1분에게라도 이 강의가 닿는다면 ... (예일대 교수 셸리 케이건) — Transcript
Full transcript
- 0:00At the end of last class, I quoted some
- 0:03words from Kurt Vonnegut, a kind of uh
- 0:06deathbed prayer confession that he'd
- 0:08written in one of his novels in which
- 0:10the basic gist of the
- 0:12uh
- 0:13prayer is to express gratitude. Uh
- 0:16how whatever the content of your life,
- 0:18the fact that at least you've been able
- 0:20to live it all, as he put it, most mud
- 0:22isn't lucky enough to sit up. Uh he
- 0:24feels lucky to have been some of the
- 0:26sitting up mud. He loved everything he
- 0:29saw. When I read that quote, I did not
- 0:31know that Kurt Vonnegut had died the
- 0:33night before. Uh immediately after the
- 0:35class ended, a visitor to the class
- 0:38brought this fact to my attention. So I
- 0:41can't pass without commenting on that
- 0:43death and just remark that I hope that
- 0:46till the very end Kurt Vonnegut, who
- 0:48lived till he was 84, uh realized how
- 0:51lucky he was to be some of the sitting
- 0:53up mud.
- 0:54All right, the question I want to turn
- 0:55to now uh is this. So we've been going
- 0:58over the various facts about the nature
- 1:01of life and death. And the question then
- 1:04is how should we live in light of the
- 1:06fact that we're going to die? Previously
- 1:08we've talked about what emotional
- 1:10response we should have to that. And
- 1:12I've argued, as I've just reminded us
- 1:14that uh
- 1:15although perhaps the most common
- 1:17reaction is one of fear or terror at
- 1:19death, it may in fact be that we should
- 1:21be grateful and consider ourselves lucky
- 1:23that we're able to have had life as
- 1:26well, life at all.
- 1:28But how then should we live in light of
- 1:30the fact that we're going to die? And
- 1:33the immediate answer that comes to mind
- 1:36seems almost like a joke. Uh I want to
- 1:38say, well, we should be careful um given
- 1:40that we could we can die, that we will
- 1:42die. There used to be a TV show, a cop
- 1:44show called Hill Street Blues. The show
- 1:46began every day with the sergeant sort
- 1:48of going over the various crimes and
- 1:50investigations that uh we're going to
- 1:52sort of fill up uh the days uh the day's
- 1:55episode. And he'd always end as he sent
- 1:57off his police uh his the cops, he'd end
- 1:59by
- 2:00be careful, or be careful out there. But
- 2:03the particular kind of care that I have
- 2:05in mind isn't just this sheer fact that,
- 2:07you know, if you're not careful, you'll
- 2:08you won't notice that the cars coming
- 2:10down the street and you'll get hit by
- 2:11the car and that'll be the end. The fact
- 2:13that we're going to die intuitively
- 2:14seems to require a particular kind of
- 2:17care
- 2:18because, as we might put it, you only go
- 2:21around once, right? Uh, you don't get
- 2:23you don't get to do it again. And so it
- 2:25seems as though the fact that we're
- 2:27mortal, the fact that we've got a finite
- 2:29lifespan
- 2:30requires us to face the fact that
- 2:33intuitively we can blow it. We we could
- 2:35do it wrong. Now the the nitpicky part
- 2:37of me wants to point out that it can't
- 2:39be mortality per se that has this
- 2:42implication. Even if we lived forever,
- 2:45we could still do it wrong. After all,
- 2:48whatever it is you've filled your life
- 2:50with, with an immortal, infinite life,
- 2:52there's still going to be the particular
- 2:54pattern of actions and activities that
- 2:57you engage in, and that particular
- 2:59pattern could still be one that wasn't
- 3:01the best pattern that was available to
- 3:04you. So the the possibility of having
- 3:06blown it, of having lived the wrong kind
- 3:09of life is a possibility that's going to
- 3:12be true of us whether or not we're
- 3:14mortal. And yet for all that, it seems
- 3:17as though mortality adds an extra risk,
- 3:21an extra danger of blowing it. Look,
- 3:24suppose we lived forever and just to
- 3:25have a kind of simplistic example, you
- 3:27might say, imagine somebody who spends
- 3:29his eternity counting the integers, 1 2
- 3:323 4 5 6. Well, that might not be as
- 3:36valuable as an eternity spent doing
- 3:37something else. Let's say, uh, doing
- 3:40more complicated math. But still, if
- 3:42you've spent a million years or a
- 3:44billion years counting the integers and
- 3:47then realized that was sort of
- 3:48pointless, you could always start over
- 3:50by doing more interesting, more deep,
- 3:53more worthwhile math. The immortality
- 3:57gives you a chance of starting over,
- 4:00gives you the possibility of do-overs.
- 4:02We might then worry that what's
- 4:04especially bad about death, the fact
- 4:07that we're mortal, is that it robs us of
- 4:10the chance of do-overs. But of course,
- 4:12that's not quite right either. I mean,
- 4:14even if you don't live forever, if you
- 4:15live 80 years or 100 years, you have the
- 4:18chance to reappraise your life at the
- 4:21age of 20 or 30 or 50 and decide you
- 4:24need to change course.
- 4:26So it's not exactly as though the
- 4:28possibility of do-overs disappears by
- 4:31death itself, via death itself.
- 4:34Still, the thought that death comes when
- 4:36it does seems to push us in the
- 4:39direction of thinking we've still got to
- 4:41be very careful because, of course,
- 4:44given that we're mortal, we have only a
- 4:47limited period of time in which to do
- 4:50the do-overs. There are there are two
- 4:51kinds of mistakes really that we might
- 4:53catch ourselves in. We might discover on
- 4:56the one hand that we made some bad
- 4:59choices in terms of what we were aiming
- 5:02for. And on the other hand, we might
- 5:04find even if we made the right choices
- 5:06in terms of our goals, we flubbed it in
- 5:08terms of actually accomplishing what we
- 5:11were trying to accomplish. And so we've
- 5:13we literally have to start over again
- 5:15and and try again. So there's two kinds
- 5:19of care that we have to take. We have to
- 5:22be careful in our aims and we have to be
- 5:25careful in our execution of our aims
- 5:28because we have, as it were, a rather
- 5:30limited amount of time to do it over.
- 5:33Now, again, the the nitpicky part of me
- 5:35wants to say strictly speaking, it's not
- 5:38the fact that we are mortal per se that
- 5:41all by itself means we have to be
- 5:44especially careful. After all, suppose
- 5:47there just weren't all that many things
- 5:49worth doing. And suppose they weren't
- 5:52all that complicated, all that difficult
- 5:56to do well. Suppose there were only five
- 5:58things worth doing. And even if you
- 5:59couldn't necessarily do every single one
- 6:02of them right the first time out, at
- 6:04most it would take two or three tries.
- 6:08And by a try I mean maybe an hour or
- 6:11two. Well that'd be a pretty
- 6:12impoverished world that could only offer
- 6:15us that much, but after all if that was
- 6:17the way the world worked and we had a
- 6:19hundred years, we wouldn't really have
- 6:22to worry all that much about being
- 6:23careful. We'd have plenty of time to aim
- 6:28for each of the five things worth having
- 6:31and plenty of time to get each one of
- 6:34the five things right. A hundred years
- 6:37of life would be more than enough. We
- 6:39wouldn't have to be careful. So it's not
- 6:41just the fact that we're mortal that
- 6:44requires us to be careful.
- 6:47It's the fact that we have a relatively
- 6:50short span of life relative to how much
- 6:54there is worth aiming for and how
- 6:58complicated and difficult it can be to
- 7:01get those things and get them right.
- 7:04It's because of the fact that there's so
- 7:07much to do and doing it properly that we
- 7:11have to be careful. We just don't have
- 7:13enough time to sort of flail around, try
- 7:16a little this, try a little of that.
- 7:18Somebody who lives like that may well
- 7:20find that the things they aimed for
- 7:24weren't really the best choices. You
- 7:27don't have to decide that these things
- 7:29weren't worth having at all given the
- 7:32relatively short period of time we've
- 7:34got. We've got the extra burden of
- 7:37deciding what are the things most worth
- 7:40going after. And we have to face the
- 7:43prospect, the chance that we'll look
- 7:46back and discover that we didn't make
- 7:48the best choices there. We aimed for the
- 7:51wrong things, not necessarily things
- 7:53that weren't worth having, but given the
- 7:56limited number of things we were going
- 7:57to be able to fill our lives with, in
- 7:59that sense the wrong choices. And we may
- 8:02discover as well that we were not
- 8:04sufficiently careful, attentive in how
- 8:07we try to achieve these things because
- 8:10it's not as though, although given the
- 8:12way life is, you've got the chance for
- 8:14do-overs, you don't have time for a
- 8:16whole lot of do-overs. And so what death
- 8:20forces us to do is to be careful. An
- 8:23analogy that comes to mind here is an
- 8:25artist who goes a musician who goes into
- 8:27a recording studio and look, he he can
- 8:31start trying to record his songs to cut
- 8:33an album uh and he may only have a
- 8:36certain number of songs in his
- 8:38repertoire. And so if he's got a long
- 8:40enough period of time, a month in the
- 8:43recording studio, he's got plenty of
- 8:45time or she's got plenty of time to sing
- 8:48a couple of songs. Maybe these wouldn't
- 8:50be the best things to record. Let's give
- 8:51it a try and we'll see. Didn't get it
- 8:54right the first take. Let's record it
- 8:56again. Let's try it a third time. Let's
- 8:57try it a fourth time. If you've got
- 8:59enough time, it's less pressing to get
- 9:03clear before you start or as you're
- 9:05going along, what are the songs I should
- 9:07try to record and can I get it on one
- 9:10take or at most two? But if instead of
- 9:12having a month in the recording studio,
- 9:15you've got only a week in the studio or
- 9:18a day in the studio, suddenly
- 9:21everything's much more pressing. Time is
- 9:25much more precious. You've got to decide
- 9:28early on just which are the songs that
- 9:31it makes sense to record. And yeah,
- 9:34there are some other songs, but these
- 9:35seem to be the better choices. And when
- 9:38you record them, you can't be as
- 9:39careless and inattentive as you try to
- 9:42get them down. You've got to try to get
- 9:44it right the first time or at worst the
- 9:47second time. That's it seems to me the
- 9:49situation we find ourselves in, not just
- 9:52given the fact that we die, but we might
- 9:55say given how incredibly rich the world
- 9:59is, how many things it offers us, how
- 10:03many choices we have in terms of what's
- 10:06worth going after. But for many of these
- 10:08things, given how difficult they are to
- 10:11accomplish. Although we've got the
- 10:13chance for do-overs, both in terms of
- 10:17changing our mind about what we should
- 10:18be aiming at and trying again for the
- 10:21things we have aimed at, we've got to be
- 10:24careful. The fact about our death
- 10:27requires pain attention. It requires
- 10:31care. Well, having said that, of course
- 10:33the immediate question then is, all
- 10:34right, so so I'm paying attention. I'm
- 10:36I'm I'm I'm trying to be careful. What
- 10:39should I do with my life? How How shall
- 10:42I What What should I fill it with? We've
- 10:44previously in the class talked about the
- 10:46possibility that being alive per se may
- 10:49have some value, but you know, above and
- 10:51beyond whatever stand we take on that,
- 10:53it's certainly also the case that part
- 10:56of what adds to the value of our lives
- 10:58are the contents of our lives.
- 11:02And so we need to ask, well, what kinds
- 11:05of contents should we try to fill our
- 11:09lives with?
- 11:11Now, I won't try to answer that. To To
- 11:15ask the question, what are the things
- 11:17really worth going after in life is to
- 11:21come up to the edge of asking, well,
- 11:25just what is the meaning of life? What's
- 11:27really worth going after?
- 11:31And although that is indeed an
- 11:33important, perhaps the important
- 11:35question, it's the question I think for
- 11:37a different class. And so having come
- 11:39close to the edge of that question, I'm
- 11:42going to now back away from it.
- 11:45But still, it seems we might say in
- 11:48broad strokes, there are two different
- 11:50strategies that we could adopt. And it's
- 11:54worth at least pausing to think about
- 11:55these two strategies.
- 11:58Strategy number one says, given that
- 12:01you've only got a finite amount of time,
- 12:05actually the basic underlying thought
- 12:07behind both strategies is just this.
- 12:09Haven't got much time, pack as much as
- 12:12you can into life. Pack as much can as
- 12:15much as you can in. But there are two
- 12:17basic strategies about how do you put
- 12:19that idea to practice. And strategy
- 12:22number one says, given the dangers of
- 12:26failure if you aim too ambitiously, you
- 12:30should settle for the kinds of goals
- 12:33that you're virtually guaranteed that
- 12:36you'll accomplish. The pleasures of
- 12:38food, company, sex, ice cream.
- 12:42Uh
- 12:42one of the paper topics asks you to
- 12:44reflect on the philosophy, eat, drink,
- 12:46and be merry for tomorrow you die. Well,
- 12:48that's one of the strategies, right?
- 12:51We're going to be dead tomorrow.
- 12:53And so while we're here, let's try to
- 12:56pack in as much as we can by going for
- 13:00the things that we've got a very high
- 13:02chance of actually accomplishing.
- 13:05Strategy number two says, that's all
- 13:08well and good. You've got a pretty high
- 13:11chance of succeeding at that. The
- 13:14trouble with strategy number one is the
- 13:17goods that you can achieve, the sort of
- 13:20sure thing goods are small. They're
- 13:24rather small potatoes as things go. Some
- 13:28of the most valuable goods in life are
- 13:32things that don't come so readily, don't
- 13:35come with guarantees of achieving them.
- 13:38You might want to write a novel, compose
- 13:40a symphony, or for that matter, raise
- 13:43marry and raise a family.
- 13:45Some of these things, strat fans of
- 13:47strategy number two argue, these things
- 13:51are the most valuable things that life
- 13:54can offer us. So that a life filled with
- 13:57these larger goods is a more valuable
- 14:00life than a life filled with the small
- 14:03potatoes goods.
- 14:06I suppose fans of the eat, drink, and be
- 14:07merry strategy don't like to call those
- 14:09small potatoes goods, but that's the
- 14:11kind of language that might be offered
- 14:13by fans of strategy number two.
- 14:17And [snorts]
- 14:18it seems to me that as a claim about
- 14:21which life, if only you had it, if you
- 14:23had a guarantee, you know, if if if God
- 14:25were going to say, look, which life do
- 14:27you want? I promise you'll get it. The
- 14:28life filled with food and drink or the
- 14:32life filled with accomplishment,
- 14:36perhaps most of us would say, well, it's
- 14:38the life filled with accomplishment
- 14:40that's the more valuable life. The
- 14:43trouble, of course, is the life with the
- 14:45greater accomplishments, the life aiming
- 14:47for greater accomplishments is also a
- 14:49life with a greater chance of failure.
- 14:52You aim for writing the great American
- 14:55novel, and 10 years later you still
- 14:57haven't finished it. 20 years later you
- 15:00decide you don't have it in you to write
- 15:02the great American novel. You try to
- 15:05produce a business and it goes under. So
- 15:09what's the right strategy to take? I
- 15:11suppose many of us would be inclined to
- 15:14say, well, the third strategy, there's a
- 15:16third strategy that's the obviously
- 15:18right thing to do, which is get the
- 15:21right mixture. Aim for a certain number
- 15:25of
- 15:25what should we call them? Large
- 15:27potatoes. Aim for a certain number of
- 15:29the large accomplishments because if you
- 15:32do manage to get them, your life will
- 15:34have more value, but also throw in a
- 15:37certain sprinkling of the smaller things
- 15:41where you're at least assured of having
- 15:42gotten something out of life. Well,
- 15:44that's all well and good as well,
- 15:47but it just now brings us to the next
- 15:50question. What is the right mixture
- 15:54after all?
- 15:57Well, I'm not going to try to answer
- 15:59that one either, but again, those of you
- 16:01who choose the topic the eat, drink, and
- 16:03be merry question, basically I'm
- 16:05inviting you in that topic to reflect on
- 16:07that question. Here's a different
- 16:09thought. The the entire, as I said, the
- 16:12underlying thought behind the the, you
- 16:15know, go for the big things, go for the
- 16:17small things Let's pack it all in. The
- 16:19underlying thoughts seem to be, well
- 16:21look, you'll as long as you've got a
- 16:24life that's got valuable contents, the
- 16:27more the better. We might say here's
- 16:30common ground between the two
- 16:32strategies. The more the better. Now
- 16:36previously we've I've argued that
- 16:39immortality would not actually be a good
- 16:42thing. Eventually rich and incredible as
- 16:45the world is, eventually
- 16:48the goods of life would run out and
- 16:51immortality would be dreadful. But
- 16:53having said that, that's not to suggest
- 16:56that we most of us come remotely close
- 16:59to that condition. For most of us it's
- 17:01certainly true that, you know, dying at
- 17:0430
- 17:05deprives you of goods that would have
- 17:07come to you if only you'd lived to 40.
- 17:10And dying at 40 deprives you of goods
- 17:12that would have come to you if only
- 17:13you'd lived to 50 or 60 or 80.
- 17:17So one thing that we're inclined to
- 17:18agree is, you know, other things being
- 17:20equal, the longer your life the better.
- 17:23So
- 17:26here's a life 50 years long.
- 17:29And suppose you live it with a certain
- 17:32amount of value in your life, 100 value
- 17:35points, whatever that is. Whatever
- 17:37whatever the however our units of
- 17:38measuring just how good a life is, we'd
- 17:40say look, better to have a life at that
- 17:43value
- 17:44instead of going for 50 years, went for
- 17:46100 years. Fair enough, we might say.
- 17:49We all agree, don't we, that quantity of
- 17:53life's a good thing. And that does seem
- 17:55plausible.
- 17:56But at the same time we'll want
- 17:57immediately to say quantity of life may
- 17:59matter, but it's not the only thing that
- 18:02matters. Quality of life matters as
- 18:05well. And again, that point fairly
- 18:07uncontroversial.
- 18:12If you had to choose between your life
- 18:13of 50 years at 100 value points
- 18:18or 50 years
- 18:24at whatever that is, 130 value points,
- 18:27you'd rather have a second life. The
- 18:29length of life isn't the only thing we
- 18:31care about. The overall quality of your
- 18:34life is something we care about as well.
- 18:36And this of course is another topic that
- 18:38we've talked about previously. Just what
- 18:40is it that goes into making a life
- 18:43better than another? So we now sort of
- 18:46see, summing it up, yeah, got to pay
- 18:48attention to quality, got to pay
- 18:49attention to quantity or duration. Of
- 18:52course, reason I just corrected myself
- 18:54is because you might say if you want to
- 18:55think about it mathematically, it all is
- 18:57just a matter of quantity as long as
- 19:01when we measure quantity, we bear in
- 19:03mind we need to measure not just the the
- 19:07length of the life, but the the height
- 19:09of the box. So the, you know, area of
- 19:12the box here is 50 times 100 units. So
- 19:15whatever that is, that's 5000
- 19:19you know
- 19:20going to get another giggle here, right?
- 19:22You know, sort of imagine a little unit.
- 19:23It's a, you know, it's a quality one
- 19:25unit of quantity one unit of quality for
- 19:28a year. So it's a quality year unit.
- 19:31Whatever it is,
- 19:325000 units. Here
- 19:366500.
- 19:41Let's say, look, we can capture the
- 19:44thought that the duration of your life
- 19:47matters, the quality of your life
- 19:48matters by by multiplying the two
- 19:50together.
- 19:51And without getting hung up on the
- 19:53numbers as though there's any kind of
- 19:54precision here, the underlying thought's
- 19:57fairly clear. The area of the box
- 20:00represents the overall quality, the
- 20:03overall quantity that you've managed to
- 20:06cram into your life in your 50 years.
- 20:08And we could we could start measuring
- 20:10different kinds of lives. We might start
- 20:12worrying about, well, look, suppose I
- 20:15could live 50 years at 130 or I could
- 20:18live, you know, whatever it is, 100
- 20:20years at some other number that's a
- 20:22little bit less. we might say, oh, less
- 20:24quality, but longer quantity, longer
- 20:26duration, more valuable life filled in
- 20:30that last box. We see how it goes. But
- 20:34the question we need to ask is, so if
- 20:36we've got this more rich sense of
- 20:38quantity where we multiply the duration
- 20:41of the lifetime is the how good a life
- 20:43you're having while you've got it, does
- 20:45that give adequate place to
- 20:50what we think is valuable? Does it give
- 20:52adequate place to quality in life?
- 20:56Let me draw some different boxes,
- 20:59some different possible lives to choose
- 21:01between.
- 21:15Let's just get the
- 21:19Suppose you had a nice long life,
- 21:22150 years.
- 21:30Again, just for the sake of
- 21:31concreteness, we assign it 50 quality
- 21:34points.
- 21:36So the area
- 21:397,500.
- 21:43Let's suppose, just so you get a feel
- 21:45for this, let's suppose that the best
- 21:48life lived on Earth so far was worth a
- 21:5210.
- 21:54So this is an incredible life to be at
- 21:5650.
- 21:57And you get it for 150 years. Very nice
- 22:01life.
- 22:03Now compare it
- 22:06with this life.
- 22:10Suppose that this life isn't really all
- 22:13that good in terms of how well off you
- 22:15are at any given time. It's plus one.
- 22:18Zero would be a life not worth having,
- 22:21though no worse than nonexistence.
- 22:23Negative numbers would be lives
- 22:24presumably that would be, you you'd be
- 22:25better off dead. This life is just
- 22:28barely worth having. It's plus one, but
- 22:33it's a very, very, very long life. So
- 22:37long that I couldn't draw it to scale.
- 22:39That's why we've got the dot dot dots in
- 22:41the middle.
- 22:42Suppose it goes on for 30,000
- 22:45years.
- 22:48Well, the math here is pretty easy.
- 22:4930,000 * 1 is 30,000 in terms of the
- 22:53area.
- 22:55Okay. So
- 22:57trying to choose between these two
- 23:00lives, life A
- 23:03or life B.
- 23:07In terms of quantity, our enriched
- 23:09notion of quantity where you measure the
- 23:11length of the life times the height of
- 23:13the box, life B's got more quantity of
- 23:17what matters, 30,000 vs 7,500.
- 23:21And yet most of us, when we think about
- 23:24this choice,
- 23:26do not find B to be a preferable life,
- 23:31even though the quantity
- 23:33of value sort of just suppose we could
- 23:35measure sort of quantity of whatever the
- 23:38goods are that we've got crammed into
- 23:40our life. Well, this has very, very,
- 23:43very small amount stretched over a very
- 23:45long time. The quantity's larger, but
- 23:47life A seems preferable. Now for any
- 23:51you know, this may not be true for
- 23:52everybody, but for those of us who share
- 23:55that thought, we might say quantity
- 23:58isn't all it's about.
- 24:00Or when we try to take quality into
- 24:04account, it wasn't so much that we
- 24:07couldn't measure it. It's that if you
- 24:09reduce the importance of quality into
- 24:13sort of fold it into quantity so that
- 24:16what it's all about is the total amount
- 24:19that you're getting, well, the total
- 24:21amount's bigger in B than A. If you
- 24:23don't think B's a better life, that
- 24:25suggests that totals aren't what it's
- 24:28all about. Well,
- 24:29what else might we then choose between
- 24:32with regard to A and B? Well, natural
- 24:34response is to say even though life A is
- 24:38shorter, it attains a kind of peak, a
- 24:42kind of height that isn't approached any
- 24:45place in life B. And perhaps then in
- 24:48evaluating lives and choosing between
- 24:51rival lives, we can't just look for the
- 24:53quantity of good. We have to look at the
- 24:57peaks. We have to look at the heights.
- 24:59In choosing between lives, it's
- 25:01important to think not just about how
- 25:04much did you pack in total, but what
- 25:08were the greatest goods that you had or
- 25:12accomplished in your life? And perhaps
- 25:14then we should conclude quality can
- 25:17trump quantity.
- 25:20Perhaps with the right quality in place,
- 25:24quantity becomes of secondary
- 25:27importance. Yeah, it might be that if we
- 25:30could have a longer life where we
- 25:32achieved great things rather than a
- 25:34shorter life where we achieved great
- 25:37things, better to have the longer life.
- 25:39Quantity might matter too as long as we
- 25:42think the quality's what matters the
- 25:45most. But a more radical version of the
- 25:47theory would say actually quality's all
- 25:51that matters. The peaks are all that
- 25:55matter. That at any rate is the position
- 25:57that gets expressed by Hölderlin in the
- 26:01poem To the Parcae, To the Fates. That
- 26:04was in one of the essays I've had you
- 26:05read, but let me let me read that now.
- 26:07To the Parcae.
- 26:08A single summer grant me, great powers,
- 26:12and a single autumn for fully ripened
- 26:14song that, sated with the sweetness of
- 26:17my playing, my heart may more willingly
- 26:20die. The soul that living did not attain
- 26:23its divine right cannot repose in the
- 26:26nether world. But once what I am bent
- 26:29on, what is holy, my poetry is
- 26:32accomplished. Be welcome, then,
- 26:34stillness of the shadows world. I shall
- 26:37be satisfied, though my lyre will not
- 26:39accompany me down there. Once I lived
- 26:42like the gods, and more is not needed.
- 26:46Hölderlin is saying he doesn't care
- 26:48about quantity at all. If he can
- 26:51accomplish something great, if he can
- 26:54ascend to the heights and do something
- 26:56great with his poetry, that's enough.
- 26:58Once he's lived like the gods, more is
- 27:02not needed. So in thinking about what we
- 27:05want to do with our lives, it's not
- 27:07enough to have the kind of theory that
- 27:10we've begun to sketch in previous weeks
- 27:14where we think about what are the
- 27:15various things worth having in a life,
- 27:18we also have to address this question of
- 27:21quality versus quantity. Is quality only
- 27:25important in so far as it gets folded
- 27:28into producing greater quantity, or does
- 27:32quality matter in its own right as
- 27:34something that's worth going for even
- 27:37when it means a smaller quantity? And if
- 27:40quality does matter, does quantity
- 27:43matter as well, or is indeed quality all
- 27:46that matters? Is Hölderlin right when he
- 27:49says once I've lived like the gods, more
- 27:52is not needed?
- 27:53Now Hölderlin, I imagine, in thinking
- 27:56about why that kind of life is the best
- 28:00kind of life he could aspire to is
- 28:03thinking in part about the lasting
- 28:06contribution that his poetry makes.
- 28:10There's a sense in which when we think
- 28:12about having done things like that, we
- 28:14feel that we attain a kind of
- 28:18immortality. We live on through our
- 28:21works. And so
- 28:23the next question I want to turn to and
- 28:26sort of thinking about strategies of how
- 28:28to live in light of the fact of in in of
- 28:31facing our mortality is,
- 28:33well, maybe a kind of immortality is
- 28:36worth going after.
- 28:40Or maybe at the very least we can take a
- 28:41kind of comfort in thinking that we have
- 28:45or can attain a kind of immortality. I I
- 28:49emphasize the word kind, of course,
- 28:51because strictly speaking, uh
- 28:54if you live on through your works, it's
- 28:56not as though you are literally living
- 28:59on. It's semi-immortality
- 29:02or quasi-immortality.
- 29:04I suppose people who don't believe in it
- 29:06would prefer to call it
- 29:07pseudo-immortality.
- 29:09Actually, this reminds me of a joke so
- 29:12here's a Woody Allen
- 29:14joke. Uh I don't want to be immortal
- 29:16through my work. I want to be immortal
- 29:18through not dying.
- 29:22Well, as you know, previously I've
- 29:23argued that genuine immortality,
- 29:26unending life would not be a good thing.
- 29:29But still, many of us aspire to this
- 29:33kind of semi-immortality.
- 29:36And actually, it can take, I think
- 29:37again, two broad forms. Sometimes people
- 29:41want to say there's a sense in which
- 29:43although it's not as though you're
- 29:44literally
- 29:45living on, there's something like that
- 29:49going on in so far as a part of you
- 29:53continues. If I have children, then
- 29:56literally some of my, in my case as a
- 29:59male, you know, one of my cells
- 30:00continues. And then their cells
- 30:03continue. And their children and their
- 30:05cells continue in their children.
- 30:08If you think of an amoeba splitting and
- 30:10splitting and splitting and splitting
- 30:11again, parts of the original amoeba
- 30:14could be there for many many many
- 30:16generations. Some people take comfort in
- 30:20the thought that literally speaking, a
- 30:23part of them will continue. If if not
- 30:26through cells, through my offspring,
- 30:29perhaps at least my atoms get recycled,
- 30:32get used again. And so I I get absorbed
- 30:36into the universe, but I never
- 30:37disappear. Some people take comfort in
- 30:40that thought.
- 30:42The German philosopher Schopenhauer
- 30:44thought that this should reduce somewhat
- 30:46the sting of death. He said, but it will
- 30:49be asked, how is the permanence of mere
- 30:51dust of crude matter to be regarded as a
- 30:55continuance of our true inner nature?
- 30:57And he answers, oh, do you know this
- 31:00dust then? Do you know what it is and
- 31:02what it can do? Learn to know it before
- 31:05you despise it. This matter now lying
- 31:08there as dust and ashes will soon form
- 31:11into crystals when dissolved in water.
- 31:14It will shine as metal. It will then
- 31:16emit electric sparks. It will indeed of
- 31:19its own accord form itself into plant
- 31:22and animal. And from its mysterious womb
- 31:25it will develop that life about the loss
- 31:28of which you in your narrowness of mind
- 31:31are so nervous and anxious.
- 31:34Well, that's a very moving passage, but
- 31:35I have to say I don't buy it. I don't
- 31:38find any comfort at all in the thought
- 31:40that my atoms will still be around
- 31:44getting reused into something else.
- 31:47So this first kind of semi-immortality
- 31:51where you take comfort in the thought
- 31:53that literally there are parts of you
- 31:57that will continue, this strikes me as a
- 31:59kind of desperate striving, desperate
- 32:03reaching for straws,
- 32:05perhaps in Schopenhauer's case leading
- 32:07him to delude himself into thinking, oh,
- 32:09it's not so bad that I'm going to die.
- 32:11I'm going to die soon. At least my atoms
- 32:13will still be around.
- 32:15Doesn't work for me.
- 32:17There's a second sort of approach though
- 32:19where it's not so much that you're
- 32:21supposed to be comforted by the thought
- 32:23that your parts will continue to last
- 32:26after you, but that your accomplishments
- 32:30will continue to last after you.
- 32:34Holderlin writes poetry which we're
- 32:36still reading some 200 years later. You
- 32:40can write a novel which can be read for
- 32:4320 or 50 or 100 or more years. You might
- 32:47make some contribution to math or
- 32:49philosophy or science, and 50 or 100
- 32:53years later people could still be
- 32:55talking about that philosophical
- 32:57argument or that mathematical result.
- 33:00You might have other kinds of
- 33:01accomplishments. You You might build a
- 33:03building that will last after you. Stone
- 33:08cutters Uh I've read interviews with
- 33:10stone cutters who take a kind of pride
- 33:13and comfort in the thought that long
- 33:14after they're gone, the buildings that
- 33:17they helped build will still be there.
- 33:20You might try to build a company that
- 33:23will last after you die, or for that
- 33:26matter, you might take pleasure and
- 33:29comfort in the accomplishment of having
- 33:32raised a family here, not so much the
- 33:34thought that, you know, some of your
- 33:36cells are in your offspring, but rather
- 33:39the thought that to have raised another
- 33:42decent human being is a non-trivial
- 33:46accomplishment, something worth having
- 33:48done with your life, and that
- 33:51accomplishment continues after you are
- 33:53gone.
- 33:55Well, what should we think about this
- 33:57second group of approaches to attaining
- 34:01semi-immortality?
- 34:04I I I've got to say that I'm of two
- 34:06minds when I think about them. Un Un
- 34:08Unlike the, you know, the dust and the
- 34:11atoms stuff where I just think you're
- 34:13deluding yourself, I find myself drawn
- 34:17to this second
- 34:19set of thoughts. I find myself tempted
- 34:23by the thought that there's something
- 34:26worth doing about producing something
- 34:31that continues for a while, that it's
- 34:34significant. And even if my life here on
- 34:37Earth is a short one, if something that
- 34:40I've accomplished continues, My life is
- 34:43the better for it.
- 34:46That's Holderlin's thought, I suppose.
- 34:50And
- 34:52it's a view that appeals to me. I
- 34:55suppose it explains in part why I write
- 34:58philosophy in the hopes that the things
- 35:01I write might still be read 20 years
- 35:04after I die or 50 years or if I'm so
- 35:06lucky 100 years after I die.
- 35:10Well, in certain moods, perhaps in most
- 35:13moods I'm drawn by that thought, but in
- 35:16other moods I've got to confess I'm
- 35:18skeptical of it.
- 35:20I I remind myself of Schopenhauer
- 35:22writing his little passage, his ode to
- 35:24dust,
- 35:25and I find myself saying just like
- 35:28Schopenhauer was so desperate that he
- 35:31deludes himself into thinking, oh, it
- 35:32doesn't matter that I'm about to turn
- 35:34into dust. Dust is really really
- 35:35important.
- 35:37I'm just deluding myself as well when I
- 35:40think there's something grander,
- 35:43something significant, something
- 35:44valuable about having made an
- 35:47accomplishment, having achieved
- 35:49something that continues beyond me. So
- 35:52in in certain moods at least I find
- 35:54myself thinking that I've just deluded
- 35:57myself.
- 35:59But that's only certain moods
- 36:01and at least most of the time I find
- 36:04myself in agreement with Holderlin.
- 36:07Not necessarily in thinking, you know,
- 36:10quantity doesn't matter at all, to have
- 36:13written, you know, one great work is all
- 36:16you need and more great works doesn't
- 36:18add anything. That strikes me as going
- 36:20too far, but at least to have done
- 36:23something significant that abides, that
- 36:26does seem to me to add to the value and
- 36:29significance of my life.
- 36:33Well, let me mention an entire different
- 36:36approach. I'm going to give a very very
- 36:38short shrift to this last approach, but
- 36:40it's probably worth mentioning as well.
- 36:43The the entire assumption of all the
- 36:47lines of thought that I've been
- 36:50discussing
- 36:51so far today have in common the
- 36:54underlying belief
- 36:58that
- 37:00the way to deal with the fact that we
- 37:02live and then we're dead
- 37:05is to try to make the life that you've
- 37:10got as good as possible, as valuable as
- 37:14possible, to pack as much into it as you
- 37:17can, even though there's room for
- 37:19disagreement about what's the best
- 37:20strategy for doing that.
- 37:23The the picture is one in which we say
- 37:27we can't do anything about the loss,
- 37:31the loss of life. So the the right
- 37:34response is to
- 37:36make the life that we've got as valuable
- 37:39as it can be, to see it as valuable as
- 37:43it can be.
- 37:46But there's a rather different approach.
- 37:48That that that that alternative approach
- 37:50says
- 37:51yes,
- 37:52we're going to lose life and and that's
- 37:55horrible, but it's only horrible in so
- 37:59far as you think of life as something
- 38:03that it's bad to lose. After all, if we
- 38:07were to decide that life wasn't really a
- 38:10valuable gift, if it wasn't really
- 38:13something worth embracing and something
- 38:16that we could turn into something full
- 38:18of value, then its loss wouldn't
- 38:20actually be a loss. That's a point we've
- 38:24seen before, right? The the central
- 38:26badness of death is explained in the
- 38:28deprivation account. You are deprived of
- 38:30the fact that you could have had more
- 38:33life that would have been worth having
- 38:34overall. But if life isn't worth having
- 38:39overall, then its loss is not a bad
- 38:41thing, but a good thing.
- 38:43The trick then isn't to make life as
- 38:45valuable as it could be, but rather to
- 38:48come to recognize
- 38:51that on balance, life isn't positive but
- 38:55negative.
- 38:58I know that what I'm about to say has a
- 38:59kind of classics illustrated simplicity
- 39:02to it, and it's a bit of an over
- 39:04exaggeration, but in gross terms we
- 39:06might say the first general outlook that
- 39:10life is good and so the loss of it is
- 39:13bad, and so the answer is make as much
- 39:16of it as we can while we've got it.
- 39:19Might say that is in broad strokes the
- 39:21Western outlook.
- 39:26And in broad strokes the notion that
- 39:28life
- 39:30isn't really as good as we take it to
- 39:33be, but is in fact bad overall. Perhaps
- 39:36it's oversimplification to call it the
- 39:37Eastern outlook, but at least it's an
- 39:39outlook that gets more expression
- 39:41typically in Eastern thought than in
- 39:42Western thought.
- 39:45Foremost example of this second outlook
- 39:48is I suppose Buddhism.
- 39:51Four noble truths in Buddhism. The first
- 39:53noble truth is that life is suffering.
- 39:58Buddhists believe if you think
- 40:02hard about the underlying nature of
- 40:06life, you'll see
- 40:08that every [clears throat] place there
- 40:10is loss, there is suffering, there's
- 40:13disease,
- 40:15there's death, there's pain.
- 40:18Sure, there are things that we want, and
- 40:21if we're lucky we get them, but then we
- 40:24lose them, and that just adds to the
- 40:27suffering and the pain and the misery.
- 40:31On balance, life isn't good.
- 40:35First noble truth, life is suffering.
- 40:39And so armed with this estimation, what
- 40:43Buddhists try to do is to free you from
- 40:46attachment to these goods
- 40:50so that
- 40:51when you lose them
- 40:53the loss is minimized. And indeed,
- 40:56Buddhists try to free you from what they
- 40:58take to be the illusion of there being a
- 41:01self.
- 41:02There is no me to lose anything.
- 41:07Death is terrifying in so far as I worry
- 41:10about it being the dissolution of
- 41:12myself. If there is no self, there's
- 41:15nothing to dissolve.
- 41:19It all makes sense
- 41:22and I have tremendous respect for
- 41:24Buddhism. It all makes sense given the
- 41:26thought that life is suffering.
- 41:34But for better or for worse, I'm a child
- 41:36of the West. I'm a child of the book of
- 41:40Genesis where God looks on the world and
- 41:42says it's good. For me at least, the
- 41:46strategy of minimize your loss by
- 41:49viewing the world as negative is not one
- 41:54that I can be at rest with.
- 41:56For me, life can be good and so the the
- 42:00choices for me and I suppose for most of
- 42:03us remain among the strategy
- 42:06the strategies with which I began. How
- 42:09is it that we can most make our lives
- 42:13valuable? What is it that we can do that
- 42:16will allow us with Holderlin to say once
- 42:20we lived like the gods?
About this transcript
This page contains the full transcript of 1분에게라도 이 강의가 닿는다면 ... (예일대 교수 셸리 케이건) by BZCF | 비즈까페, generated from the public captions YouTube serves with the video. The transcript has 6,412 words across 960 segments, with the original timestamps preserved so you can click any line to jump to that moment in the embedded player.
What you can do with it
Use the transcript to take notes, quote the speaker, build a study guide, generate a summary with ChatGPT or Claude via the YouTube Summary tool, or export it as a timed subtitle file with YouTube to SRT. You can also re-open it in the transcriber to choose a caption track available on the video.
Free YouTube transcript tool
YouTube2Text is a free YouTube transcript generator — no signup, no daily limit. Paste any YouTube link and get the full transcript instantly, with timestamps, click-to-jump, caption language selection, AI prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, and Gemini, and exports to TXT, SRT, VTT, or Markdown.