reaches us; things like
- 21:55ministries, governorships, district
- 21:57governorships, municipalities,
- 21:58universities, the Higher Education
- 22:00Council (YÖK), etc., are called
- 22:02administrative acts. Administrative
- 22:04acts have five elements, friends. Five
- 22:05elements. Let me write them down right
- 22:08here. This was also a 2024 secondary
- 22:10education exam question this year.
- 22:13Authority, form, friends, cause,
- 22:18purpose. Subject; those are the 5
- 22:22elements. If an administrative act
- 22:24violates one of these elements. For
- 22:26example, a governor takes a decision
- 22:27that a district governor should have
- 22:29taken. For example, a disciplinary
- 22:30penalty is given to a civil servant
- 22:31without receiving their defense,
- 22:32friends. For example, a salary
- 22:34deduction penalty is given for an act
- 22:35that requires a reprimand penalty. For
- 22:37example, friends, there is no public
- 22:39interest involved. There is personal
- 22:40ambition, there is personal gain. What
- 22:42do they do? They expropriate a man's
- 22:44land. So, if administrative actions
- 22:46violate one of these four or five
- 22:48principles, dear friends, what is done?
- 22:50It is taken to the administrative
- 22:51judiciary and canceled. I am moving on
- 22:52with some preliminary information.
- 22:53Penalty. Penalty, friends, refers to
- 22:57sanctions applied to acts that laws,
- 22:59especially criminal laws, deem as
- 23:02crimes. These can be imprisonment or
- 23:04fines, friends. We will discuss
- 23:06judicial fines. Compensation, friends,
- 23:08is paying for the damage you caused to
- 23:10someone. Meaning, did you cause damage
- 23:11to someone? Replace it. Replace it. So,
- 23:15friends, it is actually about balancing
- 23:17here, friends, balancing. You will
- 23:19cover the damage you caused. So what is
- 23:21present in compensation? There is the
- 23:23concept of damage. Moving on, friends.
- 23:26Forced execution. "Cebir" means force.
- 23:28"İcra" means fulfillment. Forced
- 23:30fulfillment. If you don't do it, the
- 23:32state makes you do it by force. An
- 23:34eviction order has been issued by the
- 23:36court, but the tenant is not vacating
- 23:37the house. They are removed by the
- 23:38police with force. An expropriation
- 23:40decision has been made. Everything is
- 23:41complete. The person is not leaving the
- 23:43land. What does the administration do
- 23:44with public power, friends? It removes
- 23:46them from there. You are not paying
- 23:47your debt. The person goes to the
- 23:49enforcement office and the enforcement
- 23:51court; then, through seizure and the
- 23:53like, the debt is collected. This is
- 23:55what forced execution is, friends. It
- 23:57means enforcing a debt or an action
- 23:59through the power of the state.
- 24:00Enforcing it through the power of the
- 24:02state. Another one is nullity. Nullity
- 24:05also means invalidity, friends, we say,
- 24:07and we move on. Now let's detail these,
- 24:09friends. First, of course, cancellation
- 24:12. What is cancellation, my friends?
- 24:15Cancellation is for the
- 24:16administration's unlawful actions. We
- 24:19called those administrative actions. So
- 24:21who was the administration, friends? It
- 24:23was the branch of the state reaching
- 24:25out to us. It was the branch that
- 24:26handles our daily affairs. Ministries,
- 24:28governorates, district governorships,
- 24:30municipalities, TRT, universities, YOK,
- 24:32public legal entities, in short,
- 24:34friends. Well, uh, meaning the state,
- 24:37public legal entities, like
- 24:39municipalities, TRT, universities, YOK,
- 24:42provincial special administrations,
- 24:44they carry out actions. We call these
- 24:47administrative actions. An
- 24:48administrative action has five elements
- 24:50. Authority, authority, form, reason,
- 24:57subject, and purpose. If it violates
- 25:02one of these five elements,
- 25:03administrative actions are unlawful.
- 25:05What do you do then, friends? Where are
- 25:08disputes between us and the
- 25:09administration resolved? They are not
- 25:11resolved in the courthouse or judicial
- 25:12courts. We go to the administrative
- 25:14judiciary. The referee here is the
- 25:15administrative judiciary, friends. We
- 25:17appeal to the arbitration of the
- 25:18administrative judiciary. So who is the
- 25:19administrative judiciary? The
- 25:21administrative judiciary, friends,
- 25:23consists of four types of courts. Let
- 25:25me state them right away.
- 25:27Administrative court and tax court.
- 25:29These are general courts. The most
- 25:31general one is the administrative court
- 25:32, friends. The period for filing a
- 25:34lawsuit is 60 days from the date of
- 25:35written notification. It is 30 days for
- 25:37tax cases. We go to the appellate court
- 25:39against their decisions. To the higher
- 25:41court. The appellate court, friends,
- 25:43are the regional administrative courts.
- 25:45That is, the BAM (Regional
- 25:46Administrative Courts); we go to the
- 25:47Council of State against the decision
- 25:49given by the appellate court. The
- 25:51Council of State is the court of appeal
- 25:52here. So there are four courts like
- 25:54this, tiered, friends. We go to them
- 25:57and file a lawsuit for the cancellation
- 25:58of the administrative action according
- 25:59to the subject, friends. If the court
- 26:02deems the decision made by the
- 26:03administration as unlawful, it
- 26:05eliminates the action with retroactive
- 26:08effect. Meaning it rewinds time,
- 26:10friends. The action is considered as if
- 26:13it never happened. And for example, you
- 26:15were dismissed from civil service,
- 26:17friends, you are returning. You
- 26:18continue your job as if you were never
- 26:20dismissed. Well, let's give examples,
- 26:23dear friends. A public servant was
- 26:25given an unlawful disciplinary penalty.
- 26:27What will the public servant do? They
- 26:28will go to the administrative court and
- 26:29request the cancellation of the
- 26:30administrative act. Continuing. A
- 26:33student was unfairly suspended from
- 26:34school. This could be a university.
- 26:35This could be a school affiliated with
- 26:37the Ministry of National Education. The
- 26:38student will go to the administrative
- 26:39judiciary. They will request the
- 26:40cancellation of the administrative act.
- 26:42A public servant was transferred
- 26:43elsewhere in violation of the
- 26:44regulations. In other words, the public
- 26:46servant was exiled, friends. What will
- 26:47the public servant do? They will go to
- 26:48the administrative judiciary and
- 26:49request the cancellation of the
- 26:50administrative act. The municipality
- 26:53has sealed a business. If it is done
- 26:55unlawfully, the business will go to the
- 26:56administrative judiciary and request
- 26:58the cancellation of the administrative
- 26:59act. The municipality has issued an
- 27:01unlawful expropriation decision. What
- 27:02will they do, friends? The citizen will
- 27:04go to the administrative judiciary and
- 27:05request the cancellation of the
- 27:06administrative act. Well, what happens
- 27:07if it is canceled? The act is removed
- 27:10with retroactive effect, friends.
- 27:13However, there is such a thing in
- 27:15administrative law. Administrative acts
- 27:17are considered lawful until you file a
- 27:20lawsuit. We call this the presumption
- 27:22of legality. Because they assume the
- 27:24administration will not do anything
- 27:26wrong. Therefore, what will we do,
- 27:28friends? We will go and file our
- 27:29lawsuit within the time limit. So,
- 27:31unfortunately, administrative acts
- 27:34benefit from the presumption of
- 27:35legality as long as you do not file a
- 27:38lawsuit. Let's say a question from
- 27:40ÖSYM, friends, is what? Flawed. Until
- 27:42you say it is flawed, friends, if you
- 27:44don't sue for it, what happens? Friends
- 27:46, unfortunately, if they don't withdraw
- 27:48it either, the administrative act is
- 27:50unfortunately considered valid, my
- 27:51friends. Let's move on. In such cases,
- 27:54one applies to the administrative
- 27:56judiciary. We have seen the
- 27:57administrative judiciary. If the court
- 27:59determines an illegality, the act is
- 28:00canceled. By the way, we will see these
- 28:02courts in the administrative judiciary.
- 28:03We are giving our preliminary
- 28:04information here, friends. There are
- 28:06various courts in the administrative
- 28:07judiciary. Dear friends, there is a
- 28:10cancellation lawsuit in the
- 28:11administrative judiciary. And there is
- 28:12also a full remedy lawsuit. A second
- 28:14type of lawsuit. This lawsuit is the
- 28:16compensation lawsuit in the
- 28:17administrative judiciary, friends. So,
- 28:19what is the name of the compensation
- 28:21lawsuit in administrative law? It is
- 28:23the full remedy lawsuit. Let's say you
- 28:25suffered damage from an administrative
- 28:27act. You were dismissed from your
- 28:28profession. Years passed. Then you
- 28:30returned to the profession somehow.
- 28:31Your lawsuit took a long time. For
- 28:33years you had no social security, you
- 28:35know, no salary, etc. Well, what would
- 28:37cancellation do, friends? It would
- 28:39rewind the administrative act. But you
- 28:40also have a loss. What will you do to
- 28:42cover your loss? You can go to the
- 28:44administrative judiciary and file a
- 28:46full remedy lawsuit to cover the damage
- 28:48resulting from the administrative act,
- 28:50friends. It can be filed separately, or
- 28:51it can be filed together. It depends on
- 28:53the subject, dear friends. So,
- 28:54administrative acts and actions. What
- 28:56is an action of the administration? For
- 28:57example, the municipality dug a very
- 28:59deep pit while building a road. This
- 29:01caused your house to collapse. You
- 29:03suffered damage due to an action of the
- 29:05administration. Well, what will you do?
- 29:07You will file a lawsuit against the
- 29:08administration for this damage you
- 29:09suffered to be covered. So, what is the
- 29:11name of that lawsuit? The name of that
- 29:12compensation lawsuit is the full remedy
- 29:14lawsuit. There are two lawsuits in
- 29:15administrative law. One is the lawsuit
- 29:17filed to remove an unlawful
- 29:18administrative act, which is the
- 29:19cancellation lawsuit. Also, a full
- 29:21judgment action is a lawsuit filed to
- 29:23compensate for damages arising from
- 29:24administrative acts and actions. Well,
- 29:26let's give an example. What is the
- 29:29purpose? Compensation for damage.
- 29:30Meaning the remediation of the material
- 29:32or moral damage a person has suffered,
- 29:34friends. Think of it like compensation,
- 29:36but in administrative law. For example,
- 29:38a citizen who has an accident on their
- 29:40motorcycle due to a pothole in a
- 29:42municipality-owned road will file a
- 29:44full judgment action against the
- 29:46municipality to compensate for hospital
- 29:48expenses and loss of income due to
- 29:49inability to work. There is nothing
- 29:51here that would be the subject of an
- 29:52annulment action. You will file a full
- 29:53judgment action. You will get your
- 29:54damage compensated. Let's move on,
- 29:57friends. When you think of punishment,
- 29:59the concept of crime should come to
- 30:00mind first. But punishment is not
- 30:02applied only to acts containing crimes.
- 30:04If there are acts containing crimes, a
- 30:06trial is conducted in court. Then, as a
- 30:08result of the trial, the court judge
- 30:09gives you a penalty if applicable.
- 30:11There are also penalties given without
- 30:13a trial. There are penalties given
- 30:15without a court. These, for example,
- 30:17derive their power from criminal laws.
- 30:19This one, however, derives its power
- 30:20from administrative law, friends. These
- 30:22penalties, the court gives these.
- 30:24Trials are held, etc. Here,
- 30:26administrative authorities give the
- 30:27penalty, friends. Well, first let's see
- 30:29what the penalties are that are given
- 30:31by courts in cases of violation of
- 30:33criminal laws, and the penalties given
- 30:35as a result of a trial. One is
- 30:37imprisonment, two are fines. Friends,
- 30:40there are three types of imprisonment.
- 30:42Aggravated life imprisonment and life
- 30:43imprisonment. Both are life-long,
- 30:45meaning they are sent to prison with
- 30:47the idea that the convict stays for
- 30:48life, friends. Both committed the
- 30:50qualified version of the crime. One,
- 30:51for example, killed a person. Simple.
- 30:53The other killed with monstrous
- 30:54feelings. For instance, they tortured,
- 30:56etc., that is aggravated. Now, both are
- 30:58sent to life imprisonment, but one is
- 30:59in a single-person room, one is in a
- 31:01social environment, one gets visits
- 31:03once a week, one gets visits every 15
- 31:04days. One is outdoors for one hour a
- 31:06day, one is outdoors for several hours
- 31:08a day, friends. Anyway, we say they are
- 31:10both life sentences, but are they under
- 31:11the same conditions? No. One is
- 31:13aggravated, execution conditions are
- 31:15tougher, an imprisonment penalty. That
- 31:18is what we call aggravated life
- 31:19imprisonment. And there are exception
- 31:21special situations for these, of course
- 31:23. I am skipping those. In aggravated,
- 31:26at least after 30 years, and in life
- 31:28imprisonment, from 24 years on, friends
- 31:30. With conditional release, what can be
- 31:31done, friends? One can be set free. But
- 31:33of course, this is not valid for all
- 31:35crimes. Well, a fixed-term imprisonment
- 31:38has a certain duration. We call
- 31:39penalties of at least 1 month and at
- 31:41most 20 years fixed-term imprisonment,
- 31:43friends. 1 month and 20 years. Those
- 31:46less than one year are called
- 31:48short-term imprisonment. Look, 1 month
- 31:51to 20 years is fixed-term. If it is
- 31:54less than 1 year, we call it short-term
- 31:56imprisonment, friends. Well, courts
- 32:00sometimes sentence to judicial fines
- 32:02independently or as an alternative
- 32:04sanction. What can they do with prison
- 32:07sentences of less than one year? They
- 32:08can convert them to judicial fines as
- 32:10an alternative sanction. Well, what is
- 32:13the range of days for judicial fines?
- 32:15Look, it can be given independently as
- 32:16well. It can also be given if it is
- 32:18less than one year. Independently, for
- 32:20instance, sentences between 5 and 730
- 32:22days can be converted into a judicial
- 32:25fine, friends. The daily amount is
- 32:28between 100 and 500. Murat, until last
- 32:30year, this was between 20 and 100. Of
- 32:33course, inflation also affected this
- 32:35here. What was set again as the 500
- 32:37upper limit and 100 lower limit? It was
- 32:39determined. So, what kind of justice is
- 32:41there here? Distributive justice? Or
- 32:43commutative justice? Look, pay
- 32:45attention. It does not give the same
- 32:46amount to everyone. If it did, it would
- 32:48be commutative. It will give according
- 32:50to financial status, friends;
- 32:51distributive justice comes into play
- 32:53here. The lower limit is 100, the upper
- 32:55limit is 500, friends. Well, those
- 32:57derived their source from criminal law;
- 32:58these derive their source from
- 33:00administrative law. We call the
- 33:01penalties given by administrative
- 33:03authorities, which derive their source
- 33:05from administrative law, are not given
- 33:06by a court, and are imposed without a
- 33:08trial, administrative penalties. These
- 33:10are the penalties listed in Law No. 657
- 33:13, and penalties for misdemeanors. There
- 33:15is no trial in these. There is no court
- 33:17in these. There is no judge in these.
- 33:19These are not criminal laws. They are
- 33:21administrative laws. Actually, what are
- 33:23these? They are sanctions in the nature
- 33:25of administrative acts, which is the
- 33:27previous type of sanction, friends. If
- 33:29these are unlawful, we go to the
- 33:30administrative judiciary. What do we
- 33:32ask for regarding the administrative
- 33:33act? We ask for the cancellation of
- 33:35these penalties, friends. We will see
- 33:37these in the future. Warning, reprimand
- 33:39, salary cut, step advancement
- 33:41suspension, and dismissal from civil
- 33:43service for public servants, and
- 33:44disciplinary penalties are all
- 33:46penalties in the nature of
- 33:47administrative acts. Also, traffic
- 33:50fines, smoking bans, social security
- 33:52penalties, and demolition. These are
- 33:54also administrative penalties. Friends,
- 33:55pay attention to this. In the year 2004
- 34:00, a clause was added to the
- 34:01constitution. The death penalty and the
- 34:04penalty of general confiscation cannot
- 34:05be imposed. The death penalty was
- 34:07abolished in 2004, friends; what is
- 34:09general confiscation? Let's say someone
- 34:11committed murder. They killed a man.
- 34:13The state cannot seize this person's
- 34:15assets, friends, according to the
- 34:16constitution. Meaning, it punishes
- 34:18whoever committed the crime. It does
- 34:21not punish assets. Let's seize his
- 34:22house, let's seize his car. This has
- 34:24been abolished, friends. This does not
- 34:25exist. Let's say the constitution
- 34:26prohibits this. That would be more
- 34:27accurate. However, there is special
- 34:29confiscation. What is special
- 34:30confiscation? The items used in the
- 34:32crime, the proceeds obtained from the
- 34:34crime. The state seizes these, friends.
- 34:37For example, it seizes the vehicle used
- 34:39to transport drugs if it catches it,
- 34:41and seizes the gun or knife used to
- 34:43kill the man. Confiscation of criminal
- 34:45objects. It determines the proceeds
- 34:46obtained from the crime and seizes them
- 34:48, friends. But general confiscation,
- 34:50like taking a man's house or car just
- 34:52because he received a sentence, is
- 34:54prohibited. But we say, friends, that
- 34:56special confiscation, the confiscation
- 34:58of criminal objects and proceeds,
- 35:00exists. Well then, dear friends,
- 35:04compensation. What comes to mind when
- 35:06we say compensation? It is the
- 35:07remediation of damage, friends. It is
- 35:09covering the damage. Well, if we cause
- 35:12harm to someone as a result of an
- 35:14unlawful and faulty behavior, what will
- 35:16we do with the damage we caused? We
- 35:18will compensate it, friends. We will
- 35:20replace it. Well, there are two types
- 35:22of compensation. Pecuniary and
- 35:24non-pecuniary; if someone has suffered
- 35:26damage to their assets as a result of
- 35:29unlawful behavior, meaning if you are
- 35:31physically damaging their wallet,
- 35:33friends, if we are causing economic
- 35:35harm to the person, what is this? It
- 35:39requires pecuniary compensation,
- 35:41friends; you are reducing the person's
- 35:43assets economically, you are depleting
- 35:45them. Well, for example, damage to a
- 35:48vehicle in a traffic accident reduces
- 35:50the value of the vehicle, friends. What
- 35:52does it do economically? You are
- 35:54reducing the money in your wallet. We
- 35:56call this pecuniary compensation. Well,
- 35:59what do we call compensation that is
- 36:01purely emotional, based on feelings,
- 36:04pain, sorrow, and thought, friends? We
- 36:08call it non-pecuniary compensation.
- 36:10Non-pecuniary compensation cannot be
- 36:11measured like pecuniary compensation,
- 36:13friends. For instance, you can invoice
- 36:15it here. You can document the damage,
- 36:17but that is not possible here, friends.
- 36:20This is the sorrow, sadness, and pain a
- 36:22person experiences as a result of an
- 36:24unlawful act. What could this be,
- 36:26friends? For example, a person is
- 36:29insulted or cursed at in public. The
- 36:33person feels pain and sorrow from this.
- 36:34Or, what happens as a result of a
- 36:36traffic accident, Murat? They become
- 36:38afraid to drive anymore. They can no
- 36:40longer drive. They cannot get into a
- 36:42car. What is this as well, friends? It
- 36:44is an emotional breakdown, friends.
- 36:46What can one do regarding non-pecuniary
- 36:48compensation, friends? They can request
- 36:49it as an extra. Example: A person being
- 36:53humiliated in front of society due to
- 36:55slander, friends. You already hear a
- 36:57lot of news about this, dear friends.
- 36:59It requires non-pecuniary compensation.
- 37:01If the damage can be measured,
- 37:02documented, or invoiced, it is
- 37:04pecuniary compensation. If the damage
- 37:07cannot be documented or invoiced, but
- 37:09remains as a feeling in one's thoughts
- 37:11and causes pain, sorrow, or sadness,
- 37:14And if it cannot be measured, we call
- 37:16this non-pecuniary compensation. There
- 37:19are four elements of compensation,
- 37:20friends. There must be an unlawful act.
- 37:23There must be fault. There must be
- 37:27damage. There must be a causal link.
- 37:28Let me give an example, friends. What
- 37:30do I do in traffic? I run a red light
- 37:32quickly. At that moment, a vehicle is
- 37:34coming from the other side, friends.
- 37:35Since I cannot stop, I crash. Now, did
- 37:38I act unlawfully? Against the law. Yes.
- 37:41There is unlawfulness. 2. Am I at fault
- 37:43because I ran the red light? I am at
- 37:45fault due to negligence or intent. 3. I
- 37:48crashed into that vehicle. Did I cause
- 37:49damage? Is there damage? Yes, there is.
- 37:51This can be both pecuniary and
- 37:52non-pecuniary. Maybe they will be
- 37:54afraid. And they won't be able to get
- 37:55into a car, friends. 4. Is there a
- 37:57cause-and-effect relationship, friends?
- 37:58Yes. If I hadn't run that red light, I
- 38:00wouldn't have hit that vehicle. There
- 38:02is also a causal link. A
- 38:03cause-and-effect relationship? That is
- 38:05why there is compensation. But the
- 38:06essential element in compensation is
- 38:07the existence of damage. In order for
- 38:09us to claim compensation as a result of
- 38:11a tort, what must exist, friends?
- 38:12Damage must exist, dear friends. Well,
- 38:15let's come to the third one. Forced
- 38:17execution. Forced execution means
- 38:19fulfilling something by force. Meaning,
- 38:21fulfilling it with the power of the
- 38:23state. If you don't do it, I go to the
- 38:25state. The state makes you do it by
- 38:27force. Are you not vacating the house?
- 38:30There is a court order. Are you not
- 38:31leaving? I will have the police remove
- 38:33you by force. Or we issued an
- 38:34expropriation decision. Now you need to
- 38:36leave that land. Are you not leaving?
- 38:38What will we do to you with public
- 38:39power? We will remove you by force with
- 38:40the power of the administration. Or you
- 38:41are not paying your debt. Are you not
- 38:43going to pay? I will apply for
- 38:44enforcement. To the enforcement court,
- 38:45to the enforcement office. What will
- 38:47they do to you? They will collect my
- 38:49receivables. We call this forced
- 38:50execution, friends. Well, Murat, are
- 38:53you not going to the military? No.
- 38:57Murat has gone and come back. What will
- 38:59we do to you, friends? We will take you
- 39:01to the military by force. So, what do
- 39:03we call this? We call it compulsory
- 39:04execution, my friends. Compulsory
- 39:06execution is, friends, forcing a debtor
- 39:08to fulfill their obligation through
- 39:10state power when they do not do so of
- 39:12their own free will. It’s that simple
- 39:14. If you don't do it, the state will
- 39:16make you do it by force. Who enforces
- 39:17it? You go to the enforcement office.
- 39:19You go to the enforcement court.
- 39:21Sometimes, the administration enforces
- 39:23it itself, friends. In what cases is it
- 39:26applied? If the debtor does not pay the
- 39:27creditor's debt. Friends, we’ve given
- 39:29money and they aren’t paying. If the
- 39:31debtor does not pay their taxes, there
- 39:32is also enforcement in taxes, friends.
- 39:34Just try not paying. They aren't paying
- 39:35their alimony debt. Likewise, you don't
- 39:37pay your traffic fine. Just try not
- 39:39paying your traffic fine. It piles up,
- 39:41doesn't it? Then what do they do to you
- 39:42? They collect it by force. All of
- 39:44these are examples of compulsory
- 39:45execution, dear friends. Let’s give
- 39:47an example of the process, friends. Uh,
- 39:49the most common type of enforcement.
- 39:51The debtor does not pay their debt. The
- 39:53creditor applies to the enforcement
- 39:54office. And what does the enforcement
- 39:55office do, friends? It sends a payment
- 39:57order. It requests a statement of
- 39:58assets, and so on. Anyway, the state
- 39:59puts a lien on the debtor's property.
- 40:01Then, friends, it puts it up for sale.
- 40:04It converts it into cash. It collects
- 40:06the creditor's claim. We call this
- 40:08compulsory execution. Example: B does
- 40:10not pay their debt to A. A applies to
- 40:13the enforcement office and requests
- 40:15collection. The enforcement office puts
- 40:18a lien on B's property and the money
- 40:19obtained from the sale is paid to A,
- 40:21friends. In short, we call this
- 40:24compulsory execution, my friends, and I
- 40:26am moving on. Now we have come to our
- 40:29final type of sanction, friends.
- 40:31Invalidity. This is very important,
- 40:33friends. Listen well. It’s actually
- 40:35very simple. I don't know why you get
- 40:37confused, but believe me, it is a very
- 40:39easy topic, friends. Invalidity is the
- 40:41treatment of legal transactions as
- 40:42ineffective. What is a legal
- 40:44transaction, my dear Murat? Now Murat,
- 40:46I said to you, "Hello Murat, how are
- 40:47you?" You answer. "I'm fine, teacher,
- 40:49thank you." Now, this is a declaration
- 40:51of will. Do you know what "will" is?
- 40:52What’s on my mind. What’s on my
- 40:55mind is my will. What do I do with it?
- 40:56I explain it to you. You respond, but
- 40:58the law doesn't do anything with this.
- 41:00It doesn't create a legal outcome. If
- 41:02it creates a legal outcome, friends, we
- 41:03will call it a legal transaction. My
- 41:05dear Murat, this is a pen you could
- 41:06sell for 10. I tell you, if you want it
- 41:08and it’s of use to you, let me sell
- 41:09it to you. Murat says, "Teacher, I need
- 41:11it, I'll buy it." He says. Murat then
- 41:13gives the money, friends. I deliver the
- 41:15pen. So, what do we call this, my dear
- 41:17Murat? We call it a legal transaction.
- 41:19The law gives it a result, for instance
- 41:21. We call transactions where the law
- 41:23and statutes give results, where the
- 41:24law creates a legal outcome, "legal
- 41:26transactions." If your legal
- 41:29transactions do not comply with certain
- 41:30conditions, they become invalid,
- 41:32friends. There are different types of
- 41:34invalidity, too. Let’s start with the
- 41:36simplest one, friends. Non-existence (
- 41:37Yokluk). Non-existence means the
- 41:39absence of one of the formative
- 41:40elements of a legal transaction. Now,
- 41:42if I make an offer to Murat, if Murat
- 41:44doesn't accept, is the contract formed,
- 41:46my dear Murat? I’m asking a simple
- 41:48question. It isn't formed, is it? What
- 41:49is that contract? Does it exist or not?
- 41:51It does not exist. Why? Because there
- 41:53is no declaration of acceptance. We
- 41:54call this non-existence. Look, you need
- 41:56to think simply, friends. You are
- 41:57shopping at the market. The vendor
- 41:59makes an offer, don't they? He says,
- 42:01for example, lemons are 100 for 5 kilos
- 42:03. Where? Of course, lemons are very
- 42:05expensive lately, my dear Murat. Anyway
- 42:07, what do you do after that? If you
- 42:09accept, the contract is established. If
- 42:11you don't accept, the contract is not
- 42:12established. Well, let's give an
- 42:14example, friends. A religious marriage
- 42:15performed without a marriage officer. I
- 42:17mean, this is our classic example, but
- 42:19I can give you many examples, friends.
- 42:21The constituent elements in marriage
- 42:23are these: two different genders.
- 42:24Woman-woman doesn't work. Man-man
- 42:25doesn't work either. We don't have that
- 42:27, friends. Then, uh, the verbal
- 42:28declaration, the declaration must be
- 42:31verbal. And a marriage officer is also
- 42:32required, friends. But if you go and
- 42:34just have a religious marriage without
- 42:36an officer, that marriage does not
- 42:38exist in law, friends. Meaning, you
- 42:40don't need to apply to court for a
- 42:41divorce later on. Because you are not
- 42:43legally married anyway. It lacks the
- 42:44constituent element. There is no
- 42:45marriage officer. Or there is an
- 42:46officer, but you are both men. Or you
- 42:48are both women. It won't work, dear
- 42:50friends. Or let's say it this way, my
- 42:51dear Murat, let me give a simple
- 42:52example. Look, the logic is something
- 42:54anyone can say. Can a husband and wife
- 42:56say they are divorced by making a
- 42:57written contract between themselves?
- 42:59Why? Because who gives the divorce
- 43:03decision? Does a judge give it? Does a
- 43:05district governor give it? Or can they
- 43:07give it between themselves? Where does
- 43:08divorce happen? It happens in court,
- 43:10friends. Then, uh, a divorce made
- 43:12without a court decision is null and
- 43:14void. Or you go to the district
- 43:16governor and say, "Divorce me." The
- 43:17governor says, "Come on, let's divorce
- 43:18you." He says. Well, is this, uh,
- 43:20marriage over? No. It lacks the
- 43:22constituent element, friends. It
- 43:23happens with a court decision. Okay.
- 43:27Now, the second one, friends, is
- 43:28nullity (butlan). Do you know what
- 43:30nullity means? The difference from
- 43:31non-existence. In nullity, there is a
- 43:33legal act. That is, there is a
- 43:34constituent element. Meaning, I offered
- 43:36to sell something to Murat. And Murat
- 43:38accepted. He said with pleasure. Okay?
- 43:40We made our contract. Meaning there is
- 43:42a legal act in place. Now there are
- 43:44constituent elements. Marriage officer,
- 43:46woman and man, verbal declaration,
- 43:49friends. There is a legal act, that is.
- 43:51So, nullity is different from
- 43:53non-existence in this respect, friends.
- 43:54There is a constituent element. However
- 43:56, with nullity, friends, there are
- 43:57different invalidities. It is divided
- 43:59into two. Absolute and relative. Let's
- 44:00get the absolute out of the way first.
- 44:03Absolute nullity means this, friends.
- 44:04There is a legal act. Meaning, there is
- 44:06a constituent element. Meaning the
- 44:08legal act exists on the surface but is
- 44:10invalid. And this invalidity is an
- 44:12invalidity from the very beginning,
- 44:14friends. Anyone can file a lawsuit. It
- 44:16is not subject to a statute of
- 44:17limitations. The judge takes it into
- 44:18account ex officio. Well, why? Because
- 44:20the contract you made is contrary to
- 44:22public order, personality, morality,
- 44:23etc. Now let's look at the examples.
- 44:25Absolute nullity? Lack of mental
- 44:27capacity. Now, there is a marriage
- 44:29officer, there is a woman and a man.
- 44:30There is a verbal declaration. The
- 44:33woman is severely mentally disabled,
- 44:34mentally ill. Now, does this contract
- 44:36exist on the surface, my dear Murat?
- 44:38There is a marriage officer too, but is
- 44:39it valid or invalid? Invalid. Two, lack
- 44:42of legal capacity. Meaning it is
- 44:44contrary to mandatory rules. I say, "
- 44:46Murat, my dear, I'm really annoyed at
- 44:48someone.""Here’s 10,000, go and do
- 44:50what to this guy?""Kill him." We even
- 44:52make a contract between us. Look, I’m
- 44:53even bound by the contract. I say I
- 44:54will definitely make this payment to
- 44:56you. Now, is there a contract here? On
- 44:58the surface, yes. Do you think it’s
- 44:59valid or invalid, Murat? Does it make
- 45:01any sense? It has to be invalid, right?
- 45:03Because what does it violate? It
- 45:05violates mandatory rules. Another thing
- 45:07is that it disrupts public order and
- 45:08disturbs the peace. For example,
- 45:10selling drugs, guys—same logic.
- 45:12Violation of personality rights. My
- 45:14dear Murat, someone comes to you and
- 45:16says, "Murat, come be my slave.""I will
- 45:18, uh, what will I do?""I’ll give you
- 45:20this much money a month," they say. "
- 45:22I’ll give you 100,000, 200,000,
- 45:23300,000," they say. A slavery contract,
- 45:25guys. My dear Murat, do you think this
- 45:26contract is valid or invalid?
- 45:28Does it exist on the surface? But this
- 45:29contract exists and yet is invalid,
- 45:31guys. I mean, anyway, the violation of
- 45:34personality rights, guys, this could go
- 45:36in many directions. Like saying, "I’m
- 45:38going to sell my kidney," guys. This is
- 45:40similar to that. Violation of morality
- 45:43—guys, uh, we don’t really have any
- 45:45say on moral rules, of course. General
- 45:47moral rules, the society's general
- 45:48moral rules, guys, what are they? For
- 45:50example, you tell a guy, "I’m going
- 45:51to rent a house for prostitution." Guys
- 45:53, the man makes a contract with you. Is
- 45:56this contract, guys, valid or invalid?
- 45:58Of course, even if it looks like one,
- 45:59what is it? Invalid. Another is the
- 46:01impossibility of the subject matter. My
- 46:03dear Murat, uh, someone comes to you
- 46:05and says, "Murat, I have some very
- 46:07beautiful land," he says. "Where is it,
- 46:09Murat?" he asks. "On Mars," he says,
- 46:11guys. Okay? And he says, "These will
- 46:13increase in value a lot." He’s
- 46:14tricking Murat, guys. What is he doing
- 46:15to Murat? He’s selling him land on
- 46:17Mars, guys. Now, is selling land on
- 46:18Mars possible or impossible as a
- 46:20subject matter, guys? A contract
- 46:21without a possible subject is
- 46:23impossible. I mean, this is like
- 46:24selling land on the sun. Or he says, "
- 46:26I’ll sell you the Dolmabahçe Palace.
- 46:27""I’ll sell you the Blue Mosque," he
- 46:29says to you, guys. "I’ll sell it to
- 46:30you for a great price," he says. Okay.
- 46:32What is this, guys? It’s fraud. Right
- 46:34, my dear Murat? Is there a legal
- 46:35transaction on the surface? There is,
- 46:37but it’s invalid. Muvaza, excuse me,
- 46:40muvazaa, guys, I’m sorry. What is
- 46:44muvazaa (collusion)? Muvazaa is when
- 46:46two parties agree to enter into a
- 46:48transaction that produces no legal
- 46:50effects between them in order to
- 46:53deceive third parties, that is, others.
- 46:56So, what are we doing, guys? We are
- 46:58agreeing among ourselves to deceive
- 47:00third parties. We say, "Look, it won't
- 47:02have any legal effect between us, but
- 47:03let them think it does." What does the
- 47:05guy do? To hide assets from his
- 47:07creditors, guys, he transfers all his
- 47:09property in the land registry to his
- 47:11closest relative—his brother-in-law
- 47:13or uncle. On the surface, there is a
- 47:15sale, but in reality, there is no money
- 47:16received. There is a gift. So, guys,
- 47:19what do we call this? We call it
- 47:21muvazaa. Unfortunately, it’s done a
- 47:23lot, especially in inheritances. A
- 47:24father transfers all his property to
- 47:26one child in the land registry, but
- 47:28shows it as a sale in reality. But
- 47:30there is no payment or anything
- 47:32received from that child. There is no
- 47:34statute of limitations for this, guys.
- 47:35Even if 100, 200, or 60 years pass,
- 47:37friends, invalidity can still be
- 47:39claimed. There is a legal transaction
- 47:42that appears to be absolute. But what
- 47:43is this legal transaction? It is
- 47:45invalid. Invalid from the very
- 47:47beginning. It can never be made valid.
- 47:50Anyone can file a lawsuit. It is not
- 47:52subject to a statute of limitations.
- 47:53Moving on. Now we have come to relative
- 47:56nullity, friends. Relative nullity is
- 47:59one of the two types of nullity. In
- 48:01absolute nullity, the transaction was
- 48:02invalid from the start, friends. It
- 48:04concerned public order. Invalid from
- 48:06beginning to end. In relative nullity,
- 48:08there is still a transaction between
- 48:10you. Just like in absolute nullity.
- 48:11However, this transaction, friends, can
- 48:14become valid. It can only happen if the
- 48:17aggrieved party claims its invalidity.
- 48:20The period for this is usually 1 year,
- 48:22friends. So, let's put it this way.
- 48:24There is a legal transaction. However,
- 48:27if this legal transaction has caused a
- 48:29flaw in the intent, if it was made with
- 48:32a flawed intent, and if one of the
- 48:34parties—the victim—asks for its
- 48:36cancellation or invalidity within the
- 48:38time limit, if it can be rendered
- 48:41invalid, we call that voidability,
- 48:43friends. But if they do not claim it
- 48:45within the time limit, the transaction
- 48:47remains valid. Because it is not
- 48:49invalid from the beginning, friends.
- 48:50Let's put it this way. There are four
- 48:52reasons for this, friends. Four reasons
- 48:54: error, fraud, duress, and lesion. And
- 48:58also temporary loss of mental capacity.
- 49:00Let's start with error, friends. What
- 49:03is an error? It is being mistaken. This
- 49:05originates from us, friends. We make a
- 49:07mistake. For example, we were going to
- 49:08write 10,000 in the contract. We added
- 49:10an extra zero and it became 100,000. We
- 49:12made a mistake, we were wrong. Can we
- 49:13back out of this? We can, friends. But
- 49:15if we don't within the time limit, the
- 49:17contract becomes valid. For example, we
- 49:19made a contract with the wrong person
- 49:21due to a similarity in names. The error
- 49:23originated from us. What do we do? We
- 49:25can retract it within the time limit,
- 49:27friends. We can make the transaction
- 49:28invalid. If we don't, it will remain
- 49:30valid. Second, uh, duress. Duress,
- 49:33friends, let's go in order. They call
- 49:35this "ikrah," friends. By its old name,
- 49:37duress. Someone makes you sign a
- 49:39contract by force or through fear,
- 49:40friends. They make you perform a legal
- 49:42transaction. What do you do? Once you
- 49:44have shed the fear, friends, you can
- 49:45request the cancellation of the
- 49:47contract. Otherwise, the contract
- 49:48remains valid. This could be a marriage
- 49:50, a sale, it makes no difference.
- 49:51Whatever comes to mind. Uh, another one
- 49:54, friends, is fraud. Fraud means,
- 49:56friends, that someone is deceiving you.
- 49:59It means your intent has been flawed,
- 50:00friends. Someone is deceiving you. I
- 50:02mean, for example, what do they do?
- 50:03They sell you a counterfeit product
- 50:05claiming it's original, friends. They
- 50:06sell you a fake as an original. Well,
- 50:08for instance, what is this? Deceiving
- 50:10someone, friends. For example, they say
- 50:12to you, "Hey, this watch is gold-plated
- 50:14." You wear the watch, and by the time
- 50:15you get home, it's turned bone-white.
- 50:18What happened to the watch you wore?
- 50:19The paint has worn off. What happened
- 50:22to you? They deceived you. Then you go
- 50:24looking for the guy, but he's flown
- 50:26away, friends. Things like this can
- 50:27happen. So, the other party deceiving
- 50:29you, friends, falls under what? Uh, it
- 50:32falls under relative nullity. What can
- 50:33you do with the contract? You can
- 50:35cancel it. The fourth is lesion. What
- 50:38is lesion? Taking advantage of
- 50:40someone's difficult situation,
- 50:41inexperience, or weakness to gain
- 50:43excessive benefit from them. Friends,
- 50:46look, this happens a lot in society,
- 50:48unfortunately. Uh, what is it? For
- 50:50example, we saw this a lot during the
- 50:51earthquake, friends. For example, a
- 50:53person comes along and asks for 50,000,
- 50:5660,000, or 70,000 in rent for a flat
- 50:58that is worth 1,000. Or think of an
- 51:01elderly woman, for example. People sell
- 51:03a plot of land worth 50,000 to an
- 51:05inexperienced woman for 1 million. What
- 51:08do we have here, for example, friends?
- 51:11There is an extreme imbalance between
- 51:13the performances. 50,000 on one side, 1
- 51:15million on the other. So what are you
- 51:17doing? You are taking advantage of that
- 51:19person's inexperience, weakness, and
- 51:21difficult situation to gain an extreme
- 51:23advantage. So, in cases of "gabin"(
- 51:25lesion), what can you do? You can
- 51:26cancel the contract within the time
- 51:28limit. What happens if you don't? The
- 51:29contract remains valid. Unfortunately,
- 51:32that’s how it is, friends. Okay.
- 51:33Let's repeat the name of absolute
- 51:34invalidity: "butlan"(nullity). In both,
- 51:36there is a legal transaction. In
- 51:37absolute nullity, the legal transaction
- 51:39is invalid from the beginning. Here,
- 51:40the legal transaction is valid at first
- 51:42. There is a time limit. If you don't
- 51:44cancel it within the time limit, the
- 51:45contract remains valid, friends.
- 51:47Unfortunately, the duration is usually
- 51:49one year. There are four causes.
- 51:51Mistake, deception (fraud), duress (
- 51:54fear), and "gabin"(lesion)—contracts
- 51:56involving extreme disproportion between
- 51:59performances—are voidable contracts.
- 52:03If the aggrieved party does not cancel
- 52:05it within the time limit or assert it,
- 52:07the contract becomes valid. But, as
- 52:09with absolute nullity, such as selling
- 52:11land on Mars or selling drugs—what
- 52:12are these contracts? They are invalid
- 52:14from the very beginning, friends. We
- 52:17have come to the last type of
- 52:18invalidity, friends. Unilateral
- 52:19non-bindingness. Pending invalidity,
- 52:22friends. Whose contracts is this
- 52:25applied to? The contracts of persons
- 52:27with limited capacity. Who is a person
- 52:29with limited capacity, friends? Let me
- 52:30tell you right away. Person with
- 52:32limited capacity. Children who have the
- 52:37power of discernment. For example, 15
- 52:42or 16-year-old children. Discerning
- 52:44children. And restricted adults.
- 52:48Restricted persons, that is, friends.
- 52:50What is the person? A gambler. They
- 52:52have been restricted for this reason,
- 52:53friends. By court decision, a guardian
- 52:56has been appointed for them. The law
- 52:57does not consider them devoid of will,
- 53:00but it does not leave them unprotected
- 53:02either. For example, this person can go
- 53:04and do their grocery shopping, friends.
- 53:07At 45 or 50 years old. Shouldn't they
- 53:09be able to? They can. This child can go
- 53:12and do what, friends? They can buy
- 53:14supplies from a stationery store. They
- 53:15can go and shop at a market. They are
- 53:1716, but they decide to buy a computer
- 53:20with money. Or they buy a bicycle with
- 53:23their father's money. This person goes
- 53:25to sell a car, sell a house, buy a
- 53:27house, or buy a car. The law says, "
- 53:29Stop." The law has brought these under
- 53:30protection. Even though this child has
- 53:33a will, even if this person has a will,
- 53:35this child is still under the
- 53:36protection of a guardian or parents.
- 53:39And this person is under the protection
- 53:40of a legal guardian. Under guardianship
- 53:42, friends. Therefore, when performing
- 53:45these acts, there is the matter of the
- 53:47parent's or guardian's approval. There
- 53:49is also the matter of them not giving
- 53:50it. So what did we say? The law does
- 53:52not deem them to have no will. And it
- 53:54doesn't leave them unprotected either.
- 53:56It requires the approval of the parent
- 53:58or guardian when performing these
- 53:59transactions, friends. If the parent or
- 54:01guardian gives approval, the
- 54:02transaction is valid. If they do not
- 54:04give approval, the transaction is
- 54:05invalid. Because the law has taken them
- 54:07under protection, friends. So, as an
- 54:09example, a sales contract made by a 16-
- 54:11year-old without the family's approval.
- 54:14They go and say, "I am selling my bike.
- 54:15""I am selling the car," they say. The
- 54:17mother can find the buyer and what can
- 54:20she do, friends? She can reach out to
- 54:22them, say "I do not approve of this,"
- 54:24and demand the return of the money and
- 54:26the goods, friends. The contract
- 54:29becomes invalid, but if they don't
- 54:30speak up, it's valid. No problem. Again
- 54:33, friends, this man has gone and is
- 54:35selling the house. If the guardian
- 54:36doesn't give approval—let's say the
- 54:38guardian is his wife. What is the
- 54:39contract? Invalid. What did we say? The
- 54:42law does not deem them without will.
- 54:44But it doesn't leave them unprotected
- 54:46either. Shop at the grocery store,
- 54:47that's fine. Go to the stationery store
- 54:48and buy a set of books, that's fine.
- 54:50But you cannot just go and say I'll buy
- 54:52or sell a computer on your own. The
- 54:54guardian must give approval. You are
- 54:56under guardianship. You are under
- 54:57protection. This is the same way,
- 54:59friends. In these transactions, if the
- 55:01guardian doesn't approve, the contract
- 55:03becomes invalid. It remains pending.
- 55:05Transactions that remain pending until
- 55:07approval is given. A 3rd party cannot
- 55:08say this. Murat, I say, you are the
- 55:11seller. I came and bought a phone from
- 55:13you at 17 years old. Okay. Then I took
- 55:16it and left. Then my mother said, why
- 55:18did you buy this? Where is the money?
- 55:20Let's go. I said, and so on. We came to
- 55:22you. You cannot say this. The law does
- 55:24not protect you. Well, he looked like
- 55:26he was 20. Can you say that? Even if
- 55:28you say it, it's invalid. The law
- 55:30doesn't protect your good intentions.
- 55:31So these are like this too,
- 55:32unfortunately, friends. If the guardian
- 55:34doesn't approve, your contract is
- 55:36invalid. We call this unilateral
- 55:38non-bindingness. Meaning, for
- 55:40transactions subject to approval, if
- 55:42there is no approval, the transaction
- 55:43is invalid. Well, let's go over an
- 55:45example, friends. Ah, by the way, this
- 55:47is often confused. Let me repeat
- 55:49collusion and exploitation for you.
- 55:51What is collusion? Simulation. It's
- 55:53when parties make it look like they are
- 55:55doing a transaction they don't actually
- 55:56intend to do, in order to deceive
- 55:58others. Meaning, I'm hiding assets from
- 56:00creditors. I make an agreement with my
- 56:02brother-in-law. Look, I say, I will
- 56:03show these as a sale on the title deed,
- 56:05but you won't pay me anything. Until I
- 56:08take them back from you. We call this a
- 56:11collusive contract. It's an invalid
- 56:13contract, friends. Example: a person
- 56:15transfers their house to their brother
- 56:17to avoid paying debts. In reality, the
- 56:19house is still theirs. They are living
- 56:21in the house, friends, but it's shown
- 56:23as if a sale took place. The goal is to
- 56:25deceive others. Collusive transactions
- 56:27are invalid from the very beginning.
- 56:29Friends, what is exploitation?
- 56:31Excessive advantage. Taking excessive
- 56:34advantage of someone by exploiting
- 56:36their difficult situation, lack of
- 56:38knowledge, or inexperience. Friends,
- 56:41there is an extreme imbalance between
- 56:43the performances. You sell a 50,000
- 56:45lira plot of land to an old woman for 1
- 56:46million. Well, for example, someone who
- 56:49needs money urgently is forced to sell
- 56:52their 500,000 car for just 50,000. The
- 56:56buyer gains unfair profit from their
- 56:57difficult situation. Well, is this
- 57:00contract valid from the beginning? Yes.
- 57:03But the victim, friends, can request
- 57:05the rescission of this contract within
- 57:07the time limit. Uh, if they demand it,
- 57:11the contract becomes invalid. If they
- 57:13don't demand it, unlike collusion, this
- 57:15is not a contract that is invalid from
- 57:17the start. It's a contract that can
- 57:19become invalid upon your request. This
- 57:21requires absolute nullity. And this
- 57:23requires relative nullity, we say. Well
- 57:25, if there is exploitation, the
- 57:27contract is temporarily valid. The
- 57:29injured person can have it cancelled if
- 57:31they wish. There is a time limit for
- 57:32that too, of course, friends. Well, now
- 57:34let's repeat. My dear friends.
- 57:38Non-existence: Teacher Ozlem writes "we
- 57:39are divorced" on a piece of paper to
- 57:41get a divorce from her husband as an
- 57:43example case. They both sign it at the
- 57:45bottom. There is no court, nor is there
- 57:48a judge. What is the most fundamental
- 57:49part of a divorce proceeding? A court
- 57:51ruling. Otherwise, the action never
- 57:53took place at all. There is no
- 57:54constitutive element. We call this "
- 57:56non-existence," friends. Moving on. You
- 57:59can get a closer shot of this, Murat.
- 58:01Regarding absolute nullity, Alper
- 58:03married Ayşe, who has a severe mental
- 58:05disability. Ayşe lacks the power of
- 58:07discernment. There is a marriage
- 58:09officer. There is a ceremony. There is
- 58:11a verbal declaration. Everything is
- 58:12there. But since she lacks discernment,
- 58:15friends, even if the contract appears
- 58:18to exist, it is invalid from the start.
- 58:23Regarding relative nullity, Mehmet
- 58:25thought he bought an original watch at
- 58:27the market. He thinks so, but when he
- 58:29gets home, friends, he realizes the
- 58:30watch is fake. He performed the
- 58:33transaction himself, but was his intent
- 58:34flawed? Yes, he was deceived, friends.
- 58:37Yes, there were four reasons that
- 58:38invalidate intent. Error, fraud, duress
- 58:41, and, friends, lesion. These are the
- 58:44conditions that vitiate intent. But if
- 58:46he was deceived and does not file a
- 58:48lawsuit within the time limit, or does
- 58:49not claim it, what happens to this
- 58:51contract? It becomes valid. This is its
- 58:53difference from the other, friends. The
- 58:55contract is not invalid from the
- 58:57beginning. It is "pending invalidity."
- 58:5917-year-old Ali sold his phone to
- 59:00someone without asking his family. Can
- 59:03Ali perform the transaction? Yes. The
- 59:05law does not count this as his intent,
- 59:06but it doesn't leave him unprotected
- 59:07either, friends. Yes. But family
- 59:10consent is necessary. If the family
- 59:12gives consent, does the transaction
- 59:13become valid? Yes. If they do not give
- 59:14consent, what is the status of the
- 59:15transaction? Invalid. What do we call
- 59:17this? Pending invalidity, friends, or
- 59:20unilateral non-bindingness. Dear
- 59:22friends, the types of invalidity you
- 59:25see are like this. It really is very
- 59:28easy, friends. I never want you to miss
- 59:30a question on this. We will solve
- 59:32questions to reinforce it better,
- 59:33friends. We will end our first lesson
- 59:35at the end of the questions. That might
- 59:37be why I kept the first lesson a little
- 59:38long. My goal, friends, is to ensure
- 59:40the integrity of the subject. Dear
- 59:42friends, let's look now. An annulment
- 59:44lawsuit; there were five elements of
- 59:46administrative acts—be careful—that
- 59:48were done against the law. Remember.
- 59:51Authority, form, reason, subject,
- 59:52purpose. If one of these is violated,
- 59:56what is done? It is taken to the
- 59:58administrative judiciary and is
- 59:59eliminated with retroactive effect. So,
- 1:00:01which one would not be subject to an
- 1:00:03annulment lawsuit in administrative
- 1:00:04judiciary? Let's see. A reprimand
- 1:00:06penalty given to a civil servant. Look,
- 1:00:08a reprimand is a disciplinary penalty.
- 1:00:10An administrative act issued by the
- 1:00:12administration. Municipality—look,
- 1:00:14administration—a license revocation
- 1:00:16decision issued by the municipality; an
- 1:00:18appointment process for a civil servant
- 1:00:20. If it is against the law, let it stay
- 1:00:22. A suspension decision issued by
- 1:00:24university management. Look, they are
- 1:00:26all administration. A is administration
- 1:00:27. B, C, and E are administration. Well,
- 1:00:29when we say a private company, friends,
- 1:00:31should we think of it like the
- 1:00:33administration? No. Yes. This is also
- 1:00:35an administration, but it is a private
- 1:00:36administration. This is like us.
- 1:00:38Meaning, it is not the state, friends.
- 1:00:40Therefore, the answer to our question
- 1:00:41is Denizli. The others are not, what?
- 1:00:44Not subject to annulment. Well, this
- 1:00:46one is not. The others are subject to
- 1:00:48annulment. The administrative judiciary
- 1:00:51is the judicial body that oversees the
- 1:00:53legality of the administration and
- 1:00:54looks at annulment lawsuits filed
- 1:00:55against administrative acts. Correct.
- 1:00:57Accordingly, which one falls into the
- 1:00:58jurisdiction of the administrative
- 1:01:00judiciary? Administrative judiciary.
- 1:01:01Look, we said it doesn't fall there
- 1:01:03earlier. Here it does. Divorce and
- 1:01:05custody cases, judicial judiciary,
- 1:01:06civil court of first instance, um,
- 1:01:08family court, pardon me, or civil court
- 1:01:10of first instance, let's set aside the
- 1:01:13municipality's license issue. A company
- 1:01:15partner's dividend demand, commercial
- 1:01:17court folks, land registry cancellation
- 1:01:18and registration cases, well, civil
- 1:01:20court of first instance. Look, these
- 1:01:22are things between individuals.
- 1:01:24Severance pay arising from an
- 1:01:25employment contract, well, labor court,
- 1:01:27it's between individuals. These fall
- 1:01:29under the subject of the judicial
- 1:01:30judiciary. But since the municipality
- 1:01:34is an administration, exercising the
- 1:01:35authority of a state, folks, because
- 1:01:37the actions it takes are administrative
- 1:01:39acts, what happens to an annulment suit
- 1:01:41? It becomes the subject of one. What
- 1:01:43is the result of an annulment suit? If
- 1:01:45it is annulled, the act ceases to exist
- 1:01:48with retroactive effect. It rewinds
- 1:01:51time, folks. It has an effect as if it
- 1:01:54never happened. Which one is not one of
- 1:01:57the types of penalties regulated in the
- 1:01:59Turkish Penal Code? There is a
- 1:02:00fixed-term imprisonment. 1 month, 20
- 1:02:03years. If it is less than a year, it is
- 1:02:07short-term. Is there a judicial fine?
- 1:02:10Yes, there is. 5 to 730 days, folks. A
- 1:02:14daily amount between 100 and 500. Life
- 1:02:18imprisonment, aggravated life
- 1:02:19imprisonment. Yes. Both are for life,
- 1:02:21folks, but the execution conditions
- 1:02:23were different. Traffic fines are
- 1:02:25governed by the Highway Traffic Law,
- 1:02:27folks. It stems from administrative law
- 1:02:30. There is no trial for this penalty,
- 1:02:32folks. There is no court, there is no
- 1:02:33judge. But in the others, there is a
- 1:02:36court, a judge, a trial, and penal
- 1:02:38codes. Which of the following elements,
- 1:02:43arising as a result of a tort, does
- 1:02:46compensation aim to eliminate? Folks,
- 1:02:48what was the most basic thing? Okay,
- 1:02:50these are all elements of compensation,
- 1:02:52but to eliminate which one is
- 1:02:54compensation demanded? Compensation was
- 1:02:57demanded to replace the loss, folks.
- 1:03:00Yes. A person has not been paying the
- 1:03:03alimony debt they are obligated to pay
- 1:03:05by a court decision for a long time. Oh
- 1:03:07look, the green light just turned on.
- 1:03:09They are not paying their debt. Yes,
- 1:03:11they are not paying it themselves. Upon
- 1:03:12the request of the creditor party, the
- 1:03:14debtor's salary is seized by authorized
- 1:03:16authorities. Well, what were we going
- 1:03:18to call this, folks? We were going to
- 1:03:20call it enforcement proceedings. There
- 1:03:22is no such thing as damage here. There
- 1:03:23is no administrative act. There is
- 1:03:24nothing requiring a disciplinary
- 1:03:26penalty. It directly defines
- 1:03:27enforcement here in option C1.
- 1:03:30Disturbing public order and as a crime,
- 1:03:32look, it says crime. Okay. It says
- 1:03:34disturbing order. It says crime, folks,
- 1:03:36etc. The green light is already on for
- 1:03:38me. Then what will the answer to this
- 1:03:40question be? It will be penalty. Look,
- 1:03:43compensation is not a penalty.
- 1:03:45Compensation is a private law sanction.
- 1:03:47It is the covering of the damage, folks
- 1:03:49. Yes. And whenever we say annulment,
- 1:03:53what should always come to our minds?
- 1:03:55Administrative acts should come to mind
- 1:03:57. We don't forget that. By the way,
- 1:04:01what did we call this? We called it
- 1:04:02penalty. Yes. What was nullity, folks?
- 1:04:06The transaction was considered as never
- 1:04:08born. Why? It's very simple. One of the
- 1:04:10constitutive elements was missing.
- 1:04:13There was no marriage officer. There
- 1:04:14was no court. Anyone can claim it
- 1:04:17without a court order. I mean, folks,
- 1:04:20they got married with a "crazy" wedding
- 1:04:22. There is no need to go and get a
- 1:04:24court order for divorce. Because there
- 1:04:25is no marriage in the middle. Therefore
- 1:04:27, they are all correct, folks. Option
- 1:04:30E. Which one cannot be shown as an
- 1:04:33example of a nullity sanction? Look,
- 1:04:35there is no constitutive element. A
- 1:04:36marriage performed without a marriage
- 1:04:38officer lacks the constitutive element.
- 1:04:40A contract where one of the parties is
- 1:04:42completely absent lacks the
- 1:04:43constitutive element. For example, I
- 1:04:45say to myself, "I am going to sell this
- 1:04:47pen to Murat.""Okay, I've decided, I
- 1:04:49will sell it," I say. I sold it in my
- 1:04:50head, I say I sold it. Was the contract
- 1:04:52formed? It was not. One of the parties
- 1:04:54is missing. There is no declaration of
- 1:04:56will. I am making an offer now. He is
- 1:04:58not accepting. It won't work. A
- 1:05:01contract where none of the parties have
- 1:05:02signed. It lacks the constitutive
- 1:05:04element but is also incompetent. Let's
- 1:05:06say, friends, you make a contract with
- 1:05:08someone who is mentally ill. Even if it
- 1:05:10seems like a legal transaction, what is
- 1:05:11it? Invalid. We mentioned this among
- 1:05:15the grounds for absolute nullity,
- 1:05:17friends. Which of these is not one of
- 1:05:20the reasons leading to a contract being
- 1:05:22considered absolutely void, or absolute
- 1:05:24nullity? The subject of the contract is
- 1:05:26impossible. Yes. Selling land on Mars.
- 1:05:29An act contrary to morality. Let's say
- 1:05:31something related to prostitution,
- 1:05:32friends, or something else. For example
- 1:05:34, making a contract for human smuggling
- 1:05:37, friends. You say you will take them
- 1:05:38across the border. We will pay this
- 1:05:40much money. This is also contrary to
- 1:05:41morality. One of the parties lacking
- 1:05:45the power of discernment. Mentally ill,
- 1:05:47young child, failure to comply with the
- 1:05:50legally required form. For example,
- 1:05:53what do they do? They make a sale among
- 1:05:56themselves that should have been done
- 1:05:57at a notary. The answer to this
- 1:05:59question, friends, is Denizli (D). If
- 1:06:01one of the parties is deceived by fraud
- 1:06:04, if there is a mistake, fear, usury,
- 1:06:07or excessive benefit. What were these
- 1:06:11contracts? They are subject to
- 1:06:13cancellation within a period. If not
- 1:06:15done, it would remain valid. My friends
- 1:06:17, Ali has transferred his land to his
- 1:06:19close friend Mehmet, making it appear
- 1:06:21as a sale to hide his assets from
- 1:06:23creditors. However, there is a secret
- 1:06:25agreement between them that the sale
- 1:06:27price will not be paid and the title
- 1:06:28deed will be returned after a while.
- 1:06:30There is a textbook example of sham (
- 1:06:32muvazaa) here, friends. A complete
- 1:06:34example of sham. What can be said about
- 1:06:36the transaction made in this case? The
- 1:06:37transaction is valid. However, if there
- 1:06:39is no power of discernment, it can be
- 1:06:41cancelled, friends. The transaction is
- 1:06:42invalid. Yes, it exists in appearance
- 1:06:44but is invalid. Non-existence because
- 1:06:46the transaction is contrary to the
- 1:06:47formal requirement. No, there is no
- 1:06:48non-existence, friends. The title deed
- 1:06:49and everything else have been done.
- 1:06:50There is a sale, there is an appearance
- 1:06:52, but it is invalid. The transaction
- 1:06:54becomes valid with the party's will.
- 1:06:56No. It is an invalid contract even if
- 1:06:58one of the parties says okay. It is a
- 1:07:00sham contract. The transaction is
- 1:07:03absolutely void due to sham. Let's look
- 1:07:05at E. It says the transaction is
- 1:07:06pending. Is there any situation here
- 1:07:07regarding guardian or trustee approval,
- 1:07:08friends? No. Therefore, the answer to
- 1:07:10our question will be Denizli (D). Yes,
- 1:07:13friends, another similar question. In
- 1:07:15Turkish law, a marriage between A and B
- 1:07:17without an official marriage officer is
- 1:07:19non-existence. The constitutive element
- 1:07:22is missing. A married person A making a
- 1:07:25second official marriage with B.
- 1:07:27Friends, let me ask you, no need for
- 1:07:29any information. Is it possible for a
- 1:07:32person to make a second official
- 1:07:34marriage while they are already married
- 1:07:36in Turkish law? Let's say it's possible
- 1:07:37. They did it. Well, do you think it's
- 1:07:39valid? It is invalid, friends. Well,
- 1:07:41can it become valid? No. We have
- 1:07:43monogamous marriage here. Therefore,
- 1:07:45what is the second marriage? Absolute
- 1:07:47nullity, friends. It is absolutely void
- 1:07:50. A being married to B by force. Look,
- 1:07:53being intimidated, friends. Flaws in
- 1:07:56will or duress lead us to relative
- 1:07:59nullity, meaning voidability. You can
- 1:08:03cancel the contract within the time
- 1:08:04limit. Let's see, friends. It will be
- 1:08:07non-existence, absolute nullity, and
- 1:08:08relative nullity in order. The answer
- 1:08:10to our question will be option C,
- 1:08:12friends. Look, this is the most
- 1:08:14distinct type of question that could
- 1:08:15appear. What is it if there is a
- 1:08:19deficiency in legal transactions based
- 1:08:21on a flaw in will? Error, fraud, duress
- 1:08:23, lesion, or exploitation. What is it
- 1:08:26as long as this deficiency is not
- 1:08:27asserted? You must assert it within the
- 1:08:30time limit. If you don't assert it and
- 1:08:32the contract is considered valid, what
- 1:08:34did we call this? Friends, we called it
- 1:08:37relative nullity. Let's list the
- 1:08:39reasons immediately. Right now, right
- 1:08:41now, right now. Error, fraud, duress,
- 1:08:44lesion, or exploitation. Friends, if
- 1:08:48these exist, what could happen to the
- 1:08:50contract? It may become invalid if the
- 1:08:53aggrieved party asserts it within the
- 1:08:55time limit. A transaction that was
- 1:08:57initially valid becomes invalid later.
- 1:09:01Which one is the voidability of a legal
- 1:09:02transaction? Look, there is duress.
- 1:09:04Being threatened. There is deception,
- 1:09:07fraud, and error. We cause this,
- 1:09:09friends. Wrong, we make an error. We
- 1:09:11make a contract with the wrong person.
- 1:09:13We write the wrong amount. The subject
- 1:09:15is wrong, the person is wrong. Lesion
- 1:09:18is a reason for relative nullity, but
- 1:09:19contradiction of mandatory provisions
- 1:09:21is a reason for absolute nullity. The
- 1:09:23transaction is invalid from the very
- 1:09:25beginning, friends. You know the
- 1:09:28reasons for which relative nullity is
- 1:09:30applied in the following transactions.
- 1:09:33A sales contract made by a person
- 1:09:34without the power of discernment is
- 1:09:35directly absolute nullity, friends. A
- 1:09:37second official marriage, marrying an
- 1:09:39ascendant or descendant, marrying a
- 1:09:41sibling or niece/nephew. It might be
- 1:09:44okay with a cousin, but the others are
- 1:09:45absolutely void. Being deceived by
- 1:09:48fraud is relative, this is the answer
- 1:09:49to this question, friends, it says it
- 1:09:51is not applied. Fraud is relative
- 1:09:52nullity. An excessively unbalanced
- 1:09:54contract. Lesion. Mistake, error,
- 1:09:58threat, duress. We say these are the
- 1:10:01reasons requiring relative nullity.
- 1:10:03Moving on. 16-year-old Zeynep signs a 2
- 1:10:06-year subscription contract with a
- 1:10:08phone operator. Well, Zeynep is not
- 1:10:10without will, but she is not
- 1:10:12unprotected either. Still under
- 1:10:14parental guardianship. Friends, she has
- 1:10:16limited capacity. So, since Zeynep is a
- 1:10:19minor who does not yet have full power
- 1:10:21of discernment, the legal
- 1:10:22representative's approval was not
- 1:10:23obtained during the transaction. That
- 1:10:25is, she has the power of discernment,
- 1:10:26but she is still a minor. Her
- 1:10:28guardian's approval was not obtained.
- 1:10:29Two weeks after the contract was signed
- 1:10:31, Zeynep's mother notified the operator
- 1:10:33in writing that she did not accept this
- 1:10:35contract. Remember what we were going
- 1:10:37to call that, friends. We were going to
- 1:10:39call it one-sided non-bindingness, or
- 1:10:41suspended invalidity. Zeynep is not
- 1:10:43without will, but she is not
- 1:10:45unprotected, friends. You should think
- 1:10:47of it just like those under legal
- 1:10:49restriction. Who were those people with
- 1:10:52limited capacity? Remember. Children
- 1:10:55with the power of discernment. I mean
- 1:10:58not a 3-year-old child, for example, a
- 1:11:0015-16-year-old child and restricted
- 1:11:01adults; restriction is for adults
- 1:11:03anyway. Let's say the man is what,
- 1:11:06friends? He is an alcoholic. His wife
- 1:11:09took him to court. She took away his
- 1:11:10legal capacity. The 40-year-old man has
- 1:11:12turned into a 16-year-old child. Just
- 1:11:14as this child is not without will. This
- 1:11:16man is not without will. They can do
- 1:11:18market shopping, but these people are
- 1:11:20under the protection of a guardian or
- 1:11:22custodian. If these people perform some
- 1:11:24transactions without guardian or
- 1:11:26custodian approval, what is the status
- 1:11:27of these contracts? They are subject to
- 1:11:30the provisions of one-sided
- 1:11:31non-bindingness. Let's read the
- 1:11:32question. When certain transactions
- 1:11:35made without the permission or approval
- 1:11:37of a legal representative become valid
- 1:11:39through subsequent approval. What do we
- 1:11:43call it when it is considered invalid
- 1:11:45if approval is not granted? We call it
- 1:11:47pending invalidity, my friends. Yes, my
- 1:11:49dear friends, I am sure, I am sure now,
- 1:11:53what is non-existence? What is nullity?
- 1:11:56Absolute nullity, relative nullity. You
- 1:11:57have definitely, absolutely done what
- 1:11:59with these, friends? I believe you have
- 1:12:01understood them very well. We solved
- 1:12:02plenty of questions. I may have kept
- 1:12:04this lesson a bit long for the sake of
- 1:12:06topic integrity, friends. What will we
- 1:12:08study next, friends? Types of law,
- 1:12:10characteristics of legal rules, sources
- 1:12:11of law, and so on; very important
- 1:12:13topics await us. The first lesson was
- 1:12:15like this, friends. Hope to see you in
- 1:12:17the next lesson. Take very good care of
- 1:12:19yourselves.
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 1) 2026 KPSS Vatandaşlık-Temel Hukuk Kav.–Sosyal Düzen Kuralları–Hukukun Yaptırımları–Erdal Kesekler by Benim Hocam, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 13,915 words across 2,193 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.